High-resolution melting analysis: A novel approach for clade differentiation in Pythium insidiosum and pythiosis

An update on current and novel molecular diagnostics for the diagnosis of invasive fungal infections

BACKGROUND

Invasive fungal infections cause millions of infections annually, but diagnosis remains challenging. There is an increased need for low-cost, easy to use, highly sensitive and specific molecular assays that can differentiate between colonized and pathogenic organisms from different clinical specimens.

AREAS COVERED

We reviewed the literature evaluating the current state of molecular diagnostics for invasive fungal infections, focusing on current and novel molecular tests such as polymerase chain reaction (PCR), digital PCR, high-resolution melt (HRM), and metagenomics/next generation sequencing (mNGS).

EXPERT OPINION

PCR is highly sensitive and specific, although performance can be impacted by prior/concurrent antifungal use. PCR assays can identify mutations associated with antifungal resistance, non-Aspergillus mold infections, and infections from endemic fungi. HRM is a rapid and highly sensitive diagnostic modality that can identify a wide range of fungal pathogens, including down to the species level, but multiplex assays are limited and HRM is currently unavailable in most healthcare settings, although universal HRM is working to overcome this limitation. mNGS offers a promising approach for rapid and hypothesis-free diagnosis of a wide range of fungal pathogens, although some drawbacks include limited access, variable performance across platforms, the expertise and costs associated with this method, and long turnaround times in real-world settings.

Nucleic Acid-Based Detection of Pythium insidiosum: A Systematic Review

Pythiosis, a life-threatening infectious condition caused by Pythium insidiosum, has been increasingly reported in humans and animals worldwide. Antifungal drugs usually fail to control the pathogen. The surgical removal of an infected organ is the treatment of choice. Many affected patients die due to advanced infection. A timely and accurate diagnosis could lead to a better prognosis in pythiosis patients and save their lives. Although a standard culture method is available in microbiological laboratories, it is time-consuming, laborious, and insensitive for P. insidiosum identification. Immunological assays have been developed to improve the diagnosis of pythiosis. However, immunological methods are commercially unavailable and primarily detect anti-P. insidiosum antibodies, which constitute indirect evidence of pythiosis, making it challenging to differentiate a past from a recent infection. Moreover, such immunological tests cannot diagnose patients with a local infection, such as in the eye. Nucleic acid-based tests (NATs) are efficient for the direct and rapid detection of P. insidiosum DNA in trace-amount or culture-negative specimens. The reagents and equipment required for NATs are usually available in molecular diagnostic laboratories. Herein, we provide a systematic review to comprehensively present the principal and clinical usages, advantages, and limitations of such NATs in the detection of P. insidiosum. Various NATs have been established to detect P. insidiosum, which can be classified into amplification-based (i.e., PCR assays, isothermal tests, and next-generation sequencing methods) and non-amplification-based (i.e., DNA hybridization) techniques. This concise review on NATs constitutes an up-to-date reference with which healthcare professionals can learn about and decide upon which detection method is suitable for their respective laboratory environments.

Clinical Outcomes of Radical Surgery and Antimicrobial Agents in Vascular Pythiosis: A Multicenter Prospective Study

Vascular pythiosis is a rare, neglected, life-threatening disease with mortality of 100% in patients with incomplete surgical resection or patients with persistently elevated serum β-d-glucan (BDG). The study was conducted to understand the clinical outcomes of new treatment protocols and potential use of erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) and c-reactive protein (CRP) as alternative monitoring tools, given recent favorable minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) of antibacterial agents and prohibitive cost of serum BDG in Thailand. A prospective cohort study of patients with vascular pythiosis was conducted between February 2019 and August 2020. After diagnosis, patients were followed at 0.5, 1, 1.5, 3, and 6 months. Descriptive statistics, Spearman's correlation coefficient, and general linear model for longitudinal data were used. Amongst the cohort of ten vascular pythiosis patients, four had residual disease after surgery. Among four with residual disease, one developed disseminated disease and died, one developed relapse disease requiring surgery, and two were successfully managed with antimicrobial agents. The spearman's correlation coefficients between BDG and ESR, and between BDG and CRP in patients without relapse or disseminated disease were 0.65 and 0.60, respectively. Tetracyclines and macrolides had most favorable minimum inhibitory concentrations and synergistic effects were observed in combinations of these two antibiotic classes. Adjunctive use of azithromycin and doxycycline preliminarily improved survival in vascular pythiosis patients with residual disease. Further studies are needed to understand the trends of ESR and CRP in this population.

Loop-mediated Isothermal Amplification (LAMP) for Identification of Pythium insidiosum

OBJECTIVE

Pythium insidiosum causes a life-threatening condition called pythiosis. High morbidity and mortality of pythiosis are consequences of delayed diagnosis. We aimed to develop a loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) assay for the rapid detection of P. insidiosum for use in remote areas, where pythiosis is prevalent.

METHODS

We designed four LAMP primers to amplify the rDNA sequence. A side-by-side comparison evaluated performances of LAMP and the previously-established multiplex PCR (M-PCR), using gDNA samples extracted from colonies of P. insidiosum (n = 28) and other fungi (n = 54), and tissues of animals with (n = 16) or without (n = 13) pythiosis.

RESULTS

LAMP demonstrated a 50% shorter assay duration (1.5 h) and a 10-fold lower limit of detection (10^-4 ng) than did M-PCR. Based on colony-extracted gDNAs, LAMP and M-PCR correctly reported P. insidiosum in all 28 samples, providing 100% sensitivity. While M-PCR did not amplify all fungal controls (100% specificity), LAMP falsely detected one organism (98% specificity). Based on the clinical samples, LAMP and M-PCR provided an equivalently-high specificity (100%). However, LAMP showed a markedly-higher sensitivity than that of M-PCR (88% vs. 56%).

CONCLUSIONS

LAMP is a simple, useful, efficient assay for the detection of P. insidiosum in clinical specimens and pure cultures in resource-limited laboratories.

Genotyping and phylogenetic analysis of Pythium insidiosum causing human corneal ulcer

Pythium insidiosum belongs to the Oomycetes, which are known to cause serious life-threatening infectious condition in humans and animals. Corneal infections caused by P. insidiosum are rare and difficult to treat. The molecular-based diagnosis of Pythium is employed for the species identification and to study molecular phylogenetic relationship. Based on Cytochrome oxidase II (cox II) gene, P. insidiosum is categorized into three clades or groups: Clade-I or ATH (American strains), Clade-II or BTH (American, Asian, and Australian strains), and Clade-III or CTH (mostly Thailand strains). This study focused on the molecular identification of Pythium insidiosum from patients with corneal ulcer using ITS regions and clade identification by cox II gene sequencing and correlated with the clinical outcome. The isolates were collected from Aravind Eye Hospital, Madurai, India, from April to December 2018. Through the microbiological laboratory reports, 15 isolates of Pythium sp. from keratitis patient were selected, followed by DNA extraction, ITS, and cox II gene sequencing and phylogenetic analysis using the reference sequences from NCBI database. All 15 P. insidiosum isolates were phylogenetically clustered together as a single group and where also placed distantly from other Pythium species (outgroup). Most ocular isolates fell into either clade BTH or clade CTH, and none of our ocular isolates were in clade ATH. Two of the strains were very distinct and did not match any of the clusters indicating different lineages. There was no significant difference between clinical outcome and genotype of P. insidiosum.

Equine pythiosis in Egypt: clinicopathological findings, detection, identification and genotyping of Pythium insidiosum

BACKGROUND

Equine pythiosis is an emerging, devastating disease that is hard to treat. The tumour-like nodular skin masses grow rapidly and the outcome is generally fatal, and thus early diagnosis and intervention are important.

OBJECTIVES

(i) To highlight the clinical, histological and haematological findings in pythiosis, and (ii) to evaluate the efficacy of direct sample multiplex-PCR targeting the single nucleotide polymorphisms within the ribosomal DNA region for detection and genotyping of Pythium insidiosum.

ANIMALS

Two hundred and twenty horses including 204 Arabian and 16 draft horses were surveyed.

METHODS

Case series study diagnosis was based on clinical, pathological and haematological findings typical of P. insidiosum infection, culture identification, immunohistochemical investigation and direct sample PCR.

RESULTS

The affected horses (24 of 220, 10.91%) presented with unifocal or multiple lesions on the abdomen, limbs, chest, face and mammary gland. Cases commonly had a history of access to stagnant water, ponds and intentionally flooded rice fields. Most were pregnant mares (58.33%). Histopathology revealed granulomatous reaction, blood vessel endotheliosis, heavy infiltration of eosinophils in the dermal layer, multifocal necrosis and Splendore-Hoeppli phenomenon. Unlike direct microscopy (50%) and culture (91.6%), multiplex-PCR assay identified P. insidiosum (Clade II) in all tested samples. To the best of the authors knowledge, this is the first study determining a clade of P. insidiosum causing equine pythiosis in Egypt.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL IMPORTANCE

Direct sample multiplex-PCR assay is a potential tool for the early and rapid diagnosis of equine pythiosis. It overcomes limitations associated with morphological identification and provides a definitive diagnosis.

In Vitro Susceptibility of Thai Pythium insidiosum Isolates to Antibacterial Agents

Human pythiosis is a life-threatening human disease caused by Pythium insidiosum In Thailand, vascular pythiosis is the most common form and carries a mortality rate of 10 to 40%, despite aggressive treatment with radical surgery, antifungal agents, and immunotherapy. Itraconazole and terbinafine have been the mainstay of treatment, until recently, based on case report data showing potential synergistic effects against Brazilian P. insidiosum isolates. However, the synergistic effects of itraconazole and terbinafine against Thai P. insidiosum isolates were not observed. This study tested the in vitro susceptibilities of 27 Thai human P. insidiosum isolates (clade II, n = 17; clade IV, n = 10), 12 Thai environmental P. insidiosum isolates (clade II, n = 4; clade IV, n = 8), and 11 non-Thai animal P. insidiosum isolates (clade I, n = 9; clade II, n = 2) to antibiotics in eight antibacterial classes to evaluate alternative effective treatments. Tetracycline and macrolide antibiotics demonstrated in vitro activity against Thai P. insidiosum isolates, with doxycycline MICs (1 to 16 μg/ml), minocycline MICs (1 to 4 μg/ml), tigecycline MICs (1 to 4 μg/ml), azithromycin MICs (1 to 16 μg/ml), and clarithromycin MICs (0.125 to 8 μg/ml) being the lowest, on average. Synergistic effects of tetracyclines and macrolides were also observed.

Clinical outcomes in ocular pythiosis patients treated with a combination therapy protocol in Thailand: A prospective study

Ocular pythiosis is the second most common form of human pythiosis, and the rates of evisceration/enucleation in Thailand are 55-79%. This prospective study was conducted to evaluate treatment outcomes of the combination therapy protocol and the potential use of serum (1→3)-β-glucan (BG) and Pythium insidiosum-specific antibody (Pi-Ab) as an aid to diagnosis and monitoring of ocular pythiosis. Thirty patients were enrolled in the study and 14 (non-globe salvage) required evisceration/enucleation. The globe salvage group was significantly younger, and first ocular surgeries were performed significantly sooner than in the non-globe salvage group. Serum BG and Pi-Ab levels were similar among the 2 groups over time. In vitro susceptibility testing of antifungal agents revealed relatively high minimum inhibitory concentrations and lack of synergistic effect. Serum BG and Pi-Ab would not be useful in diagnosis and monitoring of ocular pythiosis. Until effective antimicrobial agents are discovered, ocular surgeries are still the mainstay therapy in Thailand.

Human Pythiosis: Emergence of Fungal-Like Organism

Pythiosis is an emerging infectious disease caused by the aquatic oomycete Pythium insidiosum, a fungal-like organism. It is believed that P. insidiosum's zoospores, its infected form, play major role in pathogenesis. Vascular and ocular infections are the most common clinical manifestation in humans. It is difficult to establish the diagnosis given its relatively rarity and difficulty to distinguish P. insidiosum from other molds. Delay in diagnosis and treatment has been associated with poor outcomes. High index of suspicion is the key, particularly in thalassemia patients with arterial insufficiency and patients with fungal keratitis/endophthalmitis without improvement on antifungal therapy. Tissue culture and zoospore induction remain gold standard for diagnosis; however, DNA-based method should be performed simultaneously. The combination of radical surgery, antifungal agents, and immunotherapy has been recommended. It was previously believed that surgery with negative surgical margins was the essential to survive in vascular pythiosis; however, it was recently found that patients could have residual disease despite documented negative surgical margins as infected clot may be dislodged to proximal arterial sites prior to surgery. Serum β-D-glucan (BG) has been used to monitor disease response after treatment initiation in vascular pythiosis. A significant decrease in BG levels within 2 weeks after surgery is indicative of the absence of residual infection. Unfortunately, monitoring tools for ocular pythiosis are not yet available. Itraconazole plus terbinafine have generally been used in P. insidiosum-infected patients; however, antibacterial agents, including azithromycin and linezolid, have also been used with favorable outcomes in ocular disease. Recently, azithromycin or clarithromycin plus doxycyclin were used in two relapsed vascular pythiosis patients with good outcomes.

Can the pyruvate: ferredoxin oxidoreductase (PFOR) gene be used as an additional marker to discriminate among Blastocystis strains or subtypes?

BACKGROUND

Blastocystis spp. are the most prevalent intestinal eukaryotes identified in humans, with at least 17 genetic subtypes (ST) based on genes coding for the small-subunit ribosomal RNA (18S). It has been argued that the 18S gene should not be the marker of choice to discriminate between STs of these strains because this marker exhibits high intra-genomic polymorphism. By contrast, pyruvate:ferredoxin oxidoreductase (PFOR) is a relevant enzyme involved in the core energy metabolism of many anaerobic microorganisms such as Blastocystis, which, in other protozoa, shows more polymorphisms than the 18S gene and thus may offer finer discrimination when trying to identify Blastocystis ST. Therefore, the objective of the present study was to assess the suitability of the PFOR gene as an additional marker to discriminate among Blastocystis strains or subtypes from symptomatic carrier children.

METHODS

Faecal samples from 192 children with gastrointestinal symptoms from the State of Mexico were submitted for coprological study. Twenty-one of these samples were positive only for Blastocystis spp.; these samples were analysed by PCR sequencing of regions of the 18S and PFOR genes. The amplicons were purified and sequenced; afterwards, both markers were assessed for genetic diversity.

RESULTS

The 18S analysis showed the following frequencies of Blastocystis subtypes: ST3 = 43%; ST1 = 38%; ST2 = 14%; and ST7 = 5%. Additionally, using subtype-specific primer sets, two samples showed mixed Blastocystis ST1 and ST2 infection. For PFOR, Bayesian inference revealed the presence of three clades (I-III); two of them grouped different ST samples, and one grouped six samples of ST3 (III). Nucleotide diversity (π) and haplotype polymorphism (θ) for the 18S analysis were similar for ST1 and ST2 (π = ~0.025 and θ = ~0.036); remarkably, ST3 showed almost 10-fold lower values. For PFOR, a similar trend was found: clade I and II had π = ~0.05 and θ = ~0.05, whereas for clade III, the values were almost 6-fold lower.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the fragment of the PFOR gene analysed in the present study did not allow discrimination between Blastocystis STs, this marker grouped the samples in three clades with strengthened support, suggesting that PFOR may be under different selective pressures and evolutionary histories than the 18S gene. Interestingly, the ST3 sequences showed lower variability with probable purifying selection in both markers, meaning that evolutionary forces drive differential processes among Blastocystis STs.

Monitoring Anti-Pythium insidiosum IgG Antibodies and (1→3)-β-d-Glucan in Vascular Pythiosis

Despite aggressive treatment, vascular pythiosis has a mortality rate of 40%. This is due to delays in diagnosis and a lack of effective monitoring tools. To overcome this drawback, serum beta-d-glucan (BG) and P. insidiosum-specific antibody (Pi-Ab) were examined as potential monitoring markers in vascular pythiosis. A prospective cohort study of vascular pythiosis patients was carried out from January 2010 to July 2016. Clinical information and blood samples were collected and evaluated by the BG and Pi-Ab assays. Linear mixed-effect models were used to compare BG and Pi-Ab levels. The in vitro susceptibility test was performed with all P. insidiosum isolates from culture-positive cases. A total of 50 patients were enrolled: 45 survived and 5 died during follow-up. The survivors had a significantly shorter time to medical care (P < 0.0001) and a significantly shorter waiting time to the first surgery (P < 0.0001). There were no differences in BG levels among the groups at diagnosis (P = 0.33); however, BG levels among survivors were significantly lower than those of the deceased group at 0.5 months (P < 0.0001) and became undetectable after 3 months. Survivors were able to maintain an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) value (EV) of Pi-Ab above 8, whereas the EV among deceased patients was less than 4. In vitro susceptibility results revealed no synergistic effects between itraconazole and terbinafine. This study showed that BG and Pi-Ab are potentially valuable markers to monitor the disease after treatment initiation. An unchanged BG level at 2 weeks after surgery should prompt an evaluation for residual disease.