An unsolved problem of the clonal selection theory and the model of an oligomeric B-cell antigen receptor

Antigen Receptor Function in the Context of the Nanoscale Organization of the B Cell Membrane

The B cell antigen receptor (BCR) plays a central role in the self/nonself selection of B lymphocytes and in their activation by cognate antigen during the clonal selection process. It was long thought that most cell surface receptors, including the BCR, were freely diffusing and randomly distributed. Since the advent of superresolution techniques, it has become clear that the plasma membrane is compartmentalized and highly organized at the nanometer scale. Hence, a complete understanding of the precise conformation and activation mechanism of the BCR must take into account the organization of the B cell plasma membrane. We review here the recent literature on the nanoscale organization of the lymphocyte membrane and discuss how this new information influences our view of the conformational changes that the BCR undergoes during activation.

Experimental Support for the Ecoimmunity Theory: Distinct Phenotypes of Nonlymphocytic Cells in SCID and Wild-Type Mice

Immune tolerance toward "self" is critical in multiple immune disorders. While there are several mechanisms to describe the involvement of immune cells in the process, the role of peripheral tissue cells in that context is not yet clear. The theory of ecoimmunity postulates that interactions between immune and tissue cells represent a predator-prey relationship. A lifelong interaction, shaped mainly during early ontogeny, leads to selection of nonimmune cell phenotypes. Normally, therefore, nonimmune cells that evolve alongside an intact immune system would be phenotypically capable of evading immune responses, and cells whose phenotype falls short of satisfying this steady state would expire under hostile immune responses. This view was supported until recently by experimental evidence showing an inferior endurance of severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID)-derived pancreatic islets when engrafted into syngeneic immune-intact wild-type (WT) mice, relative to islets from WT. Here we extend the experimental exploration of ecoimmunity by searching for the presence of the phenotypic changes suggested by the theory. Immune-related phenotypes of islets, spleen, and bone marrow immune cells were determined, as well as SCID and WT nonlymphocytic cells. Islet submass grafting was performed to depict syngeneic graft functionality. Islet cultures were examined under both resting and inflamed conditions for expression of CD40 and major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I/II and release of interleukin-1α (IL-1α), IL-1β, IL-6, tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α), IL-10, and insulin. Results depict multiple pathways that appear to be related to the sculpting of nonimmune cells by immune cells; 59 SCID islet genes displayed relative expression changes compared with WT islets. SCID cells expressed lower tolerability to inflammation and higher levels of immune-related molecules, including MHC class I. Accordingly, islets exhibited a marked increase in insulin release upon immunocyte depletion, in effect resuming endocrine function that was otherwise suppressed by resident immunocytes. This work provides further support of the ecoimmunity theory and encourages subsequent studies to identify its role in the emergence and treatment of autoimmune pathologies, transplant rejection, and cancer.

Receptor Dissociation and B-Cell Activation

The B-cell antigen receptor (BCR) is one of the most abundant receptors on the surface of B cells with roughly 100,000-200,000 copies per cell. Signaling through the BCR is crucial for the activation and differentiation of B cells. Unlike other receptors, the BCR can be activated by a large set of structurally different ligands, but the molecular mechanism of BCR activation is still a matter of controversy. Although dominant for a long time, the cross-link model (CLM) of BCR activation is not supported by recent studies of the nanoscale organization of the BCR on the surface of resting B cells. In contrast to the prediction of CLM, the numerous BCR complexes on these cells are not randomly distributed monomers but rather form oligomers which reside within membrane confinements. This finding is more in line with the dissociation activation model (DAM), wherein B-cell activation is accompanied by an opening of the auto-inhibited BCR oligomers instead of a cross-linking of the BCR monomers. In this review, we discuss in detail the new findings and their implications for BCR signaling.

Pre-clustering of the B cell antigen receptor demonstrated by mathematically extended electron microscopy

The B cell antigen receptor (BCR) plays a crucial role in adaptive immunity, since antigen-induced signaling by the BCR leads to the activation of the B cell and production of antibodies during an immune response. However, the spatial nano-scale organization of the BCR on the cell surface prior to antigen encounter is still controversial. Here, we fixed murine B cells, stained the BCRs on the cell surface with immuno-gold and visualized the distribution of the gold particles by transmission electron microscopy. Approximately 30% of the gold particles were clustered. However the low staining efficiency of 15% precluded a quantitative conclusion concerning the oligomerization state of the BCRs. To overcome this limitation, we used Monte-Carlo simulations to include or to exclude possible distributions of the BCRs. Our combined experimental-modeling approach assuming the lowest number of different BCR sizes to explain the observed gold distribution suggests that 40% of the surface IgD-BCR was present in dimers and 60% formed large laminar clusters of about 18 receptors. In contrast, a transmembrane mutant of the mIgD molecule only formed IgD-BCR dimers. Our approach complements high resolution fluorescence imaging and clearly demonstrates the existence of pre-formed BCR clusters on resting B cells, questioning the classical cross-linking model of BCR activation.

B lymphocyte antigen receptor signaling: initiation, amplification, and regulation

B lymphocytes and their differentiated daughters are charged with responding to the myriad pathogens in our environment and production of protective antibodies. A sample of the protective antibody produced by each clone is utilized as a component of the cell's antigen receptor (BCR). Transmembrane signals generated upon antigen binding to this receptor provide the primary directive for the cell's subsequent response. In this report, we discuss recent progress and current controversy regarding B cell receptor signal initiation, transduction and regulation.

A mouse variable gene fragment binds to DNA independently of the BCR context: a possible role for immature B-cell repertoire establishment

B-cell maturation occurs in several steps and requires constant stimulus for its continuing development. From the emergence of the pre-B-cell receptor, signal transduction stimulates and supports B-cell development. Current viewpoints indicate that both positive selection pressure for autoantigens and tonic signaling constitutively stimulate B-cell maturation. In this work, we tested for the presence of a putative DNA binding site in a variable gene segment in a germline configuration, independently of VDJ recombination. After a survey of the public antibody databases, we chose a single mouse heavy variable gene segment that is highly represented in anti-nucleic acid antibodies and tested it for ssDNA binding. A phage display approach was used to search for intrinsic binding to oligo deoxythymidine. The results revealed that binding to an antigen can be influenced by the use of a specific DNA binding V[Formula: see text] gene segment. Our data support the idea that some variable genes have intrinsic reactivity towards specific types of endogenous autoantigens, and this property may contribute to the establishment of the immature B-cell repertoire.

The SH2-domain of SHIP1 interacts with the SHIP1 C-terminus: impact on SHIP1/Ig-α interaction

The SH2-containing inositol 5'-phosphatase, SHIP1, negatively regulates signal transduction from the B cell antigen receptor (BCR). The mode of coupling between SHIP1 and the BCR has not been elucidated so far. In comparison to wild-type cells, B cells expressing a mutant IgD- or IgM-BCR containing a C-terminally truncated Ig-α respond to pervanadate stimulation with markedly reduced tyrosine phosphorylation of SHIP1 and augmented activation of protein kinase B. This indicates that SHIP1 is capable of interacting with the C-terminus of Ig-α. Employing a system of fluorescence resonance energy transfer in S2 cells, we can clearly demonstrate interaction between the SH2-domain of SHIP1 and Ig-α. Furthermore, a fluorescently labeled SH2-domain of SHIP1 translocates to the plasma membrane in an Ig-α-dependent manner. Interestingly, whereas the SHIP1 SH2-domain can be pulled-down with phospho-peptides corresponding to the immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motif (ITAM) of Ig-α from detergent lysates, no interaction between full-length SHIP1 and the phosphorylated Ig-α ITAM can be observed. Further studies show that the SH2-domain of SHIP1 can bind to the C-terminus of the SHIP1 molecule, most probably by inter- as well as intra-molecular means, and that this interaction regulates the association between different forms of SHIP1 and Ig-α.

The dissociation activation model of B cell antigen receptor triggering

To detect its cognate antigen, each B lymphocyte contains up to 120000 B cell antigen receptor (BCR) complexes on its cell surface. How these abundant receptors remain silent on resting B cells and how they can be activated by a molecularly diverse set of ligands is poorly understood. The antigen-specific activation of the BCR is currently explained by the cross-linking model (CLM). This model predicts that the many BCR complexes on the surface of a B cell are dispersed signalling-inert monomers and that it is BCR dimerization that initiates signalling from the receptor. The finding that the BCR forms auto-inhibited oligomers on the surface of resting B cells falsifies these predictions of the CLM. We propose the dissociation activation model (DAM), which fits better with the existing body of experimental data.

It's all about change: the antigen-driven initiation of B-cell receptor signaling

B-cell responses are initiated by the binding of foreign antigens to the clonally distributed B-cell receptors (BCRs) resulting in the triggering of signaling cascades that activate a variety of genes associated with B-cell activation. Although we now understand the molecular nature of the signaling pathways in considerable detail what remains only poorly understood are the mechanisms by which the information that antigen has bound to the BCR ectodomain is transduced across the B-cell membrane to the BCR cytoplasmic domains to trigger signaling. To a large part this gap in knowledge is because of the paucity of techniques to temporally and spatially resolve changes in the behavior of the BCR that occur within several seconds of antigen binding. With the advent of new live-cell imaging technologies we are gaining our first clear views of the events that lead up to the triggering of BCR signaling cascades. These events may provide potential new targets for therapeutic intervention in disease involving hyper or chronic activation of B cells.

The membrane skeleton controls diffusion dynamics and signaling through the B cell receptor

Early events of B cell activation after B cell receptor (BCR) triggering have been well characterized. However, little is known about the steady state of the BCR on the cell surface. Here, we simultaneously visualize single BCR particles and components of the membrane skeleton. We show that an ezrin- and actin-defined network influenced steady-state BCR diffusion by creating boundaries that restrict BCR diffusion. We identified the intracellular domain of Igβ as important in mediating this restriction in diffusion. Importantly, alteration of this network was sufficient to induce robust intracellular signaling and concomitant increase in BCR mobility. Moreover, by using B cells deficient in key signaling molecules, we show that this signaling was most probably initiated by the BCR. Thus, our results suggest the membrane skeleton plays a crucial function in controlling BCR dynamics and thereby signaling, in a way that could be important for understanding tonic signaling necessary for B cell development and survival.

Low-valency, but not monovalent, antigens trigger the B-cell antigen receptor (BCR)

Antigen binding to the B-cell antigen receptor (BCR) leads to receptor triggering and B-lymphocyte activation. Here, we have probed the molecular requirements for BCR triggering in primary murine B cells using a set of defined soluble haptenated peptides. Bi- and trivalent haptens activated the BCR, as measured by protein phosphorylation, Ca(2+) influx, BCR down-modulation and CD69, CD86 and MHC class II up-regulation. In contrast, four distinct monovalent haptens were ineffective. Next, we used two different anti-idiotypic antibodies, which bind to the antigen-combining site of the BCR. Again, monovalent Fab fragments were ineffective, whereas bivalent antibodies could stimulate the BCR. These findings are compatible with ligand-induced clustering of monomeric BCRs or re-organization of BCR complexes within pre-formed BCR oligomers. Lastly, an increase in the valency of the haptenated peptides improved the activation potential, whereas variations in the distance between two haptens had no effect. This finding contributes to understand how the immune system can efficiently recognize structurally diverse antigens but still discriminate between foreign and self.

The SCHOOL of nature: I. Transmembrane signaling

Receptor-mediated transmembrane signaling plays an important role in health and disease. Recent significant advances in our understanding of the molecular mechanisms linking ligand binding to receptor activation revealed previously unrecognized striking similarities in the basic structural principles of function of numerous cell surface receptors. In this work, I demonstrate that the Signaling Chain Homooligomerization (SCHOOL)-based mechanism represents a general biological mechanism of transmembrane signal transduction mediated by a variety of functionally unrelated single- and multichain activating receptors. within the SCHOOL platform, ligand binding-induced receptor clustering is translated across the membrane into protein oligomerization in cytoplasmic milieu. This platform resolves a long-standing puzzle in transmembrane signal transduction and reveals the major driving forces coupling recognition and activation functions at the level of protein-protein interactions-biochemical processes that can be influenced and controlled. The basic principles of transmembrane signaling learned from the SCHOOL model can be used in different fields of immunology, virology, molecular and cell biology and others to describe, explain and predict various phenomena and processes mediated by a variety of functionally diverse and unrelated receptors. Beyond providing novel perspectives for fundamental research, the platform opens new avenues for drug discovery and development.

A conformation-induced oligomerization model for B cell receptor microclustering and signaling

The B cell receptor (BCR) generates both antigen-independent and dependent intracellular signals that are essential for B cell development and antibody responses against pathogens. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying the initiation of BCR signaling are not understood completely yet. The advent of new imaging technologies is allowing the earliest events in B cell signaling to be viewed both in vivo in lymphoid tissues and in vitro in living cells, in real-time, down to the single molecule level. Here we review recent progress in the use of these technologies to decipher the earliest events that follow B cell antigen recognition. Based on recent data using these techniques, we propose a model for the initiation of BCR signaling in which the binding of antigen induces a conformational change in the BCR's extracellular domains leading to BCR oligomerization and signaling. We conclude that testing this model will require an in-depth understanding of the unique structural and organizational features of the BCR in the plasma membrane of living B cells in the presence and absence of antigen.

The constant region of the membrane immunoglobulin mediates B cell-receptor clustering and signaling in response to membrane antigens

B cells are activated in vivo after the B cell receptors (BCRs) bind to antigens captured on the surfaces of antigen-presenting cells. Antigen binding results in BCR microclustering and signaling; however, the molecular nature of the signaling-active BCR clusters is not well understood. Using single-molecule imaging techniques, we provide evidence that within microclusters, the binding of monovalent membrane antigens results in the assembly of immobile signaling-active BCR oligomers. The oligomerization depends on interactions between the membrane-proximal Cmicro4 domains of the membrane immunoglobulin that are both necessary and sufficient for assembly. Antigen-bound BCRs that lacked the Cmicro4 domain failed to cluster and signal, and conversely, Cmicro4 domains alone clustered spontaneously and activated B cells. These results support a unique mechanism for the initiation of BCR signaling in which antigen binding induces a conformational change in the Fc portion of the BCR, revealing an interface that promotes BCR clustering.

A critical role of TAK1 in B-cell receptor-mediated nuclear factor kappaB activation

The kinase TAK1 is essential for T-cell receptor (TCR)-mediated nuclear factor kappaB (NF-kappaB) activation and T-cell development. However, the role of TAK1 in B-cell receptor (BCR)-mediated NF-kappaB activation and B-cell development is not clear. Here we show that B-cell-specific deletion of TAK1 impaired the transition from transitional type 2 to mature follicular (FO) B cells and caused a marked decrease of marginal zone (MZ) B cells. TAK1-deficient B cells exhibited an increase of BCR-induced apoptosis and impaired proliferation in response to BCR ligation. Importantly, TAK1-deficient B cells failed to activate NF-kappaB after BCR stimulation. Thus, TAK1 is critical for B-cell maturation and BCR-induced NF-kappaB activation.

Permissive geometry model

Ligand binding to the T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) evokes receptor triggering and subsequent T-lymphocyte activation. Although TCR signal transduction pathways have been extensively studied, a satisfactory mechanism that rationalizes how the information of ligand binding to the receptor is transmitted into the cell remains elusive. Models proposed for TCR triggering can be grouped into two main conceptual categories: receptor clustering by ligand binding and induction of conformational changes within the TCR. None of these models or their variations (see Chapter 6 for details) can satisfactorily account for the diverse experimental observations regarding TCR triggering. Clustering models are not compatible with the presence of preformed oligomeric receptors on the surface of resting cells. Models based on conformational changes induced as a direct effect of ligand binding, are not consistent with the requirement for multivalent ligand to initiate TCR signaling. In this chapter, we discuss the permissive geometry model. This model integrates receptor clustering and conformational change models, together with the existence of preformed oligomeric receptors, providing a mechanism to explain TCR signal initiation.

New insights into the early molecular events underlying B cell activation

The appropriate activation of B cells is critical for the development and operation of immune responses and is dependent on the extensive coordination of intra- and intercellular communications in response to antigen stimulation. An accurate description of the B cell-activation process requires investigation of these interactions within their correct cellular context both at high resolution and in real time. Here, we discuss a number of recent studies that have offered insight into the early molecular events of B cell activation. We suggest that segregation within the B cell membrane triggers localized cytoskeleton reorganisation and signaling, allowing the formation of B cell receptor (BCR) microclusters. These BCR microclusters are the sites for the coordinated recruitment of the signalosome and are propagated during B cell spreading. We discuss the recent identification of a critical role for CD19 in the B cell response to membrane-bound antigen and suggest a mechanism involving BCR microclusters by which it mediates its stimulatory function. Finally, we consider research that has taken advantage of recent technological advances in multiphoton microscopy that have allowed its application to the investigation of the dynamics of membrane-bound antigen presentation and subsequent B cell activation in lymph nodes in vivo.

Ecoimmunity: immune tolerance by symmetric co-evolution

It is widely accepted that immune tolerance toward "self" is established by central and peripheral adaptations of the immune system. Mechanisms that have been demonstrated to play a role in the induction and maintenance of tolerance include thymic deletion of self-reactive T cells, peripheral T cell anergy and apoptosis, as well as thymic and peripheral induction of regulatory T cells. However, a large body of experimental findings cannot be rationalized solely based on adaptations of the immune system to its environment. Here we propose a new model termed Ecoimmunity, where the immune system and the tissue are viewed as two sides of a continuously active and co-evolving predator-prey system. Ecoimmunity views self-tolerance, not as an equilibrium in which autoimmunity is chronically suppressed, but as a symmetrical balanced conflict between the ability of immune cells to destroy tissue cells by numerous mechanisms, and the capacity of adapted tissue cells to avoid predation. This balance evolves during ontogeny, in parallel to immune adaptations, embryonic tissue cells adapt their phenotype to the corresponding immune activity by developing the ability to escape or modulate damaging local immune responses. This phenotypic plasticity of tissue cells is directed by epigenetic selection of gene expression pattern and cellular phenotype amidst an ongoing immune pressure. Thus, whereas some immune cells prey predominantly on pathogens and infected cells, self-reactive cells continuously prey on incompetent tissue cells that fail to express the adapted phenotype and resist predation. This model uses ecological generalization to reconcile current contradictory observations as well as classical enigmas related to both autoimmunity and to tolerance toward foreign tissues. Finally, it provides empirical predictions and alternative strategies toward clinical challenges.

Phospholipase Cgamma2 contributes to light-chain gene activation and receptor editing

Phospholipase Cgamma2 (PLCgamma2) is critical for pre-B-cell receptor (pre-BCR) and BCR signaling. Current studies discovered that PLCgamma2-deficient mice had reduced immunoglobulin lambda (Iglambda) light-chain usage throughout B-cell maturation stages, including transitional type 1 (T1), transitional type 2 (T2), and mature follicular B cells. The reduction of Iglambda rearrangement by PLCgamma2 deficiency was not due to specifically increased apoptosis or decreased proliferation of mutant Iglambda+ B cells, as lack of PLCgamma2 exerted a similar effect on apoptosis and proliferation of both Iglambda+ and Igkappa+ B cells. Moreover, PLCgamma2-deficient IgHEL transgenic B cells exhibited an impairment of antigen-induced receptor editing among both the endogenous lambda and kappa loci in vitro and in vivo. Importantly, PLCgamma2 deficiency impaired BCR-induced expression of IRF-4 and IRF-8, the two transcription factors critical for lambda and kappa light-chain rearrangements. Taken together, these data demonstrate that the PLCgamma2 signaling pathway plays a role in activation of light-chain loci and contributes to receptor editing.

A native antibody-based mobility-shift technique (NAMOS-assay) to determine the stoichiometry of multiprotein complexes

Characterization of multiprotein complexes (MPCs) is an important step toward an integrative view of protein interaction networks and prerequisite for a molecular understanding of how a certain MPC functions. Here, we present a technique utilizing monoclonal subunit-specific antibodies for an electrophoretic immunoshift assay in Blue Native-gels (NAMOS-assay), which allows the determination of the stoichiometry of MPCs. First, we use the B cell antigen receptor as a model MPC whose stoichiometry is known, confirming the HC(2)LC(2)Igalpha/beta(1) stoichiometry. Second, we demonstrate that the digitonin-extracted T cell antigen receptor (TCR) extracted from T cells has a stoichiometry of alphabetaepsilon(2)gammadeltazeta(2). We then show that the NAMOS-assay does not require purified MPCs, since it can determine the stoichiometry of an MPC in cell lysates. The NAMOS-assay is also compatible with use of epitope tags appended to the protein of interest, as e.g. the widely used HA-tag, and anti-epitope antibodies for the assay. Given its general applicability, this method has a wide potential for MPC research.

Association of protein kinase C-δ with the B cell antigen receptor complex

Protein kinase C (PKC)-delta is a diacylglycerol-dependent, calcium-independent novel PKC isoform and has been demonstrated to exert negative regulatory functions in B lymphocytes as well as in mast cells. Whereas in mast cells PKC-delta functionally interacts with the high-affinity receptor for IgE, FcepsilonR1, no such association has been described for the B cell antigen receptor (BCR). In this report, for the first time, we demonstrate the interaction of PKC-delta with different classes of BCR by means of affinity purification and native protein complex analysis. Using a C-terminally truncated Ig-alpha as well as non-phosphorylated and phosphorylated peptides representing C-terminal regions of Ig-alpha, the dependence of this BCR/PKC-delta interaction on tyrosine-phosphorylated Ig-alpha is shown. Finally, splenocytes from PKC-delta-deficient mice are found to exert reduced phosphorylation of PKD (a.k.a. PKC-mu) in response to BCR engagement, suggesting the early, membrane-proximal activation of an attenuating kinase complex including PKC-delta and PKD.

Essential role of phospholipase C gamma 2 in early B-cell development and Myc-mediated lymphomagenesis

Phospholipase Cgamma2 (PLCgamma2) is a critical signaling effector of the B-cell receptor (BCR). Here we show that PLCgamma2 deficiency impedes early B-cell development, resulting in an increase of B220+ CD43+ BP-1+ CD24hi pre-BCR+ large pre-B cells. PLCgamma2 deficiency impairs pre-BCR-mediated functions, leading to enhanced interleukin-7 (IL-7) signaling and elevated levels of RAGs in the selected large pre-B cells. Consequently, PLCgamma2 deficiency renders large pre-B cells susceptible to transformation, resulting in dramatic acceleration of Myc-induced lymphomagenesis. PLCgamma2(-/-) Emu-Myc transgenic mice mainly develop lymphomas of B220+ CD43+ BP-1+ CD24hi pre-BCR+ large pre-B-cell origin, which are uncommon in wild-type Emu-Myc transgenics. Furthermore, lymphomas from PLCgamma2(-/-) Emu-Myc transgenic mice exhibited a loss of p27Kip1 and often displayed alterations in Arf or p53. Thus, PLCgamma2 plays an important role in pre-BCR-mediated early B-cell development, and its deficiency leads to markedly increased pools of the most at-risk large pre-B cells, which display hyperresponsiveness to IL-7 and express high levels of RAGs, making them prone to secondary mutations and Myc-induced malignancy.

Distinct roles of phosphoinositide-3 kinase and phospholipase Cgamma2 in B-cell receptor-mediated signal transduction

During B-cell receptor (BCR) signaling, phosphoinositide-3 kinase (PI3K) is thought to function upstream of phospholipase Cgamma2 (PLCgamma2). PLCgamma2 deficiency specifically impedes transitional type 2 (T2) to follicular (FO) mature B-cell transition. Here, we demonstrate that PI3K deficiency specifically impaired T2-to-FO mature B-cell transition and marginal zone B-cell development. Furthermore, we investigated the functional relationship between PI3K and PLCgamma2 using PI3K-/-, PLCgamma2-/-, and PI3K-/- PLCgamma2-/- B cells. Interestingly, PLCgamma2 deficiency had no effect on BCR-mediated PI3K activation, whereas PI3K deficiency only partially blocked activation of PLCgamma2. Moreover, whereas PI3K-/- PLCgamma2-/- double deficiency did not affect hematopoiesis, it resulted in embryonic lethality. PI3K-/- PLCgamma2-/- fetal liver cells transplanted into B-cell null JAK3-/- mice failed to restore development of peripheral B cells and failed to progress through early B-cell development at the pro-B- to pre-B-cell transition, a more severe phenotype than was observed with either PI3K or PLCgamma2 single-deficiency B cells. Consistent with this finding, BCR signaling was more severely impaired in the absence of both PI3K and PLCgamma2 genes than in the absence of either one alone. Taken together, these results demonstrate that whereas PI3K functions upstream of PLCgamma2, activation of PLCgamma2 can occur independently of PI3K and that PI3K and PLCgamma2 also have distinct functions in BCR signal transduction.

Initiation of pre-B cell receptor signaling: Common and distinctive features in human and mouse

B cell development in the bone marrow is a highly regulated process and expression of a functional pre-BCR represents a crucial checkpoint, common to human and mouse. In this review, we discuss pre-BCR analogies and differences between the two species leading to pre-B cell differentiation and proliferation. In addition, the mechanisms triggering pre-BCR activation are reviewed, taking into account the recent report of heparan sulfates and galectin 1 as stromal cell-derived pre-BCR ligands. Finally, ligand-induced pre-BCR activation models are proposed on the bases of the differences reported for pre-BCR and IL7 dependencies in the two species.

B cells productively engage soluble antigen-pulsed dendritic cells: visualization of live-cell dynamics of B cell-dendritic cell interactions

Interactions between B lymphocytes and Ag-bearing dendritic cells (DC) likely occur at inflammatory sites and within lymphoid organs. To better understand these interactions we imaged B cells (TgB) from hen egg lysozyme (HEL) transgenic mice and DC pulsed with HEL (DC-HEL) in collagen matrices. Analysis of live-cell dynamics revealed autonomous movements and repeated encounters between TgB cells and DC-HEL that are best described by a "kiss-run and engage" model, whereas control B cells had only short-lived interactions. Ag localized at contact sites between TgB cells and DC-HEL, and both cell types rearranged their actin cytoskeletons toward the contact zone. The interaction of a TgB cell with a HEL-bearing DC triggered strong Ca2+ transients in the B cells. Thus, B cells can productively interact with DC displaying their cognate Ag.

Evidence of marginal-zone B cell-positive selection in spleen

Antigen receptor-mediated signaling is critical for the development and survival of B cells. However, it has not been established whether B cell development requires a signal from self-ligand engagement at the immature stage, a process known as "positive selection." Here, using a monoclonal B cell receptor (BCR) mouse line, specific for the self-Thy-1/CD90 glycoprotein, we demonstrate that BCR crosslinking by low-dose self-antigen promotes survival of immature B cells in culture. In spleen, an increase in BCR signaling strength, induced by low-dose self-antigen, directed naive immature B cells to mature, not into the default follicular B cell fate, but instead into the marginal-zone B cell subset. These data indicate that positive selection can occur in developing B cells and that BCR signal strength is a key factor in deciding between two functionally distinct mature B cell compartments in the microenvironment of the spleen.

Large increases in attractant concentration disrupt the polar localization of bacterial chemoreceptors

In bacterial chemotaxis, the chemoreceptors [methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins (MCPs)] transduce chemotactic signals through the two-component histidine kinase CheA. At low but not high attractant concentrations, chemotactic signals must be amplified. The MCPs are organized into a polar lattice, and this organization has been proposed to be critical for signal amplification. Although evidence in support of this model has emerged, an understanding of how signals are amplified and modulated is lacking. We probed the role of MCP localization under conditions wherein signal amplification must be inhibited. We tested whether a large increase in attractant concentration (a change that should alter receptor occupancy from c. 0% to > 95%) would elicit changes in the chemoreceptor localization. We treated Escherichia coli or Bacillus subtilis with a high level of attractant, exposed cells to the cross-linking agent paraformaldehyde and visualized chemoreceptor location with an anti-MCP antibody. A marked increase in the percentage of cells displaying a diffuse staining pattern was obtained. In contrast, no increase in diffuse MCP staining is observed when cells are treated with a repellent or a low concentration of attractant. For B. subtilis mutants that do not undergo chemotaxis, the addition of a high concentration of attractant has no effect on MCP localization. Our data suggest that interactions between chemoreceptors are decreased when signal amplification is unnecessary.

The roles of CARMA1, Bcl10, and MALT1 in antigen receptor signaling

Lymphocyte activation plays a critical role in immune responses. Dysregulation of lymphocyte activation can cause autoimmune, immunodeficient diseases, or leukemia/lymphoma. Lymphocyte activation is triggered by stimulation of antigen receptors, T cell receptors (TCR) or B cell receptors (BCR), on the surfaces of T or B lymphocyte, respectively. Stimulation of TCR or BCR induces a series of signal transduction cascades leading to activation of multiple transcription factors including NF-kappaB. Recent studies demonstrate that CARMA1, a scaffold protein, plays an essential role in mediating TCR- or BCR-induced NF-kappaB activation by recruiting two adaptor proteins, Bcl10 and MALT1, to lipid rafts following stimulation of antigen receptors. In this review, we will discuss the mechanism by which proximal signaling components connect antigen receptor signaling to CARMA1, and how CARMA1 regulates Bcl10 and MALT1, leading to activation of NF-kappaB. In addition, the roles of CARMA1, Bcl10, and MALT1 in lymphocyte activation and development will also be discussed.

Ligand-independent tonic signaling in B-cell receptor function

The random and inherently imprecise process of V(D)J recombination is the foundation for generation of the B-cell receptor (BCR). Signals must be generated to trigger selective processes that retain cells expressing a functional BCR, and these signals must be antigen-independent to insure an unbiased and diverse pool of newly formed B cells. Moreover, BCR expression, and presumably signaling, is essential for the continued survival of the B cell. Although BCR signaling is generally thought to depend upon ligand-induced aggregation, recent studies argue that some aspects of BCR signaling occur independently of antigen, and, furthermore, these non-induced or 'tonic' signals are linked to specific cellular processes operating at multiple stages of B-cell development. The potential co-existence of tonic and induced signaling suggests a unique aspect of BCR complexes, or at least an aspect of receptors that has previously been under-appreciated.

Receptor editing in positive and negative selection of B lymphopoiesis

In B lymphopoiesis, Ag receptor expression and signaling are critical to determine developmental progression, survival, and activation. Several positive and negative selection checkpoints to test this receptor have been described in B lymphopoiesis, aiming to ensure the generation of functionally competent, nonautoimmune repertoire. Secondary Ag receptor gene recombination allows B lymphocytes to replace an inappropriate receptor with a new receptor, a mechanism called receptor editing. This salvage mechanism uncouples the Ag receptor fate from that of the cell itself, suggesting that B cell repertoire is regulated by a process of receptor selection. Secondary rearrangements are stimulated in different stages of B cell development, where editing of the receptor is necessary to fulfill stage-specific requirements. In this study, we discuss the contribution of receptor editing in B lymphopoiesis and its regulation by positive and negative selection signals.

An important role of phospholipase Cgamma1 in pre-B-cell development and allelic exclusion

Phospholipase Cgamma1 (PLCgamma1) has been reported to be expressed predominantly in T cells and to play an important role in T-cell receptor signaling. Here we show that PLCgamma1 is expressed throughout B-cell development, with high expression in B-cell progenitors, and is involved in pre-B-cell receptor (pre-BCR) signaling. Reduced expression of PLCgamma1, in the absence of PLCgamma2 (PLCgamma1+/-PLCgamma2-/-), impedes early B-cell development at the pro-B- to pre-B-cell transition and impairs immunoglobulin heavy chain allelic exclusion, hallmarks of defective pre-BCR signaling. In contrast, early B-cell development is largely normal, whereas late B-cell maturation is impaired in the absence of PLCgamma2 alone (PLCgamma2-/-) and overexpression of PLCgamma1 in PLCgamma2-/- mice fails to restore BCR-mediated B-cell proliferation and maturation. These studies reveal an essential role of PLCgamma1, distinct from that of PLCgamma2, in B-cell development.

Defined alphabeta T cell receptors with distinct ligand specificities do not require those ligands to signal double negative thymocyte differentiation

During T cell development in the thymus, pre–T cell receptor (TCR) complexes signal CD4⁻ CD8⁻ (double negative [DN]) thymocytes to differentiate into CD4⁺ CD8⁺ (double positive [DP]) thymocytes, and they generate such signals without apparent ligand engagements. Although ligand-independent signaling is unusual and might be unique to the pre-TCR, it is possible that other TCR complexes such as αβ TCR or αγ TCR might also be able to signal the DN to DP transition in the absence of ligand engagement if they were expressed on DN thymocytes. Although αγ TCR complexes efficiently signal DN thymocyte differentiation, it is not yet certain if αβ TCR complexes are also capable of signaling DN thymocyte differentiation, nor is it certain if such signaling is dependent upon ligand engagement. This study has addressed these questions by expressing defined αβ TCR transgenes in recombination activating gene 2^−/− pre-Tα^−/− double deficient mice. In such double deficient mice, the only antigen receptors that can be expressed are those encoded by the αβ TCR transgenes. In this way, this study definitively demonstrates that αβ TCR can in fact signal the DN to DP transition. In addition, this study demonstrates that transgenic αβ TCRs signal the DN to DP transition even in the absence of their specific MHC–peptide ligands.

Basal Igalpha/Igbeta signals trigger the coordinated initiation of pre-B cell antigen receptor-dependent processes

The pro-B to pre-B transition during B cell development is dependent upon surface expression of a signaling competent pre-B cell Ag receptor (pre-BCR). Although the mature form of the BCR requires ligand-induced aggregation to trigger responses, the requirement for ligand-induced pre-BCR aggregation in promoting B cell development remains a matter of significant debate. In this study, we used transmission electron microscopy on murine primary pro-B cells and pre-B cells to analyze the aggregation state of the pre-BCR. Although aggregation can be induced and visualized following cross-linking by Abs to the pre-BCR complex, our analyses indicate that the pre-BCR is expressed on the surface of resting cells primarily in a nonaggregated state. To evaluate the degree to which basal signals mediated through nonaggregated pre-BCR complexes can promote pre-BCR-dependent processes, we used a surrogate pre-BCR consisting of the cytoplasmic regions of Igalpha/Igbeta that is targeted to the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane of primary pro-B cells. We observed enhanced proliferation in the presence of low IL-7, suppression of V(H)(D)J(H) recombination, and induced kappa light (L) chain recombination and cytoplasmic kappa L chain protein expression. Interestingly, Igalpha/Igbeta-mediated allelic exclusion was restricted to the B cell lineage as we observed normal TCRalphabeta expression on CD8-expressing splenocytes. This study directly demonstrates that basal signaling initiated through Igalpha/Igbeta-containing complexes facilitates the coordinated control of differentiation events that are associated with the pre-BCR-dependent transition through the pro-B to pre-B checkpoint. Furthermore, these results argue that pre-BCR aggregation is not a requirement for pre-BCR function.

Survival of resting mature B lymphocytes depends on BCR signaling via the Igalpha/beta heterodimer

We previously showed that type I interferon-induced, Cre-mediated ablation of surface BCR expression in mature B cells through Ig-heavy chain deletion results in apoptosis of these cells. This led to the hypothesis that survival signals from the BCR are vital for mature B cells. Here, we test two critical assumptions of this model. First, we demonstrate loss of mature B cells upon induced mutation of a signaling module of the BCR, not precluding BCR surface expression. Second, we show that the cells are also lost upon BCR inactivation in the absence of an exogenous inducer like interferon, excluding that cell death depends on previous cellular activation by the latter. Kinetic data demonstrate that BCR-less mature B cells have a severely reduced lifespan, with a half-life of 3-6 days. Together these results establish that BCR signaling is required to keep resting mature B cells alive in vivo.

Immunologic basis for the rare occurrence of true nonsecretory plasma cell dyscrasias

Lymphocytes and plasma cells are major actors of the adaptive immune response and can rightly be considered as human health keepers. However, recombination and mutation events occurring at high rate in the B cell lineage also expose these cells to gene alterations, potentially resulting in uncontrolled and life-threatening cell proliferation. Although in cultured cell lines, such gene alterations frequently generate nonsecretory variants, most immunoproliferative B cell disorders feature in vivo immunoglobulin (Ig) secretion. In this paper, we review the molecular mechanisms involved in various instances of the rare, nonsecretory myelomas, in light of current notions about the molecular control of Ig production, assembly, and secretion in normal B cells. We finally document the attractive hypothesis that B cell clones, which retain nonsecretable, intracellular Igs, may be ideal, in vivo targets for efficient anti-idiotypic immune responses, and clones featuring an abundant secretion may by contrast easily induce T cell anergy and escape the anti-tumoral immune surveillance.

LFA-1/ICAM-1 Interaction Lowers the Threshold of B Cell Activation by Facilitating B Cell Adhesion and Synapse Formation

The integrin LFA-1 and its ligand ICAM-1 mediate B cell adhesion, but their role in membrane-bound antigen recognition is still unknown. Here, using planar lipid bilayers and cells expressing ICAM-1 fused to green fluorescence protein, we found that the engagement of B cell receptor (BCR) promotes B cell adhesion by an LFA-1-mediated mechanism. LFA-1 is recruited to form a mature B cell synapse segregating into a ring around the BCR. This distribution is maintained over a wide range of BCR/antigen affinities (10(6) M(-1) to 10(11) M(-1)). Furthermore, the LFA-1 binding to ICAM-1 reduces the level of antigen required to form the synapse and trigger a B cell. Thus, LFA-1/ICAM-1 interaction lowers the threshold for B cell activation by promoting B cell adhesion and synapse formation.

Positive and negative selection during B lymphocyte development

Our laboratory is interested in a variety of issues related to lymphocyte development. More specifically, we have focused on the processes that regulate the decision to commit to the B lymphocyte (B cell) lineage, then the subsequent signals that are involved in maintaining this commitment to the B cell lineage. These signals result in the positive selection of those B cells that properly execute the complex genetic changes associated with B cell development, then trigger the elimination of B cells that are responsive to self-antigens and, therefore, possess the potential to mediate autoimmune disease. Our general experimental approach has been to address these issues from the perspective of signal transduction. Our goal is to define the biochemical and genetic processes that are integrated in order to accomplish these selection processes. To do so, we employ in vivo animal models as well as more defined in vitro studies, using both primary and transformed cell lines. For the past several years, we have been primarily interested in the precise mechanisms by which the B cell antigen receptor (BCR), and intermediate forms of this receptor, regulate these complex developmental processes. We have used the ongoing studies described below as two representative examples of how we are approaching these issues and some of the insights that we have made. To place both of these studies in context, we will begin with a brief introduction into B cell development.

Modification of ligand-independent B cell receptor tonic signals activates receptor editing in immature B lymphocytes

Maturation of B lymphocytes strictly depends on the signaling competence of the B cell antigen receptor (BCR). Autoreactive receptors undergo negative selection and can be replaced by receptor editing. In addition, the process of maturation of non-self B cells and migration to the spleen, referred to as positive selection, is limited by the signaling competence of the BCR. Using 3-83Tg mice deficient of CD19 we have shown that signaling incompetence not only blocks positive selection but also activates receptor editing. Here we study the role of ligand-independent BCR tonic tyrosine phosphorylation signals in activation of receptor editing. We find that editing, immature 3-83Tg B cells deficient of CD19 have elevated BCR tonic signals and that lowering these tonic signals effectively suppresses receptor editing. Furthermore, we show that elevation of BCR tonic signals in non-editing, immature 3-83Tg B cells stimulates significant receptor editing. We also show that positive selection and developmental progression from the bone marrow to the spleen are limited to cells capable of establishing appropriate tonic signals, as in contrast to immature cells, splenic 3-83Tg B cells deficient of CD19 have BCR tonic signals similar to those of the control 3-83Tg cells. This developmental progression is accompanied by activation of molecules signaling for growth and survival. Hence, we suggest that ligand-independent BCR tonic signals are required for promoting positive selection and suppressing the receptor-editing mechanism in immature B cells.

Bam32 links the B cell receptor to ERK and JNK and mediates B cell proliferation but not survival

Bam32 is an adaptor protein recruited to the plasma membrane upon B cell receptor (BCR) crosslinking in a phosphoinositol 3-kinase (PI3K)-dependent manner; however, its physiologic function is unclear. To determine its physiologic function, we produced Bam32-deficient mice. Bam32(-/-) B cells develop normally but have impaired T-independent antibody responses in vivo and diminished responses to BCR crosslinking in vitro. Biochemical analysis revealed that Bam32 acts in a novel pathway leading from the BCR to MAPK/ERK Kinases (MEK1/2), MAPK/ERK Kinase Kinase-1 (MEKK1), extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK), and c-jun NH2-terminal kinase (JNK), but not p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase (p38). This pathway appears to be initiated by hematopoietic progenitor kinase-1 (HPK1), which interacts directly with Bam32, and differs from all previously characterized BCR signaling pathways in that it is required for normal BCR-mediated proliferation but not for B cell survival.

A high-molecular-weight complex of membrane proteins BAP29/BAP31 is involved in the retention of membrane-bound IgD in the endoplasmic reticulum

B cell antigen receptors (BCRs) are multimeric transmembrane protein complexes comprising membrane-bound immunoglobulins (mIgs) and Ig-alpha/Ig-beta heterodimers. In most cases, transport of mIgs from the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) to the cell surface requires assembly with the Ig-alpha/Ig-beta subunits. In addition to Ig-alpha/Ig-beta, mIg molecules also bind two ER-resident membrane proteins, BAP29 and BAP31, and the chaperone heavy chain binding protein (BiP). In this article, we show that neither Ig-alpha/Ig-beta nor BAP29/BAP31 nor BiP bind simultaneously to the same mIgD molecule. Blue native PAGE revealed that only a minor fraction of intracellular mIgD is associated with high-molecular-weight BAP29/BAP31 complexes. BAP-binding to mIgs was found to correlate with ER retention of chimeric mIgD molecules. On high-level expression in Drosophila melanogaster S2 cells, mIgD molecules were detected on the cell surface in the absence of Ig-alpha/Ig-beta. This aberrant transport was prevented by coexpression of BAP29 and BAP31. Thus, BAP complexes contribute to ER retention of mIg complexes that are not bound to Ig-alpha/Ig-beta. Furthermore, the mechanism of ER retention of both BAP31 and mIgD is not through retrieval from a post-ER compartment, but true ER retention. In conclusion, BAP29 and BAP31 might be the long sought after retention proteins and/or chaperones that act on transmembrane regions of various proteins.

Multitasking of Ig-alpha and Ig-beta to regulate B cell antigen receptor function

Since their discovery as signaling subunits of the B cell antigen receptor (BCR), Ig-alpha and Ig-beta are discussed to serve either a redundant or distinct function for B cell development, maintenance, and activation. Dependent upon the experimental system that has been used to address this issue, evidence could be provided to support both possibilities. Only recently has it become clear that Ig-alpha and Ig-beta possess a unique signaling identity but that both together are required to orchestrate proper B cell function in vivo. Here we discuss some of the underlying mechanisms that may involve direct coupling to discrete subsets of BCR effector proteins, such as protein tyrosine kinases or the intracellular adaptor SLP-65/BLNK.

Convergence of signaling pathways on the activation of ERK in B cells

The B cell receptor (BCR) initiates three major signaling pathways: the Ras pathway, which leads to extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK) activation; the phospholipase C-gamma pathway, which causes calcium mobilization; and the phosphoinositide 3-kinase (PI 3-kinase) pathway. These combine to induce different biological responses depending on the context of the BCR signal. Both the Ras and PI 3-kinase pathways are important for B cell development and activation. Several model systems show evidence of cross-regulation between these pathways. Here we demonstrate through the use of PI 3-kinase inhibitors and a dominant-negative PI 3-kinase construct that the BCR-induced phosphorylation and activation of ERK is dependent on PI 3-kinase. PI 3-kinase feeds into the Ras signaling cascade at multiple points, both upstream and downstream of Ras. We also show that ERK activation is dependent on phospholipase C-gamma, in keeping with its dependence on calcium mobilization. Last, the activation of PI 3-kinase itself is completely dependent on Ras. We conclude that the PI 3-kinase and Ras signaling cascades are intimately connected in B cells and that the activation of ERK is a signal integration point, since it requires simultaneous input from all three major signaling pathways.

A point mutation in the constant region of Ig lambda1 prevents normal B cell development due to defective BCR signaling

Surface expression of B cell antigen receptors (BCRs) containing Ig and Igalpha/Igbeta generates signals required to transit discrete developmental checkpoints. The mechanism by which BCR components collaborate to initiate signals is still unclear. The expression of Iglambda1 in SJL mice is 50-fold lower than in other strains. Here, we demonstrate by gene targeting that a point mutation, which changes a glycine to a valine in the lambda1 constant region, is responsible for this defect. In vitro experiments show that Ig receptors bearing this mutation, while expressed normally, are deficient in signaling. These findings reveal a direct involvement of the Ig light chain (IgL) in B cell signaling and development beyond the requirement of light chains for BCR assembly.

Ligand-independent signaling functions for the B lymphocyte antigen receptor and their role in positive selection during B lymphopoiesis

Signal transduction through the B cell antigen receptor (BCR) is determined by a balance of positive and negative regulators. This balance is shifted by aggregation that results from binding to extracellular ligand. Aggregation of the BCR is necessary for eliciting negative selection or activation by BCR-expressing B cells. However, ligand-independent signaling through intermediate and mature forms of the BCR has been postulated to regulate B cell development and peripheral homeostasis. To address the importance of ligand-independent BCR signaling functions and their regulation during B cell development, we have designed a model that allows us to isolate the basal signaling functions of immunoglobulin (Ig)alpha/Igbeta-containing BCR complexes from those that are dependent upon ligand-mediated aggregation. In vivo, we find that basal signaling is sufficient to facilitate pro-B --> pre-B cell transition and to generate immature/mature peripheral B cells. The ability to generate basal signals and to drive developmental progression were both dependent on plasma membrane association of Igalpha/Igbeta complexes and intact immunoregulatory tyrosine activation motifs (ITAM), thereby establishing a correlation between these processes. We believe that these studies are the first to directly demonstrate biologically relevant basal signaling through the BCR where the ability to interact with both conventional as well as nonconventional extracellular ligands is eliminated.