Incomplete penetrance in primary immunodeficiency: a skeleton in the closet

Common variable immunodeficiency, cross currents, and prevailing winds

Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) is a heterogenous disease category created to distinguish late-onset antibody deficiencies from early-onset diseases like agammaglobulinemia or more expansively dysfunctional combined immunodeficiencies. Opinions vary on which affected patients should receive a CVID diagnosis which confuses clinicians and erects reproducibility barriers for researchers. Most experts agree that CVID's most indeliable feature is defective germinal center (GC) production of isotype-switched, affinity-maturated antibodies. Here, we review the biological factors contributing to CVID-associated GC dysfunction including genetic, epigenetic, tolerogenic, microbiome, and regulatory abnormalities. We also discuss the consequences of these biological phenomena to the development of non-infectious disease complications. Finally, we opine on topics and lines of investigation we think hold promise for expanding our mechanistic understanding of this protean condition and for improving the lives of affected patients.

Inborn errors of immunity: an expanding universe of disease and genetic architecture

Inborn errors of immunity (IEIs) are generally considered to be rare monogenic disorders of the immune system that cause immunodeficiency, autoinflammation, autoimmunity, allergy and/or cancer. Here, we discuss evidence that IEIs need not be rare disorders or exclusively affect the immune system. Namely, an increasing number of patients with IEIs present with severe dysregulations of the central nervous, digestive, renal or pulmonary systems. Current challenges in the diagnosis of IEIs that result from the segregated practice of specialized medicine could thus be mitigated, in part, by immunogenetic approaches. Starting with a brief historical overview of IEIs, we then discuss the technological advances that are facilitating the immunogenetic study of IEIs, progress in understanding disease penetrance in IEIs, the expanding universe of IEIs affecting distal organ systems and the future of genetic, biochemical and medical discoveries in this field.

Activation of gp130 signaling in T cells drives TH17-mediated multi-organ autoimmunity

The IL-6-gp130-STAT3 signaling axis is a major regulator of inflammation. Activating mutations in the gene encoding gp130 and germline gain-of-function mutations in STAT3 (STAT3GOF) are associated with multi-organ autoimmunity, severe morbidity, and adverse prognosis. To dissect crucial cellular subsets and disease biology involved in activated gp130 signaling, the gp130-JAK-STAT3 axis was constitutively activated using a transgene, L-gp130, specifically targeted to T cells. Activating gp130 signaling in T cells in vivo resulted in fatal, early onset, multi-organ autoimmunity in mice that resembled human STAT3GOF disease. Female mice had more rapid disease progression than male mice. On a cellular level, gp130 signaling induced the activation and effector cell differentiation of T cells, promoted the expansion of T helper type 17 (TH17) cells, and impaired the activity of regulatory T cells. Transcriptomic profiling of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells from these mice revealed commonly dysregulated genes and a gene signature that, when applied to human transcriptomic data, improved the segregation of patients with transcriptionally diverse STAT3GOF mutations from healthy controls. The findings demonstrate that increased gp130-STAT3 signaling leads to TH17-driven autoimmunity that phenotypically resembles human STAT3GOF disease.

Post-transplant Inflammatory Bowel Disease Associated with Donor-Derived TIM-3 Deficiency

Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) occurring following allogeneic stem cell transplantation (aSCT) is a very rare condition. The underlying pathogenesis needs to be better defined. There is currently no systematic effort to exclude loss- or gain-of-function mutations in immune-related genes in stem cell donors. This is despite the fact that more than 100 inborn errors of immunity may cause or contribute to IBD. We have molecularly characterized a patient who developed fulminant inflammatory bowel disease following aSCT with stable 100% donor-derived hematopoiesis. A pathogenic c.A291G; p.I97M HAVCR2 mutation encoding the immune checkpoint protein TIM-3 was identified in the patient's blood-derived DNA, while being absent in DNA derived from the skin. TIM-3 expression was much decreased in the patient's serum, and in vitro-activated patient-derived T cells expressed reduced TIM-3 levels. In contrast, T cell-intrinsic CD25 expression and production of inflammatory cytokines were preserved. TIM-3 expression was barely detectable in the immune cells of the patient's intestinal mucosa, while being detected unambiguously in the inflamed and non-inflamed colon from unrelated individuals. In conclusion, we report the first case of acquired, "transplanted" insufficiency of the regulatory TIM-3 checkpoint linked to post-aSCT IBD.

Clinical heterogeneity in families with multiple cases of inborn errors of immunity

BACKGROUND

Inborn errors of immunity (IEI) are a diverse range of genetic immune system illnesses affecting the innate and/or adaptive immune systems. Variable expressivity and incomplete penetrance have been reported in IEI patients with similar clinical diagnoses or even the same genetic mutation.

METHODS

Among all recorded patients in the national IEI registry, 193 families with multiple cases have been recognized. Clinical, laboratory and genetic variability were compared between 451 patients with different IEI entities.

RESULTS

The diagnosis of the first children led to the earlier diagnosis, lower diagnostic delay, timely treatment and improved survival in the second children in the majority of IEI. The highest discordance in familial lymphoproliferation, autoimmunity and malignancy were respectively observed in STK4 deficiency, DNMT3B deficiency and ATM deficiency. Regarding immunological heterogeneity within a unique family with multiple cases of IEI, the highest discordance in CD3+, CD4+, CD19+, IgM and IgA levels was observed in syndromic combined immunodeficiencies (CID), while non-syndromic CID particularly severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) manifested the highest discordance in IgG levels. Identification of the first ATM-deficient patient can lead to improved care and better survival in the next IEI children from the same family.

CONCLUSION

Intrafamilial heterogeneity in immunological and/or clinical features could be observed in families with multiple cases of IEI indicating the indisputable role of appropriate treatment and preventive environmental factors besides specific gene mutations in the variable observed penetrance or expressivity of the disease. This also emphasizes the importance of implementing genetic evaluation in all members of a family with a history of IEI even if there is no suspicion of an underlying IEI as other factors besides the underlying genetic defects might cause a milder phenotype or delay in presentation of clinical features. Thus, affected patients could be timely diagnosed and treated, and their quality of life and survival would improve.

Identification of Two Variants c.2697A > C and c.3305A > C in USP7 by Analysis of Whole-Exome Sequencing in Chinese Patients with Hao-Fountain Syndrome

Background  Variants of ubiquitin-specific protease 7 ( USP7 ) gene in humans are associated with a neurodevelopmental disorder-Hao-Fountain syndrome, its core symptoms including developmental delay, intellectual disability, and speech delay. Other variable symptoms can affect multiple systems. In present study, we report two patients with core features from two unrelated consanguineous families originating from the Tianjin Children's Hospital. Methods and Results  Genomic DNA was extracted from the peripheral blood samples collected from the probands with their family members and whole-exome sequencing (WES) was used to detect the pathogenic genes in the probands. Suspected variants were subsequently validated by Sanger sequencing. In family 1, WES revealed that the proband carried the de novo variant c.2697A > C (p.Leu899Phe) in USP7 (NM_003470.3). In family 2, WES identified the variant c.3305A > C (p.Asn1102Thr) in USP7 (NM_003470.3) from the proband. Conclusion  We reported two cases of Hao-Fountain syndrome caused by novel USP7 variants. In addition, we report the first case of mosaicism with a USP7 variant in Chinese family. Our findings demonstrate the importance of WES in diagnosis of genetic diseases and expands the USP7 variants spectrum in Hao-Fountain syndrome. Moreover, we summarize the cases caused by USP7 variants in the literature. Our study can provide a vital reference for the diagnosis of future cases.

Identification of a novel heterozygous PTH1R variant in a Chinese family with incomplete penetrance

BACKGROUND

Mutations in PTH1R are associated with Jansen-type metaphyseal chondrodysplasia (JMC), Blomstrand osteochondrodysplasia (BOCD), Eiken syndrome, enchondroma, and primary failure of tooth eruption (PFE). Inheritance of the PTH1R gene can be either autosomal dominant or autosomal recessive, indicating the complexity of the gene. Our objective was to identify the phenotypic differences in members of a family with a novel PTH1R mutation.

METHODS

The proband was a 13-year, 6-month-old girl presenting with short stature, abnormal tooth eruption, skeletal dysplasia, and midface hypoplasia. The brother and father of the proband presented with short stature and abnormal tooth eruption. High-throughput sequencing was performed on the proband, and the variant was confirmed in the proband and other family members by Sanger sequencing. Amino acid sequence alignment was performed using ClustalX software. Three-dimensional structures were analyzed and displayed using the I-TASSER website and PyMOL software.

RESULTS

High-throughput genome sequencing and Sanger sequencing validation showed that the proband, her father, and her brother all carried the PTH1R (NM_000316) c.1393G>A (p.E465K) mutation. The c.1393G>A (p.E465K) mutation was novel, as it has not been reported in the literature database. According to the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) guidelines, the p.E465K variant was considered to have uncertain significance. Biological information analysis demonstrated that this identified variant was highly conserved and highly likely pathogenic.

CONCLUSIONS

We identified a novel heterozygous mutation in the PTH1R gene leading to clinical manifestations with incomplete penetrance that expands the spectrum of known PTH1R mutations.

A zebrafish model of Ifih1-driven Aicardi-Goutières syndrome reproduces the interferon signature and the exacerbated inflammation of patients

Type I interferonopathies are a heterogenic group of rare diseases associated with an increase in type I interferon (IFN). The main challenge for the study of Type I interferonopathies is the lack of a well-founded animal model to better characterize the phenotype as well as to perform fast and large drug screenings to offer the best treatment options. In this study, we report the development of a transgenic zebrafish model of Type I interferonopathy overexpressing ifih1 carrying the mutation p.Arg742His (Tg(ifih1_mut)), corresponding to the human mutation p.Arg779His. RNA sequence analysis from Tg(ifih1_mut) larvae revealed a systemic inflammation and IFN signature upon a suboptimal poly I:C induction compared with wild-type larvae, confirming the phenotype observed in patients suffering from Type I interferonopathies. More interestingly, the phenotype was manifested in the zebrafish inflammation and Type I IFN reporters nfkb:eGFP and isg15:eGFP, respectively, making this zebrafish model suitable for future high-throughput chemical screening (HTS). Using the unique advantages of the zebrafish model for gene editing, we have generated Tg(ifih1_mut) knocked down for mavs and ikbke, which completely abrogated the Poly I:C induction and activation of the GFP of the reporters. Finally, we used an FDA-approved drug, Baricitinib (Jak1/Jak2 inhibitor), which was able to reduce the inflammation and the ISG expression. Our results demonstrate the potential of this model to further understand AGS pathological mechanisms and to identify novel therapeutic drugs by HTS.

Immunologic and Genetic Contributors to CD46-Dependent Immune Dysregulation

Mutations in CD46 predispose to atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome (aHUS) with low penetrance. Factors driving immune-dysregulatory disease in individual mutation carriers have remained ill-understood. In addition to its role as a negative regulator of the complement system, CD46 modifies T cell-intrinsic metabolic adaptation and cytokine production. Comparative immunologic analysis of diseased vs. healthy CD46 mutation carriers has not been performed in detail yet. In this study, we comprehensively analyzed clinical, molecular, immune-phenotypic, cytokine secretion, immune-metabolic, and genetic profiles in healthy vs. diseased individuals carrying a rare, heterozygous CD46 mutation identified within a large single family. Five out of six studied individuals carried a CD46 gene splice-site mutation causing an in-frame deletion of 21 base pairs. One child suffered from aHUS and his paternal uncle manifested with adult-onset systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Three mutation carriers had no clinical evidence of CD46-related disease to date. CD4+ T cell-intrinsic CD46 expression was uniformly 50%-reduced but was comparable in diseased vs. healthy mutation carriers. Reconstitution experiments defined the 21-base pair-deleted CD46 variant as intracellularly-but not surface-expressed and haploinsufficient. Both healthy and diseased mutation carriers displayed reduced CD46-dependent T cell mitochondrial adaptation. Diseased mutation carriers had lower peripheral regulatory T cell (Treg) frequencies and carried potentially epistatic, private rare variants in other inborn errors of immunity (IEI)-associated proinflammatory genes, not found in healthy mutation carriers. In conclusion, low Treg and rare non-CD46 immune-gene variants may contribute to clinically manifest CD46 haploinsufficiency-associated immune-dysregulation.

Tooth ultrastructure changes induced by a nonsense mutation in the FAM83H gene: insights into the diversity of amelogenesis imperfecta

OBJECTIVES

The current research on single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) mutation sites at different positions of the FAM83H gene and their phenotypic changes leading to amelogenesis imperfecta (AI) is inconsistent. We identified a previously reported heterozygous nonsense mutation c.1192C>T (p.Q398*) in the FAM83H gene and conducted a comprehensive analysis of the dental ultrastructure and chemical composition changes induced by this mutation. Additionally, we predicted the protein feature affected by this mutation site. The aim was to further deepen our understanding of the diversity of AI caused by different mutation sites in the FAM83H gene.

METHODS

Whole-exome sequencing (WES) and Sanger sequencing were used to confirm the mutation sites. Physical features of the patient's teeth were investigated using various methods including cone beam computer tomography (CBCT), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), contact profilometry (roughness measurement), and a nanomechanical tester (nanoindentation measurement). The protein features of wild-type and mutant FAM83H were predicted using bioinformatics methods.

RESULTS

One previously discovered FAM83H heterozygous nonsense mutation c.1192C>T (p.Q398*) was detected in the patient. SEM revealed inconsistent dentinal tubules, and EDS showed that calcium and phosphorus were lower in the patient's dentin but higher in the enamel compared to the control tooth. Roughness measurements showed that AI patients' teeth had rougher occlusal surfaces than those of the control tooth. Nanoindentation measurements showed that the enamel and dentin hardness values of the AI patients' teeth were both significantly reduced compared to those of the control tooth. Compared to the wild-type FAM83H protein, the mutant FAM83H protein shows alterations in stability, hydrophobicity, secondary structure, and tertiary structure. These changes could underlie functional differences and AI phenotype variations caused by this mutation site.

CONCLUSIONS

This study expands the understanding of the effects of FAM83H mutations on tooth structure.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Our study enhances our understanding of the genetic basis of AI and may contribute to improved diagnostics and personalized treatment strategies for patients with FAM83H-related AI.

Nature and nurture: understanding phenotypic variation in inborn errors of immunity

The overall disease burden of pediatric infection is high, with widely varying clinical outcomes including death. Among the most vulnerable children, those with inborn errors of immunity, reduced penetrance and variable expressivity are common but poorly understood. There are several genetic mechanisms that influence phenotypic variation in inborn errors of immunity, as well as a body of knowledge on environmental influences and specific pathogen triggers. Critically, recent advances are illuminating novel nuances for fundamental concepts on disease penetrance, as well as raising new areas of inquiry. The last few decades have seen the identification of almost 500 causes of inborn errors of immunity, as well as major advancements in our ability to characterize somatic events, the microbiome, and genotypes across large populations. The progress has not been linear, and yet, these developments have accumulated into an enhanced ability to diagnose and treat inborn errors of immunity, in some cases with precision therapy. Nonetheless, many questions remain regarding the genetic and environmental contributions to phenotypic variation both within and among families. The purpose of this review is to provide an updated summary of key concepts in genetic and environmental contributions to phenotypic variation within inborn errors of immunity, conceptualized as including dynamic, reciprocal interplay among factors unfolding across the key dimension of time. The associated findings, potential gaps, and implications for research are discussed in turn for each major influencing factor. The substantial challenge ahead will be to organize and integrate information in such a way that accommodates the heterogeneity within inborn errors of immunity to arrive at a more comprehensive and accurate understanding of how the immune system operates in health and disease. And, crucially, to translate this understanding into improved patient care for the millions at risk for serious infection and other immune-related morbidity.

Rare Variants in Primary Immunodeficiency Genes and Their Functional Partners in Severe COVID-19

The development of severe COVID-19, which is a complex multisystem disease, is thought to be associated with many genes whose action is modulated by numerous environmental and genetic factors. In this study, we focused on the ideas of the omnigenic model of heritability of complex traits, which assumes that a small number of core genes and a large pool of peripheral genes expressed in disease-relevant tissues contribute to the genetics of complex traits through interconnected networks. We hypothesized that primary immunodeficiency disease (PID) genes may be considered as core genes in severe COVID-19, and their functional partners (FPs) from protein-protein interaction networks may be considered as peripheral near-core genes. We used whole-exome sequencing data from patients aged ≤ 45 years with severe (n = 9) and non-severe COVID-19 (n = 11), and assessed the cumulative contribution of rare high-impact variants to disease severity. In patients with severe COVID-19, an excess of rare high-impact variants was observed at the whole-exome level, but maximal association signals were detected for PID + FP gene subsets among the genes intolerant to LoF variants, haploinsufficient and essential. Our exploratory study may serve as a model for new directions in the research of host genetics in severe COVID-19.

Autoimmunity and immunodeficiency associated with monoallelic LIG4 mutations via haploinsufficiency

BACKGROUND

Biallelic mutations in LIG4 encoding DNA-ligase 4 cause a rare immunodeficiency syndrome manifesting as infant-onset life-threatening and/or opportunistic infections, skeletal malformations, radiosensitivity and neoplasia. LIG4 is pivotal during DNA repair and during V(D)J recombination as it performs the final DNA-break sealing step.

OBJECTIVES

This study explored whether monoallelic LIG4 missense mutations may underlie immunodeficiency and autoimmunity with autosomal dominant inheritance.

METHODS

Extensive flow-cytometric immune-phenotyping was performed. Rare variants of immune system genes were analyzed by whole exome sequencing. DNA repair functionality and T-cell-intrinsic DNA damage tolerance was tested with an ensemble of in vitro and in silico tools. Antigen-receptor diversity and autoimmune features were characterized by high-throughput sequencing and autoantibody arrays. Reconstitution of wild-type versus mutant LIG4 were performed in LIG4 knockout Jurkat T cells, and DNA damage tolerance was subsequently assessed.

RESULTS

A novel heterozygous LIG4 loss-of-function mutation (p.R580Q), associated with a dominantly inherited familial immune-dysregulation consisting of autoimmune cytopenias, and in the index patient with lymphoproliferation, agammaglobulinemia, and adaptive immune cell infiltration into nonlymphoid organs. Immunophenotyping revealed reduced naive CD4+ T cells and low TCR-Vα7.2+ T cells, while T-/B-cell receptor repertoires showed only mild alterations. Cohort screening identified 2 other nonrelated patients with the monoallelic LIG4 mutation p.A842D recapitulating clinical and immune-phenotypic dysregulations observed in the index family and displaying T-cell-intrinsic DNA damage intolerance. Reconstitution experiments and molecular dynamics simulations categorize both missense mutations as loss-of-function and haploinsufficient.

CONCLUSIONS

This study provides evidence that certain monoallelic LIG4 mutations may cause human immune dysregulation via haploinsufficiency.

COVID-19 severity: does the genetic landscape of rare variants matter?

Rare variants affecting host defense against pathogens may be involved in COVID-19 severity, but most rare variants are not expected to have a major impact on the course of COVID-19. We hypothesized that the accumulation of weak effects of many rare functional variants throughout the exome may contribute to the overall risk in patients with severe disease. This assumption is consistent with the omnigenic model of the relationship between genetic and phenotypic variation in complex traits, according to which association signals tend to spread across most of the genome through gene regulatory networks from genes outside the major pathways to disease-related genes. We performed whole-exome sequencing and compared the burden of rare variants in 57 patients with severe and 29 patients with mild/moderate COVID-19. At the whole-exome level, we observed an excess of rare, predominantly high-impact (HI) variants in the group with severe COVID-19. Restriction to genes intolerant to HI or damaging missense variants increased enrichment for these classes of variants. Among various sets of genes, an increased signal of rare HI variants was demonstrated predominantly for primary immunodeficiency genes and the entire set of genes associated with immune diseases, as well as for genes associated with respiratory diseases. We advocate taking the ideas of the omnigenic model into account in COVID-19 studies.

The link between rheumatic disorders and inborn errors of immunity

Inborn errors of immunity (IEIs) are immunological disorders characterized by variable susceptibility to infections, immune dysregulation and/or malignancies, as a consequence of damaging germline variants in single genes. Though initially identified among patients with unusual, severe or recurrent infections, non-infectious manifestations and especially immune dysregulation in the form of autoimmunity or autoinflammation can be the first or dominant phenotypic aspect of IEIs. An increasing number of IEIs causing autoimmunity or autoinflammation, including rheumatic disease have been reported over the last decade. Despite their rarity, identification of those disorders provided insight into the pathomechanisms of immune dysregulation, which may be relevant for understanding the pathogenesis of systemic rheumatic disorders. In this review, we present novel IEIs primarily causing autoimmunity or autoinflammation along with their pathogenic mechanisms. In addition, we explore the likely pathophysiological and clinical relevance of IEIs in systemic rheumatic disorders.

Serum amyloid A proteins reduce bone mass during mycobacterial infections

Introduction

Osteopenia has been associated to several inflammatory conditions, including mycobacterial infections. How mycobacteria cause bone loss remains elusive, but direct bone infection may not be required.

Methods

Genetically engineered mice and morphometric, transcriptomic, and functional analyses were used. Additionally, inflammatory mediators and bone turnover markers were measured in the serum of healthy controls, individuals with latent tuberculosis and patients with active tuberculosis.

Results and discussion

We found that infection with Mycobacterium avium impacts bone turnover by decreasing bone formation and increasing bone resorption, in an IFNγ- and TNFα-dependent manner. IFNγ produced during infection enhanced macrophage TNFα secretion, which in turn increased the production of serum amyloid A (SAA) 3. Saa3 expression was upregulated in the bone of both M. avium- and M. tuberculosis-infected mice and SAA1 and 2 proteins (that share a high homology with murine SAA3 protein) were increased in the serum of patients with active tuberculosis. Furthermore, the increased SAA levels seen in active tuberculosis patients correlated with altered serum bone turnover markers. Additionally, human SAA proteins impaired bone matrix deposition and increased osteoclastogenesis in vitro. Overall, we report a novel crosstalk between the cytokine-SAA network operating in macrophages and bone homeostasis. These findings contribute to a better understanding of the mechanisms of bone loss during infection and open the way to pharmacological intervention. Additionally, our data and disclose SAA proteins as potential biomarkers of bone loss during infection by mycobacteria.

A Novel RAC2 Mutation Causing Combined Immunodeficiency

PURPOSE

Ras-related C3 botulinum toxin substrate 2 (RAC2) acts as a molecular switch and has crucial roles in cell signaling and actin dynamics. A broad spectrum of genetic RAC2 mutations can cause various types of primary immunodeficiency, with complete penetrance. Here, we report a novel heterozygous missense mutation in RAC2 with incomplete penetrance, and the associated phenotypes, in a Chinese family.

METHODS

Immunological phenotype was detected by flow cytometry. T cell receptor excision circles (TRECs) and K-deleting recombination excision circles (KRECs) were assessed by real-time quantitative PCR. Gene mutations were detected by whole-exome sequencing (WES) and confirmed by Sanger sequencing.

RESULTS

The proband was an 11-year-old girl who presented with recurrent respiratory infections, bronchiectasis, persistent Epstein-Barr virus viremia, infectious mononucleosis, encephalitis, and cutaneous human papillomavirus infections. Laboratory analyses revealed increased serum IgG and decreased IgM levels, reduced naïve CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ T cells, an inverted CD4⁺/CD8⁺ ratio, and low TREC and KREC numbers. The mutation resulted in increased production of reactive oxygen species, while impaired actin polarization in neutrophils; diminished proliferative responses, increased cytokine production and a dysregulated phenotype in T lymphocytes; as well as accelerated apoptosis and hyperactivity of AKT in HL-60 human leukemia cells. WES identified a c.44G > A mutation in RAC2 resulting in a p.G15D substitution. Despite sharing the same mutation as the proband, her father suffered from recurrent respiratory infections and bronchiectasis, and had similar immunological defects, whereas her sister was apparently healthy, other than cutaneous human papillomavirus infections, and only mild immunological defects were detected preliminarily.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings broaden the clinical and genetic spectra of RAC2 mutations and underline the importance of RAC2 gain-of-function mutations with complete or incomplete penetrance.

Gene-environment interactions in birth defect etiology: Challenges and opportunities

Birth defects are relatively common congenital outcomes that significantly impact affected individuals, their families, and communities. Effective development and deployment of prevention and therapeutic strategies for these conditions requires sufficient understanding of etiology, including underlying genetic and environmental causes. Tremendous progress has been made in defining the genetic basis of familial and syndromic forms of birth defects. However, the majority of birth defect cases are considered nonsyndromic and thought to result from multifactorial gene-environment interactions. While substantial advances have been made in elucidating the genetic landscape of these etiologically complex conditions, significant biological and technical constraints have stymied progress toward a refined knowledge of environmental risk factors. Defining specific gene-environment interactions in birth defect etiology is even more challenging. However, progress has been made, including demonstration of critical proofs of concept and development of new conceptual and technical approaches for resolving complex gene-environment interactions. In this review, we discuss current views of multifactorial birth defect etiology, comparing them with other diseases that also involve gene-environment interactions, including primary immunodeficiency and cancer. We describe how various model systems have illuminated mechanisms of multifactorial etiology and these models' individual strengths and weaknesses. Finally, suggestions for areas of future emphasis are proposed.

Designing Studies for Epigenetic Biomarker Development in Autoimmune Rheumatic Diseases

In just a few years, the number of epigenetic studies in autoimmune rheumatic and inflammatory diseases has greatly increased. This is in part due to the need of identifying additional determinants to genetics to explain the pathogenesis and development of these disorders. In this regard, epigenetics provides potential mechanisms that determine gene function, are linked to environmental factors, and could explain a wide range of phenotypic variability among patients with these diseases. Despite the high interest and number of studies describing epigenetic alterations under these conditions and exploring their relationship to various clinical aspects, few of the proposed biomarkers have yet reached clinical practice. The potential of epigenetic markers is high, as these alterations link measurable features with a number of biological traits. In the present article, we present published studies in the field, discuss some frequent limitations in the existing research, and propose a number of considerations that should be taken into account by those starting new projects in the field, with an aim to generate biomarkers that could make it into the clinics.

Clinical genomics and precision medicine

Precision Medicine emerges from the genomic paradigm of health and disease. For precise molecular diagnoses of genetic diseases, we must analyze the Whole Exome (WES) or the Whole Genome (WGS). By not needing exon capture, WGS is more powerful to detect single nucleotide variants and copy number variants. In healthy individuals, we can observe monogenic highly penetrant variants, which may be causally responsible for diseases, and also susceptibility variants, associated with common polygenic diseases. But there is the major problem of penetrance. Thus, there is the question of whether it is worthwhile to perform WGS in all healthy individuals as a step towards Precision Medicine. The genetic architecture of disease is consistent with the fact that they are all polygenic. Moreover, ancestry adds another layer of complexity. We are now capable of obtaining Polygenic Risk Scores for all complex diseases using only data from new generation sequencing. Yet, review of available evidence does not at present favor the idea that WGS analyses are sufficiently developed to allow reliable predictions of the risk components for monogenic and polygenic hereditary diseases in healthy individuals. Probably, it is still better for WGS to remain reserved for the diagnosis of pathogenic variants of Mendelian diseases.

Individual Genetic Heterogeneity

Genetic variation has been widely covered in literature, however, not from the perspective of an individual in any species. Here, a synthesis of genetic concepts and variations relevant for individual genetic constitution is provided. All the different levels of genetic information and variation are covered, ranging from whether an organism is unmixed or hybrid, has variations in genome, chromosomes, and more locally in DNA regions, to epigenetic variants or alterations in selfish genetic elements. Genetic constitution and heterogeneity of microbiota are highly relevant for health and wellbeing of an individual. Mutation rates vary widely for variation types, e.g., due to the sequence context. Genetic information guides numerous aspects in organisms. Types of inheritance, whether Mendelian or non-Mendelian, zygosity, sexual reproduction, and sex determination are covered. Functions of DNA and functional effects of variations are introduced, along with mechanism that reduce and modulate functional effects, including TARAR countermeasures and intraindividual genetic conflict. TARAR countermeasures for tolerance, avoidance, repair, attenuation, and resistance are essential for life, integrity of genetic information, and gene expression. The genetic composition, effects of variations, and their expression are considered also in diseases and personalized medicine. The text synthesizes knowledge and insight on individual genetic heterogeneity and organizes and systematizes the central concepts.

Identification of variants in genes associated with autoinflammatory disorders in a cohort of patients with psoriatic arthritis

Objectives

Besides adaptive immunity genes, genetic risk factors for psoriatic arthritis (PsA) include innate immunity loci, which suggests an autoinflammatory disease mechanism, at least in a subset of patients. Here, we aimed at investigating the autoinflammatory genetic background of PsA.

Methods

A total of 120 patients with PsA visiting the outpatient clinics of the Hannover University hospital underwent targeted next-generation sequencing, searching for variations in genes linked with inborn errors of immunity classified as autoinflammatory disorders (AIDs). Deleteriousness of rare variants was evaluated through in silico analysis.

Results

We found 45 rare predicted deleterious variants in 37 out of 120 (30.8%) patients with PsA. Relatively common were variants in AP1S3, PLCG2, NOD2 and NLRP12. All 45 variants were monoallelic and 25 of them, identified in 20 out of 120 (16.7%) patients, were localised in genes associated with autosomal dominant (AD) disorders. Detection of those variants is associated with pustular psoriasis or a coexisting inflammatory bowel disease (IBD).

Conclusions

Approximately 30% of patients with PsA harboured at least one variant in a gene associated with an AID, suggesting an autoinflammatory disease mechanism. Detection of variants in genes linked to AD-AIDs may explain extra-articular manifestations of PsA, such as pustular psoriasis and IBD.

Rare genetic variants in genes and loci linked to dominant monogenic developmental disorders cause milder related phenotypes in the general population

Many rare monogenic diseases are known to be caused by deleterious variants in thousands of genes, however the same variants can also be found in people without the associated clinical phenotypes. The penetrance of these monogenic variants is generally unknown in the wider population, as they are typically identified in small clinical cohorts of affected individuals and families with highly penetrant variants. Here, we investigated the phenotypic effect of rare, potentially deleterious variants in genes and loci where similar variants are known to cause monogenic developmental disorders (DDs) in a large population cohort. We used UK Biobank to investigate phenotypes associated with rare protein-truncating and missense variants in 599 monoallelic DDG2P genes by using whole-exome-sequencing data from ∼200,000 individuals and rare copy-number variants overlapping known DD loci by using SNP-array data from ∼500,000 individuals. We found that individuals with these likely deleterious variants had a mild DD-related phenotype, including lower fluid intelligence, slower reaction times, lower numeric memory scores, and longer pairs matching times compared to the rest of the UK Biobank cohort. They were also shorter, had a higher BMI, and had significant socioeconomic disadvantages: they were less likely to be employed or be able to work and had a lower income and higher deprivation index. Our findings suggest that many genes routinely tested within pediatric genetics have deleterious variants with intermediate penetrance that may cause lifelong sub-clinical phenotypes in the general adult population.

Postzygotic mutations and where to find them - Recent advances and future implications in the field of non-neoplastic somatic mosaicism

The technological progress of massively parallel sequencing (MPS) has triggered a remarkable development in the research on postzygotic mutations. Although the overwhelming majority of studies in the field focus on oncogenesis, non-neoplastic diseases are attracting more and more attention. The aim of this review was to summarize some of the most recent findings in the field of somatic mosaicism in diseases other than neoplastic events. We discuss the abundance and role of postzygotic mutations, with a special emphasis on disorders which occur only in a mosaic form (obligatory mosaic diseases; OMDs). Based on the list of OMDs compiled from the published literature and three databases (OMIM, Orphanet and MosaicBase), we demonstrate the prevalence of cancer-related genes across OMDs and suggest other sources to further explore OMDs and OMD-related genes. Additionally, we comment on some practical aspects related to mosaic diseases, such as approaches to tissue sampling, the MPS coverage required to detect variants at a very low frequency, as well as on bioinformatic and molecular tools dedicated to detect somatic mutations in MPS data.

Human OTULIN haploinsufficiency impairs cell-intrinsic immunity to staphylococcal α-toxin

The molecular basis of interindividual clinical variability upon infection with Staphylococcus aureus is unclear. We describe patients with haploinsufficiency for the linear deubiquitinase OTULIN, encoded by a gene on chromosome 5p. Patients suffer from episodes of life-threatening necrosis, typically triggered by S. aureus infection. The disorder is phenocopied in patients with the 5p- (Cri-du-Chat) chromosomal deletion syndrome. OTULIN haploinsufficiency causes an accumulation of linear ubiquitin in dermal fibroblasts, but tumor necrosis factor receptor-mediated nuclear factor κB signaling remains intact. Blood leukocyte subsets are unaffected. The OTULIN-dependent accumulation of caveolin-1 in dermal fibroblasts, but not leukocytes, facilitates the cytotoxic damage inflicted by the staphylococcal virulence factor α-toxin. Naturally elicited antibodies against α-toxin contribute to incomplete clinical penetrance. Human OTULIN haploinsufficiency underlies life-threatening staphylococcal disease by disrupting cell-intrinsic immunity to α-toxin in nonleukocytic cells.

Targeted RNAseq Improves Clinical Diagnosis of Very Early-Onset Pediatric Immune Dysregulation

Despite increased use of whole exome sequencing (WES) for the clinical analysis of rare disease, overall diagnostic yield for most disorders hovers around 30%. Previous studies of mRNA have succeeded in increasing diagnoses for clearly defined disorders of monogenic inheritance. We asked if targeted RNA sequencing could provide similar benefits for primary immunodeficiencies (PIDs) and very early-onset inflammatory bowel disease (VEOIBD), both of which are difficult to diagnose due to high heterogeneity and variable severity. We performed targeted RNA sequencing of a panel of 260 immune-related genes for a cohort of 13 patients (seven suspected PID cases and six VEOIBD) and analyzed variants, splicing, and exon usage. Exonic variants were identified in seven cases, some of which had been previously prioritized by exome sequencing. For four cases, allele specific expression or lack thereof provided additional insights into possible disease mechanisms. In addition, we identified five instances of aberrant splicing associated with four variants. Three of these variants had been previously classified as benign in ClinVar based on population frequency. Digenic or oligogenic inheritance is suggested for at least two patients. In addition to validating the use of targeted RNA sequencing, our results show that rare disease research will benefit from incorporating contributing genetic factors into the diagnostic approach.

A novel FAM83H variant causes familial amelogenesis imperfecta with incomplete penetrance

Background

Amelogenesis imperfecta (AI) is known to be a monogenic genetic disease caused by a variety of genes demonstrating a wide spectrum of penetrance. FAM83H is reported to be involved in AI: however, whether FAM83H causes AI with incomplete penetrance is unclear.

Methods

Whole‐exome sequencing was performed on two patients with AI, and putative disease‐related variants were validated by Sanger sequencing. Bioinformatic and in vitro functional analyses were performed to functionally characterize the identified disease‐causing variants.

Results

We identified a novel heterozygous nonsense variant of FAM83H (NM_198488: c.1975G > T, p.Glu659Ter); in vitro functional analysis showed that this mutant produced mislocalized proteins and was deleterious. Surprisingly, the clinical manifestations of each of the six individuals carrying this variant were different, with one carrier appearing to be completely asymptomatic for AI.

Conclusion

Our findings expand the variant spectrum for FAM83H and the phenotypic spectrum for FAM83H‐associated AI and suggest that FAM83H‐mediated AI exhibits incomplete penetrance.

[When to consider type I interferonopathy in adulthood?]

Type I interferonopathies (IP1) are a heterogeneous group of Mendelian diseases characterized by overactivation of the type I interferon (IFN) pathway. They are caused by monogenic (rarely digenic) mutations of proteins involved in this key pathway of innate immunity. IP1 transmission can be dominant, recessive or X-linked and penetrance differs from one IP1 to another. The clinical spectrum is broad and mainly includes central nervous system involvement with calcifications of the basal ganglia, skin disorders such as cutaneous vasculitis that can be mutilating. Joint disorders including non-destructive deforming arthropathy, pulmonary involvement such as intra-alveolar haemorrhage or interstitial lung disease, and haematological symptoms with cytopenia and/or immune deficiency are also seen. The clinical manifestations vary from one IP1 to another and their spectrum is constantly expanding along with the description of new IP1s and patients. The inflammatory syndrome is generally mild and autoimmune stigmata are frequently found. Almost all patients display overexpression of the type I IFN pathway detected, for instance, by the evaluation of IFN-stimulated genes expression, referred as "interferon signature". The related morbidity and mortality are high. However, the beneficial effect on certain symptoms of targeted therapies inhibiting type I IFN, such as JAK inhibitors, has led to a promising improvement in the management of these patients.

Lung Inflammation in STING-Associated Vasculopathy with Onset in Infancy (SAVI)

STING-associated vasculopathy with onset in infancy (SAVI) is a type I interferonopathy caused by gain-of-function mutations in STING1 encoding stimulator of interferon genes (STING) protein. SAVI is characterized by severe inflammatory lung disease, a feature not observed in previously described type I interferonopathies i.e., Mendelian autoinflammatory disorders defined by constitutive activation of the type I interferon (IFN) pathway. Molecular defects in nucleic acid metabolism or sensing are central to the pathophysiology of these diseases, with such defects occurring at any step of the tightly regulated pathway of type I IFN production and signaling (e.g., exonuclease loss of function, RNA-DNA hybrid accumulation, constitutive activation of adaptor proteins such as STING). Among over 30 genotypes, SAVI and COPA syndrome, whose pathophysiology was recently linked to a constitutive activation of STING signaling, are the only type I interferonopathies presenting with predominant lung involvement. Lung disease is the leading cause of morbidity and mortality in these two disorders which do not respond to conventional immunosuppressive therapies and only partially to JAK1/2 inhibitors. In human silicosis, STING-dependent sensing of self-DNA following cell death triggered by silica exposure has been found to drive lung inflammation in mice and human models. These recent findings support a key role for STING and nucleic acid sensing in the homeostasis of intrinsic pulmonary inflammation. However, mechanisms by which monogenic defects in the STING pathway lead to pulmonary damages are not yet fully elucidated, and an improved understanding of such mechanisms is fundamental to improved future patient management. Here, we review the recent insights into the pathophysiology of SAVI and outline our current understanding of self-nucleic acid-mediated lung inflammation in humans.

The type I interferonopathies: 10 years on

As brutally demonstrated by the COVID-19 pandemic, an effective immune system is essential for survival. Developed over evolutionary time, viral nucleic acid detection is a central pillar in the defensive armamentarium used to combat foreign microbial invasion. To ensure cellular homeostasis, such a strategy necessitates the efficient discrimination of pathogen-derived DNA and RNA from that of the host. In 2011, it was suggested that an upregulation of type I interferon signalling might serve as a defining feature of a novel set of Mendelian inborn errors of immunity, where antiviral sensors are triggered by host nucleic acids due to a failure of self versus non-self discrimination. These rare disorders have played a surprisingly significant role in informing our understanding of innate immunity and the relevance of type I interferon signalling for human health and disease. Here we consider what we have learned in this time, and how the field may develop in the future.

Incomplete Penetrance and Variable Expressivity: From Clinical Studies to Population Cohorts

The same genetic variant found in different individuals can cause a range of diverse phenotypes, from no discernible clinical phenotype to severe disease, even among related individuals. Such variants can be said to display incomplete penetrance, a binary phenomenon where the genotype either causes the expected clinical phenotype or it does not, or they can be said to display variable expressivity, in which the same genotype can cause a wide range of clinical symptoms across a spectrum. Both incomplete penetrance and variable expressivity are thought to be caused by a range of factors, including common variants, variants in regulatory regions, epigenetics, environmental factors, and lifestyle. Many thousands of genetic variants have been identified as the cause of monogenic disorders, mostly determined through small clinical studies, and thus, the penetrance and expressivity of these variants may be overestimated when compared to their effect on the general population. With the wealth of population cohort data currently available, the penetrance and expressivity of such genetic variants can be investigated across a much wider contingent, potentially helping to reclassify variants that were previously thought to be completely penetrant. Research into the penetrance and expressivity of such genetic variants is important for clinical classification, both for determining causative mechanisms of disease in the affected population and for providing accurate risk information through genetic counseling. A genotype-based definition of the causes of rare diseases incorporating information from population cohorts and clinical studies is critical for our understanding of incomplete penetrance and variable expressivity. This review examines our current knowledge of the penetrance and expressivity of genetic variants in rare disease and across populations, as well as looking into the potential causes of the variation seen, including genetic modifiers, mosaicism, and polygenic factors, among others. We also considered the challenges that come with investigating penetrance and expressivity.

Identification of Germline Monoallelic Mutations in IKZF2 in Patients with Immune Dysregulation

Helios, encoded by IKZF2, is a member of the Ikaros family of transcription factors with pivotal roles in T-follicular helper, NK- and T-regulatory cell physiology. Somatic IKZF2 mutations are frequently found in lymphoid malignancies. Although germline mutations in IKZF1 and IKZF3, encoding Ikaros and Aiolos, have recently been identified in patients with phenotypically similar immunodeficiency syndromes, the effect of germline mutations in IKZF2 on human hematopoiesis and immunity remains enigmatic. We identified germline IKZF2 mutations (one nonsense (p.R291X)- and 4 distinct missense variants) in six patients with systemic lupus erythematosus, immune thrombocytopenia or EBV-associated hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis. Patients exhibited hypogammaglobulinemia, decreased number of T-follicular helper and NK-cells. Single-cell RNA sequencing of PBMCs from the patient carrying the R291X variant revealed upregulation of pro-inflammatory genes associated with T-cell receptor activation and T-cell exhaustion. Functional assays revealed the inability of HeliosR291X to homodimerize and bind target DNA as dimers. Moreover, proteomic analysis by proximity-dependent Biotin Identification revealed aberrant interaction of 3/5 Helios mutants with core components of the NuRD complex conveying HELIOS-mediated epigenetic and transcriptional dysregulation.

Monogenic Adult-Onset Inborn Errors of Immunity

Inborn errors of immunity (IEI) are a heterogenous group of disorders driven by genetic defects that functionally impact the development and/or function of the innate and/or adaptive immune system. The majority of these disorders are thought to have polygenic background. However, the use of next-generation sequencing in patients with IEI has led to an increasing identification of monogenic causes, unravelling the exact pathophysiology of the disease and allowing the development of more targeted treatments. Monogenic IEI are not only seen in a pediatric population but also in adulthood, either due to the lack of awareness preventing childhood diagnosis or due to a delayed onset where (epi)genetic or environmental factors can play a role. In this review, we discuss the mechanisms accounting for adult-onset presentations and provide an overview of monogenic causes associated with adult-onset IEI.

Five novel copy number variations detected in patients with familial exudative vitreoretinopathy

Purpose

Familial exudative vitreoretinopathy (FEVR) is an inherited retinal vascular disease genetically heterogeneous with multiple causative genes. The aim of this study is to report five novel copy number variation (CNV) regions in FEVR patients and to investigate the possible contributions of novel CNVs to FEVR.

Methods

In this study, 824 FEVR families were collected. All cases were performed using the targeted next generation sequencing (NGS) assay, and families with no definite pathogenic mutations in FEVR genes were screened for CNVs according to the NGS results. Droplet digital polymerase chain reaction (ddPCR) testing was introduced to validate the screened CNV regions. We also reviewed the clinical presentations of the probands and affected family members associated with the novel CNVs and conducted segregation analysis.

Results

Five CNVs in five patients were detected in this study: heterozygous deletions of kinesin family member 11 (KIF11) exons 2-4, KIF11 exon 11, KIF11 exons 1-10, tetraspanin-12 (TSPAN12) exons 1-3, and low-density lipoprotein receptor-related protein 5 (LRP5) exons 19-21. Among the five affected families, TSPAN12 exons 1-3 heterozygous deletion and LRP5 exons 19-21 heterozygous deletion originate from the mother and the father of the proband, respectively. No other family members manifested as FEVR except for the probands. The correlation between disease severity and CNV loci seems uncertain.

Conclusions

Five novel CNV loci in FEVR patients were uncovered in this study, including one maternally-inherited and one paternally-inherited CNV region. Though there is no evidence of co-segregation between these CNVs and FEVR, our findings suggest novel genetic risk factors for FEVR.

Activated PI3Kδ syndrome, an immunodeficiency disorder, leads to sensorimotor deficits recapitulated in a murine model

The phosphoinositide-3-kinase (PI3K) family plays a major role in cell signaling and is predominant in leukocytes. Gain-of-function (GOF) mutations in the PIK3CD gene lead to the development of activated PI3Kδ syndrome (APDS), a rare primary immunodeficiency disorder. A subset of APDS patients also displays neurodevelopmental delay symptoms, suggesting a potential role of PIK3CD in cognitive and behavioural function. However, the extent and nature of the neurodevelopmental deficits has not been previously quantified. Here, we assessed the cognitive functions of two APDS patients, and investigated the causal role of the PIK3CD GOF mutation in neurological deficits using a murine model of this disease. We used p110δ^E1020K knock-in mice, harbouring the most common APDS mutation in patients. We found that APDS patients present with visuomotor deficits, exacerbated by autism spectrum disorder comorbidity, whereas p110δ^E1020K mice exhibited impairments in motor behaviour, learning and repetitive behaviour patterning. Our data indicate that PIK3CD GOF mutations increase the risk for neurodevelopmental deficits, supporting previous findings on the interplay between the nervous and the immune system. Further, our results validate the knock-in mouse model, and offer an objective assessment tool for patients that could be incorporated in diagnosis and in the evaluation of treatments.

Maximizing insights from monogenic immune disorders

Monogenic immune disorders provide unprecedented insights into the consequences of disrupting single genes in humans, thereby informing our understanding of fundamental immune function and disease. Genomics has accelerated monogenic disease discovery while also revealing the complexity of human disease, where several factors beyond the genome can govern pathogenesis. At this juncture, the optimal path forward will focus on maximizing basic and translational immunology insights from these disorders. This pursuit will be most direct and impactful if human disease gene discovery is paired with mechanistic studies employing integrative omics and mouse modeling to leverage their unique strengths.

Reducing Delays in Diagnosing Primary Immunodeficiency Through the Development and Implementation of a Clinical Decision Support Tool: A Study Protocol

Background

Primary immunodeficiencies (PIs) are a set of heterogeneous chronic disorders characterized by immune dysfunction. They are diagnostically challenging because of their clinical heterogeneity, knowledge gaps among primary care physicians, and continuing shortages of clinically trained immunologists. As a result, patients with undiagnosed PIs are at increased risk for recurrent infections, cancers, and autoimmune diseases.

Objective

The aim of this research is to develop and implement a clinical decision support (CDS) tool for the identification of underlying PIs.

Methods

We will develop and implement a CDS tool for the identification of underlying PIs among patients who receive primary care through a health care provider at the University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics. The CDS tool will function through an algorithm that is based on the Immune Deficiency Foundation’s 10 Warning Signs for Primary Immunodeficiency. Over the course of a year, we will use Lean Six Sigma principles and the Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, and Control (DMAIC) framework to guide the project. The primary measure is the number of newly diagnosed PI patients per month. Secondary measures include the following: (1) the number of new patients identified by the CDS as being at high risk for PI, (2) the number of new PI cases in which immunoglobulin replacement or rotating antibiotics are started, (3) the cost of evaluation of each patient identified by the CDS tool as being at high risk for PIs, (4) the number of new consults not diagnosed with a PI, and (5) patient satisfaction with the process of referral to the Immunology Clinic.

Results

This study was determined to not be Human Subjects Research by the Institutional Review Board at the University of Iowa. Data collection will begin in August 2021.

Conclusions

The development and implementation of a CDS tool is a promising approach to identifying patients with underlying PI. This protocol assesses whether such an approach will be able to achieve its objective of reducing diagnostic delays. The disciplined approach, using Lean Six Sigma and the DMAIC framework, will guide implementation to maximize opportunities for a successful intervention that meets the study’s goals and objectives as well as to allow for replication and adaptation of these methods at other sites.

International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID)

PRR1-10.2196/32635

Genetic screening of children with marrow failure. The role of primary Immunodeficiencies

The differential diagnosis of marrow failure (MF) is crucial in the diagnostic work-up, since genetic forms require specific care. We retrospectively studied all patients with single/multi-lineage MF evaluated in a single-center to identify the type and incidence of underlying molecular defects. The diepoxybutane test was used to screen Fanconi Anemia. Other congenital MFs have been searched using Sanger and/or Next Generation Sequencing analysis, depending on the available tools over the years. Between 2009-2019, 97 patients (aged 0-32 years-median 5) with single-lineage (29%) or multilineage (68%) MF were evaluated. Fifty-three (54%) and 28 (29%) were diagnosed with acquired and congenital MF, respectively. The remaining 16 (17%), with trilinear (n=9) and monolinear (n=7) MF, were found to have an underlying primary immunodeficiency (PID) and showed clinical and biochemical signs of immune-dysregulation in 10/16 (62%) and in 14/16 (87%) of cases, respectively. Clinical signs were also found in 22/53 (41%) and 8/28 (28%) patients with idiopathic and classical cMF, respectively. Eight out of 16 PIDs patients were successfully transplanted, four received immunosuppression, two did not require treatment, and the remaining two died. We show that patients with single/multi-lineage MF may have underlying PIDs in a considerable number of cases and that MF may represent a relevant clinical sign in patients with PIDs, thus widening their clinical phenotype. An accurate immunological work-up should be performed in all patients with MF, and PID-related genes should be considered when screening MF in order to identify disorders that may receive targeted treatments and/or appropriate conditioning regimens before transplant.

One Gene, Many Facets: Multiple Immune Pathway Dysregulation in SOCS1 Haploinsufficiency

Background

Inborn errors of immunity (IEI) present with a large phenotypic spectrum of disease, which can pose diagnostic and therapeutic challenges. Suppressor of cytokine signaling 1 (SOCS1) is a key negative regulator of cytokine signaling, and has recently been associated with a novel IEI. Of patients described to date, it is apparent that SOCS1 haploinsufficiency has a pleiotropic effect in humans.

Objective

We sought to investigate whether dysregulation of immune pathways, in addition to STAT1, play a role in the broad clinical manifestations of SOCS1 haploinsufficiency.

Methods

We assessed impacts of reduced SOCS1 expression across multiple immune cell pathways utilizing patient cells and CRISPR/Cas9 edited primary human T cells.

Results

SOCS1 haploinsufficiency phenotypes straddled across the International Union of Immunological Societies classifications of IEI. We found that reduced SOCS1 expression led to dysregulation of multiple intracellular pathways in immune cells. STAT1 phosphorylation is enhanced, comparably with STAT1 gain-of-function mutations, and STAT3 phosphorylation is similarly reduced with concurrent reduction of Th17 cells. Furthermore, reduced SOCS1 E3 ligase function was associated with increased FAK1 in immune cells, and increased AKT and p70 ribosomal protein S6 kinase phosphorylation. We also found Toll-like receptor responses are increased in SOCS1 haploinsufficiency patients.

Conclusions

SOCS1 haploinsufficiency is a pleiotropic monogenic IEI. Dysregulation of multiple immune cell pathways may explain the variable clinical phenotype associated with this new condition. Knowledge of these additional dysregulated immune pathways is important when considering the optimum management for SOCS1 haploinsufficient patients.

Targeted NGS Yields Plentiful Ultra-Rare Variants in Inborn Errors of Immunity Patients

Inborn errors of immunity (IEI) include a large group of inherited diseases sharing either poor, dysregulated, or absent and/or acquired function in one or more components of the immune system. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) has driven a rapid increase in the recognition of such defects, though the wide heterogeneity of genetically diverse but phenotypically overlapping diseases has often prevented the molecular characterization of the most complex patients. Two hundred and seventy-two patients were submitted to three successive NGS-based gene panels composed of 58, 146, and 312 genes. Along with pathogenic and likely pathogenic causative gene variants, accounting for the corresponding disorders (37/272 patients, 13.6%), a number of either rare (probably) damaging variants in genes unrelated to patients’ phenotype, variants of unknown significance (VUS) in genes consistent with their clinics, or apparently inconsistent benign, likely benign, or VUS variants were also detected. Finally, a remarkable amount of yet unreported variants of unknown significance were also found, often recurring in our dataset. The NGS approach demonstrated an expected IEI diagnostic rate. However, defining the appropriate list of genes for these panels may not be straightforward, and the application of unbiased approaches should be taken into consideration, especially when patients show atypical clinical pictures.

Human TBK1 deficiency leads to autoinflammation driven by TNF-induced cell death

TANK binding kinase 1 (TBK1) regulates IFN-I, NF-κB, and TNF-induced RIPK1-dependent cell death (RCD). In mice, biallelic loss of TBK1 is embryonically lethal. We discovered four humans, ages 32, 26, 7, and 8 from three unrelated consanguineous families with homozygous loss-of-function mutations in TBK1. All four patients suffer from chronic and systemic autoinflammation, but not severe viral infections. We demonstrate that TBK1 loss results in hypomorphic but sufficient IFN-I induction via RIG-I/MDA5, while the system retains near intact IL-6 induction through NF-κB. Autoinflammation is driven by TNF-induced RCD as patient-derived fibroblasts experienced higher rates of necroptosis in vitro, and CC3 was elevated in peripheral blood ex vivo. Treatment with anti-TNF dampened the baseline circulating inflammatory profile and ameliorated the clinical condition in vivo. These findings highlight the plasticity of the IFN-I response and underscore a cardinal role for TBK1 in the regulation of RCD.

An overview of germline variations in genes of primary immunodeficiences through integrative analysis of ClinVar, HGMD® and dbSNP databases

Primary immunodeficiencies (PID) are a diverse group of genetic disorders caused by inadequate development and function of immune system. Identifying genetic etiology is important for genetic counselling and treatment decisions. Clinical relevance of genetic variants is a complex problem depending on gene-specific and variant specific genotype-phenotype interactions. To address this challenge, we aimed to characterize the pathogenic landscape of PID genes by combining the analysis of germline variations reported in ClinVar and HGMD^® and identification of damaging variations available in dbSNP. We generated a joint ClinVar/HGMD database, which included 111,940 variants, among them 32,452 were classified as pathogenic/likely pathogenic. From a total of 5,415,794 bi- or multiallelic variants in PID genes recorded in dbSNP, we retrieved 38,291 high impact (HI) biallelic variants with presumably disruptive impact in the protein, of them 25,500 variants were not present in ClinVar/HGMD. Using a functional prediction algorithm, we additionally identified 28,507 deleterious and 56,016 neutral missense variants among dbSNP variants and created a collection of damaging and neutral variations in PID genes, not currently present in ClinVar/HGMD, with their allele frequencies and mappings to protein domains. The distribution of pathogenic variants from ClinVar/HGMD, HI variants and deleterious missense variants from dbSNP was analyzed in the context of hereditary pattern and gene specific metrics, such as pLI and haploinsufficiency. Our report summarized data on complex gene-specific variability in PID genes and might be useful for the identification of the most promising variants and gene regions for further study.

Approach to genetic diagnosis of inborn errors of immunity through next-generation sequencing

Patients with inborn errors of immunity (IEI) present with a heterogeneous clinical and immunological phenotype, therefore a correct molecular diagnosis is crucial for the classification and subsequent therapeutic management. On the other hand, IEI are a group of rare congenital diseases with highly diverse features and, in most cases, an as yet unknown genetic etiology. Next generation sequencing has facilitated genetic examinations of rare inherited disorders during the recent years, thus allowing a suitable molecular diagnosis in the IEI patients. This review aimed to investigate the current findings about these techniques in the field of IEI, suggesting an efficient stepwise approach to molecular diagnosis of inborn errors of immunity.

Strategies to Uplift Novel Mendelian Gene Discovery for Improved Clinical Outcomes

Rare genetic disorders, while individually rare, are collectively common. They represent some of the most severe disorders affecting patients worldwide with significant morbidity and mortality. Over the last decade, advances in genomic methods have significantly uplifted diagnostic rates for patients and facilitated novel and targeted therapies. However, many patients with rare genetic disorders still remain undiagnosed as the genetic etiology of only a proportion of Mendelian conditions has been discovered to date. This article explores existing strategies to identify novel Mendelian genes and how these discoveries impact clinical care and therapeutics. We discuss the importance of data sharing, phenotype-driven approaches, patient-led approaches, utilization of large-scale genomic sequencing projects, constraint-based methods, integration of multi-omics data, and gene-to-patient methods. We further consider the health economic advantages of novel gene discovery and speculate on potential future methods for improved clinical outcomes.

The New "Wholly Trinity" in the Diagnosis and Management of Inborn Errors of Immunity

The field of immunology has a rich and diverse history, and the study of inborn errors of immunity (IEIs) represents both the "cake" and the "icing on top of the cake," as it has enabled significant advances in our understanding of the human immune system. This explosion of knowledge has been facilitated by a unique partnership, a triumvirate formed by the physician who gathers detailed immunological and clinical phenotypic information from, and shares results with, the patient; the laboratory scientist/immunologist who performs diagnostic testing, as well as advanced functional correlative studies; and the genomics scientist/genetic counselor, who conducts and interprets varied genetic analyses, all of which are essential for dissecting constitutional genetic disorders. Although the basic principles of clinical care have not changed in recent years, the practice of clinical immunology has changed to reflect the prodigious advances in diagnostics, genomics, and therapeutics. An "omic/tics"-centric approach to IEI reflects the tremendous strides made in the field in the new millennium with recognition of new disorders, characterization of the molecular underpinnings, and development and implementation of personalized treatment strategies. This review brings renewed attention to bear on the indispensable "trinity" of phenotypic, genomic, and immunological analyses in the diagnosis, management, and treatment of IEIs.

Comprehensive comparison between 222 CTLA-4 haploinsufficiency and 212 LRBA deficiency patients: a systematic review

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte antigen 4 (CTLA-4) haploinsufficiency (CHAI) and lipopolysaccharide-responsive beige-like anchor (LRBA) deficiency (LATAIE) are newly identified inborn errors of immunity with shared molecular pathomechanisms and clinical manifestations. In this review, we aimed to provide differential comparisons regarding demographic, clinical, immunological and molecular characteristics between these two similar conditions. A literature search was conducted in PubMed, Web of Science and Scopus databases and included studies were systematically evaluated. Overall, 434 (222 CHAI and 212 LATAIE) patients were found in 101 eligible studies. The CHAI patients were mainly reported from North America and western Europe, while LATAIE patients were predominantly from Asian countries. In CHAI, positive familial history (P < 0·001) and in LATAIE, consanguineous parents (P < 0·001) were more common. In CHAI patients the rates of granulomas (P < 0·001), malignancies (P = 0·001), atopy (P = 0·001), cutaneous disorders (P < 0·001) and neurological (P = 0·002) disorders were higher, while LATAIE patients were more commonly complicated with life-threatening infections (P = 0·002), pneumonia (P = 0·006), ear, nose and throat disorders (P < 0·001), organomegaly (P = 0·023), autoimmune enteropathy (P = 0·038) and growth failure (P < 0·001). Normal lymphocyte subsets and immunoglobulins except low serum levels of CD9⁺ B cells (14·0 versus 38·4%, P < 0·001), natural killer (NK) cells (21 versus 41·1%, P < 0·001), immunoglobulin (Ig)G (46·9 versus 41·1%, P = 0·291) and IgA (54·5 versus 44·7%, P = 0·076) were found in the majority of CHAI and LATAIE patients, respectively. The most frequent biological immunosuppressive agents prescribed for CHAI and LATAIE patients were rituximab and abatacept, respectively. Further investigations into the best conditioning and treatment regimens pre- and post-transplantation are required to improve the survival rate of transplanted CHAI and LATAIE patients.

Cellular and molecular mechanisms breaking immune tolerance in inborn errors of immunity

In addition to susceptibility to infections, conventional primary immunodeficiency disorders (PIDs) and inborn errors of immunity (IEI) can cause immune dysregulation, manifesting as lymphoproliferative and/or autoimmune disease. Autoimmunity can be the prominent phenotype of PIDs and commonly includes cytopenias and rheumatological diseases, such as arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), and Sjogren's syndrome (SjS). Recent advances in understanding the genetic basis of systemic autoimmune diseases and PIDs suggest an at least partially shared genetic background and therefore common pathogenic mechanisms. Here, we explore the interconnected pathogenic pathways of autoimmunity and primary immunodeficiency, highlighting the mechanisms breaking the different layers of immune tolerance to self-antigens in selected IEI.

Perspective: Application of the American College of Medical Genetics Variant Interpretation Criteria to Common Variable Immunodeficiency Disorders

Common variable immunodeficiency disorders (CVIDs) are rare primary immunodeficiency diseases (PIDs) mostly associated with late onset antibody failure leading to immune system failure. Patients with CVID are predisposed to disabling complications such as bronchiectasis and systemic autoimmunity. In recent years a large number of genetic defects have become associated with these disorders. Patients with a causative mutation are deemed to have CVID-like disorders, while those with mutations predisposing to or modifying disease severity remain within the spectrum of CVID as defined by current diagnostic criteria. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) allows simultaneous analysis of multiple genes. Potential mutations identified from NGS are commonly evaluated with the American College of Medical Genetics (ACMG) variant interpretation criteria to determine their pathogenicity (causality). Patients with CVID and CVID-like disorders have marked genetic, allelic, and phenotypic heterogeneity. Although all patients with a CVID phenotype should undergo genetic testing, the complexity of the genetics associated with these disorders is challenging. Variants of unknown significance (VUS) remain a significant barrier to realising the full potential of NGS in CVID and CVID-like disorders. Here we explore the nuances of applying the ACMG criteria to patients with CVID and CVID-like disorders. Close collaboration between the clinician, bioinformatics, and genetics professionals will improve the diagnostic yield from genetic testing and reduce the frequency of VUS.

Next-generation sequencing for inborn errors of immunity

Inborn errors of immunity (IEIs) include several hundred gene defects affecting various components of the immune system. As with other constitutional disorders, next-generation sequencing (NGS) is a powerful tool for the diagnosis of these diseases. While NGS can provide molecular confirmation of disease in a patient with a suspected or classic phenotype, it can also identify new molecular defects of the immune system, expand gene-disease phenotypes, clarify mechanism of disease, pattern of inheritance or identify new gene-disease associations. Multiple clinical specialties are involved in the diagnosis and management of patients with IEI, and most have no formal genetic training or expertise. To effectively utilize NGS tools and data in clinical practice, it is relevant and pragmatic to obtain a modicum of knowledge about genetic terminology, the variety of platforms and tools available for high-throughput genomic analysis, the interpretation and implementation of such data in clinical practice. There is considerable variability not only in the technologies and analytical tools used for NGS but in the bioinformatics approach to variant identification and interpretation. The ability to provide a molecular basis for disease has the potential to alter therapeutic management and longer-term treatment of the disease, including developing personalized approaches with molecularly targeted therapies. This review is intended for the clinical specialist or diagnostic immunologist who works in the area of inborn errors of immunity, and provides an overview of the need for genetic testing in these patients (the "why" aspect), the various technologies and analytical approaches, bioinformatics tools, resources, and challenges (the "how" aspect), and the clinical evidence for identifying which patients might be best served by such testing (the "when" aspect).

STING-Mediated Lung Inflammation and Beyond

Mendelian autoinflammatory diseases characterized by constitutive activation of the type I interferon pathway, the so-called type I interferonopathies, constitute a rapidly expanding group of inborn errors of immunity. Among the type I interferonopathies, STING-associated vasculopathy with onset in infancy (SAVI) and COPA syndrome were described in the last 6 years, both manifesting a major inflammatory lung component associated with significant morbidity and increased mortality. There is striking clinical and histopathological overlap between SAVI and COPA syndrome, although distinct features are also present. Of note, there is a remarkably high frequency of clinical non-penetrance among individuals harboring pathogenic COPA mutations. SAVI is caused by, principally heterozygous, gain-of-function mutations in STING1 (previously referred to as TMEM173) encoding STING, a key adaptor of the interferon signaling pathway induced by DNA. COPA syndrome results from heterozygous dominant-negative mutations in the coatomer protein subunit alpha, forming part of a complex involved in intracellular cargo protein transport between the Golgi and the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). Of importance, a role for COPA in regulating the trafficking of STING, an ER-resident protein which translocates to the Golgi during the process of its activation, was recently defined, thereby possibly explaining some aspects of the phenotypic overlap between SAVI and COPA syndrome. Here, we review the expanding phenotype of these diseases, highlighting common as well as specific features, and recent advances in our understanding of STING biology that have informed therapeutic decision-making in both conditions. Beyond these rare Mendelian disorders, DNA sensing through STING is likely relevant to the pathology of several diseases associated with lung inflammation, including systemic lupus erythematosus, dermatomyositis, environmental toxin exposure, and viral infection.