Higher autoantibody levels and recognition of a linear NH2-terminal epitope in the autoantigen GAD65, distinguish stiff-man syndrome from insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus

An analysis of the cross-reactivity of autoantibodies to GAD65 and GAD67 in diabetes

Background

Autoantibodies to GAD65 (anti-GAD65) are present in the sera of 70–80% of patients with type 1 diabetes (T1D), but antibodies to the structurally similar 67 kDa isoform GAD67 are rare. Antibodies to GAD67 may represent a cross-reactive population of anti-GAD65, but this has not been formally tested.

Methodology/Principal Findings

In this study we examined the frequency, levels and affinity of anti-GAD67 in diabetes sera that contained anti-GAD65, and compared the specificity of GAD65 and GAD67 reactivity. Anti-GAD65 and anti-GAD67 were measured by radioimmunoprecipitation (RIP) using ¹²⁵I labeled recombinant GAD65 and GAD67. For each antibody population, the specificity of the binding was measured by incubation with 100-fold excess of unlabeled GAD in homologous and heterologous inhibition assays, and the affinity of binding with GAD65 and GAD67 was measured in selected sera. Sera were also tested for reactivity to GAD65 and GAD67 by immunoblotting. Of the 85 sera that contained antibodies to GAD65, 28 contained anti–GAD67 measured by RIP. Inhibition with unlabeled GAD65 substantially or completely reduced antibody reactivity with both ¹²⁵I GAD65 and with ¹²⁵I GAD67. In contrast, unlabeled GAD67 reduced autoantibody reactivity with ¹²⁵I GAD67 but not with ¹²⁵I GAD65. Both populations of antibodies were of high affinity (>10¹⁰ l/mol).

Conclusions

Our findings show that autoantibodies to GAD67 represent a minor population of anti-GAD65 that are reactive with a cross-reactive epitope found also on GAD67. Experimental results confirm that GAD65 is the major autoantigen in T1D, and that GAD67 per se has very low immunogenicity. We discuss our findings in light of the known similarities between the structures of the GAD isoforms, in particular the location of a minor cross-reactive epitope that could be induced by epitope spreading.

A critical update on the immunopathogenesis of Stiff Person Syndrome

BACKGROUND

Stiff Person Syndrome (SPS) is a relatively rare but often overlooked autoimmune neurological disorder that targets antigens within the brain's inhibitory pathways resulting in incapacitating stiffness and spasms that impact on the patients' quality of life. Although a number of immunomodulating therapies significantly improve the patients' symptoms, the exact pathogenic mechanisms remain unclear.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The current literature on SPS was reviewed and combined with the authors' experience with many patients and various laboratory studies. The majority of the patients have high-titre anti-GAD (Glutamic Acid Decarboxylase) antibodies in the sera and CSF suggesting dysfunction of the GABAergic neurotransmission. These antibodies are excellent disease markers but their pathogenic role remains uncertain.

CONCLUSIONS

This review provides a critical assessment on the immunobiology of SPS, describes the identification of anti-GABARAP antibodies as a new antigenic target in the GABAergic synapse and identifies the areas for future research.

Anxious depression and the stiff-person plus syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To present the case of a patient with anxiety and depressive symptoms who developed the clinical picture of stiff-person plus syndrome (SPS-plus).

BACKGROUND

Before the onset of typical SPS symptoms, psychiatric symptoms (like depression and anxiety) may be prominent and as such misleading, resulting in the diagnosis of a psychiatric condition.

METHOD

We describe the case of a woman who initially presented with anxious depression and remained resistant to treatment with different classes of antidepressants and additional therapy with lithium and atypical antipsychotics.

RESULTS

Evidence of neurologic dysfunction and significantly increased levels of serum autoantibodies for glutamic acid decarboxylase supported the diagnosis of SPS. The patient appeared to benefit from short-term immunosuppressive therapy with methylprednisolone.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors believe that anxious depression and SPS-plus seen in this patient are the result of the same underlying autoimmune process, together forming a unique syndrome. Anxious and depressive symptoms in SPS can be explained by alterations in GABAergic neurotransmission.

A case of stiff-person syndrome, type 1 diabetes, celiac disease and dermatitis herpetiformis

Antibodies against glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) are involved in the pathophysiology of stiff-person syndrome (SPS) and type 1 diabetes. GAD catalyses the conversion of glutamate to gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA). GABA acts as a neurotransmitter between neurones, while in pancreatic beta cells it plays an integral role in normal insulin secretion, hence the clinical presentation of muscular spasms in SPS and insulin deficiency in diabetes. Despite this apparent major overlap in pathophysiology, SPS only rarely occurs in individuals with type 1 diabetes. We report the case of a 41-year-old man presenting with a simultaneous diagnosis of both these conditions. His case is unusual in that it is the first reported case in the literature of these conditions occurring in someone with celiac disease (CD) and dermatitis herpetiformis. We discuss why SPS and type 1 diabetes co-exist in only a minority of cases and speculate on the underlying mechanism of the association with CD and dermatitis herpetiformis in our patient.

GAD65 as a prototypic autoantigen

The repertoire of known autoantigens is limited to a very small proportion of all human proteins, and the reason why only some proteins become autoantigens is unclear, but is likely associated with structural features. The 65kDa isoform of the enzyme glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD65) is a major autoantigen in type I diabetes, and in various neurological diseases, whereas the closely related isoform, GAD67, is rarely antigenic. Conformational epitopes of GAD65 have been mapped using human monoclonal antibodies to GAD65 and GAD mutated by GAD65/67 sequence exchanges or point mutations, but these studies have been limited by a lack of structural information. The recent publication of crystal structures for the two isoforms has shown that the N-, C- and middle domains that have been identified previously as likely epitope regions are closely associated within the GAD dimer. Two major epitope regions, ctc1 and ctc2, have been identified in the C-terminal domain of GAD65, that encompass N- and C-terminal residues, and middle and C-terminal residues respectively. These regions are highly flexible compared with the equivalent regions in GAD67, and T cell epitopes have been localized to the same surface region of GAD65. Comparative analysis of these two structurally similar isoforms, GAD65 and GAD67, only one of which is autoantigenic should provide new insights into the provocations to autoimmunity.

[Steroid treatment in four cases of anti-GAD cerebellar ataxia]

INTRODUCTION

Few neurological diseases are linked with anti-glutamic acid decarboxylase antibodies (GAD-ab); stiff man syndrome is an example. Cerebellar ataxia is a new feature of this expanding spectrum. No therapeutic trial is yet available in these diseases. We here report on four patients suffering from cerebellar ataxia linked with GAD-ab and review the data in the literature on this recently described syndrome.

METHOD

We conducted an open trial with monthly pulsed steroids. Steroid pulses were given six months followed with placebo for another six months. Main clinical and biological parameters were monitored monthly (International Cooperative Cerebellar Ataxia Rating Scale [ICARS] and GAD-ab).

RESULT

The clinical response was found limited and inconstant. Transient decline in GAD-ab level was noted in two patients. Moreover, GAD-ab level was found highly variable and did not correlate with clinical parameters.

DISCUSSION

Cerebellar ataxia with GAD-ab is an increasingly described syndrome. Outcome can be severe, leading to definitive cerebellar atrophy. Diagnosis is supported by high level of serum GAD-ab with intrathecal secretion. Experimental data have suggested a direct excitotoxic effect of GAD-ab on Purkinje cells. Response to various treatments is often disappointing. Improvement has been obtained with veinoglobulins in individual patients. A weak clinical and biological response was associated with monthly steroid pulses.

Antigen presentation of detergent-free glutamate decarboxylase (GAD65) is affected by human serum albumin as carrier protein

The smaller isoform of glutamate decarboxylase (GAD65) is a major autoantigen in type 1 diabetes (TID). Its hydrophobic character requires detergent to keep the protein in solution, which complicates studies of antigen processing and presentation. In this study an attempt was made to replace detergent with human serum albumin (HSA) for in vitro antigen presentation. Different preparations of recombinant human GAD65 solubilized by HSA were incubated with Priess B cells (HLA DRB1*0401) and antigen presentation was tested with HLA DRB1*0401-restricted and epitope-specific T33.1 (GAD65 epitope 274-286) and T35 (GAD65 epitope 115-127) T-cell hybridomas. Specific epitope recognition by T33.1 (274-286) and T35 (115-127) cells varied between the different GAD65/HSA preparations, and a reverse pattern of antigen presentation was detected by the two hybridoma. The HSA-specific T-cell hybridoma 17.9 response to the different GAD65/HSA preparations followed the same pattern as that observed for the T33.1 cells. The content of immunoreactive GAD65 measured with four GAD65 antibodies indicated that the lowest GAD65 concentration resulted in the highest 274-286, but the lowest 115-127 presentation. This suggests that HSA-GAD65 interactions qualitatively affect the epitope specificity of GAD65 presentation. HSA may enhance the 274-286 epitope presentation, while suppressing the 115-127 epitope.

High definition profiling of autoantibodies to glutamic acid decarboxylases GAD65/GAD67 in stiff-person syndrome

Highly reliable biomarkers for the diagnosis of neurological diseases are not widely available. Here we evaluated a luciferase immunoprecipitation technology (LIPS) for the diagnosis of a CNS autoimmune disorder, stiff-person syndrome (SPS). Analysis by LIPS of 40 sera samples from SPS and control subjects for anti-GAD65 antibodies revealed dramatic titer differences allowing diagnosis of SPS with 100% sensitivity and 100% specificity. Anti-GAD65 antibody titers of SPS were segregated from controls with values greater than 23 standard deviations above the control subject mean. By analyzing patient antibody responses directly to GAD65 sub-fragments, the central region containing the decarboxylase catalytic domain was highly immunoreactive with all of the SPS sera, while the N- and C-terminal regions showed lower antibody titers and only reacted with subsets of SPS sera. Additional profiling revealed that some SPS patients showed autoantibodies against GAD67 and tyrosine hydroxylase, but no significant immunoreactivity was detected with cysteine sulfinic acid decarboxylase or GABA transaminase. This study validates LIPS as a robust method to interrogate autoantibodies for the diagnosis of SPS and potentially other neurological diseases.

Acute ataxia, Graves' disease, and stiff person syndrome

Stiff person syndrome (SPS) has been associated with autoimmune diseases, such as Type 1 diabetes mellitus and autoimmune thyroid disease (Hashimoto's thyroiditis), among others. The association of SPS with hyperthyroidism is extremely rare. We describe a patient with uncontrolled Graves' disease and undiagnosed SPS, who presented initially with acute ataxia simulating a cerebrovascular accident. Initiation of immunosuppressive therapy dramatically improved the patient's Graves' disease within 2 weeks but the neurological symptoms were not alleviated after a follow-up period of 3 years.

GAD autoantibody affinity and epitope specificity identify distinct immunization profiles in children at risk for type 1 diabetes

OBJECTIVE

Autoantibodies to insulin and GAD are features of preclinical type 1 diabetes in children. For insulin autoantibodies, the antibody affinity and epitope specificity predict which children progress to diabetes. We asked whether autoantibodies to GAD (GADAs) are heterogeneous in affinity and epitope recognition and whether diabetes-related GADA are restricted to high-affinity responses.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

GADA affinity was measured by competitive binding experiments with [(125)I]-labeled and -unlabeled recombinant human GAD65 in the first GADA-positive sample from 95 children with a type 1 diabetes family history who were prospectively followed from birth and in follow-up samples from 65 of these children.

RESULTS

At first GADA appearance, affinity ranged from 10(7) to 10(10) l/mol. Affinity was higher in multiple islet autoantibody-positive children (P < 0.0001) and in HLA DR3-positive children (P = 0.006). GADA affinities were >10(9) l/mol in 52 of 53 multiple autoantibody-positive children. In contrast, children who were single GADA positive often had lower affinity GADA and/or GADA with specificities that were restricted to minor NH(2)-terminal GAD65 epitopes. At follow-up, affinity increased from low to high in 3 of 65 children. All 24 children who developed diabetes had high-affinity GADAs before diabetes onset.

CONCLUSIONS

Children develop discrete, heterogeneous antibody responses to GAD that could arise from distinct immunization events, only some of which are diabetes relevant. Subtyping the GADA responses using affinity measurement will improve type 1 diabetes risk assessment.

Epitope mapping of human aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase

Autoimmune polyendocrine syndrome type I (APS I) is a rare hereditary condition considered a model disease for organ specific autoimmunity. A wide range of autoantibodies targeting antigens present in the affected organs have been identified. Autoantibodies against aromatic L-amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) are present in about 50% of APS I patients. In order to increase our understanding of autoantibody specificity in APS I, the aim of the present study was to localize target regions on AADC recognized by sera from APS I patients. Using several complementing strategies, we have shown that autoantibodies against AADC mainly recognize conformational epitopes. The major antigenic determinants were detected N-terminally to amino acid residue 237. Replacement of amino acids 227-230 (ERDK) with alanine residues reduced the reactivity towards AADC by >80% in all patient sera tested, suggesting that amino acids 227-230 are an important part of an immunodominant epitope.

Molecular characterization of a disease associated conformational epitope on GAD65 recognised by a human monoclonal antibody b96.11

Autoantibodies to the 65kDa isoform of glutamate decarboxylase (GAD65) are associated with type I diabetes and recognise highly conformational epitope(s) that remain to be defined. The human recombinant Fab from mAb b96.11 inhibits binding of most GAD65 antibody positive sera from patients and its epitope has previously been localized to the middle region of GAD65. Recent studies indicate that b96.11 antibody specificity predicts the risk of developing type 1 diabetes in prediabetic individuals. We describe the use homology modelling, protein-protein docking simulations and biopanning of random peptide phage displayed libraries with b96.11 to predict contact amino acids on the interface of GAD65/Fab b96.11 complex. Further analysis by in vitro mutagenesis of GAD65 followed by radioimmunoprecipitation refined the amino acids contributing to the b96.11 epitope. Our studies show an interface characterized by a protruding antibody-combining site centered on the long heavy chain CDR3 loop of Fab b96.11 establishing interactions with the critical residue Phe(344) in the core of the epitope on GAD65, surrounded by charged sites within (375)RK(376) and (305)DER(307). The epitope requires residues from both middle and the C-terminal domains, and is the first precise definition of an epitope on GAD65. The nature of the b96.11 epitope leads to considerations of potential structural variations for differences in antigenicity between the isoforms GAD65 and GAD67. The study shows the utility of using a combination of in silico techniques and experimental data for molecular characterization and localization of conformational epitopes for which crystal structures are lacking.

Activity-dependent cleavage of brain glutamic acid decarboxylase 65 by calpain

Previously, we reported that l-glutamic acid decarboxylase isoform 65 (GAD65) could be cleaved in vitro to release a stable truncated form which lacks amino acid 1-69 from the N-terminus, GAD65(Delta1-69). However, whether such a truncated form is also present under certain physiological conditions remains elusive. In the present study, we showed that, upon sustained neuronal stimulation, GAD65 could be cleaved into a truncated form in a rat synaptosomal preparation. This truncated form had similar electrophoretic mobility to purified recombinant human GAD65(Delta1-69). Furthermore, we demonstrated that this conversion was calcium dependent. Calcium-chelating reagents such as EDTA and 1,2-bis-(o-aminphenoxy)-ethane-N,N,N',N'-tetra-acetic acid tetra-acetoxy-methyl ester prevented the cleavage of GAD65. In addition, our data suggested that calpain, a calcium-dependent cysteine protease, is activated upon neuronal stimulation and could be responsible for the conversion of full-length GAD65 to truncated GAD65 in the brain. Moreover, calpain inhibitors such as calpain inhibitor I or calpastatin could block the cleavage. Results of our in vitro cleavage assay using purified calpain and immunopurified rat GAD65 also supported the idea that GAD65 could be directly cleaved by calpain.

Analysis of GAD65 autoantibodies in Stiff-Person syndrome patients

Autoantibodies to the 65-kDa isoform of glutamate decarboxylase GAD65 (GAD65Ab) are strong candidates for a pathological role in Stiff-Person syndrome (SPS). We have analyzed the binding specificity of the GAD65Ab in serum and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of 12 patients with SPS by competitive displacement studies with GAD65-specific rFab-derived from a number of human and mouse mAbs specific for different determinants on the Ag. We demonstrate considerable differences in the epitope specificity when comparing paired serum and CSF samples, suggesting local stimulation of B cells in the CSF compartment of these patients. Moreover, these autoantibodies strongly inhibit the enzymatic activity of GAD65, thus blocking the formation of the neurotransmitter gamma-aminobutyric acid. The capacity of the sera to inhibit the enzymatic activity of GAD65 correlated with their binding to a conformational C-terminal Ab epitope. Investigation of the inhibitory mechanism revealed that the inhibition could not be overcome by high concentrations of glutamate or the cofactor pyridoxal phosphate, suggesting a noncompetitive inhibitory mechanism. Finally, we identified a linear epitope on amino acids residues 4-22 of GAD65 that was recognized solely by autoantibodies from patients with SPS but not by serum from type 1 diabetes patients. A mAb (N-GAD65 mAb) recognizing this N-terminal epitope was successfully humanized to enhance its potential therapeutic value by reducing its overall immunogenicity.

Humoral autoimmune responses to glutamic acid decarboxylase have similar target epitopes and subclass that show titer-dependent disease association

Glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) is an autoantigen in stiff man syndrome (SMS) and type 1 diabetes (T1DM). Different GAD autoantibody characteristics in these disorders have suggested distinct underlying mechanisms of autoimmunity. Here, it is shown that increased prevalence of autoantibodies to GAD65 amino terminal and GAD67 epitopes and autoantibodies of IgG2, IgG3, or IgG4 subclass in patients with SMS (P < 0.001 vs. T1DM) are secondary to the markedly higher autoantibody titers in SMS patients (P < 0.0001) and that autoantibody epitopes and subclasses were similar when patients were matched for autoantibody titer. Exposure to autoantigen in the disorders is likely to involve similar humoral antigenic determinants, but different B cell regulation.

Developments in the prediction of type 1 diabetes mellitus, with special reference to insulin autoantibodies

The prodromal phase of type 1 diabetes is characterised by the appearance of multiple islet-cell related autoantibodies (Aab). The major target antigens are islet-cell antigen, glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD), protein-tyrosine phosphatase-2 (IA-2) and insulin. Insulin autoantibodies (IAA), in contrast to the other autoimmune markers, are the only beta-cell specific antibodies. There is general consensus that the presence of multiple Aab (> or = 3) is associated with a high risk of developing diabetes, where the presence of a single islet-cell-related Aab has usually a low predictive value. The most commonly used assay format for the detection of Aab to GAD, IA-2 and insulin is the fluid-phase radiobinding assay. The RBA does not identify or measure Aab, but merely detects its presence. However, on the basis of molecular studies, disease-specific constructs of GAD and IA-2 have been employed leading to somewhat improved sensitivity and specificity of the RBA. Serological studies have shown epitope restriction of IAA that can differentiate diabetes-related from unrelated IAA, but current assays do not distinguish between disease-predictive and non-predictive IAA or between IAA and insulin antibodies (IA). More recently, phage display technology has been successful in identifying disease-specific anti-idiotopes of insulin. In addition, phage display has facilitated the in vitro production of antibodies with high affinity. Identification of disease-specific anti-idiotopes of insulin should enable the production of a high affinity reagent against the same anti-idiotope. Such a development would form the basis of a disease-specific radioimmunoassay able to identify and measure particular idiotypes, rather than merely detect and titrate IAA.

Glutamate Decarboxylase: Loss of N-terminal Segment Does Not Affect Homodimerization and Determination of the Oxidation State of Cysteine Residues

Glutamate decarboxylase (GAD) produces GABA, the main inhibitory neurotransmitter in adult mammalian brain. The physical characteristics of GAD were studied using mass spectrometry and partial protein digests. The N-termini of the two main isoforms, GAD65 and GAD67, were processed by removal of the initial methionine residues and acetylation of the penultimate alanines. Native recombinant GAD65 and GAD67 exist as homodimers that can be dissociated with non-reducing methods, indicating that homodimerization does not involve intermolecular disulfide bonds. Truncation of the N-terminal segment with trypsin digestion did not affect homodimerization but increased activity by decreasing the Km of GAD67 and increasing the Vmax of both isoforms. Of the 15 cysteines in GAD65, the six found in the N-terminal segment can form disulfide bonds and of the 13 cysteines in GAD67, cysteines 32 and 38 can form a disulfide bond. The in vitro formation of disulfide bonds in the N-termini, and the removal of the termini with relatively low amounts of trypsin, indicate that the N-terminal segments of GAD65 and GAD67 are exposed and flexible. The formation of a disulfide bridge between cysteines 30 and 45 of GAD65 suggests that alteration of normal redox conditions could affect GAD targeting.

Antigenic differences between neurological and diabetic patients with anti-glutamic acid decarboxylase antibodies

Antibodies to glutamic acid decarboxylase (GADAb) are found in Stiff-Person syndrome, type 1 diabetes, cerebellar ataxia and other neurological disorders (such as epilepsy and myoclonus) involving the GABAergic ways. GADAb are usually detected by immunohistochemistry (IHC), radioimmunoassay (RIA) or enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). This study analysed the serum of 14 patients with neurological disorders who were positive by IHC for GADAb. The performance of a commercial RIA was compared with in-house immunoblotting and ELISA methods using recombinant GAD65 (rGAD65). RIA was positive in 14 of 14, immunoblotting was positive in seven of 14 and ELISA in 12 of 14. There was no correlation between the RIA result and the ELISA optical densities. Using a sodium thiocyanate chaotrope system with ELISA to determine antibody affinity, we found no significant correlation between antibody affinity and the RIA result. A consensus should be defined concerning which assay could be used as the gold standard for detecting GADAb. The most intriguing finding was that GAD antibodies from uncomplicated diabetics do not appear to recognize GAD in frozen sections from the rat cerebellum, whereas GAD antibodies from neurologically compromised diabetics do. A working proposal is therefore that type 1 diabetic patients with unusual neurological symptoms should be tested for GADAb both by RIA and IHC.

Clinical and genetic characteristics of diabetic patients with high-titer (>10,000 U/ml) of antibodies to glutamic acid decarboxylase

We investigated the clinical aspects and genetic background of 13 diabetic patients with high-titers (>10,000 U/ml) of anti-glutamic acid decarboxylase antibody (Group A) and compared these 28 middle-aged (35-51 years, Group B) and 13 elderly (66-79 years, Group C) patients with anti-GAD(+) (<1100 U/ml) who were diagnosed initially as having type 2 diabetes. The mean age and mean age at onset of Group A were 70.8 +/- 3.9 years (range, 64-78) and 50.4 +/- 5.4 years (range, 43-61), respectively. In Group A, the prevalence of insulin-deficient patients was significantly lower (30.8%, 4 of 13) than in Group C (96.3%, 27 of 28, P < 0.001). Patients in Group A had a significantly longer interval between the clinical onset of diabetes to initiation insulin therapy (21.8 +/- 2.3 years) compared to patients in both Group B (1.8+/-1.1 years, P < 0.001) and Group C (14.8 +/- 7.1 years, P = 0.049). The frequency of DRB1*0405-DQB1*0401/DRB1*1502-DQB1*0601 or DRB*1501-DQB*0602 heterozygous genotypes in Group A (53.8%, 7 of 13) was significantly higher than in both Group B (3.6%, 1 of 28, P < 0.01) and Group C (7.7%, 1 of 13, P < 0.05). Compared with Group B, Group A had an increased frequency of the TNFA-U01 haplotype and the IL-10 -592 C allele (TNFA-U01; 53.8% versus 30.4%, P = 0.05 and IL-10 -592 C; 57.7% versus 33.9 %, P = 0.042). All sera from Group A reacted with GAD(65) protein on Western blots. We conclude that adult-onset diabetic patients with a high-titer of anti-GDAab differ from patients with latent autoimmune diabetes mellitus in adult (LADA) with respect to beta-cell function, cellular autoimmunity and genetic background. Our study also showed that high-titers of antibodies to glutamic acid decarboxylase (anti-GADab) were not predictive of later development of insulin deficiency in adult and/or elderly patients with type 2 diabetes. Furthermore, our results suggest that HLA-DRB1*1502-DQB1*0601 or DRB1*1501-DQB1*0602/DRB1*0405-DQB1*0401 heterozygous genotypes may be associated with high production of anti-GADab that recognizes the linear epitope(s) on the GAD(65) protein.

Homozygosity for a missense mutation in the 67 kDa isoform of glutamate decarboxylase in a family with autosomal recessive spastic cerebral palsy: parallels with Stiff-Person Syndrome and other movement disorders

BACKGROUND

Cerebral palsy (CP) is an heterogeneous group of neurological disorders of movement and/or posture, with an estimated incidence of 1 in 1000 live births. Non-progressive forms of symmetrical, spastic CP have been identified, which show a Mendelian autosomal recessive pattern of inheritance. We recently described the mapping of a recessive spastic CP locus to a 5 cM chromosomal region located at 2q24-31.1, in rare consanguineous families.

METHODS

Here we present data that refine this locus to a 0.5 cM region, flanked by the microsatellite markers D2S2345 and D2S326. The minimal region contains the candidate gene GAD1, which encodes a glutamate decarboxylase isoform (GAD67), involved in conversion of the amino acid and excitatory neurotransmitter glutamate to the inhibitory neurotransmitter gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA).

RESULTS

A novel amino acid mis-sense mutation in GAD67 was detected, which segregated with CP in affected individuals.

CONCLUSIONS

This result is interesting because auto-antibodies to GAD67 and the more widely studied GAD65 homologue encoded by the GAD2 gene, are described in patients with Stiff-Person Syndrome (SPS), epilepsy, cerebellar ataxia and Batten disease. Further investigation seems merited of the possibility that variation in the GAD1 sequence, potentially affecting glutamate/GABA ratios, may underlie this form of spastic CP, given the presence of anti-GAD antibodies in SPS and the recognised excitotoxicity of glutamate in various contexts.

Conformation-dependent GAD65 autoantibodies in diabetes

AIMS/HYPOTHESIS

Conformation-dependent autoantibodies directed against GAD65 are markers of Type 1 diabetes. In this study we aimed to determine whether the substitution of GAD65 with GAD67 amino acids would affect the binding of conformation-dependent GAD65 autoantibodies.

METHODS

We used PCR-based site-directed mutagenesis to generate a series of mutated GAD65 cDNA constructs in which specific GAD65 coding sequences for regions of the protein critical for autoantibody binding were replaced with GAD67 coding sequences.

RESULTS

The introduction of a point mutation at position 517, substituting glutamic acid with proline, markedly reduced the binding of disease-associated GAD65 antibodies. The binding of GAD65 antibodies to the E517P mutant was reduced in the sera of all newly diagnosed Type 1 diabetes patients ( n=85) by a mean of 72% ( p<0.0001) compared with binding to wild-type GAD65. Patients with latent autoimmune diabetes in adults ( n=24) showed a similar reduction in binding (79% reduction, p<0.0001). First-degree relatives who subsequently progressed to Type 1 diabetes ( n=12) showed a reduction in binding of 80% compared with a reduction of only 65% among relatives who had not progressed to disease ( n=38; p=0.025). In healthy GAD65Ab-positive individuals who did not progress to diabetes during a 9-year follow-up period ( n=51), binding to GAD65-E517P was reduced by only 28% compared with binding to wild-type GAD65.

CONCLUSIONS/INTERPRETATION

Differences in autoantibody binding to wild-type GAD65 versus GAD65-E517P may provide predictive information about Type 1 diabetes risk beyond that provided by the presence or absence of GAD65 autoantibodies. Lack of binding to mutant GAD65-E517P defines GAD65-positive individuals who are at higher risk of developing diabetes.

Stiff-Person Syndrome

BACKGROUND

Stiff-person syndrome (SPS) is a rare neurologic disorder with autoimmune features. It is characterized by progressive, severe muscle rigidity or stiffness most prominently affecting the spine and lower extremities.

REVIEW SUMMARY

Superimposed muscle spasms result in simultaneous contraction of agonist and antagonist muscles which are detectable by electromyography (EMG) and relieved by administration of benzodiazepines. The exacerbation of SPS by emotional stressors often results in the referral of these patients for psychiatric assessment although this was more common before the discovery of an association with antibodies to glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD antibodies). Formerly known as stiff-man syndrome, the female to male ratio is 2:1 and the principle paraneoplastic variant is associated with breast cancer. Although rare, this is a disease of middle age that severely curtails the functional capacity of those it strikes. It is frequently associated with diabetes and other autoimmune diseases. IVIg is recently demonstrated to be effective in the treatment of SPS; diazepam remains useful in managing the symptoms.

CONCLUSIONS

This article summarizes the history of SPS, describes important clinical features, discusses management, touches upon areas of uncertainty, and postulates some avenues for research.

Antibodies to GAD65 epitopes at diagnosis and over the first 10 years of clinical type 1 diabetes mellitus

Antibodies to glutamate decarboxylase (GAD65Ab) may persist, and their titres even increase after the clinical onset of type 1 diabetes. To characterize this phenomenon in detail, we analysed sequentially antibodies to GAD65 epitope clusters in a radio-binding assay in patients with type 1 diabetes. Serum samples were taken at diagnosis and 2, 5 and 10 years later from 50 young patients who had tested positive for GAD65Ab at least once during observation. The levels of GAD65Ab peaked in 21 patients after diagnosis. Antibodies to the middle region of GAD65 (GAD65-M-Ab, 88%) were more common at diagnosis than antibodies to the C-terminal (GAD65-C-Ab, 68%, P < 0.05) or N-terminal region (4%, P < 0.001). Antibodies to middle and especially to C-terminal epitopes decreased in those with decreasing levels of GAD65Ab (P < 0.001), whereas the frequencies of GAD65-M-Ab and GAD65-C-Ab remained quite stable among the subjects with increasing levels. Lower exogenous insulin dose and HbA(1) levels and stronger humoral immune response to islet cells were observed in those with increasing levels of GAD65-M-Ab than in those with decreasing levels (P < 0.05). The present observation supports the view that the middle region of GAD65 comprises immunodominant epitopes. An enhanced humoral immune response to GAD65 after diagnosis is related to persistent immune reactivity to the middle and C-terminal regions.

A delayed diagnosis of stiff person syndrome

A 37-year-old industrial designer presented in February 2002 with a 6-week history of thirst, polydipsia and polyuria. Urine dipstick showed glucose and 3+ ketones. Diabetes was diagnosed following fasting glucose of 13 mmol/litre and glycosylated haemoglobin (Hba1c) of 10.3%. He was commenced on insulin therapy.

He had been healthy until 1995 when he described the onset of muscle spasm and pain in upper back and shoulders. There was no obvious precipitating injury. He described the muscle over his left shoulder tightening up like a knot. It subsequently spread to his neck, upper and, later, lower back, giving significant rigidity and pain. Exertion and sporting activities cause his whole back to seize up with extreme pain afterwards. The spasms spread to his legs twice in the last 7 years, but the rigidity was fortunately only short lasting. He sought advice from a chiropractor and various medical specialists including an orthopaedic surgeon, rheumatologist and pain consultant. He had many investigations including isotope bone scan and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan of cervical and thoracic spine which were all normal. There was no explanation for his symptoms and no diagnosis was given. He was prescribed baclofen, which brought some relief.

Clinical examination was normal except for markedly increased tone of muscles over his left shoulder. There was no obvious truncal rigidity or exaggerated lumbar lordosis and no pyramidal or extrapyramidal signs. He was clinically euthyroid.

Antiglutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) 65 antibody was highly elevated at 220 U/ml (normal range (NR) <1 U/ml; >100 U/ml associated with neurological disease). Thyroid function test showed normal free thyroxine of 16.3 pmol/litre (NR 10–25.0 pmol/litre) with elevated thyroid-stimulating hormone of 8.43 mU/litre (NR 0.4–4 mU/litre) and positive thyroid peroxidase (TPO) antibody at 82 IU/ml (NR <37.0 IU/ml). Nerve conduction studies showed no evidence of neuropathy. Electromyograph studies were not done because of the difficulty of excluding voluntary movement from this quite painful test. Full blood count, renal, liver and bone profile were normal. CSF was not examined.

The typical history of painful muscle spasm and strongly positive anti-GAD 65 antibody suggested the diagnosis of stiff person syndrome. The association with an autoimmune condition, in this case type 1 diabetes, and elevated TPO antibody levels further supports the diagnosis.

Stratification of type 1 diabetes risk on the basis of islet autoantibody characteristics

Family history of type 1 diabetes and autoantibodies to the islet antigens insulin (IAA), glutamate decarboxylase (GADA), and the protein tyrosine phosphatase-like protein IA-2 (IA-2A) are strong predictors of type 1 diabetes, but the rate of progression to diabetes in multiple islet autoantibody-positive relatives varies widely. We asked whether detailed characterization of islet autoantibodies that included determination of titer, epitope specificity, and IgG subclass would improve diabetes prediction in a large cohort of autoantibody-positive relatives. The study shows a strong association between risk and high titer, broad antibody responses to IA-2 and insulin. The highest risks were associated with high-titer IA-2A and IAA, IgG2, IgG3, and/or IgG4 subclass of IA-2A and IAA, and antibodies to the IA-2-related molecule IA-2beta. Using models based on these antibody characteristics, autoantibody-positive relatives can be classified into groups with risks of diabetes ranging from 7 to 89% within 5 years.

Development of vigabatrin-induced lesions in the rat brain studied by magnetic resonance imaging, histology, and immunocytochemistry

Vigabatrin, the gamma-aminobutyric acid transaminase (GABA-T)-inhibiting anticonvulsant drug, was given orally at a dose of 275 mg/kg/day to rats (n = 6) in their feed for a period of 12 weeks, during which T2-weighted magnetic resonance images (MRIs) and diffusion-weighted MRIs (DWIs) were collected at weeks 1, 3, 6, 9, and 12. Half the rats (n = 3; and half their age-matched littermate controls; n = 3) were then killed for histopathological confirmation of the observed VGB-induced cerebellar and cortical white-matter lesions. VGB was removed from the diet and additional MRIs of the remaining rats taken at weeks 14, 17, 20, and 24, at which time they (n = 3), along with remaining controls (n = 3), were also killed for histopathology. The T2-weighted MRIs acquired were used to compute T2 relaxation time maps. Statistically significant VGB-induced T2 increases were observed in the frontal and occipital cortices and in the cerebellar white matter (CWM). The cerebellar lesions were more clearly discerned by eye in the DWIs than by T2-contrast alone. During the recovery period the VGB-treatment group CWM-T2 and CWM-DWI hyperintensity greatly decreased as the reversible lesion disappeared. As expected, histological and immunocytochemical examinations demonstrated the presence of intra-myelinic edema, microvacuolation, and reactive astrocytosis in the CWM and cortex after 12 weeks VGB-treatment. In the remaining animals microvacuolation of the white matter had not completely resolved during the 12-week recovery phase. The data show that quantitative MRI T2-relaxometry can be used to detect VGB-induced CNS pathology, and also suggest that DWI is particularly sensitive to the cerebellar lesion. The reversible neurotoxicity of global GABA-elevation in experimental animals is discussed.

Recombinant Fabs of human monoclonal antibodies specific to the middle epitope of GAD65 inhibit type 1 diabetes-specific GAD65Abs

Autoantibodies to the 65-kDa isoform of GAD (GAD65Abs) are associated with type 1 diabetes development, but the conformational nature of the GAD65Ab epitopes complicates the evaluation of disease risk. Six GAD65-specific recombinant Fabs (rFabs) were cloned from monoclonal antibodies b96.11, DP-C, DP-A, DPD, 144, and 221-442. The binding of GAD65Abs in 61 type 1 diabetic patients to GAD65 was analyzed by competitive radioimmunoassays with the six rFabs to ascertain disease-specific GAD65Ab binding specificities. The median binding was reduced significantly by rFab b96.11 (72%) (P < 0.0001), DP-A (84%) (P < 0.0001), DP-C (84%) (P < 0.0001), 221-442 (79%) (P < 0.0001), and DP-D (80%) (P < 0.0001). The competition pattern in type 1 diabetic patients differed from that in GAD65Ab-positive late autoimmune diabetes in adults (LADA) patients (n = 44), first-degree relatives (n = 38), and healthy individuals (n = 14). Whereas 87 and 72% of the type 1 diabetic sera were competed by rFab b96.11 and DP-C, respectively, only 34 and 26% of LADA patients, 18 and 25% of first-degree relatives, and 7 and 28% of healthy individuals showed competition (P < 0.0001). These findings support the view that type 1 diabetes is associated with disease- and epitope-specific GAD65Abs and supports the notion that the middle epitope is disease associated. These GAD65-specific rFabs should prove useful in predicting type 1 diabetes and in the study of conformational GAD65Ab epitopes.

Humoral and Cellular Autoimmune Responses in Stiff Person Syndrome

Stiff person syndrome (SPS) is a chronic autoimmune disease associated with humoral and cellular immune responses to glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) 65. Another chronic autoimmune disease, type 1 diabetes (T1D), is also associated with autoimmune responses to this antigen, but T1D patients develop SPS only extremely rarely and only a third of SPS patients develop T1D (mostly mild manifestations in adulthood). In a previous study, we described important differences between T1D and SPS in the autoimmune response to GAD 65: (1) T cells of SPS patients recognize epitopes in the middle of GAD 65 (amino residues 81-171 and 313-403), whereas patients with T1D preferentially recognize another middle (161-243) and a C-terminal region (473-555); and (2) GAD antibodies (Abs) were nearly exclusively of the Th1-associated IgG1 type in T1D, whereas SPS patients had both Th1- and Th2-associated IgG4 and IgE GAD Abs. These differences were not simply related to different HLA alleles. Fine epitope mapping revealed further distinct T cell epitopes in both diseases despite similar HLA background. Therefore, a single autoantigen can elicit different immune responses causing distinct chronic autoimmune diseases possibly related to a Th1 or Th2 bias of the disease.

Lambert-Eaton Myasthenic syndrome in a child with an autoimmune phenotype

We report on a child with a family history of autoimmune defects, who presented at the age of 3(1/2) years with alopecia and Graves disease. He subsequently developed vitiligo and psoriasis. At 9(1/2) years, he developed an autoimmune form of Lambert-Eaton Myasthenic syndrome (LEMS) with a significant elevation of glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) autoantibodies. Shortly thereafter he developed chronic urticaria. HLA associations were present for Graves disease, vitiligo, psoriasis, and IgA deficiency. There was also evidence of autoimmunity involving the pancreatic islet cells and gastric parietal cells.

No specific reactivity to E. coli glutamic acid decarboxylase from sera of newly-diagnosed insulin dependent diabetic patients

The 65 kD isoform of Glutamic Acid Decarboxylase (GAD), is one of the major autoantigens in human type 1 diabetes mellitus. This enzyme shares amino acid identity, in select regions already determined as antigenic with its counterpart from E. coli. We tested the reactivity of diabetic and normal sera and an E. coli GAD-specific monoclonal antibody (2D9) to E. coli GAD by solid phase and competition ELISA, as well as immunoblotting to check for cross-reactivity of autoantibodies to the two antigens. Specific antibodies for E. coli GAD are present in diabetics and normal subjects without any differences in frequency and titer. The reactivity of such antibodies in ELISA could be blocked in a dose-dependent manner by the addition of excess antigen in the liquid phase. Furthermore, the monoclonal antibody against E. coli GAD does not recognise human recombinant GAD65 in an ELISA. We conclude that there is no basis for cross-reactivity between the two antigens, and antibody reactivity to GAD65 in man cannot arise from cross-reactivity to the E. coli enzyme.

Dual impairment of GABAA- and GABAB-receptor-mediated synaptic responses by autoantibodies to glutamic acid decarboxylase

Anti-glutamate decarboxylase autoantibodies (GAD-A) are associated with a group of patients with progressive cerebellar ataxia. We reported previously that cerebellar GABA(A)-mediated synaptic transmission was presynaptically depressed by GAD-A in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). Using whole-cell recording of rat cerebellar slices, we found in the present study that CSF immunoglobulins from ataxic patients reduced gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) release from cerebellar interneurons, thereby attenuating presynaptic inhibition on neighboring excitatory synapses through GABA(B) receptors (GABA(B)Rs). Our results suggest that in in vitro slices, GAD-A elicited the pathophysiological action of reduction in GABA release, which subsequently resulted in dual synaptic impairment in the cerebellar circuit, by depression of GABA(A) receptor (GABA(A)R)-mediated inhibitory synaptic transmissions, and attenuation of GABA(B) receptor-mediated inhibition of excitatory transmissions.

Distinct antigenic features of linear epitopes at the N-terminus and C-terminus of 65 kDa glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD65): implications for autoantigen modification during pathogenesis

Autoantibodies to 65 kDa glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD65) are produced in many patients with autoimmune polyendocrine syndrome type II (APS-II) or stiff-man syndrome (SMS) and are heterogeneous in their epitope specificities, recognizing both conformational and linear determinants. Major linear epitopes of GAD, which are recognized by autoantibodies in a minority of these patients, occur in the N-terminal and C-terminal regions. We have investigated antibody recognition of the N- and C-termini of GAD65 in relation to their structural features as an approach to understanding what modifications to the native GAD structure may occur that facilitate the generation of antibodies specific to linear epitopes in these regions during the autoimmune pathogenesis. A monoclonal antibody specific to the N-terminus of GAD65 bound both native and denatured GAD in ELISA, whereas monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies specific to the C-terminus of GAD bound only denatured GAD. These antibodies were epitope mapped using random peptide phage-display libraries and the epitopes related to a previously proposed structural model of GAD65. This has led us to propose that the alpha-helical secondary structure of the C-terminus of GAD65 must be denatured to generate linear epitopes. In contrast, the N-terminus is both surface exposed and linear in the native structure, but may be masked by membrane interactions, which must be broken to facilitate recognition by B cells.

Preservation of enzyme activity and antigenicity after mutagenesis of the membrane anchoring domain of GAD65

The smaller isoform of glutamic acid decarboxylase, GAD65, is an important autoantigen implicated in the pathogenesis of type 1 diabetes whereas the larger isoform, GAD67 appears to play no major role. The primary difference between the two isoforms resides in the N-terminal part of the molecule including the GAD65 membrane-anchoring domain. The aim of this study was to generate mutants of the membrane targeting domain spanning amino acids 24 to 31 of GAD65 to determine effects on enzyme activity and antibody recognition. Three GAD65 mutants were generated by substituting two, nine or eleven nucleotides coding for the membrane targeting with the corresponding bases of GAD67. SDS-PAGE and Western blotting wildtype (wt) and mutated GAD65 ascertained that they were of similar size and recognized GAD65-specific antibodies. No difference in enzymatic activity was found between the mutants and wt GAD65. GAD65 antibody positive sera from type 1 diabetes patients immunoprecipitated mutated GAD65 whether two, nine or eleven nucleotides were replaced. Mono-or polyclonal antibodies to the N-terminal region demonstrated that the mutated GAD65 with two or nine nucleotides replaced was immunoprecipitated markedly better than wt whereas no difference was detected using antibodies specific for the PLP-binding site in the middle part of GAD65 or the C-terminal region. Taken together, these data suggest that no major conformational changes have been introduced by mutating the membrane-anchoring domain of GAD65.

Stiff-person syndrome: autoimmunity and the central nervous system

Stiff-person syndrome (SPS) is a rare disease of severe progressive muscle stiffness in the spine and lower extremities with superimposed muscle spasms triggered by external stimuli. Patients with SPS are often referred for psychiatric evaluation and the psychiatrist may be the first to diagnosis SPS. Psychosocial stressors often precede the first manifestations of the disease; depression, anxiety, and alcohol abuse are comorbid illnesses. The identification of an association with antibodies to glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) was invaluable for definitively establishing a pathological basis for the disease; antibodies to amphiphysin and gephyrin are also found in cases of SPS but at much lower frequencies. Whether the antibodies inhibit GAD activity in vivo, target GAD-expressing neurons for immune-mediated destruction, are part of a wider immune process, or are merely a marker for destruction of GAD-expressing neurons by an independent neurodegenerative process is not yet clear. Both electromyography and the detection of GAD antibodies are useful in establishing a diagnosis of SPS. Treatment of SPS includes the use of immunomodulating therapies (plasmapheresis and intravenous immunoglobulins) and symptomatic treatment with benzodiazepines and baclofen. The use of tricyclic antidepressants and rapid withdrawal from therapy should be avoided.