Selection of the T cell repertoire during ontogeny: limiting dilution analysis

Subdominant H60 antigen-specific CD8 T-cell response precedes dominant H4 antigen-specific response during the initial phase of allogenic skin graft rejection

In allogeneic transplantation, including the B6 anti-BALB.B settings, H60 and H4 are two representative dominant minor histocompatibility antigens that induce strong CD8 T-cell responses. With different distribution patterns, H60 expression is restricted to hematopoietic cells, whereas H4 is ubiquitously expressed. H60-specific CD8 T-cell response has been known to be dominant in most cases of B6 anti-BALB.B allo-responses, except in the case of skin transplantation. To understand the mechanism underlying the subdominance of H60 during allogeneic skin transplantation, we investigated the dynamics of the H60-specific CD8 T cells in B6 mice transplanted with allogeneic BALB.B tail skin. Unexpectedly, longitudinal bioluminescence imaging and flow cytometric analyses revealed that H60-specific CD8 T cells were not always subdominant to H4-specific cells but instead showed a brief dominance before the H4 response became predominant. H60-specific CD8 T cells could expand in the draining lymph node and migrate to the BALB.B allografts, indicating their active participation in the anti-BALB.B allo-response. Enhancing the frequencies of H60-reactive CD8 T cells prior to skin transplantation reversed the immune hierarchy between H60 and H4. Additionally, H60 became predominant when antigen presentation was limited to the direct pathway. However, when antigen presentation was restricted to the indirect pathway, the expansion of H60-specific CD8 T cells was limited, whereas H4-specific CD8 T cells expanded significantly, suggesting that the temporary immunodominance and eventual subdominance of H60 could be due to their reliance on the direct antigen presentation pathway. These results enhance our understanding of the immunodominance phenomenon following allogeneic tissue transplantation.

Primary vascularization of the graft determines the immunodominance of murine minor H antigens during organ transplantation

Grafts can be rejected even when matched for MHC because of differences in the minor histocompatibility Ags (mH-Ags). H4- and H60-derived epitopes are known as immunodominant mH-Ags in H2(b)-compatible BALB.B to C57BL/6 transplantation settings. Although multiple explanations have been provided to explain immunodominance of Ags, the role of vascularization of the graft is yet to be determined. In this study, we used heart (vascularized) and skin (nonvascularized) transplantations to determine the role of primary vascularization of the graft. A higher IFN-γ response toward H60 peptide occurs in heart recipients. In contrast, a higher IFN-γ response was generated against H4 peptide in skin transplant recipients. Peptide-loaded tetramer staining revealed a distinct antigenic hierarchy between heart and skin transplantation: H60-specific CD8(+) T cells were the most abundant after heart transplantation, whereas H4-specific CD8(+) T cells were more abundant after skin graft. Neither the tissue-specific distribution of mH-Ags nor the draining lymph node-derived dendritic cells correlated with the observed immunodominance. Interestingly, non-primarily vascularized cardiac allografts mimicked skin grafts in the observed immunodominance, and H60 immunodominance was observed in primarily vascularized skin grafts. However, T cell depletion from the BALB.B donor prior to cardiac allograft induces H4 immunodominance in vascularized cardiac allograft. Collectively, our data suggest that immediate transmigration of donor T cells via primary vascularization is responsible for the immunodominance of H60 mH-Ag in organ and tissue transplantation.

MHC restriction and allogeneic immune responses

Discovery of major histocompatability complex (MHC) restriction helped in the understanding of how T-lymphocytes recognize antigens on bacteria, viruses, and tumor cells. It was initially accepted that MHC restriction was a consequence of "adaptive differentiation" in the thymus; during differentiation, the forming repertoire of T-lymphocytes "learned" a low affinity for self MHC molecules via positive selection. This view was later countered by discovery of artifacts in underlying studies and the fact that adaptive differentiation could not explain direct allogeneic and allorestricted recognition phenomena. Data from experiments with TCR transgenic animals, individual MHC/peptide complex expression, and recipients of xenogenic thymus glands yielded evidence of an ability to adapt to microenvironment and a low specificity of positive selection. These facts led to an alternative interpretation of MHC restriction explained, in part, by specificity of a pool of effector cells activated by primary immunization. Details of this phenomenon were defined in studies that noted differential primary structures of peptides that bound various allelic forms of MHC molecules. Here, the T-lymphocyte repertoire formed in the thymus was a result, in part, of random rearrangement of germinal sequences of TCR gene fragments. Such pre-selected repertoires were inherently capable of reacting with different allelic forms of MHC molecules. In contrast, MHC molecules were characterized by significant intraspecies polymorphisms; negative and positive selections were aimed at adaptation of a pre-selected repertoire to a specific microenvironment in an individual. Via elimination of autoreactive clones and sparing of a broad spectrum of specificity to potential pathogens, selection in the thymus could be considered a life-long allogeneic reaction of a pre-selected repertoire to self MHC molecules resulting in tolerance to "self," increased responsiveness to foreign MHC molecules, and cross-reactivity of the mature T-lymphocyte repertoire to individual foreign peptides plus self MHC.

Immunodominance of H60 is caused by an abnormally high precursor T cell pool directed against its unique minor histocompatibility antigen peptide

The H60 minor histocompatibility (H) antigen peptide is derived from a glycoprotein that serves as a ligand for the stimulatory NKG2D receptor. We show that this peptide is remarkably immunodominant in that it competes effectively with MHC alloantigens, is efficiently crosspresented by host antigen-presenting cells (APCs), and readily elicits naive CD8 T cell responses in vitro. H60 immunodominance is neither a consequence of NKG2D engagement nor competition among minor H antigens on APCs. Instead, H60 immunodominance is a consequence of an abnormally high naive precursor frequency of H60 peptide reactive CD8 T cells. Understanding why the H60 peptide is so immunogenic has important implications in tissue transplantation and vaccine design.

Death and destruction of activated T lymphocytes

The massive clonal expansion that occurs during an antigen-specific immune response results in the flooding of immune organs with activated T lymphocytes. At the end of a specific response, the vast majority of these activated T cells are cleared from the immune system. The T cells receive signals through specific death receptors that are expressed as a result of activation. Death receptors transmit their apoptotic signals through the activation of caspases. Function of the death receptors is intimately linked to cell-cycle control, and many cell-cycle control proteins are caspase substrates. Among CD8+ T cells, apoptotic death occurs at a specific site, the sinusoids of the liver. The liver appears to contain a mechanism for the trapping and killing of activated T cells, rendering it an immunologically privileged site.

CD4-positive/heat-stable antigen-positive thymocytes cause graft-versus-host disease across non-major histocompatibility complex incompatibilities

Single-positive thymocytes are the immediate precursors of peripheral recent thymic emigrants (RTE) which develop into mature peripheral T cells. The functional ability of RTE is unclear but their state of differentiation may be relevant to the development of tolerance to peripheral "self" antigens. Since RTE are difficult to analyze, precursor CD4+/8- thymocytes were assessed in a model in vivo to determine their functional capability and their susceptibility to tolerance induction. The ability of both heat-stable antigen-positive (HSA+) (immature) and HSA- (mature) single-positive thymocytes to cause graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) across non-major histocompatibility complex differences were examined. Both HSA- and HSA+ CD4+/8- thymocytes from C3H mice caused lethal GVHD in AKR recipients as did CD4+ peripheral T cells in controls. Further, neonatal C3H thymocytes also caused lethal GVHD in AKR recipients. Since CD4+/8- thymocytes are the precursors of RTE, these results suggest that RTE are not susceptible to tolerance induced to "minor" antigens and may have a normal immune function in vivo. This would suggest that peripheral tolerance may be dependent upon the manner of antigen presentation rather than T cell maturity.

Optimising a limiting dilution culture system for quantitating frequencies of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors

We have developed a limiting dilution assay for estimating the frequencies of allo-MHC reactive cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTL-p) in peripheral blood. The culture conditions were optimised in order to give maximum sensitivity while at the same time maintaining a high degree of specificity. While the addition of filler cells, interleukin-1 and interleukin-4 were unnecessary, the addition of interleukin-2 (IL-2) was crucial for optimal expansion of the CTL-ps. However, excess exogenous IL-2 was found to give rise to nonspecific cytotoxicity, and 5 U/ml final concentration of recombinant IL-2 added on Days 3 and 6 was optimal. The establishment of baseline control cultures for determining positivity and negativity of the test cultures is discussed. Using this modified assay system, we demonstrated that the culture conditions fulfil "single hit" criteria and that the assay is highly specific.

Frequency of SV40-specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursors in two SV40 T-antigen transgenic mouse lines

Cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursors (CTL-P) from control C57BL/6 mice and from mice of two simian virus 40 (SV40) T-antigen transgenic lines, 427 and 419, specifically nonresponsive and responsive, respectively, to SV40 T antigen, were quantitated by limiting dilution (LD) after immunization with SV40. CTL-P frequencies for the SV40 T antigen-responsive 419 line transgenic mice were within the range established in C57BL/6 mice, whereas no CTL-P could be demonstrated for the SV40 T antigen-tolerant 427 line mice. These results suggest that deletion or anergy of SV40 T antigen-responsive clones underlies the specific profound tolerance of 427 line mice.

Manifestation of allo H-2-restriction specificity by self H-2-restricted T cells

Previous study has demonstrated that a considerable number of antigen-specific, allo H-2-restricted CTLPs could be recovered from normal lymphocytes. Experiments were conducted to examine whether antigen-specific, self H-2-restricted T cells could also manifest allo H-2-restriction specificity. Non-H-2-specific, self H-2-restricted CTLs were induced in the microcultures with a limited number of responder spleen cells from B10(H-2b) mice that had been primed with C3H.SW(H-2b) spleen cells. Two hundred thirteen non-H-2-specific CTLs generated in limiting dilution culture condition were assayed for cross-reactivity against TNP-modified and unmodified allogeneic targets of 10 different H-2 haplotypes. Of these CTLs, 29 (14%) were cross-reactive to a TNP-modified allogeneic target and seventeen (8%) to an unmodified allogeneic target. The quantitative analysis for cross-reactivity of non-H-2 specific, self H-2-restricted CTLs reveals a significant number of CTLs that were cross-reactive with either alloantigen or antigen (TNP) plus allo H-2. Furthermore, CTL clones with triple specificities including self H-2-restriction specificity, allo-reactivity, and allo H-2 restriction specificity were also found. These results indicate that antigen-specific, allo H-2-restricted T cells are distinct not only from alloreactive T cells but also from antigen-specific, self H-2-restricted T cells. Significance of the manifestation of allo H-2 restriction specificity by self H-2-restricted T cells is discussed in regard to the generation of T cell repertoire.

Peripheral tolerance in mice expressing a liver-specific class I molecule: inactivation/deletion of a T-cell subpopulation

We previously demonstrated that C3H/HeJ transgenic (TG) mice that express a laboratory-engineered class I molecule, Q10/L, exclusively on liver parenchymal cells show no evidence of hepatic disease even after deliberate immunization. Nevertheless, these animals demonstrate cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) activity specific for Q10/L, although it is less than that obtained from non-TG littermates. We now show that this decrease in CTL activity is not a reflection of a decrease in precursors, since both TG and normal animals have similar numbers. When non-TG C3H mice are primed with H-2Ld and H-2Kbm1 antigens, which extensively crossreact with Q10/L, their specific in vitro CTL activity directed against H-2Ld, H-2Kbm1, and Q10/L is increased 10- to 20-fold, as expected. Although primed TG mice show similar increases in in vitro CTL activity directed against H-2Ld and H-2Kbm1, they display no increase in anti-Q10/L activity. Whereas anti-H-2Ld spleen cells from non-TG mice readily generate CTL lines and clones specific for H-2Ld and Q10/L, TG cells give rise to anti-H-2Ld lines or clones only. These data indicate that the tolerance in TG mice is accounted for by the inactivation or deletion of an important CTL subpopulation having the capability of recognizing the peripheral antigen in situ. To determine whether tolerance would persist in the absence of Q10/L, TG cells were transferred into non-TG recipients. Three weeks later Q10/L-specific lytic activity generated in in vitro bulk cultures remained reduced compared to non-TG cells, indicating that the tolerant phenotype was stable during this interval.

The thymus selects the useful, neglects the useless and destroys the harmful

Although efficient at reacting to foreign antigen in the context of MHC, mature T cells do not normally react to self antigens presented by self MHC. In this review, Harald von Boehmer and colleagues describe the investigation of self MHC restriction and self-tolerance using TCR transgenic mice expressing a receptor for the male-specific minor histocompatibility antigen, H-Y, in the context of class I H-2Db MHC antigens, on many of their T cells. CD4-8+ T cells expressing the transgenic receptor were positively selected by the restricting H-2Db MHC antigens in female transgenic mice. In the male TCR transgenic mice, CD4+8+ thymocytes were deleted, and transgene-expressing T cells with high surface-density of CD8 were-absent from the periphery. The remaining T cells could not be activated by male H-Y stimulator cells, as they lacked or expressed only low levels of CD8 molecules.

Positive selection of antigen-specific T cells in thymus by restricting MHC molecules

Thymus-derived lymphocytes (T cells) recognize antigen in the context of class I or class II molecules encoded by the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) by virtue of the heterodimeric alpha beta T-cell receptor (TCR). CD4 and CD8 molecules expressed on the surface of T cells bind to nonpolymorphic portions of class II and class I MHC molecules and assist the TCR in binding and possibly in signalling. The analysis of T-cell development in TCR transgenic mice has shown that the CD4/CD8 phenotype of T cells is determined by the interaction of the alpha beta TCR expressed on immature CD4+8+ thymocytes with polymorphic domains of thymic MHC molecules in the absence of nominal antigen. Here we provide direct evidence that positive selection of antigen-specific, class I MHC-restricted CD4-8+ T cells in the thymus requires the specific interaction of the alpha beta TCR with the restricting class I MHC molecule.

Clonal specificity analysis of mitogen-activated murine T lymphoblasts

We have determined the frequencies and specificities of MHC-reactive and MHC-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTL-p) in mitogen (ConA)-activated splenocytes of normal unprimed mice. The limiting dilution (LD) system supported the growth of one out of three Lyt2+ T cell blasts. The generated CTL-populations lysed blast cell targets specifically as determined by split well analyses. MHC-gene product expression was necessary for lysis to occur, since MHC-negative F9 teratocarcinoma cells were not lysed. The frequency determinations and split well analyses revealed: 1) equally high numbers (approximately 1/100) of CTL-p that generated specific allo-MHC or self-MHC reactive CTL populations, 2) high frequencies of CTL-p which recognized hapten (TNP) or minor H (MH)-antigens in the context of self MHC or allo-MHC determinants. The results are discussed with respect to antigen, restriction and receptor specificities of mitogen-activated unprimed T cell blasts.

Significant frequency of cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor cells specific for TNP-modified allogeneic cells in normal lymphocytes

It was tested whether the cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor (CLP) repertoire in normal mice is biased toward recognizing foreign antigen in association with self H-2 as opposed to allogeneic H-2. The frequencies of CLPs in normal mice (H-2b,k,d) specific for TNP-modified syngeneic and TNP-modified allogeneic cells have been compared by limiting dilution analysis. Normal spleen cells were cultured at a limiting dilution with TNP-modified (TNP-self) or TNP-modified allogeneic (TNP-allo) stimulator cells. Cultures were split into four aliquots and assayed against TNP-self, TNP-allo, unmodified syngeneic, and unmodified allogeneic Concanavalin A blast targets and classified for cytotoxic activity directed against TNP-self, TNP-allo, and allo H-2 determinants. In disagreement with our expectations from the literature, the frequencies of CLPs in H-2b and H-2d responder cells recognizing TNP-modified H-2k were higher than the frequencies of CLPs recognizing TNP-self. There was no clear preference for TNP-self in the case of H-2b responder and H-2d allogeneic cells, nor vice versa. Only in the case of H-2k responder cells was there a distinct preference for TNP-self. The significance of a considerable number of TNP-specific, allo H-2-restricted CLPs in normal lymphocytes is discussed.

Putrescine and its biosynthetic precursor L-ornithine augment the in vivo immunization against minor histocompatibility antigens and syngeneic tumor cells

Putrescine was found to augment strongly the in vivo priming for secondary in vitro cytotoxic responses by small numbers of syngeneic ESb-D tumor cells and MHC-compatible allogeneic cells (minor H-antigens). The cytotoxic response against minor H-antigens in putrescine-treated mice showed the typical MHC-restriction that has previously been observed after immunization with higher cell doses without putrescine. The injection of putrescine had practically no effect on the subsequent in vitro primary cytotoxic response against an unrelated set of allogeneic stimulator cells. A similar augmentation of the in vivo immunization for secondary in vitro responses was achieved with L-ornithine, the biosynthetic precursor of putrescine. A substantial secondary in vivo cytotoxic activity against minor H-antigens was also obtained by application of L-ornithine shortly after the primary immunization.

Minor but not major histocompatibility antigens of thymus epithelium tolerize precursors of cytolytic T cells

Treatment of fetal thymuses with 2-deoxyguanosine depletes these organs of many haematopoietic cells, and if such thymuses are transplanted into allogeneic athymic nude mice, intrathymic development of cytolytic T-lymphocyte precursors (CTL-P) occurs, including those which are specific for class I major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens expressed by the thymus epithelium. Thus, T cells from BALB/c (H-2d) nude mice transplanted with allogeneic C57BL/6 (H-2b) thymic epithelium can be stimulated in vitro to produce CTL specific for H-2b class I MHC antigens. We report here that thymocytes and lymph node T cells from such mice are responsive in mixed leukocyte reaction in the absence of exogenous growth factors, indicating that lack of tolerance is manifest at the level of CTL-P and proliferating T cells. We also show that T cells from such mice are tolerant to minor histocompatibility antigens of the thymus donor in the context of MHC antigens of the recipient. The results indicate that haematopoietic rather than epithelial cells tolerize CTL-P and that donor-type minor but not major histocompatability antigens can be presented in tolerogenic form by haematopoietic cells expressing recipient-type MHC antigens.

Induction of proliferative and cytotoxic responses in resting Lyt-2+ T cells with lectin and recombinant interleukin 2

The lectin leucoagglutinin has been used to induce reactivity to interleukin 2 (IL2) in unseparated spleen cells and in highly purified Lyt-2+ lymph node T cells. Recombinant human IL2 and various other IL2-containing preparations, including concanavalin A-induced spleen cell supernatant, were compared for their capacity to support DNA synthesis and cytotoxic activity. In contrast to published reports, we found that the capacity of all preparations tested was identical in both functional assays, if they were adjusted to the same IL2 titer. Our inability to detect a requirement for an externally added cytotoxic T cell differentiation factor could either mean that IL2 is sufficient for the promotion of both proliferation and differentiation in leucoagglutinin-activated resting cytotoxic T cell precursors, or that under our experimental conditions, T cell differentiation factor is endogenously produced by Lyt-2+ T cells.

Alloreactive cytotoxic T cells. I. Alloreactive and allorestricted cytotoxic T cells

Nylon wool-nonadherent spleen cells from three inbred mouse strains of H-2k (CBA), H-2d (BALB/c) and H-2b (C57BL/6) haplotype were co-cultured with 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl (TNP)-modified or nonmodified allogeneic stimulator cells in a limiting dilution system. Using a recently described restimulation protocol, a surprisingly large number of splenic cytotoxic lymphocyte precursors (CLP) was clonally expanded in this primary in vitro response to allo-H-2 plus TNP determinants; measured CLP frequencies ranged from 1/30 to 1/300. The lytic specificity patterns of individual microcultures (selected for a high probability of clonality) were defined by split well analysis, and were furthermore followed up in time by sequentially reassaying microcultures at different time points of in vitro incubation. This analysis revealed the following: a large fraction of cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones lysed TNP-modified but not nonmodified allogeneic concanavalin A blast targets, i.e., were allorestricted; this was found in all 6 allogeneic strain combinations set up with b, k and d haplotype mice; allorestricted lytic patterns predominated in microcultures with low numbers of responder cells per well, and at late time points of in vitro culture; allorestricted lytic cultures were specific for the stimulating allogeneic H-2 plus TNP determinant(s); and allorestricted lytic patterns were also found in microcultures stimulated by nonmodified allogeneic cells. To our knowledge, these are the highest CLP frequencies yet reported in limiting dilution systems that used a specific (re)stimulation protocol and measured the lytic responses obtained in a specificity-controlled readout.

Clonal specificity of concanavalin A-induced cytotoxic T lymphocytes

The specificity of polyclonally induced cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursors has been analyzed under clonal conditions. Primary clones of concanavalin A-inducible CTL, if tested on different targets, revealed that they could distinguish between (a) two different allogeneic tumor targets; (b) allogeneic and syngeneic tumor targets, and (c) syngeneic B blasts and tumor targets. No "nonspecific" CTL clones were generated under these culture conditions, and all clones were found to display classical immunological specificity.

Differential resistance to growth of a tumor expressing incompatible minor alloantigens reflects regulatory influences rather than differences in anti-minor-CTL-P frequencies

In previous studies it was found that BALB/c (H-2d) was more susceptible than (BALB/c X A)F1 (H-2d X H-2a) to a tumor bearing multiple mismatched minor histocompatibility antigens, the DBA/2 (H-2d) mastocytoma P815, and that this resistance was H-2 linked. In the present studies the immunologic basis of this effect was examined by comparing the cytotoxic-T-lymphocyte (CTL) responses of BALB/c with those of (BALB/c X A)F1. Despite the BALB/c X A)F1's 34-fold greater resistance to P815 in vivo, the numbers of effector cell precursors were found to be similar in the two hosts as shown by (a) similar anti-P815 CTL responses in vitro with T-cell growth factor, (b) similar secondary anti-DBA/2 MiHA responses after in vivo priming with irradiated P815, and (c) similar frequencies of anti-DBA/2 CTL precursors by limiting-dilution analysis. However, priming with proliferating P815 in vivo revealed a defect in the BALB/c animals: Spleen cells from such animals were unable to control the growth of contaminating P815 cells in vitro or to mount strong secondary CTL responses to DBA/2 antigens. The defective priming of BALB/c could be corrected when DBA/2 spleen cells were added to the P815 inoculum. This impaired priming by living tumor cells was not seen in (BALB/c X A)F1. It is concluded that the use of living P815 tumor cells revealed a defect in immunoregulation in BALB/c mice, which rendered them susceptible to tumor growth in spite of apparently adequate numbers of anti-minor-CTL precursors. How the additional H-2 products expressed in the (BALB/c X A)F1 might correct this defect is discussed.

Homing receptor-bearing thymocytes, an immunocompetent cortical subpopulation

Much of the differentiation of murine T cells takes place in the thymus, perhaps influenced by the operation of stringent selection mechanisms whose existence has been inferred from the high rate of thymocyte turnover in the absence of extensive emigration. The origin of those 1% of total thymocytes which leave the thymus and seed the peripheral lymphoid organs is obscure. Recent thymic emigrants are functionally and phenotypically mature, and the purported greater maturity of medullary relative to cortical thymocytes is often cited a evidence for the medullary origin of thymic emigrants, a suggestion not without its critics. To approach this question, we have now isolated a a subpopulation of thymocytes expressing high levels of a receptor that mediates the homing of blood-borne lymphocytes into peripheral lymph nodes. Surprisingly, this population of cells (1-3% of total thymocytes) is both cortical and immunocompetent, containing approximately half of all thymic cytolytic T-lymphocyte precursors. The combination of homing receptor expression and immunocompetence makes this cortical population ideally suited for emigration to peripheral lymphoid organs.

Capacity of different cell types to prime in vivo for secondary in vitro cytotoxic T-cell responses against non-major-histocompatibility antigens

The capacity of several types of cell preparations to induce in vivo a state of memory for a secondary in vitro cytotoxic response against non-major-histocompatibility antigen was markedly reduced (on a per cell basis) by uv-irradiation. This indicated that memory induction requires metabolically active stimulator cells. An "adherent cell preparation" (AC) that was enriched for dendritic cells was among the most effective memory-inducing cell populations; but concanavalin A-activated nylon-wool-nonadherent spleen cells (Con A-NWT) or concanavalin A-activated unfractionated spleen cells (Con A-spl) were on the average equally effective. Normal unfractionated spleen cells (spl) or nonactivated nylon-wool-nonadherent cells (NWT) were markedly less effective on a per cell basis. This pattern of stimulatory activity was in line with the relative stimulatory activity of these cell types in primary cytotoxic responses in the presence of interleukin 2 (IL-2) and also in line with the relative capacity to induce IL-2-dependent proliferation in H-2D-incompatible T-cell populations (cf. W. Dröge et al., J. Immunol. 132, 2749, 1984). These differences in the immunogenic potential and the requirement for metabolically active stimulator cells suggested that these cells stimulated the CTL system directly and not indirectly through antigen processing cells of the immunized host. Nevertheless, the secondary cytotoxic response after injection of low numbers of Con A-spl into H-2 heterozygous recipients, (BALB/c X BALB/b)F1, or into recipients with recombinant H-2 haplotype (A.J) was only preferentially but not exclusively restricted to the H-2 haplotype of the immunizing cell populations. Restriction was considerably more complete when AC were used for immunization.

Cytotoxic T cell responses to haptenated cells. IV. Requirements for in vivo priming

Hapten-specific cytotoxic T cells (CTL) can be generated in cultures containing mouse spleen cells and hapten-coupled syngeneic stimulator cells. A response to sparsely hapten-coupled stimulator cells is only obtained with responder cells from immunized H-2k mice. Immunization was effective with hapten coupled to syngeneic, allogeneic or xenogeneic nucleated cells or membranes thereof. Hapten-coupled erythrocytes, bacteriophages or soluble proteins did not induce CTL precursors (CTL-P) nor responses of other lymphocytes which would interfere with the response of CTL-P. The results show that antigen presentation to CTL-P is very efficient in vivo. Haptens could be presented to and recognized by CTL-P only if coupled to surface membranes of nucleated cells.

Degradation of specificity in cytolytic T lymphocyte clones: mouse strain dependence and interstrain transfer of nonspecific cytolysis

Limiting-dilution culture of murine Ly-2+ T cells with concanavalin A (Con A) and irradiated spleen filler cells produces, with high efficiency, cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones. With most mouse strains (including CBA and C57BL/6) the specificity of these CTL clones drops after day 6 of culture, so that by day 9 the majority of clones can lyse most murine target cells, whether syngeneic or allogeneic. The rate of specificity degradation and relative target cell preference varies with the mouse strain. Some strains (e.g. BALB/c) do not show this effect and CTL clones remain specific to day 9. Many low natural killer (NK) cell strains (e.g. C57BL/6J.bg) maintain CTL specificity in such cultures, but the correlation between CTL specificity and NK status is not absolute. Growth of BALB/c precursor cells on CBA filler cells leads to specificity degradation in the BALB/c CTL clones; however, the specificity of CBA-derived CTL clones is not maintained by growth on BALB/c fillers. The results suggest that specificity degradation is induced in the developing CTL-clone by factors in the culture environment, perhaps a soluble lymphokine (a differentiation factor) or by an infectious agent (an endogenous mouse virus). Although such CTL specificity loss may render many limiting dilution studies of the CTL specificity repertoire invalid, the problem may be bypassed by an appropriate choice of mouse strain.

Early events in T lymphocyte genesis in the fetal thymus

There is considerable uncertainty about the nature and level of maturation of the stem cells which colonize the thymus. Arguments are presented here which raise doubts about the claims that these cells have undergone substantial maturation along the T-lineage pathway prior to migration to the thymus. Instead, emphasis is placed on the role of thymic stromal cells in T-lymphocyte maturation. The heterogeneous nature of these cells is well established, but progress is described in analyzing the various cell types and their embryological origins. In particular, the expression of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens on thymic stromal cells might be relevant to the understanding of restriction and tolerance. The early phases of thymus lymphocyte differentiation are described; but no clear account of the generation of T-cell subsets from immature cells can, as yet, be offered.

Evidence from in vitro studies that tolerance to self antigens is MHC-restricted

Mature T cells respond to foreign antigens in the context of self major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-encoded products: T helper cells recognize antigen in the context of class II molecules, while cytotoxic T cells (CTL) recognize antigen plus class I molecules. Recent evidence suggests that the MHC-restricted T cell is unable to recognize either the foreign antigen or the self-MHC product alone, but only a complex of the two. Unresponsiveness to self antigens--self tolerance--implies the deletion or suppression of clones of T cells having reactivity to self antigens. Here we demonstrate the presence in normal mice of T cells which recognize self antigens together with allogeneic MHC products. This finding suggests the MHC restriction of T-cell recognition during the entire process of T-cell ontogeny, that is, MHC restriction of self tolerance.

Clonal analysis of helper and effector T-cell function in neonatal transplantation tolerance: clonal deletion of helper cells determines lack of in vitro responsiveness

Mice rendered tolerant at birth of H-2 alloantigens display concordant in vivo and in vitro phenotypes: they fail to reject skin grafts bearing the tolerated antigens, and their lymphoid cells fail to participate in tolerogenspecific mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLRs) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML). Tolerant animals normally reject third-party skin allografts and develop positive MLRs and CML to third-party antigens. It has been suggested that clonal deletion of antigen reactive cells is the basis for this spectrum of responses. To investigate further the basis for the lack of in vitro alloreactivity, we conducted limiting dilution studies with lymph node cells from adult mice tolerant of various H-2 disparities. When the frequencies of (a) cells responding to the tolerogen in MLR and (b) interleukin-2-producing cells against the tolerogen were determined, it appeared that both types of cells were functionally deleted, that is, the frequency of cells responding to tolerogen-bearing stimulator cells was identical with that of cells stimulated with syngeneic cells. On the assumption that cells from H-2 tolerant mice are deficient in helper cell activity toward the tolerogen, we performed CML cultures under conditions in which exogenous help was provided in the form of supernatants derived from concanavalin A stimulated rat spleen cell cultures. Lymphoid cells from H-2 tolerant mice generated significant cytotoxicity toward the tolerogen under these conditions, although the absolute level of killing was reduced compared with that of cells from normal mice. Limiting dilution assays confirmed that Tc precursors were present in tolerant mice, and that they were reduced to less than 10% of normal numbers; however, tolerogen-specific Tc precursors were present in frequencies significantly greater than self-reactive Tc precursors. These data indicate that a deletion mechanism operates in neonatal transplantation tolerance to reduce the clone size of all three categories of functional T cells assayed, but that its efficiency is greatest among cells destined to provide specific T-cell help. The absolute functional deletion of helper cells determines the in vitro CML unresponsiveness of lymphoid cells from tolerant mice, and may be a crucial factor in promoting the in vivo phenotype of skin allograft tolerance.

Somatic H-2Kk variants reveal nonidentity of serological and cytotoxic T cell-defined Kk determinants

The relationship of serologically defined determinants to determinants recognized by cytotoxic T cells on molecules encoded by the Kk gene of the murine major histocompatibility complex (H-2) has been analyzed. For this purpose we used three somatic variants of a Kk-expressing lymphoma line lacking individual determinants of the Kk molecule, as defined by monoclonal antibodies (mAb), as target cells for Kk-specific alloreactive and Kk-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) cloned by limiting dilution. Neither alloreactive nor fluorescein isothiocyanate, influenza- or Newcastle disease virus-specific Kk-restricted CTL clones were found to distinguish between variants and wild type cells, indicating that the serologically defined determinants lost by the variants were not essential for antigen recognition of CTL with these specificities. On the other hand, two of the variants lacking either one of a pair of serological determinants were discriminated from Kk wild type cells by about 40% of Kk-restricted, trinitrophenol (TNP)-specific CTL clones. The third variant, lacking both of the determinants, however, was lysed by all CTL clones to the same extent as wild type cells. From these results we conclude that the determinants restricting the TNP-specific CTL were also not identical with those defined by mAb. In experiments performed to optimize the conditions for the limiting dilution analysis we found that the specificity of the CTL stimulation was strongly dependent on the concentration of T cell growth factor (interleukin 2) in the cultures during CTL stimulation. High concentrations of IL2 resulted in a drastic increase in the frequency of CTL clones. Part of these clones, however, were found not to be specific for antigens present on the stimulator cells.

Selection of the T-cell repertoire during ontogeny

This report examines conflicting hypotheses concerning T-cell repertoire selection in terms of H-2 restriction during ontogeny. The experiments described in this report were incompatible with the hypothesis that bias in the repertoire is solely a consequence of "more or less intentional priming" by foreign antigen. Rather, results indicate that the repertoire is selected by self major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens in the absence of foreign antigens. Allorestricted T cells, the existence of which was previously thought to be incompatible with the concept of complete repertoire selection by self MHC antigens, were shown to significantly cross-react on targets expressing self MHC antigens. Thus, it is possible that allorestricted T cells are simply cross-reactive T-cell clones restricted by self MHC antigens; indeed, all experimental data were compatible with the idea of complete selection of the T-cell repertoire in terms of H-2 restriction by self MHC antigens.

Clones of cytotoxic T lymphocytes reactive to haptenated allogeneic cells: precursor frequency and characteristics as determined by a split-culture approach

CBA (H-2k) responder spleen cells have been cultured at limit dilution with trinitrophenyl (TNP)-modified BALB/c (H-2d) stimulator cells and a source of T-cell growth factor in order to generate cytotoxic effector clones. After culture, such clones were split into two to four replicates and each was assayed against a different target. This allowed identification of clones capable of lysing TNP-modified P815 (H-2d) targets but not unmodified P815 targets. Thus, clones specific for TNP and allogeneic restriction elements were detected without the need to use techniques that deplete the responder population of alloreactive cells. Cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTL-P) specific for TNP-modified P815 (major histocompatibility complex-nonidentical) targets were identified, at a low frequency (28.2 x 10(-6)) compared to CTL-P for TNP-modified C1.18 (H-2k) (identical) targets (224 x 10(-6)). The hapten specificity, H-2 restriction specificity, and Thy-1 status of these clones have been examined. Fourteen percent of CBA CTL-P reactive to TNP-modified P815 targets also showed reactivity to NIP-modified P815 targets, and 86% of CBA clones reactive to TNP-modified P815 targets ("allo-TNP-reactive" clones) failed to show reactivity to TNP-modified C1.18 targets--i.e., showed a restriction preference for allo rather than self. All such H-2d-restricted, TNP-specific clones were uniformly sensitive to anti-Thy-1 antibody and complement. Among the H-2k responders studied, we have not demonstrated CTL-P reactive to TNP-modified syngeneic cells which also react with H-2d cells or NIP-modified H-2d cells among 168 clones analyzed. This suggests that such clones, if present, are relatively rare.

H-2D products do not affect lysis of Kk target cells by Kk-specific cytotoxic T cells

Antigens coded by the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) stimulate a large number of cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursors. Matzinger and Bevan have suggested that the high alloreactivity is a result of the formation of interaction antigens between MHC and non-MHC-coded antigens. Previous work by Langhorne and Fischer Lindahl did not support this hypothesis. In this report we describe are improved culture system to show that the recognition of Kk target cells by Kk-specific clones is also unaffected by H-2D products. Using such a culture system, which controls for the induction of nonspecific CTL by interleukin 2 (T cell growth factor) we were also able to confirm the original conclusion of Langhorne and Fischer Lindahl that polymorphic minor histocompatibility antigens do not significantly contribute to putative "interaction antigens" formed by MHC and other antigens.