Potential enhancement of direct interspecies electron transfer for syntrophic metabolism of propionate and butyrate with biochar in up-flow anaerobic sludge blanket reactors

Physicochemical properties of carbon-based materials enhance in situ biomethanation performances under organic overload

Carbon-based materials gained attention for their potential to improve anaerobic digestion (AD) performance. Meanwhile, in situ biomethanation, where external H2 is injected into the AD process to enhance the CH4 content in biogas, is more subjected to process inhibition than AD while facing sudden changes in operational parameters. This study explored the effects of carbon-based materials on a semi-continuous in situ biomethanation process performance and stability. Two biochars and one granular activated carbon were tested at a concentration of 10 g·L-1. The experiment was conducted in three phases: a one-week start-up phase in AD conditions, an 8-week phase of in situ biomethanation, reaching a steady state, and a 2-week overload phase performed to create instability during the in situ biomethanation process. All additives significantly mitigated process failure under overload conditions, with CH4 production reaching 117 ± 16 vs 160 ± 16 NmL CH4·d-1 on the first week of organic overload (control vs average of all supplemented conditions). Specifically, the use of GAC-BC, with the highest surface area, pore volume, and diameter, led to a tenfold increase in CH4 production compared to the control in the overload phase. This improvement was associated with higher archaeal diversity and dominance of the Bacteroidales class. Conversely, the biochars, with lower surface properties, did not enhance microbial growth or improve final VFA consumption, resulting in final VFA concentrations similar to the control (11gCOD·L-1). These findings highlight the importance of surface properties in additives for mitigating VFA accumulation under stressed conditions during in situ biomethanation.

Magnetite-mediating direct interspecies electron transfer is not pivotal role in directing electrons toward methane production from sulfate containing wastewater

Sulfate reduction can compete for electrons with methane production, thereby reducing methane production. Several factors, such as magnetite addition, carbon sources, and the chemical oxygen demand (COD)/SO42- ratio, can influence the direction of electron flow toward methanogenesis. However, their contributions to methane production remain unclear. In this study, the addition of magnetite significantly enhanced the maximum methane production rate (Rmax). The enrichment of Methanothrix and Methanobacterium in the conductive material groups indicated the establishment of a methanogenesis process through direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET). Although the DIET pathway enhanced Rmax in the conductive material groups, this increase did not translate into a higher methane yield in this study. The contribution of DIET pathway to methane yield was negligible compared with the effect of COD/SO42- ratio and carbon sources. The relative contribution of COD/SO42- ratio exceeded 40 % in directing electron flow.

Long-term and multiscale assessment of methanogenesis enhancement mechanisms in magnetite nanoparticle-mediated anaerobic digestion reactor

Magnetite nanoparticles (Fe3O4-NPs) have been demonstrated to be involved in direct interspecies electron transfer between syntrophic bacteria, yet a comprehensive assessment of the ability of Fe3O4-NPs to cope with process instability and volatile fatty acids (VFAs) accumulation in scaled-up anaerobic reactors is still lacking. Here, we investigated the start-up characteristics of an expanded granular sludge bed (EGSB) with Fe3O4-NPs as an adjuvant at high organic loading rate (OLR). The results showed that the methane production rate of R1 (with Fe3O4-NPs) was approximately 1.65 folds of R0 (control), and effluent COD removal efficiency was maintained at approximately 98.32% upon 20 kg COD/(m3·d) OLR. The components of volatile fatty acids are acetate and propionate, and the rapid scavenging of propionate accumulation was the difference between R1 and the control. The INT-ETS activity of R1 was consistently higher than that of R0 and R2, and the electron transfer efficiencies increased by 68.78% and 131.44%, respectively. Meanwhile, the CV curve analysis showed that the current of R1 was 40% higher than R3 (temporary addition of Fe3O4-NPs), indicating that multiple electron transfer modes might coexist. High-throughput analysis further revealed that it was difficult to reverse the progressive deterioration of system performance with increasing OLR by simply reconfiguring bacterial community structure and abundance, demonstrating that the Fe3O4-NPs-mediated DIET pathway is a prerequisite for establishing multiple electron transfer systems. This study provides a long-term and multi-scale assessment of the gaining effect of Fe3O4-NPs in anaerobic digestion scale-up devices, and provides technical support for their practical engineering applications.

Syntrophic methane production from volatile fatty acids: Focus on interspecies electron transfer

Methane is a renewable biomass energy source produced via anaerobic digestion (AD). Interspecies electron transfer (IET) between methanogens and syntrophic bacteria is crucial for mitigating energy barriers in this process. Understanding IET is essential for enhancing the efficiency of syntrophic methanogenesis in anaerobic digestion. Interspecies electron transfer mechanisms include interspecies H2/formate transfer, direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET), and electron-shuttle-mediated transfer. This review summarizes the mechanisms, developments, and research gaps in IET pathways. Interspecies H2/formate transfer requires strict control of low H2 partial pressure and involves complex enzymatic reactions. In contrast, DIET enhances the electron transfer efficiency and process stability. Conductive materials and key microorganisms can be modulated to stimulate the DIET. Electron shuttles (ES) allow microorganisms to interact with extracellular electron acceptors without direct contact; however, their efficiency depends on various factors. Future studies should elucidate the key functional groups, metabolic pathways, and regulatory mechanisms of IET to guide the optimization of AD processes for efficient renewable energy production.

Integration of Digestate-Derived Biochar into the Anaerobic Digestion Process through Circular Economic and Environmental Approaches-A Review

The growing energy consumption and the need for a circular economy have driven considerable interest in the anaerobic digestion (AD) of organic waste, offering potential solutions through biogas and digestate production. AD processes not only have the capability to reduce greenhouse gas emissions but also contribute to the production of renewable methane. This comprehensive review aims to consolidate prior research on AD involving different feedstocks. The principles of AD are explored and discussed, including both chemical and biological pathways and the microorganisms involved at each stage. Additionally, key variables influencing system performance, such as temperature, pH, and C/N ratio are also discussed. Various pretreatment strategies applied to enhance biogas generation from organic waste in AD are also reviewed. Furthermore, this review examines the conversion of generated digestate into biochar through pyrolysis and its utilization to improve AD performance. The addition of biochar has demonstrated its efficacy in enhancing metabolic processes, microorganisms (activity and community), and buffering capacity, facilitating Direct Interspecies Electron Transfer (DIET), and boosting CH4 production. Biochar also exhibits the ability to capture undesirable components, including CO2, H2S, NH3, and siloxanes. The integration of digestate-derived biochar into the circular economy framework emerges as a vital role in closing the material flow loop. Additionally, the review discusses the environmental benefits derived from coupling AD with pyrolysis processes, drawing on life cycle assessment investigations. Techno-economic assessment (TEA) studies of the integrated processes are also discussed, with an acknowledgment of the need for further TEA to validate the viability of integrating the biochar industry. Furthermore, this survey examines the techno-economic and environmental impacts of biochar production itself and its potential application in AD for biogas generation, aiming to establish a more cost-effective and sustainable integrated system.

A data-driven approach for revealing the linkages between differences in electrochemical properties of biochar during anaerobic digestion using automated machine learning

Biochar is commonly used to enhance the anaerobic digestion of organic waste solids and wastewater, due to its electrochemical properties, which intensify the electron transfer of microorganisms attached to its large surface area. However, it is difficult to create biochar with both high conductivity and high capacitance, which makes selecting the right biochar for engineering applications challenging. To address this issue, two Auto algorithms (TPOT and H2O) were applied to model the effects of different biochar properties on anaerobic digestion processes. The results showed that the gradient boosting machine had the highest predictive accuracy (R2 = 0.96). Feature importance analysis showed that feedstock concentration, digestion time, capacitance, and conductivity of biochar were the main factors affecting methane yield. According to the two-dimensional (2D) partial dependence plots, high-capacitance biochar (0.27-0.29 V·mA) is favorable for substrates with low-solid content (< 19.6 TS%), while the high-conductivity biochar (80.82-170.58 mS/cm) is suitable for high-solids substrates (> 20.1 TS%). The software, based on the optimal model, can be used to obtain the ideal range of biochar for AD trials, aiding researchers in practical applications prior to implementation.

Riboflavin modified carbon cloth enhances anaerobic digestion treating food waste in a pilot-scale system

Previous laboratory-scale studies have consistently shown that carbon-based conductive materials can notably improve the anaerobic digestion of food waste, typically employing reactors with regular capacity of 1-20 L. Furthermore, incorporating riboflavin-loaded conductive materials can further address the imbalance between fermentation and methanogenesis in anaerobic systems. However, there have been few reports on pilot-scale investigation. In this study, a 10 m2 of riboflavin modified carbon cloth was incorporated into a pilot-scale (2 m3) food waste anaerobic reactor to improve its treatment efficiency. The study found that the addition of riboflavin-loaded carbon cloth can increase the maximum organic loading rate (OLR) by 40% of the pilot-scale reactor, compared to the system using carbon cloth without riboflavin loading, while ensuring efficient operation of the reaction system, effectively alleviating system acidification, sustaining methanogen activity, and increasing daily methane production by 25%. Analysis of the microbial community structure revealed that riboflavin-loaded carbon cloth enriched the methanogenic archaea in the genera of Methanothrix and Methanobacterium, which are capable of extracellular direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET). And metabolic pathway analysis identified the methane production pathway, highly enriched on the reduction of acetic acid and CO2 at riboflavin-loaded carbon cloth sample. The expression levels of genes related to methane production via DIET pathway were also significantly upregulated. These results can provide important guidance for the practical application of food waste anaerobic digestion engineering.

Biochar mediated high-rate anaerobic bioreactors: A critical review on high-strength wastewater treatment and management

Treatment of high-strength wastewater is critical for the aquatic environment and receiving water bodies around the globe. Untreated or partially treated high-strength wastewater may cause severe damage to the existing water bodies. Various high-rate anaerobic bioreactors have been developed in the last decades for treating high-strength wastewater. High-rate anaerobic bioreactors are effective in treating industrial wastewater and provide energy in the form of methane as well. However, the physical or chemical properties of high-strength industrial wastewater, sometimes, disrupt the functioning of a high-rate anaerobic bioreactor. For example, the disintegration of granular sludge in up flow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor or membrane blocking in an anaerobic membrane bioreactor are the results of a high-strength wastewater treatment which hamper the proper functioning and may harm the wastewater treatment plant economically. Biochar, if added to these bioreactors, may help to alleviate the ill-functioning of high-rate anaerobic bioreactors. The primary mechanisms by biochar work in these bioreactors are direct interspecies electron transfer, microbial immobilization, or gene level alternations in microbial structure. The present article explores and reviews the recent application of biochar in a high-rate anaerobic bioreactor treating high-strength industrial wastewater.

Role of KOH-activated biochar on promoting anaerobic digestion of biomass from Pennisetumgianteum

Pennisetum giganteum is a promising non-food crop feedstock for biogas production due to its high productivity and bio-methane potential. However, the accumulation of volatile fatty acids (VFA) usually restricts the conversion efficiency of P. giganteum biomass (PGB) during anaerobic digestion (AD). Here, the role of KOH-activated biochar (KB) in improving the AD efficiency of PGB and the related mechanisms were investigated in detail. The results revealed that KB exhibited excellent electrical conductivity, electron transfer capacity and specific capacitance, which might be related to the decrease in the electron transfer resistance after adding KB to the AD process. In addition, the KB addition not only reinforced metabolisms of energy and VFAs but also promoted the conversion of VFAs to methane, leading to a 52% increase in the methane production rate. Bioinformatics analysis showed that Smithella and Methanosaeta were key players in the KB-mediated AD process of PGB. The stimulatory effect of methanogenesis probably resulted from the establishment of direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) between VFA-oxidizing acetogens (e.g., Smithella) and Methanosaeta. These findings provided a key step to improve the PGB-based AD process.

Riboflavin-loaded carbon cloth aids the anaerobic digestion of cow dung by promoting direct interspecies electron transfer

Cow dung generates globally due to increased beef and milk consumption, but its treatment efficiency remains low. Previous studies have shown that riboflavin-loaded conductive materials can improve anaerobic digestion through enhance direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET). However, its effect on the practical anaerobic digestion of cow dung remained unclear. In this study, carbon cloth loaded with riboflavin (carbon cloth-riboflavin) was added into an anaerobic digester treating cow dung. The carbon cloth-riboflavin reactor showed a better performance than other two reactors. The metagenomic analysis revealed that Methanothrix on the surface of the carbon cloth predominantly utilized the CO2 reduction for methane production, further enhanced after riboflavin addition, while Methanothrix in bulk sludge were using the acetate decarboxylation pathway. Furthermore, the carbon cloth-riboflavin enriched various major methanogenic pathways and activated a large number of enzymes associated with DIET. Riboflavin's presence altered the microbial communities and the abundance of functional genes relate to DIET, ultimately leading to a better performance of anaerobic digestion for cow dung.

Sugarcane-bagasse-ash in enhanced mesophilic Co-digestion for biogas and nutrient recovery: A concept of developing rural circular bioeconomy

Conductive agro-industrial wastes as accelerants in the anaerobic digestion (AD) of organic waste is a good technique for developing a rural circular economy, such as producing bioenergy and biofertilizer. This study disclosed the a role of sugar cane bagasse ash (SCBA) in enhancing the bioenergy (biogas) yield and digestate fertility via anaerobic co-digestion (AcoD) of buffalo dung (BD) and vegetable residue (VR) under mesophilic conditions (37 ᴼC). Firstly, an optimal BD/VR ratio (1:3) was determined based on biogas yield by introducing five different BD/VR ratios (1:0, 3:1, 1:1, 1:3, and 0:1) into AcoD systems. Secondly, the biogas yield was increased further by adding SCBA at five different concentrations (0, 0.5, 1, 1.5, and 2 wt%). Experimental results disclosed that the 1.5 wt% of SCBA gave the highest cumulative biogas yield (153.67 mL/g VS), COD removal rate (31.18%), and fertility (5.08%). Moreover, a framework is suggested to understand the role of SCBA in the enhanced DIET mechanism. This work documents an environmentally friendly and economical technique for developing a rural circular bioeconomy via the AD of organic agro-waste.

Evaluating effects of biochar on anaerobic digestion of dewatered waste activated sludge: Digester performance, microbial co-metabolism and underlying mechanism

Biochar has been proven to be capable of improving the performance of anaerobic digestion (AD). However, the effect of biochar on microbial communities remains ambiguous. In this study, the influence of pH was excluded in a semi-continuous anaerobic digestor for the treatment of dewatered waste activated sludge (WAS) to determine the effect of biochar on microbes. Compared with the control group, the average methane production increased by 24.5% and 23.2% at the organic loading rates (OLRs) of 1.56 and 3.00 gTS/L/d, respectively, in the presence of biochar. This study innovatively found biochar accelerated the enrichment of Methanofastidiosaceae, which competed with Methanobacteriaceae for H2, and its abundance increased from 0.99% at the OLR of 1.56 g TS/L/d to 16.57% and 38.11% at the OLR of 3.00 and 5.60 gTS/L/d, respectively. The efficient metabolic network of f__norank_o__Aminicenantales, syntrophic bacteria, Methanofastidiosaceae and Methanosaetaceae promoted the conversion of WAS to CH4 in the biochar group. In addition, metagenome analysis revealed that biochar optimized the metabolites related to energy conservation and electron transfer, particularly for hydrogenase (frhABG, mbhLHK and hndA-D), confirming that biochar changed the way H2 was involved in methanogenesis. These findings provide novel insights into the direct effect of biochar on microbial evolution and facilitate the reduction of WAS to achieve higher economic benefits in biogas production.

Enhancing methane production from food waste with iron-carbon micro-electrolysis in a two-stage process

A two-stage process, consisting of a leach-bed reactor (LBR) and an up-flow anaerobic sludge blanket reactor (UASB), has been commonly adopted to improve food waste anaerobic digestion. However, its application is limited due to low hydrolysis and methanogenesis efficiencies. This study proposed a strategy of incorporating iron-carbon micro-electrolysis (ICME) into the UASB and recirculating its effluent to the LBR to improve the two-stage process efficiency. Results showed that the integration of the ICME with the UASB significantly increased the CH4 yield by 168.29%. The improvement of the food waste hydrolysis in the LBR mainly contributed to the enhanced CH4 yield (approximately 94.5%). The enrichment of hydrolytic-acidogenic bacterial activity, facilitated by the Fe2+ generated through ICME, might be the primary cause of the improved food waste hydrolysis. Moreover, ICME enriched the growth of hydrogenotrophic methanogens and stimulated the hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis pathway in the UASB, contributing partially to the enhanced CH4 yield.

Direct interspecies electron transfer enables anaerobic oxidation of sulfide to elemental sulfur coupled with CO2-reducing methanogenesis

Electric syntrophy between fatty acid oxidizers and methanogens through direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) is essential for balancing acidogenesis and methanogenesis in anaerobic digestion. Promoting DIET using electrically conductive additives proved effective in enhancing methanogenesis; however, its possibility to affect other microbial redox reactions in methanogenic systems has been little studied. This study provides the first confirmation of the electro-syntrophic coupling of sulfide oxidation to S0 with CO2-reducing methanogenesis in sulfur-rich methanogenic cultures supplemented with conductive magnetite (100-700-nm particle size). The H2S content in biogas, initially exceeding 5000 ppmv, decreased to below 1 ppmv along with an accumulation of extracellular S0 (60-70 mg/L; initially <1 mg/L) at a magnetite dose of 20 mM Fe, while there were no significant changes in methane yield. A comprehensive polyphasic approach demonstrated that the S0 formation occurs through electro-syntrophic oxidation of sulfide coupled with CO2-reducing methanogenesis, involving Methanothrix as the dominant methanogen.

Acclimatizing waste activated sludge in a thermophilic anaerobic fixed-bed biofilm reactor to maximize biogas production for food waste treatment at high organic loading rates

Thermophilic anaerobic digestion (TAD) provides a promising solution for sustainable high-strength waste treatment due to its enhanced methane-rich biogas recovery. However, high organic loading rates (OLR) exceeding 3.0 kgCOD/m3/day and short hydraulic retention times (HRT) below 10 days pose challenges in waste-to-energy conversion during TAD, stemming from volatile fatty acids (VFAs) accumulation and methanogenesis failure. In this study, we implemented a stepwise strategy for acclimatizing waste activated sludge (WAS) in a thermophilic anaerobic fixed-bed biofilm reactor (TA-FBBR) to optimize methanogen populations, thereby enhancing waste-to-energy efficiencies under elevated OLRs in food waste treatment. Results showed that following stepwise acclimatization, the TA-FBBR achieved stable methane production of approximately 5.8 L/L-reactor/day at an ultrahigh OLR of ∼20 kgCOD/m3/day and ∼15 kgVS/m3/day at 6-day HRT in food waste treatment. The average methane yield reached 0.45 m3/kgCODremoval, attaining the theoretical production in TAD. Moreover, VFA concentrations were stabilized below 1000 mg/L at the ultrahigh OLR under 6-day HRT, while maintaining an acetate/propionate ratio of > 1.8 and a VFA/TAK ratio of < 0.3 serving as effective indicators of system stability and methane yield potential. The microbial community analysis revealed that the WAS acclimatization strategy fostered the microbial diversity and abundance of Methanothermobacter and Methanosarcina. Methanosarcina in the biofilm were observed to be twice as abundant as Methanothermobacter, indicating a potential preference for biofilm existence among methanogens. The findings demonstrated an effective strategy, specifically the stepwise acclimatization of WAS in a thermophilic fixed-bed biofilm reactor, to enhance the food waste treatment performance at high OLRs, contributing valuable mechanistic and technical insights for future sustainable high-strength waste management.

Effects of different concentrations of butyrate on microbial community construction and metabolic pathways in anaerobic digestion

Investigating the effect of butyric acid concentration on anaerobic digestion systems in complex systems is important for the efficient degradation of butyric acid and improving the efficiency of anaerobic digestion. In this study, different loadings of butyric acid with 2.8, 3.2, and 3.6 g/(L·d) were added to the anaerobic reactor. At a high organic loading rate of 3.6 g/(L·d), methane was efficiently produced with VBP (Volumetric Biogas Production) of 1.50 L/(L·d) and biogas content between 65% and 75%. VFAs concentration remained below 2000 mg/L. Metagenome sequencing revealed changes in the functional flora within different stages. Methanosarcina, Syntrophomonas, and Lentimicrobium were the main and functional microorganisms. That the relative abundance of methanogens exceeded 35% and methanogenic metabolic pathways were increased indicated the methanogenic capacity of the system significantly improved. The presence of a large number of hydrolytic acid-producing bacteria also indicated the importance of the hydrolytic acid-producing stage in the system.

Emerging Strategies for Enhancing Propionate Conversion in Anaerobic Digestion: A Review

Anaerobic digestion (AD) is a triple-benefit biotechnology for organic waste treatment, renewable production, and carbon emission reduction. In the process of anaerobic digestion, pH, temperature, organic load, ammonia nitrogen, VFAs, and other factors affect fermentation efficiency and stability. The balance between the generation and consumption of volatile fatty acids (VFAs) in the anaerobic digestion process is the key to stable AD operation. However, the accumulation of VFAs frequently occurs, especially propionate, because its oxidation has the highest Gibbs free energy when compared to other VFAs. In order to solve this problem, some strategies, including buffering addition, suspension of feeding, decreased organic loading rate, and so on, have been proposed. Emerging methods, such as bioaugmentation, supplementary trace elements, the addition of electronic receptors, conductive materials, and the degasification of dissolved hydrogen, have been recently researched, presenting promising results. But the efficacy of these methods still requires further studies and tests regarding full-scale application. The main objective of this paper is to provide a comprehensive review of the mechanisms of propionate generation, the metabolic pathways and the influencing factors during the AD process, and the recent literature regarding the experimental research related to the efficacy of various strategies for enhancing propionate biodegradation. In addition, the issues that must be addressed in the future and the focus of future research are identified, and the potential directions for future development are predicted.

Enhancement of perfluorooctanoic acid and perfluorooctane sulphonic acid removal in constructed wetland using iron mineral: Performance and mechanisms

Polyfluoroalkyl substance (PFAS) pose a threat to the aquatic environment due to their environmental persistence. The removal of PFAS using constructed wetlands (CWs) has received interest, but the adsorption saturation and limited removal capacity of the substrate is frequently challenging. To enhance the microbial degradation and performance of the substrate, different configurations of iron minerals were used as substrate to remove perfluorooctane sulphonic acid (PFOS) and perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) from CWs. The addition of iron minerals resulted in elimination of 57.2% and 63.9% of PFOS and PFOA in the effluent, respectively, which were 35.0% and 36.8% higher than that of control. Moreover, up to 85.4%, 86%, and 85.1% of NH₄⁺, NO₃^-, and phosphorus, respectively, was removed using iron minerals. The enhanced electron transfer in iron mineral-based CWs was confirmed by a 61.2% increase in cytochrome C reductase content and an increased Fe(III)/Fe(II) ratio. Microbial analysis showed that the proportions of microbes with PFAS removal capacity (e.g. Burkholderiae and Pseudomonas), and the key pathways of the TCA cycle and glycolysis were increased in iron mineral-based CW. Based on these findings, we conclude that supplementation with iron mineral could enhance PFOA and PFOS removal in CWs.

Effects of biochar addition towards the treatment of blackwater in anaerobic dynamic membrane bioreactor (AnDMBR): Comparison among room temperature, mesophilic and thermophilic conditions

Effects of biochar addition on the performance of anaerobic dynamic membrane bioreactor (AnDMBR) under different temperatures for blackwater treatment was investigated. When the organic load ratios (OLR) was 1.0 g COD/L·d, the specific methane yield for the three biochar-amended reactors were 125.7, 148.0 and 182.3 mLCH₄/g COD_removed, respectively. Compare to those digesters without biochar participation, the methane production in the thermophilic reactor with biochar increased by 12% while the other two digesters increased by 6-10%. An analysis of membrane filtration resistance showed a reduction in total resistance (R_t) of 6.2 × 10¹¹-7.3 × 10¹¹ m^-1 when biochar was added to the three reactors. The thermophilic reactors with biochar increased the relative abundance of Methanothermobacter and promoted gene expression of metabolic pathways related to hydrolysis, acid production and methane production. Overall, biochar showed great potential as an inexpensive conductive material to increase methane production with reduced membrane fouling in AnDMBR systems.

Role of biochar in anaerobic microbiome enrichment and methane production enhancement during olive mill wastewater biomethanization

The current research work attempted to investigate, for the first time, the impact of biochar addition, on anaerobic digestion of olive mill wastewater with different initial chemical oxygen demand loads in batch cultures (10 g/L, 15 g/L, and 20 g/L). Methane yields were compared by applying one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by post-hoc Tukey's analysis. The results demonstrated that adding at 5 g/L biochar to olive mill wastewater with an initial chemical oxygen demand load of 20 g/L increased methane yield by 97.8% and mitigated volatile fatty acid accumulation compared to the control batch. According to the results of microbial community succession revealed by the Illumina amplicon sequencing, biochar supplementation significantly increased diversity of the microbial community and improved the abundance of potential genera involved in direct interspecies electron transfer, including Methanothrix and Methanosarcina. Consequently, biochar can be a promising alternative in terms of the recovery of metabolic activity during anaerobic digestion of olive mill wastewater at a large scale.

Enhancing anaerobic digestion of food waste with granular activated carbon immobilized with riboflavin

Previous studies have shown that anaerobic digestion of food waste can be enhanced by addition of conductive materials that stimulate direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) between bacteria and methanogens. However, at extremely high organic loading rates (OLRs), volatile fatty acids (VFAs) still tend to accumulate even in the presence of conductive materials because of an imbalance between the formation of fermentation products and the rate of methanogenesis. In this study, granular activated carbon (GAC) immobilized with riboflavin (GAC-riboflavin) was added to an anaerobic digester treating food waste. The GAC-riboflavin reactor operated stably at OLRs as high as 11.5 kgCOD/ (m³·d) and kept VFA concentrations below 69.4 mM, COD removal efficiencies, methane production rates, and biogas methane concentrations were much higher in the GAC-riboflavin reactor than the GAC- and non-amended reactors. Transcripts associated with genes that code for proteins involved in DIET based metabolism were somewhat more highly expressed by Methanothrix in the GAC-riboflavin reactor. However, it is unlikely that riboflavin acted as an electron shuttle to stimulate DIET. Rather, it seemed to provide nutrients that enhanced the growth of microorganisms involved in the anaerobic digestion process, including those that are capable of DIET.

Roles of Fe-C amendment on sulfate-containing pharmaceutical wastewater anaerobic treatment: Microbial community and sulfur metabolism

The effects of multiple two-phase anaerobic treatment involving acidification coupling Fe-C on sulfate-containing chemical synthesis-based pharmaceutical wastewater treatment were investigated. Fe-C was added as a filler with 25% vol. to acidogenic reactors for semi-continuous operation. The results suggested that Fe-C amendment promoted sulfate removal efficiency by 47.5% and shortened the reaction time by 50% in the acidogenic phase. With mitigation of sulfate inhibition, SCOD removal efficiency and methane production were further increased by 24.6% and 398% compared to direct raw wastewater anaerobic digestion, respectively, in methanogenic phase. The results of sulfate removal kinetics confirmed a 150% increase of removal rate in acidogenic phase. However, the apparent kinetic microbial sulfate removal constant without Fe-C amendment was maintained at approximately 0.06 h^-1. The Fe-C amendment not only increased the relative abundance of Methanothrix and Desulfovibrio for sulfate reduction but also enriched unclassified_p__Chloroflexi and unclassified_c__Deltaproteobacteria for acidification. Metagenomic results indicated that Fe-C enhanced dissimilatory sulfate reduction and PAPS synthesis of assimilatory step. The hydrogen sulfide production through the 3-mercaptopyruvate to pyruvate pathways was also enhanced. Butyrate-oxidizing genes were increased synchronously to convert butyrate to acetate.

Enhancing anaerobic methane production in integrated floating-film activated sludge system filled with novel MWCNTs-modified carriers

Conductive materials can enhance anaerobic methane production by accelerating interspecies electron transfer between electroactive bacteria and methanogens. However, the daily loss or less specific surface area of small/big size of conductive materials always limits their application in anaerobic digestion. In this study, the conductive multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) (15 wt% and 20 wt%) were mixed with high-density polyethylene (HDPE) and novel conductive suspended carriers were prepared. Results showed the conductivity of the novel conductive suspended carriers increased by 1-2 orders of magnitude comparing with HDPE carriers, as well as the attached biomass improved from 3.93 g/m² (HDPE carriers) to 5.82 g/m² (15 wt% MWCNTs-modified carriers) and 6.67 g/m² (20 wt% MWCNTs-modified carriers). Integrated floating-film activated sludge (IFFAS) filled with MWCNT-modified carriers showed significant advantages in chemical oxygen demand (COD) removal (removal efficiency increased by 3.6-37.2%) and methanogenic performance (cumulative methane increased by 12.28-62.91%) compared with the control reactor filled with conventional HDPE carriers when treating sodium propionate wastewater at the organic loading rates (OLR) of 11.3-26.3 kg COD/(m³∙d). SEM images and high-throughput sequencing results proved potential direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) had been established successfully on the MWCNTs-modified carriers. The syntrophic electroactive bacteria (Geobacter, Thauera) and Methanotrix were enriched by 2.28-4.58% and 9.41-16.80% respectively owning to the addition of novel conductive carriers. This study proved IFFAS process filled with novel MWCNTs-modified suspended carriers showed great potential in establishing DIET to enhance anaerobic digestion in practical application.

Glycol/glycerol-fed electrically conductive aggregates suggest a mechanism of stimulating direct interspecies electron transfer in methanogenic digesters

The possibility of stimulating direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) within aggregates of methanogenic digesters respectively with ethanol, glycol, and glycerol as a primary substrate was investigated to better understand the mechanisms of alcohol compounds stimulating DIET. Aggregates fed with ethanol, glycol, and glycerol were electrically conductive (10.4-19.4 uS/cm), with a temperature dependence of metallic-like conductivity. Close examination of transmission electron microscope images observed the potential interspecies connected networks assembled by filaments within these aggregates. Further investigations via metatranscriptomics found that, genes for electrically conductive pili (e-pili) (Log₂FPKM, 9.39-10.96) and c-type cytochromes (8.90-9.64) were highly expressed within aggregates. Glycerol-fed aggregates exhibited the highest gene expression for e-pili, while glycol-fed aggregates exhibited the highest gene expression for c-type cytochromes. Methanothrix species were dominant and metabolically active within aggregates. Genes encoding the enzymes involved in carbon dioxide reduction were highly expressed in Methanothrix species, suggesting that they participated in DIET. In addition, transcript abundance of genes encoding alcohol dehydrogenase and NADH-quinone oxidoreductase in alcohol dehydrogenation closely associated with NADH/NAD⁺ transformation within glycol- and glycerol-fed aggregates was generally higher than that within ethanol-fed aggregates. These results, and the fact that NADH/NAD⁺ transformation was very linked to the ATP synthesis complex that further supported the formation of extracellular electrical connection components, e-pili and membrane-bound multi-heme c-type cytochromes (MHCs), provided a possibility that alcohol compounds comprised of hydroxy groups could stimulate DIET and more hydroxy groups comprised were better for this stimulation.

A comprehensive review on the use of conductive materials to improve anaerobic digestion: Focusing on landfill leachate treatment

Globally, around 70% of waste is disposed of in open dumps or landfill sites, with the leachate generated from these sites containing high concentrations of organic and inorganic compounds, which will adversely affect aquatic environments if discharged without proper treatment. Anaerobic digestion of landfill leachate is an environmentally-friendly method that efficiently converts organic compounds into methane-rich biogas. However, the widespread application of anaerobic digestion has been hindered by poor system stability, low methanogenic activity and a high level of volatile fatty acids (VFAs) accumulation, increasing the operational costs of treatment. Conductive materials can be added to the digester to improve the performance of anaerobic digestion in landfill leachate treatment systems and studies reporting the use of conductive materials for this purpose are hereby thoroughly reviewed. The mechanism of microbial growth and enrichment by conductive materials is discussed, as well as the subsequent effect on waste metabolism, methane production, syntrophic relationships and interspecies electron transfer. The porous structure, specific surface area and conductivity of conductive materials play vital roles in the facilitation of syntrophic relationships between fermentative bacteria and methanogenic archaea. In addition, the mediation of direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) by conductive materials increases the methane content of biogas from 16% to 60% as compared to indirect interspecies electron transfer (IIET) in conventional anaerobic digestion systems. This review identifies research gaps in the field of material-amended anaerobic systems, suggesting future research directions including investigations into combined chemical-biological treatments for landfill leachate, microbial management using conductive materials for efficient pollutant removal and the capacity for material reuse. Moreover, findings of this review provide a reference for the efficient and large-scale treatment of landfill leachate by anaerobic digestion with conductive materials.

Advanced strategies for enhancing dark fermentative biohydrogen production from biowaste towards sustainable environment

As a clean energy carrier, hydrogen is a promising alternative to fossil fuel so as the global growing energy demand can be met. Currently, producing hydrogen from biowastes through fermentation has attracted much attention due to its multiple advantages of biowastes management and valuable energy generation. Nevertheless, conventional dark fermentation (DF) processes are still hindered by the low biohydrogen yields and challenges of biohydrogen purification, which limit their commercialization. In recent years, researchers have focused on various advanced strategies for enhancing biohydrogen yields, such as screening of super hydrogen-producing bacteria, genetic engineering, cell immobilization, nanomaterials utilization, bioreactors modification, and combination of different processes. This paper critically reviews by discussing the above stated technologies employed in DF, respectively, to improve biohydrogen generation and stating challenges and future perspectives on biowaste-based biohydrogen production.

Improvement of Direct Interspecies Electron Transfer via Adding Conductive Materials in Anaerobic Digestion: Mechanisms, Performances, and Challenges

Anaerobic digestion is an effective and sustainable technology for resource utilization of organic wastes. Recently, adding conductive materials in anaerobic digestion to promote direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) has become a hot topic, which enhances the syntrophic conversion of various organics to methane. This review comprehensively summarizes the recent findings of DIET mechanisms with different mediating ways. Meanwhile, the influence of DIET on anaerobic digestion performance and the underlying mechanisms of how DIET mediated by conductive materials influences the lag phase, methane production, and system stability are systematically explored. Furthermore, current challenges such as the unclear biological mechanisms, influences of non-DIET mechanisms, limitations of organic matters syntrophically oxidized by way of DIET, and problems in practical application of DIET mediated by conductive materials are discussed in detail. Finally, the future research directions for practical application of DIET are outlined.

Promotion of granular activated carbon on methanogenesis of readily acidogenic carbohydrate-rich waste at low inoculation ratio

Although granular activated carbon (GAC) supplementation into food waste anaerobic digestion system is an efficient means to enhance methane production. As yet, little is known whether GAC supplementation is suitable for the extreme condition of pH below 4.5, which occurs in the use of readily acidogenic carbohydrate-rich waste (RACW) as methanogenic substrate when at low inoculation/substrate (I/S) ratio. This study investigated the effects of GAC on RACW anaerobic digestion under different inoculation/substrate (I/S) ratios. It was found that the addition of GAC was a preferred alternative method to enhancing I/S ratio for promoting methane production from RACW. The additive dose of 20 g/L was recommended for the methanogenesis of RACW at low I/S of 1:2, and the methane yield was enhanced by 12 times (505 mL/g-VS) compared with that (42 mL/g-VS) from the control. This promotion resulted from the apparently solving the over-acidogenesis problem and the adjustment of pH to the desired range. Further investigation revealed that the added GAC enhanced the activities of acetate kinase and coenzyme F₄₂₀, that engaged in the acidogenic and methanogenic reactions. Meanwhile, the decrease of hydrogenase and increase of c-Cyts implied that the metabolism of direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) was probably stimulated by GAC. Microbial investigation inferred that the enriched hydrogenotrophic methanogens and DIET-mediated syntrophic partners of Geobacter/Syntrophomonas with Methanosarcina were responsible for the enhanced methane yield.

Engineered biochar: A multifunctional material for energy and environment

Biochar is a stable carbon-rich product loaded with upgraded properties obtained by thermal cracking of biomasses in an oxygen-free atmosphere. The pristine biochar is further modified to produce engineered biochar via various physical, mechanical, and chemical methods. The hasty advancement in engineered biochar synthesis via different technologies and their application in the field of energy and environment is a topical issue that required an up-to-date review. Therefore, this review deals with comprehensive and recent mechanistic approaches of engineered biochar synthesis and its further application in the field of energy and the environment. Synthesis and activation of engineered biochar via various methods has been deliberated in brief. Furthermore, this review systematically covered the impacts of engineered biochar amendment in the composting process, anaerobic digestion (AD), soil microbial community encouragement, and their enzymatic activities. Finally, this review provided a glimpse of the knowledge gaps and challenges associated with application of engineered biochar in various fields, which needs urgent attention in future research.

Syntrophic propionate-oxidizing bacteria in methanogenic systems

The mutual nutritional cooperation underpinning syntrophic propionate degradation provides a scant amount of energy for the microorganisms involved, so propionate degradation often acts as a bottleneck in methanogenic systems. Understanding the ecology, physiology and metabolic capacities of syntrophic propionate-oxidizing bacteria (SPOB) is of interest in both engineered and natural ecosystems, as it offers prospects to guide further development of technologies for biogas production and biomass-derived chemicals, and is important in forecasting contributions by biogenic methane emissions to climate change. SPOB are distributed across different phyla. They can exhibit broad metabolic capabilities in addition to syntrophy (e.g. fermentative, sulfidogenic and acetogenic metabolism) and demonstrate variations in interplay with cooperating partners, indicating nuances in their syntrophic lifestyle. In this review, we discuss distinctions in gene repertoire and organization for the methylmalonyl-CoA pathway, hydrogenases and formate dehydrogenases, and emerging facets of (formate/hydrogen/direct) electron transfer mechanisms. We also use information from cultivations, thermodynamic calculations and omic analyses as the basis for identifying environmental conditions governing propionate oxidation in various ecosystems. Overall, this review improves basic and applied understanding of SPOB and highlights knowledge gaps, hopefully encouraging future research and engineering on propionate metabolism in biotechnological processes.

Enhanced effect of biochar on leaching vanadium and copper from stone coal tailings by Thiobacillus ferrooxidans

Among the many extraction technologies for recovering metal resources from tailings, bioleaching technology is gradually showing its momentum. In our research, the enhanced effect of biochar on the bioleaching of stone coal tailings by Thiobacillus ferrooxidans (T. ferrooxidans) has been explored. In the static bioleaching experiment for 10 days, the leaching rate of vanadium (V) and copper (Cu) increased by 26.8% and 21.0% respectively after adding 5 g/L biochar. The dynamic bioleaching experiment further verified that under the promotion of biochar, the 44 day cumulative leaching rate of V and Cu increased by 15.3% and 14.5%, respectively. The promoting effect of biochar on T. ferrooxidans was mainly reflected in two aspects. The unique porous structure of biochar created a microenvironment for free microorganisms for inhabitation, while storing abundant nutrients. Biochar can also act as an excellent electronic medium to promote electron transfer, improving the oxidation ability of T. ferrooxidans on Fe²⁺. Furthermore, the presence of biochar may effectively inhibit the formation of jarosite precipitation on tailings in bioleaching, thereby improving the dissolution of tailings and the release of metal elements. This study demonstrates that biochar-enhanced bioleaching may be an efficient and environmentally friendly method for recovering metal resources from tailings.

Enhanced anaerobic co-digestion performance by using surface-annealed titanium spheres at different atmospheres

A series of surface-annealed titanium spheres (Ti-A, Ti-B, and Ti-C) in different atmospheres were used as accelerants in anaerobic co-digestion (AcoD) systems under magnetic field (MF). Surface-annealed titanium spheres and MF exhibit remarkable coupling and promoting effects on the AcoD performance. The cumulative biogas yield (435.84-552.60 mL/g VS) and total chemical oxygen demand (COD) degradation efficiency (59.76%-71.28%) of the AcoD systems with Ti_MF, Ti-A_MF, Ti-B_MF, and Ti-C_MF were significantly higher than control (357.66 mL/g VS and 51.5%). The digestates of the AcoD system with surface-annealed Ti spheres delivered excellent stability (49.83%-59.90%) and fertilizer (4.21%-4.56%). This work clarifies the possible role of surface-annealed Ti spheres in enhancing methanogenesis.

Carbon-based conductive materials enhance biomethane recovery from organic wastes: A review of the impacts on anaerobic treatment

Amongst the most important sustainable waste management strategies, anaerobic biotechnology has had a central role over the past century in the management of high-pollution load sources, such as food, agricultural and municipal wastes. During anaerobic digestion (AD), valuable by-products such as digestate and biogas are produced. Biogas (mainly composed of methane) is generated through a series of reactions between bacteria and archaea. Enhancement of AD process with higher methane yield, accelerated methane production rate, and shorter start-up time is possible via tapping into a novel methanogenic pathway discovered a decade ago. This fundamentally new concept that is a substitute to interspecies hydrogen transfer is called direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET). DIET, a thermodynamically more feasible way of electron transfer, has been proven to occur between bacteria and methanogens. It is well-documented that amendment of carbon-based conductive materials (CCMs) can stimulate DIET via serving as an electrical conduit between microorganisms. Therefore, different types of CCMs such as biochar and activated carbon have been amended to a variety of AD reactors and enhancement of process performance was reported. In this review, a comparative analysis is presented for enhancement of AD performance in relation to major CCM related factors; electrical conductivity, redox properties, particle size and dosage. Additionally, the impacts of AD operational conditions such as organic loading rate and temperature on CCM amended reactors were discussed. Further, the changes in microbial communities of CCM amended reactors were reviewed and future perspectives along with challenges for CCM application in AD have been provided.

New insights into the r/K selection theory achieved in methanogenic systems through continuous-flow and sequencing batch operational modes

Anaerobic digestion is achieved through cooperation among various types of microorganisms, and the regulation of microbial communities is key to achieving stable system operation. In this study, the r/K selection theory was adopted to examine the system performance and microbial characteristics in anaerobic reactors with different operating modes (continuous-flow reactors, CFRs; sequencing batch reactors, SBRs) and sludge retention times (25 and 10 days). Four lab-scale reactors (CFR_25d, CFR_10d, SBR_25d, and SBR_10d) were operated. In the cycle reaction, CFR_25d achieved the highest methane yield (678.0 mL/L) and methane production rate (140.8 mL/(L·h)); while those in CFR_10d were the lowest, which could have been due to an accumulation of volatile fatty acids. CFR could wash out r-strategists efficiently, such as Methanosarcina. CFR_25d and CFR_10d significantly enriched the K-strategist Geobacter, with the relative abundances of 34.0% and 72.6%, respectively. In addition, the hydrogenotrophic methanogens of Methanolinea and Methanospirillum (K-strategists) dominated in CFR_25d and CFR_10d. Methanobacterium adapted to the diverse operational conditions, but the slow grower Methanosaeta only accounted for 0.9% in CFR_10d. Failure to enrich propionate oxidizers resulted in a functional absence of propionate degradation in the CFRs.

Nano-Biochar as a Sustainable Catalyst for Anaerobic Digestion: A Synergetic Closed-Loop Approach

Nowadays, the valorization of organic wastes using various carbon-capturing technologies is a prime research area. The anaerobic digestion (AD) technology is gaining much consideration in this regard that simultaneously deals with waste valorization and bioenergy production sustainably. Biochar, a well-recognized carbonaceous pyrogenic material and possessing a broad range of inherent physical and chemical properties, has diverse applications in the fields of agriculture, health-care, sensing, catalysis, carbon capture, the environment and energy. The nano-biochar-amended anaerobic digestion approach has intensively been explored for the past few years. However, an inclusive study of multi-functional roles of biochar and the mechanism involved for enhancing the biogas production via the AD process still need to be evaluated. The present review inspects the significant role of biochar addition and the kinetics involved, further focusing on the limitations, perspectives, and challenges of the technology. Additionally, the techno-economic analysis and life-cycle assessment of biochar-aided AD process for the closed-loop integration of biochar and AD and possible improvement practices are discussed.

Multi-faceted influences of biochar addition on swine manure digestion under tetracycline antibiotic pressure

This study explored the influence of biochar (BC) on anaerobic digestion (AD) of swine manure under various tetracycline (TC) pressures. It was found that both low (0.5 mg/L) and high (50 mg/L) TC pressures inhibited AD performance, while BC mitigated it in multi-facets. Under high TC pressure, BC accelerated syntrophic methanogenesis by boosting direct interspecies electron transfer pathway. The TC removal efficiencies were enhanced by 24.3-158.2% with BC assistance, which was attributed to the enhanced biological degradation rather than BC's physiochemical adsorption. Moreover, BC possibly acted as a protective role to alleviate intensive extracellular polymeric substances secretion under TC pressures. Integrated microbial community, metabolic function predicting, and antibiotic resistance genes (ARG) analysis revealed that BC addition not only enriched Anaerolineceae, which likely responsible for the 24.2-41.9% higher level expression of organics metabolic pathways and xenobiotics biodegradation, but also reduced ARG abundance by controlling the potential ARG host (Firmicutes) proliferation.

Feammox process driven anaerobic ammonium removal of wastewater treatment under supplementing Fe(III) compounds

Ammonium removal in wastewater treatment plants demands large quantities energy input, such as aeration for wastewater and the addition of organics for nitrate reduction. Anaerobic ammonium oxidation coupled to Fe(III) reduction, called Feammox process play a crucial role in natural nitrogen cycle, which has been rarely investigated in the field of wastewater treatment. Besides, Iron-reducing bacteria (FeRB) as function bacteria of Feammox could transfer electrons to iron oxide by oxidizing organics. The possibility of anaerobic ammonium removal coupled with organics should be investigated to assess the potential of Feammox process for conventional wastewater treatment. In this study, five Fe(III) compounds, Fe₂O₃, Fe₃O₄, Fe(OH)₃, Citrate-Fe and pyrite were supplemented to investigate the effect of iron oxides on ammonium removal in serum bottles with working volume of 100 mL. It was found that ammonium removal efficiency of the Fe₂O₃ group was the highest. To simulate wastewater treatment process in sewage treatment plant, three Up-flow anaerobic sludge blanket reactors with volume of 250 mL adding Fe₂O₃ were applied with influent of ammonium and carbon sources. It was found that the organics significantly inhibited the ammonium removal by Feammox process. This was attributed to that carbon sources and ammonium could be used as electron donors for Fe(III) reduction. In addition, this nitrogen removal was also likely related with the iron cycle, i.e., Fe(III) reduction with ammonium oxidation and Fe(II) oxidation with nitrate/nitrite reduction. This study provides a promising alternative technology for anaerobic ammonium removal in wastewater treatment. Optimizing nitrogen removal and carbon sources applied in conventional wastewater plants are required in future.

Novel bioaugmentation strategy boosted with biochar to alleviate ammonia toxicity in continuous biomethanation

This study investigated for the first time if ammonia tolerant methanogenic consortia can be stored in gel (biogel) and used in a later time on-demand as bioaugmentation inocula, to efficiently relieve ammonia inhibition in continuous biomethanation systems. Moreover, wood biochar was assessed as a potential enhancer of the novel biogel bioaugmentation process. Three thermophilic (55 °C), continuous stirred-tank reactors (R_Bgel, R_Char and R_Mix), operated at 4.5 g NH₄⁺-N L^-1 were exposed to biogel, biochar and mixture of biogel and biochar, respectively, while a fourth reactor (R_Ctrl) was used as control. The results showed that the methane production yields of R_Mix, R_Char and R_Bgel increased by 28.6%, 20.2% and 10.7%, respectively compared to R_Ctrl. The highest methane yield was achieved by the synergistic interaction between biogel and biochar. Additionally, biogel stimulated a rapid recovery of Methanoculleus thermophilus sp. and syntrophic acetate oxidising bacteria populations.

Stimulation of pyrolytic carbon materials as electron shuttles on the anaerobic transformation of recalcitrant organic pollutants: A review

Pyrolytic carbon materials (PCMs) with various surface functionalities are widely used as environmentally friendly and cost-efficient adsorbents for the removal of organic and inorganic pollutants. Recent studies have illustrated that PCMs as electron shuttles (ESs) could also show excellent performances in promoting the anaerobic transformation of recalcitrant organic pollutants (ROPs). Numerous studies have demonstrated the excellent electron-shuttle capability (ESC) of PCMs to stimulate the anaerobic reductive transformation of ROPs. However, there is a lack of consistent understanding of the mechanism of ESC formation in PCMs and the stimulation mechanism for ROPs anaerobic transformation. To gain a more comprehensive understanding of the latest developments in the study of PCMs as ESs for ROPs anaerobic transformation, this review summarizes the formation mechanism, influencing factors, and stimulation mechanisms of ESC. ESC benefits from redox functional groups (quinone and phenol groups), persistent free radicals (PFRs), redox-active metal ions, conductive graphene phase, and porous nature of their surface. The factors influencing ESC include the highest treatment temperature (HTT), feedstocks, modification methods, and environmental conditions, of which, the HTT is the key factor. PCMs promote the reductive transformation of ROPs under anaerobic conditions via abiotic and biotic pathways. Eventually, the prospects for the ROPs anaerobic transformation enhanced by PCMs are proposed.

Carbon- and metal-based mediators modulate anaerobic methanogenesis and phenol removal: Focusing on stimulatory and inhibitory mechanism

In this study, anaerobic batch experiments were conducted to investigate the effect of carbon-based (biochar) and metal-based (nanoscale zero-valent iron, NZVI and zero valent iron, ZVI) mediators on the AD process treating phenolic wastewater. Fresh apricot shell- and wood-derived biochar (BiocharA, BiocharB) could remove the phenol efficiently (77.1% and 86.2%), suggesting that biodegradation cooperated with adsorption had advantage in phenol removal. BiocharB, NZVI and ZVI enhanced the methane production by 17.6%, 23.7% and 23.2%, respectively. Apart from serving as carrier for microbial growth, BiocharB might promote the direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) since the Anaerolineaceae/Clostridium sensu stricto, which have potential for DIET, were enriched. NZVI and ZVI added systems mainly enhanced the abundance of Clostridium sensu stricto (24.5%, 37.6%) and Methanosaeta. Interestingly, BiocharA inhibited the methanogenesis completely. An inhibitory mechanism was proposed: the exposure of absorbed microbes on the BiocharA to the highly concentrated phenol in biochar' pores resulted in the inhibition of methanogens, especially for Methanosarcina. In conclusion, this study showed that suitable biochar (BiocharB) could serve as an alternative redox mediator for realizing simultaneously the efficient phenol removal and methane production.

Algae biochar enhanced methanogenesis by enriching specific methanogens at low inoculation ratio during sludge anaerobic digestion

Carbon materials are promising in improving the performance of anaerobic digestion, however, interactive mechanisms between the carbon-based enhancement and operating parameters remained unclear. Using anaerobic digested sludge as inoculum, the effects of Taihu blue algae biochar (ABC) on methanogenesis at different inoculation ratios were investigated during sludge anaerobic digestion. Results showed that ABC enhanced methane productions at the lower inoculation ratios (4% and 1%, v/v), but not at the higher ratio (10%, v/v). Mechanism analysis demonstrated methanogenic improvements at the lower inoculation ratios were not owing to initial organic loading rate increments. Otherwise, ABC addition at the lower inoculation ratios were more favorable for the enrichment of Methanosarcina than the higher ratio, which might be benefit for methanogenesis through directed interspecies electron transfer. Thus, for the improvement of sludge anaerobic digestion, the microbial enrichments at different inoculation ratios would be more important than the merely biochar addition.

The role of conductive nanoparticles in anaerobic digestion: Mechanism, current status and future perspectives

In the current scenario, alternative energy sources are the need of the hour. Organic wastes having a larger fraction of biodegradable constituents present a sustainable bioenergy source. It has been reported that the calorific value of biogas generated by anaerobic digestion (AD) is 21-25 MJ/m³ with the treatment which makes it an excellent replacement of natural gas and fossil fuels and can reduce more than 80% greenhouse gas emission to the surroundings. However, there are some limitations associated with the AD process for instance ammonia build-up at the first stage reduces the rate of hydrolysis of biomass, whereas, in the last stage it interferes with methane formation. Owing to special physicochemical properties such as high activity, high reactive surface area, and high specificity, tailor-made conductive nanoparticles can improve the performance of the AD process. In the AD process, H₂ is used as an electron carrier, referred as mediated interspecies electron transfer (MIET). Due to the diffusion limitation of these electron carriers, the MIET efficiency is relatively low that limits the methanogenesis. Direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET), which enables direct cell-to-cell electron transport between bacteria and methanogen, has been considered an alternative efficient approach to MIET that creates metabolically favorable conditions and results in faster conversion of organic acids and alcohols into methane. This paper discusses in detail the application of conductive nanoparticles to enhance the AD process efficiency. Interaction between microbes in anaerobic conditions for electron transfer with the help of CNPs is discussed. Application of a variety of conductive nanomaterials as an additive is discussed with their potential biogas production and treatment enhancement in the anaerobic digestion process.

The impact of different types of high surface area brush fibers with different electrical conductivity and biocompatibility on the rates of methane generation in anaerobic digestion

The addition of electrically conductive materials may enhance anaerobic digestion (AD) efficiency by promoting direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET) between electroactive microorganisms, but an equivalent enhancement can also be achieved using non-conductive materials. Four high surface area brush materials were added to AD reactors: non-conductive horsehair (HB) and polyester (PB), and conductive carbon fiber (CB) and stainless steel (SB) brushes. Reactors with the polyester material showed lower methane production (68 ± 5 mL/g COD_fed) than the other non-conductive material (horsehair) and the conductive (graphite or stainless steel) materials (83 ± 3 mL/g COD_fed) (p < 0.05). This difference was due in part to the higher biomass concentrations using horsehair or carbon (135 ± 43 mg) than polyester or stainless steel or materials (26 ± 1 mg). A microbial community analysis indicated that the relative abundance of electroactive microorganisms was not directly related to enhanced AD performance. These results show that non-conductive materials such as horsehair can produce the same AD enhancement as conductive materials (carbon or stainless steel). However, if the material, such as polyester, does not have good biomass retention, it will not enhance methane production. Thus, electrical conductivity alone was not responsible for enhancing AD performance. Polyester, which has been frequently used as a non-conductive control material in DIET studies, should not be used for this purpose due to its poor biocompatibility as shown by low biomass retention in AD tests.

Synergetic effects of biochars and denitrifier on nitrate removal

Nitrate is one of the most common water contaminants and has caused severe environmental problems. This work aimed to investigate the effects of integration of denitrifier with biochars on nitrate removal and understand the underlying mechanisms. The results showed that physiochemical properties of biochars varied according to different feedstocks, which influenced bacteria attachment and nitrate removal through adsorption. However, bacteria could colonize on biochars no matter biochars surface were favorable for bacteria attachment or not. Immobilization of denitrifier on biochars significantly improved nitrate removal efficiencies and reduced lag time. Underlying mechanisms investigation showed that the integration of denitrifier with biochars had synergetic effects on promoting nitrate removal, which improved not only the expression and activity of nitrate reductase, but also the electron transport system activity.

Enhancing biomethane production and pyrene biodegradation by addition of bio-nano FeS or magnetic carbon during sludge anaerobic digestion

Pyrene exerts toxic effects on methanogens during anaerobic digestion of sludge, thus affecting the efficiency of sludge treatment. This study evaluated the facilitated direct interspecific electron transfer (DIET) between bacteria and methanogens when bio-nano FeS or magnetic carbon is added into anaerobic reactors. Results showed that adding 200 mg/L bio-nano FeS or magnetic carbon clearly reduced the accumulation of short-chain fatty acids and avoided acidification during 25 days of anaerobic digestion. The methane productions were 98.38 L/kg total solid (TS) and 73.69 L/kg TS in the bio-nano FeS and magnetic carbon systems, respectively, which accelerated methane production by 58.1% and 33.4%, respectively, compared with the control system (40.26 L/kg TS). The pyrene removal rates reached 77.5% and 72.1% in the bio-nano FeS and magnetic carbon systems, whereas it was only 40.8% in the control system. Analysis of microbial community structure revealed that methanogens (e.g. Methanosarcina and Methanosaeta) and extracellular electron-transfer bacteria (e.g. Pseudomonas, Cloastridia, and Synergistetes) were enriched in the reactors added with bio-nano FeS or magnetic carbon. This result indicates that the addition of bio-nano FeS or magnetic carbon may promote the activity and growth of microorganisms to improve the efficiency of methane production and pyrene degradation by enhancing DIET.

Effect of microbial community structure in inoculum on the stimulation of direct interspecies electron transfer for methanogenesis

To investigate how the seed microbial community structure affects the improvement of methanogenesis efficiency through direct interspecies electron transfer (DIET), a biomethane potential (BMP) test was conducted using sludge collected from a total of six anaerobic digesters. DIET-stimulating microbial populations were investigated by 16S rRNA gene sequence analysis. Correlations between microbial community composition and methane production performance by DIET were analyzed. The methane production rate increased under all conditions when granular activated carbon (GAC) was injected regardless of the inoculum type. However, redundancy analysis indicated a significant correlation between the inoculum microbial community and lag time. In a network analysis, Methanolinea species distributed in the inocula formed a single modularity with lag time, suggesting that the methanogens in the inocula might reduce the lag time of methanogenesis through DIET. Overall, this study revealed that the inoculum microbial community composition is an important factor affecting methane production efficiency by DIET.

Circular utilization of food waste to biochar enhances thermophilic co-digestion performance

Codigestion is an emerging approach to improve wastewater sludge biogas production and valorize food waste (FW). This study explores FW-derived biochar as a codigestion amendment for the first time and reports a matrix experiment using four diverse biochar amendments (mixed food waste, pinewood, bonechar, unamended control) across four FW types (vegetable, rice, chicken, mixed). It demonstrated that biochar derived from mixed FW can greatly improve the performance of biogas production and yield relative to unamended control and other biochars. The mixed food waste (MFW) biochar amendment led to 34.5%, 35.6%, and 47.5% increase in methane production from mixed FW compared to biochars made of wood, bone and non-amendment control, and the maximum methane production rate of MFW biochar reactors could be up to 6.7-9.9 times of the control. These results suggest that a more circular utilization of FW by integrating biochar production with codigestion can bring great benefits to FW management.

Static-magnetic-field coupled with fly-ash accelerant: A powerful strategy to significantly enhance the mesophilic anaerobic-co-digestion

The anaerobic-co-digestion (AcoD) of dairy-manure (DM) and aloe-peel-residue (ALR) waste is enhanced by combining static-magnetic-field (SMF) and fly-ash (FA). Varying SMF intensities (5-30 mT) were applied to the co-digestion digesters containing the optimum FA concentration (1.5 wt.%), which were selected from co-digestion systems with a varying FA (0-2 wt.%). All experimental groups exhibit the greater COD removal rates (51.56-64.19%) and cumulative biogas yields (604.14-671.64 mL/g VS) than reference group (37.77% and 433.19 mL/g VS). The digester with optimum FA concentration (1.5 wt.%) under 5 mT shows the highest biogas yield (671.64 mL/g VS), and exhibits superior digestate stability (45.4%) and fertility (7.01%) for fertilizer utilization. A powerful strategy for understanding the underlying mechanism of the SMF and FA accelerant in an enhanced AcoD system is proposed. This work documents an innovative technique for an enhanced AcoD system using the SMF coupled with FA accelerant.

Ferroferric oxide promotes metabolism in Anaerolineae other than microbial syntrophy in anaerobic methanogenesis of antibiotic fermentation residue

Antibiotic fermentation residue (AFR) is a kind of protein-rich biosolids that would be utilized as valuable substrates for biogas production. However, the effectiveness of conductive material supplementation and its effect on the microbiome in anaerobic digestion of AFR have not been fully elucidated. The objective of this study is to access the impact of Fe₃O₄ addition on anaerobic digestion of AFR and reveal its microbial mechanism. By adding Fe₃O₄ at concentration of 150 mg/gTS to two typical AFRs, the methane yield was decreased while the methane production rate was significantly enhanced by 48% and 21%, respectively. Genomic analyses revealed that the Fe₃O₄ addition altered the microbial community by selecting the unknown genus of Anaerolineae with the metabolic capacity of carbohydrate hydrolysis and proteolysis. Meanwhile, the hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis was the dominant pathway in the AFR digestion system, which was mostly contributed by the Methanoculleus and Methanolinea. More interestingly, Methanoculleus might possess fermentative capability involved in the versatile hydrolysis pathway. Although the genes related to electrically conductive pili were detected, the induction of direct interspecies electron transfer by Fe₃O₄ supplementation was not confirmed in this study. In summary, except the accelerated methane production rate, Fe₃O₄ addition functioned as biostimulator for Anaerolineae other than electron conduit in anaerobic methanogenesis in the AFR digestion system.

Carbon cloth facilitates semi-continuous anaerobic digestion of organic wastewater rich in volatile fatty acids from dark fermentation

The anaerobic digestion of wastewater rich in volatile fatty acids (VFAs) provides a sustainable approach for methane production whilst reducing environmental pollution. However, the anaerobic digestion of VFAs may not be stable during long-term operation under a short hydraulic retention time. In this study, conductive carbon cloth was supplemented to investigate the impacts on the anaerobic digestion of VFAs in wastewater sourced from dark fermentation. The results demonstrated that the failure of anaerobic digestion could be avoided when carbon cloth was supplemented. In the stable stage, the methane production rate with carbon cloth supplementation was improved by 200-260%, and the chemical oxygen demand (COD) removal efficiency was significantly enhanced compared with that in the control without carbon cloth. The relative abundance of potential exoelectrogens on the carbon cloth was increased by up to 8-fold compared with that in the suspension. Electrotrophic methanogens on the carbon cloth were enriched by 4.2-17.2% compared with those in the suspension. The genera Ercella and Petrimonas along with the methanogenic archaea Methanosaeta and Methanosarcina on the carbon cloth may facilitate direct interspecies electron transfer, thereby enhancing methane production.