Why do so many haemophilia A patients develop an inhibitor?

Laboratory testing for factor VIII and IX inhibitors in haemophilia: A review

Inhibitors are antibodies directed against haemophilia treatment products which interfere with their function. Factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitors in haemophilia A and factor IX (FIX) inhibitors in haemophilia B are significant clinically when they require a change in a patient's treatment regimen. Their persistence may increase morbidity and mortality. Multiple laboratory tests are now available for detecting and understanding inhibitors in haemophilia. Inhibitors are traditionally measured by their interference in clotting or chromogenic factor assays. They may also be detected using immunologic assays, such as enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay or fluorescence immunoassay. Anti-FVIII or anti-FIX antibodies of IgG4 subclass best correlate with the presence of functional inhibitors. Improvements in inhibitor measurement have been recently introduced. Preanalytical heat treatment of patient specimens allows testing of patients without delaying treatment. Use of chromogenic and immunologic assays may aid in identification of false-positive results, which are frequent among low-titre inhibitors. Validated reagent substitutions can be used to reduce assay cost. New methods for defining assay positivity and reporting low-titre inhibitors have been suggested. Challenges remain in the areas of quality control, assay standardization, monitoring of patients undergoing immune tolerance induction therapy and testing in the presence of modified and novel treatment products.

Long-term correction of hemophilia A mice following lentiviral mediated delivery of an optimized canine factor VIII gene

Current therapies for hemophilia A include frequent prophylactic or on-demand intravenous factor treatments which are costly, inconvenient and may lead to inhibitor formation. Viral vector delivery of factor VIII (FVIII) cDNA has the potential to alleviate the debilitating clotting defects. Lentiviral-based vectors delivered to murine models of hemophilia A mediate phenotypic correction. However, a limitation of lentiviral-mediated FVIII delivery is inefficient transduction of target cells. Here, we engineer a feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) -based lentiviral vector pseudotyped with the baculovirus GP64 envelope glycoprotein to mediate efficient gene transfer to mouse hepatocytes. In anticipation of future studies in FVIII-deficient dogs, we investigated the efficacy of FIV-delivered canine FVIII (cFVIII). Codon-optimization of the cFVIII sequence increased activity and decreased blood loss as compared to the native sequence. Further, we compared a standard B-domain deleted FVIII cDNA to a cDNA including 256 amino acids of the B-domain with 11 potential asparagine-linked oligosaccharide linkages. Restoring a partial B-domain resulted in modest reduction of endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress markers. Importantly, our optimized vectors achieved wild-type levels of phenotypic correction with minimal inhibitor formation. These studies provide insights into optimal design of a therapeutically relevant gene therapy vector for a devastating bleeding disorder.

Novel therapeutic approach for hemophilia using gene delivery of an engineered secreted activated Factor VII

Hemophilia is a bleeding disorder caused by mutations in the genes encoding coagulation Factor VIII (FVIII) or FIX. Current treatment is through intravenous infusion of the missing protein. The major complication of treatment is the development of neutralizing Ab's to the clotting factor. Infusion of recombinant activated human Factor VII (rhFVIIa), driving procoagulant reactions independently of human FVIII (hFVIII) or hFIX, has been successful in such patients and could in theory provide hemostasis in all hemophilia patients. However, its high cost and short half-life have limited its use. Here, we report a novel treatment strategy with a recombinant adeno-associated virus vector delivering a modified FVII transgene that can be intracellularly processed and secreted as activated FVII (FVIIa). We show long-term expression, as well as phenotypic correction of hemophilia B mice following gene transfer of the murine FVIIa homolog, with no evidence of thrombotic complications at these doses. These data hold promise for a potential treatment for hemophilia and other bleeding disorders.

Intensive exposure to factor VIII is a risk factor for inhibitor development in mild hemophilia A

BACKGROUND

Inhibitors are rare in boys with mild hemophilia A (MHA; factor (F)VIII:C > 5%) but may arise following intense FVIII exposure, e.g. continuous infusion (CI).

OBJECTIVES

To determine the impact of intense FVIII exposure in inhibitor formation in MHA at our institution and to compare this with previous reports.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We reviewed FVIII exposure and inhibitor development in boys (ages 0-18 years) with MHA followed at our institution from 1996 to 2001 and conducted a Medline search (1966-2002) on the experience of inhibitor development following intensive/CI exposure to FVIII.

RESULTS

We identified 54 boys with MHA. Twenty-nine (54%) had been exposed to FVIII. Seven had received FVIII by CI. Four developed inhibitors; three high titer (at ages 10 years, 16 years and 17 years) and one low titer (at 1 month old). All four had received a CI of recombinant (r) FVIII of at least 6 days within 6 weeks of developing inhibitors. Baseline FVIII levels fell to < 1% in all cases and the three with high-titer inhibitors developed severe bleeding. Immune tolerance therapy (ITT) was attempted in two boys and was successful in one. Our literature search identified 35 cases (only four children) with MHA developing inhibitors following intense FVIII exposure often in the context of surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of inhibitors in our MHA population was 7.4%. If expressed according to exposure the incidence was significantly higher: 14% (4/29) for any exposure to FVIII and 57% (4/7) for exposure by CI. A prospective study to address whether CI is associated with an increased incidence of inhibitor development in MHA is warranted.

Analysis of the consequences of premature termination codons within factor VIII coding sequences

Inhibitor antibody formation is a complication of factor VIII (FVIII) replacement therapy due to a failure to synthesize sufficient FVIII protein to induce immune tolerance. The incidence of nonsense mutations in inhibitor patients is high, however, this association is variable according to the position of the mutation. We have studied the effect of nonsense mutations on accumulation of FVIII mRNA, protein translation and secretion. Appropriately processed mRNA was detected in cells transfected with wild-type R1966X and R2116X expression constructs and no evidence of nonsense-mediated decay was observed. All constructs directed the translation of detectable intracellular FVIII antigen, however, secreted FVIII was detected only in conditioned media of cells transfected with wild-type cDNA. We have also analyzed ectopic FVIII mRNA transcripts in the lymphocytes of six hemophilia A patients with nonsense mutations (Q139X, R583X, R1941X, R1966X and two unrelated patients with R2116X). FVIII mRNA was detectable in every case. In R1941X and R1966X only normally spliced transcripts were present. In Q139X, R583X and R2116X aberrantly spliced transcripts were observed with two distinct patterns in two individuals with the R2116X mutation. No correlation between mutation, transcript pattern and incidence of inhibitor development was apparent.

AAV-mediated gene transfer for hemophilia

The goal of our work has been to establish an experimental basis for gene transfer as a method of treating hemophilia, an inherited bleeding disorder that results from the absence of functional factor VIII or factor IX. Using an adeno-associated viral vector derived from AAV serotype 2, we have shown in mice and in hemophilic dogs that we can achieve long-term expression (>3 years) of clotting factor at levels that would result in an improvement of clinical symptoms of the disease. A phase I trial of intramuscular injection of AAV-F.IX showed no evidence of local or systemic toxicity in any of the subjects. Muscle biopsies showed evidence for gene transfer and expression by polymerase chain reaction, Southern blot, and immunohistochemistry. We have also shown that AAV-F.IX can be delivered into the portal veins of hemophilic dogs and that this results in high circulating levels of factor IX, on the order of 5% to 14%, whereas delivery of similar doses to skeletal muscle results in factor levels of only 1% to 2%. Based on these results, a trial of AAV-mediated liver-directed gene transfer for hemophilia B has been proposed and is reviewed here.

Adeno-associated virus-mediated gene transfer for hemophilia B

Hemophilia is the bleeding diathesis caused by mutations in the gene encoding factor VIII (hemophilia A) or factor IX (hemophilia B). Currently, the disease is treated by intravenous infusion of the missing purified clotting factor. The goal of gene transfer for treating hemophilia is to achieve sustained expression of factor VIII or factor IX at levels high enough to improve the symptoms of the disease. Hemophilia has proven to be an attractive model for those interested in gene transfer, and multiple gene-transfer strategies are currently being investigated for the hemophilias. The most promising preclinical studies have been with adeno-associated viral vectors (AAV); introduction of AAV vectors expressing factor IX into skeletal muscle or liver in hemophilic dogs has resulted in the long-term expression of factor IX at levels that are adequate to improve disease symptoms. Efforts to translate these findings into the clinical arena have proceeded slowly because of the lack of prior clinical experience with parenteral administration of AAV. In a staged approach, AAV-factor IX (AAV-F.IX) was first administered at doses of up to 1.8 x 10(12) vector genomes/kg (vg/kg) into the skeletal muscles of men with hemophilia B. This trial established the safety of parenteral administration and also showed that general characteristics of AAV transduction were similar in mice, dogs, and humans. In an ongoing trial, AAV-F.IX is being administered into the hepatic circulation of men with severe hemophilia B. The goal of these studies is to identify a safe dose that reliably yields circulating levels of factor IX >2% of normal levels in all subjects. This goal has already been achieved in the hemophilia B dog model; the ongoing study will determine whether a similar result can be achieved in humans with hemophilia B.

Incidence of factor VIII inhibitors in severe haemophilia: the importance of patient age

The potential effect of age at the start of replacement therapy on the development of factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitors was assessed in 62 severe (FVIII < 2 IU/dl) haemophilia A patients who started FVIII therapy at one of two haemophilia centres. Inhibitors were tested on an annual basis. Persistent or high-titre inhibitors were detected in 15 patients (24%). Kaplan-Meier cumulative incidence at 3 years from first FVIII exposure was 41% (95% CI 22-67%) in patients starting therapy before the age of 6 months, 29% (95% CI 13-57%) in patients starting therapy between 6 and 12 months of age, and 12% (95% CI 4-34%) in those starting therapy beyond 1 year of age (P = 0.03). By multivariate analysis, the influence of age was shown to be independent of other variables, including calendar year at the onset of therapy and baseline FVIII plasma levels. In conclusion, patient age at initial treatment appears to influence inhibitor formation. If confirmed, this finding would have a major impact on the management of haemophilia.

Development of inhibitors in patients with haemophilia from India

Four hundred and seven patients (352 haemophilia A and 55 haemophilia B) were investigated for the presence of factor VIII and IX inhibitors. Twenty-four out of 292 severe and two out of 36 moderate haemophilia A patients showed the presence of inhibitors. The mean age at development of inhibitors was 17.7 years (range 6-52 years). In 12 patients the inhibitors were detected due to suboptimal response to factor replacement therapy (symptomatic) and in the remaining 14 patients the inhibitors were detected during the routine screening of the patients' samples for inhibitors. They had, however, responded well to the usual doses of factor concentrates and there was no suspicion in these patients that they had developed an inhibitor (asymptomatic). There were two families in which the inhibitors were detected in more than one family member. The level of inhibitors in symptomatic patients ranged from 2.2 Bethesda units (BU) mL(-1) to 460.6 BU mL(-1), and in asymptomatic patients it ranged from 0.8 BU mL(-1) to 3.2 BU mL(-1). The inhibitors persisted in all patients except one, who developed an inhibitor postoperatively for a brief period of 3 months. All these patients were followed up from first factor exposure and were tested for inhibitors at least twice a year. The mean number of exposure days before they developed inhibitors was 47.5 exposure days (range 17-98 exposure days). No inhibitors appeared after more than 100 exposure days in any of the patients. When 50 consecutive patients were investigated for intron 22 inversions of the factor VIII gene, 17 patients were found to be positive for inversions (10 proximal inversion; seven distal inversion) out of whom four patients developed inhibitors, three patients belonging to the same family. Out of 35 haemophilia B patients, only one patient developed an inhibitor. The overall prevalence of inhibitors was thus 8.2%, which is similar to the reports from western countries, prior to the introduction of highly purified factor concentrate therapy.

Gene transfer as an approach to treating hemophilia

Hemophilia is an X-linked bleeding diathesis caused by a deficiency of either factor VIII or factor IX. Present treatment for hemophilia involves intravenous infusion of either recombinant or plasma-derived clotting factor concentrates. Problems with this treatment method, including the expense, need for intravenous access, and risks of blood-borne disease transmission, have fueled an interest in developing a gene-transfer approach to treatment. On the basis of experience with protein concentrate therapy, it seems likely that even modest elevations in circulating levels of factor VIII or factor IX can prevent most of the mortality and much of the morbidity associated with the disease. Hemophilia has a number of advantages as a model system for working out strategies for gene transfer as an approach to the treatment of genetic diseases; these include wide latitude in choice of target tissue, a wide therapeutic window for levels of circulating factor, ease of determining therapeutic endpoints, and existence of excellent animal models of the disease. Preclinical studies over the last decade have recently culminated in the initiation of clinical trials of gene transfer for hemophilia A and B. Three trials, each using different vectors and target tissues, are presently underway, and two additional trials are in late planning stages. This report reviews the preclinical data underlying these strategies and the design of the ongoing and proposed clinical trials.

Partial correction of murine hemophilia A with neo-antigenic murine factor VIII

We have previously reported a factor VIII knockout (FVIII KO) mouse model for hemophilia A. Here we demonstrate the presence of nonfunctional heavy chain factor VIII protein in the mouse, making it an excellent model for cross-reacting material (CRM)-positive hemophilia A patients, who express normal levels of a dysfunctional FVIII protein. We attempted to correct these mice phenotypically by transduction of wild-type mouse factor VIII cDNA delivered in an E1/E3-deleted adenoviral vector by tail vein injection. All treated mice displayed initial high-level FVIII expression that diminished after 1 month. Ten of 12 mice administered between 6 x 10(9) and 1 x 10(11) particles/mouse along with anti-CD4 antibody showed long-term FVIII activity (0.03-0.05 IU/ml, equivalent to 3-5% of normal FVIII) that corrected the phenotype. Wild-type murine FVIII was a neo-antigen to the KO mice, generating both cytotoxic and humoral immune responses. Immune suppression with anti-CD4 antibody abrogated these immune responses. These data demonstrate that despite the presence of endogenous FVIII protein the immune system still recognizes a species-specific transgene protein as a neo-antigen, eliciting a cytotoxic T cell response. This phenomenon may exist in the treatment of other genetic disorders by gene therapy.

Congenital Hemorrhagic Disorders: New Insights into the Pathophysiology and Treatment of Hemophilia

The diagnostic and treatment strategies related to hemophilia are rapidly evolving. This article focuses on some of the issues of importance. Diagnostic advances in molecular genetics are reviewed by Dr. Ginsburg in Section I, including the current state of knowledge regarding the mutations responsible for hemophilia, with reference to the potential clinical applications of DNA diagnosis and prenatal testing.

Within the area of new therapeutic approaches in hemophilia, recombinant factor VIII and factor IX concentrates, their use and availability are addressed by Dr. Lusher in Section II as well as the use of so-called “primary prophylaxis” with the aim of decreasing long-term hemophilia athropathy. The use of radionuclide synovectomy as replacement for more invasive methods is also reviewed.

Various approaches to the ongoing challenge of the management of hemophilia patients with inhibitors against factor VIII and factor IX are reviewed by Dr. Hedner in Section III, including the principles for immune tolerance induction and the use of recombinant factor VIIa to induce hemostasis in bleeding patients with inhibitors.

In Section IV, gene therapy in hemophilia is reviewed by Dr. High, who focuses on recent developments in the rapidly moving field of gene therapy for hemophilia. Three phase I trials of gene therapy for hemophilia were initiated in 1999, and additional proposed trials are currently in the regulatory review process. Certain aspects of the pathophysiology of hemophilia make it an attractive model for a gene-based approach to treatment. These include latitude in choice of target tissue, a wide therapeutic window, the availability of small and large animal models of the disease, and the ease of determining therapeutic efficacy. Since there is very little published information regarding the ongoing trials, this section reviews the approaches being used, the published pre-clinical data, and considerations affecting clinical trial design in hemophilia gene therapy.

Congenital Hemorrhagic Disorders: New Insights into the Pathophysiology and Treatment of Hemophilia

The diagnostic and treatment strategies related to hemophilia are rapidly evolving. This article focuses on some of the issues of importance. Diagnostic advances in molecular genetics are reviewed by Dr. Ginsburg in Section I, including the current state of knowledge regarding the mutations responsible for hemophilia, with reference to the potential clinical applications of DNA diagnosis and prenatal testing.

Within the area of new therapeutic approaches in hemophilia, recombinant factor VIII and factor IX concentrates, their use and availability are addressed by Dr. Lusher in Section II as well as the use of so-called “primary prophylaxis” with the aim of decreasing long-term hemophilia athropathy. The use of radionuclide synovectomy as replacement for more invasive methods is also reviewed.

Various approaches to the ongoing challenge of the management of hemophilia patients with inhibitors against factor VIII and factor IX are reviewed by Dr. Hedner in Section III, including the principles for immune tolerance induction and the use of recombinant factor VIIa to induce hemostasis in bleeding patients with inhibitors.

In Section IV, gene therapy in hemophilia is reviewed by Dr. High, who focuses on recent developments in the rapidly moving field of gene therapy for hemophilia. Three phase I trials of gene therapy for hemophilia were initiated in 1999, and additional proposed trials are currently in the regulatory review process. Certain aspects of the pathophysiology of hemophilia make it an attractive model for a gene-based approach to treatment. These include latitude in choice of target tissue, a wide therapeutic window, the availability of small and large animal models of the disease, and the ease of determining therapeutic efficacy. Since there is very little published information regarding the ongoing trials, this section reviews the approaches being used, the published pre-clinical data, and considerations affecting clinical trial design in hemophilia gene therapy.

Induction of immune tolerance with recombinant factor VIII in haemophilia A patients with inhibitors

We report on 11 patients (nine unrelated and a brother pair) with severe haemophilia A and factor VIII (FVIII) inhibitor, in whom immune tolerance (IIT) was induced with recombinant FVIII (r-FVIII). Their age ranged from 11 months to 47 years. The number of exposure days (ED) at inhibitor detection varied from 11 to 130. Nine of the 11 patients were high responders ¿>10 Bethesda units (BU) with peak inhibitor levels ranging from 10 to 566 BU. The other two were low responders with peak levels between 0.7 and 2 BU. Before inhibitor detection, the patients had been receiving products of various purities. The IIT regimens were very heterogeneous, and the treatment schedule varied from a short period with 50 IU kg-1 every 2 days, followed by 100 IU kg-1 every 2 days and then 220 IU kg-1 daily. The outcome was considered successful when the inhibitor level fell to 0.6 BU or lower after IIT treatment. The outcome overall was successful in nine out of 11 patients (81.8%), with the nine successful cases comprising seven of the nine high responders (77.8%) and the two low responders. Definite failure of IIT was observed in one high responder after two different IIT regimens. A second high responder is still on IIT treatment. All patients in whom IIT was successful are currently receiving r-FVIII on demand or prophylactically at various dosages. Despite the variability of the patient characteristics and the IIT schedules, this study demonstrates that r-FVIII represents an effective alternative for the eradication of inhibitors through IIT.

Bone marrow stromal cell-mediated gene therapy for hemophilia A: in vitro expression of human factor VIII with high biological activity requires the inclusion of the proteolytic site at amino acid 1648

To evaluate the potential of the ex vivo bone marrow stromal cell (BMSC) system as a gene therapy for hemophilia A, we studied the in vitro expression of human factor VIII (hFVIII) in canine BMSCs following transfection with plasmid vectors and transduction with retroviral vectors. Vectors were composed of B domain-deleted forms of hFVIII that either retain or delete the proteolytic site at amino acid 1648. On transfection of BMSCs, vectors supported expression and secretion of similar levels of up to 386 mU/10(6) cells/24 hr, even though only 3-9% of the cells expressed hFVIII while 42-48% of transfected cells harbored plasmid vector. Much higher percentages (approximately 70%) of cells expressing hFVIII were achieved when BMSCs were transduced by retroviral vectors, resulting in expression and secretion as high as 1000-4000 mU/10(6) cells/24 hr. Western analysis demonstrated that the B domain-deleted forms possessing the proteolytic site were secreted predominantly as heavy and light chain heterodimers that resemble native forms found in plasma. In contrast, the hFVIII lacking the proteolytic site was expressed mostly as unprocessed, single heavy-light chains. Both hFVIII forms were correctly cleaved and activated by thrombin. The proteolyzed hFVIII form possessed > or = 93% normal biological activity while the unproteolyzed form possessed consistently less than 55% normal biological activity and was therefore considered less suitable for therapeutic application. These results demonstrate that the BMSC system has potential utility in gene therapy for hemophilia A and stress the importance of selecting the appropriate hFVIII structure for prospective clinical use.

Inhibitor development and substitution therapy in a developing country: Turkey

Prevalence of inhibitor in developing countries, such as Turkey, where fresh frozen plasma (FFP) is still in use due to high cost of concentrates, is unknown. To determine the frequency of inhibitors in Turkish haemophiliacs exposed to blood products, 53 haemophilia A patients (age range 1-20; median: 11 years) and 12 haemophilia B patients (age range 3-20; median: 10 years), were evaluated; 31 haemophilia A patients (23 severe) received plasma-derived concentrates and 22 patients (10 severe) only FFP. No haemophilia B patients developed inhibitor, compared with seven of 53 (13%) haemophilia A patients, all with a severe defect (7/33; 21%) and treated with concentrates (7/23; 30%), whereas severe patients treated with FFP showed a lower risk to develop inhibitors (0/10, P = 0.07). Inhibitors were detected after 8-125 exposure days (median: 52). Intermediate-purity concentrates and pasteurization seemed to be linked with a higher risk of inhibitor compared to high-purity concentrates and solvent-detergent inactivation for seven patients with inhibitor. In four of seven inhibitor patients low-dose concentrate was administered at 25 IU kg-1 twice weekly and inhibitor disappeared in 1-4 months. This regimen might be recommended for immune tolerance in developing countries for its lower cost.

Zero incidence of inhibitor development in previously treated haemophilia A, HIV-negative patients upon exposure to a plasma-derived high-purity and double viral inactivated factor VIII concentrate

Thirty-six haemophilia A, HIV-negative, previously treated patients were changed therapy to a highpurity and double-inactivated (solvent/detergent and dry-heating) previously unused factor VIII concentrate. The mean age of these patients was 27 years at the time of the change. Twenty-three patients were severe haemophiliacs (FVIII:C < 0.02 IU mL-1), seven moderate (FVIII:C between 0.02 and 0.05 IU mL-1) and six mild (FVIII:C > 0.05 IU mL-1). The mean follow-up with this single product was 16 months, with 82 accumulated exposure days and the mean consumption was 117,300 IU of FVIII corresponding to a mean of six batches per patient. No patient developed FVIII inhibitors (upper limit of the CI95: 7.98%), resulting in an incidence rate of 0/48 patient-years (upper limit of the CI95: 77/1000 patient-years). The change in therapy to this new factor VIII concentrate was not associated with the appearance of inhibitors.

Cross-reactivity to porcine factor VIII of factor VIII inhibitors in patients with haemophilia in Australia and New Zealand

BACKGROUND

Inhibitory antibodies which neutralise factor VIII develop in 10-20% of individuals with inherited haemophilia A and rarely as autoantibodies in normal individuals to cause acquired haemophilia. The antibodies are directed against human factor VIII but cross-react to varying degrees with porcine factor VIII. Porcine factor VIII can be used for treatment in individuals with low cross-reactivity.

AIMS

To determine the cross-reactivity of factor VIII inhibitors between human factor VIII and porcine factor VIII, in a population of patients with inherited and acquired haemophilia A. Also, to determine whether patients with inherited haemophilia and inhibitors have a higher incidence of factor VIII gene inversion in intron 22.

METHODS

Samples and data sheets from 43 patients with inherited and ten with acquired haemophilia were submitted from hospitals in Australia and New Zealand. Inhibitor levels to human and porcine factor VIII were measured by the Bethesda method in 39 with inherited and nine with acquired haemophilia A.

RESULTS

Of 39 patients with inherited haemophilia A, cross-reactivity was 0% in 17 patients, 1-19% in six, 20-39% in 11 and 40-80% in five. In six of nine patients with acquired haemophilia cross-reactivity was < or = 7%. In inherited severe haemophilia A, the frequency of the intron 22 inversion was not greater in 37 study patients than in 28 patients without an inhibitor.

CONCLUSIONS

Many patients in Australia and New Zealand with inhibitors to human factor VIII presently show a low or absent level of cross-reactivity to porcine factor VIII. These may respond to treatment with this concentrate at least in the short term. There remains a group of patients with high cross-reactivity who will respond only to recombinant factor VIIa or prothrombin complex concentrates.

The Missense Mutation Arg593 → Cys Is Related to Antibody Formation in a Patient With Mild Hemophilia A

The development of inhibitory antibodies to factor VIII in patients affected by a mild form of hemophilia A (factor VIII < 0.05 IU/mL) is considered a rare event. In this study, we evaluated the relationship between genotype and anti-factor VIII antibody formation in a patient with mild hemophilia A. Mutation analysis showed that a missense mutation in the factor VIII gene leading to replacement of Arg593 by Cys in the A2 domain of factor VIII was associated with hemophilia A in this patient. The anti-factor VIII antibodies present in the patient's plasma were characterized using metabolically labeled factor VIII fragments expressed in insect cells. The anti-factor VIII antibodies, composed of subclasses IgG2 and IgG4, reacted with both the fragment corresponding to the factor VIII heavy chain and the A2 domain. The Arg593 → Cys substitution was introduced into the cDNA encoding the A2 domain of factor VIII and the resulting construct was expressed in insect cells. Strikingly, the metabolically labeled A2 domain carrying the Arg593 → Cys mutation was not recognized by the anti-factor VIII antibodies present in the plasma of the patient. These data indicate that the anti-factor VIII antibodies are exclusively directed against exogenous factor VIII. This strongly suggests that the Arg593 → Cys substitution results in recognition of wild-type factor VIII as nonself and is thereby related to the formation of anti-factor VIII antibodies after factor VIII replacement therapy in this particular patient.

Identification of novel factor VIII inhibitor epitopes using synthetic peptide arrays

OBJECTIVES

Mapping the antibody-binding sites on the factor VIII (FVIII) protein opens the prospect of studying the development of FVIII inhibitors and the alteration of inhibitor specificities over time. This paper describes a novel approach to the mapping of FVIII antibody-binding sites.

METHODS

Immobilized synthetic peptide arrays covering 80% of the complete 2351 amino acid sequence of factor VIII (FVIII) were used to determine epitope specificity of 6 alloantibodies and 3 autoantibodies inhibitory to FVIII activity. This detailed assessment was carried out using a modified enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay with plasma from normal persons or hemophilia A patients without inhibitors as negative controls.

RESULTS

Antibody-combining sites could be differentiated in both a qualitative and quantitative manner and were patient-specific. Highly reactive peptides were restricted to specific sites in the A1-A3 and C1-C2 domains and were not proximal to known proteolytic cleavage sites. Free peptides incubated in vitro with the plasmas of 3 patients significantly reduced residual inhibitor titers in a dose-dependent manner.

CONCLUSION

This technique permits the study of the development and specificity of FVIII inhibitors, can detect and differentiate between inhibitory and noninhibitory antibodies using immobilized or free peptides respectively, permits correlation of antibody-combining sites with inhibition of FVIII activity and provides a basis for the development of inhibitor adsorption or neutralization technology.

Antibodies to factor VIII in plasma of patients with hemophilia A and normal subjects

Non-neutralizing factor VIII (FVIII) antibodies (FVIII-Ab) in hemophilia A may be associated with an abnormal clinical response to FVIII concentrates. Patients with FVIII inhibitors may develop noncoagulation FVIII-Ab after the induction of immunotolerance. Natural FVIII-Ab may be detected in the plasma of some healthy subjects. The aim of this study was to analyze the presence of FVIII-Ab in the plasma of 53 normal blood donors and 124 patients with hemophilia A (18 patients had a previous history of FVIII inhibitor, but only 12 had inhibitor at the moment this study was performed). FVIIII inhibitor was measured using the Bethesda method. FVIII-Ab were analyzed by a specific ELISA assay using purified FVIII from a monoclonal concentrate and a standard plasma containing 26 Bethesda units (BU) of FVIII inhibitor. Purified FVIII was used to coat wells of a microtiter plate and was incubated with dilutions of plasma to be tested. Bound human IgG FVIII-Ab were detected by incubation with polyclonal sheep anti.human IgG alkaline phosphatase conjugate, and the OD405 was quantitated. A linear fit was obtained (by plotting FVIII-Ab positivity [OD 405nm] versus BU titer) when serial dilutions of this standard inhibitor plasma, containing titers of 0.5 BU or higher, were used. Four different levels of FVIII-Ab positivity [OD 405nm] were distinguished in this assay: Negative levels (-) were obtained with dilutions of the standard inhibitor containing < 0.5 BU. Mild levels (+) were obtained with dilutions of 0.5-5 BU. Moderate levels (+2) were obtained for dilutions ranging from 5-25 BU. Maximum positivity (+3) was obtained for dilutions of titers > 25 BU. FVIII-Ab positivity was detected in eight of the normal subjects (15%): three were found to be moderately positive (+2) and five mildly positive (+). No inhibitory activity was detectable when whole plasma was used. All the hemophilic patients with a presence of FVIII inhibitor at the time of the study were found to be positive for FVIII-Ab. In addition, the level of positivity correlated with the corresponding BU. Four of the six patients who had a history of inhibitory were negative and two positive. Twenty additional patients (16.12%) in whom no inhibitory activity was detected were found to be positive for FVIII-Ab: 16 + and four +2. The mean age of patients with FVII-Ab positivity was significantly higher than that of patients of the FVIII-Ab negative group (p < 0.005). In conclusion, FVIII-Ab positivity in patients with hemophilia A was 17.7% higher than the level of positivity detected by an inhibitory assay. We propose that this method for FVIII-Ab analysis could be used for patients with hemophilia A, at least to complement the functional inhibitor assay. FVIII recovery or half-life should be assessed in patients who test positive for FVIII-Ab and who show no evidence of inhibitor.