Predicting Drug Release from 3D Printed Oral Medicines Based on the Surface Area to Volume Ratio of Tablet Geometry

Utilizing machine learning for predicting drug release from polymeric drug delivery systems

Polymeric drug delivery systems (PDDS) play a crucial role in controlled drug release, providing improved therapeutic outcomes. However, formulating PDDS and predicting their release profiles remain challenging due to their complex structures and the numerous variables that influence their behavior. Traditional mathematical and empirical prediction methods are limited in capturing these complexities. Recent studies have unveiled the potential of Machine Learning (ML) in revolutionizing drug delivery, particularly in formulating complex PDDS. This article provides an overview of the significant and fundamental principles of various ML strategies in estimating PDDS drug release behavior. Our focus extends to the accomplishments and pivotal discoveries in current research, spanning seven distinct sustained-release drug delivery systems: matrix tablets, microspheres, implants, hydrogels, films, 3D-printed dosage forms, and other innovations. Furthermore, it addresses the challenges associated with ML-based drug release prediction and presents current solutions while delving into future perspectives. Our investigation underscores the significance of Artificial Neural Networks in ML-based PDDS release profile prediction, surpassing both traditional and alternative ML-based methods. These extensive datasets can be drawn from literature-based resources or enhanced through specific algorithms. Moreover, ensemble-based models have proven advantageous in scenarios involving intricate relationships, such as a high number of output parameters. ML-based drug release prediction notably exhibits substantial promise in 3D-printed dosage forms, presenting a frontier for personalized medicine and precise drug delivery.

Revealing Three-Dimensional Printing Technology Advances for Oral Drug Delivery: Application to Central-Nervous-System-Related Diseases

Background/Objectives. Central nervous system (CNS)-related diseases such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's, Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder (ADHD), stroke, epilepsy, and migraines are leading causes of morbidity and disability worldwide. New solutions for drug delivery are increasingly needed. In this context, three-dimensional (3D) printing technology has introduced innovative alternatives to produce more efficient medicines with diverse features, patterns, and consistencies, particularly oral medications. Even though research in this area is growing rapidly, no study has thoroughly analyzed 3D printing oral drug delivery progress for the CNS. To fill this gap this study pursues to determine a technological landscape in this field. Methods. For this aim, a Competitive Technology Intelligence (CTI) methodology was applied, examining 747 publications from 1 January 2019 to 20 May 2024 published in the Scopus database. Results. The main advances identified comprise six categories: 3D printing techniques, characteristics and applications, materials, design factors, user acceptance, and quality processes. FDM was identified as the main technique for pharmaceutical use. The main applications include pills, polypills, caplets, gel caps, multitablets, orodispersible films, and tablets, featuring external patterns and internal structures with one or more active substances. Insights show that the most utilized materials are thermoplastic polymers like PLA, PVA, PCL, ABS, and HIPS. A novel design factor involves release patterns using compartments of varying thicknesses and volumes in the core. Additionally, advances in specialized software have enabled the creation of highly complex designs. In the user acceptance category, oral drugs dosages are tailored to the specific needs and preferences of neurological patients. Finally, for the quality aspect, the precision in Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient (API) dosage and controlled-release mechanisms are critical, given the narrow margin between therapeutic doses and toxicity for CNS diseases. Conclusions. Revealing these advancements in 3D printing for oral drug delivery allows researchers, academics, and decision-makers to identify opportunities and allocate resources efficiently, promising enhanced oral medicaments for the health and well-being of individuals suffering from CNS disorders.

Exploration of Conventional and FDM-Mediated 3D Printed Tablets Fabricated Using HME-Based Filaments for pH-Dependent Drug Delivery

Hot melt extrusion (HME) helps to improve the solubility of BCS class II and IV molecules. The downstream processing of the resulting filaments was crucial in developing the final dosage form. The present work investigates advantages of combining HME with fused deposition modelling (FDM) 3-Dimensional (3D) printing in delivering the naringenin to the colon to treat inflammatory bowel disease. HME filaments were made using a pH-sensitive polymer hydroxypropyl methylcellulose acetate succinate for the localized delivery of naringenin at the colonic pH. Polyethylene glycol (PEG - 4000) and Aerosil 200 were incorporated as plasticizer and flow modulator respectively, to facilitate the extrusion process. Naringenin was converted to amorphous form as confirmed by differential scanning calorimetry and powder x-ray diffraction. The optimized filament showed 0.03, 11.52 and 77.80% drug release at pH 1.2, 6.8 and 7.4 respectively. The tablets produced with the optimized filament by compression and 3D printing also confirmed the presence of naringenin in amorphous form and demonstrated pH-dependent release followed by zero-order release independent of the concentration. The dissolution profiles of FDM 3D printed (3DP) tablets with varying dimensions and infill densities suggested that both significantly influenced drug release from the tablets without altering the composition of tablets, indicating the potential application of 3D printing technology in developing personalized medicine according to patient requirements. These promising results may be valuable in evaluating the potential of naringenin in animal models, which may further facilitate clinical applications.

Lignin as a Bioactive Additive in Chlorzoxazone-Loaded Pharmaceutical Tablets

In the present work, the application of lignin (LIG) as a bioactive additive for the preparation of drug-loaded tablets by direct compression has been studied, and its influence on the release of chlorzoxazone (CLZ) from the hydrophilic matrices has been followed. In hydrophilic matrices, the excipients Kollidon® SR (KOL) and chitosan (CHT) have been used in various amounts and tested in the preparation of 500 mg tablets. They were used as matrix-forming agents, and their influence on the flow and the compressibility properties as well as their effect on the pharmaco-chemical characteristics of the matrix tablets have been studied. Based on the initial evaluation of the pharmaco-technical analysis, pharmaco-chemical characteristics, and in vitro release profile, three matrix tablet formulations (FLa, FLb, and FLc) were selected and further tested. They were evaluated through Fourier-transform infrared spectrometry (FTIR), X-ray diffraction (XRD), thermogravimetry (TG), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), and in vitro dissolution tests. The three formulations were comparatively studied regarding the release kinetics of active substances using in vitro release testing. The in vitro kinetic study reveals a complex release mechanism occurring in two steps of drug release. The first one is a burst effect that occurs within the first 0-2 h, involving a rapid release of the majority of the drug in a short time, followed by the second step as a prolonged release of the drug, which is relatively constant with a fixed rate over the next 2-36 h. Two factors have been calculated to assess the release profile of chlorzoxazone: f1-the similarity factor and f2-the difference factor together with the correlation coefficient R2. Comparing their values, the three optimal formulations have been selected, containing 55 mg LIG (FLa), 60 mg LIG (FLb), or 65 mg LIG (FLc), confirming that LIG next to KOL and CHT influenced the release characteristics of the matrix tablets. Due to the presence of lignin in the matrix of the three formulations, FLa, FLb, and FLc tablets with CLZ, the antioxidant activity has improved. The antioxidant activity of FLc was found to be 21.36% ± 1.06 greater than that of FLa and FLb. The tablets FLa, FLb, and FLc also presented higher antimicrobial activity against Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli, Candida albicans, and colistin-resistant Klebsiella spp. The higher the concentration of LIG in the matrix (FLc), the higher the antimicrobial activity. By using LIG, the drug dose could be decreased. It can be concluded that lignin can be used as a multifunctional pharmaceutical bioactive additive/excipient for tablets. Its interesting properties have been proven, and its use as a pharmaceutical active additive should be exploited for different applications.

Spiked Systems for Colonic Drug Delivery: Architectural Opportunities and Quality Assurance of Selective Laser Sintering

Additive manufacturing has been a breakthrough therapy for the pharmaceutical industry raising opportunities for long-quested properties, such as controlled drug-delivery. The aim of this study was to explore the geometrical capabilities of selective laser sintering (SLS) by creating spiked (tapered-edged) drug-loaded specimens for administration in colon. Poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) was used as the binding material and loperamide hydrochloride was incorporated as the active ingredient. Printing was feasible without the addition of a sintering agent or other additives. Innovative printing protocols were developed to help improve the quality of the obtained products. Intentional vibrations were applied on the powder bed through rapid movements of the printing platform in order to facilitate rigidity and consistency of the printed objects. The drug-loaded products had physicochemical properties that met the pharmacopoeia standards and exhibited good biocompatibility. The behavior of spiked balls (spherical objects with prominent spikes) and their retention time in the colon was assessed using a custom ex vivo intestinal setup. The spiked balls showed favorable mucoadhesive properties over the unspiked ones. No movement on the tissue was recorded for the spiked balls, and specimens with more spikes exhibited longer retention times and potentially, enhanced bioavailability. Our results suggest that SLS 3D printing is a versatile technology that holds the potential to revolutionize drug delivery systems by enabling the creation of complex geometries and medications with tunable properties.

An investigation of the drug release kinetics of 3D-Printed two compartment Theophylline and Prednisolone tablets

Pharmaceutical 3D printing (3DP) not only offers the possibility of dose personalization but also the co-administration of multiple active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) in one combination tablet. In this study, Theophylline (TPH) and Prednisolone (PSL) were printed as bi-tablets, which are single tablets with two distinct separate compartments. New findings show that the combination therapy of TPH with systemic corticosteroids shows a highly synergistic effect in the treatment of pulmonary diseases. For TPH, a drug with a narrow therapeutic window (NTW), precise sustained release requirements are mandatory, while PSL requires immediate drug release and is individually administered in doses specifically tied to the treatment progression. The study aims to understand the extent to which the combination of two tablet compartments influences the individual drug dissolution kinetics of the respective single compartments. Utilizing a full factorial statistical experimental design, various practically relevant doses were produced, investigated for their drug release, analyzed using different mathematical model fits, and compared with respective mono-tablets. The results show that the sustained drug release of TPH is not significantly influenced by the addition of a second compartment in relationship to respective doses. Individualization of bi-tablet doses while maintaining similar release profiles is possible with the given design setup, as release curves still show high similarity. In all tablet designs, PSL release occurred sufficiently fast, with the release rate correlating to the surface area-to-volume ratio (SA/V) as the main determining parameter.

Selective laser sintering for printing bilayer tablets

In this study Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) was used to produce bilayer tablets containing rosuvastatin and acetylsalicylic acid. Initially, monolithic tablets of each drug were manufactured using different laser intensities in order to identify their impact on the tablet's dissolution, friability and hardness. After the optimization, the final bilayer tablet was fabricated using a new method, that allowed the printing using different powder blends. For that, a 3D-printed casing was employed to maintain the compartments of the tablet in the correct position during the printing process. The results demonstrated that the increased laser intensities led to denser inner cores, enhanced hardness, decreased friability, and slower drug release. Moreover, the new method was able to produce bilayer tablets completely aligned, showing a minor impact on dissolution when the two compartments were printed together in a single tablet. The work demonstrated the feasibility of using SLS in the production of multi-material drug delivery systems.

3D printing of pharmaceutical dosage forms: Recent advances and applications

Three-dimensional (3D) printing, also referred to as additive manufacturing, is considered to be a game-changing technology in many industries and is also considered to have potential use cases in pharmaceutical manufacturing, especially if individualization is desired. In this review article the authors systematically researched literature published during the last 5 years (2019 - spring 2024) on the topic of 3D printed dosage forms. Besides all kinds of oral dosage forms ranging from tablets and capsules to films, pellets, etc., numerous reports were also identified on parenteral and cutaneous dosage forms and also rectal, vaginal, dental, intravesical, and ophthalmic preparations. In total, more than 500 publications were identified and grouped according to the site of administration, and an overview of the manuscripts is presented here. Furthermore, selected publications are described and discussed in more detail. The review highlights the very different approaches that are currently used in order to develop 3D printed dosage forms but also addresses remaining challenges.

Influence of scaffold geometry on the degradation rate of 3D printed polylactic acid bone scaffold

Fabricating scaffolds using three-dimensional (3D) printing is an emerging approach in tissue engineering (TE), where filaments with a controlled arrangement are printed. Using fused deposition modeling in bone replacement enables the simulation of bone structure. However, the microenvironment created by the scaffold must meet specific requirements. These requirements aim to create an environment that promotes adhesion, proliferation, differentiation, and cell migration. One of the challenges in creating polylactic acid scaffolds is controlling the degradation rate to match the target tissue. This study investigates the degradation of scaffolds with different geometries and the relationship between scaffolds' geometry and degradation rate. These scaffolds are made of polylactic acid and prepared using 3D printing. The lattice geometry was exposed to acidic media with varying pH levels for 1 month, and pH2 was selected for all geometries for further investigation. The five selected geometries were then immersed in the desired acid for 2 months, and measurements were taken for wet weight, dry weight, morphology, molecular weight, and crystallinity during degradation. The results showed that the hexagonal sample had a 1.5% increase in wet weight, and the gyroid sample had a 1.2% increase, indicating that the wavy shapes had a higher fluid-holding capacity. The degradation analysis indicated that the hexagonal geometry had accelerated degradation compared to the other geometries. Based on these findings, it can be concluded that filament separation not only results in rapid cooling and prevents the recovery of the crystalline arrangement but also increases the surface area to volume ratio, allowing for more acid penetration and faster degradation. Finally, mechanical properties and in vitro evaluation were assessed for three selected geometries. On the 60th day, the hexagonal scaffold had the highest elastic modulus value of 105 ± 0.45 MPa, while the gyroid scaffold had the lowest value of 58.8 ± 0.40 MPa. The lattice scaffold had the highest amount of cell attachment, with 210.88 ± 0.35 cells surviving after 24 hours and 94.01 ± 0.18 cells surviving after 72 hours. These high viability rates indicate that the three scaffolds with the selected geometries are suitable for promoting cell growth.

Sustained dual delivery of metronidazole and viable Lactobacillus crispatus from 3D-printed silicone shells

Bacterial vaginosis (BV) is an imbalance of the vaginal microbiome in which there are limited lactobacilli and an overgrowth of anaerobic and fastidious bacteria such as Gardnerella. The propensity for BV recurrence is high, and therapies involving multiple treatment modalities are emerging to meet this need. However, current treatments requiring frequent therapeutic administration are challenging for patients and impact user compliance. Three-dimensional (3D)-printing offers a novel alternative to customize platforms to facilitate sustained therapeutic delivery to the vaginal tract. This study designed a novel vehicle intended for dual sustained delivery of both antibiotic and probiotic. 3D-printed compartmental scaffolds consisting of an antibiotic-containing silicone shell and a core containing probiotic Lactobacillus were developed with multiple formulations including biomaterials sodium alginate (SA), polyethylene glycol (PEG), polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), polyethylene oxide (PEO), and kappa-carrageenan (KC). The vehicles were loaded with 50 μg of metronidazole/mg polymer and 5 × 107 CFU of L. crispatus/mg scaffold. Metronidazole-containing shells exhibited cumulative drug release of 324.2 ± 31.2 μg/mL after 14 days. Multiple polymeric formulations for the probiotic core demonstrated cumulative L. crispatus recovery of >5 × 107 CFU/mg scaffold during this timeframe. L. crispatus-loaded polymeric formulations exhibited ≥2 log CFU/mL reduction in free Gardnerella in the presence of VK2/E6E7 vaginal epithelial cells. As a first step towards the goal of facilitating patient compliance, this study demonstrates in vitro effect of a novel 3D-printed dual antibiotic and probiotic delivery platform to target BV.

An Additive Manufacturing MicroFactory: Overcoming Brittle Material Failure and Improving Product Performance through Tablet Micro-Structure Control for an Immediate Release Dose Form

Additive manufacturing of pharmaceutical formulations offers advanced micro-structure control of oral solid dose (OSD) forms targeting not only customised dosing of an active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) but also custom-made drug release profiles. Traditionally, material extrusion 3D printing manufacturing was performed in a two-step manufacturing process via an intermediate feedstock filament. This process was often limited in the material space due to unsuitable (brittle) material properties, which required additional time to develop complex formulations to overcome. The objective of this study was to develop an additive manufacturing MicroFactory process to produce an immediate release (IR) OSD form containing 250 mg of mefenamic acid (MFA) with consistent drug release. In this study, we present a single-step additive manufacturing process employing a novel, filament-free melt extrusion 3D printer, the MicroFactory, to successfully print a previously 'non-printable' brittle Soluplus®-based formulation of MFA, resulting in targeted IR dissolution profiles. The physico-chemical properties of 3D printed MFA-Soluplus®-D-sorbitol formulation was characterised by thermal analysis, Fourier Transform Infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), and X-ray Diffraction Powder (XRPD) analysis, confirming the crystalline state of mefenamic acid as polymorphic form I. Oscillatory temperature and frequency rheology sweeps were related to the processability of the formulation in the MicroFactory. 3D printed, micro-structure controlled, OSDs showed good uniformity of mass and content and exhibited an IR profile with good consistency. Fitting a mathematical model to the dissolution data correlated rate parameters and release exponents with tablet porosity. This study illustrates how additive manufacturing via melt extrusion using this MicroFactory not only streamlines the manufacturing process (one-step vs. two-step) but also enables the processing of (brittle) pharmaceutical immediate-release polymers/polymer formulations, improving and facilitating targeted in vitro drug dissolution profiles.

Influence of design parameters on sustained drug release properties of 3D-printed theophylline tablets

The application of three-dimensional printing (3DP) in the pharmaceutical industry brings a broad spectrum of benefits to patients by addressing individual needs and improve treatment success. This study investigates the sustained release properties of 3DP tablets containing Theophylline (TPH), which is commonly used to treat respiratory diseases and recently having a comeback due to its potential in the treatment of conditions like Covid-19. Since TPH is a narrow therapeutic window (NTW) drug with serious side effects in the event of overdose, the release properties must be observed particularly closely. We employed a state-of-the-art single screw extrusion 3D printer, which is fed with granules containing the drug. By employing a Taguchi orthogonal array design of experiments (DOE), tablet design parameters and factor related process stability were sought to be evaluated fundamentally. Following this, examinations regarding tailored TPH dosages were undertaken and a relationship between the real printed dose of selected tablet designs and their sustained drug release was established. The release profiles were analyzed using different mathematical model fits and compared in terms of mean dissolution times (MDT). Finally, in-vivo/in-vitro correlation (IVIVC) and physiologically based pharmacokinetic (PBPK) modeling showed that a paradigm patient group could be covered with the dosage forms produced.

Design and fabrication of 3D-printed gastric floating tablets of captopril: effect of geometry and thermal crosslinking of polymer on floating behavior and drug release

The present study aims to investigate the potential of the 3D printing technique to design gastroretentive floating tablets (GFTs) for modifying the drug release profile of an immediate-release tablet. A 3D-printed floating shell enclosing a captopril tablet was designed having varying number of drug-release windows. The impact of geometrical changes in the design of delivery system and thermal cross-linking of polymers were evaluated to observe the influence on floating ability and drug release. Water uptake, water insolubilization, Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC), and Attenuated Total Reflection-Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (ATR-FTIR) were performed to assess the degree of thermal cross-linking of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) filament. The 3D-printed GFT9 was considered the optimized gastric floating tablet that exhibited >12 h of total floating time with zero floating lag time and successfully accomplished modified-drug release by exhibiting >80% of drug release in 8 h. The zero-order release model, with an r2 value of 0.9923, best fitted the drug release kinetic data of the GFT9, which followed a super case II drug transport mechanism with an n value of 0.95. The optimized gastric floating device (GFT9) also exhibited the highest MDT values (238.55), representing slow drug release from the system due to thermal crosslinking and the presence of a single drug-releasing window in the device.

The potential of three-dimensional printing for pediatric oral solid dosage forms

Pediatric patients often require individualized dosing of medicine due to their unique pharmacokinetic and developmental characteristics. Current methods for tailoring the dose of pediatric medications, such as tablet splitting or compounding liquid formulations, have limitations in terms of dosing accuracy and palatability. This paper explores the potential of 3D printing as a solution to address the challenges and provide tailored doses of medication for each pediatric patient. The technological overview of 3D printing is discussed, highlighting various 3D printing technologies and their suitability for pharmaceutical applications. Several individualization options with the potential to improve adherence are discussed, such as individualized dosage, custom release kinetics, tablet shape, and palatability. To integrate the preparation of 3D printed medication at the point of care, a decentralized manufacturing model is proposed. In this setup, pharmaceutical companies would routinely provide materials and instructions for 3D printing, while specialized compounding centers or hospital pharmacies perform the printing of medication. In addition, clinical opportunities of 3D printing for dose-finding trials are emphasized. On the other hand, current challenges in adequate dosing, regulatory compliance, adherence to quality standards, and maintenance of intellectual property need to be addressed for 3D printing to close the gap in personalized oral medication.

AI-driven design of customized 3D-printed multi-layer capsules with controlled drug release profiles for personalized medicine

Personalized medicine aims to effectively and efficiently provide customized drugs that cater to diverse populations, which is a significant yet challenging task. Recently, the integration of artificial intelligence (AI) and three-dimensional (3D) printing technology has transformed the medical field, and was expected to facilitate the efficient design and development of customized drugs through the synergy of their respective advantages. In this study, we present an innovative method that combines AI and 3D printing technology to design and fabricate customized capsules. Initially, we discretized and encoded the geometry of the capsule, simulated the dissolution process of the capsule with classical drug dissolution model, and verified it by experiments. Subsequently, we employed a genetic algorithm to explore the capsule geometric structure space and generate a complex multi-layer structure that satisfies the target drug release profiles, including stepwise release and zero-order release. Finally, Two model drugs, isoniazid and acetaminophen, were selected and fused deposition modeling (FDM) 3D printing technology was utilized to precisely print the AI-designed capsule. The reliability of the method was verified by comparing the in vitro release curve of the printed capsules with the target curve, and the f2 value was more than 50. Notably, accurate and autonomous design of the drug release curve was achieved mainly by changing the geometry of the capsule. This approach is expected to be applied to different drug needs and facilitate the development of customized oral dosage forms.

Impact of polymer chemistry on critical quality attributes of selective laser sintering 3D printed solid oral dosage forms

The aim of this study is to investigate the influence of polymer chemistry on the properties of oral dosage forms produced using selective laser sintering (SLS). The dosage forms were printed using different grades of polyvinyl alcohol or copovidone in combination with indomethacin as the active pharmaceutical ingredient. The properties of the printed structures were assessed according to European Pharmacopoeia guidelines at different printing temperatures and laser scanning speeds in order to determine the suitable printing parameters. The results of the study indicate that the chemical properties of the polymers, such as dynamic viscosity, degree of hydrolyzation, and molecular weight, have significant impact on drug release and kinetics. Drug release rate and supersaturation can be modulated by selecting the appropriate polymer type. Furthermore, the physical properties of the dosage forms printed under the same settings are influenced by the selected polymer type, which determines the ideal manufacturing settings. This study demonstrates how the chemical properties of the polymer can determine the appropriate choice of manufacturing settings and the final properties of oral dosage forms produced using SLS.

3D printed matrix solid forms: Can the drug solubility and dose customisation affect their controlled release behaviour?

The use of 3D printing in pharmaceutics has grown over the last years, along with the number of studies on the impact of the composition of these formulations on their pharmaceutical and biopharmaceutical properties. Recently, we reported the combined effect of the infill percentage and the presence of a pore former on the drug release behaviour of 3D printed matrix solid forms prepared by fused deposition modelling. However, there are some open questions about the effect of the drug solubility and the size of these dosage forms on their controlled release properties. Therefore, we produced poly(Ɛ-caprolactone) filaments containing different soluble forms of dexamethasone (free acid, DEX; acetate ester, DEX-A; and phosphate salt, DEX-P), which showed suitable mechanical properties and printability. 3D printed solid forms were produced in two different sizes. The formulations composed of DEX-P released about 50% of drug after 10 h, while those containing DEX or DEX-A released about 9%. The drug release profiles from the 3D printed forms containing the same drug form but with different sizes were almost completely overlapped. Therefore, these 3D printed matrix solid forms can have their drug content customised by adjusting their size, without changing their controlled release behaviour.

Role of Polymer Concentration on the Release Rates of Proteins from Single- and Double-Network Hydrogels

Controlled delivery of proteins has immense potential for the treatment of various human diseases, but effective strategies for their delivery are required before this potential can be fully realized. Recent research has identified hydrogels as a promising option for the controlled delivery of therapeutic proteins, owing to their ability to respond to diverse chemical and biological stimuli, as well as their customizable properties that allow for desired delivery rates. This study utilized alginate and chitosan as model polymers to investigate the effects of hydrogel properties on protein release rates. The results demonstrated that polymer properties, concentration, and crosslinking density, as well as their responses to pH, can be tailored to regulate protein release rates. The study also revealed that hydrogels may be combined to create double-network hydrogels to provide an additional metric to control protein release rates. Furthermore, the hydrogel scaffolds were also found to preserve the long-term function and structure of encapsulated proteins before their release from the hydrogels. In conclusion, this research demonstrates the significance of integrating porosity and response to stimuli as orthogonal control parameters when designing hydrogel-based scaffolds for therapeutic protein release.

A Bibliometric Analysis of 3D Printing in Personalized Medicine Research from 2012 to 2022

In recent years, the 3D printing of personalized drug formulations has attracted the attention of medical practitioners and academics. However, there is a lack of data-based analyses on the hotspots and trends of research in this field. Therefore, in this study, we performed a bibliometric analysis to summarize the 3D printing research in the field of personalized drug formulation from 2012 to 2022. This study was based on the Web of Science Core Collection Database, and a total of 442 eligible publications were screened. Using VOSviewer and online websites for bibliometric analysis and scientific mapping, it was observed that annual publications have shown a significant growth trend over the last decade. The United Kingdom and the United States, which account for 45.5% of the total number of publications, are the main drivers of this field. The International Journal of Pharmaceutics and University College London are the most prolific and cited journals and institutions. The researchers with the most contributions are Basit, Abdul W. and Goyanes Alvaro. The keyword analysis concluded that the current research hotspots are "drug release" and "drug dosage forms". In conclusion, 3D printing has broad application prospects in the field of personalized drugs, which will bring the pharmaceutical industry into a new era of innovation.

3D printed pH-responsive tablets containing N-acetylglucosamine-loaded methylcellulose hydrogel for colon drug delivery applications

The pH-responsive drug release approach in combination with three-dimensional (3D) printing for colon-specific oral drug administration can address the limitations of current treatments such as orally administered solid tablets. Such existing treatments fail to effectively deliver the right drug dosage to the colon. In order to achieve targeted drug release profiles, this work aimed at designing and producing 3D printed tablet shells using Eudragit® FS100 and polylactic acid (PLA) where the core was filled with 100 µl of N-acetylglucosamine (GlcNAc)-loaded methyl cellulose (MC) hydrogel. To meet the requirements of such tablets, the effects of polymer blending ratios and MC concentrations on physical, thermal, and material properties of various components of the tablets and most importantly in vitro drug release kinetics were investigated. The tablets with 80/20 wt% of Eudragit® FS100/PLA and the drug-loaded hydrogel with 30 mg/ml GlcNAc and 3% w/v MC showed the most promising results having the best printability, processability, and drug release kinetics besides being non-cytotoxic. Manufacturing of these tablets will be the first milestone in shifting from the conventional "one size fits all" approach to personalized medicine where different dosages and various combinations of drugs can be effectively delivered to the inflammation site.

Development of an immediate release excipient composition for 3D printing via direct powder extrusion in a hospital

3D printing offers the possibility to prepare personalized tablets on demand, making it an intriguing technology for hospital pharmacies. For the implementation of 3D-printed tablets into the digital Closed Loop Medication Management system, the required tablet formulation and development of the manufacturing process as well as the pharmaceutical validation were conducted. The goal of the formulation development was to enable an optimal printing process and rapid dissolution of the printed tablets for the selected model drugs Levodopa/Carbidopa. The 3D printed tablets were prepared by direct powder extrusion. Printability, thermal properties, disintegration, dissolution, physical properties and storage stability were investigated by employing analytical methods such as HPLC-UV, DSC and TGA. The developed formulation shows a high dose accuracy and an immediate drug release for Levodopa. In addition, the tablets exhibit high crushing strength and very low friability. Unfortunately, Carbidopa did not tolerate the printing process. This is the first study to develop an immediate release excipient composition via direct powder extrusion in a hospital pharmacy setting. The developed process is suitable for the implementation in Closed-Loop Medication Management systems in hospital pharmacies and could therefore contribute to medication safety.

Customizable 3D Printed Implants Containing Triamcinolone Acetonide: Development, Analysis, Modification, and Modeling of Drug Release

Three-dimensional-printed customizable drug-loaded implants provide promising opportunities to improve the current therapy options. In this study, we present a modular implant in which shape, dosage, and drug release can be individualized independently of each other to patient characteristics to improve parenteral therapy with triamcinolone acetonide (TA) over three months. This study focused on the examination of release modification via fused deposition modeling and subsequent prediction. The filaments for printing consisted of TA, ethyl cellulose, hypromellose, and triethyl citrate. Two-compartment implants were successfully developed, consisting of a shape-adaptable shell and an embedded drug-loaded network. For the network, different strand widths and pore size combinations were printed and analyzed in long-term dissolution studies to evaluate their impact on the release performance. TA release varied between 8.58 ± 1.38 mg and 21.93 mg ± 1.31 mg over three months depending on the network structure and the resulting specific surface area. Two different approaches were employed to predict the TA release over time. Because of the varying release characteristics, applicability was limited, but successful in several cases. Using a simple Higuchi-based approach, good release predictions could be made for a release time of 90 days from the release data of the initial 15 days (RMSEP ≤ 3.15%), reducing the analytical effort and simplifying quality control. These findings are important to establish customizable implants and to optimize the therapy with TA for specific intra-articular diseases.

Microfluidic Devices: A Tool for Nanoparticle Synthesis and Performance Evaluation

The use of nanoparticles (NPs) in nanomedicine holds great promise for the treatment of diseases for which conventional therapies present serious limitations. Additionally, NPs can drastically improve early diagnosis and follow-up of many disorders. However, to harness their full capabilities, they must be precisely designed, produced, and tested in relevant models. Microfluidic systems can simulate dynamic fluid flows, gradients, specific microenvironments, and multiorgan complexes, providing an efficient and cost-effective approach for both NPs synthesis and screening. Microfluidic technologies allow for the synthesis of NPs under controlled conditions, enhancing batch-to-batch reproducibility. Moreover, due to the versatility of microfluidic devices, it is possible to generate and customize endless platforms for rapid and efficient in vitro and in vivo screening of NPs' performance. Indeed, microfluidic devices show great potential as advanced systems for small organism manipulation and immobilization. In this review, first we summarize the major microfluidic platforms that allow for controlled NPs synthesis. Next, we will discuss the most innovative microfluidic platforms that enable mimicking in vitro environments as well as give insights into organism-on-a-chip and their promising application for NPs screening. We conclude this review with a critical assessment of the current challenges and possible future directions of microfluidic systems in NPs synthesis and screening to impact the field of nanomedicine.

3D printing tablets for high-precision dose titration of caffeine

Through 3D printing (3DP), many parameters of solid oral dosage forms can be customised, allowing for truly personalised medicine in a way that traditional pharmaceutical manufacturing would struggle to achieve. One of the many options for customisation involves dose titration, allowing for gradual weaning of a medication at dose intervals smaller than what is available commercially. In this study we demonstrate the high accuracy and precision of 3DP dose titration of caffeine, selected due to its global prevalence as a behavioural drug and well-known titration-dependent adverse reactions in humans. This was achieved using a simple filament base of polyvinyl alcohol, glycerol, and starch, utilising hot melt extrusion coupled with fused deposition modelling 3DP. Tablets containing 25 mg, 50 mg, and 100 mg doses of caffeine were successfully printed with drug content in the accepted range prescribed for conventional tablets (90 - 110%), and excellent precision whereby the weights of all doses showed a relative standard deviation of no more than 3%. Importantly, these results proved 3D printed tablets to be far superior to splitting a commercially available caffeine tablet. Additional assessment of filament and tablet samples were reviewed by differential scanning calorimetry, thermogravimetric analysis, HPLC, and scanning electron microscopy, showing no evidence of degradation of caffeine or the raw materials, with smooth and consistent filament extrusion. Upon dissolution, all tablets achieved greater than 70% release between 50 and 60 min, showing a predictable rapid release profile regardless of dose. The outcomes of this study highlight the benefits that dose titration with 3DP can offer, especially to more commonly prescribed medications that can have even more harmful withdrawal-induced adverse reactions.

Tablet Geometry Effect on the Drug Release Profile from a Hydrogel-Based Drug Delivery System

In order to achieve the optimal level of effectiveness and safety of drugs, it is necessary to control the drug release rate. Therefore, it is important to discover the factors affecting release profile from a drug delivery system. Geometry is one of these effective factors for a tablet-shaped drug delivery system. In this study, an attempt has been made to answer a general question of how the geometry of a tablet can affect the drug release profile. For this purpose, the drug release process of theophylline from two hundred HPMC-based tablets, which are categorized into eight groups of common geometries in the production of oral tablets, was simulated using finite element analysis. The analysis of the results of these simulations was carried out using statistical methods including partial least squares regression and ANOVA tests. The results showed that it is possible to predict the drug release profile by knowing the geometry type and dimensions of a tablet without performing numerous dissolution tests. Another result was that, although in many previous studies the difference in the drug release profile from several tablets with different geometries was interpreted only by variables related to the surface, the results showed that regardless of the type of geometry and its dimensions, it is not possible to have an accurate prediction of the drug release profile. Also, the results showed that without any change in the dose of the drug and the ingredients of the tablet and only because of the difference in geometry type, the tablets significantly differ in release profile. This occurred in such a way that, for example, the release time of the entire drug mass from two tablets with the same mass and materials but different geometries can be different by about seven times.

Formulation and characterization of pressure-assisted microsyringe 3D-printed scaffolds for controlled intravaginal antibiotic release

Bacterial vaginosis (BV) is a highly recurrent vaginal condition linked with many health complications. Topical antibiotic treatments for BV are challenged with drug solubility in vaginal fluid, lack of convenience and user adherence to daily treatment protocols, among other factors. 3D-printed scaffolds can provide sustained antibiotic delivery to the female reproductive tract (FRT). Silicone vehicles have been shown to provide structural stability, flexibility, and biocompatibility, with favorable drug release kinetics. This study formulates and characterizes novel metronidazole-containing 3D-printed silicone scaffolds for eventual application to the FRT. Scaffolds were evaluated for degradation, swelling, compression, and metronidazole release in simulated vaginal fluid (SVF). Scaffolds retained high structural integrity and sustained release. Minimal mass loss (<6%) and swelling (<2%) were observed after 14 days in SVF, relative to initial post-cure measurements. Scaffolds cured for 24 hr (50 °C) demonstrated elastic behavior under 20% compression and 4.0 N load. Scaffolds cured for 4 hr (50 °C), followed by 72 hr (4 °C), demonstrated the highest, sustained, metronidazole release (4.0 and 27.0 µg/mg) after 24 hr and 14 days, respectively. Based upon daily release profiles, it was observed that the 24 hr timepoint had the greatest metronidazole release of 4.08 μg/mg for scaffolds cured at 4 hr at 50 °C followed by 72 hr at 4 °C. For all curing conditions, release of metronidazole after 1 and 7 days showed > 4.0-log reduction in Gardnerella concentration. Negligible cytotoxicity was observed in treated keratinocytes comparable to untreated cells, This study shows that pressure-assisted microsyringe 3D-printed silicone scaffolds may provide a versatile vehicle for sustained metronidazole delivery to the FRT.

The Influence of Shape Parameters on Unidirectional Drug Release from 3D Printed Implants and Prediction of Release from Implants with Individualized Shapes

The local treatment of diseases by drug-eluting implants is a promising tool to enable successful therapy under potentially reduced systemic side effects. Especially, the highly flexible manufacturing technique of 3D printing provides the opportunity for the individualization of implant shapes adapted to the patient-specific anatomy. It can be assumed that variations in shape can strongly affect the released amounts of drug per time. This influence was investigated by performing drug release studies with model implants of different dimensions. For this purpose, bilayered model implants in a simplified geometrical shape in form of bilayered hollow cylinders were developed. The drug-loaded abluminal part consisted of a suitable polymer ratio of Eudragit® RS and RL, while the drug-free luminal part composed of polylactic acid served as a diffusion barrier. Implants with different heights and wall thicknesses were produced using an optimized 3D printing process, and drug release was determined in vitro. The area-to-volume ratio was identified as an important parameter influencing the fractional drug release from the implants. Based on the obtained results drug release from 3D printed implants with individual shapes exemplarily adapted to the frontal neo-ostial anatomy of three different patients was predicted and also tested in an independent set of experiments. The similarity of predicted and tested release profiles indicates the predictability of drug release from individualized implants for this particular drug-eluting system and could possibly facilitate the estimation of the performance of customized implants independent of individual in vitro testing of each implant geometry.

3D printing of amorphous solid dispersions: A comparison of fused deposition modeling and drop-on-powder printing

Nowadays, a high number of pipeline drugs are poorly soluble and require solubility enhancement by e.g., manufacturing of amorphous solid dispersion. Pharmaceutical 3D printing has great potential in producing amorphous solid oral dosage forms. However, 3D printing techniques differ greatly in terms of processing as well as tablet properties. In this study, an amorphous formulation, which had been printed via Fused Deposition Modeling and drop-on-powder printing, also known as binder jetting, was characterized in terms of solid-state properties and physical stability. Solid state assessment was performed by differential scanning calorimetry, powder X-ray diffraction and polarized microscopy. The supersaturation performance of the amorphous solid dispersion was assessed via non-sink dissolution. We further evaluated both 3D printing techniques regarding their processability as well as tablet uniformity in terms of dimension, mass and content. Challenges and limitations of each 3D printing technique were discussed. Both techniques are feasible for the production of amorphous formulations. Results indicated that Fused Deposition Modeling is better suited for production, as the recrystallization tendency was lower. Still, filament production and printing presented a major challenge. Drop-on-powder printing can be a viable alternative for the production of amorphous tablets, when a formulation is not printable by Fused Deposition Modeling.

Investigations into the use of machine learning to predict drug dosage form design to obtain desired release profiles for 3D printed oral medicines

Three-dimensional (3D) printing, digitalization, and artificial intelligence (AI) are gaining increasing interest in modern medicine. All three aspects are combined in personalized medicine where 3D-printed dosage forms are advantageous because of their variable geometry design. The geometry design can be used to determine the surface area to volume (SA/V) ratio, which affects drug release from the dosage forms. This study investigated artificial neural networks (ANN) to predict suitable geometries for the desired dose and release profile. Filaments with 5% API load and polyvinyl alcohol were 3D printed using Fused Deposition Modeling to provide a wide variety of geometries with different dosages and SA/V ratios. These were dissolved in vitro, and the API release profiles were described mathematically. Using these data, ANN architectures were designed with the goal of predicting a suitable dosage form geometry. Poor accuracies of 68.5% in the training and 44.4% in the test settings were achieved with a classification architecture. However, the SA/V ratio could be predicted accurately with a mean squared error loss of only 0.05. This study shows that the prediction of the SA/V ratio using AI works, but not of the exact geometry. For this purpose, a global database could be built with a range of geometries to simplify the prescription process.

Controlled Release of Felodipine from 3D-Printed Tablets with Constant Surface Area: Influence of Surface Geometry

In this study, 3D-printed tablets with a constant surface area were designed and fabricated using polylactic acid (PLA) in the outer compartment and polyvinyl alcohol and felodipine (FDP) in the inner compartment. The influences of different surface geometries of the inner compartment, namely, round, hexagon, square, and triangle, on drug release from 3D-printed tablets were also studied. The morphology and porosity of the inner compartment were determined using scanning electron microscopy and synchrotron radiation X-ray tomographic microscopy, respectively. Additionally, drug content and drug release were also evaluated. The results revealed that the round-shaped geometry seemed to have the greatest total surface area of the inner compartment, followed by square-shaped, hexagon-shaped, and triangle-shaped geometries. FDP-loaded 3D-printed tablets with triangle and hexagon surface geometries had the slowest drug release (about 80% within 24 h). In the round-shaped and square-shaped 3D-printed tablets, complete drug release was observed within 12 h. Furthermore, the drug release from triangle-shaped 3D-printed tablets with double the volume of the inner compartment was faster than that of a smaller volume. This was due to the fact that a larger tablet volume increased the surface area contacting the medium, resulting in a faster drug release. The findings indicated that the surface geometry of 3D-printed tablets with a constant surface area affected drug release. This study suggests that 3D printing technology may be used to develop oral solid dosage forms suitable for customized therapeutic treatments.

Additive manufacturing technologies with emphasis on stereolithography 3D printing in pharmaceutical and medical applications: A review

Three-dimensional (3D) printing or Additive Manufacturing (AM) technology is an innovative tool with great potential and diverse applications in various fields. As 3D printing has been burgeoning in recent times, a tremendous transformation can be envisaged in medical care, especially the manufacturing procedures leading to personalized medicine. Stereolithography (SLA), a vat-photopolymerization technique, that uses a laser beam, is known for its ability to fabricate complex 3D structures ranging from micron-size needles to life-size organs, because of its high resolution, precision, accuracy, and speed. This review presents a glimpse of varied 3D printing techniques, mainly expounding SLA in terms of the materials used, the orientation of printing, and the working mechanisms. The previous works that focused on developing pharmaceutical dosage forms, drug-eluting devices, and tissue scaffolds are presented in this paper, followed by the challenges associated with SLA from an industrial and regulatory perspective. Due to its excellent advantages, this technology could transform the conventional "one dose fits all" concept to bring digitalized patient-centric medication into reality.

Drop-on-powder 3D printing of amorphous high dose oral dosage forms: Process development, opportunities and printing limitations

Drop-on-powder 3D printing is able to produce highly drug loaded solid oral dosage forms. However, this technique is mainly limited to well soluble drugs. The majority of pipeline compounds is poorly soluble, though, and requires solubility enhancement, e.g., via formation of amorphous solid dispersions. This study presents a detailed and systematic development approach for the production of tablets containing high amounts of a poorly soluble, amorphized drug via drop-on-powder 3D printing (also known as binder jetting). Amorphization of the compound was achieved via hot-melt extrusion using the exemplary system of the model compound ketoconazole and copovidone as matrix polymer at drug loadings of 20% and 40%. The milled extrudate was used as powder for printing and the influence of inks and different ink-to-powder ratios on recrystallization of ketoconazole was investigated in a material-saving small-scale screening. Crystallinity assessment was performed using differential scanning calorimetry and polarized light microscopy to identify even small traces of crystallinity. Printing of tablets showed that the performed small-scale screening was capable to identify printing parameters for the development of amorphous and mechanically stable tablets via drop-on-powder printing. A stability study demonstrated physically stable tablets over twelve weeks at accelerated storage conditions.

User-designed device with programmable release profile for localized treatment

Three-dimensional printing enables precise and on-demand manufacture of customizable drug delivery systems to advance healthcare toward the goal of personalized medicine. However, major challenges remain in realizing personalized drug delivery that fits a patient-specific drug dosing schedule using local drug delivery systems. In this study, a user-designed device is developed as implantable therapeutics that can realize personalized drug release kinetics by programming the inner structural design on the microscale. The drug release kinetics required for various treatments, including dose-dense therapy and combination therapy, can be implemented by controlling the dosage and combination of drugs along with the rate, duration, initiation time, and time interval of drug release according to the device layer design. After implantation of the capsular device in mice, the in vitro-in vivo and pharmacokinetic evaluation of the device is performed, and the therapeutic effect of the developed device is achieved through the local release of doxorubicin. The developed user-designed device provides a novel platform for developing next-generation drug delivery systems for personalized and localized therapy.

3D-Printed EVA Devices for Antiviral Delivery and Herpes Virus Control in Genital Infection

Herpes viruses are widespread in the human population and can cause many different diseases. Genital herpes is common and can increase the risk of HIV infection and neonatal herpes. Acyclovir is the most used drug for herpes treatment; however, it presents some disadvantages due to its poor oral bioavailability. In this study, some ethylene vinyl acetate devices with different acyclovir amounts (0, 10, and 20 wt.%) were manufactured by fused filament fabrication in two different geometries, an intrauterine device, and an intravaginal ring. Thermal analyses suggested that the crystallinity of EVA decreased up to 8% for the sample loaded with 20 wt.% of acyclovir. DSC, SEM, and FTIR analyses confirmed that the drug was successfully incorporated into the EVA matrix. Moreover, the drug release tests suggested a burst release during the first 24 h followed by a slower release rate sustained up to 80 days. Biological assays showed the biocompatibility of the EVA/ACV device, as well as a 99% reduction in vitro replication of HSV-1. Finally, the EVA presented a suitable performance for 3D printing manufacturing that can contribute to developing personalized solutions for long-term herpes treatment.

Modified Release Kinetics in Dual Filament 3D Printed Individualized Oral Dosage Forms

On demand production of totally customizable combinative preparations is a central goal of a patient-centric pharmaceutical supply chain. Additive manufacturing techniques like fused deposition modeling (FDM) could be key technologies towards such individualized dosage forms. As so far only a limited number of studies on 3D printed combinative preparations applying FDM have been reported, a core-shell dosage form was the focus of the present study. Dosage forms with an initial and a sustained release part with theophylline as model API were successfully produced applying a dual nozzle FDM 3D printer. Investigations identified microstructural defects at the interface between the two formulations by means of µCT analysis. Dissolution testing proved the achievement of the intended release profile. In combination with additionally characterized release profile of single material prints of different shapes, the combinative release profiles could be predicted by developing model equations and taking into account the geometric composition. As these model approaches can accordingly facilitate the prediction of API release from 3D printed combinative preparations with only data from single material release. This is a first step towards a truly individualized and reliable patient-centric pharmaceutical supply via 3D printing.

Development of sustained-release drug-loaded intravesical inserts via semi-solid micro-extrusion 3D-printing for bladder targeting

Discontinued treatment and non-adherence are oftentimes weaknesses of common first-line drug therapy against bladder conditions due to their negative side-effects. To overcome these limitations and increase patients' quality of life, intravesical therapies are continuously being explored. 3D-printing offers the possibility of freely tailoring drug delivery systems to manufacture indwelling devices that may administer drugs locally over an extended time and avoiding frequently repeated administrations while minimizing systemic side-effects. In the present work, pressure-assisted micro syringe printing has been used to develop flexible drug-loaded inserts applicable via common urinary catheter that can remain up to several weeks inside the urinary bladder. Three APIs (lidocaine hydrochloride, trospium chloride (TrCl) and hydrochlorothiazide (HCT)) with different properties and solubilities were investigated for their applicability together with two different pharmaceutical polymers (biodegradable polycaprolactone (PCL) and non-degradable ethylene vinyl acetate copolymer (EVA)). The fastest release was thereby observed for the PCL-TrCl combination and the slowest for EVA-HCT depending on the API's solubility in the dissolution medium and formation of API clusters within the matrix. It was further demonstrated that the dissolution profile could be modified by adapting drug loads between 5 and 15 % or the geometry of the printed inserts indicating the possibility of tailoring release profiles.

3D Printed Mini-Floating-Polypill for Parkinson's Disease: Combination of Levodopa, Benserazide, and Pramipexole in Various Dosing for Personalized Therapy

Therapy for Parkinson’s disease is quite challenging. Numerous drugs are available for symptomatic treatment, and levodopa (LD), in combination with a dopa decarboxylase inhibitor (e.g., benserazide (BZ)), has been the drug of choice for years. As the disease progresses, therapy must be supplemented with a dopamine agonist (e.g., pramipexole (PDM)). Side effects increase, as do the required dose and dosing intervals. For these specific requirements of drug therapy, the 3D printing method fused deposition modelling (FDM) was applied in this study for personalized therapy. Hot melt extrusion was utilized to produce two different compositions into filaments: PDM and polyvinyl alcohol for rapid drug release and a fixed combination of LD/BZ (4:1) in an ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer matrix for prolonged drug release. Since LD is absorbed in the upper gastrointestinal tract, a formulation that floats in gastric fluid was desired to prolong API absorption. Using the FDM 3D printing process, different polypill geometries were printed from both filaments, with variable dosages. Dosage forms with 15−180 mg LD could be printed, showing similar release rates (f2 > 50). In addition, a mini drug delivery dosage form was printed that released 75% LD/BZ within 750 min and could be used as a gastric retentive drug delivery system due to the floating properties of the composition. The floating mini-polypill was designed to accommodate patients’ swallowing difficulties and to allow for individualized dosing with an API release over a longer period of time.

Embedding a Sensitive Liquid-Core Waveguide UV Detector into an HPLC-UV System for Simultaneous Quantification of Differently Dosed Active Ingredients during Drug Release

Individual dosing of pharmaceutics and personalized medicine have become important with regard to therapeutic safety. Dose adjustments, biorelevant drug release and combination of multiple active substances in one dosage form for the reduction in polymedication are essential aspects that increase the safety and acceptance of the patient’s pharmacotherapy. Therefore, not only innovative drug products but also new analytical methods are needed during the drug development phase and for quality control that can simultaneously determine different active ingredients and cover wide concentration ranges. We investigated a liquid-core waveguide UV absorbance flow cell detector coupled to an existing HPLC-UV system. A Teflon AF 2400 capillary tubing of 20 cm length was connected in series to the HPLC flow line and enabled a lower limit of quantification of 1 ng/mL pramipexole (increase in sensitivity by 20 compared to common 0.9 cm flow cells). This allowed the low-concentration of pramipexole and the higher concentrations of levodopa and benserazide occurring during drug release to be determined in a single chromatographic run within 22.5 min.

Blind-Watermarking—Proof-of-Concept of a Novel Approach to Ensure Batch Traceability for 3D Printed Tablets

Falsified medicines are a major issue and a threat around the world. Various approaches are currently being investigated to mitigate the threat. In this study, a concept is tested that encodes binary digits (bits) on the surface of Fused Deposition Modelling (FDM) 3D printed geometries. All that is needed is a computer, a FDM 3D printer and a paper scanner for detection. For the experiments, eleven different formulations were tested, covering the most used polymers for 3D printing in pharma: Ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA), polyvinyl alcohol (PVA), polylactic acid (PLA), Hypromellose (HPMC), ethyl cellulose (EC), basic butylated-methacrylate-copolymer (EPO), and ammonio-methacrylate-copolymer type A (ERL). In addition, the scanning process and printing process were evaluated. It was possible to print up to 32 bits per side on oblong shaped tablets corresponding to the dimensions of market preparations of oblong tablets and capsules. Not all polymers or polymer blends were suitable for this method. Only PVA, PLA, EC, EC+HPMC, and EPO allowed the detection of bits with the scanner. EVA and ERL had too much surface roughness, too low viscosity, and cooled down too slowly preventing the detection of bits. It was observed that the addition of a colorant or active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) could facilitate the detection process. Thus, the process could be transferred for 3D printed pharmaceuticals, but further improvement is necessary to increase robustness and allow use for more materials.

Dose-independent drug release from 3D printed oral medicines for patient-specific dosing to improve therapy safety

Fused deposition modelling (FDM) 3D printing provides the ability to address individual patients' therapeutic needs without having to change the formulation every time. This is particularly interesting for dosing and release modelling. In this study, a geometry model was developed that can represent variable dosages while keeping the surface area to volume (SA/V) ratio alike, so the drug release profiles remain similar. The model was tested on three different formulations. Two BCS I active pharmaceutical ingredients (API), pramipexole and levodopa, and one BCS II API, praziquantel, were used. Polyvinyl alcohol (PVA, water soluble) and a combination of vinylpyrrolidone-vinyl acetate copolymer (PVP-VA, water soluble) and ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA, water insoluble) were used as the polymer matrix. The curves were compared using the similarity factor (f₂ value) and mean dissolution time (MDT). Using a hollow cylinder-based (HCb) geometry model, a dose-independent drug release could be realized. For the PVA formulations, an 8-fold dose change could be obtained and for the EVA-PVP-VA formulation a factor of 5.5 could be achieved, with f₂ > 50. Due to the layer structure of the printed objects, very fine dose variation of 0.13 mg per layer is possible within these models. This allows variable dosing in small steps with only one basis formulation.

3D printing of pharmaceutical oral solid dosage forms by fused deposition: the enhancement of printability using plasticised HPMCAS

3D printing (3DP) by fused deposition modelling (FDM) is one of the most extensively developed methods in additive manufacturing. Optimizing printability by improving feedability, nozzle extrusion, and layer deposition is crucial for manufacturing solid oral dosage forms with desirable properties. This work aimed to use HPMCAS (Affinisol^TM HPMCAS 716) to prepare filaments for FDM-3DP using hot-melt extrusion (HME). It explored and demonstrated the effect of HME-filament composition and fabrication on printability by evaluating thermal, mechanical, and thermo-rheological properties. It also showed that the HME-Polymer filament composition used in FDM-3DP manufacture of oral solid dosage forms provides a tailored drug release profile. HME (HAAKE MiniLab) and FDM-3DP (MakerBot) were used to prepare HME-filaments and printed objects, respectively. Two diverse ways of improving the mechanical properties of HME-filaments were deduced by changing the formulation to enable feeding through the roller gears of the printer nozzle. These include plasticizing the polymer and adding an insoluble structuring agent (talc) into the formulation. Experimental feedability was predicted using texture analysis results was a function of PEG concentration, and glass-transition temperature (T_g) values of HME-filaments. The effect of high HME screw speed (100 rpm) resulted in inhomogeneity of HME-filament, which resulted in inconsistency of the printer nozzle extrudate and printed layers. The variability of the glass-transition temperature (T_g) of the HME-filament supported by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images of nozzle extrudates and the lateral wall of the printed tablet helped explain this result. The melt viscosity of HPMCAS formulations was investigated using a capillary rheometer. The high viscosity of unplasticized HPMCAS was concluded to be an additional restriction for nozzle extrusion. The plasticization of HPMCAS and the addition of talc into the formulation were shown to improve thickness consistency of printed layers (using homogeneous HME-filaments). A good correlation (R²=0.9546) between the solidification threshold (low-frequency oscillation test determined by parallel-plate rheometer) and T_g of HME-filaments was also established. Drug-loaded and placebo HPMCAS-based formulations were shown to be successfully printed, with the former providing tailored drug release profiles based on variation of internal geometry (infill).

Precise Dosing of Pramipexole for Low-Dosed Filament Production by Hot Melt Extrusion Applying Various Feeding Methods

The aim of this research was the production of low-dosed filaments via hot-melt extrusion (HME) with the model drug pramipexole for the treatment of Parkinson’s disease. The active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) and one of the polymers polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) or basic butylated methacrylate copolymer (bPMMA) were fed by various dosing techniques with the aim of achieving the smallest deviation (RSD) from the target concentration of 0.1% (w/w) pramipexole. It was found that deviation from target pramipexole concentration occurred due to degradation products in bPMMA formulations. Additionally, material temperature above 120 °C led to the formation of the anhydrous form of pramipexole within the extruded filaments and need to be considered in the calculation of the recovered API. This study clearly shows that even if equilibrium state of the extrusion parameters was reached, equilibrium condition for drug content was reached relatively late in the process. In addition, the RSD calculated by the Stange–Poole equation was proposed by us to predict the final content uniformity considering the sample size of the analyzed filament. The calculated RSD, depending on sample size and drug load, can serve as upper and lower limits of variation from target concentration and can be used to evaluate the deviations of drug content in equilibrium conditions of the HME process. The lowest deviations from target concentration in equilibrium condition for drug content were obtained in filaments extruded from previously prepared granule mixtures (RSD = 6.00%, acceptance value = 12.2). These promising results can be transferred to other API–excipient combinations to produce low-dosed filaments, which can be used for, e.g., fused filament 3D printing. The introduced calculation of the RSD by Stange–Poole equation can be used for precise determination of the homogeneity of an extruded batch.

Determination of feed forces to improve process understanding of Fused Deposition Modeling 3D printing and to ensure mass conformity of printed solid oral dosage forms

Fused Deposition Modeling is a suitable technique for the production of personalized solid oral dosage forms. For widespread application, it is necessary to be able to print a wide range of different formulations to address individual therapeutic needs. Due to the complexity of formulation composition (e.g., due to different compounds, excipients for enhancement of release and mechanical properties) and limited mechanical understanding, determination of suitable printing parameters is challenging. To address this challenge, we have developed a feed force tester using a Texture Analyser setup that mimics the actual printing process. Feed force data were compared to the mass of tablets printed from technical materials as well as pharmaceutical filaments of ketoconazole at high drug loads of 20 and 40% and polyvinyl alcohol. By determining a feed force limit for the 3D printer from feed force data of several formulations printed, it was possible to specify the operable printing range, where printing is reproducible and printed mass corresponds the target mass. Based on these results, rational optimization of the printing process in terms of speed, time and temperature for different materials and formulations is possible.