Chorioretinal coloboma and Joubert syndrome: a nonrandom association

Visual Evoked Potentials in Joubert Syndrome: A Suggested Useful Method for Evaluating Future Approaches Targeted to Improve Visual Pathways' Function

Introduction

Joubert syndrome (JS) is a recessive disorder characterized by a congenital malformation of the mid-hindbrain and a large spectrum of clinical features including optic nerve morphologic abnormalities. The function of the visual pathways, including the optic nerve, can be objectively evaluated by visual evoked potential (VEP) recordings. Our work aims to employ VEP to evaluate the neural conduction along the visual pathways in JS patients with or without optic nerve morphologic abnormalities (ONMA).

Methods

In this observational and prospective study, 18 children with genetic diagnosis of JS (mean age 8.78 ± 5.87 years) and 17 healthy age-similar control subjects (control group, 9.05 ± 6.02 years) were enrolled.

Based on presence/absence of ONMA at fundus examination, JS patients were divided into two groups: the JS-A group (eight patients with ONMA) and JS-N group (ten patients without ONMA). Following the ISCEV standards, pattern VEPs were recorded in patients and controls in response to 60’ and 15’ checks to obtain a prevalent activation of large or small axons, respectively.

Results

Compared to controls, both the JS-A and JS-N groups showed significant abnormalities in 60’ and 15’ VEP implicit time and amplitude. Only in the JS-N group were values of 15’ VEP implicit significantly correlated with the corresponding values of visual acuity.

Conclusions

Our results suggest that a visual pathways dysfunction (of both large and small axons) detectable by VEP may occur in JS patients regardless of the presence of ONMA. Since clinical trials are envisaged in the near future to address JS-related ocular problems, our results might provide information about the potential usefulness of VEP recordings to assess the efficacy of treatments targeted to improve the visual pathways’ function.

Electroretinographic Assessment in Joubert Syndrome: A Suggested Objective Method to Evaluate the Effectiveness of Future Targeted Treatment

INTRODUCTION

Joubert syndrome (JS) is an autosomal recessive disorder characterized by a congenital malformation of the mid-hindbrain and a large spectrum of clinical features including congenital retinal dystrophy. The function of different retinal elements (rod, cone, bipolar cells) can be objectively evaluated by electroretinogram (ERG) recordings. Our work aims to evaluate the retinal function (by ERG recordings) in patients with JS with or without congenital retinal dystrophy. In addition, since clinical trials should be performed in the near future in JS, our results could provide information about the possible usefulness of ERG recordings in the assessment of the efficacy of treatments targeted to improve the retinal involvement.

METHODS

In this observational and prospective study, 24 children with genetic identification for JS (mean age 10.75 ± 6.59 years) and 25 healthy age-similar normal control subjects (control group, mean age 10.55 ± 3.76 years) were enrolled. On the basis of the presence/absence of retinal dystrophy at fundus examination, patients with JS were divided into two groups: patients with JS with retinal dystrophy (16 children, mean age 11.00 ± 6.74 years, providing 16 eyes; JS-RD group) and patients with JS without retinal dystrophy (8 children, mean age 10.50 ± 6.45 years, providing 8 eyes; JS-NRD group). In patients with JS and controls, visual acuity (VA), dark-adapted, light-adapted, and 30-Hz flicker ERGs were performed according to International Society for Clinical Electrophysiology of Vision (ISCEV) standard protocols.

RESULTS

When compared to controls, patients in the JS-RD and JS-NRD groups showed significant abnormalities of the values of dark-adapted, light-adapted, and 30-Hz flicker ERG parameters. The ERG and VA changes were not significantly correlated.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that a dysfunction of photoreceptors and bipolar cells occurs in patients with JS with or without retinal dystrophy. The retinal impairment can be detected by ERG recordings and this method should be proposed to evaluate the effectiveness of adequate treatment targeted to improve the retinal impairment in patients with JS.

Joubert Syndrome: Ophthalmological Findings in Correlation with Genotype and Hepatorenal Disease in 99 Patients Prospectively Evaluated at a Single Center

PURPOSE

Joubert syndrome (JS) is caused by mutations in >34 genes that encode proteins involved with primary (nonmotile) cilia and the cilium basal body. This study describes the varying ocular phenotypes in JS patients, with correlation to systemic findings and genotype.

DESIGN

Patients were systematically and prospectively examined at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) Clinical Center in the setting of a dedicated natural history clinical trial.

PARTICIPANTS

Ninety-nine patients with JS examined at a single center.

METHODS

All patients underwent genotyping for JS, followed by complete age-appropriate ophthalmic examinations at the NIH Clinical Center, including visual acuity (VA), fixation behavior, lid position, motility assessment, slit-lamp biomicroscopy, dilated fundus examination with an indirect ophthalmoscope, and retinoscopy. Color and fundus autofluorescence imaging, Optos wide-field photography (Dunfermline, Scotland, UK), and electroretinography (ERG) were performed when possible.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The VA (with longitudinal follow-up where possible), ptosis, extraocular muscle function, retinal and optic nerve status, and retinal function as measured by ERG.

RESULTS

Among patients with JS with quantifiable VA (68/99), values ranged from 0 logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution (logMAR) (Snellen 20/20) to 1.5 logMAR (Snellen 20/632). Strabismus (71/98), nystagmus (66/99), oculomotor apraxia (60/77), ptosis (30/98), coloboma (28/99), retinal degeneration (20/83), and optic nerve atrophy (8/86) were identified.

CONCLUSIONS

We recommend regular monitoring for ophthalmological manifestations of JS beginning soon after birth or diagnosis. We demonstrate delayed visual development and note that the amblyogenic time frame may last significantly longer in JS than is typical. In general, patients with coloboma were less likely to display retinal degeneration, and those with retinal degeneration did not have coloboma. Severe retinal degeneration that is early and aggressive is seen in disease caused by specific genes, such as CEP290- and AHI1-associated JS. Retinal degeneration in INPP5E-, MKS1-, and NPHP1-associated JS was generally milder. Finally, ptosis surgery can be helpful in a subset of patients with JS; decisions as to timing and benefit/risk ratio need to be made on an individual basis according to expert consultation.

Joubert syndrome and related disorders

Joubert syndrome (JS) is a rare autosomal recessive condition characterized by a peculiar midbrain-hindbrain malformation, known as the molar tooth sign (MTS). The neurological presentation of JS includes hypotonia that evolves into ataxia, developmental delay, abnormal eye movements, and neonatal breathing abnormalities. This picture is often associated with variable multiorgan involvement, mainly of the retina, kidneys, and liver, defining a group of conditions termed Joubert syndrome and related disorders (JSRDs), that share the MTS. To date, 16 causative genes have been identified, all encoding for proteins expressed in the primary cilium or its apparatus. Indeed, JSRD present clinical and genetic overlap with a growing field of disorders due to mutations in ciliary proteins, that are collectively known as "ciliopathies." These include isolated nephronophthisis, Senior-Løken syndrome, Bardet-Biedl syndrome and, in particular, Meckel syndrome, which is allelic at JSRD at seven distinct loci. Significant genotype-phenotype correlates are emerging between specific clinical presentations and mutations in JSRD genes, with relevant implications in terms of molecular diagnosis, clinical follow-up, and management of mutated patients. Moreover, the identification of mutations allows early prenatal diagnosis in couples at risk, while fetal neuroimaging may remain uninformative until the late second trimester of pregnancy.

Uveal coloboma: clinical and basic science update

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To integrate knowledge on the embryologic and molecular basis of optic fissure closure with clinical observations in patients with uveal coloboma.

RECENT FINDINGS

Closure of the optic fissure has been well characterized and many genetic alterations have been associated with coloboma; however, molecular mechanisms leading to coloboma remain largely unknown. In the past decade, we have gained better understanding of genes critical to eye development; however, mutations in these genes have been found in few individuals with coloboma. CHD7 mutations have been identified in patients with CHARGE syndrome (coloboma, heart defects, choanal atresia, retarded growth, genital anomalies, and ear anomalies or deafness). Animal models are bringing us closer to a molecular understanding of optic fissure closure.

SUMMARY

Optic fissure closure requires precise orchestration in timing and apposition of two poles of the optic cup. The relative roles of genetics and environment on this process remain elusive. While most cases of coloboma are sporadic, autosomal dominant, autosomal recessive, and X-linked inheritance patterns have been described. Genetically, colobomata demonstrate pleiotropy, heterogeneity, variable expressivity, and reduced penetrance. Coloboma is a complex disorder with a variable prognosis and requires regular examination to optimize visual acuity and to monitor for potential complications.

Cerebral, cerebellar, and colobomatous anomalies in three related males: Sex-linked inheritance in a newly recognized syndrome with features overlapping with Joubert syndrome

We present a so far unrecognized X-linked mental retardation syndrome with features overlapping with Joubert syndrome (JBS). Two brothers showed hypotonia, mental retardation, ocular abnormalities with impaired vision and colobomas and a breathing pattern compatible with JBS. Neuroimaging revealed cerebellar vermis hypoplasia and ventriculomegaly. A tentative diagnosis of JBS was made, and autosomal recessive inheritance considered most likely. In a subsequent pregnancy that occurred after artificial donor insemination, ultrasound in the 22nd week revealed a Dandy-Walker malformation and hydrocephaly. At autopsy at 34 weeks of gestation, the male infant showed cerebellar vermis aplasia and abnormalities of the brainstem and cerebral cortex. He was considered to have the same disorder as his two half-brothers. This renders the pedigree highly suggestive of X-linked inheritance. The clinical symptoms of this syndrome resemble JBS. However, the absence of the molar tooth sign and the X-linked inheritance do not support JBS. We propose the name X-linked cerebral-cerebellar-coloboma syndrome to distinguish the two disorders. Differentiation of the two disorders is especially important in genetic counseling, where artificial donor insemination may be considered as a means of reducing the recurrence risk, or when female relatives of the patient are concerned.

Joubert-like syndrome unlinked to known candidate loci

We observed the Joubert syndrome (JS) associated with bilateral morning glory disk anomaly and cystic dysplastic kidneys in three patients from a consanguineous kindred. Homozygosity mapping excluded three JS candidate loci as sites harboring the disease gene. We thus delineate an autosomal recessive disorder, distinct from JS and related conditions.

Molar tooth sign in Joubert syndrome: clinical, radiologic, and pathologic significance

Joubert syndrome is a rare autosomal-recessive condition characterized by early hyperpnea and apnea, developmental delay, and truncal ataxia. We previously described key ocular motor signs in Joubert syndrome and the molar tooth sign resulting from dysplasia of the isthmic segment of the brain stem, superior cerebellar peduncles, and vermis. In this study, we obtained clinical and developmental data in 61 cases, and radiologic data in 46 of these, to determine the prevalence of the molar tooth sign in a large sample, and to ensure that magnetic resonance images obtained for study were representative of the Joubert syndrome population at large. We studied the morphology of the isthmic segment of the pontomesencephalic junction, the segment of the brain stem derived from the primitive isthmus. Portions of the cerebellum analyzed included the superior cerebellar peduncles, the anterior and posterior lobes of the vermis, and the flocculonodular lobe. In one case, autopsy of the brain was performed. The average age at diagnosis was 33 months. All patients were hypotonic and developmentally delayed. The molar tooth sign was present in 85% of cases with 13% of these showing additional malformations. All patients without the molar tooth sign had other mimicking conditions such as neocerebellar dysgenesis, isolated vermian atrophy, cerebellar aplasia, and cystic dilation of the cisterna magna. Autopsy showed aplasia of the cerebellar vermis with dysplasia of the dentate nucleus, elongated locus coeruleus, and marked dysplasia of the caudal medulla. A better understanding of the clinical, radiologic, and pathologic features of Joubert syndrome should help uncover the genetic basis for the syndrome.

Clinical and molecular analysis in Joubert syndrome

Joubert syndrome is an autosomal recessive disorder comprising cerebellar hypoplasia, hypotonia, developmental delay, abnormal respiratory patterns, and abnormal eye movements. The biochemical basis of the Joubert syndrome is unknown. We ascertained a cohort of 50 patients with the Joubert syndrome to evaluate the presence of associated malformations, and to initiate studies leading to the identification of the Joubert syndrome gene. Only 8% of patients had polydactyly, 4% colobomas, 2% renal cysts, and 2% had soft tissue tumors of the tongue. In addition, we evaluated the WNT1 gene as a candidate gene for the Joubert syndrome based on its expression in the developing cerebellum and an associated mutation in the swaying mouse. We searched for mutations in WNT1 in a series of Joubert syndrome patients and no mutations were detected. Our analysis suggests that mutations in WNT1 do not cause the Joubert syndrome.

"Joubert syndrome" revisited: key ocular motor signs with magnetic resonance imaging correlation

Joubert syndrome is characterized by episodic hyperpnea and apnea, developmental delay, hypotonia, truncal ataxia, ophthalmologic abnormalities, and vermian dysgenesis. We studied 15 patients with the diagnosis of Joubert syndrome to (1) more fully define the syndrome's clinical features, and (2) correlate the clinical features with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings. Eight of 15 patients had a history of episodic hyperpnea and apnea. All patients had developmental delay and hypotonia. Of the 13 patients receiving detailed neuro-ophthalmologic evaluations, three had optic nerve dysplasia, pendular nystagmus, and gaze-holding nystagmus. All 13 patients had a normal vestibulo-ocular reflex based on head thrust, but had absent to poor ability to cancel the vestibulo-ocular reflex horizontally and vertically. Twelve of 13 patients had impaired smooth pursuit. Twelve of 13 patients had defects in initiation of saccades and quick phases. Two of the most consistent radiologic features were absent or hypoplastic posterior cerebellar vermis, and deformed midbrain and pontomesencephalic junction, which based on ocular motor physiology correlate with the vestibulo-ocular reflex cancellation/ pursuit defect and saccade initiation defect, respectively. As a result of midbrain, vermian, and superior cerebellar peduncle abnormalities, axial neuroimaging showed a unique "molar tooth" appearance of these structures. These results indicate that Joubert syndrome results from maldevelopment of the midbrain and cerebellar vermis, producing a pathognomonic sign on MRI.

COACH syndrome: report of two brothers with congenital hepatic fibrosis, cerebellar vermis hypoplasia, oligophrenia, ataxia, and mental retardation

Congenital hepatic fibrosis (CHF) is probably the most common cause of non-icteric hepatosplenomegaly and is encountered mainly in children and young adults. We describe here two brothers from healthy, non-consanguineous parents. The patients showed early hepatosplenomegaly, portal hypertension, and no apparent kidney involvement. Clinical and laboratory findings were similar in both patients. Liver biopsies showed the presence of broad septa of fibrous tissue containing abundant bile ducts, portal tracts enlarged by fibrosis, and preserved lobular architecture. The histological findings were suggestive of CHF. Ophthalmological assessment demonstrated visual impairment with mild exotropia, nystagmus, and oculomotor apraxia. Neurological examination showed moderate mental retardation and cerebellar ataxia. Brain MRI confirmed cerebellar malformation with inferior vermis hypoplasia. This pattern of defects is consistent with COACH syndrome (Cerebellar vermis hypoplasia, Oligophrenia, congenital Ataxia, Coloboma, Hepatic fibrocirrhosis) which has previously been reported in five other cases. Our report may contribute to a better delineation of the COACH syndrome phenotype in the spectrum of oculo-encephalohepato-renal disorders.

Renal insufficiency is a component of COACH syndrome

Two sisters, ages 23 years and 6 years, respectively, were found to have congenital ataxia, bilateral coloboma, mental retardation and abnormal liver function. Magnetic resonance imaging showed cerebellar vermis hypoplasia in the younger girl and liver biopsy showed hepatic fibrosis in the older sister. This combination of findings suggested a diagnosis of COACH syndrome which is characterized by hypoplasia of cerebellar vermis, oligophrenia, congenital ataxia, coloboma, and hepatic fibrosis. COACH syndrome is a newly recognized condition. So far, five cases have been reported from three sibships. We report two additional cases from one sibship and suggest that several other cases may already exist in literature that were not recognized as having COACH syndrome. The occurrence of multiple cases in single sibships suggests autosomal recessive inheritance. In addition to previously described findings typical of COACH syndrome, the older of our patients showed progressive renal insufficiency with fibrocystic changes on renal biopsy. Renal function has not been described consistently in previous reports of COACH syndrome but has been abnormal in all cases in which it has been investigated. We suggest that renal insufficiency should be considered a common manifestation of COACH syndrome.

Joubert syndrome with congenital hepatic fibrosis: an entity in the spectrum of oculo-encephalo-hepato-renal disorders

Joubert syndrome is an autosomal recessive inherited condition characterized by agenesis or hypoplasia of the cerebellar vermis, retinal dystrophy, chorioretinal colobomata, oculomotor abnormalities, episodic hyperpnea, ataxia, and mental retardation. Congenital hepatic fibrosis has not previously been described in Joubert syndrome. We report two unrelated children with Joubert syndrome and hepatosplenomegaly. On histopathological examination, both had congenital hepatic fibrosis. Both were also found to have congenital medullary cystic disease of the kidneys. Joubert syndrome appears to be one of a spectrum of congenital malformation syndromes involving the central nervous system, eye, liver and kidneys.

Joubert syndrome associated with Leber amaurosis and multicystic kidneys

We describe a boy with manifestations of Joubert syndrome, Leber congenital amaurosis, and multicystic kidneys. In infants with unexplained neonatal tachypnea and late developmental delay, absence or hypoplasia of the cerebellar vermis should be sought. Joubert syndrome probably is an autosomal recessive disorder. In the subsequent pregnancy of the propositus' mother, we were able to make a prenatal diagnosis of Joubert syndrome, one of the first to be reported.

Autosomal recessive oral-facial-digital syndrome with resemblance to OFD types II, III, IV and VI: a new OFD syndrome?

We report on a son and daughter of Ashkenazi-Jewish parents with postaxial polydactyly of the hands and feet associated with syndactyly and brachydactyly, mental retardation, cerebellar hypoplasia, pectus excavatum, mesomelic shortness of the upper and lower limbs, and pretibial dimples. Although this appears to be an example of one of the OFD syndromes and has many similarities to OFD type II, III, IV and VI, it does not fit satisfactorily into any of the types previously described. Thus this may be a new OFD syndrome, although we cannot exclude a possibility that most or all autosomal recessive OFD syndromes are the result of pleiotropy of a single mutation in a homozygous state.

Joubert syndrome: a review

We review 72 previously reported and 29 new patients with the possible diagnosis of Joubert syndrome. We define diagnostic criteria for this syndrome and present the data available in 94 patients that fulfill our criteria. We present the data regarding the clinical, neuroradiological, and ophthalmological manifestations and the prognosis of these 94 patients. We propose a classification of the patients with this diagnosis in 2 groups: those with retinal dystrophy and those without. Retinal dystrophy runs true in families and was never absent when renal cysts were reported.

Autistic features in Joubert syndrome: a genetic disorder with agenesis of the cerebellar vermis

Recent reports in the literature have suggested a link between abnormalities of the cerebellar vermis and the behavioral syndrome of autism. Joubert syndrome is an autosomal recessive disorder characterized by partial or complete agenesis of the cerebellar vermis. However, there is little behavioral or psychiatric description of patients with this genetic condition. In this report, the neuropsychiatric characteristics of two children with Joubert syndrome are described in detail. One child met DSM-III-R diagnostic criteria for autistic disorder, while the other displayed autistic features. The female child displayed stereotypic behavior and impairments in social interaction and communication, had a markedly restricted repertoire of interests, and showed distress over changes in the environment. The male child demonstrated perseveration and preoccupation with sounds and textures, but had no abnormalities in social interaction. Although both children showed developmental disabilities, the degree of cognitive delay was significantly less than that described in previous reports of children with Joubert syndrome. This report adds to the growing body of evidence implicating cerebellar involvement in developmental disabilities and autistic behavior.

CHARGE and Joubert syndromes: are they a single disorder?

A patient with the CHARGE association (Coloboma of the eye, Heart defect, Atresia of the choana, Retarded growth and development, Genital hypoplasia, and Ear anomalies or deafness) had intermittent hyperpnea and cerebellar hypoplasia; therefore, he had both the CHARGE association and Joubert syndrome. The 2 syndromes have not been previously linked. We discuss their similarities and review the literature.

Hidden intelligence of a multiply handicapped child with Joubert syndrome

A child with Joubert syndrome (episodic hyperpnoea, abnormal eye-movements and ataxia) was followed from birth to eight years of age. Although severe mental retardation was suspected until approximately five years of age, unexpected and exceptional mental capacities were evident at later follow-up. Adequate testing and appropriate stimulation of children with such a severe early motor disorder are difficult, so they may give a false impression of mental retardation. The history of this child challenges the notion that mental retardation is part of Joubert syndrome.

Further delineation of a syndrome of cerebellar vermis hypo/aplasia, oligophrenia, congenital ataxia, coloboma, and hepatic fibrosis

Three children are described from two sibships. They share infantile ataxia with hypo/aplastic vermis, hepatic fibrocirrhosis, slender-shaped skeleton, peculiar face, and moderate mental retardation. One of them had a kidney biopsy that showed mild interstitial fibrosis and amyloid deposit, but had no functional impairment. Another suffered moderate proximal tubular acidosis. Two children had unilateral or bilateral choroidal coloboma. This pattern of defects is consistent with a syndrome previously reported in two other sibships. The acronym COACH (Cerebellar vermis hypo/aplasia, Oligophrenia, congenital Ataxia, Coloboma, Hepatic fibrocirrhosis) is suggested.

Joubert syndrome: early diagnosis by recognition of the behavioral phenotype and confirmation by cranial sonography

Our experience with two children with Joubert syndrome demonstrates how the diagnosis, if suspected by recognition of the behavioral phenotype, can rapidly be made by employing cranial sonography. This technique also may afford prenatal diagnosis of the syndrome in future siblings of confirmed cases. We have produced an educational videotape demonstrating the dynamic behavior of these patients. It is our hope that increased familiarity with the behavior phenotype through this report and through distribution of the videotape will lead to early and accurate diagnosis of further cases of this syndrome.

Selected eye defects of special importance in pediatrics

This article reviews six defects of special importance in the care of children: aniridia, ectopia lentis, cataracts, glaucoma, colobomata, and optic nerve hypoplasia. In addition to causing potentially serious impairment of vision, these ocular disorders may be associated with significant systemic disease and genetic abnormalities.