Effect of class II antigen matching on renal allograft survival in miniature swine

Chimerism, Transplant Tolerance, and Beyond

The present review discusses current developments in tolerance induction for solid organ transplantation with a particular emphasis on chimerism-based approaches. It explains the basic mechanisms of chimerism-based tolerance and provides an update on ongoing clinical tolerance trials. The concept of "delayed tolerance" is presented, and ongoing preclinical studies in the nonhuman primate setting-including current limitations and hurdles regarding this approach-are illustrated. In addition, a brief overview and update on cell-based tolerogenic clinical trials is provided. In a critical approach, advantages, limitations, and potential implications for the future of these different regimens are discussed.

Why some organ allografts are tolerated better than others: new insights for an old question

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

There is great variability in how different organ allografts respond to the same tolerance induction protocol. Well known examples of this phenomenon include the protolerogenic nature of kidney and liver allografts as opposed to the tolerance-resistance of heart and lung allografts. This suggests there are organ-specific factors which differentially drive the immune response following transplantation.

RECENT FINDINGS

The specific cells or cell products that make one organ allograft more likely to be accepted off immunosuppression than another are largely unknown. However, new insights have been made in this area recently.

SUMMARY

The current review will focus on the organ-intrinsic factors that contribute to the organ-specific differences observed in tolerance induction with a view to developing therapeutic strategies to better prevent organ rejection and promote tolerance induction of all organs.

Survival of Allogeneic Self-Assembled Cultured Skin

BACKGROUND

Deficiency of autologous skin for reconstruction of severe wounds is a major problem in plastic surgery. Autologous substitutes can provide additional coverage, but due to the duration of production, treatment is significantly delayed. The allogeneic approach offers a potential of having an off-the-shelf solution for the immediate application.

METHODS

In this study, we assess the engraftment and immunogenicity of allogeneic bilayered bioengineered skin prepared by a self-assembly method. Bioengineered skin has the potential immunological advantage of lacking passenger leukocytes including antigen-presenting cells. The skin constructs were transplanted across major histocompatibility complex (MHC) barriers in a porcine animal model. Animals received a second grafting of the same skin construct 7 weeks after the first set of grafts together with MHC-matched constructs to assess for clinical sensitization.

RESULTS

All alloconstructs successfully engrafted with histologic evidence of neovascularization by day 4. Complete cellular rejection and tissue loss occurred by day 8 for most grafts. After the second application, accelerated rejection (<4 days) took place with the development of swine MHC-specific cytotoxic alloantibody.

CONCLUSIONS

These data demonstrate preclinically that self-assembled allogeneic constructs engraft and reject similar to allogeneic skin despite the absence of professional donor antigen-presenting cells.

Evaluation of the Miniature Swine for Use in Immunotoxicity Assessment: I. Quantitation of Humoral Responses to Sheep Red Blood Cells and Effects of Cyclophosphamide

T-cell-dependent and t-independent humoral responses as well as cell-mediated re-sponses(1) were assessed with groups of young, Hormel-Hanford miniature swine. Test antigens established in various immunotoxicity studies with rodents were used. Results with the widely used t-dependent test antigen, sheep red blood cells (SRBC), are presented in this report. Groups of swine were immunized with varying dosages of SRBC to evaluate basal responses. Serum antibody titers were estimated by the standardized hemolysin (HLY) visual endpoint (EP) assay and a quantitative spectro-photometric (SP) variation using highly purified immunoglobulin (Ig) M and Ig G standards. The sensitivity of the EP HLY assay is about 0.5-1.0 μg for Ig G anti-SRBC; the SP variation is 10 times more sensitive. Peak responses were obtained 7 days after either the first or second injection for both males and females. Peak responses for females, however, were two to four times greater than those in males. Ig M antibodies had a three times higher specific HLY titer than those in the Ig G class. Use of purified antibody standards in either assay variation permitted conversion of dilution titers to specific amounts of antibody. The latter is a more meaningful parameter for various comparisons in either inter-or intraspecies evaluations in immunotoxicity studies.

To evaluate SRBC as a test antigen, low and intermediate doses of the immunotoxicant, cyclophosphamide, were given i.p. starting 2 days before SRBC injection. Antibody levels were reduced correspondingly to approximately 25 and 60% immunosuppression for the two dose levels in both primary and secondary responses. After 2 weeks of rest, animals recovered from treatment with CP. These studies demonstrate that SRBC immunization can be used in the FDA, Hormel-Hanford miniature swine to evaluate the immunotoxicity potential of chemicals without adjuvants or apparent harmful effects to the animal.

Organ-specific differences in achieving tolerance

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

When it comes to tolerance induction, kidney allografts behave differently from heart allografts that behave differently from lung allografts. Here, we examine how and why different organ allografts respond differently to the same tolerance induction protocol.

RECENT FINDINGS

Allograft tolerance has been achieved in experimental and clinical kidney transplantation. Inducing tolerance in experimental recipients of heart and lung allografts has, however, proven to be more challenging. New protocols being developed in nonhuman primates based on mixed chimerism and cotransplantation of tolerogenic organs may provide mechanistic insights to help overcome these challenges.

SUMMARY

Tolerance induction protocols that are successful in patients transplanted with 'tolerance-prone' organs such as kidneys and livers will most likely not succeed in recipients of 'tolerance-resistant' organs such as hearts and lungs. Separate clinical trials using more robust tolerance protocols will be required to achieve tolerance in heart and lung recipients.

Development of antidonor antibody directed toward non-major histocompatibility complex antigens in tolerant animals

BACKGROUND

The clinical significance of antibodies directed against antigens other than major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens is poorly understood, and there are few large animal models in which such antibodies can be examined. We studied, both retrospectively and prospectively, the development of antibodies to non-MHC antigens in tolerant miniature swine.

METHODS

Our database was assessed for cases of antidonor antibody formation in tolerant animals over the last 20 years. Flow cytometry, absorption assays, and familial analyses for inheritance pattern of the gene(s) potentially responsible for the antibody reactivities were carried out, and an animal determined to be negative for this reactivity was immunized by a skin graft and subcutaneous injections of peripheral blood monocyte cells from an antigen-positive donor.

RESULTS

Sixteen of 469 tolerant animals tested were found to have developed antidonor antibodies. These antibodies were found to be specific for the same, presumably single, non-MHC antigen. Familial analyses indicated that the gene encoding this antigen was expressed in an autosomal-dominant manner in approximately 95% of the herd. In a prospective study, antidonor antibodies with the same specificity as those observed retrospectively were successfully induced in an antigen-negative animal after immunization with peripheral blood monocyte cells.

CONCLUSION

To our knowledge, this is the first report of the development of antibodies to a highly prevalent, non-MHC antigen present on peripheral blood mononuclear cells and developing in tolerant animals without signs of graft dysfunction. Considering the concern often raised by the appearance of antidonor antibodies in transplant recipients, these data could have important implications for clinical transplantation.

Abrogation of renal allograft tolerance in MGH miniature swine: the role of intra-graft and peripheral factors in long-term tolerance

We have previously demonstrated that long-term tolerance (LTT) of an MHC class-I mismatched renal allograft can be achieved with a short course of cyclosporine. In order to examine regulatory mechanisms underlying tolerance in this model, we assessed the contributions of factors within the graft and in the peripheral blood for their relative roles in the maintenance of stable tolerance. Twelve LTT recipients of MHC class-I mismatched primary kidneys were subjected to a treatment consisting of donor-specific transfusion followed by leukapheresis, in order to remove peripheral leukocytes, including putative regulatory T cells (Tregs). Following treatment, 2 controls were followed clinically and 10 animals had the primary graft removed and received a second, donor-MHC-matched kidney. Neither control animal showed evidence of rejection, while 8 of 10 retransplanted animals developed either rejection crisis or full rejection of the second transplant. In vitro assays confirmed that the removed leukocytes were suppressive and that CD4(+) Foxp3(+) Treg reconstitution in blood and kidney grafts correlated with return to normal renal function in animals experiencing transient rejection crises. These data indicate that components of accepted kidney grafts as well as peripheral regulatory components both contribute to the tolerogenic environment required for tolerance of MHC class-I mismatched allotransplants.

Induction of tolerance through mixed chimerism

"Mixed chimerism" refers to a state in which the lymphohematopoietic system of the recipient of allogeneic hematopoietic stem cells comprises a mixture of host and donor cells. This state is usually attained through either bone marrow or mobilized peripheral blood stem cell transplantation. Although numerous treatment regimens have led to transplantation tolerance in mice, the induction of mixed chimerism is currently the only treatment modality that has been successfully extended to large animals and to the clinic. Here we describe and compare the use of mixed chimerism to establish transplantation tolerance in mice, pigs, monkeys, and in the clinic. We also attempt to correlate the mechanisms involved in achieving tolerance with the nature of the tolerance that has resulted in each case.

Tolerance induction: hematopoietic chimerism

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Although numerous experimental models to induce allograft tolerance have been reported, it has been difficult to translate these basic studies to clinical transplantation. However, successful induction of tolerance in HLA-mismatched kidney transplantation has recently been reported. In this review, recent progress in tolerance induction in preclinical (nonhuman primates) and clinical transplantation is summarized.

RECENT FINDINGS

Among many clinical trials to induce renal allograft tolerance, success has so far been achieved only by combining donor bone marrow with organ transplantation. Induction of renal allograft tolerance by transient or durable mixed chimerism has been reported in HLA-matched or mismatched kidney transplant recipients. More recently, renal allograft tolerance by induction of full donor chimerism has also been reported using a more intensified preparative conditioning regimen.

SUMMARY

Durable allograft tolerance has been achieved by induction of hematopoietic chimerism in clinical kidney transplantation, with outstanding long-term results in successful cases. However, these approaches have been associated with higher early complications than are seen following transplantation with conventional immunosuppression. Improvements in the consistency and safety of tolerance induction and extension of successful protocols to other organs will be the next steps in bringing tolerance to a wider range of clinical applications.

Primate models in organ transplantation

Large animal models have long served as the proving grounds for advances in transplantation, bridging the gap between inbred mouse experimentation and human clinical trials. Although a variety of species have been and continue to be used, the emergence of highly targeted biologic- and antibody-based therapies has required models to have a high degree of homology with humans. Thus, the nonhuman primate has become the model of choice in many settings. This article will provide an overview of nonhuman primate models of transplantation. Issues of primate genetics and care will be introduced, and a brief overview of technical aspects for various transplant models will be discussed. Finally, several prominent immunosuppressive and tolerance strategies used in primates will be reviewed.

Animal models for basic and translational research in reconstructive transplantation

Reconstructive transplantation represents a bona fide option for select patients with devastating tissue loss, which could better restore the appearance, anatomy, and function than any other conventional treatment currently available. Despite favorable outcomes, broad clinical application of reconstructive transplantation is limited by the potential side effects of chronic multidrug immunosuppression. Thus, any reconstructive measures to improve these non-life-threatening conditions must address a delicate balance of risks and benefits. Today, several exciting novel therapeutic strategies, such as the implementation of cellular therapies including bone marrow or stem cells that integrate the concepts of immune regulation with those of nerve regeneration, are on the horizon. The development of reliable and reproducible small and large animal models is essential for the study of the unique immunological and biological aspects of vascularized composite allografts and to translate such novel immunoregulatory and tolerance-inducing strategies and therapeutic concepts from the bench to bedside. This review provides an overview of the multitude of small and large animal models that have been particularly designed for basic and translational research related to reconstructive transplantation.

Approaches to avoid immune responses induced by repeated subcutaneous injections of allogeneic umbilical cord tissue-derived cells

BACKGROUND

Cellular treatments for repairing diseased tissues represent a promising clinical strategy. Umbilical cord tissue-derived cells (UTC) are a unique source of cells with a low immunogenic profile and potential for tissue repair. By using UTC from miniature swine, we previously demonstrated that despite their low immunogenic phenotype, UTC could induce an immune response under certain inflammatory conditions and after multiple subcutaneous (SC) injections. Given that repeat dosing of cells may be necessary to achieve a lasting therapeutic benefit, in this study, we examined approaches to avoid an immune response to multiple SC injections of UTC.

METHODS

By using in vitro and in vivo measures of sensitization to SC cellular injections, we assessed the effects of varying the location of administration site, prolongation of timing between injections, and use of immunosuppressive treatments on repeated cellular injections in Massachusetts General Hospital major histocompatibility complex-defined miniature swine.

RESULTS

Although under normal conditions, a single SC injection of major histocompatibility complex-mismatched UTC did not induce a detectable immune response, multiple SC injections of UTC demonstrated rapid humoral and cell-mediated immune responses. Avoidance of an immune response to repeat SC injection was achieved by concurrent immunosuppression with each dose of UTC.

CONCLUSIONS

UTC and other similar cell types believed to be nonimmunogenic have the potential to induce immune responses under certain conditions. These studies provide important considerations and guidelines for preclinical studies investigating allogeneic cellular therapies.

Composite tissue allotransplantation: hand transplantation and beyond

Recent advances in transplant immunology are shifting the focus from immunosuppression to immunoregulation, making composite tissue allotransplantation with novel and less potent immunosuppressive regimens a possibility. Hand transplantation has been the most frequently performed human composite tissue allotransplantation, with more than 50 upper extremity-based transplants done worldwide. Further research is needed regarding immunomodulating protocols, and careful oversight and individualized screening procedures will be required as patients seeking improved quality of life through human composite tissue allotransplantation come to accept a certain level of risk in these experimental procedures. Still, composite tissue allotransplantation offers to advance transplant medicine and reconstructive surgery.

Function and mode of regulation of endothelial major histocompatibility complex class II

Tissue engineering is a promising approach to implement endothelial cells as a cellular delivery therapy for vascular disease. We and others previously demonstrated that endothelial cells embedded in three-dimensional collagen-based matrices retain their full biosecretory spectrum, enabling them to serve as powerful regulators of vascular diseases. Fascinatingly, matrix embedding of endothelial cells not only allows for their implantation but also seems to provide protection from allo- and xenogeneic-triggered host immune responses. This is not an effect of simple physical shielding but a more fundamental influence of cell-matrix interconnectivity on the cellular immune phenotype. Reduced cytokine-induced levels of costimulatory and adhesion molecules associated with significantly lower expression levels of major histocompatibility class II expression on matrix-embedded human aortic endothelial cells when compared to the same cells cultured on two-dimensional polystyrene coated-tissue culture plates. Strikingly, the entire interferon-gamma-dependent signaling cascade resulting in MHC class II molecule expression is markedly suppressed in endothelial cells grown to confluence within three-dimensional scaffolds. These findings might be of pivotal importance for designing endothelial cell-based therapies in general and might enhance our understanding of the underlying pathophysiology in a broad range of cardiovascular diseases (e.g., atherosclerosis, vasculitis, chronic allograft vasculopathy).

Inhibition of humoral response to allogeneic porcine mesenchymal stem cell with 12 days of tacrolimus

BACKGROUND

In vivo studies have highlighted allogeneic mesenchymal stem-cell (MSC) immunogenicity. We investigated in vitro MSC-immunosuppressive drugs interaction and further tested in vivo the humoral response to intracardiac allogeneic MSC transplantation in a mini-swine model receiving a short course of immunosuppression.

METHODS

For in vitro experiments, long-term culture MSCs were used. Immunosuppressive drugs tested were mycophenolate mofetil, cyclosporin, tacrolimus (TAC), sirolimus (SIR), and everolimus. Cell proliferation/viability was assessed on day 7. For each drug, the C50 was determined, and the agonistic effect between immunosuppressive drugs and MSCs on alloreactivity was measured in proliferation assay of MSC-peripheral blood mononuclear cell cultures. For in vivo experiments, one-haplotype swine leukocyte antigen class I and II mismatch (n=11) were used. Allogeneic MSCs were transplanted into ischemic myocardium. TAC was administered 12 days. Donor-specific antibody response was assessed by flow cytometry and complement-mediated cytotoxicity assay.

RESULTS

All drugs except TAC significantly decreased cell proliferation (from 17% to 62%). In MSC-peripheral blood mononuclear cell co-culture assay, MSCs' immunomodulatory properties were maintained when TAC or SIR were used. In vivo experiments showed that only 2 of 11 animals under TAC developed donor-specific antibodies. Importantly, sera from those two animals did not elicit a complement-mediated cytotoxic response.

CONCLUSIONS

Immunosuppressive drugs significantly affect proliferation and viability of MSCs, but neither TAC nor SIR had a detrimental impact on MSCs' immunomodulatory properties. In this large-animal model, addition of short course of immunosuppression seems to overcome the immune response to intracardiac allogeneic MSCs, which was recently demonstrated to occur in the absence of immunosuppression.

Immunogenicity of umbilical cord tissue–derived cells

Umbilical cord tissue provides a unique source of cells with potential for tissue repair. Umbilical cord tissue–derived cells (UTCs) are MHC class I (MHCI) dull and negative for MHC class II (MHCII), but can be activated to increase MHCI and to express MHCII with IFN-γ stimulation. Mesenchymal stem cells with similar characteristics have been inferred to be nonimmunogenic; however, in most cases, immunogenicity was not directly assessed. Using UTC from Massachusetts General Hospital MHC-defined miniature swine, we assessed immunogenicity across a full MHC barrier. Immunogenicity was assessed by in vitro assays including mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and flow cytometry to detect serum alloantibody. A single injection of MHC-mismatched unactivated UTCs did not induce a detectable immune response. When injected in an inflamed region, injected repeatedly in the same region or stimulated with IFN-γ prior to injection, UTCs were immunogenic. As clinical cellular repair strategies may involve injection of allogeneic cells into inflamed regions of damaged tissue or repeated doses of cells to achieve the desired benefit, our results on the immunogenicity of these cells in these circumstances may have important implications for optimal success and functional improvement for this cellular treatment strategy for diseased tissues.

Although pig allogeneic mesenchymal stem cells are not immunogenic in vitro, intracardiac injection elicits an immune response in vivo

BACKGROUND

In vitro, mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) have demonstrated a low immunogenic profile. In this study, we tested the immune response to allogeneic MSCs in immunocompetent swines both in vitro and in vivo.

METHODS

Major histocompatibility complex-controlled swine leukocyte antigen (SLA) and SLA were used as donor and recipient, respectively. In vitro, proliferative responses were tested by mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) or cocultures and cytokine profiling by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. In vivo, allogeneic MSCs were injected in cardiac infarcted area (n=3) and compared with subcutaneous injections of either MSCs (n=2) or peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs; n=2). Two additional animals received a skin graft as controls. No immunosuppression was used. Specific antidonor humoral responses were tested by flow cytometry and complement-dependent cytotoxicity assay.

RESULTS

In vitro, either unstimulated MSCs or interferon (IFN)-gamma stimulated MSC failed to elicit a proliferative response (stimulation index: 1.23 vs. 1.12 vs. 36.9 for controls, P<.001). Concomitantly to the absence of proliferation to MSCs, low production of IFN-gamma and interleukin-2 was evidenced in supernatants while the production of Th2 cytokines was comparable to controls. In vivo, all animals receiving skin grafts, subcutaneous PBMCs and intracardiac MSCs injections developed donor-specific cellular and humoral responses (immunoglobulins M and G) with antibody-complement-mediated cytotoxicity. Subcutaneous MSCs injection needed a rechallenge to similarly develop a cytotoxic humoral response.

CONCLUSIONS

Intracardiac allogeneic porcine mesenchymal stem cells elicit an immune response despite their low immunogenic profile in vitro. This result suggests that in vivo characteristics of allogeneic MSCs might differ and emphasizes the importance of pursuing research both in vitro and in vivo.

Is clinical tolerance realistic in the next decade?

Tolerance to allografts would mean a better quality of life and prognosis for transplant patients. Despite the first descriptions of tolerance to alloantigens over 50 years ago, deliberately induced tolerance in the clinic on a wide scale remains a goal that is not quite in reach. However, much progress has been made in understanding tolerance in rodent models and in the few reports of induced or spontaneously occurring tolerance in humans. Here, we review this progress made in the quest to achieve clinical tolerance.

Long-Term Acceptance of Renal Allografts following Prenatal Inoculation with Adult Bone Marrow

BACKGROUND

The aim was to investigate if intravascular in utero injection of adult bone marrow into swine fetuses could lead to macrochimerism and tolerance to the donor.

METHODS

Outbred Yorkshire sows and boars screening negative for MHC allele SLA of MGH miniature swine were bred. A laparotomy was performed on the sows at 50 days gestation to expose the uterus. Bone marrow harvested from SLA miniature swine was T-cell depleted and injected intravascularly into seventeen fetuses. Flow cytometry was performed to detect donor cells (chimerism) in the peripheral blood after birth. Mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) assays were used to assess the response to donor MHC. Previously frozen skin grafts from the bone marrow donor were placed on the offspring from the first litter. Donor-matched renal transplant from SLA donors were performed on chimeric swine, with and without a short 12-day course of cyclosporine, and one nonchimeric littermate.

RESULTS

Nine inoculated offspring demonstrated donor cell chimerism in the peripheral blood and lymphohematopoietic tissues. All animals with detectable chimerism within the first three weeks were consistently nonreactive to donor MHC in vitro. Animals challenged with donor skin grafts displayed prolonged graft survival without producing antidonor antibodies. All chimeric animals accepted donor-matched kidney allografts, even one without cyclosporine. The kidney in the nonchimeric littermate rejected by day 21.

CONCLUSIONS

Transplantation of allogeneic adult bone marrow into immunocompetent fetal recipients resulted in chimerism. In utero inoculation led to operational tolerance to the donor's major histocompatibility antigens and long-term acceptance to organ allografts.

Crossing the bridge: large animal models in translational transplantation research

Many methods for reducing the immunosuppressive requirements of allotransplantation have been proposed based on a growing understanding of physiological and allospecific immunity. As these regimens are developed for clinical application, they require validation in models that are reasonably predictive of their performance in humans. This article provides an overview of the large animal models commonly used to test immunomodulatory organ transplant protocols. The rationale for the use of large animals and the effects of common immunosuppressants in the dog, pig, and non-human primate are reviewed. Promising methods for the induction of allospecific tolerance are surveyed with references to early human trials where appropriate.

Thymectomy impairs but does not uniformly abrogate long-term acceptance of semi-identical liver allograft in inbred miniature Swine temporarily treated with FK506

BACKGROUND

Long-term acceptance of semi-identical orthotopic liver transplants (OLTs) in inbred swine is induced by a 12-day course of FK506. To study whether acceptance is attributable to central or peripheral immune mechanisms, the effect of complete thymectomy was determined.

METHODS

Total thymectomy was performed in 15 swine 3 to 4 weeks before OLT. Twelve of these animals received a 12-day course of FK506 after OLT, and three animals did not receive immunosuppression. Five additional nonthymectomized pigs received OLT and a FK506 regimen. Graft survival, liver function, histology, and cellular and humoral responses were assessed.

RESULTS

Nonthymectomized, FK506-treated animals uniformly showed long-term acceptance of OLT and developed stable donor unresponsiveness. Of the 12 thymectomized, FK506-treated pigs, seven died of non-immunologic causes within 3 postoperative months, and five maintained their OLT for more than 6 months (range 180-450 days). Among these survivors, two developed a complete anti-donor response (mixed lymphocyte reaction [MLR], cell-mediated lymphocytotoxicity [CML], and immunoglobulin [IgG] antibodies) and eventually rejected their OLT at postoperative day 180. The three remaining pigs kept their liver allografts up to 450 days and developed a donor-specific unresponsiveness (a transient anti-donor MLR was observed during the follow-up but never an anti-donor CML or IgG antibodies). All three thymectomized, untreated animals rejected their allografts acutely and displayed a complete anti-donor response (MLR, CML, and IgG antibodies).

CONCLUSIONS

Complete thymectomy before OLT impaired but did not uniformly abrogate long-term acceptance of semi-identical OLT, suggesting that peripheral immune mechanisms may be sufficient to induce long-term acceptance of liver allografts in some recipients.

Preliminary findings in corneal allograft rejection in patients with keratoconus

PURPOSE

Classically, corneal allograft rejection is thought to be a T(H)1-mediated phenomenon. However, T(H)2-mediated allograft rejection has been reported in other transplanted organ systems, including the heart and kidney. We previously reported a form of T(H)2-mediated corneal allograft rejection in a murine model with a T(H)2 immune bias. In this study we sought to determine if there was any evidence for this form of corneal allograft rejection in humans.

DESIGN

Experimental study with an interventional case series.

METHODS

The clinical records of all keratoconus patients undergoing penetrating keratoplasty at the University of Texas, Southwestern Medical Center from 1994 to 1999 were reviewed. Careful attention was paid to a clinical history of atopy. Atopic patients were selected, because these patients have been shown to have a "T(H)2 immune bias." The corneal graft rejection rate in these patients and the number of repeat corneal transplants performed was determined. The experimental group consisted of patients with a clinical history of atopy and keratoconus who had at least one repeat penetrating keratoplasty for an immunologically rejected corneal transplant. Any patient with evidence of primary allograft failure was excluded from this study. Tissue specimens from these patients were embedded in paraffin, serially sectioned, stained with Giemsa stains, and examined histologically. The control group consisted of patients without a clinical history of allergy (and therefore no T(H)2 immune bias) who underwent corneal transplantation for Fuch corneal endothelial dystrophy, or aphakic/pseudophakic bullous keratopathy. Failed grafts from these control patients were also paraffin embedded, serially sectioned, stained, and examined histologically. The human experimental and control corneal specimens were compared with data obtained in a murine model of T(H)2-mediated corneal allograft rejection. Briefly, full-thickness penetrating C57BL/6ByJ corneal allografts were transplanted onto Balb/cByJ and Balb/c-IFN-gamma(tm1Ts) (Balb/c-IFN-gamma knockout) mice. Additionally, full-thickness Balb/cByJ corneal allografts were transplanted onto C57BL/6ByJ and C57BL/6ByJ-IFN-gamma(tm1Ts) mice. Corneal allograft rejection rates and mean rejection times were calculated and compared between wild-type and interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) knockout hosts. The rejected allografts were examined histologically by the same methods used in the human tissue.

RESULTS

There were 84 penetrating keratoplasties performed from 1994 to 1999 for keratoconus. Seven of these 84 patients rejected their corneal grafts. Of the 7 patients who rejected their corneal allografts, 4 had repeat penetrating keratoplasty. Of these 4 repeat corneal allografts, 3 showed eosinophilia when compared with rejected grafts in control patients. Atopic keratoconus patients had a mixed inflammatory cellular infiltrate in the rejected corneal tissue specimen with a significantly greater density of eosinophils (P =.001) compared with patients who did not have a pre-existing T(H)2 bias. The inflammatory infiltrate in these patients without a T(H)2 immune bias was mononuclear. In the murine model, corneal allograft rejection did occur in the absence of IFN-gamma, a critical T(H)1 cytokine in both fully allogeneic donor-host combinations. Histologically, rejection in these ("T(H)2 mice") was characterized by a predominant eosinophilic infiltrate in the rejected graft bed when compared with wild-type animals ("T(H)1 mice") that had a predominantly mononuclear infiltrate in the rejected corneal graft bed.

CONCLUSIONS

Preliminary findings show that corneal allograft rejection in patients with a pre-existing T(H)2 phenotype is similar to what is seen in the murine model of T(H)2-mediated corneal allograft rejection. Based on this small sample, it appears that eosinophils may play a role in corneal allograft rejection in this group of patients. However, further study is necessary to determine the importance of these cells in allograft rejection.

Split tolerance to a composite tissue allograft in a swine model

BACKGROUND

The antigenicity of skin is a major obstacle to expanding human composite tissue transplantation. For example, multiple rejection episodes of the skin have been noted in clinical hand transplant patients. We have previously demonstrated tolerance to vascularized musculoskeletal allografts in major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-matched miniature swine treated with 12 days of cyclosporine. This regimen did not reproducibly lead to tolerance to subsequent frozen donor skin grafts. However, such skin grafts did not have a primary vascular supply. The aim of this study was to determine if tolerance to limb allografts with a vascularized skin component could be achieved with MHC matching and a 12-day course of immunosuppression.

METHODS

Hind limb grafts harvested with a 100 cm(2) cutaneous paddle were transplanted heterotopically into six MHC-matched, minor antigen-mismatched miniature swine. All animals received a 12-day course of cyclosporine. One control animal was not immunosuppressed. Grafts were evaluated with biweekly biopsies and tissue viability determined by histologic analysis. To test for sensitization, frozen donor skin grafts were applied to all animals that survived to postoperative day 100.

RESULTS

All treated animals (n=6) were tolerant to their musculoskeletal allografts at the time of necropsy (>100 days) regardless of the status of the epidermis. One animal demonstrated tolerance to the skin for more than 180 days. The other five animals demonstrated prolonged survival of the epidermal portion of the graft. The control animal rejected the graft epidermis at 10 days postoperatively. Frozen donor skin grafts demonstrated accelerated rejection (<10 days) in three of the animals and led to simultaneous rejection of both the epidermis of the allograft and the skin graft in the long-term tolerant animal. The rejection of the skin grafts did not break tolerance to the musculoskeletal portion in any of the animals.

CONCLUSIONS

All animals exhibited indefinite survival of the musculoskeletal portion of their allografts but only prolonged survival of the epidermis. The loss of the graft skin appears to be the result of an isolated immune reaction to the skin, and, in particular, the epidermis. This observation is further substantiated by the accelerated rejection of secondarily placed frozen donor skin grafts.

MHC Alloantigens Elicit Secondary, But Not Primary, Indirect In Vitro Proliferative Responses

The relative contributions of direct and indirect pathways of allorecognition to graft rejection remain controversial. Recent reports suggest that the indirect pathway may play a prominent role in both acute and chronic allograft rejection. Such studies suggest that MHC-derived allopeptides are more immunogenic than those derived from minor histocompatibility or other nominal Ags. The aim of this study was to characterize the immunogenicity of MHC alloantigens in MHC-defined miniature swine via primary and secondary MLR culture assays. APCs were selectively depleted from either responder or stimulator cell populations to specifically analyze direct and indirect proliferative responses, respectively. Radio-resistant cytokine secretion and subsequent backstimulation of responder cells was eliminated by using stimulators that were either lysed or unresponsive to the responder MHC haplotypes. When the effect of backstimulation was eliminated from MLR culture assays, indirect proliferative responses were not observed among naive responders. Only after in vivo priming of responder animals could indirect proliferation be detected. These data do not refute the potential importance of indirect allorecognition in graft rejection. However, they suggest that MHC-derived alloantigens behave similarly in vitro to minor histocompatibility Ags, with comparable immunogenicity. These data also suggest that the MLR culture assay does not accurately reflect the importance of indirect mechanisms that have previously been reported in experimental models of graft rejection. A greater understanding of the indirect pathway and the associated immunogenicity of MHC allopeptides has the potential benefit of enabling the development of therapeutic interventions to prevent or halt allograft rejection.

Use of CD9 expression to enrich for porcine hematopoietic progenitors

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to develop novel markers for enrichment of hematopoietic progenitors from bone marrow of swine.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We previously showed that pig bone marrow contains a "side population" (SP) of Hoechst dye-effluxing cells that resembles the hematopoietic stem cell (HSC)-containing murine SP and therefore represents a putative pig stem cell population. We screened a panel of monoclonal antibodies for those that allowed positive or negative enrichment of porcine SP cells and tested one of these for enrichment of hematopoietic progenitors in short-term and long-term in vitro assays. We then screened an expression library to clone the gene whose product is recognized by this antibody.

RESULTS

Among a panel of 35 monoclonal lines screened, we found three that were useful for positive enrichment of SP cells and seven for negative enrichment. The 4-6 monoclonal line, allowing around 10-fold negative enrichment of SP cells, recognized the product of the porcine CD9 gene. Hematopoietic progenitors measured by short-term colony-forming unit and long-term cobblestone area-forming cell assays were around 10-fold enriched in the CD9(negative/low) fraction and were significantly depleted in the CD9(high) fraction.

CONCLUSIONS

The antibody against the porcine CD9 gene product may be of use for enrichment of porcine hematopoietic stem cells. This approach to identify novel markers for enrichment of hematopoietic progenitors may be applicable to other mammalian species.

Expression of xenogeneic MHC class II molecules in HLA-DR(+) and -DR(-) cells: influence of retrovirus vector design and cellular context

We recently established that molecular chimeras of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules, created via retroviral transfer of allogeneic class II cDNAs into bone marrow cells (BMCs), alleviated complications associated with mixed BMC chimeras while leading to T cell tolerance to renal grafts sharing the transferred class II. Initially demonstrated for allogeneic transplants in miniature swine, this concept was extended to T-dependent antibody (Ab) responses to xenogeneic antigens (Ags) in the pig --> baboon combination. Successful down-regulation of T cell responses appeared, however, to be contingent on a tight lineage-specific expression of transferred class II molecules. The present studies were, therefore, designed to evaluate the influence of construct design and cellular environment on expression of retrovirally transferred xenogeneic class II cDNAs. Proviral genomes for pig class II SLA-DR expression, differing only at the marker neo(r) or enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) gene, showed increased membrane SLA-DR density on HLA-DR(-) fibroblasts as well as HLA-DR(+), TF-1 erythroleukemia cells. More importantly, HLA-DR(+) human B cell lines, although efficiently transduced with pig DR retroviruses, exhibited unstable surface pig DR. Surface pig DR- B cells, nevertheless, stimulated autologous human T cells pre-sensitized to pig Ags, a proliferation likely occurring through presentation of class II-derived peptides. Collectively, these data suggest that surface expression of transferred class II molecules is not related to the ability of recipient cells to synthesize xenogeneic class II molecules but rather to their Ag processing capacities.

Differential alloreactivity at SLA-DR and -DQ matching in two-way mixed lymphocyte culture

The major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules are heterodimeric cell surface glycoproteins important for antigen presentation to CD4+ T lymphocytes. Class II molecules of the pig MHC, termed SLA, identified so far include DR and DQ. Thus far, functional differences between products of different loci in SLalpha class II have not been well characterized. For detailed research on this issue, SLalpha-DRbeta1 and -DQbeta typings were newly developed by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) of the reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) products. Using this method, several RFLP types were chosen from 13 CSK miniature pigs, and alloreactivities in two-way mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) derived from these pigs were examined by cell proliferation assay using flow cytometry. The responses in MLC varied according to the degree of phenotype difference. In MLC from individuals of the same RFLP type in both SLA-DRbeta1 and -DQbeta, the proliferative responses showed slight reaction indicating that they were not so stimulated by each other. On the other hand, for the RFLP type-mismatching combination, the responses were strong indicating that they recognized each others alloantigens. The reactivity of only the DQbeta mismatching combination was as strong as those of only the DRbeta1 mismatching combination. These data indicate the important role of the DQ as well as DR molecule on alloreactivity in MLC.

Involvement of the direct and indirect pathways of allorecognition in tolerance induction

It is generally accepted that there are two pathways of allorecognition, direct and indirect, that together contribute to allograft rejection. Although it has been suggested that the direct pathway predominates during early acute rejection and that the indirect pathway provides a continuous supply of alloantigen responsible for chronic rejection, the true relative contribution of each pathway to the overall rejection process is still not entirely known. It is clear, however, that any strategies designed to achieve the ultimate goal in transplantation, the induction of tolerance, will need to take into account both pathways. This review seeks to explore the involvement of the direct and indirect pathways of allorecognition on a mechanistic level as it relates to the induction of tolerance. A brief historical perspective is included for each pathway as well as a comprehensive review of the mechanisms felt to be active during tolerance induction.

The pig as a source of cardiac xenografts

The inadequate availability of human donor hearts and other organs has inspired interest in the field of xenotransplantation. Historically, ten attempts to transplant animal hearts into human recipients have been reported. Those who received hearts from nonhuman primates (i.e., baboons and chimpanzees) survived rather longer than did those who received hearts from nonprimates (i.e., sheep and pigs). Nevertheless, current opinion is that the pig is the best candidate as a source of hearts for humans despite the considerable immunologic disparity between the two species. Pigs are available in large numbers and can be bred easily and rapidly. They grow to appropriate sizes and their cardiovascular system is similar to that of humans. Substantial knowledge has been accumulated regarding both genetic engineering and tolerance induction in pigs, two strategies that may help to overcome the existing immunologic barriers. Concern has been raised, however, with regard to the potential for the transfer of a porcine infection with the pig organ to the human recipient. This brief review addresses these and other aspects of the use of the pig as a source of hearts for patients with end-stage cardiac disease.

Induction of transplantation tolerance with a short course of tacrolimus (FK506): I. Rapid and stable tolerance to two-haplotype fully mhc-mismatched kidney allografts in miniature swine

BACKGROUND

Inbred miniature swine provide a large animal model in which the effects of selective major histocompatibility complex (MHC) matching can be reproducibly studied. We have previously demonstrated that although a 12-day course of cyclosporine uniformly induces tolerance to class I-mismatched renal allografts, it does not induce tolerance across full MHC barriers. In this study, we assessed whether and at what dose tacrolimus might permit allografts to induce tolerance across different MHC barriers.

METHODS

Recipients of MHC disparate renal allografts were treated with a 12-day course of tacrolimus by continuous intravenous infusion. Groups were divided as follows: (1) class I-mismatched kidneys with 0.3 mg/kg/day tacrolimus (n=3); (2) fully MHC-mismatched kidneys with 0.3 mg/kg/day tacrolimus (n=2); and (3) fully MHC-mismatched kidneys with 0.12-0.16 mg/kg/day tacrolimus (n=4).

RESULTS

In groups 1 and 2, recipients with tacrolimus levels of 45-80 ng/ml accepted renal allografts long-term with stable renal function. Donor-specific hyporesponsiveness was demonstrated by cell-mediated lymphocytotoxicity and mixed lymphocyte response, and subsequent donor-matched grafts were also accepted, without further immunosuppression (n=4), confirming systemic tolerance. In group 3, recipients that achieved tacrolimus levels of 35 ng/ml (n=2) accepted their grafts without chronic changes, whereas recipients with levels of 20-26 ng/ml (n=2) developed chronic allograft glomerulopathy, suggesting 35 ng/ml as the threshold blood level for tolerance induction. In vitro assays demonstrated that peripheral blood lymphocytes from tolerant animals produced inhibitory cytokines, suggesting the involvement of regulatory mechanisms.

CONCLUSIONS

To our knowledge, this study represents the first demonstration of the induction of transplant tolerance across a two-haplotype full MHC barrier with a short course of immunosuppression in a large animal model. These studies may also have clinical applicability, because the time course required to induce tolerance was sufficiently short that the high drug levels required might be expected to be tolerated clinically with only transient toxicity.

Tolerance to limb tissue allografts between swine matched for major histocompatibility complex antigens

Transplantation of limb tissue allografts would greatly expand the realm of reconstructive surgery. However, the toxicity of chronic immunosuppression has adversely tilted the risk-benefit balance for clinical transplant. In this study, a procedure was sought to achieve host tolerance to limb tissue allografts through matching of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens between donor and host swine using only a 12-day course of cyclosporine. Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) miniature swine were used as a large animal model with defined MHC, and musculoskeletal grafts from the donor hind limb were transplanted heterotopically to the recipient femoral vessels. Allografts from MHC-mismatched donors treated with cyclosporine (n = 4) were rejected in less than 6 weeks by gross inspection and histologic sections. Allografts from MHC-matched, minor antigen mismatched donors not treated with cyclosporine (n = 4) were rejected between 9 and 12 weeks. Allografts from similarly matched donors treated with 12 days of cyclosporine (n = 7) showed no evidence of rejection until sacrifice between 25 and 47 weeks. Thus allograft tolerance was achieved between MHC-matched swine using a limited course of cyclosporine. Demonstration of limb tissue allograft survival in a large animal model without long-term immunosuppression represents an important step toward clinical transplantation.

TOLERANCE TO MUSCULOSKELETAL ALLOGRAFTS WITH TRANSIENT LYMPHOCYTE CHIMERISM IN MINIATURE SWINE1

BACKGROUND

Although transplantation of musculoskeletal allografts in humans is technically feasible, the adverse effects of long-term immunosuppression subject the patient to high risks for correcting a non-life-threatening condition. Achieving immunologic tolerance to musculoskeletal allografts, without the need for chronic immunosuppression, could expand the clinical application of limb tissue allografting. Tolerance to musculoskeletal allografts has been accomplished previously in miniature swine in our laboratory. Although stable, mixed chimerism has been suggested as the mechanism underlying long-term tolerance in a rat limb model, the mechanism of this tolerance induction has not been established. This report explores the possible relationship between hematopoietic chimerism and tolerance to musculoskeletal allografts in swine.

METHODS

Twelve miniature swine underwent vascularized musculoskeletal allograft transplantation from histocompatibility complex (MHC) matched, minor antigen-mismatched donors. Eight animals received a 12-day coprse of cyclosporine, one of which was excluded due to subtherapeutic levels. Four recipients were not immunosuppressed. Serial biopsies to assess graft viability and flow cytometry to assess chimerism were performed. Donor and third-party skin grafts were placed on recipients with surviving allografts greater than 100 days to validate tolerance.

RESULTS

Both groups developed early peripheral chimerism, but this chimerism became undetectable by postoperative day 19 in the cyclosporine group and by day 13 in the control group. Animals receiving cyclosporine developed permanent tolerance to their allografts, whereas those not receiving cyclosporine rejected their allografts in 6-9 weeks. Animals demonstrating tolerance to their bone allografts also demonstrated prolonged donor skin graft survival.

CONCLUSIONS

Induction of tolerance to musculoskeletal allografts can be achieved in the MHC matched swine. Although hematopoietic chimerism is present in the immediate postoperative period, persistent, long-term chimerism does not seem to be necessary for maintenance of such tolerance.

Identification of T-cell epitopes in nonstructural proteins of foot-and-mouth disease virus

Porcine T-cell recognition of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) nonstructural proteins (NSP) was tested using in vitro lymphoproliferative responses. Lymphocytes were obtained from outbred pigs experimentally infected with FMDV. Of the different NSP, polypeptides 3A, 3B, and 3C gave the highest stimulations in the in vitro assays. The use of overlapping synthetic peptides allowed the identification of amino acid regions within these proteins that were efficiently recognized by the lymphocytes. The sequences of some of these antigenic peptides were highly conserved among different FMDV serotypes. They elicited major histocompatibility complex-restricted responses with lymphocytes from pigs infected with either a type C virus or reinfected with a heterologous FMDV. A tandem peptide containing the T-cell peptide 3A[21-35] and the B-cell antigenic site VP1[137-156] also efficiently stimulated lymphocytes from infected animals in vitro. Furthermore, this tandem peptide elicited significant levels of serotype-specific antiviral activity, a result consistent with the induction of anti-FMDV antibodies. Thus, inclusion in the peptide formulation of a T-cell epitope derived from the NSP 3A possessing the capacity to induce T helper activity can allow cooperative induction of anti-FMDV antibodies by B cells.

Strategies for tolerance induction to composite tissue allografts

The emerging field of composite tissue transplantation offers the potential to replace lost tissues from cadaveric sources. Two major obstacles currently limit the future of composite tissue allotransplantation. The first is chronic rejection, attributed to both antibody deposition and cell-mediated destruction of transplanted tissue. The second obstacle is complications associated with the chronic use of immunosuppressive agents. Our laboratory has been investigating several strategies to induce tolerance to limb tissue allografts to provide solutions to many of the current limitations in allotransplantation. Three strategies show promise in the ability to induce tolerance to organ allografts. The first involves genetic matching at the HLA loci followed by a short course of immunosuppression. The second is the application of a "mixed chimerism" regimen followed by transplantation. The third is costimulatory blockade using a short course of monoclonal antibodies, such as anti-CD40 ligand and CTLA4-Ig after transplantation. Inducing a state of tolerance to limb allografts would eliminate the need for chronic immunosuppression and may also prevent the onset of chronic rejection. The ability to induce allograft tolerance would greatly expand the indications for composite tissue transplantation.

Swine composite tissue allotransplant model for preclinical hand transplant studies

Our laboratory previously developed and used an orthotopic radial forelimb osteomyocutaneous flap in the pig as a preclinical composite tissue allograft (CTA) model. To ensure that it mimicked the clinical situation as closely as possible we developed this model taking many immunologic and reconstructive considerations into account. While our original pig CTA model was ideal for studying the methods of preventing skin, muscle, bone, vessel and nerve rejection, and systemic toxicity, it did not include specialized tissues/structures of a joint and digit. Therefore, we were unable to evaluate rejection of these specialized tissues and their functional properties. Recognizing the importance of assessing joint rejection and function in hand transplantation research we developed a new swine forelimb CTA model that included the animal's medial digit. The present study describes the anatomy and the transplantation technique used in this new preclinical CTA model. We transplanted a radial osteomyocutaneous flap that included the medial digit between two size- (17-21 kg) and age- (6-8-week) matched farm pigs. We removed the digit from the recipient pig's forelimb in continuity with a section of the radial bone and replaced it with the same structure transplanted from a donor pig. After transplantation, a full-length cast was placed on the recipient pig's operated limb and changes in flap color, temperature and the presence of edema were monitored continuously for 6 h, and then regularly at predetermined intervals over 4 days. No weight bearing restrictions were placed on the animal's operated limb. After 4 days, the animal was euthanized. Direct visual monitoring of the allograft during 4 days revealed it was viable with no signs of graft failure due to technical complications associated with the transplant procedure. Upon waking from anesthesia, the animal stood and wandered freely about its cage with no apparent difficulty. Based on the animal's high level of activity at this time, we concluded that the procedure caused it minimal morbidity. At 4 days after the operation, early signs of rejection (skin erythema and edema) were observed. By incorporating a digit into our original CTA pig forelimb model we have made it a better model for performing preclinical hand transplant studies. The added advantage of being able to assess methods of preventing rejection in the specialized joint/digital tissues (articular cartilage, digital flexor and extensor systems, the nail complex) and assess long-term function of these structures is important. The fact that the procedure does not cause major morbidity to the animal makes it possible to conduct long-term graft survival and functional studies.

Injection of allogeneic bone marrow cells into the portal vein of swine in utero

The ability to safely manipulate the immune system of the developing fetus carries the hope of effective treatment strategies for certain congenital disorders that can be diagnosed during gestation. One possible intervention is the induction of specific transplantation tolerance to an adult donor who could provide tissue after birth without the need for immunosuppression. Although the introduction of allogeneic stem cells to a developing immune system has been shown to result in hematopoietic chimerism, donor-specific transplantation tolerance has not been demonstrated in a large animal model. In previous reports of in utero stem-cell transplantation, the cells were injected into the fetus by an intraperitoneal route. We sought to improve upon this technique of cell transplantation by developing a method for the safe delivery of allogeneic stem cells directly into the hepatic circulation of fetal swine. In the second phase of our study, we determined if adult allogeneic bone marrow cells delivered to the fetus by this intravascular route could result in result in hematopoietic chimerism and donor-specific transplantation tolerance. A method of successful intravascular injection was designed in which a laparotomy was performed on a sow at midgestation (50-55 days) to administer 1 cc of inoculum into the portal vein of each fetus using transuterine ultrasound guidance and a 25-gauge spinal needle. In one sow, 10 piglets were injected with saline to test safety, and 8 piglets were born. For transplantation of stem cells to the fetuses, donor bone marrow was harvested from a genetically defined miniature swine. In one sow the marrow was injected without T-cell depletion resulting in abortion. In the third sow, the marrow was depleted of T-cells to less than 0.01% using magnetic beads conjugated to anti-CD3 monoclonal antibodies. No chimerism was detected in these offspring. Only in the fourth sow where the T-cell depletion was reduced to about 1% of the cells in the inoculum did one animal demonstrate chimerism. This piglet showed reproducible blood chimerism (0.95% donor cells) detected by flow cytometry measurement of monoclonal antibodies to the donor MHC. In addition, this animal demonstrated hyporesponsiveness to donor lymphocytes in an MLR assay while reacting strongly to third-party stimulator cells. A split-thickness skin graft from the donor was accepted, and a third-party graft was rapidly rejected.

A 12-day course of FK506 allows long-term acceptance of semi-identical liver allograft in inbred miniature swine

BACKGROUND

Spontaneous tolerance to liver allograft has been reported previously in outbred pig models, but the lack of genetic background did not allow to analyze the impact of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) on tolerance induction. A model of semi-identical liver allograft was therefore developed in inbred miniature swine in order to mimic the clinical situation of living related liver transplant (parent into infant) and to study a protocol for inducing tolerance to liver allograft.

METHODS

SLAdd (class Id/d, class IId/d) pigs received orthotopic liver allograft from heterozygous SLAcd (class Ic/d, class IIc/d) miniature swine. Eight animals did not receive immunosuppression. Fourteen SLAdd animals had a 12-day course of FK506 and were divided in two subgroups. In subgroup FK-1, six pigs received a daily intramuscular injection of FK506 at 0.1-0.4 mg/kg, in order to reach daily trough levels between 7 and 20 ng/ml; in subgroup FK-2, eight additional animals received two daily injections of FK506 at 0.05 mg/kg regardless of the daily trough levels. Graft survival, liver biological tests, histology, cellular and humoral immune responses, as well as detection of microchimerism were assessed in all groups.

RESULTS

All untreated animals rejected their allograft and died within 28.1 +/- 9.5 days. These rejector animals developed a significant anti-donor cellular and humoral immune response. No peripheral or lymphoid tissue microchimerism was detected in this group. In contrast, long-term survival was obtained in five FK-treated animals (112, 154, 406, 413, and 440 days), whereas several pigs died with a normal allograft function from either overimmunosuppression or intercurrent causes. All FK-treated pigs developed a specific anti-donor unresponsiveness in both cell mediated lymphocytotoxicity and mixed lymphocyte reaction and did not develop anti-donor alloantibodies. The study of the anti-donor immune response by mixed lymphocyte reaction, during the first postoperative week, demonstrated a specific anti-donor unresponsiveness in the peripheral blood from the first posttransplant day. Although microchimerism was detectable in the peripheral blood for several postoperative weeks (maximum 10 weeks) in FK-treated animals, donor cells or DNA were not detected during the long-term follow-up in peripheral blood or lymphoid tissues.

CONCLUSIONS

Spontaneous tolerance to semi-identical orthotopic liver allograft did not occur, whereas a 12-day course of FK506 allowed long-term graft acceptance. All FK-treated animals developed in vitro signs of specific immune unresponsiveness and transient peripheral microchimerism. The specific anti-donor cellular unresponsiveness occurred on the first postoperative day after surgery and was of long-term duration. The study of the early immunological events in this model could be of major importance regarding clinical living related liver transplantation.

Blockade of CD28-B7, but not CD40-CD154, prevents costimulation of allogeneic porcine and xenogeneic human anti-porcine T cell responses

Despite increasing use of swine in transplantation research, the ability to block costimulation of allogeneic T cell responses has not been demonstrated in swine, and the effects of costimulatory blockade on xenogeneic human anti-porcine T cell responses are also not clear. We have compared the in vitro effects of anti-human CD154 mAb and human CTLA4IgG4 on allogeneic pig T cell responses and xenogeneic human anti-pig T cell responses. Both anti-CD154 mAb and CTLA4IgG4 cross-reacted on pig cells. While anti-CD154 mAb and CTLA4IgG4 both inhibited the primary allogeneic pig MLRs, CTLA4IgG4 (7.88 microg/ml) was considerably more inhibitory than anti-CD154 mAb (100 microg/ml) at optimal doses. Anti-CD154 mAb inhibited the production of IFN-gamma by 75%, but did not inhibit IL-10 production, while CTLA4IgG4 completely inhibited the production of both IFN-gamma and IL-10. In secondary allogeneic pig MLRs, CTLA4IgG4, but not anti-CD154 mAb, induced Ag-specific T cell anergy. CTLAIgG4 completely blocked the indirect pathway of allorecognition, while anti-CD154 mAb blocked the indirect response by approximately 50%. The generation of porcine CTLs was inhibited by CTLA4IgG4, but not by anti-CD154 mAb. Human anti-porcine xenogeneic MLRs were blocked by CTLA4IgG4, but only minimally by anti-CD154 mAb. Finally, CTLA4IgG4 prevented secondary xenogeneic human anti-porcine T cell responses. These data indicate that blockade of the B7-CD28 pathway was more effective than blockade of the CD40-CD154 pathway in inhibiting allogeneic pig T cell responses and xenogeneic human anti-pig T cell responses in vitro. These findings have implications for inhibiting cell-mediated immune responses in pig-to-human xenotransplantation.

Thymic Transplantation Across an MHC Class I Barrier in Swine

Thymic tissue transplantation has been performed previously in adult mice to induce donor-specific tolerance across allogeneic and xenogeneic barriers. We have now attempted to extend this technique to a large animal preclinical model and describe here our initial studies of allogeneic thymic transplantation in miniature swine. Two miniature swine were thymectomized before thymic tissue transplantation, and two remained euthymic. Donor thymic tissue was harvested from SLA class I-mismatched juvenile pigs and placed into recipient sternocephalicus muscle, kidney capsule, and omentum. A 12-day course of cyclosporin A was started on the day of transplantation. Allogeneic thymic engraftment could only be achieved in euthymic and not in thymectomized miniature swine using this treatment regimen. Both nonthymectomized animals showed good graft development, with evidence of thymopoiesis, as indicated by positive CD1 and host-type SLA class I immunoperoxidase staining of immature graft-infiltrating cells. Both animals also demonstrated donor-specific T cell hyporesponsiveness, as measured by MLR and cell-mediated lympholysis. The thymic grafts continued to develop despite the appearance of high levels of anti-donor specific cytotoxic IgG Abs. Thus, thymic tissue transplanted across an SLA class I barrier can engraft and support host thymopoiesis in euthymic miniature swine. The presence of the host thymus was required for engraftment. These data support the potential of thymic transplantation as part of a regimen to induce donor-specific tolerance to xenogeneic organ grafts.

Spontaneous acceptance or rejection of orthotopic liver transplants in outbred and partially inbred miniature swine

BACKGROUND

Results of clinical liver transplantation have shown that rejection and loss of human liver allografts occurs despite immunosuppression. Because genetic disparity and liver immunogenicity remain a matter of controversy, we reexamined the fate of outbred liver allografts without immunosuppression and used partially inbred miniature swine, in which the genetics of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens have been characterized and can be controlled.

METHODS

Orthotopic liver transplantation was performed between pairs of outbred domestic farm pigs and between pairs of inbred miniature swine with genetically defined major histocompatibility (SLA) loci. A passive splenic and vena caval to jugular vein shunt with systemic heparinization prevented hypotension during the anhepatic phase. Immunological responses were monitored by mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC), CML, skin graft rejection, liver biopsies, and serial serum chemistries.

RESULTS

Median survival of technically successful liver allografts between pairs of outbred pigs (n=20) was 38 days and between partially inbred swine matched at the SLA locus (n=17) was 79 days. MLC responsiveness did not correlate with the development of rejection. Five of 20 (25%) outbred pigs and 6 of 17 (35%) MHC matched inbred miniature swine survived more than 100 days. In the long-term survivors, donor, but not third party, MHC matched skin graft survival times were prolonged. In contrast, all SLA-mismatched inbred recipients (n=26) died rapidly from massive liver rejection, with a median survival time of 9 days. In these rejecting animals, the marked MLC responsiveness to donor lymphocytes evident pretransplant diminished rapidly after transplantation, but an undiminished PHA responsiveness and a blunted third party MLC response persisted.

CONCLUSION

The length of survival and the degree and incidence of rejection were similar in outbred pigs and in SLA-matched inbred miniature pigs, indicating that the outbred animals were, therefore, probably closely related and shared relevant genes. However, survival was significantly shortened and liver allograft rejection was accelerated in SLA-mismatched inbred swine. These results indicate that major histocompatibility differences play an important role in the rejection of liver allografts, as is true for other vascularized grafts in the unimmunosuppressed recipient. The development of liver allograft rejection across non-MHC differences is variable and, when present, appears to be a chronic process.

Characterization of a monoclonal anti-porcine CD3 antibody

Partially inbred miniature swine have been developed in this laboratory as a large animal model for studies related to transplantation tolerance and as a source of hematopoietic cells and organs for xenotransplantation. The identification of swine CD3 specific mAbs capable of activating or depleting T cells in vitro and inducing an immunosuppressive state in vivo greatly facilitates studies of the swine immune system, transplantation tolerance and xenotransplantation research. Flow cytometry was used to determine the phenotypic profile of the swine specific mAb 898H2-6-15 (2-6-15). The specificity of 2-6-15 was further defined biochemically by surface labeling and immunoprecipitation. The ability of this mAb to activate pig T cells in vitro was examined by several criteria including proliferation assays, calcium flux analysis and detection of surface CD25 upregulation by fluorescence activated cell sorter (FACS) analysis. Monoclonal antibody 898H2-6-15 is specific for swine CD3 and is capable of inducing proliferation and CD25 upregulation in cultured swine peripheral blood lymphocytes. In addition, it induces calcium flux in purified pig T cells. Surprisingly, in contrast to described antibodies to CD3 in swine and other species, the binding of this antibody to porcine CD3 is dependent on the presence of extracellular calcium. Thus calcium was required in order to immunoprecipitate labeled surface molecules for biochemical analysis and to stain cell surfaces for FACS analysis of swine lymphocytes. In this paper, we describe a new swine CD3 specific mAb, 898H2-6-15 (2-6-15) the characteristics of which make it an extremely useful tool for in vitro and in vivo studies of the swine immune system and xenotransplantation. The availability of swine T cell specific reagents should facilitate the monitoring of swine T cell engraftment and/or release amongst xenogeneic mixed chimeras and thymic transplant recipients as well as provide a means to treat potential GvHD across xenogeneic barriers. We are currently evaluating the in vivo effects of 2-6-15 in the pig.

Relationship Between Chimerism and Tolerance in a Kidney Transplantation Model

The persistence of donor leukocytes in recipients of organ allografts has been associated with long-term graft acceptance. However, it remains unclear whether this peripheral donor cell microchimerism plays an active role in graft acceptance or is simply a consequence of the maintenance of sufficient immunosuppression to avoid rejection. A model of kidney transplantation between swine leukocyte Ag (SLA)-matched miniature swine, in which tolerance can be established with or without immunosuppressive treatment, has been used to study the correlation between donor leukocyte chimerism and kidney graft acceptance. SLA-identical kidney transplants were performed from animals positive for an allelic pig leukocyte Ag to animals negative for this marker. SLA-identical kidney transplant recipients given a 12-day course of cyclosporine (CyA) (n = 3) became tolerant, showing stable serum creatinine levels (1–2 mg/dl) after cessation of CyA treatment. Donor cell chimerism (0.2–0.7%) was present by FACS in all three animals with peak levels detected at 3 wk. Two control animals receiving SLA-identical kidney grafts without CyA also showed stable serum creatinine levels and became tolerant. However, in neither of these animals could donor leukocytes be detected in the peripheral blood beyond 1 wk following transplantation. In one additional control animal, ureteral obstruction occurred at day 10, and was associated with additional peripheral chimerism, presumably related to inflammation rather than to immune status. These results indicate that the persistence of donor cell chimerism is not a requirement for the maintenance of tolerance to organ allografts in this model.

Role of the thymus in transplantation tolerance in miniature swine. III. Surgical manipulation of the thymus interferes with stable induction of tolerance to class I-mismatched renal allografts

BACKGROUND

Previous studies have demonstrated that long-term tolerance of class I mismatched renal allografts in miniature swine is induced by a short course of cyclosporine (CyA), and that a total thymectomy 21 days before transplantation abrogates the induction of stable tolerance. We have now examined the effects of surgical manipulation of the thymus, with or without a reduction in the thymic volume, on the induction of tolerance.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Miniature swine receiving a transplant of a class I-mismatched renal allograft and 12 days of CyA underwent either (1) a partial thymectomy 21 days before kidney transplantation (day -21), (2) serial thymic biopsies (to evaluate the effect of surgical trauma and reduction in volume of the thymus) or serial incisions of the thymus thymus (to evaluate the effect of surgical trauma without changes in thymic volume), (3) a sham thymectomy on day -21, or serial sham thymic surgery on the same POD as the thymic biopsies and incisions (control animals).

RESULTS

Control animals had a stable plasma creatinine, had donor-specific unresponsiveness in cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) assays, had absence of rejection in kidney biopsy specimens, and did not develop anti-donor class I immunoglobulin (Ig)G alloantibodies. Animals undergoing a partial thymectomy on day -21 or serial thymic biopsies showed severe renal dysfunction, histological evidence of rejection in kidney biopsy specimens and anti-donor reactivity in CML assays; all but one animal developed anti-donor class I IgG alloantibodies. Serial incisions of the thymus induced an increase in plasma creatinine and histological rejection in 1 of 3 animals and anti-donor cytotoxic T cells in vitro in all 3 animals.

CONCLUSIONS

A partial thymectomy or serial thymic biopsies markedly interfere with the induction of tolerance to renal allografts. Serial thymic incisions also interfere with the induction of tolerance, but to a lesser degree. These studies may have implications for tolerance-inducing protocols that involve thymic manipulation.

Role of the thymus in transplantation tolerance in miniature swine: II. Effect of steroids and age on the induction of tolerance to class I mismatched renal allografts

BACKGROUND

Recent studies in young (5-7 months) miniature swine have demonstrated that the thymus is involved in the rapid induction of stable tolerance to class I mismatched renal allografts after a 12-day course of Cyclosporine (CyA). Because both steroids and age are known to influence the structure and function of the thymus, we have now studied the effects of these two parameters on tolerance induction in this model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In young swine, the administration of methylprednisolone (MP) during the standard tolerance-inducing regimen (a 12-day course of CyA) produced severe renal dysfunction and acute cellular rejection histologically. However, the renal allografts recovered and were accepted for >100 days with histological evidence of chronic rejection. To test the effect of age, two relatively old swine (55 and 71 months) received transplants of class I mismatched renal allografts and the standard 12-day course of CyA. One animal rejected the allograft acutely on postoperative day 22, and the second also rejected, but more slowly, with manifestations of chronic rejection.

CONCLUSION

These findings suggest that both MP and old age interfere with the induction of stable tolerance in a fashion similar to the previously described effect of thymectomy. These results may have important implications for the mechanism of thymic-dependent tolerance, for the use of steroids in clinical protocols for the induction of allograft tolerance, and for the application of such protocols to adult patients.

Direct and indirect recognition: the role of MHC antigens in graft rejection

In graft rejection, T-cell stimulation by donor APCs and self-APCs (presenting peptides of donor origin) has been called 'direct' and 'indirect' recognition, respectively. Here, Dina Gould and Hugh Auchincloss consider the traditional arguments favoring direct recognition and highlight recent findings suggesting the importance of indirect responses, thereby questioning some of our basic concepts of transplantation immunology.