Intrasubunit signal transduction by the aspartate chemoreceptor

Bacterial chemoreceptors and chemoeffectors

Bacteria use chemotaxis signaling pathways to sense environmental changes. Escherichia coli chemotaxis system represents an ideal model that illustrates fundamental principles of biological signaling processes. Chemoreceptors are crucial signaling proteins that mediate taxis toward a wide range of chemoeffectors. Recently, in deep study of the biochemical and structural features of chemoreceptors, the organization of higher-order clusters in native cells, and the signal transduction mechanisms related to the on-off signal output provides us with general insights to understand how chemotaxis performs high sensitivity, precise adaptation, signal amplification, and wide dynamic range. Along with the increasing knowledge, bacterial chemoreceptors can be engineered to sense novel chemoeffectors, which has extensive applications in therapeutics and industry. Here we mainly review recent advances in the E. coli chemotaxis system involving structure and organization of chemoreceptors, discovery, design, and characterization of chemoeffectors, and signal recognition and transduction mechanisms. Possible strategies for changing the specificity of bacterial chemoreceptors to sense novel chemoeffectors are also discussed.

Mutationally altered signal output in the Nart (NarX-Tar) hybrid chemoreceptor

Signal-transducing proteins that span the cytoplasmic membrane transmit information about the environment to the interior of the cell. In bacteria, these signal transducers include sensor kinases, which typically control gene expression via response regulators, and methyl-accepting chemoreceptor proteins, which control flagellar rotation via the CheA kinase and CheY response regulator. We previously reported that a chimeric protein (Nart) that joins the ligand-binding, transmembrane, and linker regions of the NarX sensor kinase to the signaling and adaptation domains of the Tar chemoreceptor elicits a repellent response to nitrate and nitrite. As with NarX, nitrate evokes a stronger response than nitrite. Here we show that mutations targeting a highly conserved sequence (the P box) in the periplasmic domain alter chemoreception by Nart and signaling by NarX similarly. In particular, the G51R substitution converts Nart from a repellent receptor into an attractant receptor for nitrate. Our results underscore the conclusion that the fundamental mechanism of transmembrane signaling is conserved between homodimeric sensor kinases and chemoreceptors. They also highlight the plasticity of the coupling between ligand binding and signal output in these systems.

Synthetic multivalent ligands as probes of signal transduction

Cell-surface receptors acquire information from the extracellular environment and coordinate intracellular responses. Many receptors do not operate as individual entities, but rather as part of dimeric or oligomeric complexes. Coupling the functions of multiple receptors may endow signaling pathways with the sensitivity and malleability required to govern cellular responses. Moreover, multireceptor signaling complexes may provide a means of spatially segregating otherwise degenerate signaling cascades. Understanding the mechanisms, extent, and consequences of receptor co-localization and interreceptor communication is critical; chemical synthesis can provide compounds to address the role of receptor assembly in signal transduction. Multivalent ligands can be generated that possess a variety of sizes, shapes, valencies, orientations, and densities of binding elements. This Review focuses on the use of synthetic multivalent ligands to characterize receptor function.

The HAMP linker in histidine kinase dimeric receptors is critical for symmetric transmembrane signal transduction

The HAMP linker, a common structural element between a sensor and a transmitter module in various sensor proteins, plays an essential role in signal transduction. Here, by in vivo complementation experiments with Tar-EnvZ hybrid receptor mutants in which the HAMP linker forms a heterodimer with Tar and EnvZ-type subunits, we found that mutations at one linker only affect the function of EnvZ in the same subunit. However, the same mutations affect the EnvZ function of both subunits when only a Tar or EnvZ-type HAMP linker is used. These results suggest that intersubunit interactions in the HAMP linker normally mediate signal transduction through both subunits in a sensor dimer, whereas the signal is asymmetrically transduced through the linker in a heterodimer. This is the first demonstration that two HAMP linkers in a sensor dimer are functionally coupled for normal signal transduction; however, this functional coupling can be reduced when the HAMP linkers lose their symmetric nature.

Receptor methylation controls the magnitude of stimulus-response coupling in bacterial chemotaxis

Motile prokaryotes employ a chemoreceptor-kinase array to sense changes in the media and properly adjust their swimming behavior. This array is composed of a family of Type I membrane receptors, a histidine protein kinase (CheA), and an Src homology 3-like protein (CheW). Binding of an attractant to the chemoreceptors inhibits CheA, which results in decreased phosphorylation of the chemotaxis response regulator (CheY). Sensitivity of the system to stimuli is modulated by a protein methyltransferase (CheR) and a protein methylesterase (CheB) that catalyze the methylation and demethylation of specific glutamyl residues in the cytoplasmic domain of the receptors. One of the most fundamental unanswered questions concerning the bacterial chemotaxis mechanism is the quantitative relationship between ligand binding to receptors and CheA inhibition. We show that the receptor glutamyl modifications cause adaptation by changing the gain (magnitude amplification) between attractant binding and kinase inhibition without substantially affecting ligand binding affinity. The mechanism adjusts receptor sensitivity to background stimulus intensity over several orders of magnitude of attractant concentrations. The cooperative effects of ligand binding appear to be minimal with Hill coefficients for kinase inhibition less than 2, independent of the state of glutamyl modification.

Modeling the transmembrane domain of bacterial chemoreceptors

Bacterial chemoreceptors signal across the membrane by conformational changes that traverse a four-helix transmembrane domain. High-resolution structures are available for the chemoreceptor periplasmic domain and part of the cytoplasmic domain but not for the transmembrane domain. Thus, we constructed molecular models of the transmembrane domains of chemoreceptors Trg and Tar, using coordinates of an unrelated four-helix coiled coil as a template and the X-ray structure of a chemoreceptor periplasmic domain to establish register and positioning. We tested the models using the extensive data for cross-linking propensities between cysteines introduced into adjacent transmembrane helices, and we found that many aspects of the models corresponded with experimental observations. The one striking disparity, the register of transmembrane helix 2 (TM2) relative to its partner transmembrane helix 1, could be corrected by sliding TM2 along its long axis toward the periplasm. The correction implied that axial sliding of TM2, the signaling movement indicated by a large body of data, was of greater magnitude than previously thought. The refined models were used to assess effects of inter-helical disulfides on the two ligand-induced conformational changes observed in alternative crystal structures of periplasmic domains: axial sliding within a subunit and subunit rotation. Analyses using a measure of disulfide potential energy provided strong support for the helical sliding model of transmembrane signaling but indicated that subunit rotation could be involved in other ligand-induced effects. Those analyses plus modeled distances between diagnostic cysteine pairs indicated a magnitude for TM2 sliding in transmembrane signaling of several angstroms.

A piston model for transmembrane signaling of the aspartate receptor

To characterize the mechanism by which receptors propagate conformational changes across membranes, nitroxide spin labels were attached at strategic positions in the bacterial aspartate receptor. By collecting the electron paramagnetic resonance spectra of these labeled receptors in the presence and absence of the ligand aspartate, ligand binding was shown to generate an approximately 1 angstrom intrasubunit piston-type movement of one transmembrane helix downward relative to the other transmembrane helix. The receptor-associated phosphorylation cascade proteins CheA and CheW did not alter the ligand-induced movement. Because the piston movement is very small, the ability of receptors to produce large outcomes in response to stimuli is caused by the ability of the receptor-coupled enzymes to detect small changes in the conformation of the receptor.

Functional similarities among two-component sensors and methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins suggest a role for linker region amphipathic helices in transmembrane signal transduction

Signal-responsive components of transmembrane signal-transducing regulatory systems include methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins and membrane-bound, two-component histidine kinases. Prokaryotes use these regulatory networks to channel environmental cues into adaptive responses. A typical network is highly discriminating, using a specific phosphoryl relay that connects particular signals to appropriate responses. Current understanding of transmembrane signal transduction includes periplasmic signal binding with the subsequent conformational changes being transduced, via transmembrane helix movements, into the sensory protein's cytoplasmic domain. These induced conformational changes bias the protein's regulatory function. Although the mutational analyses reviewed here identify a role for the linker region in transmembrane signal transduction, no specific mechanism of linker function has yet been described. We propose a speculative, mechanistic model for linker function based on interactions between two putative amphipathic helices. The model attempts to explain both mutant phenotypes and hybrid sensor data, while accounting for recognized features of amphipathic helices.

Inversion of thermosensing property of the bacterial receptor Tar by mutations in the second transmembrane region

The aspartate chemoreceptor Tar of Escherichia coli serves as a warm sensor that produces attractant and repellent signals upon increases and decreases in temperature, respectively. However, increased levels of methylation of the cytoplasmic domain of Tar resulting from aspartate binding convert Tar to a cold sensor with the opposite signaling behavior. Detailed analyses of the methylation sites, which are located in two separate alpha-helices (MH1 and MH2), have suggested that intra- and/or intersubunit interactions of MH1 and MH2 play a critical role in thermosensing. These interactions may be influenced by binding of aspartate, which could trigger some displacement of MH1 through the second transmembrane region (TM2). As an initial step toward understanding the role of TM2 in thermosensing, we have examined the thermosensing properties of 43 mutant Tar receptors with randomized TM2 sequences (residues 190-210). Among them, we identified one mutant receptor (Tar-I2) that functioned as a cold sensor in the absence of aspartate. This is the first example of attractant-independent inversion of thermosensing in Tar. Further analyses identified the minimal essential divergence from the wild-type Tar sequence (Q191V-W192R-Q193C) required for the inverted response. Thus, displacements of TM2 seem to influence the thermosensing function of Tar.

Model of maltose-binding protein/chemoreceptor complex supports intrasubunit signaling mechanism

The Tar protein of Escherichia coli is unique among known bacterial chemoreceptors in that it generates additive responses to two very disparate ligands, aspartate and maltose. Aspartate binds directly to the periplasmic (extracytoplasmic) domain of Tar. Maltose first binds to maltose-binding protein (MBP). MBP then assumes a closed conformation in which it can interact with the periplasmic domain of Tar. MBP residues critical for binding Tar were identified in a screen of mutations that cause specific defects in maltose chemotaxis. Mutations were introduced into a plasmid-borne malE gene that encodes a mutant form of MBP in which two engineered Cys residues spontaneously generate a disulfide bond in the oxidizing environment of the periplasmic space. This disulfide covalently crosslinks the NH3-terminal and COOH-terminal domains of MBP and locks the protein into a closed conformation. Double-Cys MBP confers a dominant-negative phenotype for maltose taxis, and we reasoned that third mutations that relieve this negative dominance probably alter residues that are important for the initial interaction of MBP with Tar. The published three-dimensional structures of MBP and the periplasmic domain of E. coli Tar were docked in a computer simulation that juxtaposed the residues in MBP identified in this way with residues in Tar that have been implicated in maltose taxis. The resulting model of the MBP-Tar complex exhibits good complementarity between the surfaces of the two proteins and supports the idea that aspartate and MBP may each initiate an attractant signal through Tar by inducing similar conformational changes in the chemoreceptor.

Chemotaxis receptors: a progress report on structure and function

Recent biochemical and structural studies have provided many new insights into the structure and function of bacterial chemoreceptors. Aspects of their ligand binding, conformational changes, and interactions with other members of the signaling pathway are being defined at the structural level. It is anticipated that the combined effort will soon provide a detailed, unified view of an entire response system.

Intersubunit interaction between transmembrane helices of the bacterial aspartate chemoreceptor homodimer

The transmembrane domain that connects the extracellular and intracellular domains of cell-surface receptors must play a critical role in signal transduction. Here, we report studies of the interaction between the transmembrane helices (TM1 and TM2) of the Escherichia coli aspartate chemoreceptor (Tar). Tar exists as a homodimer regardless of its state of ligand occupancy. A particular residue substitution in TM1 (A19K) abolishes the signaling ability of Tar. This signaling defect can be suppressed by single residue substitutions in TM2 (W192R, A198E, V201E, and V202L). We have found that these suppressors can be divided into two groups. A198E and V201E (class 1) almost completely suppress the defects caused by A19K, and this suppression occurs between two subunits of the Tar dimer. In contrast, W192R and V202L (class 2) fail to suppress some signaling defects, and their suppression does not occur between subunits. Because disulfide-crosslinking studies predict that residues 198 and 201 point toward residue 19 of the partner subunit, we propose that the class 1 suppressors form an intersubunit salt bridge with Lys-19. Indeed, A19K was suppressed by several additional aspartate or glutamate substitutions on the same face of TM2 occupied by residues 198 and 201. None of these intersubunit salt bridges perturb signaling function, suggesting that the mechanism of transmembrane signal propagation does not involve large displacements (such as extensive rotation) of the TM1 and TM2 helices relative to each other.

Stimulus response coupling in bacterial chemotaxis: receptor dimers in signalling arrays

In the Escherichia coli chemotaxis system, a family of chemoreceptors in the cytoplasmic membrane binds stimulatory ligands and regulates the activity of an associated histidine kinase CheA to modulate swimming behaviour and thereby cause a net migration towards attractants and away from repellents. The chemoreceptors themselves have been shown to be predominantly dimeric, but in the presence of the kinase CheA plus an adapter protein, CheW, much higher order structures have been observed. Recent results indicate that transmembrane signalling occurs within receptor clusters rather than through isolated dimers. We propose that the mechanism involves receptor arrays where binding of ligands at the outside surface of the membrane affects lateral packing interactions that cause perturbations in the organization of the signalling array at the opposing surface of the membrane. Results with receptor chimeras as well as findings with tyrosine kinase receptors suggest that this mechanism may represent a common theme in membrane receptor function.

A mechanism for simultaneous sensing of aspartate and maltose by the Tar chemoreceptor of Escherichia coli

The Tar chemoreceptor of Escherichia coli exhibits partial sensory additivity. Tar can mediate simultaneous responses to two disparate ligands, aspartate and substrate-loaded maltose-binding protein (MBP). To investigate how one receptor generates concurrent signals to two stimuli, ligand-binding asymmetry was imposed on the rotationally symmetric Tar homodimer. Mutations causing specific defects in aspartate or maltose chemotaxis were introduced pairwise into plasmid-borne tar genes. The doubly mutated tar genes did not restore aspartate or maltose chemotaxis in a strain containing a chromosomal deletion of tar (delta tar). However, when Tar proteins with complementing sets of mutations were co-expressed from compatible plasmids, the resulting heterodimeric receptors enabled delta tar cells to respond to aspartate or maltose. The effect of one attractant on the response to the other depended on the relative orientations of the functional binding sites for aspartate and MBP. When the sites were in the 'same' orientation, saturating levels of one attractant strongly inhibited chemotaxis to the other. In the 'opposite' orientation, such inhibitory effects were negligible. These data demonstrate that opposing subunits of Tar can transmit signals to aspartate and maltose independently if the ligands are restricted to the 'opposite' binding orientation. When aspartate and MBP bind in the 'same' orientation, they compete for signalling through one subunit. In the wild-type Tar dimer, aspartate and MBP can bind in either the 'same' or the 'opposite' orientation, a freedom that can explain the partial additivity of the aspartate and maltose responses that is seen with tar+ cells.

HtrI is a dimer whose interface is sensitive to receptor photoactivation and His-166 replacements in sensory rhodopsin I

Single cysteine substitutions were introduced into three positions of otherwise cysteineless HtrI, a phototaxis transducer found in Halobacterium salinarum that transmits signals from the photoreceptor sensory rhodopsin I (SRI) to a cytoplasmic pathway controlling the cell's motility. Oxidative cross-linking of the monocysteine HtrI mutants in membrane suspensions resulted in dimer forms evident in SDS-polyacrylamide gels. The rate of cross-linking of I64C on the cytoplasmic side of HtrI was accelerated by SRI binding in the dark and further increased by SRI photoactivation. Several residue replacements of His-166 in SRI accelerated the cross-linking rate of I64C in the dark and His-166 mutants that exhibit "inverted signaling" (mediating repellent instead of the normally attractant response to orange light) inverted the light effect on the cross-linking rate of I64C. Secondary structure prediction of HtrI indicates a coiled coil structure in the cytoplasmic region following TM2, a dimerization domain found in a diverse group of proteins. We conclude that 1) HtrI exists as a dimer both in the absence of SRI and in the SRI-HtrI complex, 2) binding of SRI in the dark increases reactivity of the two cysteines at position 64 in the dimer by increasing their proximity or mobility, 3) light activation of wild-type SRI further increases their reactivity, 4) His-166 replacements in the SRI receptor have conformational effects on the structure of HtrI at position 64, and 5) inverted signaling by His-166 mutants likely results from an inverted conformational change at this region induced by SRI photoactivation.

A single-headed dimer of Escherichia coli ribosomal protein L7/L12 supports protein synthesis

During protein synthesis, the two elongation factors Tu and G alternately bind to the 50S ribosomal subunit at a site of which the protein L7/L12 is an essential component. L7/L12 is present in each 50S subunit in four copies organized as two dimers. Each dimer consists of distinct domains: a single N-terminal ("tail") domain that is responsible for both dimerization and binding to the ribosome via interaction with the protein L10 and two independent globular C-terminal domains ("heads") that are required for binding of elongation factors to ribosomes. The two heads are connected by flexible hinge sequences to the N-terminal domain. Important questions concerning the mechanism by which L7/L12 interacts with elongation factors are posed by us in response to the presence of two dimers, two heads per dimer, and their dynamic, mobile properties. In an attempt to answer these questions, we constructed a single-headed dimer of L7/L12 by using recombinant DNA techniques and chemical cross-linking. This chimeric molecule was added to inactive core particles lacking wild-type L7/L12 and shown to restore activity to a level approaching that of wild-type two-headed L7/L12.

Receptor-mediated protein kinase activation and the mechanism of transmembrane signaling in bacterial chemotaxis

Chemotaxis responses of Escherichia coli and Salmonella are mediated by type I membrane receptors with N-terminal extracytoplasmic sensing domains connected by transmembrane helices to C-terminal signaling domains in the cytoplasm. Receptor signaling involves regulation of an associated protein kinase, CheA. Here we show that kinase activation by a soluble signaling domain construct involves the formation of a large complex, with approximately 14 receptor signaling domains per CheA dimer. Electron microscopic examination of these active complexes indicates a well defined bundle composed of numerous receptor filaments. Our findings suggest a mechanism for transmembrane signaling whereby stimulus-induced changes in lateral packing interactions within an array of receptor-sensing domains at the cell surface perturb an equilibrium between active and inactive receptor-kinase complexes within the cytoplasm.

Transient channel-opening in bacteriorhodopsin: an EPR study

Active translocation of ions across membranes requires alternating access of the ion binding site inside the pump to the two membrane surfaces. Proton translocation by bacteriorhodopsin (bR), the light-driven proton pump in Halobacterium salinarium, involves this kind of a change in the accessibility of the centrally located retinal Schiff base. This key event in bR's photocycle ensures that proton release occurs to the extracellular side and proton uptake from the cytoplasmic side. To study the role of protein conformational changes in this reprotonation switch, spin labels were attached to pairs of engineered cysteine residues in the cytoplasmic interhelical loops of bR. Light-induced changes in the distance between a spin label on the EF interhelical loop and a label on either the AB or the CD interhelical loop were observed, and the changes were monitored following photoactivation with time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. Both distances increase transiently by about 5 A during the photocycle. This opening occurs between proton release and uptake, and may be the conformational switch that changes the accessibility of the retinal Schiff base to the cytoplasmic surface after proton release to the extracellular side.

Thermosensing properties of mutant aspartate chemoreceptors with methyl-accepting sites replaced singly or multiply by alanine

The aspartate chemoreceptor Tar has a thermosensing function that is modulated by covalent modification of its four methylation sites (Gln295, Glu302, Gln309, and Glu491). Without posttranslational deamidation, Tar has no thermosensing ability. When Gln295 and Gln309 are deamidated to Glu, the unmethylated and heavily methylated forms function as warm and cold sensors, respectively. In this study, we carried out alanine-scanning mutagenesis of the methylation sites. Although alanine substitutions influenced the signaling bias and the methylation level, all of the mutants retained aspartate-sensing function. Those with single substitutions had almost normal thermosensing properties, indicating that substitutions at any particular methylation site do not seriously impair thermosensing function. In the posttranslational modification-defective background, some of the alanine substitutions restored thermosensing ability. Warm sensors were found among mutants retaining two glutamate residues, and cold sensors were found among those with one or no glutamate residue. This result suggests that the negative charge at the methylation sites is one factor that determines thermosensor phenotypes, although the size and shape of the side chain may also be important. The warm, cold, and null thermosensor phenotypes were clearly differentiated, and no intermediate phenotypes were found. Thus, the different thermosensing phenotypes that result from covalent modification of the methylation sites may reflect distinct structural states. Broader implications for the thermosensing mechanism are also discussed.

Converting a transmembrane receptor to a soluble receptor: recognition domain to effector domain signaling after excision of the transmembrane domain

The bacterial aspartate receptor was reconstructed to eliminate the transmembrane domain, thus connecting the recognition domain directly to the effector domain. The resulting soluble receptor folded correctly and was no longer an integral membrane protein. Upon aspartate binding, this soluble receptor was stabilized to a similar extent as that of the native receptor. Of interest, this soluble receptor retained the ability to signal from the recognition to the effector domain. This result defines more clearly the role of the membrane and transmembrane domains in signal transduction and suggests that some ligand-induced motions in receptor proteins do not require the membrane or transmembrane domain for information transmission.

Apo structure of the ligand-binding domain of aspartate receptor from Escherichia coli and its comparison with ligand-bound or pseudoligand-bound structures

The aspartate receptor from E. coli is a dimeric transmembrane-signaling protein that mediates chemotaxis behavior and is the most studied system among the chemotaxis receptors to understand the molecular mechanism for transmembrane signaling. However, there is an unresolved issue for the structural event which initiates the transmembrane signal upon binding to the ligand. Biochemical and genetic evidence implies an intrasubunit mechanism (monomeric model) whereas crystallographic evidence implies an intersubunit mechanism (dimeric model). Crystallographic evidence has been ambiguous because all the apo protein structures contained a pseudoligand sulfate, and a completely ligand-free structure has not been available thus far. Here we present the crystal structure of the ligand binding domain of the aspartate receptor free of the ligand aspartate or pseudoligand sulfate. The structural comparison of this structure with those of ligand-bound and pseudoligand-bound forms revealed that, on ligand or pseudoligand binding, the conformational change in the ligand-binding domain is relatively small, but there is a considerable rotation between two subunits, supporting the dimeric model.

An aspartate/insulin receptor chimera mitogenically activates fibroblasts

A gene encoding the ligand-binding domain of the Escherichia coli aspartate receptor fused to the cytoplasmic domain of the insulin receptor tyrosine kinase to produce the chimeric aspartate insulin receptor (AIR) was expressed in mammalian cells. A murine fibroblast transfectant line designated CA3 was generated that stably expressed the AIR receptor. This 70,000 Mr receptor containing the tyrosine kinase of the insulin receptor was recognized by aspartate receptor-specific antisera. When isolated in cellular membrane preparations, AIR was found to be capable of autophosphorylation and phosphorylation of histone H2B on tyrosine. The receptor was found to be predominately cytoplasmic and to be situated in the endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi membranes by immunofluorescence imaging of CA3 cells. Mitogenic effects of AIR were observed; CA3 cells continued DNA synthesis under serum deprivation conditions that prevented parental cells from cycling. These results demonstrate that a chimeric receptor containing procaryotic transmembrane sequences is expressed by a eucaryotic cell in intracellular membranes and functionally couples to cellular signaling pathways.

Signaling by the Escherichia coli aspartate chemoreceptor Tar with a single cytoplasmic domain per dimer

Many transmembrane receptors are oligomeric proteins. Binding of a ligand may alter the oligomeric state of the receptor, induce structural changes within the oligomer, or both. The bacterial aspartate chemoreceptor Tar forms a homodimer in the presence or absence of ligands. Tar mediates attractant and repellent responses by modulating the activity of the cytoplasmic kinase CheA. In vivo intersubunit suppression was used to show that certain combinations of full-length and truncated mutant Tar proteins complemented each other to restore attractant responses to aspartate. These results suggest that heterodimers with only one intact cytoplasmic domain are functional. The signaling mechanism may require interactions between dimers or conformational changes within a single cytoplasmic domain.

Detecting the conformational change of transmembrane signaling in a bacterial chemoreceptor by measuring effects on disulfide cross-linking in vivo

Transmembrane signaling by bacterial chemoreceptors is thought to involve relative movement among the four transmembrane helices of the homodimer. We assayed that movement by measuring effects of ligand occupancy on rates of oxidative cross-linking between cysteines introduced into neighboring helices of the transmembrane domain of chemoreceptor Trg from Escherichia coli. Measurements were done on chemoreceptors in their native environment, intact cells that were motile and chemotactically responsive. Receptor occupancy did not appear to cause drastic rearrangement of the four-helix structure since, among 67 cysteine pairs tested, the same 19 exhibited oxidative cross-linking in the presence or absence of saturating chemoattractant. However, occupancy did cause subtle changes that were detected as effects on rates of cross-linking. Among the seven disulfides appropriate for measurements of initial rates of formation, ligand occupancy had significant and different effects on all three cross-links that connected the two helices within a subunit but had minimal effects on the four that spanned the packing interface between subunits. This constitutes direct evidence that the conformational change of transmembrane signaling involves significant movement within a subunit and minimal movement between subunits, a pattern deduced from several previous studies and now documented directly. Among possible modes of movement between the two helices of a subunit, axial sliding of one helix relative to the other was the conformational change that best accounted for the observed effects on cross-linking.

Mutational analysis of a transmembrane segment in a bacterial chemoreceptor

Trg is a member of a family of receptors that mediates chemotaxis by Escherichia coli. Its transmembrane domain is a loose four-helix bundle consisting of two helices from each of the two identical subunits. This domain mediates transmembrane signaling through a conformational change in which the second transmembrane segment (TM2) is thought to move relative to TM1, but mutational analysis of TM2 by cysteine scanning had identified only a few positions at which substitutions perturbed function or induced signaling. Thus, we performed mutational analysis by random mutagenesis and screening. Among 42 single-residue substitutions in TM2 that detectably altered function, 16 had drastic effects on receptor activity. These substitutions defined a helical face of TM2. This functionally important surface was directed into the protein interior of the transmembrane domain, where TM2 faces the helices or the other subunit. The functionally perturbing substitutions did not appear to cause general disruption of receptor structure but rather had more specific effects, altering aspects of transmembrane signaling. An in vivo assay of signaling identified some substitutions that reduced and others that induced signaling. These two classes were distributed along adjacent helical faces in a pattern that strongly supports the notion that conformational signaling involves movement between TM2 and TM1 and that signaling is optimal when stable interactions are maintained across the interface between the homologous helices in the transmembrane domain. Our mutational analysis also revealed a striking tolerance of the chemoreceptor for substitutions, including charged residues, usually considered to be disruptive of transmembrane segments.

A peptide derived from a beta2-adrenergic receptor transmembrane domain inhibits both receptor dimerization and activation

One of the assumptions of the mobile receptor hypothesis as it relates to G protein-coupled receptors is that the stoichiometry of receptor, G protein, and effector is 1:1:1 (Bourne, H. R., Sanders, D. A., and McCormick, F.(1990) Nature 348, 125-132). Many studies on the cooperativity of agonist binding are incompatible with this notion and have suggested that both G proteins and their associated receptors can be oligomeric. However, a clear physical demonstration that G protein-coupled receptors can indeed interact as dimers and that such interactions may have functional consequences was lacking. Here, using differential epitope tagging we demonstrate that beta2-adrenergic receptors do form SDS-resistant homodimers and that transmembrane domain VI of the receptor may represent part of an interface for receptor dimerization. The functional importance of dimerization is supported by the observation that a peptide derived from this domain that inhibits dimerization also inhibits beta-adrenergic agonist-promoted stimulation of adenylyl cyclase activity. Moreover, agonist stimulation was found to stabilize the dimeric state of the receptor, while inverse agonists favored the monomeric species, which suggests that interconversion between monomeric and dimeric forms may be important for biological activity.

Molecular mechanism of transmembrane signaling by the aspartate receptor: a model

The aspartate receptor of bacterial chemotaxis is representative of a large class of membrane-spanning receptors found in prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms. These receptors, which regulate histidine kinase pathways and possess two putative transmembrane helices per subunit, appear to control a wide variety of cellular processes. The best characterized subgroup of the two-helix receptor class is the homologous family of chemosensory receptors from Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium, including the aspartate receptor. This receptor binds aspartate, an attractant, in the periplasmic compartment and undergoes an intramolecular, transmembrane conformational change, thereby modulating the autophosphorylation rate of a bound histidine kinase in the cytoplasm. Here, we analyze recent results from x-ray crystallographic, solution 19F NMR, and engineered disulfide studies probing the aspartate-induced structural change within the periplasmic and transmembrane regions of the receptor. Together, these approaches provide evidence that aspartate binding triggers a "swinging-piston" displacement of the second membrane-spanning helix, which is proposed to communicate the signal across the bilayer.

Imitation of Escherichia coli aspartate receptor signaling in engineered dimers of the cytoplasmic domain

Transmembrane signaling by bacterial chemotaxis receptors appears to require a conformational change within a receptor dimer. Dimers were engineered of the cytoplasmic domain of the Escherichia coli aspartate receptor that stimulated the kinase CheA in vitro. The folding free energy of the leucine-zipper dimerization domain was harnessed to twist the dimer interface of the receptor, which markedly affected the extent of CheA activation. Response to this twist was attenuated by modification of receptor regulatory sites, in the same manner as adaptation resets sensitivity to ligand in vivo. These results suggest that the normal allosteric activation of the chemotaxis receptor has been mimicked in a system that lacks both ligand-binding and transmembrane domains. The most stimulatory receptor dimer formed a species of tetrameric size.

Bacterial chemotaxis: a field in motion

Many different types of studies are being combined to provide an increasingly detailed picture of the bacterial chemotaxis system. The structures of periplasmic receptors and a cytoplasmic response regulator, along with structures of domains of a membrane receptor, a receptor-modifying enzyme and a cytoplasmic histidine kinase, have been determined. These structures provide a basis for other work which is likely to open up new structural avenues.

The N-terminal cytoplasmic tail of the aspartate receptor is not essential in signal transduction of bacterial chemotaxis

To determine the role in transmembrane signaling of the N-terminal peptide of the first transmembrane region of the aspartate receptor, it was subjected to extensive mutagenesis. Drastic changes did not alter the chemotactic ability of the receptor to aspartate significantly. Thus the cytoplasmic N terminus of the first transmembrane region does not play an essential role in transmembrane signaling, and the entire signal that is transmitted to the cytoplasmic domain must be sent through the second transmembrane region. This eliminates the models requiring an interaction of this N-terminal peptide with the remaining cytoplasmic portion of the receptor.

Determination of the distance between two spin labels attached to a macromolecule

An EPR "spectroscopic ruler" was developed using a series of alpha-helical polypeptides, each modified with two nitroxide spin labels. The EPR line broadening due to electron-electron dipolar interactions in the frozen state was determined using the Fourier deconvolution method. These dipolar spectra were then used to estimate the distances between the two nitroxides separated by 8-25 A. Results agreed well with a simple alpha-helical model. The standard deviation from the model system was 0.9 A in the range of 8-25 A. This technique is applicable to complex systems such as membrane receptors and channels, which are difficult to access with high-resolution NMR or x-ray crystallography, and is expected to be particularly useful for systems for which optical methods are hampered by the presence of light-interfering membranes or chromophores.

Signal transduction in bacteria: phospho-neural network(s) in Escherichia coli?

The molecular basis of many forms of signal transfer in living organisms is provided via the transient phosphorylation of regulatory proteins by transfer of phosphoryl groups between these proteins. The dominant form of signal transduction in prokaryotic microorganisms proceeds via so-called two-component regulatory systems. These systems constitute phosphoryl transfer pathways, consisting of two or more components. Most of these pathways are linear, but some converge and some are divergent. The molecular properties of some of the well-characterised representatives of two-component systems comply with the requirements to be put upon the elements of a neural network: they function as logical operators and show the phenomenon of autoamplification. Because there are many phosphoryl transfer pathways in parallel and because there also appears to be cross-talk between these pathways, the total of all two-component regulatory systems in a single prokaryotic cell may show the typical characteristics of a 'phospho-neural network'. This may well lead to signal amplification, associative responses and memory effects, characteristics which are typical for neural networks. One of the main challenges in molecular microbial physiology is to determine the extent of the connectivity of the constituting elements of this presumed 'phospho-neural network', and to outline the extent of intelligence-like behaviour this network can generate. Escherichia coli is the organism of choice for this characterization.

Identification of functionally important helical faces in transmembrane segments by scanning mutagenesis

We applied mutational analysis to a protein domain that functions in neither catalysis nor binding but, rather, in transmembrane signaling. The domain is part of chemoreceptor Trg from Escherichia coli. It contains four transmembrane segments, two from each subunit of the homodimer. We used cysteine scanning to investigate the functional importance of each of 54 residues in the two transmembrane segments. Cysteines at some positions resulted in subtle but significant reductions in tactic response. Those positions defined a specific helical face on each segment, implying that the segments function as helices. The functionally important faces corresponded to structural, helical packing faces identified independently by biochemical studies. All functionally impaired receptors exhibited altered signaling properties, either reduced signaling upon stimulation or induced signaling in the absence of stimulation. The distribution of substitutions creating these two phenotypes implied that conformational signaling involves movement between the two transmembrane helices within a subunit and that signaling is optimal when stable interactions are maintained across the interface between subunits.

Transmembrane signaling characterized in bacterial chemoreceptors by using sulfhydryl cross-linking in vivo

Transmembrane signaling by bacterial chemoreceptors is thought to involve conformational changes within a stable homodimer. We investigated the functional consequences of constraining movement between pairs of helices in the four-helix structure of the transmembrane domain of chemoreceptor Trg. Using a family of cysteine-containing receptors, we identified oxidation treatments for intact cells that catalyzed essentially complete sulfhydryl cross-linking at selected positions and yet left flagellar and sensory functions largely unperturbed. Constraining movement by cross-links between subunits had little effect on tactic response, but constraining movement between transmembrane segments of the monomer drastically reduced function. We deduce that transmembrane signaling requires substantial movement between transmembrane helices of a monomer but not between interacting helices across the interface between subunits.

Transmembrane signalling and the aspartate receptor

BACKGROUND

The aspartate receptor is a transmembrane protein that mediates bacterial chemotaxis. The structures of the periplasmic ligand-binding domain reveal a dimer, each subunit with four alpha-helix bundles, with aspartate binding to one of two sites at the subunit interface. The transmembrane regions of the receptor were not included in these structures.

RESULTS

To investigate the structure of the transmembrane region, we have made a mutant protein with two cross-links, restraining the subunit-subunit interface on both sides of the membrane, and have made an energy-minimized model of the transmembrane region. We demonstrate that the transmembrane helices form a coiled coil which extends from the periplasmic subunit through the membrane. We have constructed a model of the ligand-binding domains with the amino-terminal transmembrane helices.

CONCLUSIONS

We draw three conclusions from our model. Firstly, the interface between receptor subunits in the intact receptor consists of an uninterrupted coiled coil. Secondly, this structure rules out several postulated mechanisms of signalling. Thirdly, side chain packing constraints within the helices dictate that local structural changes must be small, but are propagated over a long distance rather than being dissipated locally. Low energy changes in the conformation of side chains are a probable mechanism of signal transduction in the aspartate receptor.

Mutational activation of CheA, the protein kinase in the chemotaxis system of Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium, appropriate changes of cell swimming patterns are mediated by CheA, an autophosphorylating histidine protein kinase whose activity is regulated by receptor/transducer proteins. The molecular mechanism underlying this regulation remains unelucidated but may involve CheA shifting between high-activity and low-activity conformations. We devised an in vivo screen to search for potential hyperkinase variants of CheA and used this screen to identify two cheA point mutations that cause the CheA protein to have elevated autokinase activity. Each point mutation resulted in alteration of proline 337. In vitro, CheA337PL and CheA337PS autophosphorylated significantly more rapidly than did wild-type CheA. This rate enhancement reflected the higher affinities of the mutant proteins for ATP and an increased rate constant for acquisition by CheA of the gamma-phosphoryl group of ATP within a kinetically defined CheA.ATP complex. In addition, the mutant proteins reacted with ADP more rapidly than did wild-type CheA. We considered the possibility that the mutations served to lock CheA into an activated signaling conformation; however, we found that both mutant proteins were regulated in a normal fashion by the transducer Tsr in the presence of CheW. We exploited the activated properties of one of these mutants to investigate whether the CheA subunits within a CheA dimer make equivalent contributions to the mechanism of trans phosphorylation. Our results indicate that CheA trans phosphorylation may involve active-site residues that are located both in cis and in trans to the autophosphorylation site and that the two protomers of a CheA dimer make nonequivalent contributions in determining the affinity of the ATP-binding site(s) of CheA.

A single carboxy-terminal arginine determines the amino-terminal helix conformation of an alanine-based peptide

Arginine is a stabilizing element in both thermophilic and low molecular weight proteins. Similarly Lys+-->Arg+ substitutions increase the helix content of designed helical peptides. Here we explore this 'arginine effect' by examining how Lys+-->Arg+ substitutions influence the 3(10)-helix-->alpha-helix equilibrium in the helical peptide Ac-(AAAAK)3A-NH2. The unsubstituted sequence contains a significant amount of 3(10)-helix, however, single Lys+-->Arg+ substitutions shift the peptide conformation toward alpha-helix in a position-dependent fashion. The single substitution closest to the carboxy terminus induces the largest conformational change at the helix amino terminus. These findings suggest that a single strategically-placed arginine can exert long range control on helix structure.

Attractant- and disulfide-induced conformational changes in the ligand binding domain of the chemotaxis aspartate receptor: a 19F NMR study

The isolated ligand binding domain of the chemotaxis aspartate receptor is the focus of the present study, which both (a) identifies structural regions involved in the attractant-induced conformational change and (b) investigates the kinetic parameters of attractant binding. To analyze the attractant-induced conformational change within the homodimeric domain, 19F NMR is used to monitor six para-fluorophenylalanine (4-F-Phe) positions within each identical subunit of the homodimer. The binding one molecule of aspartate to the homodimer perturbs three of the 4-F-Phe resonances significantly: 4-F-Phe150 in the attractant binding site, 4-F-Phe107 located 26 A from the site, and 4-F-Phe180 at a distance of 40 A from the site. Comparison of the frequency shifts triggered by aspartate and glutamate reveals that these attractants generate different conformations in the vicinity of the attractant site but trigger indistinguishable long-range conformational effects at distant positions. This long-range conformational change is specific for attractant binding, since formation of the Cys36-Cys36' disulfide bond or the nonphysiological binding of 1,10-phenanthroline to an aromatic pocket distal to the attractant site each yield conformational changes which are significantly more localized. The attractant-triggered perturbations detected at 4-F-Phe107 and 4-F-Phe180 indicate that the structural change includes an intrasubunit component communicated through the domain to its C-terminal region, which, in the full-length receptor, continues through the membrane as the second membrane-spanning helix. It would thus appear that the transmembrane signal is transmitted through this helix.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

A collision gradient method to determine the immersion depth of nitroxides in lipid bilayers: application to spin-labeled mutants of bacteriorhodopsin

Ten mutants of bacteriorhodopsin, each containing a single cysteine residue regularly spaced along helix D and facing the lipid bilayer, were derivatized with a nitroxide spin label. Collision rates of the nitroxide with apolar oxygen increased with distance from the membrane/solution interface. Collision rates with polar metal ion complexes decreased over the same distance. Although the collision rates depend on steric constraints imposed by the local protein structure and on the depth in the membrane, the ratio of the collision rate of oxygen to those of a polar metal ion complex is independent of structural features of the protein. The logarithm of the ratio is a linear function of depth within the membrane. Calibration of this ratio parameter with spin-labeled phospholipids allows localization of the individual nitroxides, and hence the bacteriorhodopsin molecule, relative to the plane of the phosphate groups of the bilayer. The spacing between residues is consistent with the pitch of an alpha-helix. These results provide a general strategy for determining the immersion depth of nitroxides in bilayers.

"Frozen" dynamic dimer model for transmembrane signaling in bacterial chemotaxis receptors

The crystal structures of the ligand binding domain of a bacterial aspartate receptor suggest a simple mechanism for transmembrane signaling by the dimer of the receptor. On ligand binding, one domain rotates with respect to the other, and this rotational motion is proposed to be transmitted through the membrane to the cytoplasmic domains of the receptor.

Preformed dimeric state of the sensor protein VirA is involved in plant--Agrobacterium signal transduction

Plant signal molecules such as acetosyringone and certain monosaccharides induce the expression of Agrobacterium tumefaciens virulence (vir) genes, which are required for the processing, transfer, and possibly integration of a piece of the bacterial plasmid DNA (T-DNA) into the plant genome. Two fo the vir genes, virA and virG, belonging to the bacterial two-component regulatory system family, control the induction of vir genes by plant signals. virA encodes a membrane-bound sensor kinase protein and virG encodes a cytoplasmic regulator protein. Although it is well established from in vitro studies that the signal transduction process involves VirA autophosphorylation and subsequent phosphate transfer to VirG, the structural state of the VirA protein involved in signal transduction is not understood. In this communication, we describe an in vivo crosslinking approach which provides physical evidence that VirA exists as a homodimer in its native configuration. The dimerization of VirA neither requires nor is stimulated by the plant signal molecule acetosyringone. We also present genetic data which support the hypothesis that VirA exists as a homodimer which is the functional state transducing the plant signal in an intersubunit mechanism. To our knowledge, this report provides the first evidence that a bacterial membrane-bound sensor kinase exists and functions as a homodimer in vivo.

Polar location of the chemoreceptor complex in the Escherichia coli cell

The eukaryotic cell exhibits compartmentalization of functions to various membrane-bound organelles and to specific domains within each membrane. The spatial distribution of the membrane chemoreceptors and associated cytoplasmic chemotaxis proteins in Escherichia coli were examined as a prototypic functional aggregate in bacterial cells. Bacterial chemotaxis involves a phospho-relay system brought about by ligand association with a membrane receptor, culminating in a switch in the direction of flagellar rotation. The transduction of the chemotaxis signal is initiated by a chemoreceptor-CheW-CheA ternary complex at the inner membrane. These ternary complexes aggregate predominantly at the cell poles. Polar localization of the cytoplasmic CheA and CheW proteins is dependent on membrane-bound chemoreceptor. Chemoreceptors are not confined to the cell poles in strains lacking both CheA and CheW. The chemoreceptor-CheW binary complex is polarly localized in the absence of CheA, whereas the chemoreceptor-CheA binary complex is not confined to the cell poles in strains lacking CheW. The subcellular localization of the chemotaxis proteins may reflect a general mechanism by which the bacterial cell sequesters different regions of the cell for specialized functions.

Strategies in pathogenesis: mechanistic specificity in the detection of generic signals

The virulence genes of the plant pathogen Agrobacterium tumefaciens are induced by more than 40 low-molecular-weight phenolic compounds. The prevailing opinion is that (i) wound-derived phenols produced on breach of the integrity of the cell wall act as the initiating signal in a series of events which results in host cell transformation, and (ii) a classical membrane receptor, putatively VirA, is responsible for the recognition of all such phenolic inducers. Here, we argue that the discovery of the subset of inducers that are relatives of the dehydrodiconiferyl alcohol glucoside (DCG) growth factors redirects our attention to work on the plant wound as a site of cell division, and suggests that we further explore the implications of early work on the relationship between transformation efficiency and the status of the cell cycle of the host. In addition, we argue that the significant structural diversity allowed in the para position of the phenol ring of inducers suggests that a receptor-ligand interaction based solely on structural recognition is insufficient, but that recognition followed by a specific proton transfer event may be sufficient to explain vir induction activity. Hence, the specificity of the response of A. tumefaciens may be a consequence of the features required for a chemical reaction to occur on the receptor surface. Finally, we review affinity labelling studies which exploit this phenol detection mechanism and which provide evidence that the phenol receptor may be other than VirA, the sensory kinase of the two component regulatory system implicated in Agrobacterium virulence.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)