The herpes simplex virus type 1 major capsid protein (VP5-UL19) promoter contains two cis-acting elements influencing late expression

Adaptation of transgene mRNA translation boosts the anticancer efficacy of oncolytic HSV1

BACKGROUND

Transgenes deliver therapeutic payloads to improve oncolytic virus immunotherapy. Transgenes encoded within oncolytic viruses are designed to be highly transcribed, but protein synthesis is often negatively affected by viral infection, compromising the amount of therapeutic protein expressed. Studying the oncolytic herpes simplex virus-1 (HSV1), we found standard transgene mRNAs to be suboptimally translated in infected cells.

METHODS

Using RNA-Seq reads, we determined the transcription start sites and 5'leaders of HSV1 genes and uncovered the US11 5'leader to confer superior activity in translation reporter assays. We then incorporated this 5'leader into GM-CSF expression cassette in oncolytic HSV1 and compared the translationally adapted oncolytic virus with the conventional, leaderless, virus in vitro and in mice.

RESULTS

Inclusion of the US11 5'leader in the GM-CSF transgene incorporated into HSV1 boosted translation in vitro and in vivo. Importantly, treatment with US11 5'leader-GM-CSF oncolytic HSV1 showed superior antitumor immune activity and improved survival in a syngeneic mouse model of colorectal cancer as compared with leaderless-GM-CSF HSV1.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrates the therapeutic value of identifying and integrating platform-specific cis-acting sequences that confer increased protein synthesis on transgene expression.

Differential effects of Sp cellular transcription factors on viral promoter activation by varicella-zoster virus (VZV) IE62 protein

The immediate early (IE) 62 protein is the major varicella-zoster virus (VZV) regulatory factor. Analysis of the VZV genome revealed 40 predicted GC-rich boxes within 36 promoters. We examined effects of ectopic expression of Sp1-Sp4 on IE62- mediated transactivation of three viral promoters. Ectopic expression of Sp3 and Sp4 enhanced IE62 activation of ORF3 and gI promoters while Sp3 reduced IE62 activation of ORF28/29 promoter and VZV DNA replication. Sp2 reduced IE62 transactivation of gI while Sp1 had no significant influence on IE62 activation with any of these viral promoters. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSA) confirmed binding of Sp1 and Sp3 but not Sp2 and Sp4 to the gI promoter. Sp1-4 bound to IE62 and amino acids 238-258 of IE62 were important for the interaction with Sp3 and Sp4 as well as Sp1. This work shows that Sp family members have differential effects on IE62-mediated transactivation in a promoter-dependent manner.

Complexity of Interferon-γ Interactions with HSV-1

The intricacies involving the role of interferon-gamma (IFN-γ) in herpesvirus infection and persistence are complex. Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) uses a variety of receptors to enter cells and is transported to and from the host cell nucleus over the microtubule railroad via retrograde and anterograde transport. IFN-γ exerts dual but conflicting effects on microtubule organization. IFN-γ stimulates production of suppressors of cytokine signaling 1 and 3 (SOCS1 and SOCS3), which are involved in microtubule stability and are negative regulators of IFN-γ signaling when overexpressed. IFN-γ also interferes with the correct assembly of microtubules causing them to undergo severe bundling, contributing to its anti-viral effect. Factors leading to the decision for a replicative virus lytic cycle or latency in the trigeminal ganglion (TG) occur on histone 3 (H3), involve IFN-γ produced by natural killer cells and non-cytolytic CD8⁺T cells, SOCS1, SOCS3, and M2 anti-inflammatory microglia/macrophages maintained by inhibitory interleukin 10 (IL-10). Both M2 microglia and CD4⁺CD25⁺Foxp3⁺ Treg cells produce IL-10. Histone deacetylases (HDACs) are epigenetic regulators maintaining chromatin in an inactive state necessary for transcription of IFN-γ-activated genes and their anti-viral effect. Following inhibition of HDACs by stressors such as ultraviolet light, SOCS1 and SOCS3 are acetylated, and chromatin is relaxed and available for virus replication. SOCS1 prevents expression of MHC class 1 molecules on neuronal cells and SOCS3 attenuates cytokine-induced inflammation in the area. A model is presented to unify the effects of IFN-γ, SOCS1, SOCS3, and HSV-1 on H3 and chromatin structure in virus latency or reactivation. HSV-1 latency in the TG is viewed as an active ongoing process involving maintenance of microglia in an M2 anti-inflammatory state by IL-10. IL-10 is produced in an autocrine manner by the M2 microglia/macrophages and by virus-specific CD4⁺Foxp3⁺ Treg cells interacting with virus-specific non-cytolytic CD8⁺ T cells.

Suppression of transcription factor early growth response 1 reduces herpes simplex virus lethality in mice

Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) infection is the most common cause of sporadic, fatal encephalitis, but current understanding of how the virus interacts with cellular factors to regulate disease progression is limited. Here, we show that HSV-1 infection induced the expression of the cellular transcription factor early growth response 1 (Egr-1) in a human neuronal cell line. Egr-1 increased viral replication by activating promoters of viral productive cycle genes through binding to its corresponding sequences in the viral promoters. Mouse studies confirmed that Egr-1 expression was enhanced in HSV-1-infected brains and that Egr-1 functions to promote viral replication in embryonic fibroblasts. Furthermore, Egr-1 deficiency or knockdown of Egr-1 by a DNA-based enzyme greatly reduced the mortality of HSV-1-infected mice by decreasing viral loads in tissues. This study provides what we believe is the first evidence that Egr-1 increases the mortality of HSV-1 encephalitis by enhancing viral replication. Moreover, blocking this cellular machinery exploited by the virus could prevent host mortality.

Stabilized binding of TBP to the TATA box of herpes simplex virus type 1 early (tk) and late (gC) promoters by TFIIA and ICP4

We have recently shown that ICP4 has a differential requirement for the general transcription factor TFIIA in vitro (S. Zabierowski and N. DeLuca, J. Virol. 78:6162-6170, 2004). TFIIA was dispensable for ICP4 activation of a late promoter (gC) but was required for the efficient activation of an early promoter (tk). An intact INR element was required for proficient ICP4 activation of the late promoter in the absence of TFIIA. Because TFIIA is known to stabilize the binding of both TATA binding protein (TBP) and TFIID to the TATA box of core promoters and ICP4 has been shown to interact with TFIID, we tested the ability of ICP4 to stabilize the binding of either TBP or TFIID to the TATA box of representative early, late, and INR-mutated late promoters (tk, gC, and gC8, respectively). Utilizing DNase I footprinting analysis, we found that ICP4 was able to facilitate TFIIA stabilized binding of TBP to the TATA box of the early tk promoter. Using mutant ICP4 proteins, the ability to stabilize the binding of TBP to both the wild-type and the INR-mutated gC promoters was located in the amino-terminal region of ICP4. When TFIID was substituted for TBP, ICP4 could stabilize the binding of TFIID to the TATA box of the wild-type gC promoter. ICP4, however, could not effectively stabilize TFIID binding to the TATA box of the INR-mutated late promoter. The additional activities of TFIIA were required to stabilize the binding of TFIID to the INR-mutated late promoter. Collectively, these data suggest that TFIIA may be dispensable for ICP4 activation of the wild-type late promoter because ICP4 can substitute for TFIIA's ability to stabilize the binding of TFIID to the TATA box. In the absence of a functional INR, ICP4 can no longer stabilize TFIID binding to the TATA box of the late promoter and requires the additional activities of TFIIA. The stabilized binding of TFIID by TFIIA may in turn allow ICP4 to more efficiently activate transcription from non-INR containing promoters.

Differential cellular requirements for activation of herpes simplex virus type 1 early (tk) and late (gC) promoters by ICP4

The herpes simplex virus type 1 immediate-early protein, ICP4, activates the transcription of viral early and late genes and is essential for viral growth. It has been shown to bind DNA and interact with components of the general transcription machinery to activate or repress viral transcription, depending upon promoter context. Since early and late gene promoters have different architectures and cellular metabolism may be very different at early and late times after infection, the cellular requirements for ICP4-mediated activation of early and late genes may differ. This hypothesis was tested using tk and gC as representative early and late promoters, respectively. Nuclear extracts and phosphocellulose column fractions derived from nuclear extracts were able to reconstitute basal and ICP4-activated transcription of both promoters in vitro. When examining the contribution of the general transcription factors on the ability of ICP4 to activate transcription, the fraction containing the general transcription factor TFIIA was not essential for ICP4 activation of the gC promoter, but it was required for efficient activation of the tk promoter. The addition of recombinant TFIIA restored the ability of ICP4 to efficiently activate the tk promoter, but it had no net effect on activation of the gC promoter. The dispensability of TFIIA for ICP4 activation of the gC promoter required an intact INR element. In addition, microarray and Northern blot analysis indicated that TFIIA abundance may be reduced at late times of infection. This decrease in TFIIA expression during infection and its dispensability for activation of late but not early genes suggest one of possibly many mechanisms for the transition from viral early to late gene expression.

Multiple 5′ ends of human cytomegalovirus UL57 transcripts identify a complex, cycloheximide-resistant promoter region that activates oriLyt

The human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) UL57 gene lies adjacent to HCMV oriLyt, from which it is separated by an organizationally conserved, mostly noncoding region that is thought to both regulate UL57 expression and activate oriLyt function. However, the UL57 promoter has not been studied. We determined the 5' ends of UL57 transcripts toward an understanding of the potential relationship between UL57 expression and oriLyt activation. The results presented here identified three distinct 5' ends spread over 800 bp, at nt 90302, 90530, and 91138; use of these sites exhibited differential sensitivity to phosphonoformic acid treatment. Interestingly, a 10-kb UL57 transcript accumulated in cycloheximide-treated infected cells, even though other early transcripts were not detectable. However, the 10-kb transcript did not accumulate in cells treated with the more stringent translation inhibitor anisomycin. Consistent with the notion that the identified 5' ends arise from distinct transcription start sites, the sequences upstream of sites I and II functioned as promoters responsive to HCMV infection in transient assays. However, the origin-proximal promoter region III required downstream sequences for transcriptional activity. Mutation of candidate core promoter elements suggested that promoter III is regulated by an initiator region (Inr) and a downstream promoter element. Finally, a 42-bp sequence containing the candidate Inr activated a minimal oriLyt core construct in transient replication assays. Thus, these studies showed that a large, complex promoter region with novel features controls UL57 expression, and identified a sequence that regulates both UL57 transcription and oriLyt activation.

The initiator element in a herpes simplex virus type 1 late-gene promoter enhances activation by ICP4, resulting in abundant late-gene expression

The start site regions of late genes of herpes simplex virus type 1 are similar to the eukaryotic initiator sequence (Inr), have been shown to affect the levels of expression, and may also play a role in transcription activation by the viral activator ICP4. A series of linker-scanning mutations spanning the start site of transcription and several downstream mutations in the true late gC promoter were analyzed in reconstituted in vitro transcription reactions with and without ICP4, as well as in the context of the viral genome during infection. The nucleotide contacts previously found to be important for Inr function were also found to be important for optimal induction by ICP4. While the Inr had a substantial effect on the accumulation of gC RNA during infection, no other sequence downstream of the TATA box to +124 had a significant effect on levels of expression during infection. Therefore, these studies suggest that TATA box and the Inr are the only cis-acting elements required to achieve optimal expression of gC, and that the high levels of late-gene transcription may be largely due to the induction by ICP4, functioning through the Inr element.

Regulation of herpes simplex virus gene expression

Expression of the more than 80 individual genes of herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) takes place in a tightly regulated sequential manner that was first described over 20 years ago. Investigations since that time have focused on understanding the mechanisms that regulate this orderly and efficient expression of viral genes. This review examines recent findings that have shed light on how this process is regulated during productive infection of the cell. Although the story is still not complete, several aspects of HSV gene expression are now clearer as a result of these findings. In particular, several new functions have recently been ascribed to some of the known viral regulatory proteins. The results indicate that the viral gene expression is regulated through transcriptional as well as post-transcriptional mechanisms. In addition, it has become increasingly clear that the virus has evolved specific functions to interact with the host cell in order to divert and redirect critical host functions for its own needs. Understanding the interactions of HSV and the host cell during infection will be essential for a complete understanding of how viral gene expression is regulated. Future challenges in the field will be to develop a complete understanding of the mechanisms that temporally regulate virus gene expression, and to identify and characterize the relevant interactions between the virus and the distinctive cell types normally infected by the virus.

Two leaky-late HSV-1 promoters differ significantly in structural architecture

The HSV-1 VP5 and VP16 transcripts are expressed with leaky-late (gamma1) kinetics and reach maximal levels after viral DNA replication. While the minimal VP5 promoter includes only an Sp1 site at -48, a TATA box at -30, and an initiator (Inr) element at the cap site, here we show that elements upstream of -48 can functionally compensate for the mutational loss of the critical Sp1 site at -48. To determine whether this is a general feature of leaky-late promoters, we have carried out a detailed analysis of the VP16 promoter in the context of the viral genome at the gC locus. Sequence analysis suggests a great deal of similarity between the two. Despite this, however, mutational analysis revealed that the 5' boundary of the VP16 promoter extends to ca. -90. This region includes an Sp1 binding site at -46, CAAT box homology at -77, and "E box" (CACGTG) at -85. Mutational and deletional analyses demonstrate that the proximal Sp1 site plays little or no role in promoter strength; despite this it can be shown to bind Sp1 protein using DNA mobility shift assays. Like the VP5 promoter, the VP16 promoter also requires an initiator element at the cap site. The VP16 Inr element differs in sequence from that of the VP5 promoter, and its deletion or mutation has a significantly smaller effect on promoter strength. The difference between these two Inr elements was confirmed by our finding that the VP16 initiator element binds to the 65-kDa YY1 transcription factor, and the VP5 Inr element competes poorly for the binding between the VP16 element and infected cell proteins in comparative bandshift assays. While the VP16 Inr sequence is identical to that of several murine TATA-less promoters, the VP16 Inr requires a TATA box for measurable activity.

The exchange of cognate TATA boxes results in a corresponding change in the strength of two HSV-1 early promoters

Previous analysis of two Herpes Simplex Virus Type-1 (HSV-1) promoters controlling expression of mRNA encoding early genes (U(L)37 and U(L)50) showed that the U(L)50 (dUTPase) promoter is at least 6-fold stronger both in its normal genomic location and in the non-essential gC locus. In the present report we demonstrate that the TATA element of either promoter is the major determinant of promoter strength. When the U(L)37 TATA element (CGTATAAC) was mutated with two base changes to the U(L)50 TATA sequence (CATAAAAC) in recombinant viruses, the activity of the U(L)37 promoter was increased to that of the U(L)50 promoter. Conversely, when the U(L)50 TATA element was changed to that of the U(L)37 promoter, U(L)50 promoter activity was reduced to the level of the U(L)37 promoter. In addition, we investigated the spacing of the TATA box with respect to upstream promoter elements. We found that re-positioning the U(L)37 TATA box to a location equivalent to that of the U(L)50 promoter relative to the transcript start site; i.e. three bases upstream of its cognate location, significantly diminished activity. Substitution of the U(L)50 TATA box at the new position could only partially restore promoter activity. Thus, we also conclude that the spacing of TATA elements vis-à-vis upstream promoter elements is also a critical determinant of promoter strength.

The kinetics of VP5 mRNA expression is not critical for viral replication in cultured cells

We generated recombinant viruses in which the kinetics of expression of the leaky-late VP5 mRNA was altered. We then analyzed the effect of such alterations on viral replication in cultured cells. The VP5 promoter and leader sequences from positions -36 to +20, containing the TATA box and an initiator element, were deleted and replaced with a strong early (dUTPase), an equal-strength leaky-late (VP16), or a strict-late (U(L)38) promoter. We found that recombinant viruses containing the dUTPase promoter inserted in the VP5 locus expressed VP5-encoding mRNA with early kinetics, while virus with the U(L)38 promoter inserted expressed such mRNA with strict-late kinetics. Further, in spite of differences in its functional architecture, the VP16 promoter fully substituted for the VP5 promoter. Western blot analysis demonstrated that the amounts of VP5 capsid protein produced by the recombinant viruses differed somewhat; however, on complementing C32 and noncomplementing Vero cells, such viruses replicated to titers equivalent to those of the rescued wild-type virus controls. Multistep virus growth in mouse embryo fibroblasts, rabbit skin cells, and Vero cells also demonstrated equivalent replication efficiencies for both recombinant and wild-type viruses. Further, recombinant viruses did not show any impairment in their ability to replicate on serum-starved or quiescent human lung fibroblasts. We conclude that the kinetics of the essential VP5 mRNA expression is not critical for viral replication in cultured cells.

Regulation of herpesvirus replication by subcellular compartmentalization

The transcriptional regulation of herpesvirus gene expression has been well documented. A second model is proposed that is superimposed on regulation at the transcriptional level. The regulation is post-translational in nature. Three examples of the model are found in viral DNA replication, capsid assembly, and the cleavage and packaging of DNA into capsids. For each example, at least one viral protein depends upon an interaction with a second viral protein for transport into the nucleus. A model is proposed whereby these protein-protein interactions control the efficiency of these processes by the formation of the appropriate protein complexes in the cytoplasm. The model predicts that these interactions impose a necessary control and that mechanisms to bypass this control would deleteriously affect virus replication. It is probable that level of regulation extends for each of these processes among other herpesviruses.

Characterization of the initiator and downstream promoter elements of herpes simplex virus 1 late genes

Previously identified cis-acting regulatory elements of herpes simplex virus (HSV) 1 late promoters include a TATA element upstream from the start of transcription, an initiator-like element at the start of transcription, and sequences downstream from the start of transcription. To determine whether these elements are functionally equivalent to similar elements from other eukaryotic genes, model late promoters were constructed using well-characterized regulatory elements from non-HSV genes. These modular promoters were then inserted into the viral genome upstream from a lacZ marker gene. Results showed that a eukaryotic initiator element, along with a TATA element, can function as a late HSV promoter. Several initiator sequences from both viral and nonviral genes were functionally similar to the initiator-like element in HSV-1 late promoters; however, a random sequence of the same size and a similarly located sequence from the HSV-1 early thymidine kinase promoter could not substitute for the initiator element. These results indicate that eukaryotic initiator elements are functionally equivalent to HSV-1 late promoter initiator elements. In addition, the downstream element of the late glycoprotein C promoter was further analyzed by construction of a series of small deletions and insertions. The presence of the downstream glycoprotein C region in a promoter consisting of a strong TATA and initiator element increased mRNA expression by a modest amount; this effect appeared to be sequence specific and dependent on its exact alignment with the upstream elements of the promoter.

Analysis of factors influencing kinetics of herpes simplex virus transcription utilizing recombinant virus

The herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) transcription program is a regulated cascade in which early and late phases of gene expression are separated by viral DNA replication. While promoters controlling expression of transcripts encoding immediate-early proteins contain virus-specific cis-acting elements, these are in the context of cellular promoter elements, and the promoters controlling expression of other viral transcripts contain only cellular cis-acting elements. We had developed and continue to refine a general method for the production of recombinant viruses in which modified promoters can be inserted into nonessential loci within the viral genome through homologous recombination. This approach has been especially useful in defining the features of model promoters of the various kinetic classes. Our work suggests that class-specific differences in promoter architecture are critical factors in the ability of the cellular transcription machinery to form stable preinitiation complexes at various phases of infection and, thus, mediate kinetic class-specific transcription. Early (beta) promoters contain a TATA box and upstream activation elements while sequences downstream of the TATA homology are dispensible for transcription. Late transcripts can be catagorized as either leaky-late (beta gamma) or strict late (gamma) depending on whether they are readily detectable prior to viral DNA replication. Promoters controlling both types are clearly distinct from early ones in that sequences near the transcription start site which resemble consensus mammalian initiator elements are required along with the TATA box and activator elements. Strict late promoters do not contain elements upstream of the TATA box but include what appears to be a class specific element downstream of the transcription start site.

Identification of positive and negative regulatory regions involved in regulating expression of the human cytomegalovirus UL94 late promoter: role of IE2-86 and cellular p53 in mediating negative regulatory function

The human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) UL94 gene product is a herpesvirus-common virion protein that is expressed with true late kinetics. To identify the important cis- and trans-acting factors which contribute to UL94 transcriptional regulation, we have cloned, sequenced, and analyzed UL94 promoter function by transient transfection analysis. Transfection of UL94 promoter-reporter gene constructs into permissive human fibroblasts or U373(MG) cells indicated that promoter activity was detected following infection with HCMV. Point mutations within a TATA-like element located upstream of the RNA start site significantly reduced UL94 promoter activity. Deletion mutagenesis of the promoter indicated that a positive regulatory element (PRE) was likely to exist downstream of the UL94 mRNA start site, while a negative regulatory element (NRE) was present upstream of the TATA box. At late times of infection, the PRE appeared to have a dominant effect over the NRE to stimulate maximum levels of UL94 promoter activity, while at earlier times of infection, no activity associated with the PRE could be detected. The NRE, however, appeared to cause constitutive down-regulation of UL94 promoter activity. Binding sites for the cellular p53 protein located within the NRE appeared to contribute to NRE function, and NRE function could be recapitulated in cotransfection assays by concomitant expression of p53 and HCMV IE2-86 protein. Our results suggest a novel mechanism by which the cellular protein p53, which is involved in both transcriptional regulation and progression of cellular DNA synthesis, plays a central role in the regulation of a viral promoter which is not activated prior the onset of viral DNA replication.

The herpes simplex virus type 1 VP5 promoter contains a cis-acting element near the cap site which interacts with a cellular protein

The promoter controlling the expression of the transcript encoding the major herpes simplex virus type 1 capsid protein (VP5, UL19) extends only 60 bases or so from a functional Sp1 site at --48 to include a cis-acting element 3' of the transcript start site. In the present communication, we report the generation of recombinant viruses bearing mutations between --6 and + 8 relative to the cap site in the VP5 promoter controlling expression of a reporter gene. Analysis of the effects of these mutations upon reporter gene expression along with the results of protein binding assays demonstrates that this cap transcription element functionally interacts with a cellular protein of a normal size of 40 kDa. Thus, like the strict late UL38 promoter characterized earlier, the late VP5 promoter has the essential properties of a cellular promoter.

Herpes simplex virus recombination vectors designed to allow insertion of modified promoters into transcriptionally "neutral" segments of the viral genome

The use of recombinant viruses has been essential in investigation of the biology of herpes simplex virus (HSV). In this communication we describe a number of viral recombination vectors that we have generated for use in promoter structure/function analysis within the context of the HSV-1 genome. We have utilized two regions of the HSV genome that contain genes nonessential for replication in cultured cells--the glycoprotein C (gC or UL44) locus in the UL of the genome and the area encompassing the promoter and 5' portion of the latency associated transcript (LAT) within the RL factual influence on promoters due to the site of insertion. Two different kinetic promoters were analyzed, those controlling expression of the gamma UL 38 and the beta dUTPase genes, in both loci. All constructs tested displayed reporter gene mRNA expression with expected kinetics, and we conclude that there are no neighboring cryptic promoter elements that could interfere with expression studies using the vectors described.

Transcriptional activation of the herpes simplex virus type 1 UL38 promoter conferred by the cis-acting downstream activation sequence is mediated by a cellular transcription factor

The herpes simplex virus (HSV) type 1 strict late (gamma) UL38 promoter contains three cis-acting transcriptional elements: a TATA box, a specific initiator element, and the downstream activation sequence (DAS). DAS is located between positions +20 and +33 within the 5' untranslated leader region and strongly influences transcript levels during productive infection. In this communication, we further characterize DAS and investigate its mechanism of action. DAS function has a strict spacing requirement, and DAS contains an essential 6-bp core element. A similarly positioned element from the gamma gC gene (UL44) has partial DAS function within the UL38 promoter context, and the promoter controlling expression of the gamma US11 transcript contains an identically located element with functional and sequence similarity to UL38 DAS. These data suggest that downstream elements are a common feature of many HSV gamma promoters. Results with recombinant viruses containing modifications of the TATA box or initiator element of the UL38 promoter suggest that DAS functions to increase transcription initiation and not the efficiency of transcription elongation. In vitro transcription assays using uninfected HeLa nuclear extracts show that, as in productive infection with recombinant viruses, the deletion of DAS from the UL38 promoter dramatically decreases RNA expression. Finally, electrophoretic mobility shift assays and UV cross-linking experiments show that DAS DNA forms a specific, stable complex with a cellular protein (the DAS-binding factor) of approximately 35 kDa. These data strongly suggest that the interaction of cellular DAS-binding factor with DAS is required for efficient expression of UL38 and other HSV late genes.