Muscle spindles and Golgi tendon organs in bovine calf extraocular muscle studied by means of double-fluorescent labeling, electron microscopy, and three-dimensional reconstruction

Proprioceptors in extraocular muscles

Proprioception is the sense that lets us perceive the location, movement and action of the body parts. The proprioceptive apparatus includes specialized sense organs (proprioceptors) which are embedded in the skeletal muscles. The eyeballs are moved by six pairs of eye muscles and binocular vision depends on fine-tuned coordination of the optical axes of both eyes. Although experimental studies indicate that the brain has access to eye position information, both classical proprioceptors (muscle spindles and Golgi tendon organ) are absent in the extraocular muscles of most mammalian species. This paradox of monitoring extraocular muscle activity in the absence of typical proprioceptors seemed to be resolved when a particular nerve specialization (the palisade ending) was detected in the extraocular muscles of mammals. In fact, for decades there was consensus that palisade endings were sensory structures that provide eye position information. The sensory function was called into question when recent studies revealed the molecular phenotype and the origin of palisade endings. Today we are faced with the fact that palisade endings exhibit sensory as well as motor features. This review aims to evaluate the literature on extraocular muscle proprioceptors and palisade endings and to reconsider current knowledge of their structure and function.

Distribution Heterogeneity of Muscle Spindles Across Skeletal Muscles of Lower Extremities in C57BL/6 Mice

Muscle spindles, an important proprioceptor scattered in the skeletal muscle, participate in maintaining muscle tension and the fine regulation of random movement. Although muscle spindles exist in all skeletal muscles, explanations about the distribution and morphology of muscle spindles remain lacking for the indetermination of spindle location across muscles. In this study, traditional time-consuming histochemical technology was utilized to determine the muscle spindle anatomical and morphological characteristics in the lower extremity skeletal muscle in C57BL/6 mice. The relative distance from spindles to nerve-entry points varied from muscles in the ventral-dorsal direction, in which spindles in the lateral of gastrocnemius were not considered to be close to its nerve-entry point. In the longitudinal pattern, the domain with the highest abundance of spindles corresponded to the nerve-entry point, excluding the tibialis anterior. Spindles are mainly concentrated at the middle and rostral domain in all muscles. The results suggest a heterogeneity of the distribution of spindles in different muscles, but the distribution trend generally follows the location pattern of the nerve-entry point. Histochemical staining revealed that the spindle did not have a symmetrical structure along the equator, and this result does not agree with previous findings. Exploring the distribution and structural characteristics of muscle spindles in skeletal muscle can provide some anatomical basis for the study of muscle spindles at the molecular level and treatment of exercise-related diseases and provide a comprehensive understanding of muscle spindle morphology.

Palisade Endings Are a Constant Feature in the Extraocular Muscles of Frontal-Eyed, But Not Lateral-Eyed, Animals

Purpose

To test whether palisade endings are a general feature of mammalian extraocular muscles (EOMs).

Methods

Thirteen species, some frontal-eyed (human, monkey, cat, and ferret), and others lateral-eyed (pig, sheep, calf, horse, rabbit, rat, mouse, gerbil, and guinea pig) were analyzed. Palisade endings were labeled by using different combinations of immunofluorescence techniques. Three-dimensional reconstructions of immunolabeled palisade endings were done.

Results

In all frontal-eyed species, palisade endings were a consistent feature in the rectus EOMs. Their total number was high and they exhibited an EOM-specific distribution. In particular, the number of palisade endings in the medial recti was significantly higher than in the other rectus muscles. In the lateral-eyed animals, palisade endings were infrequent and, when present, their total number was rather low. They were only found in ungulates (sheep, calf, pig, and horse) and in rabbit. In rodents (rat, guinea pig, mouse, and gerbil) palisade endings were found infrequently (e.g., rat) or were completely absent. Palisade endings in frontal-eyed species and in some lateral-eyed species (pig, sheep, calf, and horse) had a uniform morphology. They generally lacked α-bungarotoxin staining, with a few exceptions in primates. Palisade endings in other lateral-eyed species (rabbit and rat) exhibited a simplified morphology and bound α-bungarotoxin.

Conclusions

Palisade endings are not a universal feature of mammalian EOMs. So, if they are proprioceptors, not all species require them. Because in frontal-eyed species, the medial rectus muscle has the highest number of palisade endings, they likely play a special role in convergence.

Palisade endings and proprioception in extraocular muscles: a comparison with skeletal muscles

This article describes current views on motor and sensory control of extraocular muscles (EOMs) based on anatomical data. The special morphology of EOMs, including their motor innervation, is described in comparison to classical skeletal limb and trunk muscles. The presence of proprioceptive organs is reviewed with emphasis on the palisade endings (PEs), which are unique to EOMs, but the function of which is still debated. In consideration of the current new anatomical data about the location of cell bodies of PEs, a hypothesis on the function of PEs in EOMs and the multiply innervated muscle fibres they are attached to is put forward.

Nonclassical innervation patterns in mammalian extraocular muscles

PURPOSE

The abducens (CN6) and oculomotor (CN3) nerves (nn) enter target extraocular muscles (EOMs) via their global surfaces; the trochlear (CN4) nerve enters the superior oblique (SO) muscle on its orbital surface. Motor nn are classically described as entering the EOMs in their middle thirds. We investigated EOM innervation that does not follow the classic pattern.

METHODS

Intact, whole orbits of two humans and one each monkey, cow, and rabbit were paraffin embedded, serially sectioned in coronal plane, and prepared with Masson's trichrome and by choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) immunohistochemistry. Nerves innervating EOMs were traced from the orbital apex toward the scleral insertion, and some were reconstructed in three dimensions.

RESULTS

Classical motor nn positive for ChAT entered rectus and SO EOMs and coursed anteriorly, without usually exhibiting recurrent branches. In every orbit, nonclassical (NC) nn entered each EOM well posterior to classical motor nn. These NC nn entered and arborized in the posterior EOMs, mainly within the orbital layer (OL), but often traveled into the global layer or entered an adjacent EOM. Other NC nn originated in the orbital apex and entered each EOM through its orbital surface, ultimately anastomosing with classical motor nn. Mixed sensory and motor nn interconnected EOM spindles.

CONCLUSIONS

EOMs exhibit a previously undescribed pattern of NC innervation originating in the proximal orbit that partially joins branches of the classical motor nn. This NC innervation appears preferential for the OL, and may have mixed supplemental motor and/or proprioceptive functions, perhaps depending upon species. The origin of the NC innervation is currently unknown.

Do palisade endings in extraocular muscles arise from neurons in the motor nuclei?

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to localize the cell bodies of palisade endings that are associated with the myotendinous junctions of the extraocular muscles.

METHODS

Rhesus monkeys received tract-tracer injections (tetramethylrhodamine dextran [TMR-DA] or choleratoxin subunit B [CTB]) into the oculomotor and trochlear nuclei, which contain the motoneurons of extraocular muscles. All extraocular muscles were processed for the combined immunocytochemical detection of the tracer and SNAP-25 or synaptophysin for the visualization of the complete muscle innervation.

RESULTS

In all muscles--except the lateral rectus--en plaque and en grappe motor endings, but also palisade endings, were anterogradely labeled. In addition a few tracer-labeled tendon organs were found. One group of tracer-negative nerve fibers was identified as thin tyrosine hydroxylase-positive sympathetic fibers, and a second less numerous group of tracer-negative fibers may originate from the trigeminal ganglia. No cellular or terminal tracer labeling was present within the mesencephalic trigeminal nucleus or the trigeminal ganglia.

CONCLUSIONS

These results confirm those of earlier studies and furthermore suggest that the somata of palisade endings are located close to the extraocular motor nuclei--in this case, probably within the C and S groups around the periphery of the oculomotor nucleus. The multiple en grappe endings have also been shown to arise from these cells groups, but it is not possible to distinguish different populations in these experiments.

Increased mRNA expression of collagen V gene in pulmonary fibrosis of systemic sclerosis

BACKGROUND

Collagen V shows promise as an inducer of interstitial lung fibrosis in experimental systemic sclerosis (SSc).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Remodelling of the pulmonary interstitium was evaluated based on the clinical data and open lung biopsies from 15 patients with SSc. Normal lung tissues obtained from eight individuals who died of traumatic injuries were used as control group. Immunofluorescence, immunohistochemistry, morphometry, tri-dimensional reconstruction and a real-time polymerase chain reaction were used to evaluate the quantity, structure and molecular chains of collagen V. The impact of these markers was tested on clinical data.

RESULTS

The main difference in collagen V content between SSc patients and the control group was an increased, abnormal and distorted fibre deposition in the alveolar septa and the pre-acinar artery wall. The lungs from SSc patients presented [alpha1(V)] and [alpha2(V)] mRNA chain expression increased, but [alpha2(V)] was proportionally increased compared with the control group. High levels of collagen V were inversely associated with vital capacity (r = -0.72; P = 0.002), forced vital capacity (r = -0.76; P < 0.001), forced expiratory volume in 1-s (r = -0.89; P < 0.001) and diffusing capacity for carbon monoxide (r = -0.62; P = 0.04).

CONCLUSIONS

Abnormal collagen V fibres are overproduced in lungs from SSc patients and may play an important role in the pathogenesis of the disease as this molecule regulates tissue collagen assembly. The aberrant histoarchitecture observed in SSc can be related to the overexpression of the [alpha2(V)] gene of unknown origin.

Palisade endings are present in canine extraocular muscles and have a cholinergic phenotype

Classical proprioceptors, like Golgi tendon organs and muscle spindles are absent in the extraocular muscles (EOMs) of most mammals. Instead, a nerve end organ was detected in the EOMs of each species including sheep, cat, rabbit, rat, monkey, and human examined so far: the palisade ending. Until now no clear evidence appeared that palisade endings are also present in canine EOMs. Here, we analyzed dog EOMs by confocal laser scanning microscopy, 3D reconstruction, and transmission electron microscopy. In EOM wholemount preparations stained with antibodies against neurofilament and synaptophysin we could demonstrate typical palisade endings. Nerve fibers coming from the muscle extend into the tendon. There, the nerve fibers turn 180 degrees and return to branch into preterminal axons which establish nerve terminals around a single muscle fiber tip. Fine structural analysis revealed that each palisade ending in dog EOMs establish nerve terminals on the tendon. In some palisade endings we found nerve terminals contacting the muscle fiber as well. Such neuromuscular contacts have a basal lamina in the synaptic cleft. By using an antibody against choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) we proved that canine palisade endings are ChAT-immunoreactive. This study shows that palisade endings are present in canine EOMs. In line with prior findings in cat and monkey, palisade endings in dog have a cholinergic phenotype.

Determination of slow-tonic MyHC immunoreactivity is an important step in the evaluation of muscle spindles in porcine extraocular muscles

We have tested our hypothesis suggesting (i) that for the reliable determination and counting of muscle spindles (Msp) at the light microscopy level in extraocular muscles (EOM), analysis of the spindle specific myosin heavy chain (MyHC) immunoreactivity of intrafusal fibers, especially after staining with anti-slow-tonic MyHC antibodies, is the most convenient tool, (ii) that the number of Msp determined by the slow-tonic MyHC immunoreactivity of intrafusal fibers in EOM is much lower than that based on histological examination and (iii) that the previously reported numbers of Msp based on histological examination of EOM could be overestimated. In order to determine the number and distribution of Msp and to analyze the MyHC isoform immunoreactivity of intrafusal fibers in porcine EOM, paraffin sections of three 9-month-old pig medial (MR) and lateral rectus (LR), levator palpebrae (LP) and retractor bulbi (RB) muscles were stained histologically or using specific monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) against MyHC isoforms. Msp in recti and LP muscles studied by immunocytochemistry contained nuclear bag (NB) fiber(s) reacting with mAbs against slow-tonic, slow-twitch, alpha-cardiac and neonatal MyHCs, but not with the mAb against fast-twitch MyHC, which, on the contrary, stained nuclear chain (NC) fibers. Based on determination of spindle specific slow-tonic MyHC isoform immunoreactivity we have found 72 Msp in the MR and 68 Msp in the LR and 12 Msp in LP muscles, which was only 62, 55 and 32% of the Msp total counts according to histological examination, respectively. In the RB muscle, we have even found only 15 spindle-like-structures composed of encapsulated thin muscle fibers, which possessed only a reaction with anti-fast-twitch MyHC mAb, but lacked slow-tonic, slow-twitch or alpha-cardiac MyHCs immunoreactivity. Our analysis of porcine EOM confirmed the above suggestions, demonstrating, for the first time in the pig, the presence of "false Msp" mimicking encapsulated muscle fibers on histological sections that lack spindle specific MyHC immunoreactivity. In analogy with other muscles we suggest that "false Msp" are not innervated by sensory axons and therefore do not contribute to the physiological sensation of the muscle length changes. Our results thus show that the reliable identification of functionally effective Msp in EOM must involve immunohistochemical analysis of spindle specific MyHC isoforms of intrafusal fibers, as "false" spindles appearing on histologically stained sections as encapsulated muscle fibers could be regarded as "true" Msp and thus increase the spindle number counts in earlier studies.

Interstitial and vascular type V collagen morphologic disorganization in usual interstitial pneumonia

Recent evidence suggests that type V collagen plays a role in organizing collagen fibrils, thus maintaining fibril size and spatial organization uniform. In this study we sought to characterize the importance of type V collagen morphological disorganization and to study the relationship between type V collagen, active remodeling of the pulmonary vascular/parenchyma (fibroblastic foci), and other collagen types in usual interstitial pneumonia (UIP). We examined type V collagen and several other collagens in 24 open lung biopsies with histological pattern of UIP from patients with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF). We used immunofluorescence, morphometry, and three-dimensional reconstruction to evaluate the amount of collagen V and its interaction with the active remodeling progression in UIP, as well as types I and III collagen fibers. Active remodeling progression was significantly related to type V collagen density (p<0.05), showing a gradual and direct increase to minimal, moderate, and severe fibrosis degree in UIP and in the three different areas: normal, intervening, and mural-organizing fibrosis in UIP. Parenchymal changes were characterized by morphological disorganization of fibrillar collagen with diverse disarray and thickness when observed by three-dimensional reconstruction. We concluded that in the different temporal stages of UIP, vascular/parenchyma collagen type V is increased, in disarray, and is the most important predictor of survival.

Proprioception in the extraocular muscles of mammals and man

This article summarizes the authors' previous studies on proprioceptors in extraocular muscles (EOMs) of mammals and man. They report on muscle spindles in the EOMs of man, Golgi tendon organs in the EOMs of even-toed ungulates, and palisade endings in the EOMs of the cat. Muscle spindles: Muscle spindles are present in the EOMs of some mammals and in the EOMs of man. Compared with muscle spindles in other skeletal muscles, those in human EOMs exhibit structural differences. These structural differences may indicate a special function. Golgi tendon organs: Golgi tendon organs are absent in human EOMs. Golgi tendon organs exhibiting a specific morphology are present in the EOMs of even-toed ungulates. Their high number and rich innervation indicate functional importance. Palisade endings: Palisade endings are nervous end organs confined to the EOMs of mammals and man. It is assumed that these organs have a proprioceptive function. The authors show that palisade endings are immunoreactive for antibodies against choline acetyltransferase. Neuromuscular contacts, if present in palisade endings, are alpha -bungarotoxin positive as well. Taken together, these results show that palisade endings exhibit molecular characteristics of effector organs.

Proprioception and Palisade Endings in Extraocular Eye Muscles

Palisade endings occur only in extraocular muscles, and their function is unknown. They form a cuff of nerve terminals around the tips of muscle fibers. We describe here the advantages of using antibodies to a synaptosomal-associated protein (SNAP-25) to study properties of palisade endings in man, monkey, and rat. The stain can be combined readily with other immunofluorescence procedures, and results suggest that the synapses of palisade endings do not bind alpha-bungarotoxin (i.e., are not motor), nor do they contain substance P. These double-labeling data support the hypothesis that palisade endings are non-nociceptive sensory receptors, and could serve a proprioceptive function. With SNAP-25 immunolabeling, palisade endings were identified in the rat for the first time. Thus, palisade endings appear to be present in all vertebrate extraocular muscles studied to date. Their apparent universality, which contrasts with the more variable manifestation of extraocular muscle spindles and Golgi tendon organs, would be expected if proprioceptive feedback is necessary to the function of the ocular motor system, and if palisade endings are the critical proprioceptive structure.

Sensory control of extraocular muscles

The role of sensory receptors in eye muscles is not well understood, but there is physiological and clinical evidence for the presence of proprioceptive signals in many areas of the central nervous system. It is unclear which structures generate these sensory signals, and which central neural pathways are involved. Three different types of receptors are associated with eye muscles: (1) muscle spindles, (2) palisade endings, and (3) Golgi tendon organs, but their occurrence varies wildly between species. A review of their organization shows that each receptor is mainly confined to a morphologically separate layer of the eye muscle. The palisade endings - which are unique to eye muscles, are associated with the global layer; and they have been found in all mammals studied so far. Their function is unknown. The muscle spindles, if they are present in a species, lie in the orbital layer, or at its junction to the global layer. Golgi tendon organs appear to be unique to artiodactyls (i.e., sheep and goats, etc.); they lie in an outer distal marginal layer of the eye muscle, called the "peripheral patch layer" in sheep. The specific association between palisade endings and the multiply innervated type of muscle fibers of the global layer has led to the hypothesis that together they may act as a sensory receptor, and provide a source of central proprioceptive signals. But other interpretations of the morphological evidence do not support this role.

Confocal laser scanning microscopy in orthopaedic research

Confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) is a type of high-resolution fluorescence microscopy that overcomes the limitations of conventional widefield microscopy and facilitates the generation of high-resolution 3D images from relatively thick sections of tissue. As a comparatively non-destructive imaging technique, CLSM facilitates the in situ characterization of tissue microstructure. Images generated by CLSM have been utilized for the study of articular cartilage, bone, muscle, tendon, ligament and menisci by the foremost research groups in the field of orthopaedics including those teams headed by Bush, Errington, Guilak, Hall, Hunziker, Knight, Mow, Poole, Ratcliffe and White. Recent evolutions in techniques and technologies have facilitated a relatively widespread adoption of this imaging modality, with increased "user friendliness" and flexibility. Applications of CLSM also exist in the rapidly advancing field of orthopaedic implants and in the investigation of joint lubrication.

Palisade endings in extraocular eye muscles revealed by SNAP-25 immunoreactivity

Palisade endings form a cuff of nerve terminals around the tip of muscle fibres. They are found only in extraocular muscles, but no definite evidence for their role in eye movements has been established. Palisade endings have been reported in all species so far investigated except the rat. In this study we demonstrate that antibodies against SNAP-25, the synaptosomal associated protein of 25 kDa, reliably visualize the complete motor, sensory and autonomic innervation of the extraocular muscles in human, monkey and rat. The SNAP-25 antibody can be combined with other immunofluorescence procedures, and is used here to study properties of palisade endings. With SNAP-25 immunolabelling putative palisade endings are identified in the rat for the first time. They are not well branched, but fulfil several criteria of palisade endings, being associated with non-twitch fibres as shown by double labelling with 'myosin heavy chain slow-twitch' antibodies. The putative palisade endings of the rat lack alpha-bungarotoxin binding, which implies that these synapses are sensory. If palisade endings are sensory then they could function as an eye muscle proprioceptor. They seem to be a general feature of all vertebrate eye muscles, unlike the other two extraocular proprioceptors, muscle spindles and Golgi tendon organs, the presence of which varies widely between species.