The role of "indirect" recognition in initiating rejection of skin grafts from major histocompatibility complex class II-deficient mice

Involvement of the direct and indirect pathways of allorecognition in tolerance induction

It is generally accepted that there are two pathways of allorecognition, direct and indirect, that together contribute to allograft rejection. Although it has been suggested that the direct pathway predominates during early acute rejection and that the indirect pathway provides a continuous supply of alloantigen responsible for chronic rejection, the true relative contribution of each pathway to the overall rejection process is still not entirely known. It is clear, however, that any strategies designed to achieve the ultimate goal in transplantation, the induction of tolerance, will need to take into account both pathways. This review seeks to explore the involvement of the direct and indirect pathways of allorecognition on a mechanistic level as it relates to the induction of tolerance. A brief historical perspective is included for each pathway as well as a comprehensive review of the mechanisms felt to be active during tolerance induction.

Role of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in allorecognition: lessons from corneal transplantation

Corneal transplantation represents an interesting model to investigate the contribution of direct vs indirect Ag recognition pathways to the alloresponse. Corneal allografts are naturally devoid of MHC class II+ APCs. In addition, minor Ag-mismatched corneal grafts are more readily rejected than their MHC-mismatched counterparts. Accordingly, it has been hypothesized that these transplants do not trigger direct T cell alloresponse, but that donor Ags are presented by host APCs, i.e., in an indirect fashion. Here, we have determined the Ag specificity, frequency, and phenotype of T cells activated through direct and indirect pathways in BALB/c mice transplanted orthotopically with fully allogeneic C57BL/6 corneas. In this combination, only 60% of the corneas are rejected, while the remainder enjoy indefinite graft survival. In rejecting mice the T cell response was mediated by two T cell subsets: 1) CD4+ T cells that recognize alloantigens exclusively through indirect pathway and secrete IL-2, and 2) IFN-gamma-producing CD8+ T cells recognizing donor MHC in a direct fashion. Surprisingly, CD8+ T cells activated directly were not required for graft rejection. In nonrejecting mice, no T cell responses were detected. Strikingly, peripheral sensitization to allogeneic MHC molecules in these mice induced acute rejection of corneal grafts. We conclude that only CD4+ T cells activated via indirect allorecognition have the ability to reject allogeneic corneal grafts. Although alloreactive CD8+ T cells are activated via the direct pathway, they are not fully competent and cannot contribute to the rejection unless they receive an additional signal provided by professional APCs in the periphery.

Rejection of mouse cardiac allografts by costimulation in trans

The activation of T cells by B7 costimulation in trans has been demonstrated in vitro, but the in vivo relevance is unknown. To study costimulation in trans of CD4(+) T cells in vivo, we performed cardiac transplants from B7-1/B7-2-deficient mice to recipients that do not express MHC class II molecules on peripheral APCs, but do have functional CD4(+) T cells (II(-)/4(+) mice). This model restricts the B7-dependent activation of CD4(+) T cells to costimulation in trans and excludes any contribution from indirect Ag presentation. We find that II(-)/4(+) recipients reject B7-deficient grafts as rapidly as wild-type grafts, suggesting that costimulation in trans can mediate rejection as potently as costimulation in cis. Treatment of II(-)/4(+) recipients of B7-deficient grafts with depleting Abs to CD4 or CD8 demonstrates that indirect Ag presentation to CD8(+) cells does not significantly contribute to rejection. This is the first demonstration that costimulation in trans can mediate an immune response in vivo and has important therapeutic implications.

Why do we reject grafts?

One of the puzzles in clinical and experimental organ and tissue transplantation has been why it is that, with the exception of transplantation between genetically identical twin pairs, transplantation results in a rapidly progressing immune response to the point of tissue necrosis in a matter of a few days, even though the recipient has not been immunized to the donor. Indeed, the numbers of T lymphocytes predetermined to react against grafts are relatively abundant compared to those that recognize microbial antigens. Cellular, molecular, and genetic studies are now revealing the nature of T-cell recognition, and why it is that we cannot freely exchange tissue grafts.

CD4+ T cell recognition of a single discordant HLA-A2-transgenic molecule through the indirect antigen presentation pathway induces acute rejection of murine cardiac allografts

To further define the role of indirect allorecognition, cardiac allografts from HLA-A2-transgenic (HLA-A2+) C57BL/6 mice were heterotopically transplanted into normal C57BL/6, CD4 T cell-knockout (KO) C57BL/6 mice, CD8 T cell-KO C57BL/6 mice, fully MHC-discordant BALB/c mice (allogeneic control), and HLA-A2+ C57BL/6 mice (syngeneic control). HLA-A2+ grafts were acutely rejected when transplanted into BALB/c mice (mean survival time: 10+/-0.8 days), normal C57BL/6 mice (mean survival time: 16.5+/-2.1 days) as well as CD8-KO mice (mean survival time: 12.8+/-1.3 days). Histopathological analysis revealed classical acute cellular rejection with moderate to severe diffuse interstitial CD4+ and CD8+ cellular infiltrates and significant intra-graft deposition of IgG and complement. In contrast, HLA-A2+ grafts were not rejected when transplanted into CD4-KO mice or HLA-A2+ mice. CD8-KO recipients treated with an anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody, but not with an anti-NK monoclonal antibody, failed to reject their allografts with prolonged administration of antibody (30 days). Spleen cells from mice rejecting HLA-A2+ allografts failed to lyse HLA-A2+ target cells indicating a lack of involvement of CD8+ T cells in the rejection process. In contrast, spleen cells from rejecting animals proliferated significantly to both HLA-A2+ cells and to a peptide derived from the HLA-A2 molecule. Development of anti-HLA-A2 antibodies was observed in all animals rejecting HLA-A2+ allografts. These results suggest that indirect allorecognition of donor MHC class I molecules leads to rejection of cardiac allografts and development of alloantibodies in this unique transplant model in which there is a single MHC discordance between donor and recipient.

Allorecognition

Until recently, the vigorous T cell response via the direct pathway has overshadowed studies involving the indirect pathway. Thus, while the direct pathway has previously been considered to be the main driving force in alloimmune responses, there is an increasing body of data to support a prominent role of the indirect pathway in transplant rejection. Most importantly, while the direct anti-donor alloresponse diminishes with time after transplantation, the indirect alloresponse is likely to be permanently active due to traffic of recipient dendritic cells (DCs) through the graft. Consequently, the future challenge in the induction of allograft tolerance is to design interventions that will target the cells involved in the indirect pathway, especially the T cells with indirect allospecificity.

Xenogeneic transplantation

This review summarizes the clinical history and rationale for xenotransplantation; recent progress in understanding the physiologic, immunologic, and infectious obstacles to the procedure's success; and some of the strategies being pursued to overcome these obstacles. The problems of xenotransplantation are complex, and a combination of approaches is required. The earliest and most striking immunologic obstacle, that of hyperacute rejection, appears to be the closest to being solved. This phenomenon depends on the binding of natural antibody to the vascular endothelium, fixation of complement by that antibody, and finally, activation of the endothelium and initiation of coagulation. Therefore, these three pathways have been targeted as sites for intervention in the process. The mechanisms responsible for the next immunologic barrier, that of delayed xenograft/acute vascular rejection, remain to be fully elucidated. They probably also involve multiple pathways, including antibody and/or immune cell binding and endothelial cell activation. The final immunologic barrier, that of the cellular immune response, involves mechanisms that are similar to those involved in allograft rejection. However, the strength of the cellular immune response to xenografts is so great that it is unlikely to be controlled by the types of nonspecific immunosuppression used routinely to prevent allograft rejection. For this reason, it may be essential to induce specific immunologic unresponsiveness to at least some of the most antigenic xenogeneic molecules.

Indirect recognition of allopeptides promotes the development of cardiac allograft vasculopathy

Graft loss from chronic rejection has become the major obstacle to the long-term success of whole organ transplantation. In cardiac allografts, chronic rejection is manifested as a diffuse and accelerated form of arteriosclerosis, termed cardiac allograft vasculopathy. It has been suggested that T-cell recognition of processed alloantigens (allopeptides) presented by recipient antigen-presenting cells through the indirect pathway of allorecognition plays a critical role in the development and progression of chronic rejection. However, definitive preclinical evidence to support this hypothesis is lacking. To examine the role of indirect allorecognition in a clinically relevant large animal model of cardiac allograft vasculopathy, we immunized MHC inbred miniature swine with synthetic polymorphic peptides spanning the alpha(1) domain of an allogeneic donor-derived swine leukocyte antigen class I gene. Pigs immunized with swine leukocyte antigen class I allopeptides showed in vitro proliferative responses and in vivo delayed-type hypersensitivity responses to the allogeneic peptides. Donor MHC class I disparate hearts transplanted into peptide-immunized cyclosporine-treated pigs not only rejected faster than unimmunized cyclosporine-treated controls (mean survival time = 5.5 +/-1.7 vs. 54.7 +/-3.8 days, P < 0.001), but they also developed obstructive fibroproliferative coronary artery lesions much earlier than unimmunized controls (<9 vs. >30 days). These results definitively link indirect allorecognition and cardiac allograft vasculopathy.

Indirectly primed CD8+ T cells are a prominent component of the allogeneic T-cell repertoire after skin graft rejection in mice

BACKGROUND

Alloreactive CD4 and CD8 T lymphocytes recognize antigen through both the direct and the indirect pathways. Although indirect priming of CD4+ T cells has been well described, little is known about the frequency and cytokine profile of indirectly primed CD8+ T cells during fully allogeneic graft rejection.

METHODS

We used a cytokine enzyme-linked immunosorbent spot assay to characterize indirect priming of alloreactive CD8 and CD4 cells in mice.

RESULTS

Interferon-gamma-producing CD8+ T cells specific for indirectly presented alloantigen were detectable in allograft-primed mice at a frequency of 50-100 per million cells (compared with 3000 per million for responses through the direct pathway) and were similar in frequency to indirectly primed CD4 cells.

CONCLUSION

CD8+ T cells primed through the indirect pathway are a prominent component of the alloreactive T-cell repertoire induced after skin graft placement in mice, raising the possibility that these cells may play a significant role in the rejection process itself.

Induction of T-cell response to cryptic MHC determinants during allograft rejection

The presentation of MHC peptides by recipient and donor antigen presenting cells is an essential element in allorecognition and allograft rejection. MHC proteins contains two sets of determinants: the dominant determinants that are efficiently processed and presented to T cells, and the cryptic determinants that are not presented sufficiently enough to induce T-cell responses in vivo. In transplanted mice, initial T-cell response to MHC peptides is consistently limited to a single or a few immunodominant determinants on donor MHC molecule. However, in this article we show that under appropriate circumstances the hierarchy of determinants on MHC molecules can be disrupted. First, we observed that gamma IFN can trigger de novo presentation of cryptic self-MHC peptides by spleen cells. Moreover, we showed that allotransplantation is associated with induction of T-cell responses to formerly cryptic determinants on both syngeneic and allogeneic MHC molecules. Our results suggest that cross-reactivity and inflammation are responsible for the initiation of these auto- and alloimmune responses after transplantation.

Heterogeneity of T cell clones specific for a single indirect alloantigenic epitope (I-Ab/H-2Kd54-68) that mediate transplant rejection

BACKGROUND

One of the complexities of solid organ allograft rejection is the inherent diversity of the specific T cell antigenic epitopes that participate in this response, including the role of direct alloantigen recognition and indirect recognition of donor-derived peptides in recipient antigen-presenting cells. To probe the role of distinct T cell receptor (TCR) avidity differences and the role of cytokine expression patterns of different effector T cells that may participate in allograft rejections, we have identified a dominant allopeptide derived from the H-2Kd molecule, recognized by H-2b CD4 T cells in the context of syngeneic I-Ab.

METHODS

To identify a stimulatory peptide derived from the H-2Kd molecule, a panel of synthetic overlapping peptides was screened for immunogenicity and a panel of T cell clones established. These clones were characterized for TCR Vbeta usage by mAb staining and/or reverse transcribed-polymerase chain reaction analysis, peptide dose sensitivity as a marker of TCR avidity, cytokine expression phenotype in vitro, and their ability to mediate rejection of a vascularized cardiac allograft after adoptive transfer to immunodeficient mice.

RESULTS

The H-2Kd54-68 peptide was identified as a dominant stimulatory peptide by the ability of T cells from C57BL/6 (H-2b) mice primed by a combination of allogeneic spleen cell injection and mixed peptide immunization to mount an in vitro proliferative response and interferon-gamma production by peptide stimulation. Furthermore, direct immunization with synthetic H-2Kd54-68 peptide of normal C57BL/6 mice resulted in accelerated rejection of both skin and cardiac allografts from B10.D2 (H-2d) mice, but not 3rd party B10.BR (H-2k) grafts. A panel of 15 distinct CD4+ clones specific for H-2Kd54-68 peptide were established and shown to utilize a variety of TCR Vbeta and different apparent TCR avidities to H-2Kd54-68 peptide when stimulated in vitro. To characterize these clones further, two clones were chosen based on the difference of avidity to H-2Kd54-68 peptide. The cytokine expression pattern was determined and indirect alloantigen specificity confirmed by analysis of responses to purified peptide and B10.D2 spleen cells using normal H.2b and I-Abeta chain knockout mice as APC donors. Both of these T cell clones were able to mediate rejection of B10.D2, but not B10.BR hearts, in immunodeficient mice, but the morphological pattern of T cell infiltration was distinct.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate the potential importance of fine dissection of the alloantigeneic response to solid organ transplants and provide unique insights into the role of TCR avidity and cytokine expression patterns in different morphological patterns of transplant rejection.

Role of dendritic cells in the immune response against allografts

Graft-derived 'passenger' dendritic cells have been classically considered as the instigators of acute organ rejection. However, recent advances have revealed that dendritic cells are also involved in the induction/maintenance of peripheral tolerance. This paper briefly reviews the most recent knowledge of the role of donor and recipient dendritic cells during the immune response against allografts, and of the clinical potential of 'tolerogenic' dendritic cells.

CD4 T cell-mediated cardiac allograft rejection requires donor but not host MHC class II

Numerous studies indicate that CD4 T cells are required for acute cardiac allograft rejection. However, the precise role for CD4 T cells in this response has remained ambiguous owing to the multipotential properties of this T-cell subpopulation. In the current study, we demonstrate the capacity of CD4 T cells to serve as direct effector cells of cardiac allograft rejection. We show that CD4 T cells are both necessary and sufficient for acute graft rejection, as indicated by adoptive transfer experiments in immune-deficient SCID and rag1(-/-) recipients. We have analyzed the contribution of direct (donor MHC class II restricted) and indirect (host MHC class II restricted) antigen recognition in CD4-mediated rejection. Acute CD4 T cell-mediated rejection required MHC class II expression by the allograft, indicating the importance of direct graft recognition. In contrast, reciprocal experiments indicate that CD4 T cells can acutely reject allogeneic cardiac allografts established in rag1(-/-) hosts that were also MHC class II deficient. This latter result indicates that indirect presentation of donor antigens by host MHC class II is not required for acute CD4-mediated rejection. Taken together, these results indicate that CD4 T cells can serve as effector cells for primary acute cardiac allograft rejection, predominantly via direct donor antigen recognition and independent of indirect reactivity.

CD8+ T cells are necessary for recognition of allelic, but not locus-mismatched or xeno-, HLA class I transplantation antigens

Although HLA transgenic mice (HLA TgM) could provide a powerful approach to investigate human MHC-specific T cell responsiveness, the extent to which these molecules are recognized by the mouse immune system remains unclear. We established TgM expressing HLA class I alleles A2, B7, or B27 in their fully native form (HLAnat) or as hybrid molecules (HLAhyb) of the HLA alpha1/alpha2 domains linked to the H-2Kb alpha3, transmembrane, and cytoplasmic domains (i.e., to maintain possible species-specific interactions). Comparison of each as xeno- (i.e., by non-TgM) vs allo- (i.e., by TgM carrying an alternate HLA allele) transplantation Ags revealed the following: 1) Although HLAhyb molecules induced stronger xeno-CD8+ T cell responses in vitro, additional effector mechanisms must be active in vivo because HLAnat skin grafts were rejected faster by non-TgM; 2) gene knockout recipients showed that xenorejection of HLAnat and, unexpectedly, HLAhyb grafts doesn't depend on CD8+ or CD4+ T cells or B cells; 3) each HLAhyb strain developed tolerance to "self" but rejected allele- (-B27 vs -B7) and locus- (-B vs -A) mismatched grafts, the former requiring CD8+ T cells, the latter by CD8+ T cell-independent mechanisms. The finding that recognition of xeno-HLAhyb does not require CD8+ T cells while recognition of the identical molecule in a strictly allo context does, demonstrates an alpha1/alpha2 domain-dependent difference in effector mechanism(s). Furthermore, the CD8+ T cell-independence of locus-mismatched rejection suggests the degree of similarity between self and non-self alpha1/alpha2 determines the effector mechanism(s) activated. The HLA Tg model provides a unique approach to characterize these mechanisms and develop tolerance protocols in the context of human transplantation Ags.

Peptide analogues as a strategy to induce tolerance in T cells with indirect allospecificity

BACKGROUND

It has been demonstrated that indirect recognition of allogeneic MHC molecules might play an important role in provoking graft rejection. Although direct recognition of allogeneic molecules on antigen presenting cells of the graft may induce a state of tolerance, the continuous presentation of processed alloantigens by specialized antigen presenting cells does not allow the same phenomenon to occur. Tolerance to interleukin-2 secreting T cells can be achieved in different ways, among these is the exposure to mutants of the wild type allopeptide. We have investigated whether peptide analogues of the allopeptide can induce tolerance in T cells with indirect allospecificity.

METHODS

T cell clones with indirect anti-HLA-A2-specificity generated from a HLA-A2-DRB1*1502+ patient who chronically rejected a HLA-A2-expressing kidney allograft were used for this study. Nine peptide analogues of HLA-A2 (residues: 103-120) were produced with single amino acid substitutions at the putative T cell receptor for antigen contact positions. Their effect on the proliferation of a panel of T cell clones was evaluated.

RESULTS

Peptide analogues and wild type peptide had similar capacity to bind to the restriction molecule HLA-DRB1*1502. Co-presentation of the peptide analogues 111R/A, H, K and 114H/K, with the wild type peptide inhibited T cell responses, indicative of antagonism. In addition, one analogue 112G/S induced unresponsiveness in the T cells to subsequent culture with the wild type peptide.

CONCLUSIONS

The data presented here suggest that using reagents such as altered peptides may represent a strategy to prevent the activation of T cells with indirect alloreactivity and allograft rejection in vivo.

Replacement of graft-resident donor-type antigen presenting cells alters the tempo and pathogenesis of murine cardiac allograft rejection

BACKGROUND

Graft-resident antigen presenting cells (APCs) are potent stimulators of the alloresponse. To test whether replacement of graft-resident donor-type APCs with those of recipient-type alters allorecognition and the pathogenesis of both acute and chronic rejection, we created chimeric hearts for transplantation into naive recipients.

METHODS

To replace donor-type APCs with those of recipient-type, chimeric animals were created by bone marrow transplantation (BMT) in fully allogeneic mouse and rat strain combinations. The degree of APC replacement in chimeric organs was assessed phenotypically and functionally. Chimeric hearts were transplanted heterotopically into untreated recipients.

RESULTS

Flow cytometric and immunohistochemical analysis did not detect residual bone marrow recipient-type APCs in mouse BMT chimeras. Although semi-quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction detected 0.001-0.01% residual cells, APCs isolated from chimeric organs were functionally unable to stimulate donor-type cells. When transplanted into naive recipients, chimeric mouse hearts had significantly prolonged survival but were nevertheless rejected acutely. Similar results were obtained in the ACI --> LEW rat strain combination. However, in the PVG --> DA rat model, the majority of chimeric hearts survived >100 days and all long-surviving hearts developed cardiac allograft vasculopathy.

CONCLUSIONS

BMT leads to near complete replacement of organ-resident APCs. The virtual absence of donor-type APCs in chimeric hearts delays or prevents acute rejection in a strain-dependent manner. In contrast, this type of graft modification does not prevent cardiac allograft vasculopathy. This suggests that, although the CD4+ direct pathway may play a role in acute rejection, it is not essential for the development of chronic rejection in rodent cardiac allografts.

H2-DMalpha(-/-) mice show the importance of major histocompatibility complex-bound peptide in cardiac allograft rejection

The role played by antigenic peptides bound to major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules is evaluated with H2-DMalpha(-/)- mice. These mice have predominantly class II-associated invariant chain peptide (CLIP)-, not antigenic peptide-bound, MHC class II. H2-DMalpha(-/)- donor heart grafts survived three times longer than wild-type grafts and slightly longer than I-A(beta)(b)-(/)- grafts. Proliferative T cell response was absent, and cytolytic response was reduced against the H2-DMalpha(-/)- grafts in vivo. Residual cytolytic T cell and antibody responses against intact MHC class I lead to eventual rejection. Removal of both H2-DMalpha and beta2-microglobulin (beta2m) in cardiac grafts lead to greater (8-10 times) graft survival, whereas removal of beta2m alone did not have any effect. These results demonstrate the significance of peptide rather than just allogeneic MHC, in eliciting graft rejection.

Organ donor or graft pretreatment to prolong allograft survival: lessons learned in the murine model

Permanent donor-specific tolerance to allografts is the goal of transplantation research. Currently, morbid immunosuppressive therapy is used to mitigate rejection initiated in part by Ia-bearing interstitial graft dendritic or antigen-presenting cells (APCs) that are thought to migrate into the host after transplantation. We hypothesized that donor or organ immune modulation directed against graft APCs might influence graft immunogenicity and promote prolonged graft acceptance in histoincompatible hosts in the absence of immunosuppressive therapy. Haplotype-specific monoclonal antibodies (mAb), mAb specific to graft APC, adhesion or costimulatory molecules and anti-LFA-1-Ricin and anti-Iak-Ricin immunoconjugates (IC) were prepared and administered in varying doses and time intervals to donor C3H/HeJ (H-2k) mice. Thereafter, their spleens and hearts were removed at varying time intervals and used either as stimulator cells in one-way mixed lymphocyte reaction or transplanted into naive Balb/c (H-2d) recipients, respectively. Explanted C3H hearts were pretreated with anti-Iak mAb on the Langendorf apparatus. Hearts were also used from major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I, MHC class II, and MHC class I- and II-deficient "knockout" mice. Splenocytes exposed to at least 500 microg of anti-Iak mAb in vivo for more than 4 hr were able to inhibit the mixed lymphocyte reaction to almost background levels, but only after incubation with rabbit complement in vitro. Similarly pretreated cardiac allografts (both in vivo or explanted and pretreated on the Langendorf apparatus) did not experience prolonged survival in nonimmunosuppressed Balb/C recipients when compared with control solutions, regardless of the concomitant use of complement. Splenocytes from immunoconjugate pretreated donors inhibited the mixed lymphocyte reaction completely without the use of complement; however, hearts from these donors also did not experience prolonged survival nor donor hearts exposed to mAb specific for graft APC, adhesion or costimulatory molecules. Only hearts from MHC class I and class II "knockout" mice survived significantly longer than controls. We conclude that donor or graft pretreatment with haplotype-specific anti-Ia mAb, haplotype-specific immunoconjugates, or mAb directed against graft APC, adhesion or costimulation molecules have little efficacy in promoting acceptance of cardiac allografts in nonimmunosuppressed recipients. The enhanced survival of hearts from MHC class I- and class II-deficient donors suggest that novel methods to effect the immunogenicity of the graft will be required if long-term allograft acceptance is to be achieved in the absence of host immunosuppression.

Altered intragraft immune responses and improved renal function in MHC class II-deficient mouse kidney allografts

BACKGROUND

During renal allograft rejection, expression of MHC class II antigens is up-regulated on the parenchymal cells of the kidney. This up-regulation of MHC class II proteins may stimulate the intragraft alloimmune response by promoting their recognition by recipient CD4+ T cells. In previous studies, absence of donor MHC class II antigens did not affect skin graft survival, but resulted in prolonged survival of cardiac allografts.

METHODS

To further explore the role of MHC class II antigens in kidney graft rejection, we performed vascularized kidney transplants using donor kidneys from A(beta)b-deficient mice that lack MHC class II expression.

RESULTS

At 4 weeks after transplant, GFR was substantially depressed in control allografts (2.18+/-0.46 ml/min/kg) compared to nonrejecting isografts (7.98+/-1.62 ml/min/kg; P<0.01), but significantly higher in class II- allografts (4.38+/-0.60 ml/min/kg; P<0.05). Despite the improvement in renal function, class II- allograft demonstrated histologic features of acute rejection, not unlike control allografts. However, morphometric analysis at 1 week after transplantation demonstrated significantly fewer CD4+ T cells infiltrating class II- allografts (12.8+/-1.2 cells/mm2) compared to controls (25.5+/-2.6 cells/mm2; P=0.0007). Finally, the intragraft profile of cytokines was altered in class II- allografts, with significantly reduced expression of Th2 cytokine mRNA compared to controls.

CONCLUSIONS

These results support a role of MHC class II antigens in the kidney regulating immune cells within the graft. Further, effector pathways triggered by class II antigens promote renal injury during rejection.

Donor MHC class II antigen is essential for induction of transplantation tolerance by bone marrow cells

Posttransplant infusion of donor bone marrow cells (BMC) induces tolerance to allografts in adult mice, dogs, nonhuman primates, and probably humans. Here we used a mouse skin allograft model and an allogeneic radiation chimera model to examine the role of MHC Ags in tolerance induction. Infusion of MHC class II Ag-deficient (CIID) BMC failed to prolong C57BL/6 (B6) skin grafts in ALS- and rapamycin-treated B10.A mice, whereas wild-type B6 or MHC class I Ag-deficient BMC induced prolongation. Removal of class II Ag-bearing cells from donor BMC markedly reduced the tolerogenic effect compared with untreated BMC, although graft survival was significantly longer in mice given depleted BMC than that in control mice given no BMC. Infusion of CIID BMC into irradiated syngeneic B6 or allogeneic B10.A mice produced normal lymphoid cell reconstitution including CD4+ T cells except for the absence of class II Ag-positive cells. However, irradiated B10.A mice reconstituted with CIID BMC rejected all B6 and a majority of CIID skin grafts despite continued maintenance of high degree chimerism. B10.A mice reconstituted with B6 BMC maintained chimerism and accepted both B6 and CIID skin grafts. Thus, expression of MHC class II Ag on BMC is essential for allograft tolerance induction and peripheral chimerism with cells deficient in class II Ag does not guarantee allograft acceptance.

Blockade of CD28-B7, but not CD40-CD154, prevents costimulation of allogeneic porcine and xenogeneic human anti-porcine T cell responses

Despite increasing use of swine in transplantation research, the ability to block costimulation of allogeneic T cell responses has not been demonstrated in swine, and the effects of costimulatory blockade on xenogeneic human anti-porcine T cell responses are also not clear. We have compared the in vitro effects of anti-human CD154 mAb and human CTLA4IgG4 on allogeneic pig T cell responses and xenogeneic human anti-pig T cell responses. Both anti-CD154 mAb and CTLA4IgG4 cross-reacted on pig cells. While anti-CD154 mAb and CTLA4IgG4 both inhibited the primary allogeneic pig MLRs, CTLA4IgG4 (7.88 microg/ml) was considerably more inhibitory than anti-CD154 mAb (100 microg/ml) at optimal doses. Anti-CD154 mAb inhibited the production of IFN-gamma by 75%, but did not inhibit IL-10 production, while CTLA4IgG4 completely inhibited the production of both IFN-gamma and IL-10. In secondary allogeneic pig MLRs, CTLA4IgG4, but not anti-CD154 mAb, induced Ag-specific T cell anergy. CTLAIgG4 completely blocked the indirect pathway of allorecognition, while anti-CD154 mAb blocked the indirect response by approximately 50%. The generation of porcine CTLs was inhibited by CTLA4IgG4, but not by anti-CD154 mAb. Human anti-porcine xenogeneic MLRs were blocked by CTLA4IgG4, but only minimally by anti-CD154 mAb. Finally, CTLA4IgG4 prevented secondary xenogeneic human anti-porcine T cell responses. These data indicate that blockade of the B7-CD28 pathway was more effective than blockade of the CD40-CD154 pathway in inhibiting allogeneic pig T cell responses and xenogeneic human anti-pig T cell responses in vitro. These findings have implications for inhibiting cell-mediated immune responses in pig-to-human xenotransplantation.

Transplant surgery injury recruits recipient MHC class II-positive leukocytes into the kidney

BACKGROUND

CD4 T cells, which are stimulated by the "indirect pathway" of antigen-presentation, participate in rejection. These T cells are sensitized by recipient major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II-positive leukocytes that migrate into the transplant. Therefore, an important early step in rejection is the immigration of these recipient MHC class II-positive leukocytes into the renal transplant. The regulation of this early step is not understood. We now test the hypothesis that such leukocytes immigrate into the renal transplant in response to ischemic injury occurring during the transplant procedure.

METHODS

We transplanted Brown Norway (BN) kidneys into F1 Lewis/Brown Norway (L/BN) recipients. The F1 recipients are tolerant to the parental BN antigens, and any infiltration of recipient MHC class II-positive leukocytes results from injury occurring during transplantation surgery. In addition, ischemia/reperfusion injury was also induced by temporarily occluding the native renal arteries for 30 minutes. Transplanted kidneys and native kidneys, which suffered ischemia/reperfusion injury, were studied by immunohistochemistry on days 3, 7, 14, and 28 after surgery. Staining by the new monoclonal antibody (mAb) OX62 and antibodies to MHC class II identified dendritic cells. In addition, the following monoclonal antibodies identified: gamma/delta T cells, V65; B cells, OX33; cells that may be macrophages, dendritic cells, or dendritic cell precursors, ED1 (+) and OX62 (-); and recipient class II MHC, OX3.

RESULTS

After transplantation, the serum creatinine increased to 4 mg/dl and then decreased, which was consistent with reversible injury during transplantation and the absence of rejection. We found that the injury of transplantation itself resulted in the infiltration of recipient MHC class II-positive leukocytes into the transplanted kidney. This infiltrate peaked at days 7 to 14 after surgery. The inflammation was peritubular and patchy and involved cortex and outer medulla. Double staining for OX62 and OX3 identified some of the infiltrating leukocytes as dendritic cells. Other recipient leukocytes were MHC class II positive, ED1 positive, and OX62 negative. We also found that MHC class II leukocytes, including dendritic cells, infiltrated native kidneys injured by ischemia/reperfusion injury.

CONCLUSION

To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration that injury to the kidney during transplantation recruits recipient MHC class II-positive leukocytes into the kidney. Some of these leukocytes are dendritic cells.

Transplantation tolerance-where do we stand?

Our understanding of tolerance mechanisms has progressed to the point that tolerance-induction protocols are being tested in humans for organ transplantation. However, a range of scientific, ethical, logistic and commercial issues have arisen, and must be resolved before tolerance induction for human allograft patients can become a reality.

Gene targeting: applications in transplantation research

Gene targeting, the manipulation of gene in the mouse genome using homologous recombination in embryonic stem cells, is a powerful experimental tool that has been widely utilized in a number of disciplines. The ability to precisely alter genes in this way provides an avenue for investigating the role of a gene product in normal and pathological processes in the intact animal, with a precision and efficacy not possible using pharmacological agents, antibodies or engineered proteins. In transplant research, gene targeting provides a unique tool for discriminating the contributions of gene expression in donor versus recipient tissues. This review focuses on several areas in transplantation research where gene targeting has made useful contributions. These include studies of the role of donor and recipient multiple histocompatibility complex antigens in regulating rejection responses, the role of CD4+ T cell in mediating acute rejection, and the functions of cytokines during rejection and tolerance induction. These studies highlight the unique advantages of gene targeting in studies of complex processes in whole animals and illustrate the contributions of this technique to understanding the pathogenesis of allograft rejection.

Cellular and humoral mechanisms of vascularized allograft rejection induced by indirect recognition of donor MHC allopeptides

INTRODUCTION

To investigate the role and mechanisms of indirect allorecognition in allograft rejection, we studied whether priming T cells with donor-derived MHC allopeptides could accelerate rejection in a vascularized allograft model.

METHODS

Lewis recipients of fully mismatched Wistar Furth cardiac allografts were immunized before transplantation with donor MHC allopeptides.

RESULTS

Animals immunized with immunogenic class II MHC allopeptides rejected their grafts in a significantly accelerated fashion compared with controls. Additional studies demonstrated that a single immunodominant RT1.D (HLA-DR like) allopeptide was responsible for accelerating the rejection process. Histological analysis of rejected allografts revealed marked vascular rejection in the accelerated, although not the control, group as well as severe cellular rejection. Peak production of IgM and IgG donor-specific alloantibodies was detected by flow cytometry 1 week earlier in the sera of the accelerated group compared with the control group. Immunohistological analysis of grafts from the accelerated compared with the control group showed increased endothelial deposition of IgG2b, C3, and fibrin, and up-regulation of class II MHC molecule expression. Increased intragraft expression of interferon-y and the interferon-gamma-induced chemokines, inducible protein-10 and Mig, and infiltration by activated mononuclear cells expressing CXCR3, the receptor for inducible protein-10 and Mig, was also seen.

CONCLUSION

These novel data provide evidence of a definitive link between indirect allorecognition of donor-derived MHC class II peptides and the cellular and humoral mechanisms of vascularized allograft rejection.

Human Anti-Porcine T Cell Response: Blocking with Anti-Class I Antibody Leads to Hyporesponsiveness and a Switch in Cytokine Production

Intervention in the molecular interactions that lead to an immune response is possible at various stages of Ag recognition and T cell activation. Perturbation of the interaction of the TCR with the MHC/peptide ligand complex is one approach that has shown promise for autoimmunity and graft rejection in blocking T cell-activated responses. In this study, we investigated the effect of altering the target MHC class I molecule by blocking with Abs. We established a system that analyzed the human T cell response against MHC class I+/class II− porcine stimulatory cell targets. The primary human response against porcine smooth muscle cells was CD8+ T cell dependent. In the presence of F(ab′)2 fragments of the MHC class I-reactive Ab, PT-85, the proliferative response was inhibited and production of IL-2 and IFN-γ was blocked. Moreover, in a secondary response, proliferation was reduced and type 1 cytokine levels were inhibited. In contrast, levels of IL-10 and IL-4 were sustained or slightly increased. These findings indicate that Ab against MHC class I blocked the recognition of porcine cells by the human CD8+ T cells and altered the cytokine secretion profile. Thus, a single treatment with PT-85 F(ab′)2 directed against the MHC class I molecule provides an attractive approach to the induction of T cell tolerance that may provide long-term graft survival in porcine-to-human cell transplantation.

Hypothesis: is renal allograft rejection initiated by the response to injury sustained during the transplant process?

Allograft rejection can be caused by numerous factors such as damage to the donor kidney during surgical removal or implantation, injury sustained during the transport process between the donor and recipient, and suboptimal allograft perfusion during the intra- and post-operative period. In cadaveric allografts, damage can occur during cold storage, during the transit stage between donor and recipient, and hemodynamic instability due to the initial damage that caused its removal from the donor (such as brain death or trauma). We hypothesize that rejection requires recognition of this injury in addition to recognition of alloantigens. If indeed injury proves to be one factor in acute rejection episodes, then therapeutic efforts can be made to reduce injury during the transplantation process.

Indirect recognition of donor HLA class I peptides in lung transplant recipients with bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome

BACKGROUND

The presentation of donor MHC class II-derived peptides by host antigen-presenting cells in the context of self-MHC class II molecules has been suggested as a mechanism for the chronic rejection of kidney and heart allografts. The aim of this study was to determine whether indirect allorecognition of HLA class I-derived peptides occurred in lung transplant (LTx) recipients and whether it correlated with the development of bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome (BOS).

METHODS

Peripheral blood mononuclear cells from LTx recipients were cultured with synthetic peptides corresponding to the hypervariable regions of the mismatched HLA class I antigens of the donor. Proliferation and precursor frequency (PF) of allopeptide reactive T cells were determined by the incorporation of [3H]thymidine into DNA and limiting dilution analysis.

RESULTS

Peripheral blood leukocytes of LTx recipients with BOS mismatched for HLA class I molecules showed a proliferative response three- to fourfold higher than those observed in mismatched recipients without BOS and in normal control individuals (P<0.001). Similarly, the PF of allopeptide-reactive T cell was 3- to 24-fold higher in recipients with BOS compared with recipients without BOS (P<0.05) as well as normal control individuals (P<0.03). The T cell PF to donor-specific allopeptides, as well as irrelevant allopeptides, was not significantly different in LTx recipients without BOS and normal control individuals.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that T cells from LTx recipients are sensitized to mismatched HLA class I antigens. The sensitization was significantly higher in LTx recipients with BOS compared with LTx recipients without BOS. Strategies to block T-cell responses generated by indirect allorecognition after lung transplantation may provide a means for the prevention or treatment of BOS in LTx recipients.

Tolerance to Antigen-Presenting Cell-Depleted Islet Allografts Is CD4 T Cell Dependent

Pretreatment of pancreatic islets in 95% oxygen culture depletes graft-associated APCs and leads to indefinite allograft acceptance in immunocompetent recipients. As such, the APC-depleted allograft represents a model of peripheral alloantigen presentation in the absence of donor-derived costimulation. Over time, a state of donor-specific tolerance develops in which recipients are resistant to donor APC-induced graft rejection. Thus, persistence of the graft is sufficient to induce tolerance independent of other immune interventions. Donor-specific tolerance could be adoptively transferred to immune-deficient SCID recipient mice transplanted with fresh immunogenic islet allografts, indicating that the original recipient was not simply “ignorant” of donor antigens. Interestingly, despite the fact that the original islet allograft presented only MHC class I alloantigens, CD8+ T cells obtained from tolerant animals readily collaborated with naive CD4+ T cells to reject donor-type islet grafts. Conversely, tolerant CD4+ T cells failed to collaborate effectively with naive CD8+ T cells for the rejection of donor-type grafts. In conclusion, the MHC class I+, II− islet allograft paradoxically leads to a change in the donor-reactive CD4 T cell subset and not in the CD8 subset. We hypothesize that the tolerant state is not due to direct class I alloantigen presentation to CD8 T cells but, rather, occurs via the indirect pathway of donor Ag presentation to CD4 T cells in the context of host MHC class II molecules.

Regulatory function of human CD4+ cytolytic T lymphocytes

Allograft rejection is mediated by both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. The lytic function of the classic CD8+ cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) occurs through recognition of allogeneic major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I on the surface of the graft. CD4+ CTL recognize MHC class II through a direct recognition pathway or an indirect pathway where MHC peptides are presented in the context of self MHC class II. Lytic CD4+ cells may destroy graft tissue or, we hypothesize, the indirect CD4+ T cell may down regulate CD8+ CTL by recognition of donor MHC peptides presented by self MHC class II expressed on CD8+ T cells. To define the role of CD4+ CTL in allograft outcome we used a CD4+ CTL that is MHC class II restricted, recognizing human leucocyte antigen (HLA)-A1 and HLA-B8 peptides in the context of HLA-DR4. This line (MDSxA1/B8) will lyse DR4+ B lymphoblastoid cells (LCL) pulsed with HLA-A1/B8 peptides (amino acids 60-84 of the alpha1 domain of the MHC class I molecule). These T cells will also lyse peptide-pulsed antigen-specific T cell clones, both CD4+ and CD8+, that express HLA-DR4. These clones must process and present the MHC class I peptides for recognition and lysis to occur. These results suggest a possible mechanism to explain allograft tolerance. Lytic CD4+ T cells, that recognize donor HLA peptides through an indirect antigen presentation pathway, down-regulate donor-specific CTL through peptide-specific lysis resulting in graft tolerance.

Evidence of indirect allorecognition in long-term human renal transplantation

The purpose of this study was to investigate indirect alloreactivity in the peripheral blood of long-term renal transplanted patients. We evaluated the T cell proliferative response to a whole pool of donor cell-derived allopeptides, processed and presented by host antigen-presenting cells (APC), rather than to synthetic peptides. For the indirect pathway, proliferation assays were performed using APC-depleted donor cells. Indirect alloreactivity was detected in 57% (8/14) of the patients, 6 of whom presented no evidence of rejection, but 2 patients had a diagnosis of chronic rejection. In 4 of 8 positive cases (50%), proliferation was detected with 5 days of culture, and sometimes indirect alloresponse was the dominant route. We present evidence that the indirect alloproliferative response to a pool of naturally processed donor peptides is present in the peripheral blood of long-term renal transplanted patients irrespective of rejection.

Direct and indirect recognition: the role of MHC antigens in graft rejection

In graft rejection, T-cell stimulation by donor APCs and self-APCs (presenting peptides of donor origin) has been called 'direct' and 'indirect' recognition, respectively. Here, Dina Gould and Hugh Auchincloss consider the traditional arguments favoring direct recognition and highlight recent findings suggesting the importance of indirect responses, thereby questioning some of our basic concepts of transplantation immunology.

The role of CD8 and CD4 T cells in intestinal allograft rejection: a comparison of monoclonal antibody-treated and knockout mice

BACKGROUND

The relative contribution of CD8 and CD4 T cells to allograft rejection remains an unresolved issue. Experimental results suggest that the relative importance of these T-cell subsets may vary depending on the model used and the organ studied. We have previously shown that treatment of murine recipients of intestinal allografts with a depleting anti-CD8 or a depleting anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody (mAb) significantly inhibited allograft rejection. This study was undertaken to further examine the contribution of CD8 and CD4 T cells to the rejection of intestinal allografts.

METHODS

Intestinal allografts from B6C3F1/J (C57BL/6 x C3H/HeJ) mice were transplanted into C57BL/6 recipients. Recipient groups included mice with an acquired deficiency in CD8 or CD4 T cells caused by treatment with depleting mAb or mice genetically deficient in CD8 or CD4 T cells as a result of disruption of the genes encoding major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I, MHC class II, CD8, or CD4. In all cases, rejection was assessed histologically at predetermined time points. In some recipient groups, graft function was also assessed using a maltose absorption assay.

RESULTS

Rejection, assessed between days 10 and 28 after transplantation, was significantly inhibited in mice deficient in CD8 or CD4 T cells after treatment with depleting mAb. In contrast, mice genetically deficient in either CD8 T cells (MHC class I or CD8 knockouts) or CD4 T cells (MHC class II or CD4 knockouts) rejected intestinal allografts promptly. Both histologic and functional evaluation of anti-CD8 mAb-treated mice on day 60 showed that the inhibition of rejection persisted even after the return of a substantial number of CD8 T cells. Although intestinal allografts from anti-CD8 mAb-treated mice displayed little to no evidence of rejection on day 60 after transplantation, these mice were able to reject both donor and third-party skin grafts.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate that the inhibition of intestinal allograft rejection associated with mAb treatment is not attributable solely to depletion of CD8 or CD4 T cells. Furthermore, anti-CD8 mAb administration did not induce donor-specific tolerance or cause nonspecific immune suppression, as indicated by the skin-grafting experiments. Our findings suggest that at least some depleting mAbs mediate their protective effect on allograft rejection via an alternative mechanism such as the induction of a regulatory cell population(s).

Contributions of Direct and Indirect T Cell Alloreactivity During Allograft Rejection in Mice

The immune response to transplanted allogeneic tissues is mediated by T cells that recognize donor histocompatibility Ags either via direct (donor MHC and peptides) or indirect (recipient MHC and donor-derived peptides) allorecognition pathways. The relative contribution of each of these pathways to allograft rejection remains largely unknown. To address this, we used an enzyme-linked immunospot assay to define the frequency and cytokine phenotype of T cells responding via direct and indirect pathways to alloantigens at various time points following placement of allogeneic B10.A skin grafts on BALB/c recipient mice. During acute graft rejection &gt;90% of the anti-B10.A T cell repertoire was directed toward intact donor MHC molecules, while T cells recognizing indirectly presented, donor-derived peptides accounted for &lt;10%. This indirect response was comprised of reactivity toward both MHC-derived and, to a lesser extent, minor Ag-derived determinants. The direct and indirect alloresponses were predominantly detected in recipient lymph nodes and were mediated by T cells displaying a mixed type 1/type 2 cytokine phenotype. Six weeks following rejection, however, the memory allospecific T cell response became predominant in the recipient spleen, with only minimal activity detectable in the draining lymph nodes. This work provides a new approach for analysis of the immunophysiology of allograft rejection and should be useful for monitoring immune responses to graft Ags in human transplant recipients.

Induction of immunologic tolerance for transplantation

In the second half of the 20th century, the transplantation of replacement organs and tissues to cure disease has become a clinical reality. Success has been achieved as a direct result of progress in understanding the cellular and molecular biology of the immune system. This understanding has led to the development of immunosuppressive pharmaceuticals that are part of nearly every transplantation procedure. All such drugs are toxic to some degree, however, and their chronic use, mandatory in transplantation, predisposes the patient to the development of infection and cancer. In addition, many of them may have deleterious long-term effects on the function of grafts. New immunosuppressive agents are constantly under development, but organ transplantation remains a therapy that requires patients to choose between the risks of their primary illness and its treatment on the one hand, and the risks of life-long systemic immunosuppression on the other. Alternatives to immunosuppression include modulation of donor grafts to reduce immunogenicity, removal of passenger leukocytes, transplantation into immunologically privileged sites like the testis or thymus, encapsulation of tissue, and the induction of a state of immunologic tolerance. It is the last of these alternatives that has, perhaps, the most promise and most generic applicability as a future therapy. Recent reports documenting long-term graft survival in the absence of immunosuppression suggest that tolerance-based therapies may soon become a clinical reality. Of particular interest to our laboratory are transplantation strategies that focus on the induction of donor-specific T-cell unresponsiveness. The basic biology, protocols, experimental outcomes, and clinical implications of tolerance-based transplantation are the focus of this review.

The effector component of the cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response has a biphasic pattern after burn injury

INTRODUCTION

Burn injury delays allograft rejection and impairs the host defense against infection. These functions are mediated via the cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) response. The CTL response is divided into antigen recognition/processing and effector phases. Presensitization allows selective analysis of changes, induced by burn injury, in the effector limb of the CTL response in relation to time and burn size.

METHODS

Anesthetized CBA mice were primed with either a flank allograft from C57BL/6 (B6) mice or an autograft (negative control). Five weeks after grafting, animals were anesthetized and received either a 0, 20, or 40% burn. Spleens were harvested 3, 7, 10, and 14 days after burn injury (n = 96), cocultured with B6 stimulator splenocytes, and assessed for CTL response to radiolabeled allogeneic targets in a 51Cr release assay. In experiment 2, spleens were harvested from unburned and 40% burned animals on Postburn Days 3 and 14. After triple staining, cells were analyzed by flow cytometry for CD4, CD8, and CD25 antigens. In experiment 3, splenocytes from 0 and 40% burned animals on Postburn Days 3 and 14, were cocultured with B6 stimulators for 5 days. Supernatants were evaluated for interleukin (IL)-2, IL-5, and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) using ELISA:

RESULTS

The CTL response for 20 and 40% burned animals decreased 3 days postburn (-11.9 and -30.1%, P < 0.05), returned to baseline in 7-10 days, and was increased by 14 days postburn (15.8 and 22.6%, P < 0.05). The T-helper lymphocyte population (CD4) from 40% burn animals was significantly decreased on Postburn Days 3 and 14 (10.12 +/- 0.45% vs 11.78 +/- 0.29% and 10.19 +/- 0.24% vs 14.21 +/- 0.97%, respectively, P < 0.05). The CTL effector (CD8) splenocyte population was significantly higher in the burned animals on Postburn Day 14 (4.55% vs 3.71%, P < 0.05). On Postburn Day 3, average IL-5 production was higher in the burned animals (1.80 pg/ml vs 0.59 pg/ml, respectively, P < 0.05). The burn group, on Postburn Days 3 and 14, showed a decrease in mean IL-2 production (212.81 pg/ml vs 263.6 pg/ml and 342.7 pg/ml vs 421.4 pg/ml, respectively, P < 0.05). Mean IFN-gamma production on Postburn Days 3 and 14 was decreased in burned mice (263.75 pg/ml vs 285.57 pg/ml and 218.16 pg/ml vs 263.42 pg/ml, P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Burn injury impairs the effector limb of the CTL response as a function of burn size in the immediate postburn period. CTL activity returns to baseline within 7-10 days postburn and has a rebound increase by Day 14. Early CTL suppression, after burn injury, may be due to a decrease in the T-helper subpopulation. The late increase in cytotoxicity may be secondary to an increase in the effector CTL population in the late postburn period. Burn injury causes a T-helper-2 phenotype as demonstrated by depressed IL-2 and IFN-gamma production and increased IL-5 production.

Cutting Edge: Linked Suppression of Skin Graft Rejection Can Operate Through Indirect Recognition

Adult mice can be rendered immunologically tolerant of allogeneic tissues if transplanted under cover of mAbs to CD4 and CD8. Tolerance generated in this manner is characterized by the presence of regulatory CD4+ T cells that can recruit naive T cells to become tolerant also through “infectious tolerance.” Regulatory CD4+ T cells can also suppress rejection of third party transplant Ags provided they are expressed on the same graft as the tolerated Ags. This process of linked suppression can act across whole MHC barriers and represents a powerful mechanism with therapeutic potential. Tolerance can also be induced to reprocessed minor transplantation Ags presented through host APCs (indirect recognition). We here demonstrate that linked suppression can also be induced through the indirect pathway. This finding may be important in the development of transplantation tolerance in the clinic.

Effect of major histocompatibility complex expression on murine intestinal graft survival

BACKGROUND

Clinical intestinal transplantation has been plagued by frequent and severe graft rejection. It has been proposed that the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens might play a critical role in this process owing to their extensive expression on enterocytes and mucosa-associated immune cells.

METHODS

The present study examined the role of MHC antigens in intestinal graft rejection using MHC class I-deficient and MHC class II-deficient donors.

RESULTS

Grafts with normal MHC expression were rejected by 9 days, whereas survival was prolonged to 14 days in the MHC class II-deficient grafts (P=NS) and to 20 days in the MHC I-deficient grafts (P<0.002). In all groups, early rejection was characterized by (1) increased crypt cell apoptosis, as detected by the terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase-mediated dUTP-biotin nick end labeling (TUNEL) technique of in situ labeling; and (2) the increased expression of perforin and a CD8 phenotype in the graft-infiltrating cells.

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that MHC antigens, CD8-positive T cells, and perforin-expressing cells contribute to intestinal graft rejection. Apoptosis of the progenitor epithelial crypt cells during early intestinal rejection may impair the gut's ability to regenerate and repair mucosal damage.

Role of donor and recipient antigen-presenting cells in priming and maintaining T cells with indirect allospecificity

BACKGROUND

It has been suggested that the sensitization of recipient T lymphocytes against peptides derived from allogeneic major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens in the context of self-MHC molecules may contribute to the pathogenesis of chronic allograft rejection. The purpose of this study was to quantitate and characterize the indirect alloresponse in renal transplantation.

METHODS

An HLA-A2-negative patient whose A2-positive kidney transplant failed as a result of chronic rejection was selected for this study. T-cell clones were raised using a cocktail of peptides corresponding to polymorphic regions of the A2 sequence and studied by measuring their proliferation using [3H]thymidine incorporation. The presence in vivo of HLA-A2-specific T cells was assessed using limiting dilution analysis.

RESULTS

T-cell clones were specific for a single peptide of HLA-A2, residues 92-120, and restricted by HLA-DRB1*1502. The frequency of interleukin-2-secreting T cells specific for this A2 peptide was 1:86,000, only 2-fold lower than that measured against the recall antigen tetanus toxoid. Capitalizing on the similarity of the donor and recipient DR15 alleles (DRB1*1501 and 1502), the question was addressed as to how these T cells had been primed in vivo. Although the large majority of clones responded to A2 synthetic peptide presented by both DR15 alleles, only 3 of 10 clones responded to cells co-expressing DRB1*1501 and A2.

CONCLUSION

These data suggest that antigen presentation by recipient APCs is responsible for maintaining T cells with indirect allospecificity in vivo and that, in the context of partial DR matching, indirect presentation by the parenchymal cells of the graft may serve to induce tolerance in T cells with indirect allospecificity.

The presentation of self and allogeneic MHC peptides to T lymphocytes

The presentation of donor-derived MHC peptides by recipient APCs to T cells is an essential component of the rejection of allografts (indirect allorecognition). Initial alloreactive T cell response is confined to a few well processed and presented dominant determinants on donor MHC. However, during long-term graft rejection, T cell response spreads to formerly poorly presented cryptic allogeneic MHC peptides. This phenomenon is likely to play an important role in the amplification and the perpetuation of the rejection process. Additionally, we present evidence that T cell repertoire selection to allogeneic MHC peptides is acquired via recognition of self-MHC peptides presented in the thymus during ontogeny. Supporting this view, we have shown that indirect alloresponses can lead to self-T cell tolerance breakdown to cross-reactive determinants on self-MHC molecules or alternatively that sensitization of recipients to self-MHC peptides can lead to accelerated graft rejection. It is therefore essential to determine the factors which govern the processing and presentation of self and allogeneic MHC molecules and to elucidate the mechanisms regulating subsequent T cell responses in order to design antigen-specific based immune therapies in transplantation.

Indirect T Cell Allorecognition and Alloantibody-Mediated Rejection of MHC Class I-Disparate Heart Grafts

Recent studies in the rat have identified a role for T cell-dependent alloantibody in rejection of MHC class I-disparate allografts. RT1Aa-disparate PVG.R8 heart grafts are rejected acutely in naive, and hyperacutely in sensitized, PVG.RT1u recipients by CD4 T cell-dependent alloantibody. Here, we examined the T cell Ag recognition pathways responsible and show that direct injection into skeletal muscle of plasmid DNA, encoding a water-soluble form of the RT1Aa MHC class I heavy chain (pcmu-tAa), stimulates IgG2b cytotoxic alloantibody and markedly accelerates rejection of PVG.R8 heart grafts (median survival time 2 days). pcmu-tAa injection did not induce CTL to Aa, arguing against direct allorecognition of soluble Aa. Treatment with mAbs confirmed that the alloimmune response to pcmu-tAa injection depended on CD4, not CD8, T cells. Priming T cells for indirect allorecognition by injection of 15-mer peptides spanning the α1 and α2 domains of Aa failed to stimulate anti-Aa Ab but caused an accelerated Ab response to a PVG.R8 heart and a modest acceleration in graft rejection (median survival time 4 days). These results suggest that both soluble MHC class I and allopeptides prime CD4 T cells by the indirect pathway, but that soluble class I is a more effective immunogen for humoral alloimmunity because its tertiary protein structure provides B cell epitopes. We propose that priming humoral alloimmunity, like CTL priming, requires recognition of intact MHC on donor cells, but essential T cell help can be provided by CD4 T cells recognizing allogeneic class I exclusively by the indirect pathway.

Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay spot detection of interferon-gamma and interleukin 5-producing cells as a predictive marker for renal allograft failure

BACKGROUND

Despite improvements in the short-term survival of renal transplants, many allografts fail over the 5-10 years after transplantation. We sought to identify an immunologic assay that could identify those patients at high risk for future allograft failure.

METHODS

Blood samples were obtained from 23 renal allograft recipients with acute and/or chronic graft dysfunction and from 22 controls. Isolated peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) were tested for interferon (IFN)-gamma and interleukin (IL)-5 production using an enzyme-linked immunosorbent spot assay. IFN-gamma:IL-5 ratios were calculated and compared between groups. Among the 23 patients with graft dysfunction, the ratios were also compared with graft function at 6 months.

RESULTS

IFN-gamma:IL-5 ratios of > or = 15 were associated with allograft rejection episodes in 8 of 12 cases, whereas 10 of 11 episodes of graft dysfunction from other causes (infection, drug toxicity, obstruction) were associated with values <15. All normal controls had values <15 (22/22). Among the graft recipients with acute renal failure, all patients with IFN-gamma:IL-5 ratios <15 exhibited improved renal function at 6-month follow-up (14/14), whereas 8 of 9 patients with IFN-gamma:IL-5 ratios > or = 15 developed allograft failure at 6 months (sensitivity 100%, specificity 93.3%).

CONCLUSION

In renal transplant recipients with acute allograft dysfunction, mitogen-induced peripheral blood lymphocyte IFN-gamma:IL-5 ratios > or = 15 were highly predictive of allograft failure within 6 months of the assay. This test may be a useful prognostic marker for identification of transplant recipients with acute graft dysfunction who are at high risk for future graft loss and thus allow targeted therapeutic interventions to prolong graft survival.

Immunogenicity of cultured keratinocyte allografts deficient in major histocompatibility complex antigens

BACKGROUND

Full-thickness (FT) and cultured keratinocyte (CK) allografts have been used as temporary skin replacements in patients with massive burns, but these grafts are ultimately rejected after restoration of host immunocompetence. Genetic engineering has permitted the creation of knockout (KO) mice deficient in class I or class II major histocompatibility antigens. This study examines the immunogenicity of such grafts to determine if these genetically modified keratinocytes could be used for permanent wound coverage.

METHODS

Host sensitization to alloantigen was assessed by second-set rejection. CBA mice (n = 111) were primed with flank grafts consisting of FT and CK allografts from normal C57BL/6 donors, FT and CK class I KO allografts, FT and CK class II KO allografts, and CK autografts. Three weeks later, hosts were challenged with normal tail allografts and observed for second-set rejection. Median graft survival was analyzed by chi2 and Wilcoxon rank tests. In the second experiment, cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) were harvested from CBA mice (n = 28) 3 weeks after flank grafting. CTL effectors were tested on radiolabeled targets at various ratios in a 51Cr release assay. Dilution curves of CTL activity were compared by analysis of variance.

RESULTS

Hosts primed with CK or FT allografts demonstrated accelerated rejection of second-set tail grafts compared with hosts covered with CBA autografts. CK knockout grafts were less immunogenic than FT knockout skin; class II KO allografts were considerably less immunogenic than class I KO allografts. CTL activity against the knockout CK allografts was negligible compared with that of hosts primed with normal allografts or FT knockout allografts.

CONCLUSION

Although full-thickness knockout skin retains substantial immunogenicity, cultured keratinocytes deficient in class II antigens fail to prime for accelerated second-set rejection and do not elicit a CTL response in the graft recipient. This lack of immunogenicity may permit the indefinite survival of allogeneic knockout keratinocytes in patients requiring massive wound excision and coverage.