The detrimental effect of donor-specific antibodies is irrespective of its level in highly-immunized living donor kidney transplant recipients: A case-control series

Background

The impact of donor-specific antibodies (DSA) in (highly-) immunized living donor kidney transplant recipients is reported differentially in various patient cohorts.

Methods

We have performed a retrospective analysis of all consecutive HLA-incompatible living donor kidney transplant recipients in our center between 2010-2019. Recipients who underwent plasmafiltration for a positive CDC-crossmatch were excluded. For each DSA+ recipient (DSA+), one immunized recipient without DSA (pPRA+) and two non-immunized recipients (pPRA-) were included. Patient and graft survival were analyzed and a subgroup analysis of DSA+ recipients was performed.

Results

For 63 DSA+ recipients, 63 PRA+ and 126 PRA- recipients were included. 26 (41%) had class I, 24 (38%) class II and 13 (21%) combined HLA class I and II DSA. Death-censored graft survival was inferior in DSA+ recipients compared to pPRA+ (HR 2.38 [95% CI 1.00-5.70]) as well as to pPRA- (HR 3.91 [1.86-8.22]). In multivariate analysis, DSA remained of negative influence on death-censored graft survival. Flowcytometric crossmatch, MFI value, HLA class and origin of DSA were not of significant impact.

Conclusion

In our cohort of (highly-) immunized recipients, pretransplant DSA led to inferior death-censored graft survival. There were no "safe" DSA characteristics since only DSA per se impacted death-censored graft survival.

P–420 uncomplicated oocyte donation pregnancies display elevated CD163 positive type 2 macrophage load in the decidua, which is associated with fetal-maternal HLA class II mismatches

Study question

Do quantity and composition of decidual macrophages differ between uncomplicated oocyte donation (OD) pregnancies and non-OD in vitro fertilization (IVF) pregnancies?

Summary answer

OD placentas show higher decidual CD163 positive fraction within the total macrophage population compared to non-OD IVF placentas.

What is known already

The embryo of an OD pregnancy is completely allogeneic to the mother, which may lead to a bigger challenge for the maternal immune system to tolerize the fetus compared to autologous pregnancies. Placental macrophages may be essential in maintaining a healthy pregnancy. Macrophages can be classified into different categories based on phenotype and characteristics, in which type 2 macrophages are thought to exhibit immune suppressive activity.

Study design, size, duration

This retrospective case-control study included patients who delivered in the Leiden University Medical Center between January 1st 2006 and July 1st 2016. A total of 42 pregnancies were enrolled in this study, conceived by uncomplicated singleton OD pregnancies (n = 25) or non-OD IVF pregnancies (n = 17). Medical records were reviewed and clinical data were collected. Placental tissue samples were collected for immunohistochemical staining and blood samples were collected for HLA typing.

Participants/materials, setting, methods

Placentas were collected and immunohistochemically stained for CD14 (pan-macrophage marker) and CD163 (type 2 macrophage marker). The extent of staining was quantitated by digital image analysis software. To assess mismatching, maternal and fetal DNA was typed for HLA-A, -B, C, -DRB1, and -DQB1.

Main results and the role of chance

A significantly lower percentage of CD14 positive staining was observed in the decidua basalis of OD pregnancies compared to non-OD IVF pregnancies (p = 0.030). Consequently, the CD163/CD14 ratio in OD group was higher than in non-OD IVF group (p = 0.243). In the parietalis, OD pregnancies demonstrated a significantly higher percentage of CD163+ staining (p = 0.040) and a significantly higher CD163/CD14 ratio (p = 0.032) compared to non-OD IVF group. The reproducibility of this quantitative analysis was found to be high. OD group was separated into a syngeneic group (number of mismatches lower than half of the antigens per HLA locus) and an allogeneic group (number of mismatches higher than half of the antigens per HLA locus). Significant differences of CD163+ and CD163/CD14 ratio were found in the decidua parietalis when comparing the HLA-classII-allogeneic OD group with the non-OD IVF group (p = 0.047). This difference was not found for the HLA-class-II-syngeneic OD group.

Limitations, reasons for caution

Our study only focused on decidua basalis and parietalis, no other locations in the placentas. Larger sample size might be needed to verify the association between macrophages and HLA mismatches.

Wider implications of the findings: To our knowledge, this study is the first to quantify a higher CD163 positive M2 macrophages load within the total decidual macrophages of uncomplicated OD pregnancy compared to non-OD IVF pregnancies.

Trial registration number

Not applicable

P-420 Pre-selected for an award: Uncomplicated oocyte donation pregnancies display elevated CD163 positive type 2 macrophage load in the decidua, which is associated with fetal-maternal HLA class II mismatches

Study question

Do quantity and composition of decidual macrophages differ between uncomplicated oocyte donation (OD) pregnancies and non-OD in vitro fertilization (IVF) pregnancies?

Summary answer

OD placentas show higher decidual CD163 positive fraction within the total macrophage population compared to non-OD IVF placentas.

What is known already

The embryo of an OD pregnancy is completely allogeneic to the mother, which may lead to a bigger challenge for the maternal immune system to tolerize the fetus compared to autologous pregnancies. Placental macrophages may be essential in maintaining a healthy pregnancy. Macrophages can be classified into different categories based on phenotype and characteristics, in which type 2 macrophages are thought to exhibit immune suppressive activity.

Study design, size, duration

This retrospective case-control study included patients who delivered in the Leiden University Medical Center between January 1st 2006 and July 1st 2016. A total of 42 pregnancies were enrolled in this study, conceived by uncomplicated singleton OD pregnancies (n = 25) or non-OD IVF pregnancies (n = 17). Medical records were reviewed and clinical data were collected. Placental tissue samples were collected for immunohistochemical staining and blood samples were collected for HLA typing.

Participants/materials, setting, methods

Placentas were collected and immunohistochemically stained for CD14 (pan-macrophage marker) and CD163 (type 2 macrophage marker). The extent of staining was quantitated by digital image analysis software. To assess mismatching, maternal and fetal DNA was typed for HLA-A, -B, C, -DRB1, and -DQB1.

Main results and the role of chance

A significantly lower percentage of CD14 positive staining was observed in the decidua basalis of OD pregnancies compared to non-OD IVF pregnancies (p = 0.030). Consequently, the CD163/CD14 ratio in OD group was higher than in non-OD IVF group (p = 0.243). In the parietalis, OD pregnancies demonstrated a significantly higher percentage of CD163+ staining (p = 0.040) and a significantly higher CD163/CD14 ratio (p = 0.032) compared to non-OD IVF group. The reproducibility of this quantitative analysis was found to be high. OD group was separated into a syngeneic group (number of mismatches lower than half of the antigens per HLA locus) and an allogeneic group (number of mismatches higher than half of the antigens per HLA locus). Significant differences of CD163+ and CD163/CD14 ratio were found in the decidua parietalis when comparing the HLA-classII-allogeneic OD group with the non-OD IVF group (p = 0.047). This difference was not found for the HLA-class-II-syngeneic OD group.

Limitations, reasons for caution

Our study only focused on decidua basalis and parietalis, no other locations in the placentas. Larger sample size might be needed to verify the association between macrophages and HLA mismatches.

Wider implications of the findings

To our knowledge, this study is the first to quantify a higher CD163 positive M2 macrophages load within the total decidual macrophages of uncomplicated OD pregnancy compared to non-OD IVF pregnancies.

Trial registration number

not applicable

Reciprocal HLA-DR allogenicity between mother and child affects pregnancy outcome parameters

Successful pregnancy outcome depends on local immunoregulatory mechanisms preventing a detrimental immune response towards the semi-allogeneic fetus. We investigated the influence of HLA-DR (in)compatibility on pregnancy outcome parameters in 480 women. The parameters tested were birth weight, individualized birthweight ratio (IBR), gestational age, and maternal highest diastolic blood pressure. Irrespective of pregnancy complications, maternal-fetal HLA-DR incompatibility resulted in increased IBR. We conclude that reciprocal HLA-DR allogenicity between mother and child positively affect pregnancy outcome parameters.

Presence of intragraft B cells during acute renal allograft rejection is accompanied by changes in peripheral blood B cell subsets

B cells have various functions, besides being plasma cell precursors. We determined the presence of intragraft B cells at time of acute rejection (AR) and looked for correlates of B cell involvement in peripheral blood. Renal biopsies at time of AR or stable graft function were analysed for the presence of B cells and B cell‐related gene expression, as well as C4d staining. Peripheral blood B cell subset distribution was analysed at various time‐points in patients with AR and controls, alongside serum human leucocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies. AR was accompanied by intragraft CD20⁺ B cells, as well as elevated CD20 (MS4A1) and CD19 gene expression compared to controls. B cell infiltrates were proportional to T cells, and accompanied by the chemokine pair C‐X‐C motif chemokine ligand 13 (CXCL13)–C‐X‐C motif chemokine receptor 5 (CXCR5) and B cell activating factor (BAFF). Peripheral blood memory B cells were decreased and naive B cells increased at AR, in contrast to controls. While 22% of patients with AR and 5% of controls showed de‐novo donor‐specific antibodies (DSA), all biopsies were C4d‐negative. These results suggest a role for B cells in AR by infiltrating the graft alongside T cells. We hypothesize that the shift in peripheral blood B cell composition is related to the graft infiltration at time of AR.

Differential effects of donor-specific HLA antibodies in living versus deceased donor transplant

The presence of donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies (DSAs) is associated with increased risk of graft failure after kidney transplant. We hypothesized that DSAs against HLA class I, class II, or both classes indicate a different risk for graft loss between deceased and living donor transplant. In this study, we investigated the impact of pretransplant DSAs, by using single antigen bead assays, on long-term graft survival in 3237 deceased and 1487 living donor kidney transplants with a negative complement-dependent crossmatch. In living donor transplants, we found a limited effect on graft survival of DSAs against class I or II antigens after transplant. Class I and II DSAs combined resulted in decreased 10-year graft survival (84% to 75%). In contrast, after deceased donor transplant, patients with class I or class II DSAs had a 10-year graft survival of 59% and 60%, respectively, both significantly lower than the survival for patients without DSAs (76%). The combination of class I and II DSAs resulted in a 10-year survival of 54% in deceased donor transplants. In conclusion, class I and II DSAs are a clear risk factor for graft loss in deceased donor transplants, while in living donor transplants, class I and II DSAs seem to be associated with an increased risk for graft failure, but this could not be assessed due to their low prevalence.

Pretransplant Numbers of CD16+ Monocytes as a Novel Biomarker to Predict Acute Rejection After Kidney Transplantation: A Pilot Study

Acute rejection is one of the major immunological determinants of kidney graft function and survival. Early biomarkers to predict rejection are lacking. Emerging evidence reveals a crucial role for the monocyte/macrophage lineage cells in the pathogenesis of rejection. We hypothesized that higher pretransplant numbers of proinflammatory CD16+ monocytes can predict rejection. The study cohort consisted of 104 kidney transplant recipients (58 with no rejection and 46 with biopsy-proven rejection) and 33 healthy persons. Posttransplant median follow-up time was 14.7 mo (interquartile range 0.3-34 mo). Pretransplantation blood samples were analyzed by flow cytometry for monocyte immunophenotypes. Groups were compared by Cox regression models for the occurrence of acute rejection. We documented a significantly increased absolute number of pretransplant CD16+ monocytes in patients who developed biopsy-proven rejection after transplantation compared with those with no rejection (hazard ratio [HR] 1.60, 95% CI 1.28-2.00, p < 0.001) and healthy persons (HR 1.47, 95% CI 1.18-1.82, p < 0.001). In parallel, significantly fewer absolute numbers of CD16- monocytes were observed at pretransplant time points in rejectors versus nonrejectors (HR 0.74, 95% CI 0.58-0.94, p < 0,014). A higher pretransplant number of CD16+ monocytes is significantly associated with a higher risk of acute rejection after kidney transplantation.

A Memory B Cell Crossmatch Assay for Quantification of Donor-Specific Memory B Cells in the Peripheral Blood of HLA-Immunized Individuals

Humoral responses against mismatched donor HLA are routinely measured as serum HLA antibodies, which are mainly produced by bone marrow-residing plasma cells. Individuals with a history of alloimmunization but lacking serum antibodies may harbor circulating dormant memory B cells, which may rapidly become plasma cells on antigen reencounter. Currently available methods to detect HLA-specific memory B cells are scarce and insufficient in quantifying the complete donor-specific memory B cell response due to their dependence on synthetic HLA molecules. We present a highly sensitive and specific tool for quantifying donor-specific memory B cells in peripheral blood of individuals using cell lysates covering the complete HLA class I and class II repertoire of an individual. Using this enzyme-linked immunospot (ELISpot) assay, we found a median frequency of 31 HLA class I and 89 HLA class II-specific memory B cells per million IgG-producing cells directed at paternal HLA in peripheral blood samples from women (n = 22) with a history of pregnancy, using cell lysates from spouses. The donor-specific memory B cell ELISpot can be used in HLA diagnostic laboratories as a cross-match assay to quantify donor-specific memory B cells in patients with a history of sensitizing events.

Allo-HLA Cross-Reactivities of Cytomegalovirus-, Influenza-, and Varicella Zoster Virus-Specific Memory T Cells Are Shared by Different Healthy Individuals

Virus-specific T cells can recognize allogeneic HLA (allo-HLA) through TCR cross-reactivity. The allospecificity often differs by individual (private cross-reactivity) but also can be shared by multiple individuals (public cross-reactivity); however, only a few examples of the latter have been described. Because these could facilitate alloreactivity prediction in transplantation, we aimed to identify novel public cross-reactivities of human virus-specific CD8⁺ T cells directed against allo-HLA by assessing their reactivity in mixed-lymphocyte reactions. Further characterization was done by studying TCR usage with primer-based DNA sequencing, cytokine production with ELISAs, and cytotoxicity with ⁵¹ chromium-release assays. We identified three novel public allo-HLA cross-reactivities of human virus-specific CD8⁺ T cells. CMV B35/IPS CD8⁺ T cells cross-reacted with HLA-B51 and/or HLA-B58/B57 (23% of tetramer-positive individuals), FLU A2/GIL (influenza IMP[58-66] HLA-A*02:01/GILGFVFTL) CD8⁺ T cells with HLA-B38 (90% of tetramer-positive individuals), and VZV A2/ALW (varicella zoster virus IE62[593-601] HLA-A*02:01/ALWALPHAA) CD8⁺ T cells with HLA-B55 (two unrelated individuals). Cross-reactivity was tested against different cell types including endothelial and epithelial cells. All cross-reactive T cells expressed a memory phenotype, emphasizing the importance for transplantation. We conclude that public allo-HLA cross-reactivity of virus-specific memory T cells is not uncommon and may create novel opportunities for alloreactivity prediction and risk estimation in transplantation.

How can we reduce costs of solid-phase multiplex-bead assays used to determine anti-HLA antibodies?

Solid-phase multiplex-bead assays are widely used in transplantation to detect anti-human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies. These assays enable high resolution detection of low levels of HLA antibodies. However, multiplex-bead assays are costly and yield variable measurements that limit the comparison of results between laboratories. In the context of a Dutch national Consortium study we aimed to determine the inter-assay and inter-machine variability of multiplex-bead assays, and we assessed how to reduce the assay reagents costs. Fifteen sera containing a variety of HLA antibodies were used yielding in total 7092 median fluorescence intensities (MFI) values. The inter-assay and inter-machine mean absolute relative differences (MARD) of the screening assay were 12% and 13%, respectively. The single antigen bead (SAB) inter-assay MARD was comparable, but showed a higher lot-to-lot variability. Reduction of screening assay reagents to 50% or 40% of manufacturers' recommendations resulted in MFI values comparable to 100% of the reagents, with an MARD of 12% or 14%, respectively. The MARD of the 50% and 40% SAB assay reagent reductions were 11% and 22%, respectively. From this study, we conclude that the reagents can be reliably reduced at least to 50% of manufacturers' recommendations with virtually no differences in HLA antibody assignments.

Glycemic Stability Through Islet-After-Kidney Transplantation Using an Alemtuzumab-Based Induction Regimen and Long-Term Triple-Maintenance Immunosuppression

Pancreatic islet transplantation is performed in a select group of patients with type 1 diabetes mellitus. Immunosuppressive regimens play an important role in long-term islet function. We aimed to investigate the efficacy of islet transplantation in patients with type 1 diabetes and a previous kidney transplantation using an alemtuzumab-based induction regimen and triple maintenance immunosuppression. Patients with type 1 diabetes, who had received a kidney transplant previously, were treated with alemtuzumab as induction therapy for their first islet transplantation and basiliximab induction therapy for subsequent islet transplantations. Maintenance immunosuppression consisted of triple immunosuppression (tacrolimus, mycophenolate mofetil, and prednisolone). Thirteen patients (age 50.9 ± 9.2 years, duration of diabetes 35 ± 9 years) received a total of 22 islet transplantations. One- and 2-year insulin independence was 62% and 42%, respectively; graft function was 100% and 92%, respectively. HbA1c dropped from 57.2 ± 13.1 (7.4 ± 1.2%) to 44.5 ± 11.8 mmol/molHb (6.2 ± 0.9%) (p = 0.003) after 2 years. Six of 13 patients suffered from severe hypoglycemia before islet transplantation. After transplantation, severe hypoglycemia was restricted to the only patient who lost graft function. Creatinine clearance was unchanged. Islet-after-kidney transplantation in patients with type 1 diabetes using an alemtuzumab-based induction regimen leads to considerable islet allograft function and improvement in glycemic control.

Follicular T helper cells and humoral reactivity in kidney transplant patients

Memory B cells play a pivotal role in alloreactivity in kidney transplantation. Follicular T helper (Tfh) cells play an important role in the differentiation of B cells into immunoglobulin-producing plasmablasts [through interleukin (IL)-21]. It is unclear to what extent this T cell subset regulates humoral alloreactivity in kidney transplant patients, therefore we investigated the absolute numbers and function of peripheral Tfh cells (CD4(POS) CXCR5(POS) T cells) in patients before and after transplantation. In addition, we studied their relationship with the presence of donor-specific anti-human leucocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies (DSA), and the presence of Tfh cells in rejection biopsies. After transplantation peripheral Tfh cell numbers remained stable, while their IL-21-producing capacity decreased under immunosuppression. When isolated after transplantation, peripheral Tfh cells still had the capacity to induce B cell differentiation and immunoglobulin production, which could be inhibited by an IL-21-receptor-antagonist. After transplantation the quantity of Tfh cells was the highest in patients with pre-existent DSA. In kidney biopsies taken during rejection, Tfh cells co-localized with B cells and immunoglobulins in follicular-like structures. Our data on Tfh cells in kidney transplantation demonstrate that Tfh cells may mediate humoral alloreactivity, which is also seen in the immunosuppressed milieu.

Matching for Human Leukocyte Antigens (HLA) in corneal transplantation - to do or not to do

As many patients with severe corneal disease are not even considered as candidates for a human graft due to their high risk of rejection, it is essential to find ways to reduce the chance of rejection. One of the options is proper matching of the cornea donor and recipient for the Human Leukocyte Antigens (HLA), a subject of much debate. Currently, patients receiving their first corneal allograft are hardly ever matched for HLA and even patients undergoing a regraft usually do not receive an HLA-matched graft. While anterior and posterior lamellar grafts are not immune to rejection, they are usually performed in low risk, non-vascularized cases. These are the cases in which the immune privilege due to the avascular status and active immune inhibition is still intact. Once broken due to infection, sensitization or trauma, rejection will occur. There is enough data to show that when proper DNA-based typing techniques are being used, even low risk perforating corneal transplantations benefit from matching for HLA Class I, and high risk cases from HLA Class I and probably Class II matching. Combining HLA class I and class II matching, or using the HLAMatchmaker could further improve the effect of HLA matching. However, new techniques could be applied to reduce the chance of rejection. Options are the local or systemic use of biologics, or gene therapy, aiming at preventing or suppressing immune responses. The goal of all these approaches should be to prevent a first rejection, as secondary grafts are usually at higher risk of complications including rejections than first grafts.

The PROCARE consortium: toward an improved allocation strategy for kidney allografts

Kidney transplantation is the best treatment option for patients with end-stage renal failure. At present, approximately 800 Dutch patients are registered on the active waiting list of Eurotransplant. The waiting time in the Netherlands for a kidney from a deceased donor is on average between 3 and 4 years. During this period, patients are fully dependent on dialysis, which replaces only partly the renal function, whereas the quality of life is limited. Mortality among patients on the waiting list is high. In order to increase the number of kidney donors, several initiatives have been undertaken by the Dutch Kidney Foundation including national calls for donor registration and providing information on organ donation and kidney transplantation. The aim of the national PROCARE consortium is to develop improved matching algorithms that will lead to a prolonged survival of transplanted donor kidneys and a reduced HLA immunization. The latter will positively affect the waiting time for a retransplantation. The present algorithm for allocation is among others based on matching for HLA antigens, which were originally defined by antibodies using serological typing techniques. However, several studies suggest that this algorithm needs adaptation and that other immune parameters which are currently not included may assist in improving graft survival rates. We will employ a multicenter-based evaluation on 5429 patients transplanted between 1995 and 2005 in the Netherlands. The association between key clinical endpoints and selected laboratory defined parameters will be examined, including Luminex-defined HLA antibody specificities, T and B cell epitopes recognized on the mismatched HLA antigens, non-HLA antibodies, and also polymorphisms in complement and Fc receptors functionally associated with effector functions of anti-graft antibodies. From these data, key parameters determining the success of kidney transplantation will be identified which will lead to the identification of additional parameters to be included in future matching algorithms aiming to extend survival of transplanted kidneys and to diminish HLA immunization. Computer simulation studies will reveal the number of patients having a direct benefit from improved matching, the effect on shortening of the waiting list, and the decrease in waiting time.

Diagnosis of early pancreas graft failure via antibody-mediated rejection: single-center experience with 256 pancreas transplantations

Early pancreas graft loss is usually attributed to technical failure while the possibility of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) is generally overlooked. To investigate the role of AMR in early pancreas graft loss, we retrospectively assessed 256 patients with simultaneous pancreas-kidney transplantation (SPK) between 1985 and 2010 at our institute. We included 33 SPK patients who lost their pancreas graft <1 year after transplantation. AMR was diagnosed based on donor-specific antibodies, C4d and histology in 7 cases, 8 cases were suspicious for AMR and 18 pancreas graft losses were not due to AMR. Acute AMR occurred >1 month after transplantation in 6/7 cases, whereas all other causes typically led to loss <1 month after transplantation. Thrombotic lesions occurred equally among the 33 cases. In 12/18 concurrent kidney specimens, the diagnostic results paralleled those of the pancreas graft. All patients with acute AMR of the pancreas graft lost their renal grafts <1 year after transplantation. In the setting of a thrombotic event, histopathological analysis of early pancreas graft loss is advisable to rule out the possibility of AMR, particularly because a diagnosis of acute AMR has important consequences for renal graft outcomes.

Cross-validation of IFN-γ Elispot assay for measuring alloreactive memory/effector T cell responses in renal transplant recipients

Assessment of donor-specific alloreactive memory/effector T cell responses using an IFN-γ Elispot assay has been suggested to be a novel immune-monitoring tool for evaluating the cellular immune risk in renal transplantation. Here, we report the cross-validation data of the IFN-γ Elispot assay performed within different European laboratories taking part of the EU RISET consortium. For this purpose, development of a standard operating procedure (SOP), comparisons of lectures of IFN-γ plates assessing intra- and interlaboratory assay variability of allogeneic or peptide stimuli in both healthy and kidney transplant individuals have been the main objectives. We show that the use of a same SOP and count-settings of the Elispot bioreader allow low coefficient variation between laboratories. Frozen and shipped samples display slightly lower detectable IFN-γ frequencies than fresh samples. Importantly, a close correlation between different laboratories is obtained when measuring high frequencies of antigen-specific primed/memory T cell alloresponses. Interestingly, significant high donor-specific alloreactive T cell responses can be similarly detected among different laboratories in kidney transplant patients displaying histological patterns of acute T cell mediated rejection. In conclusion, assessment of circulating alloreactive memory/effector T cells using an INF-γ Elispot assay can be accurately achieved using the same SOP, Elispot bioreader and experienced technicians in kidney transplantation.

Algorithms for the determination of unacceptable HLA antigen mismatches in kidney transplant recipients

One of the major tasks of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) laboratories is the pretransplant determination of unacceptable HLA antigen mismatches (UAM) in organ transplant recipients. HLA antigen specificities are determined against which the patient has circulating alloantibodies that are expected to harm the transplanted organ. Using the information on UAM, negative crossmatch (XM) prediction or 'virtual XM' is possible when a potential donor's complete HLA typing is available. Before the introduction of solid-phase antibody detection assays, UAM were determined using the complement-dependent cytotoxicity methodology. After the introduction of the single antigen bead technique, however, various UAM determination algorithms have emerged. In this report, six different laboratories worldwide present how they determine UAM in their collective of kidney transplant recipients in the pretransplant phase and proceed thereafter to transplantation.

Immune responses against islet allografts during tapering of immunosuppression--a pilot study in 5 subjects

Transplantation of isolated islet of Langerhans cells has great potential as a cure for type 1 diabetes but continuous immune suppressive therapy often causes considerable side effects. Tapering of immunosuppression in successfully transplanted patients would lower patients' health risk. To identify immune biomarkers that may prove informative in monitoring tapering, we studied the effect of tapering on islet auto- and alloimmune reactivity in a pilot study in five transplant recipients in vitro. Cytokine responses to the graft were measured using Luminex technology. Avidity of alloreactive cytotoxic T Lymphocytes (CTL) was determined by CD8 blockade. The influence of immunosuppression was mimicked by in vitro replenishment of tacrolimus and MPA, the active metabolite of mycophenolate mofetil. Tapering of tacrolimus was generally followed by decreased C-peptide production. T-cell autoreactivity increased in four out of five patients during tapering. Overall alloreactive CTL precursor frequencies did not change, but their avidity to donor mismatches increased significantly after tapering (P = 0·035). In vitro addition of tacrolimus but not MPA strongly inhibited CTL alloreactivity during tapering and led to a significant shift to anti-inflammatory graft-specific cytokine production. Tapering of immunosuppression is characterized by diverse immune profiles that appear to relate inversely to plasma C-peptide levels. Highly avid allospecific CTLs that are known to associate with rejection increased during tapering, but could be countered by restoring immune suppression in vitro. Immune monitoring studies may help guiding tapering of immunosuppression after islet cell transplantation, even though we do not have formal prove yet that the observed changes reflect direct effects of immune suppression on immunity.

A NOVel ELISPOT assay to quantify HLA-specific B cells in HLA-immunized individuals

Quantification of the humoral alloimmune response is generally achieved by measuring serum HLA antibodies, which provides no information about the cells involved in the humoral immune response. Therefore, we have developed an HLA-specific B-cell ELISPOT assay allowing for quantification of B cells producing HLA antibodies. We used recombinant HLA monomers as target in the ELISPOT assay. Validation was performed with human B-cell hybridomas producing HLA antibodies. Subsequently, we quantified B cells producing HLA antibodies in HLA-immunized individuals, non-HLA-immunized individuals and transplant patients with serum HLA antibodies. B-cell hybridomas exclusively formed spots against HLA molecules of corresponding specificity with the sensitivity similar to that found in total IgG ELISPOT assays. HLA-immunized healthy individuals showed up to 182 HLA-specific B cells per million total B cells while nonimmunized individuals had none. Patients who were immunized by an HLA-A2-mismatched graft had up to 143 HLA-A2-specific B cells per million total B cells. In conclusion, we have developed and validated a highly specific and sensitive HLA-specific B-cell ELISPOT assay, which needs further validation in a larger series of transplant patients. This technique constitutes a new tool for quantifying humoral immune responses.

TCR cross-reactivity and allorecognition: new insights into the immunogenetics of allorecognition

Alloreactive T cells are core mediators of graft rejection and are a potent barrier to transplantation tolerance. It was previously unclear how T cells educated in the recipient thymus could recognize allogeneic HLA molecules. Recently it was shown that both naïve and memory CD4+ and CD8+ T cells are frequently cross-reactive against allogeneic HLA molecules and that this allorecognition exhibits exquisite peptide and HLA specificity and is dependent on both public and private specificities of the T cell receptor. In this review we highlight new insights gained into the immunogenetics of allorecognition, with particular emphasis on how viral infection and vaccination may specifically activate allo-HLA reactive T cells. We also briefly discuss the potential for virus-specific T cell infusions to produce GvHD. The progress made in understanding the molecular basis of allograft rejection will hopefully be translated into improved allograft function and/or survival, and eventually tolerance induction.

Alloreactivity from human viral specific memory T-cells

The mechanisms by which alloreactive memory T-cells are generated in non-sensitized individuals have begun to be elucidated. It is generally accepted that a very high level of crossreactivity is an essential feature of the T-cell receptor. Indeed it has recently been shown that alloreactivity from viral specific memory T-cells is far more common than predicted, 45% of viral specific T-cell clones were found to be allo-HLA crossreactive. In this overview the evidence for crossreactive alloresponses from human viral specific memory T-cells is discussed with special emphasis on the unexpected high frequency of these crossreactive responses, the peptide and tissue specificity of the responses, and the mechanistic insights gleaned from the elucidation of the crystal structure of an allo-HLA crossreactive viral specific TCR. The possible implications for clinical solid organ and bone marrow transplantation and tolerance induction will be discussed.

Calcineurin inhibitors affect B cell antibody responses indirectly by interfering with T cell help

In general, humoral immune responses depend critically upon T cell help. In transplantation, prevention or treatment of humoral rejection therefore require drugs that ideally inhibit both B cell and T helper cell activity. Here, we studied the effects of commonly used immunosuppressive drugs [tacrolimus, cyclosporin, mycophenolic acid (MPA) and rapamycin] on T cell helper activity and on T cell-dependent B cell responses. T cells were activated polyclonally in the presence of immunosuppressive drugs in order to analyse the effect of these drugs on T cell proliferation, co-stimulatory ligand expression and cytokines. The impact of immunosuppressive drugs on T cell-dependent immunoglobulin production by B cells was addressed in T-B cell co-cultures. All drugs affected T cell proliferation and attenuated T cell co-stimulatory ligand (CD154 and CD278) expression when T cells were activated polyclonally. Tacrolimus, cyclosporin and rapamycin also attenuated B cell stimulatory cytokine mRNA levels in T cells. As a consequence, a decrease in immunoglobulin levels was observed in autologous T-B cell co-cultures, where T cell help is essential for immunoglobulin production. In contrast, when pre-activated T cells were used to stimulate autologous B cells, calcineurin inhibitors failed to inhibit B cell immunoglobulin production, whereas MPA and rapamycin did show inhibition. From these studies, it is evident that calcineurin inhibitors affect the humoral immune response by interfering with T helper signals, but not by targeting B cells directly. Furthermore, our studies support the necessity of intervening in T cell helper function to attenuate humoral responses.

Intravenous immunoglobulin preparations have no direct effect on B cell proliferation and immunoglobulin production

Intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) is used for treatment of a variety of immunological disorders and in transplantation. As one of its applications in transplantation is the reduction of donor specific antibodies in the circulation, we examined the direct effect of IVIg on essential parameters of human B cell responses in vitro. Purified human B cells, human B cell hybridomas and T cells were cultured in the presence of graded concentrations of IVIg to test its effect on their proliferative capacity. To address the effect of IVIg on immunoglobulin production, we designed a novel technique making use of quantitative polymerase chain reaction to assess IgM and IgG levels. IVIg failed to inhibit proliferation of human B cells and human B cell hybridomas. In contrast, when IVIg was added to T cell cultures, a dose-dependent reduction of the proliferative capacity was observed. IVIg did not affect the levels of IgM and IgG mRNA of activated B cells. Our data show that IVIg is not capable of directly inhibiting key B cell responses. Direct B cell inhibition by IVIg seems therefore unlikely, implying that alteration in humoral immunity by IVIg is due to indirect effects on T cells and/or interactions with circulating antibodies and complement factors.

New tools to monitor the impact of viral infection on the alloreactive T-cell repertoire

Accumulating evidence suggests that alloreactive memory T-cells may be generated as a result of viral infection. So far, a suitable tool to define the individual human leukocyte antigen (HLA) cross-reactivity of virus-specific memory T-cells is not available. We therefore aimed to develop a novel system for the detection of cross-reactive alloresponses using single HLA antigen expressing cell lines (SALs) as stimulator. Herein, we generated Epstein-Barr Virus (EBV) EBNA3A specific CD8 memory T-cell clones (HLA-B*0801/FLRGRAYGL peptide restricted) and assayed for alloreactivity against a panel of SALs using interferon-gamma Elispot as readout. Generation of the T-cell clones was performed by single cell sorting based on staining with viral peptide/major histocompatibility complex-specific tetramer. Monoclonality of the T-cell clones was confirmed by T-cell receptor (TCR) polymerase chain reaction analysis. First, we confirmed the previously described alloreactivity of the EBV EBNA3A-specific T-cell clones against SAL-expressing HLA-B*4402. Further screening against the entire panel of SALs also showed additional cross-reactivity against SAL-expressing HLA-B*5501. Functionality of the cross-reactive T-cell clones was confirmed by chromium release assay using phytohemagglutinin blasts as targets. SALs are an effective tool to detect cross-reactivity of viral-specific CD8 memory T-cell clones against individual class I HLA molecules. This technique may have important implications for donor selection and monitoring of transplant recipients.

Relevance of cytotoxic alloreactivity under different immunosuppressive regimens in clinical islet cell transplantation

Islet or beta cell transplantation provides a promising cure for type 1 diabetes patients, but insulin-independency decreases frequently over time. Immunosuppressive regimens are implemented attempting to cope with both auto- and alloimmunity after transplantation. We analysed the influence of different immunotherapies on autoreactive and alloreactive T cell patterns and transplant outcome. Patients receiving three different immunosuppressive regimens were analysed. All patients received anti-thymocyte globulin induction therapy. Twenty-one patients received tacrolimus-mycophenolate mofetil maintenance immunosuppression, whereas the other patients received tacrolimus-sirolimus (SIR, n = 5) or SIR only (n = 5). Cellular autoreactivity and alloreactivity (CTL precursor frequency) were measured ex vivo. Clinical outcome in the first 6 months after transplantation was correlated with immunological parameters. C-peptide levels were significantly different between the three groups studied (P = 0.01). We confirm that C-peptide production was correlated negatively with pretransplant cellular autoreactivity and low graft size (P = 0.001, P = 0.007 respectively). Combining all three therapies, cellular autoimmunity after transplantation was not associated with delayed insulin-independence or C-peptide production. In combined tacrolimus-SIR and SIR-treated patients, CTL alloreactivity was associated with less insulin independence and C-peptide production (P = 0.03). The percentage of donors to whom high CTLp frequencies were measured was lower in insulin-independent recipients (P = 0.03). In this cohort of islet cell graft recipients, clinical outcome in the first 6 months after transplantation correlates with the applied immunosuppressive regimen. An association exists between insulin-independence and lower incidence of CTL alloreactivity towards donor human leucocyte antigen. This observational study demonstrates the usefulness of monitoring T cell reactivity against islet allografts to correlate immune function with graft survival.

Allograft-specific cytokine profiles associate with clinical outcome after islet cell transplantation

Islet cell transplantation can cure type 1 diabetes, but allograft rejection and recurrent autoimmunity may contribute to decreasing insulin independence over time. In this study we report the association of allograft-specific proliferative and cytokine profiles with clinical outcome. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were obtained of 20 islet recipients. Cytokine values in mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) were determined using stimulator cells with graft-specific HLA class II. Qualitative and quantitative cytokine profiles were determined before and after islet transplantation, blinded from clinical outcome. Cytotoxic T Lymphocyte precursor (CTLp) assays were performed to determine HLA class I alloreactivity. Allograft-specific cytokine profiles were skewed toward a Th2 or regulatory (Treg) phenotype after transplantation in insulin-independent, but not in insulin-requiring recipients. IFNgamma/IL10 ratio and MLC proliferation decreased after transplantation in insulin-independent recipients (p = 0.006 and p = 0.01, respectively). Production of the Treg cytokine IL10 inversely correlated with proliferation in alloreactive MLC (p = 0.008) and CTLp (p = 0.005). Production of IL10 combined with low-MLC reactivity associated significantly with insulin independence. The significant correlation between allograft-specific cytokine profiles and clinical outcome may reflect the induction of immune regulation in successfully transplanted recipients. Islet donor-specific IL10 production correlates with low alloreactivity and superior islet function.

Bortezomib affects the function of human B cells: possible implications for desensitization protocols

Bortezomib is a potent inducer of apoptosis in malignant as well as non-malignant human plasma cells. Recently, bortezomib has come to attention for the treatment of humoral rejection. As bortezomib is a proteasome inhibitor, it likely affects other cell types, such as activated B cells, as well. Since additional anti-B cell effects could be beneficial for the treatment of humoral rejection, we tested whether bortezomib inhibited human B cell function. When B cells were activated in a CD40 mAb driven culture system, bortezomib dose-dependently abrogated their IgM and IgG production as well as their proliferation. This bortezomib induced inhibition was caused by induction of apoptosis, since levels of caspase 3/7 activity were increased. In addition to its effects on plasma cells, bortezomib profoundly inhibits activated human B cells. This finding suggests that when bortezomib is used for desensitization or for the treatment of humoral rejection, there is no need for additional anti-B cell therapy, such as anti-CD20 mAb (Rituximab) treatment.

Donor-derived mesenchymal stem cells remain present and functional in the transplanted human heart

Mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) are characterized by their multilineage differentiation capacity and immunosuppressive properties. They are resident in virtually all tissues and we have recently characterized MSC from the human heart. Clinical heart transplantation offers a model to study the fate of transplanted human MSC. In this study, we isolated and expanded MSC from heart tissue taken before, and 1 week up to 6 years after heart transplantation. MSC from posttransplantation tissue were all of donor origin, demonstrating the longevity of endogenous MSC and suggesting an absence of immigration of recipient MSC into the heart. MSC isolated from transplanted tissue showed an immunophenotype that was characteristic for MSC and maintained cardiomyogenic and osteogenic differentiation capacity. They furthermore preserved their ability to inhibit the proliferative response of donor-stimulated recipient peripheral blood mononuclear cells. In conclusion, functional MSC of donor origin remain present in the heart for several years after transplantation.

Monitoring of indirect allorecognition: wishful thinking or solid data?

Monitoring of T cells involved in the alloimmune response after transplantation requires the availability of reliable in vitro assays for the detection of T cells with both direct and indirect allospecificity. While generally accepted assays exist to measure helper and cytotoxic T cells involved in direct allorecognition, consensus about an assay for monitoring indirect T-cell allorecognition in clinical transplantation is lacking. Many studies claim a relationship between the reactivity of T cells with indirect allospecificity and graft rejection, but different protocols are used and essential controls are often lacking. In this review, the disadvantages and pitfalls of the current approaches are discussed, in some cases supported by the results of our own in vitro experiments. We conclude that an international workshop is necessary to establish and validate a uniform, robust and reliable assay for the monitoring of transplant recipients and to study the actual role of indirect allorecognition in acute and chronic rejection.

Comparison of macrophage phenotype between decidua basalis and decidua parietalis by flow cytometry

The two regions of the maternal decidua, decidua basalis and decidua parietalis, differ in the extent of trophoblast invasion and consequently in cytokines and other biological mediators, extracellular matrix and cellular components. Our aim was to compare the phenotypic features of macrophages from the two decidual regions across a broad gestational age range. We isolated macrophages by enzymatic digestion from healthy decidua samples obtained after elective abortions, at 9-18-week and at 19-23-weeks, or after term deliveries (caesarean sections at term and spontaneous term vaginal deliveries). Macrophages were analysed by flow cytometry applying the same instrument settings to all the samples to allow semi-quantitative comparison of the expression of a particular marker between different samples. We found higher expressions of CD80, CD86 and HLA-DR, suggestive of a more activated phenotype of decidual macrophages, at early/mid pregnancy than at term. Marginal differences were found between term decidual macrophages obtained after spontaneous vaginal deliveries or caesarean sections which imply that the parturient process is not associated with decidual macrophage activation. The expressions of CD105, DC-SIGN and MMR were the strongest in decidua basalis of mid pregnancy and indicate the importance of decidual macrophages in tissue homeostasis at the uteroplacental interface.

Highly diverged MHC class I mismatches are acceptable for haematopoietic stem cell transplantation

A fully major histocompatilbility complex (MHC) matched donor is not available for the majority of patients in need of a haematopoietic stem cell transplantation (SCT), which illustrates the need for a tool to define acceptable MHC disparities. Previously, we noticed that a variety of single MHC class I mismatched allogeneic donor-recipient pairs did not elicit an allogeneic cytotoxic-lymphocyte (CTL) response in vitro if the MHC amino-acid sequences had five or more differences in the alpha-helices plus five or more differences in the beta-sheet (> or =5alpha5beta) (7). To address the clinical relevance of this observation, we analysed CTL precursor (CTLp) assay outcome and SCT outcome in 53 Dutch recipients of a single MHC class I mismatched graft from an unrelated donor. Overall patient survival was 44% after 4 years. In multivariate analysis, recipients of a > or =5alpha5beta mismatched graft with negative CTLp frequencies in vitro before transplantation demonstrated superior survival: survival at 4 years was 80% as compared to 47% in recipients of other mismatched grafts with negative CTLp frequencies (hazard ratio=0.131; 95% CI=(0.03-0.61); P=0.009). This option of acceptable mismatches may enlarge the pool of potentially acceptable stem cell donors.

Selective unresponsiveness to beta cell autoantigens after induction immunosuppression in pancreas transplantation with anti-interleukin-2 receptor antibody versus anti-thymocyte globulin

Pancreas transplantation in type 1 diabetes patients could result in (re)activation of allo- and autoreactive T lymphocytes. Anti-thymocyte globulin (ATG) induction treatment is a successful, but broadly reactive anti-lymphocyte therapy used in pancreas and islet transplantation. A more selective alternative is daclizumab, a monoclonal antibody directed against the interleukin-2 receptor (CD25) on activated lymphocytes. We tested the hypothesis that daclizumab is more selective and has less immunological side effects than ATG. Thirty-nine simultaneous pancreas-kidney transplantation patients with type 1 diabetes were randomized for induction therapy with ATG or daclizumab. Auto- and recall immunity was measured cross-sectionally by lymphocyte stimulation tests with a series of auto- and recall antigens in 35 successfully transplanted patients. T cell autoimmunity to islets was low in both groups, except for a marginal but significantly higher reactivity against glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD)65 in daclizumab-treated patients. The memory responses to recall antigens were significantly higher in the daclizumab-treated group compared to ATG-treated patients, specifically against purified protein derivative (PPD) (anti-bacterial immunity), Haemophilus influenzae virus matrix protein-1 (anti-viral immunity) and p53 [anti-tumour (auto)immunity]. These data imply that daclizumab is more specifically affecting diabetes-related immune responses than ATG. The autoimmunity is affected effectively after daclizumab induction, while memory responses towards bacterial, viral and tumour antigens are preserved.

Mechanisms of Antibody Immunotherapy on Clonal Islet Reactive T Cells

Clinical intervention trials evaluating the efficacy of antibody immunotherapy in type 1 diabetes are in progress. We tested effects on prediabetic islet antigen-specific autoreactive T cells of antithymocyte globulin (ATG) and humanized monoclonal antibodies against CD3 (ChAglyCD3) or CD25 (daclizumab) with regard to downmodulation of the target protein, proliferation, cytokine production, complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC), antibody-dependent cell cytotoxicity (ADCC), and survival. ATG leads to depletion of autoreactive CD4+ T cells by ADCC, CDC, and apoptosis, whereas anti-CD3 and anti-CD25 inhibited T-cell autoreactivity in a nondepleting fashion. ATG treatment led to a cytokine burst of Th1- and Th2-associated cytokines. Modulation of cytokine release through humanized monoclonal antibodies was moderate and selective: anti-CD25 led to increased release of IL-2 and reduced production of TNFalpha, whereas anti-CD3 decreased release of interferon-y and IL-5 and increased secretion of IL-10. ATG and the humanized monoclonal antibodies displayed contrasting mechanisms of action.

Differential Distribution of CD4+CD25bright and CD8+CD28− T-cells in Decidua and Maternal Blood During Human Pregnancy

During pregnancy several maternal and fetal mechanisms are established to prevent a destructive immune response against the allogeneic fetus. Despite these mechanisms, fetus specific T-cells persist throughout gestation but little is known about the regulation of these T-cells. Recently, CD4(+)CD25(+) regulatory T-cells have been identified in human decidua. Human decidua forms the maternal part of the fetal-maternal interface and is subdivided in two distinct regions: the decidua (d.) basalis and the decidua (d.) parietalis. The aim of this study was to determine the distribution of specific T-cell subsets in d. basalis and d. parietalis in early and term pregnancy, with a special emphasis on the presence of CD4(+)CD25(bright) (regulatory) T-cells and CD8(+)CD28(-) (suppressor) T-cells. In addition, we compared phenotypic characteristics of decidua derived T-cell subsets with maternal peripheral blood (mPBL) T-cells and T-cells from non-pregnant controls. We identified significantly higher percentages of CD4(+)CD25(bright) and CD8(+)CD28(-) T-cells in decidua compared to peripheral blood suggesting an important role for these T-cell subsets locally at the fetal-maternal interface. The major differences in T-cell subset distribution and the presence of additional phenotypic differences between T-cells in d. basalis, d. parietalis and mPBL may reflect specific immunomodulatory functions of these T-cell subsets at these different sites during pregnancy.

The effect of noninherited maternal antigens in allogeneic transplantation

Confrontation of the unborn child immune system with the noninherited maternal antigens (NIMAs) has a lifelong modulating impact on the immune response of the child against the NIMAs. In this review we summarize the clinical evidence for the existence of the NIMA effect, discuss the possible cellular and molecular basis of the phenomenon, and outline the necessity of further clinical research.

[The possible role of microchimerism in the aetiology of autoimmune diseases]

The aetiology of several autoimmune diseases has not yet been elucidated. Microchimerism, the persistence of small numbers ofallogeneic cells in an individual, has been mentioned recently in connection with the occurrence of autoimmune diseases such as systemic sclerosis and juvenile inflammatory idiopathic myopathy. These allogeneic cells can originate from mutual foeto-maternal exchange of blood cells during pregnancy or from a donor after blood transfusion or (organ) transplantation. In some cases, a syndrome then develops that resembles the chronic graft-versus-host reaction after stem-cell transplantation, in which allogeneic cells react with autologous cells. Studies on microchimerism in patients with systemic sclerosis and juvenile inflammatory idiopathic myopathy, compared to controls, sometimes reveal a clearly increased prevalence of microchimerism in patients. However, microchimerism can also be found in healthy individuals. Direct proof of a causal relation between microchimerism and autoimmune diseases does not exist. Additional genetic or environmental factors may be partly responsible for a disturbed balance between tolerance and aggression.

Permissible and immunogenic HLA-A mismatches: cytotoxic T-cell precursor frequencies reflect graft survival data

Analysis of the in vivo immunogenicity of single HLA mismatches, in the context of a patient's own human leukocyte antigen (HLA) phenotype, has been used to define permissible and immunogenic HLA mismatches. Kidney graft survival in the case of permissible mismatches was similar to that of completely HLA matched combinations, whereas immunogenic mismatches lead to a significantly poorer graft survival. The present study tested whether such permissible and immunogenic HLA mismatches are reflected in the in vitro cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) allorepertoire. Limiting dilution experiments were performed to analyze the number of precursor CTL directed against individual HLA class I antigens. In general, the frequency of CTLp directed against permissible HLA-A antigens (n = 70, mean frequency 27 CTLp per million peripheral blood lymphocytes [PBL]) was found to be significantly lower compared with the CTLp directed against immunogenic HLA-A antigens (n = 73, mean frequency 59 CTLp per million PBL). The difference was found both in healthy individuals and a population of renal transplant candidates. These results were confirmed by a retrospective analysis of CTLp frequencies performed between partly mismatched unrelated bone marrow donors and their potential recipients. In conclusion, on the population level the permissible and immunogenic HLA-A mismatches are indeed reflected in the CTL allorepertoire. However, due to the big overlap of the CTLp frequencies in these populations, the permissible or immunogenic nature of a mismatch for a particular patient should be determined on an individual basis.

Modulation of the alloimmune response by blood transfusions

Blood transfusions can induce both immune activation and immunosuppression. The former is expressed by the induction of HLA alloantibodies and T cell activation, while the latter is accompanied by enhanced graft survival in transfused versus non-transfused recipients. The immunological mechanism leading to downregulation of the alloimmune response has not yet been elucidated. Possible explanations include the induction of a Th2 response by non-professional antigen presentation by the transfused blood cells and blockage of alloreactive T cell reactivity by soluble HLA and soluble FasL in the supernatant of blood components. These mechanisms, however, do not explain the observations which have shown that the degree of HLA compatibility between the transfusion donor and patient is a determining factor. Transfusions in which the donor blood shares at least one HLA-DR antigen with the recipient induce tolerance, while fully HLA-DR mismatched transfusions lead to immunization. The importance of HLA-DR sharing suggests a central role for CD4+ regulatory T cells. In this case, indirect recognition of an allopeptide in the context of self-HLA-DR on the transfusion donor by CD4+ T cells of the recipient might be the clue to the induction of tolerance. Recent data from our laboratory in fact show that CD4+ T cells specific for an allopeptide in the context of self HLA-DR are able to downregulate the alloimmune response of autologous T cells. As these regulatory T cells produce IL-10, they may also be involved in the extension of tolerance via their modulatory effect on dendritic cells. It remains to be established whether these regulatory T cells are indeed responsible for the 'blood transfusion effect' in organ transplantation.

REJECTION OF A KIDNEY TRANSPLANT DOES NOT ALWAYS LEAD TO PRIMING OF CYTOTOXIC T CELLS AGAINST MISMATCHED DONOR HLA CLASS I ANTIGENS1

BACKGROUND

Previous studies showed that graft rejection is often associated with the presence of primed cytotoxic T cells (CTLs) with a high avidity for donor cells. Similar high avidity CTLs have been found in individuals who have formed IgG anti-HLA antibodies. The presence of such CTLs to a specific HLA mismatch is therefore considered to be a reflection of an activated immune system, and a contraindication for retransplantation with a donor sharing this particular HLA class I mismatch.

METHODS

In our study we investigated whether patients have always primed CTLs against all individual HLA class I mismatches present on a rejected graft. Therefore, 14 patients who had undergone transplantectomy after irreversible kidney graft rejection were analyzed with respect to donor-specific CTLp frequencies and the presence or absence of high avidity CTLs directed against HLA class I mismatches present on the rejected graft.

RESULTS

Patients, who have not formed anti-HLA antibodies against the donor have mainly naive CTLs. Most of the patients, that have developed IgG anti-HLA antibodies against a donor mismatch, have primed CTLs directed against that particular mismatch. However, patients with IgM anti-HLA antibodies only, and patients with IgG anti-HLA antibodies in historical sera but no IgG anti-HLA antibodies in current sera, have mainly naive CTLs against the donor HLA mismatch.

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest that it is not always necessary to exclude repeated HLA class I mismatches for a subsequent transplantation. In addition to good anti-HLA antibody screening, the CTLp-assay may be a useful tool for donor-selection in retransplant candidates.

Pregnancy can induce long-persisting primed CTLs specific for inherited paternal HLA antigens

Previous studies showed that pregnancy can prime the maternal cellular immune response directed against paternal HLA antigens. Primed CTLs specific for inherited paternal HLA antigens (IPA) were found in women who had formed HLA allo antibodies, whereas naive CTLs were present in women who did not form antibodies against the paternal HLA antigens. As HLA allo antibodies may disappear in time, it is not clear which women on the waiting list for transplantation have been sensitized to paternal HLA antigens and are at risk for graft rejection if paternal HLA antigens are shared by the donor organ. The presence of primed CTLs specific for a particular antigen is considered to be a reflection of sensitization.In the present study we investigated whether these primed CTLs persist in women who had been pregnant and had formed antibodies against the inherited paternal HLA class I antigens. For this purpose 14 women who had their last pregnancy 10 years ago were analyzed with respect to IPA-specific CTLp frequencies and the presence of high avidity CTLs directed against inherited paternal HLA class I antigens. Although primed CTLs specific for IPA's were found more frequently in women with persisting alloantibodies, they still can be detected when the antibodies have disappeared. The current data show that primed CTLs directed against inherited paternal HLA antigens towards which antibodies have been formed in the past can persist for more than 10 years after pregnancy. The cellular test used in our study can be useful to detect presensitization in women with a history of pregnancy, who enter the waiting list for transplantation.

Immunomodulation by blood transfusions

Blood transfusions can affect the immune response in two opposite ways. They may either lead to immunization or to tolerance induction. Immunization is reflected by the induction of HLA alloantibodies and T cell activation while the induction of tolerance is suggested by the enhanced graft survival in transfused versus non-transfused recipients. The immunological mechanism leading to downregulation of the alloimmune response is not clear. One possible explanation is the induction of a Th2 response by non-professional antigen presentation by the transfused blood cells. On the other hand, evidence is accumulating that the degree of HLA compatibility between transfusion donor and patient is a determining factor. Transfusions sharing at least one HLA-DR antigen with the recipient induce tolerance while fully HLA-DR mismatched transfusions lead to immunization. The importance of the degree of HLA-DR sharing suggests a central role for CD4+ regulatory T cells. We hypothesize that indirect recognition of an allopeptide in the context of self-HLA-DR on the transfusion donor by CD4+ T cells of the recipient might be the clue to tolerance induction. Preliminary data show indeed that CD4+ T cells specific for an allopeptide in the context of self HLA-DR are able to downregulate the alloimmune response of autologous T cells. Further analysis of transplanted patients, who have received an HLA-DR shared transfusion, should reveal whether such CD4+ regulatory T cells are indeed responsible for the beneficial effect of pretransplant blood transfusions.

The importance of H2 haplotype sharing in the induction of specific unresponsiveness by pretransplant blood transfusions

BACKGROUND

The beneficial effect on graft survival achieved by pretransplant blood transfusions is well established. Previous studies have shown that the degree of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) (mis)-match between the transfusion donor and the recipient plays a determining role. However, other factors are also involved. In this study, we explored the hypothesis that, in addition to sharing of MHC antigens between the transfusion donor and the recipient, the MHC type of the organ donor is also of importance.

METHODS

To mimic the human situation, F1 mice, rather than inbred strains, were pretreated with haplotype-shared allogeneic whole blood transfusions and transplanted with hearts of organ donors with different matched or mismatched H2 haplotypes.

RESULTS

When a heart was transplanted 1 week after donor-specific transfusion (DST; blood transfusion donor=organ donor), an excellent prolongation of graft survival was obtained (median survival time: 77 days vs. 9 days in untreated mice). However, this was only the case when a haplotype was shared with the recipient; a DST given with no match between organ donor (=BT donor) and recipient did not induce any prolongation. Furthermore, in order to obtain the optimal beneficial effect of a haplotype-shared blood transfusion, the other haplotype of the transfusion donor had to be mismatched with the recipient. The immunogenetic studies showed that haplotype-shared blood transfusions in combinations where the H2 type of the organ donor differed from that of the transfusion donor are less efficient in inducing prolongation of graft survival.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate that haplotype-shared blood transfusions can induce a significantly prolonged survival of cardiac allografts in F1 mice. The immunogenetic studies suggest that presentation of alloantigen-derived peptides in the context of self MHC (the indirect pathway of allorecognition) is essential for the beneficial effect of haplotype-shared blood transfusions.

Immunoregulation by CD4 T cells in the induction of specific immunological unresponsiveness to alloantigens in vivo: evidence for a reduction in the frequency of alloantigen-specific cytotoxic T cells in vitro

Donor-specific unresponsiveness to allogeneic cardiac allografts in mice can be induced by the combined pretreatment with donor alloantigen and anti-CD4 antibody (anti-CD4+DST). We have investigated whether the induction of unresponsiveness in this model is due to the presence of T cells that regulate immune responsiveness towards the allograft. First, we analysed the functional characteristics of splenocytes from pretreated mice at the time of transplantation. A significant reduction in the frequency of donor specific cytotoxic precursor was found only after the anti-CD4+DST treatment. Next, we designed an in vitro assay to identify the phenotype of the splenocyte population responsible. CD4+ and CD4- fractions were purified from mice treated with anti-CD4+DST or anti-CD4 alone (controls) by cell sorting. Interestingly, only the addition of CD4+ cells from anti-CD4+DST treated mice resulted in a selective reduction and a bimodal distribution in the donor specific CTLp response, indicating the presence of a regulatory population. CD4+ cells from controls did not have this effect. These in vitro findings were substantiated by adoptive transfer experiments in vivo. These data demonstrate that CD4+ cells with the ability to regulate immune responsiveness to a cardiac allograft are present at the time of transplantation following pretreatment with donor alloantigen in combination with anti-CD4.

HLA-DRB1 amino acid disparity is the major stimulus of interleukin-2 production by alloreactive helper T-lymphocytes

The generation of interleukin-2 (IL-2)-mediated helper activity is a central step in the immune response induced by allogeneic histocompatibility antigens, and IL-2-producing helper T-lymphocyte precursor (HTLp) frequencies have been proposed as a measure of alloreactivity in transplant recipients. We analyzed the influence of HLA-matching on the alloresponse of HTLp in limiting dilution assays derived from healthy individuals. Mean HTLp frequencies were significantly higher in HLA-DR antigen-mismatched than HLA-DR-matched combinations. Significant differences in the effect of one or two mismatched HLA-DR antigens on mean HTLp frequencies were also detected. Mean HLA class I (HLA-A, -B, -Cw) mismatches were not significantly different in each group and had no apparent influence on HTLp frequencies. Analysis of HLA protein sequence disparities revealed no significant difference in the number of mismatched amino acid residues at the HLA-DRB1 locus between one and two HLA-DR antigen-mismatched combinations but correlated strongly with HTLp frequency. The positive correlation was evident with mismatched residues in the beta sheet and alpha helical regions of the HLA-DRB1 molecule, suggesting a predominant influence of bound peptides in the stimulation of alloreactive helper cells. This finding was supported by analysis of the location of individual residue mismatches. Evidence of an effect of polymorphism in the CD4-binding region in the beta-2 domain of HLA-DRB1 molecules was also found. Our results demonstrate the major influence of HLA-DR amino acid sequence mismatching on alloreactive HTLp frequencies but also suggest that additional genetic or environmental influences affect the alloreactive helper T-cell repertoire.

Resting B cells as tolerogens in vivo but only for minor histocompatibility antigens: evidence for activation of resting B cells in vivo

BACKGROUND

Small, resting B cells (rB cells) express major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules but not the putative costimulatory molecules, B7-1 (CD80) and B7-2 (CD86); they are classified as nonprofessional antigen-presenting cells. rB cells have been shown to be capable of anergizing T cells in vitro and inducing the prolonged survival of skin grafts mismatched for a single minor histocompatibility (miH) antigen, H-Y. The aim of this study was to investigate ability of rB cells to induce unresponsiveness to multiple miH and MHC antigens.

METHODS

Mice were pretreated with 1 x 10(7) donor rB cells 14 days before transplantation of cardiac grafts mismatched for either a single or multiple miH and/or MHC antigens in vivo.

RESULTS

rB cells induced indefinite prolongation of cardiac grafts mismatched for H-Y antigen (C57BL/10 male to female). Moreover, 50% of grafts mismatched for multiple miH antigens (C3H to CBA) were accepted indefinitely in recipients treated with donor rB cells. In marked contrast, when grafts were mismatched for either a single MHC class I antigen, Kb (CBK to CBA), or multiple MHC and miH antigens (C57BL/10 to C3H), pretreatment with rB cells did not prolong graft survival. To investigate why rB cells were ineffective tolerogens for grafts mismatched for MHC antigens, we examined the fate of the cells in vivo. We demonstrate that, after intravenous injection of rB cells, expression of B7-2 was induced within 24 hr.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that rB cells may be less effective at inducing specific unresponsiveness to MHC antigens because of their rapid activation in vivo.

Deletion of alloantigen-reactive thymocytes as a mechanism of adult tolerance induction following intrathymic antigen administration

Direct injection of foreign antigen into the adult thymus is a potent route of antigen delivery for the induction of tolerance in vivo. In this report, we demonstrate that tolerance to C57BL/10 (H2b/BL10) alloantigens can be induced in CBA/Ca (H2k/CBA) mice by intrathymic (IT) administration of BL10 spleen leukocytes coincident with transient peripheral immunomodulation of CD4+ T cells using a depleting anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody. T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic mice (BM3.6; H2k) expressing a CD8-independent TCR specific for H2Kb were used as recipients to facilitate investigation of the mechanisms responsible for tolerance induction by allowing visualization of events in the thymus following IT injection. IT administration of 5 x 10(7) BL10 spleen leukocytes and concomitant transient peripheral T cell depletion in BM3.6 mice resulted in a substantial H2Kb-specific deletion of transgenic-TCR+ (tg-TCR) thymocytes which was dependent on the level of tg-TCR expression. IT deletion and the failure to export CD8+ T cells to the peripheral lymphoid organs correlated with the induction of tolerance to H2Kb; TCR transgenic mice that had received IT injection of BL10 splenocytes and peripheral T cell depletion accepted a H2Kb+ cardiac allograft indefinitely. Analysis of tolerant BM3.6 mice revealed that there were low numbers of CD8+ T cells in the periphery giving rise to a substantially reduced reactivity in vitro despite the fact that no donor cells or IT deletion were observed in the thymi of the majority of tolerant mice. These results demonstrate for the first time that IT injection of foreign alloantigen into an adult thymus results in the deletion of thymocytes expressing a TCR specific for the injected alloantigen and suggest that this is an important mechanism of tolerance induction following IT injection of alloantigen in vivo. Furthermore, analysis of tolerant TCR-transgenic mice suggests that IT deletion is not required for the maintenance of tolerance, and that peripheral mechanisms enforce continued hyporesponsiveness to H2Kb following transplantation.