The structure of the transitional and aganglionic zones of Auerbach's plexus in patients with Hirschsprung's disease: a computer-assisted three-dimensional reconstruction study

Routine use of Circumferential 'Doughnut' Biopsy in Pull through Surgery for Hirschsprung's Disease: Advantages and Limitations

Aims:

The aim of this study was to review the use of the on-table “doughnut” biopsy for frozen section assessment of bowel in the operative management of Hirschsprung's disease (HD).

Methods:

This was a single-center retrospective review of doughnut histopathology reports, operation notes, and slides from 2010 to 2017. Data were assessed for the presence of transition zone (TZ) features and the subsequent decision as to the level of pull-through.

Results:

Fifty-five patients had a doughnut biopsy taken as part of their intraoperative frozen section histopathology for pull-through for HD during the study period. Forty-eight required a single doughnut, six required a second more proximal doughnut, and one required a third doughnut. Of the 55 first doughnuts, 37 were identified as normal bowel, 17 were TZ, and not defined in the report in one case. Of the 17 TZ doughnuts, 8 were accepted for pull-through and 7 underwent second doughnuts (normal = 4 and TZ = 3). The third doughnut (one case) was normal. TZ was accepted for pull-through in 10/54 (18.5%) patients despite the use of a doughnut. However, TZ was avoided in six (11.1%), where the single-point biopsy was “normal.”

Conclusions:

The doughnut allows the entire circumference of pull-through level to be assessed, enabling TZ identification that can be missed by single seromuscular biopsies. This allows identification and avoidance of TZ pull-through, although sometimes, it is accepted for other reasons.

Surgery, Surgical Pathology, and Postoperative Management of Patients With Hirschsprung Disease

Endorectal pullthrough surgery is integral in the treatment of patients with Hirschsprung disease. Several different surgical procedures exist, which share as common goals to excise the aganglionic segment and upstream transition zone and attach ganglionic bowel just proximal to the anal canal. The operation requires collaboration between surgeon and pathologist to localize ganglionic bowel and prevent retention of transition zone. Intraoperative frozen sections are extremely important, first to establish that ganglion cells are present and subsequently to exclude features of transition zone (partial circumferential aganglionosis, myenteric hypoganglionosis, and submucosal nerve hypertrophy) at the proximal surgical (anastomotic) margin. Postoperative histopathological analysis of resection specimens should be tailored to document distal aganglionosis, document the length of the aganglionic segment and its proximity to the anastomotic margin, and confirm that transition zone has been resected completely. Adherence to the recommendations described in this review will reduce the likelihood of transition zone pullthrough and should decrease the incidence of persistent postoperative obstructive symptoms.

Submucosal nerve diameter of greater than 40 μm is not a valid diagnostic index of transition zone pull-through

BACKGROUND

Submucosal nerve hypertrophy is a feature of the transition zone in Hirschsprung disease and has been used as a primary diagnostic feature of transition zone pull-through for patients with persistent obstructive symptoms after their initial surgery. Most published criteria for identification of hypertrophy rely on a nerve diameter of greater than 40μm, based primarily on data from a relatively small number of infants with Hirschsprung disease and controls. The validity of these objective measures has not been validated in appropriate controls for post-pull-through patients.

SCIENTIFIC APPROACH

The primary pull-through specimens and post pull-through biopsies +/- redo pull-through resections from a series of 9 patients with Hirschsprung disease were reviewed to assess the prevalence of submucosal nerves >40μm in diameter and 400× microscopic fields containing two or more such nerves. Similar data from multiple colonic locations were collected from a series of 40 non-Hirschsprung autopsy and surgical controls.

RESULTS

The overwhelming majority of Hirschsprung patients harbored submucosal nerves >40μm in their post-pull-through specimens independent of other features of transition zone pathology, and despite normal innervation at the proximal margins of their initial resections. Measurement of submucosal nerve diameters in autopsy and surgical non-Hirschsprung control samples indicated that nerves >40μm are normal in the distal rectum after 1year of age and are found in more proximal colon at older ages.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that diagnostic criteria currently used to recognize submucosal nerve hypertrophy in the neorectum after a pull-through for Hirschsprung disease are not justified and should not be regarded as definitive evidence for transition zone pull-through.

Transitional zone pull through: surgical pathology considerations

Incomplete resection of the transitional zone (TZ) between histologically normal and aganglionic bowel in Hirschsprung disease is a putative cause of postoperative dysmotility. A review of literature indicates that diverse histopathological indexes have been used to define the TZ, and validated and reproducible diagnostic criteria have not been established. As a consequence, the proximal margin of the TZ is difficult to delimit, and the length of the TZ in a given patient depends on the diagnostic criteria used. Seromuscular biopsies are inadequate to exclude TZ, as diagnostic indexes may involve only a portion of the bowel circumference or the submucosa. Most published investigations of postoperative outcome after a TZ pull through (TZPT) conclude that the latter can cause persistent obstructive symptoms, which necessitate reoperation. However, the results of these studies are difficult to translate into clinical practice because most lack appropriate controls, and the overwhelming majority provide inadequate histopathological descriptions for reference at the time of intraoperative frozen section analysis. At present, a conservative approach based on frozen section examination of the entire proximal margin of the resection to exclude obvious subcircumferential aganglionosis (contiguous gap between ganglia of more than one-eighth of the circumference), hypoganglionosis (continuous string of myenteric ganglia comprised of 1 or 2 ganglion cells without surrounding neuropil), or hypertrophic submucosal nerves (>2 nerves with widths ≥40 μm per high-power field) seems prudent. Well-controlled studies to correlate proximal margin histology, especially subtle anatomic or immunohistochemical changes, with postoperative outcome are needed.

Morphological and quantitative study of the myenteric plexus in the human tenia coli

The longitudinal muscle in the large intestine in humans and some other mammalian species is concentrated in regions known as "tenia coli." The myenteric plexus under the tenia is believed to be highly developed to control the adjacent large muscle mass, however, data on the innervation of this region are very scarce. We used whole mount preparations of human colon to characterize the organization of the myenteric plexus under the tenia coli (UT) and compared it with the plexus between the tenia (BT). Using histochemical staining for NADPH diaphorase, we found that the meshwork UT was 50% denser than BT, and that the ganglia UT were 30% wider. The density and size of the NADPH-d positive neurons UT were similar to those of BT. We conclude that the myenteric plexus UT is considerably more developed than BT, and suggest to understand the control of colonic motility, the myenteric plexus UT needs to be further investigated.

Reoperation for Hirschsprung disease: pathology of the resected problematic distal pull-through

Hirschsprung disease, which consists of aganglionosis of the rectum and sometimes more proximal bowel, requires surgical removal of the aganglionic bowel and creation of ganglionated neorectum using proximal normally innervated bowel. The border between aganglionic and ganglionic bowel is irregular; the transition zone features variable quantities of ganglion cells and numerous large nerves. We report the histopathology of pull-through bowel segments resected because of poor postoperative outcome from 30 patients (22 boys, 8 girls). The most common indication for reoperation was severe constipation/obstruction. Transition zone (bowel with at least two nerves ≥40 µm diameter per 400× high-power field, and ganglion cells) or aganglionic bowel (bowel with at least two nerves ≥40 µm per high-power field diameter, but without ganglion cells) was found in 19/30 (63%) resections. In colons resected because of familial adenomatous polyposis, rare high-power fields showed two enlarged nerves; the mean age of those patients (135 ± 49.4 months) was significantly higher than that of the patients undergoing redo pull-through surgery (67.9 ± 42.8 months). Additional pathology included stricture and enterocolitis. Although there are multiple causes for poor outcomes following surgical therapy for Hirschsprung disease, abnormal innervation of the bowel used for pull-through is common. We recommend that intraoperative consultation at primary pull-through procedure include frozen section evaluation of the circumference of the bowel to be used for pull-through to confirm histologically the presence of both ganglion cells and normal-caliber nerves. The criteria used in this study are most suitable for infants and young children.

Long-term results of treatment of Hirschsprung's disease

Many children with Hirschsprung's disease (HD) have a good outcome following surgical treatment, but long-term follow-up studies have identified a number of concerns. Analysis of long-term function in children after surgical management is difficult. The most commonly encountered problems include constipation, incontinence, enterocolitis and the overall impact of the disease on lifestyle (quality of life). Other complications are less frequent. Each of these problems will be discussed.

Does transitional zone pull-through in Hirschsprung's disease imply a poor prognosis?

PURPOSE

Accurate frozen section interpretation of intraoperative biopsies is critical to the success of the Duhamel procedure. Errors during sampling or interpretation may result in an abnormal pull-through. The authors' aim was to determine the incidence and outcome of transitional zone pull-through (TZPT).

METHODS

Ninety-six children who underwent a Duhamel procedure between January 1987 and May 2002 were followed up prospectively. The outcome of 18 children with TZPT was compared statistically with that of a cohort of 58 patients with a ganglionic pull-through.

RESULTS

The incidence of TZPT was 18.8%. Concordance rate between frozen and paraffin-section analyses was 88.5%. The incidence of enterocolitis (P =.003) and intractable constipation (P =.02) was found to be significantly higher in TZPT. There was no significant difference in continence (P =.34), rectal sensation (P =.35), and control (P =.53). Five (27.8%) TZPT patients required a revisional surgery for failure of conservative management. The incidence of stoma placement and revision was significantly less in the ganglionic group (3.4%, P =.007).

CONCLUSIONS

Up to one third of patients with TZPT will require revisional surgery for intractable symptoms. Vigilance is warranted in view of the greater risk of enterocolitis. Continence is not significantly affected.

Hirschsprung's disease: problems with transition-zone pull-through

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

It is generally accepted that if surgery for Hirschsprung's disease is to be successful, ganglionic bowel must be anastomosed to the lower rectum or anal canal. Above the aganglionic distal bowel lies a transition zone (TZ) where more subtle abnormalities of innervation are apparent. The significance of this transition zone in respect to the functional outcome of surgery has received little attention. The aim of this study was to identify the incidence of transition zone pull-through (TZPT) in a cohort of children who underwent surgery for Hirschsprung's disease, to identify the reasons why TZPTs occurred, and to identify the functional consequences. The authors report the long-term outcome of these children with emphasis on bowel function and the results of subsequent surgery.

METHODS

A Retrospective study was conducted of children treated at a single institution from 1979 through 1994. TZPT patients were subject to detailed review of surgical records and histopathologic material.

RESULTS

Thirteen children were identified with a TZPT. In 12 cases, histopathologic errors contributed to the TZPT: in 5 cases this was caused by single point biopsies missing an asymmetrical TZ, whereas in 7 cases the histopathologic features of the TZ were not recognized. In 1 case the TZPT was caused by surgical error. As a consequence of the TZPT 7 children underwent repeat pull-through. One child is fully continent, one has daytime fecal continence, and 2 others are incontinent. Two children have permanent stomas. One child is clean with antegrade colonic washouts. Repeat pull-throughs were not attempted in 6 children. Two children have achieved full continence, 2 have permanent stomas, 1 is clean with antegrade colonic washouts, and 1 child receives regular suppositories.

CONCLUSIONS

Transition zone pull-throughs occurred because of a combination of surgical and histopathologic errors. The transition zone may follow an asymmetric course around the circumference of the bowel and may be missed if single-point extramucosal biopsy specimens are taken. Recognition of the subtle histologic features of the transition zone requires an experienced pathologist. The functional consequences of a TZPT are severe, with symptoms of constipation, diarrhea, and incontinence. The results of revisional pull-through were disappointing. Serious consideration should be given to alternative procedures such as the antegrade continence enema operation.

Circumferential distribution of ganglion cells in the transition zone of children with Hirschsprung disease

We prospectively studied the circumferential distribution of ganglion cells in the transition zone from a study population of 21 patients with Hirschsprung disease (HD) undergoing a pull-through procedure over a 26-month period. Twelve cases were satisfactory for examination, in that the transition zone was contained within a single surgical specimen and specimen distortion was minimal. Ganglion cells in the submucosa were counted in all 12 cases. In seven of the cases, the transition zone was proximal to the rectal sleeve and myenteric plexus ganglion cells were also counted. We found an uneven circumferential distribution of ganglion cells in both myenteric plexus and submucosa of the transition zone, resulting in a "leading edge" of ganglion cells extending into aganglionic distal bowel. The maximum length of this leading edge was 2.4 cm and 2.1 cm in the myenteric plexus and submucosa, respectively. Ganglion cells at the tip of the leading edge were present in clusters of up to six ganglion cells, in marked contrast to an absence of ganglion cells for most of the remainder of the circumference. Closely spaced myenteric plexus ganglia were seen at the tip of the leading edge in some cases. The leading edge was more frequently observed along the antimesenteric side, but this was not statistically significant. Our findings have relevance in the interpretation of intraoperative biopsies at the time of pull-through surgery and subsequent biopsies of neorectum in patients with surgically corrected HD.

Cytoplasmic delayed neuronal death in the myenteric plexus of the rat small intestine after ischemia

The present study demonstrates light and electron microscopic changes in neurons in the myenteric plexus of the rat ileum following four-hour ischemia. Macroscopically, an intestinal constriction occurred at the damaged portion at three weeks after ischemia; the segment oral to the constriction markedly swelled at four weeks. In light microscopy, at three weeks after ischemia, the myenteric neurons appeared spongy or foamy, containing many vacuoles in their somatic cytoplasm. At four weeks, the neuronal cytoplasm and nerve fiber bundles had disintegrated to form vacant spaces in the myenteric plexus. The neuronal nucleus of the damaged plexus did not show positive nick-end labeling. In electron microscopy, neuronal cytoplasm revealed degenerative signs already at one week after ischemia: a distended endoplasmic reticulum and swollen mitochondria with fragmentary cristae. The nerve fibers also showed destruction of the mitochondria, and degenerative changes in the postsynaptic sites appeared earlier than the presynaptic terminals. The results suggest that intestinal ischemia causes delayed neuronal death, which differs from the apoptotic process previously demonstrated in the ischemia-damaged brain.

Morphological investigation of the enteric nervous system in Hirschsprung's disease and hypoganglionosis using whole-mount colon preparation

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

A suction rectal mucosal biopsy with positive staining for acetylcholinesterase is a useful test for diagnosis of Hirschsprung's disease (HD). However, hypoganglionosis has not been diagnosed by a rectal mucosal biopsy. The authors morphologically examined the enteric nervous systems in HD and hypoganglionosis patients using whole-mount preparations.

METHODS

Six HD patients, two hypoganglionosis patients, and 10 with normally innervated colons were examined. Colonic specimens were incubated with the primary antibodies against protein gene product 9.5 (PGP 9.5) mixed with S-100b protein, tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP), substance P (SP), and neurofilament protein 200 kDa (NFH). They were observed by histochemical technique using light-microscopy in whole-mount preparations.

RESULTS

The aganglionic distal colon had thick nerve strands stained with PGP 9.5 mixed with S100 or NFH located in the layer between the longitudinal muscle and the circular one, and the submucosal layer. The nerve strands in the myenteric layer contained few CGRP- and SP-positive fibers and ran along the long axis of the intestine. Ganglion cells appeared along with those thick nerve strands in the transitional zone of HD. In hypoganglionosis, we found small myenteric ganglia with no thick nerve strands.

CONCLUSIONS

The enteric nervous system in oligoganglionic segments of HD morphologically differed from the one in hypoganglionosis. A suction rectal mucosal biopsy would be of no use in the diagnosis of hypoganglionosis.

In vivo fibre optic confocal imaging of microvasculature and nerves in the rat vas deferens and colon

A fluorescence confocal microscopy technique was employed to obtain subsurface images of nerve and microvascular structure in the vas deferens and colon of the living rat. The use of dual labelling with vital dyes and 2-channel confocal acquisition allowed differentiation of microscopic structure at both low and higher magnification. Characteristic staining patterns of nerves and blood vessels were repeatedly obtained in each tissue, suggesting the potential of this technique for studying morphological changes associated with surgical procedures and/or models of neuronal or vascular pathology.