Sequence and structural determinants of the interaction between the 5'-noncoding region of picornavirus RNA and rhinovirus protease 3C

Crystal structures of the 3C proteases from Coxsackievirus B3 and B4

Enteroviruses cause a wide range of disorders with varying presentations and severities, and some enteroviruses have emerged as serious public health concerns. These include Coxsackievirus B3 (CVB3), an active causative agent of viral myocarditis, and Coxsackievirus B4 (CVB4), which may accelerate the progression of type 1 diabetes. The 3C proteases from CVB3 and CVB4 play important roles in the propagation of these viruses. In this study, the 3C proteases from CVB3 and CVB4 were expressed in Escherichia coli and purified by affinity chromatography and gel-filtration chromatography. The crystals of the CVB3 and CVB4 3C proteases diffracted to 2.10 and 2.01 Å resolution, respectively. The crystal structures were solved by the molecular-replacement method and contained a typical chymotrypsin-like fold and a conserved His40-Glu71-Cys147 catalytic triad. Comparison with the structures of 3C proteases from other enteroviruses revealed high similarity with minor differences, which will guide the design of 3C-targeting inhibitors with broad-spectrum properties.

Exploration of Potential Broad-Spectrum Antiviral Targets in the Enterovirus Replication Element: Identification of Six Distinct 5' Cloverleaves

Enterovirus genomic replication initiates at a predicted RNA cloverleaf (5'CL) at the 5' end of the RNA genome. The 5'CL contains one stem (SA) and three stem-loops (SLB, SLC, SLD). Here, we present an analysis of 5'CL conservation and divergence for 209 human health-related serotypes from the enterovirus genus, including enterovirus and rhinovirus species. Phylogenetic analysis indicates six distinct 5'CL serotypes that only partially correlate with the species definition. Additional findings include that 5'CL sequence conservation is higher between the EV species than between the RV species, the 5'CL of EVA and EVB are nearly identical, and RVC has the lowest 5'CL conservation. Regions of high conservation throughout all species include SA and the loop and nearby bases of SLB, which is consistent with known protein interactions at these sites. In addition to the known protein binding site for the Poly-C binding protein in the loop of SLB, other conserved consecutive cytosines in the stems of SLB and SLC provide additional potential interaction sites that have not yet been explored. Other sites of conservation, including the predicted bulge of SLD and other conserved stem, loop, and junction regions, are more difficult to explain and suggest additional interactions or structural requirements that are not yet fully understood. This more intricate understanding of sequence and structure conservation and variability in the 5'CL may assist in the development of broad-spectrum antivirals against a wide range of enteroviruses, while better defining the range of virus isotypes expected to be affected by a particular antiviral.

Picornavirus 3C Proteins Intervene in Host Cell Processes through Proteolysis and Interactions with RNA

The Picornaviridae family comprises a large group of non-enveloped viruses with enormous impact on human and animal health. The picornaviral genome contains one open reading frame encoding a single polyprotein that can be processed by viral proteases. The picornaviral 3C proteases share similar three-dimensional structures and play a significant role in the viral life cycle and virus-host interactions. Picornaviral 3C proteins also have conserved RNA-binding activities that contribute to the assembly of the viral RNA replication complex. The 3C protease is important for regulating the host cell response through the cleavage of critical host cell proteins, acting to selectively 'hijack' host factors involved in gene expression, promoting picornavirus replication, and inactivating key factors in innate immunity signaling pathways. The protease and RNA-binding activities of 3C are involved in viral polyprotein processing and the initiation of viral RNA synthesis. Most importantly, 3C modifies critical molecules in host organelles and maintains virus infection by subtly subverting host cell death through the blocking of transcription, translation, and nucleocytoplasmic trafficking to modulate cell physiology for viral replication. Here, we discuss the molecular mechanisms through which 3C mediates physiological processes involved in promoting virus infection, replication, and release.

Structural basis for cloverleaf RNA-initiated viral genome replication

The genomes of positive-strand RNA viruses serve as a template for both protein translation and genome replication. In enteroviruses, a cloverleaf RNA structure at the 5' end of the genome functions as a switch to transition from viral translation to replication by interacting with host poly(C)-binding protein 2 (PCBP2) and the viral 3CDpro protein. We determined the structures of cloverleaf RNA from coxsackievirus and poliovirus. Cloverleaf RNA folds into an H-type four-way junction and is stabilized by a unique adenosine-cytidine-uridine (A•C-U) base triple involving the conserved pyrimidine mismatch region. The two PCBP2 binding sites are spatially proximal and are located on the opposite end from the 3CDpro binding site on cloverleaf. We determined that the A•C-U base triple restricts the flexibility of the cloverleaf stem-loops resulting in partial occlusion of the PCBP2 binding site, and elimination of the A•C-U base triple increases the binding affinity of PCBP2 to the cloverleaf RNA. Based on the cloverleaf structures and biophysical assays, we propose a new mechanistic model by which enteroviruses use the cloverleaf structure as a molecular switch to transition from viral protein translation to genome replication.

Structure of Senecavirus A 3C Protease Revealed the Cleavage Pattern of 3C Protease in Picornaviruses

Senecavirus A (SVA) is an emerging picornavirus infecting porcine of all age groups and causing foot and mouth disease (FMD)-like symptoms. One of its key enzymes is the 3C protease (3C^pro), which is similar to other picornaviruses and essential for virus maturation by controlling polyprotein cleavage and RNA replication. In this study, we reported the crystal structure of SVA 3C^pro at a resolution of 1.9 Šand a thorough structural comparison against all published picornavirus 3C^pro structures. Using statistical and graphical visualization techniques, we also investigated the sequence specificity of the 3C^pro. The structure revealed that SVA 3C^pro adopted a typical chymotrypsin-like fold with the S1 subsite as the most conservative site among picornavirus 3C^pro. The surface loop, A1-B1 hairpin, adopted a novel conformation in SVA 3C^pro and formed a positively charged protrusion around S' subsites. Correspondingly, SVA scissile bonds preferred Asp rather than neutral amino acids at P3' and P4'. Moreover, SVA 3C^pro showed a wide range tolerance to P4 residue volume (acceptable range: 67 ų to 141 ų), such as aromatic side chain, in contrast to other picornaviruses. In summary, our results provided valuable information for understanding the cleavage pattern of 3C^pro. IMPORTANCE Picornaviridae is a group of RNA viruses that harm both humans and livestock. 3C^pro is an essential enzyme for picornavirus maturation, which makes it a promising target for antiviral drug development and a critical component for virus-like particle (VLP) production. However, the current challenge in the development of antiviral drugs and VLP vaccines includes the limited knowledge of how subsite structure determines the 3C^pro cleavage pattern. Thus, an extensive comparative study of various picornaviral 3C^pro was required. Here, we showed the 1.9 Šcrystal structure of SVA 3C^pro. The structure revealed similarities and differences in the substrate-binding groove among picornaviruses, providing new insights into the development of inhibitors and VLP.

Picornavirus 3C - a protease ensuring virus replication and subverting host responses

The protease 3C is encoded by all known picornaviruses, and the structural features related to its protease and RNA-binding activities are conserved; these contribute to the cleavage of viral polyproteins and the assembly of the viral RNA replication complex during virus replication. Furthermore, 3C performs functions in the host cell through its interaction with host proteins. For instance, 3C has been shown to selectively 'hijack' host factors involved in gene expression, promoting picornavirus replication, and to inactivate key factors in innate immunity signaling pathways, inhibiting the production of interferon and inflammatory cytokines. Importantly, 3C maintains virus infection by subtly subverting host cell death and modifying critical molecules in host organelles. This Review focuses on the molecular mechanisms through which 3C mediates physiological processes involved in virus-host interaction, thus highlighting the picornavirus-mediated pathogenesis caused by 3C.

Inhibitory antibodies identify unique sites of therapeutic vulnerability in rhinovirus and other enteroviruses

The existence of multiple serotypes renders vaccine development challenging for most viruses in the Enterovirus genus. An alternative and potentially more viable strategy for control of these viruses is to develop broad-spectrum antivirals by targeting highly conserved proteins that are indispensable for the virus life cycle, such as the 3C protease. Previously, two single-chain antibody fragments, YDF and GGVV, were reported to effectively inhibit human rhinovirus 14 proliferation. Here, we found that both single-chain antibody fragments target sites on the 3C protease that are distinct from its known drug site (peptidase active site) and possess different mechanisms of inhibition. YDF does not block the active site but instead noncompetitively inhibits 3C peptidase activity through an allosteric effect that is rarely seen for antibody protease inhibitors. Meanwhile, GGVV antagonizes the less-explored regulatory function of 3C in genome replication. The interaction between 3C and the viral genome 5' noncoding region has been reported to be important for enterovirus genome replication. Here, the interface between human rhinovirus 14 3C and its 5' noncoding region was probed by hydrogen-deuterium exchange coupled mass spectrometry and found to partially overlap with the interface between GGVV and 3C. Consistently, prebinding of GGVV completely abolishes interaction between human rhinovirus 14 3C and its 5' noncoding region. The epitopes of YDF and GGVV, therefore, represent two additional sites of therapeutic vulnerability in rhinovirus. Importantly, the GGVV epitope appears to be conserved across many enteroviruses, suggesting that it is a promising target for pan-enterovirus inhibitor screening and design.

Long-Range Communication between Different Functional Sites in the Picornaviral 3C Protein

The 3C protein is a master regulator of the picornaviral infection cycle, responsible for both cleaving viral and host proteins, and interacting with genomic RNA replication elements. Here we use nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and molecular dynamics simulations to show that 3C is conformationally dynamic across multiple timescales. Binding of peptide and RNA lead to structural dynamics changes at both the protease active site and the RNA-binding site, consistent with these sites being dynamically coupled. Indeed, binding of RNA influences protease activity, and likewise, interactions at the active site affect RNA binding. We propose that RNA and peptide binding re-shapes the conformational energy landscape of 3C to regulate subsequent functions, including formation of complexes with other viral proteins. The observed channeling of the 3C energy landscape may be important for regulation of the viral infection cycle.

Mutational robustness and resilience of a replicative cis-element of RNA virus: Promiscuity, limitations, relevance

Since replication of RNA-viruses is generally a low-fidelity process, it would be advantageous, if specific interactions of their genomic cis-elements with dedicated ligands are relatively tolerant to mutations. The specificity/promiscuity trade-off of such interactions was addressed here by investigating structural requirements of the oriL (also known as the clover leaf-like element), of poliovirus RNA, a replicative cis-element containing a conserved essential tetraloop functionally interacting with the viral protein 3CD. The sequence of this tetraloop and 2 adjacent base-pairs was randomized in the viral genome, and viable viruses were selected in susceptible cells. Strikingly, each position of this octanucleotide in 62 investigated viable viruses could be occupied by any nucleotide (with the exception of one position, which lacked U), though with certain sequence preferences, confirmed by engineering mutant viral genomes whose phenotypic properties were found to correlate with the strength of the cis-element/ligand interaction. The results were compatible with a hypothesis that functional recognition by 3CD requires that this tetraloop should stably or temporarily adopt a YNMG-like (Y=U/C, N=any nucleotide, M=A/C) fold. The fitness of "weak" viruses could be increased by compensatory mutations "improving" the tetraloops. Otherwise, the recognition of "bad" tetraloops might be facilitated by alterations in the 3CD protein. The virus appeared to tolerate mutations in its cis-element relaying on either robustness (spatial structure degeneracy) or resilience (a combination of dynamic RNA folding, low-fidelity replication modifying the cis-element or its ligand, and negative selection). These mechanisms (especially resilience involving metastable low-fit intermediates) can also contribute to the viral evolvability.

Virus Proteinase Inhibitors — What Next after HIV?

The recent approval by the regulatory authorities in the United States of several HIV proteinase inhibitors as therapeutics for the treatment of AIDS confirms that virus proteinases are valid molecular targets in the search for new antiviral drugs. This review summarizes the available approaches that can be taken to discover virus proteinase inhibitors and reviews the current status of our knowledge with respect to virus proteinases in viruses of clinical significance other than HIV. The major focus is on proteinases identified in the viruses that cause the common cold, hepatitis C virus and the herpesviruses.

Functional binding of hexanucleotides to 3C protease of hepatitis A virus

Oligonucleotides as short as 6 nt in length have been shown to bind specifically and tightly to proteins and affect their biological function. Yet, sparse structural data are available for corresponding complexes. Employing a recently developed hexanucleotide array, we identified hexadeoxyribonucleotides that bind specifically to the 3C protease of hepatitis A virus (HAV 3C(pro)). Inhibition assays in vitro identified the hexanucleotide 5'-GGGGGT-3' (G(5)T) as a 3C(pro) protease inhibitor. Using (1)H NMR spectroscopy, G(5)T was found to form a G-quadruplex, which might be considered as a minimal aptamer. With the help of (1)H, (15)N-HSQC experiments the binding site for G(5)T was located to the C-terminal β-barrel of HAV 3C(pro). Importantly, the highly conserved KFRDI motif, which has previously been identified as putative viral RNA binding site, is not part of the G(5)T-binding site, nor does G(5)T interfere with the binding of viral RNA. Our findings demonstrate that sequence-specific nucleic acid-protein interactions occur with oligonucleotides as small as hexanucleotides and suggest that these compounds may be of pharmaceutical relevance.

Crystal structure of human enterovirus 71 3C protease

Human enterovirus 71 (EV71) is the major pathogen that causes hand, foot and mouth disease that particularly affects young children. Growing hand, foot and mouth disease outbreaks were observed worldwide in recent years and caused devastating losses both economically and politically. However, vaccines or effective drugs are unavailable to date. The genome of EV71 consists of a positive sense, single-stranded RNA of ∼7400 bp, encoding a large precursor polyprotein that requires proteolytic processing to generate mature viral proteins. The proteolytic processing mainly depends on EV71 3C protease (3C(pro)) that possesses both proteolysis and RNA binding activities, which enable the protease to perform multiple tasks in viral replication and pathogen-host interactions. The central roles played by EV71 3C(pro) make it an appealing target for antiviral drug development. We determined the first crystal structure of EV71 3C(pro) and analyzed its enzymatic activity. The crystal structure shows that EV71 3C(pro) has a typical chymotrypsin-like fold that is common in picornaviral 3C(pro). Strikingly, we found an important surface loop, also denoted as β-ribbon, which adopts a novel open conformation in EV71 3C(pro). We identified two important residues located at the base of the β-ribbon, Gly123 and His133, which form hinges that govern the intrinsic flexibility of the ribbon. Structure-guided mutagenesis studies revealed that the hinge residues are important to EV71 3C(pro) proteolytic activities. In summary, our work provides the first structural insight into EV71 3C(pro), including a mobile β-ribbon, which is relevant to the proteolytic mechanism. Our data also provides a framework for structure-guided inhibitor design against EV71 3C(pro).

Purification of a toxic cysteine protease produced by pathogenic Aeromonas hydrophila isolated from rainbow trout

An extracellular lethal toxin produced by Aeromonas hydrophila strain RT860715K originally isolated from diseased rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) was purified by using Fast Protein Liquid Chromatography system with hydrophobic interaction chromatography and anion exchange columns. The toxin was a cysteine protease, inhibited by L -cysteine, iodoacetic acid, N -ethylamleimide, P-chloromercuibenzene-sulfonic acid and N-α-p-tosyl-1-lysine-chloromethyl ketone (TLCK), and showed maximal activity at pH 6.0. The molecular weight of the purified enzyme proved to be 94 kDa as estimated by SDS-PAGE. In addition, the toxin was also completely inhibited by HgCl(2) but partially inhibited by ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA) and CuCl₂. Both the extracellular products of Aeromonas hydrophila RT860715K and the purified protease were lethal to rainbow trout (weighing 18 g) with LD₅₀ values of 2.87 and 0.93 μg protein g⁻¹ fish body weight, respectively. The addition of L-cysteine completely inhibited the lethal toxicity of the purified protease, indicating that this cysteine protease was a lethal toxin produced by the bacterium.

A picornaviral loop-to-loop replication complex

Picornaviruses replicate their RNA genomes through a highly conserved mechanism that involves an interaction between the principal viral protease (3C(pro)) and the 5'-UTR region of the viral genome. The 3C(pro) catalytic site is the target of numerous replication inhibitors. This paper describes the first structural model of a complex between a picornaviral 3C(pro) and a region of the 5'-UTR, stem-loop D (SLD). Using human rhinovirus as a model system, we have combined NMR contact information, small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) data, and previous mutagenesis results to determine the shape, position and relative orientation of the 3C(pro) and SLD components. The results clearly identify a 1:1 binding stoichiometry, with pronounced loops from each molecule providing the key binding determinants for the interaction. Binding between SLD and 3C(pro) induces structural changes in the proteolytic active site that is positioned on the opposite side of the protease relative to the RNA/protein interface, suggesting that subtle conformational changes affecting catalytic activity are relayed through the protein.

Phylogenetic relationships and molecular adaptation dynamics of human rhinoviruses

Human rhinoviruses (HRVs) are responsible for nearly 50% of all common cold infections. Ordinarily, HRV infections are mild and self-limiting; nonetheless, every year they result in significant loss of economic productivity and substantial inappropriate antibiotic use. Development of effective vaccine and antiviral prophylaxis against HRV has been hampered by the extensive antigenic diversity present among the nearly 100 serotypes. To gain new insights into the evolutionary processes that create the genetic diversity present among HRVs, we tested for recombination and selection for individual genes and the coding genome for 45 HRV serotypes using estimated phylogenetic relationships. Although the structural capsid genes and nonstructural genes recovered incongruent tree topologies, no recombination was detected using substitution methods. Therefore, the coding genome was determined to be appropriate for phylogenetic tests. Results of the Shimodaira-Hasegawa (SH) test support the hypothesis that the capsid genes recover a different evolutionary history than the nonstructural genes. Our best phylogenetic estimate based on the coding genome suggests that HRV-B is more closely related to enterovirus than to HRV-A; however, several alternative phylogenetic hypotheses were not rejected by the SH test. Positive selection was examined by using two different approaches; d(N)/d(S) rate ratio and the physicochemical phenotypes for 31 amino acid properties. Analyses using d(N)/d(S) failed to detect positive selection. However, protein phenotypic expression appears to be a more sensitive approach. There was extensive stabilizing and destabilizing positive selection in HRV-A major and HRV-B serotypes for all proteins, except in 3A in HRV-B, which overlapped with functional, structural, and to a greater extent in uncharacterized genomic regions. In contrast, the evolution of HRV-A minor serotypes appears to be driven primarily by destabilizing selection. Our results demonstrate that HRV-A major, HRV-A minor, and HRV-B serotypes have not been similarly influenced by purifying selection.

Identification of the oriI-binding site of poliovirus 3C protein by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy

Replication of picornaviral genomes requires recognition of at least three cis-acting replication elements: oriL, oriI, and oriR. Although these elements lack an obvious consensus sequence or structure, they are all recognized by the virus-encoded 3C protein. We have studied the poliovirus 3C-oriI interaction in order to begin to decipher the code of RNA recognition by picornaviral 3C proteins. oriI is a stem-loop structure that serves as the template for uridylylation of the peptide primer VPg by the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase. In this report, we have used nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques to study 3C alone and in complex with two single-stranded RNA oligonucleotides derived from the oriI stem. The (1)H-(15)N spectra of 3C recorded in the presence of these RNAs revealed site-specific chemical shift perturbations. Residues that exhibit significant perturbations are primarily localized in the amino terminus and in a highly conserved loop between residues 81 and 89. In general, the RNA-binding site defined in this study is consistent with predictions based on biochemical and mutagenesis studies. Although some residues implicated in RNA binding by previous studies are perturbed in the 3C-RNA complex reported here, many are unique. These studies provide unique site-specific insight into residues of 3C that interact with RNA and set the stage for detailed structural investigation of the 3C-RNA complex by NMR. Interpretation of our results in the context of an intact oriI provides insight into the architecture of the picornavirus VPg uridylylation complex.

Interaction between polypeptide 3ABC and the 5'-terminal structural elements of the genome of Aichi virus: implication for negative-strand RNA synthesis

Secondary structural elements at the 5' end of picornavirus genomic RNA function as cis-acting replication elements and are known to interact specifically with viral P3 proteins in several picornaviruses. In poliovirus, ribonucleoprotein complex formation at the 5' end of the genome is required for negative-strand synthesis. We have previously shown that the 5'-end 115 nucleotides of the Aichi virus genome, which are predicted to fold into two stem-loops (SL-A and SL-C) and one pseudoknot (PK-B), act as a cis-acting replication element and that correct folding of these structures is required for negative-strand synthesis. In this study, we investigated the interaction between the 5'-terminal 120 nucleotides of the genome and the P3 proteins, 3AB, 3ABC, 3C, and 3CD, by gel shift assay and Northwestern analysis. The results showed that 3ABC and 3CD bound to the 5'-terminal region specifically. The binding of 3ABC was observed on both assays, while that of 3CD was detected only on Northwestern analysis. No binding of 3AB or 3C was observed. Binding assays using mutant RNAs demonstrated that disruption of the base pairings of the stem of SL-A and one of the two stem segments of PK-B (stem-B1) abolished the 3ABC binding. In addition, the specific nucleotide sequence of stem-B1 was responsible for the efficient 3ABC binding. These results suggest that the interaction of 3ABC with the 5'-terminal region of the genome is involved in negative-strand synthesis. On the other hand, the ability of 3CD to interact with the 5'-terminal region did not correlate with the RNA replication ability.

Picornavirus genome replication. Identification of the surface of the poliovirus (PV) 3C dimer that interacts with PV 3Dpol during VPg uridylylation and construction of a structural model for the PV 3C2-3Dpol complex

Picornaviruses have a peptide termed VPg covalently linked to the 5'-end of the genome. Attachment of VPg to the genome occurs in at least two steps. First, Tyr-3 of VPg, or some precursor thereof, is used as a primer by the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, 3Dpol, to produce VPg-pUpU. Second, VPg-pUpU is used as a primer to produce full-length genomic RNA. Production of VPg-pUpU is templated by a single adenylate residue located in the loop of an RNA stem-loop structure termed oriI by using a slide-back mechanism. Recruitment of 3Dpol to and its stability on oriI have been suggested to require an interaction between the back of the thumb subdomain of 3Dpol and an undefined region of the 3C domain of viral protein 3CD. We have performed surface acidic-to-alanine-scanning mutagenesis of 3C to identify the surface of 3C with which 3Dpol interacts. This analysis identified numerous viable poliovirus mutants with reduced growth kinetics that correlated to reduced kinetics of RNA synthesis that was attributable to a change in VPg-pUpU production. Importantly, these 3C derivatives were all capable of binding to oriI as well as wild-type 3C. Synthetic lethality was observed for these mutants when placed in the context of a poliovirus mutant containing 3Dpol-R455A, a residue on the back of the thumb required for VPg uridylylation. These data were used to guide molecular docking of the structures for a poliovirus 3C dimer and 3Dpol, leading to a structural model for the 3C(2)-3Dpol complex that extrapolates well to all picornaviruses.

NMR structure of stem-loop D from human rhinovirus-14

The 5'-cloverleaf of the picornavirus RNA genome is essential for the assembly of a ribonucleoprotein replication complex. Stem-loop D (SLD) of the cloverleaf is the recognition site for the multifunctional viral protein 3Cpro. This protein is the principal viral protease, and its interaction with SLD also helps to position the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (3Dpol) for replication. Human rhinovirus-14 (HRV-14) is distinct from the majority of picornaviruses in that its SLD forms a cUAUg triloop instead of the more common uYACGg tetraloop. This difference appears to be functionally significant, as 3Cpro from tetraloop-containing viruses cannot bind the HRV-14 SLD. We have determined the solution structure of the HRV-14 SLD using NMR spectroscopy. The structure is predominantly an A-form helix, but with a central pyrimidine-pyrimidine base-paired region and a significantly widened major groove. The stabilizing hydrogen bonding present in the uYACGg tetraloop was not found in the cUAUg triloop. However, the triloop uses different structural elements to present a largely similar surface: sequence and underlying architecture are not conserved, but key aspects of the surface structure are. Important structural differences do exist, though, and may account for the observed cross-isotype binding specificities between 3Cpro and SLD.

Role of RNA structure and RNA binding activity of foot-and-mouth disease virus 3C protein in VPg uridylylation and virus replication

The uridylylation of the VPg peptide primer is the first stage in the replication of picornavirus RNA. This process can be achieved in vitro using purified components, including 3B (VPg) with the RNA dependent RNA polymerase (3Dpol), the precursor 3CD, and an RNA template containing the cre/bus. We show that certain RNA sequences within the foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) 5' untranslated region but outside of the cre/bus can enhance VPg uridylylation activity. Furthermore, we have shown that the FMDV 3C protein alone can substitute for 3CD, albeit less efficiently. In addition, the VPg precursors, 3B(3)3C and 3B(123)3C, can function as substrates for uridylylation in the absence of added 3C or 3CD. Residues within the FMDV 3C protein involved in interaction with the cre/bus RNA have been identified and are located on the face of the protein opposite from the catalytic site. These residues within 3C are also essential for VPg uridylylation activity and efficient virus replication.

A GCUA tetranucleotide loop found in the poliovirus oriL by in vivo SELEX (un)expectedly forms a YNMG-like structure: Extending the YNMG family with GYYA

The cloverleaf structure in the 5'-untranslated region of enterovirus RNA that regulates viral RNA replication contains an evolutionarily conserved YNMG tetraloop closed by a Y-G base pair. This loop is believed to interact specifically with the viral protease 3C. To further characterize the specificity of this interaction, the tetraloop and two flanking base pairs of the poliovirus RNA were randomized, and viable viral clones were obtained using in vivo SELEX. Among many different mutants with the canonical YNMG sequences to be described elsewhere, a large-plaque-forming clone contained a deviating uGCUAg sequence. The NMR structure of a small hairpin capped with uGCUAg that we present here shows that the GCUA tetraloop adopts a novel fold, which is highly similar to that of the YNMG tetraloop with common stacking properties and hydrogen-bond interactions including an unusual syn conformation of the adenosine. Thermodynamic studies show moderate stabilities of hairpins with canonical YNMG and the novel GCUA loops, which, together with the similarity of spatial structures, illustrates that the tetraloop structure itself is crucial for the RNA-protein interaction required for the viral replication. A re-evaluation of the ribosomal secondary structure database reveals a hairpin containing a GCUA loop, which covaries with YNMG and is involved in a tertiary interaction, and in the 50S ribosomal subunit from Haloarcula marismortui the structurally comparable apex of stem-loop 35a is a recognition site for protein L2. These observations show a more general occurrence and importance of the so-far unrecognized GYYA hairpin loops.

Hepatitis A virus proteinase 3C binding to viral RNA: correlation with substrate binding and enzyme dimerization

Proteinase 3C of hepatitis A virus (HAV) plays a key role in the viral life cycle by generating mature viral proteins from the precursor polyprotein. In addition to its proteolytic activity, 3C binds to viral RNA, and thus influences viral genome replication. In order to investigate the interplay between proteolytic activity and RNA binding at the molecular level, we subjected HAV 3C and three variants carrying mutations of the cysteine residues [C24S (Cys-24-->Ser), C172A and C24S/C172A] to proteolysis assays with peptide substrates, and to surface plasmon resonance binding studies with peptides and viral RNA. We report that the enzyme readily forms dimers via disulphide bridges involving Cys-24. Dissociation constants (K(D)) for peptides were in the millimolar range. The binding kinetics for the peptides were characterized by k(on) and k(off) values of the order of 10(2) M(-1) x s(-1) and 10(-2) to 10(-1) s(-1) respectively. In contrast, 3C binding to immobilized viral RNA, representing the structure of the 5'-terminal domain, followed fast binding kinetics with k(on) and k(off) values beyond the limits of the kinetic resolution of the technique. The affinity of viral RNA depended strongly on the dimerization status of 3C. Whereas monomeric 3C bound to the viral RNA with a K(D) in the millimolar range, dimeric 3C had a significantly increased binding affinity with K(D) values in the micromolar range. A model of the 3C dimer suggests that spatial proximity of the presumed RNA-binding motifs KFRDI is possible. 3C binding to RNA was also promoted in the presence of substrate peptides, indicating co-operativity between RNA binding and protease activity. The data imply that the dual functions of 3C are mutually dependent, and regulate protein and RNA synthesis during the viral life cycle.

Detecting selection in noncoding regions of nucleotide sequences

We present a maximum-likelihood method for examining the selection pressure and detecting positive selection in noncoding regions using multiple aligned DNA sequences. The rate of substitution in noncoding regions relative to the rate of synonymous substitution in coding regions is modeled by a parameter zeta. When a site in a noncoding region is evolving neutrally zeta = 1, while zeta > 1 indicates the action of positive selection, and zeta < 1 suggests negative selection. Using a combined model for the evolution of noncoding and coding regions, we develop two likelihood-ratio tests for the detection of selection in noncoding regions. Data analysis of both simulated and real viral data is presented. Using the new method we show that positive selection in viruses is acting primarily in protein-coding regions and is rare or absent in noncoding regions.

Mutations at KFRDI and VGK domains of enterovirus 71 3C protease affect its RNA binding and proteolytic activities

The 3C protease (3C(pro)) of enterovirus 71 (EV71) is a good molecular target for drug discovery. Notably, this protease was found to possess RNA-binding activity. The regions responsible for RNA binding were classified as 'KFRDI' (positions 82-86) and 'VGK' (positions 154-156) in 3C(pro) by mutagenesis study. Although the RNA-binding regions are structurally distinct from the catalytic site of EV71 3C(pro), mutations in the RNA-binding regions influenced 3C(pro) proteolytic activity. In contrast, mutations at the catalytic site had almost no influence on RNA binding ability. We identified certain mutations within 3C(pro) which abrogated both the RNA-binding activity of the expressed, recombinant, protease and the ability to rescue virus from an infectious full-length clone of EV71 (pEV71). Interestingly, mutation at position 84 from Arg(R) to Lys(K) was found to retain good RNA binding and proteolytic activity for the recombinant 3C(pro); however, no virus could be rescued when pEV71 with the R84K mutation was introduced into the infectious copy. Together, these results may provide useful information for using 3C(pro) as the molecular target to develop anti-EV71 agents.

The nsp9 replicase protein of SARS-coronavirus, structure and functional insights

As part of a high-throughput structural analysis of SARS-coronavirus (SARS-CoV) proteins, we have solved the structure of the non-structural protein 9 (nsp9). This protein, encoded by ORF1a, has no designated function but is most likely involved with viral RNA synthesis. The protein comprises a single beta-barrel with a fold previously unseen in single domain proteins. The fold superficially resembles an OB-fold with a C-terminal extension and is related to both of the two subdomains of the SARS-CoV 3C-like protease (which belongs to the serine protease superfamily). nsp9 has, presumably, evolved from a protease. The crystal structure suggests that the protein is dimeric. This is confirmed by analytical ultracentrifugation and dynamic light scattering. We show that nsp9 binds RNA and interacts with nsp8, activities that may be essential for its function(s).

The structure of the stemloop D subdomain of coxsackievirus B3 cloverleaf RNA and its interaction with the proteinase 3C

Stemloop D (SLD) of the 5' cloverleaf RNA is the cognate ligand of the coxsackievirus B3 (CVB3) 3C proteinase (3Cpro). Both are indispensable components of the viral replication initiation complex. SLD is a structurally autonomous subunit of the 5' cloverleaf. The SLD structure was solved by NMR spectroscopy to an rms deviation of 0.66 A (all heavy atoms). SLD contains a novel triple pyrimidine mismatch motif with a central Watson-Crick type C:U pair. SLD is capped by an apical uCACGg tetraloop adopting a structure highly similar to stable cUNCGg tetraloops. Binding of CVB3 3Cpro induces changes in NMR spectra for nucleotides adjacent to the triple pyrimidine mismatch and of the tetraloop implying them as sites of specific SLD:3Cpro interaction. The binding of 3Cpro to SLD requires the integrity of those structural elements, strongly suggesting that 3Cpro recognizes a structural motif instead of a specific sequence.

Analysis of the cloverleaf element in a human rhinovirus type 14/poliovirus chimera: correlation of subdomain D structure, ternary protein complex formation and virus replication

RNA genomes of enteroviruses and rhinoviruses contain a 5'-terminal structure, the cloverleaf (CL), which serves as signal in RNA synthesis. Substitution of the poliovirus [PV1(M)] CL with that of human rhinovirus type 2 (HRV2) was shown previously to produce a viable chimeric PV, whereas substitution with the HRV14 CL produced a null phenotype. Fittingly, the HRV14 CL failed to form a complex with PV-specific proteins 3CD(pro)-3AB or 3CD(pro)-PCBP2, considered essential for RNA synthesis. It was reported previously (Rohll et al., J Virol 68, 4384-4391, 1994) that the major determinant for the null phenotype of a PV/HRV14 chimera resides in subdomain Id of the HRV14 CL. Using a chimeric PV/HRV14 CL in the context of the PV genome, stem-loop Id of HRV14 CL was genetically dissected. It contains the sequence C(57)UAU(60)-G, the underlined nucleotides forming the loop that is shorter by 1 nt when compared to the corresponding PV structure (UUGC(60)GG). Insertion of a G nucleotide to form a tetra loop (C(57)UAU(60)GG(61)) did not rescue replication of the chimera. However, an additional mutation at position 60 (C(57)UAC(60)GG(61)) yielded a replicating genome. Only the mutant PV/HRV14 CL with the UAC(60)G tetra loop formed ternary complexes efficiently with either PV proteins 3CD(pro)-3AB or 3CD(pro)-PCBP2. Thus, in the context of PV RNA synthesis, the presence of a tetra loop in subdomain D of the CL per se is not sufficient for function. The sequence and, consequently, the structure of the tetra loop plays an essential role. Biochemical assays demonstrated that the function of the CL element and the function of the cis-acting replication element in the 3D(pol)-3CD(pro)-dependent uridylylation of VPg are not linked.

Interaction in vitro between the proteinase of Tomato ringspot virus (genus Nepovirus) and the eukaryotic translation initiation factor iso4E from Arabidopsis thaliana

Eukaryotic initiation factor eIF(iso)4E binds to the cap structure of mRNAs leading to assembly of the translation complex. This factor also interacts with the potyvirus VPg and this interaction has been correlated with virus infectivity. In this study, we show an interaction between eIF(iso)4E and the proteinase (Pro) of a nepovirus (Tomato ringspot virus; ToRSV) in vitro. The ToRSV VPg did not interact with eIF(iso)4E although its presence on the VPg-Pro precursor increased the binding affinity of Pro for the initiation factor. A major determinant of the interaction was mapped to the first 93 residues of Pro. Formation of the complex was inhibited by addition of m(7)GTP (a cap analogue), suggesting that Pro-containing molecules compete with cellular mRNAs for eIF(iso)4E binding. The possible implications of this interaction for translation and/or replication of the virus genome are discussed.

The 3C protease activity of enterovirus 71 induces human neural cell apoptosis

The human glioblastoma SF268 cell line was used to investigate the induction of apoptosis by the 3C protease of enterovirus 71 (EV71). Transient expression in these cells of the wild-type 3C protein encoded by EV71 induced morphological alterations typical of apoptosis, including generation of apoptotic bodies. Degradation of cellular DNA in nucleosomes was also observed. When two of the amino acids in the catalytic motif of 3C were changed by mutagenesis, the 3C protein not only lost its proteolytic activity, but also its ability to induce apoptosis in the SF268 cells. Twenty-four hours after 3C transfection, poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase, a DNA repair enzyme, was cleaved, indicating that caspases were activated by the expression of EV71 3C. The 3C-induced apoptosis was blocked by the caspase inhibitors DEVD-fmk and VAD-fmk. Our findings suggest that the proteolytic activity of 3C triggers apoptosis in the SF268 cells through a mechanism involving caspase activation and that this apoptotic pathway may play an important role in the pathogenesis of EV71 infection.

Rapid multiserotype detection of human rhinoviruses on optically coated silicon surfaces

BACKGROUND

More than 100 immunologically distinct serotypes of human rhinoviruses (HRV) have been discovered, making detection of surface exposed capsid antigens impractical. However, the non-structural protein 3C protease (3Cpro) is essential for viral replication and is relatively highly conserved among serotypes, making it a potential target for diagnostic testing. The thin film biosensor is an assay platform that can be formatted into a sensitive immunoassay for viral proteins in clinical specimens. The technology utilizes an optically coated silicon surface to convert specific molecular binding events into visual color changes by altering the reflective properties of light through molecular thin films.

OBJECTIVE

To develop a rapid test for detection of HRV by developing broadly serotype reactive antibodies to 3Cpro and utilizing them in the thin film biosensor format.

STUDY DESIGN

Polyclonal antibodies to 3Cpro were purified and incorporated into the thin film assay. The in vitro sensitivity, specificity and multiserotype cross-reactivity of the 3Cpro assay were tested. Nasal washes from naturally infected individuals were also tested to verify that 3Cpro was detectable in clinical specimens.

RESULTS

The 3Cpro assay is a 28-min, non-instrumented room temperature test with a visual limit of detection of 12 pM (picomolar) 3Cpro. In terms of viral titer, as few as 1000 TCID(50) equivalents of HRV2 were detectable. The assay detected 45/52 (87%) of the HRV serotypes tested but showed no cross-reactivity to common respiratory viruses or bacteria. The thin film assay detected 3Cpro in HRV-infected cell culture supernatants coincident with first appearance of cytopathic effect. Data are also presented demonstrating 3Cpro detection from clinical samples collected from HRV-infected individuals. The assay detected 3Cpro in expelled nasal secretions from a symptomatic individual on the first day of illness. In addition, 9/11 (82%) concentrated nasal wash specimens from HRV infected children were positive in the 3Cpro test.

CONCLUSION

We have described a novel, sensitive thin film biosensor for rapid detection of HRV 3Cpro. This test may be suitable for the point of care setting, where rapid HRV diagnostic test results could contribute to clinical decisions regarding appropriate antibiotic or antiviral therapy.

Activation of human rhinovirus-14 3C protease

The catalytic efficiency of human rhinovirus-14 (HRV14) 3C protease as a function of solvents and other regulators has been investigated using synthetic peptides as substrates. The proteolytic activity of HRV14 3C was found to be strongly stimulated by a series of anions in vitro and the activation was accompanied by changed Km, kcat, and increased kcat/Km values. A more than 72-fold increase in the 3C catalytic efficiency toward peptide substrates was observed in the presence of 0.8 M sodium sulfate. Several approaches, including size-exclusion chromatography and chemical cross-linking experiments, suggested that no oligomerization of the 3C enzyme occurred in the presence of activating anions. However, the anions did induce a significant conformational change of HRV14 3C protease, as revealed by circular dichroism spectrometry and tyrosine fluorescence analyses, which might contribute to 3C enzyme activation. Finally, the results obtained from 3C protease inhibitor studies suggested that the S1 specificity pocket of HRV14 3C was mainly affected by the activating anions. An induced-fit catalysis mechanism for viral proteases is discussed.

Protease inhibitors as potential antiviral agents for the treatment of picornaviral infections

The picornavirus family contains several human pathogens including human rhinovirus (HRV) and hepatitis A virus (HAV). In the case of HRVs, these small single-stranded positive-sense RNA viruses translate their genetic information into a polyprotein precursor which is further processed mainly by two viral proteases designated 2A and 3C. The 2A protease (2Apro) makes the first cleavage between the structural and non-structural proteins, while 3C protease (3Cpro) catalyzes most of the remaining internal cleavages. It has been shown that both 2Apro and 3Cpro are cysteine proteases but their overall protein folding is more like trypsin-type serine proteases. Due to their unique protein structure and essential roles in viral replication, 2Apro and 3Cpro have been viewed as excellent targets for antiviral intervention. In recent years, considerable efforts have been made in the development of antiviral compounds targeting these proteases. This article summarizes the recent approaches in the design of novel 2A and 3C protease inhibitors as potential antiviral agents for the treatment of picornaviral infections.

Functional features of the bovine enterovirus 5'-non-translated region

The bovine enterovirus (BEV) serotypes exhibit unique features of the non-translated regions (NTRs) which separate them from the other enteroviruses. Their most remarkable property is an additional genome region of 110 nt located between the 5'-cloverleaf and the internal ribosome entry site (IRES). This genome region has the potential to form an additional cloverleaf structure (domain I*) separated from the 5'-cloverleaf (domain I) by a small stem-loop (domain I**). Other characteristics involve the putative IRES domains III and VI. In order to investigate the features of the 5'-NTR, several full-length coxsackievirus B3 (CVB3) cDNA plasmids with hybrid 5'-NTRs were engineered. After exchange of the CVB3 cloverleaf with the BEV1 genome region representing both cloverleafs, a viable virus chimera was generated. Deletion of domain I** within the exchanged region also yielded viable virus albeit with reduced growth capacity. Deletion of sequences encoding either the first or the second BEV cloverleaf resulted in non-infectious constructs. Hybrid plasmids with exchanges of the IRES-encoding sequence or the complete 5'-NTR were non-infectious. Transfection experiments with SP6 transcripts containing 5'-NTRs fused to the luciferase message indicated that IRES-driven translation is enhanced by the presence of the CVB3 cloverleaf and both BEV1 cloverleaf structures, respectively. Deletion of either the first or the second BEV cloverleaf domain reduced but did not abolish enhanced luciferase expression. These results suggest that the substitution of two putative BEV cloverleaf structures for the putative coxsackieviral cloverleaf yields viable virus, while BEV sequences encoding the IRES fail to functionally replace CVB3 IRES-encoding sequences.

Paradoxes of the replication of picornaviral genomes

A wealth of experimental data on the mechanism of the picornavirus genome replication has accumulated. Not infrequently, however, conclusions derived from these data appear to contradict each other. On the one hand, initiation of a complementary RNA strand can be demonstrated to occur in a solution containing only the poliovirus RNA polymerase, VPg, uridine triphosphate, poly(A) template and appropriate ions. On the other hand, convincing experiments suggest that efficient initiation of a viral complementary RNA strand requires complex cis-acting signals on the viral RNA template, additional viral and possibly cellular proteins as well as a membrane-containing environment. On the one hand, there is evidence that the viral RNA, in order to be replicated, should first be translated, but on the other hand, the viral RNA polymerase appears to be unable to overcome the ribosome barrier. Possible solutions for these and several other similar paradoxes are discussed, along with less contradictory results on the properties of the picornaviral replicative proteins. Recent results suggesting that recombination and other rearrangements of the viral RNA genomes may be accomplished not only by the replicative template switching but also by nonreplicative mechanisms are also briefly reviewed.

Proteolytic Enzymes of the Viruses of the Family Picornaviridae

This chapter deals with proteolytic enzymes of the viruses of the family picornaviridae. The picornaviral 3C proteinases constitute an ideal target for the rational design of antiviral drugs. The chapter discusses the chymotrypsin-like cysteine proteinases, which constitute a unique class of enzymes with a distinct substrate specificity, and are so far only found in +RNA viruses. Within these viruses the 3C proteinases perform a central and indispensable role during the viral life cycle and 3C proteinase inhibitors have the potential to limit the spread of viral infections. The chapter concludes that there is a wealth of experimental information available for the best-studied examples of the viruses of the Picornaviridae. This information provides an opportunity to design inhibitors against the viral 3C proteinase. Effective inhibitors of the picornaviral 3C proteinase have the potential to become effective antiviral drugs against human diseases such as the common cold, HAV, enteroviral infections, and diseases caused by related + RNA viruses.

Protease inhibitors as potential antiviral agents for the treatment of picornaviral infections

The picornavirus family contains several human pathogens including human rhinovirus (HRV) and hepatitis A virus (HAV). In the case of HRVs, these small single-stranded positive-sense RNA viruses translate their genetic information into a polyprotein precursor which is further processed mainly by two viral proteases designated 2A and 3C. The 2A protease (2Apro) makes the first cleavage between the structural and non-structural proteins, while 3C protease (3Cpro) catalyzes most of the remaining internal cleavages. It has been shown that both 2Apro and 3Cpro are cysteine proteases but their overall protein folding is more like trypsin-type serine proteases. Due to their unique protein structure and essential roles in viral replication, 2Apro and 3Cpro have been viewed as excellent targets for antiviral intervention. In recent years, considerable efforts have been made in the development of antiviral compounds targeting these proteases. This article summarizes the recent approaches in the design of novel 2A and 3C protease inhibitors as potential antiviral agents for the treatment of picornaviral infections.

RNA binding activity of NIa proteinase of tobacco etch potyvirus

The C-terminal domain of NIa protein (NIaPro) from tobacco etch potyvirus (TEV) is a sequence-specific proteinase required for processing of the viral polyprotein. This proteinase also interacts with NIb, the TEV RNA-dependent RNA polymerase. NIaPro and two NIaPro-containing polyproteins (NIa and 6/NIa) were analyzed from extracts of recombinant Escherichia coli. Using RNA-protein blot and UV-crosslinking assays, NIaPro and the NIaPro-containing polyproteins were shown to possess RNA-binding activity. NIaPro bound nonspecifically to several RNAs, including plus- and minus-strands of the TEV 5' and 3' noncoding regions. Saturation binding data obtained using the UV-crosslinking assay were consistent with a possible cooperative RNA-binding activity of NIaPro. In addition, the RNA-binding activities of NIaPro and full-length NIa protein were similar. Based on its RNA-binding activity and other known functions, NIaPro or a NIaPro-containing polyprotein is proposed to serve one or more direct roles during TEV RNA synthesis.

Interaction of hepatitis A virus (HAV) precursor proteins 3AB and 3ABC with the 5' and 3' termini of the HAV RNA

RNA secondary structures within the terminal nontranslated regions of entero- and rhinoviral genomes interact specifically with viral nonstructural proteins and are required in cis for viral RNA replication. Here we show that recombinant hepatitis A virus (HAV) polypeptide 3ABC specifically interacts in vitro with secondary RNA structures formed at both the 5' and 3' terminus of the viral genome. Similar to protein 3AB, HAV 3ABC bound to the 3' terminal RNA structure which did not interact with the mature proteinase 3C. In contrast to 3AB, 3ABC interacted with RNA stem-loop IIa and combinations of individual secondary structure elements of the 5' noncoding region. RNA binding of the precursor polypeptide 3ABC was 50 times stronger than that of 3AB and 3C, implicating a specific role of this stable processing intermediate in viral genome replication.

Viral cysteine proteinases

Dozens of novel cysteine proteinases have been identified in positive single-stranded RNA viruses and, for the first time, in large double-stranded DNA viruses. The majority of these proteins are distantly related to papain or chymotrypsin and may be direct descendants of primordial proteolytic enzymes. Virus genome synthesis and expression, virion formation, virion entry into the host cell, as well as cellular architecture and functioning can be under the control of viral cysteine proteinases during infection. RNA virus proteinases mediate their liberation from giant multidomain precursors in which they tend to occupy conserved positions. These proteinases possess a narrow substrate specificity, can cleave in cis and in trans, and may also have additional, nonproteolytic functions. The mechanisms of catalysis, substrate recognition and RNA binding were highlighted by the recent analysis of the three-dimensional structure of the chymotrypsin-like cysteine proteinases of two RNA viruses.