Ensuring Stakeholder Feedback in the Design and Conduct of Clinical Trials for Rare Diseases: ISCTM Position Paper of the Orphan Disease Working Group

The 1983 Orphan Drug Act in the United States (US) changed the landscape for development of therapeutics for rare or orphan diseases, which collectively affect approximately 300 million people worldwide, half of whom are children. The act has undoubtedly accelerated drug development for orphan diseases, with over 6,400 orphan drug applications submitted to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) from 1983 to 2023, including 350 drugs approved for over 420 indications. Drug development in this population is a global and collaborative endeavor. This position paper of the International Society for Central Nervous System Clinical Trials and Methodology (ISCTM) describes some potential best practices for the involvement of key stakeholder feedback in the drug development process. Stakeholders include advocacy groups, patients and caregivers with lived experience, public and private research institutions (including academia and pharmaceutical companies), treating clinicians, and funders (including the government and independent foundations). The authors articulate the challenges of drug development in orphan diseases and propose methods to address them. Challenges range from the poor understanding of disease history to development of endpoints, targets, and clinical trials designs, to finding solutions to competing research priorities by involved parties.

The NIMH 'Fast-Fail Trials' (FAST) Initiative: Rationale, Promise, and Progress

In 2012, the US National Institute of Mental Health launched three clinical trial contracts under a new FAST initiative. The overall goal for these contracts (Fast-Fail Trials) was to focus early-stage trials, testing novel pharmacologic agents that target the central nervous system, on pharmacologic-based designs to objectively identify doses that produce central nervous system effects. The three contracts targeted different psychiatric populations: psychotic (FAST-PS), mood and anxiety (FAST-MAS), and autism spectrum disorders (FAST-AS). The FAST initiative was a first attempt for the National Institute of Mental Health to adapt an experimental medicine approach to its clinical trial portfolio. As the Fast-Fail trials implemented this new approach for the field, we present the rationale for each trial, design considerations, results, and how each one contributed new knowledge to the field of psychopharmacology; important lessons for pharma and biotech. Under the FAST initiative, the National Institute of Mental Health assembled research teams with a broad range of expertise, who developed and validated the outcome measures and study protocol, and conducted multi-site clinical trials, testing candidate compounds. In the FAST-PS contract, the team validated an imaging-based pharmacodynamic biomarker of the effect of ketamine in the brain that could be utilized in subsequent clinical trials. The initial FAST-AS study was an important first step in the design of early-stage target-engagement trials in autism spectrum disorder, suggesting that a resting electroencephalogram can be used as a pharmacodynamic measure in future studies. The FAST-MAS study showed that blocking the kappa-opioid receptor significantly affects functional magnetic resonance imaging ventral striatal activation in the monetary incentive delay task in anticipation of gain. Together, the outcomes of the FAST-FAIL trials demonstrated the importance of rigorously designed and informative central nervous system trials, including the value of pharmacodynamic measures in early-stage trials. Use of these measures furthered our knowledge about the relationship between specific molecular mechanisms, brain effects, and therapeutic effects in patients with mental illnesses.

Challenges in developing drugs for pediatric CNS disorders: A focus on psychopharmacology

Many psychiatric and behavioral disorders manifest in childhood (attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, obsessive compulsive disorder, anxiety, depression, schizophrenia, autism spectrum disorder, etc.) and the opportunity for intervening early may attenuate full development of the disorder and lessen long term disability. Yet, pediatric drug approvals for CNS indications are limited, and pediatric testing generally occurs only after establishing adult efficacy, more as an afterthought rather than with the initial goal of developing the medication for a pediatric CNS indication. With pharmaceutical companies decreasing funding of their neuroscience research divisions overall, the prospects for moving promising investigational drugs forward into pediatrics will only decline. The goal of this review is to highlight important challenges around pediatric drug development for psychiatric disorders, specifically during clinical development, and to present opportunities for filling these gaps, using new strategies for de-risking investigational drugs in new clinical trial designs/models. We will first present the current trends in pediatric drug efficacy testing in academic research and in industry trials, we will then discuss the regulatory landscape of pediatric drug testing, including policies intended to support and encourage more testing. Obstacles that remain will then be presented, followed by new designs, funding opportunities and considerations for testing investigational drugs safely.

Raising intracellular calcium attenuates neuronal apoptosis triggered by staurosporine or oxygen-glucose deprivation in the presence of glutamate receptor blockade

The relationship between intracellular Ca(2+) ([Ca(2+)](i)) regulation and programmed cell death is not well-defined; both increases and decreases in [Ca(2+)](i) have been observed in cells undergoing apoptosis. We determined [Ca(2+)](i) in cultured murine cortical neurons undergoing apoptosis after exposure to staurosporine or following oxygen-glucose deprivation in the presence of glutamate receptor antagonists. Neuronal [Ca(2+)](i) was decreased 1-4 h after exposure to staurosporine (30 nM). A [Ca(2+)](i) decrease was also observed 1 h after the end of the oxygen-glucose deprivation period when MK-801 and 6-cyano-7-nitroquinoxaline-2,3-dione (CNQX) were added to the bathing medium during the deprivation period. A similar decrease in [Ca(2+)](i) produced by reducing extracellular Ca(2+) or chelating intracellular Ca(2+) was sufficient to induce neuronal apoptosis. Raising [Ca(2+)](i) either by activating voltage-sensitive Ca(2+) channels with (-) Bay K8644 or by application of low concentrations of kainate attenuated both staurosporine and oxygen-glucose deprivation-induced apoptosis.

Preconditioned resistance to oxygen-glucose deprivation-induced cortical neuronal death: alterations in vesicular GABA and glutamate release

Central neurons exposed to several types of sublethal stress, including ischemia, acquire resistance to injury induced by subsequent ischemic insults, a phenomenon called ischemic preconditioning. We modeled this phenomenon in vitro, utilizing exposure to 45 mM KCl to reduce the vulnerability of cultured murine cortical neurons to subsequent oxygen-glucose deprivation. Twenty-four hours after preconditioning, cultures exhibited enhanced depolarization-induced, tetanus toxin-sensitive GABA release and a modest decrease in glutamate release. Total cellular GABA levels were unaltered. Inhibition of GABA degradation with the GABA transaminase inhibitor (+/-)-gamma-vinyl GABA, or addition of low levels of GABA, muscimol, or chlormethiazole to the bathing medium, mimicked the neuroprotective effect of preconditioning against oxygen-glucose deprivation-induced death. However, neuronal death was enhanced by higher levels of these manipulations, as well as by prior selective destruction of GABAergic neurons by kainate. Finally, selective blockade of GABA(A) receptors during oxygen-glucose deprivation or removal of GABAergic neurons eliminated the neuroprotective effects of prior preconditioning. Taken together, these data predict that presynaptic alterations, specifically enhanced GABA release together with reduced glutamate release, may be important mediators of ischemic preconditioning, but suggest caution in regard to interventions aimed at increasing GABA(A) receptor activation.

Role of the outward delayed rectifier K+ current in ceramide-induced caspase activation and apoptosis in cultured cortical neurons

We studied the novel hypothesis that an up-modulation of channels for outward delayed rectifier K+ current (I(K)) plays a key role in ceramide-induced neuronal apoptosis. Exposure for 6-10 h to the membrane-permeable C2-ceramide (25 microM) or to sphingomyelinase (0.2 unit/ml), but not to the inactive ceramide analogue C2-dihydroceramide (25 microM), enhanced the whole-cell I(K) current without affecting the transient A-type K+ current and increased caspase activity, followed by neuronal apoptosis 24 h after exposure onset. Tetraethylammonium (TEA) or 4-chloro-N,N-diethyl-N-heptylbenzenebutanaminium tosylate (clofilium), at concentrations inhibiting I(K), attenuated the C2-ceramide-induced caspase-3-like activation as well as neuronal apoptosis. Raising extracellular K+ to 25 mM similarly blocked the C2-ceramide-induced cell death; the neuroprotection by 25 mM K+ or TEA was not eliminated by blocking voltage-gated Ca2+ channels. An inhibitor of tyrosine kinases, herbimycin A (10 nM) or lavendustin A (0.1-1 microM), suppressed I(K) enhancement and/or apoptosis induced by C2-ceramide. It is suggested that ceramide-induced I(K) current enhancement is mediated by tyrosine phosphorylation and plays a critical role in neuronal apoptosis.

Ischemic tolerance in murine cortical cell culture: critical role for NMDA receptors

Murine cortical cultures containing both neurons and glia (days in vitro 13-15) were exposed to periods of oxygen-glucose deprivation (5-30 min) too brief to induce neuronal death. Cultures "preconditioned" by sublethal oxygen-glucose deprivation exhibited 30-50% less neuronal death than controls when exposed to a 45-55 min period of oxygen-glucose deprivation 24 hr later. This preconditioning-induced neuroprotection was specific in that neuronal death induced by exposure to excitotoxins or to staurosporine was not attenuated. Neuroprotection was lost if the time between the preconditioning and severe insult were decreased to 7 hr or increased to 72 hr and was blocked if the NMDA antagonist 100 microM 3-((D)-2-carboxypiperazin-4-yl)-propyl-1-phosphonic acid was applied during the preconditioning insult. This was true even if the duration of preconditioning was increased as far as possible (while still remaining sublethal). A similar preconditioning effect was also produced by sublethal exposure to high K+, glutamate, or NMDA but not to kainate or trans-1-aminocyclopentane-1, 3-dicarboxylic acid.

Neurochemical and morphological responses to acutely and chronically implanted brain microdialysis probes

The purpose of this study was to compare, in rats, brain microdialysis results obtained using microdialysis probes implanted acutely for 2 h versus probes implanted chronically for 24 h in the caudate. Specific comparisons included: (1) dialysate purine and amino acid profiles during cerebral ischemia; (2) diffusional characteristics of the microdialysis probe; and (3) tissue morphology surrounding the probe. During ischemia, the increase in dialysate levels of adenosine, inosine, and hypoxanthine was less pronounced from probes implanted chronically, while dialysate xanthine levels increased to a greater extent. An increase in dialysate amino acid neurotransmitters during cerebral ischemia was observed in the acutely implanted probes within 10 min of the onset of cerebral ischemia; in the chronically implanted probes this increase did not occur until after 50 min of severe ischemia. Both in vitro and in vivo tests revealed a diffusional barrier in chronically implanted probes. Moreover, the tissue surrounding chronically implanted probes exhibited a high degree of inflammation, and fibrin deposits were substantial. In addition, uric acid levels (an indicator of tissue injury) sampled from chronically implanted probes were 7-fold greater than levels sampled from acutely implanted probes. These data raise concerns about the use of chronically implanted microdialysis probes for the measurement of purine and amino acid profiles during cerebral ischemia.

Adenosine receptor blockade augments interstitial fluid levels of excitatory amino acids during cerebral ischemia

The excitotoxic hypothesis suggests that cerebral ischemic damage results in part from the accumulation of the excitatory and potentially toxic neurotransmitters glutamate and aspartate. Adenosine, which also increases during cerebral ischemia, is proposed to inhibit neurotransmitter release. The purpose of this study was to determine if adenosine receptor blockade exacerbates the accumulation of glutamate and aspartate during cerebral ischemia. Microdialysis probes, implanted bilaterally in the caudate nucleus of halothane-anesthetized rats, were used to (1) assess changes in interstitial fluid (ISF) glutamate, aspartate, adenosine, and adenosine metabolites; (2) measure local cerebral blood flow (H2 clearance); and (3) deliver 8-(p-sulfophenyl)theophylline (SPT), an adenosine receptor antagonist, locally to the brain. The probe on one side of the brain was perfused with artificial cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) containing 10(-3) M SPT, while the probe on the opposite side received only artificial CSF. Animals were exposed to 20 min of ischemia (carotid occlusion+arterial blood pressure = 50 mm Hg) followed by 60 min of reperfusion. Dialysate glutamate and aspartate increased during and after cerebral ischemia, but were increased to a greater extent in the presence of adenosine receptor blockade. Likewise, the increase in dialysate adenosine and adenosine metabolites was enhanced on the side of locally administered SPT. These data suggest that endogenous adenosine attenuates the accumulation of glutamate and aspartate during cerebral ischemia.