Branching and laminar origin of projections between visual cortical areas in the cat

Suppressing feedback signals to visual cortex abolishes attentional modulation

Attention improves perception by enhancing the neural encoding of sensory information. A long-standing hypothesis is that cortical feedback projections carry top-down signals to influence sensory coding. However, this hypothesis has never been tested to establish causal links. We used viral tools to label feedback connections from cortical area V4 targeting early visual cortex (area V1). While monkeys performed a visual-spatial attention task, inactivating feedback axonal terminals in V1 without altering local intracortical and feedforward inputs reduced the response gain of single cells and impaired the accuracy of neural populations for encoding external stimuli. These effects are primarily manifested in the superficial layers of V1 and propagate to downstream area V4. Attention enhances sensory coding across visual cortex by specifically altering the strength of corticocortical feedback in a layer-dependent manner.

Evaluation of advances in cortical development using model systems

Compared with that of even the closest primates, the human cortex displays a high degree of specialization and expansion that largely emerges developmentally. Although decades of research in the mouse and other model systems has revealed core tenets of cortical development that are well preserved across mammalian species, small deviations in transcription factor expression, novel cell types in primates and/or humans, and unique cortical architecture distinguish the human cortex. Importantly, many of the genes and signaling pathways thought to drive human-specific cortical expansion also leave the brain vulnerable to disease, as the misregulation of these factors is highly correlated with neurodevelopmental and neuropsychiatric disorders. However, creating a comprehensive understanding of human-specific cognition and disease remains challenging. Here, we review key stages of cortical development and highlight known or possible differences between model systems and the developing human brain. By identifying the developmental trajectories that may facilitate uniquely human traits, we highlight open questions in need of approaches to examine these processes in a human context and reveal translatable insights into human developmental disorders.

A direct interareal feedback-to-feedforward circuit in primate visual cortex

The mammalian sensory neocortex consists of hierarchically organized areas reciprocally connected via feedforward (FF) and feedback (FB) circuits. Several theories of hierarchical computation ascribe the bulk of the computational work of the cortex to looped FF-FB circuits between pairs of cortical areas. However, whether such corticocortical loops exist remains unclear. In higher mammals, individual FF-projection neurons send afferents almost exclusively to a single higher-level area. However, it is unclear whether FB-projection neurons show similar area-specificity, and whether they influence FF-projection neurons directly or indirectly. Using viral-mediated monosynaptic circuit tracing in macaque primary visual cortex (V1), we show that V1 neurons sending FF projections to area V2 receive monosynaptic FB inputs from V2, but not other V1-projecting areas. We also find monosynaptic FB-to-FB neuron contacts as a second motif of FB connectivity. Our results support the existence of FF-FB loops in primate cortex, and suggest that FB can rapidly and selectively influence the activity of incoming FF signals.

Visual Corticocortical Inputs to Ferret Area 18

Visual cortical areas in the adult mammalian brain are linked by a network of interareal feedforward and feedback circuits. We investigated the topography of feedback projections to ferret (Mustela putorius furo) area 18 from extrastriate areas 19, 21, and Ssy. Our objective was to characterize the anatomical organization of the extrastriate feedback pool to area 18. We also wished to determine if feedback projections to area 18 share similar features as feedback projections to area 17. We injected the tracer cholera toxin B subunit (CTb) into area 18 of adult ferrets to visualize the distribution and pattern of retrogradely labeled cells in extrastriate cortex. We find several similarities to the feedback projection to area 17: (i) Multiple visual cortical areas provide feedback to area 18: areas 19, 21, Ssy, and weaker inputs from posterior parietal and lateral temporal visual areas. Within each area a greater proportion of feedback projections arises from the infragranular than from the supragranular layers. (ii) The cortical area immediately rostral to area 18 provides the greatest proportion of total cortical feedback, and has the greatest peak density of cells providing feedback to area 18. (iii) The spacing (peak cell density and nearest neighbor distances) of cells in extrastriate cortex providing feedback to areas 17 and 18 are similar. However, peak density of feedback cells to area 18 is comparable in the supra- and infragranular layers, whereas peak density of feedback cells to area 17 is higher in the infragranular layers. Another prominent difference is that dorsal area 18 receives a cortical input that area 17 does not: from ventral cortex representing the upper visual field; this appears to be roughly 25% of the feedback input to area 18. Lastly, area 17 receives a greater proportion of cortical feedback from area 21 than from Ssy, whereas area 18 receives more feedback from Ssy than from area 21. While the organization of feedback projections from extrastriate cortex to areas 17 and 18 is broadly similar, the main difference in input topography might arise due to differences in visual field representations of the two areas.

The Mouse Cortical Connectome, Characterized by an Ultra-Dense Cortical Graph, Maintains Specificity by Distinct Connectivity Profiles

The inter-areal wiring pattern of the mouse cerebral cortex was analyzed in relation to a refined parcellation of cortical areas. Twenty-seven retrograde tracer injections were made in 19 areas of a 47-area parcellation of the mouse neocortex. Flat mounts of the cortex and multiple histological markers enabled detailed counts of labeled neurons in individual areas. The observed log-normal distribution of connection weights to each cortical area spans 5 orders of magnitude and reveals a distinct connectivity profile for each area, analogous to that observed in macaques. The cortical network has a density of 97%, considerably higher than the 66% density reported in macaques. A weighted graph analysis reveals a similar global efficiency but weaker spatial clustering compared with that reported in macaques. The consistency, precision of the connectivity profile, density, and weighted graph analysis of the present data differ significantly from those obtained in earlier studies in the mouse.

Approximating the Architecture of Visual Cortex in a Convolutional Network

Deep convolutional neural networks (CNNs) have certain structural, mechanistic, representational, and functional parallels with primate visual cortex and also many differences. However, perhaps some of the differences can be reconciled. This study develops a cortex-like CNN architecture, via (1) a loss function that quantifies the consistency of a CNN architecture with neural data from tract tracing, cell reconstruction, and electrophysiology studies; (2) a hyperparameter-optimization approach for reducing this loss, and (3) heuristics for organizing units into convolutional-layer grids. The optimized hyperparameters are consistent with neural data. The cortex-like architecture differs from typical CNN architectures. In particular, it has longer skip connections, larger kernels and strides, and qualitatively different connection sparsity. Importantly, layers of the cortex-like network have one-to-one correspondences with cortical neuron populations. This should allow unambiguous comparison of model and brain representations in the future and, consequently, more precise measurement of progress toward more biologically realistic deep networks.

Translaminar circuits formed by the pyramidal cells in the superficial layers of cat visual cortex

Pyramidal cells in the superficial layers of the neocortex provide a major excitatory projection to layer 5, which contains the pyramidal cells that project to subcortical motor-related targets. Both structurally and functionally rather little is known about this interlaminar pathway, especially in higher mammals. Here, we made sparse ultrastructural reconstructions of the projection to layer 5 of three pyramidal neurons from layer 3 in cat V1 whose morphology, physiology, and synaptic connections with layers 2 and 3 were known. The dominant targets of the 74 identified synapses in layer 5 were the dendritic spines of pyramidal cells. The fractions of target spiny dendrites were 59, 61, and 84% for the three cells, with the remaining targets being dendrites of smooth neurons. These fractions were similar to the distribution of targets of unlabeled asymmetric synapses in the surrounding neuropil. Serial section reconstructions revealed that the target dendrites were heterogenous in morphology, indicating that different cell types are innervated. This new evidence indicates that the descending projection from the superficial layer pyramidal cells does not simply drive the output pyramidal cells that project to cortical and subcortical targets, but participates in the complex circuitry of the deep cortical layers.

Feedback from visual cortical area 7 to areas 17 and 18 in cats: How neural web is woven during feedback

To investigate the feedback effect from area 7 to areas 17 and 18, intrinsic signal optical imaging combined with pharmacological, morphological methods and functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) was employed. A spatial frequency-dependent decrease in response amplitude of orientation maps was observed in areas 17 and 18 when area 7 was inactivated by a local injection of GABA, or by a lesion induced by liquid nitrogen freezing. The pattern of orientation maps of areas 17 and 18 after the inactivation of area 7, if they were not totally blurred, paralleled the normal one. In morphological experiments, after one point at the shallow layers within the center of the cat's orientation column of area 17 was injected electrophoretically with HRP (horseradish peroxidase), three sequential patches in layers 1, 2 and 3 of area 7 were observed. Employing fMRI it was found that area 7 feedbacks mainly to areas 17 and 18 on ipsilateral hemisphere. Therefore, our conclusions are: (1) feedback from area 7 to areas 17 and 18 is spatial frequency modulated; (2) feedback from area 7 to areas 17 and 18 occurs mainly ipsilaterally; (3) histological feedback pattern from area 7 to area 17 is weblike.

Anatomy of hierarchy: feedforward and feedback pathways in macaque visual cortex

The laminar location of the cell bodies and terminals of interareal connections determines the hierarchical structural organization of the cortex and has been intensively studied. However, we still have only a rudimentary understanding of the connectional principles of feedforward (FF) and feedback (FB) pathways. Quantitative analysis of retrograde tracers was used to extend the notion that the laminar distribution of neurons interconnecting visual areas provides an index of hierarchical distance (percentage of supragranular labeled neurons [SLN]). We show that: 1) SLN values constrain models of cortical hierarchy, revealing previously unsuspected areal relations; 2) SLN reflects the operation of a combinatorial distance rule acting differentially on sets of connections between areas; 3) Supragranular layers contain highly segregated bottom-up and top-down streams, both of which exhibit point-to-point connectivity. This contrasts with the infragranular layers, which contain diffuse bottom-up and top-down streams; 4) Cell filling of the parent neurons of FF and FB pathways provides further evidence of compartmentalization; 5) FF pathways have higher weights, cross fewer hierarchical levels, and are less numerous than FB pathways. Taken together, the present results suggest that cortical hierarchies are built from supra- and infragranular counterstreams. This compartmentalized dual counterstream organization allows point-to-point connectivity in both bottom-up and top-down directions.

Predictions not commands: active inference in the motor system

The descending projections from motor cortex share many features with top-down or backward connections in visual cortex; for example, corticospinal projections originate in infragranular layers, are highly divergent and (along with descending cortico-cortical projections) target cells expressing NMDA receptors. This is somewhat paradoxical because backward modulatory characteristics would not be expected of driving motor command signals. We resolve this apparent paradox using a functional characterisation of the motor system based on Helmholtz's ideas about perception; namely, that perception is inference on the causes of visual sensations. We explain behaviour in terms of inference on the causes of proprioceptive sensations. This explanation appeals to active inference, in which higher cortical levels send descending proprioceptive predictions, rather than motor commands. This process mirrors perceptual inference in sensory cortex, where descending connections convey predictions, while ascending connections convey prediction errors. The anatomical substrate of this recurrent message passing is a hierarchical system consisting of functionally asymmetric driving (ascending) and modulatory (descending) connections: an arrangement that we show is almost exactly recapitulated in the motor system, in terms of its laminar, topographic and physiological characteristics. This perspective casts classical motor reflexes as minimising prediction errors and may provide a principled explanation for why motor cortex is agranular.

Communication and wiring in the cortical connectome

In cerebral cortex, the huge mass of axonal wiring that carries information between near and distant neurons is thought to provide the neural substrate for cognitive and perceptual function. The goal of mapping the connectivity of cortical axons at different spatial scales, the cortical connectome, is to trace the paths of information flow in cerebral cortex. To appreciate the relationship between the connectome and cortical function, we need to discover the nature and purpose of the wiring principles underlying cortical connectivity. A popular explanation has been that axonal length is strictly minimized both within and between cortical regions. In contrast, we have hypothesized the existence of a multi-scale principle of cortical wiring where to optimize communication there is a trade-off between spatial (construction) and temporal (routing) costs. Here, using recent evidence concerning cortical spatial networks we critically evaluate this hypothesis at neuron, local circuit, and pathway scales. We report three main conclusions. First, the axonal and dendritic arbor morphology of single neocortical neurons may be governed by a similar wiring principle, one that balances the conservation of cellular material and conduction delay. Second, the same principle may be observed for fiber tracts connecting cortical regions. Third, the absence of sufficient local circuit data currently prohibits any meaningful assessment of the hypothesis at this scale of cortical organization. To avoid neglecting neuron and microcircuit levels of cortical organization, the connectome framework should incorporate more morphological description. In addition, structural analyses of temporal cost for cortical circuits should take account of both axonal conduction and neuronal integration delays, which appear mostly of the same order of magnitude. We conclude the hypothesized trade-off between spatial and temporal costs may potentially offer a powerful explanation for cortical wiring patterns.

Segregation of feedforward and feedback projections in mouse visual cortex

Hierarchical organization is a common feature of mammalian neocortex. Neurons that send their axons from lower to higher areas of the hierarchy are referred to as "feedforward" (FF) neurons, whereas those projecting in the opposite direction are called "feedback" (FB) neurons. Anatomical, functional, and theoretical studies suggest that these different classes of projections play fundamentally different roles in perception. In primates, laminar differences in projection patterns often distinguish the two projection streams. In rodents, however, these differences are less clear, despite an established hierarchy of visual areas. Thus the rodent provides a strong test of the hypothesis that FF and FB neurons form distinct populations. We tested this hypothesis by injecting retrograde tracers into two different hierarchical levels of mouse visual cortex (area 17 and anterolateral area [AL]) and then determining the relative proportions of double-labeled FF and FB neurons in an area intermediate to them (lateromedial area [LM]). Despite finding singly labeled neurons densely intermingled with no laminar segregation, we found few double-labeled neurons (≈5% of each singly labeled population). We also examined the development of FF and FB connections. FF connections were present at the earliest timepoint we examined (postnatal day 2, P2), while FB connections were not detectable until P11. Our findings indicate that, even in cortices without laminar segregation of FF and FB neurons, the two projection systems are largely distinct at the neuronal level and also differ with respect to the timing of their axonal outgrowth.

Functional biases in visual cortex neurons with identified projections to higher cortical targets

BACKGROUND

Visual perception involves information flow from lower- to higher-order cortical areas, which are known to process different kinds of information. How does this functional specialization arise? As a step toward addressing this question, we combined fluorescent retrograde tracing with in vivo two-photon calcium imaging to simultaneously compare the tuning properties of neighboring neurons in areas 17 and 18 of ferret visual cortex that have different higher cortical projection targets.

RESULTS

Neurons projecting to the posterior suprasylvian sulcus (PSS) were more direction selective and preferred shorter stimuli, higher spatial frequencies, and higher temporal frequencies than neurons projecting to area 21, anticipating key differences between the functional properties of the target areas themselves. These differences could not be explained by a correspondence between anatomical and functional clustering within early visual cortex, and the largest differences were in properties generated within early visual cortex (direction selectivity and length preference) rather than in properties present in its retinogeniculate inputs.

CONCLUSIONS

These projection cell groups, and hence the higher-order visual areas to which they project, likely obtain their functional properties not from biased retinogeniculate inputs but from highly specific circuitry within the cortex.

Neonatal enucleation during a critical period reduces the precision of cortico-cortical projections in visual cortex

Previous studies have reported that intrahemispheric connections between area 17 (V1, striate cortex) and other cortical visual areas are not point-to-point, but instead have some degree of convergence and divergence. Many pathological conditions can interfere with the normal development of patterns of cortico-cortical connections, but there is little information regarding whether or not early pathological insults can also induce permanent changes in the convergence and divergence of cortical connections. Obtaining this information is important because loss of precision in neural projections can contribute to functional deficits and behavioral impairment. In the present study we investigated whether retinal input is required for the development of normal values of convergence and divergence in the visual callosal pathway. We found that enucleation performed at birth induced significant increases in convergence and divergence compared to control animals. In contrast, values of convergence and divergence in rats enucleated at postnatal day 7 (P7) were similar to those in controls. Previous studies have shown that retinal input during the first postnatal week is required for the specification of the overall distribution and internal topography of visual callosal pathways. Our present results therefore extend these previous finding by showing that retinal input during the first postnatal week also specifies the precision of cortico-cortical projections. These findings raise the possibility that the precision of neural connections may be reduced in other pathological conditions that affect early development of neural connections.

Weight consistency specifies regularities of macaque cortical networks

To what extent cortical pathways show significant weight differences and whether these differences are consistent across animals (thereby comprising robust connectivity profiles) is an important and unresolved neuroanatomical issue. Here we report a quantitative retrograde tracer analysis in the cynomolgus macaque monkey of the weight consistency of the afferents of cortical areas across brains via calculation of a weight index (fraction of labeled neurons, FLN). Injection in 8 cortical areas (3 occipital plus 5 in the other lobes) revealed a consistent pattern: small subcortical input (1.3% cumulative FLN), high local intrinsic connectivity (80% FLN), high-input form neighboring areas (15% cumulative FLN), and weak long-range corticocortical connectivity (3% cumulative FLN). Corticocortical FLN values of projections to areas V1, V2, and V4 showed heavy-tailed, lognormal distributions spanning 5 orders of magnitude that were consistent, demonstrating significant connectivity profiles. These results indicate that 1) connection weight heterogeneity plays an important role in determining cortical network specificity, 2) high investment in local projections highlights the importance of local processing, and 3) transmission of information across multiple hierarchy levels mainly involves pathways having low FLN values.

Evidence regarding the integrity of the posterior medial lateral suprasylvian visual area in the cat

Among the areas of lateral suprasylvian visual cortex in cats defined by Palmer et al. (J Comp Neurol [1978] 177:237-256), PMLS (posterior lateral suprasylvian area) has been the most studied. Although PMLS has strong and well-documented connections with area 17, it is unclear whether these connections extend to its upper visual field representation. We asked what cortical areas send input to the upper field representation in PMLS by making tracer injections in areas 17, 19, and posterior suprasylvian cortex. Tracer injections made in area 17's upper field representation in 15 cats failed to label the corresponding region in PMLS. Instead, they showed that area 17 is strongly connected with the posterior bank of the posterior suprasylvian sulcus (pSS), a region attributed by Palmer et al. to area 21a. Injections in area 19 had the same outcome. We consider this posterior upper field representation plus the lower field representation in PMLS to belong to a single area, LS (lateral suprasylvian visual area). Our data suggest that the upper field representation in PMLS belongs to a different area, most likely AMLS (anterior medial lateral suprasylvian area).

Spatial and temporal features of synaptic to discharge receptive field transformation in cat area 17

The aim of the present study was to characterize the spatial and temporal features of synaptic and discharge receptive fields (RFs), and to quantify their relationships, in cat area 17. For this purpose, neurons were recorded intracellularly while high-frequency flashing bars were used to generate RFs maps for synaptic and spiking responses. Comparison of the maps shows that some features of the discharge RFs depended strongly on those of the synaptic RFs, whereas others were less dependent. Spiking RF duration depended poorly and spiking RF amplitude depended moderately on those of the underlying synaptic RFs. At the other extreme, the optimal spatial frequency and phase of the discharge RFs in simple cells were almost entirely inherited from those of the synaptic RFs. Subfield width, in both simple and complex cells, was less for spiking responses compared with synaptic responses, but synaptic to discharge width ratio was relatively variable from cell to cell. When considering the whole RF of simple cells, additional variability in width ratio resulted from the presence of additional synaptic subfields that remained subthreshold. Due to these additional, subthreshold subfields, spatial frequency tuning predicted from synaptic RFs appears sharper than that predicted from spiking RFs. Excitatory subfield overlap in spiking RFs was well predicted by subfield overlap at the synaptic level. When examined in different regions of the RF, latencies appeared to be quite variable, but this variability showed negligible dependence on distance from the RF center. Nevertheless, spiking response latency faithfully reflected synaptic response latency.

Visual and motor connectivity and the distribution of calcium-binding proteins in macaque frontal eye field: implications for saccade target selection

The frontal eye field (FEF) contributes to directing visual attention and saccadic eye movement through intrinsic processing, interactions with extrastriate visual cortical areas (e.g., V4), and projections to subcortical structures (e.g., superior colliculus, SC). Several models have been proposed to describe the relationship between the allocation of visual attention and the production of saccades. We obtained anatomical information that might provide useful constraints on these models by evaluating two characteristics of FEF. First, we investigated the laminar distribution of efferent connections from FEF to visual areas V4 + TEO and to SC. Second, we examined the laminar distribution of different populations of GABAergic neurons in FEF. We found that the neurons in FEF that project to V4 + TEO are located predominantly in the supragranular layers, colocalized with the highest density of calbindin- and calretinin-immunoreactive inhibitory interneurons. In contrast, the cell bodies of neurons that project to SC are found only in layer 5 of FEF, colocalized primarily with parvalbumin inhibitory interneurons. None of the neurons in layer 5 that project to V4 + TEO also project to SC. These results provide useful constraints for cognitive models of visual attention and saccade production by indicating that different populations of neurons project to extrastriate visual cortical areas and to SC. This finding also suggests that FEF neurons projecting to visual cortex and SC are embedded in different patterns of intracortical circuitry.

Auditory cortex projections target the peripheral field representation of primary visual cortex

The purpose of the present study was to identify projections from auditory to visual cortex and their organization. Retrograde tracers were used to identify the sources of auditory cortical projections to primary visual cortex (areas 17 and 18) in adult cats. Two groups of animals were studied. In the first group, large deposits were centered on the lower visual field representation of the vertical meridian located along the area 17 and 18 border. Following tissue processing, characteristic patterns of cell body labeling were identified in extrastriate visual cortex and the visual thalamus (LGN, MIN, & LPl). In auditory cortex, of the four tonotopically-organized regions, neuronal labeling was identified in the supragranular layers of the posterior auditory field (PAF). Little to no labeling was evident in the primary auditory cortex, the anterior auditory field, the ventral posterior auditory field or in the remaining six non-tonotopically organized regions of auditory cortex. In the second group, small deposits were made into the central or peripheral visual field representations of primary visual cortex. Labeled cells were identified in PAF following deposits into regions of primary visual cortex representing peripheral, but not central, visual field representations. Furthermore, a coarse topography was identified in PAF, with neurons projecting to the upper field representation being located in the gyral portion of PAF and neurons projecting to the lower field representation located in the sulcal portion of PAF. Therefore, direct projections can be identified from tonotopically organized auditory cortex to the earliest stages of visual cortical processing.

Connections of cat auditory cortex: II. Commissural system

The commissural projections between 13 areas of cat auditory cortex (AC) were studied using retrograde tracers. Areal and laminar origins were characterized as part of a larger study of thalamic input and cortical origins of projections to each area. Cholera toxin beta subunit (CTbeta) and cholera toxin beta subunit gold-conjugate (CTbetaG) were injected separately within an area or in different areas in an experiment. The areas were identified independently with SMI-32, which revealed differences in neurofilament immunoreactivity in layers III, V, and VI. Each area received convergent AC input from 3 to 6 (mean, 5) contralateral areas. Most of the projections (>75%) were homotopic and from topographically organized loci in the corresponding area. Heterotopic projections (>1 mm beyond the main homotopic projection) constituted approximately 25% of the input. Layers III and V contained >95% of the commissural neurons. Commissural projection neurons were clustered in all areas. Commissural divergence, assessed by double labeling, was less than 3% in each area. This sparse axonal branching is consistent with the essentially homotopic connectivity of the commissural system. The many heterotopic origins represent unexpected commissural influences converging on an area. Areas more dorsal on the cortical convexity have commissural projections originating in layers III and V; more ventral areas favor layer III at the expense of layer V, to its near-total exclusion in some instances. Some areas have almost entirely layer III origins (temporal cortex and area AII), whereas others have a predominantly layer V input (anterior auditory field) or dual contributions from layers III and V (the dorsal auditory zone). A topographic distribution of commissural cells of origin is consistent with the order observed in thalamocortical and corticocortical projections, and which characterizes all extrinsic projection systems (commissural, corticocortical, and thalamocortical) in all AC areas. Thus, laminar as well as areal differences in projection origin distinguish the auditory cortical commissural system.

Branched projections in the auditory thalamocortical and corticocortical systems

Branched axons (BAs) projecting to different areas of the brain can create multiple feature-specific maps or synchronize processing in remote targets. We examined the organization of BAs in the cat auditory forebrain using two sensitive retrograde tracers. In one set of experiments (n=4), the tracers were injected into different frequency-matched loci in the primary auditory area (AI) and the anterior auditory field (AAF). In the other set (n=4), we injected primary, non-primary, or limbic cortical areas. After mapped injections, percentages of double-labeled cells (PDLs) in the medial geniculate body (MGB) ranged from 1.4% (ventral division) to 2.8% (rostral pole). In both ipsilateral and contralateral areas AI and AAF, the average PDLs were <1%. In the unmapped cases, the MGB PDLs ranged from 0.6% (ventral division) after insular cortex injections to 6.7% (dorsal division) after temporal cortex injections. Cortical PDLs ranged from 0.1% (ipsilateral AI injections) to 3.7% in the second auditory cortical area (AII) (contralateral AII injections). PDLs within the smaller (minority) projection population were significantly higher than those in the overall population. About 2% of auditory forebrain projection cells have BAs and such cells are organized differently than those in the subcortical auditory system, where BAs can be far more numerous. Forebrain branched projections follow different organizational rules than their unbranched counterparts. Finally, the relatively larger proportion of visual and somatic sensory forebrain BAs suggests modality specific rules for BA organization.

Crossmodal audio-visual interactions in the primary visual cortex of the visually deprived cat: a physiological and anatomical study

Blind individuals often demonstrate enhanced non-visual perceptual abilities. Neuroimaging and transcranial magnetic stimulation experiments have suggested that computations carried out in the occipital cortex may underlie these enhanced somatosensory or auditory performances. Thus, cortical areas that are dedicated to the analysis of the visual scene may, in the blind, acquire the capacity to participate in other sensory processing. However, the neural substrate that underlies this transfer of function is not fully characterized. Here we studied the synaptic and anatomical basis of this phenomenon in cats that were visually deprived by dark rearing, either early visually deprived after birth (EVD), or late visually deprived after the end of the critical period (LVD); data were compared with those obtained in normally reared cats (controls). The presence of synaptic and spike responses to auditory stimulation was examined by means of intracellular recordings in area 17 and the border between areas 17 and 18. While none of the cells recorded in control and LVD cats showed responses to sound, 14% of the cells recorded in EVD cats showed both subthreshold synaptic responses and suprathreshold spike responses to auditory stimuli. Synaptic responses were of small amplitude, but well time-locked to the stimuli and had an average latency of 30+/-12ms. In an attempt to identify the origin of the inputs carrying auditory information to the visual cortex, wheat germ agglutinin-horseradish peroxidase (WGA-HRP) was injected in the visual cortex and retrograde labeling examined in the cortex and thalamus. No significant retrograde labeling was found in auditory cortical areas. However, the proportion of neurons projecting from supragranular layers of the posteromedial and posterolateral parts of the lateral suprasylvian region to V1 was higher than that in control cats. Retrograde labeling in the lateral geniculate nucleus showed no difference in the total number of neurons between control and visually deprived cats, but there was a higher proportion of labeling in C-laminae in deprived cats. Labeled cells were not found in the medial geniculate nucleus, a thalamic relay for auditory information, in either control or visually deprived cats. Finally, immunohistochemistry of the visual cortex of deprived cats revealed a striking decrease in pavalbumin- and calretinin-positive neurons, the functional implications of which we discuss.

Graded classes of cortical connections: quantitative analyses of laminar projections to motion areas of cat extrastriate cortex

Current hierarchical models of the cerebral cortex are mainly based on qualitative connection studies. From wheatgerm-agglutinin-horseradish peroxidase injections, we examined the laminar patterns of projections to and between the three major subdivisions of the motion-processing lateral suprasylvian (LS) complex [areas posteromedial lateral suprasylvian area (PMLS), anteromedial lateral suprasylvian (AMLS), posterolateral lateral suprasylvian area (PLLS)] of cat extrastriate cortex and of an adjoining form-processing area, 21a. We counted approximately 145,000 labelled projection cells in 20 cortical areas in 11 cats, and applied various analyses to the data, expressed as the percent supragranular layer (%SG) origin of each connection. We report two main results. (i) A wide range of %SG values was obtained, both from each individual cat and across the 163 projections examined. Nonetheless, both hierarchical and non-parametric cluster analyses of the pooled connection origins suggested the presence of three distinct laminar projection classes, constrained by graded %SG values of 0-33%, 39-69% and 76-97%. These conformed, respectively, to feedback, lateral and feedforward laminar patterns seen qualitatively in our material. (ii) Hierarchical connectivity analyses suggested that PMLS, AMLS and PLLS are ordered in a hierarchical sequence. Macaque motion areas V5/MT, MST and FST are arranged in a similar sequence, and areas at equivalent levels of the two motion hierarchies have some analogous functional specializations. Our findings provide the first objective support for the three laminar projection classes that underpin existing theoretical models of hierarchical cortical organization, and they suggest that the implementation of higher-order motion processing evolved along similar lines in the cat and monkey visual cortex.

CLARIFYING HOMOLOGIES IN THE MAMMALIAN CEREBRAL CORTEX: THE CASE OF THE THIRD VISUAL AREA (V3)

1. Experiments in mammalian models are the main source of information on the neural architecture underlying human visual perception, establishing scientific boundaries for the interpretation of experiments using non-invasive techniques in humans and for the realistic modelling of visual processes. Thus, it is important to define the homology between visual areas in different species. 2. To date, relatively few visual areas can be defined with certainty across mammalian Orders. Here, we review the evidence pointing to the fact that the third visual area (V3; or area 19) is a crucial node of a system involved in shape recognition that exists in most, if not all, eutherian mammals. 3. The size and shape of area V3 are variable, even between species that belong to the same Order. Although some features of the visuotopic organization of V3 are constant (including the relative location of the representations of the upper and lower quadrant and correspondence between the anterior border and the representation of the vertical meridian of the visual field), others are variable between species and even individuals. A complex pattern of representation, involving topological discontinuities, can exist. 4. In addition to its location in relation to the first (V1) and second (V2) visual areas, the identification of V3 homologues can be aided by certain other features, including low myelination, weak cytochrome oxidase reactivity, response properties that are indicative in the processing of stimulus shape, relationship to clusters of neurons forming interhemispheric connections and projections from the koniocellular (W-cell-like) components of the lateral geniculate nucleus. 5. Recent research in primates has clarified the organization of the V3 homologue in members of this Order. Regions of cortex that were formerly thought to belong to V3 (including a densely myelinated region near the dorsal midline) are better considered as part of a separate dorsomedial area, involved in motion analysis and visuomotor integration. The redefined V3, which includes the 'ventral posterior area' and parts of the dorsolateral complex proposed by earlier studies, is very similar to V3 (area 19) of other species in terms of structure and function.

Neuronal circuits of the neocortex

We explore the extent to which neocortical circuits generalize, i.e., to what extent can neocortical neurons and the circuits they form be considered as canonical? We find that, as has long been suspected by cortical neuroanatomists, the same basic laminar and tangential organization of the excitatory neurons of the neocortex is evident wherever it has been sought. Similarly, the inhibitory neurons show characteristic morphology and patterns of connections throughout the neocortex. We offer a simple model of cortical processing that is consistent with the major features of cortical circuits: The superficial layer neurons within local patches of cortex, and within areas, cooperate to explore all possible interpretations of different cortical input and cooperatively select an interpretation consistent with their various cortical and subcortical inputs.

Reaching beyond the classical receptive field of V1 neurons: horizontal or feedback axons?

It is commonly assumed that the orientation-selective surround field of neurons in primary visual cortex (V1) is due to interactions provided solely by intrinsic long-range horizontal connections. We review evidence for and against this proposition and conclude that horizontal connections are too slow and cover too little visual field to subserve all the functions of suppressive surrounds of V1 neurons in the macaque monkey. We show that the extent of visual space covered by horizontal connections corresponds to the region of low contrast summation of the receptive field center mechanism. This region encompasses the classically defined receptive field center and the proximal surround. Beyond this region, feedback connections are the most likely substrate for surround suppression. We present evidence that inactivation of higher order areas leads to a major decrease in the strength of the suppressive surround of neurons in lower order areas, supporting the hypothesis that feedback connections play a major role in center-surround interactions.

Quantitative analyses of principal and secondary compound parieto-occipital feedback pathways in cat

The purpose of our study was to quantify the magnitude of principal and secondary pathways emanating from the middle suprasylvian (MS) region of visuoparietal cortex and terminating in area 18 of primary visual cortex. These pathways transmit feedback signals from visuoparietal cortex to primary visual cortex. (1) WGA-HRP was injected into area 18 to identify inputs from visual structures. In terms of numbers of neurons, feedback projections to area 18 from MS sulcal cortex (areas PMLS, AMLS and PLLS) comprise 26% of inputs from all visual structures. Of these neurons, between 21% and 34.9% are located in upper layers 2-4 and the dominant numbers are located in deep layers 5 and 6. Areas 17 (11.8%) and 19 (11.2%) provide more modest cortical inputs, and another eight areas provide a combined total of 4.3% of inputs. The sum of neurons in all subcompartments of the lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN) accounts for another 34.8% of the input to area 18, whereas inputs from the lateral division of the lateral-posterior nucleus (LPl) account for the final 11.9%. (2) Injection of tritiated-((3)H)-amino acids into MS sulcal cortex revealed substantial direct projections from MS cortex that terminated in all layers of area 18, but with a markedly lower density in layer 4. Projections from MS cortex to both areas 17 and 19 are of similar density and characteristics, whereas those to other cortical targets have very low densities. Quantification also revealed minor-to-modest axon projections to all components of LGN and a massive projection throughout the LP-Pul complex. (3) Superposition of the labeled terminal and cell fields identified secondary, compound feedback pathways from MS cortex to area 18. The largest secondary pathway is massive and it includes the LPl nucleus. Much more modest secondary pathways include areas 17 and 19, and LGN. The relative magnitudes of the secondary pathways suggest that the one through LPl exerts a major influence on area 18, whereas the others exert more modest or minor influences. MS cortex in the contralateral hemisphere also innervates area 18 directly. These data are important for interpreting the impact of deactivating feedback projections from visuoparietal cortex on occipital cortex.

Independent projection streams from macaque striate cortex to the second visual area and middle temporal area

The interareal wiring of the neocortex is usually depicted as a network of single point-to-point connections, often side-stepping the possibility that some neurons may project to multiple cortical areas. The prevalence of such neurons is unknown; if they are abundant, cortical circuits are more likely to be connectionally diffuse. We used a dual-tracer approach to determine whether single neurons in the macaque primary visual cortex (V1) project to two extrastriate areas, the second visual area (V2) and the middle temporal area (MT). We found two large intermingled groups of single-labeled neurons in layer 4B of V1 projecting independently to either V2 or MT. A third, sparser group of double-labeled neurons projected to both areas; we termed these manifold neurons. We also found that MT-projecting cells were distributed indiscriminately with respect to cytochrome oxidase compartment in layer 4B, revealing a subpopulation that provides a potential source of patch input from V1 to MT. The results demonstrate that primary sensory cortices can use multiple projection strategies to distribute signals to higher areas, and suggest that feedforward projections may route signals with more specificity than feedback pathways.

Electrophysiological classes of cat primary visual cortical neurons in vivo as revealed by quantitative analyses

To facilitate the characterization of cortical neuronal function, the responses of cells in cat area 17 to intracellular injection of current pulses were quantitatively analyzed. A variety of response variables were used to separate the cells into subtypes using cluster analysis. Four main classes of neurons could be clearly distinguished: regular spiking (RS), fast spiking (FS), intrinsic bursting (IB), and chattering (CH). Each of these contained significant subclasses. RS neurons were characterized by trains of action potentials that exhibited spike frequency adaptation. Morphologically, these cells were spiny stellate cells in layer 4 and pyramidal cells in layers 2, 3, 5, and 6. FS neurons had short-duration action potentials (<0.5 ms at half height), little or no spike frequency adaptation, and a steep relationship between injected current intensity and spike discharge frequency. Morphologically, these cells were sparsely spiny or aspiny nonpyramidal cells. IB neurons typically generated a low frequency (<425 Hz) burst of spikes at the beginning of a depolarizing current pulse followed by a tonic train of action potentials for the remainder of the pulse. These cells were observed in all cortical layers, but were most abundant in layer 5. Finally, CH neurons generated repetitive, high-frequency (350-700 Hz) bursts of short-duration (<0.55 ms) action potentials. Morphologically, these cells were layer 2-4 (mainly layer 3) pyramidal or spiny stellate neurons. These results indicate that firing properties do not form a continuum and that cortical neurons are members of distinct electrophysiological classes and subclasses.

Neural connections and receptive field properties in the primary visual cortex

A cubic millimeter of primary visual cortex contains about 100,000 neurons that are heavily interconnected by intrinsic and extrinsic afferents. The effort of many neuroanatomists over the past has revealed the general outline of these connections; however, their function remains a mystery. Recently, combined physiological and anatomical approaches are beginning to reveal the role of these connections in the generation of cortical receptive fields. A common theme emerges from all these studies: cortical connections are remarkably specific and this specificity is determined in great extent by the type of connection and the neuronal response properties. Feedforward connections follow relatively rigid rules of wiring selectively targeting neurons with receptive fields matched in position and contrast polarity (thalamus --> cortical layer 4) or position and orientation selectivity (layer 4 --> layers 2 + 3). In contrast, horizontal connections follow more flexible rules connecting distant cells that are not retinotopically aligned and neighboring cells with different orientation preferences. These differences in connectivity may give a hint on how visual stimuli are processed in the primary visual cortex. An attractive hypothesis is that local stimuli use the highly selective feedforward inputs to reliably drive cortical neurons while background stimuli modulate their activity through more flexible horizontal (and feedback) connections.

Auditory Neurons with Transitory Axons to Visual Areas Form Short Permanent Projections

The kitten's auditory cortex (including the first and second auditory fields AI and AII) is known to send transient axons to either ipsi- or contralateral visual areas 17 and 18. By the end of the first postnatal month the transitory axons, but not their neurons of origin, are eliminated. Here we investigated where these neurons project after the elimination of the transitory axon. Eighteen kittens received early (postnatal day (pd) 2 - 5) injections of long lasting retrograde fluorescent traces in visual areas 17 and 18 and late (pd 35 - 64) injections of other retrograde fluorescent tracers in either hemisphere, mostly in areas known to receive projections from AI and AII in the adult cat. The middle ectosylvian gyrus was analysed for double-labelled neurons in the region corresponding approximately to AI and AII. Late injections in the contralateral (to the analysed AI, AII) hemisphere including all of the known auditory areas, as well as some visual and 'association' areas, did not relabel neurons which had had transient projections to either ipsi- or contralateral visual areas 17 - 18. Thus, AI and AII neurons after eliminating their transient juvenile projections to visual areas 17 and 18 do not project to the other hemisphere. In contrast, relabelling was obtained with late injections in several locations in the ipsilateral hemisphere; it was expressed as per cent of the population labelled by the early injections. Few neurons (0 - 2.5%) were relabelled by large injections in the caudal part of the posterior ectosylvian gyrus and the adjacent posterior suprasylvian sulcus (areas DP, P, VP). Multiple injections in the middle ectosylvian gyrus relabelled a considerably larger percentage of neurons (13%). Single small injections in the middle ectosylvian gyrus (areas AI, AII), the caudal part of the anterior ectosylvian gyrus and the rostral part of the posterior ectosylvian gyrus relabelled 3.1 - 7.0% of neurons. These neurons were generally near (<2.0 mm) the outer border of the late injection sites. Neurons with transient projections to ipsi- or contralateral visual areas 17 and 18 were relabelled in similar proportions by late injections at any given location. Thus, AI or AII neurons which send a transitory axon to ipsi- or contralateral visual areas 17 and 18 are most likely to form short permanent cortical connections. In that respect, they are similar to medial area 17 neurons that form transitory callosal axons and short permanent axons to ipsilateral visual areas 17 and 18.

Projections from Areas 18 and 19 to Cat Striate Cortex: Divergence and Laminar Specificity

The results of electrical stimulation experiments [Bullier et al., (1988) Exp. Brain Res., 70, 90 - 98] demonstrated that afferents from areas 18 and 19 contact different functional types of neurons in area 17. We were therefore interested in examining whether these results could be explained by differences in the morphology of the terminals of these two groups of afferent connections to area 17. We also wanted to confirm, by a direct method, our earlier results [Salin et al. (1989) J. Comp. Neurol., 283, 486 - 512] that cortical afferents to area 17 in the cat present extensive divergences. We therefore placed small injections of anterograde tracers in areas 18 and 19 and examined the laminar distributions of terminals thus revealed and the extent of the surface of area 17 contacted by these terminals. Three tracers were used: wheat germ agglutinin - horseradish peroxidase (WGA - HRP), Phaseolus vulgaris leucoagglutinin (Pha-L) and biocytin. The results show that the divergence of these afferent connections are very extensive: 7 - 8 mm in the rotrocaudal direction and 3.5 - 6 mm in the mediolateral direction. In other words, neurons located in a region a few hundreds micron wide in areas 18 or 19 contact a region of area 17 covering several millimeters. Corticocortical connections are therefore not organized in a point-to-point fashion but are strongly divergent. The laminar distributions of terminals from areas 18 and 19 displayed a specific pattern. Area 19 projects most heavily to layers 5 and 6, also terminates in layers 1 - 3 and very little is present in layer 4. In contrast, the afferent terminals from area 18 are heaviest in layers 1, 2, 3, 4A and 5 and are rare in layer 6. Injections placed at different depths in area 18 revealed that upper layer neurons in that area mostly project to layers 1, 2, 3 and 5 in area 17, whereas lower layer neurons send their heaviest projections to layers 4A, 5 and 6 and hardly project to layers 1, 2 and 3.

Laminar distribution of neurons in extrastriate areas projecting to visual areas V1 and V4 correlates with the hierarchical rank and indicates the operation of a distance rule

The directionality of corticocortical projections is classified as feedforward (going from a lower to higher hierarchical levels), feedback (interconnecting descending levels), and lateral (interconnecting equivalent levels). Directionality is determined by the combined criteria of the laminar patterns of the axon terminals as well as the cells of origins and has been used to construct models of the visual system, which reveals a strict hierarchical organization (Felleman and Van Essen, 1991; Hilgetag et al., 1996a). However, these models are indeterminate partly because we have no indication of the distance separating adjacent levels. Here we have attempted to determine a graded parameter describing the anatomical relationship of interconnected areas. We have investigated whether the precise percentage of labeled supragranular layer neurons (SLN%) in each afferent area after injection in either visual areas V1 or V4 determines its hierarchical position in the model. This shows that pathway directionality in the Felleman and Van Essen model is characterized by a range of SLN% values. The one exception is the projection of the frontal eye field to area V4, which resembles a feedforward projection. Individual areal differences in SLN% values are highly significant, and the number of hierarchical steps separating a target area from a source area is found to be tightly correlated to SLN%. The present results show that the hierarchical rank of each afferent area is reliably indicated by SLN%, and therefore this constitutes a graded parameter that is related to hierarchical distance.

Effects of feedback projections from area 18 layers 2/3 to area 17 layers 2/3 in the cat visual cortex

In the absence of a direct geniculate input, area 17 cells in the cat are nevertheless able to respond to visual stimuli because of feedback connections from area 18. Anatomic studies have shown that, in the cat visual cortex, layer 5 of area 18 projects to layer 5 of area 17, and layers 2/3 of area 18 project to layers 2/3 of area 17. What is the specific role of these connections? Previous studies have examined the effect of area 18 layer 5 blockade on cells in area 17 layer 5. Here we examine whether the feedback connections from layers 2/3 of area 18 influence the orientation tuning and velocity tuning of cells in layers 2/3 of area 17. Experiments were carried out in anesthetized and paralyzed cats. We blocked reversibly a small region (300 microm radius) in layers 2/3 of area 18 by iontophoretic application of GABA and recorded simultaneously from cells in layers 2/3 of area 17 while stimulating with oriented sweeping bars. Area 17 cells showed either enhanced or suppressed visual responses to sweeping bars of various orientations and velocities during area 18 blockade. For most area 17 cells, orientation bandwidths remained unaltered, and we never observed visual responses during blockade that were absent completely in the preblockade condition. This suggests that area 18 layers 2/3 modulate visual responses in area 17 layers 2/3 without fundamentally altering their specificity.

Area-specific laminar distribution of cortical feedback neurons projecting to cat area 17: quantitative analysis in the adult and during ontogeny

Corticocortical pathways can be classified as feedback and feedforward, in part according to the laminar distribution of the parent cell bodies. Here, we have developed exhaustive sampling procedures to determine unambiguously this laminar distribution. This shows that individual extrastriate areas in the adult cat have highly stereotyped proportions of supragranular layer neurons with respect to the total population of neurons back-projecting to area 17. During development, these adult laminar patterns emerge from an initially uniform radial distribution through a process of selective reorganization, which is highly specific to each area. Injections of fluorescent retrograde tracers were made in area 17. In areas 19, 20, posteromedial lateral suprasylvian area, and anteromedial lateral suprasylvian area, we defined a projection zone as the region containing retrogradely labeled neurons. In the neonate, counts of labeled neurons throughout the projection zones show constant percentages of 40% in the supragranular layers. During development, there is an area-specific reduction in the percentage of supragranular labeled neurons generating the laminar distributions characteristic of each area. Numbers of labeled neurons were estimated at different eccentricities of the projection zone. This finding indicates that during development there is a relative decrease in the numbers of labeled neurons of the periphery of the projection zone in the supragranular layers but not in the infragranular layers. This decrease is accompanied by a relative decrease in the dimensions of the supragranular projection zone with respect to the infragranular projection zone. These findings suggest that each extrastriate area precisely adjusts the proportions of supragranular layer neurons back-projecting to striate cortex in part by developmental changes in the divergence-convergence values of individual neurons. This shaping of corticocortical connectivity occurs relatively late in postnatal development and could, therefore, be under epigenetic control.

Influences of area 17 on neuronal activity of simple and complex cells of area 18 in cats

To understand the influence of the ascending path linking area 17 to area 18 of visual cortices, experiments were carried out in which a small neuronal population of area 17 was inactivated with GABA, while unitary responses were recorded in area 18. In the latter, cells are identified as belonging to the simple or complex family according to their firing pattern evoked in response to sine-wave gratings scrolling through the receptive fields. Anesthetized cats were prepared for single-cell recordings. In area 17, a GABA-containing pipette was placed in superficial layers in order to inactivate reversibly a small neuronal population. Prior to blockade, the orientation tuning curves were obtained in both areas and the difference in optimal orientation between areas 17 and 18 was recorded. In area 18, cells were classified as simple or complex. The strategy was to study the reaction of neurons in area 18 prior to, during and after area 17 depression. In most simple cells, whenever the difference in orientation was in the iso-range, that is when the difference in optimal orientations of the injected site (in area 17) and of the neuron in area 18 was less than 30 degrees, the GABA application produced a decline of the evoked discharges, whereas GABA injection augmented the evoked firing rate when the difference was in the cross-range (>60 degrees). In contrast to simple cells, GABA depression enhanced the responses in the majority of complex cells with like orientations in both areas. When the difference between recording sites was in the cross-range, then area 17 depression produced weaker evoked firing. A tangential penetration of the injecting pipette, allowing injection of different orientation sites while testing the same unit in area 18, revealed that the latter could react with an enhancement or a decline of the responses as the injecting pipette shifted from iso (or cross) to cross (or iso) disparity in optimal orientations between areas 17 and 18. These results suggest that the path connecting area 17 to area 18 may be functionally discriminated on the basis of the orientation domain and cell types. In addition, our data suggest that the ascending visual streams are required to generate orientation specificity in area 18.

Anatomical evidence for glutamate and/or aspartate as neurotransmitters in the geniculo-, claustro-, and cortico-cortical pathways to the cat striate cortex

Data obtained by using various experimental approaches suggest that in the mammalian brain, most neurons within the visual system projecting to the striate cortex employ excitatory amino acids as transmitters. In order to investigate further the neurotransmitter phenotype of the ipsilateral afferents to area 17 of the cat, we have injected D-[3H]-aspartate, a retrograde tracer which selectively reveals putative glutamatergic and/or aspartatergic pathways, into this area. Retrogradely labelled neurons were observed in the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus, visual claustrum, cortical areas 18, 19, 21a, and in both posteromedial and posterolateral parts of the suprasylvian areas but not in other known thalamic afferents such as the lateral posterior-pulvinar complex and the intralaminar nuclei. The distribution and localization of the labelled cells in all these regions were similar to that observed by using the non-selective tracer horseradish peroxidase conjugated to wheat germ agglutinin, though the number of cells was higher with the latter. Our findings provide additional evidence for the presence of excitatory amino acids as neurotransmitters in the major afferents to the cat striate cortex.

The organization of visual corticocortical connections in early postnatal kittens

We tested the hypothesis that, in newborn kittens, superficial layers of the extrastriate cortex receive more specific patterns of corticocortical innervation from the striate cortex than deep layers. First, we injected retrogradely transported tract-tracers at a range of depths in area 18 to label area 17. All injections were of similar tangential diameter and were in the same region of rostral area 18, where the visual field 10-20 degrees below the horizontal meridian is represented. Injections that involved only the superficial layers of area 18 labelled cells mainly in the superficial layers (future layers 2-4) of area 17, across a region that was 2-3 mm wider than the diameter of the injection site in the rostrocaudal direction. Injections that involved all layers of area 18 labelled cells in both superficial and deep layers (5 and 6) of area 17, across a region that was 6-9 mm wider than the diameter of the injection site in the rostrocaudal direction. These values demonstrate that, in neonates, the convergence of projections from area 17 to the superficial layers of area 18 is less than that to the deep layers of area 18. The lower values for convergence obtained by injecting only the superficial layers of area 18 in kittens were similar to those obtained by injecting all layers of area 18 in adult cats; the values obtained by injecting all layers of area 18 in kittens were much higher. Second, we injected the full depth of area 17 in newborn kittens with labels that travel anterogradely and retrogradely. Confirming the conclusions from the use of retrograde tracers, these focal injections produced very widespread labelling of the deep layers of area 18, but much more localized and topographically organized labelling of its superficial layers. These results indicate that there is a considerable postnatal improvement in the accuracy with which corticocortical cells in striate visual cortex target appropriate regions in extrastriate cortex, in agreement with previous findings. They also demonstrate that this change occurs mainly among those striate cortical neurons that innervate a wide region of the deep layers of extrastriate cortex at birth. The innervation of the superficial layers of extrastriate cortex is much more accurate from the outset.

Trends in the anatomical organization and functional significance of the mammalian thalamus

The last decade has witnessed major changes in the experimental approach to the study of the thalamus and to the analysis of the anatomical and functional interrelations between thalamic nuclei and cortical areas. The present review focuses on the novel anatomical approaches to thalamo-cortical connections and thalamic functions in the historical framework of the classical studies on the thalamus. In the light of the most recent data it is here discussed that: a) the thalamus can subserve different functions according to functional changes in the cortical and subcortical afferent systems; b) the multifarious thalamic cellular entities play a crucial role in the different functional states.

Comparative morphology of three types of projection-identified pyramidal neurons in the superficial layers of cat visual cortex

The morphology and dendritic organization of corticocortical neurons in the superficial layers of area 18 that project to area 17 were studied by intracellular injection of lucifer yellow in the fixed-slice preparation. This corticocortical population contains primarily standard pyramidal cells, but occasional nonpyramidal, modified, fusiform, star, and inverted pyramidal cells were also seen. All cell types were present throughout layer 2 and in the upper and middle parts of layer 3. Standard pyramidal cells were found exclusively in lower layer 3. The mean somatic area of the area 17 projecting neurons was 251 microns 2. The width of basal dendritic fields was correlated to cell size for standard pyramidal cells but not for the other cell types. Next, the morphology and dendritic organization of the area 17 projecting neurons were compared to the pyramidal cells of the local horizontal patch networks and of the callosal system. The depth profile of the area 17 projecting and callosal pyramidal groups was virtually identical, peaking at 400 microns from the pial surface, whereas the local patch pyramidal group peaked at 281 microns. The local patch, area 17 projecting, and callosal pyramidal cells displayed increasingly larger mean somatic areas and basilar dendritic field width measurements. The number of basal dendritic branch points was greatest for callosal cells, and it was indistinguishable between local patch and area 17 projecting neurons. In the tangential plane, circular dendritic fields were observed on all callosal cells, but they were found on only approximately half of the local patch and area 17 projecting neurons. The remaining local patch and area 17 projecting neurons displayed mediolaterally and anteroposteriorly elongated basal dendritic fields, respectively.

Estimates of the convergence of association projections from area 17 to rostral area 18 in the cat depend on injection site size

To estimate the degree of convergence of corticocortical projections from area 17 to the rostral part of area 18 in the cat, we injected the retrograde tracer diamidino yellow either at single or multiple adjacent sites in area 18. We measured the diameters of the individual or larger composite injections and the diameters of the labelled regions in area 17; from these values we estimated convergence factors. Small injections led to underestimates of the overall convergence of this pathway. A maximal value for convergence (about 3 mm) was obtained with larger composite injections (above about 3 mm in diameter). These results indicate that some area 17-to-18 projections may arborize widely in area 18. Their detection may require that injected tracer covers a large portion of their arbors.

Areas PMLS and 21a of cat visual cortex are not only functionally but also hodologically distinct

In several cats, paired visuotopically matched injections of retrogradely transported fluorescent dyes, diamidino yellow (DY) and fast blue (FB), were made into two visuotopically organized, functionally distinct extrastriate cortical areas, the posteromedial lateral suprasylvian area (PMLS area) and area 21a respectively. After an appropriate survival time, the numbers of thalamic, claustral and cortical cells which were single-labelled with each dye as well as the numbers of cells in these structures labelled with both dyes (double-labelled cells) were assessed. The clear majorities of thalamic cells projecting to PMLS area (DY labelled cells) and to area 21a (FB labelled cells) were located in the ipsilateral lateral posterior-pulvinar complex with smaller proportions located in the laminae C and the medial intralaminar nucleus of the ipsilateral dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus and several nuclei of the rostral intralaminar thalamic group. Despite the fact that DY labelled (PMLS-projecting) and FB labelled (area 21 a-projecting) cells in all thalamic nuclei were well intermingled, only 1-5% of retrogradely labelled thalamic cells projected to both areas (cells double-labelled with both dyes). Small proportions of retrogradely labelled cells were located in the ipsilateral and to a lesser extent the contralateral dorsocaudal claustra. The proportions of claustral neurons retrogradely labelled with both dyes varied from 4 to 9%. Over half of the cortical neurons labelled retrogradely from area 21a or PMLS area were located in the supragranular layers of the ipsilateral area 17, with smaller proportions located in the supragranular layers of the ipsilateral areas 18 and 19 and even smaller proportions located in mainly but not exclusively, the infragranular layers of the ipsilateral areas 21b and 20a. Again despite strong spatial intermingling of neurons labelled with DY and these labelled with FB, the proportions of associational cortical neurons double-labelled with both dyes were small (2 to 5.5%). Finally, small proportions of neurons retrogradely labelled with DY or FB were located, mainly but not exclusively, in the supragranular layers of the contralateral areas 17, 18, 19 and 21a. Again, the proportions of the double-labelled neurons in the contralateral cortices were small (1-4.5%). Thus, the present study indicates that despite the fact that the diencephalic and telencephalic inputs to the visuotopically corresponding parts of area 21a and PMLS area originate from the same nuclei, areas and layers, the two areas receive their afferents from the largely separate populations of neurons.

Laminar pattern of termination of the ipsilateral cortical projection from SII to SI in cats

The present light and electron microscopic experiments were carried out on the first somatic sensory area (SI) of cats to determine the laminar distribution of axon terminals from the ipsilateral second somatic sensory area (SII) and to identify the types of synapses between these terminals and the neuronal elements of SI. Phaseolus vulgaris-leucoagglutinin (PHA-L) was iontophoretically injected into multiple sites and at different cortical depths of the forepaw representation zone of SII. Fixed brain blocks containing the injected SII and ipsilateral SI were cut into slices and processed immunocytochemically to stain PHA-L-filled fibers and terminals. Light microscopic examination of SI revealed patches of anterograde labeling in the forepaw representation zone, concentrated mainly in supragranular layers. In these layers, thin immunolabeled fibers branched extensively and formed a dense plexus that was more prominent in layers II and I. Conversely, the infragranular layers contained fragments of vertically oriented thick fibers that rarely emitted axon collaterals. PHA-L-labeled axons had numerous swellings along their course, interpreted as boutons en passant, and stalked boutons. Of 19,661 labeled terminals (17,833 beads and 1,828 stalked boutons), 84.74% were observed in supragranular layers, with the highest concentration in layer II (33.15%) and lower in layers I (26.27%) and III (25.30%). The proportion of terminals was lower in layers IV (6.49%) and V (5.45%) and lowest in layer VI (3.32%). These counts also showed that boutons en passant were the majority (90.70%) and stalked boutons, the minority (9.30%). The ratio of these two types of presynaptic specializations was similar (9:1) in all six layers. Electron microscopic examination of the labeled regions of SI showed that both axon swellings and stalked boutons formed synapses of the asymmetric type with SI neuronal elements. The majority (85.37%) of a sample of 130 labeled terminals synapsed on SI neurons in layers I-III. The identified postsynaptic profiles were dendritic spines (61.11%) or medium-sized and small dendrites (38.89%). These results are discussed in relation to those of a companion study on the laminar pattern of the projection from SI to SII of cats (P. Barbaresi, A. Minelli, and T. Manzoni, 1994, J. Comp. Neurol. 343:582-596). Based on the anatomical organization of these reciprocal connections, there seems to be no clear hierarchicalal relationship between SI and SII in cats.

Adult plasticity in the visual system

When visual cortical neurons in adult mammals are deprived of their normal afferent input from retinae, they are capable of acquiring new receptive fields by modifying the effectiveness of existing intrinsic connections, a basis for topographic map reorganization. To gain insights into the underlying mechanisms and functional significance of this adult plasticity, we measured the spatial limits and time course of retinotopic map reorganization. We also determined whether reactivated neurons exhibit normal receptive field properties. We found that virtually all units in the denervated zone of cortex acquired new receptive fields (i.e., there were no silent areas in the cortex) and map reorganization can take place within hours of deafferentation provided that retinal lesions are relatively small (< 5 degrees). Furthermore, after long periods of recovery, reactivated units exhibited strikingly normal selectivity to stimulus orientation, direction of movement, and spatial frequency if relatively high contrast stimuli were used. However, responsiveness of these neurons, measured in terms of the maximum response amplitude and the contrast threshold, was clearly reduced. Thus, contrary to traditional belief, the adult visual cortex is capable of exhibiting considerable plasticity, and reactivated neurons are capable of contributing to an analysis of a visual scene.

Topography of developing thalamic and cortical pathways in the visual system of the cat

Adult patterns of connectivity could emerge during development by a process of selective elimination from an earlier, more widespread, connectivity. We have addressed this issue by examining the topography of developing projections to area 17 in the cat. At different postnatal ages, paired injections of the retrograde tracers diamidino yellow and fast blue were made in area 17. Interinjection separations were carefully controlled and the spatial distribution of the two populations of labelled neurones investigated. Projections to the striate cortex from the lateral geniculate nucleus, area 18, as well as connections intrinsic to area 17 were analysed quantitatively with a graphic method that uses a two-dimensional model of the projection. This allows two parameters of the projection to be calculated: the divergence (the spatial extent of area 17 contacted by an infinitely small region of an afferent structure) and the convergence (the extent of an afferent structure that projects to an infinitely small region of area 17). During postnatal development, the bulk of the connections making up the geniculostriate and corticocortical pathways showed no variation either in their convergence and divergence. However, the projection of area 18 to area 17 and the intrinsic area 17 connections (but not the geniculostriate projection) in the 3-15-day-old kittens were each found to contain a small subpopulation of widely scattered neurones with widespread axonal trajectories. These results, showing that many initially formed connections display a high degree of topographical order, are discussed in terms of the control mechanisms specifying axonal trajectories during development.

Retinotopic and nonretinotopic field potentials in cat visual cortex

Two types of field potentials were identified in cat visual cortex using contrast reversal of oriented bar gratings: a short-latency fast-local component with a retinotopic organization similar to that seen with single-unit discharges at the same cortical site, and a slow, nonretinotopic component with a longer peak latency. The slow-distributed component had an extensive receptive field mapped by measuring the amplitude of binary kernels and showed strong inhibitory interactions within the receptive field. The peak latency of the slow-local component increased with distance from the retinotopic center, suggesting a possible conduction delay. Both components showed some orientation bias depending on the laminar location, but the bias could be independent of the orientation preferred by single units in the immediate vicinity. The present findings indicate that locally generated field potentials reflect cortical mechanisms for nonlinear integration over wide areas of the visual field.

Pyramidal neurons in layer 5 of the rat visual cortex. I. Correlation among cell morphology, intrinsic electrophysiological properties, and axon targets

Previous work has established two structure/function correlations for pyramidal neurons of layer 5 of the primary visual cortex of the rat. First, cells projecting to the superior colliculus have thick apical dendrites with a florid terminal arborization in layer 1, whereas those projecting to the visual cortex of the opposite hemisphere have thinner apical dendrites that terminate below layer 1, without a terminal tuft (e.g., Hallman et al.: J Comp Neurol 272:149, '90). Second, intracellular recording combined with dye injection has revealed two classes of cells: the first has a thick, tufted apical dendrite and fires a distinctive initial burst of two or more impulses, of virtually fixed, short interspike interval, in response to current injection; and the other, with a slender apical dendrite lacking a terminal tuft, tends to have a longer membrane time constant and higher input resistance, and does not fire characteristic bursts (e.g., Larkman and Mason: J Neurosci 10:1407, '90). The present study combined intracellular recording in isolated slices of rat visual cortex and injection of carboxyfluorescein, to reveal soma-dendritic morphology, with prior injection of rhodamine-conjugated microspheres into the superior colliculus or contralateral visual cortex to label neurons according to the target of their axons. This permitted a complete correlation of morphology, intrinsic electrophysiological properties, and identity of the projection target for individual pyramidal cells. Neurons retrogradely labeled from the opposite visual cortex were found in all layers except layer 1 while those labeled from the superior colliculus lay exclusively in layer 5. Within layer 5 interhemispheric cells were more concentrated in the lower half of the layer but extensively overlapped the distribution of corticotectal cells. Every cell studied that projected to the superior colliculus was of the bursting type and had a thick apical dendrite with a terminal tuft. Every cell in this study projecting to the opposite visual cortex was a "nonburster" and had a slender apical dendrite with fewer oblique branches that ended without a terminal tuft, usually in the upper part of layer 2/3. Interhemispheric cells also had rounder, less conical somata and generally had fewer basal dendrites than corticotectal neurons. Many cells with the physiological and morphological characteristics of interhemispheric cells were not back-labeled from the opposite visual cortex, implying that pyramidal cells of this type can have other projection targets (e.g., other cortical sites in the ipsilateral hemisphere).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)