Strategies for eliciting multiple lineages of broadly neutralizing antibodies to HIV by vaccination

A polyvalent DNA prime with matched polyvalent protein/GLA-SE boost regimen elicited the most robust and broad IgG and IgG3 V1V2 binding antibody and CD4+ T cell responses among 13 HIV vaccine trials

Developing an effective HIV vaccine is a momentous challenge. An exceptionally wide range of candidate HIV vaccines have been tested, yet many were poorly immunogenic, and of the select few that advanced into efficacy trials, only one demonstrated any efficacy. Here we report the results of the largest-scale cross-protocol immunogenicity comparison to date: 13 HIV vaccine trials (including 36 vaccine regimens) conducted across nine countries worldwide, strengthened by standardized trial designs, validated assays in centralized laboratories, and harmonized immunogenicity endpoints - providing an objective approach to identify the HIV vaccine candidate(s) with the best immunogenicity. A polyvalent DNA prime + protein boost regimen (HVTN 124) including Env immunogens of four subtypes, matched between prime and boost, achieved the best anti-V1V2 antibody responses by a large margin and also induced high CD4+ T-cell responses - two key immune responses implicated in HIV vaccine protection. Our results provide strong support to test this promising HIV vaccine design in more advanced phase clinical trials and will also guide the future design of additional HIV vaccines.Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT01799954..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT02109354..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT02404311..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT02207920..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT02296541..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT03284710..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT02915016..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT02997969..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT03122223..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT03409276..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT02968849..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT03060629..Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT00223080..

Navigating the Complexities of HIV Vaccine Development: Lessons from the Mosaico Trial and Next-Generation Development Strategies

Background/Objectives: The development of an effective HIV vaccine has faced persistent challenges, as evidenced by the recent discontinuation of the Mosaico phase 3 trial. This study aims to critically examine the obstacles encountered in HIV vaccine development, with a focus on the Mosaico trial, which tested the Ad26.Mos4.HIV vaccine among 3,900 participants across multiple countries. We also explore emerging vaccine technologies and their potential in overcoming these challenges, while reflecting on lessons from previous trials to inform future strategies. Methods: We reviewed the Mosaico trial's approach, which involved testing the efficacy of the Ad26.Mos4.HIV vaccine. We compared the outcomes of the Mosaico trial with other major HIV vaccine trials, including HVTN 702, Imbokodo, and RV144. We explored the limitations of the immune responses elicited by the Mosaico vaccine. The review focused on the generation of broadly neutralizing antibodies (bNAbs) and the challenges related to antigenic diversity and B-cell engagement. Emerging vaccine technologies, such as virus-like particles (VLPs), nanoparticles, SOSIP trimers, and mRNA platforms, were also analysed for their scalability, immune durability, and potential to advance HIV vaccine development. Results: The Mosaico trial was discontinued due to insufficient efficacy in reducing HIV acquisition, primarily due to the inability of the vaccine to induce bNAbs, which are crucial for targeting the diverse HIV-1 strains. A major challenge was the inadequate engagement of germline B-cell precursors, compounded by the antigenic diversity of the virus. The analysis showed that emerging vaccine platforms, such as VLPs, nanoparticles, SOSIP trimers, and mRNA-based approaches, hold promise but present challenges related to scalability and the durability of immune responses. The role of T cells and adjuvants in enhancing vaccine efficacy was also highlighted as critical for integrating both humoral and cellular immunity. Conclusions: The Mosaico trial, as well as other major HIV vaccine trials, underscores the need for a multi-pronged approach that incorporates both antibody and T-cell responses to tackle the complexities of HIV-1. Future efforts in HIV vaccine development must focus on inducing bNAbs, generating robust T-cell responses, and utilizing scalable vaccine platforms. The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into vaccine design offers new opportunities to optimize immunogenic targets, which could significantly improve the potential for durable and broad immune protection. The development of a successful HIV vaccine by 2030 is achievable but relies on leverage on advanced technologies including artificial intelligence, innovation and insights from past trial data.

Phenomenological Modeling of Antibody Response from Vaccine Strain Composition

The elicitation of broadly neutralizing antibodies (bnAbs) is a major goal of vaccine design for highly mutable pathogens, such as influenza, HIV, and coronavirus. Although many rational vaccine design strategies for eliciting bnAbs have been devised, their efficacies need to be evaluated in preclinical animal models and in clinical trials. To improve outcomes for such vaccines, it would be useful to develop methods that can predict vaccine efficacies against arbitrary pathogen variants. As a step in this direction, here, we describe a simple biologically motivated model of antibody reactivity elicited by nanoparticle-based vaccines using only antigen amino acid sequences, parametrized with a small sample of experimental antibody binding data from influenza or SARS-CoV-2 nanoparticle vaccinations. Results: The model is able to recapitulate the experimental data to within experimental uncertainty, is relatively insensitive to the choice of the parametrization/training set, and provides qualitative predictions about the antigenic epitopes exploited by the vaccine, which are testable by experiment. For the mosaic nanoparticle vaccines considered here, model results suggest indirectly that the sera obtained from vaccinated mice contain bnAbs, rather than simply different strain-specific Abs. Although the present model was motivated by nanoparticle vaccines, we also apply it to a mutlivalent mRNA flu vaccination study, and demonstrate good recapitulation of experimental results. This suggests that the model formalism is, in principle, sufficiently flexible to accommodate different vaccination strategies. Finally, we show how the model could be used to rank the efficacies of vaccines with different antigen compositions. Conclusions: Overall, this study suggests that simple models of vaccine efficacy parametrized with modest amounts of experimental data could be used to compare the effectiveness of designed vaccines.

An engineered immunogen activates diverse HIV broadly neutralizing antibody precursors and promotes acquisition of improbable mutations

Elicitation of HIV broadly neutralizing antibodies (bnAbs) by vaccination first requires the activation of diverse precursors, followed by successive boosts that guide these responses to enhanced breadth through the acquisition of somatic mutations. Because HIV bnAbs contain mutations in their B cell receptors (BCRs) that are rarely generated during conventional B cell maturation, HIV vaccine immunogens must robustly engage and expand B cells with BCRs that contain these improbable mutations. Here, we engineered an immunogen that activates diverse precursors of an HIV V3-glycan bnAb and promotes their acquisition of a functionally critical improbable mutation. This immunogen was validated biochemically, structurally, and in three different humanized immunoglobulin mouse models that were designed to test HIV immunogens. These results provide a blueprint for rationally designing priming immunogens that explicitly target the elicitation of antibodies with functional yet improbable mutations.

Beyond glycan barriers: non-cognate ligands and protein mimicry approaches to elicit broadly neutralizing antibodies for HIV-1

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) vaccine immunogens capable of inducing broadly neutralizing antibodies (bNAbs) remain obscure. HIV-1 evades immune responses through enormous diversity and hides its conserved vulnerable epitopes on the envelope glycoprotein (Env) by displaying an extensive immunodominant glycan shield. In elite HIV-1 viremic controllers, glycan-dependent bNAbs targeting conserved Env epitopes have been isolated and are utilized as vaccine design templates. However, immunological tolerance mechanisms limit the development of these antibodies in the general population. The well characterized bNAbs monoclonal variants frequently exhibit extensive levels of somatic hypermutation, a long third heavy chain complementary determining region, or a short third light chain complementarity determining region, and some exhibit poly-reactivity to autoantigens. This review elaborates on the obstacles to engaging and manipulating the Env glycoprotein as an effective immunogen and describes an alternative reverse vaccinology approach to develop a novel category of bNAb-epitope-derived non-cognate immunogens for HIV-1 vaccine design.

Recapitulation of HIV-1 Neutralization Breadth in Plasma by the Combination of Two Broadly Neutralizing Antibodies from Different Lineages in the Same SHIV-Infected Rhesus Macaque

Viral infection generally induces polyclonal neutralizing antibody responses. However, how many lineages of antibody responses can fully represent the neutralization activities in sera has not been well studied. Using the newly designed stable HIV-1 Env trimer as hook, we isolated two distinct broadly neutralizing antibodies (bnAbs) from Chinese rhesus macaques infected with SHIV1157ipd3N4 for 5 years. One lineage of neutralizing antibodies (JT15 and JT16) targeted the V2-apex in the Env trimers, similar to the J038 lineage bnAbs identified in our previous study. The other lineage neutralizing antibody (JT18) targeted the V3 crown region in the Env, which strongly competed with human 447-52D. Each lineage antibody neutralized a different set of viruses. Interestingly, when the two neutralizing antibodies from different lineages isolated from the same macaque were combined, the mixture had a neutralization breath very similar to that from the cognate sera. Our study demonstrated that a minimum of two different neutralizing antibodies can fully recapitulate the serum neutralization breadth. This observation can have important implications in AIDS vaccine design.

Antibodies targeting the fusion peptide on the HIV envelope provide protection to rhesus macaques against mucosal SHIV challenge

The fusion peptide (FP) on the HIV-1 envelope (Env) trimer can be targeted by broadly neutralizing antibodies (bNAbs). Here, we evaluated the ability of a human FP-directed bNAb, VRC34.01, along with two vaccine-elicited anti-FP rhesus macaque mAbs, DFPH-a.15 and DF1W-a.01, to protect against simian-HIV (SHIV)BG505 challenge. VRC34.01 neutralized SHIVBG505 with a 50% inhibitory concentration (IC50) of 0.58 μg/ml, whereas DF1W-a.01 and DFPH-a.15 were 4- or 30-fold less potent, respectively. VRC34.01 was infused into four rhesus macaques at a dose of 10 mg/kg and four rhesus macaques at a dose of 2.5 mg/kg. The animals were intrarectally challenged 5 days later with SHIVBG505. In comparison with all 12 control animals that became infected, all four animals infused with VRC34.01 (10 mg/kg) and three out of four animals infused with VRC34.01 (2.5 mg/kg) remained uninfected. Because of the lower potency of DF1W-a.01 and DFPH-a.15 against SHIVBG505, we infused both Abs at a higher dose of 100 mg/kg into four rhesus macaques each, followed by SHIVBG505 challenge 5 days later. Three of four animals that received DF1W-a.01 were protected against infection, whereas all animals that received DFPH-a.15 were protected. Overall, the protective serum neutralization titers observed in these animals were similar to what has been observed for other bNAbs in similar SHIV infection models and in human clinical trials. In conclusion, FP-directed mAbs can thus provide dose-dependent in vivo protection against mucosal SHIV challenges, supporting the development of prophylactic vaccines targeting the HIV-1 Env FP.

The Mechanism of bnAb Production and Its Application in Mutable Virus Broad-Spectrum Vaccines: Inspiration from HIV-1 Broad Neutralization Research

Elite controllers among HIV-1-infected individuals have demonstrated a stronger ability to control the viral load in their bodies. Scientists have isolated antibodies with strong neutralizing ability from these individuals, which can neutralize HIV-1 variations; these are known as broadly neutralizing antibodies. The nucleic acid of some viruses will constantly mutate during replication (such as SARS-CoV-2), which will reduce the protective ability of the corresponding vaccines. The immune escape caused by this mutation is the most severe challenge faced by humans in the battle against the virus. Therefore, developing broad-spectrum vaccines that can induce broadly neutralizing antibodies against various viruses and their mutated strains is the best way to combat virus mutations. Exploring the mechanism by which the human immune system produces broadly neutralizing antibodies and its induction strategies is crucial in the design process of broad-spectrum vaccines.

Structural basis for breadth development in the HIV-1 V3-glycan targeting DH270 antibody clonal lineage

Antibody affinity maturation enables adaptive immune responses to a wide range of pathogens. In some individuals broadly neutralizing antibodies develop to recognize rapidly mutating pathogens with extensive sequence diversity. Vaccine design for pathogens such as HIV-1 and influenza has therefore focused on recapitulating the natural affinity maturation process. Here, we determine structures of antibodies in complex with HIV-1 Envelope for all observed members and ancestral states of the broadly neutralizing HIV-1 V3-glycan targeting DH270 antibody clonal B cell lineage. These structures track the development of neutralization breadth from the unmutated common ancestor and define affinity maturation at high spatial resolution. By elucidating contacts mediated by key mutations at different stages of antibody development we identified sites on the epitope-paratope interface that are the focus of affinity optimization. Thus, our results identify bottlenecks on the path to natural affinity maturation and reveal solutions for these that will inform immunogen design aimed at eliciting a broadly neutralizing immune response by vaccination.

CD4 binding site immunogens elicit heterologous anti-HIV-1 neutralizing antibodies in transgenic and wild-type animals

Passive transfer of broadly neutralizing anti-HIV-1 antibodies (bNAbs) protects against infection, and therefore, eliciting bNAbs by vaccination is a major goal of HIV-1 vaccine efforts. bNAbs that target the CD4 binding site (CD4bs) on HIV-1 Env are among the most broadly active, but to date, responses elicited against this epitope in vaccinated animals have lacked potency and breadth. We hypothesized that CD4bs bNAbs resembling the antibody IOMA might be easier to elicit than other CD4bs antibodies that exhibit higher somatic mutation rates, a difficult-to-achieve mechanism to accommodate Env's N276gp120 N-glycan, and rare five-residue light chain complementarity-determining region 3. As an initial test of this idea, we developed IOMA germline-targeting Env immunogens and evaluated a sequential immunization regimen in transgenic mice expressing germline-reverted IOMA. These mice developed CD4bs epitope-specific responses with heterologous neutralization, and cloned antibodies overcame neutralization roadblocks, including accommodating the N276gp120 glycan, with some neutralizing selected HIV-1 strains more potently than IOMA. The immunization regimen also elicited CD4bs-specific responses in mice containing polyclonal antibody repertoires as well as rabbits and rhesus macaques. Thus, germline targeting of IOMA-class antibody precursors represents a potential vaccine strategy to induce CD4bs bNAbs.

Dependence on a variable residue limits the breadth of an HIV MPER neutralizing antibody, despite convergent evolution with broadly neutralizing antibodies

Broadly neutralizing antibodies (bNAbs) that target the membrane-proximal external region (MPER) of HIV gp41 envelope, such as 4E10, VRC42.01 and PGZL1, can neutralize >80% of viruses. These three MPER-directed monoclonal antibodies share germline antibody genes (IGHV1-69 and IGKV3-20) and form a bNAb epitope class. Furthermore, convergent evolution within these two lineages towards a ^111.2GW^111.3 motif in the CDRH3 is known to enhance neutralization potency. We have previously isolated an MPER neutralizing antibody, CAP206-CH12, that uses these same germline heavy and light chain genes but lacks breadth (neutralizing only 6% of heterologous viruses). Longitudinal sequencing of the CAP206-CH12 lineage over three years revealed similar convergent evolution towards ^111.2GW^111.3 among some lineage members. Mutagenesis of CAP206-CH12 from ^111.2GL^111.3 to ^111.2GW^111.3 and the introduction of the double GWGW motif into CAP206-CH12 modestly improved neutralization potency (2.5–3-fold) but did not reach the levels of potency of VRC42.01, 4E10 or PGZL1. To explore the lack of potency/breadth, viral mutagenesis was performed to map the CAP206-CH12 epitope. This indicated that CAP206-CH12 is dependent on D⁶⁷⁴, a highly variable residue at the solvent-exposed elbow of MPER. In contrast, VRC42.01, PGZL1 and 4E10 were dependent on highly conserved residues (W⁶⁷², F⁶⁷³, T⁶⁷⁶, and W⁶⁸⁰) facing the hydrophobic patch of the MPER. Therefore, while CAP206-CH12, VRC42.01, PGZL1 and 4E10 share germline genes and show some evidence of convergent evolution, their dependence on different amino acids, which impacts orientation of binding to the MPER, result in differences in breadth and potency. These data have implications for the design of HIV vaccines directed at the MPER epitope.

Germline-targeting immunogens are a promising HIV vaccine design strategy. This approach is reliant on the identification of broadly neutralizing antibody (bNAb) classes, which use the same germline antibody genes to target the same viral epitopes. Here, we compare four HIV Envelope MPER-directed antibodies (4E10, VRC42.01, PGZL1 and CAP206-CH12) that despite having shared antibody genes, show distinct neutralization profiles. We show that CAP206-CH12 is dependent on a highly variable residue in the MPER, which results in low neutralization breadth. In contrast, the 4E10, PGZL1 and VRC42.01 mAbs are dependent on highly conserved residues in the MPER, resulting in exceptional neutralization breadth. Our data suggest that while shared germline genes within bNAb epitope classes are required, in some cases these are not sufficient to produce neutralization breadth, and MPER immunogens will need to trigger responses to conserved sites.

Principles and practical applications of structure-based vaccine design

Viral proteins fold into a variety of structures as they perform their functions. Structure-based vaccine design aims to exploit knowledge of an antigen’s architecture to stabilize it in a vulnerable conformation. We summarize the general principles of structure-based vaccine design, with a focus on the major types of sequence modifications: proline, disulfide, cavity-filling, electrostatic and hydrogen-bond substitution, as well as domain deletion. We then review recent applications of these principles to vaccine-design efforts across five viral families: Coronaviridae, Orthomyxoviridae, Paramyxoviridae, Pneumoviridae, and Filoviridae. Outstanding challenges include continued application of proven design principles to pathogens of interest, as well as development of new strategies for those pathogens that resist traditional techniques.