Bacterial defense systems exhibit synergistic anti-phage activity

Recent advancements in bacterial anti-phage strategies and the underlying mechanisms altering susceptibility to antibiotics

The rapid spread of multidrug-resistant bacteria and the challenges in developing new antibiotics have brought renewed international attention to phage therapy. However, in bacteria-phage co-evolution, the rapid development of bacterial resistance to phage has limited its clinical application. This review consolidates the latest advancements in research on anti-phage mechanisms, encompassing strategies such as systems associated with reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+) to halt the propagation of the phage, symbiotic bacteria episymbiont-mediated modulation of gene expression in host bacteria to resist phage infection, and defence-related reverse transcriptase (DRT) encoded by bacteria to curb phage infections. We conduct an in-depth analysis of the underlying mechanisms by which bacteria undergo alterations in antibiotic susceptibility after developing phage resistance. We also discuss the remaining challenges and promising directions for phage-based therapy in the future.

Responding to exogenous quorum-sensing signals promotes defense against phages by repressing OmpV expression in Pseudomonas syringae pv. actinidiae

Bacteriophages as viral predators can restrict host strains and shape the bacterial community. Conversely, bacteria also adopt diverse strategies for phage defense. Pseudomonas syringae pv. actinidiae (Psa) is the causal agent of bacterial canker on kiwifruit. Though Psa lacks quorum sensing signaling molecule synthase LuxI, two (PsaR1 and PsaR3) of three LuxR homologous were confirmed to bind with exogenous N-acyl homoserine lactone (AHL), OXO-C8-HSL. The adsorption and infection efficiency of phage KBC54 to Psa significantly reduced by adding OXO-C8-HSL or heterologous expression of traI of Agrobacterium tumefaciens in Psa. By generating PsaR1 and PsaR3 mutants, as well as PsaR-AHL MST assays, we specified that the two PsaRs can recruit AHL to enhance bacterial resistance against phage. Absence of PsaR1 and PsaR3 resulted in up-regulation of the outer membrane protein OmpV, and knockout of ompV led to impaired phage adsorption efficiency. Given that OmpV specifically interacted with the phage tail fiber protein Tp3 in pull-down assay, we deduced that OmpV serves as a cell surface receptor recognized by phage. This study highlights the remarkable ability of Psa recruiting QS signals to inhibit phage infection. This may be a common strategy for non-AHL producing bacteria that evolved to take control of phage infection and promote host fitness by orchestrating QS signals in living niches.

A miniature CRISPR-Cas10 enzyme confers immunity by an inverse signaling pathway

Microbial and viral co-evolution has created immunity mechanisms involving oligonucleotide signaling that share mechanistic features with human anti-viral systems 1 . In these pathways, including CBASS and type III CRISPR systems in bacteria and cGAS-STING in humans, oligonucleotide synthesis occurs upon detection of virus or foreign genetic material in the cell, triggering the antiviral response 2-4 . In a surprising inversion of this process, we show here that the CRISPR-related enzyme mCpol synthesizes cyclic oligonucleotides constitutively as part of an active mechanism that maintains cell health. Cell-based experiments demonstrated that the absence or loss of mCpol-produced cyclic oligonucleotides triggers cell death, preventing spread of viruses that attempt immune evasion by depleting host cyclic nucleotides. Structural and mechanistic investigation revealed mCpol to be a di-adenylate cyclase whose product, c-di-AMP, prevents toxic oligomerization of the effector protein 2TMβ. Analysis of cells by fluorescence microscopy showed that lack of mCpol allows 2TMβ-mediated cell death due to inner membrane collapse. These findings unveil a powerful new defense strategy against virus-mediated immune suppression, expanding our understanding of oligonucleotides in cell health and disease. These results raise the possibility of similar protective roles for cyclic oligonucleotides in other organisms including humans.

Study of the probability of resistance to phage infection in a collection of clinical isolates of Pseudomonas aeruginosa in relation to the presence of Pf phages

Pseudomonas aeruginosa is a bacterial pathogen that is a major cause of lung infections in cystic fibrosis (CF) and other patients. Isolates of P. aeruginosa from CF patients commonly carry filamentous phages (Pf phages), which constitute a family of temperate phages known to be related to biofilm production and antibiotic sequestration. In this study, we identified 12 new Pf phage genomes in a collection of clinical isolates of P. aeruginosa from CF patients. Study of the anti-phage defense systems in the bacterial isolates revealed the presence of 89 such systems, of which eight were encoded in the Pf phage genomes. Finally, although a weak relation between resistance to phage infection and the number of anti-phage defense systems was detected, it was observed that the phage resistance was related to the presence of Pf phages and the anti-phage defense systems encoded in these phages.IMPORTANCEBacteria harbor a wide range of defense mechanisms to avoid phage infections that hamper the application of phage therapy because they can lead to the rapid acquisition of phage resistance. In this study, eight anti-phage defense systems were found in the genome of 12 Pf phages that were presents in 56% of the CF isolates of P. aeruginosa. The high prevalence of these phages underlines the importance of our findings about newly discovered filamentous phages and the role of these phages in resistance to phage infections. Thus, the knowledge of the anti-defense system in the Pf phage genomes could be useful in assessing the possible application of phage therapy to treat an infectious disease.

Phage engineering to overcome bacterial Tmn immunity in Dhillonvirus

Bacteria possess numerous defense systems against phage infections, which limit phage infectivity and pose challenges for phage therapy. This study aimed to engineer phages capable of evading these defense systems, using the Tmn defense system as a model. We identified an anti-Tmn protein in the ΦSMS22 phage from the Dhillonvirus genus that inhibits Tmn function in Escherichia coli. Introducing this gene into the Tmn-sensitive ΦKSS9 phage enabled it to evade Tmn immunity. Additionally, we found that a single mutation in the nmad5 gene, a DNA modification enzyme in Dhillonvirus, prevented Tmn from sensing phage infection. By mutating the nmad5 gene in the Tmn-sensitive Dhillonvirus, we demonstrated that engineering phages to evade bacterial sensing mechanisms is another viable strategy. These two phage engineering approaches-introducing anti-defense genes and mutating sensing-related genes-present a promising strategy for establishing effective phage therapy by neutralizing bacterial defense systems.

Chemical inhibition of a bacterial immune system 1

The rise of antibiotic resistance motivates a revived interest in phage therapy. However, bacteria possess dozens of anti-bacteriophage immune systems that confer resistance to therapeutic phages. Chemical inhibitors of these anti-phage immune systems could be employed as adjuvants to overcome resistance in phage-based therapies. Here, we report that anti-phage systems can be selectively inhibited by small molecules, thereby sensitizing phage-resistant bacteria to phages. We discovered a class of chemical inhibitors that inhibit the type II Thoeris anti-phage immune system. These inhibitors block the biosynthesis of a histidine-ADPR intracellular 'alarm' signal by ThsB and prevent ThsA from arresting phage replication. These inhibitors promiscuously inhibit type II Thoeris systems from diverse bacteria-including antibiotic-resistant pathogens. Chemical inhibition of the Thoeris defense improved the efficacy of a model phage therapy against a phage-resistant strain of P. aeruginosa in a mouse infection, suggesting a therapeutic potential. Furthermore, these inhibitors may be employed as chemical tools to dissect the importance of the Thoeris system for phage defense in natural microbial communities.

Timescale and genetic linkage explain the variable impact of defense systems on horizontal gene transfer

Prokaryotes have evolved a wide repertoire of defense systems to prevent invasion by mobile genetic elements (MGEs). However, because MGEs are vehicles for the exchange of beneficial accessory genes, defense systems could consequently impede rapid adaptation in microbial populations. Here, we study how defense systems impact horizontal gene transfer (HGT) in the short term and long term. By combining comparative genomics and phylogeny-aware statistical methods, we quantify the association between the presence of seven widespread defense systems and the abundance of MGEs in the genomes of 196 bacterial and one archaeal species. We also calculate the differences in the rates of gene gain and loss between lineages that possess and lack each defense system. Our results show that the impact of defense systems on HGT is highly taxon and system dependent and, in most cases, not statistically significant. Timescale analysis reveals that defense systems must persist in a lineage for a relatively long time to exert an appreciable negative impact on HGT. In contrast, for shorter evolutionary timescales, frequent coacquisition of MGEs and defense systems results in a net positive association of the latter with HGT. Given the high turnover rates experienced by defense systems, we propose that the inhibitory effect of most defense systems on HGT is masked by their strong linkage with MGEs. These findings help explain the contradictory conclusions of previous research by pointing at mobility and within-host retention times as key factors that determine the impact of defense systems on genome plasticity.

Antiviral defence arsenal across members of the Bacillus cereus group

Bacteria co-evolve with bacteriophages to overcome each other's defence arsenal. Bacillus cereus group gathers bacteria of medical and agricultural importance, including foodborne pathogens. So far, few studies have portrayed a complete defence arsenal of microorganisms, and the role of antiviral systems in the Bacillus cereus group has been overlooked. Here, we investigate the repertoire of defence systems in 6354 B. cereus group's genomic assemblies, using bioinformatics tools DefenseFinder and PADLOC. Our analyses provide an overview of the diversity and abundance of defence systems in this group, with 83,738 systems distributed by 2 to 33 within each assembly. Comparing PADLOC and DefenseFinder predictions showed that the most prevalent strategy is Restriction-Modification, but many abortive infection systems also intervene in the group's defence, such as Septu, Gabija and Lamassu. Most defences were encoded on both plasmids and the chromosome, though some tend to have a preferential genomic location. We also studied the defence systems associations within the genomic assemblies. Overall, our results establish a baseline picturing the rich and complex antiviral arsenal encoded by B. cereus group's species and provide clues for studying co-existing strategies displayed by these bacteria to subvert phages and other MGEs invasions.

Adaptive modification of antiviral defense systems in microbial community under Cr-induced stress

BACKGROUND

The prokaryotic antiviral defense systems are crucial for mediating prokaryote-virus interactions that influence microbiome functioning and evolutionary dynamics. Despite the prevalence and significance of prokaryotic antiviral defense systems, their responses to abiotic stress and ecological consequences remain poorly understood in soil ecosystems. We established microcosm systems with varying concentrations of hexavalent chromium (Cr(VI)) to investigate the adaptive modifications of prokaryotic antiviral defense systems under abiotic stress.

RESULTS

Utilizing hybrid metagenomic assembly with long-read and short-read sequencing, we discovered that antiviral defense systems were more diverse and prevalent in heavily polluted soils, which was corroborated by meta-analyses of public datasets from various heavy metal-contaminated sites. As the Cr(VI) concentration increased, prokaryotes with defense systems favoring prokaryote-virus mutualism gradually supplanted those with defense systems incurring high adaptive costs. Additionally, as Cr(VI) concentrations increased, enriched antiviral defense systems exhibited synchronization with microbial heavy metal resistance genes. Furthermore, the proportion of antiviral defense systems carried by mobile genetic elements (MGEs), including plasmids and viruses, increased by approximately 43% and 39%, respectively, with rising Cr concentrations. This trend is conducive to strengthening the dissemination and sharing of defense resources within microbial communities.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, our study reveals the adaptive modification of prokaryotic antiviral defense systems in soil ecosystems under abiotic stress, as well as their positive contributions to establishing prokaryote-virus mutualism and the evolution of microbial heavy metal resistance. These findings advance our understanding of microbial adaptation in stressful environments and may inspire novel approaches for microbiome manipulation and bioremediation. Video Abstract.

Combinatorial phenotypic landscape enables bacterial resistance to phage infection

Success of phage therapies is limited by bacterial defenses against phages. While a large variety of anti-phage defense mechanisms has been characterized, how expression of these systems is distributed across individual cells and how their combined activities translate into protection from phages has not been studied. Using bacterial single-cell RNA sequencing, we profiled the transcriptomes of ~50,000 cells from cultures of a human pathobiont, Bacteroides fragilis, infected with a lytic bacteriophage. We quantified the asynchronous progression of phage infection in single bacterial cells and reconstructed the infection timeline, characterizing both host and phage transcriptomic changes as infection unfolded. We discovered a subpopulation of bacteria that remained uninfected and determined the heterogeneously expressed host factors associated with protection. Each cell's vulnerability to phage infection was defined by combinatorial phase-variable expression of multiple genetic loci, including capsular polysaccharide (CPS) biosynthesis pathways, restriction-modification systems (RM), and a previously uncharacterized operon likely encoding fimbrial genes. By acting together, these heterogeneously expressed phase-variable systems and anti-phage defense mechanisms create a phenotypic landscape where distinct protective combinations enable the survival and re-growth of bacteria expressing these phenotypes without acquiring additional mutations. The emerging model of complementary action of multiple protective mechanisms heterogeneously expressed across an isogenic bacterial population showcases the potent role of phase variation and stochasticity in bacterial anti-phage defenses.

In silico characterization of defense system hotspots in Acinetobacter spp

The bacteria-phage arm race drives the evolution of diverse bacterial defenses. This study identifies and characterizes the defense hotspots in Acinetobacter baumannii using a reference-free approach. Among 4383 high-quality genomes, we found a total of 17,430 phage defense systems and with 54.54% concentrated in 21 hotspots. These hotspots exhibit distinct preferences for different defense systems, and co-occurrence patterns suggest synergistic interactions. Additionally, the mobile genetic elements are abundant around these hotspots, likely facilitating horizontal transfer and evolution of defense systems. The number of hotspots increases in species phylogenetically closer to Acinetobacter baumannii, but the number of defense systems per hotspot varies due to particular selective pressures. These findings provide critical insights into the genetic organization of phage defense systems, contributing to a broader understanding of bacterial immunity and the evolutionary dynamics that shape Acinetobacter genomes. This knowledge lays the foundation for developing targeted interventions  to combat antibiotic resistance Acinetobacter baumannii.

A Class 1 OLD family nuclease encoded by Vibrio cholerae is countered by a vibriophage-encoded direct inhibitor

Bacteria are constantly threatened by their viral predators (phages), which has resulted in the development of defense systems for bacterial survival. One family of defense systems found widely across bacteria are OLD (for overcoming lysogeny defect) family nucleases. Despite recent discoveries regarding Class 2 and 4 OLD family nucleases and how phages overcome them, Class 1 OLD family nucleases warrant further study as there has only been one anti-phage Class 1 OLD family nuclease described to date. Here, we identify the Vibrio cholerae-encoded Class 1 OLD family nuclease Vc OLD and describe its disruption of genome replication of the lytic vibriophage ICP1. Furthermore, we examine its in vitro activity, identifying Vc OLD as a DNA nickase. Finally, we identify the first direct inhibitor of a Class 1 OLD family nuclease, the ICP1-encoded Oad1. Our research further illuminates Class 1 OLD family nucleases' role in phage defense and explores the dynamic arms race between V. cholerae and its predatory phage ICP1.

Cas10 relieves host growth arrest to facilitate spacer retention during type III-A CRISPR-Cas immunity

Cells from all kingdoms of life can enter growth arrest in unfavorable environmental conditions. Key to this process are mechanisms enabling recovery from this state. Staphylococcal type III-A CRISPR-Cas loci encode the Cas10 complex that uses a guide RNA to locate complementary viral transcripts and start an immune response. When the target sequence is expressed late in the viral lytic cycle, defense requires the activity of Csm6, a non-specific RNase that inhibits the growth of the infected cell. How Csm6 protects from infection and whether growth can be restored is not known. Here, we show that growth arrest provides immunity at the population level, preventing viral replication and allowing uninfected cells to propagate. In addition, the ssDNase activity of Cas10 is required for the regrowth of a subset of the arrested cells and the recovery of the infected host, presumably ending the immune response through degradation of the viral DNA.

Genome Analysis of Anti-Phage Defense Systems and Defense Islands in Stenotrophomonas maltophilia: Preservation and Variability

Anti-phage defense systems are widespread in bacteria due to the latter continuous adaptation to infection by bacteriophages (phages). Stenotrophomonas maltophilia has a high degree of intrinsic antibiotic resistance, which makes phage therapy relevant for the treatment of infections caused by this species. Studying the array of anti-phage defense systems that could be found in S. maltophilia helps in better adapting the phages to the systems present in the pathogenic bacteria. Pangenome analysis of the available S. maltophilia strains with complete genomes that were downloaded from GenBank, including five local genomes, indicated a wide set of 72 defense systems and subsystems that varied between the strains. Seven of these systems were present in more than 20% of the studied genomes and the proteins encoded by the systems were variable in most of the cases. A total of 27 defense islands were revealed where defense systems were found; however, more than 60% of the instances of systems were found in four defense islands. Several elements linked to the transfer of these systems were found. No obvious associations between the pattern of distribution of the anti-phage defense systems of S. maltophilia and the phylogenetic features or the isolation site were found.

Unveiling Hidden Allies: In Silico Discovery of Prophages in Tenacibaculum Species

Tenacibaculosis, caused by Tenacibaculum species, is a significant disease in aquaculture, leading to high mortality and economic losses. Antibiotic treatment raises concerns about resistance, making phage therapy an interesting alternative. Analyzing phage traces in Tenacibaculum genomes is crucial for developing these bacteriophage-based strategies.

METHODS

We assessed the presence of prophages in 212 Tenacibaculum genomes/assemblies available in the NCBI repository, comprising several species and global locations, using the PHASTEST program. Then, we focused on those regions classified as intact, evaluating the most common phages found using VICTOR. The protein of interest discovered in the prophages was evaluated using the ProtParam, DeepTMHMM, InterPro, and Phyre2 tools. In addition, we evaluated the presence of antiphage defense systems in those genomes with intact prophages using the DefenseFinder tool.

RESULTS

We identified 25 phage elements in 24 out of the 212 Tenacibaculum genomes/assemblies analyzed, with 11% of the assemblies containing phage elements. These were concentrated in T. maritimum and T. mesophilum, which harbored 10 and 7 prophage regions, respectively. Of the identified elements, six were classified as intact, including four in T. maritimum, with the most common phages belonging to the Pippivirus and Siphoviridae families. Bioinformatic analysis showed that the putative endolysin is a stable protein of 432 amino acids and 49.8 kDa, with three transmembrane helices and a CHAP domain, structurally similar to the CHAP lytic domain of S. aureus bacteriophage K.

CONCLUSIONS

Key prophage elements in Tenacibaculum, especially in T. maritimum, show promise for phage therapy against tenacibaculosis, supporting sustainable, antibiotic-free treatments in aquaculture.

Pipolins are bimodular platforms that maintain a reservoir of defense systems exchangeable with various bacterial genetic mobile elements

Defense genes gather in diverse types of genomic islands in bacteria and provide immunity against viruses and other genetic mobile elements. Here, we disclose pipolins, previously found in diverse bacterial phyla and encoding a primer-independent PolB, as a new category of widespread defense islands. The analysis of the occurrence and structure of pipolins revealed that they are commonly integrative elements flanked by direct repeats in Gammaproteobacteria genomes, mainly Escherichia, Vibrio or Aeromonas, often taking up known mobile elements integration hotspots. Remarkably, integrase dynamics correlates with alternative integration spots and enables diverse lifestyles, from integrative to mobilizable and plasmid pipolins, such as in members of the genera Limosilactobacillus, Pseudosulfitobacter or Staphylococcus. Pipolins harbor a minimal core and a large cargo module enriched for defense factors. In addition, analysis of the weighted gene repertoire relatedness revealed that many of these defense factors are actively exchanged with other mobile elements. These findings indicate pipolins and, potentially other defense islands, act as orthogonal reservoirs of defense genes, potentially transferable to immune autonomous MGEs, suggesting complementary exchange mechanisms for defense genes in bacterial populations.

Cyanobacteria-cyanophage interactions between freshwater and marine ecosystems based on large-scale cyanophage genomic analysis

The disparities in harmful algal blooms dynamics are largely attributed to variations in cyanobacteria populations within aquatic ecosystems. However, cyanobacteria-cyanophage interactions and their role in shaping cyanobacterial populations has been previously underappreciated. To address this knowledge gap, we isolated and sequenced 42 cyanophages from diverse water sources in China, with the majority (n = 35) originating from freshwater sources. We designated these sequences as the "Novel Cyanophage Genome sequence Collection" (NCGC). NCGC displayed notable genetic variations, with 95 % (40/42) of the sequences representing previously unidentified taxonomic ranks. By integrating NCGC with public data of cyanophages and cyanobacteria, we found evidence for more frequent historical cyanobacteria-cyanophage interactions in freshwater ecosystems. This was evidenced by a higher prevalence of prophage integrase-related genes in freshwater cyanophages (37.97 %) than marine cyanophages (7.42 %). In addition, freshwater cyanophages could infect a broader range of cyanobacteria orders (n = 4) than marine ones (n = 0). Correspondingly, freshwater cyanobacteria harbored more defense systems per million base pairs in their genomes, indicating more frequent phage infections. Evolutionary and cyanophage epidemiological studies suggest that interactions between cyanobacteria and cyanophages in freshwater and marine ecosystems are interconnected, and that brackish water can act as a transitional zone for freshwater and marine cyanophages. In conclusion, our research significantly expands the genetic information database of cyanophage, offering a wider selection of cyanophages to control harmful cyanobacterial blooms. Additionally, we represent a pioneering large-scale and comprehensive analysis of cyanobacteria and cyanophage sequencing data, and it provides theoretical guidance for the application of cyanophages in different environments.

Ecological Determinants of Altruism in Prokaryote Antivirus Defense

Prokaryote evolution is driven in large part by the incessant arms race with viruses. Genomic investments in antivirus defense can be coarsely classified into two categories, immune systems that abrogate virus reproduction resulting in clearance, and altruistic programmed cell death (PCD) systems. Prokaryotic defense systems are enormously diverse, as revealed by an avalanche of recent discoveries, but the basic ecological determinants of defense strategy remain poorly understood. Through mathematical modeling of defense against lytic virus infection, we identify two principal determinants of optimal defense strategy and, through comparative genomics, we test this model by measuring the genomic investment into immunity vs PCD among diverse bacteria and archaea. First, as viral pressure grows, immunity becomes the preferred defense strategy. Second, as host population size grows, PCD becomes the preferred strategy. We additionally predict that, although optimal strategy typically involves investment in both PCD and immunity, overinvestment in immunity can result in system antagonism, increasing the probability a PCD-competent cell will lyse due to infection. Together these findings indicate that, generally, PCD is preferred at low multiplicity of infection (MOI) and immunity is preferred at high MOI, and that the landscape of prokaryotic antivirus defense is substantially more complex than previously suspected.

Single phage proteins sequester signals from TIR and cGAS-like enzymes

Prokaryotic anti-phage immune systems use TIR and cGAS-like enzymes to produce 1''-3'-glycocyclic ADP-ribose (1''-3'-gcADPR) and cyclic dinucleotide (CDN) and cyclic trinucleotide (CTN) signalling molecules, respectively, which limit phage replication1-3. However, how phages neutralize these distinct and common systems is largely unclear. Here we show that the Thoeris anti-defence proteins Tad14 and Tad25 both achieve anti-cyclic-oligonucleotide-based anti-phage signalling system (anti-CBASS) activity by simultaneously sequestering CBASS cyclic oligonucleotides. Apart from binding to the Thoeris signals 1''-3'-gcADPR and 1''-2'-gcADPR, Tad1 also binds to numerous CBASS CDNs and CTNs with high affinity, inhibiting CBASS systems that use these molecules in vivo and in vitro. The hexameric Tad1 has six binding sites for CDNs or gcADPR, which are independent of the two high-affinity binding sites for CTNs. Tad2 forms a tetramer that also sequesters various CDNs in addition to gcADPR molecules, using distinct binding sites to simultaneously bind to these signals. Thus, Tad1 and Tad2 are both two-pronged inhibitors that, alongside anti-CBASS protein 2 (Acb26-8), establish a paradigm of phage proteins that use distinct binding sites to flexibly sequester a considerable breadth of cyclic nucleotides.

Nucleotide Immune Signaling in CBASS, Pycsar, Thoeris, and CRISPR Antiphage Defense

Bacteria encode an arsenal of diverse systems that defend against phage infection. A common theme uniting many prevalent antiphage defense systems is the use of specialized nucleotide signals that function as second messengers to activate downstream effector proteins and inhibit viral propagation. In this article, we review the molecular mechanisms controlling nucleotide immune signaling in four major families of antiphage defense systems: CBASS, Pycsar, Thoeris, and type III CRISPR immunity. Analyses of the individual steps connecting phage detection, nucleotide signal synthesis, and downstream effector function reveal shared core principles of signaling and uncover system-specific strategies used to augment immune defense. We compare recently discovered mechanisms used by phages to evade nucleotide immune signaling and highlight convergent strategies that shape host-virus interactions. Finally, we explain how the evolutionary connection between bacterial antiphage defense and eukaryotic antiviral immunity defines fundamental rules that govern nucleotide-based immunity across all kingdoms of life.

Bacterial defense and phage counterdefense lead to coexistence in a modeled ecosystem

Bacteria have evolved many defenses against invading viruses (phage). Despite the many bacterial defenses and phage counterdefenses, in most environments, bacteria and phage coexist, with neither driving the other to extinction. How is coexistence realized in the context of the bacteria/phage arms race, and how are immune repertoire sizes determined in conditions of coexistence? Here we develop a simple mathematical model to consider the evolutionary and ecological dynamics of competing bacteria and phage with different immune/counterimmune repertoires. We find an ecologically stable fixed point exhibiting coexistence, in agreement with the experimental observation that each individual bacterium typically carries multiple defense systems, though fewer than the maximum number possible. However, in simulations, the populations typically remain dynamic, exhibiting chaotic fluctuations around this fixed point. These dynamics enable coexistence even when phage (predator) strains outnumber bacteria (prey) strains. We obtain quantitative predictions for the mean, amplitude, and timescale of these dynamics. Our results provide a framework for understanding the evolutionary and ecological dynamics of the bacteria/phage arms race and demonstrate how bacteria/phage coexistence can stably arise from the coevolution of bacterial defense systems and phage counterdefense systems.

Phage defence loci of Streptococcus thermophilus-tip of the anti-phage iceberg?

Bacteria possess (bacterio)phage defence systems to ensure their survival. The thermophilic lactic acid bacterium, Streptococcus thermophilus, which is used in dairy fermentations, harbours multiple CRISPR-Cas and restriction and modification (R/M) systems to protect itself against phage attack, with limited reports on other types of phage-resistance. Here, we describe the systematic identification and functional analysis of the phage resistome of S. thermophilus using a collection of 27 strains as representatives of the species. In addition to CRISPR-Cas and R/M systems, we uncover nine distinct phage-resistance systems including homologues of Kiwa, Gabija, Dodola, defence-associated sirtuins and classical lactococcal/streptococcal abortive infection systems. The genes encoding several of these newly identified S. thermophilus antiphage systems are located in proximity to the genetic determinants of CRISPR-Cas systems thus constituting apparent Phage Defence Islands. Other phage-resistance systems whose encoding genes are not co-located with genes specifying CRISPR-Cas systems may represent anchors to identify additional Defence Islands harbouring, as yet, uncharacterised phage defence systems. We estimate that up to 2.5% of the genetic material of the analysed strains is dedicated to phage defence, highlighting that phage-host antagonism plays an important role in driving the evolution and shaping the composition of dairy streptococcal genomes.

Structural basis for regulation of a CBASS-CRISPR-Cas defense island by a transmembrane anti-σ factor and its ECF σ partner

How CRISPR-Cas and cyclic oligonucleotide-based antiphage signaling systems (CBASS) are coordinately deployed against invaders remains unclear. We show that a locus containing two CBASS and one type III-B CRISPR-Cas system, regulated by the transmembrane anti-σ DdvA and its cognate extracytoplasmic function (ECF) σ DdvS, can defend Myxococcus xanthus against a phage. Cryo-electron microscopy reveals DdvA-DdvS pairs assemble as arrow-shaped transmembrane dimers. Each DdvA periplasmic domain adopts a separase/craspase-type tetratricopeptide repeat (TPR)-caspase HetF-associated with TPR (TPR-CHAT) architecture with an incomplete His-Cys active site, lacking three α-helices conserved among CHAT domains. Each active site faces the dimer interface, raising the possibility that signal-induced caspase-like DdvA autoproteolysis in trans precedes RseP-mediated intramembrane proteolysis and DdvS release. Nuclear magnetic resonance reveals a DdvA cytoplasmic CHCC-type zinc-bound three-helix bundle that binds to DdvS σ2 and σ4 domains, undergoing σ4-induced helix extension to trap DdvS. Altogether, we provide structural-mechanistic insights into membrane anti-σ-ECF σ regulation of an antiviral CBASS-CRISPR-Cas defense island.

Architecture and activation mechanism of the bacterial PARIS defence system

Bacteria and their viruses (bacteriophages or phages) are engaged in an intense evolutionary arms race1-5. While the mechanisms of many bacterial antiphage defence systems are known1, how these systems avoid toxicity outside infection yet activate quickly after infection is less well understood. Here we show that the bacterial phage anti-restriction-induced system (PARIS) operates as a toxin-antitoxin system, in which the antitoxin AriA sequesters and inactivates the toxin AriB until triggered by the T7 phage counterdefence protein Ocr. Using cryo-electron microscopy, we show that AriA is related to SMC-family ATPases but assembles into a distinctive homohexameric complex through two oligomerization interfaces. In uninfected cells, the AriA hexamer binds to up to three monomers of AriB, maintaining them in an inactive state. After Ocr binding, the AriA hexamer undergoes a structural rearrangement, releasing AriB and allowing it to dimerize and activate. AriB is a toprim/OLD-family nuclease, the activation of which arrests cell growth and inhibits phage propagation by globally inhibiting protein translation through specific cleavage of a lysine tRNA. Collectively, our findings reveal the intricate molecular mechanisms of a bacterial defence system triggered by a phage counterdefence protein, and highlight how an SMC-family ATPase has been adapted as a bacterial infection sensor.

Functional and practical insights into three lactococcal antiphage systems

The persistent challenge of phages in dairy fermentations requires the development of starter cultures with enhanced phage resistance. Recently, three plasmid-encoded lactococcal antiphage systems, named Rhea, Aristaios, and Kamadhenu, were discovered. These systems were found to confer high levels of resistance against various Skunavirus members. In the present study, their effectiveness against phage infection was confirmed in milk-based medium, thus validating their potential to ensure reliable dairy fermentations. We furthermore demonstrated that Rhea and Kamadhenu do not directly hinder phage genome replication, transcription, or associated translation. Conversely, Aristaios was found to interfere with phage transcription. Two of the antiphage systems are encoded on pMRC01-like conjugative plasmids, and the Kamadhenu-encoding plasmid was successfully transferred by conjugation to three lactococcal strains, each of which acquired substantially enhanced phage resistance against Skunavirus members. Such advances in our knowledge of the lactococcal phage resistome and the possibility of mobilizing these protective functions to bolster phage protection in sensitive strains provide practical solutions to the ongoing phage problem in industrial food fermentations.IMPORTANCEIn the current study, we characterized and evaluated the mechanistic diversity of three recently described, plasmid-encoded lactococcal antiphage systems. These systems were found to confer high resistance against many members of the most prevalent and problematic lactococcal phage genus, rendering them of particular interest to the dairy industry, where persistent phage challenge requires the development of starter cultures with enhanced phage resistance characteristics. Our acquired knowledge highlights that enhanced understanding of lactococcal phage resistance systems and their encoding plasmids can provide rational and effective solutions to the enduring issue of phage infections in dairy fermentation facilities.

Structure and rational engineering of the PglX methyltransferase and specificity factor for BREX phage defence

Bacteria have evolved a broad range of systems that provide defence against their viral predators, bacteriophages. Bacteriophage Exclusion (BREX) systems recognise and methylate 6 bp non-palindromic motifs within the host genome, and prevent replication of non-methylated phage DNA that encodes these same motifs. How BREX recognises cognate motifs has not been fully understood. In this study we characterise BREX from pathogenic Salmonella and present X-ray crystallographic structures of the conserved BREX protein, PglX. The PglX N-terminal domain encodes the methyltransferase, whereas the C-terminal domain is for motif recognition. We also present the structure of PglX bound to the phage-derived DNA mimic, Ocr, an inhibitor of BREX activity. Our analyses propose modes for DNA-binding by PglX and indicate that both methyltransferase activity and defence require larger BREX complexes. Through rational engineering of PglX we broaden both the range of phages targeted, and the host motif sequences that are methylated by BREX. Our data demonstrate that PglX is used to recognise specific DNA sequences for BREX activity, contributing to motif recognition for both phage defence and host methylation.

Comprehensive blueprint of Salmonella genomic plasticity identifies hotspots for pathogenicity genes

Understanding the dynamic evolution of Salmonella is vital for effective bacterial infection management. This study explores the role of the flexible genome, organised in regions of genomic plasticity (RGP), in shaping the pathogenicity of Salmonella lineages. Through comprehensive genomic analysis of 12,244 Salmonella spp. genomes covering 2 species, 6 subspecies, and 46 serovars, we uncover distinct integration patterns of pathogenicity-related gene clusters into RGP, challenging traditional views of gene distribution. These RGP exhibit distinct preferences for specific genomic spots, and the presence or absence of such spots across Salmonella lineages profoundly shapes strain pathogenicity. RGP preferences are guided by conserved flanking genes surrounding integration spots, implicating their involvement in regulatory networks and functional synergies with integrated gene clusters. Additionally, we emphasise the multifaceted contributions of plasmids and prophages to the pathogenicity of diverse Salmonella lineages. Overall, this study provides a comprehensive blueprint of the pathogenicity potential of Salmonella. This unique insight identifies genomic spots in nonpathogenic lineages that hold the potential for harbouring pathogenicity genes, providing a foundation for predicting future adaptations and developing targeted strategies against emerging human pathogenic strains.

Diversity and phage sensitivity to phages of porcine enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli

Enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli (ETEC) is a diverse and poorly characterized E. coli pathotype that causes diarrhea in humans and animals. Phages have been proposed for the veterinary biocontrol of ETEC, but effective solutions require understanding of porcine ETEC diversity that affects phage infection. Here, we sequenced and analyzed the genomes of the PHAGEBio ETEC collection, gathering 79 diverse ETEC strains isolated from European pigs with post-weaning diarrhea (PWD). We identified the virulence factors characterizing the pathotype and several antibiotic resistance genes on plasmids, while phage resistance genes and other virulence factors were mostly chromosome encoded. We experienced that ETEC strains were highly resistant to Enterobacteriaceae phage infection. It was only by enrichment of numerous diverse samples with different media and conditions, using the 41 ETEC strains of our collection as hosts, that we could isolate two lytic phages that could infect a large part of our diverse ETEC collection: vB_EcoP_ETEP21B and vB_EcoS_ETEP102. Based on genome and host range analyses, we discussed the infection strategies of the two phages and identified components of lipopolysaccharides ( LPS) as receptors for the two phages. Our detailed computational structural analysis highlights several loops and pockets in the tail fibers that may allow recognition and binding of ETEC strains, also in the presence of O-antigens. Despite the importance of receptor recognition, the diversity of the ETEC strains remains a significant challenge for isolating ETEC phages and developing sustainable phage-based products to address ETEC-induced PWD.IMPORTANCEEnterotoxigenic Escherichia coli (ETEC)-induced post-weaning diarrhea is a severe disease in piglets that leads to weight loss and potentially death, with high economic and animal welfare costs worldwide. Phage-based approaches have been proposed, but available data are insufficient to ensure efficacy. Genome analysis of an extensive collection of ETEC strains revealed that phage defense mechanisms were mostly chromosome encoded, suggesting a lower chance of spread and selection by phage exposure. The difficulty in isolating lytic phages and the molecular and structural analyses of two ETEC phages point toward a multifactorial resistance of ETEC to phage infection and the importance of extensive phage screenings specifically against clinically relevant strains. The PHAGEBio ETEC collection and these two phages are valuable tools for the scientific community to expand our knowledge on the most studied, but still enigmatic, bacterial species-E. coli.

Molecular mechanism of plasmid elimination by the DdmDE defense system

Seventh-pandemic Vibrio cholerae strains contain two pathogenicity islands that encode the DNA defense modules DdmABC and DdmDE. In this study, we used cryogenic electron microscopy to determine the mechanistic basis for plasmid defense by DdmDE. The helicase-nuclease DdmD adopts an autoinhibited dimeric architecture. The prokaryotic Argonaute protein DdmE uses a DNA guide to target plasmid DNA. The structure of the DdmDE complex, validated by in vivo mutational studies, shows that DNA binding by DdmE triggers disassembly of the DdmD dimer and loading of monomeric DdmD onto the nontarget DNA strand. In vitro studies indicate that DdmD translocates in the 5'-to-3' direction, while partially degrading the plasmid DNA. These findings provide critical insights into the mechanism of DdmDE systems in plasmid elimination.

A nuclease domain fused to the Snf2 helicase confers antiphage defence in coral-associated Halomonas meridiana

The coral reef microbiome plays a vital role in the health and resilience of reefs. Previous studies have examined phage therapy for coral pathogens and for modifying the coral reef microbiome, but defence systems against coral-associated bacteria have received limited attention. Phage defence systems play a crucial role in helping bacteria fight phage infections. In this study, we characterized a new defence system, Hma (HmaA-HmaB-HmaC), in the coral-associated Halomonas meridiana derived from the scleractinian coral Galaxea fascicularis. The Swi2/Snf2 helicase HmaA with a C-terminal nuclease domain exhibits antiviral activity against Escherichia phage T4. Mutation analysis revealed the nickase activity of the nuclease domain (belonging to PDD/EXK superfamily) of HmaA is essential in phage defence. Additionally, HmaA homologues are present in ~1000 bacterial and archaeal genomes. The high frequency of HmaA helicase in Halomonas strains indicates the widespread presence of these phage defence systems, while the insertion of defence genes in the hma region confirms the existence of a defence gene insertion hotspot. These findings offer insights into the diversity of phage defence systems in coral-associated bacteria and these diverse defence systems can be further applied into designing probiotics with high-phage resistance.

Going viral: The role of mobile genetic elements in bacterial immunity

Bacteriophages and other mobile genetic elements (MGEs) pose a significant threat to bacteria, subjecting them to constant attacks. In response, bacteria have evolved a sophisticated immune system that employs diverse defensive strategies and mechanisms. Remarkably, a growing body of evidence suggests that most of these defenses are encoded by MGEs themselves. This realization challenges our traditional understanding of bacterial immunity and raises intriguing questions about the evolutionary forces at play. Our review provides a comprehensive overview of the latest findings on the main families of MGEs and the defense systems they encode. We also highlight how a vast diversity of defense systems remains to be discovered and their mechanism of mobility understood. Altogether, the composition and distribution of defense systems in bacterial genomes only makes sense in the light of the ecological and evolutionary interactions of a complex network of MGEs.

A layered effect in bacterial defense

Defense systems that protect bacteria from invaders, such as viruses, are believed to be multi-layered and driven by interactions. In this issue of Cell Host & Microbe, Wu, Garushyants et al.1 delve into the dynamics between these safeguard mechanisms and unravel synergistic interactions.