Production of human papillomavirus type 16 virions in a keratinocyte cell line

Vorinostat, a pan-HDAC inhibitor, abrogates productive HPV-18 DNA amplification

Human papillomaviruses (HPVs) cause epithelial proliferative diseases. Persistent infection of the mucosal epithelia by the high-risk genotypes can progress to high-grade dysplasia and cancers. Viral transcription and protein activities are intimately linked to regulation by histone acetyltransferases and histone deacetylases (HDACs) that remodel chromatin and regulate gene expression. HDACs are also essential to remodel and repair replicating chromatin to enable the progression of replication forks. As such, Vorinostat (suberoylanilide hydroximic acid), and other pan-HDAC inhibitors, are used to treat lymphomas. Here, we investigated the effects of Vorinostat on productive infection of the high-risk HPV-18 in organotypic cultures of primary human keratinocytes. HPV DNA amplifies in the postmitotic, differentiated cells of squamous epithelia, in which the viral oncoproteins E7 and E6 establish a permissive milieu by destabilizing major tumor suppressors, the pRB family proteins and p53, respectively. We showed that Vorinostat significantly reduced these E6 and E7 activities, abrogated viral DNA amplification, and inhibited host DNA replication. The E7-induced DNA damage response, which is critical for both events, was also compromised. Consequently, Vorinostat exposure led to DNA damage and triggered apoptosis in HPV-infected, differentiated cells, whereas uninfected tissues were spared. Apoptosis was attributed to highly elevated proapoptotic Bim isoforms that are known to be repressed by EZH2 in a repressor complex containing HDACs. Two other HDAC inhibitors, Belinostat and Panobinostat, also inhibited viral DNA amplification and cause apoptosis. We suggest that HDAC inhibitors are promising therapeutic agents to treat benign HPV infections, abrogate progeny virus production, and hence interrupt transmission.

Cutaneous HPV8 and MmuPV1 E6 Proteins Target the NOTCH and TGF-β Tumor Suppressors to Inhibit Differentiation and Sustain Keratinocyte Proliferation

Cutaneous beta-papillomaviruses are associated with non-melanoma skin cancers that arise in patients who suffer from a rare genetic disorder, Epidermodysplasia verruciformis (EV) or after immunosuppression following organ transplantation. Recent studies have shown that the E6 proteins of the cancer associated beta human papillomavirus (HPV) 5 and HPV8 inhibit NOTCH and TGF-β signaling. However, it is unclear whether disruption of these pathways may contribute to cutaneous HPV pathogenesis and carcinogenesis. A recently identified papillomavirus, MmuPV1, infects laboratory mouse strains and causes cutaneous skin warts that can progress to squamous cell carcinoma. To determine whether MmuPV1 may be an appropriate model to mechanistically dissect the molecular contributions of cutaneous HPV infections to skin carcinogenesis, we investigated whether MmuPV1 E6 shares biological and biochemical activities with HPV8 E6. We report that the HPV8 and MmuPV1 E6 proteins share the ability to bind to the MAML1 and SMAD2/SMAD3 transcriptional cofactors of NOTCH and TGF-beta signaling, respectively. Moreover, we demonstrate that these cutaneous papillomavirus E6 proteins inhibit these two tumor suppressor pathways and that this ability is linked to delayed differentiation and sustained proliferation of differentiating keratinocytes. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the ability of MmuPV1 E6 to bind MAML1 is necessary for papilloma formation in experimentally infected mice. Our results, therefore, suggest that experimental MmuPV1 infection in mice will be a robust and useful experimental system to model key aspects of cutaneous HPV infection, pathogenesis and carcinogenesis.

In vitro and Animal Models for Antiviral Therapy in Papillomavirus Infections

The need for antiviral therapies for papillomavirus infections is well recognized but the difficulties of reproducing the infectious cycle of papillomaviruses in vitro has hindered our understanding of virus-cell interactions and the regulation of viral gene expression during permissive growth. Recent advances in understanding the temporal expression and function of papillomavirus proteins has enabled consideration of a targeted approach to papillomavirus chemotherapy and in particular the inhibition of viral replication by targeting the E1 and E2 proteins. There are in vitro culture systems available for the screening of new chemotherapeutic agents, since significant advances have been made with culture systems which promote epithelial differentiation in vitro. However, to date, there are no published data which show that virions generated in vitro can infect keratinocytes and initiate another round of replication in vitro. In vivo animal models are therefore necessary to assess the efficacy of antivirals in preventing and treating viral infection, particularly for the low-risk genital viruses which are on the whole refractory to culture in vitro. Although papillomaviruses affect a wide variety of hosts in a species-specific manner, the animals most useful for modelling papillomavirus infections include the rabbit, ox, mouse, dog, horse, primate and sheep. The ideal animal model should be widely available, easy to house and handle, be large enough to allow for adequate tissue sampling, develop lesions on anatomical sites comparable with those in human diseases and these lesions should be readily accessible for monitoring and ideally should yield large amounts of infectious virus particles for use in both in vivo and in vitro studies. The relative merits of the various papillomavirus animal models available in relation to these criteria are discussed.

Development of a cellular assay system to study the genome replication of high- and low-risk mucosal and cutaneous human papillomaviruses

We found that recircularized high-risk (type 16 and 18) and low-risk mucosal (type 6b and 11) and cutaneous (type 5 and 8) human papillomavirus (HPV) genomes replicate readily when delivered into U2OS cells by electroporation. The replication efficiency is dependent on the amount of input HPV DNA and can be followed for more than 3 weeks in proliferating cell culture without selection. Cotransfection of recircularized HPV genomes with a linear G418 resistance marker plasmid has allowed subcloning of cell lines, which, in a majority of cases, carry multicopy episomal HPV DNA. Analysis of the HPV DNA status in these established cell lines showed that HPV genomes exist in these cells as stable extrachromosomal oligomers. When the cell lines were cultivated as confluent cultures, a 3- to 10-fold amplification of the HPV genomes per cell was induced. Two-dimensional (2D) agarose gel electrophoresis confirmed amplification of mono- and oligomeric HPV genomes in these confluent cell cultures. Amplification occurred as a result of the initiation of semiconservative two-dimensional replication from one active origin in the HPV oligomer. Our data suggest that the system described here might be a valuable, cost-effective, and efficient tool for use in HPV DNA replication studies, as well as for the design of cell-based assays to identify potential inhibitors of all stages of HPV genome replication.

Human papillomaviruses: a growing field

A combination of functional studies on human papillomavirus (HPV) oncoproteins and epidemiological studies on persistence of HPV infection firmly established a role for HPV in the etiology of cervical cancers. Understanding the viral life cycle of HPVs has been more difficult. In this issue of Genes & Development, Wang et al. (pp. 181 - 194) describe an efficient method to propagate infectious HPV in differentiating epithelium, providing clear evidence for temporal separation of viral and cellular replication.

Critical evaluation of HPV16 gene copy number quantification by SYBR green PCR

BACKGROUND

Human papilloma virus (HPV) load and physical status are considered useful parameters for clinical evaluation of cervical squamous cell neoplasia. However, the errors implicit in HPV gene quantification by PCR are not well documented. We have undertaken the first rigorous evaluation of the errors that can be expected when using SYBR green qPCR for quantification of HPV type 16 gene copy numbers. We assessed a modified method, in which external calibration curves were generated from a single construct containing HPV16 E2, HPV16 E6 and the host gene hydroxymethylbilane synthase in a 1:1:1 ratio.

RESULTS

When testing dilutions of mixed HPV/host DNA in replicate runs, we observed errors in quantifying E2 and E6 amplicons of 5-40%, with greatest error at the lowest DNA template concentration (3 ng/microl). Errors in determining viral copy numbers per diploid genome were 13-53%. Nevertheless, in cervical keratinocyte cell lines we observed reasonable agreement between viral loads determined by qPCR and Southern blotting. The mean E2/E6 ratio in episome-only cells was 1.04, but with a range of 0.76-1.32. In three integrant-only lines the mean E2/E6 ratios were 0.20, 0.72 and 2.61 (values confirmed by gene-specific Southern blotting). When E2/E6 ratios in fourteen HPV16-positive cervical carcinomas were analysed, conclusions regarding viral physical state could only be made in three cases, where the E2/E6 ratio was < or = 0.06.

CONCLUSION

Run-to-run variation in SYBR green qPCR produces unavoidable inaccuracies that should be allowed for when quantifying HPV gene copy number. While E6 copy numbers can be considered to provide a useable indication of viral loads, the E2/E6 ratio is of limited value. Previous studies may have overestimated the frequency of mixed episomal/integrant HPV infections.

Induction of productive human papillomavirus type 11 life cycle in epithelial cells grown in organotypic raft cultures

The study of the human papillomavirus (HPV) life cycle was hampered for more than 50 years by the lack of a conventional cell culture system for propagating HPV. Considerable progress has been made in the production of several HPV types using either organotypic rafts or human epithelial xenografts in immunocompromised mice. In this study, we demonstrated episomal maintenance of HPV-11 DNA in N-Tert cells. HPV-11 episomal DNA containing cell populations grown in raft culture showed induction of the productive viral life cycle. HPV-11 DNA amplification and viral capsid antigen synthesis were detected in differentiated layers of epithelia. The viruses generated were able to infect keratinocytes in vitro, which indicate that viruses generated were infectious. The demonstration of the productive HPV-11 life cycle in raft culture from cloned HPV-11 DNA will facilitate genetic analyses of viral gene functions that was not possible using the human xenograft athymic mouse model.

Progression from productive infection to integration and oncogenic transformation in human papillomavirus type 59-immortalized foreskin keratinocytes

Studies of changes in the virus and host cell upon progression from human papillomavirus (HPV) episomal infection to integration are critical to understanding HPV-related malignant transformation. However, there exist only a few in vitro models of both productive HPV infection and neoplastic progression on the same host background. We recently described a unique foreskin keratinocyte cell line (ERIN 59) that contains HPV 59 (a close relative of HPV 18). Early passages of ERIN 59 cells (passages 9-13) contained approximately 50 copies of episomes/cell, were feeder cell-dependent, and could be induced to differentiate and produce infectious virus in a simple culture system. We now report that late passage cells (passages greater than 50) were morphologically different from early passage cells, were feeder cell independent, and did not differentiate or produce virus. These late passage cells contained HPV in an integrated form. An integration-derived oncogene transcript was expressed in late passage cells. The E2 open reading frame was interrupted in this transcript at nucleotide 3351. Despite a lower viral genome copy number in late passage ERIN 59 cells, expression of E6/E7 oncogene transcripts was similar to early passage cells. We conclude that ERIN 59 cells are a valuable cell line representing a model of progression from HPV 59 episomal infection and virus production to HPV 59 integration and associated oncogenic transformation on the same host background.

Propagation of infectious human papillomavirus type 16 by using an adenovirus and Cre/LoxP mechanism

Human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV16) infection is a major risk factor for the development of squamous cell cancers of the cervix and of the head and neck. A major barrier to understanding the progression from initial infection to cancer has been the lack of in vitro models that allow infection, replication, and persistence of the viral genome as an episome in differentiated epithelial cells. To overcome this barrier, we designed an adenoviral delivery vector that contained a full HPV16 genome flanked by LoxP homologous recombination sites and a fluorescent reporter that was expressed only after the HPV genome was excised by Cre recombinase. This system delivered circular HPV16 genomes to cervical epithelial cells and well differentiated human airway epithelia. After delivery, the HPV16 genome replicated and persisted as an episome in cervical keratinocytes. These cells developed an immortalized phenotype and a dysplastic epithelial appearance. Moreover, induction of differentiation led to the expression of late genes and production of infectious HPV16 virions. This work provides a means of introducing biologically active HPV genomes into epithelial cells, which are normally difficult to transfect. These methods allow the study of HPV genome replication and gene expression in the earliest stages of HPV genome establishment, and they may provide a means to study nononcogenic HPV viral types.

Human papillomavirus type 59 immortalized keratinocytes express late viral proteins and infectious virus after calcium stimulation

Human papillomavirus type 59 (HPV 59) is an oncogenic type related to HPV 18. HPV 59 was recently propagated in the athymic mouse xenograft system. A continuous keratinocyte cell line infected with HPV 59 was created from a foreskin xenograft grown in an athymic mouse. Cells were cultured beyond passage 50. The cells were highly pleomorphic, containing numerous abnormally shaped nuclei and mitotic figures. HPV 59 sequences were detected in the cells by DNA in situ hybridization in a diffuse nuclear distribution. Southern blots were consistent with an episomal state of HPV 59 DNA at approximately 50 copies per cell. Analysis of the cells using a PCR/reverse blot strip assay, which amplifies a portion of the L1 open reading frame, was strongly positive. Differentiation of cells in monolayers was induced by growth in F medium containing 2 mM calcium chloride for 10 days. Cells were harvested as a single tissue-like sheet, and histologic analysis revealed a four-to-six cell-thick layer. Transcripts encoding involucrin, a cornified envelope protein, and the E1/E4 and E1/E4/L1 viral transcripts were detected after several days of growth in F medium containing 2 mM calcium chloride. The E1/E4 and L1 proteins were detected by immunohistochemical analysis, and virus particles were seen in electron micrographs in a subset of differentiated cells. An extract of differentiated cells was prepared by vigorous sonication and was used to infect foreskin fragments. These fragments were implanted into athymic mice. HPV 59 was detected in the foreskin xenografts removed 4 months later by DNA in situ hybridization and PCR/reverse blot assay. Thus, the complete viral growth cycle, including production on infectious virus, was demonstrated in the HPV 59 immortalized cells grown in a simple culture system.

The relationship between connexins, gap junctions, tissue architecture and tumour invasion, as studied in a novel in vitro model of HPV-16-associated cervical cancer progression

Disruption of gap junctional intercellular communication (GJIC) and/or connexins (gap junction proteins) is frequently reported in malignant cell lines and tumours. Certain human papillomaviruses (HPV) associated with the development of cancers, especially of the cervix, have previously been reported to downregulate GJIC in vitro. There is also evidence for reduced gap junctions in cervical dysplasia. However, many squamous hyperproliferative conditions, including HPV-induced warts, often show extensive upregulation of certain connexins. The association between HPV and GJIC, and the mechanism and consequence of deregulated GJIC in cervical tumour progression, remains unclear. Therefore, using a variety of nonmalignant and malignant cell lines and an organotypic raft-culture system, we investigated the relationship between HPV, gap junctions and tumour progression. Established cervical tumour cell lines carrying HPV were unable to communicate via gap junctions (when assayed by dye-transfer techniques). This correlated with lack of connexin protein expression, while transfection with connexins 26 or 43 led to functional gap junction membrane plaques. On the other hand, immortal but nonmalignant cell lines that contained episomal or integrated HPV-16, but required feeder-layer and growth-factor support, were consistently well coupled, and expressed multiple connexins at membrane junctions. In vitro selection of feeder-layer and growth-factor-independent variants eventually lead to loss of GJIC, which correlated with loss of membrane and increased cytoplasmic connexin 43 localization. However, this was preceded by loss of differentiation and stromal invasion, as assayed on the organotypic raft-culture model. Using this model, a comparison between noncoupled, well-coupled and connexin-transfected cell lines revealed no firm correlation between GJIC and dysplasia, but GJIC appeared to favour increased stratification. These findings demonstrate that loss of GJIC is frequent, but appears to occur more as a consequence of, rather than being the cause of, epithelial dysplasia, and may be influenced by, but is not directly attributable to, HPV.

Quantitative role of the human papillomavirus type 16 E5 gene during the productive stage of the viral life cycle

Human papillomaviruses (HPVs) are small circular DNA viruses that cause warts. Infection with high-risk anogenital HPVs, such as HPV type 16 (HPV16), is associated with human cancers, specifically cervical cancer. The life cycle of HPVs is intimately tied to the differentiation status of the host epithelium and has two distinct stages: the nonproductive stage and the productive stage. In the nonproductive stage, which arises in the poorly differentiated basal epithelial compartment of a wart, the virus maintains itself as a low-copy-number nuclear plasmid. In the productive stage, which arises as the host cell undergoes terminal differentiation, viral DNA is amplified; the capsid genes, L1 and L2, are expressed; and progeny virions are produced. This stage of the viral life cycle relies on the ability of the virus to reprogram the differentiated cells to support DNA synthesis. Papillomaviruses encode multiple oncoproteins, E5, E6, and E7. In the present study, we analyze the role of one of these viral oncogenes, E5, in the viral life cycle. To assess the role of E5 in the HPV16 life cycle, we introduced wild-type (WT) or E5 mutant HPV16 genomes into NIKS, a keratinocyte cell line that supports the papillomavirus life cycle. By culturing these cells under conditions that allow them to remain undifferentiated, a state similar to that of basal epithelial cells, we determined that E5 does not play an essential role in the nonproductive stage of the HPV16 life cycle. To determine if E5 plays a role in the productive stage of the viral life cycle, we cultured keratinocyte populations in organotypic raft cultures, which promote the differentiation and stratification of epithelial cells. We found that cells harboring E5 mutant genomes displayed a quantitative reduction in the percentage of suprabasal cells undergoing DNA synthesis, compared to cells containing WT HPV16 DNA. This reduction in DNA synthesis, however, did not prevent amplification of viral DNA in the differentiated cellular compartment. Likewise, late viral gene expression and the perturbation of normal keratinocyte differentiation were retained in cells harboring E5 mutant genomes. These data demonstrate that E5 plays a subtle role during the productive stage of the HPV16 life cycle.

Saccharomyces cerevisiae is permissive for replication of bovine papillomavirus type 1

We recently demonstrated that Saccharomyces cerevisiae protoplasts can take up bovine papillomavirus type 1 (BPV1) virions and that viral episomal DNA is replicated after uptake. Here we demonstrate that BPV virus-like particles are assembled in infected S. cerevisiae cultures from newly synthesized capsid proteins and also package newly synthesized DNA, including full-length and truncated viral DNA and S. cerevisiae-derived DNA. Virus particles prepared in S. cerevisiae are able to convey packaged DNA to Cos1 cells and to transform C127 cells. Infectivity was blocked by antisera to BPV1 L1 but not antisera to BPV1 E4. We conclude that S. cerevisiae is permissive for the replication of BPV1 virus.

HPV episomal copy number closely correlates with cell size in keratinocyte monolayer cultures

W12E keratinocytes maintaining episomal copies of HPV DNA were separated according to size by centrifugal elutriation. HPV DNA copy number was greatly increased in the largest, most differentiated cells of the population. The large cells with the highest HPV copy number also showed evidence of endoreduplication of host cell DNA. Other cell lines maintaining episomal copies of HPV18 and HPV31 were also tested with all lines showing similar results. The results demonstrate that increase in HPV DNA copy number correlates well with increased cell size, a fundamental marker of keratinocyte differentiation. The results also indicate that simple monolayer cultures may be useful for studying the relationship between differentiation, HPV DNA replication, and cell-cycle events.

Detection of Viral DNA and E4 Protein in Basal Keratinocytes of Experimental Canine Oral Papillomavirus Lesions

We studied experimental canine oral papillomavirus (COPV) infection by in situ hybridization and immunohistochemistry of weekly biopsies. After 4 weeks, viral DNA in rete ridges suggested a keratinocyte stem cell target. Abundant viral DNA was seen in E4-positive cells only. E4 was predominantly cytoplasmic but also nuclear, being concentrated in the nucleoli during wart formation. Infected cells spread laterally along the basal layer and into the parabasal layers, accompanied by E7 transcription and increased mitoses. Most of the lower epithelium was positive for viral DNA, but, in mature warts, higher levels of E4 expression and genome amplification occurred in only sporadic superficial cells. L1 expression was late and in only a subset of E4-positive cells. During regression, viral DNA was less abundant in deep epithelial layers, suggesting downregulation of replication prior to replacement of infected cells from beneath. Detection of viral DNA in post-regression tissue indicated latent infection.

The human papillomavirus type 16 E7 oncogene is required for the productive stage of the viral life cycle

The production of the human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV-16) is intimately tied to the differentiation of the host epithelium that it infects. Infection occurs in the basal layer of the epithelium at a site of wounding, where the virus utilizes the host DNA replication machinery to establish itself as a low-copy-number episome. The productive stage of the HPV-16 life cycle occurs in the postmitotic suprabasal layers of the epithelium, where the virus amplifies its DNA to high copy number, synthesizes the capsid proteins (L1 and L2), encapsidates the HPV-16 genome, and releases virion particles as the upper layer of the epithelium is shed. Papillomaviruses are hypothesized to possess a mechanism to overcome the block in DNA synthesis that occurs in the differentiated epithelial cells, and the HPV-16 E7 oncoprotein has been suggested to play a role in this process. To determine whether E7 plays a role in the HPV-16 life cycle, an E7-deficient HPV-16 genome was created by inserting a translational termination linker (TTL) in the E7 gene of the full HPV-16 genome. This DNA was transfected into an immortalized human foreskin keratinocyte cell line shown previously to support the HPV-16 life cycle, and stable cell lines were obtained that harbored the E7-deficient HPV-16 genome episomally, the state of the genome found in normal infections. By culturing these cells under conditions which promote the differentiation of epithelial cells, we found E7 to be necessary for the productive stage of the HPV-16 life cycle. HPV-16 lacking E7 failed to amplify its DNA and expressed reduced amounts of the capsid protein L1, which is required for virus production. E7 appears to create a favorable environment for HPV-16 DNA synthesis by perturbing the keratinocyte differentiation program and inducing the host DNA replication machinery. These data demonstrate that E7 plays an essential role in the papillomavirus life cycle.

The human papillomavirus type 16 negative regulatory RNA element interacts with three proteins that act at different posttranscriptional levels

In human papillomaviruses, expression of the late genes L1 and L2, encoding the capsid proteins, is restricted to the upper layers of the infected epithelium. A 79-nt GU-rich negative regulatory element (NRE) located at the 3' untranslated region of the human papillomavirus 16 L1 gene was identified previously as key to the posttranscriptional control of late gene expression. Here, we demonstrate that in epithelial cells, the NRE can directly bind the U2 auxiliary splicing factor 65-kDa subunit, the cleavage stimulation factor 64-kDa subunit, and the Elav-like HuR protein. On induction of epithelial cell differentiation, levels of the U2 auxiliary splicing factor 65-kDa subunit decrease, levels of the cleavage stimulation factor 64-kDa subunit increase, and the levels of HuR remain unchanged, although redistribution of the HuR from the nucleus to the cytoplasm is observed. Late gene transcripts, which appear to be fully processed, are detected in undifferentiated W12 cells, but are confined in the nucleus. We propose that repression of late gene expression in basal epithelial cells may be caused by nuclear retention or cytoplasmic instability of NRE-containing late gene transcripts.

Establishment of the human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV-16) life cycle in an immortalized human foreskin keratinocyte cell line

The study of human papillomaviruses (HPVs) in cell culture has been hindered because of the difficulty in recreating the three-dimensional structure of the epithelium on which the virus depends to complete its life cycle. Additionally, the study of genetic mutations in the HPV genome and its effects on the viral life cycle are difficult using the current method of transfecting molecularly cloned HPV genomes into early-passage human foreskin keratinocytes (HFKs) because of the limited life span of these cells. Unless the HPV genome transfected into the early-passage HFK extends the life span of the cell, analysis of stable transfectants becomes difficult. In this study, we have used BC-1-Ep/SL cells, an immortalized human foreskin keratinocyte cell line, to recreate the HPV-16 life cycle. This cell line exhibits many characteristics of the early-passage HFKs including the ability to stratify and terminally differentiate in an organotypic raft culture system. Because of their similarity to early-passage HFKs, these cells were tested for their ability to support the HPV-16 life cycle. The BC-1-Ep/SL cells could stably maintain two HPV genotypes, HPV-16 and HPV-31b, episomally. Additionally, when the BC-1-Ep/SL cell line was stably transfected with HPV-16 and cultured using the organotypic raft culture system (rafts), it sustained the HPV-16 life cycle. Evidence for the productive stage of the HPV-16 life cycle was provided by: DNA in situ hybridization demonstrating HPV-16 DNA amplification in the suprabasal layers of the rafts, immunohistochemical staining for L1 showing the presence of capsid protein in the suprabasal layers of the rafts, and electron microscopy indicating the presence of virus like particles (VLPs) in nuclei from cells in the differentiated layers of the rafts.

Molecular targets for human papillomaviruses: prospects for antiviral therapy

A substantial medical need exists for the development of antiviral medicines for the treatment of diseases associated with infection by human papillomaviruses (HPVs). HPVs are associated with various benign and malignant lesions including benign genital condyloma, common skin warts, laryngeal papillomas and anogenital cancer. Since treatment options are limited and typically not very satisfactory, the development of safe and effective antiviral drugs for HPV could have substantial clinical impact. In the last few years, exciting advances have been made in our understanding of papillomavirus replication and the effects that the virus has on growth of the host cell. Although still somewhat rudimentary, techniques have been developed for limited virion production in vitro offering the promise of more rapid advances in the dissection and understanding of the virus life cycle. Of the 8-10 HPV gene products that are made during infection, only one encodes enzymatic activities, the E1 helicase. Successful antiviral therapies have traditionally targeted viral enzymes such as polymerases, kinases and proteases. In contrast, macromolecular interactions which mediate the functions of E6, E7 and E2 are thought to be more difficult targets for small molecule therapy.

Isolation and propagation of human papillomavirus type 16 in human xenografts implanted in the severe combined immunodeficiency mouse

We report the isolation and propagation of human papillomavirus type 16, the main agent of cervical cancer, using human foreskin fragments implanted in severe combined immunodeficiency mice. The infection produced viral particles, and with each passage of the virus it caused lesions identical to intraepithelial neoplasia, the precursor to carcinoma.

Expression of human papillomavirus type 16 L1 protein in Escherichia coli: denaturation, renaturation, and self-assembly of virus-like particles in vitro

Major capsid protein L1 of HPV16 was produced in a fused form in Escherichia coli using an inducible expression system. The protein formed insoluble aggregations (inclusion bodies) and the yield was more than 10% of total cell proteins. The inclusion bodies were isolated and solubilised with 8 M urea and the L1 proteins were purified by chromatographic separation. Following removal of the urea by gradual dialysis, the denatured L1 proteins spontaneously renatured and subsequently assembled into polymorphologic aggregations in vitro. Electron microscopy showed that the assembled material included structures resembling native empty capsids as well as incompletely formed capsids. After separation from the pool of polymorphologic structures by sucrose gradient sedimentation, the correctly formed virus-like particles (VLE. coliPs) were recognised by a HPV16 type-specific, conformational-dependent monoclonal antibody in an ELISA. This system offers not only a model for investigation of the intrinsic interactions that occur during L1 assembly, but also a potential route for convenient manufacture of highly purified VLP vaccines.

Evidence for a switch in the mode of human papillomavirus type 16 DNA replication during the viral life cycle

The study of human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV-16) replication has been impaired because of the lack of a cell culture system that stably maintains viral replication. Recently, cervical epithelial cell populations that stably maintain HPV-16 replicons at a copy number of approximately 1,000 per cell were derived from an HPV-16-infected patient (W12 cell clone 20863 [W12-E cells]). We used neutral/neutral and neutral/alkaline two-dimensional gel electrophoretic techniques to characterize HPV-16 DNA replication in these cells. When W12-E cells were maintained in an undifferentiated state mimicking the nonproductive stage of the life cycle, HPV-16 DNA was found to replicate primarily by theta structures in a bidirectional manner. The initiation site of HPV-16 DNA replication was mapped to approximately nucleotide 100, and the termination site was mapped to between nucleotides 3398 and 5990. To study the productive stage of HPV-16 DNA replication, W12-E cells were grown under culture conditions that promote differentiation of epithelial cell types. Under these conditions, where virus-like particles were detected, the mode of viral DNA replication changed from theta structure to what is apparently a rolling circle mode. Additionally, CIN 612-9E cells, which were derived from an HPV-31-infected patient and harbor HPV-31 extrachromosomally, exhibited the same switch in the mode of DNA replication upon induction of differentiation. These data argue that a fundamental switch in the mechanism of viral DNA replication occurs during the life cycle of the papillomavirus.

Coinfection of human foreskin fragments with multiple human papillomavirus types (HPV-11, -40, and -LVX82/MM7) produces regionally separate HPV infections within the same athymic mouse xenograft

The athymic mouse xenograft system was used to prepare infectious stocks of two additional anogenital tissue-targeting human papillomaviruses (HPVs) in a manner similar to that for the development of infectious stocks of HPV-11. An anal condyloma from a transplant patient was used as material for extraction of infectious virus, and human foreskin fragments were incubated with the virus suspension and transplanted subrenally into athymic mice. Partial viral sequencing indicated that two rare HPV types (HPV-40 and HPVLVX82/MM7) were concurrently present in both the patient condyloma and the foreskin xenografts, and passage of both types was achieved as a mixed infection with HPV-40 predominating. Xenografts that developed from simultaneous infection of human foreskin fragments with HPV-11, -40, and -LVX82/MM7 virions produced regionally separate areas of HPV-11 and -40 infection as determined by in situ hybridization. In addition, in situ hybridization with HPV-40 and HPVLVX82/MM7 DNA probes demonstrated that both of these HPV types were present as adjacent but separate infections within the same anal condyloma of the transplant patient. These studies indicate that multiple HPV types can simultaneously infect genital tissue and that each HPV type predominantly maintains regional separation within the same papilloma.

Demonstration of human papillomavirus (HPV) genomic amplification and viral-like particles from CaSki cell line in SCID mice

We demonstrate that from the CaSki cervical cancer cell line, integrated HPV-16 genome was amplified and viral-like particles were generated in an in vivo SCID mouse model. The in vivo tumor growth of several HPV-containing cell lines and 2 HPV-negative cell lines was examined in SCID mice. Tumor growth was noted with the HeLa, CaSki, ME-180, and MS751 cell lines within 2 months after subcutaneous injection. Squamous differentiation was appreciated in focal areas of tumors derived from CaSki and ME-180. In the CaSki tumors, DNA in situ hybridization revealed homogeneous staining of nuclei in some cells in the differentiated areas, suggesting HPV genomic amplification. In contrast, punctate or speckled patterns of hybridization were identified in the less differentiated areas, suggesting continued integration of the HPV genome. Immunocytochemical staining for HPV-16 L1 capsid protein showed it to be concentrated in cells from the differentiated areas, correlating with the results of hybridization. Electron microscopic studies revealed 50 nm uniform particles, consistent with HPV viral-like particles, in the nuclei of some cells in well-differentiated areas. Furthermore, Southern transfer and hybridization of the Hirt's extract from the CaSki tumors was positive for HPV-16 DNA, indicating non-integrated, low molecular weight HPV-16 DNA. Our results show HPV genomic amplification of integrated viral DNA and generation of HPV viral-like particles in CaSki cancer cells in SCID mice and that viral DNA amplification and the formation of viral-like particles are coupled to cellular differentiation. This experimental model provides a potential system for studying the molecular pathogenesis of HPV infections.

A cellular 65-kDa protein recognizes the negative regulatory element of human papillomavirus late mRNA

Papillomavirus late gene expression is tightly linked to the differentiation state of the host cell. Levels of late mRNAs are only in part controlled by regulation of the late promoter, other posttranscriptional mechanisms exist that reduce the amount of late mRNA in undifferentiated cells. Previously we described a negative regulatory element (NRE) located upstream of the human papillomavirus type 16 late poly(A) site. We have delineated the NRE to a 79-nt region in which a G+U-rich region was the major determinant of NRE activity. UV-crosslinking assays identified a prominent nuclear protein of 65 kDa as the only factor in close contact with the NRE, and a complex of at least five proteins, including the 65-kDa protein, was enriched on NRE-RNA. Binding of the 65-kDa protein was depleted by preincubation with poly(U) Sepharose in high salt, a property characteristic of the U2 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein auxiliary factor U2AF65 and bacterially expressed U2AF65 exhibited NRE binding. The 65-kDa protein bound to the G+U-rich NRE 3' half which shows homology to the B2P2 sequence a known U2AF65 binding site in the alpha-tropomyosin gene, and the G+U-rich element can be replaced by B2P2 in the binding assay. Treatment of cells with phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate reduced binding of the 65-kDa protein, induced NRE binding of a cytoplasmic protein, and relieved the NRE block on reporter gene expression.

A high capacity assay for inhibitors of human papillomavirus DNA replication

The discovery of antiviral compounds against human papillomaviruses (HPV) has been hindered by the difficulties in culturing virus in vitro or assaying stable HPV DNA replication. However, plasmids containing the HPV replication origin replicate transiently upon co-transfection with HPV E1 and E2 expression vectors. We have adapted this assay using secreted alkaline phosphatase (SAP) as a reporter for rapid analysis of DNA copy number. Use of the SV40 early promoter in controlling SAP expression was critical in ensuring both a strong signal and copy number dependence: the stronger beta-actin promotor inhibited replication, while the weaker SV40 late promoter yielded very low levels of SAP. The precise configuration of the E1 and E2 expression vectors also was critical, most pre-existing vectors did not support efficient replication and SAP secretion. The extent of DNA replication and SAP secretion were both proportional to the amount of E1/E2 vector used in transfections; under optimal conditions SAP increased 100-fold during replication. The assay has been developed for compound screening in 96-well plates and several inhibitors have been identified. Quantitative Southern blot analysis has shown that most of these inhibit HPV DNA replication rather than SAP accumulation or activity, and several are under test in models of viral replication. The assay also provides a rapid system for functional analysis of the HPV E1, E2 genes and the replication origin.

Integration of human papillomavirus type 16 into the human genome correlates with a selective growth advantage of cells

Integration of human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV-16) DNA into a host chromosome has been hypothesized to result in altered expression of two viral transforming genes, E6 and E7, in cervical cancers. In order to investigate the role that changes in viral genomic state and gene expression play in cervical carcinogenesis, we have derived clonal populations of human cervical epithelial cells which harbor multiple copies of either extrachromosomal or integrated viral DNA. The clonal populations harboring extrachromosomal HPV-16 DNA stably maintained approximately 1,000 viral copies for at least 15 passages (approximately 100 cell doublings), which contrasted with the unstable HPV-16 replicons in the parental counterpart. In the clonal populations harboring integrated viral DNA, 3 to 60 copies of HPV-16 DNA were found integrated in either of two forms: type 1, in which all the copies of HPV-16 DNA were disrupted in the E2 open reading frame upon integration, and type 2, in which intact viral copies were flanked by disrupted viral copies and cellular sequences. Despite the lower HPV-16 DNA copy number, the clonal populations with integrated viral DNA had levels of E7 protein that were in most cases higher than those found in the clonal populations harboring extrachromosomal viral DNA. Irrespective of viral genomic state, the clonal populations were capable of undergoing terminal differentiation and unable to form colonies in soft agar, which is indicative of the nontumorigenic nature of these cells. Importantly, a cell population with integrated viral DNA was found to outgrow another with extrachromosomal DNA when these cells were cocultured over a period of time. Thus, integration of human papillomaviral DNA correlates with increased viral gene expression and cellular growth advantage. These observations are consistent with the hypothesis that integration provides a selective advantage to cervical epithelial precursors of cervical carcinoma.

Papilloma formation in human foreskin xenografts after inoculation of human papillomavirus type 16 DNA

A mouse model of high-risk human papillomavirus infection was developed in which human papillomavirus (HPV) type 16 DNA was inoculated into human foreskin grafted to the skin of severe combined immunodeficient (scid) mice. Grafted skin contained human epidermis and dermis and, like normal human skin, expressed involucrin in differentiating keratinocytes. HPV type 16 DNA, attached to gold particles, was delivered directly into human epidermal cells and induced exophytic papilloma with histologic features of papillomavirus infection, including koilocytosis and expression of papillomavirus capsid antigen. This model should be useful for determining in vivo the functions of viral genes and for developing strategies to prevent and treat HPV-associated disease. It may also be of value in developing animal models of other human skin diseases.

Epithelial differentiation fails to support replication of cloned human papillomavirus type 16 DNA in transfected keratinocytes

Research on the life cycle of human papillomaviruses (HPVs) has suffered from the lack of a model system that allows the use of molecularly cloned HPV DNA. In this study, we analyzed replication of molecularly cloned HPV-16 genomes after transfection into cells of two human keratinocyte cell lines. Transfected cells were grown in cell culture (in vitro) or in transplantation chambers on the flanks of nude mice (in vivo). When DNA was extracted after different time intervals, replication of HPV-16 DNA could not be detected. Even the formation of a stratified epithelium under in vivo conditions failed to support vegetative replication. In contrast, transfection of molecularly cloned HPV-11 DNA resulted in replication of viral DNA in vitro. It seems likely that besides epithelial cell differentiation, a number of other factors influence HPV-16 replication.

Efficient self-assembly of human papillomavirus type 16 L1 and L1-L2 into virus-like particles

The L1 genes of two human papillomavirus type 16 (HPV16) isolates derived from condylomata acuminata were used to express the L1 major capsid protein in insect cells via recombinant baculoviruses. Both L1 major capsid proteins self-assembled into virus-like particles (VLP) with high efficiency and could be purified in preparative amounts on density gradients. The yield of VLP was 3 orders of magnitude higher than what has been obtained previously, using L1 derived from the prototype HPV16. DNA sequence comparison identified a single nonconserved amino acid change to be responsible for the inefficient self-assembly of the prototype L1. VLP were also obtained by expressing L1 of HPV6, HPV11, and cottontail rabbit papillomavirus, indicating that L1 from a variety of papillomaviruses has the intrinsic capacity to self-assemble into VLP. Coexpression of HPV16 L1 plus L2 by using a baculovirus double-expression vector also resulted in efficient self-assembly of VLP, and the average particle yield increased about fourfold in comparison to when L1 only was expressed. Coimmunoprecipitation of L1 and L2 and cosedimentation of the two proteins in a sucrose gradient demonstrated that L2 was incorporated into the particles. The ability to generate preparative amounts of HPV16 L1 and L1-L2 VLP may have implications for the development of a serological assay to detect anti-HPV16 virion immune responses to conformational epitopes and for immunoprophylaxis against HPV16 infection.

Evaluation of serum antibody response to a newly identified B-cell epitope in the minor nucleocapsid protein L2 of human papillomavirus type 16

The aim of this work was to identify B-cell epitopes in the minor nucleocapsid (L2) protein of human papillomavirus (HPV) type 16 and characterization of allied antibody response. Serum samples of 513 individuals (323 women with various degrees of cervical atypia, 150 men and 40 small children) were available for the study. Synthetic peptides overlapping the L2 protein of HPV 16 twice were applied in ELISA for epitope scanning and antibody determination. An HPV 16 L2 derived dodecamer SGYIPANTTIPF (amino acids 391-402) proved to be the major B-cell epitope. Both IgA antipeptide antibody positivity (range 7-28%) and mean IgA antibody levels (range 13.2 EIU to 42.4 EIU, P < 0.05) increased with the degree of cervical atypia, whereas antipeptide IgG antibodies showed an opposite trend. During a 2-years follow-up significantly (P < 0.0005) decreasing IgA antibody levels to the SGYIPANTTIPF peptide were associated with regression of koilocytotic atypia. Analysis of anti-peptide IgA antibodies of 118 women with known HPV type revealed that a majority of positives had HPV 16/18 DNA. It was concluded that antibody response to the newly discovered peptide was partially type- and disease-specific. Our results also suggest an impairment of the IgG but not IgA class antibody response to HPV 16 in patients with persistent cervical HPV infection.

In vivo cytokeratin-expression pattern of stratified squamous epithelium from human papillomavirus-type-16-immortalized ectocervical and foreskin keratinocytes

The association between human papillomavirus (HPV) type 16 and cervical squamous-cell carcinoma has been well documented, and HPV 16 DNA has been shown to immortalize human genital keratinocytes in vitro. Using a panel of cytokeratin(CK)-specific antibodies, we examined the CK expression pattern, an important characteristic of epithelia, of the stratified squamous epithelium reconstructed in vivo from monolayer cultures of 2 human ectocervical and 3 human foreskin keratinocyte cell lines immortalized by HPV 16 DNA. Whereas the abnormal epithelium formed from these grafts presented certain aspects of mature terminal differentiation, such as morphology and expression of CK10/11, the expression patterns for CK19, and especially CK13, were more obviously abnormal. CK18 expression was not detectable in any of the epithelia formed from the 5 cell lines. In contrast, for an HPV-16-immortalized endocervical cell line and the CaSki cervical-carcinoma cell line there was expression of CK18. Our results indicate that HPV-16-induced immortalization of keratinocytes is associated with disruption of the normal CK expression pattern in stratified squamous epithelium and that expression of particular CKs can be differentially disrupted.

Immunoelectron microscopical localization of human papillomavirus type 16 L1 and E4 proteins in cervical keratinocytes cultured in vivo

The human papillomavirus (HPV) causes warts, but is also associated with the development of squamous cell dysplasia and carcinoma. The virus is host and tissue specific and the numerous HPV types show predilection for different body sites. Experimental production of HPV 16 particles is at present only possible using in vivo culture of keratinocytes containing episomal viral DNA. Using immunoelectron microscopy, we have investigated the localization of HPV 16 E4 and L1 proteins in a keratinized epithelium formed by grafting HPV 16-containing cervical keratinocytes onto the athymic mouse. New viral progeny are produced in this system, as confirmed by labeling of intranuclear particles with a mouse monoclonal antibody against the HPV 16 major capsid (L1) protein. The role of the E4 protein is not yet clear, although it is believed to be important for the later stages of the virus life cycle. Here we confirm its cytoplasmic localization in the cells of the spinous and granular layers and demonstrate co-localization with keratin tonofilaments.

Infectious virus replication in papillomas induced by molecularly cloned cottontail rabbit papillomavirus DNA

The ability to obtain infectious papillomavirus virions from molecularly cloned DNA has not been previously reported. We demonstrate here that viral genomes isolated from a recombinant++ DNA clone of cottontail rabbit papillomavirus (CRPV) gave rise to infectious virus when inoculated into cottontail rabbit skin. Replication occurred in papillomas that formed at inoculation sites. Extract of a DNA-induced papilloma was serially passaged to naive rabbits with high efficiency. Complete virus was fractionated on cesium chloride density gradients, and papillomavirus particles were visualized by electron microscopy. CRPV DNA isolated from virions contained DNA sequence polymorphisms that are characteristic of the input CRPV-WA strain of virus, thereby proving that the newly generated virus originated from the molecularly cloned viral genome. These findings indicate that this will be a useful system in which to perform genetic analysis of viral gene functions involved in replication.

Towards vaccines against human papillomavirus type-16 genital infections

Human papillomavirus type-16 (HPV-16) is strongly associated with cervical carcinoma and cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. It may soon be possible to develop prophylactic vaccines designed to induce neutralizing antibodies to HPV-16 virions in genital secretions and therapeutic vaccines to induce cytotoxic T-cell responses against HPV-16 early proteins in cervical intraepithelial neoplasia and cervical cancers. Although significant advances have been achieved, problems remain before such vaccines can be used routinely.

Cervical cancer, human papillomavirus and vaccines

HPV-16 has been strongly implicated in the aetiology of cervical cancer and pre-malignant cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. Despite current technical difficulties it may soon be possible to treat these tumours with anti-HPV-16 vaccines. A prophylactic vaccine could, in theory, be developed to induce neutralizing antibodies to HPV-16 virions in genital secretions, and a therapeutic vaccine to elicit cytotoxic T-cell responses against established lesions.

Transient replication of human papillomavirus DNAs

Information on papillomavirus DNA replication has primarily derived from studies with bovine papillomavirus type 1 (BPV-1). Our knowledge of DNA replication of the human papillomaviruses (HPVs) is quite limited, in part because of the lack of a cell culture system capable of supporting the stable replication of HPV DNA. This study demonstrates that the full-length genomic DNAs of HPV types 11 and 18 (HPV-11 and HPV-18), but not HPV-16, are able to replicate transiently after transfection into several different human squamous cell carcinoma cell lines. This system was used to identify the viral cis and trans elements required for DNA replication. The viral origins of replication were localized to a region of the viral long control region. Like BPV-1, E1 and E2 were the only viral factors required in trans for the replication of plasmids containing the origin. Cotransfection of a plasmid expressing the E1 open reading frame (ORF) from HPV-11 with a plasmid that expresses the E2 ORF from HPV-6, HPV-11, HPV-16, or HPV-18 supported the replication of plasmid DNAs containing the origin regions of HPV-11, HPV-16, or HPV-18, indicating that there are functions shared among the corresponding E1 and E2 proteins and origins of these viruses. Although HPV-16 genomic DNA did not replicate by itself under experimental conditions that supported the replication of HPV-11 and HPV-18 genomic DNAs, expression of the HPV-16 early region functions from a strong heterologous promoter supported the replication of a cotransfected plasmid containing the HPV-16 origin of replication. This finding suggests that the inability of the HPV-16 genomic DNA to replicate transiently in the cell lines tested was most likely due to insufficient expression of the viral E1 and/or E2 genes required for DNA replication.

Biosynthesis of human papillomavirus from a continuous cell line upon epithelial differentiation

The study of the human pathogen papillomaviruses (HPVs) has been hampered by the inability to propagate the virus in tissue culture. The addition of 12-O-tetradecanoyl phorbol-13-acetate to the media of organotypic (raft) cultures increased expression of physiological markers of keratinocyte differentiation and concomitantly induced production of virions. Capsid production was detected in differentiated suprabasal cells. Virions approximately 54 nanometers in size were observed by electron microscopy in raft tissue cross sections in the suprabasal layers. Virions purified through isopycnic gradients were found to contain type 31b DNA and exhibited an icosahedral shape similar to that of papillomaviruses found in clinical samples.

Production of human papillomavirus and modulation of the infectious program in epithelial raft cultures. OFF

Human papillomaviruses trophic for anogenital epithelia cause benign warts, and certain genotypes are closely associated with cervical neoplasia. By using our modifications of the epithelial raft culture system, we were able to recapitulate and modulate the infectious program of a papillomavirus in vitro for the first time. Small pieces of a condyloma containing human papillomavirus type 11 were explanted onto a dermal equivalent consisting of a collagen matrix with fibroblasts and were cultured at the medium-air interface. The infected stem cells proliferated rapidly across the matrix, stratified, and differentiated, as judged by histology. The results correlated with the state of epithelial differentiation, which, in turn, was dependent on the type of fibroblast in the matrix. Under conditions where the epithelial outgrowth underwent terminal differentiation, the entire productive program took place, leading to virion assembly. In contrast, using an alternative condition where the outgrowth failed to achieve terminal differentiation, only the E-region RNAs from the E1 promoter accumulated to any appreciable extent. The proliferating cell nuclear antigen was induced in the differentiated suprabasal cells in the productive cyst growth, which also exhibited high copy viral DNA and abundant E6-E7 RNAs. Comparable cells in the nonproductive cyst outgrowth were negative for all three. These results suggest that the E6 and E7 proteins may play a role in establishing a cellular environment conducive to vegetative viral replication. The culture conditions described should be useful for genetic analysis of this family of important human pathogens and for testing potential pharmacological agents.

Replication of plasmid-derived human papillomavirus type 11 DNA in cultured keratinocytes

Plasmid-derived human papillomavirus type 11 (HPV11) DNA has been shown to replicate episomally and semiconservatively following transfection of primary human foreskin keratinocytes. HPV11 DNA was excised from the bacterial plasmid, religated to form circular molecules, and cotransfected along with pSV2Neo. Transfectants were selected and shown to contain replicated episomal HPV DNA. Once selected, HPV11 DNA persists in cells through at least two additional passages.