A 9L gliosarcoma transplantation model for studying adoptive immunotherapy into the brains of conscious rats

Animal models for vaccine therapy

Animal models are important for defining paradigms of tumor immunology and for evaluating therapeutic efficacy of immunotherapy. Many animal models have been used for evaluating in vivo characteristics of malignant gliomas and their responses to therapy. No animal model, however, is perfect because malignant glioma has a very heterogeneous biological behavior. There are so many parallels between mouse and human immunology, but there are significant discrepancies in immune system. Animal models for vaccine therapy can be classified as transplantable tumor models and models of spontaneous tumor in genetically engineered animals. Although transplantable tumor models have been used to test immunotherapeutic efficacy and remain a mainstay in study of brain tumor immunology, a lot of tumor vaccines that look promising in experimental animals have turned out to be ineffective clinically. Recent advances of laboratory techniques and understanding of genetic and molecular characteristics of gliomas allows for animal models of gliomas with similar biologic characteristics. Well-designed glioma models that accurately reflect the biology, pathology and clinical behaviors of human gliomas can provide more useful preclinical informations to predict clinical efficacy of novel immunotherapies and cancer vaccines.

Microglia phagocytose alloreactive CTL-damaged 9L gliosarcoma cells

Intracranial adoptive transfers of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (aCTL) for brain tumor treatment were safe and showed promise in preclinical and early clinical trials. To better understand the endogenous immune responses that may ensue following cellular therapy with aCTL, we examined the ability of microglia to phagocytose aCTL-damaged and undamaged rat 9L gliosarcoma cells in vitro and in vivo. In vitro, 5.5+/-0.9% of microglial cells isolated from adult tumor-bearing rat brains phagocytosed aCTL-damaged 9L cells, whereas microglia did not bind to or ingest undamaged 9L cells. Addition of supernates from either 9L cell cultures or from aCTL+9L co-incubate cell cultures to microglia did not significantly alter their ability to bind to or phagocytose damaged glioma cells even though the latter contained T helper 1 and 2 cytokines. At 3 days following intracranial 9L cell infusion, 17.5+/-0.1% of the microglia phagocytosed CFSE-labeled aCTL-damaged 9L tumor cells within the adult rat brain, confirming the in vitro data. The results suggest that microglia within the tumor microenvironment of the adult rat glioma model selectively remove damaged, but not undamaged, glioma cells.

Interactions of the allogeneic effector leukemic T cell line, TALL-104, with human malignant brain tumors

TALL-104 is a human leukemic T cell line that expresses markers characteristic of both cytotoxic T lymphocytes and natural killer cells. TALL-104 cells are potent tumor killers, and the use of lethally irradiated TALL-104 as cellular therapy for a variety of tumors has been explored. We investigated the interactions of TALL-104 cells with human brain tumor cells. TALL-104 cells mediated increased lysis of a panel of brain tumor cells at low effector-to-target ratios over time. We obtained evidence that TALL-104 cells injured glioma cells by both apoptotic and necrotic pathways. A 7-amino actinomycin D flow cytometry assay revealed that the percentages of both apoptotic and necrotic glioma cells increased after TALL-104 cell/glioma cell coincubations. Fluorescent microscopy studies and a quantitative morphologic assay confirmed that TALL-104 cell/glioma cell interactions resulted in tumor cell apoptosis. Cytokines are secreted when TALL-104 cells are coincubated with brain tumor cells; however, morphologic analysis assays revealed that the soluble factors contained within clarified supernates obtained from 4 h coincubates added back to brain tumor cell cultures did not trigger the glioma apoptosis. TALL-104 cells do not express Fas ligand, even upon coincubation with glioma targets, which suggests that the Fas/Fas ligand apoptotic pathway is not likely responsible for the cell injury observed. We obtained evidence that cell injury is calcium dependent and that lytic granule exocytosis is triggered by contact of TALL-104 cells with human glioma cells, suggesting that this pathway mediates glioma cell apoptosis and necrosis.

Human alloreactive CTL interactions with gliomas and with those having upregulated HLA expression from exogenous IFN-gamma or IFN-gamma gene modification

By flow cytometry, a panel of 18 primary glioma cell explants exhibited high expression of class I HLA-A, B, C, but class II HLA-DR expression was absent. Freshly isolated normal brain cells displayed little or no HLA antigens. Alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (aCTL), sensitized to the HLA of the patient, were generated in a one-way mixed lymphocyte response (MLR). The specificity of aCTL was confirmed to be to target cells (patient glioma cells or lymphoblasts) expressing the relevant HLA antigens. However, nontumor patient-specific aCTL did not lyse normal brain cells. Titration of antibodies to HLA class I into cytotoxicity assays blocked lysis of gliomas by aCTL, confirming aCTL T cell receptor (TCR) interactions with the class I antigen on gliomas. Furthermore, aCTL interactions with glioma cells caused their apoptosis. Coincubations of aCTL with gliomas resulted in upregulated cytokine secretion. Importantly, dexamethasone, an immunosuppressive steroid used for brain edema, did not affect aCTL lytic function against tumor, indicating that steroid-dependent patients may benefit from the immunotherapy. We also explored the use of interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) to increase aCTL tumor recognition. Coincubation of gliomas with exogenous IFN-gamma (500 U/ml, 48 h) caused a 3-fold upregulation of HLA class I and a slight induction of class II antigen expression. Gene-modified glioma cells producing IFN-gamma similarly displayed upregulated HLA expression. Glioma cells incubated with exogenous IFN-gamma or IFN-gamma-transduced glioma cells were more susceptible to lysis by aCTL than their parental counterparts, thus supporting the concept of combining IFN-gamma cytokine gene therapy with adoptive aCTL immunotherapy for brain tumor treatment.

Gamma interferon transduced 9L gliosarcoma. Cytokine gene therapy and its relevance to cellular therapy with alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes

In earlier studies, we demonstrated that intratumoral infusions of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (aCTL), sensitized to the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens of the host, effectively retarded the intracranial growth of Fischer 9L gliosarcoma. We further demonstrated that continuous in vitro exposure to gamma-interferon (gammaIFN) upregulates MHC on 9L gliosarcoma cells and that they were better targets of anti-Fischer aCTL. We hypothesized that the efficacy of cellular therapy with aCTL could be further improved by in situ transduction of the tumor with retroviral vectors coding for gammaIFN, which would generate continuous secretion of the cytokine and maintain upregulated MHC expression by the tumor cells. 9L gliosarcoma and Herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (tk) transductants of those cells were transduced with a retrovirus carrying the murine gammaIFN gene. By limiting dilution, clones of these cells, designated 9Lgamma 7, 9Lgamma tk8, and 9Lgamma tk10, which produced similar levels of gammaIFN (383-411 ng gammaIFN/10(6) cells/24 h) were isolated. The production of gammaIFN by one clone, 9Lgamma 7, was stable when monitored over 6 weeks in vitro. The clones also demonstrated upregulated MHC class I expression, and the tk-transduced clones maintained their sensitivity to ganciclovir. Compared to the wildtype cells, 9Lgamma 7 had approximate 6- and 1.5-fold increases in the relative antigen densities of MHC I and II, respectively. Addition of exogenous gammaIFN to 9Lgamma 7 cultures did not significantly increase the MHC expression. In cytotoxicity assays, 9Lgamma 7 cells, or 9Lgamma 7 incubated with exogenous gammaIFN, were better targets of aCTL than the parental 9L cells. The growth rate of 9Lgamma-transduced cells was decreased compared to the wildtype cells both in vitro and in vivo. Proliferation studies with transwell plated 9L, 9Lgamma 7, and 9Lgamma tk10 cells in various combinations revealed that the secreted cytokine itself caused a decrease in proliferation. However, the transduced cells exhibited a much reduced growth rate, which likely was a consequence of redirected metabolic activity of the cells. In vivo growth of the 9L and 9Lgamma 7 tumors in rat brains given identical inoculums similarly demonstrated significantly reduced 9Lgamma 7 tumor volumes at various timepoints, indicative of slower growth of the gammaIFN-producing tumors.

Characterization of 9L glioma model of the Wistar rat

The aim of our study was to develop and characterize solid brain tumors in Wistar rats, which could be used in investigations concerning the molecular mechanisms that lay beneath the genesis of the gliomas as well as in the testing of curative potentials of various therapeutics. The tumors were induced by intracerebral inoculation of 9L glioma cells and characterized by morphometrical, histological and immunohistochemical analysis after 7, 14 and 21 postimplantation days. Immunohistochemical characterization included detection of the nuclear antigene Ki-67 as the proliferative cell marker, GFAP as a tracer of reactive gliosis surrounding the tumor mass, and CD4/CD8 and ED1 antigens, as markers of the immunological response. Our results showed that after 7 days all experimental animals developed solid, well-circumcised tumors, which were clearly separated from the surrounding brain tissue. Tumors showed progressive growth from the 7th to the 21st day despite the observed immunological response starting after 14 days. Histologically tumors were hypercellular with neovascularization and necrosis. These results indicate that reproducible morphometric evaluation can be performed on 9L tumors growing in immunocompetent Wistar rats, enabling its use as an animal tumor model for the evaluation of various therapeutic approaches.

Effects of IFN-gamma and interleukin-1beta on major histocompatibility complex antigen and intercellular adhesion molecule-1 expression by 9L gliosarcoma: relevance to its cytolysis by alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes

To enhance the efficacy of cellular immunotherapy for gliomas, we tested the concept of using proinflammatory cytokine treatment with interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) or interleukin-1beta (IL-1beta) or both to render glioma cells more susceptible to cytolysis by alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (aCTL). The cytokines, separately or in combination, were able to upregulate major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I antigen or intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1) on Fischer rat 9L gliosarcoma cells. 9L cells were incubated in vitro for 24, 48, or 72 h with varying concentrations of rat IFN-gamma (0-2000 U/ml) or recombinant human IL-1 (rHUIL-1) (0-1000 U/ml) or both. By 48 h, IFN-gamma (500 U/ml) maximally induced the percentage of positive expressing cells and the relative antigen density of MHC class I and ICAM-1 on 9L cells, whereas IL-1 induced only ICAM-1 expression. Simultaneous incubation of IL-1 with IFN-gamma did not further affect the induction of class I on 9L cells more than that achieved with IFN-gamma alone. 9L cells with upregulated MHC class I and ICAM-1 expression were more sensitive to lysis by aCTL in in vitro cytotoxicity assays, regardless of whether the precursor aCTL came from naive or from 9L-immunized rats. Furthermore, inhibition of 9L cytotoxicity in assays that included blocking antibodies to MHC class I or to ICAM-1 revealed that T cell receptor (TCR) interactions with MHC class I and that ICAM-1 interactions with lymphocyte function-associated-1 (LFA-1) antigen account for a portion of the glioma lysis by aCTL.

Immunologic approaches to therapy for brain tumors

Malignant brain tumors are notoriously invasive. Although surgical debulking can relieve the patient of the main mass of tumor, adjuvant treatments are needed to target the glioma cells that infiltrate through normal parenchyma as single cells or pockets of tumor cells from which recurrent tumors arise. Successful adjuvant cellular therapy of brain tumors, or activation of endogenous immune cells, requires that either cell effectors make direct contact with tumor cells or come within close proximity to them and exert an indirect effect. This review examines current clinical trials aimed at direct lysis of glioma cells and trials making gliomas more visible to the endogenous immune system.

Limitations of the C6/Wistar rat intracerebral glioma model: implications for evaluating immunotherapy

OBJECTIVE

Intracranial rat glioma models are a useful method for evaluating the efficacy and toxicity of novel therapies for malignant glioma. The C6/Wistar model has been used extensively as a reproducible in vivo model for studying primary brain tumors including anti-glioma immune responses. The objective of the present study is to provide in vivo evidence that the C6 rat glioma model is allogeneic within Wistar rats and is therefore inappropriate for evaluating immune responses.

METHODS

Growth patterns and immune responses of C6 cells implanted into the brain and flank of Wistar rats were analyzed and compared to an immunogenic syngeneic model (9L/Fischer).

RESULTS

Wistar rats with C6 tumors developed a potent humoral and cellular immune response to the tumor. Wistar rats given simultaneous flank and intracerebral tumors had a survival rate of 100% compared to an 11% survival rate in control animals receiving only intracranial C6 cells.

CONCLUSION

The C6 rat glioma induces a vigorous immune reaction that may mimic a specific anti-tumor response in Wistar rats. Efficacy of immunotherapy within this model must be cautiously interpreted.

Interleukin-2 and histamine in combination inhibit tumour growth and angiogenesis in malignant glioma

Biotherapy including interleukin-2 (IL-2) treatment seems to be more effective outside the central nervous system when compared to the effects obtained when the same tumour is located intracerebrally. Recently published studies suggest that reduced activity of NK cells in tumour tissue can be increased by histamine. The present study was designed to determine whether IL-2 and histamine, alone or in combination, can induce anti-tumour effects in an orthotopic rat glioma model. One group of rats was treated with histamine alone (4 mg kg(-1)s.c. as daily injections from day 6 after intracranial tumour implantation), another group with IL-2 alone as a continuous subcutaneous infusion and a third group with both histamine and IL-2. The animals were sacrificed at day 24 after tumour implantation. IL-2 and histamine in combination significantly reduced tumour growth. The microvessel density was significantly reduced, an effect mainly affecting the small vessels. No obvious alteration in the pattern of VEGF mRNA expression was evident and no significant changes in apoptosis were observed. Neither IL-2 nor histamine alone caused any detectable effects on tumour growth. Histamine caused an early and pronounced decline in tumour blood flow compared to normal brain. The results indicate that the novel combination of IL-2 and histamine can be of value in reducing intracerebral tumour growth and, thus, it might be of interest to re-evaluate the therapeutic potential of biotherapy in malignant glioma.

Morphometrical characterization of two glioma models in the brain of immunocompetent and immunodeficient rats

Although several glioma models exist, systematic morphometrical studies on such experimental tumors are lacking. The purpose of this study was the quantitative assessment of how rat strains, cell lines, injection techniques and location affect tumors reproducibility and histopathological features. Glioma cells were implanted in 3 brain locations, with different injection techniques (free hand, stereotactic, water-tight device), variable volumes, cell concentrations and infusion rates. Tumors were developed from 2 rat glioma cell lines (9L and C6) in immunocompetent (Wistar and Fischer 344) and immunodeficient rats (New Zealand). Animals underwent daily neurological examination. At the scheduled time the tumors were macro and microscopically evaluated and a quantitative morphometrical analysis was performed. C6 gliomas appeared very infiltrative and irregularly shaped; 9L gliomas showed, by using the same injection technique, a grossly regular shape. Margins at the tumor-brain interface were macroscopically demarcated in the immunocompetent rats. In the nude rats, 9L tumors appeared microscopically more infiltrative, although regularly shaped, with a closer morphological resemblance to human gliomas. The implantation in the frontal area, anterior to the nucleus caudatus (3 mm anterior the coronal suture) gave reproducible tumor shape and size, no hydrocephalus and no early neurological deterioration. The use of a stereotactic technique or of a water-tight device, small volume (< 10 microl) of cell suspension, low infusion rate were useful to reduce morbidity and to improve data reproducibility. No difference in morbidity and mortality were observed in immunocompetent and immunodeficient rats. The 9L glioma model with stereotactic implantation constitutes a good option for reliable morphometrical evaluation of tumor growth. We propose a location for tumor implantation anterior to the nucleus caudatus. This produced the longest symptom-free survival.

Rat brain tumor models in experimental neuro-oncology: the 9L, C6, T9, F98, RG2 (D74), RT-2 and CNS-1 gliomas

Rat brain tumor models have been widely used in experimental neuro-oncology for almost three decades. The present review, which will be selective rather than comprehensive, will focus entirely on seven rat brain tumor models and their utility in evaluating the efficacy of various therapeutic modalities. Although no currently available animal brain tumor model exactly simulates human high grade brain tumors, the rat models that are currently available have provided a wealth of information on in vitro and in vivo biochemical and biological properties of brain tumors and their in vivo responses to various therapeutic modalities. Ideally, valid brain tumor models should be derived from glial cells, grow in vitro and in vivo with predictable and reproducible growth patterns that simulate human gliomas, be weakly or non-immunogenic, and their response to therapy, or lack thereof, should resemble human brain tumors. The following tumors will be discussed. The 9L gliosarcoma, which was chemically induced in an inbred Fischer rat, has been one of the most widely used of all rat brain tumor models and has provided much useful information relating to brain tumor biology and therapy. The T9 glioma, although generally unrecognized, was and probably still is the same as the 9L. Both of these tumors can be immunogenic under the appropriate circumstances, and this must be taken into consideration when using either of them for studies of therapeutic efficacy, especially if survival is used as an endpoint. The C6 glioma, which was chemically induced in an outbred Wistar rat, has been extensively used for a variety of studies, but is not syngeneic to any inbred strain. Its potential to evoke an alloimmune response is a serious limitation, if it is being used in survival studies. The F98 and RG2 (D74) gliomas were both chemically induced tumors that appear to be either weakly or non-immunogenic. These tumors have been refractory to a variety of therapeutic modalities and their invasive pattern of growth and uniform lethality following an innoculum of as few as 10 tumor cells make them particularly attractive models to test new therapeutic modalities. The Avian Sarcoma Virus induced tumors and a continuous cell line derived from one of them, designated RT-2, have been useful for studies in which de novo tumor induction is an important requirement. These tumors, however, are immunogenic and this may limit their usefulness for survival studies. Finally, a new chemically induced tumor recently has been described, the CNS-1, and it appears to have a number of properties that should make it useful in experimental neuro-oncology. It is essential to recognize, however, the limitations of each of the models that have been described, and depending upon the nature of the study to be conducted, it is important that the appropriate model be selected.

Intracranial administrations of single or multiple source allogeneic cytotoxic T lymphocytes: chronic therapy for primary brain tumors

Previous investigations by our group demonstrated the efficacy of single source allogeneic cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) given multiple times in reducing or curing tumor burden in the rat 9L gliosarcoma model. In this study, the lack of toxicity to normal brain when single source allogeneic CTLs were intracranially administered multiple times is documented. Additionally, the efficacy and lack of toxicity of allogeneic CTLs from multiple sources, each given once is documented. CTLs sensitized to Fischer antigen were prepared from major histocompatibility complex incompatible DA, PVG, Sprague-Dawley and Wistar-Furth rat lymphocytes. CTLs from multiple donors were administered one time each to Fischer rats bearing established 9L tumor at staggered intervals over a two week period and survival was monitored in relation to a sham treated group. Additional groups of nontumor-bearing rats received either multiple source allogeneic CTLs or single source DA anti Fischer CTLs in the same treatment regimen. Histological evaluation of the nontumor-bearing brains receiving either single or multiple source allogeneic CTL infusions showed minimal localized brain damage confined to the cannulation tract. No neuronal loss or inflammatory reaction was seen either adjacent to or remote from the administration site. Brains from the long-term survivors of the tumor-bearing animals showed no residual neoplasm; the instillation site had focal sterile abscesses; gliosis and neuronal loss did not extend into adjacent brain. The safety and potential of chronic, local allogeneic CTL administration, derived from multiple donors, as adjuvant local therapy for brain tumors was demonstrated.

A rat glioma model, CNS-1, with invasive characteristics similar to those of human gliomas: a comparison to 9L gliosarcoma

A glioma cell line, CNS-1, was developed in the inbred Lewis rat to obtain a histocompatible astrocytoma cell line with infiltrative and growth patterns that more closely simulate those observed in human gliomas. Rats were given weekly intravenous injections for a six month period with N-nitroso-N-methylurea to produce neoplasm in the central nervous system. Intracranial tumor was isolated, enzymatically and mechanically digested, and placed into culture. The tumor cell line injected subcutaneously on the flanks of Lewis rats grew extensively in situ as cohesive tumor masses but did not metastasize. Intracranially, CNS-1 demonstrated single cell infiltration of paranchyma and leptomeningeal, perivascular, and periventricular spread with expansion of the tumor within choroid plexus stroma. CNS-1 cells titrated in right frontal brain of Lewis rats at 10(5), 5 x 10(5), 10(5), 5 x 10(4) cells per group had mean survival times ranging from 20.5 to 30.2 days. CNS-1 was immunoreactive for glial fibrillary acidic protein, S100 protein, vimentin, neural cell adhesion molecule, retinoic acid receptor alpha, intercellular adhesion molecule, and neuron specific enolase. The CNS-1 cells commonly had one or more trisomies of chromosomes 11, 13 or 18; losses, possibly random, of chromosomes (3, 5, 19, 30, X or Y) were noticed, and a marker chromosome made up of approximately 3 chromosomes was usual. Comparisons of CNS-1 to 9L gliosarcoma tumor were made. The glial CNS-1 tumor model provides an excellent system in which to investigate a variety of immunological therapeutic modalities. It spreads within brain in a less cohesive mass than 9L and is accepted without rejection in non-central nervous system sites by Lewis rats.