Friedreich's ataxia and other hereditary ataxias in Greece: An 18-year perspective

Screening for SCA27B, CANVAS and other repeat expansion disorders in Greek patients with late-onset cerebellar ataxia suggests a need to update current diagnostic algorithms

OBJECTIVE

Late-onset cerebellar ataxia (LOCA) is a slowly progressive cerebellar disorder with symptom onset ≥30years of age. Intronic tandem repeat expansions (TREs) in RFC1 and FGF14 have recently emerged as common causes of LOCA. The relative contribution of classic vs. newly discovered TREs has not been systematically investigated in LOCA cohorts.

METHODS

Over 28 years, 206 consecutive Greek LOCA index patients were referred for genetic testing and, based on clinical data and inheritance pattern, screened for FRDA, SCA1,2,3,6,7, FXTAS, CANVAS and SCA27B.

RESULTS

A genetic diagnosis was reached in 62 of 206 cases (30.1 %). Mean age was 60.1 ± 11.2 (35-87) years and mean age at onset (AAO) 52.5 ± 11.4 (30-80) years. SCA27B accounted for 9.7 % of LOCA cases, CANVAS for 7.8 % and FRDA for 4.4 %. The overall frequency of SCA1, SCA2 and SCA7 was 6.8 %. No cases of SCA3 and SCA6 were identified. FXTAS contributed 1.5 % of cases. In sporadic cases, the diagnostic yield was 22.8 % (34 of 149; SCA27B: 8.7 %, CANVAS: 8.1 %, FRDA: 2.7 %, SCA2: 1.3 %, FXTAS: 1.3 % and SCA7: 0.7 %). In familial cases, the diagnostic yield was 49.1 % (28 of 57). Two cases with CANVAS had pseudodominant inheritance. Patients with SCA27B, CANVAS and FXTAS had mean AAO > 50 years, whereas patients with FRDA, SCA1, SCA2 and SCA7 had mean AAO < 50 years.

CONCLUSION

Recently-discovered TREs causing SCA27B and CANVAS represent the commonest known genetic causes of LOCA. Prioritizing testing for FGF14 and RFC1 expansions in the diagnostic algorithm of LOCA is recommended.

Spinocerebellar Ataxias: Phenotypic Spectrum of PolyQ versus Non-Repeat Expansion Forms

Spinocerebellar ataxias (SCA) are most frequently due to (CAG)n (coding for polyglutamine, polyQ) expansions and, less so, to expansion of other oligonucleotide repeats (non-polyQ) or other type of variants (non-repeat expansion SCA). In this study we compared polyQ and non-repeat expansion SCA, in a cohort of patients with hereditary ataxia followed at a tertiary hospital. From a prospective study, 88 patients (51 families) with SCA were selected, 74 (40 families) of whom genetically diagnosed. Thirty-eight patients (51.4%, 19 families) were confirmed as having a polyQ (no other repeat-expansions were identified) and 36 (48.6%, 21 families) a non-repeat expansion SCA. Median age-at-onset was 39.5 [30.0-45.5] for polyQ and 7.0 years [1.00-21.50] for non-repeat expansion SCA. PolyQ SCA were associated with cerebellar onset, and non-repeat expansion forms with non-cerebellar onset. Time to diagnosis was longer for non-repeat expansion SCA. The most common polyQ SCA were Machado-Joseph disease (MJD/SCA3) (73.7%) and SCA2 (15.8%); whereas in non-repeat expansion SCA ATX-CACNA1A (14.3%), ATP1A3-related ataxia, ATX-ITPR1, ATX/HSP-KCNA2, and ATX-PRKCG (9.5% each) predominated. Disease duration (up to inclusion) was significantly higher in non-repeat expansion SCA, but the difference in SARA score was not statistically significant. Cerebellar peduncles and pons atrophy were more common in polyQ ataxias, as was axonal neuropathy. SCA had a wide range of genetic etiology, age-at-onset and presentation. Proportion of polyQ and non-repeat expansion SCA was similar; the latter had a higher genetic heterogeneity. While polyQ ataxias were typically linked to cerebellar onset in adulthood, non-repeat expansion forms associated with early onset and non-cerebellar presentations.

Prevalence and Diagnostic Journey of Friedreich's Ataxia in the State of São Paulo, Brazil

Friedreich's Ataxia (FRDA) is the leading cause of ataxia worldwide, but data on epidemiology and diagnostic journey are scarce, particularly in Latin America. Herein we estimated the prevalence of FRDA in the most populous Brazilian state and characterized the diagnostic odyssey of the disease. We received anonymized data of patients with FRDA from advocacy groups and physicians. Prevalence was estimated dividing the number of patients by the population of the state as reported in the last census. Patients were invited to answer an online survey to describe clinical data and diagnostic journey of the disease. FRDA estimated prevalence was 0.367:100,000, with a slight predominance of women (58.2% vs 41.7%). One hundred and four patients answered the survey (mean age of 37.3 ± 13.8 years; 75.9% classical and 24.0% late onset). On average, 6.2 ± 4.1 physicians were visited before reaching the diagnosis. Mean diagnostic delay was 7.8 ± 6.7 years; no difference between classical and LOFA groups was found. Most of the patients reported unsteadiness and gait abnormalities as the first symptom. Neurologists and orthopedical surgeons were the main specialties first sought by patients. We found a prevalence of 0.36:100,000 for FRDA in the state of São Paulo, Brazil. The disease is characterized by remarkable diagnostic delay, with no relevant differences between classical and LOFA patients.

Epidemiology of Spinocerebellar Ataxias in Europe

Spinocerebellar ataxias (SCAs) are a heterogenous group of rare neurodegenerative conditions sharing an autosomal dominant pattern of inheritance. More than 40 SCAs have been genetically determined. However, a systematic review of SCA epidemiology in Europe is still missing. Here we performed a narrative review of the literature on the epidemiology of the most common SCAs in Europe. PubMed, Embase, and MEDLINE were searched from inception until 1 April 2023. All English peer-reviewed articles published were considered and then filtered by abstract examination and subsequently by full text reading. A total of 917 original articles were retrieved. According to the inclusion criteria and after reviewing references for useful papers, a total of 35 articles were included in the review. Overall, SCA3 is the most frequent spinocerebellar ataxia in Europe. Its frequency is strikingly higher in Portugal, followed by Germany, France, and Netherlands. None or few cases were described in Italy, Russia, Poland, Serbia, Finland, and Norway. SCA1 and SCA2 globally displayed similar frequencies, and are more prevalent in Italy, United Kingdom, Poland, Serbia, and France.

The FGF14 GAA repeat expansion in Greek patients with late-onset cerebellar ataxia and an overview of the SCA27B phenotype across populations

A pathogenic GAA repeat expansion in the first intron of the fibroblast growth factor 14 gene (FGF14) has been recently identified as the cause of spinocerebellar ataxia 27B (SCA27B). We herein screened 160 Greek index cases with late-onset cerebellar ataxia (LOCA) for FGF14 repeat expansions using a combination of long-range PCR and bidirectional repeat-primed PCRs. We identified 19 index cases (12%) carrying a pathogenic FGF14 GAA expansion, a diagnostic yield higher than that of previously screened repeat-expansion ataxias in Greek LOCA patients. The age at onset of SCA27B patients was 60.5 ± 12.3 years (range, 34-80). Episodic onset (37%), downbeat nystagmus (32%) and vertigo (26%) were significantly more frequent in FGF14 expansion-positive cases compared to expansion-negative cases. Beyond typical cerebellar signs, SCA27B patients often displayed hyperreflexia (47%) and reduced vibration sense in the lower extremities (42%). The frequency and phenotypic profile of SCA27B in Greek patients was similar to most other previously studied populations. We conclude that FGF14 GAA repeat expansions are the commonest known genetic cause of LOCA in the Greek population and recommend prioritizing testing for FGF14 expansions in the diagnostic algorithm of patients with LOCA.

Screening for the FMR1 premutation in Greek patients with late-onset movement disorders

Fragile X-associated tremor/ataxia syndrome (FXTAS) is a late-onset, X-linked, neurodegenerative disorder that affects premutation carriers of the FMR1 gene. FXTAS is often misdiagnosed as spinocerebellar ataxia (SCA) or Parkinson's disease (PD). Herein, we sought to investigate the frequency, genotypic and phenotypic profile of FXTAS in two cohorts of Greek patients with late-onset movement disorders, one with cerebellar ataxia and the other with PD. In total, 90 index patients with late-onset cerebellar ataxia and 171 with PD were selected. None of the cases had male-to-male transmission. Genetic screening for the FMR1 premutation was performed using standard methodology. The FMR1 premutation was detected in two ataxia patients (2.2%) and two PD patients (1.2%). Additional clinical features in FXTAS patients from the ataxia cohort included neuropathy, mild parkinsonism, cognitive impairment and pyramidal signs. The FXTAS patients from the PD cohort had typical PD. We conclude that, in the Greek population, the FMR1 premutation is an important, albeit rare, cause of late-onset movement disorders. Routine premutation screening should be considered in SCA panel-negative late-onset ataxia cases. Directed premutation screening should be considered in all ataxia and PD cases with additional features suggestive of FXTAS. Our study highlights the importance of FMR1 genetic testing in the diagnosis of late-onset movement disorders.

A systematic review of disease prevalence, health-related quality of life, and economic outcomes associated with Friedreich's Ataxia

INTRODUCTION

Friedreich ataxia (FA) is a rare, inherited neuromuscular disease characterized by an early onset and progressive limb and gait ataxia. Currently, there are no approved treatments for FA. It is important to understand the burden of FA, including its extent and the most salient elements. The objective of this study is therefore to systematically review the literature regarding the aspects of prevalence, health-related quality of life (HRQoL), and economic outcomes that are associated with FA, and to subsequently identify relevant knowledge gaps.

METHODS

Three systematic literature reviews were conducted to assess publications regarding FA prevalence, HRQoL, and economic outcomes. Search strategies were implemented in MEDLINE (Ovid) and EMBASE databases; study selection and quality assessment were conducted using current best practices. For each review, study characteristics and findings were summarized.

RESULTS

A total of 36 studies were included. Review of prevalence studies (n = 22) indicated variation in the number of cases by region, and many regions were not represented at all. Regarding HRQoL (n = 12 studies), physical domains were consistently impacted, although findings regarding other domains and overall HRQoL were less clear. Cost studies (n = 2) encompassed 4 regions and revealed that costs related to the provision of care, including non-medical direct costs and indirect costs, accounted for the majority of FA-related costs.

DISCUSSION

Findings from this systematic review revealed several knowledge gaps that would preclude the conduct of a robust assessment of the benefits and outcomes associated with a disease-modifying FA therapy. Additional understanding regarding patient and caregiver HRQoL and costs is required.

Autosomal recessive adult onset ataxia

Autosomal recessive ataxias (ARCA) represent a complex group of diseases ranging from primary ataxias to rare and complex metabolic disorders in which ataxia is a part of the clinical picture. Small number of ARCA manifest exclusively in adulthood, while majority of typical childhood onset ARCA may also start later with atypical clinical presentation. We have systematically searched the literature for ARCA with adult onset, both in the group of primary ataxias including those that are less frequently described in isolated or in a small number of families, and also in the group of complex and metabolic diseases in which ataxia is only part of the clinical picture. We propose an algorithm that could be used when encountering a patient with adult onset sporadic or recessive ataxia in whom the acquired causes are excluded. ARCA are frequently neglected in the differential diagnosis of adult-onset ataxias. Rising awareness of their clinical significance is important, not only because some of these disorders may be potentially treatable, but also for prognostic implications and inclusion of patients to future clinical trials with disease modifying agents.

Biallelic RFC1 pentanucleotide repeat expansions in Greek patients with late-onset ataxia

Cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy and vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS) has been recently linked to biallelic expansions of a pentanucleotide repeat in the replication factor C subunit 1 (RFC1) gene. Herein, we sought to investigate the presence of pathological RFC1 expansions in selected Greek patients with late-onset ataxia and delineate the phenotypic spectrum of genetically confirmed CANVAS in the Greek population. We screened genetically a total of 77 selected index patients, 67 originating from a cerebellar ataxia cohort and 10 from a hereditary neuropathy cohort. We identified five index cases (6.5%) with biallelic pathological RFC1 expansions, two in the cerebellar ataxia cohort (3%) and three in the neuropathy cohort (30%). Overall, four out of five of cases with full-blown CANVAS and one case with sensory ataxic neuropathy had biallelic pathological expansions. The phenotypic spectrum of positive cases (including two affected siblings) was consistent with previous reports and implied that the sensory neuropathy may be the earliest feature in genetically confirmed CANVAS. Screening for biallelic RFC1 expansions is recommended in all cases with late-onset ataxia of unknown cause, particularly when a sensory neuropathy is present.

Origins and Spread of Machado-Joseph Disease Ancestral Mutations Events

Machado-Joseph disease (MJD) is the most common autosomal dominant spinocerebellar ataxia reported worldwide, but it shows marked geographic differences in prevalence. The study of ancestral origins and spreading routes of MJD mutational events has contributed to explain such differences. During human evolution, at least two independent de novo MJD expansions occurred in distinct haplotype backgrounds: TTACAC and GTGGCA (named Joseph and Machado lineages). The most ancient Joseph lineage, probably of Asian origin, has been introduced recently in Europe, where founder effects are responsible for the high MJD prevalence, as occurs in the Portuguese/Azorean island of Flores and Northeastern mainland. The Machado lineage is geographically more restricted, with most known families in Portugal (island of São Miguel and along the Tagus valley). The hypothesis of other mutational origins has been raised, namely to explain the disease among Australian aborigines; however, a comprehensive haplotype study suggested the introduction of the Joseph lineage in that community via Asia. Also, additional SNP-based haplotypes (TTAGAC, TTGGAC and GTGCCA) were observed in other MJD families, but phylogenetic analysis with more polymorphic flanking markers did not point to independent mutational events, reinforcing the hypothesis of a very low mutation rate underlying this repeat expansion locus.

Mortality Statistics and their Contribution to Improving the Knowledge of Rare Diseases Epidemiology: The Example of Hereditary Ataxia in Europe

Official mortality statistics provide population-based data and serve to improve epidemiological knowledge of rare diseases (RDs), by helping with the description of the natural history of the disease. They are an important complement of registries and estimates of disease burden and costs. At the same time, they heighten both the visibility of these diseases and the interest in their study and the search for treatments that may increase survival. This chapter contains a European analysis of hereditary ataxia mortality, which considers the time trend in different countries and the geographical variability in risk of death. Despite the limitations of applying this data source to RDs, mortality statistics share criteria which facilitate international comparisons and are of great utility for obtaining sufficiently uniform and robust time series for analysis of low-prevalence diseases.

Degenerative Ataxias: challenges in clinical research

The degenerative ataxias are a very heterogeneous group of disorders that include numerous genetic diseases as well as apparently “sporadic” entities. There has been an explosion of discoveries related to genetic defects and related pathomechanisms that has brought us to the threshold of meaningful therapies in some but not all of these diseases. There also continues to be lack of knowledge of the causation of disease in a sizeable proportion of these patients. The overall rarity of ataxias as a whole and certainly of the individual genetic entities together with slow and variable progression and variable prognosis in juxtaposition with a rapid development of possible therapies in the horizon such as gene replacement and gene knock‐down strategies places the ataxias in a unique position distinct from other similar neurodegenerative diseases. The pace of laboratory research seems not matched by the pace of clinical research and clinical trial readiness. This review summarizes the author's views on the various challenges in translational research in ataxias and hopes to stimulate further thought and discussions on how to bring real help to these patients.

Spinocerebellar ataxia: relationship between phenotype and genotype - a review

Spinocerebellar ataxia (SCA) comprises a large group of heterogeneous neurodegenerative disorders inherited in an autosomal dominant fashion. It is characterized by progressive cerebellar ataxia with oculomotor dysfunction, dysarthria, pyramidal signs, extrapyramidal signs, pigmentary retinopathy, peripheral neuropathy, cognitive impairment and other symptoms. It is classified according to the clinical manifestations or genetic nosology. To date, 40 SCAs have been characterized, and include SCA1-40. The pathogenic genes of 28 SCAs were identified. In recent years, with the widespread clinical use of next-generation sequencing, the genes underlying SCAs, and the mutants as well as the affected phenotypes were identified. These advances elucidated the phenotype-genotype relationship in SCAs. We reviewed the recent clinical advances, genetic features and phenotype-genotype correlations involving each SCA and its differentiation. The heterogeneity of the disease and the genetic diagnosis might be attributed to the regional distribution and clinical characteristics. Therefore, recognition of the phenotype-genotype relationship facilitates genetic testing, prognosis and monitoring of symptoms.