Challenges and emerging trends in liquid chromatography-based analyses of mRNA pharmaceuticals

Characterization of intact mRNA-based therapeutics by charge detection mass spectrometry and mass photometry

The impressive success of mRNA-based vaccines to combat COVID-19 has encouraged biopharmaceutical companies to invest in broader applications of alike vaccines for various diseases. Analytical approaches must keep pace to support this surge in the development of mRNA-based therapies. Intact mass analysis of mid- to large mRNA molecules (>1,000 nt) poses significant analytical challenges due to mRNA size, heterogeneity, and instability. Here, we demonstrate how single-particle Orbitrap-based charge detection mass spectrometry (CDMS) and mass photometry (MP) approaches can rapidly measure the mass of various intact high-mass capped mRNAs, up to 9,400 nt (∼3 MDa) in size. While ensemble MS yielded approximate masses for mRNAs <2,000 nt, it failed to provide information on samples of longer sequences. The drawbacks of ensemble MS could be avoided by recording individual ions. Low-charge mRNA components showed unstable ion behavior, hampering initial CDMS measurements, whereas high-charge populations offered better signal-to-noise and reduced charge uncertainty, with drastically improved mass accuracy. Lastly, in-solution MP enabled the measurement of mRNAs with high accuracy, while revealing low amounts of mRNA fragments and dimers that are sometimes overlooked in CDMS. Overall, CDMS and MP provide complementary methods that enable the study of large heterogeneous mRNA without requiring prior digestion or online separation.

DNAzyme approach for simultaneous mRNA cap and poly(A) tail length analysis: A one-step method to multiple quality attributes

The dynamic landscape of mRNA technology highlights the need for innovative quality control (QC) strategies. In this study, we described an efficient one-step digestion approach for concurrent generation of 5'- and 3'-end fragments, enabling simultaneous mRNA capping and poly(A) tail analysis. Tailored 10-23-type DNAzymes, designed from 5'- and 3'-Untranslated Regions (UTRs), selectively cleaved mRNA to release both the 5'-Capped or uncapped short fragments and 3'-Poly(A) tail cleavage products. Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) and ion pair reversed-phase liquid chromatography (IP-RP LC) analyses confirmed the production of 5'- and 3'-cleavage fragments in a single-step reaction, and LC-mass spectrometry (LC MS) validated these findings. The DNAzyme-mediated cleavage offers notable advantages over other assays for mRNA cap and tail characterization. Direct and simultaneous analysis of both capping efficiency and poly(A) tail length post-cleavage by DNAzymes, without additional purification steps and costly MS analysis, markedly streamlines the sample preparation and analysis process, making it highly suitable for QC testing.

Systematic comparison of wide pore size exclusion chromatography columns for the characterization of gene therapy products

A new generation of wide pore SEC columns was systematically evaluated for the determination of size variants for mRNAs ranging from 1000 to 5000 nucleotides and for multiple recombinant adeno-associated viruses (rAAVs) serotypes. Among the six SEC columns (450 to 700 Å) employed for rAAV analysis, the DNACore AAV-SEC column shows the highest efficiency (11,000 plates), probably due to its monodisperse 3 µm silica particles, while the SRT SEC-500 column showed the lowest efficiency (< 1000 plates) attributed to its 5 µm particle packing. Optimal selectivity for rAAVs was observed with columns having larger pore sizes (550 - 700 Å). However, the final resolution for different rAAV serotypes was highly sample-dependent, and no single column consistently provided the best separation of size variants. Additionally, the six columns were suitable to study the degradation trends of rAAVs subjected to accelerated stress conditions. Among the five SEC columns (700 - 1000 Å) evaluated for mRNA analysis, the Biozen dSEC-7 LC column (700 Å) column systematically achieved the highest efficiency, and was particularly well suited for analyzing small mRNA (∼ 1000 nts). However, columns with larger pore sizes such as AdvanceBio SEC 1000A were more appropriate for larger mRNA (> 1000 nt). Despite these findings, the separation of low molecular weight species (LMWS) and high molecular weight species (HMWS) of mRNA remains limited across all tested columns, making integration challenging and the quantification of LMWS and HMWS less accurate. However, comparable (but not strictly identical) quantitative performance was obtained among the columns, with only a few exceptions.

Proof of Concept Application of Hydrophilic Interaction Chromatography for Direct Online Disruption of Lipid Nanoparticles, Intact mRNA Analysis, and Measure of Encapsulation Efficiency

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) are a key platform for delivering mRNA vaccines and therapeutics with numerous innovative drugs under development. However, characterizing these complex and unstable products remains challenging. Developing fast, reliable methods to assess critical quality attributes (CQAs) of the mRNA component is crucial for ensuring the safety and efficacy of these medicines. Currently, evaluating key CQAs, such as mRNA integrity and encapsulation efficiency, often involves a labor-intensive manual extraction protocol, which requires LNP disruption prior to analysis. However, these additional offline steps contribute to mRNA degradation and measurement uncertainties, highlighting the urgent need for rapid and effective methods capable of performing an online LNP disruption. Hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) might offer a promising solution to address this need. Due to the presence of high concentrations of organic solvent and the possibility to work at elevated temperatures, HILIC might enable on-column disruption of LNPs while preserving the full integrity of the mRNA payload, facilitating a streamlined characterization process. To evaluate this, we developed two proof of concept HILIC methods. The first one disrupts LNPs and retains the mRNA payload using a high percentage of organic solvent and elevated temperatures. The second one, relying on milder conditions, retains only the unencapsulated mRNA, which can be used to evaluate the encapsulation efficiency. Both methods were used on Comirnaty and Spikevax vaccines and on Sanofi's in-development mRNA product as model samples. Our preliminary findings suggest that HILIC holds potential for online LNP disruption, mRNA integrity assessment, and encapsulation efficiency analysis. They also highlight the limitations of small-pore-sized columns currently available on the market.

A platform method for simultaneous quantification of lipid and nucleic acid components in lipid nanoparticles

Nucleic acid-based medicines have achieved significant advancements in recent years, with lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) being a pivotal platform for their delivery. However, the complexity of LNP presents significant challenges, requiring analytical methods to identify and quantify individual components to guide formulation development and ensure quality and safety. Current approaches often perform nucleic acid and lipid analysis separately and focus on a single type of formulation, highlighting the need for a simple platform method that can be applied to diverse formulations. We present a platform ion-pair reversed-phase HPLC method with UV and charged aerosol detection (CAD) to simultaneously separate and quantify lipid and nucleic acid components in LNPs. The method separated and quantified 12 lipid species and three types of nucleic acids (antisense oligonucleotide, single-guide RNA, and mRNA), covering a broad range of therapeutic cargoes. Notably, this can be achieved for the first time by one HPLC run with one-step facile sample preparation. Specifically, we used a simple buffer containing Triton and heparin to enable the single-step, simultaneous extraction of both nucleic acid and lipid components from LNPs, achieving quantification recoveries of 90-110 %. We further applied this method and addressed process and quality control challenges of LNPs, including the recovery rate of individual LNP components after purification and simultaneous quantification of co-loaded, different nucleic acid species for potential gene editing applications. This new platform method offers a robust and widely applicable tool to assess the quality of lipid-based nucleic acid therapies.

Selected new approaches and future perspectives in liquid chromatography for the analysis of emerging modalities

Emerging biopharmaceutical modalities, such as genetic medicines and RNA therapies, offer transformative potential for treating previously intractable diseases. However, these complex drugs present unique analytical challenges due to their intricate structures, sophisticated manufacturing processes, and modality-specific product quality attributes. Liquid chromatography (LC) has emerged as a versatile tool for addressing these challenges, enabling precise characterization and quality control strategies. This review highlights recent advancements in LC technologies, including low-adsorption hardware, ultra-wide pore size exclusion chromatography (SEC) columns, and innovative separation modes such as slalom chromatography and pressure-enhanced liquid chromatography (PELC). These developments tackle issues such as non-specific adsorption, carryover, and inadequate selectivity while improving resolution and robustness for large biomolecules like mRNA, adeno-associated viruses (AAVs), and lipid nanoparticles (LNPs). Novel approaches, such as tandem SEC systems, gradient SEC columns, and dual stationary phase gradients, further expand the scope of LC techniques by enhancing separations for diverse analyte sizes and complexities. Additionally, practical innovations like bracketed injection methods and new enzymatic tools for oligo-mapping improve reproducibility, efficiency, and confidence in RNA sequence analysis. These advancements not only address current analytical limitations but also pave the way for regulatory-compliant approaches, which will support the broader adoption of LC in both discovery and quality control settings. As the field continues to evolve, these innovations are poised to play a pivotal role in ensuring the safety, efficacy, and consistency of next-generation therapeutics.

Characterisation and analysis of mRNA critical quality attributes using liquid chromatography based methods

mRNA technology has been successfully deployed to rapidly develop and mass-manufacture vaccines. Beyond vaccines, RNA-based therapeutics have potential for treatments for infectious diseases, cancer, metabolic disorders, cardiovascular conditions and autoimmune diseases. mRNA based vaccines and therapeutics work by translating exogenous mRNA into the target protein. Analytical methods for mRNA characterisation, lot release and stability testing of mRNA drug substance and drug product must be developed and performed to monitor critical quality attributes (CQAs). mRNA is a highly polar molecule due to its extensive negatively charged phosphodiester backbone. Its single stranded nature forms dynamic alternative secondary structures that can generate potential sample heterogeneity, creating challenges for the analysis and characterisation of this large biomolecule. In this review, we describe current analytical methods, focussing on high performance liquid chromatography in conjunction with both UV detection and mass spectrometry for the analysis and characterisation of mRNA. In particular, we describe recent developments covering a wide range of methods centred on liquid chromatography for the analysis of important CQAs including mRNA identity, mRNA integrity, 5' capping efficiency and poly(A) tail length and heterogeneity.

Mass photometry as a fast, facile characterization tool for direct measurement of mRNA length

Oligonucleotide integrity is a critical quality attribute for many new therapeutic modalities. Current assays often measure attributes such as length using capillary electrophoresis or liquid chromatography. The length is then corroborated with sequencing data to ensure oligonucleotide quality. An orthogonal measure to these classical separations is to measure intact mass, which traditional mass spectrometry cannot. Herein, we report the use of mass photometry to directly measure RNA length using RNA ladders as a calibrant.

Retention mechanism in slalom chromatography: Perspectives on the characterization of large DNA and RNA biopolymers in cell and gene therapy

Significant progress has been made in the last two decades in producing small (<2μm), high-purity, and low-adsorption particles, columns and system hardware, for ultra-high pressure liquid chromatography (UHPLC). Simultaneously, the recent rapid expansion of cell and gene therapies for treating diseases necessitates novel analytical technologies for analyzing large (>2 kbp) plasmid double-stranded (ds) DNA (which encodes for the in vitro transcription (IVT) of single-stranded (ss) mRNA therapeutics) and dsRNAs (related to IVT production impurities) biopolymers. In this context, slalom chromatography (SC), a retention mode co-discovered in 1988, is being revitalized using the most advanced column technologies for improved determination of the critical quality attributes (CQAs) of such new therapeutics. In this review, we first recall non-exhaustively the main currently available analytical techniques (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), agarose gel electrophoresis (AGE), pulse field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), capillary gel electrophoresis (CGE), mass photometry (MP), anion-exchange chromatography (AEX), ion-pairing reversed-phase liquid chromatography (IP-RPLC), hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC), size-exclusion chromatography (SEC), hydrodynamic chromatography (HDC), highly converging flow ultra-filtration (HCF-UF), asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation (AF4), mass spectrometry (MS), and atomic force microscopy (AFM)) for analyzing mixtures containing large nucleic acid biopolymers, while assessing their strengths and weaknesses. We then focus comprehensively on the SC technique, report on its past applications since its birth, and review in detail the history and evolution of the proposed retention mechanisms accounting for the observations made in SC. This includes and emphasizes the latest physico-chemical insights (shear rates in packed HPLC columns, entropic elasticity and relaxation of dsDNA, dsRNA, and mRNA biopolymers) governing the retention behavior of such biopolymers in SC. Finally, based on the recent advancements in understanding the fundamentals of retention in SC, we provide some perspectives and recent proof-of-concept for the analytical characterization by SC of large dsDNAs (plasmid digests, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) verification), the separation of supercoiled/circular and linear dsDNAs (plasmid linearization), the isolation and quantification of large dsRNAs impurities present in mRNA samples produced by IVT, and the differentiation between dsRNA conformers.

High-Throughput Quantification and Characterization of Dual Payload mRNA/LNP Cargo via Deformulating Size Exclusion and Ion Pairing Reversed Phase Assays

Therapeutic drugs and multivalent vaccines based on the delivery of mRNA via lipid nanoparticle (LNP) technologies are expected to dominate the biopharmaceutical industry landscape in the coming years. Many of these innovative therapies include several nucleic acid components (e.g., nuclease mRNA and guide RNA) posing unique analytical challenges when monitoring the quantity and quality of each individual payload substance in the formulated LNP. Current methods were optimized for single payload analysis and often lack resolving power needed to investigate nucleic acid mixtures. Ion pairing reversed phase (IP-RP) and size exclusion chromatography (SEC) are increasingly being used to characterize nucleic acids. Here, we studied their application for payload quantification in formulated LNP drug-like products. Using a detergent to disrupt the LNPs, the liberated payloads can be separated on an octadecyl RP column using a fast gradient. Reproducible results were obtained as lipids, and surfactants were efficiently eluted using a high organic solvent wash protocol. Alternatively, we also established an online SEC disruption analysis of the mRNA/LNPs wherein an alcohol and detergent containing a mobile phase was applied. Such conditions universally deformulated all tested LNP samples, indicating that a 5 min-long SEC separation can be used as a high-throughput platform method. In both approaches, the measurements facilitate a multiattribute analysis. Apart from quantitation, the characterization of specific impurities is achieved: IP-RP reveals mRNA-lipid adducts, while SEC informs on size variants, which in turn reduces a laboratory's analytical workload. These easy-to-adopt LC-based assays are expected to fortify the analytical toolbox for emerging gene therapeutics.

Ion exchange chromatography of biotherapeutics: Fundamental principles and advanced approaches

Ion exchange chromatography (IEX) is an important analytical technique for the characterization of biotechnology-derived products, such as monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) and more recently, cell and gene therapy products such as messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) and adeno-associated viruses (AAVs). This review paper first outlines the basic principles and separation mechanisms of IEX for charge variant separation of biotherapeutics, and examines the different elution modes based on salt or pH gradients. It then highlights several recent trends when applying IEX for the characterization of biotechnology-derived products, including: i) the effective use of pH gradients, ii) the improvement of selectivity by using organic solvents in the mobile phase, multi-step gradients, or by combining ion pairing and ion exchange, and iii) the increase in analytical throughput using ultra-short columns or automated screening of conditions. The review also discusses the incorporation of IEX into multidimensional liquid chromatography setups, integrating it with other chromatographic dimensions for the analysis of complex biotherapeutic products. It also covers the coupling of IEX with mass spectrometry (MS), ion mobility spectrometry (IMS), and multi-angle light scattering (MALS) to identify the various species contained in complex biotherapeutic samples. In conclusion, IEX is considered today as an essential technique in the analytical toolbox for the characterization and quality control of biotechnology-derived products. It offers a unique separation mechanism and can be coupled with highly informative detectors, such as MS and MALS.

Roadmap to discovery and early development of an mRNA loaded LNP formulation for liver therapeutic genome editing

INTRODUCTION

mRNA therapeutics were a niche area in drug development before COVID vaccines. They are now used in vaccine development, for non-viral therapeutic genome editing, in vivo chimeric antigen receptor T (CAR T) cell therapies and protein replacement.  mRNA is large, charged, and easily degraded by nucleases. It cannot get into cells, escape the endosome, and be translated to a disease-modifying protein without a delivery system such as lipid nanoparticles (LNPs).

AREAS COVERED

This article covers how to design, select, and develop an LNP for therapeutic genome editing in the liver. The roadmap is divided into selecting the right LNP for discovery via a design, make, test, and analyze cycle (DMTA). The design elements are focused on ionizable lipids in a 4-component LNP, and insights are provided for how to set an in vitro and in vivo testing strategy. The second section focuses on transforming the LNP into a clinical drug product and covers formulation, analytical development, and process optimization, with brief notes on supply and regulator strategies.

EXPERT OPINION

The perspective discusses the impact that academic-industry collaborations can have on developing new medicines for therapeutic genome editing in the liver. From the cited collaborations an enhanced understanding of intracellular trafficking, notably endosomal escape, and the internal structure of LNPs were attained and are deemed key to designing effective and safe LNPs. The knowledge gained will also enable additional assays and structural activity relationships, which would lead to the design of the next-generation delivery systems for nucleic acid therapies.

Evaluation of ion pairing reversed-phase liquid chromatography for the separation of large RNA molecules

The rapid development of mRNA-based therapeutics, especially post-COVID-19, has necessitated the precise characterization of mRNA quality attributes, including sequence integrity. Ion-pairing reversed-phase liquid chromatography (IP-RPLC) has been widely accepted as a reference method for the characterization of small oligonucleotides. Some studies have already investigated the use of IP-RPLC for RNA, but no systematic approach has been developed to assess the impact of ion-pairing agents (IPAs) on the separation of large RNA molecules. This study addresses this gap by investigating the potential of IP-RPLC for the separation and characterization of large RNA molecules, with a specific focus on optimizing the use of IPAs to enhance retention and selectivity. Thirteen different IPAs, varying in hydrophobicity, were systematically tested using a supermacroporous polymeric (divinylbenzene) column with a very broad pore size range under various conditions, including different temperatures, pH, and IPA concentrations. The results demonstrate that moderately hydrophobic IPAs provide superior resolution for RNA species up to 6000 nucleotides. An optimized combination of 100 mM butylammonium acetate and 50 mM tripropylammonium acetate achieved the best overall separation, significantly improving resolution by 35% compared to individual IPAs. The study also identifies optimal conditions for RNA separation, including a mobile phase pH of 7.0, acetonitrile as the organic solvent, and a column temperature of 65 °C. In a second step, a solution to increase the retention of small nucleotides and thereby separate nucleic acids ranging from 1 to 6000 nucleotides allowing to characterize IVT-mRNA differing in length and study their integrity and fragmentation or monitor the presence of in-process impurities (nucleotides) was investigated by combining two different LC columns. These findings enhance the analytical toolbox for evaluating the critical quality attributes of RNA, supporting the development of reliable and efficient RNA-based therapeutics.

Oligonucleotide therapeutics in sports? An antidoping perspective

Within the last two decades, the European Medicines Agency and the US Food and Drug Administration have approved several gene therapies. One category is oligonucleotide therapeutics, which allow for the regulation of the expression of target genes. Besides already approved therapeutics, there are several preclinical and clinical trials ongoing. The World Anti-Doping Agency prohibits the use of "nucleic acids or nucleic acid analogs that may alter genome sequences and/or alter gene expression by any mechanism" as a nonspecified method at all times. Hence, the administration of nucleic acids or analogs by athletes would cause an Anti-Doping Rule Violation. Herein, we discuss types of oligonucleotide therapeutics, their potential to be misused in sports, and considerations to sample preparation and mass spectrometric approaches with regard to antidoping analysis.

Exploring the Impact of In Vitro-Transcribed mRNA Impurities on Cellular Responses

Advances in mRNA technology have enabled mRNA-based therapies to enter a new era of medicine. Such therapies benefit from a single, standardized in vitro transcription (IVT) manufacturing process applicable to a wide range of targets. This process includes several downstream purification steps, which aim to eliminate impurities that potentially affect safety and efficacy. However, it is not fully understood which impurities are the most critical; hence, some efforts are still needed to establish the correlation between RNA impurities and their role in limiting therapeutic efficacy. To study this relationship, we produced in vitro-transcribed mRNAs using several bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerases, including one wild-type and four engineered variants. Important attributes of the mRNA such as integrity, purity, and functional activity were then measured using advanced physicochemical and cellular assays. For impurities including abortive transcripts, mRNAs containing partial poly(A) tails, and double-stranded (ds)RNA byproducts, structure-function relationships have been established by tracking cellular responses (i.e., protein expression, reactogenicity) in multiple cell models. By varying the T7 RNA polymerase, different levels of sense-antisense dsRNA byproducts were measured by mass photometry, contributing directly to immunological reactogenicity in bone marrow-derived dendritic cells. T7 RNA polymerase differences with regard to short (<20 nucleotides) 3'-loopback dsRNA byproducts were also further investigated using native mass spectrometry by precisely resolving these impurities at the nucleotide level. Overall, this study highlights the importance of developing sensitive and advanced analytical methods to characterize IVT mRNA impurities and understand their interaction with cellular machinery in order to ensure quality control of RNA-based therapies.

Anion exchange-HPLC method for evaluating the encapsulation efficiency of mRNA-loaded lipid nanoparticles using analytical quality by design

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) are emerging nucleic acid delivery systems in the development of mRNA therapeutics such as the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 vaccines. However, a suitable analytical method for evaluating the encapsulation efficiency (EE) of the LNPs is required to ensure drug efficacy, as current analytical methods exhibit throughput issues and require long analysis times. Hence, we developed and validated an anion-exchange HPLC method using Analytical Quality by Design. Three critical method parameters (CMPs) were identified using risk assessment and Design of Experiments: column temperature, flow rate, and sodium perchlorate concentration. The CMPs were optimized using Face-Centered Central Composite Design. The discriminating power of the optimized HPLC method and RiboGreen assay was comparable. The main advantage of this method is that LNPs can be directly injected into the HPLC system without bursting the LNPs loaded with encapsulated poly(A). The optimized HPLC method was validated as robust, high-throughput, and sufficiently sensitive according to the ICH Q2 guidelines. We believe our findings could promote efficient LNPs-based drug development.

Development of an advanced separation and characterization platform for mRNA and lipid nanoparticles using multi-detector asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation

In recent years, the use of lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) for delivery of messenger RNA (mRNA)-based therapies has gained substantial attention in the field of drug development. In such an application, multiple LNP attributes have to be carefully characterized to ensure product safety and quality, whereas accurate and efficient characterization of these complex mRNA-LNP formulations remains a challenging endeavor. Here, we present the development and application of an online separation and characterization platform designed for the isolation and in-depth analysis of mRNAs and mRNA-loaded LNPs. Our asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation with a multi-detector (MD-AF4) method has demonstrated exceptional resolution between mRNA-LNPs and mRNAs, delivering excellent recoveries (over 70%) for both analytes and exceptional repeatability. Notably, this platform allows for comprehensive and multi-attribute LNP characterization, including online particle sizing, morphology characterization, and determination of encapsulation efficiency, all within a single injection. Furthermore, real-time online sizing by synchronizing multi-angle light scattering (MALS) and dynamic light scattering (DLS) presented higher resolution over traditional batch-mode DLS, particularly in differentiating heterogeneous samples with a low abundance of large-sized particles. Additionally, our method proves to be a valuable tool for monitoring LNP stability under varying stress conditions. Our work introduces a robust and versatile analytical platform using MD-AF4 that not only efficiently provides multi-attribute characterizations of mRNA-LNPs but also holds promise in advancing studies related to formulation screening, quality control, and stability assessment in the evolving field of nanoparticle delivery systems for mRNAs.

Stability indicating ion-pair reversed-phase liquid chromatography method for modified mRNA

Modified messenger RNA (mRNA) represents a rapidly emerging class of therapeutic drug product. Development of robust stability indicating methods for control of product quality are therefore critical to support successful pharmaceutical development. This paper presents an ion-pair reversed-phase liquid chromatography (IP-RPLC) method to characterise modified mRNA exposed to a wide set of stress-inducing conditions, relevant for pharmaceutical development of an mRNA drug product. The optimised method could be used for separation and analysis of large RNA, sized up to 1000 nucleotides. Column temperature, mobile phase flow rate and ion-pair selection were each studied and optimised. Baseline separations of the model RNA ladder sample were achieved using all examined ion-pairing agents. We established that the optimised method, using 100 mM Triethylamine, enabled the highest resolution separation for the largest fragments in the RNA ladder (750/1000 nucleotides), in addition to the highest overall resolution for the selected modified mRNA compound (eGFP mRNA, 996 nucleotides). The stability indicating power of the method was demonstrated by analysing the modified eGFP mRNA, upon direct exposure to heat, hydrolytic conditions and treatment with ribonucleases. Our results showed that the formed degradation products, which appeared as shorter RNA fragments in front of the main peak, could be well monitored, using the optimised method, and the relative stability of the mRNA under the various stressed conditions could be assessed.

Optimizing Messenger RNA Analysis Using Ultra-Wide Pore Size Exclusion Chromatography Columns

Biopharmaceutical products, in particular messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA), have the potential to dramatically improve the quality of life for patients suffering from respiratory and infectious diseases, rare genetic disorders, and cancer. However, the quality and safety of such products are particularly critical for patients and require close scrutiny. Key product-related impurities, such as fragments and aggregates, among others, can significantly reduce the efficacy of mRNA therapies. In the present work, the possibilities offered by size exclusion chromatography (SEC) for the characterization of mRNA samples were explored using state-of-the-art ultra-wide pore columns with average pore diameters of 1000 and 2500 Å. Our investigation shows that a column with 1000 Å pores proved to be optimal for the analysis of mRNA products, whatever the size between 500 and 5000 nucleotides (nt). We also studied the influence of mobile phase composition and found that the addition of 10 mM magnesium chloride (MgCl2) can be beneficial in improving the resolution and recovery of large size variants for some mRNA samples. We demonstrate that caution should be exercised when increasing column length or decreasing the flow rate. While these adjustments slightly improve resolution, they also lead to an apparent increase in the amount of low-molecular-weight species (LMWS) and monomer peak tailing, which can be attributed to the prolonged residence time inside the column. Finally, our optimal SEC method has been successfully applied to a wide range of mRNA products, ranging from 1000 to 4500 nt in length, as well as mRNA from different suppliers and stressed/unstressed samples.

Size exclusion chromatography of biopharmaceutical products: From current practices for proteins to emerging trends for viral vectors, nucleic acids and lipid nanoparticles

The 21st century has been particularly productive for the biopharmaceutical industry, with the introduction of several classes of innovative therapeutics, such as monoclonal antibodies and related compounds, gene therapy products, and RNA-based modalities. All these new molecules are susceptible to aggregation and fragmentation, which necessitates a size variant analysis for their comprehensive characterization. Size exclusion chromatography (SEC) is one of the reference techniques that can be applied. The analytical techniques for mAbs are now well established and some of them are now emerging for the newer modalities. In this context, the objective of this review article is: i) to provide a short historical background on SEC, ii) to suggest some clear guidelines on the selection of packing material and mobile phase for successful method development in modern SEC; and iii) to highlight recent advances in SEC, such as the use of narrow-bore and micro-bore columns, ultra-wide pore columns, and low-adsorption column hardware. Some important innovations, such as recycling SEC, the coupling of SEC with mass spectrometry, and the use of alternative detectors such as charge detection mass spectrometry and mass photometry are also described. In addition, this review discusses the use of SEC in multidimensional setups and shows some of the most recent advances at the preparative scale. In the third part of the article, the possibility of SEC for the characterization of new modalities is also reviewed. The final objective of this review is to provide a clear summary of opportunities and limitations of SEC for the analysis of different biopharmaceutical products.

Evaluation of size-exclusion chromatography, multi-angle light scattering detection and mass photometry for the characterization of mRNA

The recent approval of messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) as vaccine to combat the COVID-19 pandemic has been a scientific turning point. Today, the applicability of mRNA is being demonstrated beyond infectious diseases, for example in cancer immunotherapy, protein replacement therapy and gene editing. mRNA is produced by in vitro transcription (IVT) from a linear DNA template and modified at the 3' and 5' ends to improve translational efficiency and stability. Co-existing impurities such as RNA fragments and double-stranded RNA (dsRNA), amongst others, can drastically impact mRNA quality and efficacy. In this study, size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) is evaluated for the characterization of IVT-mRNA. The effect of mobile phase composition (ionic strength and organic modifier), pH, column temperature and pore size (300 Å, 1000 Å, and 2000 Å) on the separation performance and structural integrity of IVT-mRNA varying in size is described. Non-replicating, self-amplifying (saRNA), temperature degraded, and ribonuclease (RNase) digested mRNA, the latter to characterize the 3' poly(A) tail, were included in the study. Beyond ultraviolet (UV) detection, refractive index (RI) and multi-angle light scattering (MALS) detection were implemented to accurately determine molecular weight (MW) of mRNA. Finally, mass photometry is introduced as a complementary methodology to study mRNA under native conditions.

Monitoring stability indicating impurities and aldehyde content in lipid nanoparticle raw material and formulated drugs

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) are designed to protect and transport sensitive payloads or active pharmaceutical ingredients as part of new therapeutic modalities. As a multi-component particle, a high degree of quality control is necessary to ensure raw materials are free of critical impurities that could adversely impact the drug product. In this study, we demonstrate a reversed phase liquid chromatography method hyphenated with a single quadrupole mass spectrometer (RPLC-MS) as an alternative platform to methods that incorporate evaporative light scattering or charged aerosol detectors in the detection and quantitation of critical impurities associated with LNPs. The proposed RPLC-MS method offers an increase of up to 2 orders of magnitude in dynamic range and 3 orders of magnitude in sensitivity in the analysis of impurities associated with LNPs compared to conventional detectors. Access to complementary mass data enabled the detection and identification of stability indicating impurities as part of stress studies carried out on an ionizable lipid. In addition to confirmation of peak identity, complementary mass data was also used to assess residual aldehydes in raw material and formulated LNPs in accordance with regulatory guidance. Following derivatization using 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine, aldehyde content in the ionizable lipid raw material was determined to exceed the reporting threshold of 0.05% in 30% of the test cases. The experimental findings observed in this study demonstrate the utility of the proposed RPLC-MS method in the identification and monitoring of stability-indicating attributes associated with LNPs as part of current Good Manufacturing Practices for improved consumer safety in drug products.

Lipid Nanoparticle (LNP) Delivery Carrier-Assisted Targeted Controlled Release mRNA Vaccines in Tumor Immunity

In recent years, lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) have attracted extensive attention in tumor immunotherapy. Targeting immune cells in cancer therapy has become a strategy of great research interest. mRNA vaccines are a potential choice for tumor immunotherapy, due to their ability to directly encode antigen proteins and stimulate a strong immune response. However, the mode of delivery and lack of stability of mRNA are key issues limiting its application. LNPs are an excellent mRNA delivery carrier, and their structural stability and biocompatibility make them an effective means for delivering mRNA to specific targets. This study summarizes the research progress in LNP delivery carrier-assisted targeted controlled release mRNA vaccines in tumor immunity. The role of LNPs in improving mRNA stability, immunogenicity, and targeting is discussed. This review aims to systematically summarize the latest research progress in LNP delivery carrier-assisted targeted controlled release mRNA vaccines in tumor immunity to provide new ideas and strategies for tumor immunotherapy, as well as to provide more effective treatment plans for patients.

Sample transformation in online separations: how chemical conversion advances analytical technology

While the advent of modern analytical technology has allowed scientists to determine the complexity of mixtures, it also spurred the demand to understand these sophisticated mixtures better. Chemical transformation can be used to provide insights into properties of complex samples such as degradation pathways or molecular heterogeneity that are otherwise unaccessible. In this article, we explore how sample transformation is exploited across different application fields to empower analytical methods. Transformation mechanisms include molecular-weight reduction, controlled degradation, and derivatization. Both offline and online transformation methods have been explored. The covered studies show that sample transformation facilitates faster reactions (e.g. several hours to minutes), reduces sample complexity, unlocks new sample dimensions (e.g. functional groups), provides correlations between multiple sample dimensions, and improves detectability. The article highlights the state-of-the-art and future prospects, focusing in particular on the characterization of protein and nucleic-acid therapeutics, nanoparticles, synthetic polymers, and small molecules.

Electrophoretic characterization of LNP/AAV-encapsulated nucleic acids: Strengths and weaknesses

The use of nucleic acids (NAs) has revolutionized medical approaches and ushered in a new era of combating various diseases. Accordingly, there is an increasing demand for accurate identification, localization, quantification, and characterization of NAs encapsulated in nonviral or viral vectors. The vast spectrum of molecular dimensions and intra- and intermolecular interactions presents a formidable obstacle for NA analytical development. Typically, the comprehensive analysis of encapsulated NAs, free NAs, and their spatial distribution poses a challenge that is seldom tackled in its complete complexity. The identification of appropriate physicochemical methodologies for large nonencapsulated or encapsulated NAs is particularly intricate and necessitates an evaluation of the analytical outcomes and their appropriateness in addressing critical quality attributes. In this work, we examine the analytics of non-encapsulated or encapsulated large NAs (>500 nucleotides) utilizing capillary electrophoresis (CE) and liquid chromatography (LC) methodologies such as free zone CE, gel CE, affinity CE, and ion pair high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). These methodologies create a complete picture of the NA's critical quality attributes, including quantity, identity, purity, and content ratio.

Using Peptide Nucleic Acid Hybridization Probes for Qualitative and Quantitative Analysis of Nucleic Acid Therapeutics by Capillary Electrophoresis

The space of advanced therapeutic modalities is currently evolving in rapid pace necessitating continuous improvement of analytical quality control methods. In order to evaluate the identity of nucleic acid species in gene therapy products, we propose a capillary electrophoresis-based gel free hybridization assay in which fluorescently labeled peptide nucleic acids (PNAs) are applied as affinity probes. PNAs are engineered organic polymers that share the base pairing properties with DNA and RNA but have an uncharged peptide backbone. In the present study, we conduct various proof-of-concept studies to identify the potential of PNA probes for advanced analytical characterization of novel therapeutic modalities like oligonucleotides, plasmids, mRNA, and DNA released by recombinant adeno-associated virus. For single-stranded nucleic acids up to 1000 nucleotides, the method is an excellent choice that proved to be highly specific by detecting DNA traces in complex samples, while having a limit of quantification in the picomolar range when multiple probes are used. For double-stranded samples, only fragments that are similar in size to the probe could be quantified. This limitation can be circumvented when target DNA is digested and multiple probes are used opening an alternative to quantitative PCR.