Gene and cell-replacement therapy in the treatment of type 1 diabetes: how high must the standards be set?

Current Landscape of Various Techniques and Methods of Gene Therapy through CRISPR Cas9 along with its Pharmacological and Interventional Therapies in the Treatment of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus

BACKGROUND

Type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) is frequently referred to as a "lifestyle illness". In 2000, India (31.7 million) had the greatest global prevalence of diabetes mellitus, followed by China (20.8 million), the United States (17.7 million), and other countries. In recent years, the treatment of gene therapy (T2DM) has attracted intensive interest.

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to critically review the literature on the various techniques and methods, which may be a possible novel approach through the gene therapy CRISPR Cas9 and some other gene editing techniques for T2DM. Interventional and pharmacological approaches for the treatment of T2DM were also included to identify novel therapies for its treatment.

METHOD

An extensive literature survey was done on databases like PubMed, Elsevier, Science Direct and Springer.

CONCLUSION

It can be concluded from the study that recent advancements in gene-editing technologies, such as CRISPR Cas9, have opened new avenues for the development of novel therapeutic approaches for T2DM. CRISPR Cas9 is a powerful tool that enables precise and targeted modifications of the genome.

Generation of a Beta-Cell Transplant Animal Model of Diabetes Using CRISPR Technology

Since insulin deficiency results from pancreatic beta-cell destruction, all type 1 and most type 2 diabetes patients eventually require life-long insulin injections. Insulin gene synthesis could also be impaired due to insulin gene mutations as observed in diabetic patients with MODY 10. At this point, insulin gene therapy could be very effective to recompense insulin deficiency under these circumstances. For this reason, an HIV-based lentiviral vector carrying the insulin gene under the control of insulin promoter (LentiINS) was generated, and its therapeutic efficacy was tested in a beta-cell transplant model lacking insulin produced by CRISPR/Cas9-mediated genetically engineered pancreatic beta cells. To generate an insulin knockout beta-cell transplant animal model of diabetes, a dual gene knockout plasmid system involving CRISPR/Cas9 was transfected into a mouse pancreatic beta cell line (Min6). Fluorescence microscopy and antibiotic selection were utilized to select the insulin gene knockout clones. Transplantation of the genetically engineered pancreatic beta cells under the kidney capsule of STZ-induced diabetic rats revealed LentiINS- but not LentiLacZ-infected Ins2KO cells transiently reduced hyperglycemia similar to that of MIN6 in diabetic animals. These results suggest LentiINS has the potential to functionally restore insulin production in an insulin knockout beta-cell transplant animal model of diabetes.

β Cell Replacement Therapy: The Next 10 Years

β cell replacement with either pancreas or islet transplantation has progressed immensely over the last decades with current 1- and 5-year insulin independence rates of approximately 85% and 50%, respectively. Recent advances are largely attributed to improvements in immunosuppressive regimen, donor selection, and surgical technique. However, both strategies are compromised by a scarce donor source. Xenotransplantation offers a potential solution by providing a theoretically unlimited supply of islets, but clinical application has been limited by concerns for a potent immune response against xenogeneic tissue. β cell clusters derived from embryonic or induced pluripotent stem cells represent another promising unlimited source of insulin producing cells, but clinical application is pending further advances in the function of the β cell like clusters. Exciting developments and rapid progress in all areas of β cell replacement prompted a lively debate by members of the young investigator committee of the International Pancreas and Islet Transplant Association at the 15th International Pancreas and Islet Transplant Association Congress in Melbourne and at the 26th international congress of The Transplant Society in Hong Kong. This international group of young investigators debated which modality of β cell replacement would predominate the landscape in 10 years, and their arguments are summarized here.

Regenerative medicine and cell-based approaches to restore pancreatic function

The pancreas is a complex organ with exocrine and endocrine components. Many pathologies impair exocrine function, including chronic pancreatitis, cystic fibrosis and pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma. Conversely, when the endocrine pancreas fails to secrete sufficient insulin, patients develop diabetes mellitus. Pathology in either the endocrine or exocrine pancreas results in devastating economic and personal consequences. The current standard therapy for treating patients with type 1 diabetes mellitus is daily exogenous insulin injections, but cell sources of insulin provide superior glycaemic regulation and research is now focused on the goal of regenerating or replacing β cells. Stem-cell-based models might be useful to study exocrine pancreatic disorders, and mesenchymal stem cells or secreted factors might delay disease progression. Although the standards that bioengineered cells must meet before being considered as a viable therapy are not yet established, any potential therapy must be acceptably safe and functionally superior to current therapies. Here, we describe progress and challenges in cell-based methods to restore pancreatic function, with a focus on optimizing the site for cell delivery and decreasing requirements for immunosuppression through encapsulation. We also discuss the tools and strategies being used to generate exocrine pancreas and insulin-producing β-cell surrogates in situ and highlight obstacles to clinical application.

Recent Trends in Therapeutic Approaches for Diabetes Management: A Comprehensive Update

Diabetes highlights a growing epidemic imposing serious social economic crisis to the countries around the globe. Despite scientific breakthroughs, better healthcare facilities, and improved literacy rate, the disease continues to burden several sections, especially middle and low income countries. The present trends indicate the rise in premature death, posing a major threat to global development. Scientific and technological advances have witnessed the development of newer generation of drugs like sulphonylureas, biguanides, alpha glucosidase inhibitors, and thiazolidinediones with significant efficacy in reducing hyperglycemia. Recent approaches in drug discovery have contributed to the development of new class of therapeutics like Incretin mimetics, Amylin analogues, GIP analogs, Peroxisome proliferator activated receptors, and dipeptidyl peptidase-4 inhibitor as targets for potential drugs in diabetes treatment. Subsequently, the identification and clinical investigation of bioactive substances from plants have revolutionized the research on drug discovery and lead identification for diabetes management. With a focus on the emerging trends, the review article explores the current statistical prevalence of the disease, discussing the benefits and limitations of the commercially available drugs. Additionally, the critical areas in clinical diabetology are discussed, with respect to prospects of statins, nanotechnology, and stem cell technology as next generation therapeutics and why the herbal formulations are consistently popular choice for diabetes medication and management.

Development of the endocrine pancreas and novel strategies for β-cell mass restoration and diabetes therapy

Diabetes mellitus represents a serious public health problem owing to its global prevalence in the last decade. The causes of this metabolic disease include dysfunction and/or insufficient number of β cells. Existing diabetes mellitus treatments do not reverse or control the disease. Therefore, β-cell mass restoration might be a promising treatment. Several restoration approaches have been developed: inducing the proliferation of remaining insulin-producing cells, de novo islet formation from pancreatic progenitor cells (neogenesis), and converting non-β cells within the pancreas to β cells (transdifferentiation) are the most direct, simple, and least invasive ways to increase β-cell mass. However, their clinical significance is yet to be determined. Hypothetically, β cells or islet transplantation methods might be curative strategies for diabetes mellitus; however, the scarcity of donors limits the clinical application of these approaches. Thus, alternative cell sources for β-cell replacement could include embryonic stem cells, induced pluripotent stem cells, and mesenchymal stem cells. However, most differentiated cells obtained using these techniques are functionally immature and show poor glucose-stimulated insulin secretion compared with native β cells. Currently, their clinical use is still hampered by ethical issues and the risk of tumor development post transplantation. In this review, we briefly summarize the current knowledge of mouse pancreas organogenesis, morphogenesis, and maturation, including the molecular mechanisms involved. We then discuss two possible approaches of β-cell mass restoration for diabetes mellitus therapy: β-cell regeneration and β-cell replacement. We critically analyze each strategy with respect to the accessibility of the cells, potential risk to patients, and possible clinical outcomes.

Reversal of diabetes with insulin-producing cells derived in vitro from human pluripotent stem cells

Transplantation of pancreatic progenitors or insulin-secreting cells derived from human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) has been proposed as a therapy for diabetes. We describe a seven-stage protocol that efficiently converts hESCs into insulin-producing cells. Stage (S) 7 cells expressed key markers of mature pancreatic beta cells, including MAFA, and displayed glucose-stimulated insulin secretion similar to that of human islets during static incubations in vitro. Additional characterization using single-cell imaging and dynamic glucose stimulation assays revealed similarities but also notable differences between S7 insulin-secreting cells and primary human beta cells. Nevertheless, S7 cells rapidly reversed diabetes in mice within 40 days, roughly four times faster than pancreatic progenitors. Therefore, although S7 cells are not fully equivalent to mature beta cells, their capacity for glucose-responsive insulin secretion and rapid reversal of diabetes in vivo makes them a promising alternative to pancreatic progenitor cells or cadaveric islets for the treatment of diabetes.

Restoring insulin production for type 1 diabetes

Current therapies for the treatment of type 1 diabetes include daily administration of exogenous insulin and, less frequently, whole-pancreas or islet transplantation. Insulin injections often result in inaccurate insulin doses, exposing the patient to hypo- and/or hyperglycemic episodes that lead to long-term complications. Islet transplantation is also limited by lack of high-quality islet donors, early graft failure, and chronic post-transplant immunosuppressive treatment. These barriers could be circumvented by designing a safe and efficient strategy to restore insulin production within the patient's body. Porcine islets have been considered as a possible alternative source of transplantable insulin-producing cells to replace human cadaveric islets. More recently, embryonic or induced pluripotent stem cells have also been examined for their ability to differentiate in vitro into pancreatic endocrine cells. Alternatively, it may be feasible to generate new β-cells by ectopic expression of key transcription factors in endogenous non-β-cells. Finally, engineering surrogate β-cells by in vivo delivery of the insulin gene to specific tissues is also being studied as a possible therapy for type 1 diabetes. In the present review, we discuss these different approaches to restore insulin production.

Insulin gene therapy from design to beta cell generation

Despite the fact that insulin injection can protect diabetic patients from developing diabetes-related complications, recent meta-analyses indicate that rapid and long-acting insulin analogues only provide a limited benefit compared with conventional insulin regarding glycemic control. As insulin deficiency is the main sequel of type-1 diabetes (T1D), transfer of the insulin gene-by-gene therapy is becoming an attractive treatment modality even though T1D is not caused by a single genetic defect. In contrast to human insulin and insulin analogues, insulin gene therapy targets to supplement patients not only with insulin but also with C-peptide. So far, insulin gene therapy has had limited success because of delayed and/or transient gene expression. Sustained insulin gene expression is now feasible using current gene-therapy vectors providing patients with basal insulin coverage, but management of postprandial hyperglycaemia is still difficult to accomplish because of the inability to properly control insulin secretion. Enteroendocrine cells of the gastrointestinal track (K cells and L cells) may be ideal targets for insulin gene therapy, but cell-targeting difficulties have limited practical implementation of insulin gene therapy for diabetes treatment. Therefore, recent gene transfer technologies developed to generate authentic beta cells through transdifferentiation are also highlighted in this review.

Human β cell transcriptome analysis uncovers lncRNAs that are tissue-specific, dynamically regulated, and abnormally expressed in type 2 diabetes

A significant portion of the genome is transcribed as long noncoding RNAs (lncRNAs), several of which are known to control gene expression. The repertoire and regulation of lncRNAs in disease-relevant tissues, however, has not been systematically explored. We report a comprehensive strand-specific transcriptome map of human pancreatic islets and β cells, and uncover >1100 intergenic and antisense islet-cell lncRNA genes. We find islet lncRNAs that are dynamically regulated and show that they are an integral component of the β cell differentiation and maturation program. We sequenced the mouse islet transcriptome and identify lncRNA orthologs that are regulated like their human counterparts. Depletion of HI-LNC25, a β cell-specific lncRNA, downregulated GLIS3 mRNA, thus exemplifying a gene regulatory function of islet lncRNAs. Finally, selected islet lncRNAs were dysregulated in type 2 diabetes or mapped to genetic loci underlying diabetes susceptibility. These findings reveal a new class of islet-cell genes relevant to β cell programming and diabetes pathophysiology.

GPR41 gene expression is mediated by internal ribosome entry site (IRES)-dependent translation of bicistronic mRNA encoding GPR40 and GPR41 proteins

GPR41 is a G protein-coupled receptor activated by short chain fatty acids. The gene encoding GPR41 is located immediately downstream of a related gene encoding GPR40, a receptor for long chain fatty acids. Expression of GPR41 has been reported in a small number of cell types, including gut enteroendocrine cells and sympathetic ganglia, where it may play a role in the maintenance of metabolic homeostasis. We now demonstrate that GPR41, like GPR40, is expressed in pancreatic beta cells. Surprisingly, we found no evidence for transcriptional control elements or transcriptional initiation in the intergenic GPR40-GPR41 region. Rather, using 5'-rapid amplification of cDNA ends analysis, we demonstrated that GPR41 is transcribed from the promoter of the GPR40 gene. We confirmed this finding by generating bicistronic luciferase reporter plasmids, and we were able to map a potential internal ribosome entry site-containing region to a 2474-nucleotide region of the intergenic sequence. Consistent with this, we observed m(7)G cap-independent reporter gene expression upon transfection of RNA containing this region. Thus, GPR41 expression is mediated via an internal ribosome entry site located in the intergenic region of a bicistronic mRNA. This novel sequence organization may be utilized to permit coordinated regulation of the fatty acid receptors GPR40 and GPR41.

Reprogramming gut and pancreas endocrine cells to treat diabetes

Multiple approaches have been investigated with the ultimate goal of providing insulin independence to patients with either type 1 or type 2 diabetes. Approaches to produce insulin-secreting cells in culture, convert non-β-cells into functional β-cells or engineer autologous cells to express and secrete insulin in a meal-responsive manner have all been described. This research has been facilitated by significant improvements in both viral and non-viral gene delivery approaches that have enabled new experimental strategies. Many studies have examined possible avenues to confer islet cytoprotection against immune rejection, inflammation and apoptosis by genetic manipulation of islet cells prior to islet transplantation. Here we review several reports based on the reprogramming of pancreas and gut endocrine cells to treat diabetes.

Stem cells and the endocrine pancreas

BACKGROUND

Diabetes can be treated by β-cell replacement therapy but the supply of graft material from human donors is too limited to make a significant clinical impact. Substitute β-cells generated from stem cell populations offer a potential source for the large numbers of cells required.

SOURCES OF DATA

Primary peer-reviewed reports of experimental studies.

AREAS OF AGREEMENT

Embryonic stem cells and/or induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells are currently the most promising starting populations from which to generate large numbers of β-cells. Differentiation protocols that recapitulate in vivo development generate insulin-expressing cells in vitro.

AREAS OF CONTROVERSY

Differentiation outcomes may depend on the source of the initial pluripotent cells. The insulin-expressing cells are not fully functional. In vivo maturation is inconsistent and not well understood.

AREAS TIMELY FOR DEVELOPING RESEARCH

Improvement of current protocols for complete in vitro differentiation to a functional β-cell phenotype. Systematic analysis to identify the most appropriate starting material. Improved purification methods to ensure safety of material for clinical transplantation.

Remission of diabetes by insulin gene therapy using a hepatocyte-specific and glucose-responsive synthetic promoter

Efficient production of insulin in response to changes in glucose levels has been a major issue for insulin gene therapy to treat diabetes. To express target genes in response to glucose specifically in hepatocytes, we generated a synthetic promoter library containing hepatocyte nuclear factor-1, CAAT/enhancer-binding protein (C/EBP) response element, and glucose-response element. Combinations of these three cis-elements in 3-, 6-, or 9-element configurations were screened for transcriptional activity and then glucose responsiveness in vitro. The most effective promoter (SP23137) was selected for further study. Intravenous administration of a recombinant adenovirus expressing furin-cleavable rat insulin under control of the SP23137 promoter into streptozotocin (STZ)-induced diabetic mice resulted in normoglycemia, which was maintained for >30 days. Glucose tolerance tests showed that treated mice produced insulin in response to glucose and cleared exogenous glucose from the blood in a manner similar to nondiabetic control mice, although the clearance was somewhat delayed. Insulin expression was seen specifically in the liver and not in other organs. These observations indicate the potential of this synthetic, artificial promoter to regulate glucose-responsive insulin production and remit hyperglycemia, thus providing a new method of liver-directed insulin gene therapy for type 1 diabetes.

Gene therapy in diabetes

Type 1 diabetes (T1D) is a chronic autoimmune disease, whereby auto-reactive cytotoxic T cells target and destroy insulin-secreting β-cells in pancreatic islets leading to insulin deficiency and subsequent hyperglycemia. These individuals require multiple daily insulin injections every day of their life without which they will develop life-threatening diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA) and die. Gene therapy by viral vector and non-viral transduction may be useful techniques to treat T1D as it can be applied from many different angles; such as the suppression of autoreactive T cells to prevent islet destruction (prophylactic) or the replacement of the insulin gene (post-disease). The need for a better method for providing euglycemia arose from insufficient numbers of cadaver islets for transplantation and the immunosuppression required post-transplant. Ectopic expression of insulin or islet modification have been examined, but not perfected. This review examines the various gene transfer methods, gene therapy techniques used to date and promising novel techniques for the maintenance of euglycemia in the treatment of T1D.

Minireview: beta-cell replacement therapy for diabetes in the 21st century: manipulation of cell fate by directed differentiation

Pancreatic beta-cell failure underlies type 1 diabetes; it also contributes in an essential way to type 2 diabetes. beta-Cell replacement is an important component of any cure for diabetes. The current options of islet and pancreas transplantation are not satisfactory as definitive forms of therapy. Here, we review strategies for induced de novo pancreatic beta-cell formation, which depend on the targeted differentiation of cells into pancreatic beta-cells. With this objective in mind, one can manipulate the fate of three different types of cells: 1) from terminally differentiated cells, e.g. exocrine pancreatic cells, into beta-cells; 2) from multipotent adult stem cells, e.g. hepatic oval cells, into pancreatic islets; and 3) from pluripotent stem cells, e.g. embryonic stem cells and induced pluripotent stem cells, into beta-cells. We will examine the pros and cons of each strategy as well as the hurdles that must be overcome before these approaches to generate new beta-cells will be ready for clinical application.

Stem cell therapy for type 1 diabetes mellitus

The use of stem cells in regenerative medicine holds great promise for the cure of many diseases, including type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM). Any potential stem-cell-based cure for T1DM should address the need for beta-cell replacement, as well as control of the autoimmune response to cells which express insulin. The ex vivo generation of beta cells suitable for transplantation to reconstitute a functional beta-cell mass has used pluripotent cells from diverse sources, as well as organ-specific facultative progenitor cells from the liver and the pancreas. The most effective protocols to date have produced cells that express insulin and have molecular characteristics that closely resemble bona fide insulin-secreting cells; however, these cells are often unresponsive to glucose, a characteristic that should be addressed in future protocols. The use of mesenchymal stromal cells or umbilical cord blood to modulate the immune response is already in clinical trials; however, definitive results are still pending. This Review focuses on current strategies to obtain cells which express insulin from different progenitor sources and highlights the main pathways and genes involved, as well as the different approaches for the modulation of the immune response in patients with T1DM.

Current status of islet cell replacement and regeneration therapy

CONTEXT

Beta cell mass and function are decreased to varying degrees in both type 1 and type 2 diabetes. In the future, islet cell replacement or regeneration therapy may thus offer therapeutic benefit to people with diabetes, but there are major challenges to be overcome.

EVIDENCE ACQUISITION

A review of published peer-reviewed medical literature on beta-cell development and regeneration was performed. Only publications considered most relevant were selected for citation, with particular attention to the period 2000-2009 and the inclusion of earlier landmark studies.

EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS

Islet cell regenerative therapy could be achieved by in situ regeneration or implantation of cells previously derived in vitro. Both approaches are being explored, and their ultimate success will depend on the ability to recapitulate key events in the normal development of the endocrine pancreas to derive fully differentiated islet cells that are functionally normal. There is also debate as to whether beta-cells alone will assure adequate metabolic control or whether it will be necessary to regenerate islets with their various cell types and unique integrated function. Any approach must account for the potential dangers of regenerative therapy.

CONCLUSIONS

Islet cell regenerative therapy may one day offer an improved treatment of diabetes and potentially a cure. However, the various approaches are at an early stage of preclinical development and should not be offered to patients until shown to be safe as well as more efficacious than existing therapy.

Gene therapy with neurogenin 3 and betacellulin reverses major metabolic problems in insulin-deficient diabetic mice

Insulin deficiency in type 1 diabetes leads to disruptions in glucose, lipid, and ketone metabolism with resultant hyperglycemia, hyperlipidemia, and ketonemia. Exogenous insulin and hepatic insulin gene therapy cannot mimic the robust glucose-stimulated insulin secretion (GSIS) from native pancreatic islets. Gene therapy of streptozotocin-diabetic mice with neurogenin 3 (Ngn3) and betacellulin (Btc) leads to the induction of periportal oval cell-derived neo-islets that exhibit GSIS. We hence hypothesized that this gene therapy regimen may lead to a complete correction of the glucose and lipid metabolic abnormalities associated with insulin deficiency; we further hypothesized that the neo-islets formed in response to Ngn3-Btc gene delivery may display an ultrastructure and transcription profile similar to that of pancreatic islets. We injected streptozotocin-diabetic mice with helper-dependent adenoviral vectors carrying Ngn3 and Btc, which restored GSIS and reversed hyperglycemia in these animals. The treatment also normalized hepatic glucose secretion and reversed ketonemia. Furthermore, it restored hepatic glycogen content and reinstated hepatic lipogenesis-related gene transcripts back to nondiabetic levels. By transmission electron microscopy, the neo-islets displayed electron-dense granules that were similar in appearance to those in pancreatic islets. Finally, using RNA obtained by laser capture microdissection of the periportal neo-islets and normal pancreatic islets, we found that the neo-islets and pancreatic islets exhibited a very similar transcription profile on microarray-based transcriptome analysis. Taken together, this indicates that Ngn3-Btc gene therapy corrects the underlying dysregulated glucose and lipid metabolism in insulin-deficient diabetic mice by inducing neo-islets in the liver that are similar to pancreatic islets in structure and gene expression profile.

'Not taken in by media hype': how potential donors, recipients and members of the general public perceive stem cell research

BACKGROUND

Views of embryo donors, scientists and members of the general public on embryonic stem cell research (eSCR) have been widely reported. Less is known about views of potential beneficiaries of stem cell therapy and the influence of media 'hype' on perceptions of eSCR among different groups of stakeholders. This study aimed to examine the perceptions of members of the general public as well as two patient groups likely to benefit from eSCR and to explore the role of the media in shaping these views.

METHODS

A qualitative study carried out in Aberdeen, Scotland included 15 people living with Parkinson's disease (PD), 15 people living with diabetes mellitus (DM), 15 couples with infertility and 21 members of the general public who volunteered for the study. Interview transcripts were analysed thematically using grounded theory.

RESULTS

The two patient groups likely to benefit from eSCR in the future differed in their knowledge (mainly gained from the media) and understanding of eSCR. Those living with PD were older, more debilitated and better informed than those with DM who showed limited interest in potential future benefits of eSCR. Infertile couples learnt about eSCR from health professionals who explained the process of embryo donation to them, and had sought no further information. Most of the general public had accessed information on eSCR and believed themselves to be more discerning than others because of their objectivity, intelligence and 'scientific awareness'. Although, the media and internet were primary sources of information for all except couples with infertility, members of all four groups claimed not to be taken in by the media 'hype' surrounding eSCR.

CONCLUSIONS

Those who expected to benefit from eSCR in the future as well as members of the general public differ in their susceptibility to media 'hype', while believing that they are not taken in by exaggerated claims of benefits. As respondents were a selected group who were not drawn from a representative sample, the findings cannot be generalized to a wider population.

A new strategy to generate functional insulin-producing cell lines by somatic gene transfer into pancreatic progenitors

Background

There is increasing interest in developing human cell lines to be used to better understand cell biology, but also for drug screening, toxicology analysis and future cell therapy. In the endocrine pancreatic field, functional human beta cell lines are extremely scarce. On the other hand, rodent insulin producing beta cells have been generated during the past years with great success. Many of such cell lines were produced by using transgenic mice expressing SV40T antigen under the control of the insulin promoter, an approach clearly inadequate in human. Our objective was to develop and validate in rodent an alternative transgenic-like approach, applicable to human tissue, by performing somatic gene transfer into pancreatic progenitors that will develop into beta cells.

Methods and Findings

In this study, rat embryonic pancreases were transduced with recombinant lentiviral vector expressing the SV40T antigen under the control of the insulin promoter. Transduced tissues were next transplanted under the kidney capsule of immuno-incompetent mice allowing insulinoma development from which beta cell lines were established. Gene expression profile, insulin content and glucose dependent secretion, normalization of glycemia upon transplantation into diabetic mice validated the approach to generate beta cell lines.

Conclusions

Somatic gene transfer into pancreatic progenitors represents an alternative strategy to generate functional beta cell lines in rodent. Moreover, this approach can be generalized to derive cells lines from various tissues and most importantly from tissues of human origin.

Cell therapy for type 2 diabetes: is it desirable and can we get it?

The functional mass of beta-cells is decreased in type 2 diabetes. Replacing missing beta-cells or triggering their regeneration may thus allow for improved treatment of type 2 diabetes, to the extent that this is combined with therapy for improved insulin sensitivity. Although progress has been made in deriving beta-cell-like cells from stem or precursor cells in vitro, these cannot yet be obtained in sufficient quantities or well enough differentiated to envisage their therapeutic use in beta-cell replacement therapy. Likewise, our very limited understanding of beta-cell regeneration in adult man does not yet allow for development of a valid strategy for kick-starting such a process in individuals with type 2 diabetes, whether by bona fide neogenesis or self-replication of existing beta-cells. Regardless of how beta-cell mass is restored in type 2 diabetes, it will be important to prevent any renewed decrease thereafter. Current understanding suggests that islet inflammation as well as signals from (insulin-resistant/inflamed) adipose tissue and skeletal muscle contribute towards decreased beta-cell mass in type 2 diabetes. It will likely be important to protect newly formed or implanted beta-cells from these negative influences to ensure their long-term survival.

Hepatic insulin gene therapy normalizes diurnal fluctuation of oxidative metabolism in diabetic BB/Wor rats

Previous studies of hepatic insulin gene therapy (HIGT) focused on glycemic effects of insulin produced from hepatocytes. In this study, we extend the observations of glycemic control with metabolically regulated HIGT to include systemic responses and whole-body metabolism. An insulin transgene was administered with an adenoviral vector [Ad/(GlRE)(3)BP1-2xfur] to livers of BB/Wor rats made diabetic with polyinosinic polycytidilic acid (poly-I:C) (HIGT group), and results compared with nondiabetic controls (non-DM), and diabetic rats receiving different doses of continuous-release insulin implants (DM-low BG and DM-high BG). Blood glucose and growth normalized in HIGT, with lower systemic insulin levels, elevated glucagon, and increased heat production compared with non-DM. Minimal regulation of systemic insulin levels were observed with HIGT, yet the animals maintained normal switching from carbohydrate to lipid metabolism determined by respiratory quotients (RQs), and tolerated 24-hour fasts without severe hypoglycemia. HIGT did not restore serum lipids as we observed increased triglycerides (TGs) and increased free fatty acids, but reduced weight of visceral fat pads despite normal total body fat content and retroperitoneal fat depots. HIGT favorably affects blood glucose, normalizes metabolic switching in diabetic rats, and reduces intra-abdominal fat deposition.

Dual effect of cell-cell contact disruption on cytosolic calcium and insulin secretion

Cell-to-cell interactions play an important role in insulin secretion. Compared with intact islets, dispersed pancreatic beta-cells show increased basal and decreased glucose-stimulated insulin secretion. In this study, we used mouse MIN6B1 cells to investigate the mechanisms that control insulin secretion when cells are in contact with each other or not. RNAi-mediated silencing of the adhesion molecule E-cadherin in confluent cells reduced glucose-stimulated secretion to the levels observed in isolated cells but had no impact on basal secretion. Dispersed cells presented high cytosolic Ca(2+) activity, depolymerized cytoskeleton and ERK1/2 activation in low glucose conditions. Both the increased basal secretion and the spontaneous Ca(2+) activity were corrected by transient removal of Ca(2+) or prolonged incubation of cells in low glucose, a procedure that restored the ability of dispersed cells to respond to glucose (11-fold stimulation). In conclusion, we show that dispersed pancreatic beta-cells can respond robustly to glucose once their elevated basal secretion has been corrected. The increased basal insulin secretion of dispersed cells is due to spontaneous Ca(2+) transients that activate downstream Ca(2+) effectors, whereas engagement of cell adhesion molecules including E-cadherin contributes to the greater secretory response to glucose seen in cells with normal intercellular contacts.

Nonvirally modified autologous primary hepatocytes correct diabetes and prevent target organ injury in a large preclinical model

BACKGROUND

Current gene- and cell-based therapies have significant limitations which impede widespread clinical application. Taking diabetes mellitus as a paradigm, we have sought to overcome these limitations by ex vivo electrotransfer of a nonviral insulin expression vector into primary hepatocytes followed by immediate autologous reimplantation in a preclinical model of diabetes.

METHODS AND RESULTS

In a single 3-hour procedure, hepatocytes were isolated from a surgically resected liver wedge, electroporated with an insulin expression plasmid ex vivo and reimplanted intraparenchymally under ultrasonic guidance into the liver in each of 10 streptozotocin-induced diabetic Yorkshire pigs. The vector was comprised of a bifunctional, glucose-responsive promoter linked to human insulin cDNA. Ambient glucose concentrations appropriately altered human insulin mRNA expression and C-peptide secretion within minutes in vitro and in vivo. Treated swine showed correction of hyperglycemia, glucose intolerance, dyslipidemia and other metabolic abnormalities for > or = 47 weeks. Metabolic correction correlated significantly with the number of hepatocytes implanted. Importantly, we observed no hypoglycemia even under fasting conditions. Direct intrahepatic implantation of hepatocytes did not alter biochemical indices of liver function or induce abnormal hepatic lobular architecture. About 70% of implanted hepatocytes functionally engrafted, appeared histologically normal, retained vector DNA and expressed human insulin for > or = 47 weeks. Based on structural tissue analyses and transcriptome data, we showed that early correction of diabetes attenuated and even prevented pathological changes in the eye, kidney, liver and aorta.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrate that autologous hepatocytes can be efficiently, simply and safely modified by electroporation of a nonviral vector to express, process and secrete insulin durably. This strategy, which achieved significant and sustained therapeutic efficacy in a large preclinical model without adverse effects, warrants consideration for clinical development especially as it could have broader future applications for the treatment of other acquired and inherited diseases for which systemic reconstitution of a specific protein deficiency is critical.

Beta-cell replacement and regeneration: Strategies of cell-based therapy for type 1 diabetes mellitus

Pancreatic islet transplantation has demonstrated that long-term insulin independence may be achieved in patients suffering from diabetes mellitus type 1. However, because of limited availability of islet tissue, new sources of insulin producing cells that are responsive to glucose are required. Development of pancreatic beta-cell lines from rodent or human origin has progressed slowly in recent years. Current experiments for ex vivo expansion of beta cells and in vitro differentiation of embryonic and adult stem cells into insulin producing beta-cell phenotypes led to promising results. Nevertheless, the cells generated to date lack important characteristics of mature beta cells and generally display reduced insulin secretion and loss of proliferative capacity. Therefore, much better understanding of the mechanisms that regulate expansion and differentiation of stem/progenitor cells is necessary. Here, we review recent advances in the identification of potential cellular sources, and the development of strategies to regenerate or fabricate insulin producing and glucose sensing cells that might enable future cell-based therapies of diabetes mellitus type 1.

Insulin-expressing engineered cell lines and primary cells: surrogate β cells from liver, gut, and other sources

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Islet transplantation is being used to treat type 1 diabetes but is currently limited by the shortage of tissue available and by insufficient long-term function of transplanted islets. Thus, there remains significant interest in developing substitute sources of insulin-producing cells. Here we review progress in this area, focusing on insulin gene therapy and generation of new insulin-producing cells by redirecting hepatic and intestinal tissues towards a β-cell phenotype.

RECENT FINDINGS

Insulin gene therapy using non-β cells has been improved by utilizing modified insulin constructs controlled by regulatory elements to confer nutrient responsiveness, and by inducing insulin production in endocrine cells that are equipped for rapid and in some cases glucose-responsive secretion. Significant advances have also been made towards generation of insulin-producing cells via transcriptional manipulation of hepatic and intestinal cells. These approaches offer the potential of generating a virtually limitless supply of insulin-producing cells.

SUMMARY

The major challenge associated with insulin gene therapy in non-β cells is to achieve rapid, glucose-responsive secretion, while transdifferentiation approaches require additional characterization of the function and stability of insulin-producing cells. Continued efforts in these areas are warranted, as re-establishment of endogenous insulin production would be a welcome replacement to insulin injections for diabetes treatment.

Reversal of type 1 diabetes by engineering a glucose sensor in skeletal muscle

Type 1 diabetic patients develop severe secondary complications because insulin treatment does not guarantee normoglycemia. Thus, efficient regulation of glucose homeostasis is a major challenge in diabetes therapy. Skeletal muscle is the most important tissue for glucose disposal after a meal. However, the lack of insulin during diabetes impairs glucose uptake. To increase glucose removal from blood, skeletal muscle of transgenic mice was engineered both to produce basal levels of insulin and to express the liver enzyme glucokinase. After streptozotozin (STZ) administration of double-transgenic mice, a synergic action in skeletal muscle between the insulin produced and the increased glucose phosphorylation by glucokinase was established, preventing hyperglycemia and metabolic alterations. These findings suggested that insulin and glucokinase might be expressed in skeletal muscle, using adeno-associated viral 1 (AAV1) vectors as a new gene therapy approach for diabetes. AAV1-Ins+GK-treated diabetic mice restored and maintained normoglycemia in fed and fasted conditions for >4 months after STZ administration. Furthermore, these mice showed normalization of metabolic parameters, glucose tolerance, and food and fluid intake. Therefore, the joint action of basal insulin production and glucokinase activity may generate a "glucose sensor" in skeletal muscle that allows proper regulation of glycemia in diabetic animals and thus prevents secondary complications.

The bioartificial pancreas: progress and challenges

Diabetes remains a devastating disease, with tremendous cost in terms of human suffering and healthcare expenditures. A bioartificial pancreas has the potential as a promising approach to preventing or reversing complications associated with this disease. Bioartificial pancreatic constructs are based on encapsulation of islet cells with a semipermeable membrane so that cells can be protected from the host's immune system. Encapsulation of islet cells eliminates the requirement of immunosuppressive drugs, and offers a possible solution to the shortage of donors as it may allow the use of animal islets or insulin-producing cells engineered from stem cells. During the past 2 decades, several major approaches for immunoprotection of islets have been studied. The microencapsulation approach is quite promising because of its improved diffusion capacity, and technical ease of transplantation. It has the potential for providing an effective long-term treatment or cure of Type 1 diabetes.

Islet- and stem-cell-based tissue engineering in diabetes

New sources of insulin-producing cells are needed to overcome the limited availability of islet tissue for transplantation to diabetic patients. The engineering of murine or human transformed beta-cell lines and of non beta-cells has progressed slowly in recent years, while significant achievements have been claimed in the differentiation of insulin-producing cells from embryonic and adult stem cells. Some of the results have been questioned, however, and the generated cells lack many characteristics of differentiated beta-cells. A much better understanding of the processes that govern the expansion and differentiation of stem cells is needed.

Generation, culture, and differentiation of human embryonic stem cells for therapeutic applications

Embryonic stem (ES) cells, derived from the inner cell mass of the mammalian blastocyst, can continuously proliferate in an undifferentiated state and can also be induced to differentiate into a desired cell lineage. These abilities make ES cells an appealing source for cell replacement therapies, the study of developmental biology, and drug/toxin screening studies. As compared to mouse ES cells, human ES cells have only recently been derived and studied. Although there are many differences in properties between mouse and human ES cells, the study of mouse ES cells has provided important insights into human ES cell research. In this review, we describe the advantages and disadvantages of methods used for human ES cell derivation, the expansion of human ES cells, and the current status of human ES cell differentiation research. In addition, we discuss the endeavor that scientists have undertaken toward the therapeutic application of these cells, which includes therapeutic cloning and the improvement of human ES cell culture conditions.

Lineage tracing and characterization of insulin-secreting cells generated from adult pancreatic acinar cells

Although several studies have suggested that insulin-secreting cells can be generated in vitro from cells residing in adult exocrine pancreas, neither the origin of these cells nor their precise insulin secretory properties was obtained. We show here that insulin-secreting cells can be derived from adult mouse pancreatic exocrine cells by suspension culture in the presence of EGF and nicotinamide. The frequency of insulin-positive cells was only 0.01% in the initial preparation and increased to approximately 5% in the culture conditions. Analysis by the Cre/loxP-based direct cell lineage tracing system indicates that these newly made cells originate from amylase/elastase-expressing pancreatic acinar cells. Insulin secretion is stimulated by glucose, sulfonylurea, and carbachol, and potentiation by glucagon-like peptide-1 also occurs. Insulin-containing secretory granules are present in these cells. In addition, we found that the enzymatic dissociation of pancreatic acini itself leads to activation of EGF signaling, and that inhibition of EGF receptor kinase blocks the transdifferentiation. These data demonstrate that pancreatic acinar cells can transdifferentiate into insulin-secreting cells with secretory properties similar to those of native pancreatic beta cells, and that activation of EGF signaling is required in such transdifferentiation.

New sources of pancreatic beta-cells

Two major initiatives are under way to correct the beta-cell deficit of diabetes: one would generate beta-cells ex vivo that are suitable for transplantation, and the second would stimulate regeneration of beta-cells in the pancreas. Studies of ex vivo expansion suggest that beta-cells have a potential for dedifferentiation, expansion, and redifferentiation. Work with mouse and human embryonic stem (ES) cells has not yet produced cells with the phenotype of true beta-cells, but there has been recent progress in directing ES cells to endoderm. Putative islet stem/progenitor cells have been identified in mouse pancreas, and formation of new beta-cells from duct, acinar and liver cells is an active area of investigation. Peptides, including glucagon-like peptide-1/exendin-4 and the combination of epidermal growth factor and gastrin, can stimulate regeneration of beta-cells in vivo. Recent progress in the search for new sources of beta-cells has opened promising new opportunities and spawned clinical trials.

Chronic hyperglycemia, independent of plasma lipid levels, is sufficient for the loss of beta-cell differentiation and secretory function in the db/db mouse model of diabetes

The beta-cell is a highly specialized cell with a unique differentiation that optimizes glucose-induced insulin secretion (GIIS). Here, we evaluated changes in gene expression that accompany beta-cell dysfunction in the db/db mouse model of type 2 diabetes. In db/db islets, mRNA levels of many genes implicated in beta-cell glucose sensing were progressively reduced with time, as were several transcription factors important for the maintenance of beta-cell differentiation. Conversely, genes normally suppressed in beta-cells, such as a variety of stress response mediators and inhibitor of differentiation/DNA binding 1, a gene capable of inhibiting differentiation, were markedly increased. We assessed whether this global alteration in the pattern of beta-cell gene expression was related more to chronic hyperglycemia or hyperlipidemia; db/db mice were treated with phlorizin, which selectively lowered plasma glucose, or bezafibrate, which selectively lowered plasma lipids. GIIS as well as the majority of the changes in gene expression were completely normalized by lowering glucose but were unaffected by lowering lipids. However, the restoration of GIIS was not accompanied by normalized uncoupling protein 2 or peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma mRNA levels, which were upregulated in db/db islets. These studies demonstrate that hyperglycemia, independent of plasma lipid levels, is sufficient for the loss of beta-cell differentiation and secretory function in db/db mice.

Plasmid-electroporated primary hepatocytes acquire quasi-physiological secretion of human insulin and restore euglycemia in diabetic mice

We describe the durable correction of streptozotocin-induced murine diabetes by in vivo implantation of primary mouse hepatocytes electroporated ex vivo with a human proinsulin cDNA plasmid construct controlled by glucose and zinc regulatory elements. Transfected hepatocytes increased insulin transgene transcription and secretion within 10-20 min of exposure to 25 mM glucose or 60 microM zinc. Insulin release did not occur from secretory granules. Electroporated Rosa26 hepatocytes ( approximately 8 x 10(5) viable cells) were implanted in C57BL/6J diabetic mice in one of three sites: unresected liver, regenerating liver or mesentery. Control diabetic mice were implanted with untransfected hepatocytes. At 30 days after implantation, 8/15 control mice were alive, while 19/19 treated mice were alive. The ratio of body weight on day 30/nadir body weight was significantly higher for all treated groups compared with controls. All eight surviving control mice were hyperglycemic 30 days post-implantation, while 16/19 treated diabetic mice remained normoglycemic. Treated mice had lower mean glucose values (P< or =0.001) without fasting hypoglycemia and better glucose tolerance (P< or =0.0003) than untreated controls. All (6/6) diabetic mice implanted in regenerating liver and 71% (5/7) implanted in unresected liver were alive 77 days after implantation. Engrafted hepatocytes were identified, mainly around central veins, by staining for beta-galactosidase activity and with anti-human insulin antibody.

Harnessing the gut to treat diabetes

The gut contains one of the largest stem cell populations in the body, yet has been largely overlooked as a source of potentially therapeutic cells. The stem cells reside in the crypts located at the base of the protruding villi, reproduce themselves, and repopulate the gut lining as differentiated cells are sloughed off into the lumen. Some studies have demonstrated that gut stem cells can be isolated and maintained in culture, but the field is currently hampered by the lack of clear markers for these cells. Nevertheless, the relative accessibility of the cells and the similar pathways of differentiation of both intestinal and pancreatic endocrine cells make the gut an attractive potential source of cells to treat diabetes. In particular, it may be possible to recapitulate islet development by the introduction of specific factors to gut stem cells. Alternatively, gut endocrine cells might be coaxed to produce insulin and secrete it into the blood in a meal-responsive manner. Several investigations support the feasibility of both approaches as novel potential therapies for diabetes. Utilizing a patient's own gut cells to re-establish endogenous meal-regulated insulin secretion could represent an attractive approach to ultimately cure diabetes.

Efficient restricted gene expression in beta cells by lentivirus-mediated gene transfer into pancreatic stem/progenitor cells

AIMS/HYPOTHESIS

Gene transfer into pancreatic beta cells, which produce and secrete insulin, is a promising strategy to protect such cells against autoimmune destruction and also to generate beta cells in mass, thereby providing a novel therapeutic approach to treat diabetic patients. Until recently, exogenous DNA has been directly transferred into mature beta cells with various levels of success. We investigated whether exogenous DNA could be stably transferred into pancreatic stem/progenitor cells, which would subsequently differentiate into mature beta cells expressing the transgene.

METHODS

We designed transplantation and tissue culture procedures to obtain ex vivo models of pancreatic development. We next constructed recombinant lentiviruses expressing enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP) under the control of either the rat insulin promoter or a ubiquitous promoter, and performed viral infection of rat embryonic pancreatic tissue.

RESULTS

Embryonic pancreas infected with recombinant lentiviruses resulted in endocrine cell differentiation and restricted cell type expression of the transgene according to the specificity of the promoter used in the viral construct. We next demonstrated that the efficiency of infection could be further improved upon infection of embryonic pancreatic epithelia, followed by their in vitro culture, using conditions that favour endocrine cell differentiation. Under these conditions, endocrine stem/progenitor cells expressing neurogenin 3 are efficiently transduced by recombinant lentiviral vectors. Moreover, when eGFP was placed under the control of the insulin promoter, 70.4% of the developed beta cells were eGFP-expressing cells. All of the eGFP-positive cells were insulin-producing cells.

CONCLUSIONS/INTERPRETATION

We have demonstrated that mature rat pancreatic beta cells can be stably modified by infecting pancreatic stem/progenitor cells that undergo endocrine differentiation.

Can we make surrogate beta-cells better than the original?

Insufficient pancreatic beta-cell mass is fundamental to the pathogenesis of both types 1 and 2 diabetes and constitutes the basis for the goal of beta-cell replacement therapy. Current methods for isolating islets from organ donor pancreases do not come close to supplying all in need, thus providing a compelling need to find new sources of insulin-producing cells. Possible sources include generation of cells from embryonic stem cells (ESC), adult stem/precursor cells, transdifferentiation of other cell types and xenodonors. Bioengineering can be used to improve secretory performance and strengthen cells to better withstand the challenges of transplantation. Strategies include protection against hypoxia, inflammation, and immune attack.