Host-generalist fungal pathogens of seedlings may maintain forest diversity via host-specific impacts and differential susceptibility among tree species

Fungal community and taxa specialization to host and environment interactions in two temperate forests

The structure and function of plant-associated fungal communities (i.e. mycobiome) is shaped by biotic and abiotic factors, and can impact plant community dynamics. We evaluated the effects of different environmental factors in structuring the communities of seedling-associated fungi in temperate tree species, considering both the Janzen-Connell hypothesis as well as the impacts of climate warming. We tested the hypothesis that fungal host-specialization is observed at both the individual fungus and fungal community levels and is modulated by environmental conditions. The seedling fungal communities were characterized from tree species grown in two forests, under experimental manipulation of light, warming, and distance to and density of conspecifics. Fungal communities were analyzed using generalized joint attribute models. While warming, light, and forest site played a role in structuring seedling fungal communities, host, distance to, and density of conspecifics were stronger contributors. Furthermore, we could identify which fungal taxa responded to which predictors. This work supports the concept of fungal host-specialization at the community level, and points to particular fungal taxa which may play roles in density- and distance-dependent regulation of plant species diversity in the studied forests.

Soil Nutrient Dynamics and Fungal Community Shifts Drive the Degradation of Pinus sylvestris var. mongholica Plantations in the Loess Plateau

The degradation of Pinus sylvestris var. mongholica plantations in Youyu County on the Loess Plateau has caused major ecological issues, though the mechanisms remain poorly understood. This study explores the effects of stand age and soil properties on the rhizosphere fungal community and their potential roles in plantation degradation. Soil samples were collected from plantations of different stand ages (13, 20, 25, and 35 years), and their fungal diversity and composition were analyzed using high-throughput sequencing. The results showed that soil organic carbon and total nitrogen declined with stand age due to high nutrient demand and limited litter input. The available phosphorus and available potassium (AK) contents were identified as key limiting factors, influencing ectomycorrhizal fungi abundance and the overall soil fungal diversity. With an increasing stand age, the fungal diversity decreased, the ectomycorrhizal fungi declined, and the pathogenic fungi increased, exacerbating plantation degradation. Regression analysis further indicated a significant negative correlation between AK content and stand age, suggesting potassium deficiency as a critical driver of tree health decline. This study highlights the pivotal role of soil nutrient availability in shaping rhizosphere fungal communities and sustaining P. sylvestris plantations, offering insights into degradation mechanisms and strategies to enhance forest resilience on the Loess Plateau.

Local Stabilising Density Effects in the Context of Ecological Disturbance and Community Assembly

The maintenance of species diversity in ecological communities has many promising explanations, including certain types of local biotic interactions that generate differential effects on the performance of conspecific and heterospecific individuals. To date, most studies of these local biotic interactions have focused on relatively stable systems, such as mature forests or undisturbed grasslands. However, many ecosystems are far from a stable state, especially under accelerating global climate change. Here, we present a synthesis of local differences between conspecific and heterospecific interactions following disturbances-and how disturbances may alter the strength and scaling of these effects to population growth and species diversity. First, we clarify terminology and categorise disturbances based on their primary mode of impact on species interactions. Second, we leverage existing literature to develop a framework for understanding how disturbances may alter the strength and role of local biotic interactions in regenerating communities. Third, we use prominent examples of disturbance: drought, windthrow and wildfire, to highlight remaining gaps in knowledge. Finally, we discuss implications for future populations and communities in unstable states. We emphasise the need for empirical studies to further integrate disturbance and local conspecific density effects within broader ecological models of community assembly and functioning.

Soil microbial communities in dry and moist tropical forests exhibit distinct shifts in community composition but not diversity with succession

Soil microbial communities are integral to ecosystem function but our understanding of how they respond to secondary succession in fragmented landscapes is limited, particularly in tropical dry forests. We used DNA metabarcoding to evaluate successional changes in soil bacteria and fungi, comparing land managed for cattle, young, and older secondary forests at moist and dry sites in the Republic of Panama. We highlight key functional groups of microbes that interact with plants, including arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF), nitrogen-fixing bacteria, and plant pathogenic fungi. Plant diversity was higher at the moist site and increased with succession as the plant communities changed at both sites. By contrast, bacterial diversity was similar across sites and successional stages, and while overall fungal diversity was higher at the moist site, it also showed no changes with succession at either site. However, microbial community composition did change, with pastures and older forests having distinct bacterial and fungal communities and young secondary forests often displaying transitional ones. Functional groups of microbes showed contrasting patterns between sites, with the dry forest having a higher diversity of Nitrogen-fixing bacteria despite lower densities of legumes, higher diversity and different communities of AMF, and a much lower incidence of putative fungal plant pathogens than the moist site. Our findings highlight the importance of looking at aboveground and belowground effects together and demonstrate that predictions generated for soil microbes in moist tropical forests may not apply to dry forests. These results may also inform the restoration of climate-resilient forests.

IMPORTANCE

Secondary forests are important components of neotropical landscapes and soil microbes help to shape these forests and the ecosystem services that they provide. This study demonstrates that soil microbial communities in moist and dry tropical forests can recover and reassemble after only 20 years of natural succession following the removal of cattle. However, successional patterns that are seen in the plant community are not always seen belowground. These patterns were more predictable at the moist than the dry site where the patchiness of the landscape likely restricts dispersal of both plants and soil microbes. We highlight the importance of preserving remaining tropical dry forests as they host unique microbial biodiversity that may help forests respond to drought conditions. As community shifts in soil microbes influence plant establishment, forest productivity, and other aspects of ecosystem functioning during the succession of tropical forest communities, our results can inform the restoration of climate-resilient forests.

Interactive effects of leaf pathogens and plant mycorrhizal type on plant diversity-productivity relationships

Diversity-productivity relationships can differ between forests dominated by different mycorrhizal types and be modulated by specialist and generalist pathogens. However, little is known about how these factors interact to modulate biodiversity effects. We addressed this knowledge gap with a 2-year experiment combining the manipulation of plant richness (one, two, four, eight species) and mycorrhizal tree type (arbuscular mycorrhizal [AM] tree-dominated; ecto-mycorrhizal [ECM] tree-dominated) with fungicide application for leaf pathogens (added or control). Biodiversity effects were quantified for community productivity and its two components (shoots and roots). We observed nonlinear diversity-productivity relationships, with the productivity of ECM tree-dominated communities increasing at low to intermediate diversity and declining at the highest species richness. Foliar fungicide application reduced positive complementarity effects and increased productivity in both ECM tree monocultures as well as eight-species mixtures. This finding suggests that the dilution effects of specialized pathogens may dominate at low diversity, while the spillover effects of generalist pathogens may become dominant at high diversity, resulting in unimodal diversity-productivity relationships. In AM tree-dominated communities, aboveground productivity strongly increased in response to leaf pathogen suppression in eight-species mixtures, and the release from leaf pathogens benefited most of the species that were most productive in fungicide-treated monocultures. This agrees with the prediction that spillover effects of generalist pathogens in diverse plant communities could differentially suppress highly productive species due to the trade-off between growth and defense. In addition, positive biodiversity effects on root production were significantly stronger in AM tree- than ECM tree-dominated communities. Our results demonstrate that relationships between plant diversity and productivity can be nonlinear due to the combined effects of specialized and generalized plant-fungal interactions, depend on plant mycorrhizal type, and differ between aboveground and belowground compartments.

Evolutionary Trajectories of Shoots vs. Roots: Plant Volatile Metabolomes Are Richer but Less Structurally Diverse Belowground in the Tropical Tree Genus Protium

The breadth and depth of plant leaf metabolomes have been implicated in key interactions with plant enemies aboveground. In particular, divergence in plant species chemical composition-amongst neighbors, relatives, or both-is often suggested as a means of escape from insect herbivore enemies. Plants also experience strong pressure from enemies such as belowground pathogens; however, little work has been carried out to examine the evolutionary trajectories of species' specialized chemistries in both roots and leaves. Here, we examine the GCMS detectable phytochemistry (for simplicity, hereafter referred to as specialized volatile metabolites) of the tropical tree genus Protium, testing the hypothesis that phenotypic divergence will be weaker belowground compared to aboveground due to more limited dispersal by enemies. We found that, after controlling for differences in chemical richness, roots expressed less structurally diverse compounds than leaves, despite having higher numbers of specialized volatile metabolites, and that species' phylogenetic distance was only positively correlated with compound structural distance in roots, not leaves. Taken together, our results suggest that root specialized volatile metabolites exhibit significantly less phenotypic divergence than leaf specialized metabolites and may be under relaxed selection pressure from enemies belowground.

Oomycete communities in lowland tropical forest soils vary in species abundance and comprise saprophytes and pathogens of seeds and seedlings of multiple plant species

PREMISE

The soils in lowland tropics are teeming with microbial life, which can impact plant community structure and diversity through plant-soil feedbacks. While bacteria and fungi have been the focus of most studies in the tropics, oomycetes may have an outsized effect on seed and seedling health and survival, given their affinity for moister, warmer environments.

METHODS

We assessed the diversity and pathogenicity of oomycete species present in a lowland tropical forest in Panama. We used a culture-dependent leaf-baiting assay and culture-independent soil DNA metabarcoding methods to quantify zoospore abundance and species diversity. A subset of the isolates from the baiting assay were used to evaluate pathogenicity and symptom severity on seedlings of three tree species.

RESULTS

Oomycetes were ubiquitous and common members of the soil microbial community in lowland tropical forests, and zoospore abundance was far greater compared to similar studies from temperate and mediterranean forests. The various oomycete species also varied in the ability to infect host plants. Species of Pythium were more virulent, while species of Phytopythium caused less severe symptoms but were more diverse and commonly isolated from the soil. Finally, we found that individual hosts accumulated a distinct oomycete community and was the only factor that had an effect on community structure.

CONCLUSIONS

Collectively, these findings demonstrate that oomycetes are ubiquitous, host-generalist pathogens and saprophytes, that can impact seed and seedling survival in lowland tropical forests.

Consequences of Local Conspecific Density Effects for Plant Diversity and Community Dynamics

Conspecific density dependence (CDD) in plant populations is widespread, most likely caused by local-scale biotic interactions, and has potentially important implications for biodiversity, community composition, and ecosystem processes. However, progress in this important area of ecology has been hindered by differing viewpoints on CDD across subfields in ecology, lack of synthesis across CDD-related frameworks, and misunderstandings about how empirical measurements of local CDD fit within the context of broader ecological theories on community assembly and diversity maintenance. Here, we propose a conceptual synthesis of local-scale CDD and its causes, including species-specific antagonistic and mutualistic interactions. First, we compare and clarify different uses of CDD and related concepts across subfields within ecology. We suggest the use of local stabilizing/destabilizing CDD to refer to the scenario where local conspecific density effects are more negative/positive than heterospecific effects. Second, we discuss different mechanisms for local stabilizing and destabilizing CDD, how those mechanisms are interrelated, and how they cut across several fields of study within ecology. Third, we place local stabilizing/destabilizing CDD within the context of broader ecological theories and discuss implications and challenges related to scaling up the effects of local CDD on populations, communities, and metacommunities. The ultimate goal of this synthesis is to provide a conceptual roadmap for researchers studying local CDD and its implications for population and community dynamics.

Time-dependent interaction modification generated from plant-soil feedback

Pairwise interactions between species can be modified by other community members, leading to emergent dynamics contingent on community composition. Despite the prevalence of such higher-order interactions, little is known about how they are linked to the timing and order of species' arrival. We generate population dynamics from a mechanistic plant-soil feedback model, then apply a general theoretical framework to show that the modification of a pairwise interaction by a third plant depends on its germination phenology. These time-dependent interaction modifications emerge from concurrent changes in plant and microbe populations and are strengthened by higher overlap between plants' associated microbiomes. The interaction between this overlap and the specificity of microbiomes further determines plant coexistence. Our framework is widely applicable to mechanisms in other systems from which similar time-dependent interaction modifications can emerge, highlighting the need to integrate temporal shifts of species interactions to predict the emergent dynamics of natural communities.

Closing the gap in the Janzen-Connell hypothesis: What determines pathogen diversity?

The high tree diversity in tropical forests has long been a puzzle to ecologists. In the 1970s, Janzen and Connell proposed that tree species (hosts) coexist due to the stabilizing actions of specialized enemies. This Janzen-Connell hypothesis was subsequently supported by theoretical studies. Yet, such studies have taken the presence of specialized pathogens for granted, overlooking that pathogen coexistence also requires an explanation. Moreover, stable ecological coexistence does not necessarily imply evolutionary stability. What are the conditions that allow Janzen-Connell effects to evolve? We link theory from community ecology, evolutionary biology and epidemiology to tackle this question, structuring our approach around five theoretical frameworks. Phenomenological Lotka-Volterra competition models provide the most basic framework, which can be restructured to include (single- or multi-)pathogen dynamics. This ecological foundation can be extended to include pathogen evolution. Hosts, of course, may also evolve, and we introduce a coevolutionary model, showing that host-pathogen coevolution can lead to highly diverse systems. Our work unpacks the assumptions underpinning Janzen-Connell and places theoretical bounds on pathogen and host ecology and evolution. The five theoretical frameworks taken together provide a stronger theoretical basis for Janzen-Connell, delivering a wider lens that can yield important insights into the maintenance of diversity in these increasingly threatened systems.

Are Plant-Soil Feedbacks Caused by Many Weak Microbial Interactions?

We used high-throughput sequencing and multivariate analyses to describe soil microbial community composition in two four-year field plant-soil feedback (PSF) experiments in Minnesota, USA and Jena, Germany. In descending order of variation explained, microbial community composition differed between the two study sites, among years, between bulk and rhizosphere soils, and among rhizosphere soils cultivated by different plant species. To try to identify soil organisms or communities that may cause PSF, we correlated plant growth responses with the microbial community composition associated with different plants. We found that plant biomass was correlated with values on two multivariate axes. These multivariate axes weighted dozens of soil organisms, suggesting that PSF was not caused by individual pathogens or symbionts but instead was caused by 'many weak' plant-microbe interactions. Taken together, the results suggest that PSFs result from complex interactions that occur within the context of a much larger soil microbial community whose composition is determined by factors associated with 'site' or year, such as soil pH, soil type, and weather. The results suggest that PSFs may be highly variable and difficult to reproduce because they result from complex interactions that occur in the context of a larger soil microbial community.

Plant-soil feedback effects on conspecific and heterospecific successors of annual and perennial Central European grassland plants are correlated

Plant-soil feedbacks (PSFs), soil-mediated plant effects on conspecific or heterospecific successors, are a major driver of vegetation development. It has been proposed that specialist plant antagonists drive differences in PSF responses between conspecific and heterospecific plants, whereas contributions of generalist plant antagonists to PSFs remain understudied. Here we examined PSFs among nine annual and nine perennial grassland species to test whether poorly defended annuals accumulate generalist-dominated plant antagonist communities, causing equally negative PSFs on conspecific and heterospecific annuals, whereas well-defended perennial species accumulate specialist-dominated antagonist communities, predominantly causing negative conspecific PSFs. Annuals exhibited more negative PSFs than perennials, corresponding to differences in root-tissue investments, but this was independent of conditioning plant group. Overall, conspecific and heterospecific PSFs did not differ. Instead, conspecific and heterospecific PSF responses in individual species' soils were correlated. Soil fungal communities were generalist dominated but could not robustly explain PSF variation. Our study nevertheless suggests an important role for host generalists as drivers of PSFs.

Distance and density dependence in two native Bornean dipterocarp species

The Janzen-Connell hypothesis proposes that density and distance-dependent mortality generated by specialist natural enemies prevent competitive dominance. Much literature on Janzen-Connell mechanisms comes from the neotropics, and evidence of the role of distance and density-dependence is still relatively sparse. We tested the predictions of the Janzen-Connell hypothesis in a South-East Asian system dominated by mast fruiting species. We hypothesized that seedling survival would decrease with distance and density, seedling growth would increase, and herbivory would decrease, according to the predictions of the Janzen-Connell hypothesis. Experiments were conducted to determine the strength of the Janzen-Connell mechanism by manipulating the density and identity of tree species as a function of the distance from parent trees. Survival of conspecific seedlings was reduced near adult trees of one species, but not another. High densities of seedlings decreased the growth of conspecific seedlings of both species. In both species, herbivory rates decreased with distance in low-density areas. This study indicates that dipterocarp species experienced weak Janzen-Connell effects of distance and density dependence at the growth stage studied. Future studies in this system might focus on earlier life-history stages such as seeds and small seedlings, as well as studying mortality during mast-seeding events.

Functional shifts in soil fungal communities regulate differential tree species establishment during subalpine forest succession

Soil fungi can differentially affect plant performance and community dynamics. While fungi play key roles in driving the plant-soil feedbacks (PSFs) that promote grassland succession, it remains unclear how the fungi-mediated PSFs affect tree species establishment during forest succession. We inoculated pioneer broadleaf (Betula platyphylla and Betula albosinensis) and nonpioneer coniferous tree seedlings (Picea asperata and Abies faxoniana) with fungal-dominated rooting zone soils collected from dominant plant species of early-, mid- and late-successional stages in a subalpine forest, and compared their biomass and fungal communities. All tree species accumulated abundant pathogenic fungi in early-successional inoculated soil, which generated negative biotic feedbacks and lowered seedling biomass. High levels of soil ectomycorrhizal fungi from mid- and late-successional stages resulted in positive biotic PSFs and strongly facilitated slow-growing coniferous seedling performance to favour successional development. B. albosinensis also grew better in mid- and late-successional soils with fewer pathogenic fungi than in early-successional soil, indicating its large susceptibility to pathogen attack. In contrast, the growth of another pioneer tree, B. platyphylla, was significantly suppressed in late-successional soil and was mostly driven by saprotrophic fungi, despite the unchanged pathogenic fungal community traits between the two fast-growing species. This unexpected result suggested a host specificity-dependent mechanism involved in the different impacts of fungal pathogens on host trees. Our findings reveal a critical role of functional shifts in soil fungal communities in mediating differential PSFs of tree species across successional stages, which should be considered to improve the prediction and management of community development following forest disturbances.

Simulating environmentally-sensitive tree recruitment in vegetation demographic models

Vegetation demographic models (VDMs) endeavor to predict how global forests will respond to climate change. This requires simulating which trees, if any, are able to recruit under changing environmental conditions. We present a new recruitment scheme for VDMs in which functional-type-specific recruitment rates are sensitive to light, soil moisture and the productivity of reproductive trees. We evaluate the scheme by predicting tree recruitment for four tropical tree functional types under varying meteorology and canopy structure at Barro Colorado Island, Panama. We compare predictions to those of a current VDM, quantitative observations and ecological expectations. We find that the scheme improves the magnitude and rank order of recruitment rates among functional types and captures recruitment limitations in response to variable understory light, soil moisture and precipitation regimes. Our results indicate that adopting this framework will improve VDM capacity to predict functional-type-specific tree recruitment in response to climate change, thereby improving predictions of future forest distribution, composition and function.

Deciphering the role of specialist and generalist plant-microbial interactions as drivers of plant-soil feedback

Feedback between plants and soil microbial communities can be a powerful driver of vegetation dynamics. Plants elicit changes in the soil microbiome that either promote or suppress conspecifics at the same location, thereby regulating population density-dependence and species co-existence. Such effects are often attributed to the accumulation of host-specific antagonistic or beneficial microbiota in the rhizosphere. However, the identity and host-specificity of the microbial taxa involved are rarely empirically assessed. Here we review the evidence for host-specificity in plant-associated microbes and propose that specific plant-soil feedbacks can also be driven by generalists. We outline the potential mechanisms by which generalist microbial pathogens, mutualists and decomposers can generate differential effects on plant hosts and synthesize existing evidence to predict these effects as a function of plant investments into defence, microbial mutualists and dispersal. Importantly, the capacity of generalist microbiota to drive plant-soil feedbacks depends not only on the traits of individual plants but also on the phylogenetic and functional diversity of plant communities. Identifying factors that promote specialization or generalism in plant-microbial interactions and thereby modulate the impact of microbiota on plant performance will advance our understanding of the mechanisms underlying plant-soil feedback and the ways it contributes to plant co-existence.