A porcine rotavirus strain with dual VP7 serotype specificity

Serological characterization of novel P11[14],G8 bovine group A rotavirus, Sun9, isolated in Japan

In this study, a novel bovine group A rotavirus (BoRV-A), Sun9, isolated from calf diarrhea in Tochigi Prefecture, Japan, was serologically characterized by a cross-neutralization assay, and serological surveillance by using its reassortant was performed on cattle bred in Japan. The G serotype of Sun9 was identified as G serotype 8 based on the one- or two-way serological relationships observed in Sun9 and other G8 strains. The P serotype of Sun9 was identified as P serotype 11 based on the one- or two-way serological relationships observed in Sun9, its reassortants, and the P11 lapine group A rotavirus R-2. The serological surveillance data indicated that 2.4% of the specimens appeared to possess antibodies against the P11[14] antigen. Few P11[14] bovine group A rotaviruses may exist in the Japanese cattle population.

Isolation and characterization of dually reactive strains of group a rotavirus from hospitalized children

Seven rotavirus strains dually reactive to serotype G1- and G2-specific monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) from hospitalized children with rotavirus diarrhea were culture adapted. Six strains were neutralized with G1 antiserum to a higher titer than that of G2, and one was neutralized with G1 and G2 antisera to equal titers. Of these, four strains were also neutralized with G6 antiserum. Five strains with short RNA pattern could not be serotyped, and the remaining two strains with long RNA pattern were serotyped as G1 strains. In addition, two strains showing dual reactivity to G2 and G4 MAbs and one G2-like strain from a nontypeable specimen were isolated. The dual reactivity of the isolates could not be attributed to mixed infections.

Genetic and antigenic diversity of human rotaviruses: potential impact on the success of candidate vaccines

Licensing of the first human rotavirus vaccine raises the hope of a reduction in the burden of paediatric diarrheal disease. However, the less than optimal performance of this vaccine in trials carried out in developing countries indicates that improvements in vaccine design are necessary. Analysis of the genetic and antigenic diversity of rotavirus isolates collected from various geographical locations suggests that future vaccine formulations may need to include a broader spectrum of strains. This may increase vaccine efficacy by providing comprehensive coverage against circulating viruses. Continued surveillance and genetic analysis of the rotavirus population prior to and after the introduction of routine vaccination will reveal if the diversity of this pathogen will impact on the success of vaccine programs.

Characterization of human rotavirus genotype P[8]G5 from Brazil by probe-hybridization and sequence

We report the molecular characterization of rotavirus genotype P[8]G5 strains found in fecal specimens collected in four different regions of Brazil, using digoxigenin(dig)-labeled oligonucleotide probes, sequence analysis, and RNA-RNA hybridization. The closest sequence relationships of the neutralization antigens of these strains were to the VP4 protein of P1A[8]G1 strain KU (93.3% identity in amino acids 11 to 282) and to the VP7 protein of G serotype 5 strain OSU (87.6% identity in amino acids 8 to 232). Based on VP7 sequence differences, we designed dig-probes that allowed us to discriminate porcine OSU-like strains from G5 strains isolated from Brazilian infants. The genetic relationships of two P[8]G5 isolates to other rotavirus genogroups were analyzed by RNA-RNA hybridization with [32P]-GTP probes representative of serotypes P1A[8]G1 (Wa), P[8]G3 (AU17), and P9[7]G5 (OSU). The Brazilian P[8]G5 strains showed sequence homology with genes of Wa-like and OSU-like strains, suggesting that these two strains were naturally occurring reassortants between members of the Wa and porcine rotavirus genogroups. The identification of these strains in diverse geographic areas of Brazil underscores their stability and demonstrates the emergence of clinically important rotavirus diarrhea strains by reassortment.

Single point mutations may affect the serotype reactivity of serotype G11 porcine rotavirus strains: a widening spectrum?

A panel of single and double neutralization-resistant escape mutants of serotype G11 porcine rotavirus strains A253 and YM, selected with G11 monotype- and serotype-specific neutralizing monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) to VP7, was tested in neutralization assays with hyperimmune sera raised against rotavirus strains of different serotypes. Escape mutants with an amino acid substitution in antigenic region A (amino acids [aa] 87 to 101) resulting in a residue identical or chemically similar to those present at the same positions in serotype G3 strains, at positions 87 for strain A253 and 96 for strain YM, were significantly more sensitive than the parental strains to neutralization with sera against some serotype G3 strains. Also, one YM antigenic variant (YM-5E6.1) acquired reactivity by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay with MAbs 159, 57/8, and YO-1E2, which react with G3 strains, but not with the serotype G11 parental strain YM. Cross-adsorption studies suggested that the observed cross-neutralization by the G3-specific sera was due to the sera containing antibodies reactive with the parental strain plus antibodies reactive with the epitope(s) on the antigenic variant that mimick the serotype G3 specific one(s). Moreover, antibodies reactive with antigenic region F (aa 235 to 242) of VP7 might also be involved since cross-reactivity to serotype G3 was decreased in double mutants carrying an additional mutation, which creates a potential glycosylation site at position 238. Thus, single point mutations can affect the serotype reactivity of G11 porcine rotavirus strains with both monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies and may explain the origin of rotavirus strains with dual serotype specificity based on sequence divergence of VP7.

Identification of bovine rotaviruses in Venezuela: antigenic and molecular characterization of a bovine rotavirus strain

Two serotypes of bovine group A rotaviruses were demonstrated by enzyme-linked immunoassay (ELISA) and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) in 20 of 171 faecal samples collected from diarrhoeic calves in two dairy farms in Venezuela. By serotyping ELISA using G and P serotype-specific monoclonal antibodies, bovine rotaviruses (BRV) circulating on one farm were identified as serotype G6, while BRVs circulating on the other farm were identified as serotype G10. Only one BRV (033) could be successfully isolated in MA104 cells, and the nucleotide sequences of the VP7 and the VP8* trypsin-cleavage product of the VP4 were determined. Cross-neutralization tests and comparative sequence analysis showed that BRV 033 belonged to serotype G6 and genotype P1. This is the first report of BRVs identified in Venezuela.

Sequence of the VP7 gene of an atypical human rotavirus: evidence for genetic and antigenic drift

The nucleotide sequence of the gene encoding the outer capsid glycoprotein, VP7, isolated from a reassortant human rotavirus, M3014, was determined. The deduced amino acid sequence exhibited significant identity to the VP7 from a standard strain belonging to serotype G4, although the antigenic regions of the M3014 VP7 resembled sequences from both serotype G4 and G9 viruses. However, reactivity with G4 or G9 serotype-specific monoclonal antibodies was not observed. We suggest that the M3014 VP7 was derived from sequential mutation of a G4-like progenitor gene resulting in a protein with novel antigenic properties.

Serological and genomic characterization of porcine rotaviruses in Thailand: detection of a G10 porcine rotavirus

A total of 557 fecal specimens collected from piglets with diarrhea in Thailand were examined for rotavirus RNA by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Twenty-three, one, and two samples were positive for group A, group B, and group C rotaviruses, respectively. Two samples exhibited two segments found in picobirnavirus RNA. RNA electropherotyping of 23 group A rotaviruses showed that they were classified into five patterns. By serotyping by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and PCR, viruses in 3 and 14 specimens were found to be serotype G3 and serotype G10, respectively. For one specimen, containing a serotype G10 virus (strain P343), virus was isolated in MA-104 cells, and the nucleotide sequences of the VP7 and VP4 genes were determined. Comparative sequence analysis and cross-neutralization tests showed that strain P343 has B223-like G10 and UK-like P7 serotype (or VP4 genotype 5) specificities. Rotaviruses having such antigenic specificities have not been detected in piglets. Thus, the interspecies transmission of rotaviruses between cows and pigs was suggested.

Cross-reactive, serotype- and monotype-specific neutralization epitopes on VP7 of serotype G3 and G5 porcine rotavirus strains

VP7 specific monoclonal antibodies raised against serotype G5 porcine rotavirus strains isolated in Venezuela showed either a serotype G5- or monotype-specific pattern of reactivity by neutralization against a panel of 53 group A rotavirus isolates representative of all established G serotypes. Monoclonal antibodies raised against two G3 porcine strains were either specific for a subset of porcine G3 strains or reactive with another subset of porcine G3 strains and with most G5 strains. Neither were reactive with G3 strains from other species. Analysis of neutralization resistant mutants selected with these monoclonal antibodies indicated that epitopes defined by cross-reactive, serotype- and monotype-specific monoclonal antibodies overlap functionally and that binding and neutralization by these antibodies depended on specific amino acid residues in the region A or C of VP7. Results indicate that a high degree of monotypic variation occurs among G5 and G3 porcine rotavirus strains and the existence of at least one common epitope shared by G5 and G3 porcine strains, in the major neutralization domain of these VP7s.

Comparative amino acid sequence analysis of the major outer capsid protein (VP7) of porcine rotaviruses with G3 and G5 serotype specificities isolated in Venezuela and Argentina

Seven porcine group A rotavirus strains isolated in Venezuela were shown to be antigenically related to serotype G3 (five strains) or to serotype G5 (two strains), whereas two strains isolated in Argentina were classified as serotype G5. The serological classification of eight of these strains was confirmed by sequence analysis of the gene encoding the VP7 glycoprotein. A high degree of homology was observed among strains belonging to the same G serotype, although some variations in the serotype-specific regions were detected among different strains. Comparison with the published VP7 amino acid sequences of serotype G3 indicated that most porcine rotavirus strains are more closely related to each other and to human rotavirus strains than to rotavirus strains isolated from other species. Amino acid sequence comparison among serotype G5 porcine strains revealed that Venezuelan porcine isolates were more closely related to the American strain OSU, while the Argentinian strains had a higher similarity to the Australian strain TRF-41. This report confirms the worldwide distribution of these G serotypes among the porcine population.

Rotavirus vaccines and vaccination potential

The development of a successful rotavirus vaccine is a complex problem. Our review of rotavirus vaccine development shows that many challenges remain, and priorities for future studies need to be established. For example, the evaluation of administration of a vaccine with OPV or breast milk might receive less emphasis until a vaccine is made that shows clear efficacy against all virus serotypes. Samples remaining from previous trials should be analyzed to determine epitope-specific serum and coproantibody responses to clarify why only some trials were successful. Detailed evaluation of the antigenic properties of the viruses circulating and causing illness in vaccinated children also should be performed for comparisons with the vaccine strains. In future trials, sample collection should include monitoring for asymptomatic infections and cellular immune responses should be analyzed. The diversity of rotavirus serotype distribution must be monitored before, during, and after a trial in the study population and placebo recipients must be matched carefully to vaccine recipients. Epidemiologic and molecular studies should be expanded to document, or disprove, the possibility of animal to human rotavirus transmission, because, if this occurs, vaccine protection may be more difficult in those areas of the world where cohabitation with animals occurs. We also need to have an accurate assessment of the rate of protection that follows natural infections. Is it realistic to try to achieve 90% protective efficacy with a vaccine if natural infections with these enteric pathogens only provide 60% or 70% protection? Subunit vaccines should be considered to be part of vaccine strategies, especially if maternal antibody interferes with the take of live vaccines. The constraints on development of new vaccines are not likely to come from molecular biology. The challenge remains whether the biology and immunology of rotavirus infections can be understood and exploited to permit effective vaccination. Recent advances in developing small animal models for evaluation of vaccine efficacy should facilitate future vaccine development and understanding of the protective immune response(s) (Ward et al. 1990b; Conner et al. 1993).

Characterization of full-length and polymerase chain reaction-derived partial-length Gottfried and OSU gene 4 probes for serotypic differentiation of porcine rotaviruses

To determine the VP4 (P type) specificity of porcine rotaviruses, full- and partial-length gene 4 probes were produced from cloned Gottfried and OSU porcine rotavirus genomic segment 4 cDNAs. The gene 4 segments from the prototype Gottfried (VP7 serotype 4) and OSU (VP7 serotype 5) porcine rotavirus strains were selected for study because of their distinct P types and the occurrence of rotaviruses with similar serotypes among swine. Partial-length gene 4 cDNAs were produced and amplified by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and encompassed portions of the variable region (nucleotides 211 to 612) of VP8 encoded by genomic segment 4. The hybridization stringency conditions necessary for optimal probe specificity and sensitivity were determined by dot or Northern (RNA) blot hybridizations against a diverse group of human and animal rotaviruses of heterologous group A serotypes and against representative group B and C porcine rotaviruses. The PCR-derived gene 4 probes were more specific than the full-length gene 4 probes but demonstrated equivalent sensitivity. The Gottfried PCR-derived probe hybridized with Gottfried, SB2, SB3, and SB5 G serotype 4 porcine rotaviruses. The OSU PCR-derived probe hybridized with OSU, EE, A580, and SB-1A porcine rotaviruses and equine H1 rotavirus. Results of the hybridization reactions of the PCR-derived gene 4 probes with selected porcine rotavirus strains agreed with previous serological or genetic analyses, indicating their suitability as diagnostic reagents.

A variant serotype G3 rotavirus isolated from an unusually severe outbreak of diarrhoea in piglets

About 80% of faecal samples from severe outbreak of porcine diarrhoea (scours) were positive for rotavirus. Rotavirus positive samples were analyzed for their antigenic properties and amino acid sequences of the glycoprotein genes. These viruses could not be assigned to any serotypes using serotyping monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) developed for porcine rotaviruses [Nagesha and Holmes: Journal of Medical Virology 35:206-211, 1991b]. When two such viruses were isolated in cell culture and analyzed by neutralization tests using hyperimmune sera they showed only one way antigenic relation with both human and porcine viruses belonging to serotype G3. In addition none of the serotyping MAbs neutralized these two virus isolates. There was no base variation between VP7 genes of faecal and cell culture isolates. Predicted amino acid sequences of the VP7 gene showed marked epitope variation from other porcine type G3 isolates with amino acid substitutions and an additional glycosylation site at residue 238. This antigenic variation seen in rotaviruses appears similar to that of influenza viruses undergoing antigenic drift.

Genetic variation in rotavirus serotype 4 subtypes

Serotype 4 rotavirus strains have been classified into two antigenic "subtypes" by a solid phase immune electron microscopy technique in which cross-absorbed animal polyclonal immune sera are used as the source of antibodies. The sequences of the gene encoding the outer capsid glycoprotein VP7 from a single serotype 4 rotavirus field strain identified as subtype A ("ST3-like") and from three field strains identified as subtype B ("VA70-like") were determined. A comparison of the deduced amino acid sequences indicated that 15 amino acid residues were divergent between subtypes but were conserved within a subtype. Three of these 15 amino acid residues (at positions 96, 212, and 217) were located in regions of the VP7 that have been defined as serotype-specific antigenic sites. These data suggest that VP7 subtype differences may result from critical amino acid substitutions within an immunodominant serotype 4-specific antigenic site. Whether these differences are an important mechanism in the epidemiology of rotaviruses requires further investigation.

Relation of VP7 amino acid sequence to monoclonal antibody neutralization of rotavirus and rotavirus monotype

The neutralization epitopes of the VP7 of human rotavirus RV-4 were studied by using five neutralizing mouse monoclonal antibodies to select virus variants resistant to neutralization by each of the antibodies. Antibody resistance patterns and sequence analysis of the RV-4 variants revealed that at least four sites on VP7, located at amino acids 94 (region A), 147 to 148 (region B), 213 (region C), and 291, are involved in neutralization of the human G1 rotavirus RV-4. The A-region site elicited antibody cross-reactive between G types and showed species-restricted immunodominance not related to carbohydrate attachment. The monotype 1b rotavirus M37 lacked this site. The B region contained strain-specific and cross-reactive sites, absent in monotype 1c rotaviruses. The C-region site was present in all G1 rotaviruses tested. Monotype 1a rotaviruses contained all these sites of neutralization. Virus monotype and sensitivity to monoclonal antibody neutralization usually related to the presence of a particular amino acid(s) at or next to the positions at which the mutations were selected in the virus variants.

Direct serotyping of porcine rotaviruses using VP7-specific monoclonal antibodies by an enzyme immunoassay

Employing a serotyping EIA test using MAbs both cell culture adapted and faecal porcine rotaviruses were classified into serotypes G3, G3/5, G4, and G5. The MAbs have confirmed and extended the serotyping results obtained using polyclonal antisera. These MAbs are therefore potential reagents for serotyping of porcine rotaviruses. Using subgroup specific MAbs serotypes G3, G3/5, and G5 were found to contain subgroup I antigens while G4 rotaviruses contained either subgroup II or subgroup I antigens.

VP4 monotype specificities among porcine rotavirus strains of the same VP4 serotype

The porcine rotavirus OSU strain was used to produce monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) directed against the outer capsid protein VP4. From two separate fusions, eight MAbs that inhibited hemagglutination activity of the OSU strain were selected. All MAbs immunoprecipitated both the OSU VP4 protein derived from a lysate of infected MA104 cells and the OSU VP4 protein expressed in Sf9 cells by a recombinant baculovirus. By immunoprecipitation of in vitro-translated OSU gene 4 transcripts of different length, the eight MAbs were found to be specific for the VP8 subunit of VP4. All MAbs neutralized the OSU strain but failed to neutralize human, bovine, and simian rotavirus strains. Antiserum to the expressed OSU VP4 protein was used to study the distribution of VP4 antigenicity among porcine rotaviruses. At least two distinct specificities were identified among 14 rotavirus strains that had been previously assigned to four distinct VP7 serotypes. Five groups of monotype specificities of the VP4 protein were identified by the eight anti-VP4 MAbs among 11 porcine strains that share the same VP4 serotype.

VP4 relationships between porcine and other rotavirus serotypes

VP4 relationship of Australian porcine rotaviruses were identified using genetic reassortants and MAbs. All porcine virus isolates except BEN-144 appeared to share VP4 antigenicity with OSU virus. VP4 and BEN-144 virus (Gottfried-like virus) showed some antigenic relationships with the human neonatal viruses ST-3 and RV-3. In addition, VP4 of porcine CRW-8 showed antigenic relationships with simian SA-11. RRV and also canine K9 viruses, while that of porcine TFR-41 showed at least one way VP4 antigenic relatedness with UK bovine rotavirus. Furthermore, BMI-1 virus which is antigenically similar to an American virus SB1-A (a naturally occurring reassortant) may have arisen similarly by gene reassortment in nature in Australia.