Assessing whether dairy cow welfare is "better" in pasture-based than in confinement-based management systems

Consumers perceive pasture-based systems of milk production as natural and therefore better for cow welfare than confinement systems. However both systems are heterogeneous and continually evolving, varying from total confinement to total pasture with many hybrid intermediaries. To compare the welfare of dairy cows in these various systems, we use the three spheres framework, comprising biological functioning, natural behaviour and affective states. Considering biological functioning, pasture-based cows are less at risk of subclinical and clinical mastitis, claw lesions, lameness, metritis, early embryonic mortality, culling and mortality, but at more risk of internal parasitism, malnutrition and delayed onset of oestrous activity postpartum than confined cows. Regarding natural behaviours, pasture-based cows exhibit less agonistic behaviour, better lying behaviour, more normal oestrous behaviours and better synchronicity of behaviours than confined cows. They also have the opportunity to graze, which is one of the main features of the behavioural repertoire of dairy cows, but, they may also experience long periods away from pasture in larger herds, and severe climatic stresses which will become increasingly important as the climate changes. Our current ability to assess the affective state of dairy cows is poor. For example, hunger is an important subjective state that cannot be measured directly. The growing focus on ensuring that animals have lives worth living, means that dairy cows should garner some positive emotions from their lives, and it seems clear that pasture access is essential for this. Clearly measurement of affective state is an important challenge for future dairy cow welfare research. At the extremes of management systems, there can be major differences in animal welfare but in hybrid systems, dairy cows experience elements of both confinement and pasture which may ameliorate the negative effects of each on cow welfare. Ultimately, the optimal system gives cows an element of choice between both environments. Moreover management of the system, whether it is confinement or pastured-based, may be as important as the system of management in ensuring good dairy cow welfare and addressing societal concerns.Abbreviations: BCS: Body condition score; TMR: Total mixed ration.

Artificial rearing affects the emotional state and reactivity of pigs post-weaning

Artificial rearing involves removing piglets from their mother at seven days of age and feeding them milk replacer until weaning. Earlylife rearing conditions can influence piglets' mental development, as reflected by their emotional state and reactivity. This study compared the post-weaning emotional state and reactivity of pigs which were either sow-reared or artificially reared pre-weaning. Behavioural tests (startle test, novel object test, human-animal relationship test and open door test) were conducted one week post-weaning (weaner 1, 34 [± 0.6] days old), one week after movement to weaner 2 (69 [±1.2] days old) and to finisher (100 [± 1.3] days old) stages. Qualitative Behavioural Assessments (QBA) were conducted on the same days in weaner 2 and finisher stages. QBA descriptors were computed by PCA and all other data were analysed using linear models. Artificially reared pigs were less fearful of human contact in weaner 1 (45.1 [± 8.43] vs 81.3 [± 7.89]%) and finisher (25.8 [± 5.19] vs 45.7 [± 6.00]%) stages; but there was no difference in the other tests. Artificially reared pigs had a higher QBA score (more positive) than sow-reared pigs in weaner 2 (54.49 [± 10.102] vs 17.88 [± 9.94]) but not in finisher (70.71 [± 8.860] vs 52.76 [± 9.735]) stage. In conclusion, artificially reared pigs appeared to have a more positive emotional state transiently post-weaning and a lower fearfulness towards humans, which are likely mediated by their pre-weaning conditions. These data emphasise the need to consider the entire life of the animals to fully evaluate the long-term impacts of a rearing system.

Identifying physiological measures of lifetime welfare status in pigs: exploring the usefulness of haptoglobin, C- reactive protein and hair cortisol sampled at the time of slaughter

BACKGROUND

Physiological measures indicative of the welfare status of animals during rearing could form part of an abattoir-based animal health and welfare assessment tool. A total of 66 pigs were used in this study, the aim of which was to assess how serum concentrations of haptoglobin (Hp) and C-reactive protein (CRP) (assessed in 51 pigs), and hair concentrations of cortisol (assessed in 65 pigs), measured at or close to slaughter, reflected welfare-related indicators recorded from the animal during its lifetime. These indicators were recorded at intervals between 7 and 21 weeks of age and included assigning scores for levels of tail and skin lesions, recording the presence or absence of certain health issues, and conducting qualitative behavioural assessments (QBA).

RESULTS

Pigs recorded as having tail lesions during their lifetime had higher hair cortisol levels than those with no tail lesions (tail lesions: 47.87 ± 3.34 pg/mg, no tail lesions: 42.20 ± 3.29 pg/mg, P = 0.023), and pigs recorded as having moderate or severe tail lesions had higher Hp levels than those with no or mild tail lesions (moderate/severe: 1.711 mg/ml ± 0.74, none/mild: 0.731 mg/ml ±0.10, P = 0.010). Pigs recorded as being lame during their lifetime tended to have higher hair cortisol levels than non-lame pigs (lame: 52.72 pg/mg ± 3.83, not lame: 43.07 pg/mg ± 2.69, P = 0.062). QBA scores were not associated with any of the physiological measures (P > 0.05). Receiver Operator Curve (ROC) analysis was also carried out to get a better understanding of the usefulness of the physiological measures in discriminating animals that had had welfare-related issues recorded during their lifetime from those that had not. Hair cortisol was determined as having 'moderate' accuracy in discriminating pigs that were tail bitten on-farm from unbitten pigs (AUC: 0.748) while Hp and CRP were determined to have no meaningful discriminatory ability (AUC < 0.600).

CONCLUSION

This research should be repeated on a larger scale, but the results suggest that hair cortisol measured at slaughter could provide insight into the welfare status of pigs during their lifetime. Hp may be a useful indicator of tail lesions in pigs. However, further research utilising a greater proportion of severely bitten pigs is required before conclusions can be drawn.

Validation of carcass lesions as indicators for on-farm health and welfare of pigs

Incorporating indicators for pig health and welfare at meat inspection could reduce the need for on-farm assessments. Skin and tail lesions are important welfare indicators in pigs with good potential to record during meat inspection and could possibly function as iceberg indicators of on farm welfare. The aim of this study was to validate the use of these carcass lesions at meat inspection for the assessment of pig health and welfare on farm. Thirty-one farrow-to-finish pig farms (∼12% of Irish herds) were assessed using an adapted version of the Welfare Quality protocol by inspecting 6 randomly selected pens of pigs in the first weaner (4 to 8 wk), second weaner (8 to 13 wk) and finisher stage (13 to 23 wk). The average prevalence of welfare outcomes for each stage was calculated. One batch of pigs was observed at slaughter and skin and tail lesions were scored according to severity for each carcass. The average prevalence of carcass lesion outcomes was calculated for each farm. Linear regression models were developed to predict the prevalence of each welfare outcome in each stage based on the prevalence of the different carcass lesions. The welfare outcomes of different welfare aspects that were best predicted by abattoir information (highest ) were poor body condition (first weaner stage), bursitis (second weaner stage), huddling (first weaner stage), severe tail lesions (finisher stage) and coughing (second weaner stage). Regression trees and receiver-operating curves (ROC) were used to evaluate the usefulness of carcass lesions as monitoring tools. Receiver-operating curves were created using the 75th percentile to classify farms as a problem farm for these welfare outcomes. Cut-off values of predictive carcass lesion prevalence were similar using both techniques. Models for predicting problem farms with poor body condition, bursitis and severe tail lesions were moderately accurate. Sensitivity and specificity ranged from 75 to 100% and 70 to 87%, respectively at the optimal cut-off value of the predictive carcass lesion prevalence. Results show potential for using carcass skin and tail lesions as iceberg indicators of pig health and welfare on farm. Future work is needed to evaluate the cost of including carcass lesion recording at meat inspection, the cost of failing to identify problem farms and the cost of incorrectly visiting or penalizing problem farms before carcass lesions can be used as welfare indicators in a commercial setting.

Abstract P2-08-05: Phase I/II trial of palbociclib in combination with bicalutamide for the treatment of androgen receptor (AR)+ metastatic breast cancer (MBC)

This abstract was withdrawn by the authors.

Effects of gestation housing system and floor type during lactation on locomotory ability; body, limb, and claw lesions; and lying-down behavior of lactating sows

This study evaluated the influence of housing system during gestation and floor type during lactation on the welfare and lying-down behavior of lactating sows. Multiparous sows (n = 85) were housed either in individual gestation stalls (n = 42) or loose (n = 43) in a single dynamic group with 2 electronic sow feeders moved to farrowing crates on either slatted steel (n = 48) or cast iron (n = 37) flooring. Lameness (0 = normal to 5 = severely lame) was scored on transfer to the farrowing crate (-5 d). Limb and body lesions were recorded on -5 d, 24 h after entering the farrowing crate (-4 d), 10-d postpartum, and before weaning. Claw lesions were recorded on -5 d and before weaning, whereas all behavioral observations were made on -5, -4, and 10 d. Median (Me) scores were calculated for claw, body, and limb lesions and classified as either less than or equal to the Me or greater than the Me lesion scores. Sows were classified as nonlame (≤ 1) or lame (≥ 2). Loose-housed sows had an increased (P < 0.01) risk of lameness; a reduced (P < 0.05) risk for claw lesions, particularly white line damage, horizontal wall cracks, and dewclaw injuries; and a reduced (P < 0.05) risk for calluses and bursitis on the limbs compared to stall-housed sows. Sows housed on cast iron floors during lactation had a reduced (P < 0.01) risk for heel overgrowth and erosion and heel-sole cracks compared with sows on slatted steel floors. There was no (P > 0.05) association between flooring type during lactation and body lesion score. On -4 d, loose-housed sows had a shorter latency to lie down (P < 0.01), spent more time inactive (P < 0.05), and shifted weight between the limbs more often (P = 0.05) while standing compared with stall-housed sows. Lame sows had a shorter (P < 0.01) latency to lie down compared to nonlame sows on -5 and -4 d. In conclusion, there was an increased risk of lameness in sows housed loose compared to those housed in gestation stalls on transfer to the farrowing crate. Claw health deteriorated in the farrowing crate regardless of gestation housing or floor type but the deterioration in claw health was increased on slatted steel compared to on cast iron.

Strategies to overcome obstacles to successful immunotherapy of melanoma

The immunogenicity of malignant melanomas has been recognized by the observed recruitment of tumor-specific cytotoxic T-cells (CTL), leading to the identification of several melanoma associated antigen (MAA). However, numerous strategies to treat melanoma with immunotherapy have resulted in only partial success. In this editorial, we discuss recent data related to the ability of tumors to elude immune responses. We therefore discuss different strategies to induce a clinically effective immune response. These approaches include 1) immunostimulation: including peptide/protein based vaccines, dendritic cell vaccines, and adoptive cell transfer; and 2) overcoming immunosuppression, including targeting of checkpoint molecules such as CTLA-4, circumventing the activity of Tregs, and assuring antigen expression by tumor cells (thwarting antigen silencing). Finally, we discuss recent advances in gene therapy, including adoptive therapy with engineered T cell receptors (TCRs). These issues lead to the conclusion that successful immunotherapy in malignant melanoma requires a combination of strategies aimed at both inducing immunostimulation and blocking immunosuppression.

Age-related changes in pro-inflammatory cytokines, acute phase proteins and cortisol concentrations in neonatal piglets

Age-related changes have been described in the resting levels of cortisol and acute phase proteins in the neonatal pig. This study evaluated the plasma concentrations of the pro-inflammatory cytokines tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), interleukin-1beta (IL-1beta), the acute phase proteins C-reactive protein (CRP), serum amyloid A (SAA) and haptoglobin (Hp), as well as cortisol during the first week of postnatal life in piglets. The influence of invasive managerial practices such as teeth clipping, ear notching and tail docking on possible age-related changes in the production of these inflammatory mediators was also assessed. A total of 96 piglets were selected from 24 litters at birth, and were randomly assigned to one of four sampling times over the first week of life and one of two treatments. Blood samples were taken at 1, 3, 5 or 7 days of age. Piglets were ear notched, teeth clipped and tail docked (NCD), or were left untreated (CON). Significant effects of age were found in plasma concentrations of TNF-alpha, SAA, Hp and cortisol (p < 0.001). Concentrations of TNF-alpha and Hp increased with age, and peak concentrations were found on day 5. SAA and cortisol levels were highest on day 1, decreasing gradually with age. NCD piglets tended to have higher levels of plasma Hp than CON animals (p = 0.066). However, no differences between NCD and CON piglets were found in any other parameter measured. Furthermore, age effects were not affected by these husbandry practices. These results indicate that age-related changes exist in several inflammatory mediators, and suggest that these managerial practices do not result in systemic inflammation in early postnatal life of piglets.

A novel autocrine pathway of tumor escape from immune recognition: melanoma cell lines produce a soluble protein that diminishes expression of the gene encoding the melanocyte lineage melan-A/MART-1 antigen through down-modulation of its promoter

We have observed that malignant melanoma cells produce a soluble protein factor(s), which down-regulates melanocyte lineage Melan-A/MART-1 Ag expression by melanoma cells with concomitant loss of recognition by Melan-A/MART-1-specific T cells. This down-modulation of Melan-A/MART-1 expression, which we refer to as "Ag silencing," is mediated via its minimal promoter, whereas the promoter for the restricting Ag-presenting HLA-A2 molecule is not affected. Significantly, this Ag silencing is reversible, as removal of factor-containing supernatants from Melan-A/MART-1-expressing cells results in up-regulation of the promoter for the gene encoding this Ag, and renewed expression of the protein. We have evaluated over 20 known factors, none of which accounts for the Ag-silencing activity of the melanoma cell culture supernatants. The existence of this autocrine pathway provides an additional novel explanation for melanoma tumor progression in vivo in the presence of CTL specific for this melanocyte lineage Ag. These observations may have important implications for Melan-A/MART-1-specific CTL-mediated immunotherapy of melanoma tumors.

Outer membrane protein A, peptidoglycan-associated lipoprotein, and murein lipoprotein are released by Escherichia coli bacteria into serum

Complexes containing lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and three outer membrane proteins (OMPs) are released by gram-negative bacteria incubated in human serum and into the circulation in an experimental model of sepsis. The same OMPs are bound by immunoglobulin G (IgG) in the cross-protective antiserum raised to Escherichia coli J5 (anti-J5 IgG). This study was performed to identify the three OMPs. The 35-kDa OMP was identified as outer membrane protein A (OmpA) by immunoblotting studies using OmpA-deficient bacteria and recombinant OmpA protein. The 18-kDa OMP was identified as peptidoglycan-associated lipoprotein (PAL) based on peptide sequences from the purified protein and immunoblotting studies using PAL-deficient bacteria. The 5- to 9-kDa OMP was identified as murein lipoprotein (MLP) based on immunoblotting studies using MLP-deficient bacteria. The studies identify the OMPs released into human serum and into the circulation in an experimental model of sepsis as OmpA, PAL, and MLP.

Release of gram-negative outer-membrane proteins into human serum and septic rat blood and their interactions with immunoglobulin in antiserum to Escherichia coli J5

Prior studies indicate that 3 bacterial outer-membrane proteins (OMPs) are released into serum associated with lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and are bound by IgG in antiserum to Escherichia coli J5 (anti-J5 IgG). The present studies analyzed the interaction of the OMPs with anti-J5 IgG and evaluated their release in an infected burn model of gram-negative sepsis. Affinity purification studies were performed on filtrates of bacteria incubated in human serum and plasma from rats with sepsis by use of O chain-specific anti-LPS IgG and anti-J5 IgG. All 3 OMPs were captured from septic rat blood by anti-LPS IgG. Release of OMPs into serum was highest for immature bacterial cultures and was increased by antibiotics in vitro and in vivo. Anti-J5 IgG selectively captured an 18-kDa OMP released into serum and into plasma from septic rats. The results raise the possibility that anti-J5 IgG may, in part, protect via anti-OMP antibodies.

Melanoma antigen recognition by tumour-infiltrating T lymphocytes (TIL): effect of differential expression of melan-A/MART-1

We have isolated, from an individual patient with metastatic melanoma, a series of eight TIL clones capable of lysing autologous melanoma cell targets. Six of the eight clones expressed TCRAV2S1 and lysed targets expressing HLA-A2 and the Melan-A/MART-1 peptide: AAGIGILTV. Polymerase chain reaction-single stranded conformational polymorphism (PCR-SSCP) analysis showed that the Melan-A/MART-1-specific clones were predominant in the bulk culture prior to cloning. However, the tumour progressed in vivo even in the presence of these tumour cell-lytic clones. Using the anti-Melan-A/MART-1 MoAb (A-103), we noted that Melan-A/MART-1 expression on three melanoma cell lines varied considerably during in vitro culture, in the absence of T cell immunoselection, relative to cell density. Tumour cells which spontaneously decreased Melan-A/MART-1 expression were less susceptible to specific TIL lysis. Melan-A/MART-1 expression and susceptibility to lysis increased in cells cultured at lower density. These data suggest that modulation of tumour antigen may account for tumour progression in the presence of tumour cell-lytic T lymphocytes. The observations suggest a possible explanation for the common finding of Melan-A/MART-1-specific lytic TIL in clinically progressing melanomas, as well as a possible pathway for therapeutic intervention.

Oligoclonality of Vdelta1 and Vdelta2 cells in human peripheral blood mononuclear cells: TCR selection is not altered by stimulation with gram-negative bacteria

Despite the enormous potential repertoire of gammadelta T cells, there are several observations which suggest that the expressed gammadelta repertoire in the periphery of normal individuals is often quite restricted. To assess selective expansions among gammadelta T cells from both adult and newborn blood samples, PBMC from 12 normal adults and cord blood from 15 normal newborns were analyzed for TCRDV1 and TCRDV2 junctional diversity by CDR3 size spectratyping and single-strand conformational polymorphism. Although TCRBV usage showed extensive heterogeneity in adults and newborns, both populations often showed CDR3 region restriction for TCRDV1 and TCRDV2. Analysis of the CDR3 spectratype patterns of newborn twins suggested that clonal selection for TCRDV is independent of genetic background. The possible role of Gram-negative bacteria in driving selective responsiveness of gammadelta T cells in PBMCs from adults was examined by in vitro stimulation with Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Donors whose TCRDV repertoire was highly clonal in the unstimulated blood cells showed the same predominant clones among the bacteria-stimulated cultures. In individuals whose gammadelta T cells were less restricted, in vitro stimulation did not select for clonality; rather, the TCRDV repertoires were similar before and after bacterial stimulation. Together, these data indicate that gammadelta T cells are often clonally restricted in adults as well as in newborns and suggest that the prominent stimulatory activity of Gram-negative bacteria does not by itself account for the restriction or diversity of the gammadelta T cell repertoire.

In vivo accumulation of the same anti-melanoma T cell clone in two different metastatic sites

In a patient with progressing metastatic melanoma, we showed that the same autologous tumor-cytolytic CD8+ tumor infiltrating lymphocyte (TIL) clone accumulated in two separate metastatic sites. This clone, which represented three of eight independently derived clones from a tumor deposit on the skin of the abdomen, also represented two of eight clones derived from a skin lesion on the shoulder. This clone could be identified by its use of a unique TCRBV2-nD1n-J1S6 sequence, and could also be detected by single-stranded conformational polymorphism (SSCP) as the dominant TCRBV2-expressing clone among CD8+ TILs propagated from both shoulder and abdominal lesions. Using SSCP analysis, we also demonstrated that this clone was dominant in the fresh tumor tissue and in all TILs in which CD8+ were strongly represented, including several separate but parallel cultures. The SSCP pattern for this clone was not apparent among CD4+ TILs or CD8+ peripheral blood mononuclear cells. The SSCP analysis of the tumor tissue prior to in vitro culture is an indication that the selection for this anti-tumor cytotoxic T cell clone was a reflection of its in vivo accumulation. Thus, we provide evidence that melanomas are immunogenic and able to select for cytotoxic antitumor-specific TIL clones that are expanded in vivo and can circulate to accumulate in different tumor sites. However, because these clones were isolated from progressing tumor metastases, the accumulation of these specific cytotoxic T cells was not sufficient to contain tumor growth.

Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa induce expansion of V delta 2 cells in adult peripheral blood, but of V delta 1 cells in cord blood

Human peripheral blood T cells proliferate in response to Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. We observed that during the first few days after stimulation a large percentage of the responding PBMC were gamma delta T cells. In our study we characterized the early T cell responses of freshly isolated adult and newborn PBMC to soluble preparations of heat-killed E. coli and P. aeruginosa. Specimens from all healthy adults tested showed intense proliferation in response to both bacterial preparations; at 6 days, the responding cells were mainly T cell blasts, of which high percentages (up to 80%) were gamma delta T cells, most expressing V delta 2/V gamma 9. All newborn blood specimens tested also showed T cell proliferative responses, which included a marked expansion of gamma delta T cells, mainly of the V delta 1 subset. Populations of purified V delta 1 and V delta 2 T cells were obtained from adult PBMC following stimulation with E. coli; both subsets proliferated upon rechallenge with the bacterial preparations. Protease treatment of the bacterial preparations did not appreciably affect their ability to induce expansion of gamma delta T cells in either adult or cord blood, indicating that the stimulatory components were not proteins. The response of gamma delta T cells from newborns indicates that prior exposure to bacterial products is not necessary and suggests that gamma delta T cells are important elements in natural immunity to these extracellular organisms.

Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa induce expansion of V delta 2 cells in adult peripheral blood, but of V delta 1 cells in cord blood

Human peripheral blood T cells proliferate in response to Escherichia coli and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. We observed that during the first few days after stimulation a large percentage of the responding PBMC were gamma delta T cells. In our study we characterized the early T cell responses of freshly isolated adult and newborn PBMC to soluble preparations of heat-killed E. coli and P. aeruginosa. Specimens from all healthy adults tested showed intense proliferation in response to both bacterial preparations; at 6 days, the responding cells were mainly T cell blasts, of which high percentages (up to 80%) were gamma delta T cells, most expressing V delta 2/V gamma 9. All newborn blood specimens tested also showed T cell proliferative responses, which included a marked expansion of gamma delta T cells, mainly of the V delta 1 subset. Populations of purified V delta 1 and V delta 2 T cells were obtained from adult PBMC following stimulation with E. coli; both subsets proliferated upon rechallenge with the bacterial preparations. Protease treatment of the bacterial preparations did not appreciably affect their ability to induce expansion of gamma delta T cells in either adult or cord blood, indicating that the stimulatory components were not proteins. The response of gamma delta T cells from newborns indicates that prior exposure to bacterial products is not necessary and suggests that gamma delta T cells are important elements in natural immunity to these extracellular organisms.

T cell receptor gene rearrangements and cytotoxic activities of clones isolated from tumour-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) from melanoma patients

The lymphocytes which infiltrate tumours and are grown in vitro to be used in adoptive immunotherapy are often characterized by dominant rearrangement of their T cell receptor (TCR) genes. To investigate the frequency and function of cells contributing to the 'dominant' rearrangement, we have cloned two bulk cell lines of TIL derived from melanoma patients (TIL-1 and TIL-5). These IL-2-propagated TIL cell lines had a CD8+ phenotype and exerted strong cytotoxic activity against autologous melanoma cells, but not against the natural killer (NK)-sensitive K-562 cell line or LAK targets such as Daudi cells. We derived 40 clones from TIL-1 and 23 from TIL-5. All tested clones were CD3+, CD4-, CD8+ and expressed the alpha/beta TCR. From TIL-1, 27 of 40 clones, and 13/19 of the TIL-5 clones lysed autologous tumour cells. In contrast to the NK-negative bulk cultures, K-562 killing was detected in 21 of the TIL-1 clones and 17 of the TIL-5 clones. TIL-1 contained eight clones and TIL-5 two clones with lytic capacity against neither autologous tumour cells nor the K562 cell line, although these clones possessed lytic potential as evidenced in a lectin-mediated lysis assay. LAK activity was not detected in most clones. Cytotoxic activity against autologous tumour could be inhibited by preincubation with anti-CD3 or anti-HLA class I MoAbs. Of the 34 TIL-1 clones analysed, 15 shared a rearranged TCR beta EcoRI restriction fragment of approximately 9.5 kb with the bulk culture. Clones sharing the EcoRI 10.5-kb dominant band present in TIL-5 bulk culture were also isolated. When the pattern of TCR beta rearrangement was compared with the cytotoxic functions, the following conclusions could be drawn: (i) clones contributing to the dominant band had heterogeneous functions. Most killed autologous tumour cells, but clones with no cytotoxic activity or even with no proliferative capacity in response to autologous tumour cells were also detected among those contributing rearrangement; (ii) some clones that share an apparently identical rearranged band different from the 'dominant' rearrangement, may demonstrate the same cytotoxic function. In addition, our data suggest that many of the clones that share the dominant rearrangement originated from diverse progenitors. The high frequency of clonally diverse anti-tumour reactive TIL is likely to be a reflection of the in vivo selection of the TCR repertoire at the site of tumour.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Dominant rearrangements among human tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes. Analysis of T-cells derived from 32 patients with melanoma, lung, and renal cell carcinoma

Dominant rearrangements of T-cell receptor (TCR) beta-chain genes are reported among tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL). After interleukin-2 expansion of TIL from renal and lung carcinoma and melanoma biopsy tissues, rearrangements of TCR beta-chain genes were analyzed by Southern blotting. Nongermline restriction fragments, indicating dominant rearrangements, were detected among the TIL from all 6 patients with renal cell carcinoma, 17 of 20 patients with melanoma, and 3 of 6 patients with lung tumors. The restriction-fragment sizes of these dominant rearrangements were heterogeneous among the various patients. Rearrangements into C beta 1 were more common than C beta 2 rearrangements. Phenotypic analyses indicated that dominant rearrangements occurred in both CD4 and CD8 predominant TIL populations. The TIL populations that were extracted were expanded to derive large cell numbers suitable for in vivo transfer in an interleukin-2 and TIL immunotherapy program. The data indicated that the cells delivered to these patients usually were characterized by dominant populations of T-cells with selective TCR gene rearrangements. The significance of selective TCR use requires evaluation of the function and specificity of the TIL comprising these dominant populations both in their native in vivo setting and in the context of therapeutic transfer.

Expression of cell adhesion molecules in human melanoma cell lines and their role in cytotoxicity mediated by tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes

The role of cell adhesion molecules (CAM) LFA1, ICAM-1, LFA3, VLA1, VLA4, CD29, CD44, and CD56 in tumor-infiltrating lymphocyte (TIL) and natural killer cell (NK)-mediated killing of target cells was studied. Melanoma cell lines and autologous TIL were derived from seven patients with metastatic melanoma, and cytotoxicity assays were done in the presence and absence of monoclonal antibodies (MoAb) to CAM expressed on melanoma cells or TIL. The melanoma cell lines analyzed were all positive for CD29 and LFA3 expression, negative for LFA1 expression, but showed variable expression of ICAM-1, VLA1, VLA4, CD44, and CD56. The effects of anti-CAM antibodies on TIL-mediated melanoma killing fell into three categories: (1) consistent inhibition of TIL-mediated killing was observed when melanoma cells were pretreated with anti-ICAM1 and anti-LFA-3 MoAb or when TIL were pretreated with anti-LFA1; (2) no effect was observed when melanoma cells were pretreated with anti-CD56; or (3) a discreet, but significant, inhibition was observed when target cells were pretreated with anti-CD29, anti-VLA1, anti-VLA4, and anti-CD44. Cytotoxicity was significantly enhanced by pretreatment of target cells with gamma-interferon (gamma-IFN), although gamma-IFN did not augment surface expression of the CAM studied. The NK-mediated killing of K562 cells was blocked by anti-LFA1, anti-CD18, and anti-ICAM, and partially inhibited by anti-CD44 MoAb. Together, these results suggest that several accessory CAM may play a role in regulating cellular cytotoxicity. Because cytotoxicity generally correlated with the level of expression of CAM in melanoma cells, weak CAM surface expression may provide a means for melanomas to escape immune surveillance.

Expression of HLA-A2 antigen in human melanoma cell lines and its role in T-cell recognition

Previous studies have suggested that, in human melanoma, expression of HLA-A2 antigen is important for tumor cell recognition by autologous T-lymphocytes. Because of the recent demonstration that expression of HLA Class I antigens may be selectively lost in several human tumors, including melanoma, we derived pairs of tumor infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) and melanoma cell lines from 4 human lymphocytic antigen (HLA)-A2+ patients with metastatic melanoma. We observed that, although all 4 TIL cultures expressed HLA-A2 antigen, only 2 melanoma cell lines did so. Melanoma cells derived from the other 2 patients showed neither surface expression of the HLA-A2 antigen nor presence of the corresponding mRNA. We also observed some correlation between loss of HLA-A2 expression and level of c-myc transcription. TIL derived from patients whose melanoma cell lines had normal expression of HLA-A2 had a CD8 phenotype and were capable of lysing autologous melanoma cells. Melanoma cell killing was CD3 and major histocompatibility complex Class I restricted in both cases, but HLA-A2 restricted in only one case. On the other hand, TIL derived from the 2 patients whose melanoma cell lines had lost expression of HLA-A2 had a predominant CD4 phenotype and virtually no cytotoxic activity. Preincubation of the HLA-A2 negative melanoma cell lines with alpha- or gamma-interferon did not induce the re-expression of the HLA-A2 antigen. In an attempt to restore HLA-A2 antigen expression in one of the melanoma cell lines that were HLA-A2 negative, we transfected these cells with the HLA-A2 gene subcloned in the pSV2-neo vector. Four transfected clones, with high levels of HLA-A2 antigen expression, were expanded and characterized. Proliferative and cytotoxic activities of TIL against the autologous transfected clones as well as the untransfected parental melanoma cell line were measured and compared. CD4+ TIL showed no difference in the proliferative response to autologous parental and HLA-A2 transfected clones. However, we observed selective recognition of the HLA-A2 expressing clones by autologous cultured peripheral blood lymphocytes (which contained CD8 cells) as well as allogeneic CD8+ TIL with a HLA-A2 restricted pattern of recognition. In contrast, virtually no cytotoxic activity was detected against either parental or HLA-A2 transfected clones. Overall, our data suggest that selective down-regulation of HLA-A2 antigen expression in melanoma cells may represent one of the mechanisms by which tumor cells escape immunological recognition.

Clonal analysis of graft-infiltrating lymphocytes from renal and cardiac biopsies. Dominant rearrangements of TcR beta genes and persistence of dominant rearrangements in serial biopsies

Graft-infiltrating lymphocytes from both human renal and cardiac allografts were propagated in interleukin 2 in order to evaluate rearrangements in the T-cell receptor (TcR) beta-chain genes. Individual biopsies from renal allografts during episodes of cellular rejection were examined as well as multiple biopsies of heart transplant patients from whom endomyocardial samples were taken prior to, during, and after episodes of rejection. TcR beta-chain rearrangements were evaluated in Southern blots using DNA extracted from interleukin 2-propagated cells and digested with restriction endonucleases permitting assessment of rearrangements to both C beta 1 and C beta 2. Rearrangements shared among greater than 5% of the "bulk" culture appear as nongermline bands when hybridized with a C beta probe. Single-cell progeny were generated from limiting dilution, and the rearrangements among the cloned progeny compared to the "bulk" of the cultured progeny of graft-infiltrating lymphocytes. The results indicate that "dominant" rearrangements are a common feature of renal allograft-infiltrating lymphocytes (14 of 15 cases examined). Since the number of cells which can be recovered from a given cardiac biopsy may be limiting, evaluation of clonal dominance from these cultures is more difficult to evaluate. However, sharing of "dominant" rearrangements among multiple biopsies from the same cardiac allograft patient indicates an in vivo selection for T cells with the same receptor rearrangement. Analysis of individual clones showed 3/33 clones from a renal allograft sharing the "dominant" rearrangement noted in the bulk culture, but none of these "dominant" clones showed antidonor specificity.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Tumor-derived interleukin-2-dependent lymphocytes in adoptive immunotherapy of lung cancer

A trial of adoptive immunotherapy was performed in which long-term cultured, interleukin-2 (IL2)-dependent T-lymphocytes were administered to patients with metastatic adenocarcinoma of the lung. Lymphocytes were isolated from explants of cancer tissues that were cultured in medium with recombinant IL-2. These T-cells expressed surface markers of activation, and killed a broad panel of tumor targets. Intravenously injected 111indium-labeled T-cell blasts distributed primarily to lungs, liver, and spleen. Despite a paucity of infused lymphocytes detected by external imaging at sites of tumor, five of seven patients showed reduction of their cancers. However, in no case was greater than 50% reduction of total tumor burden achieved. Evidence of increased delayed cutaneous hypersensitivity to protein antigens was observed in three patients following therapy. We conclude that long-term cultured tumor-derived T-cells can be transferred safely into humans and that these cells may be capable of enhancing immune responses and mediating tumor reduction in vivo.

Two-color flow cytometry and functional analysis of lymphocytes cultured from human renal allografts: identification of a Leu-2+3+ subpopulation

The phenotype of T lymphocyte subsets present in renal biopsies showing acute cellular allograft rejection in six patients on cyclosporine have been characterized in situ by immunoperoxidase staining, and after expansion in vitro in interleukin 2 (IL-2) by two-color flow cytometry, sorting, and functional analysis. After 8 to 42 days in organ culture, both Leu-3+ (CD4) and Leu-2+ (CD8) subsets were found in each culture, in a ratio that varied from 0.2 to 5.0, which was not significantly different than the results of in situ immunoperoxidase staining of the uncultured biopsy. The cultured cells were almost all Leu-4+ (CD3) T cells (89% +/- 4), which expressed the activation markers DR (82% +/- 6) and the IL 2 (CD25) receptor (15% +/- 4). The Leu-3+ cells were largely Leu-8- (90% +/- 6), whereas a minority of the Leu-2+ cells were Leu-15+ (CD11) (26% +/- 4). Only a small fraction of the Leu-2+ cells stained for Leu-7 (8% +/- 6). Functional analysis of FACS-purified Leu-2-3+ and Leu-2+3- populations indicated that both subsets proliferated in response to graft donor antigens in a mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and produced IL 2. Only the Leu-2+3- population demonstrated donor-specific cytotoxic activity. A minor subpopulation in each culture were both Leu-3+ and Leu-2+ (2.0%). Leu-2+3+ cells from one biopsy were purified to homogeneity (99.8%), and were found to express the T cell antigen receptor complex Ti/CD3 (WT-31+, Leu-4+), but not the common thymocyte antigen CD1 (OKT6). The Leu-2+3+ cells neither responded in the MLR, nor showed any cytotoxic capacity. The Leu-2+3+ cells were capable of IL 2 but not interferon-gamma production. None of the purified cultures demonstrated NK activity. A subset of the purified Leu-2+3+ cells lost Leu-2+ during 1 to 3 wk in culture, and became Leu-2-3+. These studies provide evidence that the cells that infiltrate renal allografts during rejection include alloproliferative, lymphokine-producing cells of both Leu-2+ and Leu-3+ subsets. The Leu-2+3- cells are also highly cytotoxic against donor lymphocytes, indicating the presence of helper independent cytotoxic T cells. A minor population of Leu-2+3+ T cells that do not express donor specific function was also identified.

Two-color flow cytometry and functional analysis of lymphocytes cultured from human renal allografts: identification of a Leu-2+3+ subpopulation

The phenotype of T lymphocyte subsets present in renal biopsies showing acute cellular allograft rejection in six patients on cyclosporine have been characterized in situ by immunoperoxidase staining, and after expansion in vitro in interleukin 2 (IL-2) by two-color flow cytometry, sorting, and functional analysis. After 8 to 42 days in organ culture, both Leu-3+ (CD4) and Leu-2+ (CD8) subsets were found in each culture, in a ratio that varied from 0.2 to 5.0, which was not significantly different than the results of in situ immunoperoxidase staining of the uncultured biopsy. The cultured cells were almost all Leu-4+ (CD3) T cells (89% +/- 4), which expressed the activation markers DR (82% +/- 6) and the IL 2 (CD25) receptor (15% +/- 4). The Leu-3+ cells were largely Leu-8- (90% +/- 6), whereas a minority of the Leu-2+ cells were Leu-15+ (CD11) (26% +/- 4). Only a small fraction of the Leu-2+ cells stained for Leu-7 (8% +/- 6). Functional analysis of FACS-purified Leu-2-3+ and Leu-2+3- populations indicated that both subsets proliferated in response to graft donor antigens in a mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and produced IL 2. Only the Leu-2+3- population demonstrated donor-specific cytotoxic activity. A minor subpopulation in each culture were both Leu-3+ and Leu-2+ (2.0%). Leu-2+3+ cells from one biopsy were purified to homogeneity (99.8%), and were found to express the T cell antigen receptor complex Ti/CD3 (WT-31+, Leu-4+), but not the common thymocyte antigen CD1 (OKT6). The Leu-2+3+ cells neither responded in the MLR, nor showed any cytotoxic capacity. The Leu-2+3+ cells were capable of IL 2 but not interferon-gamma production. None of the purified cultures demonstrated NK activity. A subset of the purified Leu-2+3+ cells lost Leu-2+ during 1 to 3 wk in culture, and became Leu-2-3+. These studies provide evidence that the cells that infiltrate renal allografts during rejection include alloproliferative, lymphokine-producing cells of both Leu-2+ and Leu-3+ subsets. The Leu-2+3- cells are also highly cytotoxic against donor lymphocytes, indicating the presence of helper independent cytotoxic T cells. A minor population of Leu-2+3+ T cells that do not express donor specific function was also identified.

Functional characterization of T lymphocytes propagated from human lung carcinomas

Tissue fragments from biopsies of six patients with malignant tumors of the lung were cultured in interleukin 2 (IL-2). Cultures of proliferating lymphocytes were isolated from all cases. Tumor cell lines (small cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma) were established in parallel cultures from two of these patients. Lymphocytes that proliferated in vitro were virtually all mature T lymphocytes (greater than 95% T3+, T11+). The T8+ subset accounted for an average of 70% while T4+ cells averaged 20% of the cells in culture. HNK-1 antigen was presented on 23% of cells. Seventy-four percent of cells expressed Ia (HLA-DR) antigens. B cells did not proliferate under these conditions. In all cases the cells lysed K562 targets and were active in lectin-mediated cytolysis against human lymphoblasts. All cultures produced lymphokines (IL-2 and IFN-gamma) when stimulated with PHA. Lymphocytes grown from a tissue specimen with adenocarcinoma were capable of killing autologous tumor cells in vitro. Specific cytotoxicity has been maintained by these cultured lymphocytes for greater than 6 months. IL-2 activated peripheral blood cells in this case showed little specific cytotoxicity for autologous tumor cells. Lymphocytes from another specimen of adenocarcinoma also lysed this tumor, but cells from the other four specimens did not. Lymphocytes propagated from the specimen of small cell undifferentiated cancer did not lyse autologous tumor cells. These data show that primary lung tumors contain activated T cells which will respond to IL-2 in vitro. These tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes have demonstrable function, which can include cytolytic activity against autologous lung tumor.

Heteroantibody duplexes target cells for lysis by cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Antibodies to the clonally unique variable-region determinants (idiotype) of the antigen-specific alpha beta heterodimeric receptor of a clone of cytotoxic T cells (CTLs) were shown previously to render diverse cells, regardless of their own surface antigens, susceptible to lysis by that clone of CTLs. To extend these findings, we have sought to develop a general means for targeting cells for destruction by any CTL, without regard to its alpha beta idiotype and specificity for antigen. We explored the use of heteroantibody duplexes formed by joining covalently an antibody to the T3 complex (anti-T3), which is associated with the alpha beta receptors on all human mature T cells, and a second antibody, specific for an antigen on the intended target cell. The second antibody selected in this study was specific for the idiotype (Id) of the surface immunoglobulin of a human B-lymphoma (anti-Ig Id). In the presence of the anti-T3/anti-Ig Id heteroantibody duplex the B-lymphoma cells were lysed by a clone of human T8+ CTLs (of unrelated specificity) but not by a noncytotoxic clone of human T4+ helper T cells, and lysis by the CTLs was specifically blocked by the uncoupled anti-T3 or the uncoupled anti-Ig Id antibodies. The extent of the heteroantibody-dependent cytolysis depended both on the heteroantibody concentration and on whether the intended target cells or the CTL effectors were initially preincubated with the heteroantibody. Under optimal conditions, heteroantibody-dependent lysis of the surrogate target (B-lymphoma) cells by the CTLs compared favorably with lysis of their natural target cells by the same CTLs. Overall, our findings suggest that heteroantibody duplexes containing anti-T3 antibody may be capable of targeting selected cells, such as tumor cells, for destruction in vivo by the body's CTLs.

Characterization of in vivo-activated allospecific T lymphocytes propagated from human renal allograft biopsies undergoing rejection

To evaluate in situ lymphocyte responses in cell-mediated immune tissue injury, we have developed an approach for propagation of human allospecific T lymphocytes directly from tissue biopsies. We have utilized renal allograft tissue obtained from eight patients undergoing cellular rejection. Needle biopsy tissue was cultured in medium containing interleukin 2 (IL 2), including recombinant-DNA-produced IL 2. In each case, lymphoblasts migrated out of the tissue and increased in numbers, especially adjacent to the tissue. In two cases in which there was no cellular infiltrate present in the biopsy, no lymphocytes proliferated in vitro. Instead, fibroblasts eventually filled the wells from these allograft biopsies. The continued presence of the allograft tissue enhanced the viability and growth of the lymphoblasts in cultures from rejecting allografts. The isolated lymphoblasts had surface markers of mature OKT3+ lymphocytes of either OKT4+ or OKT8+ subsets. OKT8+ cells predominated. There was variability (41 to 97%) in the percentage of T lymphoblasts that bore surface HLA-DR antigens. In assays of lymphoblasts obtained from eight separate renal allografts, there was donor-specific cytotoxicity, and in all but two of the cases there was donor-induced proliferation. The specificity of the cytotoxic reaction was tested by using 51Cr-labeled, PHA-stimulated target cells prepared from a panel of HLA-typed donors. Proliferation was tested after 48 hr in the presence of mitomycin C-treated peripheral blood mononuclear cells as stimulator cells by using only 10(4) responder T lymphoblasts. Of particular note was that the cytotoxicity of the isolated lymphoblasts showed specificity against both "private" HLA class I alloantigens (of the allograft donor) as well as "public" cross-reacting epitopes. This method permits the propagation and functional characterization of in vivo-activated T lymphoblasts that are obtained from the actual sites of immune-mediated injury. Preliminary studies of other tissues with diverse inflammatory processes indicate the possible widespread applicability of obtaining in vivo-activated lymphocytes.

Characterization of in vivo-activated allospecific T lymphocytes propagated from human renal allograft biopsies undergoing rejection

To evaluate in situ lymphocyte responses in cell-mediated immune tissue injury, we have developed an approach for propagation of human allospecific T lymphocytes directly from tissue biopsies. We have utilized renal allograft tissue obtained from eight patients undergoing cellular rejection. Needle biopsy tissue was cultured in medium containing interleukin 2 (IL 2), including recombinant-DNA-produced IL 2. In each case, lymphoblasts migrated out of the tissue and increased in numbers, especially adjacent to the tissue. In two cases in which there was no cellular infiltrate present in the biopsy, no lymphocytes proliferated in vitro. Instead, fibroblasts eventually filled the wells from these allograft biopsies. The continued presence of the allograft tissue enhanced the viability and growth of the lymphoblasts in cultures from rejecting allografts. The isolated lymphoblasts had surface markers of mature OKT3+ lymphocytes of either OKT4+ or OKT8+ subsets. OKT8+ cells predominated. There was variability (41 to 97%) in the percentage of T lymphoblasts that bore surface HLA-DR antigens. In assays of lymphoblasts obtained from eight separate renal allografts, there was donor-specific cytotoxicity, and in all but two of the cases there was donor-induced proliferation. The specificity of the cytotoxic reaction was tested by using 51Cr-labeled, PHA-stimulated target cells prepared from a panel of HLA-typed donors. Proliferation was tested after 48 hr in the presence of mitomycin C-treated peripheral blood mononuclear cells as stimulator cells by using only 10(4) responder T lymphoblasts. Of particular note was that the cytotoxicity of the isolated lymphoblasts showed specificity against both "private" HLA class I alloantigens (of the allograft donor) as well as "public" cross-reacting epitopes. This method permits the propagation and functional characterization of in vivo-activated T lymphoblasts that are obtained from the actual sites of immune-mediated injury. Preliminary studies of other tissues with diverse inflammatory processes indicate the possible widespread applicability of obtaining in vivo-activated lymphocytes.