Contribution of bone marrow cells and lack of expression of thymocytes in genetic controls of immune responses for two immunopotent regions within poly-(Phe,Glu)-poly-Pro--poly-Lys in inbred mouse strains

Characterization of immunogenic properties of haptenated liposomal model membranes in mice. I. Thymus independence of the antigen

This paper describes a rather simple coupling method for tripeptide enlarged haptens to phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) and the incorporation of these conjugates into liposomal model membranes (haptenated liposomes). These haptenated liposomes evoke a hapten-specific humoral immune response in mice. The magnitude of the response as measured by the appearance of direct plaque forming cells in the spleen is dependent on the route of immunization and the dose and epitope density of the hapten-PE derivatives. It was not possible to evoke an IgG response after either primary or secondary immunization with haptenated liposomes (as measured by the production of indirect plaques or mercaptoethanol-resistant antibody). These data, in addition to the observations that mice depleted of, or deficient in thymus-derived (T) lymphocytes respond to haptenated liposomes, indicate that these haptenated liposomes are T-cell independent antigens.

Complexity of cell interactions: analysis using antigens under Ir gene control

The properties of three I region associated immunoregulatory factors involved in cell interactions are described. These are antigen specific T helper factor, suppressor factor produced by metabolically active T cells and genetically restricted factor, which is produced by macrophages and is involved in T helper cell induction. The use of these factors to analyse cell interactions is discussed.

In vitro studies on H-2 linked unresponsiveness. 1. Normal helper cells to (T,G)-A-L and GAT in low and non-responder mice

Lymphoid cells from unprimed high responder (C57BL/10) and low responder mice (B10.Br, B10.A, CBA) to (T,G)-A-L and high responder (B10, B10.A) and non-responder (B10.G, DBA/I) mice to GAT can be induced to form antigen specific T-helper cells in vitro under identical culture conditions. The helper cells induced from high and low or non-responder mice appear to be identical in efficiency, antigen concentration requirement for induction and induction kinetics.

Role of antigenic structure in cell to cell cooperation

Two synthetic polypeptides which differ only in the order of amino acids in their NH2-terminal side chains, namely, (Tyr-Tyr-Glu-Glu)-poly(DLAla)- -poly(LLys) and (Tyr-Glu-Try-Glu)-poly(DLAla)- -poly(LLys), were found to be under different genetic control. By three different in vivo systems for thymus-derived cell depletion, it was demonstrated that (Tyr-Tyr-Glu-Glu)-poly(DLAla)- -poly(LLys), which represents the random poly(Tyr,Glu)-poly(DLAla)- -poly(Lys) in the pattern of immune responses and in the quality of antibodies they elicit, is thymus-dependent whereas (Tyr-Glu-Tyr-Glu)-poly(DLAla)-poly(LLys) does not require thymus-derived cell help for efficient antibody production. Therefore, the two ordered polypeptides which are similar chemically differ in parameters, not yet determined, which affect their capability to trigger bone marrow-derived cells.

Analysis of the role of different cell types in the genetic regulation of antibody production to the thymus-independent synthetic polypeptide poly (DTyr, DGlu)-poly (DPro)--poly (DLys)

The immune response potential of mice to the thymus-independent synthetic polypeptide poly (DTyr, DGlu)-poly(DPro)--poly(DLys)[D(T,G)-Pro--L] is genetically regulated. The defect in the ability of low responder mice to mount an immune response to this antigen appears to be expressed in their B cell population since the presence of thymocytes, or addition of "educated T cells" or supernatant of T cells after stimulation with the antigen neither enhanced, nor suppressed the level of antibodies produced in both low and high responder mice. Low responsiveness could not be enhanced either by stimulation of macrophages or by injection of poly(A) - poly(U) in contrast to the significant effect of these agents on low responses to the thymus-dependent poly(LTyr, LGlu)-poly(LPro)--poly(LLys) [L(T,G)-Pro--L]. These results suggest that macrophages do not participate in the limiting step, or are not involved at all, in antibody production towards the thymus-independent polypeptide. The antibodies produced in response to D(T,G)-Pro--L were found to be mainly of the 7 S class. T cells are not required for the production of mercaptoethanol resistant antibodies to this immunogen since they were found in intact mice as well as in T cell depleted animals.

The effect of the thymus-independent antigens, collagen and synthetic collagen-like polypeptide, on the requirement of cell cooperation in the immune response to thymus-dependent antigens

The effect of thymus-independent antigens on the need for cell cooperation in the immune response to thymus-dependent antigens was investigated. Irradiated recipient mice transplanted with either bone marrow cells or a mixture of bone marrow and thymus cells, were immunized with the thymus-independent antigen (Pro-Gly-Pro)n covalently conjugated to the thymus-dependent ovalbumin, or with a mixture of (Pro-Gly-Pro)n and ovalbumin. In both cases an effective response towards ovalbumin was observed in the absence of thymus cells as was found for the thymus-independent (Pro-Gly-Pro)n. The same effect on ovalbumin was demonstrated when a mixture of the thymus-independent collagen and ovalbumin was used for immunization. On the other hand, when irradiated reconstituted mice were immunized with a mixture of ovalbumin and the thymus-dependent gelatin, which is the denatured product of collagen, cell-to-cell cooperation was required for an immune response to both immunogens. The effect of (Pro-Gly-Pro)n and collagen on the response to the thymus-dependent ovalbumin in vivo was observed in in vitro experiments using sheep red blood cells (SRBC) as the immunogen as well. In the presence of reduced and carboxymethylated (RCM) Ascaris collagen and (Pro-Gly-Pro)n, nude spleen cells could produce significant numbers of plaque-forming cells towards SRBC. Thus, (Pro-Gly-Pro)n and collagen can deliver the signal required to stimulate B cells to produce antibody towards thymus-dependent antigens in the absence of T cells. In contrast to the results with (Pro-Gly-Pro)n and collagen, the thymus-independent synthetic polypeptide poly(DTyr, DGlu-)-poly(DPro)--poly(DLys) did not affect the requirement for cell cooperation of the thymus-dependent immunogens, ovalbumin and SRCB. It thus appears that the ability to substitute for T cells for antibody production towards thymus-dependent immunogens is not a general characteristic of thymus-independent antigens.

Genetic control of immune response. The dose of antigen given in aqueous solution is critical in determining which mouse strain is high responder to poly(LTyr, LGlu)-poly(LPro)--poly(LLys)

Antibody response to different doses of (T,G)-Pro--L, given in aqueous solution, was investigated in the high responder SJL and low responder DBA/1 strains by measuring hemolytic plaque-forming cells (PFC) in the spleens as well as hemagglutination titers in the sera. The gene responsible for the difference between the two strains in the response to this antigen, given in complete Freund's adjuvant, has been previously denoted Ir-3. This gene is not linked to the major histocompatibility locus. In the response to the optimal dose (1 mug) of antigen, no difference could be shown between the strains. The peak of the response and the numbers of direct and indirect PFC were similar in both strains in the primary and secondary response. After injection of higher doses (10-100 mug) of antigen, both the direct and indirect PFC responses were lower in the low responder than in the high responder strain. Moreover, the peak of the response occurred earlier in the high responder strain in the primary response to the 10 mu dose of antigen. After administration of a suboptimal dose (0.02 mug) of antigen, the low responder strain produced in the primary response 4-20 times more indirect plaques than the high responder strain. Also the number of direct plaques was higher in the low responder than in the high responder strain. The serum antibody responses to the optimal and higher doses of antigen were parallel to the PFC responses. From inhibition of PFC with free antigen, it was concluded that a similar proportion of cells was producing high and low affinity antibodies to (T,G)-Pro--L in both strains. High and low zone tolerance could be induced in the two strains with (T,G)-Pro--L, but no difference could be shown between the strains. It is suggested that the Ir-3 gene plays a role in the regulation of the balance stimulation and suppression according to the dose of antigen given.

Genetic control of the antibody response to poly-L(Tyr,Glu)-poly-D,L-Ala--poly-L-Lys in C3H--CWB tetraparental mice

In order to further delineate the mechanisms underlying genetic unresponsiveness, tetraparental mice were constructed from immune response-1A gene high responder and low responder parental genotypes, then were immunized with poly-L-(Tyr,Glu)-poly-D,L-Ala--poly-L-Lys ((T,G)-A--L). An analysis of the total serum allotype mixture and of the antigen-binding capacity of the separated allotypes demonstrated that in the milieu of a tetraparental mouse, both high and low responder B cells could be stimulated equally to produce identical high titered anti-(T,G)-A--L responses. Furthermore, these studies show that effective stimulation could occur across a histocompatibility disparity.

Tolerance to thymus-independent antigens. Characteristics of induction of tolerance to thymus-independent synthetic polypeptides

The conditions have been studied for induction of tolerance in mice to two thymus-independent multichain synthetic polypeptides, poly(DTyr,DGlu)-polyDPro--polyDLys, and poly(DTyr,DGlu)-polyLPro--polyLLys. The antigens are of very similar structure, differing only in the optical configuration of proline and lysine residues.

The tolerance thresholds were established by giving a single injection of antigen in solution in saline, followed later by challenge of antigen in adjuvant. For both antigens it was possible to induce high dose tolerance, which was preceded by a zone of priming at lower doses. In neither case was low zone tolerance observed. The induction of high zone tolerance was accompanied by a passing phase of antibody production in the case of poly(DTyr,DGlu)-polyDPro--polyDLys, but not in the case of poly(DTyr,DGlu)-polyLPro--polyLLys. Furthermore, the threshold doses for high zone tolerance for the two antigens differed by two orders of magnitude, being at about 100 μg per mouse for the former and at 1 μg per mouse for the latter. It appears that thymus-independent antigens, even if very similar structurally, can differ very markedly in the characteristics of their interaction with B cells.

The role of the thymus in a genetically controlled defect of the immune response at the carrier level

The genetic control of the immune response may be either specific for antigenic carrier or for determinant. We describe here results which show that a carrier-dependent strain defect in immune response is reflected in thymocytes. These results are in agreement with our hypothesis that the genetic defect in the immune response is reflected in thymocytes when the poor response is at the carrier level, whereas it is expressed in the bone marrow population when the low responsiveness is strictly at the determinant level. SWR mice are low responders to multichain polyproline. Furthermore, this mouse strain does not produce antibodies to determinants such as peptides of phenylalanine and glutamic acid (Phe,Glu) or to the loop peptide of lysozyme when attached to polyproline, although they respond well to the same antigenic determinants when conjugated to multichain poly(DL-alanine). Transfer experiments in which irradiated SWR recipients were injected with excess of DBA/1 thymocytes (which do not exhibit a defect in response to polyproline) mixed with graded numbers of SWR marrow cells, prior to immunization with poly(Tyr,Glu)-poly(Pro)--poly(Lys), have indicated that the poor response potential of SWR mice to polyproline is not reflected in their bone marrow cells. Allogeneic transfers in which mixtures of thymocytes and marrow cells from high and low responders were injected into irradiated mice, followed by immunization with poly(Tyr,Glu)-poly(Pro)--poly(Lys) or poly(Phe,Glu)-poly(Pro)--poly(Lys) have demonstrated a clear defect in the thymus derived population of SWR mice when the response potential to polyproline and to determinants attached to it was tested.

Thymus independence of a collagen-like synthetic polypeptide and of collagen, and the need for thymus and bone marrow-cell cooperation in the immune response to gelatin

Several inbred mouse strains were screened for their ability to respond to the ordered periodic collagen-like polymer (Pro-Gly-Pro)(n), to the random copolymer (Pro(66), Gly(34))(n), to the protein conjugate Pro-Gly-Pro-ovalbumin, to rat tail tendon collagen, rat tail tendon gelatin, and to Ascaris cuticle collagen. Differences were obtained in the magnitude of the antibody titers towards the above immunogens among the strains tested. The level of the response to the ordered polymer (Pro-Gly-Pro)(n) was not similar to that towards the random (Pro(66), Gly(34))(n), confirming differences in the antigenic determinants of the two immunogens. The role of the thymus in the immune response to (Pro-Gly-Pro)(n) and (Pro(66), Gly(34))(n) as well as to two collagens and gelatin, was studied in order to find out a possible correlation with the structural features of the immunogens. Heavily irradiated recipients were injected with syngeneic thymocytes, marrow cells, or a mixture of both cell populations and were immunized with the above-mentioned antigens. An efficient immune response to the ordered collagen-like (Pro-Gly-Pro)(n) was obtained in the absence of transferred thymocytes. The thymus independence of (Pro-Gly-Pro)(n) was confirmed when thymectomized irradiated mice were used as recipients. In contrast with these results, cooperation between thymus and marrow cells was necessary in order to elicit an immune response to (Pro(56), Gly(34))(n). Similarly, the immune response to the triple helical collagen was found to be independent of the thymus, whereas for an effective response to its denatured product, gelatin, thymus cells were required. These findings indicate that a unique three-dimensional structure of immunogens possessing repeating antigenic determinants plays an important role in determining the need for cell to cell interaction in order to elicit an antibody response.

The role of thymocytes and bone marrow cells in defining the response to the dinitrophenyl hapten attached to positively and negatively charged synthetic polypeptide carriers. Cell fractionation over charged columns

An inverse relationship exists between the net electrical charge of immunogens and the antibodies they elicit (1). Results of an earlier study have demonstrated that the net charge phenomenon has a cellular basis, since the immune response potential of murine spleen cells to 2,4-dinitrophenyl (DNP) on a negatively charged synthetic polypeptide carrier was reduced by cell fractionation over negatively charged glass beads, whereas the response to the same hapten on a positively charged carrier was unaffected (14). To verify that the net charge correlation is expressed at the cellular level, spleen cells were fractionated over positively charged poly-L-lysine-coated glass bead columns, and their immunocompetence to DNP on positively and negatively charged carriers was tested by cell transfers in irradiated recipient mice. In this case, the fractionated cells showed reduced response potential to DNP on the positively charged carrier only. Thus, the cellular basis of the net charge phenomenon has been demonstrated for both positively and negatively charged immunogens (for the same specificity) by cell separation techniques over columns of opposite charge. In order to establish whether the cell population relevant for the charge properties of immunogens was of thymus or marrow origin, thymocytes and bone marrow cells were selectively passed over positively or negatively charged columns and mixed with unfractionated cells of the complementary type. Transfers of the filtered and unfiltered cell mixtures in irradiated recipient mice immunized with DNP on either a positive or a negative synthetic polypeptide carrier indicated that fractionation of thymocytes, but not of marrow cells, correlated with the spleen population. Thus, thymocytes fractionated over negatively charged columns and mixed with unfractionated marrow cells exhibited reduced response to DNP on the negative carrier, but normal responses to DNP on the positive carrier. The opposite result was obtained when thymocytes were passed over positively charged columns. No effect on the anti-DNP response was detected by filtration of bone marrow cells over columns of either charge. These findings indicate that it is possible to distinguish between thymocytes on the basis of their capacity to react with more acidic or more basic surfaces and that a population of thymus-derived cells may recognize immunogens on the basis of their overall electrical charge. No evidence was found by these techniques that marrow-derived cells contribute to the net charge phenomenon.

Thymus-independence of slowly metabolized immunogens

The role of thymus in antibody responses to a series of four synthetic polypeptide immunogens of the general formula multi-copoly(Tyr,Glu)-poly(Pro)-poly(Lys) was investigated as a function of the optical activity of the amino acids composing their structure. Irradiated nonthymectomized and thymectomized SJL mice were injected with thymocytes, marrow cells, or a mixture of both. Each group of recipients was immunized with the following copolymer enantiomorphs: all L-amino acids; L-amino acids outside and D inside; D-amino acids outside and L inside; or all D-amino acids. The antibody response to the immunogen composed of all L-amino acids was thymus-dependent, whereas the responses to the other three copolymers were all independent of the thymus. Similar cell transfers were performed in DBA/1 mice immunized with multi-copoly(L-Phe,L-Glu)-poly(D-Pro)-poly(D-Lys). This mouse strain produces specific antibodies against the (Phe,Glu) region and against the poly(D-prolyl) region. The immune response to the determinant with only L-amino acids on the outside was thymusdependent, whereas the response to the inside immunopotent region with only D-amino acids was thymusindependent. Since earlier studies have demonstrated that synthetic polypeptide antigens that contain D-amino acids are poorly metabolized, the thymus-independence of the antibody responses to these multichain synthetic polypeptides that possess repeating antigenic determinants was correlated with the metabolizability of the immunogens or their component determinants.

Contribution of different cell types to the genetic control of immune responses as a function of the chemical nature of the polymeric side chains (poly-L-prolyl and poly-DL-alanyl) of synthetic immunogens

Genetic regulation of immunological responsiveness was studied at the cellular level by comparing the limiting dilutions of immunocompetent cells from spleen, thymus, and bone marrow of high and low responders as a function of the poly-L-prolyl and poly-DL-alanyl side chains of two synthetic polypeptide immunogens. The spleens of immunized and unimmunized high responder DBA/1 mice were found to contain respectively, 18- and 7-fold more limiting precursor cells specific for (Phe, G)-A--L than the spleens of SJL low responder donors. These results, using a synthetic polypeptide built on multichain poly-DL-alanine, confirm the findings reported for polypeptides built on multichain poly-L-proline (1, 2), that there is a direct correlation between immune response potential and the relative number of immunocompetent precursors stimulated. Cell cooperation between thymocytes and bone marrow cells was demonstrated for both (T, G)-Pro--L and (Phe, G)-A--L. Limiting dilutions of thymus and bone marrow cells in the presence of an excess amount of the complementary cell type indicated an eightfold lower number of detected (T, G)-Pro--L-specific precursors in DBA/1 (low responder) marrow when compared with SJL (high responder) marrow. No differences were observed in the frequency of relevant high and low responder thymocytes for the (T, G)-Pro--L immunogen. These results are similar to those reported for the (Phe, G)-Pro--L (3). In contrast to the cellular studies reported for the Pro--L series of immunogens, the marrow and thymus cell dilution experiments for (Phe, G)-A--L revealed genetically associated differences in both the marrow and thymus populations of immunocytes from high (DBA/1) and low (SJL) responders. In addition to a fivefold difference in limiting marrow cell precursors (similar to that seen in the Pro--L studies), a striking difference was observed between the helper cell activity of high responder DBA/1 and low responder SJL thymocytes. This difference was indicated by the observation that low responder thymocyte dilutions followed the predictions of the Poisson model, whereas dilutions of high responder thymocytes did not conform to Poisson statistics. Transfers of allogeneic thymus and marrow cell mixtures from DBA/1 and SJL donors confirmed the syngeneic dilution studies showing that the genetic defect of immune responsiveness to (Phe, G)-A--L is expressed at both the thymus and marrow immunocompetent cell level. The parameters presently known for genetic control of immune responses specific for (Phe, G) (Ir-1 gene) and for Pro--L (Ir-3 gene) have been compared. The Ir-1 and Ir-3 genes are not only distinct by genetic linkage tests (to H-2) (5, 6, 9), but they are also seen to be different by cellular studies. Furthermore, expression of low responsiveness within a given cell population was shown to depend on the chemical structure of the whole immunogenic macromolecule.

Immunologic memory cells of bone marrow origin. Increased burst size of specific immunocyte precursors

Individual immunocompetent precursor cells of (C57BL/10 x C3H)F(1) mouse marrow generate, on transplantation, three to five times more antibody-forming cells localized in recipient spleens during secondary than during primary immune responses. The increased burst size is immunologically specific since antigens of horse and chicken erythrocytes and of Salmonella typhimurium do not cause this effect in marrow cells responsive to sheep red blood cells. Both sensitized and nonsensitized precursors require the helper function of thymus-derived cells and antigen for the final steps of differentiation and maturation. The burst size of primed precursor cells is the same after cooperative interactions with virgin or educated helper cells of thymic origin. The greater potential of these marrow precursors may be attributable to self-replication and migration before differentiation into antibody-forming descendants. In fact, the progeny cells of primed precursor units are distributed among a multiplicity of foci, whereas those of nonimmune precursors are clustered into one focus. The described properties of specifically primed marrow precursors are those underlying immunologic memory. It remains to be established whether memory cells are induced or selected by antigens and whether the thymus plays a role in this process.

Genetic control of bone marrow graft rejection. I. Determinant-specific difference of reactivity in two pairs of inbred mouse strains

Transplantation of 5 x 10(5) DBA/2 (H-2(d)) bone marrow cells into irradiated B10 and 129-strain mice (both H-2(b)) resulted in graft failure in the first recipient strain and in graft take in the second. Transplantation of B10 (H-2(b)) cells into irradiated B10.BR and C3H mice (both H-2(k)) also resulted in failure in the congenic B10.BR recipients and take in the C3H mice. Resistance and susceptibility of B10 and 129-strain animals were specific for given H-2 alleles of donor cells. Transplantation of DBA/2 marrow into (B10 x 129)F(2) mice and of B10 marrow into (B10.BR x C3H)F(1) x C3H backcross mice revealed definite genetic control of the graft-rejection process, presumably at the level of alloantigen recognition. Resistance to allografts, or responder status, was conferred upon segregating mice by dominant alleles of two major independent autosomal loci. The effects of the loci were additive. Conversely, susceptibility to allografts, or nonresponder status, was due to the apparently recessive alleles of both loci. None of the genes was closely linked with the markers tf (tufted) and T (brachyury) of linkage group IX, A(w) (white-bellied agouti) of linkage group V, Sl (steel) of linkage group IV, and c(ch) (chinchilla) and p (pink eye, dilute) of linkage group I. There were suggestions, however, that the regulator genes of marrow graft rejection are either non-H-2 histocompatibility genes or other genetic factors closely linked with them.