Anti-GaL IgG antibodies in sera of newborn humans and baboons and its significance in pig xenotransplantation

Antibody production and tolerance to the α-gal epitope as models for understanding and preventing the immune response to incompatible ABO carbohydrate antigens and for α-gal therapies

This review describes the significance of the α-gal epitope (Galα-3Galβ1-4GlcNAc-R) as the core of human blood-group A and B antigens (A and B antigens), determines in mouse models the principles underlying the immune response to these antigens, and suggests future strategies for the induction of immune tolerance to incompatible A and B antigens in human allografts. Carbohydrate antigens, such as ABO antigens and the α-gal epitope, differ from protein antigens in that they do not interact with T cells, but B cells interacting with them require T-cell help for their activation. The α-gal epitope is the core of both A and B antigens and is the ligand of the natural anti-Gal antibody, which is abundant in all humans. In A and O individuals, anti-Gal clones (called anti-Gal/B) comprise >85% of the so-called anti-B activity and bind to the B antigen in facets that do not include fucose-linked α1-2 to the core α-gal. As many as 1% of B cells are anti-Gal B cells. Activation of quiescent anti-Gal B cells upon exposure to α-gal epitopes on xenografts and some protozoa can increase the titer of anti-Gal by 100-fold. α1,3-Galactosyltransferase knockout (GT-KO) mice lack α-gal epitopes and can produce anti-Gal. These mice simulate human recipients of ABO-incompatible human allografts. Exposure for 2-4 weeks of naïve and memory mouse anti-Gal B cells to α-gal epitopes in the heterotopically grafted wild-type (WT) mouse heart results in the elimination of these cells and immune tolerance to this epitope. Shorter exposures of 7 days of anti-Gal B cells to α-gal epitopes in the WT heart result in the production of accommodating anti-Gal antibodies that bind to α-gal epitopes but do not lyse cells or reject the graft. Tolerance to α-gal epitopes due to the elimination of naïve and memory anti-Gal B cells can be further induced by 2 weeks in vivo exposure to WT lymphocytes or autologous lymphocytes engineered to present α-gal epitopes by transduction of the α1,3-galactosyltransferase gene. These mouse studies suggest that autologous human lymphocytes similarly engineered to present the A or B antigen may induce corresponding tolerance in recipients of ABO-incompatible allografts. The review further summarizes experimental works demonstrating the efficacy of α-gal therapies in amplifying anti-viral and anti-tumor immune-protection and regeneration of injured tissues.

The Quantification of IgG Specific to α-Gal Could Be Used as a Risk Marker for Suffering Mammalian Meat Allergy

The alpha-Gal Syndrome is a delayed meat allergy characterized by the presence of sIgE against α-Gal epitope. It is known that the α-Gal present in tick saliva induces the sensitization to this epitope ending in the production of sIgG and sIgE to α-Gal. It could be considered that the more times a person is bitten by tick species, the higher the probability of making the switch from sIgG to sIgE to α-Gal and developing allergy, but it is no clear when the switch occurs. To determine the likelihood that a subject bitten by ticks but without AGS be at risk of developing this allergy, we quantified the levels of sIgG to α-Gal by an automated system (ImmunoCap). To stablish a cut-off value for sIgG to α-Gal, a receiving operating curve (ROC) was constructed. The statistical analysis demonstrated that the risk of suffering AGS in individuals bitten by ticks was 35% when the sIgG to α-Gal was greater than or equal to 40 µg/mL. Our data indicate that the sIgG values against α-Gal could be used as a prognostic marker for developing mammalian meat allergy.

The immune system in infants: Relevance to xenotransplantation

Despite the improvement in surgical interventions in the treatment of congenital heart disease, many life-threatening lesions (eg, hypoplastic left heart syndrome) ultimately require transplantation. However, there is a great limitation in the availability of deceased human cardiac donors of a suitable size. Hearts from genetically engineered pigs may provide an alternative source. The relatively immature immune system in infants (eg, absence of anti-carbohydrate antibodies, reduced complement activation, reduced innate immune cell activity) should minimize the risk of early antibody-mediated rejection of a pig graft. Additionally, recipient thymectomy, performed almost routinely as a preliminary to orthotopic heart transplantation in this age-group, impairs the T-cell response. Because of the increasing availability of genetically engineered pigs (eg, triple-knockout pigs that do not express any of the three known carbohydrate antigens against which humans have natural antibodies) and the ability to diagnose congenital heart disease during fetal life, cardiac xenotransplantation could be preplanned to be carried out soon after birth. Because of these several advantages, prolonged graft survival and even the induction of tolerance, for example, following donor-specific pig thymus transplantation, are more likely to be achieved in infants than in adults. In this review, we summarize the factors in the infant immune system that would be advantageous in the success of cardiac xenotransplantation in this age-group.

Complement activation by human IgG antibodies to galactose-α-1,3-galactose

Some human antibodies may paradoxically inhibit complement activation on bacteria and enhance pathogen survival in humans. This property was also claimed for IgG antibodies reacting with terminal galactose-α-1,3-galactose (Galα3Gal; IgG anti-αGal), a naturally occurring and abundant antibody in human plasma that targets numerous different pathogens. To reinvestigate these effects, we used IgG anti-αGal affinity isolated from a pool of normal human IgG and human hypogammaglobulinaemia serum as a complement source. Flow cytometry was performed to examine antibody binding and complement deposition on pig erythrocytes, Escherichia coli O86 and Streptococcus pneumoniae serotype 9V. Specific nanobodies were used to block the effect of single complement factors and to delineate the complement pathways involved. IgG anti-αGal was capable of activating the classical complement pathway on all the tested target cells. The degree of activation was exponentially related to the density of bound antibody on E. coli O86 and pig erythrocytes, but more linearly on S. pneumoniae 9V. The alternative pathway of complement amplified complement deposition. Deposited C3 fragments covered the activating IgG anti-αGal, obstructing its detection and highlighting this as a likely general caveat in studies of antibody density and complement deposition. The inherent capacity for complement activation by the purified carbohydrate reactive IgG anti-αGal was similar to that of normal human IgG. We propose that the previously reported complement inhibition by IgG anti-αGal relates to suboptimal assay configurations, in contrast to the complement activating property of the antibodies demonstrated in this paper.

B Cell Responses in the Development of Mammalian Meat Allergy

Studies of meat allergic patients have shown that eating meat poses a serious acute health risk that can induce severe cutaneous, gastrointestinal, and respiratory reactions. Allergic reactions in affected individuals following meat consumption are mediated predominantly by IgE antibodies specific for galactose-α-1,3-galactose (α-gal), a blood group antigen of non-primate mammals and therefore present in dietary meat. α-gal is also found within certain tick species and tick bites are strongly linked to meat allergy. Thus, it is thought that exposure to tick bites promotes cutaneous sensitization to tick antigens such as α-gal, leading to the development of IgE-mediated meat allergy. The underlying immune mechanisms by which skin exposure to ticks leads to the production of α-gal-specific IgE are poorly understood and are key to identifying novel treatments for this disease. In this review, we summarize the evidence of cutaneous exposure to tick bites and the development of mammalian meat allergy. We then provide recent insights into the role of B cells in IgE production in human patients with mammalian meat allergy and in a novel mouse model of meat allergy. Finally, we discuss existing data more generally focused on tick-mediated immunomodulation, and highlight possible mechanisms for how cutaneous exposure to tick bites might affect B cell responses in the skin and gut that contribute to loss of oral tolerance.

The Possible Role of Anti-Neu5Gc as an Obstacle in Xenotransplantation

Seventy to ninety percentage of preformed xenoreactive antibodies in human serum bind to the galactose-α(1,3)-galactose Gal epitope, and the creation of Gal knockout (KO) pigs has eliminated hyperacute rejection as a barrier to xenotransplantation. Now other glycan antigens are barriers to move ahead with xenotransplantation, and the N-glycolyl neuraminic acid, Neu5Gc (or Hanganutziu-Deicher antigen), is also a major pig xenoantigen. Humans have anti-Neu5Gc antibodies. Several data indicate a strong immunogenicity of Neu5Gc in humans that may contribute to an important part in antibody-dependent injury to pig xenografts. Pig islets express Neu5Gc, which reacted with diet-derived human antibodies and mice deleted for Neu5Gc reject pancreatic islets from wild-type counterpart. However, Neu5Gc positive heart were not rejected in Neu5Gc KO mice indicating that the role of Neu5Gc-specific antibodies has to be nuanced and depend of the graft situation parameters (organ/tissue, recipient, implication of other glycan antigens). Recently generated Gal/Neu5Gc KO pigs eliminate the expression of Gal and Neu5Gc, and improve the crossmatch of humans with the pig. This review summarizes the current and recent experimental and (pre)clinical data on the Neu5Gc immunogenicity and emphasize of the potential impact of anti-Neu5Gc antibodies in limiting xenotransplantation in humans.

The Case for Cardiac Xenotransplantation in Neonates: Is Now the Time to Reconsider Xenotransplantation for Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome?

Neonatal cardiac transplantation for hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS) is associated with excellent long-term survival compared to older recipients. However, heart transplantation for neonates is greatly limited by the critical shortage of donor hearts, and by the associated mortality of the long pre-transplant waiting period. This led to the development of staged surgical palliation as the first-line surgical therapy for HLHS. Recent advances in genetic engineering and xenotransplantation have provided the potential to replicate the excellent results of neonatal cardiac allotransplantation while eliminating wait-list-associated mortality through genetically modified pig-to-human neonatal cardiac xenotransplantation. The elimination of the major pig antigens in addition to the immature B-cell response in neonates allows for the potential to induce B-cell tolerance. Additionally, the relatively mature neonatal T-cell response could be reduced by thymectomy at the time of operation combined with donor-specific pig thymus transplantation to "reprogram" the host's T-cells to recognize the xenograft as host tissue. In light of the recent significantly increased graft survival of genetically-engineered pig-to-baboon cardiac xenotransplantation, we propose that now is the time to consider devoting research to advance the potential clinical application of cardiac xenotransplantation as a treatment option for patients with HLHS. Employing cardiac xenotransplantation could revolutionize therapy for complex congenital heart defects and open a new chapter in the field of pediatric cardiac transplantation.

Toward a solution for cardiac failure in the newborn

The newborn infant with severe cardiac failure owed to congenital structural heart disease or cardiomyopathy poses a daunting therapeutic challenge. The ideal solution for both might be cardiac transplantation if availability of hearts was not limiting and if tolerance could be induced, obviating toxicity of immunosuppressive therapy. If one could safely and effectively exploit neonatal tolerance for successful xenotransplantation of the heart, the challenge of severe cardiac failure in the newborn infant might be met. We discuss the need, the potential for applying neonatal tolerance in the setting of xenotransplantation and the possibility that other approaches to this problem might emerge.

An approach to induction of tolerance to pig cardiac xenografts in neonates

There is a continuing need for donor hearts for infants with complex congenital heart defects. The transplantation of hearts from neonatal pigs would be an alternative to human organs, particularly if donor-specific immunological tolerance could be achieved. The great majority of infant humans do not make natural (preformed) antibodies against triple-knockout (TKO) pigs (that do not express any of the three known pig antigens against which humans have natural anti-pig antibodies). The transplantation of a heart from a TKO pig into an infant would therefore minimize any risk of early antibody-mediated rejection, and, with adequate immunosuppressive therapy, prolonged graft survival may well be achieved. Total host thymectomy (commonly carried out at the time of orthotopic heart transplantation in this age group) ± residual T-cell depletion and donor-specific pig thymus tissue transplantation might induce T-cell tolerance and allow immunosuppressive therapy to be discontinued (if there is in vitro evidence of T-cell and B-cell nonresponsiveness to donor-specific pig cells). Even if tolerance were not achieved, with continuing immunosuppressive therapy, the graft would likely "bridge" the patient until a suitable allograft became available or be associated with prolonged xenograft function.

Modifying the sugar icing on the transplantation cake

As a transplant surgeon, my interest in glycobiology began through my research into ABO-incompatible allotransplantation, and grew when my goal became overcoming the shortage of organs from deceased human donors by the transplantation of pig organs into patients with terminal organ failure (xenotransplantation/cross-species transplantation). The major target for human "natural" (preformed) anti-pig antibodies is galactose-α(1,3)-galactose (the "Gal" epitope), which is expressed on many pig cells, including the vascular endothelium. The binding of human IgM and IgG antibodies to Gal antigens initiates the process of hyperacute rejection, resulting in destruction of the pig graft within minutes or hours. This major barrier has been overcome by the production of pigs in which the gene for the enzyme α(1,3)-galactosyltransferase (GT) has been deleted by genetic engineering, resulting in GT knockout (GTKO) pigs. The two other known carbohydrate antigenic targets on pig cells for human anti-pig antibodies are (i) the product of the cytidine monophosphate-N-acetylneuraminic acid hydroxylase (CMAH) gene, i.e., N-glycolylneuraminic acid, and (ii) the product of the β1,4 N-acetylgalactosaminyltransferase gene, i.e., the Sd(a) antigen. Expression of these two has also been deleted in pigs. These genetic manipulations, together with others directed to overcoming primate complement and coagulation activation (the latter of which also relates to glycobiology) have contributed to the prolongation of pig graft survival in nonhuman primate recipients to many months rather than a few minutes. Clinical trials of the transplantation of pig cells are already underway and transplantation of pig organs may be expected within the relatively near future.

The pathobiology of pig-to-primate xenotransplantation: a historical review

The immunologic barriers to successful xenotransplantation are related to the presence of natural anti-pig antibodies in humans and non-human primates that bind to antigens expressed on the transplanted pig organ (the most important of which is galactose-α1,3-galactose [Gal]), and activate the complement cascade, which results in rapid destruction of the graft, a process known as hyperacute rejection. High levels of elicited anti-pig IgG may develop if the adaptive immune response is not prevented by adequate immunosuppressive therapy, resulting in activation and injury of the vascular endothelium. The transplantation of organs and cells from pigs that do not express the important Gal antigen (α1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout [GTKO] pigs) and express one or more human complement-regulatory proteins (hCRP, e.g., CD46, CD55), when combined with an effective costimulation blockade-based immunosuppressive regimen, prevents early antibody-mediated and cellular rejection. However, low levels of anti-non-Gal antibody and innate immune cells and/or platelets may initiate the development of a thrombotic microangiopathy in the graft that may be associated with a consumptive coagulopathy in the recipient. This pathogenic process is accentuated by the dysregulation of the coagulation-anticoagulation systems between pigs and primates. The expression in GTKO/hCRP pigs of a human coagulation-regulatory protein, for example, thrombomodulin, is increasingly being associated with prolonged pig graft survival in non-human primates. Initial clinical trials of islet and corneal xenotransplantation are already underway, and trials of pig kidney or heart transplantation are anticipated within the next few years.

Anti-Gal IgM, IgA and IgG natural antibodies in childhood

The target for the most abundant xenoreactive natural antibodies in humans is the α-Gal epitope. Anti-Gal could provide natural immune defense against pathogens that express the α-Gal epitope. Anti-Gal natural antibodies are usually studied in adult individuals. Data demonstrating the incidence and concentration of anti-Gal natural antibodies in childhood are in short supply and incomplete. In the present study we prospectively quantified anti-Gal IgM, IgA and IgG levels in different age groups of children from delivery to 24 months of age and compared these levels to the level of these antibodies in their respective mothers. Measurement of anti-Gal antibodies may broaden the spectrum of specific antibodies that are available for determination of specific antibody responses in physiological and pathological conditions in children. Plasma was collected from umbilical cord blood of full term newborn, from blood of infants at age 6, 12 and 24 months and from their respective mothers at time of delivery. Quantitative determination of anti-Gal antibodies IgM, IgA and IgG were made with the enzyme immunoassays Human Anti-Alpha Galactosyl IgM ELISA, IgG ELISA and IgA ELISA. Hemagglutination activity was titrated against rabbit erythrocytes. The kinetic processes for the formation of natural antibodies in the first two years of life, in general, compared with the kinetics for the formation of total immunoglobulins IgM, IgA and IgG. There were no detectable anti-Gal IgM and IgA in the cord blood, whereas anti-Gal IgG were found at similar levels in both neonate cord blood and peripheral blood of their respective mothers. When comparing the percentage of natural antibodies in the plasma of children, the level of natural antibodies in children at the age of two years was approximately 37% for IgM, 25% for IgG and 15% for IgA. The titration of antibodies required for agglutination of rabbit red blood cells over the 24 month period followed the same trend observed for the formation of natural antibodies. Our study demonstrates the kinetics of formation of anti-Gal IgM, IgA and IgG natural antibodies in the first two years of life. The relative lack of these antibodies in this period should be taken into account when assessing for humoral immunodeficiencies, particularly with regards to the potential for children to mount an anti-carbohydrate response.

Plasma anti-α-galactoside antibody binds to serine- and threonine-rich peptide sequence of apo(a) subunit in Lp(a)

Lipoprotein(a) immune complexes [Lp(a) IC] of varying particle density obtained by ultracentrifugation of plasma from normal healthy donors were markedly dominated by IgG. Lp(a) and immunoglobulins were liberated from plasma Lp(a) IC by treatment with melibiose, a sugar specific for circulating anti-α-galactoside antibody (anti-Gal). Upon incubation with plasma lipoprotein fraction anti-Gal but not the α-glucoside-specific antibody from human plasma formed de novo IC with Lp(a). Binding of Lp(a) sugar-reversibly enhanced the fluorescence of FITC-labeled anti-Gal as did binding of α-galactoside-containing glycoproteins. This effect apparently due to conformational shift in the Fc region of the antibody was also produced by apo(a) subunit separated from Lp(a) and de-O-glycosylated apo(a) but not by any other plasma lipoproteins or by Lp(a) pre-incubated with the O-glycan-specific lectin jacalin. O-Glycans and their terminal sialic acid moieties in apo(a) of circulating Lp(a)-anti-Gal IC, in contrast to those in pure Lp(a), were inaccessible to jacalin and anion exchange resin, respectively. Unlike other plasma lipoproteins, Lp(a) inhibited Griffonia simplicifolia isolectin B4 which also accommodates serine- and threonine-rich peptide sequence (STPS) as surrogate ligand to α-galactosides at its binding site. Results suggest that anti-Gal recognizes STPS in the O-glycan-rich regions of apo(a) subunit in Lp(a) which contains no α-linked galactose.

Anti-gal antibodies in α1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout pigs

Serum anti-galactose-α1,3-galactose (Gal) IgM and IgG antibody levels were measured by ELISA in α1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout (GTKO) pigs (78 estimations in 47 pigs). A low level of anti-Gal IgM was present soon after birth, and rose to a peak at 4-6 m, which was maintained thereafter even in the oldest pigs tested (at >2 yr). Anti-Gal IgG was also present at birth, peaked at 3 m, and after 6 m steadily decreased until almost undetectable at 20 m. No differences in this pattern were seen between pigs of different gender. Total IgM followed a similar pattern as anti-Gal IgM, but total IgG did not decrease after 6m. The data provide useful baseline data for future experimental studies in GTKO pigs, e.g., relating to the antibody response to WT pig allografts.

Late onset of development of natural anti-nonGal antibodies in infant humans and baboons: implications for xenotransplantation in infants

If an ABO-incompatible heart is transplanted into an infant before natural antibodies have developed to the specific donor carbohydrate A/B antigen(s), then B-cell tolerance to the donor A/B antigen is achieved, and these antibodies never develop. Anti-carbohydrate antibodies play a role in the rejection of wild type (WT) and alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase gene-knockout (GT-KO) pig xenografts. We investigated development of these antibodies in infant baboons and humans. Serum samples from infant baboons (n = 42) and humans (n = 42) were tested by flow cytometry for immunoglobulin M and immunoglobulin G binding to peripheral blood mononuclear cells from WT and GT-KO pigs, and for complement-dependent cytotoxicity. The presence of anti-blood group antibodies was tested in baboon serum. In infant baboons and humans, cytotoxic anti-Galalpha1,3Gal antibodies develop during the first 3 months, and steadily increase with age, whereas cytotoxic anti-nonGal antibodies are either absent or minimal in the majority of cases throughout the first year of life. Anti-blood group antibodies were not detected before 16 weeks of age. Our data suggest GT-KO pig organ/cell transplants could be carried out in early infancy in the absence of preformed cytotoxic anti-nonGalalpha1,3Gal antibodies.

Feasibility of xeno-transplantation

Within a relatively short time span, a significant number of barriers to xeno-transplantation have been identified and potential solutions generated; however, the survival rates for pig-to-primate heart transplantation remain modest at best, with the longest functioning heterotopic heart transplant surviving only 99 days and the longest functioning orthotopic heart transplant surviving only 39 days. A great deal of improvement in immunological strategies will be needed to make xeno-transplantation a clinical reality. The most exciting prospect in the near term is the use of organs from homozygous alphaGal knockout pigs. The diversity of the biological pathways involved in the total spectrum of xenograft rejection, however, makes it highly likely that the clinical feasibility of xeno-transplantation will depend on a multipronged approach that incorporates the advantages of genetically eliminating the alphaGal epitope on hyperacute and acute xenograft rejection and the advantages of tolerance induction on cellular and chronic xenograft rejection.

Xenotransplantation and pig endogenous retroviruses

Xenotransplantation, in particular transplantation of pig cells, tissues and organs into human patients, may alleviate the current shortage of suitable allografts available for human transplantation. This overview addresses the physiological, immunological and virological factors considered with regard to xenotransplantation. Among the issues reviewed are the merits of using pigs as xenograft source species, the compatibility of pig and human organ physiology and the immunological hindrances with regard to the various types of rejection and attempts at abrogating rejection. Advances in the prevention of pig organ rejection by creating genetically modified pigs that are more suited to the human microenvironment are also discussed. Finally, with regard to virology, possible zoonotic infections emanating from pigs are reviewed, with special emphasis on the pig endogenous retrovirus (PERV). An in depth account of PERV studies, comprising their discovery as well as recent knowledge of the virus, is given. To date, all retrospective studies on patients with pig xenografts have shown no evidence of PERV transmission, however, many factors make us interpret these results with caution. Although the lack of PERV infection in xenograft recipients up to now is encouraging, more basic research and controlled animal studies that mimic the pig to human xenotransplantation setting more closely are required for safety assessment.

Xenotransplantation

The continued and growing success of lung allotransplantation has intensified the worldwide shortage of donor organs. Yet, xenotransplantation remains a daunting challenge. Additional molecular incompatibilities and unforeseen complications will continue to be discovered. Progress has been made, notably on the generation of alpha-Gal double knockout pigs. Progressive increases in organ survival times have been seen for most organs after significant investments of time and money. The lung continues to be an organ with the lowest supply of cadaveric donors and the least potential for expanded living donation or mechanical alternatives. As such, the impetus for xenotransplantation is strong. The lung appears to be exquisitely sensitive to xenograft rejection and resistant to strategies that have been moderately successful in other organs. A complex program involving genetically modified donor organs, recipient preparation for antibody removal or tolerance promotion, and multitargeted drug therapy will likely be required for successful clinical application.

Are anti-endothelial cell antibodies a pre-requisite for the acute vascular rejection of xenografts?

BACKGROUND

Vascular rejection occurring within the first few weeks after transplantation is still the major immunological barrier to the long term survival of xenografts. Currently there is no consensus about what to call this type of rejection (acute vascular rejection, delayed xenograft rejection or acute humoral xenograft rejection), nor about how to prevent or treat it.

METHODS

A review of published evidence to define the heterogeneity of this phase of rejection and examine the role of antibodies, complement and graft-infiltrating inflammatory cells.

RESULTS

i) antibodies are always involved in acute vascular rejection; ii) this antibody-mediated rejection may be complement-dependent or -independent; iii) inflammatory cells may mediate an antibody- and complement-independent phase of rejection in some small animal models (which, in its pure form cannot be called 'vascular rejection') iv) there remain significant questions about the relevance of 'accommodation' and the importance of coagulation abnormalities.

CONCLUSIONS

Without doubt, future research would be helped by distinguishing between these different forms of delayed xenograft rejection, using terminology to reflect the involvement of specific pathophysiological mechanisms. An updated classification of the stages of xenograft rejection is proposed here.

Induction of cytolytic anti-Gal antibodies in alpha-1,3-galactosyltransferase gene knockout mice by oral inoculation with Escherichia coli O86:B7 bacteria

Naturally occurring antibodies against [Gal alpha-1,3-Gal] structures (anti-Gal antibodies) are the primary effectors of human hyperacute rejection (HAR) of nonhuman tissue. Unlike most mammals, humans lack a functional alpha-1,3-galactosyltransferase (GalT) gene and produce abundant anti-Gal antibodies, putatively in response to GalT(+) enteric bacteria. GalT knockout (KO) mice have been generated as a small animal model of HAR but inconsistently express anti-Gal antibodies. We hypothesized that enteric exposure of GalT KO mice to live GalT(+) bacteria would produce cytolytic anti-Gal antibodies. Naive mice lacking anti-Gal antibodies were orally immunized with 10(10) live GalT(+) Escherichia coli O86:B7 bacteria and assayed for anti-Gal antibody titer, isotype, and cytolytic activity. Fecal samples were tested for E. coli O86:B7 prior to and after inoculation. In two separate experiments, 77 to 100% (n = 31) of mice developed serum anti-Gal immunoglobulin G (IgG; titer, 1:5 to 1:80) and/or anti-Gal IgM antibodies (titer, 1:5 to 1:1,280) 14 days postinoculation. Induced anti-Gal antibodies caused complement-mediated cytolysis of GalT(+) target cells, with extensive cytolysis observed consistently at serum IgM titers of >/=1:320. Absorption with synthetic [Gal alpha-1,3-Gal] inhibited both antibody binding and cytolysis. E. coli O86:B7 was recovered from stool samples from 83 to 94% of inoculated mice but not from naive mice, thus confirming enteric exposure. These findings demonstrate that oral inoculation with E. coli O86:B7 is a novel and effective method to induce cytolytic anti-Gal antibodies in GalT KO mice and support the premise that enteric exposure to GalT(+) bacteria induces anti-Gal antibodies in humans. These studies also suggest a role for GalT KO mice in elucidating anti-Gal responses in microbial immunity.

Gal mismatch alone causes skin graft rejection in mice

BACKGROUND

Elimination of galactose-alpha1,3-galactose (Gal), the major xenoantigen between pig and human, may extend pig-to-human xenograft survival beyond the current barrier of acute vascular rejection. However, it has been suggested that Gal is an essential molecule in the pig and that the generation of a Gal-deleted (Gal KO) pig will not be possible. Should this be the case, understanding the Gal-mediated immune response will be crucial in developing strategies to overcome pig xenograft rejection in humans. There are no existing models of xenograft rejection in which the sole difference between donor and recipient is Gal. We describe a model of exclusively Gal-mismatched skin graft rejection.

METHODS

The survival of Gal skin grafts on Gal KO mice with the same genetic background was analyzed. To examine innate anti-Gal immunity, Gal KO recipients that were also deficient in T and B cells (RAG-1 KO) were used. To study the role of cognate immunity, recipients were sensitized with a primary Gal allograft before receiving a second Gal graft that was otherwise isogeneic. To test the role of anti-Gal antibodies in this model, recipients were passively immunized with a non-complement-fixing anti-Gal monoclonal antibody.

RESULTS

Gal KO mice chronically reject Gal skin grafts by 100 days at a rate of 48% (n=25) on a BALB/c background and 25% (n=8) on a C57BL/6 background. The grafts had an infiltrate that consisted predominantly of CD4 T cells and macrophages, whereas recipients deficient in T and B cells were incapable of rejection and survived for more than 120 days (n=5). Sensitization with a primary Gal allograft increased the incidence and the tempo of rejection of a second Gal-only mismatched skin graft with 99% rejection that ranged from 11 to 45 days (n=26). Passive transfer of mouse IgG anti-Gal monoclonal-antibody-induced rejection in Gal KO and RAG-1/Gal double-KO recipients at a rate of 92% (n=13).

CONCLUSIONS

We have established a model to study rejection based solely on a Gal mismatch. Our results indicate that non-complement-fixing anti-Gal antibody can cause rejection in the acute vascular rejection time frame and that T-cell-mediated chronic rejection will be a further barrier to overcome if Gal cannot be deleted from the pig.

Characterization of baboon anti-porcine IgG antibodies during acute vascular rejection of porcine kidney xenograft

In the pig-to-baboon model, the removal of anti-porcine natural antibodies abrogates hyperacute vascular rejection (HAVR), but the xenograft then undergoes an acute vascular rejection (AVR) concomitantly to the appearance of newly formed anti-porcine antibodies. The use of anti-IgM monoclonal antibody (mAb) in baboons allowed to avoid HAVR of pig-to-baboon renal xenografts, but, at post-operative day 6, AVR occurred because of a rapid return of anti-porcine antibodies. The aim of this work was to characterize the anti-porcine antibodies during AVR. Sera from anti-IgM-treated animals were assessed prior to the graft and at the time of AVR by enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to determine anti-porcine antibodies concentration as well as the IgG subtypes. The same sera were tested on confluent cultures of porcine aortic endothelial cells (PAECs) to assess (i) the cytolytic complement-dependent activity and (ii) the E-selectin expression. The K affinity of anti-Gal IgG antibodies was measured by ELISA. Anti-porcine (Gal and non-Gal) IgG antibodies were tested on PAECs by flow cytometry to discriminate the presence of Gal epitopes from the recognition of other porcine epitopes. We found that both anti-porcine IgM and IgG antibodies presented a significantly increased cytolytic activity and E-selectin expression on PAECs during AVR. These characteristics are related to an important increase of the antibody (Ab) titer (especially anti-galactosyl) and a switch to anti-galactosyl IgG1 subclass production, whereas the K affinity remained unchanged. The deleterious effects of both IgM and IgG antibodies observed during AVR showed the crucial need for treatment controlling the cells producing anti-porcine antibodies.

Development and characterization of anti-Gal B cell receptor transgenic Gal-/- mice

BACKGROUND

The successful clinical application of pig-to-primate xenotransplantation is currently limited by the development of an acute vascular rejection, which is thought to involve an induced humoral immune response to the galactose alpha1,3 galactose (alpha-Gal) antigen. Successful xenotransplantation may require the development of novel methods for removal or neutralization of anti-Gal antibodies and anti-Gal-producing B cells. The large diversity of the B-cell repertoire makes it difficult, however, to isolate and study anti-Gal B-cell development.

METHODS

We have established a transgenic mouse model for investigating anti-Gal B cells by introducing a transgene encoding both heavy and light chains for an anti-Gal IgM antibody into an alpha-galactosyltransferase-deficient (Gal-/-) background. We have characterized the frequency, phenotype, and function of transgenic anti-Gal B cells by multiparameter flow cytometric analysis and ELISA.

RESULTS

ELISA analysis of serum from animals with the transgene in an alpha-galactosyltransferase-deficient background (Tg Gal-/-), from transgenic animals with a heterozygous alpha-galactosyltransferase background (Tg Gal-/+), and from nontransgenic alpha-galactosyltransferase-deficient littermates (Gal-/-) demonstrated elevated expression of anti-Gal antibodies in Tg Gal-/- mice compared with nontransgenic Gal-/- animals and a lack of transgene expression in the Tg Gal-/+ mice. Anti-Gal antibody expression in Tg Gal-/- mice could be increased by immunization with an ovalbumin-Gal glycoconjugate in vivo and through stimulation with lipopolysaccharide in vitro. Multiparameter flow cytometric analysis indicates that 50% to 80% of splenic and peritoneal B cells expressed the transgene and excluded endogenous immunoglobulin gene rearrangements. The majority of these B cells expressed anti-Gal receptors on the surface, as identified by staining with a fluorescein isothiocyanate-bovine serum albumin-Gal glycoconjugate. FACS analysis of the Tg Gal-/- B cells identified them as a population of CD21highCD23lowIgMhigh marginal zone B cells in the spleen and CD5-CD23low B1 cells in the peritoneal cavity.

CONCLUSIONS

These observations suggest that this model can be used to study the regulation of anti-Gal B cells and can establish a reliable source of functional anti-Gal B cells, which could be used to test the effectiveness of alpha-Gal-specific immunosuppressive reagents.

Will the pig solve the transplantation backlog?

The increasing shortage of human cadaveric organs for purposes of transplantation has become the critical limiting factor in the number of transplants performed each year. Some of this deficit is being met by the use of organs or partial organs from living donors, but this source is insufficient. Xenotransplantation-the transplantation of organs between species, namely from the pig to human-could provide a solution if immunologic and other associated problems could be solved. When a pig organ is transplanted into a primate, hyperacute rejection, induced by anti-pig antibody and mediated by complement and the coagulation system, develops rapidly. This immediate problem can now be overcome, but the return or persistence of anti-pig antibody leads to a delayed form of humoral rejection, acute humoral xenograft rejection, which leads to destruction of the organ within days or weeks. We review the various approaches being investigated to overcome this barrier. Whether they will also prevent subsequent acute cellular rejection remains unknown. Brief mention is made of the potential physiologic incompatibilities between pig and human organs, as well as the microbiologic safety aspects of xenotransplantation. Finally, the question of patient and societal acceptance of xenotransplantation is discussed.

Anti-Gal alpha 1-3Gal IgM and IgG antibody levels in sera of humans and old world non-human primates

Organs transplanted from pig to primate are rejected within minutes or hours by an antibody-dependent, complement-mediated mechanism [hyperacute rejection (HAR)]. Even after depletion of anti-Gal alpha 1-3Gal (Gal) antibody (Ab), for example by extracorporeal immunoadsorption, return of natural Ab is believed to be a major factor in the initiation of acute humoral xenograft rejection. Various non-human primates are used as recipients of pig organs in experimental discordant xenotransplantation (XTx) models. However, anti-Gal IgM and IgG levels in non-human primates may differ from those in humans. Serum levels of anti-Gal IgM and IgG were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) in humans (n=14), chimpanzees (n=8), baboons (n=214), cynomolgus monkeys (n=29), rhesus monkeys (n=23) and Japanese monkeys (n=6). The mean level of anti-Gal IgM was significantly higher in chimpanzees than in other groups, while in rhesus monkeys it was significantly lower than in other groups, except baboons and Japanese monkeys. The mean human anti-Gal IgG level was higher than in other groups and this difference reached statistical significance except with regard to chimpanzees. The mean anti-Gal IgG level in baboons was significantly lower than that in humans, chimpanzees and cynomolgus monkeys. The measured differences in anti-Gal IgM and IgG levels may affect the kinetics of Ab removal and rate of return in different species, and thus may have relevance for translating work in non-human primate models to the clinical setting.

Evidence for polyreactive xenoreactive antibodies in the repertoire of human anti-swine antibodies: the 'next' humoral barrier to xenotransplantation?

The xenoreactive nature of anti-Galalpha1-3Gal antibodies, and to a lesser extent, polyreactive antibodies, has been characterized by a number of investigators. With the advent of therapies that avoid hyperacute xenograft rejection due to anti-Galalpha1-3Gal antibodies coupled with the possible development of Galalpha1-3Gal deficient swine, the Galalpha1-3Gal antigen may soon cease to be a barrier to xenotransplantation. With this in mind, the potential xenoreactive nature of polyreactive antibodies was investigated using several approaches. The levels of polyreactive antibodies from the serum of newborn (n = 2) and adult (n = 4) baboons undergoing pulmonary xenotransplantation were evaluated. Depletion of 95% and 94% of total serum IgM, without any decrease in albumin levels, was observed in the newborn baboons. This finding indicates that the IgM present at birth and germ line polyreactive IgM was adsorbed by the xenografts. The depletion of polyreactive antibodies (43-83% reduction of anti-DNP IgM) from adult baboons was also observed following pulmonary xenotransplantation or immunoadsorption therapy plus pulmonary xenotransplantation. Additional experiments using human cord serum indicated that most human polyreactive IgM were adsorbed by pig lung homogenate and that the human polyreactive IgM bound approximately two-fold more to immobilized pig lung antigens than to immobilized human lung antigens. These findings indicate that germline polyreactive antibodies are, for the most part, xenoreactive. These data suggest that polyreactive antibodies, although autoreactive, may be more xenoreactive than autoreactive.

Xenogeneic transplantation

This review summarizes the clinical history and rationale for xenotransplantation; recent progress in understanding the physiologic, immunologic, and infectious obstacles to the procedure's success; and some of the strategies being pursued to overcome these obstacles. The problems of xenotransplantation are complex, and a combination of approaches is required. The earliest and most striking immunologic obstacle, that of hyperacute rejection, appears to be the closest to being solved. This phenomenon depends on the binding of natural antibody to the vascular endothelium, fixation of complement by that antibody, and finally, activation of the endothelium and initiation of coagulation. Therefore, these three pathways have been targeted as sites for intervention in the process. The mechanisms responsible for the next immunologic barrier, that of delayed xenograft/acute vascular rejection, remain to be fully elucidated. They probably also involve multiple pathways, including antibody and/or immune cell binding and endothelial cell activation. The final immunologic barrier, that of the cellular immune response, involves mechanisms that are similar to those involved in allograft rejection. However, the strength of the cellular immune response to xenografts is so great that it is unlikely to be controlled by the types of nonspecific immunosuppression used routinely to prevent allograft rejection. For this reason, it may be essential to induce specific immunologic unresponsiveness to at least some of the most antigenic xenogeneic molecules.

Both IgG and IgM anti-pig antibodies induce complement activation and cytotoxicity

Hyperacute rejection of pig xenografts transplanted in humans is caused by endothelial cell binding of pre-formed xenoreactive antibodies (XAb) and activation of the classical pathway of complement. Human XAb mainly consist of anti-Galalpha1 3Gal antibodies, which occur in IgM, IgG and IgA classes. Whereas IgM anti-Galalpha1 3Gal antibodies have an established role in hyperacute rejection, the potential role of IgG XAb in this process is still controversial. The aim of the present study was to assess the specificity and functional properties of IgG and IgM XAb. Both classes were present in all human plasma samples tested, with a high inter-individual variability. Levels of IgG XAb did not correlate with levels of IgM XAb. Binding to Galalpha1 3Gal is strongly correlated with binding to the pig cell line PK15, both for IgG and for IgM, pointing to Galalpha1 3Gal as the major antigen recognized. Both purified IgM and IgG induced C3 deposition on PK15 cells and complement-dependent cytotoxicity in a dose-dependent way. The combination of IgG and IgM XAb resulted in an additive effect on cytotoxicity. Affinity-purified IgG anti-Galalpha1 3Gal antibodies were 22 times less potent than IgM in induction of cytotoxicity. These results indicate a quantitative, but not a qualitative, difference between IgM and IgG anti-pig antibodies concerning their complement-activating properties. Therefore, both classes of XAb are of importance in the pathogenesis of hyperacute rejection, and the relative importance of each class may differ considerably between individual patients, depending on the ratio of IgG and IgM XAb present in serum.

Report of the Xenotransplantation Advisory Committee of the International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation: the present status of xenotransplantation and its potential role in the treatment of end-stage cardiac and pulmonary diseases

An urgent and steadily increasing need exists world-wide for a greater supply of donor thoracic organs. Xenotransplantation offers the possibility of an unlimited supply of hearts and lungs that could be available electively when required. However, anti-body- mediated mechanisms cause the rejection of pig organs transplanted into non-human primates, and these mechanisms provide major immunologic barriers that have not yet been overcome. Having reviewed the literature on xenotransplantation, we present a number of conclusions on its present status with regard to thoracic organs, and we make a number of recommendations relating to eventual clinical trials. Although pig hearts have functioned in heterotopic sites in non-human primates for periods of several weeks, median survival of orthotopically transplanted hearts is currently ,1 month. No transplanted pig lung has functioned for even 24 hours. Current experimental results indicate that a clinical trial would be premature. A potential risk exists, hitherto undetermined, of transferring infectious organisms along with the donor pig organ to the recipient, and possibly to other members of the community. A clinical trial of xeno-transplantation should not be undertaken until experts in microbiology and the relevant regulatory authorities consider this risk to be minimal. A clinical trial should be considered when approximately 60% survival of life-supporting pig organs in non-human primates has been achieved for a minimum of 3 months, with at least 10 animals surviving for this minimum period. Furthermore, evidence should suggest that longer survival (.6 months) can be achieved. These results should be achieved in the absence of life-threatening complications caused by the immunosuppressive regimen used. The relationship between the presence of anti-HLA antibody and anti-pig antibody and their cross-reactivity, and the outcome of pig-organ xenotransplantation in recipients previously sensitized to HLA antigens require further investigation. We recommend that the patients who initially enter into a clinical trial of cardiac xenotransplantation be unacceptable for allotransplantation, or acceptable for allotransplantation but unlikely to survive until a human cadaveric organ becomes available, and in whom mechanical assist-device bridging is not possible. National bodies that have wide-reaching government-backed control over all aspects of the trials should regulate the initial clinical trial and all subsequent clinical xenotransplantation procedures for the foreseeable future. We recommend coordination and monitoring of these trials through an international body, such as the International Society for Heart and Lung Transplantation, and setting up a registry to record and widely disperse the results of these trials. Xenotransplantation has the potential to solve the problem of donor-organ supply, and therefore research in this field should be actively encouraged and supported.

Influence of cold ischemia time, pretransplant anti-porcine antibodies, and donor/recipient size matching on hyperacute graft rejection after discordant porcine to cynomolgus kidney transplantation

Organs transplanted between phylogenetically disparate species, such as from the pig into the primate, are subject to hyperacute rejection (HAR). This form of xenograft rejection is mediated by preformed natural antibodies and is believed to occur invariably in discordant xenografts thus leading to rapid destruction and complete thrombosis of the graft. Recent data, however, have shown that in the porcine to cynomolgus monkey setting, HAR is not inevitably seen after porcine kidney transplantation. The influence of preoperative antiporcine antibody levels in the recipient, cold ischemia time, and donor organ weight on the onset of HAR was investigated by using unmodified large white pigs (aged 3-12 weeks) as organ donors and adult cynomolgus monkeys (aged 1.5-3.5 years) as recipients. Porcine kidney xenotransplantation was performed in either a non-life-supporting model (n=7) or in a life-supporting model (n=8). In both models, no correlation was found between cold ischemia time and HAR. When preoperative anti-porcine antibody levels were investigated, a significant increase in incidence of HAR was observed in animals with elevated anti-porcine IgM (P<0.05) but not IgG levels (P=NS). Interestingly, although 5 of 12 grafts with an organ weight of less than 50 g underwent HAR, none of three grafts with a donor organ weight of more than 70 g showed signs of HAR. In addition, all three larger grafts showed intraoperative and postoperative urine production, although only in 1 (48 g) of the 12 grafts weighing less than 50 g primary graft function was observed. In one animal, a second porcine kidney (23 g) was successfully transplanted (without HAR) immediately after HAR and subsequent removal of a first porcine kidney (20 g). These results indicate that in the porcine to cynomolgus monkey setting anti-porcine IgM rather than IgG anti-porcine antibody levels seem to be of predominant importance for the induction of HAR. By increasing the donor organ size and weight the frequency of the onset of HAR can be at least reduced. This is most likely due to immunoabsorption of the recipients preformed antibodies in the porcine kidney without lethal damage for the graft.

Target cell susceptibility to lysis by human natural killer cells is augmented by alpha(1,3)-galactosyltransferase and reduced by alpha(1, 2)-fucosyltransferase

Susceptibility of porcine endothelial cells to human natural killer (NK) cell lysis was found to reflect surface expression of ligands containing Gal alpha(1,3)Gal beta(1,4)GlcNAc [corrected], the principal antigen on porcine endothelium recognized by xenoreactive human antibodies. Genetically modifying expression of this epitope on porcine endothelium by transfection with the alpha(1,2)-fucosyltransferase gene reduced susceptibility to human NK lysis. These results indicate that surface carbohydrate remodeling profoundly affects target cell susceptibility to NK lysis, and suggest that successful transgenic strategies to limit xenograft rejection by NK cells and xenoreactive antibodies will need to incorporate carbohydrate remodeling.

Discordant organ xenotransplantation in primates: world experience and current status

The pig-to-primate model is increasingly being utilized as the final preclinical means of assessing therapeutic strategies aimed at allowing discordant xenotransplantation. We review here the world experience of both pig-to-human and pig-to-nonhuman primate organ transplantation. Eight whole organ transplants using discordant mammalian donors have been carried out in human recipients; only one patient was reported (in 1923) to have survived for longer than 72 hr. Therapeutic approaches in the experimental laboratory setting have included pharmacologic immunosuppression, antibody and/or complement depletion or inhibition, the use of pig organs transgenic for human complement regulatory proteins, and conditioning regimens aimed at inducing a state of tolerance or specific immunologic hyporesponsiveness. The greatest success to date has been obtained with methods that inhibit complement-mediated injury, either by the administration of cobra venom factor or soluble complement receptor I to the recipient (with organ survival up to 6 weeks) or by the use of donor organs transgenic for human decay-accelerating factor (with organ survival up to 2 months). The future of xenotransplantation may lie in the judicious combination of current approaches.

Triple immunosuppression reduces mononuclear cell infiltration and prolongs graft life in pig-to-newborn baboon cardiac xenotransplantation

OBJECTIVE

Pig hearts transplanted into unmedicated newborn baboons do not undergo hyperacute rejection by preformed xenoantibody and complement. These grafts are rejected at days 3 to 4 in association with the infiltration of macrophages and natural killer cells. We investigated whether an immunosuppressive regimen used widely in cardiac allotransplantation could reduce this cellular response and prolong xenograft life.

METHODS

Ten newborn baboons underwent heterotopic pig cardiac xenotransplantation. Five baboons were immunosuppressed with mycophenolate mofetil (100 mg/kg), methylprednisolone acetate (0.8 mg/kg), and cyclosporine A (INN: ciclosporin; 10 mg/kg). Xenograft rejection was studied by light microscopy and immunofluorescence. The induced humoral response to porcine xenoantigens was documented by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay using synthetic alpha-1,3-galactosyl epitopes coupled to bovine serum albumin.

RESULTS

Graft life was extended from a mean of 3.6 +/- 0.5 days (n = 5) to a mean of 6.2 +/- 1.1 days (n = 5, p = 0.01). In comparison with controls, explanted grafts from medicated baboons demonstrated reduced infiltration with natural killer cells and macrophages, but increased evidence of complement-mediated rejection substantiated by increased deposition of immunoglobulin M, complement, and fibrin. In all baboons receiving transplants, levels of both immunoglobulin M and immunoglobulin G anti-galactose were significantly increased after transplantation, with immunoglobulin G levels remaining persistently elevated.

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that cyclosporine-based triple immunosuppression marginally prolonged xenograft survival and appears to have reduced the natural killer cell and macrophage infiltrates. The immunosuppressive protocol, however, was not adequate to prevent the induced immunoglobulin M humoral response and prevent complement-mediated graft injury.

Role of natural killer cells, macrophages, and accessory molecule interactions in the rejection of pig-to-primate xenografts beyond the hyperacute period

Pig-to-primate cardiac xenografts surviving beyond the period of hyperacute rejection succumb after 3-4 days to a secondary immunologic response characterized by xenograft infiltration with NK cells and macrophages. Circulating baboon mononuclear cells contain NK cell precursors which mediate lysis of porcine endothelium by two distinct mechanisms: antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity and lymphokine activation. IL-2 activated NK lysis of porcine endothelium was 2.4-fold stronger than lysis occurring following engagement of FcRIII by xenoreactive IgG. IL-2 augmented NK lysis involved interactions between CD2 and CD49d on baboon NK cells and their respective ligands on porcine endothelium, since NK lysis was reduced either by using Mabs against CD2, CD49d, or porcine VCAM, or by treating endothelial cells with PIPLC to cleave GPI-linked molecules. These results imply that interactions between accessory molecule receptor-ligand pairs on primate NK cells, macrophages and porcine endothelium are of critical importance in delayed xenograft rejection.

Xenoantigens and xenoantibodies

Major efforts are being directed towards determining and modifying the glycosylated epitopes on pig vascular endothelial cells, against which human natural antibodies are directed. Genetic engineering techniques are being used in an effort to knock out or replace the major alpha galactosyl (alpha Gal) epitopes in mice, but to-date these have been only modestly successful in prolonging functional survival of such modified organs. Competitive glycosylation involving insertion of the gene for alpha 1,2 fucosyltransferase results in reduction of alpha Gal expression but also of presentation of hitherto cryptic antigens against which natural human antibodies are directed or could develop. The introduction of the gene for N-acetylglucosaminyltransferase III has been demonstrated to significantly reduce alpha Gal expression, and the intracellular expression of single chain Fv antibodies against alpha 1,3 galactosyltransferase also represses this enzyme activity. Several other carbohydrate antigens have been identified that could act as targets for human natural antibodies, and these include Gal alpha 1-3Le(x), Hanganutziu-Deicher, Tn, and Forssman antigens. The alternative approach, namely, the depletion of the recipient's natural antibodies, is proving difficult, but techniques for inducing B cell tolerance are being explored. The induction of a state of mixed hematopoietic chimerism in alpha Gal knockout mice has resulted in tolerance to the alpha Gal antigen. Tolerance to the SLA antigens of miniature swine is also being attempted in baboons by the transfer of SLA Class II genes into baboon bone marrow cells. It is hoped that one or a combination of these approaches may overcome the problem created by the presence of pig antigens against which humans have xenoreactive antibodies.