Somatic hypermutation of an immunoglobulin mu heavy chain transgene

AID targeting in antibody diversity

Antibody maturation requires class switch recombination (CSR) and somatic hypermutation (SHM), both of which are initiated by activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID). AID deaminates cytosine residues resulting in mismatches that are differentially processed to produce double-strand breaks in Ig switch (S) regions that lead to CSR, or to point mutations in variable (V) exons resulting in SHM. Although AID was first thought to be Ig-specific, recent work indicates that it also targets a diverse group of non-Ig loci, including genes such as Bcl6 and c-myc, whose modification by AID results in lymphoma-associated mutations and translocations. Here, we review the recent literature on AID targeting and the role for transcriptional stalling in recruitment of this enzyme to Ig and non-Ig loci. We propose a model for AID recruitment based on transcriptional stalling, which reconciles several of the key features of SHM, CSR, and lymphoma-associated translocation.

Preferential targeting of somatic hypermutation to hotspot motifs and hypermutable sites and generation of mutational clusters in the IgVH alleles of a rheumatoid factor producing lymphoblastoid cell line

Epstein-Barr virus transforms human peripheral B cells into lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL) that secrete specific antibodies. Our previous studies showed that a monoclonal LCL that secretes a rheumatoid factor expressed activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) and displayed an ongoing process of somatic hypermutation (SHM) at a frequency of 1.7×10⁻³ mut/bp in its productively rearranged IgVH gene. The present work shows that SHM similarly affects the nonproductive IgVH allele of the same culture. Sequencing of multiple cDNA clones derived from cellular subclones of the parental culture, showed that both alleles exhibited an ongoing mutational process with mutation rates of 2-3×10⁻⁵ mut/bp×generation with a high preference for C/G transition mutations and lack of a significant strand bias. About 50% of the mutations were targeted to the underlined C/G bases in the WRCH/DGYW and RCY/RGY hotspot motifs, indicating that they were due to the initial phase of AID activity. Mutations were targeted to the VH alleles and not to the Cμ or to the GAPDH genes. Genealogical trees showed a stepwise accumulation of only 1-3 mutations per branch of the tree. Unexpectedly, 27% of all the mutations in the two alleles occurred repeatedly and independently within certain sites (not necessarily the canonical hotspot motifs) in cellular clones belonging to different branches of the lineage tree. Furthermore, some of the mutations seem to arise as recurrent mutational clusters, independently generated in different cellular clones. Statistical analysis showed that it is very unlikely that these clusters were due to random targeting of equally accessible hotspots, indicating the presence of 'hypermutable sites' that generate recurring mutational clusters in the IgVH alleles. Intrinsic hypermutable sites may enhance affinity maturation and generation of effective mutated antibody repertoires against invading pathogens.

Autoantibody-catalyzed hydrolysis of amyloid beta peptide

We describe IgM class human autoantibodies that hydrolyze amyloid beta peptide 1-40 (Abeta40). A monoclonal IgM from a patient with Waldenström's macroglobulinemia hydrolyzed Abeta40 at the Lys-28-Gly-29 bond and Lys-16-Ala-17 bonds. The catalytic activity was inhibited stoichiometrically by an electrophilic serine protease inhibitor. Treatment with the catalytic IgM blocked the aggregation and toxicity of Abeta40 in neuronal cell cultures. IgMs purified from the sera of patients with Alzheimer disease (AD) hydrolyzed Abeta40 at rates superior to IgMs from age-matched humans without dementia. IgMs from non-elderly humans expressed the least catalytic activity. The reaction rate was sufficient to afford appreciable degradation at physiological Abeta and IgM concentrations found in peripheral circulation. Increased Abeta concentrations in the AD brain are thought to induce neurodegenerative effects. Peripheral administration of Abeta binding antibodies has been suggested as a potential treatment of AD. Our results suggest that catalytic IgM autoantibodies can help clear Abeta, and they open the possibility of using catalytic Abs for AD immunotherapy.

Targeting of somatic hypermutation

Somatic hypermutation (SHM) introduces mutations in the variable region of immunoglobulin genes at a rate of approximately 10(-3) mutations per base pair per cell division, which is 10(6)-fold higher than the spontaneous mutation rate in somatic cells. To ensure genomic integrity, SHM needs to be targeted specifically to immunoglobulin genes. The rare mistargeting of SHM can result in mutations and translocations in oncogenes, and is thought to contribute to the development of B-cell malignancies. Despite years of intensive investigation, the mechanism of SHM targeting is still unclear. We review and attempt to reconcile the numerous and sometimes conflicting studies on the targeting of SHM to immunoglobulin loci, and highlight areas that hold promise for further investigation.

Elucidation of IgH intronic enhancer functions via germ-line deletion

Studies of chimeric mice demonstrated that the core Ig heavy chain (IgH) intronic enhancer (iEmu) functions in V(D)J and class switch recombination at the IgH locus. To more fully evaluate the role of this element in these and other processes, we generated mice homozygous for germ-line mutations in which the core sequences of iEmu (cEmu) were either deleted (cEmu(Delta/Delta) mice) or replaced with a pgk-Neo(R) cassette (cEmu(N/N) mice). The cEmu(Delta/Delta) mice had reduced B cell numbers, in association with impaired D to J(H) and V(H) to DJ(H) rearrangement, whereas cEmu(N/N) mice had a complete block in IgH V(D)J(H) recombination, confirming that additional cis elements cooperate with iEmu to enforce D to J(H) recombination. In addition, developing cEmu(Delta/Delta) and cEmu(N/N) B lineage cells had correspondingly decreased levels of germ-line transcripts from the J(H) region of the IgH locus (mu0 and Imu transcripts); although both had normal levels of germ-line V(H) transcripts, suggesting that cEmu may influence IgH locus V(D)J recombination by influencing accessibility of J(H) proximal regions of the locus. Consistent with chimera studies, peripheral cEmu(Delta/Delta) B cells had normal surface Ig and relatively normal class switch recombination. However, cEmu(Delta/Delta) B cells also had relatively normal somatic hypermutation of their IgH variable region genes, showing unexpectedly that the cEmu is not required for this process. The availability of mice with the iEmu mutation in their germ line will facilitate future studies to elucidate the roles of iEmu in V(H)(D)J(H) recombination in the context of IgH chromatin structure and germ-line transcription.

Hypothesis: biological role for J-C intronic matrix attachment regions in the molecular mechanism of antigen-driven somatic hypermutation

A major function of J-C intronic matrix attachment regions (MAR) during immune diversification via somatic hypermutation (SHM) at immunoglobulin loci may be to manipulate the topology of DNA within the upstream target domain. The suggestion that SHM induction requires MAR-induced torsional strain, in conjunction with DNA remodelling at the J-C intron, completes the definition of a cogent paradigm within which all extant molecular data on the issue may be interpreted. Moreover, the suggestion that a mutagenic mechanism relieves MAR-generated superhelicity could provide an indication as to the evolutionary basis of SHM.

Antibody class switch recombination: roles for switch sequences and mismatch repair proteins

Mechanisms and targeting of antibody class switch DNA recombination are reviewed. Particular emphasis is on the roles for the DNA sequences comprising switch (S) regions, including the S-region tandem repeats, and on the roles of proteins that are involved in both DNA mismatch repair and in class switch recombination.

The immunoglobulin heavy-chain locus hs3b and hs4 3' enhancers are dispensable for VDJ assembly and somatic hypermutation

The more distal enhancers of the immunoglobulin heavy-chain 3' regulatory region, hs3b and hs4, were recently demonstrated as master control elements of germline transcription and class switch recombination to most immunoglobulin constant genes. In addition, they were shown to enhance the accumulation of somatic mutations on linked transgenes. Since somatic hypermutation and class switch recombination are tightly linked processes, their common dependency on the endogenous locus 3' enhancers could be an attractive hypothesis. VDJ structure and somatic hypermutation were analyzed in B cells from mice carrying either a heterozygous or a homozygous deletion of these enhancers. We find that hs3b and hs4 are dispensable both for VDJ assembly and for the occurrence of mutations at a physiologic frequency in the endogenous locus. In addition, we show that cells functionally expressing the immunoglobulin M (IgM) class B-cell receptor encoded by an hs3b/hs4-deficient locus were fully able to enter germinal centers, undergo affinity maturation, and yield specific antibody responses in homozygous mutant mice, where IgG1 antibodies compensated for the defect in other IgG isotypes. By contrast, analysis of Peyer patches from heterozygous animals showed that peanut agglutinin (PNAhigh) B cells functionally expressing the hs3b/hs4-deficient allele were dramatically outclassed by B cells expressing the wild-type locus and normally switching to IgA. This study thus also highlights the role of germinal centers in the competition between B cells for affinity maturation and suggests that membrane IgA may promote recruitment in an activated B-cell compartment, or proliferation of activated B cells, more efficiently than IgM in Peyer patches.

Somatic translocation and differential expression of Ig mu transgene copies implicate a role for the Igh locus in memory B cell development

Memory B cells of mice with Ig mu transgenes often carry transgene copies that have moved into the Igh locus via somatic translocation. This phenomenon has been attributed to a selection pressure for somatic hypermutations, which generally are observed at much higher frequencies in translocated copies than in ectopic copies. We tested this idea by immunizing Ig-mu transgenic mice in a manner designed to select B cells that required only one V(H) mutation for a switch in antigenic specificity and recruitment into the memory pool. Despite the minimal mutation requirement, hybridomas carrying somatic translocations to the Igh locus were obtained. Importantly, this occurred despite the fact that translocated and untranslocated mu-transgenes were mutated comparably. Evidently, a strong selection advantage was conferred upon B cells by the somatic translocations. Among the hybridomas, translocated mu-transgenes were active, while ectopic mu-transgenes were uniformly silent. The translocated copy that had conferred an affinity-based selection advantage was expressed at the highest level. Moreover, translocated copies were differentially expressed among hybridoma members, which belonged to a common post-mutational lineage. This suggests that adjustments in transgene expression levels had occurred during memory cell development. These results indicate that, apart from their potential influences on somatic hypermutagenesis and class switch recombination, elements in the Igh locus promote the selection of memory B cells in another way, possibly by regulating the level of Ig expression at various stages of antigen-driven differentiation.

B cell selection and affinity maturation during an antibody response in the mouse with limited B cell diversity

The quasi-monoclonal mouse has limited B cell diversity, whose major (approximately 80%) B cell Ag receptors are comprised of the knockin V(H) 17.2.25 (V(H)T)-encoded H chain and the lambda1 or lambda2 L chain, thereby being specific for 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenylacetyl. The p-nitrophenylacetyl (pNP) was found to be a low affinity analog of nitrophenylacetyl. We examined affinity maturation of anti-pNP IgG by analyzing mAbs obtained from quasi-monoclonal mice that were immunized with this low affinity Ag. The results are: 1) Although V(H)T/lambda1 and V(H)T/lambda2 IgM were equally produced, V(H)T/lambda2 IgG almost exclusively underwent affinity maturation toward pNP. 2) A common mutation in complementarity-determining region 3 of V(H)T (T313A) mainly contributed to generating the specificity for pNP. 3) Because mutated V(H)T-encoded gamma-chains could form lambda1-bearing IgG in Chinese hamster ovary cells, apparent absence of V(H)T/lambda1 anti-pNP IgG may not be due to the incompatibility between the gamma-chains and the lambda1-chain, but may be explained by the fact that V(H)T/lambda1 B cells showed 50- to 100-fold lower affinity for pNP than V(H)T/lambda2 B cells. 4) Interestingly, a pNP-specific IgM mAb that shared common mutations including T313A with high affinity anti-pNP IgG was isolated, suggesting that a part of hypermutation coupled with positive selection can occur before isotype switching. Thus, even weak B cell receptor engagement can elicit an IgM response, whereas only B cells that received signals stronger than a threshold may be committed to an affinity maturation process.

Gene conversion-like sequence transfers between transgenic antibody V genes are independent of RAD54

Homology-based Ig gene conversion is a major mechanism for Ab diversification in chickens and the Rad54 DNA repair protein plays an important role in this process. In mice, although gene conversion appears to be rare among endogenous Ig genes, Ab H chain transgenes undergo isotype switching and gene conversion-like sequence transfer processes that also appear to involve homologous recombination or gene conversion. Furthermore, homology-based DNA repair has been suggested to be important for somatic mutation of endogenous mouse Ig genes. To assess the role of Rad54 in these mouse B cell processes, we have analyzed H chain transgene isotype switching, sequence transfer, and somatic hypermutation in mice that lack RAD54. We find that Rad54 is not required for either transgene switching or transgene hypermutation. Furthermore, even transgene sequence transfers that are known to require homology-based recombinations are Rad54 independent. These results indicate that mouse B cells must use factors for promoting homologous recombination that are distinct from the Rad54 proteins important in homology-based chicken Ab gene recombinations. Our findings also suggest that mouse H chain transgene sequence transfers might be more closely related to an error-prone homology-based somatic hypermutational mechanism than to the hyperconversion mechanism that operates in chicken B cells.

The different process of class switching and somatic hypermutation; a novel analysis by CD27(-) naive B cells

The relationship between class switch recombination (CSR) and somatic hypermutation has been unclear. By using human CD27(-) naive B cells, we investigated the somatic hypermutation and producibility of immunoglobulins (Igs) that occur after CSR. Although neither adult CD27(-) nor cord blood B cells, which showed the unmutated Ig V-region genes, produced IgG, IgM, or IgA in response to conventional stimuli, they produced IgG and IgM but not IgA in the presence of Staphylococcus aureus Cowan strain (SAC) + interleukin-2 (IL-2) + IL-10 + anti-CD40 mAb + CD32 transfectants (CD40/CD32T). The naive B cells also produced IgE when combined with IL-4 + CD40/CD32T. In parallel with IgG production, the expression of mature gamma1 and gamma 2 transcripts was induced from naive B cells by the stimuli. The CD27 expression on human naive B cells was induced remarkably by CD40 signaling or B-cell receptor engagement, but somatic hypermutation could not be induced. The proliferation and differentiation into plasma cells were induced from naive B cells, whereas most of the plasma cells displayed very low levels of mutations in Ig V-region genes. CD27(-) naive B cells expressed activation-induced cytidine deaminase messenger RNA by the stimuli later than CD27(+) memory B cells. Our results demonstrate that CSR, but not noticeable somatic hypermutation, can be induced from CD27(-) naive B cells upon B-cell receptor engagement and CD40 signaling in cooperation with cytokines, suggesting that CSR and somatic hypermutation processes can occur independently, and the antibodies produced in this in vitro system are low-affinity antibodies.

Mechanism and control of class-switch recombination

Class-switch recombination (CSR) occurs by an unusual and intriguing mechanism that has not been clearly elucidated as yet. Currently, we know that this mechanism involves recombination between large and highly repetitive switch (S) regions, is targeted by S-region transcription and requires the activity of the newly discovered activation-induced deaminase (AID). In this review, we discuss the potential role of these factors in CSR, discuss potential relationships between CSR and somatic hypermutation, and speculate how CSR and related mechanisms might contribute to genomic instability.

Gene conversion-like sequence transfers in a mouse antibody transgene: antigen selection allows sensitive detection of V region interactions based on homology

Gene conversion is important for antibody diversification in chickens, rabbits and cows. In mice, however, conversion events appear to be infrequent among endogenous antibody genes. DNA sequence transfer events that resemble gene conversions have been reported for a mouse H chain transgene (VVC(mu)) that contains two closely spaced homologous VDJ segments. Surprisingly, these reported VVC(mu) sequence transfers were found frequently among mouse B cells responding to immunization. Transgene sequence transfers could be occurring at high frequency in responding VVC(mu) B cells or could be occurring at lower frequency with subsequent amplification by preferential antigen selection. To distinguish these possibilities, we have analyzed a second transgene (InVVC(mu)) that is identical to VVC(mu) except that the two VDJ regions have been exchanged in position. We find that transgene sequence transfers are much less frequent among responding B cells in InVVC(mu) mice, demonstrating the importance of selection in the frequent transgene conversions observed in VVC(mu) mice. These results suggest that mice, like other species, can use gene conversion to diversify antibodies. Such diversification events are apparently infrequent, however, and might only be detected among endogenous Ig genes with a favorable arrangement of V genes and an antigenic stimulation that selects cells with conversions. For both VVC(mu) and InVVC(mu) mice, conversion-like sequence transfers are strongly correlated with somatic hypermutation. Based on these results, we hypothesize that, in mice, gene conversions represent infrequent alternative reactions of a homology-based DNA repair process that is central in the somatic hypermutational mechanism.

A hallmark of active class switch recombination: transcripts directed by I promoters on looped-out circular DNAs

To specify when and where Ig class switch recombination (CSR) takes place, a good molecular marker closely associated with active CSR is required. CSR is accompanied by deletion of circular DNA from the Ig heavy chain locus. The circular DNA contains a DNA segment between Smu and a target S region including its I promoter, which is driven by specific cytokine stimulation before CSR. We found that the specific I promoter is still active in looped-out circular DNA and directs production of I-Cmu transcripts termed "circle transcripts." Reverse transcription-PCR demonstrated transient induction of specific circle transcripts upon CSR in a murine lymphoma cell line, CH12F3-2A, as well as spleen B cells. Production of the circle transcripts appeared to depend on expression of activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), an essential factor for CSR. A comparison of kinetics between circle transcripts and circular DNA showed more rapid disappearance of circle transcripts. Thus, circle transcripts may serve as a hallmark for active CSR in vitro and in vivo.

A pivotal role for DNase I-sensitive regions 3b and/or 4 in the induction of somatic hypermutation of IgH genes

Chimeric mice were prepared from embryonic stem cells transfected with IgH genes as transgenes and RAG-2-deficient blastocysts for the purpose of identifying the cis-acting elements responsible for the induction of somatic hypermutation. Among the three transgene constructs used, the V(H) promoter, the rearranged V(H)-D-J(H), an intron enhancer/matrix attachment region, and human Cmu were common to all, but the 3'-untranslated region in each construct was different. After immunization of mice with a T cell-dependent Ag, the distribution and frequency of hypermutation in transgenes were analyzed. The transgene lacking the 3' untranslated region showed a marginal degree of hypermutation. Addition of the 3' enhancer resulted in a slight increase in the number of mutations. However, the transgene containing DNase I-sensitive regions 3b and 4 in addition to the 3' enhancer showed more than a 10-fold increase in hypermutation, reaching levels comparable to those observed in endogenous V(H)186.2 genes of C57BL/6 mice.

Linking class-switch recombination with somatic hypermutation

The recent discovery of a molecular link between two apparently different genetic alteration events--class-switch recombination and somatic hypermutation--has led to the idea that the recognition and cleavage of target DNA in these two events might be mediated by similar or identical molecules to those involved in RNA editing. This could mean that the complexity of mammalian genetic information may be enriched by an interplay between RNA editing and DNA modification.

Class switch recombination and hypermutation require activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), a potential RNA editing enzyme

Induced overexpression of AID in CH12F3-2 B lymphoma cells augmented class switching from IgM to IgA without cytokine stimulation. AID deficiency caused a complete defect in class switching and showed a hyper-IgM phenotype with enlarged germinal centers containing strongly activated B cells before or after immunization. AID-/- spleen cells stimulated in vitro with LPS and cytokines failed to undergo class switch recombination although they expressed germline transcripts. Immunization of AID-/- chimera with 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenylacetyl (NP) chicken gamma-globulin induced neither accumulation of mutations in the NP-specific variable region gene nor class switching. These results suggest that AID may be involved in regulation or catalysis of the DNA modification step of both class switching and somatic hypermutation.

Predicting Regional Mutability in Antibody V Genes Based Solely on Di- and Trinucleotide Sequence Composition

Somatic mutations are not distributed randomly throughout Ab V region genes. A sequence-specific target bias is revealed by a defined hierarchy of mutability among di- and trinucleotide sequences located within Ig intronic DNA. Here we report that the di- and trinucleotide mutability preference pattern is shared by mouse intronic JH and Jκ clusters and by human VH genes, suggesting that a common mutation mechanism exists for all Ig V genes of both species. Using di- and trinucleotide target preferences, we performed a comprehensive analysis of human and murine germline V genes to predict regional mutabilities. Heavy chain genes of both species exhibit indistinguishable patterns in which complementarity-determining region 1 (CDR1), CDR2, and framework region 3 (FR3) are predicted to be more mutable than FR1 and FR2. This prediction is borne out by empirical mutation data from nonproductively rearranged human VH genes. Analysis of light chain genes in both species also revealed a common, but unexpected, pattern in which FR2 is predicted to be highly mutable. While our analyses of nonfunctional Ig genes accurately predicts regional mutation preferences in VH genes, observed relative mutability differences between regions are more extreme than expected. This cannot be readily accounted for by nascent mRNA secondary structure or by a supplemental gene conversion mechanism that might favor nucleotide replacements in CDR. Collectively, our data support the concept of a common mutation mechanism for heavy and light chain genes of mice and humans with regional bias that is qualitatively, but not quantitatively, accounted for by short nucleotide sequence composition.

Induction of Ig Somatic Hypermutation and Class Switching in a Human Monoclonal IgM+ IgD+ B Cell Line In Vitro: Definition of the Requirements and Modalities of Hypermutation

Partly because of the lack of a suitable in vitro model, the trigger(s) and the mechanism(s) of somatic hypermutation in Ig genes are largely unknown. We have analyzed the hypermutation potential of human CL-01 lymphocytes, our monoclonal model of germinal center B cell differentiation. These cells are surface IgM+ IgD+ and, in the absence of T cells, switch to IgG, IgA, and IgE in response to CD40:CD40 ligand engagement and exposure to appropriate cytokines. We show here that CL-01 cells can be induced to effectively mutate the expressed VHDJH-Cμ, VHDJH-Cδ, VHDJH-Cγ, VHDJH-Cα, VHDJH-Cε, and VλJλ-Cλ transcripts before and after Ig class switching in a stepwise fashion. In these cells, induction of somatic mutations required cross-linking of the surface receptor for Ag and T cell contact through CD40:CD40 ligand and CD80:CD28 coengagement. The induced mutations showed intrinsic features of Ig V(D)J hypermutation in that they comprised 110 base substitutions (97 in the heavy chain and 13 in the λ-chain) and only 2 deletions and targeted V(D)J, virtually sparing CH and Cλ. These mutations were more abundant in secondary VHDJH-Cγ than primary VHDJH-Cμ transcripts and in V(D)J-C than VλJλ-Cλ transcripts. These mutations were also associated with coding DNA strand polarity and showed an overall rate of 2.42 × 10−4 base changes/cell division in VHDJH-CH transcripts. Transitions were favored over transversions, and G nucleotides were preferentially targeted, mainly in the context of AG dinucleotides. Thus, in CL-01 cells, Ig somatic hypermutation is readily inducible by stimuli different from those required for class switching and displays discrete base substitution modalities.

Induction of Ig somatic hypermutation and class switching in a human monoclonal IgM+ IgD+ B cell line in vitro: definition of the requirements and modalities of hypermutation

Partly because of the lack of a suitable in vitro model, the trigger(s) and the mechanism(s) of somatic hypermutation in Ig genes are largely unknown. We have analyzed the hypermutation potential of human CL-01 lymphocytes, our monoclonal model of germinal center B cell differentiation. These cells are surface IgM+ IgD+ and, in the absence of T cells, switch to IgG, IgA, and IgE in response to CD40:CD40 ligand engagement and exposure to appropriate cytokines. We show here that CL-01 cells can be induced to effectively mutate the expressed VHDJH-C mu, VHDJH-C delta, VHDJH-C gamma, VHDJH-C alpha, VHDJH-C epsilon, and V lambda J lambda-C lambda transcripts before and after Ig class switching in a stepwise fashion. In these cells, induction of somatic mutations required cross-linking of the surface receptor for Ag and T cell contact through CD40:CD40 ligand and CD80: CD28 coengagement. The induced mutations showed intrinsic features of Ig V(D)J hypermutation in that they comprised 110 base substitutions (97 in the heavy chain and 13 in the lambda-chain) and only 2 deletions and targeted V(D)J, virtually sparing CH and C lambda. These mutations were more abundant in secondary VHDJH-C gamma than primary VHDJH-C mu transcripts and in V(D)J-C than V lambda J lambda-C lambda transcripts. These mutations were also associated with coding DNA strand polarity and showed an overall rate of 2.42 x 10(-4) base changes/cell division in VHDJH-CH transcripts. Transitions were favored over transversions, and G nucleotides were preferentially targeted, mainly in the context of AG dinucleotides. Thus, in CL-01 cells, Ig somatic hypermutation is readily inducible by stimuli different from those required for class switching and displays discrete base substitution modalities.

Deletion of a Recombined Ig Heavy Chain Transgene in B-Lineage Cells of Transgenic Mice

Fully recombined transgenes are stable in their transmission in the germline of transgenic mice, in common with the endogenous genetic complement of most mammalian somatic tissues, including the genes for lymphoid Ag receptors somatically generated from germline minigenes. There have, however, been isolated reports of unusual low frequency transgene losses in various transgenic mice. Here we show, using Southern blots and PCR-based assays, that plasmablast hybridomas and B cells from three independently derived founder lines of transgenic mice bearing a recombined heavy chain Ig transgene we have been studying show a significant net loss of transgene copies. This loss is more marked in the B cells expressing endogenous heavy chains than in those expressing transgenic heavy chains. We have also examined cells of the B lineage in the bone marrow, and a small degree of deletion is also evident in CD19+CD23−IgM− immature B-lineage cells. As greater deletion is observed in mature B cells, it is possible that the deletion process either continues into B cell maturity and/or provides a selective advantage. We have investigated the relationship between transgene expression and deletion, and we find that while thymocytes in these mice express the transgene well, T cell hybridomas derived from transgenic thymus do not show any loss of the transgene. Thus, a recombined Ig heavy chain transgene prominently undergoes somatic deletion in B-lineage cells independent of its insertion site or expression. This transgenic instability is significant to the analysis of genomic stability as well as to the design of gene therapy strategies.

A unifying hypothesis for the molecular mechanism of somatic mutation and gene conversion in rearranged immunoglobulin variable genes

We have reviewed available data concerning the mechanism of somatic hypermutation in rearranged variable genes of Ig in B lymphocytes of mice and the gene conversion process which generates diversity in these genes in the B lymphocytes of chickens. In our view, these data are consistent with a unifying hypothesis of diversity generating mechanisms involving reverse transcription to produce cDNA from RNA transcripts followed by homologous recombination into chromosomal DNA. Thus, seemingly different processes in the mouse and chicken may have a common molecular basis.

Monitoring and interpreting the intrinsic features of somatic hypermutation

We have used both normal and transgenic mice to analyse the recruitment and targeting of somatic hypermutation to the immunoglobulin loci. We compare methods for analysing hypermutation and discuss how large databases of mutations can be assembled by PCR amplification of the rearranged V-gene flanks from the germinal centre B cells of normal mice as well as by transgene-specific amplification from transgenic B cells. Such studies confirm that hypermutation is preferentially targeted to the immunoglobulin V gene with the bcl6 gene, for example, escaping this intense mutational targeting in germinal centre B cells. We review our data concerning the nature of the hypermutation domain and the targeting of hotspots within that domain. We consider how enhancer-mediated recruitment of hypermutation to the immunoglobulin loci operates in a clonally maintained fashion and illustrate how both the degree of expression and demethylation of the transgene broadly correlate with its mutability.

Cis-acting sequences that affect somatic hypermutation of Ig genes

We review our studies on the mechanism of somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes. Most experiments were carried out using Ig transgenes. We showed in these experiments that all required cis-acting elements are present within the 10-16 kb of a transgene. Only the Ig variable region and its proximate flanks are mutated, not the constant region. Several Ig gene enhancers are permissive for somatic mutation. Association of the enhancer with its natural Ig promoter is not necessary. However, the mutation process seems specific for Ig genes. No mutations were found in housekeeping genes from cells with high levels of somatic hypermutation of their Ig genes. The Ig enhancers may provide the Ig gene specificity. An exception may be the BCL6 gene, which was mutated in human but not in mouse B cells. Transcription of a region is required for its mutability. When the transcriptional promoter located upstream of the variable region is duplicated upstream of the constant region, this region also becomes mutable. This suggests a model in which a mutator factor associates with the RNA polymerase at the promoter, travels with the polymerase during elongation, and causes mutations during polymerase pausing. The DNA repair systems, nucleotide excision repair and DNA mismatch repair, are not required. Our recent data with an artificial substrate of somatic mutation suggest that pausing may be due to secondary structure of the DNA or nascent RNA, and the specific mutations to preferences of the mutator factor.

Somatic hypermutation in mouse lambda chains

The frequency and distribution of somatic hypermutation in immunoglobulin genes and the effect of amino acid substitution on the structure/function of antibodies were studied using hybridomas that secrete anti-(4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) monoclonal antibodies bearing lambda 1 chains. A high frequency of mutation was observed in V-J exons and J-C introns of rearranged and active lambda 1 chains but not in the 5'-non-coding regions of these chains. Since a similar distribution was observed in inactive lambda 2 chain genes, 5'-non-coding regions containing a promoter were considered to be protected from mutation in view of their apparent importance. Using transgenic mice carrying chloramphenicol acetyl transferase transgenes driven by the VH promoter and heavy-chain intron enhancer, it was also revealed that these cis-acting elements are important in the induction of somatic hypermutation and are capable of inducing mutation even in non-immunoglobulin genes. Affinity of anti-NP Abs to NP increased with time after immunization to approximately 8,000-fold (affinity maturation); however, fine specificity, such as heteroclicity, remained unchanged. Memory B cells, which are responsible for affinity maturation, were analyzed in terms of the mutation from Trp to Leu at position 33, a change known to raise affinity about 10-fold and considered to be a memory B-cell marker. These cells were found predominantly in the early stage (2-3-week) hybridomas but rarely in late stage (> 12-week) ones, suggesting that a dynamic change in the memory B-cell population occurs during the immunization process.

The signature of somatic hypermutation appears to be written into the germline IgV segment repertoire

We present here a unifying hypothesis for the molecular mechanism of somatic hypermutation and somatic gene conversion in IgV genes involving reverse transcription using RNA templates from the V-gene loci to produce cDNA which undergoes homologous recombination with chromosomal V(D)J DNA. Experimental evidence produced over the last 20 years is essentially consistent with this hypothesis. We also review evidence suggesting that somatically generated IgV sequences from B lymphocytes have been fed back to germline DNA over evolutionary time.

Immunoglobulin hypermutation in cultured cells

Studies of endogenous and engineered Ig genes in mice have begun to reveal some of the cis-acting regions that are involved in the somatic hypermutation of variable regions in vivo. These studies suggest that the initiation of transcription plays a role in this process. However, it will be difficult to identify and manipulate the individual genetic elements and the trans-acting proteins that regulate and target the mutational events using solely in vivo assays. These studies would be greatly facilitated if constructs containing the genetic elements that are essential for V-region mutation could be transfected into cultured cells and undergo high rates of V-region mutation in vitro, and if permissive and non-permissive cell lines could be identified. Such in vitro systems would also allow a detailed molecular and biochemical analysis of this process. Here, we discuss some of the in vitro systems that have been developed and use data from our own studies in cultured cells to illustrate the potential benefits of studying V-region hypermutation in model in vitro systems.

The roles of antibody variable region hypermutation and selection in the development of the memory B-cell compartment

Somatic hypermutation and selection of immunoglobulin (Ig) variable (V)-region genes, working in concert, appear to be essential for memory B-cell development in mammals. There has been substantial progress on the nature of the cis-acting DNA elements that regulate hypermutation. The data obtained suggest that the mechanisms of Ig gene hypermutation and transcription are intimately intertwined. While it has long been appreciated that stringent phenotypic selection forces are imposed on the somatically mutated Ig V regions generated during a T-cell dependent B-cell response, the mechanisms involved in this selection have remained enigmatic. Our studies have questioned the role of foreign antigen deposited on follicular dendritic cells in affinity-based positive selection of V regions, and have shown that this selection takes place in a "clone-autonomous" fashion. In addition, our data strongly suggest that affinity for antigen alone is not the driving force for selection of B-cell clones into the memory compartment. In contrast, we suggest that a combination of positive selection for increased foreign antigen binding, and negative selection of antibody V regions that are autoreactive at the onset of the response, or have acquired autoreactivity via hypermutation, results in the "specificity maturation" of the memory B-cell response.

Multiple sequences from downstream of the J kappa cluster can combine to recruit somatic hypermutation to a heterologous, upstream mutation domain

Recruitment of somatic hypermutation to the Ig kappa locus has previously been shown to depend on the enhancer elements, Ei/MAR and E3'. Here we show that these elements are not sufficient to confer mutability. However, hypermutation is effectively targeted to a chimeric beta-globin/Ig kappa transgene whose 5' end is composed of the human beta-globin gene (promoter and first two exons) and whose 3' end consists of selected sequences derived from downstream of the J kappa cluster (Ei/MAR, C kappa + flank and E3'). Thus, multiple downstream Ig kappa sequences (all derived from 3' of the J kappa cluster) can combine to recruit mutation to a heterologous mutation domain. The location of this hypermutation domain is defined by the position of the transcription start site and this applies even if the Ig kappa Ei/MAR is positioned upstream of the promoter. Hotspots within the mutation domain are, however, defined by local DNA sequence as evidenced by a new hotspot being created within the beta-globin domain by a mutation within the transgene. We propose that multiple, moveable Ig kappa sequences (that are normally located downstream of the transcription start site) cooperate to bring a hypermutation priming factor to the transcription initiation complex; a mutation domain is thereby created downstream of the promoter but the local sequence defines the detailed pattern of mutation within that domain.

Somatic transgene immunization with DNA encoding an immunoglobulin heavy chain

A plasmid DNA containing a chimeric immunoglobulin heavy-chain gene with tissue-specific promoter and enhancer elements was used as a model system to study the events triggered by a single intraspleen DNA inoculation in adult C57Bl/6 mice. A single intraspleen inoculation was followed in a week by secretion of transgene immunoglobulins and production of immunoglobulin M (IgM) anti-immunoglobulins. Their kinetics of serum appearance were almost superimposable. While anti-immunoglobulin antibodies remained detectable for over 6 months, transgene immunoglobulins disappeared after 3-4 weeks. However, transgene mRNA was detected in the spleen for 4 months. A multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis on splenic genomic DNA 17 days after inoculation demonstrated that the transgene was integrated in the host chromosomal DNA. The nucleotide sequence of the rearranged VDJ region from splenic genomic DNA was identical to that of the parental plasmid DNA, hence ruling out that hypermutation had occurred. A booster injection of immunoglobulin encoded by the transgene on day 200 elicited a typical secondary immune response with IgG1 and IgG2b antibodies. These results demonstrate that a single inoculation of an immunoglobulin heavy-chain DNA targeted to spleen lymphocytes leads to spontaneous integration of the transgene into the host DNA, and that this is sufficient to initiate immunity and establish immunologic memory. Our data also show that minute amounts (<100 ng/ml) of an endogenously produced protein secreted in the microenvironment of a lymphoid tissue generate immunity and establish immunologic memory rather than tolerance.

Insertion of 2 kb of bacteriophage DNA between an immunoglobulin promoter and leader exon stops somatic hypermutation in a kappa transgene

Somatic hypermutation in rearranged immunoglobulin variable genes occurs in a 2kb region of DNA that is delimited on the 5' side by the promoter and on the 3' side by intron DNA. To identify sequence features that activate the mutation mechanism, we increased the distance between the promoter and the leader region to test whether the spacing of these elements was important. The promoter was separated from the leader sequence by inserting a 2 kb fragment of noncoding bacteriophage lambda DNA between the TATA box and ATG initiator codon in a kappa transgene. Mice from three founder lines were immunized, RNA and DNA were isolated from spleen and Peyer's patch B cells, and transcription of the transgene was confirmed. The frequency of mutation in endogenous heavy chain genes was high, indicating that some B cells underwent hypermutation. However, no hypermutation was found in the transgenic bacteriophage or variable region sequences. Hypermutation did occur in another kappa transgene that had a deletion of the VJ coding sequence, showing that the basic construct is functional and that the VJ exon is not necessary for the mutation mechanism. It is likely that the bacteriophage sequence is a potential substrate for mutation because other heterologous sequences have been shown to undergo mutation if placed downstream of the leader exon. The results suggest that the promoter should be contiguous with the leader exon for the mutation mechanism to function.

Evaluation of the role of the 3'alpha heavy chain enhancer [3'alpha E(hs1,2)] in Vh gene somatic hypermutation

Previous work on the cis-acting elements that control heavy chain variable region (VH) gene somatic hypermutation has indicated the presence of an as yet unidentified element(s) 3' of the intron enhancer that is necessary for high rate mutation. Examination of cis-acting elements involved in kappa light chain V gene hypermutation has demonstrated a requirement for both the intronic and 3' kappa enhancers in this process. To examine whether the 3'alpha heavy chain enhancer [3'alpha E(hs1,2)] is required for somatic hypermutation of VH genes, we generated two types of transgenic mice. One type was generated using a construct containing a VH promoter, a rearranged VDJ, the heavy chain intronic enhancer, and the murine heavy chain 3'alpha E(hs1,2). The transgenes in the second lines were similar to the transgenes in the first with the addition of a second complete matrix attachment region (MAR) 3' of the heavy chain intronic enhancer, and splice acceptor and polyadenylation sites between the two enhancers. Analysis of both transgenes revealed levels of mutation at least 10-fold lower than endogenous VH genes. These data suggest that the 3'alpha E(hs1,2) does not play a role analogous to the 3' kappa enhancer in the regulation of the hypermutation process. Moreover, in one of the transgenes, the presence of the 3'alpha E(hs1,2) resulted in a lack of transcription in vivo, suggesting a negative regulatory role for this enhancer in certain contexts.

Mechanism of antigen-driven somatic hypermutation of rearranged immunoglobulin V(D)J genes in the mouse

Available data relevant to the mechanism of somatic hypermutation have been critically evaluated in the context of alternative models: (i) error-generating reverse transcription (RT) followed by homologous recombination; and (ii) error-prone DNA replication/repair. A set of basic principles concerning somatic hypermutation has also been formulated and a revised and expanded "RT-Mutatorsome" concept (analogous to telomerase) is presented which is consistent with these principles and all data on the distribution of somatic mutations in normal and Ig transgenic mice carrying particular V(D)J and flanking region constructs. It is predicted that in the mouse VH and Vk loci. the J-C intronic Enhancer-Nuclear Matrix Attachment Region (Ei/MAR) contains a unique sequence motif or secondary structure which ensures that only V(D)J sequences mutate whilst other regions of the genome are not mutated.

The transcriptional promoter regulates hypermutation of the antibody heavy chain locus

A somatic process introduces mutations into antibody variable (V) region genes at a high rate in many vertebrates, and is a major source of antibody diversity. The mechanism of this hypermutation process remains enigmatic, although retrospective studies and transgenic experiments have recently suggested a role for transcriptional regulatory elements. Here, we demonstrate that mouse heavy (H) chain loci in which the natural VH promoter has been replaced by a heterologous promoter undergo hypermutation. However, while the distribution of mutation in such loci appears normal, the frequency of mutation does not. Conversely, moving the VH promoter 750 bp upstream of its normal location results in a commensurate change in the site specificity of hypermutation in H chain loci, and the foreign DNA inserted into the VH leader intron to produce this promoter displacement is hypermutated in a manner indistinguishable from natural Ig DNA. These data establish a direct mechanistic link between the IgH transcription and hypermutation processes.

Strategies for expressing human antibody repertoires in transgenic mice

Repertoires of human antibodies can be created in transgenic mice carrying human immunoglobulin-gene loci in germline configuration. These 'transloci', introduced either as miniloci or as almost locus-sized regions, undergo rearrangement and hypermutation in mouse lymphoid tissue. Here, Marianne Brüggemann and Michael Neuberger review the use of such mice for raising antigen-specific human monoclonal antibodies, as well as their exploitation for studying regulatory aspects of antibody repertoire formation.

Differential V region mutation of two transfected Ig genes and their interaction in cultured B cell lines

We have established B cell culture systems in which transfected and stably integrated Ig constructs spontaneously undergo high rates of variable (V) region mutation. Mutation rates were determined using reversion analysis of an Ig V region nonsense codon (Vn). A construct (Vn/gamma2a) in which a Vn was associated with the gamma2a constant region and its intervening and immediate flanking sequences mutated at a high rate of 2.2 x 10(-4)/bp/generation in the NSO myeloma cell line. This same Vn, when associated with the mu constant region (Vn/mu), mutated at a 1000-fold lower rate in NSO. The Vn/gamma2a construct also mutated at high rates in the 18.81 pre-B and the S107 myeloma cell lines and at a low rate in the J558 myeloma cell line. In NSO, the presence of the gamma2a construct raised the mutation rate of the mu construct and the mu decreased the mutation rate of gamma2a. These results suggest that there is both positive and negative regulation of V region mutation and that different cell lines express different combinations and/or amounts of trans-acting factors that are involved in the mutational process.

Analysis of hypermutation in immunoglobulin heavy chain passenger transgenes

Somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin (Ig) genes plays a critical role in the maturation of the human antibody response. The molecular basis of this important process is, however, unknown. To identify cis-acting sequences that initiate and target hypermutation, we have made three minitransgenes containing different portions of an Ig heavy chain (IgH) locus. Each transgene is a passenger, bearing a nonsense mutation preventing its translation; thus, transgene mutations reflect the endogenous mutational process and are not subject to affinity selection. To study transgenes after their circulation through the compartment associated with hypermutation in vivo, we rescued B cells as hybridomas after hyperimmunizing mice with the hapten 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl (NP). Hybridoma transgene and endogenous variable regions were amplified by polymerase chain reaction, subcloned, and sequenced. Endogenous anti-NP VDJ regions show the expected, at times extensive degree of base substitution. In mice bearing the smallest construct, which includes 2.4 kb of 5' IgH sequences, a rearranged VDJ region, the 5' matrix attachment region, and the intron enhancer, one of four evaluable hybridomas demonstrates two base substitutions in the V segment of one transgene copy. The two larger constructs include additional 3' IgH sequences (an alpha constant region and the 3' enhancer) and either the original VDJ segment or a substituted T cell receptor beta segment. Ten hybridomas derived from mice bearing these larger constructs demonstrate no evidence of targeted mutation, despite demonstrable transgene transcription in all hybridomas. In our system, mutation of a rearranged VDJ segment and surrounding promoter/enhancer regions is not increased by the juxtaposition of a constant region segment and the IgH 3' enhancer.

Amplification of genes, single transcripts and cDNA libraries from one cell and direct sequence analysis of amplified products derived from one molecule

We report a procedure to generate and amplify cDNA libraries and to amplify and sequence genes and single RNA transcript molecules from the same cell without cloning. An absence of cloning steps minimizes potential sources of contamination, which can be especially problematic when working at the single cell level. Potential contamination is further reduced by an absence of any purification step prior to PCR amplification. Amplifications are designed to minimize the production of aberrant molecules in favor of full-length products, which is especially advantageous when generating cDNA libraries. Genes are amplified from isolated single nuclei, which are segregated from cytoplasmic lysates by microcentrifugation. Specific cDNA, total cDNA or both are synthesized from aliquots of the cytoplasmic lysate, and single cDNA molecules are isolated from others of the same species by limiting dilution prior to PCR amplification. In this way, the frequency of amplified products provides for a direct calculation of cDNA copy number by a Poisson analysis. Incorporation errors by Taq DNA polymerase occur at a low frequency and can be eliminated by sequencing independently amplified cDNA molecules from the same cell. Single molecule amplifications provide sufficient material for numerous (approximately 150) direct DNA sequencing reactions. The limiting dilution approach also permits sequence information to be obtained from a single cDNA, when highly related transcripts derived from distinct genes are present in the same cell and simultaneously amplified with the same primers. In sum, this method provides for a maximum amount of nucleic acid information to be extracted from one cell. It has a wide range of applications to studies of the immune system where, to a first approximation, each lymphocyte has a unique receptor identity, where specific states of differentiation may be difficult to assess in a mixed cell population, and where cell immortalization procedures are not always possible nor practical.

Somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes

The relationship between somatic hypermutation and affinity maturation in the mouse is delineated. Recent work on the anatomical and cellular site of this process is surveyed. The molecular characteristics of somatic hypermutation are described in terms of the region mutated and the distinctive patterns of nucleotide changes that are observed. The results of experiments utilizing transgenic mice to find out the minimum cis-acting sequences required to recruit hypermutation are summarized. The hypothesis that V gene sequences have evolved in order to target mutation to certain sites but not others is discussed. The use that different species make of somatic hypermutation to generate either the primary or secondary B cell repertoire is considered. Possible molecular mechanisms for the hypermutation process and future goals of research are outlined.

The molecular basis of somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes

Somatic hypermutation amplifies the variable region repertoire of immunoglobulin genes. Recent experimental evidence has thrown light on various molecular models of somatic hypermutation. A link between somatic hypermutation and transcription coupled DNA repair is shaping up.

Somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes is linked to transcription initiation

To identify DNA sequences that target the somatic hypermutation process, the immunoglobulin gene promoter located upstream of the variable (V) region was duplicated upstream of the constant (C) region of a kappa transgene. Normally, kappa genes are somatically mutated only in the VJ region, but not in the C region. In B cell hybridomas from mice with this kappa transgene (P5'C), both the VJ region and the C region, but not the region between them, were mutated at similar frequencies, suggesting that the mutation mechanism is related to transcription. The downstream promoter was not occluded by transcripts from the upstream promoter. In fact, the levels of transcripts originating from the two promoters were similar, supporting a mutation model based on initiation of transcripts. Several "hot-spots" of somatic mutation were noted, further demonstrating that this transgene has the hallmarks of somatic mutation of endogenous immunoglobulin genes. A model linking somatic mutation to transcription-coupled DNA repair is proposed.

Chromatin domains and prediction of MAR sequences

Polynuceosomes are constrained into loops or domains and are insulated from the effects of chromatin structure and torsional strain from flanking domains by the cross-complexation of matrix-attached regions (MARs) and matrix proteins. MARs or SARs have an average size of 500 bp, are spaced about every 30 kb, and are control elements maintaining independent realms of gene activity. A fraction of MARs may cohabit with core origin replication (ORIs) and another fraction might cohabit with transcriptional enhancers. DNA replication, transcription, repair, splicing, and recombination seem to take place on the nuclear matrix. Classical AT-rich MARs have been proposed to anchor the core enhancers and core origins complexed with low abundancy transcription factors to the nuclear matrix via the cooperative binding to MARs of abundant classical matrix proteins (topoisomerase II, histone H1, lamins, SP120, ARBP, SATB1); this creates a unique nuclear microenvironment rich in regulatory proteins able to sustain transcription, replication, repair, and recombination. Theoretical searches and experimental data strongly support a model of activation of MARs and ORIs by transcription factors. A set of 21 characteristics are deduced or proposed for MAR/ORI sequences including their enrichment in inverted repeats, AT tracts, DNA unwinding elements, replication initiator protein sites, homooligonucleotide repeats (i.e., AAA, TTT, CCC), curved DNA, DNase I-hypersensitive sites, nucleosome-free stretches, polypurine stretches, and motifs with a potential for left-handed and triplex structures. We are establishing Banks of ORI and MAR sequences and have undertaken a large project of sequencing a large number of MARs in an effort to determine classes of DNA sequences in these regulatory elements and to understand their role at the origins of replication and transcriptional enhancers.