Genetic characterization of Leishmania isolates at 37 enzyme loci

Molecular biology techniques in parasite ecology

Molecular techniques are increasingly being used to study the ecology of a variety of organisms. These techniques represent important tools for the study of the systematics, population genetics, biogeography and ecology of parasites. Here, we review the techniques that have been employed to study the ecology and systematics of parasites (including bacteria and viruses). Particular emphasis is placed on the techniques of isoenzyme electrophoresis, in situ hybridisation and nucleic acid amplification to characterise parasite/microbial communities. The application of these techniques will be exemplified using ticks, bacterial endosymbionts and parasitic protozoa.

Isolation, propagation and characterisation of Cryptosporidium

This review consists of 11 papers presented at the Consensus Conference on Cryptosporidium in Water (Parasitology Stream), held in Melbourne, Australia, from 5 to 6th October 1998. The conference was sponsored by the Water Services Association of Australia, the Australian Water and Wastewater Association, and the Collaborative Research Centre for Water Quality and Treatment. The papers summarise the advantages and disadvantages of various contemporary technologies applicable to parasite propagation and biochemical/molecular characterisation. Studies have detected distinct genetic differences between clinical isolates from humans and animals, and it is hoped that comprehensive documentation studies will facilitate the identification of environmental isolates in the not too distant future.

The importance of systematics in parasitological research

The discipline of systematics plays a central role in all branches of biology. In today's technology-orientated research world, it is important to realise the continuing value of systematics, the basic tenet of which is to combine diverse types of data to produce classifications that reflect the natural history of living organisms. Accurate classification systems are crucial in the field of parasitology, not only because they provide the means to identify species and strains of parasites, but also because they provide a framework around which a parasite's biology can be studied. The construction of such a classification system is often hampered by the parasite's biology, which may preclude the application of traditional techniques or concepts (such as morphological differentiation or the biological species concept) to delineate species. It is often the case that these difficulties can be overcome by the use of molecular systematic techniques. In this paper, it is proposed that a detailed understanding of the phylogeny of a group of organisms can be used as a basis to examine other aspects of their systematics. This is illustrated using the protozoan parasite Giardia intestinalis. Data gathered using the complementary techniques of allozyme electrophoresis and nucleotide sequencing have been used to infer the phylogenetic relationships of G. intestinalis isolated from various host species. The results, supported by biological data, suggest that G. intestinalis is a species-complex. As we move towards the year 2000, molecular systematics will play an increasingly important role in elucidating host-parasite relationships. However, its use as a taxonomic tool will require a general acceptance by parasitologists and the adoption of formal procedures to allow the description of new species by these methods. The aim of this approach is not to dismiss traditional methods, but to use them in combination with contemporary methods in the true spirit of the discipline of systematics.

Multilocus enzyme electrophoresis: a valuable technique for providing answers to problems in parasite systematics

The aim of this review is to highlight the effectiveness of the technique of multilocus enzyme electrophoresis in answering questions relating to the systematics of parasites and to highlight errors in the way the technique has been used and the results interpreted. We have approached this topic by answering specific questions that we have been asked by colleagues and students not necessarily familiar with the technique, the method of data analysis and its application. Although the technique has been applied to provide answers for taxonomic and population genetics studies, it remains under-utilised, perhaps because of recent advances in newer molecular technology. Rather than not acknowledge or dismiss the value of more traditional technology, we suggest that researchers examine problems in the systematics of parasites by the comparison of data derived from morphological, biochemical and molecular techniques.

Comparison of the levels of intra-specific genetic variation within Giardia muris and Giardia intestinalis

The extent of intra-specific genetic variation between isolates of Giardia muris was assessed by allozyme electrophoresis. Additionally, the levels of allozymic variation detected within G. muris were compared with those observed between members of the two major assemblages of the morphologically distinct species Giardia intestinalis. Four isolates of G. muris were analysed. Three (Ad-120, -150, -151) were isolated from mice in Australia, while the fourth (R-T) was isolated from a golden hamster in North America. The 11 isolates of G. intestinalis (Ad-1, -12, -2, -62, representing genetic Groups I and II of Assemblage A and BAH-12, BRIS/87/HEPU/694, Ad-19, -22, -28, -45, -52, representing genetic Groups III and IV of Assemblage B) were from humans in Australia. Intra-specific genetic variation was detected between G. muris isolates at four of the 23 enzyme loci examined. Similar levels of variation were found within the genetic groups that comprise Assemblages A and B of G. intestinalis. These levels of intra-specific variation are similar to those observed within other morphologically-distinct species of protozoan parasites. We suggest that the magnitude of the genetic differences detected within G. muris provides an indication of the range of genetic variation within other species of Giardia and that this can be used as a model to delineate morphologically similar but genetically distinct (cryptic) species within this genus.

Paradigms and expectations: the nature of research and diagnostics

Researchers are judged by their best work. No matter what disasters happen at the researcher's bench, there is time to repeat experiments, discard ambiguous data and work steadily toward a clearer understanding of the research problem. The work practices of researchers are matters of personal choice, because the process of peer review prior to publication considers only the work that is reported and not all work done by the researcher. On the other hand, the diagnostician's credibility is directly linked to every experiment performed, because a customer is waiting for the result. This paper contrasts aspects of the work of researchers and diagnosticians and concludes that researchers could benefit from understanding the framework within which diagnosticians operate.

Division of Giardia isolates from humans into two genetically distinct assemblages by electrophoretic analysis of enzymes encoded at 27 loci and comparison with Giardia muris

Giardia that infect humans are known to be heterogeneous but they are assigned currently to a single species, Giardia intestinalis (syn. G. lamblia). The genetic differences that exist within G. intestinalis have not yet been assessed quantitatively and neither have they been compared in magnitude with those that exist between G. intestinalis and species that are morphologically similar (G. duodenalis) or morphologically distinct (e.g. G. muris). In this study, 60 Australian isolates of G. intestinalis were analysed electrophoretically at 27 enzyme loci and compared with G. muris and a feline isolate of G. duodenalis. Isolates of G. intestinalis were distinct genetically from both G. muris (approximately 80% fixed allelic differences) and the feline G. duodenalis isolate (approximately 75% fixed allelic differences). The G. intestinalis isolates were extremely heterogeneous but they fell into 2 major genetic assemblages, separated by fixed allelic differences at approximately 60% of loci examined. The magnitude of the genetic differences between the G. intestinalis assemblages approached the level that distinguished the G. duodenalis isolate from the morphologically distinct G. muris. This raises important questions about the evolutionary relationships of the assemblages with Homo sapiens, the possibility of ancient or contemporary transmission from animal hosts to humans and the biogeographical origins of the two clusters.

Differences in a ribosomal DNA sequence of morphologically indistinguishable species within the Hypodontus macropi complex (Nematoda: Strongyloidea)

The nucleotide sequence of the second internal transcribed spacer (ITS-2) from ribosomal DNA has been determined for 3 members of the Hypodontus macropi species complex. Sequences were compared from nematodes collected from 3 species of Australian macropodid marsupial, Petrogale persephone, Macropus robustus robustus and Thylogale billardierii. The ITS-2 of each operational taxonomic unit ranged from 287 to 292 bases in length, and had a GC content of 36.6-40.1%. Differences in nucleotide sequence between nematodes from the different host species ranged from 25.0% to 28.3%. The data suggest that H. macropi from P. persephone represents a different species to those in M. r. robustus and T. billardierii. The unique feature of this study is that it represents a comparison of the ribosomal DNA sequences of nematode species which are morphologically indistinguishable but which have been demonstrated to be genetically distinct (i.e. cryptic) species based on electrophoretic data. The results also demonstrate further that morphological characters alone are often not adequate for species recognition. Differences between these 3 species of H. macropi in their recognition sites for restriction endonucleases, indicates that a PCR-RFLP approach could be used, in conjunction with allozyme electrophoresis, to establish how many species are present within the H. macropi complex.

Discrimination of Leishmania isolates using a limited set of enzymatic loci

The characterization of more than 200 Leishmania isolates, using 18 enzymatic loci, indicated that only a limited number of enzymes produces diagnostic alleles which are potentially useful in the identification of species or zymodemes. 6-Phospho-gluconate dehydrogenase was the most polymorphic enzyme, containing enzyme, containing the majority of diagnostic alleles, and could be used to separate strains of the subgenus Leishmania from those of Viannia. It appears that just a few enzymatic loci, chosen a priori, are all that are needed in many taxonomic and epidemiological studies of Leishmania.

Characterization of a polymorphic family of integral membrane proteins in promastigotes of different Leishmania species

Antibodies raised against a Leishmania major recombinant promastigote surface antigen 2 (PSA-2) fragment recognized three major polypeptides of approximate M(r) 96,000, 80,000 and 50,000 in promastigotes of three Israeli isolates of L. major including the cloned line LRC-L137-V121, but detected a different array of polypeptides in other L. major isolates. The pattern was different both in number of polypeptides detected and their molecular weight. The antibodies to L. major PSA-2 also recognized polypeptides in L. tropica, L. donovani and very weakly in L. mexicana promastigotes and in Crithidia lucilliae. The number and size of the polypeptides was different in each species. In addition to the membrane-bound PSA-2 polypeptides we identified water-soluble forms of PSA-2 released in promastigote culture supernatants. Peptide maps of the various L. major PSA-2 membrane polypeptides showed they were different from each other. N-terminal amino acid sequence of the three polypeptides expressed by L. major showed they are similar but distinct, consistent with being members of a polymorphic family. Because of the extensive sequence similarity between the PSA-2 genes it has been difficult to assign protein products to individual genes. As a first step towards solving this problem, we have transfected into L. mexicana a genomic clone of a L. major PSA-2 gene and shown that it produces a M(r) 35,000 polypeptide recognized by monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies to L. major PSA-2.

Selection of specific genotypes of Giardia intestinalis by growth in vitro and in vivo

This study examined whether allelic changes observed when clinical isolates of Giardia intestinalis made in suckling mice were adapted to in vitro growth occurred as a result of gene switching (alternate isoenzymes) or through selection of organisms with different genotypes from mixed infections. Samples were compared electrophoretically at 20 enzyme loci. Marked allelic differences were detected between the uncloned clinical isolates grown in mice and the axenic cultures established from them. Furthermore, the allelic profiles of the uncloned isolates changed during the course of in vivo or in vitro growth. In contrast, all clones produced from each isolate retained identical allelic profiles, regardless of whether they were grown in vivo or in vitro. These findings argue against gene switching as an explanation for the observed allozyme changes and support preferential selection of organisms with specific genotypes by growth conditions. The data indicate the presence of at least 2 and possibly up to 4 distinct genotypes within each clinical isolate. The genetic differences detected between clinical isolates in suckling mice were of similar magnitude to those that separate different axenic isolates of G. intestinalis into cryptic species. Conversely, the genetic differences between the isolates were limited when sampled after establishment in vitro. These findings have significant implications for research on Giardia and other medically important parasites and raise the possibility that culture may exert a similar selective bias on the genotypes isolated from infections with other parasitic protozoa.

Changes in allozyme pattern of the protozoan parasite Giardia intestinalis

The present study compares the allelic profiles of Giardia intestinalis grown in vivo and in vitro. Three clinical isolates of G. intestinalis were established in suckling mice and subsequently adapted to in vitro culture to test the null hypothesis that samples of the same clinical isolate grown in different culture conditions have identical allelic profiles. For each isolate, a mouse-derived and an axenically cultured sample were analysed electrophoretically at 11 enzyme loci. In each case, the axenically cultured sample of each isolate showed marked allelic differences from its corresponding in vivo sample. These data suggest that there may be either regulated expression of alternative genes encoding distinct isozymes (i.e. gene switching) or selection by different growth conditions of specific genotypes from a mixture present within the original clinical isolate. Although these hypotheses are not tested in this study, the data highlight the importance of confirming that allozymes (or isozymes) are stable genetic characters for the identification and characterization of protozoan taxa.

18S rRNA sequences of Leishmania enriettii promastigote and amastigote

Dideoxy sequencing with reverse transcriptase and universal primers was used to obtain partial sequences of the 18S rRNAs from the promastigote and amastigote life-cycle stages of L. enriettii. Approximately 1400 nucleotides of sequence from the two stages were compared. Unlike Plasmodium berghei, in which 18S rRNAs from the mosquito stage and the mammalian stage of the life cycle are only 96.5% similar, the amastigote and promastigote rRNAs of L. enriettii are identical. In addition, a comparison of 1425 bases of the L. enriettii promastigote sequence with the published sequence of L. donovani revealed only four differences; the two sequences are 99.8% similar. A likely explanation for this high similarity, considering the 97% similarity between L. donovani and the related genus Crithidia fasciculata, is that the two species are closely related and of comparatively recent origin. The low diversity between the 18S rRNA sequences of Leishmania species is similar to that reported for 13 Tetrahymena species, where similarities ranged from 98.1 to 99.9%, but different from the pattern reported in the genus Naegleria, where divergence was greater.

Leishmania major: expression and gene structure of the glycoprotein 63 molecule in virulent and avirulent clones and strains

Two Leishmania membrane glycoconjugates, gp63 and lipophosphoglycan, have been implicated in parasite attachment and uptake into the host macrophage. Moreover, recent data suggest that parasite virulence is associated with high expression of gp63. In this study we have surveyed gp63 gene copy number, in addition to the level of expression of gp63 mRNA and protein in several Leishmania major isolates, as well as virulent and avirulent strains and clones. The highest level of gp63 expression was found in the avirulent cloned line LRC-L119.3G7, which expresses about a 15-fold higher level of gp63 RNA and protein than the virulent cloned line LRC-L137/7/V121, suggesting that large amounts of gp63 are not sufficient for infectivity and do not correlate with virulence. L119.3G7 has eight copies of the gp63 gene compared to five copies in the virulent cloned line V121 and its parental virulent isolate LRC-L137. A series of avirulent clones derived from LRC-L137 also had five copies of the gene, suggesting that gp63 copy number is maintained among closely related parasites. Different virulent isolates of L. major from different geographic regions exhibited six copies of the gp63 gene. The variation in total gene copy number is due to different numbers of the tandemly repeated gp63 isogene in different strains. Our data show that there is wide variability between strains of L. major in the copy number of gp63 genes as well as in the amount of RNA and protein expressed.

A genetic approach to species criteria in the amoeba genus Naegleria using allozyme electrophoresis

The present study employs allozyme electrophoresis to characterize and inter-relate 61 isolates of Naegleria. Diploidy was confirmed, with heterozygotes observed at 29 of the 33 loci established and in all but two isolates. With a single exception, isolates clustered at two levels of similarity, either below 21% or above 52%. It is argued that such a major discontinuity provides a sound biological basis for a species concept in Naegleria. On this basis the present species-level taxonomy does not reflect the genetic diversity of the genus. The study recognized 18 genetic groups of species rank. The subspecies N. australiensis italica deserves specific rank; additional thermophilic species not closely related to N. fowleri and N. lovaniensis are recognized; and N. gruberi as currently conceived is a complex of 10 species, at least five of which are represented in the formal culture collections. Most species are genetically too different for relationships to be elucidated by allozyme electrophoresis, supporting the view that some of the times of divergence within the genus are extremely ancient.

Genetic characterization of three species of Onchocerca at 23 enzyme loci

The technique of allozyme electrophoresis was applied to species of Onchocerca from cattle to increase the number of enzyme loci established and therefore provide a genetic basis for a rational species-level taxonomy. Twenty-three enzyme loci were established and provided unequivocal genetic evidence for the taxonomic validity of Onchocerca gibsoni, O. gutturosa and O. lienalis. Furthermore, the diagnostic enzyme markers detected form the basis for identification of life-cycle stages, individuals and species and population structure analyses.

Giardia intestinalis: electrophoretic evidence for a species complex

The technique of allozyme electrophoresis was applied to 29 Australasian stocks and 48 clones of Giardia intestinalis from humans as a means of increasing the number of genetic markers currently available for identification and classification. Fifty different enzymes were examined and of these 26 loci were found to be suitable for use as genetic markers. The data indicate the presence of four discrete genetic groups within the sample of G. intestinalis examined. The groups had fixed genetic differences at 23-69% of loci established. The evidence suggests that G. intestinalis is a species complex. The results have important implications for the systematics of human isolates of Giardia, as well as for studies on the epidemiology and demography of giardiasis in Australia and elsewhere.

Identification of life cycle stages of the nematode Echinocephalus overstreeti by allozyme electrophoresis

Data presented in this study highlight the potential of allozyme electrophoresis in providing unequivocal genetic evidence for the identification of life cycle stages, particularly where species have complex life cycles. Adults of the nematode Echinocephalus overstreeti parasitize the elasmobranch Heterodontus portusjacksoni. The putative larval form which is morphologically dissimilar is found in two species of marine molluscs, Chlamys bifrons and Pecten albus. Electrophoretic analysis indicated that the adult and larval forms shared alleles at all of the 34 enzyme loci established. Furthermore, there were no fixed allelic differences between larval forms from different mollusc species.