Toward gene therapy for hemophilia A: long-term persistence of factor VIII-secreting fibroblasts after transplantation into immunodeficient mice

Gene therapy strategies for hemophilia: benefits versus risks

Hemophilia is an inherited bleeding disorder caused by a deficiency of functional clotting factors VIII or IX in the blood plasma. The drawbacks of the classical protein substitution therapy fueled interest in alternative treatments by gene therapy. Hemophilia has been recognized as an ideal target disease for gene therapy because a relatively modest increase in clotting factor levels can result in a significant therapeutic benefit. Consequently, introducing a functional FVIII or FIX gene copy into the appropriate target cells could ultimately provide a cure for hemophilic patients. Several cell types have been explored for hemophilia gene therapy, including hepatocytes, muscle, endothelial and hematopoietic cells. Both nonviral and viral vectors have been considered for the development of hemophilia gene therapy, including transposons, γ-retroviral, lentiviral, adenoviral and adeno-associated viral vectors. Several of these strategies have resulted in stable correction of the bleeding diathesis in hemophilia A and B murine as well as canine models, paving the way towards clinical trials. Although clotting factor expression has been detected in hemophilic patients treated by gene therapy, the challenge now lies in obtaining prolonged therapeutic FVIII or FIX levels in these patients. This review highlights the benefits and potential risks of the different gene therapy strategies for hemophilia that have been developed.

The therapeutic effect of bone marrow-derived liver cells in the phenotypic correction of murine hemophilia A

The transdifferentiation of bone marrow cells (BMCs) into hepatocytes has created enormous interest in applying this process to the development of cellular medicine for degenerative and genetic diseases. Because the liver is the primary site of factor VIII (FVIII) synthesis, we hypothesized that the partial replacement of mutated liver cells by healthy cells in hemophilia A mice could manage the severity of the bleeding disorder. We perturbed the host liver with acetaminophen to facilitate the engraftment and hepatic differentiation of lineage-depleted enhanced green fluorescent protein-expressing BMCs. Immunohistochemistry experiments with the liver tissue showed that the donor-derived cells expressed the markers of both hepatocytes (albumin and cytokeratin-18) and endothelial cells (von Willebrand factor). The results of fluorescent in situ hybridization and immunocytochemistry experiments suggested that differentiation was direct in this model. The BMC-recipient mice expressed FVIII protein and survived in a tail clip challenge experiment. Furthermore, a coagulation assay confirmed that the plasma FVIII activity was maintained at 20.4% (+/- 3.6%) of normal pooled plasma activity for more than a year without forming its inhibitor. Overall, this report demonstrated that BMCs rescued the bleeding phenotype in hemophilia A mice, suggesting a potential therapy for this and other related disorders.

Systemic and Localized Reversible Regulation of Transgene Expression by Tetracycline with tetR-Mediated Transcription Repression Switch

BACKGROUND

We recently developed a new tetracycline-inducible gene switch employing the tetracycline operator-containing hCMV major immediate-early promoter and the tetracycline repressor, tetR, rather than the previously used tetR-mammalian cell transcription factor fusion derivatives.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The present study demonstrates that this tetR-mediated transcription repression system can function as a powerful gene switch for On-and-Off regulation of therapeutic gene expression in ex vivo gene transfer protocols. Firstly, for achieving regulated gene expression in a localized tissue environment, R11/OEGF cells, a stable line that expresses hEGF under the control of the tetR-mediated transcription repression switch, were transplanted into porcine full-thickness wounds enclosed by wound chambers.

RESULTS

By topically applying tetracycline in wound chambers at various concentrations or at different time points post-transplantation, the levels and timing of hEGF expression in transplanted wounds could be reversibly regulated by tetracycline. Over 3000-fold induction in hEGF expression was achieved in the local wound microenvironment. Secondly, R11/OEGF cells were intramuscularly injected into NCr outbread nude mice to test the efficacy of intermittent systemic gene delivery of a soluble peptide(s).

CONCLUSIONS

Basal circulating hEGF was undetectable and induced up to at least 1,500-fold after administration of tetracycline. Furthermore, the timing and duration of hEGF expression could be finely adjusted by the presence or the absence of tetracycline in the drinking water.

Genetic engineering for haemophilia A

At first sight, haemophilia A would appear to be an ideal candidate for treatment by gene therapy. There is a single gene defect; cells in different parts of the body, but especially the liver, produce Factor VIII, and only 5% of normal levels of Factor VIII are necessary to prevent the serious symptoms of bleeding. This review attempts to outline the status of gene therapy at present and efforts that have been made to overcome the difficulties and remaining problems that require solving. Undoubtedly, success will be achieved, but it is likely that considerably more work will be necessary before experimental models can be introduced into the clinic with any likelihood of success. The most successful results in animals that may have clinical application were from introducing the Factor VIII gene to newborn animals before antibodies are produced, presumably inducing a state of tolerance.

Sustained transgene expression by human cord blood derived CD34+ cells transduced with simian immunodeficiency virus agmTYO1-based vectors carrying the human coagulation factor VIII gene in NOD/SCID mice

BACKGROUND

Gene therapy is being studied as the next generation therapy for hemophilia and several clinical trials have been carried out, albeit with limited success. To explore the possibility of utilizing autologous bone marrow transplantation of genetically modified hematopoietic stem cells for hemophilia gene therapy, we investigated the efficacy of genetically engineered CD34+ cell transplantation to NOD/SCID mice for expression of human factor VIII (hFVIII).

METHODS

CD34+ cells were transduced with a simian immunodeficiency virus agmTYO1 (SIV)-based lentiviral vector carrying the enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP) gene (SIVeGFP) or the hFVIII gene (SIVhFVIII). CD34+ cells transduced with SIV vectors were transplanted to NOD/SCID mice. Engraftment of transduced CD34+ cells and expression of transgenes were studied.

RESULTS

We could efficiently transduce CD34+ cells using the SIVeGFP vector in a dose-dependent manner, reaching a maximum (99.6 +/- 0.1%) at MOI of 5 x 10(3) vector genome/cell. After transducing CD34+ cells with SIVhFVIII, hFVIII was produced (274.3 +/- 20.1 ng) from 10(6) CD34+ cells during 24 h in vitro incubation. Transplantation of SIVhFVIII-transduced CD34+ cells (5-10 x 10(5)) at a multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 50 vector genome/cell into NOD/SCID mice resulted in successful engraftment of CD34+ cells and production of hFVIII (minimum 1.2 +/- 0.9 ng/mL, maximum 3.6 +/- 0.8 ng/mL) for at least 60 days in vivo. Transcripts of the hFVIII gene and the hFVIII antigen were also detected in the murine bone marrow cells.

CONCLUSIONS

Transplantation of ex vivo transduced hematopoietic stem cells by non-pathogenic SIVhFVIII without exposure of subjects to viral vectors is safe and potentially applicable for gene therapy of hemophilia A patients.

Blood coagulation factor VIII: An overview

Factor VIII (FVIII) functions as a co-factor in the blood coagulation cascade for the proteolytic activation of factor X by factor IXa. Deficiency of FVIII causes hemophilia A, the most commonly inherited bleeding disorder. This review highlights current knowledge on selected aspects of FVIII in which both the scientist and the clinician should be interested.

Recombinant factor VIII expression in hematopoietic cells following lentiviral transduction

Autologous transplantation of gene-modified hematopoietic stem cells may provide a therapeutic strategy for several monogeneic disorders. In previous studies, retroviral gene transfer of coagulation factor VIII (FVIII) into FVIII(-/-) mouse bone marrow (BM) cells did not result in detectable plasma FVIII levels. However, specific immune tolerance was achieved against neo-antigenic FVIII. Here, we used lentiviral vectors to study the ability of various hematopoietic cell types to synthesize and secrete recombinant FVIII. Several myeloid, monocytic and megakaryocytic cell lines (K-562, TF-1, Monomac-1, Mutz-3, Meg-01) expressed FVIII at 2-12 mU/10(4) cells. In contrast, two lymphatic cell lines, BV-173 and Molt-4, were less-efficiently transduced and did not express detectable FVIII. Similarly, peripheral blood-derived primary monocytes were transduced efficiently and expressed up to 20 mU/10(4) cells, whereas primary lymphocytes did not express FVIII. Although human and canine CD34(+) cells were transduced efficiently, the cells expressed very low levels of FVIII (up to 0.8 mU/10(4) cells). Following xenotransplantation of transduced CD34(+) into NOD/SCID mice, ELISA failed to detect FVIII in the plasma of engrafted mice. However, NOD/SCID repopulating cell (SRC)-derived human monocytes isolated from BM of these mice secreted functional recombinant FVIII after culture ex vivo. Again, SRC-derived human lymphocytes did not secrete FVIII. Therefore, certain hematopoietic cell types are able to synthesize and secrete functional recombinant FVIII. Our results show for the first time that transplantation of transduced CD34(+) progenitors may give rise to differentiated hematopoietic cells secreting a nonhematopoietic recombinant protein.

Efficient production of human FVIII in hemophilic mice using lentiviral vectors

Lentiviral vectors (LV) have the ability to integrate their proviral DNA containing a therapeutic gene into the host cell's genome. Therefore, these vectors have a great potential for gene therapy especially in the treatment of hereditary diseases like hemophilia A, which require lifelong expression of the transgene. We constructed an HIV-1-based LV containing human B-domain-deleted factor VIII (FVIII) cDNA under the control of a promoter consisting of the chicken beta-actin promoter, CMV enhancers, and a large synthetic intron (CAG), which is a robust transcription promoter. High levels of FVIII expression from this vector could be demonstrated in vitro in 293T cells, primary liver cells, and hematopoietic progenitor cells. To test whether this viral vector was able to correct the bleeding disorder of C57BL/6 FVIII knockout mice, we transduced these mice with the FVIII LV either by intraperitoneal injection or by transplantation with transduced syngeneic bone marrow. FVIII production was analyzed in the blood plasma for a period of 3 months; however, only low levels of FVIII (<50 mU), which were below 5% of normal FVIII levels of 1000 mU, could be detected. Further analysis revealed that the low levels of FVIII activity present in the blood plasma were due to the presence of neutralizing antibodies to FVIII and not due to lack of expression of FVIII from the viral vector. FVIII expression could be detected in the tissues of the transduced mice by Western blot analysis and in ex vivo cultures. These data demonstrate that LVs are able to produce therapeutic levels of FVIII in knockout mice when administered by ip infection or by transduced hematopoietic cells. The challenge is to overcome the immune barriers to the therapeutic gene product.

Therapeutic levels of human factor VIII in mice implanted with encapsulated cells: potential for gene therapy of haemophilia A

BACKGROUND

A gene therapy delivery system based on microcapsules enclosing recombinant cells engineered to secrete a therapeutic protein has been evaluated. The microcapsules are implanted intraperitoneally. In order to prevent cell immune rejection, cells are enclosed in non-antigenic biocompatible alginate microcapsules prior to their implantation into mice. It has been shown that encapsulated myoblasts can deliver therapeutic levels of Factor IX (FIX) in mice. The delivery of human Factor VIII (hFVIII) in mice using microcapsules was evaluated in this study.

METHODS

Mouse C2C12 myoblasts and canine MDCK epithelial kidney cells were transduced with MFG-FVIII (B-domain deleted) vector. Selected recombinant clones were enclosed in alginate microcapsules. Encapsulated recombinant clones were subsequently implanted intraperitoneally into C57BL/6 and immunodeficient SCID mice.

RESULTS

Plasma of mice receiving C2C12 and encapsulated MDCK cells had transient therapeutic levels of FVIII in immunocompetent C57BL/6 mice (up to 20% and 7% of physiological levels, respectively). In addition, FVIII delivery in SCID mice was also transient, suggesting that a non-immune mechanism must have contributed to the decline of hFVIII in plasma. Quantitative RT-PCR analysis confirmed directly that the decline of hFVIII is due to a reduction in steady-state hFVIII mRNA, consistent with transcriptional repression. Furthermore, encapsulated cells retrieved from implanted mice were viable, but secreted FVIII ex vivo at three-fold lower levels than the pre-implantation levels. In addition, antibodies to hFVIII were detected in immunocompetent C57BL/6 mice.

CONCLUSIONS

Implantable microcapsules can deliver therapeutic levels of FVIII in mice, suggesting the potential of this gene therapy approach for haemophilia A. The findings suggest vector down-regulation in vivo.

Gene therapy for hemophilia

Hemophilia A and B are X-chromosome linked recessive bleeding disorders that result from a deficiency in factor VIII (FVIII) and factor IX (FIX) respectively. Though factor substitution therapy has greatly improved the lives of hemophiliac patients, there are still limitations to the current treatment that have triggered interest in alternative treatments by gene therapy. Significant progress has recently been made in the development of gene therapy for the treatment of hemophilia A and B. These advances parallel the technical improvements of existing vector systems including MoMLV-based retroviral, adenoviral and AAV vectors, and the development of new delivery methods such as lentiviral vectors, helper-dependent adenoviral vectors and improved non-viral gene delivery methods. Therapeutic and physiologic levels of FVIII and FIX could be achieved in FVIII- and FIX-deficient mice and hemophilia dogs by different gene therapy approaches. Long-term correction of the bleeding disorders and in some cases a permanent cure has been realized in these preclinical studies. However, the induction of neutralizing antibodies often precludes stable phenotypic correction. Another complication is that certain promoters are prone to transcriptional inactivation in vivo, precluding long-term FVIII or FIX expression. Several gene therapy phase I clinical trials are currently ongoing in patients suffering from severe hemophilia A or B. No significant adverse side-effects were reported, and semen samples were negative for vector sequences by sensitive PCR assays. Most importantly, some subjects report fewer bleeding episodes and occasionally have very low levels of clotting factor activity detected. The results from the extensive preclinical studies in normal and hemophilic animal models and encouraging preliminary clinical data indicate that the simultaneous development of different strategies is likely to bring a permanent cure for hemophilia one step closer to reality.

Fibroblasts and dermal gene therapy: a minireview

This review highlights our current understanding of the biology of, survival of, and transgene expression by genetically modified fibroblasts (GMFb) carrying stably integrated transgenes in vivo. Experimental data demonstrate that three elements will enhance expression by and survival of GMFb in vivo: a matrix scaffolding to take the place of the existing dermis, the presence of elements of the extracellular matrix in the construct used to move GMFb to the in vivo setting, and the utilization of immortalized fibroblasts to carry the transgenes. Although moving GMFb to an in vivo setting is an invasive procedure, there are a number of clinical settings where GMFb appear to be the suitable cell for gene therapy.

Long-term persistence of human bone marrow stromal cells transduced with factor VIII-retroviral vectors and transient production of therapeutic levels of human factor VIII in nonmyeloablated immunodeficient mice

The potential of using bone marrow (BM)-derived human stromal cells for ex vivo gene therapy of hemophilia A was evaluated. BM stromal cells were transduced with an intron-based Moloney murine leukemia virus (Mo-MuLV) retroviral vector that contained the B domain-deleted human factor VIII (FVIIIdeltaB) cDNA. This FVIII-retroviral vector was pseudotyped with the gibbon ape leukemia virus envelope (GALV-env) to attain higher transduction efficiencies. Using optimized transduction methods, high in vitro FVIII expression levels of 700 to 2500 mU of FVIII/10(6) cells per 24 hr were achieved without selective enrichment of the transduced BM stromal cells. After xenografting of 1.5-3 x 106 engineered BM stromal cells into the spleen of nonobese diabetic severe combined immunodeficient (NOD-SCID) mice, human plasma FVIII levels rose to 13 +/- 4 ng/ml but declined to basal levels by 3 weeks postinjection because of promoter inactivation. About 10% of these stromal cells engrafted in the spleen and persisted for at least 4 months after transplantation in the absence of myeloablative conditioning. No human BM stromal cells could be detected in other organs. These findings indicate that retroviral vector-mediated gene therapy using engineered BM stromal cells may lead to therapeutic levels of FVIII in vivo and that long-term engraftment of human BM stromal cells was achieved in the absence of myeloablative conditioning and without neo-organs. Hence, BM stromal cells may be useful for gene therapy of hemophilia A, provided prolonged expression can be achieved by using alternative promoters.

Long-term expression of human coagulation factor VIII and correction of hemophilia A after in vivo retroviral gene transfer in factor VIII-deficient mice

Hemophilia A is caused by a deficiency in coagulation factor VIII (FVIII) and predisposes to spontaneous bleeding that can be life-threatening or lead to chronic disabilities. It is well suited for gene therapy because a moderate increase in plasma FVIII concentration has therapeutic effects. Improved retroviral vectors expressing high levels of human FVIII were pseudotyped with the vesicular stomatitis virus G glycoprotein, were concentrated to high-titers (10(9)-10(10) colony-forming units/ml), and were injected intravenously into newborn, FVIII-deficient mice. High-levels (>/=200 milliunits/ml) of functional human FVIII production could be detected in 6 of the 13 animals, 4 of which expressed physiologic or higher levels (500-12,500 milliunits/ml). Five of the six expressers produced FVIII and survived an otherwise lethal tail-clipping, demonstrating phenotypic correction of the bleeding disorder. FVIII expression was sustained for >14 months. Gene transfer occurred into liver, spleen, and lungs with predominant FVIII mRNA expression in the liver. Six of the seven animals with transient or no detectable human FVIII developed FVIII inhibitors (7-350 Bethesda units/ml). These findings indicate that a genetic disease can be corrected by in vivo gene therapy using retroviral vectors.

High-efficiency transduction and long-term gene expression with a murine stem cell retroviral vector encoding the green fluorescent protein in human marrow stromal cells

Bone marrow stromal cells (MSCs) are unique mesenchymal cells that have been utilized as vehicles for the delivery of therapeutic proteins in gene therapy protocols. However, there are several unresolved issues regarding their potential therapeutic applications. These include low transduction efficiency, attenuation of transgene expression, and the technical problems associated with drug-based selection markers. To address these issues, we have developed a transduction protocol that yields high-level gene transfer into human MSCs, employing a murine stem cell virus-based bicistronic vector containing the green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene as a selectable marker. Transduction of MSCs plated at low density for 6 hr per day for 3 days with high-titer viral supernatant resulted in a gene transfer efficiency of 80+/-6% (n = 10) as measured by GFP fluorescence. Neither centrifugation nor phosphate depletion increased transduction efficiency. Assessment of amphotropic receptor (Pit-2) expression by RT-PCR demonstrated that all MSCs expressing the receptor were successfully transduced. Cell cycle distribution profiles measured by propidium iodide staining showed no correlation with the susceptibility of MSCs to transduction by the retroviral vector. Human MSCs sequentially transduced with an adenoviral vector encoding the ecotropic receptor and ecotropic retroviral vector encoding GFP demonstrated that all MSCs are susceptible to retroviral transduction. We further showed that both genes of bicistronic vector are expressed for at least 6 months in vitro and that transgene expression did not affect the growth or osteogenic differentiation potential of MSCs. Future studies will be directed toward the development of gene therapy protocols employing this strategy.

Biologic aspects of expression of stably integrated transgenes in cells of the skin in vitro and in vivo

The observation that transgenes can be stably integrated into the genome of fibroblasts using recombinant retroviruses enhanced interest in using these cells as a vector for gene therapy. This enthusiasm has lessened during the past 8 years, not because skin has lost the features that make it attractive for gene therapy, but rather because stable transgene expression in vivo has not been achieved. All investigators who have used genetically modified fibroblasts to study in vivo aspects of gene therapy have shown a decrease in transgene expression with time. This contrasts with transgene expression in similarly transduced fibroblasts in vitro, where expression is not lost or is lost very slowly. We have initiated an approach to bring further understanding to the biology of transgene expression by fibroblasts carrying stably integrated transgenes in an in vivo setting. Experiments described permit the following conclusions. Expression by and survival of genetically modified fibroblasts a) requires a persistent matrix scaffold in in vivo settings; b) is prolonged if the matrix is allowed to mature in vitro; c) is enhanced if the matrix is partially sequestered behind a coating of normal fibroblasts; and d) can be substantively prolonged in vivo by immortalizing the cells. These observations support the notion that prolonged expression of transgenes by fibroblasts can be achieved in vivo and that gene therapy utilizing fibroblasts and other cells of the skin has clinical utility.

Efficient adenoviral vector transduction and expression of functional human factor VIII in cultured primary human hepatocytes

Hemophilia A is a severe bleeding disorder caused by a deficiency in blood coagulation factor VIII (FVIII). Adenoviral vectors containing a potent human FVIII expression cassette encoding a truncated FVIII cDNA were developed that mediated sustained FVIII expression in normal and haemophiliac mice and complete phenotypic correction of the bleeding disorder in haemophiliac mice and dogs (Connelly and Kaleko, Haemophilia, 1998; 4: 380-8). Here, we evaluated two E1/E2a/E3-deleted adenoviral vectors encoding human FVIII, one containing the full-length cDNA and the second containing a truncated cDNA lacking the B-domain. Viral vectors encoding the human full-length FVIII cDNA have not been described previously. Hepatocyte transduction was efficient and dose dependent, ranging from 50% to 100%. High levels of functional FVIII were secreted from transduced cells at amounts up to 6000 mU-1 10(6)cells-1 60 h. B-domain deleted FVIII was expressed at levels at least 8-fold higher than the full-length FVIII protein, whereas FVIII RNA levels were similar with both vectors. These data provide the first demonstration of FVIII adenoviral vector function in primary human cells and verify the potential clinical utility of adenoviral vectors for the treatment of haemophilia A.

Evaluation of fibroblast-mediated gene therapy in a feline model of mucopolysaccharidosis type VI

Fibroblast-mediated ex vivo gene therapy was evaluated in the N-acetylgalactosamine 4-sulfatase (4S) deficient mucopolysaccharidosis type VI (MPS VI) cat. Skin biopsies were obtained at birth from severely affected MPS VI kittens and used to initiate fibroblast outgrowths for retroviral transduction with the 4S cDNA. 4S gene expression in transduced cells was under the transcriptional control of the MoMLV long terminal repeat promoter or the cytomegalovirus (CMV) immediate-early promoter. Characterisation of gene-transduced fibroblasts demonstrated the cells to be over-expressing 4S activity. Twenty-four to forty million autologous, gene-corrected fibroblasts were implanted under the renal capsule of three MPS VI kittens at 8-16 weeks of age. Transient, low levels of 4S activity were detected in peripheral blood leukocytes shortly after implantation but were not detectable within 3-8 weeks' post-implantation. Long-term biochemical and clinical evaluation of these cats demonstrated identical disease progression to that previously described in untreated, clinically severe MPS VI cats.

Hemophilia. A new approach to an old disease

The history of hemophilia diagnosis and therapy has been a turbulent one. We are coming full circle, back to the use of genetics as the main diagnostic tool for this disease. Therapeutically, the retroviruses that ravaged one generation of hemophiliac patients now may participate in the cure for the next generation. The hemophilia community hopes that the future of hemophilia care will follow a course guided by this modified quote from James Russell Lowell: "New times demand new measures, and men [and women]. As the world advances and in time outgrows the laws that in our fathers' [and mothers'] days were the best, doubtless after us some purer scheme will be shaped out by wiser man [and women] than we, made wiser by the steady growth of truth."

Haemophilia A gene therapy

Gene therapy for haemophilia A would represent a significant improvement over the current treatment by providing prophylactic expression of FVIII and correction of the coagulation defect. Furthermore, a gene therapy protocol allowing simple, infrequent vector administration may extend haemophilia treatment to remote locations world-wide that currently lack access to FVIII replacement therapy. Within the last half decade, significant progress has been made on the development of gene therapy for the treatment of haemophilia A. Recent achievements include high level clotting factor expression in mice, dogs, and monkeys as well as phenotypic correction in haemophiliac mice and dogs. With the efforts that are currently directed toward the improvement of gene transfer vectors and the development of technologies to enable sustained clotting factor expression, gene therapy for haemophilia A will ultimately become a reality.

Sustained Phenotypic Correction of Murine Hemophilia A by In Vivo Gene Therapy

Hemophilia A is caused by a deficiency of blood coagulation factor VIII (FVIII) and has been widely discussed as a candidate for gene therapy. While the natural canine model of hemophilia A has been valuable for the development of FVIII pharmaceutical products, the use of hemophiliac dogs for gene therapy studies has several limitations such as expense and the long canine generation time. The recent creation of two strains of FVIII-deficient mice provides the first small animal model of hemophilia A. Treatment of hemophiliac mice of both genotypes with potent, human FVIII-encoding adenoviral vectors resulted in expression of biologically active human FVIII at levels, which declined, but remained above the human therapeutic range for over 9 months. The duration of expression and FVIII plasma levels achieved were similar in both hemophiliac mouse strains. Treated mice readily survived tail clipping with minimal blood loss, thus showing phenotypic correction of murine hemophilia A by in vivo gene therapy.

Sustained Phenotypic Correction of Murine Hemophilia A by In Vivo Gene Therapy

Hemophilia A is caused by a deficiency of blood coagulation factor VIII (FVIII) and has been widely discussed as a candidate for gene therapy. While the natural canine model of hemophilia A has been valuable for the development of FVIII pharmaceutical products, the use of hemophiliac dogs for gene therapy studies has several limitations such as expense and the long canine generation time. The recent creation of two strains of FVIII-deficient mice provides the first small animal model of hemophilia A. Treatment of hemophiliac mice of both genotypes with potent, human FVIII-encoding adenoviral vectors resulted in expression of biologically active human FVIII at levels, which declined, but remained above the human therapeutic range for over 9 months. The duration of expression and FVIII plasma levels achieved were similar in both hemophiliac mouse strains. Treated mice readily survived tail clipping with minimal blood loss, thus showing phenotypic correction of murine hemophilia A by in vivo gene therapy.

Bone marrow stromal cells as targets for gene therapy of hemophilia A

Attempts to develop an ex vivo gene therapy strategy for hemophilia A, using either primary T cells or bone marrow (BM) stem/progenitor cells have been unsuccessful, due to the inability of these cell types to express coagulation factor VIII (FVIII). As an alternative, we evaluated the potential of BM-derived stromal cells which can be readily obtained and expanded in vitro. Human and murine BM stromal cells were transduced with an intron-based Moloney murine leukemia virus (MoMLV) retroviral vector expressing a B-domain-deleted human factor VIII cDNA (designated as MFG-FVIIIdeltaB). Transduction efficiencies were increased 10- to 15-fold by phosphate depletion and centrifugation, which obviated the need for selective enrichment of the transduced BM stromal cells. This resulted in high FVIII expression levels in transduced human (180 +/- 4 ng FVIII/10[6] cells per 24 hr) and mouse (900 +/- 130 ng FVIII/10[6] cells per 24 hr) BM stromal cells. Pseudotyping of the MFG-FVIIIdeltaB retroviral vectors with the gibbon ape leukemia virus envelope (GALV-env) resulted in significantly higher transduction efficiencies (100 +/- 20%) and FVIII expression levels (390 +/- 10 ng FVIII/10[6] cells per 24 hr) in transduced human BM stromal cells than with standard amphotropic vectors. This difference in transduction efficiency correlated with the higher titer of the GALV-env pseudotyped viral vectors and with the higher GALV receptor (GLVR-1) versus amphotropic receptor (GLVR-2) mRNA expression levels in human BM stromal cells. These findings demonstrate the potential of BM stromal cells for gene therapy in general and hemophilia A in particular.

Gut epithelial cells as targets for gene therapy of hemophilia

Gut epithelium is an attractive target for gene therapy of hemophilia due to the large number of rapidly dividing cells that should be readily accessible to a wide range of vectors by a noninvasive route of administration. We have performed in vitro tests to determine the suitability of gut epithelial cells for gene transfer, protein synthesis, and secretion of coagulation factors VIII and IX. The results with retroviral vectors indicate that transduced epithelial cells from human, rat, or porcine small or large intestine can synthesize significant amounts of factor VIII or factor IX and that two-thirds or more of the recombinant protein is secreted in a basolateral direction (i.e., away from the lumen and toward underlying capillaries and lymphatics). Furthermore, we have demonstrated that intestinal epithelial cells are susceptible to efficient gene transfer by lipofection and adenovirus vectors. In the case of factor IX, we have produced a high-titer adenovirus vector capable of transducing gut epithelial cells resulting in synthesis of factor IX. The results of our in vitro studies indicate that gene transfer targeting gut epithelium as a new approach to hemophilia gene therapy is rational and merits in vivo studies in hemophilia animal models.

In vitro and in vivo gene delivery mediated by a synthetic polycationic amino polymer

A synthetic polyamino polymer with a glucose backbone was used for gene transfer in vitro and in vivo. Gene transfer in vitro to various human carcinoma cell lines was achieved with an efficiency superior to a commercially available cationic liposome preparation. The polymer was resistant to inhibition by serum, which allowed for efficient gene transfer in vivo. Direct Intracranial tumor injection using this reagent resulted in reporter gene expression levels comparable to those achieved by a recombinant adenoviral vector. Thus, this compound represents a new class of agent that may have broad utility for gene transfer and gene therapy applications.

Use of cloned genetically modified human fibroblasts to assess long-term survival in vivo

Because human fibroblasts are easily brought to tissue culture conditions and can be stably transduced with retroviral vectors encoding transgenes ex vivo, genetically modified fibroblasts are frequently considered in strategies to correct disease with gene therapy. This enthusiasm has been dampened by studies showing that transgene expression by genetically modified fibroblasts diminishes with time in vivo, but not in vitro, for reasons that are unclear. We elected to study this problem using cloned human fibroblasts that had been cloned by limiting dilution and stably transduced with a retroviral vector encoding lacZ ex vivo. These were seeded onto a nonbiodegradable nylon matrix that was transplanted to nude mice. Transgene expression was followed prospectively by histologic exam. Data show that human fibroblasts can withstand the pressure of cloning by limiting dilution. In addition, they can be passaged from 10 to > 20 times, and > 1 x 10(20) of genetically modified fibroblasts can be generated as progeny of one cell. Loss of transgene expression by the cloned genetically modified fibroblasts in vivo occurs in an orderly and progressive fashion, but is not complete by 4 months. Neither the loss nor the persistence of expression appear to be random. These observations are most compatible with the thesis that a major cause of the loss of transgene expression in vivo is secondary to apoptosis of the genetically modified fibroblast. Loss of expression of transgenes in senescent genetically modified fibroblasts occurs more rapidly than in their presenescent counterparts in the age-neutral, in vivo setting of the nude mouse.

Cutaneous gene therapy

Gene therapy efforts in a variety of tissues have foundered on fundamental technologic barriers, such as difficulties in achieving high-efficiency gene transfer to diseased tissues and in sustaining delivered transgene production. The skin offers an attractive tissue for development of approaches to therapeutic gene delivery by virtue of its accessibility for regulation by topical agents, the ease of gene transfer into cutaneous tissues, and the ready ability to monitor the impact of somatic gene transfer. With the ability of the skin to deliver therapeutic polypeptides to the systemic circulation and the recent molecular characterization of monogenic skin diseases, efforts to target genes to the skin are expected to accelerate. The current status of gene therapy efforts is reviewed, with a special focus on the skin.

Hemophilia 1996. New approach to an old disease

The history of hemophilia diagnosis and therapy has been a turbulent one. We are coming full circle, back to the use of genetics as the main diagnostic tool for this disease. Therapeutically, the retroviruses that ravaged one generation of hemophiliac patients now may participate in the cure for the next generation. The hemophilia community hopes that the future of hemophilia care will follow a course guided by this modified quote from James Russell Lowell: "New times demand new measures, and men [and women]. As the world advances and in time outgrows the laws that in our fathers' [and mothers'] days were the best, doubtless after us some purer scheme will be shaped out by wiser men [and women] than we, made wiser by the steady growth of truth."

High-level tissue-specific expression of functional human factor VIII in mice

Hemophilia A results from subnormal levels of blood coagulation factor VIII (FVIII) and is an attractive target for gene therapy. However, progress has been impeded by features of FVIII biology such as low mRNA accumulation and the instability of the protein. We have shown previously that a FVIII adenoviral vector, Av1ALH81, allowed high-level expression of human FVIII in mice sustained for several weeks. Here, we have generated a second FVIII adenoviral vector, Av1ALAPH81, in which an intron was introduced into the FVIII expression cassette. Administration of Av1ALAPH81 to mice resulted in significantly increased FVIII plasma levels, 1,046 +/- 163 ng/ml compared to 307 +/- 93 ng/ml of FVIII detected in mice that received Av1ALH81. Normal FVIII levels in humans are 100-200 ng/ml and therapeutic levels are as low as 10 ng/ml. Therapeutic levels are defined as the amount of FVIII necessary to convert severe hemophilia to a moderate or mild hemophiliac condition. The increased potency of the second FVIII adenoviral vector allowed the administration of significantly lower, less toxic vector doses, while retaining the potential for high FVIII expression. Furthermore, we demonstrate that adenoviral-mediated expression of human FVIII can be limited to the liver by inclusion of a liver-specific promoter, thereby achieving the first step in regulated expression of human FVIII in vivo.

Development and analysis of retroviral vectors expressing human factor VIII as a potential gene therapy for hemophilia A

To develop a potential gene therapy strategy for the treatment of hemophilia A, we constructed several retroviral vectors expressing a B-domain-deleted factor VIII (FVIII) cDNA. We confirmed previous reports that when the FVIII cDNA is inserted into a retroviral vector, the vector mRNA is decreased resulting in significantly (100- to 1,000-fold) lower vector titers. In an attempt to overcome this inhibition we pursued two independent strategies. First, site-directed mutagenesis was employed to change the structure of a putative 1.2-kb FVIII RNA inhibitory sequence (INS). Second, the FVIII gene was transcribed from a retroviral vector containing a 5' intron. Results demonstrated that the intron increased FVIII expression up to 20-fold and viral titer up to 40-fold but conservative mutagenesis of the putative FVIII INS region failed to yield a significant increase in FVIII expression or titer. Using the improved FVIII splicing vector, we transduced a variety of cell types and were able to demonstrate relatively high FVIII expression (10-60 ng of FVIII/10(6) cells/24 hr). These results underscore the usefulness of these transduced cell types for potential in vivo delivery of FVIII.

Retroviral-mediated gene transfer and expression of human lipoprotein lipase in somatic cells

Lipoprotein lipase (LPL) is an enzyme responsible for the hydrolysis of triglyceride-rich circulating lipoproteins. Humans with complete defects in LPL activity present from infancy with failure to thrive, eruptive xanthomas, pancreatitis, and lactescent plasma. In addition, heterozygous carriers for this disorder may be at increased risk for the development of coronary artery disease. In view of a potential strategy for correcting complete or partial LPL deficiency, a 1.56-kb human LPL cDNA was inserted into a series of recombinant myeloproliferative sarcoma virus (MPSV)-based retroviral vectors under transcriptional control of the constitutive MPSV long terminal repeat (LTR). Stable gene transfer and enhanced expression of human LPL was observed at both the RNA and protein level in a variety of somatic cell types in vitro. Genetically modified cell populations included mouse NIH-3T3 fibroblasts and C2C12 myoblasts, primary human fibroblasts, and established human hematopoietic cell lines of erythroid (K562), myelocytic (HL60), and monocytic (U937,THP-1) type. The achieved levels of bioactive human LPL were found to vary widely between the different transduced cell lines, which may be critical to an approach to gene therapy. Transduced primary human fibroblasts yielded maximal elevation of LPL immunoreactive mass and activity of at least 24- and 50-fold, respectively, above constitutively expressed levels for this cell type. Human fibroblasts, therefore, appear to accommodate in vitro the complex processes readily leading to the maturation and secretion of bioactive human LPL and may serve as an effective cellular vehicle for LPL gene delivery and expression in human LPL deficiency.

Gene therapy for hemophilia A: production of therapeutic levels of human factor VIII in vivo in mice

Continuous delivery of factor VIII (FVIII) protein in hemophiliacs by gene therapy will represent a major clinical advance over the current practice of infrequent administration of purified FVIII. Conceptually, retroviral vectors that can permanently insert the FVIII gene into the DNA of the host cell appear the most suitable vehicles for this specific purpose. However, most retroviral vector systems have shown a poor performance in the production of FVIII from primary cells in vitro and in vivo. Here we report the retroviral-mediated gene delivery of a B-domain-deleted human FVIII by using the MFG vector system. This vector permitted efficient transduction of the majority of the primary cells in culture without the use of a selectable marker. High levels of FVIII were produced by various transduced primary cells in vitro. Upon transplantation of primary fibroblasts into mice, therapeutic levels of FVIII in the circulation were obtained for > 1 week. The capacity of primary cells to deliver the FVIII into the circulation was strongly dependent on the site of implantation. These results represent a major step forward in development of gene therapy for treating hemophilia A.

Sustained production of human transferrin by transduced fibroblasts implanted into athymic mice: a model for somatic gene therapy

Somatic gene therapy has been proposed as a means of treating inherited diseases involving defective or absent plasma proteins, viral diseases, and cancer. Introduction of the gene of interest into fibroblasts and implantation of these genetically modified fibroblasts using a skin equivalent system may be an attractive model for gene therapy because skin fibroblasts are easily obtained and propagated in culture. This study evaluated expression of the gene for human transferrin (hTf) by genetically modified fibroblasts in vitro and in vivo. NIH 3T3 fibroblasts, which form non-metastasizing tumors in athymic mice, were transduced with a retroviral vector encoding hTf. The transduced cells were cloned by limiting dilution and hTf production by the cloned cells measured. Two clones of cells producing high levels of hTf were used to seed collagen-coated nylon matrices, which were maintained in culture for up to 53 d. The rate of synthesis of hTf by the seeded matrices was constant after 22 d in vitro. Matrices seeded with cloned, transduced cells were implanted subcutaneously into seven athymic mice, and plasma levels of hTf were assessed biweekly. In all animals, the plasma level of hTf was detectable at week 6 after implantation. Levels of hTf remained elevated in the animals until the implants were removed at week 12. At week 10, the level of hTf in the plasma correlated with tumor volume in tumors less than 2000 mm3 in size. The half-life of hTf in the mice was 39.5 h. In this model, gene expression did not decline for the 12-week observation period.

In vivo gene delivery and expression of physiological levels of functional human factor VIII in mice

Hemophilia A is caused by blood coagulation factor VIII (FVIII) deficiency and is an attractive target for gene therapy. However, features of FVIII physiology, such as the instability of the mRNA and protein, have provided obstacles to the design of a feasible strategy for the transfer and expression of the human FVIII gene in vivo. We have constructed a recombinant adenoviral vector, Av1ALH81, that contains the human FVIII cDNA from which the B-domain has been deleted (BDD FVIII) and extensively characterized this vector in vitro and in vivo. In vitro, HepG2, human hepatoma cells, transduced with Av1ALH81 secreted high levels of biologically active human BDD FVIII measured by the Coatest bioassay (> 2,400 mU per 10(6) cells per 24 hr). Administration of Av1ALH81 to mice, via tail vein, resulted in expression of human BDD FVIII in the mouse plasma at levels averaging 307 +/- 93 ng/ml 1 week post-injection, measured by a sensitive human FVIII-specific ELISA. Normal FVIII levels in humans are 100-200 ng/ml, and therapeutic levels are as low as 10 ng/ml. Purification of the human FVIII from the mouse plasma, and subsequent Coatest analysis, revealed that the human FVIII produced in the mice was biologically active. In addition, the duration of FVIII expression in vivo was followed, and high-level FVIII expression was sustained over a period of several weeks. The finding that an adenoviral vector can mediate high-level expression of human FVIII in an animal model provides the basis for the development of gene therapy for hemophilia A.

Gene therapy in heart disease

As the technology for gene therapy develops in vitro and in vivo in animal models, it is becoming clear that the three principal approaches--recombinant retroviruses, recombinant adenovirus, and direct DNA delivery--will ultimately have applications in specific therapeutic situations that take full advantage of the unique features of the specific delivery system: low level persistent expression after ex vivo recombinant retroviral therapy, high level transient expression after in vivo recombinant adenoviral therapy, or moderate level transient expression after in vivo administration of a synthetic DNA complex, which in principle could be repeated as desired.

Genetically modified skin to treat disease: potential and limitations

Molecular definition of disease at the level of the gene and advances in recombinant DNA technology suggest that many diseases are amenable to correction by genes not bearing the defective elements that result in disease. Many questions must be answered before this therapy can be used to correct chronic diseases. These questions fall into safety and efficacy categories. Experience with transplanting cellular elements of skin or skin substitutes (defined as skin that possess the cell types and a dermal structure to develop into a functioning skin) to athymic rodents is considerable and is seen as a system where these questions can be answered. This paper reviews these questions and presents our early analysis of genetically modified cells in skin substitutes in vivo and in vitro. Experimental data demonstrate that both a matrix of woven nylon, housing a fibroblast generated collage, and dead dermis can be utilized to shuttle genetically modified human fibroblasts from the laboratory to an in vivo setting. Genetically modified fibroblasts do not migrate from the shuttle to the surrounding tissue. The survival of significant numbers, approximately 70%, of genetically modified fibroblasts for at least 6 weeks in these shuttles, supports this general approach as having clinical utility. It is also concluded that skin substitute systems can be used to generate a genetically modified skin in vitro that has the capacity to develop into functional skin in vivo. Further, as genetically modified keratinocytes differentiate there is increased production by the transgene, supporting the concept that keratinocytes have true potential as shuttles for therapeutic genes. This work demonstrates that transplantation of systems containing genetically modified cells of the skin can be used to experimentally define many aspects of gene therapy using skin before this technology is taken to the clinic. Examples include determining the effect of gene transduction and expression on structure and function of the genetically modified skin as well as on distant skin and an assessment of the translational capacity of the transgene as function of time and cell number.

A murine model for B-lymphocyte somatic cell gene therapy

Mature primary B lymphocytes represent a potentially important cellular target for somatic cell gene therapy, which could prove advantageous for the treatment of certain metabolic and immunologic disorders. Their capacity to serve as antigen-presenting cells could be utilized for triggering and/or potentiating immune responses to tumors and viruses. Alternatively, B cells expressing an autoantigen could be manipulated to induce antigen-specific unresponsiveness for treatment of autoimmune diseases. Efficient expression of an exogenous gene product in long-lived B lymphocytes could be particularly useful for providing a corrected gene product in the bloodstream. Despite these advantages, efficient gene transfer into mature primary B cells has not been reported. One reason for this is that current protocols for retroviral vector-mediated gene transfer into lymphocytes rely on in vitro expansion and/or drug selection. This precludes the use of mature primary B cells as targets, since they cannot be readily cultured for long periods of time. In this report, we describe an efficient and rapid protocol for the introduction of exogenous genes into primary B cells without the need for drug selection. We have used retroviral vectors containing the human adenosine deaminase gene as a marker gene, since the biological activity of this enzyme is easy to measure and is readily distinguishable from that of the endogenous mouse adenosine deaminase. Upon adoptive transfer into SCID mice, infected B cells continuously expressing one to three copies of the human adenosine deaminase gene could be found in the spleens of recipient animals for at least 3 months.

In vivo production of human factor VII in mice after intrasplenic implantation of primary fibroblasts transfected by receptor-mediated, adenovirus-augmented gene delivery

Hemophilia A is caused by defects in the factor VIII gene. This results in life-threatening hemorrhages and severe arthropathies. Today, hemophiliacs are treated with human blood-derived factor VIII. In the future, it may be possible to use gene therapy to avoid long-term complications of conventional therapy and to improve the quality of life. However, initial gene therapy models using retroviral vectors and nonviral gene transfer techniques to introduce factor VIII gene constructs have been hampered by low expression levels of factor VIII. We show here that high expression levels of the B-domain-deleted human factor VIII in primary mouse fibroblasts and myoblasts are obtained by using receptor-mediated, adenovirus-augmented gene delivery (transferrinfection). We demonstrate that, presumably owing to the high molecular weight of factor VIII or its metabolic instability, secretion into the blood and attainment of therapeutic in vivo levels of factor VIII is achieved only if transfected autologous primary fibroblasts or myoblasts are delivered to the liver or spleen, but not if myoblasts are implanted into muscle, a strategy known to be successful for factor IX delivery.