Melanomas and melanoma cell lines do not express HLA-G, and the expression cannot be induced by gammaIFN treatment

Harnessing the potential of HLA-G in cancer therapy: advances, challenges, and prospects

Immune checkpoint blockades have been prized in circumventing and ablating the impediments posed by immunosuppressive receptors, reaching an exciting juncture to be an innovator in anticancer therapy beyond traditional therapeutics. Thus far, approved immune checkpoint blockades have principally targeted PD-1/PD-L1 and CTLA-4 with exciting success in a plethora of tumors and yet are still trapped in dilemmas of limited response rates and adverse effects. Hence, unveiling new immunotherapeutic targets has aroused immense scientific interest in the hope of expanding the clinical application of immune checkpoint blockades to scale new heights. Human leukocyte antigen-G (HLA-G), a non-classical major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecule, is enriched on various malignant cells and is involved in the hindrance of immune effector cells and the facilitation of immunosuppressive cells. HLA-G stands out as a crucial next-generation immune checkpoint showing great promise for the benefit of cancer patients. Here, we provide an overview of the current understanding of the expression pattern and immunological functions of HLA-G, as well as its interaction with well-characterized immune checkpoints. Since HLA-G can be shed from the cell surface or released by various cells as free soluble HLA-G (sHLA-G) or as part of extracellular vesicles (EVs), namely HLA-G-bearing EVs (HLA-GEV), we discuss the potential of sHLA-G and HLA-GEV as predictive biomarkers. This review also addresses the advancement of HLA-G-based therapies in preclinical and clinical settings, with a focus on their clinical application in cancer.

HLA-G/sHLA-G and HLA-G-Bearing Extracellular Vesicles in Cancers: Potential Role as Biomarkers

As a non-classic major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecule, human leukocyte antigen G (HLA-G) is expressed in fetal-maternal interface and immunoprivileged site only in healthy condition, and in pathological conditions such as cancer, it can be de novo expressed. It is now widely accepted that HLA-G is a key molecule in the process of immune escape of cancer cells, which is ubiquitously expressed in the tumor environment. This raises the possibility that it may play an adverse role in tumor immunity. The expression level of HLA-G has been demonstrated to be highly correlated with clinical parameters in many tumors, and its potential significance in the diagnosis and prognosis of cancer has been postulated. However, because HLA-G itself has up to seven different subtypes, and for some subtypes, detected antibodies are few or absent, it is hard to evaluate the actual expression of HLA-G in tumors. In the present work, we described (a) the structure and three main forms of HLA-G, (b) summarized the mechanism of HLA-G in the immune escape of tumor cells, (c) discussed the potential role of HLA-G as a tumor marker, and reviewed (d) the methods for detecting and quantifying HLA-G.

HLA-G expression in melanomas

OBJECTIVE

Human leukocyte antigen G (HLA-G) is a non-classical HLA class I molecule involved in inducing tolerance at the feto-maternal interface and in escape of immune response by tumor cells. The aim of the study is to review the published literature on the expression of HLA-G in malignant melanomas and its clinicopathological and prognostic correlates.

METHODS

A systematic search was carried out in electronic databases. Studies dealing with HLA-G expression in surgically-removed human samples were retrieved and analyzed.

RESULTS

Of 1737 retrieved articles, 16 were included. The main themes regarded HLA-G expression in malignant melanocytic lesions, assessed by immunohistochemistry (IHC), soluble or molecular techniques, and its relationship with clinicopathological features, such as tumor thickness and malignant behavior. Overall significant HLA-G expression was found in 460/843 tumors (55%), and specifically in 251/556 melanomas (45%) evaluated with IHC, in 208/250 cases (83%) examined with soluble methods and in 13/23 melanoma lesions (57%) tested with polymerase chain reaction. Despite the correlation with parameters indicating an aggressive behavior, no studies demonstrated any prognostic value of HLA-G expression. Furthermore, uveal melanomas were constantly negative for this biomarker.

CONCLUSION

Overall, published data indicate that while HLA-G is involved in the interactions between melanomas and the immune system, it is unlikely to be the only factor to play such a role, therefore making it difficult to designate it as a prognostically relevant molecule. Evidence further suggests that HLA-G is not implicated in the immunobiology of uveal melanomas.

The Molecular and Functional Characteristics of HLA-G and the Interaction with Its Receptors: Where to Intervene for Cancer Immunotherapy?

Human leukocyte antigen G (HLA-G) mediates maternal-fetal immune tolerance. It is also considered an immune checkpoint in cancer since it may mediate immune evasion and thus promote tumor growth. HLA-G is, therefore, a potential target for immunotherapy. However, existing monoclonal antibodies directed against HLA-G lack sufficient specificity and are not suitable for immune checkpoint inhibition in a clinical setting. For this reason, it is essential that alternative approaches are explored to block the interaction between HLA-G and its receptors. In this review, we discuss the structure and peptide presentation of HLA-G, and its interaction with the receptors Ig-like transcript (ILT) 2, ILT4, and Killer cell immunoglobulin-like receptor 2DL4 (KIR2DL4). Based on our findings, we propose three alternative strategies to block the interaction between HLA-G and its receptors in cancer immunotherapy: (1) prevention of HLA-G dimerization, (2) targeting the peptide-binding groove of HLA-G, and (3) targeting the HLA-G receptors. These strategies should be an important focus of future studies that aim to develop immune checkpoint inhibitors to block the interaction between HLA-G and its receptors for the treatment of cancer.

Characterization of HLA-G Regulation and HLA Expression in Breast Cancer and Malignant Melanoma Cell Lines upon IFN-γ Stimulation and Inhibition of DNA Methylation

The potential role of human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-G as a target for new cancer immunotherapy drugs has increased the interest in the analysis of mechanisms by which HLA-G expression is regulated, and how the expression can be manipulated. We characterized HLA expression in breast cancer and malignant melanoma cell lines and investigated the induction of HLA-G expression by two distinct mechanisms: stimulation with interferon (IFN)-γ or inhibition of methylation by treatment with 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine (5-aza-dC). The effect of IFN-γ and 5-aza-dC on HLA expression was dependent on the cancer cell lines studied. However, in general, surface expression of HLA class Ia was induced on all cell lines. Surface expression of HLA-G was inconclusive but induction of HLA-G mRNA was prevalent upon treatment with 5-aza-dC and a combination of IFN-γ and 5-aza-dC. IFN-γ alone failed to induce HLA-G expression in the HLA-G-negative cell lines. The results support that HLA-G expression is regulated partly by DNA methylation. Furthermore, IFN-γ may play a role in the maintenance of HLA-G expression rather than inducing expression. The study demonstrates the feasibility of manipulating HLA expression and contributes to the exploration of mechanisms that can be potential targets for immunotherapy in breast cancer and malignant melanoma.

Tumor-induced escape mechanisms and their association with resistance to checkpoint inhibitor therapy

Immunotherapy aims to activate the immune system to fight cancer in a very specific and targeted manner. Despite the success of different immunotherapeutic strategies, in particular antibodies directed against checkpoints as well as adoptive T-cell therapy, the response of patients is limited in different types of cancers. This attributes to escape of the tumor from immune surveillance and development of acquired resistances during therapy. In this review, the different evasion and resistance mechanisms that limit the efficacy of immunotherapies targeting tumor-associated antigens presented by major histocompatibility complex molecules on the surface of the malignant cells are summarized. Overcoming these escape mechanisms is a great challenge, but might lead to a better clinical outcome of patients and is therefore currently a major focus of research.

MHC/HLA Class I Loss in Cancer Cells

In this chapter I describe Tumour Immune Escape mechanisms associated with MHC/HLA class I loss in human and experimental tumours. Different altered HLA class-I phenotypes can be observed that are produced by different molecular mechanisms. Experimental and histological evidences are summarized indicating that at the early stages of tumour development there is an enormous variety of tumour clones with different MHC class I expression patterns. This phase is followed by a strong T cell mediated immune-selection of MHC/HLA class-I negative tumour cells in the primary tumour lesion. This transition period results in a formation of a tumour composed only of HLA-class I negative cells. An updated description of this process observed in a large variety of human tumors is included. In the second section I focus on MHC/HLA class I alterations observed in mouse and human metastases, and describe the generation of different tumor cell clones with altered MHC class I phenotypes, which could be similar or different from the original tumor clone. The biological and immunological relevance of these observations is discussed. Finally, the interesting phenomenon of metastatic dormancy is analyzed in association with a particular MHC class I negative tumor phenotype.

HLA-G: At the Interface of Maternal-Fetal Tolerance

During pregnancy, semiallogeneic fetal extravillous trophoblasts (EVT) invade the uterine mucosa without being rejected by the maternal immune system. Several mechanisms were initially proposed by Peter Medawar half a century ago to explain this apparent violation of the laws of transplantation. Then, three decades ago, an unusual human leukocyte antigen (HLA) molecule was identified: HLA-G. Uniquely expressed in EVT, HLA-G has since become the center of the present understanding of fetus-induced immune tolerance. Despite slow progress in the field, the last few years have seen an explosion in our knowledge of HLA-G biology. Here, we critically review new insights into the mechanisms controlling the expression and function of HLA-G at the maternal-fetal interface, and discuss their relevance for fetal tolerance.

The Pathophysiological Impact of HLA Class Ia and HLA-G Expression and Regulatory T Cells in Malignant Melanoma: A Review

Malignant melanoma, a very common type of cancer, is a rapidly growing cancer of the skin with an increase in incidence among the Caucasian population. The disease is seen through all age groups and is very common in the younger age groups. Several studies have examined the risk factors and pathophysiological mechanisms of malignant melanoma, which have enlightened our understanding of the development of the disease, but we have still to fully understand the complex immunological interactions. The examination of the interaction between the human leucocyte antigen (HLA) system and prognostic outcome has shown interesting results, and a correlation between the down- or upregulation of these antigens and prognosis has been seen through many different types of cancer. In malignant melanoma, HLA class Ia has been seen to influence the effects of pharmaceutical drug treatment as well as the overall prognosis, and the HLA class Ib and regulatory T cells have been correlated with tumor progression. Although there is still no standardized immunological treatment worldwide, the interaction between the human leucocyte antigen (HLA) system and tumor progression seems to be a promising focus in the way of optimizing the treatment of malignant melanoma.

HLA-G and classical HLA class I expression in primary colorectal cancer and associated liver metastases

De novo expression of HLA-G has been demonstrated in colorectal cancer. HLA-G, amongst others, inhibits natural killer cell function, contributing to host immune defense evasion. Another mechanism to escape anti-tumor immunity is loss of HLA class I. Therefore, we determined HLA-G and HLA class I expression on primary colorectal tumors and associated liver metastases, in order to get insight in the metastasizing process regarding escaping anti-tumor immunity. HLA-G expression was evaluated using three mAbs; 4H84, MEM-G/1 and MEM-G/2. In total 81 colorectal cancer patients were evaluated. Formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue sections of primary tumors and associated liver metastases, were immunohistochemically stained. A concordance between expression or loss/downregulation in the primary tumor and associated liver metastasis regarding HLA class I expression was observed in 80% of the cases. In contrast with the hypothesis of escaping NK cell-killing, we demonstrated for each HLA-G detecting mAbs used in this study, that the majority of the primary tumors that positively stained for HLA-G did not express HLA-G in the associated liver metastasis. Furthermore, we revealed the existence of non-specific binding and in addition we found that the different epitopes of HLA-G detected by 4H84, MEM-G/1 and MEM-G/2 mAbs were expressed differentially in colorectal tumor tissues.

Treatment with 5-Aza-2'-Deoxycytidine Induces Expression of NY-ESO-1 and Facilitates Cytotoxic T Lymphocyte-Mediated Tumor Cell Killing

BACKGROUND

NY-ESO-1 belongs to the cancer/testis antigen (CTA) family and represents an attractive target for cancer immunotherapy. Its expression is induced in a variety of solid tumors via DNA demethylation of the promoter of CpG islands. However, NY-ESO-1 expression is usually very low or absent in some tumors such as breast cancer or multiple myeloma. Therefore, we established an optimized in vitro treatment protocol for up-regulation of NY-ESO-1 expression by tumor cells using the hypomethylating agent 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine (DAC).

METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

We demonstrated de novo induction of NY-ESO-1 in MCF7 breast cancer cells and significantly increased expression in U266 multiple myeloma cells. This effect was time- and dose-dependent with the highest expression of NY-ESO-1 mRNA achieved by the incubation of 10 μM DAC for 72 hours. NY-ESO-1 activation was also confirmed at the protein level as shown by Western blot, flow cytometry, and immunofluorescence staining. The detection and quantification of single NY-ESO-1 peptides presented at the tumor cell surface in the context of HLA-A*0201 molecules revealed an increase of 100% and 50% for MCF7 and U266 cells, respectively. Moreover, the enhanced expression of NY-ESO-1 derived peptides at the cell surface was accompanied by an increased specific lysis of MCF7 and U266 cells by HLA-A*0201/NY-ESO-1(157-165) peptide specific chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) CD8+ T cells. In addition, the killing activity of CAR T cells correlated with the secretion of higher IFN-gamma levels.

CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE

These results indicate that NY-ESO-1 directed immunotherapy with specific CAR T cells might benefit from concomitant DAC treatment.

Early endosomal rerouting of major histocompatibility class I conformers

Major histocompatibility class I (MHC-I) molecules are present at the cell surface both as fully conformed trimolecular complexes composed of heavy chain (HC), beta-2-microglobulin (β2m) and peptide, and various open forms, devoid of peptide and/or β2m (open MHC-I conformers). Fully conformed MHC-I complexes and open MHC-I conformers can be distinguished by well characterized monoclonal antibody reagents that recognize their conformational difference in the extracellular domain. In the present study, we used these tools in order to test whether conformational difference in the extracellular domain determines endocytic and endosomal route of plasma membrane (PM) proteins. We analyzed PM localization, internalization, endosomal trafficking, and recycling of human and murine MHC-I proteins on various cell lines. We have shown that fully conformed MHC-I and open MHC-I conformers segregate at the PM and during endosomal trafficking resulting in the exclusion of open MHC-I conformers from the recycling route. This segregation is associated with their partitioning into the membranes of different compositions. As a result, the open MHC-I conformers internalized with higher rate than fully conformed counterparts. Thus, our data suggest the existence of conformation-based protein sorting mechanism in the endosomal system.

The immunosuppressive molecule HLA-G and its clinical implications

Human leukocyte antigen G (HLA-G) is a non-classical major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecule that, through interaction with its receptors, exerts important tolerogenic functions. Its main physiological expression occurs in placenta where it seems to participate in the maternal tolerance toward the fetus. HLA-G has been studied as a marker of pregnancy complications such as abortion or pre-eclapmsia. Although HLA-G is not expressed in most adult tissues, its ectopic expression has been observed in some diseases such as viral infections, autoimmune disorders, and especially cancer. HLA-G neo-expression in cancer is associated with the capability of tumor cells to evade the immune control. In this review, we will summarize HLA-G biology and how it participates in these physiopathological processes. Special attention will be paid to its role as a diagnostic tool and also as a therapeutic target.

Biology of HLA-G in cancer: a candidate molecule for therapeutic intervention?

Although the expression of the non-classical HLA class I molecule HLA-G was first reported to be restricted to the fetal-maternal interface on the extravillous cytotrophoblasts, the distribution of HLA-G in normal tissues appears broader than originally described. HLA-G expression was found in embryonic tissues, in adult immune privileged organs, and in cells of the hematopoietic lineage. More interestingly, under pathophysiological conditions HLA-G antigens may be expressed on various types of malignant cells suggesting that HLA-G antigen expression is one strategy used by tumor cells to escape immune surveillance. In this article, we will focus on HLA-G expression in cancers of distinct histology and its association with the clinical course of diseases, on the underlying molecular mechanisms of impaired HLA-G expression, on the immune tolerant function of HLA-G in tumors, and on the use of membrane-bound and soluble HLA-G as a diagnostic or prognostic biomarker to identify tumors and to monitor disease stage, as well as on the use of HLA-G as a novel therapeutic target in cancer.

The prognostic role of classical and nonclassical MHC class I expression in endometrial cancer

The aim of this study was to investigate classical MHC class I and nonclassical MHC (human leukocyte antigen-G [HLA-G]) expression in a large cohort of patients with endometrial cancer, to determine the prognostic value of these cell surface markers and their relation with clinicopathological variables. Tissue microarrays containing epithelial endometrial carcinoma tissue from 554 patients were stained for classical and nonclassical MHC class I using the following monoclonal antibodies: 4H84 (anti-HLA-G), beta2-m (anti-beta-2-microglobulin) and HC-10 (MHC class I antigen heavy chain). Expression data were linked to known clinicopathological characteristics and survival. HLA-G upregulation and MHC class I downregulation in neoplastic cells was observed in 40% and 48%, respectively. Nonendometrioid tumor type, advanced stage disease (FIGO stage > or = II) and poorly or undifferentiated tumors were associated with MHC class I downregulation. Absence of HLA-G expression was independently associated with MHC class I downregulation. In univariate analysis, MHC class I downregulation was a predictor of worse disease-specific survival. Prognostic unfavorable tumor characteristics were correlated with downregulation of MHC class I expression in endometrial cancer cells. Furthermore, downregulated MHC class I has a negative impact on disease-specific survival, observed in a large cohort of patients with endometrial cancer. As there seems to be a relation between classical and nonclassical MHC class I molecules (HLA-G), further research is warranted to unravel this regulatory mechanism.

Symposium: innovative techniques in human embryo viability assessment. Soluble human leukocyte antigen-G and pregnancy success

Non-invasive methods of assessing embryo quality are critical for pregnancy success following IVF or intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI). The addition of new non-invasive morphological and biochemical analyses may further improve pregnancy success, allowing the transfer of a single embryo, thereby reducing the risks involved in multiple births following IVF/ICSI. The presence of a protein, soluble human leukocyte antigen-G (sHLA-G), in embryo cultures has been suggested as a way to non-invasively predict embryo quality and pregnancy success, especially when used in conjunction with current embryo quality assessment methods. Detection of sHLA-G in embryo culture medium has been correlated with pregnancy success in 12 studies, but three studies were not able to detect sHLA-G. This is a review of the literature on sHLA-G detection in IVF/ICSI, and reasons are proposed for the reported discrepancies, as well as guidelines for reporting of data in future studies. Furthermore, it is suggested that the use of an HLA-G transgenic mouse model would advance understanding of the mechanism of action of sHLA-G in preimplantation embryos and its correlation to embryo health and viability. Research on a mouse model, combined with clinical studies, should enable the development of a fast and reliable method for utilizing sHLA-G detection to improve pregnancy success after IVF/ICSI.

Non-classical HLA-G antigen and its role in the cancer progression

Various changes take place during the progression of cancer, some of which are favorable for tumor development and may help to escape the immunosurvillance. These include changes in the microenvironment around the developing tumor, which could be produced in response to phenotypic alterations or could modulate the expression of certain markers of tumor development. One such newly discovered molecule is HLA-G, which has been found to have immunosuppressive and immunomodulatory roles in the cancer development. The regulatory sequences, as seen, may be induced by various factors that may be present in tumor microenvironment. A recent study has investigated the antigen -G as a marker of susceptibility to chemotherapy. Further, its expression on tumors and how it can be exploited for diagnosis and therapy is discussed in this article.

HLA-G gene activation in tumor cells involves cis-acting epigenetic changes

The tissue distribution of HLA-G molecules is broader than originally reported in trophoblastic cells. On the basis of numerous studies, HLA-G is also expressed in malignant tumors and involved in tumor immune escape. The mechanisms of HLA-G gene regulation differ from those of classical HLA class I genes and involve epigenetic processes. Here, we provide additional evidence on the influence of DNA demethylation on HLA-G activation. We also analyze the 5' regulatory region of HLA-G in 2 cellular models, melanoma (FON, M8) and choriocarcinoma (JEG-3, JAR), either expressing HLA-G transcripts or not. The data strongly suggest that HLA-G is silenced as a result of CpG site hypermethylation within a 5' regulatory region encompassing 450 bp upstream of the start codon, whereas it is activated upon demethylation. This result correlates with the acetylation status of histones within this region and the putative locus control region located at -1.2 kb. cis-acting epigenetic changes and the fact that demethylating agents activate HLA-G expression at least 5 days following treatment should be taken into account in epigenetic cancer therapies.

Differential in vivo and in vitro HLA-G expression in melanoma cells: potential mechanisms

The potential role of human leukocyte antigen G (HLA-G) in tumor immune escape has stimulated interest in the analysis of the expression of this molecule in malignant cells. In melanoma approximately 30% and less than 1% of surgically-removed lesions and cultured cell lines, respectively, have been found to express HLA-G protein. The reason for the marked difference in HLA-G expression frequency is unknown. Here we discuss the potential role of HLA-G detection methodology, stress factors in the tumor microenvironment, and epigenetic changes during tumor progression in the differential in vivo and in vitro HLA-G expression in melanoma cells. We propose a model that may account for the preferential in vivo HLA-G expression in melanoma cells. If proven correct, this model represents a useful background to investigate the mechanisms regulating HLA-G expression in melanoma cells and to devise strategies to counteract HLA-G expression in patients with melanoma.

Detection of HLA-G5 secreting cells

Soluble human leukocyte antigen-G molecules (HLA-G5) can be found in the peripheral blood of healthy females and males, and in other body fluids. To identify cells secreting HLA-G5 we generated a rabbit antiserum against a peptide motif encoded by intron-4 of HLA-G (RaHLA-G/I-4). Utilizing this antiserum as capture and antihuman beta 2-microglobulin as detection reagent, an enzyme-linked immunospot assay specific for HLA-G5 was developed. The results of this enzyme-linked immunospot assay format were proven by the HLA-G1 and soluble HLA-G5 (sHLA-G5) specific mAb MEM/G9 used in parallel as capture reagent. For the choriocarcinoma cell line JEG3 the number of HLA-G5 specific spots was found to be increased after stimulation with IFN-alpha, IFN-beta, and IFN-gamma at various concentrations. In contrast to this, no substantial variation of HLA-G5 specific spots was observed after incubation with lymphokines such as leukemia inhibitory factor, interleukin-10 (IL-10), IL-2, IL-4, and granulocyte-colony-stimulating factor. To clarify the cellular source of secreted HLA-G5 molecules, peripheral blood monocytes, CD4 and CD8 positive T and B cells from healthy donors (n = 14) were tested at a fixed cell number (5000/well) in the absence and presence of IFN-gamma (500 U/ml, 24 hours). In all experiments the number of HLA-G5 specific spots was significantly (p < 0.001) increased primarily in monocytes compared with T and B cells, which suggests that peripheral blood monocytes are the predominant cells secreting HLA-G5.

Exosomes bearing HLA-G are released by melanoma cells

Tumor cells release membrane vesicles, named exosomes, capable of specific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte activation by transferring tumor antigens to dendritic cells. By contrast, the nonclassical human leucocyte antigen (HLA)-G class I molecule displays immunotolerant properties and can be ectopically expressed by tumor cells, thereby allowing their escape from immunosurveillance. We describe here that a melanoma cell line, named Fon, established from an HLA-G-positive melanoma biopsy, spontaneously expressed high levels of the HLA-G1 membrane-bound isoform. Exosomes released by Fon cells were purified and analyzed both for their density on sucrose gradient and their protein composition by Western blotting and flow cytometry. Besides the expression of well-described proteins such as Lamp-2, notably, these melanoma-derived exosomes bore HLA-G1. In addition, exosomes harboring HLA-G1 were secreted by the HLA-G-negative M8 melanoma cells transfected with the HLA-G1 cDNA. Thus, the presence of tolerogenic HLA-G molecules on melanoma-derived exosomes may provide a novel way for tumors to modulate host's immune response.

Secretion of sHLA-G molecules in malignancies

Our clinical studies revealed significantly increased soluble HLA-G (sHLA-G) plasma levels in patients suffering from malignant melanoma, glioma, breast and ovarian cancer. Specific ELISpot assays demonstrate that sHLA-G molecules expressing intron-4 sequences are preferentially secreted by peripheral blood monocytes. In vitro, the sHLA-G secretion of monocytes and tumor cells was strongly enhanced by TH1 cytokines like IFN-alpha, -beta, -gamma whereas TH2 cytokines (e.g. IL-4, -10) had minor effects. As sHLA-G can inhibit the functions of T and NK cells high concentration of these molecules should systemically or at the tumor side reduce the immune surveillance and thus favour the progression of cancer.

HLA-G in melanoma: can the current controversies be solved?

The potential role of HLA-G in tumor immune escape has stimulated interest in the analysis of HLA-G antigens in malignant cells. Malignant melanoma is the tumor which has been mostly analyzed for HLA-G expression. Results obtained by seven groups of investigators about HLA-G expression in 108 melanoma cell lines have been concordant. HLA-G mRNA has been found in about 50% of the cell lines tested, whereas HLA-G protein has been found in less than 1% of the cell lines analyzed. In contrast, results obtained from six groups of investigators about HLA-G protein expression in 133 melanoma lesions have been conflicting. The possible causes of these conflicting results as well as the reasons for the discrepancy in HLA-G expression between cultured melanoma cell lines and surgically removed lesions have been discussed. Lastly, data about the potential clinical relevance of HLA-G expression in melanoma has been reviewed. The available data in the literature strongly suggest that progress in this exciting research area would greatly benefit from experiments to solve the current controversies in the field.

HLA-G in cancer: a way to turn off the immune system

The expression of HLA-G in cancer represents a strategy employed by tumors to avoid immune destruction. Indeed, this non-classical HLA class I molecule suppresses various immune cell functions through binding to inhibitory receptors. We here review the studies done by our group that described for the first time (i) HLA-G expression in malignancies such as melanomas, renal and breast carcinomas. (ii) the up-regulation of HLA-G gene transcription by tumor environmental factors such as cytokines and stress and by agents used in chemotherapy such as demethylating molecules, and (iii) the biological relevance of such HLA-G expression in the evasion of malignant cells from antitumor immune response.

Analysis of HLA-G expression in malignant hematopoetic cells from leukemia patients

It has been suggested that HLA-G antigens may provide tumor cells with an effective immune escape mechanism. So far mostly solid tumors have been analyzed; HLA-G antigen was only exceptionally detected. To further examine HLA-G expression, patients were chosen with different forms of leukemia: AML (25), CML (4), ALL (9), CLL (8), HCL (2) and NHL (3). Using flow cytometry with three HLA-G specific mAbs (87G, 01G and MEM-G/9), western blotting with two specific mAbs (4H84 and MEM-G/1) and RT-PCR, neither HLA-G antigen nor mRNA for any HLA-G isoform was detected. These results strongly suggest that HLA-G antigen is not expressed in freshly isolated human leukemia cells and therefore is not involved in their escape from immune attack.

HLA-G does not have a pathophysiological role in Graves' disease

AIMS

It has been suggested that the non-classic HLA class I molecule HLA-G plays a role in autoimmune disease by protecting tissues from damage by infiltrating cytotoxic T cells. Such infiltration occurs in the thyroid of patients with Graves' disease (GD) and Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT) and can eventually result in tissue destruction. The aim of the current study was to analyse thyroid tissue and thyrocytes obtained from individuals with autoimmune thyroid disease for the expression of HLA-G.

METHODS

HLA-G expression was analysed in thyroid tissue taken from six patients with GD and one with HT by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction. Thyroid tissue samples isolated from six patients with multinodular goitre (MNG) were used as non-autoimmune controls. HLA-G expression was also examined in cultured thyroid follicular cells (TFCs).

RESULTS

The expression of HLA-G was not detected in the thyroid gland of patients with either GD, HT, or MNG. Furthermore, HLA-G expression could not be detected in cultured patient TFCs under basal conditions or after stimulation with the proinflammatory cytokines-interleukin 1alpha, interferon gamma, and tumour necrosis factor alpha.

CONCLUSIONS

HLA-G expression does not occur in the thyroid of patients with GD, indicating that HLA-G does not play a pathophysiological role in this autoimmune disorder. Although the expression of HLA-G was not detected in the thyroid sample of the patient with HT, a greater sample size would be required to conclude that HLA-G does not have a part to play in this autoimmune thyroid disease.

Mild acid treatment induces cross-reactivity of 4H84 monoclonal antibody specific to nonclassical HLA-G antigen with classical HLA class I molecules

Mild acid treatment by releasing beta(2)m and antigenic peptides leaves human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I free heavy chains attached to the cell surface. Acid treatment thus allows detection of the cell surface class I antigens by monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) specific to HLA-free heavy chains. We found that acid treatment also enables detection of the cell surface non-classical HLA-G class I antigen with mAbs specific for HLA-G free heavy chains, including 4H84 mAb recognizing all isoforms. Furthermore, we found that 4H84 mAb, but not other mAbs specific to HLA-G free heavy chains, binds to the surface of 8 out of 16 acid-treated leukemia cell lines. Nevertheless, HLA-G antigen is not present in any of these leukemia cells. This was demonstrated by failure to detect any antigen with 4H84 mAb in immunoblotting as well as by inability to detect HLA-G mRNA by RT-PCR. The antigen recognized by 4H84 mAb in some acid treated leukemia cells was identified by immunoprecipitation as a 45 kDa protein. A number of observations indicate that 45 kDa proteins are none other than classical class I heavy chains. Acid treatment thus induces the ability of the 4H84 mAb to recognize some classical HLA class I molecules. Remarkably, 4H84 determinant on HLA-G is linear but corresponding determinant present on some partially folded classical HLA class I free heavy chains is conformational. In view of the unexpected cross-reactivity, detection of HLA-G with this mAb must be carefully evaluated to avoid false detection.

HLA-G Molecules: from Maternal–Fetal Tolerance to Tissue Acceptance

Over the past few years, HLA-G, the non-classical HLA class I molecule, has been the center of investigations that have led to the description of its specific structural and functional properties. Although located in the HLA class I region of chromosome six, the HLA-G gene may be distinguished from other HLA class I genes by its low polymorphism and alternative splicing that generates seven HLA-G proteins, whose tissue-distribution is restricted to normal fetal and adult tissues that display a tolerogeneic function toward both innate and acquired immune cells. We review these points, with special emphasis on the role of HLA-G in human pathologies, such as cancer, viral infection, and inflammatory diseases, as well as in organ transplantation.

Analysis of HLA-G expression in breast cancer tissues

Among the different mechanisms by which cancer can elude the immune system, alterations in the expression of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I molecules on tumor cells may play a crucial role by impairing the HLA molecules interaction with T and natural killer (NK) cells specific receptors. More recently, aberrant expression of HLA-G has been described in different tumor tissues in addition to HLA class I downregulation. The HLA-G molecule is a nonclassical HLA class I antigen selectively expressed by trophoblast and thymic epithelial cells. Several studies reported that the HLA-G function might represent an additional mechanism of tumor immune escape, mainly inhibiting NK and cytotoxic T-cell activity. Here we report the analysis of HLA-G expression both at RNA level by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction and at protein level by Western blot and immunohistochemistry in 25 breast cancer patient tissues. The aim of this study was to elucidate the HLA-G gene expression pattern in breast tumor tissues and correlate it with HLA class I alterations. Our results demonstrated that HLA-G molecules expression was never found even in a group of patients revealing HLA class I total loss, and that HLA-G is not expressed in breast cancer tissue with a low-tumor grade (G1-G2) and minimal stromal contamination.

A functional role of HLA-G expression in human gliomas: an alternative strategy of immune escape

HLA-G is a nonclassical MHC molecule with highly limited tissue distribution that has been attributed chiefly immune regulatory functions. Glioblastoma is paradigmatic for the capability of human cancers to paralyze the immune system. To delineate the potential role of HLA-G in glioblastoma immunobiology, expression patterns and functional relevance of this MHC class Ib molecule were investigated in glioma cells and brain tissues. HLA-G mRNA expression was detected in six of 12 glioma cell lines in the absence of IFN-gamma and in 10 of 12 cell lines in the presence of IFN-gamma. HLA-G protein was detected in four of 12 cell lines in the absence of IFN-gamma and in eight of 12 cell lines in the presence of IFN-gamma. Immunohistochemical analysis of human brain tumors revealed expression of HLA-G in four of five tissue samples. Functional studies on the role of HLA-G in glioma cells were conducted with alloreactive PBMCs, NK cells, and T cell subpopulations. Expression of membrane-bound HLA-G1 and soluble HLA-G5 inhibited alloreactive and Ag-specific immune responses. Gene transfer of HLA-G1 or HLA-G5 into HLA-G-negative glioma cells (U87MG) rendered cells highly resistant to direct alloreactive lysis, inhibited the alloproliferative response, and prevented efficient priming of cytotoxic T cells. The inhibitory effects of HLA-G were directed against CD8 and CD4 T cells, but appeared to be NK cell independent. Interestingly, few HLA-G-positive cells within a population of HLA-G-negative tumor cells exerted significant immune inhibitory effects. We conclude that the aberrant expression of HLA-G may contribute to immune escape in human glioblastoma.

Specific activation of the non-classical class I histocompatibility HLA-G antigen and expression of the ILT2 inhibitory receptor in human breast cancer

The HLA-G molecule is a non-classical HLA class I antigen selectively expressed by trophoblastic cells that invade the maternal decidua during human pregnancy. HLA-G is believed to contribute to tolerance of the semi-allogeneic fetus by inhibiting maternal immune responses. Similarly, HLA-G expression in tumour cells may favour their escape from host immune surveillance. This study investigated HLA-G expression in human mammary tumours. Immunohistochemical analysis of cryo-preserved and paraffin-embedded breast tissue biopsies, using two HLA-G-specific antibodies, revealed that unlike non-cancerous breast tissue in the vicinity of the tumour, 14 out of 36 breast cancer lesions selectively expressed HLA-G. HLA-G expression was significantly more frequent in lesions that were highly infiltrated by host immune cells, thus correlating HLA-G activation with inflammation. Further histological and double-staining immunofluorescence analysis attributed HLA-G expression mainly to tumour epithelial cells and to subsets of infiltrating CD68+ and CD8+ cells. RT-PCR analysis suggested that HLA-G was activated at the transcriptional level in breast tumours. The presence of ILT2 (Ig-like transcript 2) killing inhibitory receptors known to interact with HLA-G was also demonstrated in host immune cells that infiltrate breast cancer lesions. These results indicate that HLA-G is up-regulated at high frequencies in human breast cancer, where it may impair efficient anti-tumour immunity.

HLA-G remains a mystery

In this brief summary, we argue that many widely held beliefs about HLA-G are questionable. Recent research has led to a re-evaluation of many of the characteristics that were thought to make HLA-G unusual among the MHC class I molecules. First, contrary to reports suggesting that the gene encoding HLA-G exhibits marked polymorphism in some human populations, recent data have shown that the HLA-G gene has comparatively little polymorphism - a feature that might allow it to be expressed in the placenta without causing rejection by the maternal immune system. Second, although truncated forms of HLA-G are generated in the placenta, most of them are unlikely to have significant biological effects as they do not reach the cell surface. Third, the hypothesis that a major role of HLA-G is to prevent attack of the placenta by maternal natural killer cells is now the subject of renewed scrutiny. Finally, there is little evidence that the induction of expression of HLA-G is a major mechanism by which tumor cells avoid immune attack. HLA-G has once again become as mysterious as when it was discovered: an MHC class I molecule expressed at a challengingly extraordinary site--the immunologically uneasy interface between mother and fetus.

Investigation of HLA class I downregulation in breast cancer by RT-PCR

Downregulation of HLA class I antigen expression has been reported in a significant proportion of primary breast carcinomas suggesting an escape mechanism from CTL mediated lysis leading to tumor dissemination and metastasis. We have previously reported the biochemical and immunohistochemical analysis of HLA total class I (W6/32 mAb), alpha-chain (Q1/28,TP25.99 mAbs) and beta(2)-microglobulin (Namb-1 mAb) subunits expression in 25 primary breast carcinomas. This study at protein level resulted in the observation of three different HLA class I expression patterns by both techniques: high, low, and absent downregulation patterns. To better characterize the HLA class I antigens downregulation we extended such analysis also at RNA level by RT-PCR using HLA-A, HLA-B, HLA-C, and beta(2)-microglobulin specific primers either in breast cancer or normal tissues derived from the same patient. None (100%) of the alpha-chain genes analyzed in patient tumor tissues showed significant reduction of expression. In 10 patients out of 25 (40%) the beta(2)-microglobulin gene showed complete loss of expression compared with the corresponding normal tissue counterpart, which showed a constitutive expression, whereas in 2 patients (12.5%) its expression was comparable with the normal counterpart. Sequence analysis at genomic level revealed no defects affecting beta(2)-microglobulin gene in those patients showing lack of expression. Also TAP1 and TAP2 genes expression were investigated in order to confirm or exclude involvement of the MHC class I molecules assembling machinery. The RT-PCR approach mainly confirmed our beta(2)-microglobulin biochemical analysis indicating that in breast cancer specimens it is possible to address the HLA class I gene downregulation as a phenomenon occurring at post-transcriptional level mainly affecting the beta(2)-microglobulin gene expression.