Molecular mechanism of immunoglobulin class switch recombination

New paradigms for functional HIV-specific nonneutralizing antibodies

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Although a large number of novel broadly neutralizing antibodies has been recently described, the induction of such antibodies via vaccination has proven difficult. By contrast, nonneutralizing antibodies arise early during infection and have been repeatedly associated with both protection from infection and disease progression.

RECENT FINDINGS

We are beginning to gain new insights into the broader landscape of antiviral mechanisms that nonneutralizing antibodies may harness to fight HIV, providing an unprecedented breadth of approaches by which HIV can be blocked and contained.

SUMMARY

In this review, we summarize the characteristics of nonneutralizing antibodies, their role in HIV infection, and new paradigm-shifting functions that may be exploited by next-generation vaccine approaches aimed at blocking HIV infection.

Evolution of the Immunoglobulin Heavy Chain Class Switch Recombination Mechanism

To mount an optimum immune response, mature B lymphocytes can change the class of expressed antibody from IgM to IgG, IgA, or IgE through a recombination/deletion process termed immunoglobulin heavy chain (IgH) class switch recombination (CSR). CSR requires the activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), which has been shown to employ single-stranded DNA as a substrate in vitro. IgH CSR occurs within and requires large, repetitive sequences, termed S regions, which are parts of germ line transcription units (termed "C(H) genes") that are composed of promoters, S regions, and individual IgH constant region exons. CSR requires and is directed by germ line transcription of participating C(H) genes prior to CSR. AID deamination of cytidines in S regions appears to lead to S region double-stranded breaks (DSBs) required to initiate CSR. Joining of two broken S regions to complete CSR exploits the activities of general DNA DSB repair mechanisms. In this chapter, we discuss our current knowledge of the function of S regions, germ line transcription, AID, and DNA repair in CSR. We present a model for CSR in which transcription through S regions provides DNA substrates on which AID can generate DSB-inducing lesions. We also discuss how phosphorylation of AID may mediate interactions with cofactors that facilitate access to transcribed S regions during CSR and transcribed variable regions during the related process of somatic hypermutation (SHM). Finally, in the context of this CSR model, we further discuss current findings that suggest synapsis and joining of S region DSBs during CSR have evolved to exploit general mechanisms that function to join widely separated chromosomal DSBs.

Evolution of antibody class switching: identification and transcriptional control of an Inu exon in the duck (Anas platyrhynchos)

Immunoglobulin class switching is characteristic to the tetrapod lineage, but the nature of this process has been elucidated only in mammals, where I-exon transcription initiates and directs the recombination in the IgH locus. Here, it is shown that an I-exon occurs 5' of the nu (IgY constant region) gene of the duck (Anas platyrhynchos): it is longer than mammalian I-exons and comprised primarily of tandem repeats. The Inu promoter was identified and shown to be responsive to stimulation with IL-4 but not LPS. It contains Oct, LYF-1, ATF, and C/EBP motifs. Site directed mutagenesis indicates that 2 C/EBP motifs are uniquely necessary for the response of the promoter to IL-4, as tested in the mouse pre-B cell line, 70Z/3. These results support the conclusion that the signal transduction pathways controlling I-exon promoter responses to cytokines have been highly conserved in vertebrate evolution.

Genomic characterization of the chromosomal breakpoints of t(4;14) of multiple myeloma suggests more than one possible aetiological mechanism

Using FISH-based techniques, rearrangements of the immunoglobulin heavy-chain (IgH) locus at 14q32 have been found in the majority of cases of multiple myeloma (MM). Some of these IgH translocations are recurrent and we have characterized the genomic breakpoints of seven t(4;14) translocations from MM patients, using a combination of vectorette and conventional polymerase chain reaction methods, the aim being to understand the molecular mechanism leading to MM. Conventionally, the chromosome 14q32 breakpoints in these reciprocal translocations are believed to be located in the IgH mu switch (S) region and a further downstream S region with deletion of intervening DNA occurring as a result of aberrant class switch recombination (CSR); this was seen in five of the cases analysed. However, in two patients it was possible to demonstrate that the rearranged hybrid switch region sequence was joined to DNA from chromosome 4p16, suggesting that IgH translocations can occur in B cells that have already undergone legitimate CSR. The complex nature of these rearrangements leads us to speculate that primary IgH translocations may occur at different time points in the development in MM plasma cells, either at the time of physiological CSR or at a later stage, possibly involving a different mechanism.

Immunological disorders and DNA repair

Cellular DNA continuously incurs damage and a range of damage response mechanisms function to maintain genomic integrity in the face of this onslaught. During the development of the immune response, the cell utilises three defined processes, V(D)J recombination, class switch recombination and somatic hypermutation, to create genetic diversity in developing T and B cells. Curiously, the damage response mechanisms employed to maintain genomic stability in somatic cells have been exploited and adapted to help generate diversity during immune development. As a consequence of this overlap, there is mounting evidence that disorders attributable to impaired damage response mechanisms display associated immunodeficiency. Since double strand breaks (DSB) are created during at least two of the mechanisms used to create immunoglobulin diversity, namely V(D)J recombination and class switch recombination, it is not surprising that disorders associated with defects in the response to double strand breaks are those most associated with immunodeficiency. Here, we review the steps involved in the generation of genetic diversity during immune development with a focus on the damage response mechanisms employed and then consider human immunodeficiency disorders associated with impaired damage response mechanisms.

Molecular mechanism of class switch recombination: linkage with somatic hypermutation

Class switch recombination (CSR) and somatic hypermutation (SHM) have been considered to be mediated by different molecular mechanisms because both target DNAs and DNA modification products are quite distinct. However, involvement of activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) in both CSR and SHM has revealed that the two genetic alteration mechanisms are surprisingly similar. Accumulating data led us to propose the following scenario: AID is likely to be an RNA editing enzyme that modifies an unknown pre-mRNA to generate mRNA encoding a nicking endonuclease specific to the stem-loop structure. Transcription of the S and V regions, which contain palindromic sequences, leads to transient denaturation, forming the stem-loop structure that is cleaved by the AID-regulated endonuclease. Cleaved single-strand tails will be processed by error-prone DNA polymerase-mediated gap-filling or exonuclease-mediated resection. Mismatched bases will be corrected or fixed by mismatch repair enzymes. CSR ends are then ligated by the NHEJ system while SHM nicks are repaired by another ligation system.

IgH class switch recombination to IgG1 in DNA-PKcs-deficient B cells

To assess the role of the DNA-PKcs nonhomologous DNA end-joining (NHEJ) protein in Ig heavy chain class switch recombination (CSR), we assayed CSR ability of DNA-PKcs-deficient (DP-T) B cells generated via complementation of DP-T mice with Ig heavy chain and light chain knock-in transgenes (DP-T/HC/LC mice). DP-T/HC/LC mice were severely deficient for all serum IgH isotypes except IgM and, unexpectedly, IgG1. Upon appropriate stimulation, DP-T/HC/LC B cells showed normal proliferation, germline C(H) gene transcription, and AID induction, indicating that DNA-PKcs deficiency did not affect cellular events upstream to CSR. Yet, in vitro activated DP-T/HC/LC B cells again underwent switching only to IgG1 and, like wild-type cells, frequently underwent CSR to gamma1 on both chromosomes. We conclude that DNA-PKcs is required for CSR to most C(H) genes but that CSR to gamma1 occurs via a DNA-PKcs-independent mechanism.

Mechanism and control of class-switch recombination

Class-switch recombination (CSR) occurs by an unusual and intriguing mechanism that has not been clearly elucidated as yet. Currently, we know that this mechanism involves recombination between large and highly repetitive switch (S) regions, is targeted by S-region transcription and requires the activity of the newly discovered activation-induced deaminase (AID). In this review, we discuss the potential role of these factors in CSR, discuss potential relationships between CSR and somatic hypermutation, and speculate how CSR and related mechanisms might contribute to genomic instability.

The tight interallelic positional coincidence that distinguishes T-cell receptor Jalpha usage does not result from homologous chromosomal pairing during ValphaJalpha rearrangement

The T-cell receptor (TCR) alpha locus is thought to undergo multiple cycles of secondary rearrangements that maximize the generation of alphabeta T cells. Taking advantage of the nucleotide sequence of the human Valpha and Jalpha segments, we undertook a locus-wide analysis of TCRalpha gene rearrangements in human alphabeta T-cell clones. In most clones, ValphaJalpha rearrangements occurred on both homologous chromosomes and, remarkably, resulted in the use of two neighboring Jalpha segments. No such interallelic coincidence was found for the position of the two rearranged Valpha segments, and there was only a loose correlation between the 5' or 3' chromosomal position of the Valpha and Jalpha segments used in a given rearrangement. These observations question the occurrence of extensive rounds of secondary Valpha-->Jalpha rearrangements and of a coordinated and polarized usage of the Valpha and Jalpha libraries. Fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis of developing T cells in which TCRalpha rearrangements are taking place showed that the interallelic positional coincidence in Jalpha usage cannot be explained by the stable juxtaposition of homologous Jalpha clusters.

The mu switch region tandem repeats are important, but not required, for antibody class switch recombination

Class switch DNA recombinations change the constant (C) region of the antibody heavy (H) chain expressed by a B cell and thereby change the antibody effector function. Unusual tandemly repeated sequence elements located upstream of H chain gene exons have long been thought to be important in the targeting and/or mechanism of the switch recombination process. We have deleted the entire switch tandem repeat element (S(mu)) from the murine (mu) H chain gene. We find that the S(mu) tandem repeats are not required for class switching in the mouse immunoglobulin H-chain locus, although the efficiency of switching is clearly reduced. Our data demonstrate that sequences outside of the S(mu) tandem repeats must be capable of directing the class switch mechanism. The maintenance of the highly repeated S(mu) element during evolution appears to reflect selection for a highly efficient switching process rather than selection for a required sequence element.

Class switch recombination and hypermutation require activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID), a potential RNA editing enzyme

Induced overexpression of AID in CH12F3-2 B lymphoma cells augmented class switching from IgM to IgA without cytokine stimulation. AID deficiency caused a complete defect in class switching and showed a hyper-IgM phenotype with enlarged germinal centers containing strongly activated B cells before or after immunization. AID-/- spleen cells stimulated in vitro with LPS and cytokines failed to undergo class switch recombination although they expressed germline transcripts. Immunization of AID-/- chimera with 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenylacetyl (NP) chicken gamma-globulin induced neither accumulation of mutations in the NP-specific variable region gene nor class switching. These results suggest that AID may be involved in regulation or catalysis of the DNA modification step of both class switching and somatic hypermutation.