Production of offspring after sperm chromosome screening: an experiment using the mouse model

STUDY QUESTION

Is it possible to produce offspring after sperm chromosome screening?

SUMMARY ANSWER

It is possible to produce zygotes after examining the genome of individual spermatozoa prior to embryo production.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Chromosomal aberrations in gametes are a major cause of pregnancy loss in women treated with assisted reproductive technology. However, to our knowledge, there are no reports on the successful genomic screening of spermatozoa, although some attempts have been made using the mouse as a model.

STUDY DESIGN

To prevent the transmission of chromosomal aberrations from fathers to offspring, we performed sperm chromosome screening (SCS) prior to fertilization using the mouse as a model. The production of offspring after SCS consists of (i) replication of the sperm chromosomes, (ii) analysis of one copy of the replicated sperm chromosomes, (iii) construction of a zygote using another set of chromosomes and (iv) production of a transferable embryo.

MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

A single spermatozoon of a male mouse, with or without a Robertsonian translocation, was injected into an enucleated oocyte to allow the replication of sperm chromosomes. One of the sister blastomeres of a haploid androgenic 2-cell embryo was used for chromosome analysis. The other blastomere was fused with an unfertilized oocyte, activated and allowed to develop to a blastocyst before transfer to a surrogate mother.

MAIN RESULTS AND ROLE OF CHANCE

With high efficiency, we were able to analyze sperm chromosomes in a blastomere from the androgenic 2-cell embryos and culture zygotes, with and without aberrant chromosomes, to the blastocyst stage before embryo transfer. The karyotypes of the offspring faithfully reflected those of the blastomeres used for SCS.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

This study was conducted using a mouse model; whether or not the method is applicable to humans is not known.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

This study has shown that it is possible to produce zygotes without any paternally inherited aberrations by examining the genome of individual spermatozoa prior to embryo production.

377 SPERMATOZOA RETRIEVED FROM MALE MICE FROZEN FOR 15 YEARS CAN PRODUCE NORMAL OFFSPRING

Cryopreservation of male germ cells is a strategy to conserve animal species and strains of animals valuable to biomedical research. However, to minimize damage that may occur during freezing and thawing, complex cryopreservation protocols that have been optimized for the stage and species of male germ cells are usually employed. Recently, we have found that mouse male germ cells can be cryopreserved at -80�C by freezing the whole epididymides and testes without cryoprotectant for at least one year (Ogonuki et al. 2006 Reprod. Fertil. Dev. 18, 286 abst). This study was undertaken to determine whether mouse male germ cells retrieved from the bodies of mice frozen at -20�C for 15 years could produce normal offspring by microinsemination. Mature males of BALB/c-nude and C3H/He (8 weeks of age) were euthanized by overdose of pentobarbital on February 20 and March 8, 1991, respectively, and kept in a -20�C freezer. The frozen body was thawed about 15 years after freezing (February 2006) by putting it in a water bath until the outer surface of the body was softened. The body was then removed from the water, and the testes were isolated through an abdominal incision. Testicular spermatozoa were collected from the testes and microinseminated into B6D2F1 oocytes. Within 24 h after sperm injection, over 80% of oocytes developed into 2-cell embryos. Apparently normal pups were born after embryo transfer in both strains of mice at rates of 21% (17/81) and 12% (12/97) per transfer, respectively. Two pups from the BALB/c-nude group died shortly after Caesarian section due to respiratory failure, but others grew normally and were proven to be fertile when they matured (at least 19 mice out of 20 mice tested). We further mated these F1 offspring and confirmed that the nude gene was safely propagated. The present study demonstrates that spermatozoa can retain their fertilizing ability in frozen whole bodies for longer than we anticipated. If spermatozoa of extinct mammalian species (e.g. woolly mammoth) can be retrieved from animal bodies that were kept frozen in permanent frost, live animals might be restored by injecting them into oocytes from females of closely related species.

Fertilization and developmental initiation of oocytes by injection of spermatozoa and pre-spermatozoal cells

The essence of fertilization is the union and mingling of male and female genomes. Therefore it is not surprising that microsurgical deposition of a single spermatozoon in an oocyte (ICSI) results in the development of normal offspring. Poorly motile or structurally aberrant spermatozoa, which are unable to fertilize under ordinary conditions, are not necessarily genomically abnormal. This is the reason why normal offspring are obtained after ICSI using such spermatozoa. At present, ICSI is most successful in humans and mice, but there is no reason to believe that ICSI does not work in other animal species as well. Injection of round spermatids into oocytes (ROSI) works routinely in the mouse, but it is controversial in humans. While some investigators have claimed successes, many others have reported complete failure. There must be several reasons for this, including the difficulty of distinguishing true spermatids from other small cells. Insufficient oocyte activation following ROSI and the functional immaturity of the centrosome could also be responsible for this. In mice, it is possible to obtain normal offspring by injection of primary or secondary spermatocytes into oocytes. The nucleus of a spermatocyte undergoes meiotic division(s) within the oocyte's cytoplasm before a haploid sperm pronucleus unites with an oocyte's haploid pronucleus. However, only a few of the produced zygotes have developed into fertile offspring. There are many hurdles to clear before ROSI and spermatocyte injection becomes efficient and medically safe methods for assisted fertilization.

Reproductive semi-cloning respecting biparental origin. A biologically unsound principle

The original debate article proposed the use of "semi-cloning" as a viable method for assisted reproduction. This debate counters the proposal as being biologically unsound. Given the fundamental limitations of chromosomal segregation and genomic imprinting, the notion of using the MII oocyte to drive haploidization of a somatic cell genome and thereby obtain a substitute for authentic gametes is ill-conceived and untenable.

Adult murine neurons: their chromatin and chromosome changes and failure to support embryonic development as revealed by nuclear transfer

Fully differentiated neurons in adult mammalian brains do not divide; consequently, their metaphase chromosomes have never been examined. Here we report metaphase chromosome constitutions of cortical neurons in adult mice visualized by a nuclear transfer technique. We found that although some reconstructed oocytes cloned from neuronal nuclei have an apparently normal karyotype, the majority do not. Regardless of chromosome morphology, nuclei of adult neurons totally lack the ability to support embryonic development. These findings support the hypothesis that fully differentiated neurons in adult mammalian brains are genomically altered.

Cloning: experience from the mouse and other animals

Cloning mammals has been successful for many years by splitting an early embryo or transferring embryonic cell nuclei into enucleated oocytes. Cloning is now possible with adult somatic cells. At present, cloning efficiency--as determined by the proportion of live offspring developed from all oocytes that received donor cell nuclei--is low regardless of the cell type (including, embryonic stem (ES) cells) and animal species used. In all animals, except of Japanese black beef cattle, the vast majority (>97%) of cloned embryos perish before reaching full term. Even in the Japanese cattle, less than 20% of cloned embryos reach the adulthood. This low efficiency of cloning seems to be due largely to faulty epigenetic reprogramming of donor cell nuclei after transfer into recipient oocytes. Cloned embryos with major epigenetic errors die before or soon after implantation. Those with relatively 'minor' epigenetic errors may survive birth and reach adulthood. We found that almost all fetuses of inbred mice die at birth from respiratory problems, while those of hybrid mice do not, suggesting that genomic heterogeneity masks-to some extent-faulty epigenetic errors. Thus far, the majority of cloned mice that survived birth, had a normal life span and were fertile. However, these animals may not be totally free of health problems. Postpubertal obesity in certain strains of mice is one example. A trial and error approach may discover better cells for cloning, but it would be wiser to understand the molecular mechanisms of epigenetic nuclear programming and reprogramming to find the way to make cloning safer and more efficient. The relatively high cloning success rate in the Japanese black cattle may provide us a clue of solving the problem of high mortality of cloned offspring.

Gamete manipulation for development: new methods for conception

Mammalian oocytes microsurgically injected with spermatozoa can develop into normal offspring. Apparently the oocyte has the ability to decompose or eliminate such sperm components as the plasma membrane and acrosomal contents, which normally do not enter its cytoplasm. Species in which normal offspring were obtained by direct sperm injection include: human, mouse, rabbit, horse, sheep, cattle, pig, and monkey. In the mouse, normal offspring can also be obtained routinely by the injection of round spermatid nuclei into oocytes. This suggests that all post-meiotic modifications of spermatozoa (spermiogenesis, sperm maturation, capacitation and the acrosome reaction) evolved as processes solely dedicated to delivering male genomes into female gametes. Birth of normal offspring after injection of spermatocytes into maturing or mature oocytes suggests that the mechanisms controlling meiosis of male and female germ cells are similar, if not the same. Spermatozoa do not need to be morphologically normal or alive in the conventional sense to participate in embryo development; as long as they have intact genomes, they are able to produce normal offspring. Chromosomes within the first and second polar bodies can be used as substitutes for female pronuclei for the production of normal offspring. The nuclei of adult somatic cells can be used for production of animals. This procedure, involving introduction of cell nuclei into enucleated oocytes (genomic cloning), is rather inefficient at present. Many obstacles must be overcome before it is accepted as a safe, novel method to reproduce scientifically, medically or economically valuable animals. For human cloning the prime consideration must be the welfare of the child.

Birth of normal calves after intracytoplasmic sperm injection of bovine oocytes: a methodological approach

Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) is advantageous when only very few spermatozoa are available for insemination. Bovine spermatozoa were injected individually into matured oocytes using a piezo electric actuator. Spermatozoa were "immobilized", by scoring their tails immediately before injection, or "killed", by repeated freezing and thawing. About 4 h after ICSI, the oocytes with two polar bodies (activated by sperm injection) were selected and treated 5 min with 7% ethanol before further culture. When examined 19-21 h after ICSI, nearly 90% of the oocytes were fertilized normally (two pronuclei and two polar bodies) irrespective of the sperm treatment (immobilization or killing) prior to ICSI, but subsequent preimplantation embryo development was much superior (cleavage 72%: blastocysts 20%) after ICSI with immobilized spermatozoa than by using killed spermatozoa (cleavage 28%; blastocysts 1%). Ethanol activation of bovine oocytes with two polar bodies 4 h after ICSI improved the cleavage (33% versus 72%) and blastocyst (12% versus 20%) rates markedly (P < 0.05). Five normal calves were born after transplantation of ten blastocysts to ten surrogate cows. These results show that piezo-ICSI using immobilized spermatozoa, combined with ethanol treatment of sperm-injected oocytes, is an effective method to produce bovine offspring.

Fertilization without spermatozoa

Mammalian spermatozoa first acquire the ability to fertilize oocytes as they pass through the epididymis to mature. Due to recent advances in microinsemination techniques, not only mature spermatozoa, but also immature sperm cells at certain stages in the testis, have been used to construct diploid zygotes, some of which subsequently develop to normal offspring. Using round spermatids, the most youngest haploid male germ cells, normal births have been reported in the mouse, rabbit, and human. Furthermore, in the mouse, secondary and primary spermatocytes also support full term development after incorporation into immature or mature homologous oocytes. Spermatogenic cells of several species can be cryopreserved easily in simple cryoprotectant solutions. Thus, the microinsemination techniques using spermatogenic cells give us a way to treat infertility, and provide valuable information on gametogenesis, including spermatogenesis, meiosis, and genomic imprinting.

Placentomegaly in cloned mouse concepti caused by expansion of the spongiotrophoblast layer

Hypertrophic placenta, or placentomegaly, has been reported in cloned cattle and mouse concepti, although their placentation processes are quite different from each other. It is therefore tempting to assume that common mechanisms underlie the impact of somatic cell cloning on development of the trophoblast cell lineage that gives rise to the greater part of fetal placenta. To characterize the nature of placentomegaly in cloned mouse concepti, we histologically examined term cloned mouse placentas and assessed expression of a number of genes. A prominent morphological abnormality commonly found among all cloned mouse placentas examined was expansion of the spongiotrophoblast layer, with an increased number of glycogen cells and enlarged spongiotrophoblast cells. Enlargement of trophoblast giant cells and disorganization of the labyrinth layer were also seen. Despite the morphological abnormalities, in situ hybridization analysis of spatiotemporally regulated placenta-specific genes did not reveal any drastic disturbances. Although repression of some imprinted genes was found in Northern hybridization analysis, it was concluded that this was mostly due to the reduced proportion of the labyrinth layer in the entire placenta, not to impaired transcriptional activity. Interestingly, however, cloned mouse fetuses appeared to be smaller than those of litter size-matched controls, suggesting that cloned mouse fetuses were under a latent negative effect on their growth, probably because the placentas are not fully functional. Thus, a major cause of placentomegaly is expansion of the spongiotrophoblast layer, which consequently disturbs the architecture of the layers in the placenta and partially damages its function.

Assessment of the developmental totipotency of neural cells in the cerebral cortex of mouse embryo by nuclear transfer

When neural cells were collected from the entire cerebral cortex of developing mouse fetuses (15.5-17.5 days postcoitum) and their nuclei were transferred into enucleated oocytes, 5.5% of the reconstructed oocytes developed into normal offspring. This success rate was the highest among all previous mouse cloning experiments that used somatic cells. Forty-four percent of live embryos at 10.5 days postcoitum were morphologically normal when premature and early-postmitotic neural cells from the ventricular side of the cortex were used. In contrast, the majority (95%) of embryos were morphologically abnormal (including structural abnormalities in the neural tube) when postmitotic-differentiated neurons from the pial side of the cortex were used for cloning. Whereas 4.3% of embryos cloned with ventricular-side cells developed into healthy offspring, only 0.5% of those cloned with differentiated neurons in the pial side did so. These facts seem to suggest that the nuclei of neural cells in advanced stages of differentiation had lost their developmental totipotency. The underlying mechanism for this developmental limitation could be somatic DNA rearrangements in differentiating neural cells.

Maintenance of genetic integrity in frozen and freeze-dried mouse spermatozoa

Chromosome stability was maintained in mouse spermatozoa after freeze-drying or freezing without cryoprotection in a simple Tris.HCl buffer containing EGTA (50 mM) and NaCl (50 mM). The ability of spermatozoa to activate oocytes spontaneously was not destroyed by freeze-drying or freezing without cryoprotection in this solution. Embryos derived after injecting oocytes with sperm heads from rehydrated freeze-dried and from thawed spermatozoa developed normally. Provided the DNA integrity of the sperm nucleus is maintained, embryos can be generated by the intracytoplasmic sperm injection technique (ICSI) from severely damaged spermatozoa that are no longer capable of normal physiological activity. This procedure was effective for preserving spermatozoa from strains (C57BL/6J, 129/SvJ, and BALB/c) in which the fertility of spermatozoa frozen conventionally is extremely poor. The technique provides an effective means of storing mouse spermatozoa from many different inbred, mutant, and transgenic strains for biomedical research.

Contribution of cumulus cells and serum to the maturation of oocyte cytoplasm as revealed by intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI)

The fertilisability and developmental capacity of mouse oocytes matured in vitro were examined by in vitro fertilisation (IVF) and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI). While more than 50% of cumulus-enclosed oocytes were fertilised by IVF after maturation in serum-supplemented medium, none were fertilised when the oocytes matured without serum. By ICSI, the majority (78-94%) of the oocytes were fertilised regardless of the presence or absence of serum in oocyte maturation media. Although the majority (88-92%) of cumulus-free germinal vesicle oocytes underwent nuclear maturation in both serum-free and serum-containing media, those matured in the presence of serum were more readily fertilised by ICSI (43%) than those matured without it (3-5%). The cumulus-free oocytes co-cultured with cumulus cells but without serum were fertilised at 36%, suggesting some secreted factor promotes the oocyte's cytoplasmic maturation. The oocytes fertilised by ICSI developed into normal-term fetuses regardless of the presence or absence of serum or cumulus cells in oocyte maturation medium. These results lead us to conclude that (a) the cytoplasm of the oocytes can mature in serum-free medium and (b) the presence of both the serum and the cumulus cells in the medium surrounding maturing oocytes is beneficial for the development of the fertilisation- and development-competence of oocyte cytoplasm.

Comparison of intracytoplasmic sperm injection for inbred and hybrid mice

We compared the results of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) that leads to full term development of hybrid (B6C3F1 and B6D2F1) and inbred (C57BL/6) mouse embryos. Although fertilization and pre-implantation development of C57BL/6 eggs were similar to those of F1 hybrid eggs, post-implantation development of the embryos from C57BL/6 females was significantly poorer than those of the eggs from hybrid females. Reciprocal crosses of C57BL/6 and B6C3F1 gametes revealed that the low rate of post-implantation development of C57BL/6 embryos was due to oocyte factor(s), rather than the sperm factor.

Live human germ cells in the context of their spermatogenic stages

BACKGROUND

Various types of live, dispersed, human testicular cells in vitro were previously compared with the morphologic characteristics of human spermatogenic germ cells in situ within seminiferous tubules. The current study extends those observations by placing live human germ cells in the context of their developmental steps and stages of the spermatogenic cycle.

METHODS

Live human testicular tissue was obtained from an organ-donating, brain-dead person. A cell suspension was obtained by enzymatic digestion, and dispersed cells were observed live with Nomarski optics. Testes from 10 men were obtained at autopsy within ten hours of death, fixed in glutaraldehyde, further fixed in osmium, embedded in Epon, sectioned at 20 microm, and observed unstained by Nomarski optics.

RESULTS

In both live and fixed preparations, Sertoli cells have oval to pear-shaped nuclei with indented nuclear envelopes and large nucleoli, which makes their appearance distinctly different from germ cells. For germ cells, size, shape, and chromatic pattern of nuclei, the presence of meiotic metaphase figures, acrosomic vesicles/structures, tails, and/or mitochondria in the middle piece are characteristically seen in live dispersed cells and those in the fixed seminiferous tubules. These lead to identification of live germ cells in man and placement of each in the context of their developmental steps of spermatogenesis at corresponding stages of the spermatogenic cycle.

CONCLUSIONS

This comparative approach allows verification of the identity of individual germ cells seen in vitro and provides a checklist of distinguishing characteristics of live human germ cells to be used in clinical procedures or by scientists interested in studying live cells at known steps in spermatogenic development characteristic of germ cells in specific stages of the spermatogenic cycle.

Epigenetic instability in ES cells and cloned mice

Cloning by nuclear transfer (NT) is an inefficient process in which most clones die before birth and survivors often display growth abnormalities. In an effort to correlate gene expression with survival and fetal overgrowth, we have examined imprinted gene expression in both mice cloned by nuclear transfer and in the embryonic stem (ES) cell donor populations from which they were derived. The epigenetic state of the ES cell genome was found to be extremely unstable. Similarly, variation in imprinted gene expression was observed in most cloned mice, even in those derived from ES cells of the same subclone. Many of the animals survived to adulthood despite widespread gene dysregulation, indicating that mammalian development may be rather tolerant to epigenetic aberrations of the genome. These data imply that even apparently normal cloned animals may have subtle abnormalities in gene expression.

Effect of cytokinesis inhibitors, DMSO and the timing of oocyte activation on mouse cloning using cumulus cell nuclei

Cloning methods are now well described and in almost routine use. However, the frequencies of production of live offspring from activated oocytes remain at < 3% and little is known about the factors that affect these frequencies. The effects of cytokinesis inhibitors, dimethylsulphoxide (DMSO) and the cell cycle of recipient cytoplasm on the cloning of mice were examined. Reconstructed oocytes, which were activated immediately after nucleus injection and cultured without cytochalasin B, developed into blastocysts at a frequency of 30--54% and into live cloned offspring at a frequency of 2--3%. Activated zygotes did not support development to full term after nuclear transfer. Reconstructed oocytes were activated 1--3 h after nuclear transfer and were exposed separately to three inhibitors of cytokinesis (cytochalasin B, cytochalasin D or nocodazole) to examine the toxicity of these inhibitors on cloning. All of the oocytes exposed to nocodazole-containing media formed many small pseudo-pronuclei, whereas with cytochalasin-containing media most of the activated oocytes formed only two pseudo-pronuclei. Despite such differences, 42--61% of reconstructed embryos developed to the morula-blastocyst stage and 1--3% developed to full term in all groups. Addition of 1% (v/v) DMSO to the activation medium significantly improved the frequency of development to the blastocyst stage and full term; however, this improvement did not lead to a higher success rate in the generation of live cloned offspring. These results show that activated mouse oocytes/zygotes are not effective cytoplasmic recipients with the methods described and that the lack of success of cloning is not due to inhibition of cytokinesis.

DNA methylation variation in cloned mice

Mammalian cloning has been accomplished in several mammalian species by nuclear transfer. However, the production rate of cloned animals is quite low, and many cloned offspring die or show abnormal symptoms. A possible cause of the low success rate of cloning and abnormal symptoms in many cloned animals is the incomplete reestablishment of DNA methylation after nuclear transfer. We first analyzed tissue-specific methylation patterns in the placenta, skin, and kidney of normal B6D2F1 mice. There were seven spots/CpG islands (0.5% of the total CpG islands detected) methylated differently in the three different tissues examined. In the placenta and skin of two cloned fetuses, a total of four CpG islands were aberrantly methylated or unmethylated. Interestingly, three of these four loci corresponded to the tissue-specific loci in the normal control fetuses. The extent of aberrant methylation of genomic DNA varied between the cloned animals. In cloned animals, aberrant methylation occurred mainly at tissue-specific methylated loci. Individual cloned animals have different methylation aberrations. In other words, cloned animals are by no means perfect copies of the original animals as far as the methylation status of genomic DNA is concerned.

Hybrid vigor, fetal overgrowth, and viability of mice derived by nuclear cloning and tetraploid embryo complementation

To assess whether heterozygosity of the donor cell genome was a general parameter crucial for long-term survival of cloned animals, we tested the ability of embryonic stem (ES) cells with either an inbred or F(1) genetic background to generate cloned mice by nuclear transfer. Most clones derived from five F(1) ES cell lines survived to adulthood. In contrast, clones from three inbred ES cell lines invariably died shortly after birth due to respiratory failure. Comparison of mice derived from nuclear cloning, in which a complete blastocyst is derived from a single ES cell, and tetraploid blastocyst complementation, in which only the inner cell mass is formed from a few injected ES cells, allows us to determine which phenotypes depend on the technique or on the characteristics of the ES cell line. Neonatal lethality also has been reported in mice entirely derived from inbred ES cells that had been injected into tetraploid blastocysts (ES cell-tetraploids). Like inbred clones, ES cell-tetraploid pups derived from inbred ES cell lines died shortly after delivery with signs of respiratory distress. In contrast, most ES cell-tetraploid neonates, derived from six F(1) ES cell lines, developed into fertile adults. Cloned pups obtained from both inbred and F(1) ES cell nuclei frequently displayed increased placental and birth weights whereas ES cell-tetraploid pups were of normal weight. The potency of F(1) ES cells to generate live, fertile adults was not lost after either long-term in vitro culture or serial gene targeting events. We conclude that genetic heterozygosity is a crucial parameter for postnatal survival of mice that are entirely derived from ES cells by either nuclear cloning or tetraploid embryo complementation. In addition, our results demonstrate that tetraploid embryo complementation using F(1) ES cells represents a simple, efficient procedure for deriving animals with complex genetic alterations without the need for a chimeric intermediate.

Mouse cloning with nucleus donor cells of different age and type

We have tested different cell types as sources for nucleus donors to determine differences in cloning efficiency. When donor nuclei were isolated from cumulus cells and injected into recipient oocytes from adult hybrid mice (B6D2F1 and B6C3F1), the success rate of cloning was 1.5-1.9%. When cumulus cell donor nuclei were isolated from adult inbred mice (C57BL/6, C3H/He, DBA/2, 129/SvJ, and 129/SvEvTac), reconstructed oocytes did not develop to full term or resulted in a very low success rate (0-0.3%) with the exception of 129 strains which yielded 0.7-1.4% live young. When fetal (13.5-15.5 dpc), ovarian, and testicular cells were used as nucleus donors, 2.2 and 1.0% of reconstructed oocytes developed into live offspring, respectively. When various types of adult somatic cells (fibroblasts, thymocytes, spleen cells, and macrophages) were used, oocytes receiving thymocyte nuclei never developed beyond implantation, whereas those receiving the nuclei of other cell types did. These results indicate that adult somatic cells are not necessarily inferior to younger cells (fetal and ES cells) in the context of mouse cloning. Although fetal cells are believed to have less genetic damage than adult somatic cells, the success rate of cloning using any cell types were very low. This may largely be due to technical problems and/or problems of genomic reprogramming by oocytes rather than the accumulation of mutational damage in adult somatic cells.

Offspring from normal mouse oocytes injected with sperm heads from the azh/azh mouse display more severe sperm tail abnormalities than the original mutant

Sperm with abnormalities in the position and shape of the head were obtained from the azh/azh mutant and injected into the cytoplasm of mature mouse oocytes to determine whether sperm from the offspring display both head (club shape) and tail (looping, folding, and fusion) abnormalities observed in the mutant donor. Although quantitative differences were observed among the three examined offspring, we found that abnormalities in sperm head shape were less frequent than in the donor mutant, but that tail malformations predominated. In addition, we found that the frequency of tail abnormalities increased during sperm epididymal transit. A typical defect was the multiple folding of the sperm tail and eventual fusion of closely apposed plasma membranes. As a consequence, sperm forward motility and natural fertility were compromised. Results of this study indicate that the azh/azh mutant and offspring generated by intracytoplasmic sperm injection provide a valuable model for determining the role of the manchette and keratin-containing outer dense fibers and fibrous sheath during spermiogenesis. Furthermore, our findings stress the risk of enhancing a phenotypic abnormality caused by mutant male genotypes introduced through bypassing the biologic mechanisms of natural sperm selection during fertilization.

X-Chromosome inactivation in cloned mouse embryos

To study whether cloning resets the epigenetic differences between the two X chromosomes of a somatic female nucleus, we monitored X inactivation in cloned mouse embryos. Both X chromosomes were active during cleavage of cloned embryos, followed by random X inactivation in the embryo proper. In the trophectoderm (TE), X inactivation was nonrandom with the inactivated X of the somatic donor being chosen for inactivation. When female embryonic stem cells with two active X chromosomes were used as donors, random X inactivation was seen in the TE and embryo. These results demonstrate that epigenetic marks can be removed and reestablished on either X chromosome during cloning. Our results also suggest that the epigenetic marks imposed on the X chromosomes during gametogenesis, responsible for normal imprinted X inactivation in the TE, are functionally equivalent to the marks imposed on the chromosomes during somatic X inactivation.

Mouse embryonic stem (ES) cell lines established from neuronal cell-derived cloned blastocysts

We have established mouse embryonic stem (ES) cell lines from blastocysts derived by transfer of nuclei of fetal neuronal cells. These neuronal cell-derived embryonic cell lines had properties that characterize them as ES cells, including typical cell markers and alkaline phosphatase activity. Moreover, the cells had a normal karyotype and were pluripotent, as they were capable of differentiating into all three germ layers. Although they were derived from neuronal donor nuclei, the cells no longer expressed neuronal markers; however, they were capable of differentiating into cells with neuronal characteristics. These results suggest that the clone-derived cells have fully acquired an ES cell character. Thus, ES cells can be derived from embryos resulting from nuclear transfer, which results in reprogramming of the genetic information and acquisition of pluripotency. ES cells established from somatic cell-derived blastocysts could be useful not only as research tools for studying reprogramming but also as models for cell-based transplantation therapy.

Application of ICSI for cryptorchid therapy

Recent advances are provided in assisted reproductive technology and application of ICSI as treatment for infertile patients with previous cryptorchidism. Fertility rates were 25-81% and 8-48% in patients with unilateral and bilateral cryptorchidism, respectively. With the advent of assisted reproductive technology, pregnancy was not possible without sperm. Research in humans has resulted in pregnancy and live births after the injection of haploid germ cells (round spermatids) into the oocytes. In the mouse tetraploid germ cells (primary spermatocytes), nuclei have been injected into oocytes, which undergo meiosis, forming an embryo and live young. In animal models, round spermatids from both cryptorchid and previously cryptorchid testes can initiate normal embryo development when injected into mature oocytes. These cells may be used as substitutes for mature sperm. However, cryptorchidism in humans is often associated with inherent defects of spermatogenesis. With successive breakthroughs in treatment of impaired fertility associated with cryptorchidism, there is an increased risk of genetic abnormalities in the progeny. It is incumbent on clinicians who are involved in reproductive medicine to proceed cautiously with the development and application of assisted reproductive techniques to avoid creating future generations of genetically abnormal individuals.

Birth of mice after nuclear transfer by electrofusion using tail tip cells

Mice have been successfully cloned from cumulus cells, fibroblast cells, embryonic stem cells, and immature Sertoli cells only after direct injection of their nuclei into enucleated oocytes. This technical feature of mouse nuclear transfer differentiates it from that used in domestic species, where electrofusion is routinely used for nuclear transfer. To examine whether nuclear transfer by electrofusion can be applied to somatic cell cloning in the mouse, we electrofused tail tip fibroblast cells with enucleated oocytes, and then assessed the subsequent in vitro and in vivo development of the reconstructed embryos. The rate of successful nuclear transfer (fusion and nuclear formation) was 68.8% (753/1094) and the rate of development into morulae/blastocysts was 40.8% (260/637). After embryo transfer, seven (six males and one female; 2.5% per transfer) normal fetuses were obtained at 17.5-21.5 dpc. These rates of development in vitro and in vivo are not significantly different from those after cloning by injection (44.7% to morulae/blastocysts and 4.8% to term). These results indicate that nuclear transfer by electrofusion is practical for mouse somatic cell cloning and provide an alternative method when injection of donor nuclei into recipient oocytes is technically difficult.

Sonication per se is not as deleterious to sperm chromosomes as previously inferred

Although sonication is a simple way to immobilize ("kill") spermatozoa prior to injection into oocytes, this has been thought to be destructive to sperm chromosomes. Mouse and human spermatozoa were immobilized by sonication and kept in various media for up to 2 h, then their nuclei were individually injected into mouse oocytes for the analysis of chromosomes at the first cleavage metaphase. In both the mouse and human, incidence of structural chromosome aberrations was much higher in the spermatozoa sonicated and stored in Biggers-Whitten-Whittingham medium for 2 h at 37.5 degrees C than in those stored for 5 min in the same medium. We concluded, therefore, that it is not sonication per se but a prolonged exposure of sperm nuclei to extracellular milieu that is detrimental to sperm chromosomes. The incidence of structural chromosome aberrations of mouse and human spermatozoa was significantly reduced when the spermatozoa were sonicated and stored in K(+)-rich nucleus isolation medium containing EDTA. This suggests that sperm chromosome degradation following sperm immobilization by sonication is partly due to detrimental effects of a Na(+)-rich medium and of DNase on sperm chromatin. Ideally, it should be possible to prepare artificial media that maintain the integrity of sperm chromosomes for many hours after immobilization.

Postnatal growth and behavioral development of mice cloned from adult cumulus cells

Since the first successful cloning of mammals from adult somatic cells, there has been no examination of the learning or behavior of cloned offspring. The possibility of adverse effects on animals produced through adult somatic cell cloning is high because many natural biological processes are bypassed and DNA from adult cells, which presumably contain mutations, are used. In this study, we compared cloned mice produced by microinjection transfer of cumulus cell nuclei into enucleated oocytes, to control mice that were specifically generated to eliminate confounding factors that are unique to our cloning procedure. Postnatal weight gain of clones was significantly greater than that of controls. Preweaning development observations revealed that first appearance or performance of 3 out of 10 measures was delayed in cloned mice; however, results of subsequent tests of learning and memory, activity level, and motor skills were comparable for both groups. Together, these data suggest that nuclear transfer of adult somatic cell nuclei to produce cloned mice may delay the appearance of a few developmental milestones but it does not adversely affect the overall postnatal behavior of mice. In addition, this procedure may cause late onset of significantly increased body weight in cloned offspring, the cause or causes of which are being further examined.

Further evidence that sperm nuclear proteins are necessary for embryogenesis

We have recently presented evidence that the structural integrity of the mouse sperm nuclear matrix may be necessary for the proper unpackaging of sperm DNA for participation in embryogenesis. It is likely that the sperm nuclear matrix contributes to the organisation of the sperm DNA and its disturbance can seriously damage the paternal genome or its expression. In this work, we confirm our previous data and further suggest that even very subtle changes in the sperm nuclear structure may have a significant impact on embryo development. As reported previously, dithiothreitol (DTT) in the presence of an ionic detergent, ATAB, destabilized the nuclear matrix as measured by the halo assay, and oocytes injected with these nuclei failed to develop. We also discovered that omitting the protease inhibitor PMSF from the buffers used to extract spermatozoa prevented sperm injected into oocytes from participating in development. The organization of DNA into loop domains by the nuclear matrix in these nuclei appeared normal, as measured by the halo assay. Oocytes injected with sperm nuclei that had been washed with ATAB in the presence of phenylmethylsulphonyl fluoride (PMSF) but in the absence of DTT resulted in live births. Neither DTT treatment nor the absence of PMSF would be expected to disrupt the integrity of the paternal DNA. The data therefore suggest that even very subtle alterations in the structural proteins of the nucleus are enough to deprive sperm DNA of the ability to contribute to embryonic development.

Mammalian oocyte activation by the synergistic action of discrete sperm head components: induction of calcium transients and involvement of proteolysis

Sperm-borne oocyte-activating factor (SOAF) elicits activation sufficient for full development and originates from sperm head submembrane matrices. SOAF comprises discrete, heat-sensitive and -stable components (referred to here respectively as SOAF-I and -II) which are each necessary but not sufficient to activate oocytes. The heat-sensitive SOAF component, SOAF-I(m), becomes solubilized from the perinuclear matrix under reducing conditions (the SOAF transition) to generate SOAF-I(s). Although calcium transients likely play an important role in oocyte activation at fertilization, the question is open as to whether demembranated heads or SOAF-I(s) and/or SOAF-II can induce calcium transients. We now report that injection of demembranated sperm heads into mouse oocytes efficiently induced Ca(2+) oscillations. When injected independently, SOAF-I(s) and demembranated heads heated to 48 degrees C failed to generate Ca(2+) oscillations. However, co-injection of SOAF-I(s) and 48 degrees C-heated heads induced oscillations, mirroring their synergistic ability to activate oocytes. This suggests that SOAF-mediated activation proceeds via pathways resembling those at fertilization and provides the first direct evidence that multiple sperm components are required to induce Ca(2+) oscillations. We probed the SOAF-I(s) liberation at the center of this activation and show that in vitro it was sensitive to a profile of serine protease inhibitors. These findings support a model in which mammalian oocyte activation, including the induction of calcium transients, involves proteolytic processing of SOAF from sperm head submembrane compartments.

Mice cloned from embryonic stem cells

Cloning allows the asexual reproduction of selected individuals such that the offspring have an essentially identical nuclear genome. Cloning by nuclear transfer thus far has been reported only with freshly isolated cells and cells from primary cultures. We previously reported a method of cloning mice from adult somatic cells after nuclear transfer by microinjection. Here, we apply this method to clone mice from widely available, established embryonic stem (ES) cell lines at late passage. With the ES cell line R1, 29% of reconstructed oocytes developed in vitro to the morula/blastocyst stage, and 8% of these embryos developed to live-born pups when transferred to surrogate mothers. We thus cloned 26 mice from R1 cells. Nuclei from the ES cell line E14 also were shown to direct development to term. We present evidence that the nuclei of ES cells at G(1)- or G(2)/M-phases are efficiently able to support full development. Our findings demonstrate that late-passage ES cells can be used to produce viable cloned mice and provide a link between the technologies of ES cells and animal cloning. It thus may be possible to clone from a single cell a large number of individuals over an extended period.

A comparative morphological study of human germ cells in vitro or in situ within seminiferous tubules

For many infertile couples, intracytoplasmic germ cell/spermatozoon injection into unfertilized eggs may be their only hope for producing their own biological children. Thus far, success with injection of pre-spermatozoan germ cells such as round spermatids has not been as great as that of spermatozoon injection. This could be due in part to the difficulty of identifying younger (less mature) male germ cells in testicular biopsy dispersions. To improve the identification of various types of live, dispersed, human testicular cells in vitro, a comparative study of the morphological characteristics of human spermatogenic germ cells in vitro or in situ within seminiferous tubules was conducted. Live human testicular tissue was obtained from an organ-donating, brain-dead person with a high density of various germ cells. A cell suspension was obtained by enzymatic digestion, and cells were cultured for 3 days in an excessive volume (100-fold medium:cells; v:v) of HEPES-TC 199 medium at 5 degrees C and observed live with Nomarski optics (interference-contrast microscopy). For comparative purposes, testes from ten men obtained at autopsy were fixed, embedded in epoxy resin, sectioned at 20 microm, and observed unstained by Nomarski optics. This approach allowed comparison of morphological characteristics of individual germ cells seen in vitro or in situ in the human testis. In both live and fixed preparations from control men with varied daily sperm production rates, Sertoli cells have oval to pear-shaped nuclei with indented nuclear envelopes and large nucleoli, which makes their appearance distinctly different from germ cells. The size, shape, and chromatin pattern of nuclei, and the presence of meiotic metaphase figures, acrosomic vesicles/structures, tails, and/or mitochondria in the middle piece of germ cells are characteristically seen in live cells in vitro and in those cells observed in the fixed seminiferous tubules. Hence, this comparative approach allows verification of the identity of individual germ cells seen in vitro and provides a checklist of distinguishing characteristics of live human germ cells, to be used by scientists and technical staff in infertility clinics when selecting specific germ cells from a testicular aspirate or enzymatically digested biopsy.

Chromosome analysis of BALB/c mouse spermatozoa with normal and abnormal head morphology

To assess the relationship between mouse sperm head morphology and karyotype, sperm heads with either a normal or an abnormal morphology were injected individually into enucleated mouse oocytes that were karyotyped at the metaphase of the first cleavage. BALB/c male mice that produce an unusually high proportion of morphologically abnormal spermatozoa were used as sperm donors. Abnormal karyotypes were found in a significantly higher proportion of eggs injected with severely misshapen sperm heads (36-38%) as compared to those injected with normal and quasi-normal heads (15-21%) (p < 0.01). Most karyotype abnormalities were structural rather than numerical, the most common being breaks and exchanges of chromosome type in both normal and abnormal spermatozoa.

Comparison of Oocyte-Activating Agents for Mouse Cloning

Since somatic cell components are unable to activate oocytes following injection or fusion, enucleated oocytes receiving adult somatic cells during the cloning process must be activated artificially for their development. We compared the efficiency of four types of oocyte-activating agents: strontium, ethanol, single electric pulse, and spermatozoa. Although strontium was the best in supporting preimplantation development of reconstructed mouse oocytes, there was no significant difference among the four agents with respect to the rate of postimplantation embryo development and the birth of live offspring.

Effect of sperm immobilisation and demembranation on the oocyte activation rate in the mouse

To analyse the effect of the state of the sperm plasma membrane on oocyte activation rate following intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI), three types of human and mouse spermatozoa (intact, immobilised and Triton X-100 treated) were individually injected into mouse oocytes. At 30, 60 and 120 min after injection, maternal chromosomes and sperm nuclei within oocytes were examined. Following human sperm injection, the fastest and the most efficient oocyte activation and sperm head decondensation occurred when the spermatozoa were treated with Triton X-100. Intact spermatozoa were the least effective in activating oocytes. Thus, the rate of mouse oocyte activation following human sperm injection is greatly influenced by the state of the sperm plasma membrane during injection. When mouse spermatozoa were injected into mouse oocytes, the rates of oocyte activation and sperm head decondensation within activated oocytes were the same irrespective of the type of sperm treatment prior to injection. We witnessed that live human spermatozoa injected into moue oocytes often kept moving very actively within the ooplasm for more than 60 min, whereas motile mouse spermatozoa usually became immotile within 20 min after injection into the ooplasm. In 0.002% Triton X-100 solution, mouse spermatozoa are immobilised faster than human spermatozoa. These facts seem to suggest that human sperm plasma membranes are physically and biochemically more stable than those of mouse spermatozoa. Perhaps the physical and chemical properties of the sperm plasma membrane vary from species to species. For those species whose spermatozoa have 'stable' plasma membranes, prior removal or 'damage' of sperm plasma membranes would increase the success rate of ICSI.

Bypassing spermiogenesis for several generations does not have detrimental consequences on the fertility and neurobehavior of offspring: a study using the mouse

PURPOSE

This study was conducted to determine whether the omission of spermiogenesis and all prefertilization events for five generations in mice affects the fertility or behavior of offspring.

METHODS

Fifth-generation hybrid (C57BL/6 x DBA/2) mice were produced using round spermatid injection (ROSI). Control groups consisted of mice born after natural mating with and without sham operation. The growth, fertility, and behavior of offspring were compared. Behavior tests conducted assessed elementary reasoning (Krushinsky test), emotionality (Mouse Defense Test Battery), and spatial learning and memory (Morris water maze).

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in the growth and fertility of fifth-generation ROSI mice compared to natural fertilization mice. We also found no evidence of significant learning or behavioral deficits of the fifth-generation ROSI mice.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, we found no evidence that bypassing the natural biological processes involved in spermiogenesis produces adverse effects on the growth, fertility, or behavior of mouse offspring.

Fertility of mouse spermatozoa retrieved from cadavers and maintained at 4 degrees C

After male animals die, the spermatozoa within the testis and epididymis eventually disintegrate. In this study, the motility, viability and fertility of mouse spermatozoa were examined after retrieval from the epididymis at various days after death. Cadavers were maintained in a refrigerator at 4 degrees C. About 30% of the spermatozoa collected 10 days after death were viable, but they had limited ability to fertilize oocytes in vitro. However, when the spermatozoa were injected into oocytes, the fertilization rate was over 80%. Normal live fetuses were even obtained using immotile spermatozoa retrieved 20 days after death. Therefore, when valuable male animals die unexpectedly and sperm cryopreservation is not possible immediately, temporal storage of cadavers (or epididymis and vas deferens) at 4 degrees C in a regular refrigerator followed by intracytoplasmic sperm injection may help to preserve the genome of individuals. This procedure could be particularly important in endangered species.

Cloning the laboratory mouse

A brief account is given of early attempts to clone mammals (mice) by transferring cells (nuclei) of preimplantation embryos into enucleated oocytes, zygotes or blastomeres of two-cell embryos. This is followed by a brief review of recent successes using adult somatic cells: mammary gland cells for sheep, muscle cells for cattle and cumulus cells for mice. We have developed a technique for cloning the laboratory mouse by transferring cumulus cell nuclei into enucleated oocytes. With this technique, we have produced a population of over 80 cloned animals, and have carried the process over four generations. Development and fertility of these appear normal. However, the yield is very low; only approximately 1% of injected oocytes are carried to term. The challenge is now to understand the reason for this high loss. Is it a problem of technique, genomic reprogramming, somatic mutation, imprinting or incompatible cell cycle phases?

Mammalian transgenesis by intracytoplasmic sperm injection

Coinjection of unfertilized mouse oocytes with sperm heads and exogenous DNA encoding either a green fluorescent protein (GFP) or beta-galactosidase reporter produced 64 to 94 percent transgene-expressing embryos, reflecting DNA-sperm head association before coinjection. Nonselective transfer to surrogate mothers of embryos in the GFP series generated about 20 percent offspring expressing the integrated transgene. These data indicate that exogenous DNA can reproducibly be delivered into an oocyte by microinjected spermatozoa and suggest an adaptable method of transgenesis.

Fate of genetically marked mitochondrial DNA from spermatocytes microinjected into mouse zygotes

Cytoplasts from single spermatocytes of NZB/BinJ mice were separated from the nuclei and individually microinjected into B6D2F1 (C57BL/6 x DNBA/2J) hybrid embryos at the pronuclear stage (20 h after hCG injection). Of 363 zygotes injected, 311 (86%) survived and developed. From these experiments, we transferred 222 embryos into 20 pseudopregnant recipients. Eighteen (90%) became pregnant and 82 pups were born (37% of transfers). Mitochondrial DNA (mt DNA) from the NZB/BinJ strain lacks a RsaI restriction site and can thus be distinguished from the host embryo following PCR amplification. We were unable to detect the transferred mtDNA in blastocysts on day 4-5 after injection. Nor could we detect NZB/BinJ mtDNA in placentae, nor in tissues from mice born to host mothers following the transfer of blastocysts that developed from injected zygotes. Rejection of paternal mitochondria by the embryo normally occurs at the 4- to 8-cell stage in mice and is apparently dependent on mutual recognition between the mitochondria and the nuclear genome. We conclude that this mechanism has probably already developed by the time the germ cells have become committed to meiosis.