Mutation of W215 compromises thrombin cleavage of fibrinogen, but not of PAR-1 or protein C

Fbg αC 389-402 Enhances Factor XIII Cross-Linking in the Fibrinogen αC Region Via Electrostatic and Hydrophobic Interactions

Coagulation Factor XIII (FXIII) stabilizes blood clots by cross-linking glutamines and lysines in fibrin and other proteins. FXIII activity in the fibrinogen αC region (Fbg αC 221-610) is critical for clot stability and growth. Fbg αC 389-402 is a binding site for thrombin-activated FXIII, (FXIII-A*), with αC E396 promoting FXIII-A* binding and activity in αC. The current study aimed to discover additional residues within Fbg αC 389-402 that accelerate transglutaminase activity toward αC. Electrostatic αC residues (E395, E396, and D390), hydrophobic αC residues (W391 and F394), and residues αC 328-425 were studied by mutations to recombinant Fbg αC 233-425. FXIII activity was monitored through MS-based glycine ethyl ester (GEE) cross-linking and gel-based fluorescence monodansylcadaverine (MDC) cross-linking assays. Truncation mutations 403 Stop (Fbg αC 233-402), 389 Stop (Fbg αC 233-388), and 328 Stop (Fbg αC 233-327) reduced Q237-GEE and MDC cross-linking compared to wild-type (WT). Comparable cross-linking between 389 Stop and 328 Stop showed that FXIII is mainly affected by the loss of Fbg αC 389-402. Substitution mutations E396A, D390A, W391A, and F394A decreased cross-linking relative to WT, whereas E395A, E395S, E395K, and E396D had no effect. Similar FXIII-A* activities were observed for double mutants (D390A, E396A) and (W391A, E396A), relative to D390A and W391A, respectively. In contrast, cross-linking was reduced in (F394A, E396A), relative to F394A. In conclusion, Fbg αC 389-402 boosts FXIII activity in Fbg αC, with D390, W391, and F394 identified as key contributors in enhancing αC cross-linking.

How Thrombomodulin Enables W215A/E217A Thrombin to Cleave Protein C but Not Fibrinogen

The W215A/E217A mutant thrombin is called "anticoagulant thrombin" because its activity toward its procoagulant substrate, fibrinogen, is reduced more than 500-fold whereas in the presence of thrombomodulin (TM) its activity toward its anticoagulant substrate, protein C, is reduced less than 10-fold. To understand how these mutations so dramatically alter one activity over the other, we compared the backbone dynamics of wild type thrombin to those of the W215A/E217A mutant thrombin by hydrogen-deuterium exchange coupled to mass spectrometry (HDX-MS). Our results show that the mutations cause the 170s, 180s, and 220s C-terminal β-barrel loops near the sites of mutation to exchange more, suggesting that the structure of this region is disrupted. Far from the mutation sites, residues at the N-terminus of the heavy chain, which need to be buried in the Ile pocket for correct structuring of the catalytic triad, also exchange much more than in wild type thrombin. TM binding causes reduced H/D exchange in these regions and also alters the dynamics of the β-strand that links the TM binding site to the catalytic Asp 102 in both wild type thrombin and in the W215A/E217A mutant thrombin. In contrast, whereas TM binding reduces the dynamics the 170, 180 and 220 s C-terminal β-barrel loops in WT thrombin, this region remains disordered in the W215A/E217A mutant thrombin. Thus, TM partially restores the catalytic activity of W215A/E217A mutant thrombin by allosterically altering its dynamics in a manner similar to that of wild type thrombin.

19F NMR reveals the conformational properties of free thrombin and its zymogen precursor prethrombin-2

The conformational properties of trypsin-like proteases and their zymogen forms remain controversial because of a lack of sufficient information on their free forms. Specifically, it is unclear whether the free protease is zymogen-like and shifts to its mature form upon a ligand-induced fit or exists in multiple conformations in equilibrium from which the ligand selects the optimal fit via conformational selection. Here we report the results of ¹⁹F NMR measurements that reveal the conformational properties of a protease and its zymogen precursor in the free form. Using the trypsin-like, clotting protease thrombin as a relevant model system, we show that its conformation is quite different from that of its direct zymogen precursor prethrombin-2 and more similar to that of its fully active Na⁺-bound form. The results cast doubts on recent hypotheses that free thrombin is zymogen-like and transitions to protease-like forms upon ligand binding. Rather, they validate the scenario emerged from previous findings of X-ray crystallography and rapid kinetics supporting a pre-existing equilibrium between open (E) and closed (E*) forms of the active site. In this scenario, prethrombin-2 is more dynamic and exists predominantly in the E* form, whereas thrombin is more rigid and exists predominantly in the E form. Ligand binding to thrombin takes place exclusively in the E form without significant changes in the overall conformation. In summary, these results disclose the structural architecture of the free forms of thrombin and prethrombin-2, consistent with an E*-E equilibrium and providing no evidence that free thrombin is zymogen-like.

Residues W215, E217 and E192 control the allosteric E*-E equilibrium of thrombin

A pre-existing, allosteric equilibrium between closed (E*) and open (E) conformations of the active site influences the level of activity in the trypsin fold and defines ligand binding according to the mechanism of conformational selection. Using the clotting protease thrombin as a model system, we investigate the molecular determinants of the E*-E equilibrium through rapid kinetics and X-ray structural biology. The equilibrium is controlled by three residues positioned around the active site. W215 on the 215-217 segment defining the west wall of the active site controls the rate of transition from E to E* through hydrophobic interaction with F227. E192 on the opposite 190-193 segment defining the east wall of the active site controls the rate of transition from E* to E through electrostatic repulsion of E217. The side chain of E217 acts as a lever that moves the entire 215-217 segment in the E*-E equilibrium. Removal of this side chain converts binding to the active site to a simple lock-and-key mechanism and freezes the conformation in a state intermediate between E* and E. These findings reveal a simple framework to understand the molecular basis of a key allosteric property of the trypsin fold.

Accurate Prediction of Amide Exchange in the Fast Limit Reveals Thrombin Allostery

Amide hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDXMS) of proteins has become extremely popular for identifying ligand-binding sites, protein-protein interactions, intrinsic disorder, and allosteric changes upon protein modification. Such phenomena are revealed when amide exchange is measured in the fast limit, that is, within a few minutes of exchange in deuterated buffer. The HDXMS data have a resolution of the length of peptides and are difficult to interpret because many different phenomena lead to changes in hydrogen/deuterium exchange. We present a quantitative analysis of accelerated molecular dynamics simulations that provides impressive agreement with peptide-length HDXMS data. Comparative analysis of thrombin and a single-point mutant reveals that the simulation analysis can distinguish the subtle differences in exchange due to mutation. In addition, the results provide a deeper understanding of the underlying changes in dynamics revealed by the HDXMS that extend far from the site of mutation.

Dynamic Consequences of Mutation of Tryptophan 215 in Thrombin

Thrombin normally cleaves fibrinogen to promote coagulation; however, binding of thrombomodulin to thrombin switches the specificity of thrombin toward protein C, triggering the anticoagulation pathway. The W215A thrombin mutant was reported to have decreased activity toward fibrinogen without significant loss of activity toward protein C. To understand how mutation of Trp215 may alter thrombin specificity, hydrogen-deuterium exchange experiments (HDXMS), accelerated molecular dynamics (AMD) simulations, and activity assays were carried out to compare the dynamics of Trp215 mutants with those of wild type (WT) thrombin. Variation in NaCl concentration had no detectable effect on the sodium-binding (220s_CT) loop, but appeared to affect other surface loops. Trp215 mutants showed significant increases in amide exchange in the 170s_CT loop consistent with a loss of H-bonding in this loop identified by the AMD simulations. The W215A thrombin showed increased amide exchange in the 220s_CT loop and in the N-terminus of the heavy chain. The AMD simulations showed that a transient conformation of the W215A thrombin has a distorted catalytic triad. HDXMS experiments revealed that mutation of Phe227, which engages in a π-stacking interaction with Trp215, also caused significantly increased amide exchange in the 170s_CT loop. Activity assays showed that only the F227V mutant had wild type catalytic activity, whereas all other mutants showed markedly lower activity. Taken together, the results explain the reduced pro-coagulant activity of the W215A mutant and demonstrate the allosteric connection between Trp215, the sodium-binding loop, and the active site.

Interplay between conformational selection and zymogen activation

Trypsin-like proteases are synthesized as zymogens and activated through a mechanism that folds the active site for efficient binding and catalysis. Ligand binding to the active site is therefore a valuable source of information on the changes that accompany zymogen activation. Using the physiologically relevant transition of the clotting zymogen prothrombin to the mature protease thrombin, we show that the mechanism of ligand recognition follows selection within a pre-existing ensemble of conformations with the active site accessible (E) or inaccessible (E*) to binding. Prothrombin exists mainly in the E* conformational ensemble and conversion to thrombin produces two dominant changes: a progressive shift toward the E conformational ensemble triggered by removal of the auxiliary domains upon cleavage at R271 and a drastic drop of the rate of ligand dissociation from the active site triggered by cleavage at R320. Together, these effects produce a significant (700-fold) increase in binding affinity. Limited proteolysis reveals how the E*-E equilibrium shifts during prothrombin activation and influences exposure of the sites of cleavage at R271 and R320. These new findings on the molecular underpinnings of prothrombin activation are relevant to other zymogens with modular assembly involved in blood coagulation, complement and fibrinolysis.

Screening cleavage of Factor XIII V34X Activation Peptides by thrombin mutants: A strategy for controlling fibrin architecture

In blood coagulation, thrombin converts fibrinogen into fibrin monomers that polymerize into a clot network. Thrombin also activates Factor XIII by cleaving the R37-G38 peptide bond of the Activation Peptide (AP) segment. The resultant transglutaminase introduces covalent crosslinks into the fibrin clot. A strategy to modify clot architecture would be to design FXIII AP sequences that are easier or more difficult to be thrombin-cleaved thus controlling initiation of crosslinking. To aid in this design process, FXIII V34X (28-41) Activation Peptides were kinetically ranked for cleavage by wild-type thrombin and several anticoagulant mutants. Thrombin-catalyzed hydrolysis of aromatic FXIII F34, W34, and Y34 APs was compared with V34 and L34. Cardioprotective FXIII L34 remained the variant most readily cleaved by wild-type thrombin. The potent anticoagulant thrombins W215A and W215A/E217A (missing a key substrate platform for binding fibrinogen) were best able to hydrolyze FXIII F34 and W34 APs. Thrombin I174A and L99A could effectively accommodate FXIII W34 and Y34 APs yielding kinetic parameters comparable to FXIII AP L34 with wild-type thrombin. None of the aromatic FXIII V34X APs could be hydrolyzed by thrombin Y60aA. FXIII F34 and W34 are promising candidates for FXIII - anticoagulant thrombin systems that could permit FXIII-catalyzed crosslinking in the presence of reduced fibrin formation. By contrast, FXIII Y34 with thrombin (Y60aA or W215A/E217A) could help assure that both fibrin clot formation and protein crosslinking are hindered. Regulating the activation of FXIII is predicted to be a strategy for helping to control fibrin clot architecture and its neighboring environments.

Structural Architecture of Prothrombin in Solution Revealed by Single Molecule Spectroscopy

The coagulation factor prothrombin has a complex spatial organization of its modular assembly that comprises the N-terminal Gla domain, kringle-1, kringle-2, and the C-terminal protease domain connected by three intervening linkers. Here we use single molecule Förster resonance energy transfer to access the conformational landscape of prothrombin in solution and uncover structural features of functional significance that extend recent x-ray crystallographic analysis. Prothrombin exists in equilibrium between two alternative conformations, open and closed. The closed conformation predominates (70%) and features an unanticipated intramolecular collapse of Tyr(93) in kringle-1 onto Trp(547) in the protease domain that obliterates access to the active site and protects the zymogen from autoproteolytic conversion to thrombin. The open conformation (30%) is more susceptible to chymotrypsin digestion and autoactivation, and features a shape consistent with recent x-ray crystal structures. Small angle x-ray scattering measurements of prothrombin wild type stabilized 70% in the closed conformation and of the mutant Y93A stabilized 80% in the open conformation directly document two envelopes that differ 50 Å in length. These findings reveal important new details on the conformational plasticity of prothrombin in solution and the drastic structural difference between its alternative conformations. Prothrombin uses the intramolecular collapse of kringle-1 onto the active site in the closed form to prevent autoactivation. The open-closed equilibrium also defines a new structural framework for the mechanism of activation of prothrombin by prothrombinase.

Loop Electrostatics Asymmetry Modulates the Preexisting Conformational Equilibrium in Thrombin

Thrombin exists as an ensemble of active (E) and inactive (E*) conformations that differ in their accessibility to the active site. Here we show that redistribution of the E*-E equilibrium can be achieved by perturbing the electrostatic properties of the enzyme. Removal of the negative charge of the catalytic Asp102 or Asp189 in the primary specificity site destabilizes the E form and causes a shift in the 215-217 segment that compromises substrate entrance. Solution studies and existing structures of D102N document stabilization of the E* form. A new high-resolution structure of D189A also reveals the mutant in the collapsed E* form. These findings establish a new paradigm for the control of the E*-E equilibrium in the trypsin fold.

Design of Factor XIII V34X activation peptides to control ability to interact with thrombin mutants

Thrombin helps to activate Factor XIII (FXIII) by hydrolyzing the R37-G38 peptide bond. The resultant transglutaminase introduces cross-links into the fibrin clot. With the development of therapeutic coagulation factors, there is a need to better understand interactions involving FXIII. Such knowledge will help predict ability to activate FXIII and thus ability to promote/hinder the generation of transglutaminase activity. Kinetic parameters have been determined for a series of thrombin species hydrolyzing the FXIII (28-41) V34X activation peptides (V34, V34L, V34F, and V34P). The V34P substitution introduces PAR4 character into the FXIII, and the V34F exhibits important similarities to the cardioprotective V34L. FXIII activation peptides containing V34, V34L, or V34P could each be accommodated by alanine mutants of thrombin lacking either the W60d or Y60a residue in the 60-insertion loop. By contrast, FXIII V34F AP could be cleaved by thrombin W60dA but not by Y60aA. FXIII V34P is highly reliant on the thrombin W215 platform for its strong substrate properties whereas FXIII V34F AP becomes the first segment that can maintain its K(m) upon loss of the critical thrombin W215 residue. Interestingly, FXIII V34F AP could also be readily accommodated by thrombin L99A and E217A. Hydrolysis of FXIII V34F AP by thrombin W217A/E217A (WE) was similar to that of FXIII V34L AP whereas WE could not effectively cleave FXIII V34P AP. FXIII V34F and V34P AP show promise for designing FXIII activation systems that are either tolerant of or greatly hindered by the presence of anticoagulant thrombins.

Redesigning allosteric activation in an enzyme

Enzyme activation by monovalent cations is widely documented in plants and the animal world. In type II enzymes, activation entails two steps: binding of the monovalent cation to its allosteric site and transduction of this event into enhanced catalytic activity. The effect has exquisite specificity for either Na(+) or K(+), the most abundant cations present in physiological environments. Enzymes requiring K(+) such as kinases and molecular chaperones are not activated as well or at all by the larger cation Cs(+) or the smaller cations Na(+) and Li(+). Enzymes requiring Na(+) such as β-galactosidase and clotting proteases are not activated as well by Li(+), or the larger cations K(+), Rb(+), and Cs(+). Efforts to switch specificity between Na(+) and K(+) in this large class of enzymes and completely redesign the mechanism of allosteric transduction leading to enhanced catalytic activity have so far been unsuccessful. Here we show how mutagenesis of two loops defining the Na(+) binding site of thrombin, a Na(+)-activated clotting protease, generates a construct that is most active in the presence of K(+) toward synthetic and physiological substrates. The effect is the result of a higher binding affinity and more efficient allosteric transduction of binding into enhanced catalytic activity for K(+) compared to Na(+), which represents a complete reversal of the properties of wild type. In addition, the construct features altered specificity toward physiological substrates resulting in a significant anticoagulant profile. The findings are relevant to all Na(+)-activated proteases involved in blood coagulation and the complement system.

The development of inflammatory joint disease is attenuated in mice expressing the anticoagulant prothrombin mutant W215A/E217A

Thrombin is a positive mediator of thrombus formation through the proteolytic activation of protease-activated receptors (PARs), fibrinogen, factor XI (fXI), and other substrates, and a negative regulator through activation of protein C, a natural anticoagulant with anti-inflammatory/cytoprotective properties. Protease-engineering studies have established that 2 active-site substitutions, W215A and E217A (fII(WE)), result in dramatically reduced catalytic efficiency with procoagulant substrates while largely preserving thrombomodulin (TM)-dependent protein C activation. To explore the hypothesis that a prothrombin variant favoring antithrombotic pathways would be compatible with development but limit inflammatory processes in vivo, we generated mice carrying the fII(WE) mutations within the endogenous prothrombin gene. Unlike fII-null embryos, fII(WE/WE) mice uniformly developed to term. Nevertheless, these mice ultimately succumbed to spontaneous bleeding events shortly after birth. Heterozygous fII(WT/WE) mice were viable and fertile despite a shift toward an antithrombotic phenotype exemplified by prolonged tail-bleeding times and times-to-occlusion after FeCl₃ vessel injury. More interestingly, prothrombin(WE) expression significantly ameliorated the development of inflammatory joint disease in mice challenged with collagen-induced arthritis (CIA). The administration of active recombinant thrombin(WE) also suppressed the development of CIA in wild-type mice. These studies provide a proof-of-principle that pro/thrombin variants engineered with altered substrate specificity may offer therapeutic opportunities for limiting inflammatory disease processes.

Engineering thrombin for selective specificity toward protein C and PAR1

Thrombin elicits functional responses critical to blood homeostasis by interacting with diverse physiological substrates. Ala-scanning mutagenesis of 97 residues covering 53% of the solvent accessible surface area of the enzyme identifies Trp(215) as the single most important determinant of thrombin specificity. Saturation mutagenesis of Trp(215) produces constructs featuring k(cat)/K(m) values for the hydrolysis of fibrinogen, protease-activated receptor PAR1, and protein C that span five orders of magnitude. Importantly, the effect of Trp(215) replacement is context dependent. Mutant W215E is 10-fold more specific for protein C than fibrinogen and PAR1, which represents a striking shift in specificity relative to wild-type that is 100-fold more specific for fibrinogen and PAR1 than protein C. However, when the W215E mutation is combined with deletion of nine residues in the autolysis loop, which by itself shifts the specificity of the enzyme from fibrinogen and PAR1 to protein C, the resulting construct features significant activity only toward PAR1. These findings demonstrate that thrombin can be re-engineered for selective specificity toward protein C and PAR1. Mutations of Trp(215) provide important reagents for dissecting the multiple functional roles of thrombin in the blood and for clinical applications.

Crystal structure of thrombin bound to the uncleaved extracellular fragment of PAR1

Abundant structural information exists on how thrombin recognizes ligands at the active site or at exosites separate from the active site region, but remarkably little is known about how thrombin recognizes substrates that bridge both the active site and exosite I. The case of the protease-activated receptor PAR1 is particularly relevant in view of the plethora of biological effects associated with its activation by thrombin. Here, we present the 1.8 A resolution structure of thrombin S195A in complex with a 30-residue long uncleaved extracellular fragment of PAR1 that documents for the first time a productive binding mode bridging the active site and exosite I. The structure reveals two unexpected features of the thrombin-PAR1 interaction. The acidic P3 residue of PAR1, Asp(39), does not hinder binding to the active site and actually makes favorable interactions with Gly(219) of thrombin. The tethered ligand domain shows a considerable degree of disorder even when bound to thrombin. The results fill a significant gap in our understanding of the molecular mechanisms of recognition by thrombin in ways that are relevant to other physiological substrates.

Mechanism of the anticoagulant activity of thrombin mutant W215A/E217A

The thrombin mutant W215A/E217A (WE) is a potent anticoagulant both in vitro and in vivo. Previous x-ray structural studies have shown that WE assumes a partially collapsed conformation that is similar to the inactive E* form, which explains its drastically reduced activity toward substrate. Whether this collapsed conformation is genuine, rather than the result of crystal packing or the mutation introduced in the critical 215-217 beta-strand, and whether binding of thrombomodulin to exosite I can allosterically shift the E* form to the active E form to restore activity toward protein C are issues of considerable mechanistic importance to improve the design of an anticoagulant thrombin mutant for therapeutic applications. Here we present four crystal structures of WE in the human and murine forms that confirm the collapsed conformation reported previously under different experimental conditions and crystal packing. We also present structures of human and murine WE bound to exosite I with a fragment of the platelet receptor PAR1, which is unable to shift WE to the E form. These structural findings, along with kinetic and calorimetry data, indicate that WE is strongly stabilized in the E* form and explain why binding of ligands to exosite I has only a modest effect on the E*-E equilibrium for this mutant. The E* --> E transition requires the combined binding of thrombomodulin and protein C and restores activity of the mutant WE in the anticoagulant pathway.

How Na+ activates thrombin--a review of the functional and structural data

Thrombin is the ultimate coagulation factor; it is the final protease generated in the blood coagulation cascade and is the effector of clot formation. Regulation of thrombin activity is thus of great relevance to determining the correct haemostatic balance, with dysregulation leading to bleeding or thrombosis. One of the most enigmatic and controversial regulators of thrombin activity is the monovalent cation Na+. When bound to Na+, thrombin adopts a 'fast' conformation which cleaves all procoagulant substrates more rapidly, and when free of Na+, thrombin reverts to a 'slow' state which preferentially activates the protein C anticoagulant pathway. Thus, Na+-binding allosterically modulates the activity of thrombin and helps determine the haemostatic balance. Over the last 30 years, there has been much research investigating the structural basis of thrombin allostery. Biochemical and mutagenesis studies established which regions and residues are involved in the slow-->fast conformational change, and recently several crystal structures of the putative slow form have been solved. In this article, the biochemical and crystallographic data are reviewed to see if we are any closer to understanding the conformational basis of the Na+ activation of thrombin.

Role of A-chain in functioning of the active site of human alpha-thrombin

This review summarizes current data suggesting that A-chain of the human alpha-thrombin molecule plays a role of allosteric effector in catalytic reactions with various substrates. Special attention is paid to the relationship between A-chain structure and catalytic activity of thrombin. The existence of this relationship is based on studies of natural mutation of A-chain of the alpha-thrombin molecule. Use of molecular and essential dynamics confirmed the role of A-chain in changes of conformation and catalytic properties of this enzyme; these changes involve residues located in the specificity sites and some inserting loops. Current knowledge on structure and properties of thrombin can be used for the development of new antithrombin agents.

Thrombin

Thrombin is a Na+-activated, allosteric serine protease that plays opposing functional roles in blood coagulation. Binding of Na+ is the major driving force behind the procoagulant, prothrombotic and signaling functions of the enzyme, but is dispensable for cleavage of the anticoagulant protein C. The anticoagulant function of thrombin is under the allosteric control of the cofactor thrombomodulin. Much has been learned on the mechanism of Na+ binding and recognition of natural substrates by thrombin. Recent structural advances have shed light on the remarkable molecular plasticity of this enzyme and the molecular underpinnings of thrombin allostery mediated by binding to exosite I and the Na+ site. This review summarizes our current understanding of the molecular basis of thrombin function and allosteric regulation. The basic information emerging from recent structural, mutagenesis and kinetic investigation of this important enzyme is that thrombin exists in three forms, E*, E and E:Na+, that interconvert under the influence of ligand binding to distinct domains. The transition between the Na+ -free slow from E and the Na+ -bound fast form E:Na+ involves the structure of the enzyme as a whole, and so does the interconversion between the two Na+ -free forms E* and E. E* is most likely an inactive form of thrombin, unable to interact with Na + and substrate. The complexity of thrombin function and regulation has gained this enzyme pre-eminence as the prototypic allosteric serine protease. Thrombin is now looked upon as a model system for the quantitative analysis of biologically important enzymes.

Important role of the cys-191 cys-220 disulfide bond in thrombin function and allostery

Little is known on the role of disulfide bonds in the catalytic domain of serine proteases. The Cys-191-Cys-220 disulfide bond is located between the 190 strand leading to the oxyanion hole and the 220-loop that contributes to the architecture of the primary specificity pocket and the Na+ binding site in allosteric proteases. Removal of this bond in thrombin produces an approximately 100-fold loss of activity toward several chromogenic and natural substrates carrying Arg or Lys at P1. Na+ activation is compromised, and no fluorescence change can be detected in response to Na+ binding. A 1.54-A resolution structure of the C191A/C220A mutant in the free form reveals a conformation similar to the Na+-free slow form of wild type. The lack of disulfide bond exposes the side chain of Asp-189 to solvent, flips the backbone O atom of Gly-219, and generates disorder in portions of the 186 and 220 loops defining the Na+ site. This conformation, featuring perturbation of the Na+ site but with the active site accessible to substrate, offers a possible representation of the recently identified E* form of thrombin. Disorder in the 186 and 220 loops and the flip of Gly-219 are corrected by the active site inhibitor H-D-Phe-Pro-Arg-CH(2)Cl, as revealed by the 1.8-A resolution structure of the complex. We conclude that the Cys-191-Cys-220 disulfide bond confers stability to the primary specificity pocket by shielding Asp-189 from the solvent and orients the backbone O atom of Gly-219 for optimal substrate binding. In addition, the disulfide bond stabilizes the 186 and 220 loops that are critical for Na+ binding and activation.

Exosites in the substrate specificity of blood coagulation reactions

The specificity of blood coagulation proteinases for substrate, inhibitor, and effector recognition is mediated by exosites on the surfaces of the catalytic domains, physically separated from the catalytic site. Some thrombin ligands bind specifically to either exosite I or II, while others engage both exosites. The involvement of different, overlapping constellations of exosite residues enables binding of structurally diverse ligands. The flexibility of the thrombin structure is central to the mechanism of complex formation and the specificity of exosite interactions. Encounter complex formation is driven by electrostatic ligand-exosite interactions, followed by conformational rearrangement to a stable complex. Exosites on some zymogens are in low affinity proexosite states and are expressed concomitant with catalytic site activation. The requirement for exosite expression controls the specificity of assembly of catalytic complexes on the coagulation pathway, such as the membrane-bound factor Xa*factor Va (prothrombinase) complex, and prevents premature assembly. Substrate recognition by prothrombinase involves a two-step mechanism with initial docking of prothrombin to exosites, followed by a conformational change to engage the FXa catalytic site. Prothrombin and its activation intermediates bind prothrombinase in two alternative conformations determined by the zymogen to proteinase transition that are hypothesized to involve prothrombin (pro)exosite I interactions with FVa, which underpin the sequential activation pathway. The role of exosites as the major source of substrate specificity has stimulated development of exosite-targeted anticoagulants for treatment of thrombosis.

Structural basis of Na+ activation mimicry in murine thrombin

Unlike human thrombin, murine thrombin lacks Na+ activation due to the charge reversal substitution D222K in the Na+ binding loop. However, the enzyme is functionally stabilized in a Na+-bound form and is highly active toward physiologic substrates. The structural basis of this peculiar property is unknown. Here, we present the 2.2 A resolution x-ray crystal structure of murine thrombin in the absence of inhibitors and salts. The enzyme assumes an active conformation, with Ser-195, Glu-192, and Asp-189 oriented as in the Na+-bound fast form of human thrombin. Lys-222 completely occludes the pore of entry to the Na+ binding site and positions its side chain inside the pore, with the Nzeta atom H-bonded to the backbone oxygen atoms of Lys-185, Asp-186b, and Lys-186d. The same architecture is observed in the 1.75 A resolution structure of a thrombin chimera in which the human enzyme carries all residues defining the Na+ pore in the murine enzyme. These findings demonstrate that Na+ activation in thrombin is linked to the architecture of the Na+ pore. The molecular strategy of Na+ activation mimicry unraveled for murine thrombin is relevant to serine proteases and enzymes activated by monovalent cations in general.

Rapid kinetics of Na+ binding to thrombin

The kinetic mechanism of Na(+) binding to thrombin was resolved by stopped-flow measurements of intrinsic fluorescence. Na(+) binds to thrombin in a two-step mechanism with a rapid phase occurring within the dead time of the spectrometer (<0.5 ms) followed by a single-exponential slow phase whose k(obs) decreases hyperbolically with increasing [Na(+)]. The rapid phase is due to Na(+) binding to the enzyme E to generate the E:Na(+) form. The slow phase is due to the interconversion between E(*) and E, where E(*) is a form that cannot bind Na(+). Temperature studies in the range from 5 to 35 degrees C show significant enthalpy, entropy, and heat capacity changes associated with both Na(+) binding and the E to E(*) transition. As a result, under conditions of physiologic temperature and salt concentrations, the E(*) form is negligibly populated (<1%) and thrombin is almost equally partitioned between the E (40%) and E:Na(+) (60%) forms. Single-site Phe mutations of all nine Trp residues of thrombin enabled assignment of the fluorescence changes induced by Na(+) binding mainly to Trp-141 and Trp-215, and to a lesser extent to Trp-148, Trp-207, and Trp-237. However, the fast phase of fluorescence increase is influenced to different extents by all Trp residues. The distribution of these residues over the entire thrombin surface demonstrates that Na(+) binding induces long-range effects on the structure of the enzyme as a whole, contrary to the conclusions drawn from recent structural studies. These findings elucidate the mechanism of Na(+) binding to thrombin and are relevant to other clotting factors and enzymes allosterically activated by monovalent cations.

Crystal structure of thrombin in a self-inhibited conformation

The activating effect of Na(+) on thrombin is allosteric and depends on the conformational transition from a low activity Na(+)-free (slow) form to a high activity Na(+)-bound (fast) form. The structures of these active forms have been solved. Recent structures of thrombin obtained in the absence of Na(+) have also documented inactive conformations that presumably exist in equilibrium with the active slow form. The validity of these inactive slow form structures, however, is called into question by the presence of packing interactions involving the Na(+) site and the active site regions. Here, we report a 1.87A resolution structure of thrombin in the absence of inhibitors and salts with a single molecule in the asymmetric unit and devoid of significant packing interactions in regions involved in the allosteric slow --> fast transition. The structure shows an unprecedented self-inhibited conformation where Trp-215 and Arg-221a relocate >10A to occlude the active site and the primary specificity pocket, and the guanidinium group of Arg-187 penetrates the protein core to fill the empty Na(+)-binding site. The extreme mobility of Trp-215 was investigated further with the W215P mutation. Remarkably, the mutation significantly compromises cleavage of the anticoagulant protein C but has no effect on the hydrolysis of fibrinogen and PAR1. These findings demonstrate that thrombin may assume an inactive conformation in the absence of Na(+) and that its procoagulant and anticoagulant activities are closely linked to the mobility of residue 215.

Thrombin-Cofactor Interactions

Precise modulation of thrombin activity throughout the hemostatic response is essential for efficient cessation of bleeding while preventing inappropriate clot growth or dissemination which causes thrombosis. Regulating thrombin activity is made difficult by its ability to diffuse from the surface on which it was generated and its ability to cleave at least 12 substrates. To overcome this challenge, thrombin recognition of substrates is largely controlled by cofactors that act by localizing thrombin to various surfaces, blocking substrate binding to critical exosites, engendering new exosites for substrate recognition and by allosterically modulating the properties of the active site of thrombin. Thrombin cofactors can be classified as either pro- or anticoagulants, depending on how substrate preference is altered. The procoagulant cofactors include glycoprotein Ibα, fibrin, and Na + , and the anticoagulants are heparin and thrombomodulin. Over the last few years, crystal structures have been reported for all of the thrombin-cofactor complexes. The purpose of this article is to summarize the features of these structures and to discuss the mechanisms and physiological relevance of cofactor binding in thrombin regulation.

Structural basis for sequential cleavage of fibrinopeptides upon fibrin assembly

Nonsubstrate interaction of thrombin with fibrinogen promotes sequential cleavage of fibrinopeptides A and B (fpA and fpB, respectively) from the latter, resulting in its conversion into fibrin. The recently established crystal structure of human thrombin in complex with the central part of human fibrin clarified the mechanism of this interaction. Here, we reveal new details of the structure and present the results of molecular modeling of the fpA- and fpB-containing portions of the Aalpha and Bbeta chains, not identified in the complex, in both fibrinogen and protofibrils. The analysis of the results reveals that in fibrinogen the fpA-containing portions are in a more favorable position to bind in the active site cleft of bound thrombin. Surface plasmon resonance experiments establish that the fpB-containing portions interact with the fibrin-derived dimeric D-D fragment, suggesting that in protofibrils they bind to the newly formed DD regions bringing fpB into the vicinity of bound thrombin. These findings provide a coherent rationale for the preferential removal of fpA from fibrinogen at the first stage of fibrin assembly and the accelerated cleavage of fpB from protofibrils and/or fibrils at the second stage.

Murine Thrombin Lacks Na+ Activation but Retains High Catalytic Activity

Human thrombin utilizes Na+ as a driving force for the cleavage of substrates mediating its procoagulant, prothrombotic, and signaling functions. Murine thrombin has Asp-222 in the Na+ binding site of the human enzyme replaced by Lys. The charge reversal substitution abrogates Na+ activation, which is partially restored with the K222D mutation, and ensures high activity even in the absence of Na+. This property makes the murine enzyme more resistant to the effect of mutations that destabilize Na+ binding and shift thrombin to its anticoagulant slow form. Compared with the human enzyme, murine thrombin cleaves fibrinogen and protein C with similar k(cat)/K(m) values but activates PAR1 and PAR4 with k(cat)/K(m) values 4- and 26-fold higher, respectively. The significantly higher specificity constant toward PAR4 accounts for the dominant role of this receptor in platelet activation in the mouse. Murine thrombin can also cleave substrates carrying Phe at P1, which potentially broadens the repertoire of molecular targets available to the enzyme in vivo.

Crystal structure of wild-type human thrombin in the Na+-free state

Regulation of thrombin activity is critical for haemostasis and the prevention of thrombosis. Thrombin has several procoagulant substrates, including fibrinogen and platelet receptors, and essential cofactors for stimulating its own formation. However, thrombin is also capable of serving an anticoagulant function by activating protein C. The specificity of thrombin is primarily regulated by binding to the cofactor TM (thrombomodulin), but co-ordination of Na+ can also affect thrombin activity. The Na+-free form is often referred to as 'slow' because of reduced rates of cleavage of procoagulant substrates, but the slow form is still capable of rapid activation of protein C in the presence of TM. The molecular basis of the slow proteolytic activity of thrombin has remained elusive, in spite of two decades of solution studies and many published crystallographic structures. In the present paper, we report the first structure of wild-type unliganded human thrombin grown in the absence of co-ordinating Na+. The Na+-binding site is observed in a highly ordered position 6 A (1 A=0.1 nm) removed from that seen in the Na+-bound state. The movement of the Na+ loop results in non-catalytic hydrogen-bonding in the active site and blocking of the S1 and S2 substrate-binding pockets. Similar, if more dramatic, changes were observed in a previous structure of the constitutively slow thrombin variant E217K. The slow behaviour of thrombin in solutions devoid of Na+ can now be understood in terms of an equilibrium between an inert species, represented by the crystal structure described in the present paper, and an active form, where the addition of Na+ populates the active state.

The natural mutation by deletion of Lys9 in the thrombin A-chain affects the pKa value of catalytic residues, the overall enzyme's stability and conformational transitions linked to Na+ binding

The catalytic competence of the natural thrombin mutant with deletion of the Lys9 residue in the A-chain (deltaK9) was found to be severely impaired, most likely due to modification of the 60-loop conformation and catalytic triad geometry, as supported by long molecular dynamics (MD) simulations in explicit water solvent. In this study, the pH dependence of the catalytic activity and binding of the low-molecular mass inhibitor N-alpha-(2-naphthylsulfonyl-glycyl)-4-amidinophenylalanine-piperidine (alpha-NAPAP) to the wild-type (WT) and deltaK9 thrombin forms were investigated, along with their overall structural stabilities and conformational properties. Two ionizable groups were found to similarly affect the activity of both thrombins. The pKa value of the first ionizable group, assigned to the catalytic His57 residue, was found to be 7.5 and 6.9 in ligand-free deltaK9 and WT thrombin, respectively. Urea-induced denaturation studies showed higher instability of the deltaK9 mutant compared with WT thrombin, and disulfide scrambling experiments proved weakening of the interchain interactions, causing faster release of the reduced A-chain in the mutant enzyme. The sodium ion binding affinity was not significantly perturbed by Lys9 deletion, although the linked increase in intrinsic fluorescence was lower in the mutant. Essential dynamics (ED) analysis highlighted different conformational properties of the two thrombins in agreement with the experimental conformational stability data. Globally, these findings enhanced our understanding of the perturbations triggered by Lys9 deletion, which reduces the overall stability of the molecule, weakens the A-B interchain interactions, and allosterically perturbs the geometry and protonation state of catalytic residues of the enzyme.

Slow thrombin in solution

As a tool for understanding biological mechanisms, X-ray crystallography possesses unparalleled power to enlighten, resolve controversy and shift a field of study on to a secure new paradigm. Thanks largely to developments in crystallographic methods, the technique has become accessible to the general biochemist and we have thus witnessed an exponential increase in the number of protein structures deposited every year. It is now commonplace for several structures to be published of the same protein under different crystallization conditions, sometimes resulting in conflicting mechanistic interpretations. Such a controversy has arisen over thrombin's conformational response to Na+ co-ordination, and in this issue of Biochemical Journal, De Filippis and colleagues put the two structural models of thrombin allostery to the test by returning to the techniques of solution biochemistry.

Determinants of specificity in coagulation proteases

Proteases play diverse roles in a variety of essential biological processes, both as non-specific catalysts of protein degradation and as highly specific agents that control physiologic events. Here, we review the mechanisms of substrate specificity employed by serine proteases and focus our discussion on coagulation proteases. We dissect the interplay between active site and exosite specificity and how substrate recognition is regulated allosterically by Na+ binding. We also draw attention to a functional polarity that exists in the serine protease fold, which sheds light on the structural linkages between the active site and exosites.

Activated protein C variants with normal cytoprotective but reduced anticoagulant activity

Recombinant activated protein C (APC), a well-defined anticoagulant enzyme, reduced mortality in severe sepsis patients in a phase 3 trial. However, 2 potent anticoagulants, antithrombin III and recombinant tissue factor pathway inhibitor, failed to do so, implying the physiologic relevance of APC's less well-defined anti-inflammatory and antiapoptotic activities. Recombinant APC therapy conveys an increased risk of serious bleeding complications due to APC anticoagulant activity. To generate recombinant APC variants with reduced risk of bleeding due to reduced anticoagulant activity, we dissected APC's anticoagulant activity from its cytoprotective activity by site-directed mutagenesis. Using staurosporine-induced endothelial cell apoptosis assays, we show here that Ala mutations (RR229/230AA and KKK191_ 193AAA) in 2 APC surface loops that severely reduce anticoagulant activity result in 2 APC variants that retain normal antiapoptotic activity that requires protease activated receptor-1 and endothelial cell protein C receptor. Thus, it is possible to reduce anticoagulant activity while preserving antiapoptotic activity of recombinant APC variants. We suggest that therapeutic use of such APC variants may reduce serious bleeding risks while providing the beneficial effects of APC acting directly on cells.

The molecular basis of thrombin allostery revealed by a 1.8 A structure of the "slow" form

Thrombin participates in its own positive and negative feedback loops, and its allosteric state helps determine the hemostatic balance. Here we present the 1.8 A crystallographic structure of S195A thrombin in two conformational states: active site occupied and active site free. The active site-occupied form shows how thrombin can accommodate substrates, such as protein C. The active site-free form is in a previously unobserved closed conformation of thrombin, which satisfies all the conditions of the so-called "slow" form. A mechanism of allostery is revealed, which relies on the concerted movement of the disulphide bond between Cys168 and 182 and aromatic residues Phe227, Trp215, and Trp60d. These residues constitute an allosteric switch, which is flipped directly through sodium binding, resulting in the fast form with an open active site.

Three-dimensional models of proteases involved in patterning of the Drosophila Embryo. Crucial role of predicted cation binding sites

Three-dimensional models of the catalytic domains of Nudel (Ndl), Gastrulation Defective (Gd), Snake (Snk), and Easter (Ea), and their complexes with substrate suggest a possible organization of the enzyme cascade controlling the dorsoventral fate of the fruit fly embryo. The models predict that Gd activates Snk, which in turn activates Ea. Gd can be activated either autoproteolytically or by Ndl. The three-dimensional models of each enzyme-substrate complex in the cascade rationalize existing mutagenesis data and the associated phenotypes. The models also predict unanticipated features like a Ca(2+) binding site in Ea and a Na(+) binding site in Ndl and Gd. These binding sites are likely to play a crucial role in vivo as suggested by mutant enzymes introduced into embryos as mRNAs. The mutations in Gd that eliminate Na(+) binding cause an apparent increase in activity, whereas mutations in Ea that abrogate Ca(2+) binding result in complete loss of activity. A mutation in Ea predicted to introduce Na(+) binding results in apparently increased activity with ventralization of the embryo, an effect not observed with wild-type Ea mRNA.

Ser(214) is crucial for substrate binding to serine proteases

Highly conserved amino acids that form crucial structural elements of the catalytic apparatus can be used to account for the evolutionary history of serine proteases and the cascades into which they are organized. One such evolutionary marker in chymotrypsin-like proteases is Ser(214), located adjacent to the active site and forming part of the primary specificity pocket. Here we report the mutation of Ser(214) in thrombin to Ala, Thr, Cys, Asp, Glu, and Lys. None of the mutants seriously compromises active site catalytic function as measured by the kinetic parameter k(cat). However, the least conservative mutations result in large increases in K(m) because of lower rates of substrate diffusion into the active site. Therefore, the role of Ser(214) is to promote the productive formation of the enzyme-substrate complex. The S214C mutant is catalytically inactive, which suggests that during evolution the TCN-->AGY codon transitions for Ser(214) occurred through Thr intermediates.

Three-dimensional modeling of thrombin-fibrinogen interaction

Three-dimensional models of thrombin complexed with large fragments of the fibrinogen Aalpha and Bbeta chains are presented. The models are consistent with the results of recent mutagenesis studies of thrombin and with the information available on naturally occurring fibrinogen mutants. Thrombin recognizes fibrinogen with an extended binding surface, key elements of which are Tyr(76) in exosite I, located about 20 A away from the active site, and the aryl binding site located in close proximity to the catalytic triad. A highly conserved aromatic-Pro-aromatic triplet motif is identified in the primed site region of fibrinogen and other natural substrates of thrombin. The role of this triplet, based on the three-dimensional models, is to correctly orient the substrate for optimal bridge binding to exosite I and the active site. The three-dimensional models suggest a possible pattern of recognition by thrombin that applies generally to other natural substrates.

Molecular mapping of thrombin-receptor interactions

In addition to its procoagulant and anticoagulant roles in the blood coagulation cascade, thrombin works as a signaling molecule when it interacts with the G-protein coupled receptors PAR1, PAR3, and PAR4. We have mapped the thrombin epitopes responsible for these interactions using enzymatic assays and Ala scanning mutagenesis. The epitopes overlap considerably, and are almost identical to those of fibrinogen and fibrin, but a few unanticipated differences are uncovered that help explain the higher (90-fold) specificity of PAR1 relative to PAR3 and PAR4. The most critical residues for the interaction with the PARs are located around the active site where mutations affect recognition in the order PAR4 > PAR3 > PAR1. Other important residues for PAR binding cluster in a small area of exosite I where mutations affect recognition in the order PAR1 > PAR3 > PAR4. Owing to this hierarchy of effects, the mutation W215A selectively compromises PAR4 cleavage, whereas the mutation R67A abrogates the higher specificity of PAR1 relative to PAR3 and PAR4. 3D models of thrombin complexed with PAR1, PAR3, and PAR4 are constructed and account for the perturbations documented by the mutagenesis studies.

Determinants of thrombin specificity

Thrombin recognizes a number of natural substrates that are responsible for important physiologic functions. Its high specificity is controlled by residues within the active site, and by separate recognition sites located on the surface of the enzyme. A number of studies have addressed the question of how thrombin changes its specificity from fibrinogen to protein C, switching from a procoagulant to an anticoagulant enzyme. Site directed mutagenesis studies have revealed important aspects of how this switch takes place. Specifically, residues W215 and E217 have emerged as key residues in controlling the interaction with fibrinogen in that mutation of these residues compromises the procoagulant function of the enzyme up to 500-fold. The loss of fibrinogen clotting reaches 20,000-fold in the double mutant W215A/E217A, whereas protein C activation is compromised less than sevenfold. These findings demonstrate that thrombin specificity can be dissected at the molecular level using Ala-scanning mutagenesis and the procoagulant function of the enzyme can be abrogated rationally and selectively. It is now possible to extend this strategy to the study of other interactions of thrombin, as well as to related serine proteases.

Replacement of thrombin residue G184 with Lys or Arg fails to mimic Na+ binding

Na+ binding to thrombin enhances the catalytic activity toward numerous synthetic and natural substrates. The bound Na+ is located in a solvent channel 16 A away from the catalytic triad, and connects with D189 in the S1 site through an intervening water molecule. Molecular modeling indicates that the G184K substitution in thrombin positions the protonated epsilon-amino group of the Lys side-chain to replace the bound Na+. Likewise, the G184R substitution positions the guanidinium group of the longer Arg side-chain to replace both the bound Na+ and the connecting water molecule to D189. We explored whether the G184K or G184R substitution would replace the bound Na+ and yield a thrombin derivative stabilized in the highly active fast form. Both the G184K and G184R mutants lost sensitivity to monovalent cations, as expected, but their activity toward a chromogenic substrate was compromised up to 200-fold as a result of impaired diffusion into the S1 site and decreased deacylation rate. Interestingly, both G184K and G184R substitutions compromised cleavage of procoagulant substrates fibrinogen and PAR1 more than that of the anticoagulant substrate protein C. These findings demonstrate that Na+ binding to thrombin is difficult to mimic functionally with residue side-chains, in analogy with results from other systems.

Rational design of a potent anticoagulant thrombin

Thrombin acts as a procoagulant when it cleaves fibrinogen and promotes the formation of a fibrin clot and functions as an anticoagulant when it activates protein C with the assistance of the cofactor thrombomodulin. The dual function of thrombin in the blood poses the challenge to turn the enzyme into a potent anticoagulant by selectively abrogating fibrinogen cleavage. Using functional and structural data, we have rationally designed a thrombin mutant, W215A/E217A, that cleaves fibrinogen with a value of k(cat)/K(m) about 20,000-fold slower than wild-type but activates protein C in the presence of thrombomodulin with a specificity comparable with wild-type. This mutant demonstrates for the first time that the relative specificity of thrombin toward fibrinogen and protein C can be completely reversed.