Chromosomal aberrations in UVB-induced tumors of immunosuppressed mice

In immunocompromised individuals, such as organ transplant recipients, the risk of cutaneous squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) is increased 60-250 fold, and there is an increased likelihood to develop aggressive, metastatic SCC. An understanding of the genes involved in SCC tumorigenesis is critical to prevent SCC-associated morbidity and mortality. Mouse models show that different immunosuppressive drugs lead to SCCs varying in size, number, and malignant potential. In this study, we used mouse models that mimic adult transplant recipients to study the effect of immunosuppressive drugs and UV light on SCC development. UV-induced tumors from six treatment groups, control, tacrolimus (Tac), rapamycin (Rap), cyclosporin (CsA), mycophenolate mofetil (MMF), and Rap plus CsA, were evaluated by array comparative genomic hybridization. Mouse SCCs appear to show similar genomic aberrations as those reported in human SCCs and offer the ability to identify genomic changes associated with specific and combinatorial effects of drugs. Fewer aberrations were seen in tumors of mice treated with MMF or Rap. Tumors from Tac-treated animals showed the highest number of changes. Calcineurin inhibitors (Tac and CsA) did not cluster together by their genomic aberrations, indicating their contribution to UV mediated carcinogenesis may be through different pathways. The combination treatment (Rap plus CsA) did not cluster with either treatment individually, suggesting it may influence SCC tumorigenesis via a different mechanism. Future studies will identify specific genes mapping to regions of aberration that are different between treatment groups to identify target pathways that may be affected by these drugs.

The hairless mouse in skin research

The hairless (Hr) gene encodes a transcriptional co-repressor highly expressed in the mammalian skin. In the mouse, several null and hypomorphic Hr alleles have been identified resulting in hairlessness in homozygous animals, characterized by alopecia developing after a single cycle of relatively normal hair growth. Mutations in the human ortholog have also been associated with congenital alopecia. Although a variety of hairless strains have been developed, outbred SKH1 mice are the most widely used in dermatologic research. These unpigmented and immunocompetent mice allow for ready manipulation of the skin, application of topical agents, and exposure to UVR, as well as easy visualization of the cutaneous response. Wound healing, acute photobiologic responses, and skin carcinogenesis have been extensively studied in SKH1 mice and are well characterized. In addition, tumors induced in these mice resemble, both at the morphologic and molecular levels, UVR-induced skin malignancies in man. Two limitations of the SKH1 mouse in dermatologic research are the relatively uncharacterized genetic background and its outbred status, which precludes inter-individual transplantation studies.

Sirolimus reduces the incidence and progression of UVB-induced skin cancer in SKH mice even with co-administration of cyclosporine A

Transplant immunosuppressants have been implicated in the increased incidence of non-melanoma skin cancer in transplant recipients, most of whom harbor considerable UVB-induced DNA damage in their skin prior to transplantation. This study was designed to evaluate the effects of two commonly used immunosuppressive drugs, cyclosporine A (CsA) and sirolimus (SRL), on the development and progression of UVB-induced non-melanoma skin cancer. SKH-1 hairless mice were exposed to UVB alone for 15 weeks, and then were treated with CsA, SRL, or CsA+SRL for 9 weeks following cessation of UVB treatment. Compared with vehicle, CsA treatment resulted in enhanced tumor size and progression. In contrast, mice treated with SRL or CsA+SRL had decreased tumor multiplicity, size, and progression compared with vehicle-treated mice. CsA, but not SRL or combined treatment, increased dermal mast cell numbers and TGF-beta1 levels in the skin. These findings demonstrate that specific immunosuppressive agents differentially alter the cutaneous tumor microenvironment, which in turn may contribute to enhanced development of UVB-induced skin cancer in transplant recipients. Furthermore, these results suggest that CsA alone causes enhanced growth and progression of skin cancer, whereas co-administration of SRL with CsA causes the opposite effect. JID JOURNAL CLUB ARTICLE: For questions, answers, and open discussion about this article please go to http://network.nature.com/group/jidclub

Depletion of CD4+ Cells Exacerbates the Cutaneous Response to Acute and Chronic UVB Exposure

Solid organ transplant recipients have a 60-250-fold increased likelihood of developing sunlight-induced squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) compared with the general population. This increased risk is linked to the immunosuppressive drugs taken by these patients to modulate T cell function, thus preventing organ rejection. To determine the importance of T cells in the development of cutaneous SCC, we examined the effects of selectively depleting Skh-1 mice of systemic CD4+ or CD8+ T cells, using monoclonal antibodies, on ultraviolet B (UVB) radiation-induced inflammation and tumor development. Decreases in systemic CD4+ but not CD8+ T cells significantly increased and prolonged the acute UVB-induced cutaneous inflammatory response, as measured by neutrophil influx, myeloperoxidase activity, and prostaglandin E2 levels. Significantly more p53+ keratinocytes were observed in UVB-exposed CD4-depleted than in CD4-replete mice, and this difference was abrogated in mice depleted of neutrophils before UVB exposure. Increased acute inflammation was associated with significantly increased tumor numbers in CD4-depleted mice chronically exposed to UVB. Furthermore, topical treatment with the anti-inflammatory drug celecoxib significantly decreased tumor numbers in both CD4-replete and CD4-depleted mice. Our findings suggest that CD4+ T cells play an important role in modulating both the acute inflammatory and the chronic carcinogenic response of the skin to UVB.

Human CD4+CD25low Adaptive T Regulatory Cells Suppress Delayed-Type Hypersensitivity during Transplant Tolerance

Adaptive T regulatory (T(R)) cells mediate the suppression of donor-specific, delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) in tolerant organ transplant recipients. We hypothesized that cells belonging to the CD4(+)CD25(+) T cell subset but distinct from natural T(R) cells may fulfill this role. To test this hypothesis, PBMC and biopsy samples from two tolerant kidney transplant recipients (K1 and K2) were analyzed. When transferred with recipient APC into a SCID mouse footpad, CD4(+) T cells were hyporesponsive in DTH to donor type HLA-B Ags and derivative allopeptides. However, anti-human TGF-beta1 Ab revealed a response to immunodominant allopeptides in both patients, suggesting that CD4(+) T effector (T(E)) cells coexisted with suppressive, TGF-beta1-producing CD4(+) T(R) cells. During in vitro culture, allopeptide stimulation induced both IFN-gamma-producing and surface TGF-beta1(+) T cells. The relative strength of the latter response in patient K1 was inversely correlated with the level of systemic anti-donor DTH, which varied over a 6-year interval. Allopeptide-induced surface TGF-beta1 expression was found primarily in Forkhead box P3 (FoxP3)-negative CD4(+)CD25(low) T cells, which could adoptively transfer suppression of donor-specific DTH. Biopsy samples contained numerous surface TGF-beta1(+) mononuclear cells that costained for CD4 and, less frequently CD25, but were negative for FoxP3. The CD4(+)TGF-beta1(+) T cells were localized primarily to the tubulointerstitium, whereas TGF-beta1(-)FoxP3(+)CD25(+) cells were found mainly in lymphoid aggregates. Thus, adaptive T(R) cells suppressing T(E) cell responses to donor allopeptides in two tolerant patients appear to be functionally and phenotypically distinct from CD4(+)CD25(high)FoxP3(+) T cells.

TGF-beta inhibition of CTL re-stimulation requires accessory cells and induces peroxisome-proliferator-activated receptor-gamma (PPAR-gamma)

Effective cellular immunity to Epstein-Barr virus (EBV), necessary to prevent or cure many post-transplant lymphoproliferative disorders (PTLD), can be inhibited by transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta). In vitro, TGF-beta inhibits memory CTL re-stimulation from whole PBMC. We show that the effect of TGF-beta on CTL re-stimulation is not directly on the T cell, but requires an accessory cell (AC) population. Further, pre-treatment of AC with TGF-beta significantly reduces memory CTL re-stimulation and suppresses delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses. Addition of exogenous interferon-gamma to the AC overcomes the effects of TGF-beta. TGF-beta pre-treatment also up-regulates expression of peroxisome-proliferator-activated receptor-gamma (PPAR-gamma) in CD14(+) AC. Importantly, pre-treatment of AC with the PPAR-gamma ligand, ciglitazone, results in significantly reduced memory CTL re-stimulation. Thus, the effects of TGF-beta in this system may be mediated in part via PPAR-gamma, and PPAR-gamma activation could have significant inhibitory effects on memory T-cell responses by affecting AC function. These data have important implications in understanding how memory CTL are re-stimulated and function to prevent disease, especially PTLD.

IFN-gamma gene polymorphisms associate with development of EBV+ lymphoproliferative disease in hu PBL-SCID mice

Posttransplantation lymphoproliferative disorder (PTLD) is a devastating post-transplantation complication often associated with Epstein-Barr virus (EBV). Although the type and length of immunosuppression are risk factors, a patient's inherent immune capacity also likely contributes to this disorder. This report uses severe-combined immunodeficient mice given injections of human peripheral blood leukocytes (hu PBL-SCID [Severe Combined Immunodeficient] mice) to test the hypothesis that cytokine genotype associates with the development of EBV-associated lymphoproliferative disease (LPD). We observed that the A/A (adenosine/adenosine) genotype for base + 874 of the interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) gene was significantly more prevalent in PBLs producing rapid, high-penetrance LPD in hu PBL-SCID mice, compared to PBLs producing late, low-penetrance LPD or no LPD. In examining the relationship between genotype and cytolytic T-lymphocyte (CTL) function, transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta) inhibited restimulation of CTLs in PBLs with adenosine at IFNG base + 874, but not in PBLs homozygous for thymidine. Importantly, neutralization of TGF-beta in hu PBL-SCID mice injected with A/A genotype PBLs resulted in reduced LPD development and expanded human CD8(+) cells. Thus, our data show that TGF-beta may promote tumor development by inhibiting CTL restimulation and expansion. Further, our data indicate that IFNG genotype may provide valuable information for both identifying transplant recipients at greater risk for PTLD and developing preventive and curative strategies.

A phase I study of interleukin 12 with trastuzumab in patients with human epidermal growth factor receptor-2-overexpressing malignancies: analysis of sustained interferon gamma production in a subset of patients

PURPOSE

On the basis of preclinical studies, we hypothesized that interleukin (IL)12 would potentiate the antitumor actions of an antihuman epidermal growth factor receptor-2 (HER2) monoclonal antibody (trastuzumab). We conducted a Phase I trial to determine the safety and optimal biological dose of IL-12 when given in combination with trastuzumab.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Patients with metastatic HER2-positive malignancies received trastuzumab on day 1 of each weekly cycle. Beginning in week 3, patients also received intravenous injections of IL-12 on days 2 and 5. The IL-12 component was dose-escalated within cohorts of 3 patients (30, 100, 300, or 500 ng/kg). Correlative assays were conducted using serum samples and peripheral blood cells obtained during the course of therapy.

RESULTS

Fifteen patients were treated, including 12 with HER2 2+ or 3+ breast cancer. The regimen was well tolerated with IL-12-induced grade 1 nausea and grade 2 fatigue predominating. Evaluation of dose-limiting toxicity and biological end points suggested that the 300 ng/kg dose was both the maximally tolerated dose and the optimal biological dose of IL-12 for use in combination with trastuzumab. Two patients with HER2 3+ breast cancer within the 500 ng/kg dose level experienced grade 1 asymptomatic decreases in left ventricular ejection fraction of 12% and 19% after 3 and 10 months of therapy, respectively. There was one complete response in a patient with HER2 3+ breast cancer metastatic to the axillary, mediastinal, and supraclavicular nodes, and 2 patients with stabilization of bone disease lasting 10 months and >12 months, respectively. Correlative assays showed sustained production of interferon (IFN)gamma by natural killer cells only in those patients experiencing a clinical response or stabilization of disease. Elevated serum levels of macrophage inflammatory protein-1alpha, tumor necrosis factor-alpha, and the antiangiogenic factors IFN-gamma inducible protein-10 and monokine induced by gamma were also observed in these patients. Patient genotyping suggested that a specific IFN-gamma gene polymorphism might have been associated with increased IFN-gamma production. The ability of patient peripheral blood cells to conduct antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity against tumor targets in vitro did not correlate with clinical response or dose of IL-12.

CONCLUSIONS

The addition of IL-12 to trastuzumab therapy did not appear to enhance the efficacy of this antibody treatment. Sustained production of IFN-gamma and other cytokines were observed in three patients: One who exhibited a complete response and two others who had stabilization of disease lasting over 6 months. Given the small sample size and heterogeneity of the patient population, the effects of IL-12 on the innate immune response to trastuzumab therapy should be further explored in the context of a larger clinical trial.

Clinical significance of MHC-reactive alloantibodies that develop after kidney or kidney-pancreas transplantation

The purpose of this study was to determine the relationships between acute rejection, anti-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I and/or class II-reactive alloantibody production, and chronic rejection of renal allografts following kidney or simultaneous kidney-pancreas transplantation. Sera from 277 recipients were obtained pretransplant and between 1 month and 9.5 years post-transplant (mean 2.6years). The presence of anti-MHC class I and class II alloantibodies was determined by flow cytometry using beads coated with purified MHC molecules. Eighteen percent of recipients had MHC-reactive alloantibodies detected only after transplantation by this method. The majority of these patients produced alloantibodies directed at MHC class II only (68%). The incidence of anti-MHC class II, but not anti-MHC class I, alloantibodies detected post-transplant increased as the number of previous acute rejection episodes increased (p = 0.03). Multivariate analysis demonstrated that detection of MHC class II-reactive, but not MHC class I-reactive, alloantibodies post-transplant was a significant risk factor for chronic allograft rejection, independent of acute allograft rejection. We conclude that post-transplant detectable MHC class II-reactive alloantibodies and previous acute rejection episodes are independent risk factors for chronic allograft rejection. Implementing new therapeutic strategies to curtail post-transplant alloantibody production, and avoidance of acute rejection episodes, may improve long-term graft survival by reducing the incidence of chronic allograft rejection.

A role for TGFbeta and B cells in immunologic tolerance after intravenous injection of soluble antigen

BACKGROUND

Intravenous injection of soluble antigen has been reported to induce immunologic tolerance through a variety of mechanisms including T-cell deletion, anergy, and suppression. To clarify the reported discrepancies, we studied mechanisms of intravenous tolerance to a defined transgenic minor transplantation antigen in mice.

METHODS

Wild-type C57BL/6 (B6) mice or congenic B6 B-cell knockout mice were made tolerant to beta-galactosidase (beta-gal). Clinical tolerance was assessed by placement of B6 beta-gal transgenic (tg) and third-party skin grafts. In vitro analysis of T- and B-cell immunity and in vivo treatment with anti-TGFbeta antibodies were used to define mechanisms of induced tolerance.

RESULTS

Intravenous injection of beta-gal induced true immunologic tolerance to beta-gal tg skin in wild-type but not in B-cell-deficient recipients, suggesting that antigen presentation by B cells was required for the effect. The tolerogenic manipulation primed a population of CD4+, beta-gal-specific, TGFbeta-producing T cells. Although evidence for both anergy and suppression were observed, subsequent data demonstrated that TGFbeta was a critical immunoregulatory mediator of the tolerant state: neutralizing anti-TGFbeta antibodies fully prevented the induction of tolerance to B6 beta-gal tg skin grafts. Second male beta-gal tg grafts placed onto female recipients that were previously made tolerant to female beta-gal tg skin were rapidly rejected, however, suggesting that this TGFbeta-induced tolerance could not be linked to additional antigenic determinants.

CONCLUSIONS

The studies demonstrate a critical role for TGFbeta in mediating tolerance after intravenous injection of antigen but additionally raise concerns about the stability of this tolerant state.

Human allograft acceptance is associated with immune regulation

The ultimate goal of transplantation is drug-free allograft acceptance, which is rarely encountered in transplant recipients. Using a novel human-to-mouse "trans vivo" delayed-type hypersensitivity assay, we assessed donor-reactive cell-mediated immune responses in kidney and liver transplant patients, four of whom discontinued all immunosuppression. One of these subjects (J.B.) rejected his graft after 7 years of stable function, while the others (D.S., R.D., M.L.) continue to have excellent graft function 5, 28, and 4 years after the cessation of immunosuppression. PBMCs from J.B. exhibited strong responses to both donor and recall antigens whereas PBMCs from patients D.S., R.D., and M.L. responded strongly to recall, but not donor, antigens. Furthermore, when donor and recall antigens were colocalized, the recall response in these three patients was inhibited. This donor antigen-linked nonresponsiveness was observed in four other patients who are still maintained on immunosuppression. The weakness of donor-reactive DTH responses in these patients is due to donor alloantigen-triggered regulation that relies on either TGF-beta or IL-10. In D.S., regulation is triggered by a single donor HLA Class I antigen, either in membrane-bound or soluble form. This demonstrates that allograft acceptance in humans is associated with an immune regulation pattern, which may be useful in the diagnosis and/or monitoring of transplant patients for allograft acceptance.

Transforming growth factor-beta and interleukin-10 subvert alloreactive delayed type hypersensitivity in cardiac allograft acceptor mice

We have previously reported that temporary treatment of cardiac allograft recipients with gallium nitrate (GN) results in indefinite graft survival, and the inability to mount donor-reactive delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses. We report that antibodies to either transforming growth factor-beta (TGFbeta) or interleukin-10 (IL10) can uncover DTH responses to donor alloantigens in cardiac allograft acceptor mice. The DTH responses uncovered with TGFbeta-reactive antibodies can be blocked by exogenous IL10, and those uncovered with IL10-reactive antibodies can be blocked by exogenous TGFbeta. These data demonstrate that allograft acceptor mice are fully allosensitized, and poised to make donor-reactive cell-mediated immune responses. However, such responses are subverted by a donor alloantigen-dependent mechanism that involves TGFbeta and IL10, which in turn interfere with local cell-mediated immune responses.

Trans vivo analysis of human delayed-type hypersensitivity reactivity

There are clinical situations in which it may be advantageous to monitor delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses, an index of cell-mediated immunity, without exposing patients directly to the challenge antigens. For example, transplant patients may be at risk for becoming sensitized to donor antigens if injected with donor antigen during traditional skin tests. We describe an alternative method for human DTH testing, which involves the transfer of human peripheral blood mononuclear cells plus antigen into the pinnae or footpads of naive mice. This induces a measurable DTH-like swelling response, which we refer to as the "trans vivo DTH response." As proof of principle, we provide data obtained during trans vivo DTH studies with tetanus toxoid, cytomegalovirus (CMV) and alloantigens. In general, human T cells must be co-localized with antigen and human macrophages to produce swelling responses, and such responses are antigen-specific and require prior antigen sensitization. Not only does this assay offer a simple, reliable clinical monitoring device, but it also provides a model with which to study the in vivo mechanisms of human DTH responses.

Cardiac allograft tolerance: failure to develop in interleukin-4-deficient mice correlates with unusual allosensitization patterns

BACKGROUND

The development of long-term allograft survival and understanding the mechanism(s) by which it is induced are major goals of experimental transplantation. Studies by several different investigators have provided conflicting evidence for the role of interleukin (IL)-4 in the process of allograft rejection or long-term allograft survival. These studies examine the role of IL-4 in experimental cardiac allograft rejection and in inducing long-term allograft survival. A possible mechanism for long-term allograft maintenance via alternative allosensitization is discussed.

METHODS

Adult IL-4-intact or IL-4-deficient (knockout, KO) C57BL/6 (B6) mice were transplanted with heterotopic DBA/2 cardiac allografts and immunosuppressed either with gallium nitrate (GN), or the anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody, GK1.5. Cellular allosensitization was assessed by testing the allograft recipients for donor-reactive delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses. The presence of antigen-driven suppressive mechanisms was assessed using a linked unresponsiveness (bystander suppression) DTH assay.

RESULTS

In general, the results were the same with either GN or GK1.5. We observed that (1) IL-4 is not required for acute allograft rejection or allogeneic DTH responses in nonsuppressed mice, (2) IL-4 is required for long-term allograft survival in immunosuppressed mice, (3) immunosuppression creates a requirement for IL-4 in major histocompatibility complex self-restricted, but not allorestricted, DTH responses, and (4) the development of alloantigen-dependent linked DTH unresponsiveness (bystander suppression) in allograft recipients requires IL-4.

CONCLUSION

In summary, these studies demonstrate a common requirement for IL-4 during the development of long-term allograft survival and the concurrent development of alloantigen-dependent DTH down-regulation in cardiac allograft recipients after immunosuppression.

Immune mechanisms of acute rejection

An understanding of acute allograft rejection has eluded investigators for many years, despite major research efforts in this area. This understanding may not be achievable, given the current philosophic approach to the study of immune processes. An alternative approach, which is outlined here, would require investigators to develop an appreciation for the strengths and limitations of complex, adaptive networks like the interdigitated inflammatory, immune, and physiologic processes that are at work in transplanted allografts. This alternative approach is offered in the hope that it will provide new insights regarding the nature of immune responses and will be helpful in the design and interpretation of future studies of acute rejection and other transplant-related biologic processes.

Patterns of allosensitization in allograft recipients: long-term cardiac allograft acceptance is associated with active alloantibody production in conjunction with active inhibition of alloreactive delayed-type hypersensitivity

BACKGROUND

The immunologic characteristics of experimental allograft acceptance remain ill-defined. This study evaluates humoral and cell-mediated immunity in transiently immunosuppressed mice that have accepted cardiac allografts.

METHODS

DBA/2-->C57BL/6 heterotopic cardiac allograft recipients were immunosuppressed with either GK1.5 monoclonal antibody or gallium nitrate and monitored for donor-reactive delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) assessed by ear challenge and for alloantibody production detected by flow cytometry.

RESULTS

Cardiac allograft function continued for >90 days in approximately 50% of GK1.5-treated and 97% of gallium nitrate-treated transplant recipients. All nonsuppressed recipients lost graft function within 7 to 10 days. Among mice that accepted allografts, donor-reactive IgG was produced by about 50% of GK1.5 monoclonal antibody-treated mice and 80% of gallium nitrate-treated mice. None of the these mice exhibited donor-reactive DTH responses, and all could down-regulate third-party DTH responses in a donor alloantigen-dependent manner. This down-regulation is not found in nonsuppressed allograft recipients or in naive mice. Importantly, transfer into SCID mice of splenocytes from mice that accepted allografts, but not naive splenocytes, provided them with a similar ability to accept cardiac allografts, even if the grafts co-expressed third-party alloantigens.

CONCLUSIONS

IgG alloantibody production by murine cardiac allograft recipients is not a precise indicator of allosensitization leading to either cardiac allograft rejection or acceptance. However, expression of alloreactive DTH is a reliable indicator of allosensitization leading to acute rejection, and the absence of DTH in association with active DTH down-regulatory mechanisms is a reliable indicator of allograft acceptance in this experimental model. Thus, DTH analysis may hold more promise than alloantibody detection for clinical assessment of posttransplant immune status.

Transplantation immunology

The practice of clinical and experimental transplantation continues to evolve at a rapid pace. To appreciate the current transplant practices, it is first necessary to review transplant immunology in its proper context, ie, as a component of the complex series of events that promote the repair of damaged tissues. These processes are generally categorized as inflammation, immunity, and tissue repair/reinforcement. In general, there are 3 forms of graft rejection: hyperacute, acute, and chronic rejection. All 3 forms of graft rejection represent pathologic consequences of one or more of these repair-related processes. The various graft rejection responses also illustrate several complex immunologic principles that need to be considered. These include the definition of an alloantigen, the structure and function of major histocompatibility complex molecules, and the behavior of antigen-presenting cells and alloreactive T cells. This review combines these concepts and principles into a discussion of the 3 forms of graft rejection, each of which is addressed at the level of histopathology, pathobiology, incidence, and clinical strategies.

Prevention of acute murine cardiac allograft rejection: anti-CD4 or anti-vascular cell adhesion molecule one monoclonal antibodies block acute rejection but permit persistent graft-reactive alloimmunity and chronic tissue remodelling

We treated C57BL/6 mouse recipients of DBA/2 cardiac allografts with anti-CD4 monoclonal antibodies (mAb) or anti-vascular cell adhesion molecule 1 mAb to promote long-term allograft survival and subjected both the recipient animals and the long-surviving allografts to a battery of histologic and immunologic tests. The results were similar regardless of the mAb used for antirejection therapy. At all tested times after transplantation, the allografts displayed histologic evidence of ongoing microvascular endothelial activation and interstitial leukocytic infiltration. Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction analyses revealed continuous intragraft expression of messenger RNA for interleukin 1, interleukin 2, interleukin 4, interleukin 6, tumor necrosis factor, interferon gamma, and transforming growth factor beta. All grafts had histologic evidence of ongoing vascular and parenchymal tissue remodeling, including interstitial fibrosis and vascular neointimal hyperplasia. The graft recipients retained limiting dilution analysis--detectable, donor-reactive cytolytic T lymphocyte, and helper T lymphocyte in their spleens and produced high liters of donor-reactive alloantibodies. Variable amounts of allogeneic microchimerism were detectable in some, but not all of the long-surviving graft recipients. In general, these observations indicate that (1) a similar immune status is achieved in long-surviving allografts and their recipients when either anti-CD4 mAb or anti-vascular cell adhesion molecule-1 mAb was used for antirejection therapy, in spite of the major differences in lineage and distribution of cells targeted by these two mAbs, (2) this immune status is characterized by continuous, long-term inflammatory and immune processes very similar to those observed during acute allograft rejection, and (3) in spite of these processes the allografts continue to function, although they invariably develop a chronic rejection-like histopathologic condition that may ultimately limit graft function. In this regard, the recipients of long-surviving allografts do not seem to be tolerant of their graft alloantigens.

Expression of chemokine genes during rejection and long-term acceptance of cardiac allografts

Chemokines are cytokines with chemoattractant properties for leukocytes. They may play a critical role in directing leukocytes to graft sites and in amplifying intragraft inflammation during rejection. Previous studies have tested the intragraft expression of chemokine genes during the rejection of allogeneic skin grafts in mice. In the current study, we used a heterotopic heart transplant model in mice to test the intragraft expression of these genes in nonrejecting cardiac isografts, rejecting cardiac allografts, and cardiac allografts that were accepted due to immunosuppression with gallium nitrate. With the exception of low levels of interleukin-1beta and JE, intragraft expression of the the proinflammatory cytokine genes was not observed in either isografts or native heart. Two distinct patterns of chemokine mRNA were observed in the rejecting cardiac allografts. Intra-allograft expression of interleukin-1beta, interferon-gamma-inducible protein, JE, and KC was prominent by day 3 after transplantation. The expression of macrophage inflammatory protein (MIP)-1alpha, MIP-1beta, and regulated upon activation, normal T cell expressed and secreted (RANTES) was at low or undetectable levels at day 3 after transplantation but at high levels by day 8 after transplantation. Sixty days after transplantation, intra-allograft expression of chemokines in hearts from gallium nitrate-treated recipients indicated low levels of MIP-1alpha, MIP-1beta, and KC but high levels of interferon-gamma-inducible protein and RANTES.

Alloreactive delayed-type hypersensitivity in graft recipients: complexity of responses and divergence from acute rejection

BACKGROUND

Immunocompetent allograft recipients typically exhibit evidence of sensitization to graft antigens through alloantibody production and allograft rejection, as well as delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) reactivity to donor antigens. Most previous studies have relied on whole donor splenocytes, which primarily elicit allorestricted allogeneic responses, to test specific DTH responses and overlook the independent element of self-restricted responses in host-allograft interactions.

METHODS

We tested expression of self-MHC-restricted versus allo-MHC-restricted allogeneic DTH responses in both nonimmunosuppressed and tolerized C57BL/6 mice. Mice were sensitized for allogeneic DTH either by rejection of skin or cardiac allografts, or by subcutaneous injection of intact allogeneic splenocytes. Patterns of alloreactive DTH were compared in allosensitized, tolerant, and naive hosts.

RESULTS

All three methods of allosensitization resulted in equivalent self-restricted and allorestricted allogeneic DTH responses in nonimmunosuppressed mice. Gallium nitrate blocked acute rejection of cardiac allografts, and also blocked allosensitization of both self-restricted and allorestricted DTH responses, but did not influence the expression of DTH responses in presensitized mice. Gallium nitrate treatment could not block acute rejection of skin allografts, but interfered with sensitization for self-restricted, but not allorestricted, DTH responses in these recipients. This divergence of self- versus allo-MHC-restricted allosensitization for DTH was observed in two additional situations: the rates of allosensitization for self-restricted versus allorestricted DTH, and the acquisition of allorestricted, but not self-restricted, alloreactive DTH responses in cardiac allograft tolerant mice subsequently challenged with a skin allograft.

CONCLUSIONS

These studies demonstrate that acute rejection correlates generally with allogeneic DTH, whereas tolerance is associated with a lack of alloreactive DTH. However, self-restricted and allorestricted allosensitization can operate independently in allograft recipients. Thus, the relationships between alloreactive DTH and graft-induced allosensitization, acute rejection, or tolerance are more complicated than previously appreciated.

Prolonged murine cardiac allograft acceptance: characteristics of persistent active alloimmunity after treatment with gallium nitrate versus anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody

We have treated DBA/2-->C57BL/6 murine cardiac allograft recipients with anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody or with gallium nitrate to promote long-term (>60 days) allograft survival. Within this period, all grafts developed histologic evidence of ongoing vascular and parenchymal tissue remodeling, including interstitial fibrosis and neointimal hyperplasia, which are characteristic of chronic allograft rejection. To evaluate residual alloimmunity associated with the pharmacologic avoidance of acute graft rejection and the development of chronic tissue remodeling, we subjected these graft recipients to a battery of histologic and immunologic tests. Similar test results were obtained for graft recipients treated with either of the two immunosuppressive agents. All long-surviving allografts displayed histologic evidence of ongoing microvascular endothelial activation and interstitial leukocytic infiltration. Reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction analyses demonstrated intragraft expression of mRNAs for interleukin (IL)-1, IL-2, IL-4, IL-6, tumor necrosis factor, interferon-gamma, and transforming growth factor-beta. All recipients had limiting dilution analysis-detectable, graft-reactive cytolytic T lymphocytes and helper T lymphocytes in their spleens and grafts, and all produced high titers of graft-reactive alloantibodies. In general, these observations indicate that (1) a similar immune status is achieved in long-surviving allografts and their recipients when either anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody or gallium nitrate was used for antirejection therapy, (2) this immune status is characterized by continuous, long-term inflammatory and immune processes that are qualitatively similar to those observed during acute allograft rejection, and (3) no specific immune responses developed selectively in long-term graft recipients to account for the avoidance of acute graft rejection or the development of chronic tissue remodeling in the graft.

Transfusion of polarized TH2-like cell populations into SCID mouse cardiac allograft recipients results in acute allograft rejection

It has been hypothesized that TH1 cells mediate the archetypical cell-mediated immune response of acute allograft rejection, whereas TH2 cells promote allograft acceptance. To test this, we transfused SCID cardiac allograft recipients with polarized TH1-like or TH2-like graft-reactive T cells, and monitored graft function and graft-reactive immune responses in the graft recipients. Polarized THl-like cells, which were generated in vitro by stimulating syngeneic splenocytes with donor alloantigens in the presence of anti-IL-4 mAb, produced IFNg but not IL-4 when restimulated with donor alloantigen. Polarized TH2-like populations, which are generated in vitro by stimulating syngeneic splenocytes with donor alloantigens in the presence of IL-4, produced IL-4 but not IFNg when restimulated with donor alloantigen. Interestingly, bioassays of culture SN from restimulated TH1 but not TH2 cells revealed IL-2 production, although LDA analyses revealed that the TH1 and TH2 cells had identical frequencies of IL-2-producing cells. Transfusion of THl-like cells into SCID cardiac allograft recipients resulted in acute rejection within 7-10 days that was characterized by cellular infiltration, myocyte necrosis, and edema. Graft-infiltrating cells (GIC) recovered from TH1-transfused animals contained large numbers of graft-reactive IL-2-producing cells (68-269/10(6) GIC), but no LDA-detectable IL-4-producing cells. These data support the hypothesis that donor-reactive TH1 cells can promote acute allograft rejection. In contrast to the hypothesis, transfusion of the polarized TH2-like population into SCID cardiac allograft recipients also resulted in histologically similar acute rejection within 7-10 days. Infiltrating cells recovered from TH1-transfused allografts contained large numbers of graft-reactive (109-1458/10(6) GIC), LDA-detectable, IL-4-producing cells--indicating that the TH2 cells had arrived at the graft-but promoted acute allograft rejection rather than allograft acceptance.

Acute rejection of cardiac allografts by noncytolytic CD4(+) T cell populations

Cytolytic T cells were generated in vitro by culturing purified Balb/c CD4+ T cells with irradiated C57Bl/6 (B6) splenocytes plus anti-IL-4 mAb. Matched, noncytotoxic T cells were similarly generated by culturing purified Balb/c CD4+ T cells with irradiated B6 splenocytes plus recombinant murine IL-4. The latter T cells displayed to cytolytic activity, even in lectin-mediated lysis assays, but produced characteristic cytokines upon contact with specific alloantigens. Transfusion of cytolytic T cell populations into Balb/c SCID mice bearing B6 cardiac allografts resulted in acute allograft rejection within 5 to 10 days. Transfusion of noncytolytic T cell populations into Balb/c SCID mice bearing B6 cardiac allografts also resulted in acute allograft rejection within 7 to 10 days. Limiting dilution analysis (LDA) of infiltrating cells recovered from rejected allografts after collagenase digestion demonstrated that the CD4+ T cells retained their cytolytic or noncytolytic functional phenotypes in vivo throughout the rejection process. These data demonstrate that isolated CD4+ T cell populations can promote rapid acute cardiac allograft rejection, and that cytolytic activity is not necessary for this acute rejection response.

Prevention of murine cardiac allograft rejection with gallium nitrate. Comparison with anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody

Gallium nitrate (GN) was evaluated for its ability to interfere with a cute rejection of DBA/2-->C57BL/6 heterotopic cardiac allografts, in comparison with the depleting anti-CD4 mAb, GK1.5. The administration of GN for 30 days (s.c. 30 mg/kg elemental gallium on days 0 and 3, 10 mg/kg every third day) resulted in >60-day graft survival in 78% (25 of 32) of the graft recipients, whereas 2 perioperative injections of anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody (mAb) resulted in >60-day graft survival in 58% (24 of 41) of the graft recipients. Serum gallium levels peaked at about 2000 ng/ml after 2-3 weeks of treatment and decreased to about 300 ng/ml by day 60, a level that was maintained for at least 30 more days. During the early posttransplant period, 25% of GN-treated grafts, but not anti-CD4 mAb-treated grafts, exhibited an unusual, transient reduction in graft impulse strength, suggesting a transient rejection response. Macroscopically, the long-surviving (>60 days) grafts from either treatment group exhibited none of the features of rejecting allografts. Histologically, they exhibited minor edema and rare epicardial inflammation but no tissue necrosis. However, there were vascular changes in allografts from GN-treated mice, including altered endothelial morphology, associated with moderate intimal hyperplasia and mild perivascular leukocytic infiltration. Allografts from anti-CD4 mAb-treated mice exhibited prominent neointimal hyperplasia associated with endothelial morphologic changes and prominent vascular and perivascular leukocytic infiltration. In general, both GN and anti-CD4 mAb promoted long-term allograft survival, but these allografts displayed the histopathologic signs of ongoing inflammation and chronic allograft rejection.

Nonradioactive alternative to clinical mixed lymphocyte reaction

The MLR is used clinically as a functional assay for genetic HLA disparity. Traditionally this test relies on [3H]thymidine incorporation to detect T-cell proliferation as an indicator of alloantigenicity. Environmental and administrative concerns regarding radioisotope use and disposal have encouraged the development of sensitive, nonradioactive assay for T-cell alloactivation. We describe a nonradioactive alternative to the clinical MLR which uses an IL-2-dependent cell line, CTLL20.3, and MTT reduction to detect IL-2 accumulation in MLC SNs as an index of T-cell alloactivation. We first determined (a) the optimal number of CTLL20.3 cells for the assay, (b) the optimal time of SN analysis for IL-2, and (c) additional manipulations that significantly increase the assay sensitivity for IL-2. Using this assay system with patient lymphocyte combinations, we demonstrated that the CTLL20.3-MTT assays correlate well with the [3H]thymidine assays of T-cell proliferation for the detection of MHC incompatibility. Indeed, the CTLL20.3-MTT assay may be slightly more sensitive than the traditional clinical MLR.

Peptide vaccines incorporating a 'promiscuous' T-cell epitope bypass certain haplotype restricted immune responses and provide broad spectrum immunogenicity

An ideal peptide vaccine should contain both B- and T-cell epitopes. Recognition of antigen by B cells is highly dependent on the three-dimensional conformation of the antigen whereas T cells recognize antigen only after it has been processed to release a peptide fragment which is bound to the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecule. However, T cells provide 'help' to B cells displaying the same processed, MHC-restricted form of the antigen, demonstrating that the T-cell response to a protein antigen is under genetic control. Thus, strategies for co-inclusion of T cell 'helper' epitopes with the B-cell determinant elicit immune responses that are in most cases genetically restricted to only one or a few alleles of the MHC with limited activity across divergent MHC class II haplotypes. This genetically restricted T cell stimulatory activity of peptides is a serious obstacle and consequently such constructs would be of limited practical value as a vaccine targeted to a majority of an outbred population. In the study described here, we have engineered two peptides to encompass the sequences from the universally immunogenic tetanus toxoid (TT) epitope and the contraceptive vaccine candidate lactate dehydrogenase C4 (LDH-C4). We demonstrate the feasibility of using 'promiscuous' T-cell epitopes colinearly constructed with a defined B-cell epitope to induce high titer antipeptide IgG antibodies specific for native protein antigen LDH-C4 in several inbred strains of mice, outbred mice and rabbits. There appears to be a strong correlation between the capacity for the hybrid peptides to be stimulatory for the corresponding T cells in C57BL/6 (H-2b) and C3H/HeJ (H-2k) mice and their ability to be immunogenic. This correlation, however, appears to break down in H-2d strains of mice since no antibodies were detected in BALB/c and barely detectable levels of antibodies in B10.D2 although activated T cells were detectable. Conversely, high titers of antipeptide antibodies are elicited in some strains (B10.BR (H-2k); C57BL/10 (H-2b) without detectable IL-2 responses. Finally, we show that a determinant which was previously restricted to H-2k can be rendered immunogenic in H-2b with the 'promiscuous' TT epitope. Thus, certain haplotype-restricted immune responses can be bypassed, setting forth the ground work for the design of a universal vaccine by broadening the effective response in a larger number of individuals typical of the genetically diverse outbred human population.

Design and immunological properties of topographic immunogenic determinants of a protein antigen (LDH-C4) as vaccines

Antibodies elicited by immunization with short peptides containing antigenic determinants have been shown, in general, to bind with greatly reduced affinity to the corresponding region in the native proteins. Thus, contiguous linear peptides have not proven to be effective immunogens in generating high affinity neutralizing or protective antibodies and consequently appear to be poor prospects for vaccines. The molecular basis for such reduced reactivity is clear from the crystal structure determination of antibody Fabs bound to protein antigens, which showed the complementarity between interfaces to be lock-and-key-like and extending over a large area (750 A2) involving discontinuous segments of the polypeptide chain. Thus, small perturbations in the secondary and tertiary structure of the antigen have profound effects on the fit of the antigen and its corresponding antibody. Because short peptides are unlikely to assume any particular conformation in solution, the fit is likely to be poor. New strategies are therefore required to produce conformationally stable peptides that mimic the critical structural features of the protein antigenic site. Here we show that a putative topographic determinant of the testis-specific isozyme of lactate dehydrogenase C4 (LDH-C4), designed and synthesized to adopt a well defined alpha-helical secondary and tertiary structure (four-helix bundle motif) in aqueous solutions, is highly immunogenic in both rabbits and mice, inducing IgG antibodies that bind to native LDH-C4. This engineered conformational 40-residue peptide is considerably more effective in inducing antibodies, as compared with the corresponding linear peptide. The antibody response is obtained without coupling the peptide to a carrier protein, suggesting that the peptide contains a T-cell antigenic determinant. The strategy described here to produce a conformationally stable peptide that mimics the native structure may have general applications in vaccine design.

Cellular and subcellular distribution of PBP72/74, a peptide-binding protein that plays a role in antigen processing

A 72/74-kDa peptide binding protein (PBP72/74) was previously described which plays a role in the processing and/or presentation of Ag, possibly by facilitating the association of processed Ag with the MHC class II molecules. PBP72/74 was recently shown to be related to the 70-kDa family of heat shock proteins (hsp70), whose members show the general characteristic of binding to denatured or inappropriately folded proteins. Here we describe the cellular and subcellular distribution of PBP72/74. By flow cytometry with PBP72/74-specific rabbit antisera, PBP72/74 is detected on the surfaces of mouse Ig+ B cells and MAC-1+ macrophages. PBP72/74 74 was not detected on the surfaces of Thy-1+ T cells or NK1.1+ NK cells. The cell surface expression of PBP72/74 does not require MHC class II expression. Indeed, the Ia- variant B cell lymphoma cell line, M12.C3, expresses PBP72/74 at levels equivalent to that of the Ia+ parent cell line, M12.4.1, from which it was derived. Furthermore, the fibroblast L cell line, DAP.3, shows no cell surface expression of PBP72/74, nor do DAP.3 lines transfected with and expressing genes encoding the alpha- and beta-chain of the I-Ad and I-Ed molecules. Moreover, treatment of B cells with either IL-4 or LPS, which increases Ia expression severalfold, does not affect PBP72/74 expression. Thus, PBP72/74 cell surface expression appears to be a property of B cells and macrophages, independent of Ia expression. In addition, the B cell surface expression of PBP72/74 is not altered by stress in the form of heat shock. Thus, PBP72/74 appears to be a constitutive noninducible member of the hsp70 family. By immunoelectron microscopy, PBP72/74 is detected in approximately 36% of early endocytic vesicles into which surface Ig is internalized after binding to anti-Ig antibodies. This compartment was previously shown to contain class II en route to the cell surface associated with invariant chain and the proteases cathepsin B and D and is suggested to be a subcellular site of antigen processing. PBP72/74 is also found associated with the plasma membrane, endoplasmic reticulum, and membranes proximal to the Golgi stacks. The cellular and subcellular distribution of PBP72/74 is consistent with its playing a role in the processing of presentation of Ag with the MHC class II molecules.

Cellular and subcellular distribution of PBP72/74, a peptide-binding protein that plays a role in antigen processing

A 72/74-kDa peptide binding protein (PBP72/74) was previously described which plays a role in the processing and/or presentation of Ag, possibly by facilitating the association of processed Ag with the MHC class II molecules. PBP72/74 was recently shown to be related to the 70-kDa family of heat shock proteins (hsp70), whose members show the general characteristic of binding to denatured or inappropriately folded proteins. Here we describe the cellular and subcellular distribution of PBP72/74. By flow cytometry with PBP72/74-specific rabbit antisera, PBP72/74 is detected on the surfaces of mouse Ig+ B cells and MAC-1+ macrophages. PBP72/74 74 was not detected on the surfaces of Thy-1+ T cells or NK1.1+ NK cells. The cell surface expression of PBP72/74 does not require MHC class II expression. Indeed, the Ia- variant B cell lymphoma cell line, M12.C3, expresses PBP72/74 at levels equivalent to that of the Ia+ parent cell line, M12.4.1, from which it was derived. Furthermore, the fibroblast L cell line, DAP.3, shows no cell surface expression of PBP72/74, nor do DAP.3 lines transfected with and expressing genes encoding the alpha- and beta-chain of the I-Ad and I-Ed molecules. Moreover, treatment of B cells with either IL-4 or LPS, which increases Ia expression severalfold, does not affect PBP72/74 expression. Thus, PBP72/74 cell surface expression appears to be a property of B cells and macrophages, independent of Ia expression. In addition, the B cell surface expression of PBP72/74 is not altered by stress in the form of heat shock. Thus, PBP72/74 appears to be a constitutive noninducible member of the hsp70 family. By immunoelectron microscopy, PBP72/74 is detected in approximately 36% of early endocytic vesicles into which surface Ig is internalized after binding to anti-Ig antibodies. This compartment was previously shown to contain class II en route to the cell surface associated with invariant chain and the proteases cathepsin B and D and is suggested to be a subcellular site of antigen processing. PBP72/74 is also found associated with the plasma membrane, endoplasmic reticulum, and membranes proximal to the Golgi stacks. The cellular and subcellular distribution of PBP72/74 is consistent with its playing a role in the processing of presentation of Ag with the MHC class II molecules.