Regulation of defects and nitrogen species on carbon nanotube by plasma-etching for peroxymonosulfate activation: Inducing non-radical/radical oxidation of organic contaminants

Carbonized nitrogen-containing conjugated microporous polymers: Versatile platforms for high-performance carbon catalytic membranes and their angstrom-confined activation mechanism on peroxymonosulfate

Engineering high-performance N-doped carbon catalysts for peroxymonosulfate (PMS) activation and elucidating their activation mechanism are crucial for the degradation of emerging pollutants. In this study, we propose a novel self-template carbonization strategy (NSCS) based on a N-containing conjugated microporous polymer (NCMP, poly(triphenylamine)) to fabricate high-performance N-doped porous carbon catalysts. Owing to the unique N-mediated catalytic sites within the confined micropores of the NCMP precursor, the NSCS approach enables the investigation of reactive oxygen species evolution and their formation mechanisms as carbonization temperature increases from 200 to 1400 °C. The catalyst carbonized at 1000 °C exhibited high degradation activity (k = 0.170 min-1), driven primarily by O2•- and 1O2, with minor contributions from •OH and SO4•-. Additionally, a PMS self-decomposition and ¹O2 generation mechanism within angstrom-confined spaces was identified. A self-supported carbon catalytic membrane was fabricated from CPTPA-1000 (CPTPA-CNT) due to its high conjugation and thermal stability. This membrane demonstrated efficient removal of organic pollutant (k = 123.54 min-1, 220.3 L m-2 h-1 bar-1, 120 h, 99.4 %), outperforming the carbonized CNT membrane (k = 19.54 min-1, 67.5 L m-2 h-1 bar-1, 120 h, 14.8 %). This work paves an avenue for the design of high-performance carbon-based membranes and gives new insights into the 1O2 generation mechanism in N-doped carbon catalysts.

Plasma-catalytic remediation of pharmaceutical-contaminated wastewater: Catalyst design and mechanistic insights from DFT

Contaminants of emerging concern (CECs), characterized by persistence, poor biodegradability, and high toxicity, pose significant risks to aquatic ecosystems and human health. Plasma-catalytic processes may eliminate CECs, particularly micropollutants, from wastewater. However, discharge-zone thermalization and heavy-metal leaching from metal-based catalysts pose challenges for industrial adoption of cold plasma technology. This study presents a novel coaxial plasma electrode and a heteroatom-doped carbonaceous catalyst that overcome these limitations. Catalysts with varying boron and oxygen contents are synthesized through the pyrolysis of waste wood, boric acid, and zinc borate at 1000 °C. Boron-doped graphene-like carbon with 15-wt.% boric acid and 15-wt.% zinc borate exhibits superior ozone degradation and hydrogen-peroxide formation. The plasma-catalytic system demonstrates high-efficacy micropollutant degradation, achieving complete naproxen degradation in less than 30 min with a 0.1112 degradation rate and 75.67 % mineralization. Additionally, it effectively removed naproxen, rhodamine B, and Congo red from real wastewater spiked with 10 ppm of each pollutant. Density functional theory calculations elucidate the high affinity of armchair BC2O for ozone adsorption. Moreover, the dual role of zinc borate as both an activator and dopant in the synthesis of boron-doped graphene-like carbon is revealed. As the synthesized metal-free catalyst exhibits high performance for treatment of real wastewater samples, and the plasma setup is simple and efficient, this system has scalability and practical applicability in wastewater treatment plants.

Microenvironment modulation of biocatalyst derived from natural cellulose of wheat straw for enhancing p-nitrophenol degradation via boosting peroxymonosulfate activation

Defect-rich nitrogen-doped biocatalyst (B-NC) was synthesized from natural cellulose of wheat straw using straightforward mechanical method and one-step pyrolysis approach. In contrast to the nitrogen-doped biocatalyst (NC), by leveraging the synergistic effects of nitrogen dopants and surface defects, the microenvironment-modulated B-NC exhibited the enhanced mass transfer efficiency and a significant improvement in reactivity for p-nitrophenol degradation (111 %-196 %). The catalyst's exceptional performance primarily arose from graphitic N, pyridinic N and CO active sites, which mainly derived from the cellulose structure of wheat straw and nitrogen dopants. Electron paramagnetic resonance and quenching tests confirmed that the B-NC/peroxymonosulfate system generated more reactive species (SO4•-, •OH, O2•-, and 1O2) during p-nitrophenol degradation, surpassing the NC/peroxymonosulfate system. Additionally, both density functional theory calculations and electrochemical experiments provided evidence of peroxymonosulfate strongly adsorbing onto B-NC's defect sites, facilitating the formation of catalyst/peroxymonosulfate* complexes and promoting electron transfer processes. This research provides valuable insights into the regulation of defects in nitrogen-doped biocatalyst derived from natural cellulose, presenting a promising solution for remediating refractory organic pollutants.

Remarkable Active Site Utilization in Edge-Hosted-N Doped Carbocatalysts for Fenton-Like Reaction

Improving the utilization of active sites in carbon catalysts is significant for various catalytic reactions, but still challenging, mainly due to the lack of strategies for controllable introduction of active dopants. Herein, a novel "Ar plasma etching-NH3 annealing" strategy is developed to regulate the position of active N sites, while maintaining the same nitrogen species and contents. Theoretical and experimental results reveal that the edge-hosted-N doped carbon nanotubes (E-N-CNT), with only 0.29 at.% N content, show great affinity to peroxymonosulfate (PMS), and exhibit excellent Fenton-like activity by generating singlet oxygen (1O2), which can reach as high as 410 times higher than the pristine CNT. The remarkable utilization of edge-hosted nitrogen atom is further verified by the edge-hosted-N enriched carbocatalyst, which shows superior capability for 4-chlorophenol degradation with a turnover frequency (TOF) value as high as 3.82 min-1, and the impressive TOF value can even surpass those of single-atom catalysts. This work proposes a controllable position regulation of active sites to improve atom utilization, which provides a new insight into the design of excellent Fenton-like catalysts with remarkable atom utilization efficiency.

Effects of coexisting nanomaterials on the photodegradation behavior and ecotoxicity of antibiotics in the aqueous

Nanomaterials (NPs) and antibiotics, as two emergent pollutants, forms a complex contamination through their interaction, potentially causing adverse effects on the organism. This study systematically examined the influence of two NPs (CuO NPs and carbon nanotubes, CNTs) on the photodegradation behavior of tetracycline (TC) and their combined toxic effects on Chlorella vulgaris. The results showed that CuO NPs significantly accelerated TC photodegradation compared to CNTs, increasing the TC photodegradation rate constant by187.6%. Electron spin resonance (ESR) indicated that under the coexistence of CuO NPs or CNTs, 1O2、O2•- and •OH were the main active species promoting TC photodegradation. Probe and quenching experiments confirmed the predominant role of O2•- and 1O2 in the presence of CuO NPs and CNTs. Additionally, three possible TC photodegradation pathways were proposed for the coexistence of CuO NPs and CNTs. In the Chlorella vulgaris growth inhibition experiment, the combined toxicity of CuO NPs or CNTs and TC was higher than that of individual substance, indicating significant synergistic effects, especially with the combination of CNTs and TC. This study provides a new perspective on accurately assessing the environmental behaviors and risks when NPs and antibiotics coexist.

FePO4/WB as an efficient heterogeneous Fenton-like catalyst for rapid removal of neonicotinoid insecticides: ROS quantification, mechanistic insights and degradation pathways

Iron-based catalysts for peroxymonosulfate (PMS) activation hold considerable potential in water treatment. However, the slow conversion of Fe(III) to Fe(II) restricts its large-scale application. Herein, an iron phosphate tungsten boride composite (FePO4/WB) was synthesized by a simple hydrothermal method to facilitate the Fe(III)/Fe(II) redox cycle and realize the efficient degradation of neonicotinoid insecticides (NEOs). Based on electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) characterization, scavenging experiments, chemical probe approaches, and quantitative tests, both radicals (HO• and SO4⋅-) and non-radicals (1O2 and Fe(IV)) were produced in the FePO4/WB-PMS system, with relative contributions of 3.02 %, 3.58 %, 6.24 %, and 87.16 % to the degradation of imidacloprid (IMI), respectively. Mechanistic studies revealed that tungsten boride (WB) promoted the reduction of FePO4, and the generated Fe(II) dominantly activated PMS through a two-electron transfer to form Fe(IV), while a minority of Fe(II) engaged in a one-electron transfer with PMS to produce SO4⋅-, HO•, and 1O2. In addition, four degradation pathways of NEOs were proposed by analyzing the byproducts using UPLC-Q-TOF-MS/MS. Besides, seed germination experiments revealed the biotoxicity of NEOs was significantly reduced after degradation via the FePO4/WB-PMS system. Meanwhile, the recycling experiments and continuous flow reactor experiments showed that FePO4/WB exhibited high stability. Overall, this study provided a new perspective on water remediation by Fenton-like reaction. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPLICATION: Neonicotinoids (NEOs) are a type of insecticide used widely around the world. They've been found in many aquatic environments, raising concerns about their possible negative effects on the environment and health. Iron-based catalysts for peroxymonosulfate (PMS) activation hold great promise for water purification. However, the slow conversion of Fe(III) to Fe(II) restricts its large-scale application. Herein, iron phosphate tungsten boride composite (FePO4/WB) was synthesized by a simple hydrothermal method to facilitate the Fe(III)/Fe(II) redox cycle and realize the efficient degradation of NEOs. The excellent stability and reusability provided a great prospect for water remediation.

Comparative study on the activation of peroxymonosulfate and peroxydisulfate by Ar plasma-etching CNTs for sulfamethoxazole degradation: Efficiency and mechanisms

Sulfamethoxazole (SMX), a widely utilized antibiotic, was continually detected in the environment, causing serious risks to aquatic ecology and water security. In this study, carbon nanotubes (CNTs) with abundant defects were developed by argon plasma-etching technology to enhance the activation of persulfate (PS, including peroxymonosulfate (PMS) and peroxydisulfate (PDS)) for SMX degradation while reducing environmental toxicity. Obviously, the increase of ID/IG value from 0.980 to 1.333 indicated that Ar plasma-etching successfully introduced rich defects into CNTs. Of note, Ar-90-CNT, whose Ar plasma-etching time was 90 min with optimum catalytic performance, exhibited a significant discrepancy between PMS activation and PDS activation. Interestingly, though the Ar-90-CNT/PDS system (kobs = 0.0332 min-1) was more efficient in SMX elimination than the Ar-90-CNT/PMS system (kobs = 0.0190 min-1), Ar plasma-etching treatment had no discernible enhancement in the catalytic efficiency of MWCNT for PDS activation. Then the discrepancy on activation mechanism between PMS and PDS was methodically investigated through quenching experiments, electron spin resonance (ESR), chemical probes, electrochemical measurements and theoretical calculations, and the findings unraveled that the created vacancy defects were the ruling active sites for the production of dominated singlet oxygen (1O2) in the Ar-90-CNT/PMS system to degrade SMX, while the electron transfer pathway (ETP), originated from PDS activation by the inherent edge defects, was the central pathway for SMX removal in the Ar-90-CNT/PDS system. Based on the toxicity test of Microcystis aeruginosa, the Ar-90-CNT/PDS system was more effective in alleviating environmental toxicity during SMX degradation. These findings not only provide insights into the discrepancy between PMS activation and PDS activation via carbon-based materials with controlled defects regulated by the plasma-etching strategy, but also efficiently degrade sulfonamide antibiotics and reduce the toxicity of their products.

Fabrication of porous and defect-rich BiOI/MWCNTs photocatalyst by Ar plasma-etching for emerging pollutants degradation

Carbon material modification and defect engineering are indispensable for bolstering the photocatalytic effectiveness of bismuth halide oxide (BiOX). In this study, a novel porous and defect-rich Ar-CB-2 photocatalyst was synthesized for emerging pollutants degradation. Leveraging the interfacial coupling effect of multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs), we expanded the absorption spectrum of BiOI nanosheets and significantly suppressed the recombination of charge carriers. Introducing defects via Argon (Ar) plasma-etching further bolstered the adsorption efficacy and electron transfer properties of photocatalyst. In comparison to the pristine BiOI and CB-2, the Ar-CB-2 photocatalyst demonstrated superior photodegradation efficiency, with the first-order reaction rates for the photodegradation of tetracycline (TC) and bisphenol A (BPA) increasing by 2.83 and 4.53 times, respectively. Further probe experiments revealed that the steady-state concentrations of ·O2- and 1O2 in the Ar-CB-2/light system were enhanced by a factor of 1.67 and 1.28 compared to CB-2/light system. This result confirmed that the porous and defect-rich structure of Ar-CB-2 inhibited electron-hole recombination and boosted photocatalyst-oxygen interaction, swiftly transforming O2 into active oxygen species, thus accelerating their production. Furthermore, the possible degradation pathways for TC and BPA in the Ar-CB-2/light system were predicted. Overall, these findings offered a groundbreaking approach to the development of highly effective photocatalysts, capable of swiftly breaking down emerging pollutants.

Highly efficient targeted adsorption and catalytic degradation of ciprofloxacin by a novel molecularly imprinted bimetallic MOFs catalyst for persulfate activation

Given the presence of emerging pollutants at low concentrations in water bodies, which are inevitably affected by background substances during the removal process. In this study, we synthesized molecularly imprinted catalysts (Cu/Ni-MOFs@MIP) based on bimetallic metal-organic frameworks for the targeted degradation of ciprofloxacin (CIP) in advanced oxidation processes (AOPs). The electrostatic interaction and functional group binding of CIP with specific recognition sites on Cu/Ni-MOFs@MIP produced excellent selective recognition (Qmax was 14.82 mg g-1), which enabled the active radicals to approach and remove the contaminants faster. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) analysis and quenching experiments revealed the coexistence of ∙OH, SO42-, and 1O2, with ∙OH dominating the system. Based on experimental and theoretical calculations, the reaction sites of CIP were predicted and the possible degradation pathways and mechanisms of Cu/Ni-MOFs@MIP/PMS systems were proposed. This study opens up a new platform for the targeted removal of target pollutants in AOPs.

A state-of-art review on the redox activity of persistent free radicals in biochar

Biochar-bound persistent free radicals (biochar-PFRs) attract much attention because they can directly or indirectly mediate the transformation of contaminants in large-scale wastewater treatment processes. Despite this, a comprehensive top-down understanding of the redox activity of biochar-PFRs, particularly consumption and regeneration mechanisms, as well as challenges in redox activity assessment, is still lacking. To tackle this challenge, this review outlines the identification and determination methods of biochar-PFRs, which serve as a prerequisite for assessing the redox activity of biochar-PFRs. Recent developments concerning biochar-PFRs are discussed, with a main emphasis on the reaction mechanisms (both non-free radical and free radical pathways) and their effectiveness in removing contaminants. Importantly, the review delves into the mechanism of biochar-PFRs regeneration, triggered by metal cations, reactive oxygen species, and ultraviolet radiations. Furthermore, this review thoroughly explores the dilemma in appraising the redox activity of biochar-PFRs. Components with unpaired electrons (particular defects and metal ions) interfere with biochar-PFRs signals in electron paramagnetic resonance spectra. Scavengers and extractants of biochar-PFRs also inevitably modify the active ingredients of biochar. Based on these analyses, a practical strategy is proposed to precisely determine the redox activity of biochar-PFRs. Finally, the review concludes by presenting current gaps in knowledge and offering suggestions for future research. This comprehensive examination aims to provide new and significant insights into the redox activity of biochar-PFRs.

Facile synthesis of pyrite FeS2 on carbon spheres for high-efficiency Fenton-like reaction

Designing iron-based catalysts for Fenton-like reactions with peroxymonosulfate (PMS) as oxidants have attracted growing attentions. Herein, pyrite FeS2 supported on carbon spheres (FeS2@C) is synthesized by a facile low-temperature method. The FeS2@C/PMS system can degrade carbamazepine (CBZ) effectively in a wide pH range. Sulfate radicals (SO4·-), hydroxyl radicals (·OH), superoxide radical (O2·-), and singlet oxygen (1O2) are the responsible reactive oxygen species (ROSs) for CBZ degradation. Moreover, in the simulated fixed-bed reactor, the FeS2@C/PMS system can maintain a high CBZ removal ratio of >95% for than 8 h, exhibiting its excellent stability. The outstanding performance of FeS2@C/PMS system is attributed to the presence of carbon spheres and lattice S2-, which together promote the Fe(III)/Fe(II) redox cycle. The FeS2@C is a promising catalyst due to its facile synthesis, low cost, high efficiency, and excellent stability to activate PMS for organics degradation.

Blocking Metal Nanocluster Growth through Ligand Coordination and Subsequent Polymerization: The Case of Ruthenium Nanoclusters as Robust Hydrogen Evolution Electrocatalysts

Metal nanoclusters providing maximized atomic surface exposure offer outstanding hydrogen evolution activities but their stability is compromised as they are prone to grow and agglomerate. Herein, a possibility of blocking metal ion diffusion at the core of cluster growth and aggregation to produce highly active Ru nanoclusters supported on an N, S co-doped carbon matrix (Ru/NSC) is demonstrated. To stabilize the nanocluster dispersion, Ru species are initially coordinated through multiple Ru─N bonds with N-rich 4'-(4-aminophenyl)-2,2:6',2''-terpyridine (TPY-NH2) ligands that are subsequently polymerized using a Schiff base. After the pyrolysis of the hybrid composite, highly dispersed ultrafine Ru nanoclusters with an average size of 1.55 nm are obtained. The optimized Ru/NSC displays minimal overpotentials and high turnover frequencies, as well as robust durability both in alkaline and acidic electrolytes. Besides, outstanding mass activities of 3.85 A mg-1 Ru at 50 mV, i.e., 16 fold higher than 20 wt.% Pt/C are reached. Density functional theory calculations rationalize the outstanding performance by revealing that the low d-band center of Ru/NSC allows the desorption of *H intermediates, thereby enhancing the alkaline HER activity. Overall, this work provides a feasible approach to engineering cost-effective and robust electrocatalysts based on carbon-supported transition metal nanoclusters for future energy technologies.

Singlet oxygen: Properties, generation, detection, and environmental applications

Singlet oxygen (1O2) is molecular oxygen in the excited state with high energy and electrophilic properties. It is widely found in nature, and its important role is gradually extending from chemical syntheses and medical techniques to environmental remediation. However, there exist ambiguities and controversies regarding detection methods, generation pathways, and reaction mechanisms which have hindered the understanding and applications of 1O2. For example, the inaccurate detection of 1O2 has led to an overestimation of its role in pollutant degradation. The difficulty in detecting multiple intermediate species obscures the mechanism of 1O2 production. The applications of 1O2 in environmental remediation have also not been comprehensively commented on. To fill these knowledge gaps, this paper systematically discussed the properties and generation of 1O2, reviewed the state-of-the-art detection methods for 1O2 and long-standing controversies in the catalytic systems. Future opportunities and challenges were also discussed regarding the applications of 1O2 in the degradation of pollutants dissolved in water and volatilized in the atmosphere, the disinfection of drinking water, the gas/solid sterilization, and the self-cleaning of filter membranes. This review is expected to provide a better understanding of 1O2-based advanced oxidation processes and practical applications in the environmental protection of 1O2.

O2 plasma-modified carbon nanotube for sulfamethoxazole degradation via peroxymonosulfate activation: Synergism of radical and non-radical pathways boosting water decontamination and detoxification

Sulfamethoxazole (SMX), a widely used antibiotic, has triggered increasing attention due to its extensive detection in wastewater effluent, causing serious ecological threats. Herein, a carbon-based heterogeneous catalyst was developed by the O2 plasma-etching process, regulating oxygen-containing functional groups (OFGs) and defects of carbon nanotubes (O-CNT) to activate peroxymonosulfate (PMS) for highly efficient SMX abatement. Through adjusting the etching time, the desired active sites (i.e., C=O and defects) could be rationally created. Experiments collectively suggested that the degradation of SMX was owing to the contribution of synergism by radical (•OH (17.3%) and SO4•- (39.3%)) and non-radical pathways (1O2, 43.4%), which originated from PMS catalyzed by C=O and defects. In addition, the possible degradation products and transformation pathways of SMX in the system were inferred by combining the Fukui function calculations and the LC-MS/MS analysis. And the possible degradation pathway was effective in reducing the environmental toxicity of SMX, as evidenced by the T.E.S.T. software and the micronucleus experiment on Vicia faba root tip. Also, the catalytic system exhibited excellent performance for different antibiotics removal, such as amoxicillin (AMX), carbamazepine (CBZ) and isopropylphenazone (PRP). This study is expected to provide an alternative strategy for antibiotics removal in water decontamination and detoxification.

Efficient decontamination of organic pollutants from wastewater by covalent organic framework-based materials

Covalent organic frameworks (COFs), assembling through covalent bonds, are a rising class of porous materials. Nowadays, various COFs are widely applied in organic pollutants decontamination due to the outstanding capabilities of large surface area, multiple functional groups, porous structure, excellent absorptivity, flexible design and so on. This review concentrates on the applications of COFs in different decontamination technologies such as solid-phase extraction, membrane filtration and sieving, adsorption, and catalysis reaction. The factors influencing water chemistry, such as pH, temperature, salt concentration and natural organic matter, are summarized in terms of their impact on decontamination performance and the extraction mechanisms for the diverse analytes. The interaction mechanisms between COFs and organic pollutants were hydrogen bonding, π-π stacking, hydrophilic, hydrophobic, and electrostatic interactions. Furthermore, a perspective on current obstacles and upcoming developments of COFs for organic pollutant removal has been provided. Due to their adaptable and versatile design as well as elaborate and diverse functionalization, COFs possess significant possibility in ameliorating environmental pollution.

Cobalt doped nitrogen-vacancies-rich C3N5 with optimizing local electron distribution boosts peroxymonsulfate activation for tetracycline degradation: Multiple electron transfer mechanisms

Heterogeneous photocatalysis coupled with peroxymonosulfate (PMS) activation is considered as an advanced water purification technology for emerging contaminates degradation. In this study, Cobalt (Co) doped nitrogen-vacancies-rich C3N5 photocatalysts (Co/Nv-C3N5) were designed to activate PMS for tetracycline removal. The photo-chemical oxidation system displayed superior advantage, in which the observed rate constant of tetracycline degradation (0.1488 min-1) was 10.86 and 1.82 times higher than that of photo-oxidation and chemical-oxidation systems. Density functional theory calculation results verified the reconstruction of local charge distribution during PMS activation, indicating Co doping and nitrogen-vacancy engineering not only promoted photoelectrons capture, but also boosted electron transfer from the C-N framework to PMS and the generation of active species. Furthermore, several unique multiple electron transfer mechanisms were found in nonradicals (h+, 1O2 and Co(IV)) pathways. Additionally, three possible tetracycline degradation pathways were proposed and the toxicity of the intermediates was evaluated. Overall, the findings from this study provided a novel strategy for developing high-efficient photocatalyst for the rapid degradation of organic pollutants.

Coating CoFe2O4 shell on Fe particles to increase the utilization efficiencies of Fe and peroxymonosulfate for low-cost Fenton-like reactions

Bimetallic composites (Fe@CoFe2O4) with zero-valent Fe as the core encapsulated by CoFe2O4 layers are synthesized by a coprecipitation-calcination method, which are applied to activate PMS for the degradation of bisphenol A (BPA). Enhanced activity of Fe@CoFe2O4 is achieved with very fast degradation rate (kobs = 0.5737 min-1). In the fixed-bed reactor, the catalyst lifetime (tul) of Fe@CoFe2O4 is determined to be 22 h compared to 11 h of Fe, and the deactivation rate constant (kd) for Fe@CoFe2O4 is 0.0083 mg·L-1·h-1, only ∼1/10 of Fe (0.0731). The XPS results indicate that the core-shell structure of Fe@CoFe2O4 could promote the redox cycles of Co3+/Co2+ and Fe3+/Fe2+. It is proved that the coating of CoFe2O4 shell on Fe0 can protect the Fe0 core from being oxidized by PMS to form passivation layer. The electrons of Fe0 can therefore be used effectively for activating PMS to produce ROSs via the CoFe2O4 shell. This modification method of Fe0 would decrease the cost of PMS based wastewater remediation greatly, thus should have great potential on an industrial scale.

The debatable role of singlet oxygen in persulfate-based advanced oxidation processes

Singlet oxygen (¹O₂) attracts much attention in persulfate-based advanced oxidation processes (PS-AOPs), because of its wide pH tolerance and high selectivity toward electron-rich organics. However, there are conflicts about the ¹O₂ role in PS-AOPs on several aspects, including the formation of different key reactive oxygen species (ROS) at similar active sites, pH dependence, broad-spectrum activity, and selectivity in the elimination of organic pollutants. To a large degree, these conflicts root in the drawbacks of the methods to identify and evaluate the role of ¹O₂. For example, the quenchers of ¹O₂ have high reactivity to other ROS and persulfate as well. In addition, electron transfer process (ETP) also selectively oxidizes organics, having a misleading effect on the identification of ¹O₂. Therefore, in this review, we summarized and discussed some basic properties of ¹O₂, the debatable role of ¹O₂ in PS-AOPs on multiple aspects, and the methods and their drawbacks to identify and evaluate the role of ¹O₂. On the whole, this review aims to better understand the role of ¹O₂ in PS-AOPs and further help with its reasonable utilization.