Acute vascular rejection is associated with systemic complement activation in a pig-to-primate kidney xenograft model

Xenogeneic cross-circulation for extracorporeal recovery of injured human lungs

Patients awaiting lung transplantation face high wait-list mortality, as injury precludes the use of most donor lungs. Although ex vivo lung perfusion (EVLP) is able to recover marginal quality donor lungs, extension of normothermic support beyond 6 h has been challenging. Here we demonstrate that acutely injured human lungs declined for transplantation, including a lung that failed to recover on EVLP, can be recovered by cross-circulation of whole blood between explanted human lungs and a Yorkshire swine. This xenogeneic platform provided explanted human lungs a supportive, physiologic milieu and systemic regulation that resulted in functional and histological recovery after 24 h of normothermic support. Our findings suggest that cross-circulation can serve as a complementary approach to clinical EVLP to recover injured donor lungs that could not otherwise be utilized for transplantation, as well as a translational research platform for immunomodulation and advanced organ bioengineering.

GGTA1/iGb3S Double Knockout Mice: Immunological Properties and Immunogenicity Response to Xenogeneic Bone Matrix

Background

Animal tissues and tissue-derived biomaterials are widely used in the field of xenotransplantation and regenerative medicine. A potential immunogenic risk that affects the safety and effectiveness of xenografts is the presence of remnant α-Gal antigen (synthesized by GGTA1 or/and iGb3S). GGTA1 knockout mice have been developed as a suitable model for the analysis of anti-Gal antibody-mediated immunogenicity. However, we are yet to establish whether GGTA1/iGb3S double knockout (G/i DKO) mice are sensitive to Gal antigen-positive xenoimplants.

Methods

α-Gal antigen expression in the main organs of G/i DKO mice or bovine bone substitutes was detected via a standardized ELISA inhibition assay. Serum anti-α-Gal antibody titers of G/i DKO mice after immunization with rabbit red blood cells (RRBC) and implantation of raw lyophilized bone substitutes (Gal antigen content was 8.14 ± 3.17 × 10¹²/mg) or Guanhao Biotech bone substitutes (50% decrease in Gal antigen relative to the raw material) were assessed. The evaluation of total serum antibody, inflammatory cytokine, and splenic lymphocyte subtype populations and the histological analysis of implants and thymus were performed to systematically assess the immune response caused by bovine bone substitutes and bone substitute grafts in G/i DKO mice.

Results

α-Gal epitope expression was reduced by 100% in the main organs of G/i DKO mice, compared with their wild-type counterparts. Following immunization with RRBC, serum anti-Gal antibody titers of G/i DKO mice increased from 80- to 180-fold. After subcutaneous implantation of raw lyophilized bone substitutes and Guanhao Biotech bone substitutes into G/i DKO mice, specific anti-α-Gal IgG, anti-α-Gal IgM, and related inflammatory factors (IFN-γ and IL-6) were significantly increased in the raw lyophilized bone substitute group but showed limited changes in the Guanhao Biotech bone substitute group, compared with the control.

Conclusion

G/i DKO mice are sensitive to Gal antigen-positive xenogeneic grafts and can be effectively utilized for evaluating the α-Gal-mediated immunogenic risk of xenogeneic grafts.

Viable pigs after simultaneous inactivation of porcine MHC class I and three xenoreactive antigen genes GGTA1, CMAH and B4GALNT2

BACKGROUND

Cell surface carbohydrate antigens play a major role in the rejection of porcine xenografts. The most important for human recipients are α-1,3 Gal (Galactose-alpha-1,3-galactose) causing hyperacute rejection, also Neu5Gc (N-glycolylneuraminic acid) and Sd(a) blood group antigens both of which are likely to elicit acute vascular rejection given the known human immune status. Porcine cells with knockouts of the three genes responsible, GGTA1, CMAH and B4GALNT2, revealed minimal xenoreactive antibody binding after incubation with human serum. However, human leucocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies cross-reacted with swine leucocyte antigen class I (SLA-I). We previously demonstrated efficient generation of pigs with multiple xeno-transgenes placed at a single genomic locus. Here we wished to assess whether key xenoreactive antigen genes can be simultaneously inactivated and if combination with the multi-transgenic background further reduces antibody deposition and complement activation.

METHODS

Multiplex CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing and somatic cell nuclear transfer were used to generate pigs carrying functional knockouts of GGTA1, CMAH, B4GALNT2 and SLA class I. Fibroblasts derived from one- to four-fold knockout animals, and from multi-transgenic cells (human CD46, CD55, CD59, HO1 and A20) with the four-fold knockout were used to examine the effects on human IgG and IgM binding or complement activation in vitro.

RESULTS

Pigs were generated carrying four-fold knockouts of important xenoreactive genes. In vitro assays revealed that combination of all four gene knockouts reduced human IgG and IgM binding to porcine kidney cells more effectively than single or double knockouts. The multi-transgenic background combined with GGTA1 knockout alone reduced C3b/c and C4b/c complement activation to such an extent that further knockouts had no significant additional effect.

CONCLUSION

We showed that pigs carrying several xenoprotective transgenes and knockouts of xenoreactive antigens can be readily generated and these modifications will have significant effects on xenograft survival.

A Novel Model of Mouse-to-Rat Kidney Xenotransplantation

Transplantation animal models require 2 animals for each experiment, 1 as a donor and 1 as a recipient. At the present time, developing microsurgical instruments and refining surgical techniques should allow us to reduce the number of animal used for transplantation research. In this study, we aimed to harvest 2 kidneys from 1 donor to be able to minimize the number of animals needed for transplantation studies. For this purpose, we developed a kidney xenotransplantation model from mouse to rat, in which only 1 animal was used as the donor for 2 kidney recipients. Ten male Balb/c mice weighing from 25 to 30 g were used as donors, and 20 male Sprague-Dawley rats weighing from 150 to 200 g were used as recipients. In this study, the harvesting of 2 kidneys from a mouse as well as the recipient operation were described with technical detail. Although harvesting 2 kidneys from a mouse and mouse-to-rat kidney xenotransplantation is a highly challenging microsurgical procedure, we believe that every experienced surgeon should be capable of performing this surgery with some practice. This model allows us to reduce the number of animals in transplantation studies without compromising the graft quality. We strongly recommend our refined harvesting technique to researchers, particularly in terms of animal rights.

Oxidative Stress in Renal Transplant Patients Who Develop Cardiovascular Disease

Cardiovascular disease limits life expectancy of successful renal transplant patients. Reactive oxygen species have been implicated in the development of atherosclerosis, and high levels could be due to increased production or a decrease in antioxidant reserve. Cardiovascular disease in renal transplant recipients could be due to elevated levels of malondialdehyde (an index of levels of reactive oxygen species) and homocysteine and reduced levels of glutathione. Renal transplant recipients with and without cardiovascular disease were studied along with healthy controls. Serum malondialdehyde, plasma homocysteine, and red blood cell glutathione were measured. The results suggest that levels of serum malondialdehyde and plasma homocysteine were higher in patients with or without cardiovascular disease compared with controls; however, the values were similar in both groups of transplant patients. Glutathione levels in red blood cells were similar in all 3 groups. Renal transplant recipients without cardiovascular disease have high levels of oxidative stress and may develop cardiovascular disease with time.

Progress in pig-to-non-human primate transplantation models (1998-2013): a comprehensive review of the literature

BACKGROUND

The pig-to-non-human primate model is the standard choice for in vivo studies of organ and cell xenotransplantation. In 1998, Lambrigts and his colleagues surveyed the entire world literature and reported all experimental studies in this model. With the increasing number of genetically engineered pigs that have become available during the past few years, this model is being utilized ever more frequently.

METHODS

We have now reviewed the literature again and have compiled the data we have been able to find for the period January 1, 1998 to December 31, 2013, a period of 16 yr.

RESULTS

The data are presented for transplants of the heart (heterotopic and orthotopic), kidney, liver, lung, islets, neuronal cells, hepatocytes, corneas, artery patches, and skin. Heart, kidney, and, particularly, islet xenograft survival have increased significantly since 1998.

DISCUSSION

The reasons for this are briefly discussed. A comment on the limitations of the model has been made, particularly with regard to those that will affect progression of xenotransplantation toward the clinic.

Assessment of in vitro heparin complement regulation capacity during real-time cell analyzer antibody-mediated cytolysis assay: compatibility studies for pig-to-baboon xenotransplantation

OBJECTIVE

To assess the effect of sodium heparin concentrations on antibody- and complement-mediated cytolysis by means of a real-time cell analyzer system (RTCA) investigating the complement regulation ability of heparin to reduce or prevent hyperacute in an in vitro model of pig-to-baboon xenotransplantation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fibroblasts isolated from the skin of two transgenic pigs were cultured in microelectronic 96-well plates for 9 hours. Then, we added 20 μL of normal sera from two healthy adult olive baboons (Papio anubis) or two volunteer healthy humans. Simultaneous cultures had added heparin at 3.5, 5, 7.5, 15, and 30 IU. Moreover, rabbit complement was added for the exogenous complement group (ExC) versus the other group only with the complement present in the sera as an endogenous complement group (EnC). Cellular cultures were monitored over 150 hours after challenge. With cellular index (CI) data recorded by the xCELLigence software system, we calculate area under the curve versus concentration (AUC) and minimum CI (CImin) versus concentration.

RESULTS

All cultures showed decreased CI after challenge with human or baboon sera. There was a high correlation for AUC (r(2) > 0.90) and CImin versus concentration (r(2) > 0.970) during the first 40 hours postchallenge among the EnC group, regardless of human or baboon sera. However, there was no correlation for AUC and CImin for the ExC group. There was a reduction of CImin related to increased heparin concentrations.

CONCLUSIONS

The addition of heparin did not reduce antibody- and complement-mediated cytolysis assessed in vitro by RTCA in pig-to-baboon compatibility assays.

Humoral immunity and antibody-mediated rejection in solid organ transplantation

The humoral arm of the immune system provides robust protection against extracellular pathogens via the production of antibody molecules that neutralize or facilitate the destruction of microorganisms. However, the humoral immune system also provides a significant barrier to solid organ transplantation due to the antibody-mediated recognition of non-self proteins and carbohydrates expressed on transplanted organs. Historically, the presence of donor-specific antibodies (DSA) that recognize donor HLA molecules, incompatible ABO blood group antigens and other endothelial or xenogeneic antigens was considered a contraindication to transplantation. However, recent advances in antibody testing and immunosuppressive therapies have made it possible to cross certain antibody barriers successfully. In this article, we review our current understanding of antibody-mediated processes in solid organ transplantation and discuss the clinically available treatment options for preventing and treating antibody-mediated rejection.

Pig to canine auxiliary hepatic xenotransplantation model: prevention of hyperacute rejection via Kupffer cell blockade and complement regulation

OBJECTIVES

Large animal experiment models are a critical prerequisite to preclinical trials. However, the pig-to-primate model is expensive and proper experimental conditions are difficult to establish. Several pig-to-canine lung xenotransplantation experiments have shown hyperacute rejection. Therefore, we designed a pig-to-canine liver xenotransplantation model to study the diverse immunologic and hemodynamic consequences after xenotransplantation and hyperacute rejection.

METHODS

Animals were divided into two groups of 3 each: a cobra venom factor plus gadolinium trichloride (GdCl(3)) treatment group (CVF+Gd group) and a control group. Whole livers from 15-kg donor pigs were harvested and perfused with histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution. Seventy percent of the left lobe of the livers of 17-kg recipient dogs was resected. The harvested pig whole liver was transplanted using the canine left hepatic vein, left portal vein, and common hepatic artery. After graft reperfusion, blood samples and aliquots of liver, lung, and kidney tissues were obtained at 1 hour after reperfusion.

RESULTS

We successfully completed 6 pig-to-canine auxiliary hepatic xenotransplantations. In the control group, the grafts showed a patchy hypoperfused liver surface that was rubbery solid compared with the CVF+Gd group. Serum total protein, albumin, fibrinogen, and platelet counts decreased abruptly; however, there were no significant differences between the two groups. There were no identifiable changes in blood urea nitrogen and creatinine concentrations. Serum prothrombin time, partial thromboplastin time, and further degradation product were increased in both groups; however, in the CVF+Gd group, the slope was more obtuse than in the control group. At microscopy, the graft at 20, 40, and 60 minutes after reperfusion, no intravascular pathologic changes were noted. Only scant intravascular fibrin deposition was observed. Hepatocellular vacuolization and sinusoidal dilatation were seen. There was patch necrosis without a zonal distribution, and intrasinusoidal neutrophil sequestration and interstitial hemorrhage. These findings were milder in the CVF+Gd group.

CONCLUSION

A pig-to-canine partial auxiliary liver xenotransplantation model is feasible. In the CVF+Gd treatment group, pathologic findings of patch hepatocyte necrosis were less severe. Inasmuch there was no corresponding vascular pathologic finding, these abnormalities are not a direct effect of CVF+Gd treatment. Other factors such as ischemia-reperfusion injury should be considered.

Xenotransplantation: role of natural immunity

Hyperacute rejection, mediated by natural anti-Galalpha1,3Galbeta1,4GlcNAc (alphaGal) antibodies and the classically activated complement pathway, was identified as the first major barrier to the survival of porcine organs in humans. Subsequently, discordant pig-to-nonhuman primate and concordant rodent models revealed key roles for T and B lymphocytes in the second form of rejection, acute vascular rejection (AVR) or delayed xenograft rejection (DXR). As significant progress was made in strategies to circumvent or suppress xenoreactivity of the adaptive immune system, it became clear that, apart from natural antibodies, other innate immune system elements actively participate in AVR/DXR and represent a barrier to xenograft acceptance that may be particularly difficult to overcome. Observations in pig-to-primate and semi-discordant and concordant rodent models indicate that Natural Killer (NK) cells play a more prominent role in xenograft than in allograft rejection. Several mechanisms through which human NK cells recognize porcine endothelial cells have been elucidated and these appear to be more diverse than those involved in NK cell alloreactivity. Further, it has been demonstrated that human macrophages and neutrophils can directly recognize pig derived cells and can mediate direct xenograft damage. Here, we review the recent progress in the understanding of the xenoreactivity of the natural immune system, focussing on preclinical pig-to-(non)human primate systems, and discuss the proposed strategies to overcome these barriers.

Application of cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance in alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase knockout mice presensitized with Gal alpha 1-3Gal beta-4-GlcNAc antigens

PURPOSE

Hyperacute rejection (HAR) mediated by the natural antibody (nAb) against Gal alpha 1-3Gal beta-4-GlcNAc (alpha Gal) is the major obstacle in xenogeneic organ transplantation. Previously, we reported the acceptance of donor heart grafts in anti-alpha Gal nAb-producing galactosyltransferase knockout (GalT KO) mice after cyclophosphamide (CP)-induced tolerance conditioning. In the present study, we applied our tolerance induction conditioning in presensitized recipient mice.

METHODS

GalT KO (alpha Gal(-/-), H-2(b/d)) recipient mice were presensitized with alpha Gal(+) rabbit red blood cells (RRBCs). Presensitized or nonsensitized recipient mice were treated with CP-induced tolerance conditioning, consisting of AKR (alpha Gal(+/+), H-2(k)) spleen cells (SC), CP, busulfan (BU), and AKR bone marrow cells (BMC). We assessed the survival of donor hearts and skin grafts and analyzed the production of anti-alpha Gal Abs by flow cytometry.

RESULTS

Donor mixed chimerism was achieved in the presensitized GalT KO mice treated with CP-induced tolerance conditioning. In parallel with the disappearance of anti-alpha Gal Abs, permanent acceptance of donor heart grafts and skin grafts was observed in presensitized and GalT KO mice treated with CP-induced tolerance conditioning.

CONCLUSIONS

Both B-cell and T-cell tolerance was achieved in the presence of a higher titer of anti-alpha Gal Abs after treatment with CP-induced tolerance conditioning.

Human complement-activating immunoglobulin (Ig)G3 antibodies are essential for porcine endothelial cell activation

BACKGROUND

Complement-activating naturally occurring anti-porcine endothelial cell antibodies (Abs) are responsible for hyperacute rejection in porcine-to-primate transplantation, whereas the role of complement in acute vascular rejection, characterized by type II endothelial cell activation, is less well understood. We previously demonstrated a correlation between porcine type II endothelial cell activation, as detected by E-selectin expression, and human immunoglobulin (Ig)G3 anti-Gal alpha1-3Gal (Gal) Abs, which was not seen for IgG1, IgG2 or IgG4. The present study was undertaken to investigate whether there is a causal relationship between human anti-porcine IgG3 Abs and porcine endothelial cell activation.

METHODS

IgG3 was isolated employing a Protein A column to 98.3% purity. Porcine endothelial cells were incubated with isolated human IgG3 or the combination of IgG1, IgG2 and IgG4. E-selectin expression and complement activation were investigated by flow cytometry and Western blotting, respectively.

RESULTS

Purified IgG3, in contrast to the other IgG subclasses, induced a substantial increase in E-selectin expression. This activation was accompanied by complement activation as detected by C3 cleavage, and was abolished by heat inactivation or by adding the complement inhibitor FUT-175. Depletion of anti-Gal Abs reduced E-selectin expression by 60%, consistent with the presence of complement-activating anti-porcine non-Gal Abs of the IgG3 subclass.

CONCLUSIONS

Collectively, these data strengthen the hypothesis that human anti-porcine endothelial cell Abs of the IgG3 subclass are essential for endothelial cell activation in porcine-to-human species grafts and demonstrate such activation to be partly independent of Gal epitopes.

Human DAF on pig cells protects against human and non-human primate sera cytotoxicity mediated by exogenous or endogenous complement, as determined by flow cytometry

Expression of human complement regulatory proteins (CRP) in pig cells through transgenesis was proposed to prevent complement activation and the ensuing rejection of pig tissues and organs following pig-to-primate transplantation. Transplantation in non-human primates of organs from transgenic pigs for human decay accelerating factor (hDAF) did not undergo hyperacute rejection, but hDAF could not prevent humoral xenograft rejection (AHXR). A possible explanation for the lack of efficacy of the expression of human complement regulatory proteins in pig cells to prevent AHXR may be interspecies differences between human and non-human complement regulatory system. We assayed the efficacy of transgenic hDAF expressed on porcine cells to inhibit the in vitro complement activity of primate sera. The individual cytotoxicity of sera from seven untreated baboons and of pools of normal human and baboon sera was assayed with endogenous and exogenous complement using a flow-cytometry complement-mediated cytotoxicity assay (FCCA) against peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) from hDAF and non-transgenic pigs. We also analyzed the anti-Galalpha1-3Gal (alphaGal) antibody titre of the baboon sera by ELISA and the expression of hDAF on the PBL surface by immunofluorescence. Transgenic hDAF expression was capable of protecting pig cells against injury produced by both baboon and human serum. Cellular expression of hDAF reduced cytotoxicity mediated by endogenous and exogenous complement, although the former was slightly higher. Humoral cytotoxicity was not related to a particular antibody but was inversely related to hDAF expression. The presence of hDAF protected pig cells against lysis by NHS more effectively than against NBS. These results confirm in vitro the protective role of hDAF in pig cells to heterologous complement mediated damage, but they also suggest that the extent of hDAF protection decreases, however, if cells express low levels of hDAF.

Sequential analysis of anti-alpha Gal natural antibody-producing B cells in GalT knockout mice in cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance

Previously, we have shown that cyclophosphamide (CP)-induced tolerance, marked by permanent acceptance of donor skin graft and establishment of donor mixed chimerism, was readily induced with treatment with donor spleen cells (SC), CP, busulfan (BU) and donor bone marrow cells (BMC). Here, we investigated the mechanism of anti-donor natural antibody (nAb) producing B-cell tolerance in our CP-induced tolerance systems in alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase-deficient knockout mice (GalT KO; GalT-/-, H-2(b/d)). After induction of tolerance using donor AKR SC and BMC, survival of donor heart and skin grafts and production of anti-Galalpha1-3Galbeta1-4GlcNAc (anti-alphaGal) Ab in recipient GalT KO mice were analyzed. In addition, the production of anti-alphaGal Ab and the presence of Gal-BSA binding B cells in GalT KO mice were analyzed by flow cytometry (FCM) after treatments with rabbit red blood cells (RRBC) and CP. Permanent acceptance of donor skin and heart grafts and abrogation of anti-alphaGal Ab were achieved in GalT KO mice treated with donor SC + CP/BU + BMC. However, in the GalT KO mice treated with donor SC and CP, donor skin grafts were acutely rejected, even though anti-alphaGal Ab was undetectable. Similarly, anti-alphaGal Ab was undetectable in GalT KO mice treated with RRBC and CP. Our data strongly indicated the following mechanisms: the clonal destruction in the early stage and the clonal anergy or ignorance in the late stage after conventional conditioning with RRBC and CP. In conclusion, our drug-induced tolerance protocols are effective to induce tolerance in recipients that produce anti-donor nAb.

Effects of Long-term Administration of High-dose Recombinant Human Antithrombin in Immunosuppressed Primate Recipients of Porcine Xenografts

BACKGROUND

Fibrin deposition is central to the acute humoral rejection process occurring in the presence of consumptive coagulopathy when pig organs are transplanted into primates.

METHODS

To assess whether strategies aimed at preventing fibrin formation may extend xenograft survival, we administered high daily doses of recombinant human antithrombin (rhAT) (500 U/kg twice daily) to obtain both anticoagulant and anti-inflammatory effects in immunosuppressed primate recipients of porcine kidneys.

RESULTS

Some degree of consumptive coagulopathy developed in both rhAT-treated (n=3) and untreated (n=3) primates. No major differences in the coagulation parameters analyzed were observed between the 2 groups. Similarly, no difference in survival was seen between rhAT-treated (20.6+/-4 days; range: 15-23 days) and untreated animals (17.3+/-11.6 days; range: 7-30 days), although the rhAT-treated primates had a higher bleeding tendency. Despite the high daily dose of rhAT, considerable fibrin deposition was observed in the graft as early as 2 weeks after transplantation.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that a high daily dose of rhAT fails to influence survival or prevent fibrin formation and deposition in the graft in our pig-to-primate model. However, the potential role of rhAT administered in combination with heparins or other clotting inhibitor concentrates in this model remains to be determined.

Terminal complement complex in septic shock with capillary leakage: marker of complement activation?

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the value of terminal complement complex (C5b-9) plasma levels as a marker for complement activation in septic shock with concomitant capillary leak syndrome.

METHODS

In a prospective animal study 10 fasted, anaesthetized, mechanically ventilated and multi-catheterized pigs (20.6 +/- 1.3 kg) were investigated over a period of 8 h. Sepsis was induced by faecal peritonitis (1 g kg(-1) body weight faeces, n = 5) and compared to controls (n = 5). The animals received 6% hydroxyethyl starch 200/0.5 to maintain a central venous pressure of 12 mmHg. To quantify capillary leak syndrome, albumin escape rate was measured using 99mTc-labelled human serum albumin. Plasma levels of terminal complement complex were measured in a double antibody immunoassay (neoepitope-specific MoAb aE 11 as catching antibody). Immunohistological studies of renal specimens were performed to detect terminal complement complex deposition.

RESULTS

Albumen escape rate increased in septic animals (+ 52%) compared to controls (+ 3%, P < 0.05). Plasma levels of terminal complement complex decreased during the study period in both groups. In septic animals this finding was accompanied by a significant deposition of terminal complement complex in renal specimens (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

We found an activation of the complement system proven by marked deposition of terminal complement complex in renal specimen, while its plasma levels decreased during the study period in septic and control animals. These results suggest that in septic shock with capillary leak syndrome plasma level of terminal complement complex may not be a reliable marker of complement activation.

Monocyte adhesion to xenogeneic endothelium during laminar flow is dependent on alpha-Gal-mediated monocyte activation

Monocytes are the predominant inflammatory cell recruited to xenografts and participate in delayed xenograft rejection. In contrast to allogeneic leukocytes that require up-regulation of endothelial adhesion molecules to adhere and emigrate into effector tissues, we demonstrate that human monocytes adhere rapidly to unstimulated xenogeneic endothelial cells. The major xenoantigen galactosealpha(1,3)galactosebeta(1,4)GlcNAc-R (alpha-gal) is abundantly expressed on xenogeneic endothelium. We have identified a putative receptor for alpha-gal on human monocytes that is a member of the C-type family of lectin receptors. Monocyte arrest under physiological flow conditions is regulated by alpha-gal, because cleavage or blockade results in a dramatic reduction in monocyte adhesion. Recruitment of human monocytes to unactivated xenogeneic endothelial cells requires both alpha(4) and beta(2) integrins on the monocyte; binding of alpha-gal to monocytes results in rapid activation of beta(2), but not alpha(4), integrins. Thus, activation of monocyte beta(2) integrins by alpha-gal expressed on xenogeneic endothelium provides a mechanism that may explain the dramatic accumulation of monocytes in vivo.

Analysis of pig-to-human porcine endogenous retrovirus transmission in a triple-species kidney xenotransplantation model

Clinical pig-to-human xenotransplantation might be associated with the risk of transmission of xenozoonoses, especially porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERVs). We have established a pig-to-humanised-cynomolgus monkey xenotransplantation model allowing the analysis of potential PERV-transmission from normal or transgenic porcine organs to human vascular tissue. Pig-to-human kidney xenotransplantation was performed in cynomolgus monkeys. An interposition graft constructed from a human saphena vein replaced the porcine kidney vein. After graft rejection and/or death of the recipient (survival 2, 4, 6, 13, 16, 19 days), the human interposition grafts were removed. Human endothelial cells (huECs) were isolated from the interposition grafts and cultivated in vitro. Explanted human vascular tissue, isolated huECs, plasma and serum samples of the graft recipients were characterised by flow cytometry and immunohistochemistry and screened for indications of PERV transmission by quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR), reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and RT assay. PERV-specific immune response of recipients was analysed by Western blot. No evidence of PERV infection or PERV-specific immune response was detected.

FDA/PI flow cytometry assay of complement-mediated cytotoxicity of antibodies generated during xenotransplantation

BACKGROUND

A flow cytometry complement-mediated cytotoxicity assay (FCCA) using fluorescein diacetate (FDA) and propidium iodide (PI) to measure antibody-dependent toxicity is useful to determine the success of xenotransplant organs. We evaluated the validity of different mathematical models as a measure of cytotoxicity in FCCA.

METHODS

Sera from untreated baboons (n = 7) and from immunosuppressed animals (n = 5) undergoing different xenotransplantation protocols with pig organs were tested by endogenous FCCA and a similar assay also using exogenous complement, and the results were compared with those of a complement-dependent hemolytic assay to detect anti-pig antibodies (APHA). The influence of PI/FDA staining and the use of several mathematical models were analyzed.

RESULTS

For both groups of animals, we observed high correlations between the endogenous and exogenous FCCA pathways and between calculations based on PI and FDA staining. Of the four mathematical models tested--the Von Krogh equation, two exponential models, and area under the curve--the Von Krogh equation was the most appropriate in terms of goodness of fit and concordance with APHA.

CONCLUSIONS

FDA/PI FCCA is useful to measure endogenous and exogenous complement-mediated cytotoxicities, and it has advantages related to identification of potential new xenoantibodies. Although all four mathematical models produced acceptable solutions, the Von Krogh equation was the best option.

Les xénogreffes finiront-elles par être acceptées ?

Transplantation represents a major advance in modern medicine with a major impact on the interactions between individuals and society. The numbers of patients undergoing organ transplantation increased steadily over the years and around 250,000 individuals are living nowadays in Europe with a transplanted organ. On the other hand, the numbers of cadaveric (brain-dead) donors used for organ transplantation remains stable, at around 5,000 each year, and the numbers of transplantation from living donors only slowly increase in Europe. Therefore, a gap is growing between the numbers of patients in need of a transplant and the numbers of organs available for transplantation. About 45,000 patients are currently on renal transplant waiting lists in Europe and, depending on the countries considered, 15 to 30 % of candidates for liver or heart transplantation die before a life-saving transplant becomes available to them. There is therefore an urgent need to implement innovative research and to take full advantage of recent biotechnological advances to explore new avenues in xenotransplantation, and to simultaneously address the ethical, societal and public health issues related to organ replacement. Much progresses have been accomplished in the understanding of xenograft rejection processes that include hyperacute, acute vascular and cellular rejection mechanisms. Strategies to promote xenograft survival that are currently under evaluation include genetic engineering of donor pigs, adapted immunosuppressive treatments and tolerance induction. Also, the psychological acceptance has been evaluated.

The study of mitoxantrone as a potential immunosuppressor in transgenic pig renal xenotransplantation in baboons: comparison with cyclophosphamide

Mounting evidence suggests that delayed xenograft rejection (DXR) of discordant xenografts has a strong humoral component. To explore the possibility of targeting this humoral response more efficiently, we performed a preliminary study in baboons immunized against pig blood cells using the immunosuppressor mitoxantrone (Mx). The results from this study showed that, in comparison with cyclophosphamide (CyP), Mx induced a long-lasting depletion of circulating B cells within 6 days of its administration and delayed secondary anti-Gal antibody (Ab) responses to pig blood cell immunizations. Given these results, we next evaluated Mx in an in vivo model of pig to baboon renal xenotransplantation. We performed a series of renal xenotransplantations in baboons using human CD55-CD59 transgenic donor pigs. In the first group of baboons (Mx group; n = 4) Mx was administered 6 days prior to the day of transplantation, the objective being to perform the xenotransplantation in a context where the recipient would have few remaining circulating B cells and thus have an impaired capacity to mount an Ab response to the xenograft. We compared this group to a second group of baboons treated with CyP starting 1 day prior to transplantation (CyP group; n = 2). All baboons receiving Mx or CyP received an additional immunosuppression of cyclosporin A, mycophenolate mofetil and steroids. No hyperacute rejection was observed in either group but all xenografts underwent DXR. Mx did not show superiority to CyP in terms of graft survival with a mean survival time of 8 +/- 2 days compared with 9 days for both CyP-treated baboons. Neither CyP nor Mx decreased serum levels of pre-existing anti-Gal Abs but levels of these Abs decreased dramatically within 1 day of transplantation, likely reflecting their immediate trapping within the xenograft. Interestingly however, in contrast to CyP, Mx inhibited the return of anti-Gal immunoglobulin M (IgM) to the circulation, even at the time of rejection. Nevertheless, strong intragraft deposits of IgM, IgG and the activated complement complex C5b-9 were observed in biopsies at rejection. Furthermore, despite the expected profound depletion of circulating B cells by Mx within 6 days of its administration, biopsies from both groups at rejection displayed a mild B cell infiltrate accompanied by a strong macrophage and intermediate T-cell infiltration, the latter tending to be more abundant in Mx-treated animals. Our data show that in this particular model of pig to baboon xenotransplantation and at the dose used, Mx was not superior to CyP in conferring protection against rejection, despite its capacity to profoundly deplete circulating B cells and to inhibit anti-Gal Ab responses to xenografts. DXR was thus possible without the return of anti-Gal Abs and may have been mediated by the early fixation of pre-existing Abs with secondary complement activation. However, although Mx was not more efficient than CyP in controlling DXR, its capacity to deplete B cells and delay Ab recovery may be beneficial in the context of Gal knockout organ transplantation where the induced Ab response is likely to take precedence over the preformed response.

IgM-enriched human introvenous immunoglobulin strongly inhibits complement-dependent porcine cell cytotoxicity mediated by human xenoreactive antibodies

Treatment with intravenous immunoglobulin preparations consisting of human IgG (IVIgG) prevents hyperacute rejection of pig xenografts transplanted into primates by inhibition of the classical complement pathway. Recent studies indicate that IVIg preparations mainly consisting of human IgM (IVIgM) have a stronger capacity than IVIgG to inhibit the complement system. IVIg preparations also contain xenoreactive antibodies (XAb) binding to pig cells. In the present study, we compared IVIgG and IVIgM for their capacity to inhibit xenogeneic complement activation, with special reference to the roles of IgG and IgM XAb present in these preparations. Xenogeneic complement activation was studied by exposure of pig cells (PK15) to human serum. For some experiments, IVIgG and IVIgM were depleted from XAb by immune absorption. Exposure of PK15 cells to human serum induced surface deposition of C4 and C3 and cytotoxicity, which could be inhibited in a dose-dependent fashion by both IVIgM and IVIgG. The efficacy of IVIgM was more than 10 times higher than that of IVIgG. IgG XAb were detected IVIgG and IVIgM whereas IgM XAb were only present in IVIgM. Depletion of XAb from the IVIg preparations did not modify the protective properties of IVIgG against cytotoxicity induced by human serum, whereas the IVIgM-mediated protection against xenogeneic cytotoxicity was only slightly improved. IgM-enriched IVIg is a potent inhibitor of xenogeneic complement activation and complement-dependent cytotoxicity of human serum to pig cells, irrespective of the presence of cytotoxic xenoreactive IgM antibodies in this preparation. Therefore, IVIgM has a promising therapeutic significance for the treatment of (hyper)acute xenograft rejection.

Xenotransplantation of human decay accelerating factor transgenic porcine kidney to non-human primates: 4 years experience at a Canadian center

From July 1999 to December 2002, a total of 27 baboons underwent transplantation with human decay accelerating factor (hDAF) transgenic porcine kidneys. The immunosuppressive protocol included combinations of 1 or more of the following immunosuppressive agents: cyclosporine, TPC, cyclosphophamide, methylprednisolone, GAS914 (a polymeric alpha-Gal), rabbit antithymocyte serum (RATS), and rapamycin derivative (RAD). The animals were followed up clinically with monitoring of renal function based on daily creatinine and urinary output. Histopathological examination of the tissue samples was performed after paraffin embedding. Electron microscopy was performed on occasion. All pathology was read blindly with a semiquantitative scoring method to assess the presence or absence of histological features of xenotransplant rejection. Mean survival time was 20.7 days (range, 4-75 days) with 15 animals dying of classic humoral rejection and 12 dying of complications unrelated to rejection. The most frequent complications were as follows: chronic diarrhea with malabsorption, bleeding diathesis, infections, and drug toxicity. Irrespective of the immunosuppressive regimen, a significant number of baboons (10) developed untreatable diarrhea and gastrointestinal bleeding. Samples of their gastrointestinal tracts showed evidence of varying degrees of necrotizing vasculitis with immunoglobulin (Ig)G,IgM, and fibrin deposition. The survival in pig-to-baboon kidney xenotransplantation continues to be limited by acute xenograft rejection and complications of immunosuppression. Although significantly increased survivals have been obtained, an ideal protocol has not yet been achieved. Efforts will continue in an attempt to develop a protocol with minimal complications and long-term survival beyond 90 days.

Improved suppression of circulating complement does not block acute vascular rejection of pig-to-rhesus monkey cardiac transplants

At present, acute vascular rejection (AVR) remains a primary obstacle inhibiting long-term graft survival in the pig-to-non-human primate transplant model. The present study was undertaken to determine whether repetitive injection of low dose Yunnan-cobra venom factor (Y-CVF), a potent complement inhibitor derived from the venom of Naja kaouthia can completely abrogate hemolytic complement activity and subsequently improve the results in a pig-to-rhesus monkey heterotopic heart transplant model. Nine adult rhesus monkeys received a heterotopic heart transplant from wild-type pigs and the recipients were allocated into two groups: group 1 (n = 4) received repetitive injection of low dose Y-CVF until the end of the study and group 2 (n = 5) did not receive Y-CVF. All recipients were treated with cyclosporine A (CsA), cyclophosphamide (CyP) and steroids. Repetitive Y-CVF treatment led to very dramatic fall in CH50 and serum C3 levels (CH50 < 3 units/C3 remained undetectable throughout the experiment) and successfully prevented hyperacute rejection (HAR), while three of five animals in group 2 underwent HAR. However, the continuous suppression of circulating complement did not prevent AVR and the grafts in group 1 survived from 8 to 13 days. Despite undetectable C3 in circulating blood, C3 deposition was present in these grafts. The venular thrombosis was the predominant histopathologic feature of AVR. We conclude that repetitive injection of low dose Y-CVF can be used to continuously suppress circulating complement in a very potent manner and successfully prevent HAR. However, this therapy did not inhibit complement deposition in the graft and failed to prevent AVR. These data suggest that using alternative pig donors [i.e. human decay accelerating factor (hDAF)-transgenic] in combination with the systemic use of complement inhibitors may be necessary to further control complement activation and improve survival in pig-to-non-human primate xenotransplant model.

Alterations in the coagulation profile in renal pig-to-monkey xenotransplantation

Five monkey recipients of a porcine renal xenograft were studied to determine the relationship between fibrin formation in acute humoral xenograft rejection (AHXR) and procoagulant and anticoagulant factor levels to establish whether changes in coagulation parameters could be used to predict AHXR and determine whether AHXR is associated with overt disseminated intravascular coagulopathy (DIC) in this model. Variable degrees of compensated consumptive coagulopathy were observed in each primate. Elevated thrombin-antithrombin (TAT), F1+2 and D-dimer levels consistent with thrombin generation and fibrin formation were recorded. There was no consumption of the main clotting inhibitors (including antithrombin) or a progressive, severe drop in fibrinogen levels and platelet counts, although grafts were left in situ. After transplantation, D-dimer levels remained persistently high, so they were of limited value in defining this coagulopathy. At post mortem, no cases of multiorgan involvement typical of overt DIC were observed. The lack of a rapid postoperative recovery of clotting inhibitor levels after transplantation was invariably associated with early poor outcome. This study shows that AHXR is associated with various degrees of compensated consumptive coagulopathy in our pig-to-primate model. No clear relationship was found between coagulation parameter levels and graft outcome.

Potential implications of ABO blood group for vascular rejection in pig to human kidney xenotransplantation

BACKGROUND

A substantial hurdle for successful xenotransplantation is to negate the effect of xenoreactive natural antibodies [mainly Galalpha1-3Galbeta1-4GlcNAc (alpha-Gal) specific] that cause hyperacute xenograft rejection. Galalpha1-3Gal molecules (alpha-Gal) have close structural homology with human ABO blood groups and therefore an individual's blood group might influence the formation of alpha-Gal specific antibodies. Genetic heterogeneity controlling alpha-Gal specific antibody formation could have important implications for future pig to human xenotransplantation clinical trials. We have investigated the relationship between ABO blood group and immunoglobulin M (IgM) and immunoglobulin G (IgG) alpha-Gal specific antibody titres in sera obtained from renal dialysis patients and healthy blood donors.

METHODS

Serially diluted sera (n = 166) obtained from renal dialysis patients awaiting kidney transplantation (n = 116) and healthy blood donors (n = 50) were tested for IgM and IgG alpha-Gal antibodies using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) specific for alpha-Gal. The study cohort comprised 62, 48, 36 and 20 sera obtained from blood group O, A, B and AB individuals, respectively. Reciprocal alpha-Gal specific antibody titres were calculated from ELISA titration curves and stratified by individual blood group.

RESULTS

No significant heterogeneity was found in IgM alpha-Gal specific antibody titres across ABO blood groups. In contrast, marked heterogeneity was observed in IgG alpha-Gal specific antibody titres when stratified by blood group. IgG alpha-Gal specific antibody titres were higher in sera obtained from blood group O renal dialysis patients [median titre 40, interquartile range (IQR) 14 to 72], compared with blood group A (median titre 18, IQR 7 to 54, P = 0.05), blood group B (median titre 6, IQR 0 to 15, P < 0.001) and blood group AB patients (median titre 3.5, IQR 0 to 16, P = 0.002). A similar correlation was found for IgG alpha-Gal specific antibody titres in sera obtained from healthy blood donors with median titres of 20 (IQR 12 to 34), 37 (10 to 91), 9 (0 to 20), and 5.5 (0 to 12) in blood groups O, A, B and AB individuals, respectively. There was a strong interrelationship between alpha-Gal specific antibody class and blood group, with both IgM and IgG alpha-Gal specific antibodies found in 84% of the blood group O sera, 73% of blood group A sera, 50% of blood group B sera and 40% of blood group AB sera (P < 0.001). In a subgroup of 39 renal dialysis patients, IgM and IgG alpha-Gal specific antibody titres were measured in two serum samples obtained at different time-points (median time interval 581 days, range 42 to 4414), and showed a high degree of stability (correlation coefficient 0.88 and 0.90 for IgM and IgG, respectively).

CONCLUSION

IgG alpha-Gal specific antibody titres are significantly higher in the sera of blood group O and A renal dialysis patients and healthy individuals compared with blood groups B and AB. These data indicate that future clinical trials of pig to human xenotransplantation may be more problematic for non-blood group B patients who are likely to have high levels of IgG alpha-Gal specific antibodies that are associated with acute vascular rejection.

Improvement in human decay accelerating factor transgenic porcine kidney xenograft rejection with intravenous administration of gas914, a polymeric form of alphaGAL

BACKGROUND

The present study was undertaken to determine whether intravenous administration of GAS914, a polymeric form of alphaGal, would minimize porcine kidney xenograft rejection in baboons. Human decay accelerating factor renal xenografts were transplanted into 16 baboon recipients.

METHODS

Baseline immunosuppression for all groups included cyclosporine A, cyclophosphamide, SDZ-RAD, and methylprednisolone. Group 1 received only baseline immunosuppression; group 2 animals received low-dose GAS914 with baseline immunosuppression; group 3 animals received high dose GAS914 with high-dose baseline immunosuppression; and animals from group 4 received high-dose GAS914 and low-dose baseline immunosuppression.

RESULTS

None of the animals in this study developed hyperacute rejection. Intravenous administration of GAS914 significantly reduced xenoreactive antibodies as measured by antiporcine hemolytic assays and anti-Gal (immunoglobulin [Ig] G and IgM) antibody assays. Rejection was less severe in the GAS914-treated group. Only 25% (3 of 12) of GAS914-treated animals were killed as a result of rejection, whereas 75% (three of four) of non-GAS914-treated animals were killed because of terminal rejection (P<0.01). Protocol biopsies demonstrated that the degree of acute humoral xenograft rejection (AHXR) was reduced in the GAS914-treated animals compared with non-GAS914-treated animals.

CONCLUSION

The intravenous administration of GAS914 reduces xenoreactive antibody levels and reduces the degree of porcine kidney xenograft rejection, but does not improve survival. AHXR and drug toxicity remain major barriers to the long-term success of xenotransplantation.

Are anti-endothelial cell antibodies a pre-requisite for the acute vascular rejection of xenografts?

BACKGROUND

Vascular rejection occurring within the first few weeks after transplantation is still the major immunological barrier to the long term survival of xenografts. Currently there is no consensus about what to call this type of rejection (acute vascular rejection, delayed xenograft rejection or acute humoral xenograft rejection), nor about how to prevent or treat it.

METHODS

A review of published evidence to define the heterogeneity of this phase of rejection and examine the role of antibodies, complement and graft-infiltrating inflammatory cells.

RESULTS

i) antibodies are always involved in acute vascular rejection; ii) this antibody-mediated rejection may be complement-dependent or -independent; iii) inflammatory cells may mediate an antibody- and complement-independent phase of rejection in some small animal models (which, in its pure form cannot be called 'vascular rejection') iv) there remain significant questions about the relevance of 'accommodation' and the importance of coagulation abnormalities.

CONCLUSIONS

Without doubt, future research would be helped by distinguishing between these different forms of delayed xenograft rejection, using terminology to reflect the involvement of specific pathophysiological mechanisms. An updated classification of the stages of xenograft rejection is proposed here.

Role of complement in xenotransplantation

The xenotransplantation research is driven by the increasing gap between the number of patients with end-stage organ failure on waiting lists for transplantation and the supply of allografts. The lack of success in developing suitable artificial organs for permanent treatment of organ failure has further strengthened the need for xenotransplantation research. Pigs are now generally accepted to be the source animal of choice. Transplantation of pig organs to humans faces several barriers which have to be overcome before it comes to clinical application: (1) anatomical and physiological conditions; (2) immunological rejection mechanisms; (3) molecular compatibility between signal molecules of the two species; (4) risk of transmission of microorganisms, particularly pig endogenous retroviruses; and (5) legal and ethical aspects both with respect to the animal and the recipient. Here we will focus on the role of the complement system in the rejection of immediately vascularized pig-to-primate xenografts. The hyperacute rejection occurring within minutes after transplantation is mediated by binding of natural antibodies to the Galalpha(l-3)Gal epitope on the endothelial cells with subsequent complement activation. Whereas inhibition of complement activation protects against hyperacute rejection, the role of complement in the later rejection phases is less clarified.

Gal mismatch alone causes skin graft rejection in mice

BACKGROUND

Elimination of galactose-alpha1,3-galactose (Gal), the major xenoantigen between pig and human, may extend pig-to-human xenograft survival beyond the current barrier of acute vascular rejection. However, it has been suggested that Gal is an essential molecule in the pig and that the generation of a Gal-deleted (Gal KO) pig will not be possible. Should this be the case, understanding the Gal-mediated immune response will be crucial in developing strategies to overcome pig xenograft rejection in humans. There are no existing models of xenograft rejection in which the sole difference between donor and recipient is Gal. We describe a model of exclusively Gal-mismatched skin graft rejection.

METHODS

The survival of Gal skin grafts on Gal KO mice with the same genetic background was analyzed. To examine innate anti-Gal immunity, Gal KO recipients that were also deficient in T and B cells (RAG-1 KO) were used. To study the role of cognate immunity, recipients were sensitized with a primary Gal allograft before receiving a second Gal graft that was otherwise isogeneic. To test the role of anti-Gal antibodies in this model, recipients were passively immunized with a non-complement-fixing anti-Gal monoclonal antibody.

RESULTS

Gal KO mice chronically reject Gal skin grafts by 100 days at a rate of 48% (n=25) on a BALB/c background and 25% (n=8) on a C57BL/6 background. The grafts had an infiltrate that consisted predominantly of CD4 T cells and macrophages, whereas recipients deficient in T and B cells were incapable of rejection and survived for more than 120 days (n=5). Sensitization with a primary Gal allograft increased the incidence and the tempo of rejection of a second Gal-only mismatched skin graft with 99% rejection that ranged from 11 to 45 days (n=26). Passive transfer of mouse IgG anti-Gal monoclonal-antibody-induced rejection in Gal KO and RAG-1/Gal double-KO recipients at a rate of 92% (n=13).

CONCLUSIONS

We have established a model to study rejection based solely on a Gal mismatch. Our results indicate that non-complement-fixing anti-Gal antibody can cause rejection in the acute vascular rejection time frame and that T-cell-mediated chronic rejection will be a further barrier to overcome if Gal cannot be deleted from the pig.

Clinical xenotransplantation: pigs might fly?

Xenotransplantation has the potential to deliver an unlimited supply of organs for transplantation. However, this promise has yet to translate into clinical application, despite substantial research efforts in the last decade. Although increasing numbers of studies are being performed in relevant pre-clinical (pig-to-primate) transplantation models, so far these have highlighted the apparent elusiveness of long-term xenograft survival. Humoral rejection remains the main obstacle to success, but control of T cell-mediated rejection will be a problem in the future and there are major concerns about the possible transmission of porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERV) and other infectious agents. This article reviews recent advances in the understanding of acute vascular rejection (AVR), acute T cell-mediated rejection and PERV transmission and highlights some of the strategies that may prove successful in overcoming these problems. Although progress has been slow, the promise of an inexhaustible supply of organs is sufficient reason to continue research in these areas. Assuming the specific problem of AVR can be ameliorated by one of a number of strategies currently under investigation, there are grounds to believe that xenotransplantation will become a clinical reality. Pig xenografts, currently grounded, might eventually fly!

Human serum-induced porcine endothelial cell E-selectin expression is associated with IgG3 and IgM anti-Gal antibodies

Naturally occurring anti-Galalpha1-3Gal (anti-Gal) antibodies and complement induce hyperacute rejection (HAR) of porcine organs transplanted to primates. If the hyperacute reaction is prevented, an acute vascular rejection (AVR) occurs within hours to few days. Antibodies are important for the development of AVR, whereas the role of complement is still not clarified. AVR is characterized by protein synthesis-dependent endothelial cell (EC) activation. In the present study we investigated the relation between EC activation as measured by E-selectin expression, and the concentrations of anti-Gal antibodies of IgM, IgG and IgG subclasses in sera from 80 healthy blood donors selected on the basis of sex and age. There was a significant correlation between E-selectin expression and the concentration of IgG3 anti-Gal (r=0.39; P=0.019), which was not seen for the other IgG subclasses or for total IgG anti-Gal. A modest, but significant correlation was found between the concentration of IgM anti-Gal and E-selectin expression (r=0.38; P=0.040), but not between IgM and IgG3 anti-Gal. There was a large interindividual variation in anti-Gal antibodies, 50-fold for IgM and 70-fold for IgG. Females had significantly higher concentrations of IgM anti-Gal than males (P=0.0006), which was explained by a substantial increase in IgM anti-Gal concentration in younger women. The concentration of IgG anti-Gal and the degree of E-selectin expression did not differ between sex or age groups. In conclusion, the close correlation between anti-Gal antibodies of the potent complement activating IgG3 subclass and porcine EC activation, may imply that these antibodies play a role in EC activation characteristic of AVR.

Antibody-mediated activation of the classical complement pathway in xenograft rejection

Transplant rejection is a multifactorial process involving complex interactions between components of the innate and the acquired immune system. In view of the shortage of donor organs available for transplantation, xenotransplantation of pig organs into man has been considered as a potential solution. However, in comparison to allografts, xenografts are subject to extremely potent rejection processes that are currently incompletely defined. Consequently, an appropriate and safe treatment protocol ensuring long-term graft survival is not yet available. The first barrier that has to be taken for a xenograft is hyperacute rejection, a rapid process induced by the binding of pre-formed antibodies from the host to the graft endothelium, followed by activation of the classical complement pathway. The present review concentrates on the role of antibodies and complement in xenograft rejection as well as on the approaches for treatment that target these components. The first part focuses on porcine xenoantigens that are recognized by human xenoreactive antibodies and the different treatment strategies that aim on interference in antibody binding. The second part of the review deals with complement activation by xenoreactive antibodies, and summarizes the role of complement in the induction of endothelial cell damage and cell activation. Finally, various options that are currently under development for complement inhibition are discussed, with special reference to the specific inhibition of the classical complement pathway by soluble complement inhibitors.

C1-inhibitor for prophylaxis of xenograft rejection after pig to cynomolgus monkey kidney transplantation

BACKGROUND

Early rejection of discordant porcine xenografts in primate recipients is initiated by the intragraft binding of either preformed (hyperacute xenograft rejection) or induced (acute vascular rejection) antiporcine recipient antibodies with subsequent complement activation via the classical pathway. We have investigated the efficacy of the supplemental administration of C1-inhibitor (C1-INH), a specific inhibitor of the classical complement activation pathway, for prophylaxis of xenograft rejection in a pig to primate kidney xenotransplantation setting.

METHODS

Based on the results of pharmacokinetic studies performed in two nontransplanted monkeys, supplemental C1-INH therapy was administered daily to three Cynomolgus monkeys receiving a life-supporting porcine kidney transplant together with cyclophosphamide-induction/cyclosporine A/mycophenolat-mofetil/steroid immunosuppressive therapy.

RESULTS

In the three monkeys receiving porcine kidney xenografts and continuous C1-INH treatment none of the grafts underwent hyperacute rejection; all xenografts showed initial function. Recipient survival was 13, 15, and 5 days. No graft was lost due to acute vascular rejection. All animals died with a functioning graft (latest creatinine 96, 112, and 96 micromol/liter) due to bacterial septicemia.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that, in our model, supplemental C1-INH therapy together with a standard immunosuppressive regimen can be helpful for prevention of xenograft rejection in a pig to primate kidney xenotransplantation setting. The optimal dose and duration of C1-INH treatment, however, has yet to be determined.

Human serum-induced expression of E-selectin on porcine aortic endothelial cells in vitro is totally complement mediated

BACKGROUND

Whereas complement is a key mediator of hyperacute xenograft rejection, its role in acute vascular rejection (AVR) is a matter of controversy. AVR is associated with de novo synthesis of endothelial cell-derived inflammatory mediators, including the leukocyte-recruiting adhesion molecule E-selectin. Here we investigate the role and mechanism of complement in human serum-induced porcine endothelial cell activation.

METHODS

An in vitro xenotransplantation method was designed using porcine aortic endothelial cells stimulated with human serum in microculture wells. E-selectin expression was measured by cell-enzyme immunoassay. Complement inhibitors acting at different levels in the cascade were investigated for their effect on E-selectin expression.

RESULTS

E-selectin was strongly induced by normal human serum but not by heat-inactivated serum. Compstatin, a synthetic C3 inhibitor, markedly reduced human serum-induced E-selectin expression. Purified C1-inhibitor suppressed E-selectin induction completely, indicating activation through the classical or lectin pathway. Furthermore, a monoclonal antibody (mAb) that inhibits cleavage of C5 or another mAb that blocks the function of C7, completely inhibited the expression of serum-induced E-selectin, consistent with the terminal C5b-9 complement complex being the mediator of the endothelial cell activation. Inhibition of the alternative pathway using a novel antifactor D mAb did not reduce E-selectin expression.

CONCLUSION

Human serum-induced expression of porcine E-selectin is totally complement dependent, induced by a C1-inhibitor regulated pathway and mediated through the terminal complement complex. The data may have implications for therapeutic strategies, particularly of C1-inhibitor and anti-C5 mAb, to protect against endothelial cell activation and subsequent AVR of porcine xenografts.

C1-Inhibitor for treatment of acute vascular xenograft rejection in cynomolgus recipients of h-DAF transgenic porcine kidneys

At present, the major barrier to successful discordant xenotransplantation of unmodified or complement regulator transgenic porcine xenografts is acute vascular xenograft rejection (AVR). AVR is associated with the intragraft deposition of induced recipient xenoreactive antibodies and subsequent complement activation. In a life-supporting pig to primate kidney xenotransplantation setting using h-DAF transgenic donor organs and postoperative immunosuppression, episodes of AVR were either treated with boluses of cyclophosphamide and steroids or with the same regimen supplemented by a three-day course of C1-Inhibitor, a multifunctional complement regulator. In 8 out of 10 animals stable initial graft function was achieved; in all animals one or more episodes of AVR were observed. When, in 4 animals, C1-Inhibitor was added to the standard anti-rejection treatment regimen, AVR was successfully reversed in 6 out of 7 episodes, while in another group of 4 animals receiving the standard anti-rejection treatment 0 out of 4 episodes of AVR responded to treatment. Response to anti-rejection treatment was associated with a significant increase in recipient survival time. We conclude that AVR of h-DAF transgenic porcine kidneys can be successfully treated by additional short-term fluid phase complement inhibition.

Hemodynamic consequences of porcine kidney xenograft reperfusion in cynomolgus monkeys

BACKGROUND

After xenograft reperfusion, complement activation may lead to generation of anaphylatoxins and cardiocirculatory instability of the recipient.

METHODS

In 13 cynomolgus recipients of either unmodified or human decay accelerating factor transgenic porcine kidneys cardiocirculatory parameters were measured by single indicator transpulmonary thermodilution.

RESULTS

After graft reperfusion, recipient cardiac output decreased by 25.4% (P<0.05), intrathoracic blood volume by 22.8% (P<0.05), extravascular lung water increased slightly (P=n.s.). The impairment in cardiac output was neither influenced by the graft's weight or human decay accelerating factor transgenicity. sC3a and sC5b-9 complement levels in the recipient monkeys showed a sharp peak upon reperfusion.

CONCLUSIONS

After reperfusion a marked and significant cardiodepression accompanied by relative volume depletion were observed. Analysis of volume status ruled out a mere volume shift as the underlying reason for the observed drop in cardiac output. These data may be relevant for the perioperative management of human recipients of discordant xenografts in the future.