Instability of rRNA operons in Bacillus subtilis

Does Intraspecific Variation in rDNA Copy Number Affect Analysis of Microbial Communities?

Amplicon sequencing of partial regions of the ribosomal RNA loci (rDNA) is widely used to profile microbial communities. However, the rDNA is dynamic and can exhibit substantial interspecific and intraspecific variation in copy number in prokaryotes and, especially, in microbial eukaryotes. As change in rDNA copy number is a common response to environmental change, rDNA copy number is not necessarily a property of a species. Variation in rDNA copy number, especially the capacity for large intraspecific changes driven by external cues, complicates analyses of rDNA amplicon sequence data. We highlight the need to (i) interpret amplicon sequence data in light of possible interspecific and intraspecific variation, and (ii) examine the potential plasticity in rDNA copy number as an important ecological factor to better understand how microbial communities are structured in heterogeneous environments.

rRNA (rrn) operon-engineered Bacillus subtilis as a feasible test organism for antibiotic discovery

Bacillus subtilis contains 10 rRNA (rrn) operons. We found that rRNA operon-engineered B. subtilis strain RIK543, with only the rrnO operon, is specifically hypersensitive to RNA polymerase inhibitors such as rifamycin SV and rifampin (80-fold and 20-fold, respectively). In pilot screening experiments, we found actinomycete isolates successfully at an incidence of 1.9% (18/945) that produced antibacterials that were detectable only with RIK543 as the test organism. Strain RIK543 may be a feasible test organism for the discovery of novel RNA polymerase inhibitors.

The genome sequence of Bacillus subtilis subsp. spizizenii W23: insights into speciation within the B. subtilis complex and into the history of B. subtilis genetics

The genome sequence of Bacillus subtilis subsp. spizizenii W23 has been determined. The sequence strongly suggests that W23 is a direct descendant of B. subtilis ATCC 6633. W23 shares a 3.6 Mb core genome with the intensively studied model organism B. subtilis subsp. subtilis 168, and gene order within this core has been strongly conserved. Additionally, the W23 genome has 157 accessory (that is, non-core) genome segments that are not found in 168, while the 168 genome has 141 segments not found in W23. The distribution of sequences similar to these accessory segments among other genomes of the B. subtilis species complex shows that those sequences having entered into the phylogeny of the complex more recently tend to be larger and more AT-rich than those having entered earlier. A simple model can account for these observations, in which parasitic or symbiotic DNAs are transferred into the genome and then are reduced in size and modified in base composition during speciation.

Rapid changes in gene expression: DNA determinants of promoter regulation by the concentration of the transcription initiating NTP in Bacillus subtilis

In bacteria, rapid changes in gene expression can be achieved by affecting the activity of RNA polymerase with small molecule effectors during transcription initiation. An important small molecule effector is the initiating nucleoside triphosphate (iNTP). At some promoters, an increasing iNTP concentration stimulates promoter activity, while a decreasing concentration has the opposite effect. Ribosomal RNA (rRNA) promoters from Gram-positive Bacillus subtilis are regulated by the concentration of their iNTP. Yet, the sequences of these promoters do not emulate the sequence characteristics of [iNTP]-regulated rRNA promoters of Gram-negative Escherichia coli. Here, we identified the 3′-promoter region, corresponding to the transcription bubble, as key for B. subtilis rRNA promoter regulation via the concentration of the iNTP. Within this region, the conserved −5T (3 bp downstream from the −10 hexamer) is required for this regulation. Moreover, we identified a second class of [iNTP]-regulated promoters in B. subtilis where the sequence determinants are not limited to the transcription bubble region. Overall, it seems that various sequence combinations can result in promoter regulation by [iNTP] in B. subtilis. Finally, this study demonstrates how the same type of regulation can be achieved with strikingly different promoter sequences in phylogenetically distant species.

Differential responses of Bacillus subtilis rRNA promoters to nutritional stress

The in vivo expression levels of four rRNA promoter pairs (rrnp(1)p(2)) of Bacillus subtilis were determined by employing single-copy lacZ fusions integrated at the amyE locus. The rrnO, rrnJ, rrnD, and rrnB promoters displayed unique growth rate regulation and stringent responses. Both lacZ activity and mRNA levels were highest for rrnO under all growth conditions tested, while rrnJ, rrnB, and rrnD showed decreasing levels of activity. During amino acid starvation induced by serine hydroxamate (SHX), only the strong rrnO and rrnJ promoters demonstrated stringent responses. Under the growth conditions used, the rrn promoters showed responses similar to the responses to carbon source limitation induced by α-methyl glucoside (α-MG). The ratio of P2 to P1 transcripts, determined by primer extension analysis, was high for the strong rrnO and rrnJ promoters, while only P2 transcripts were detected for the weak rrnD and rrnB promoters. Cloned P1 or P2 promoter fragments of rrnO or rrnJ were differentially regulated. In wild-type (relA(+)) and suppressor [relA(S)] strains under the conditions tested, only P2 responded to carbon source limitation by a decrease in RNA synthesis, correlating with an increase in (p)ppGpp levels and a decrease in the GTP concentration. The weak P1 promoter elements remain relaxed in the three genetic backgrounds [relA(+), relA, relA(S)] in the presence of α-MG. During amino acid starvation, P2 was stringently regulated in relA(+) and relA(S) cells, while only rrnJp(1) was also regulated, but to a lesser extent. Both the relA(+) and relA(S) strains showed (p)ppGpp accumulation after α-MG treatment but not after SHX treatment. These data reveal the complex nature of B. subtilis rrn promoter regulation in response to stress, and they suggest that the P2 promoters may play a more prominent role in the stringent response.

Bacillus subtilis mutants harbouring a single copy of the rRNA operon exhibit severe defects in growth and sporulation

The number of copies of rRNA genes in bacterial genomes differs greatly among bacterial species. It is difficult to determine the functional significance of the heterogeneity of each rRNA operon fully due to the existence of multiple rRNA operons and because the sequence heterogeneity among the rRNA genes is extremely low. To overcome this problem, we sequentially deleted the ten rrn operons of Bacillus subtilis and constructed seven mutant strains that each harboured a single rrn operon (either rrnA, B, D, E, I, J or O) in their genome. The growth rates and sporulation frequencies of these mutants were reduced drastically compared with those of the wild-type strain, and this was probably due to decreased levels of ribosomes in the mutants. Interestingly, the ability to sporulate varied significantly among the mutant strains. These mutants have proved to be invaluable in our initial attempts to reveal the functional significance of the heterogeneity of each rRNA operon.

Transcription activity of individual rrn operons in Bacillus subtilis mutants deficient in (p)ppGpp synthetase genes, relA, yjbM, and ywaC

In Bacillus subtilis a null mutation of the relA gene, whose gene product is involved in the synthesis and/or hydrolysis of (p)ppGpp, causes a growth defect that can be suppressed by mutation(s) of yjbM and/or ywaC coding for small (p)ppGpp synthetases. All 35 suppressor mutations newly isolated were classified into two groups, either yjbM or ywaC, by mapping and sequencing their mutations, suggesting that there are no (p)ppGpp synthetases other than RelA, YjbM, and YwaC in B. subtilis. In order to understand better the relation between RelA and rRNA synthesis, we studied in the relA mutant the transcriptional regulation of seven rRNA operons (rrnO, -A, -J, -I, -E, -D, or -B) individually after integration of a promoter- and terminatorless cat gene. We identified the transcriptional start sites of each rrn operon (a G) and found that transcription of all rrn operons from their P1 promoters was drastically reduced in the relA mutant while this was almost completely restored in the relA yjbM ywaC triple mutant. Taken together with previous results showing that the intracellular GTP concentration was reduced in the relA mutant while it was restored in the triple mutant, it seems likely that continuous (p)ppGpp synthesis by YjbM and/or YwaC at a basal level causes a decrease in the amounts of intracellular GTP.

The origins of 168, W23, and other Bacillus subtilis legacy strains

Bacillus subtilis is both a model organism for basic research and an industrial workhorse, yet there are major gaps in our understanding of the genomic heritage and provenance of many widely used strains. We analyzed 17 legacy strains dating to the early years of B. subtilis genetics. For three--NCIB 3610T, PY79, and SMY--we performed comparative genome sequencing. For the remainder, we used conventional sequencing to sample genomic regions expected to show sequence heterogeneity. Sequence comparisons showed that 168, its siblings (122, 160, and 166), and the type strains NCIB 3610 and ATCC 6051 are highly similar and are likely descendants of the original Marburg strain, although the 168 lineage shows genetic evidence of early domestication. Strains 23, W23, and W23SR are identical in sequence to each other but only 94.6% identical to the Marburg group in the sequenced regions. Strain 23, the probable W23 parent, likely arose from a contaminant in the mutagenesis experiments that produced 168. The remaining strains are all genomic hybrids, showing one or more "W23 islands" in a 168 genomic backbone. Each traces its origin to transformations of 168 derivatives with DNA from 23 or W23. The common prototrophic lab strain PY79 possesses substantial W23 islands at its trp and sac loci, along with large deletions that have reduced its genome 4.3%. SMY, reputed to be the parent of 168, is actually a 168-W23 hybrid that likely shares a recent ancestor with PY79. These data provide greater insight into the genomic history of these B. subtilis legacy strains.

Development of a rapid detection and enumeration method for thermophilic bacilli in milk powders

Thermophilic strains of Geobacillus, Anoxybacillus and Bacillus that are able to grow at 55 degrees C and above are recognized as commonly occurring contaminants during the production of milk powders. In particular, Anoxybacillus flavithermus strain C and Bacillus licheniformis strain F are often the most prevalent. We describe here the development of a TaqMan-based real-time-PCR assay using a small amplicon of the ribosomal 16S rRNA gene for the selective and quantitative detection of thermophilic bacilli in milk powders. We further present an effective, rapid and inexpensive method for the isolation of total bacterial DNA from milk powder for quantitative PCR analysis within 20 min. With this method, the detection of thermophilic bacilli in milk powder can be accomplished within 1 h. The detection limit for reconstituted and inoculated milk was 8 vegetative cfu ml(-1) and 64 spores ml(-1), respectively.

Chromosome mapping in lactic acid bacteria

The chromosome structure of lactic acid bacteria has been investigated only recently. The development of pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) combined with other DNA-based techniques enables whole-genome analysis of any bacterium, and has allowed rapid progress to be made in the knowledge of the lactic acid bacteria genome. Lactic acid bacteria possess one of the smallest eubacterial chromosomes. Depending on the species, the genome sizes range from 1.1 to 2.6 Mb. Combined physical and genetic maps of several species are already available or close to being achieved. Knowledge of the genomic structure of these organisms will serve as a basis for future genetic studies. Macrorestriction fingerprinting by PFGE is already one of the major tools for strain differentiation, identification of individual strains, and the detection of strain lineages. The genome data resulting from these studies will be of general application strain improvement.

Atypical 16S rRNA gene copies in Ochrobactrum intermedium strains reveal a large genomic rearrangement by recombination between rrn copies

Ochrobactrum intermedium is an opportunistic human pathogen belonging to the alpha 2 subgroup of proteobacteria. The 16S rDNA sequences of nine O. intermedium isolates from a collection of clinical and environmental isolates exhibited a 46-bp insertion at position 187, which was present in only one sequence among the 82 complete or partial 16S rDNA sequences of Ochrobactrum spp. available in data banks. Reverse transcription-PCR experiments showed that the 46-bp insertion remained in the 16S rRNA. The inserted sequence folded into a stem-loop structure, which took place in and prolonged helix H184 of the 16S rRNA molecule. Helix H184 has been described as conserved in length among eubacteria, suggesting the idiosyncratic character of the 46-bp insertion. Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis experiments showed that seven of the clinical isolates carrying the 46-bp insertion belonged to the same clone. Insertion and rrn copy numbers were determined by hybridization and I-CeuI digestion. In the set of clonal isolates, the loss of two insertion copies revealed the deletion of a large genomic fragment of 150 kb, which included one rrn copy; deletion occurred during the in vivo evolution of the clone. Determination of the rrn skeleton suggested that the large genomic rearrangement occurred during events involving homologous recombination between rrn copies. The loss of insertion copies suggested a phenomenon of concerted evolution among heterogeneous rrn copies.

Localization of rRNA synthesis in Bacillus subtilis: characterization of loci involved in transcription focus formation

In Bacillus subtilis, RNA polymerase becomes concentrated into regions of the nucleoid called transcription foci. With green fluorescent protein-tagged RNA polymerase, these structures are only observed at higher growth rates and have been shown to represent the sites of rRNA synthesis. There are 10 rRNA (rrn) operons distributed around nearly half of the chromosome. In this study we analyzed the rrn composition of transcription foci with fluorescently tagged loci and showed that they comprise the origin-proximal operon rrnO but not the more dispersed rrnE or rrnD. This suggests that transcription foci comprise only the seven origin-proximal operons rrnO, rrnA, rrnJ, rrnW, rrnI, rrnH, and rrnG. These results have important implications for our understanding of microbial chromosome structure.

Variation in rRNA operon number as revealed by ribotyping of Bacillus anthracis strains

Ribotyping of various Bacillus strains with one restriction enzyme (AccI) revealed significant similarity between Bacillus anthracis strains, Bacillus thuringiensis and Bacillus cereus strains, which are all members of the Bacillus cereus group. A further ribotyping study of 10 virulent and 8 attenuated B. anthracis strains, using 4 endonucleases and both 23S and 16S probes independently, was performed. The discrimination index D of Hunter and Gaston showed that the best combination for future large-scale ribotyping studies would be either the combination of AccI and 23S, or that of EcoRI and 16S. Depending on the B. anthracis strain analyzed 10 or 11 rRNA operons were found. In all cases, many strains were grouped into 2 to 3 patterns. Attenuated strains, including a laboratory-cured strain, yielded aberrant patterns.

Variation in 16S-23S rRNA intergenic spacer regions among Bacillus subtilis 168 isolates

The genome of the Bacillus subtilis 168-type strain contains 10 ribosomal RNA (rRNA) operons. In the intergenic spacer region (ISR) between the 16S and 23S rRNA genes, five rRNA operons, rrnI-H-G and rrnJ-W, lack a trinucleotide signature region. Precise determination of molecular weight (MW), using electrospray mass spectrometry (MS), of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products from a segment of the ISR from the 168-type strain and B. subtilis 168-like strain 23071 demonstrated 114 and 111 basepair (bp) PCR products (due to the presence or absence of the insert in the operons) as predicted from sequence. However, PCR of the ISR segment for five other B. subtilis 168 isolates generated only a 114 bp PCR product, suggesting the presence of the trinucleotide signature region in all rRNA operons for these strains. Additional genetic variability between the seven B. subtilis 168 isolates was demonstrated by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) of the rRNA operons, with three distinct patterns found upon Southern blot analysis. The 168-type strain and three others (23066, 23067, and 23071) exhibited the same Southern pattern. Thus, operon deletion is not responsible for the absence of a 111 bp product on MS analysis for strains 23066 and 23067. Restriction analysis confirmed the presence of the trinucleotide signature region in the ISR of all rRNA operons for five B. subtilis 168 isolates; sequencing of rrnW/H from a representative strain also upheld this finding. These results help provide a better understanding of variations in sequence, operon number and chromosomal organization, both within a genome and among isolates of B. subtilis subgroup 168. It is also hypothesized that the presence of the trinucleotide insert in certain rRNA operons may play a role in rRNA maturation and protein synthesis.

A Brevibacterium lactofermentum 16S rRNA gene used as target site for homologous recombination

Genes for rRNA are highly conserved and present in multiple copies in most prokaryotic organisms increasing the number of theoretical sites for homologous recombination. They might be targets for integration events between unrelated microorganisms providing that an efficient genetic transfer is present. We have used a plasmid containing a portion of the 16S rRNA gene from the rrnD operon of Brevibacterium lactofermentum to transform the same strain resulting in non-essential inactivation of various rrn operons. Integration of the transforming DNA occurs in all cases. The system may be used to test possible gene transfer at least among closely related strains and is of great interest for integration of foreign DNA and for mapping.

Correlation of 16S ribosomal DNA signature sequences with temperature-dependent growth rates of mesophilic and psychrotolerant strains of the Bacillus cereus group

Sequences of the 16S ribosomal DNA (rDNA) from psychrotolerant and mesophilic strains of the Bacillus cereus group revealed signatures which were specific for these two thermal groups of bacteria. Further analysis of the genomic DNA from a wide range of food and soil isolates showed that B. cereus group strains have between 6 and 10 copies of 16S rDNA. Moreover, a number of these environmental strains have both rDNA operons with psychrotolerant signatures and rDNA operons with mesophilic signatures. The ability of these isolates to grow at low temperatures correlates with the prevalence of rDNA operons with psychrotolerant signatures, indicating specific nucleotides within the 16S rRNA to play a role in psychrotolerance.

IS6110-mediated deletions of wild-type chromosomes of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

The ipl locus is a site for the preferential insertion of IS6110 and has been identified as an insertion sequence, IS1547, in its own right. Various deletions around the ipl locus of clinical isolates of Mycobacterium tuberculosis were identified, and these deletions ranged in length from several hundred base pairs up to several kilobase pairs. The most obvious feature shared by these deletions was the presence of an IS6110 copy at the deletion sites, which suggested two possible mechanisms for their occurrence, IS6110 transposition and homologous recombination. To clarify the mechanism, an investigation was conducted; the results suggest that although deletion transpositionally mediated by IS6110 was a possibility, homologous recombination was a more likely one. The implications of such chromosomal rearrangements for the evolution of M. tuberculosis, for IS6110-mediated mutagenesis, and for the development of genetic tools are discussed. The deletion of genomic DNA in isolates of M. tuberculosis has previously been noted at only a few sites. This study examined the deletional loss of genetic material at a new site and suggests that such losses may occur elsewhere too and may be more prevalent than was previously thought. Distinct from the study of laboratory-induced mutations, the detailed analysis of clinical isolates, in combination with knowledge of their evolutionary relationships to each other, gives us the opportunity to study mutational diversity in isolates that have survived in the human host and therefore offers a different perspective on the importance of particular genetic markers in pathogenesis.

Recombination between rRNA operons created most of the ribotype variation observed in the seventh pandemic clone of Vibrio cholerae

Individual rrn operons and their flanking regions have been analysed in a study of the molecular basis of ribotype variation in the seventh pandemic clone of Vibrio cholerae. The genome of an early isolate of the seventh pandemic clone had nine rrn operons of which two were in tandem with other rrn operons. The site for BglI, the most discriminatory enzyme used for ribotyping, was found to be present in the 16S sequence of three of the operons of the earliest isolate. This site was observed to be gained or lost in specific operons in many later isolates, presumably by recombination, and this gave most of the ribotype variation. Additional rrn recombination events were uncovered by analysis of the 16S-23S intergenic spacers associated with each operon. Spacers of 431, 509, 607 and 711 bp were found. A total of at least eight rrn recombination events were detected. Three rrn loci were primarily involved in this recombination, with four new forms generated from that in the early strains for operon B and two new forms each for operons C and G. In addition there was variation due to deletion of tandem operons. The frequency of recombination between rrn operons was very high as there were nine new ribotypes found among 47 isolates sampled over the 33 year period of study. This means that any variation could undergo precise reversion by the same recombination event within the time frame covered by the study. Recombination between rrn operons may be a factor in ribotype variation in all systems. The recombination observed is thought to be that which results in concerted evolution and the data give an indication of the rate involved.

Classification and genetic characterization of pattern-forming Bacilli

One of the more natural but less commonly studied forms of colonial bacterial growth is pattern formation. This type of growth is characterized by bacterial populations behaving in an organized manner to generate readily identifiable geometric and predictable morphologies on solid and semi-solid surfaces. In our first attempt to study the molecular basis of pattern formation in Bacillus subtilis, we stumbled upon an enigma: some strains used to describe pattern formation in B. subtilis did not have the phenotypic or genotypic characteristics of B. subtilis. In this report, we show that these strains are actually not B. subtilis, but belong to a different class of Bacilli, group I. We show further that commonly used laboratory strains of B. subtilis can co-exist as mixed cultures with group I Bacilli, and that the latter go unnoticed when grown on frequently used laboratory substrates. However, when B. subtilis is grown under more stringent semiarid conditions, members of group I emerge in the form of complex patterns. When B. subtilis is grown under less stringent and more motile conditions, B. subtilis forms its own pattern, and members of group I remain unnoticed. These findings have led us to revise some of the mechanistic and evolutionary hypotheses that have been proposed to explain pattern growth in Bacilli.

Expression of small RNAs by Bacillus sp. strain PS3 and B. subtilis cells during sporulation

A small RNA sequence identified in an rRNA-tRNA cluster from the thermophilic Bacillus sp. strain PS3 was examined. An oligonucleotide probe specific for the RNA bound to multiple restriction fragments in Bacillus sp. strain PS3 DNA, thus several copies of this sequence occur in its genome. Similar findings were observed using DNA from B. subtilis, B. stearothermophilus, Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus aureus, Haemophilus influenzae and Thermus thermophilus. This sequence apparently is widespread in the eubacteria. Northern analysis of RNA from sporulating Bacillus sp. strain PS3 and B. subtilis cells revealed RNA species homologous to the probe in both bacteria. Expression of the small RNA in B. subtilis depended on sigma H.

Sequence heterogeneities of genes encoding 16S rRNAs in Paenibacillus polymyxa detected by temperature gradient gel electrophoresis

Sequence heterogeneities in 16S rRNA genes from individual strains of Paenibacillus polymyxa were detected by sequence-dependent separation of PCR products by temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE). A fragment of the 16S rRNA genes, comprising variable regions V6 to V8, was used as a target sequence for amplifications. PCR products from P. polymyxa (type strain) emerged as a well-defined pattern of bands in the gradient gel. Six plasmids with different inserts, individually demonstrating the migration characteristics of single bands of the pattern, were obtained by cloning the PCR products. Their sequences were analyzed as a representative sample of the total heterogeneity. An amount of 10 variant nucleotide positions in the fragment of 347 bp was observed, with all substitutions conserving the relevant secondary structures of the V6 and V8 regions in the RNA molecules. Hybridizations with specifically designed probes demonstrated different chromosomal locations of the respective rRNA genes. Amplifications of reverse-transcribed rRNA from ribosome preparations, as well as whole-cell hybridizations, revealed a predominant representation of particular sequences in ribosomes of exponentially growing laboratory cultures. Different strains of P. polymyxa showed not only remarkably differing patterns of PCR products in TGGE analysis but also discriminative whole-cell labeling with the designed oligonucleotide probes, indicating the different representation of individual sequences in active ribosomes. Our results demonstrate the usefulness of TGGE for the structural analysis of heterogeneous rRNA genes together with their expression, stress problems of the generation of meaningful data for 16S rRNA sequences and probe designs, and might have consequences for evolutionary concepts.

Mapping of 61 genes on the refined physical map of the chromosome of Thermus thermophilus HB27 and comparison of genome organization with that of T. thermophilus HB8

We have constructed refined physical maps of the chromosome (1 center dot 82 Mb) and the large plasmid pTT27 (250 kb) of Thermus thermophilus HB27. A total of 49 cleavage sites with five restriction enzymes, EcoRI, SspI, MunI, EcoRV and ClaI, were determined on the maps. The location of 61 genes was determined by using as probes 64 genes cloned from T. thermophilus or other Thermus strains. Comparison of the genomic organization of the chromosomes of T. thermophilus HB27 and HB8 revealed that they were basically identical, but some genes were located in different regions. Among 32 genes whose locations were determined on both the HB27 and the HB8 chromosomes, the copy number of rpsL-rpsG-fus-tufA, the locations of glyS, pol, and one copy of nusG-rplK-rplA were different. The IS1000 sequence was located only in one region on the HB27 chromosome. In contrast, IS1000 sequences were scattered over four regions on the chromosome of HB8. As each region in which glyS, pol, or one copy of nusG-rplK-rplA are present also contained IS1000 in HB8, it is suggested that IS1000 may play an important role in genomic rearrangements in Thermus strains.

I-CeuI recognition sites in the rrn operons of the Bacillus subtilis 168 chromosome: inherent landmarks for genome analysis

The Bacillus subtilis 168 circular chromosome yielded ten fragments on I-CeuI endonuclease digestion. I-CeuI recognizes a 26 bp sequence that is located within the gene encoding the 23S subunit of the rRNA in Chlamydomonas eugametos, Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium. The precise locations of the I-CeuI sites of the B. subtilis chromosome were determined on a NotI-SfiI physical map by (i) double digestion analyses with I-CeuI and SfiI, (ii) comparison of mutant strains lacking a specific rrn operon, (iii) using an I-CeuI linking clone and (iv) analysis of nucleotide sequence data of some rrn operons. In conclusion, all the I-CeuI sites were located within the B. subtilis rrn operons and the I-CeuI sites were conserved in all the B. subtilis 168 derivatives tested. Thus, variations in size of the I-CeuI fragments must be due to genome alterations. A B. subtilis 168 strain was investigated with I-CeuI. We demonstrated that the aberrant structure was the outcome of the inversion of an approximately 1700 kb DNA segment.

Effect of genome size and rrn gene copy number on PCR amplification of 16S rRNA genes from a mixture of bacterial species

In order to assess the effect of genome size and number of 16S rRNA genes (rDNAs) on the quantities of PCR-generated partial 16S rDNA fragments, equimolar amounts of DNA from pairs of different species for which these parameters are known were subjected to gene amplification. The experimentally determined ratio of PCR products obtained, as determined by image analysis of SYBR-Green I-stained amplification products, corresponded well with the predicted ratio calculated from the number of rrn genes per equimolar amounts of DNA in mixtures of Escherichia coli and "Thermus thermophilus" and of Pseudomonas aeruginosa and "T. thermophilus." The values for the pair of Bacillus subtilis and "T. thermophilus" showed greater deviations from the predicted value. The dependence of the amount of 16S rDNA amplification product on these two parameters makes it impossible to quantify the number of species represented in 16S rDNA clone libraries of environmental samples as long as these two parameters are unknown for the species present.

rRNA operon multiplicity in Escherichia coli and the physiological implications of rrn inactivation

Here we present evidence that only five of the seven rRNA operons present in Escherichia coli are necessary to support near-optimal growth on complex media. Seven rrn operons are necessary, however, for rapid adaptation to nutrient and temperature changes, suggesting it is the ability to adapt quickly to changing environmental conditions that has provided the selective pressure for the persistence of seven rrn operons in E. coli. We have also found that one consequence of rrn operon inactivation is a miscoordination of the concentrations of initiation factor IF3 and ribosomes.

Typing of Staphylococcus aureus strains by PCR-amplification of variable-length 16S-23S rDNA spacer regions: characterization of spacer sequences

To develop a rapid and accurate method of typing large numbers of clinical isolates of Staphylococcus aureus, the spacer region C of the rRNA operon [1391-507 (16S-23S)] was enzymically amplified from 322 strains. When the products were separated by denaturing PAGE, 15 variable-length rrn alleles were demonstrated, ranging in size from 906 to 1223 bp. The variable-length HpaII-digested region C [(region E; 1446-196 (16S-23S)] amplification products were cloned into M13mp18RF to sequence separate variable-length alleles. A total of 17 region E inserts were sequenced, aligned and divided into nine alleles by length (938-1174) and sequence properties. The 16S-23S spacer rDNA varied in length (303-551 bp) and in properties; three alleles contained a tRNAIle gene alone, two alleles contained a tRNAIle and a tRNAAla gene, and four alleles lacked tRNA genes. The sequences of two alleles showed less than 1% variation when isolated from two or three S. aureus strains. The 48 penicillin- and methicillin-sensitive strains were divided into 26 ribotypes; in contrast, the 274 methicillin-resistant S. aureus (MRSA) strains were divided into nine ribotypes (A-I) with 97% typing as either ribotype A or B (rrnL was missing in B). The sequence conservation of the rrn operons argues for the use of the 16S-23S spacer region as a stable and direct indicator of the evolutionary divergence of S. aureus strains.

Physical and genetic map of Streptococcus thermophilus A054

The three restriction endonucleases SfiI, BssHII, and SmaI were found to generate fragments with suitable size distributions for mapping the genome of Streptococcus thermophilus A054. A total of 5, 8, and 24 fragments were produced with SfiI, BssHII, and SmaI, respectively. An average genome size of 1,824 kb was determined by summing the total fragment sizes obtained by digestions with these three enzymes. Partial and multiple digestions of genomic DNA in conjunction with Southern hybridization were used to map SfiI, BssHII, and SmaI fragments. All restriction fragments were arranged in a unique circular chromosome. Southern hybridization analysis with specific probes allowed 23 genetic markers to be located on the restriction map. Among them, six rrn loci were precisely located. The area of the chromosome containing the ribosomal operons was further detailed by mapping some of the ApaI and SgrAI sites. Comparison of macrorestriction patterns from three clones derived from strain A054 revealed two variable regions in the chromosome. One was associated with the tandem rrnD and rrnE loci, and the other was mapped in the region of the lactose operon.

Integration of repeated sequences (pBR322) in the Bacillus subtilis 168 chromosome without affecting the genome structure

The Escherichia coli plasmid pBR322 sequence (4363 bp) was integrated at the met, pro, or leuB locus of the Bacillus subtilis chromosome without duplication of the flanking chromosomal regions. The integrated pBR322 was stably maintained as part of the chromosome regardless of its orientation or location. It was found that a DNA segment as large as 17 kb cloned in pBR322 can be readily transferred to the B. subtilis chromosome by transformation. It was demonstrated that a second pBR322 sequence could be effectively introduced at different regions of the chromosome by sequential transformation using chromosomal DNA isolated from a strain that had already acquired a pBR322 sequence at a different locus. Similarly, a third pBR322 sequence could be introduced. By this method, two or three pBR322 sequences can be incorporated at unlinked loci without affecting the overall structure of the B. subtilis genome.

Physical mapping of stable RNA genes in Bacillus subtilis using polymerase chain reaction amplification from a yeast artificial chromosome library

A new approach for mapping genes which utilizes yeast artificial chromosome clones carrying parts of the Bacillus subtilis genome and the polymerase chain reaction technique is described. This approach was used to physically map stable RNA genes of B. subtilis. Results from over 400 polymerase chain reactions carried out with the yeast artificial chromosome clone library, using primers specific for the genes of interest and designed from published sequences, were collected. The locations of 10 known rRNA gene regions (rrnO, rrnA, rrnE, rrnD, rrnB, rrnJ-rrnW, and rrnI-rrnH-rrnG) have been determined by this method, and these results correlate with those observed by standard genetic mapping. All rRNA operons, except rrnB, are found between 0 and 90 degrees, while rrnB has been placed in the area of 270 degrees on the chromosome map. Also localized were the tRNA gene clusters associated with the following ribosomal operons: rrnB (21 tRNAs), rrnJ (9 tRNAs), rrnD (16 tRNAs), and rrnO and rrnA (2 internal tRNAs). A previously unmapped four-tRNA gene cluster, trnY, a tRNA gene region that is not associated with a ribosomal operon, was found near the origin of replication. The P-RNA gene, important for processing of tRNAs, was found between map locations 197 and 204 degrees.

Stability and asymmetric replication of the Bacillus subtilis 168 chromosome structure

Chromosomal DNAs from a number of strains derived from Bacillus subtilis 168 were digested with restriction endonucleases NotI or SfiI, and the locations of chromosomal alterations were compared with the recently constructed standard NotI-SfiI restriction map (M. Itaya and T. Tanaka, J. Mol. Biol. 220:631-648, 1991). In general, the chromosome structure of B. subtilis 168 was found to be stable, as expected from the genetic stability of this species. DNA alterations, typically deletions, are formed in three limited loci on the chromosome. One of these alterations was characterized as a spontaneous deletion formed between rrn operons, and another occurred as a result of prophage SP beta excision. I found that oriC and terC are not located on precisely opposite sides of the chromosome. Replication in the counter clockwise direction was 196 kb longer than replication in the clockwise direction. The characteristic of length difference is not changed by deletion formation.

Two tRNA gene clusters associated with rRNA operons rrnD and rrnE in Bacillus subtilis

Sequence analysis of cloned rescued DNA fragments from a Bacillus subtilis strain with an inserted recombinant plasmid in ribosomal operon rrnE revealed the presence of two tRNA genes for Met and Asp at the 3' end of the operon. Probing chromosomal DNA from a strain carrying a plasmid inserted in rrnD with a fragment containing the genetically unassigned cluster of 16 tRNA genes revealed that the cluster is located immediately following the rrnD operon. Our findings show that all 10 rrn operons in B. subtilis are associated with tRNA gene clusters.

A cluster of nine tRNA genes between ribosomal gene operons in Bacillus subtilis

A cluster of nine tRNA genes located in the 1-kb region between ribosomal operons rrnJ and rrnW in Bacillus subtilis has been cloned and sequenced. This cluster contains the genes for tRNA(UACVal), tRNA(UGUThr), tRNA(UUULys), tRNA(UAGLeu). tRNA(GCCGly), tRNA(UAALeu), tRNA(ACGArg), tRNA(UGGPro), and tRNA(UGCAla). The newly discovered tRNA gene cluster combines features of the 3'-end of trnI, a cluster of 6 tRNA genes between ribosomal operons rrnI and rrnH, and of the 5'-end of trnB, a cluster of 21 tRNA genes found immediately 3' to rrnB. Neither the tRNA(UAGLeu) gene nor its product has been found previously in B. subtilis. With the discovery of this new set of tRNA genes, a total of 60 such genes have now been found in B. subtilis. These known genes account for almost all of the tRNA hybridizing restriction fragments of the B. subtilis genome. The 60 known tRNA genes of B. subtilis code for only 28 different anticodons, compared with a total of 41 different anticodons for 78 tRNA genes in Escherichia coli. This may indicate that B. subtilis does not need as many anticodons because of more flexible translation rules, similar to the situation in Mycoplasma capricolum.

Detection of intraspecific DNA polymorphism in Streptococcus salivarius subsp. thermophilus by a homologous rDNA probe

Three ribosomal probes from Streptococcus salivarius subsp. thermophilus were cloned. Sequence data demonstrate that their juxtaposition corresponds to an entire operon. They were used in order to study ribosomal operon number and organization. rRNA genes were shown to be clustered in the order 5'-16S-23S-5S-3' and the number of rrn loci to vary within the subspecies. The smallest of the 3 probes was used for strain characterization. Substantial variability in hybridization patterns was observed among strains, resulting not only from, restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) but also from the variability of ribosomal operon number.

Molecular mechanisms of deletion formation in Escherichia coli plasmids. I. Deletion formation mediated by long direct repeats

Derivatives of plasmid pBR327 with the tet gene interrupted by 165 pb or 401 bp direct repeats were constructed. In cells harboring these plasmids, deletions which restored the wild-type tet gene gave rise to tetracycline-resistant colonies, thereby allowing a simple phenotypic test for deletion formation. The frequencies of deletions in these plasmids were measured in Escherichia coli strains proficient or deficient in general recombination. The structure of plasmid DNA isolated from tetracycline-resistant transformants was analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis, restriction mapping and sequencing. The data presented here demonstrate that deletion formation is always associated with dimerization of plasmid DNA. Dimeric plasmids were of two types. Those which carried both a deletion and a compensating duplication were the major type in a Rec+ background and were rare in recA, recF, recJ and recO backgrounds. Dimers of the second type contained deletions, but no compensating duplications, and their formation was RecA-independent. The data presented demonstrate that deletion formation mediated by long direct repeats is mainly the result of unequal crossing-over between two plasmid molecules.

The stringent response blocks DNA replication outside the ori region in Bacillus subtilis and at the origin in Escherichia coli

When the Bacillus subtilis dnaB37 mutant, defective in initiation, is returned to permissive temperature after growth at 45 degrees C, DNA replication is synchronized. Under these conditions, we have shown previously that DNA replication is inhibited when the Stringent Response is induced by the amino acid analogue, arginine hydroxamate. We have now shown, using DNA-DNA hybridization analysis, that substantial replication of the oriC region nevertheless occurs during the Stringent Response, and that replication inhibition is therefore implemented downstream from the origin. On the left arm, replication continues for at least 190 x 10(3) base-pairs to the gnt gene and for a similar distance on the right arm to the gerD gene. When the Stringent Response is lifted, DNA replication resumed downstream from oriC on both arms, confirming that DNA replication is regulated at a post-initiation level during the Stringent Response in B. subtilis. Resumption of DNA synthesis following the lifting of the Stringent Response did not require protein or RNA synthesis or the initiation protein DnaB. We suggest, therefore, that a specific control region, involving Stringent Control sites, facilitate reversible inhibition of fork movement downstream from the origin via modifications of a replisome component during the Stringent Response. In contrast, in Escherichia coli, induction of the Stringent Response appears to block initiation of DNA replication at oriC itself. No DNA synthesis was detected in the oriC region and, upon lifting the Stringent Response, replication occurred from oriC. Post-initiation control in B. subtilis therefore results in duplication of many key genes involved in growth and sporulation. We discuss the possibility that such a control might be linked to differentiation in this organism.

Structure and organization of ribosomal DNA

Three trends are seen in the organization of ribosomal DNA genes during evolution: 1) gradual separation and separability of the regulation of transcription of 5S and larger subunit rRNAs; 2) retention of a transcription unit containing both large and small rRNAs; and 3) clustering of genes for both 5S and 18S-28S rDNAs, with the possible association of other 'non-rDNA' in the clusters of 18S-28S rDNA genes by the time mammals evolve.

Organization of the bacterial chromosome

Recent progress in studies on the bacterial chromosome is summarized. Although the greatest amount of information comes from studies on Escherichia coli, reports on studies of many other bacteria are also included. A compilation of the sizes of chromosomal DNAs as determined by pulsed-field electrophoresis is given, as well as a discussion of factors that affect gene dosage, including redundancy of chromosomes on the one hand and inactivation of chromosomes on the other hand. The distinction between a large plasmid and a second chromosome is discussed. Recent information on repeated sequences and chromosomal rearrangements is presented. The growing understanding of limitations on the rearrangements that can be tolerated by bacteria and those that cannot is summarized, and the sensitive region flanking the terminator loci is described. Sources and types of genetic variation in bacteria are listed, from simple single nucleotide mutations to intragenic and intergenic recombinations. A model depicting the dynamics of the evolution and genetic activity of the bacterial chromosome is described which entails acquisition by recombination of clonal segments within the chromosome. The model is consistent with the existence of only a few genetic types of E. coli worldwide. Finally, there is a summary of recent reports on lateral genetic exchange across great taxonomic distances, yet another source of genetic variation and innovation.

Genetic structure and DNA sequences at junctions involved in the rearrangements of Bacillus subtilis strains carrying the trpE26 mutation

Studies on the region upstream to ribosomal operon rrnD of Bacillus subtilis led to the characterization of two of the four chromosomal junctions involved in the rearrangements (a translocation and an inversion) of the strains carrying the trpE26 mutation. Genetic analysis, by integrative mapping, showed linkage of rrnD to cysB and hisA (both on segment A) in the trpE26-type strains. Physical analysis showed that the region upstream to rrnD is now linked to the trpE-ilvA chromosome segment as demonstrated by analyzing restriction site-polymorphism between 168 and trpE26-type strains. Similar experiments confirmed the previous genetic data on linkage in these areas in strains carrying novel rearrangements derived from the trpE26-type strains: stable merodiploids and inversions. The nucleotide sequence of the area 5' to rrnD in both types of strains (168 and trpE26), the region downstream of the citG gene and the region carrying the trpE26 mutation (made available to us by D. Henner) provided evidence for the molecular basis of the differences in structure, allowed the identification of the break points and revealed the presence of a polypurine region upstream to rrnD as seen in other systems in B. subtilis. No extensive homology was found between pairs of junctions so far sequenced. The models proposed by C. Anagnostopoulos for the role of DNA sequences of intrachromosomal homology involved in the transfer of the trpE26 mutation and the formation of novel arrangements require therefore reevaluation.

Chromosomal organization of rRNA operons in Bacillus subtilis

Integrative mapping with vectors containing ribosomal DNA sequences were used to complete the mapping of the 10 rRNA gene sets in the endospore forming bacterium Bacillus subtilis. Southern hybridizations allowed the assignment of nine operons to distinct BclI restriction fragments and their genetic locus identified by transductional crosses. Nine of the ten rRNA gene sets are located between 0 and 70 degrees on the genomic map. In the region surrounding cysA14, two sets of closely spaced tandem clusters are present. The first (rrnJ and rrnW) is located between purA16 and cysA14 closely linked to the latter; the second (rrnI, rrnH and rrnG) previously mapped within this area is located between attSPO2 and glpT6. The operons at or near the origin of replication (rrnO,rrnA and rrnJ,rrnW) represent "hot spots" of plasmid insertion.