The discovery of immunologic tolerance

Regulatory T cells in dominant immunologic tolerance

Regulatory T cells expressing the transcription factor forkhead box protein 3 mediate peripheral immune tolerance both to self-antigens and to the commensal flora. Their defective function due to inborn errors of immunity or acquired insults is associated with a broad range of autoimmune and immune dysregulatory diseases. Although their function in suppressing autoimmunity and enforcing commensalism is established, a broader role for regulatory T cells in tissue repair and metabolic regulation has emerged, enabled by unique programs of tissue adaptability and specialization. In this review, we focus on the myriad roles played by regulatory T cells in immunologic tolerance and host homeostasis and the potential to harness these cells in novel therapeutic approaches to human diseases.

The Lymphatic Vasculature in the 21st Century: Novel Functional Roles in Homeostasis and Disease

Mammals have two specialized vascular circulatory systems: the blood vasculature and the lymphatic vasculature. The lymphatic vasculature is a unidirectional conduit that returns filtered interstitial arterial fluid and tissue metabolites to the blood circulation. It also plays major roles in immune cell trafficking and lipid absorption. As we discuss in this review, the molecular characterization of lymphatic vascular development and our understanding of this vasculature's role in pathophysiological conditions has greatly improved in recent years, changing conventional views about the roles of the lymphatic vasculature in health and disease. Morphological or functional defects in the lymphatic vasculature have now been uncovered in several pathological conditions. We propose that subtle asymptomatic alterations in lymphatic vascular function could underlie the variability seen in the body's response to a wide range of human diseases.

NK cell subsets in idiopathic recurrent miscarriage and renal transplant patients

The present review article compares NK cell subsets and cytokine patterns determined in the peripheral blood as well as results of functional in-vitro assays using peripheral NK cells of idiopathic recurrent miscarriage (iRM) patients with corresponding results obtained in female healthy controls and female renal transplant recipients with good long-term graft function. Immune mechanisms, inducing transplant rejection in long-term transplant recipients might also be able to induce rejection of semi-allogeneic fetal cells in patients with iRM. Consequently, the immune status of transplant recipients with good stable long-term graft function should be different from the immune status of iRM patients. iRM patients show a strong persistent cytotoxic NK cell response in the periphery. Simultaneously, immunostimulatory Th1 as well as immunosuppressive Th2 type lymphocytes in the blood are strongly activated but plasma levels of immunosuppressive Th2 type cytokines are abnormally low. In-vitro, unstimulated NK cell cultures of iRM patients show a strong spontaneous TGF-ß1 release in the supernatant but lower TGF-ß1 levels after stimulation with tumor cell line K562, suggesting strong consumption of TGF-ß1 by pre-activated NK cells of iRM patients that might contribute to the low systemic Th2 type plasma levels. iRM patients do not show a systemic switch to a Th2 type cytokine pattern and one might hypothesize that low TGF-ß plasma levels indicate low TGF-ß levels in the micromilieu immediately before fetal rejection. Persistent TGF-ß deficiency implies a persistent unfavorable micromilieu for pregnancy resulting in failing tolerance induction due to lack of TGF-ß, a condition that might contribute to iRM.

Mesenchymal stem cells and their immunosuppressive role in transplantation tolerance

Since they were first described, mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) have been shown to have important effector mechanisms and the potential for use in cell therapy. A great deal of research has been focused on unveiling how MSCs contribute to anti-inflammatory responses, including describing several cell populations involved and identifying soluble and other effector molecules. In this review, we discuss some of the contemporary evidence for use of MSCs in the field of immune tolerance, with a special emphasis on transplantation. Although considerable effort has been devoted to understanding the biological function of MSCs, additional resources are required to clarify the mechanisms of their induction of immune tolerance, which will undoubtedly lead to improved clinical outcomes for MSC-based therapies.

Transplantation Tolerance Induction: Cell Therapies and Their Mechanisms

Cell-based therapies have been studied extensively in the context of transplantation tolerance induction. The most successful protocols have relied on transfusion of bone marrow prior to the transplantation of a renal allograft. However, it is not clear that stem cells found in bone marrow are required in order to render a transplant candidate immunologically tolerant. Accordingly, mesenchymal stem cells, regulatory myeloid cells, T regulatory cells, and other cell types are being tested as possible routes to tolerance induction, in the absence of donor-derived stem cells. Early data with each of these cell types have been encouraging. However, the induction regimen capable of achieving consistent tolerance, while avoiding unwanted sided effects, and which is scalable to the human patient, has yet to be identified. Here, we present the status of investigations of various tolerogenic cell types and the mechanistic rationale for their use in tolerance induction protocols.

Peter Brian Medawar and the discovery of acquired immunological tolerance

The immunological tolerance was described for the first time with the seminal observations made in 1945 by R.D. Owen, demonstrating that cattle dizygotic twins display red cell chimerism in adult life. F.M. Burnet and F. Fenner highlighted the Owen's discovery in their monograph "The production of Antibodies" published in 1949. In 1953, P. Medawar and his co-workers showed that tolerance can be experimentally induced in fetal mice and in chick embryos. In 1960, Medawar in recognition of the significance of his 1953 and 1956 papers was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine with Burnet for their discovery of acquired immunologic tolerance.

Regulatory T cells in early life: comparative study of CD4+CD25high T cells from foals and adult horses

The immune system of mammals is subject to continuous development during the postnatal phase of life. Studies following the longitudinal development of the immune system in healthy children are limited both by ethical considerations and sample volumes. Horses represent a particular valuable large animal model for T regulatory (Treg) cells and allergy research. We have recently characterised Treg cells from horses, demonstrated their regulatory capability and showed both their expansion and induction in vitro. Insect bite hypersensitivity (IBH) is a common allergy in horses resembling atopic dermatitis and studies have shown that first exposure to allergens in adult life results in an increased incidence of IBH. The aim of the present study was to characterize circulating CD4⁺CD25^highFoxP3⁺cells in foals, evaluate their suppressive capability and their in vitro induction compared to adult horses. 19 foals (age range, 1–5 months), their adult mothers and six one-year-old horses (yearlings) were included in the study. The proportion of FoxP3⁺ cells within the circulating CD4⁺CD25^high population was significantly higher in foals (47%) compared to their mothers (18%) and to yearlings (26%). Treg cells from foals also displayed a higher suppressive capability. Furthermore, CD4⁺CD25^high cells in foals could be induced in vitro from CD4⁺CD25⁻ cells in a significantly higher proportion compared to mares. These cells also displayed a significantly enhanced suppressive capability. In summary these findings support the notion that exposure of horses to allergens during maturation of the immune system assists the establishment of induced (i)Treg driven tolerance.

Chimerism in transfusion medicine: the grandmother effect revisited

Transfusion therapy is complicated by the production of alloantibodies to antigens present in the donor and lacking in the recipient through the poorly-understood but likely multi-factorial process of alloimmunization. The low prevalence of alloimmunization in transfused patients (6.1%) (1) suggests that processes central to immunologic tolerance may be operating in the vast majority of transfused patients who do not produce alloantibodies. Using RhD as a prototype, evidence is reviewed that the ability to make antibodies to red blood cell (RBC) antigens may result in part from immunologic tolerance acquired in utero. These ideas are extended to other examples of maternal microchimerism (MMc) of other non-inherited maternal antigens (NIMA). An evolutionary argument is offered that multi-generational immunity supports the hypothesis that MMc may partly explain the "non-responder" phenotype in RBC alloimmunization.

Immunological tolerance during fetal development: from mouse to man

The development of the adaptive immune system has been studied in the mouse primarily because it is easier to access fetal tissues and because there exists a rich array of probes for analysis of various components of the immune system. While much has been learned from this exercise, it is also clear that different species show substantial temporal variation in the development of the immune system during early life. In mice, for instance, mature α/β T cells first appear in the periphery during the final stages of fetal gestation and only increase in number after birth (Friedberg and Weissman, 1974); in humans, on the other hand, the first mature α/β T cells are seen in peripheral tissues at 10-12 gestational weeks (g.w.) and are circulating in significant numbers by the end of the second trimester (Ceppellini et al., 1971; Haynes et al., 1988; Hayward and Ezer, 1974; Kay et al., 1970). Although the functional implications of these differences remain unclear, it is likely that there are significant biological consequences associated with the relatively early development of the peripheral adaptive immune system in humans, for example, with respect to the development of peripheral tolerance as well as to the response to antigens that might cross the placenta from the mother (e.g., cells bearing noninherited maternal alloantigens, infectious agents, food antigens, and the like). Here, we will review studies of immune system ontogeny in the mouse and in humans, and then focus on the possible functional roles of fetal T cell populations during development and later in life in humans.

Impact of fetal-maternal microchimerism on women's health--a review

Microchimerism is defined by the presence of circulating cells, bi-directionally transferred from one genetically distinct individual to another. It occurs either physiologically during pregnancy, or iatrogenically after blood transfusion and organ transplants. The migrated cells may persist for decades. Much controversy exists around the role of microchimeric cells in the pathogenesis of various diseases and around their role in tissue repair. Microchimerism has been investigated in different autoimmune disorders, such as systemic sclerosis, systemic lupus erythematosus, autoimmune thyroid diseases, primary biliary cirrhosis and juvenile inflammatory myopathies. Recent data have demonstrated the promising role of microchimeric cells in the maternal response to tissue injuries by differentiating into many lineages. Therefore, further understanding of fetal-maternal microchimerism may help in anticipating its implications in disease as well as in more general women's health issues.

Modeling CTLA4-linked autoimmunity with RNA interference in mice

The CTLA4 gene is important for T lymphocyte-mediated immunoregulation and has been associated with several autoimmune diseases, in particular, type 1 diabetes. To model the impact of natural genetic variants of CTLA4, we constructed RNA interference (RNAi) "knockdown" mice through lentiviral transgenesis. Variegation of expression was observed in founders but proved surmountable because it reflected parental imprinting, with derepression by transmission from male lentigenics. Unlike the indiscriminate multiorgan autoimmune phenotype of the corresponding knockout mice, Ctla4 knockdown animals had a disease primarily focused on the pancreas, with rapid progression to diabetes. As with the human disease, the knockdown phenotype was tempered by genetic-modifier loci. RNAi should be more pertinent than gene ablation in modeling disease pathogenesis linked to a gene-dosage variation.

Loss of autoimmune T cells correlates with brain diseases: possible implications for schizophrenia?

T-cell-mediated autoimmunity participates in physiological defense, maintenance and repair of the adult brain. However, unless such autoimmune responses to insults are rigorously controlled, they might lead to an autoimmune disease or other immune-related defects, where destructive activity outweighs the beneficial effect. Here, we discuss these apparently contradictory effects of autoimmunity in schizophrenic patients, whose typical immune aberrations have prompted recent speculation about an autoimmune-related etiology. We found that, although schizophrenic patients have active immune systems, they often lack autoimmune clones specifically reactive to a major myelin protein, myelin basic protein (MBP). This, in conjunction with our discovery in rodents that T cells that recognize brain-resident proteins are needed for normal cognitive functioning, led us to propose an immune-based neurodevelopmental hypothesis, in which autoimmune-T-cell deficiency is suggested to cause onset or progression of schizophrenia.

Tolerance, suppression and the fetal allograft

In solid organ transplantation the recipient immune system recognises foreign alloantigens expressed by the graft. This results in an immune attack of the transplanted organ leading to rejection, which can be prevented only by therapeutic immunosuppression. During pregnancy the fetus should also be rejected by the maternal immune system, since it expresses antigens derived from the father. Whilst the immune system retains the ability to respond to foreign antigen, tolerance mechanisms ensure that inappropriate responses against self-antigen are prevented. Maternal immune aggression directed against the fetus is partly inhibited by peripheral tolerance mechanisms that act locally to deplete cells capable of attacking the fetus. Other local mechanisms inhibit the pathways that cause tissue damage after immune activation. Recent studies in mice and humans indicate that the maternal immune system undergoes a more systemic change that promotes materno-fetal tolerance. Naturally occurring regulatory T cells, which are commonly associated with maintaining tolerance to self-antigens, can also suppress maternal allo-responses targeted against the fetus. We review the mechanisms that mediate materno-fetal tolerance, with particular emphasis on changes in regulatory T cell function during pregnancy and discuss their implications.

Using Signaling Pathways to Overcome Immune Tolerance to Tumors

The ability of tumors to evade the immune system is thought to result from the inability of T lymphocytes to recognize and respond to tumor antigens. This lack of T cell response may depend on a failure of dendritic cells to present antigen in the proper context so that T cells become tolerant to tumor antigens rather than primed to undergo an immune response. The inability of tumor-associated dendritic cells to effectively present antigen may in turn depend on inhibitory factors in the tumor milieu. Recent experiments suggest that the administration of toll-like receptor ligands stimulate dendritic cell activation and maturation and may thus help overcome T cell tolerance to tumor antigens. Whether or not such an approach is clinically feasible remains to be seen.

Establishment of a sequence-based typing system for BoLA-DRB3 exon 2

A rapid, high-resolution sequence-based typing (SBT) system for BoLA-DRB3 exon 2 was developed. Amplification of the entire exon was achieved by a fully nested PCR with locus-specific primers and sequencing was performed directly on the PCR product. Heterozygous sequence data were obtained by automated sequence analysis of both alleles. Forward and reverse sequence data were assembled to improve identification of all heterozygous positions. Specific software (Haplofinder, Roslin Institute Software, Roslin, UK) was designed for allele assignment. Fifty-four females from a Holstein-Charolais resource herd cross, their 12 sires and five unrelated Holstein animals were used to establish the method. In parallel, these animals were typed by DRB3 polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP) to confirm the results. Polymerase chain reaction-RFLP analysis defined 15 known types in the 71 animals, while SBT of the same animals showed 19 known alleles. Subsequently, 72 more animals from the same resource herd were typed by the established SBT method without PCR-RFLP typing. This SBT strategy and the Haplofinder software can be applied to the analysis of any polymorphic locus for which suitable locus-specific primers and allelic sequences are available.

Extrathymic deletion of CD8+ alloreactive T cells in a transgenic T cell receptor model of neonatal tolerance

BACKGROUND

Immunological tolerance to foreign antigen is most easily achieved during the neonatal period. Although deletion of T cells has been demonstrated in neonatal tolerance models in which donor and recipient express different MHC class II molecules, the requirement for deletion in MHC class I-disparate models is less clear. To address this issue, we used as recipient the T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic mouse (TgM) strain 2C in which the majority of CD8+ T cells express a single alpha/beta TCR alloreactive to H-2Ld, thus facilitating direct monitoring of the class I alloreactive population.

METHODS

Newborn (less than 24 hr of age) 2C TgM received injections i.v.with syngeneic C57BL/6J (H-2b) (B6) or semiallogeneic (B6xDBA)F1 (H-2bd; H-2Ld+) splenocytes. Adults were subsequently analyzed in terms of tolerance, deletion of 2C+ T cells, and chimerism.

RESULTS

The results showed that semiallogeneic-, but not syngeneic-, injected neonates were unresponsive as adults to H-2Ld-expressing target cells in vitro and the majority of these mice accepted H-2Ld+ skin grafts. Delaying the injection to 72 hr after birth or reducing the number of cells injected essentially abolished in vivo unresponsiveness in 2C recipients. Thus, the 2C TCR Tg model demonstrates the characteristics typical of neonatal tolerance. Injection of 2C neonates within 24 hr of birth with semiallogeneic versus syngeneic cells led to more than a 12-fold reduction of CD8+ 2C+ T cells in adult spleen and LNCs. In contrast, deletion of CD8+ 2C+ cells in adult thymus was not consistently observed. Based on MHC class II expression to distinguish donor (I-E+) and recipient (I-E-) cells, semiallogeneic-injected mice were chimeric in spleens and lymph nodes (LNs).

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate that neonatal MHC class I tolerance in the adult is associated with low level hematopoietic chimerism and extrathymic deletion of alloreactive CD8+ T cells.

The human hair follicle immune system: cellular composition and immune privilege

The immunology of the hair follicle, its relationship with the 'skin immune system' and its role in hair diseases remain biologically intriguing and clinically important. In this study, we analysed the immunoreactivity patterns of 15 immunodermatological markers to determine the cellular composition and immune privilege of the human hair follicle immune system in anagen VI (growth phase). The most prominent cells located in or around the hair follicle were Langerhans cells, CD4+ or CD8+ T cells, macrophages and mast cells, whereas B cells, natural killer cells and gammadelta T cells were found very rarely. Langerhans cells (CD1a+, major histocompatibility complex, MHC class II+), and T cells (CD4+ or CD8+) were predominantly distributed in the distal hair follicle epithelium, whereas macrophages (CD68+, MHC class II+) and mast cells (Giemsa+) were located in the perifollicular connective tissue sheath. Transmission electron microscopy confirmed low numbers of immune cells in the proximal hair follicle epithelium, and very few macrophages and Langerhans cells were seen in the dermal papilla. Melanophages were observed in the connective tissue sheath and dermal papilla. MHC class I (HLA-A, -B, -C) and beta2-microglobulin immunoreactivity was found on most skin cells, but was substantially reduced on isthmus keratinocytes and virtually absent in the proximal hair follicle epithelium. Apart from the absence of Fas ligand immunoreactivity, the sharply reduced numbers of T cells and Langerhans cells, and the virtual absence of MHC class I expression all suggest that the anagen proximal hair follicle constitutes an area of immune privilege within the hair follicle immune system, whose collapse may be crucial for the pathogenesis of alopecia areata.

Immunological importance of chimerism in transplantation: new conditioning protocol in BMT and the development of chimeric state

Chimerism is an exceptional immunogenetic state, characterized by the survival and collaboration of cell populations originated from two different individuals. The prerequisits to induce chimerism are immuno-suppression, myeloablation, or severe immunodeficiency of the recipients on the one side and donor originated immuno-hematopoietic cells in the graft on the other. The pathologic or special immunogenetic conditions to establish chimerism are combined with bone marrow transplantation, transfusion, and various kinds of solid organ grafting. Different types of chimerism are known including complete, mixed and mosaic, or split chimerism. There are various methods used to detect the type of chimera state, depending on the immunogenetic differences between the donor and recipient. The induction of complete or mixed chimerism is first determinated by the effect of myeloablative therapy. The chimera state seems to be one of the leading factors to influence the course of the post-transplant period, the frequency and severity of GVHD, and the rate of relapse. However, the most important contribution of the chimeric state is in development of graft versus leukemia effect. A new conditioning protocol (DBM/Ara-C/Cy) for allogeneic BMT in CML patients and its consequence on chimera state and GVL effect is demonstrated.

The human uniqueness of HIV: innate immunity and the viral Tat protein

We have previously reported, and confirm here, that the human innate system of natural antibodies includes two, each of which is reactive, presumably by happenstance, with a specific sequence of HIV Tat protein. Comparison of cohorts of HIV+ and normal (HIV-) sera indicate that, following a period of post-infection latency, the titers of those natural antibodies decline and other Tat reactive antibodies, as evidence of induced immune response, do not arise. That human-typical pattern of innate/adaptive reactivity with HIV Tat protein is shared by chimpanzees, but not by other mammals tested in this study, in which those natural antibodies are not present, and apparently induced Tat-reactive antibodies do arise. Evidence of a temporal relationship between the decline of the Tat reactive natural antibodies and progression of HIV pathogenesis, including demise of CD4+T cells, suggests a role for those antibodies in retardation of that pathoprogression. However, that providential arrest of Tat-related pathogenicity may be limited by the immune system recognition of the natural antibody-reactive sequences of Tat as "self" with consequent induction of tolerance and restriction of production of those antibodies. The limited occurrence of progression to AIDS in chimpanzees may reflect an additional innate characteristic, one of resistance to tolerance-based diminishment of the protective natural antibodies. Although not yet defined, that characteristic may be shared by the occasionally observed HIV+ humans known as LTNP (longterm-non-progressors).