Differential involvement of CD4+ cells in mediating skin graft rejection against different amounts of transgenic H-2K(b) antigen

MHC class I recognition by monocyte-/macrophage-specific receptors

The most important transplantation antigens in the discrimination between "self" and "nonself" are encoded by genes in the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) locus (H-2 in mice). It has been assumed that T lymphocytes are the effector cells for allograft rejection, as athymic nude rodents fail to reject allografts. In 1988, we i.p. transplanted Meth A (H-2D(d)K(d)) tumor cells into C57BL/6 (H-2D(b)K(b)) mice and found macrophages to be cytotoxic against the allografts. In 1996, several groups using CD4 or CD8 knockout mice reported that non-T cells were the effector cells for the rejection of skin or organ allografts. In 1998, we ascertained that macrophages were the effector cells of skin allograft rejection. Recently, we isolated cDNA clones encoding monocyte/macrophage MHC receptors (MMRs) for H-2D(d) and H-2K(d); established H-2D(d)- and/or H-2K(d)-transgenic mice and lymphoma cells; and found, using MMR-deficient mice, that MMR and T-cell receptor were essential for the rejection of transgenic skin and lymphoma, respectively.

Nanoparticle delivery of mycophenolic acid upregulates PD-L1 on dendritic cells to prolong murine allograft survival

Conventional immunosuppressive drug delivery requires high systemic drug levels to provide therapeutic benefit, but frequently results in toxic side effects. Novel drug delivery methods, such as FDA-approved poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) nanoparticles (NPs), are promising drug delivery platforms to reduce drug doses and minimize toxicity. Using murine models of skin transplantation, we investigated whether PLGA NPs would effectively deliver mycophenolic acid (MPA), a common clinical immunosuppressant, and avoid the toxicity of conventional drug delivery. We found that intermittent treatment with NPs encapsulated with MPA (NP-MPA) resulted in a significant extension of allograft survival than intermittent conventional MPA treatment even though the concentration of MPA within NP-MPA was a 1000-fold lower than conventional drug. Importantly, recipients who were administered NP-MPA intermittently avoided drug toxicity, whereas those treated with daily conventional drug manifested cytopenias. Dendritic cells (DCs) endocytosed NP-MPA to upregulate programmed death ligand-1 (PD-L1) and displayed a decreased ability to prime alloreactive T cells. Importantly, the ability of NP-MPA to promote allograft survival was partly PD-L1 dependent. Collectively, this study indicates that NPs are potent drug delivery tools that extend allograft survival without drug toxicity.

Specific tolerance induction of allo-K(b)-skin grafts by FK506 in the CD8-depleted H-2(k) recipients required low amounts of K(b)-antigen

MHC class I allo-grafts can be directly rejected by recipient CD8 T cells and be indirectly rejected by recipient CD4 T cells. Although the experimental results using the bm mutant and C57BL/6 mice indicated that CD4-mediated rejection of class I-disparate grafts is a relatively weak process and is expected to be more sensitive to additional exogenous immunosuppression, it is unclear that whether this mechanism can be used for inducing a specific tolerance of class I disparate grafts. In this study, we hypothesize that a short course of FK506 may induce a specific tolerance of class I-disparate skin grafts in the CD8-depleted recipients. K(b)-transgenic C3H mice, Tg.H-2 K(b)-1 and Tg.H-2 K(b)-2 mice that express high copies and low copies of K(b)-antigen respectively were used as donors. Wild type C3H mice (H-2(k)) in which either CD4 or CD8 T cells were depleted by administration of anti-CD4 or CD8 monoclonal antibody (mAb) were used as recipients. Results showed that FK506 promoted longer survival of allo-K(b) skin grafts in CD8-depleted C3H mice than in CD4-depleted C3H mice. Graft survival from Tg.H-2 K(b)-2 mice was significantly longer than Tg.H-2 K(b)-1 mice. A short course of FK506 induced long-term survival of skin grafts from Tg.H-2K(b)-2 mice, but not from Tg.H-2K(b)-1 mice in CD8-depleted C3H recipients, even after FK506 was stopped. These mice also accepted grafts of Tg.H-2K(b)-1 mice when challenged with skin grafts from Tg.H-2K(b)-1 mice, but promptly rejected third party skin grafts from BALB/c (H-2(d)) mice. T cells from K(b)-tolerant C3H mice did not respond to allo-K(b)-antigen in in vitro assays of mixed lymphocyte culture and cell-mediated cytotoxicity. In conclusion we found that a short course of FK506 treatment and low amounts of K(b)-antigen induced a K(b)-specific tolerance in the CD8-depleted recipients, and this tolerance maintained even after withdrawing the anti-CD8 mAb treatment.

Ligand density determines the efficiency of negative selection in the thymus

To study the influence of antigen density on the efficiency of negative selection in the thymus, MHC class I (H-2K(b), K(b)) transgenic mice were generated, which expressed a K(b) transgene under the control of its natural promoter at 33% (K(b-lo)) or 150% (K(b-hi)) the surface density of Kb in C57BL/6 (B6, H-2(b)) mice. These mice were crossed to anti-K(b) T-cell receptor (Des-TCR) transgenic mice. In Des-TCRxK(b-hi) double transgenic mice, Des-TCR bearing T cells were completely eliminated during thymocyte maturation. In contrast, in Des-TCRxK(b-lo) double transgenic mice, two populations of Des-TCR T cells were evident, which either expressed the Des-TCR at intermediate density in the absence of CD8 (Des-TCR(int)CD8(-)) or expressed both the Des-TCR and CD8 at low density (Des-TCRloCD8lo). In the thymus of both types of double transgenic mice, no Des-TCR(+)CD4(+)CD8(+) thymocytes were detected, suggesting that deletion of Des-TCR cells occurred before the CD4(+)CD8(+) stage. Because only very few Des-TCR(+) thymocytes were found in Des-TCRxK(b-hi) transgenic mice, deletion of these T cells apparently occurred upon expression of the Des-TCR. By contrast, Des-TCRxK(b-lo) transgenic mice showed distinct populations of Des-TCR(int)CD4-8- and Des-TCR(lo)CD8(lo) thymocytes, suggesting that expression of the CD8 coreceptor was required to allow negative selection to proceed. Functional analyses showed that sublethally irradiated Des-TCRxK(b-lo) double transgenic mice were protected from lethal graft-versus-host disease by injected Des-TCR lymph node cells.

Anti-CD4 induced rat heart tolerance: no presence of primed T cells and regulatory mechanisms for cytotoxic T cells

Treatment with anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody (mAb) (OX38) induces heart, but not skin graft tolerance in WF (RT1u) to Lewis (RT1l) rat strain combinations. We examined differences in cellular responses between heart-bearing and skin-rejected hosts that were both treated with anti-CD4 mAb. In the tolerant LEW rats bearing WF heart transplants, the secondary WF heart but not skin grafts were accepted. On the other hand, in anti-CD4 treated WF skin-rejected hosts, both secondary WF heart and skin grafts were rapidly rejected. Spleen cells from anti-CD4 treated WF skin-rejected LEW rats but not from WF heart-bearing LEW rats received the same treatment generated CTL after in vitro stimulation with paraformaldehyde (PFA) treated donor WF stimulator spleen cells. Adoptive transfer of spleen cells from WF skin-rejected LEW rats with or without anti-CD4 therapy into the tolerant LEW rats at the secondary WF heart transplantation blocked the secondary heart graft acceptance. However, transfer of spleen cells from WF heart-rejected rats without immunosuppression failed to block acceptance of the secondary heart graft. Our results indicated the lack of primed T cells and presence of regulatory mechanisms for tissue specific T cells in anti-CD4 treated heart bearing hosts.

Interferon-gamma is necessary for initiating the acute rejection of major histocompatibility complex class II-disparate skin allografts

BACKGROUND

Although interferon (IFN)gamma has immunostimulatory functions, it is not essential for the acute rejection of fully allogeneic grafts in mice. It is not known whether IFNgamma plays a critical role in the acute rejection of MHC class I- or MHC class II-disparate allografts.

METHODS

We studied the survival of skin allografts transplanted from fully allogeneic (BALB/c), MHC class I-disparate (bml), or MHC class II-disparate (bm12) donors to C57BL/6 wild-type (IFNgamma+/+) and IFNgamma gene-knockout (IFNgamma-/-) recipients. We also investigated the in vitro responses of IFNgamma+/+ and IFNgamma-/- T cells to MHC class II-disparate splenocytes.

RESULTS

We found that IFNgamma-/- recipients reject BALB/c and bml skin grafts at the same rate as IFNgamma+/+ mice but are not capable of rejecting bm12 skin. Despite the inability of IFNgamma-/- mice to reject bm12 skin grafts, IFNgamma-/- T cells displayed vigorous proliferation and cytotoxic responses when stimulated with bm12 splenocytes in vitro. Furthermore, priming IFNgamma-/- recipients with bm12 splenocytes enabled these mice to reject bm12 skin grafts at a normal rate and to mount a cutaneous delayed-type hypersensitivity response to the bm12 antigen.

CONCLUSION

The data demonstrate that IFNgamma is not necessary for generating effector mechanisms associated with acute transplant rejection but that it is required for initiating alloimmune responses to MHC class II-disparate skin grafts.

CD4 T cells can reject major histocompatibility complex class I-incompatible skin grafts

We have re-investigated the roles of CD4 and CD8 T cell subsets in skin graft rejection across a single class I MHC disparity. Recipient mice were transplanted with skin from donors transgenic for the class I MHC molecule Kb. As expected, CD8 T cells were sufficient for rapid injection; but surprisingly, CD4 T cells were also competent to do the same. Rejection was dependent on one or the other subset, since elimination of both resulted in indefinite graft survival. The possibility that alloantibody was the downstream effector of CD4 mediated rejection was excluded because CD8-depleted mice rendered B cell deficient still rejected rapidly, but T cell-depleted recipients with pre-existing high titers of alloantibody were unable to do so. In addition, if CD4 cells act to reject by recruiting and/or activating macrophages then this was not dependent on CR3, IFN-gamma or TNF-alpha. Transplantation of skin grafts where the MHC class I disparity was at the level of passenger leukocytes only, demonstrated that transient bystander damage could occur, but that this was insufficient to result in full rejection. We surmise that for CD4 T cells to reject an MHC class I-incompatible graft it is necessary that an appropriate allogeneic peptide is processed and presented in the context of recipient MHC class II. CD4 T cells from B6 mice may fail to reject skin from MHC class I mutants because of the lack of such MHC class II-restricted presentation.

Enhancement of antigen-specific IFN-gamma production from CD8(+) T cells by a single amino acid-substituted peptide derived from bovine alphas1-casein

Modulation of CD8(+) T-cell responses specific for an exogenous antigen by epitope variants would be advantageous to develop a novel means of antigen-specific immune regulation. We have analyzed CD8(+) T-cell responses to single amino acid-substituted variants of a peptide corresponding to residues 142-149 (p142-149; LAYFYPEL) of alphas1-casein, a major milk allergen, which is a dominant determinant restricted by H-2Kb. An analog peptide L142I with a substitution of Ile for Leu at the nonanchor N-terminal residue induced more IFN-gamma secretion than p142-149 from specific CD8(+) T cells. Furthermore, L142I could prime CD8(+) T cells more efficiently in vivo, and these L142I-primed cells secreted more IFN-gamma than p142-149-primed CD8(+) T cells upon stimulation with p142-149 in vitro. These findings are mainly explained by the greater ability of L142I to form stable Kb-peptide complexes. These findings indicate that appropriate analog peptides may be useful as efficient inducers of CD8(+) T cells which recognize the parent peptide and secrete IFN-gamma, a potent inhibitor of Th2-dependent events, including IgE production.

Rejection of H-Y Disparate Skin Grafts by Monospecific CD4+ Th1 and Th2 Cells: No Requirement for CD8+ T Cells or B Cells

We wished to determine whether CD4+ T cells could reject a skin graft that was discordant for a single minor transplantation Ag in the absence of CD8+ T cells or Ab. Transgenic A1(M) mice were constructed that express the rearranged Vβ8.2 and Vα10 TCR genes from a T cell clone that is specific for the male Ag (H-Y) in the context of H2-Ek. In addition, the RAG-1−/− background was bred onto these mice to eliminate any endogenous TCR rearrangements. As expected, clonal deletion was found to be complete in the thymus of male A1(M)×RAG-1−/− mice, while only CD4+ T cells were positively selected and found in the periphery of females. Female A1(M)×RAG-1−/− mice were able to rapidly reject (in <14 days) male (but not female) skin grafts in a CD4-dependent fashion. After multiple grafts, it was confirmed that no CD8+ T cells or surface Ig+ B cells were present. An immunofluorescent analysis of spleen cells after grafting showed that the majority of T cells expressed activation markers (CD44, CD25, and intracytoplasmic IL-2) and a significant proportion were making IFN-γ and IL-4. Surprisingly, the transfer of either Th1 or Th2 CD4+ T cell lines from these mice into T cell-depleted recipients was sufficient to cause a specific rejection of male skin.

Cutting Edge: Induction of Antigen-Specific Hyporesponsiveness by Transplantation of Hemopoietic Cells Containing an MHC Class I Transgene Regulated by a Lymphocyte-Specific Promoter

We explored a novel approach to tolerance induction by the transplantation of bone marrow (BM) cells (BMCs) that themselves do not express a foreign histocompatibility Ag, but which give rise to mature lymphocytes that do so. Lines of transgenic (FVB) mice were generated that contained an MHC class I Dd cDNA regulated by a CD2 promoter. Because the CD2 promoter is lymphocyte-specific and activated relatively late in lymphocyte ontogeny, Dd is expressed on most mature lymphocytes in the periphery but only on developing B cells in the BM of transgenic mice. Transgenic BMCs are tolerogenic and reproducibly engraft in nontransgenic mice using a conditioning regimen that is nonpermissive for the engraftment of conventional (MHC promoter) Dd-transgenic BMCs. Engrafted BMCs generate transgene-expressing lymphocytes and confer a state of Ag-specific hyporesponsiveness on the host that is primarily attributable to a peripheral mechanism. The strategies by which tolerance can be optimized in this system are discussed.

The pharmacology of immunosuppressant drugs in skin transplant rejection in mice and other rodents

1. Skin transplantation in rodents is a convenient, widely used method, particularly in mice. It is used as much as an indicator of immune responsiveness as for pharmacological studies. 2. Many differences exist in experimental protocols, both for transplantation and drug administration and in this review, the increase in graft survival time with respect to control times is used to indicate drug effects, in an attempt to account for these differences. 3. The mechanisms underlying skin graft rejection in rodents are described, emphasising the crucial role of both helper and effector T cells. 4. The pharmacology of clinically-used immunosuppressants, including CsA, FK506, rapamycin and purine or pyrimidine synthesis inhibitors, in rodent models of skin transplantation is reviewed. 5. The effects of other potential immunosuppressants and compounds modulating immune responses are described, including the effects of UV light and involvement of platelet-derived factors, prostaglandins and thromboxanes.

CD4+ T cell-mediated rejection of major histocompatibility complex class I-disparate grafts: a role for alloantibody

Experimental studies of the T cell requirement for rejection of class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-disparate grafts have generated controversy over both the autonomy of CD8+ T cells and the mechanism whereby CD4+ T cells are able to independently mediate rejection. In this study of rejection of RT1Aa class I MHC-disparate rat cardiac and skin allografts by high-responder PVG RT1u recipients, we show that elimination of CD8+ T cells [by anti-CD8 monoclonal antibody (mAb) administration in vivo] fails to prolong graft survival, whereas partial depletion of CD4+ T cells (by anti-CD4 mAb treatment) markedly delays rejection of class I-disparate heart grafts, and marginally prolongs survival of skin grafts. Anti-CD4-treated PVG-RT1u athymic nude rats reconstituted with CD8+ T cells failed to reject class I-disparate skin grafts for several weeks and eventual rejection correlated with re-emergence of a small number of donor derived CD4+ T cells. Conversely, anti-CD8-treated nude rats reconstituted with CD4+ T cells alone rapidly rejected class I-disparate skin grafts. Passive transfer of anti-class I immune serum to anti-CD4-treated euthymic recipients promptly restored their ability to specifically reject a class I-disparate heart graft. Similarly, passive transfer of immune serum to PVG-RT1u nude rats bearing skin allografts caused destruction of class I-disparate but not third-party grafts. These results demonstrate that CD4+ T cells are both necessary and sufficient to cause rejection of class I-disparate heart and skin grafts in this model and that CD4+ T cell-dependent alloantibody plays a decisive role in effecting rejection.

Mechanism of the rejection of major histocompatibility complex class I-disparate murine skin grafts: rejection can be mediated by CD4+ cells activated by allo-class I + II antigen in CD8+ cell-depleted hosts

In the preceding article, we analyzed the immunohistochemical rejection mechanism of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I (H-2K)- disparate murine skin grafts, and showed that only CD8+ cells infiltrated at the site of the epithelial tissue of MHC class I- disparate graft. We also showed that perfect survival of MHC class I- disparate grafts were attained in thymectomized recipients treated with anti-Lyt-2 monoclonal antibody. In this report, we showed that these long-surviving allo-class I grafts were rejected in the absence of CD8+ cells by stimulation with allo-MHC class I + II-disparate graft as the second stimulation. Furthermore, it was immunohistochemically revealed that under that condition, a large number of CD4+ cells infiltrated into the epithelial tissue of these long-surviving class I grafts, which were going to be rejected 2-5 d after the transplantation of a second graft with MHC class I + II difference. This result directly shows that CD4+ cells are able to became effectors for the rejection of allo-MHC class I (H-2K) skin graft.

Skin graft rejection by beta 2-microglobulin-deficient mice

Mice homozygous for a beta 2-microglobulin (beta 2-m) gene disruption lack beta 2-m protein and are deficient for functional major histocompatibility complex class I (MHC-I) molecules. The mutant mice have normal numbers of CD4+8- T helper cells, but lack MHC-I-directed CD4-8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs). In this study we used the beta 2-m mutant mice to study the importance of MHC-I-directed immunity in skin graft rejection. Our results indicate that MHC-I-directed CD8+ CTLs are not essential in the rejection of allografts with whole MHC or multiple minor H differences. However, the absence of MHC-I-guided immunity profoundly reduces the ability of mutant mice to reject H-Y disparate grafts. In addition, we show that natural killer cells which vigorously reject MHC-I-deficient bone marrow grafts, are not effective in the destruction of MHC-I-deficient skin grafts.

Donor major histocompatibility complex (MHC) peptides are presented by recipient MHC molecules during graft rejection

Peptides from donor major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules were examined for their activation of allogeneically primed T cells. After immunization with either allogeneic spleen cells or a skin allograft, primed T cells proliferate in response to peptides derived from polymorphic regions of alpha and beta chains of class II allo-MHC molecules. The results demonstrate that presentation of donor-MHC peptides by host-derived antigen-presenting cells is a common event in vivo. Thus, self-restricted T cell recognition of processed alloantigens may play a critical role in transplantation. An in-depth understanding of this response may result in the development of additional molecular therapies to combat allograft rejection.

Cellular mechanisms of allograft rejection

It is generally agreed that a multiplicity of mechanisms are involved in the rejection of various grafts across different histocompatibility barriers. Recent publications have concentrated less on the characterization of the cells involved in the rejection process and more on their initial activation and their infiltration into the graft.