Failure of experimental vaccines to protect against infection with ovine progressive pneumonia (maedi-visna) virus

Characterization of a recombinant Sendai virus vector encoding the small ruminant lentivirus gag-P25: antiviral properties in vitro and transgene expression in sheep

Small ruminant lentiviruses (SRLV) cause multisystemic chronic inflammatory disease and significant economic losses in sheep and goats worldwide. However, no vaccines or therapies are currently available. In this study, a recombinant Sendai virus (SeV) vector encoding the SRLV gag-P25 gene (rSeV-GFP-P25) from the EV1 strain was generated using In-FUSION cloning and rescued using the SeV reverse genetic system. Transgene expression and stimulation of innate immunity and interferon-stimulated genes (ovine A3Z1, OBST2 and SAMHD1) were evaluated in ovine skin fibroblasts (OSF) transduced with SeV-GFP and rSeV-GFP-P25. Additionally, to characterize the effect of the SRLV restriction in transduced OSF, the SRLV DNA load was quantified at different times post-transduction and post-infection with strain EV1. Using immunohistochemistry and image analysis, transgene expression and tissue distribution of recombinant P25 were studied in two lambs inoculated intranasally, one with rSeV-GFP-P25 and the other with SeV-GFP. rSeV-GFP-P25 induced efficient and transient transgene expression in vitro and in vivo. Furthermore, OSF transduced with rSeV-GFP-P25 presented upregulation of TLR2, TLR3, TLR6, TLR7, RIG-I, MyD88 and IFN-β, whereas SeV-GFP did not induce TLR6 or IFN-β upregulation. Among the interferon-stimulated genes, OBST2 was significantly upregulated after transduction with rSeV-GFP-P25 compared with the empty vector. SRLV restriction gradually increased and persisted after transduction with SeV-GFP and rSeV-GFP-P25, with OSF transduced three times showing cumulative restriction. Forty-eight hours post-inoculation in vivo, marked P25 expression was observed in ciliated epithelial cells and submucosal macrophages/dendritic cells of the nasal mucosa. This study reinforces the important role of the innate immune response in controlling SRLV infection and suggests that rSeV-GFP-P25 is a potential vaccine candidate against SRLV.

In silico discovery of epitopes of gag and env proteins for the development of a multi-epitope vaccine candidate against Maedi Visna Virus using reverse vaccinology approach

Maedi Visna Virus (MVV) causes a chronic viral disease in sheep. Since there is no specific therapeutic drug that targets MVV, development of a vaccine against the MVV is inevitable. This study aimed to analyze the gag and env proteins as vaccine candidate proteins and to identify epitopes in these proteins. In addition, it was aimed to construct a multi-epitope vaccine candidate. According to the obtained results, the gag protein was detected to be more conserved and had a higher antigenicity value. Also, the number of alpha helix in the secondary structure was higher and transmembrane helices were not detected. Although many B cell and MHC-I/II epitopes were predicted, only 19 of them were detected to have the properties of antigenic, non-allergenic, non-toxic, soluble, and non-hemolytic. Of these epitopes, five were remarkable due to having the highest antigenicity value. However, the final multi-epitope vaccine was constructed with 19 epitopes. A strong affinity was shown between the final multi-epitope vaccine and TLR-2/4. In conclusion, the gag protein was a better antigen. However, both proteins had epitopes with high antigenicity value. Also, the final multi-epitope vaccine construct had a potential to be used as a peptide vaccine due to its immuno-informatics results.

DNA Vaccines Against Maedi-Visna Virus

Maedi-visna virus (MVV) is an ovine retrovirus of the Lentivirus genus, responsible for a chronic and progressive disease of sheep with a high prevalence all over the world. Therefore, measures aiming at the control of MVV infection are necessary, and the development of DNA vaccines may be the ideal approach. A DNA vaccine is an antigen-encoding bacterial plasmid designed to mimic infections safely, with ability to generate both humoral and cellular long-lasting immune responses once it is delivered to the host.Here, we describe the development and evaluation of DNA vaccines against ovine maedi-visna virus. The first step is the design of the vaccines, including the choice of the backbone vector and the nucleotide sequences to use as antigen-encoding sequences. Once constructed, the vaccines may be produced with high quality for use in in vitro and in vivo tests. In vitro assays are performed through transfection of animal cells to confirm the expression of the protein, while in vivo tests are carried out by mouse and/or sheep immunization in order to check humoral and cellular responses to the vaccines and conclude about their efficiency. Several approaches may be later performed in order to enhance the effectiveness of the vaccines, such as the introduction of targeting sequences, the use of a prime-boost strategy, the administration of a combined vaccine, and the use of liposomes as delivery vehicle.

Immunization against small ruminant lentiviruses

Multisystemic disease caused by Small Ruminant Lentiviruses (SRLV) in sheep and goats leads to production losses, to the detriment of animal health and welfare. This, together with the lack of treatments, has triggered interest in exploring different strategies of immunization to control the widely spread SRLV infection and, also, to provide a useful model for HIV vaccines. These strategies involve inactivated whole virus, subunit vaccines, DNA encoding viral proteins in the presence or absence of plasmids encoding immunological adjuvants and naturally or artificially attenuated viruses. In this review, we revisit, comprehensively, the immunization strategies against SRLV and analyze this double edged tool individually, as it may contribute to either controlling or enhancing virus replication and/or disease.

Vaccination delays Maedi-Visna lentivirus infection in a naturally-infected sheep flock

Background

The Maedi-Visna (MV) lentivirus causes two slowly progressive eventually fatal diseases of sheep, Maedi, a progressive interstitial pneumonia, and Visna, a progressive demyelinating disease of the central nervous system. Other lentiviruses also cause fatal slow infections in their natural hosts, e.g. the HIV virus in humans. Results of experimental vaccination against any lentivirus where vaccinees are challenged by natural routes, may therefore be of general interest. From 1991–1998 experiments with formalin-inactivated whole Maedi-Visna virus vaccine were carried out in the Department of Microbiology at the University of Iceland. Western Blot tests showed good immune response to all major proteins of the virus. When aluminium hydroxide was added to the vaccine all vaccinees developed neutralizing antibodies to the vaccine strain at titers 1/8 – 1/256. After housing 5 twin pairs, one twin in each pair vaccinated, the other unvaccinated, with infected sheep for 4 years, all the unvaccinated twins became infected, but only 2 of their vaccinated siblings as confirmed by virus cultivation experiments on tissues from their lungs spleens lymph nodes and choroid plexuses.

Results

One twin in each of 40 female twin pairs, born into a Maedi-Visna-infected sheep flock and kept under natural farming conditions in Cyprus, was vaccinated at birth, 3 weeks and 3 months, with formalin-inactivated whole Maedi-Visna lentivirus vaccine adjuvanted with aluminium hydroxide. 17 mothers of the twins were seronegative, 13 seroconverting and 10 had old infection. Of 17 vaccinees born to seronegative mothers 9 were uninfected at 28 months, but only 2 of their unvaccinated siblings. Of 13 unvaccinated twins born to seroconverting mothers, 12 caught infection during their first 10 weeks, but only 4 of their vaccinated siblings. Vaccination had no effects on 10 vaccinees born to mothers with long-standing Maedi-Visna infections and broad andibody response at birth of their lambs.

Conclusion

Compared with their unvaccinated siblings, natural infection was delayed in significant number of vaccinated twins born by seronegative and seroconverting mothers and vaccinated at birth, 3 weeks and 3 months with formalin inactivated whole MV vaccine adjuvanted with aluminium hydroxide. Maternal antibodies interfered with vaccination so early in life if the mother had old infection.

Use of B7 costimulatory molecules as adjuvants in a prime-boost vaccination against Visna/Maedi ovine lentivirus

RNA transcripts of the B7 family molecule (CD80) are diminished in blood leukocytes from animals clinically affected with Visna/Maedi virus (VMV) infection. This work investigates whether the use of B7 genes enhances immune responses and protection in immunization-challenge approaches. Sheep were primed by particle-mediated epidermal bombardment with VMV gag and env gene recombinant plasmids together with plasmids encoding both CD80 and CD86 or CD80 alone, boosted with gag and env gene recombinant modified vaccinia Ankara virus and challenged intratracheally with VMV. Immunization in the presence of one or both of the B7 genes resulted in CD4+ T cell activation and antibody production (before and after challenge, respectively), but only immunization with CD80 and CD86 genes together, and not CD80 alone, resulted in a reduced number of infected animals and increased early transient cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) responses. Post-mortem analysis showed an immune activation of lymphoid tissue in challenge-target organs in those animals that had received B7 genes compared to unvaccinated animals. Thus, the inclusion of B7 genes helped to enhance early cellular responses and protection (diminished proportion of infected animals) against VMV infection.

Expression of the gp150 maedi visna virus envelope precursor protein by mammalian expression vectors

There are very few previous reports of expression of native full-length maedi visna virus (MVV) Env gp150 protein in the literature. Therefore the use of different plasmid and viral expression vectors to obtain full-length gp150 was investigated. A mammalian expression plasmid, pN3-Env, was constructed containing the MVV env gene encoding the precursor protein gp150 Env. The functionality of the recombinant plasmid was tested for expression in HEK293 cells. A recombinant modified vaccinia Ankara virus, MVA-Env, with expression detected in avian cells was also made. The expression of the MVV gp150 Env precursor protein was shown for the first time upon transfection of the eukaryotic HEK293 cells by the pN3-Env plasmid DNA as demonstrated by Western blot analysis. These plasmid or viral expression vectors are of potential use in MVV vaccines.

Development of a candidate DNA vaccine against Maedi-Visna virus

DNA vaccine candidates against Maedi-Visna virus (MVV) infection in ovines were developed as an alternative to conventional vaccines. Candidates were constructed by cloning genes encoding the MVV gag polyprotein and gag proteins p16 and p25 fused to a beta-galactosidase reporter in a plasmid backbone. Transfection of different ovine cells showed a higher protein expression with plasmid lacZp16, which was hence further optimised by (i) removing a putative inhibitory sequence via reduction of the AU-content in the p16 gene or by (ii) introducing a secretory signal (Sc) to promote antigen secretion and increase its presentation to APCs. Unexpectedly, plasmids constructed on the basis of the first strategy by mutagenesis of lacZp16 (lacZp16mut(24)), led to a reduction in the expression of the antigen/reporter fusion in cultured ovine cells. This indicates that the high AU content in MVV does not inhibit protein expression. However, mice primed with lacZp16mut(24) and boosted with MVV protein displayed higher humoral response when compared with control lacZp16. The addition of the Sc signal (Sc-p16) led to lower amounts of intracellular antigen/reporter fusion in transfected ovine cells, thus confirming secretion. These findings correlate with in vivo experiments, which showed that mice primed with Sc-p16 and boosted with MVV exhibited stronger antibody responses when compared with control mice primed with lacZp16 and boosted with MVV. Stronger humoral responses were recorded by immunising mice with (i) Sc-p16 and lacZp16mut(24) plasmids together or with (ii) one plasmid containing both the mutations and the Sc signal.

Vaccination of sheep with Maedi-visna virus gag gene and protein, beneficial or harmful?

In spite of intense efforts no vaccine is yet available that protects against lentiviral infections. Sheep were immunised eight times over a period of 2.5 years with the maedi-visna (MVV) gag gene on two different vectors, 2 sheep with VR1012-gag-CTE and 2 sheep with pcDNA3.1-gag-CTE. All sheep responded to some of the mature MVV Gag proteins in Western blot (WB). Three of them responded to the virus in lymphocyte proliferation test. The sheep received a boost with recombinant Gag protein resulting in elevated antibody response. However, when they were challenged intratracheally with MVV they all became immediately infected as judged by a strong rise in antibody titer and virus isolation from blood. It is therefore clear that the vaccination gave no protection. It is even possible that it facilitated infectivity since virus was isolated earlier from all the vaccinated sheep than from any of the unvaccinated sheep infected in the same way with the same dose.

Immune response to individual maedi-visna virus gag antigens

The lesions caused by maedi-visna virus (MVV) are known to be immune mediated with a presumed contribution by the response to viral antigens. However, very little is known about the T-cell response to individual viral proteins. We have therefore expressed the three individual gag antigens of MVV strain EV1 (p16, p25, and p14) in a bacterial expression system and used the purified recombinant proteins to analyze the antibody and CD4+ T-cell response to MVV. Plasma samples were taken from sheep after 1 year of infection with MVV. The titers for antibodies in these samples were determined by indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays and were as follows: anti-p25 antibody, 1:400 to >1:3,200; anti-p16 antibody, 1:400 to 1:3,200; and anti-p14 antibody, 1:<100 to 1:3,200. When the induction of antibodies was followed over time postinfection (p.i.), samples positive for anti-p25 were seen by day 24 p.i., followed by anti-p16 by day 45 p.i., and lastly anti-p14 by day 100 p.i. T-cell proliferative responses to all three gag antigens were detected in persistently infected sheep peripheral blood lymphocytes. The antigens were therefore used to raise T-cell lines from persistently infected sheep. These T-cell lines were shown to be specific for the recombinant gag antigens and for viral antigen expressed on infected macrophages. The proliferative response was restricted to major histocompatibility complex class II HLA-DR and so was due to CD4+ T lymphocytes. All three gag antigens may therefore play a role in immune-mediated lesion formation in MVV disease by presentation on infected macrophages in lesions.

Mucosal immunization of sheep with a Maedi-Visna virus (MVV) env DNA vaccine protects against early MVV productive infection

Gene gun mucosal DNA immunization of sheep with a plasmid expressing the env gene of Maedi-Visna virus (MVV) was used to examine the protection against MVV infection in sheep from a naturally infected flock. For immunization, sheep were primed with a pcDNA plasmid (pcDNA-env) encoding the Env glycoproteins of MVV and boosted with combined pcDNA-env and pCR3.1-IFN-gamma plasmid inoculations. The pcDNA plasmid used in the control group contained the lacZ coding sequences instead of the env gene. Within a month post-challenge, the viral load in the vaccinated group was lower (p < or = 0.05) and virus was only detected transiently compared with the control group. Furthermore, 2 months later, neutralizing antibodies (NtAb) were detected in all the control animals and none of the vaccinated animals (p < or = 0.01). These results demonstrated a significant early protective effect of this immunization strategy against MVV infection that restricts the virus replication following challenge in the absence of NtAb production. This vaccine protective effect against MVV infection disappeared after two years post-challenge, when active replication of MVV challenge strain was observed. Protection conferred by the vaccine could not be explained by OLA DRB1 allele or genotype differences. Most of the individuals were DRB1 heterozygous and none was totally resistant to infection.

Epitope analysis of capsid and matrix proteins of North American ovine lentivirus field isolates

Monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) directed against two phenotypically distinct ovine lentivirus (OvLV) strains were generated by fusion of BALB/c SP2/0-Ag 14 myeloma cells with spleen cells from mice immunized with purified OvLV. Hybridomas were selected by indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and analysis of reactivity on immunoblots. The majority (17 of 21) of the MAbs recognized the gag-encoded capsid protein, CA p27, of both strains. Four other MAbs recognized a smaller structural protein, presumably a matrix protein, MA p17. Three distinct epitopes on CA p27 and one on MA p17 were distinguished by the MAbs with competition ELISA. MAbs from each epitope group were able to recognize 17 North American field isolates of OvLV and the closely related caprine arthritis-encephalitis virus (CAEV). Analysis of the data indicated that these epitopes were highly conserved among naturally occurring isolates. A representative MAb from each epitope group of anti-CA p27 MAbs reacted with four field strains of OvLV and CAEV on immunoblots. An anti-MA p17 MAb recognized the same OvLV strains on immunoblots but failed to recognize CAEV. MAbs which recognize conserved epitopes of gag-encoded lentivirus proteins (CA p27 and MA p17) are valuable tools. These MAbs can be used to develop sensitive diagnostic assays and to study the pathogenesis of lentivirus infections in sheep and goats.

Human and ovine lentiviral infections compared

Maedi-visna virus (MVV) of sheep was the first lentivirus to be isolated. The genomic organization of MVV is very similar to that of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) with several genes regulating the expression of the viral genome. Viral replication is severely restricted in the host and some cells apparently contain the genetic information in a DNA provirus form with little or no expression of viral antigens. This seems to be a major factor in causing the "slowness" of lentiviral infections and the persistence of the virus in the host since the immune system may not recognize the provirus-containing cells. The target cells for HIV and MVV are similar although T4 lymphocytes are not specifically destroyed in maedi-visna. There are also certain similarities in the pathological changes in both diseases, both in the central nervous system, the lungs and the lymphatic system. Although the severe final immunodeficiency state characteristic of AIDS has not been observed in maedi-visna, the basic biological features of the MVV and its interaction with host cells are so similar to HIV infection, that we consider ovine maedi-visna useful animal model for the human lentivirus infections.