Gene transfer to synoviocytes: prospects for gene treatment of arthritis

Osteoarthritis gene therapy in 2022

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To assess the present status of gene therapy for osteoarthritis (OA).

RECENT FINDINGS

An expanding list of cDNAs show therapeutic activity when introduced into the joints of animals with experimental models of OA. In vivo delivery with adenovirus or adeno-associated virus is most commonly used for this purpose. The list of encoded products includes cytokines, cytokine antagonists, enzymes, enzyme inhibitors, growth factors and noncoding RNA. Elements of CRISPR-Cas have also been delivered to mouse knees to ablate key genes. Several human trials have been initiated, using transgenes encoding transforming growth factor-β1, interleukin-1 receptor antagonist, interferon-β, the NKX3.2 transcription factor or variant interleukin-10. The first of these, using ex vivo delivery with allogeneic chondrocytes, gained approval in Korea which was subsequently retracted. However, it is undergoing Phase III clinical trials in the United States. The other trials are in Phase I or II. No gene therapy for OA has current marketing approval in any jurisdiction.

SUMMARY

Extensive preclinical data support the use of intra-articular gene therapy for treating OA. Translation is beginning to accelerate and six gene therapeutics are in clinical trials. Importantly, venture capital has begun to flow and at least seven companies are developing products. Significant progress in the future can be expected.

Gene therapy approaches for equine osteoarthritis

With an intrinsically low ability for self-repair, articular cartilage injuries often progress to cartilage loss and joint degeneration resulting in osteoarthritis (OA). Osteoarthritis and the associated articular cartilage changes can be debilitating, resulting in lameness and functional disability both in human and equine patients. While articular cartilage damage plays a central role in the pathogenesis of OA, the contribution of other joint tissues to the pathogenesis of OA has increasingly been recognized thus prompting a whole organ approach for therapeutic strategies. Gene therapy methods have generated significant interest in OA therapy in recent years. These utilize viral or non-viral vectors to deliver therapeutic molecules directly into the joint space with the goal of reprogramming the cells' machinery to secrete high levels of the target protein at the site of injection. Several viral vector-based approaches have demonstrated successful gene transfer with persistent therapeutic levels of transgene expression in the equine joint. As an experimental model, horses represent the pathology of human OA more accurately compared to other animal models. The anatomical and biomechanical similarities between equine and human joints also allow for the use of similar imaging and diagnostic methods as used in humans. In addition, horses experience naturally occurring OA and undergo similar therapies as human patients and, therefore, are a clinically relevant patient population. Thus, further studies utilizing this equine model would not only help advance the field of human OA therapy but also benefit the clinical equine patients with naturally occurring joint disease. In this review, we discuss the advancements in gene therapeutic approaches for the treatment of OA with the horse as a relevant patient population as well as an effective and commonly utilized species as a translational model.

New frontiers of tendon augmentation technology in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine: a concise literature review

Tissue banking programs fail to meet the demand for human organs and tissues for transplantation into patients with congenital defects, injuries, chronic diseases, and end-stage organ failure. Tendons and ligaments are among the most frequently ruptured and/or worn-out body tissues owing to their frequent use, especially in athletes and the elderly population. Surgical repair has remained the mainstay management approach, regardless of scarring and adhesion formation during healing, which then compromises the gliding motion of the joint and reduces the quality of life for patients. Tissue engineering and regenerative medicine approaches, such as tendon augmentation, are promising as they may provide superior outcomes by inducing host-tissue ingrowth and tendon regeneration during degradation, thereby decreasing failure rates and morbidity. However, to date, tendon tissue engineering and regeneration research has been limited and lacks the much-needed human clinical evidence to translate most laboratory augmentation approaches to therapeutics. This narrative review summarizes the current treatment options for various tendon pathologies, future of tendon augmentation, cell therapy, gene therapy, 3D/4D bioprinting, scaffolding, and cell signals.

Gene therapy for bone healing: lessons learned and new approaches

Although gene therapy has its conceptual origins in the treatment of Mendelian disorders, it has potential applications in regenerative medicine, including bone healing. Research into the use of gene therapy for bone healing began in the 1990s. Prior to this period, the highly osteogenic proteins bone morphogenetic protein (BMP)-2 and -7 were cloned, produced in their recombinant forms and approved for clinical use. Despite their promising osteogenic properties, the clinical usefulness of recombinant BMPs is hindered by delivery problems that necessitate their application in vastly supraphysiological amounts. This generates adverse side effects, some of them severe, and raises costs; moreover, the clinical efficacy of the recombinant proteins is modest. Gene delivery offers a potential strategy for overcoming these limitations. Our research has focused on delivering a cDNA encoding human BMP-2, because the recombinant protein is Food and Drug Administration approved and there is a large body of data on its effects in people with broken bones. However, there is also a sizeable literature describing experimental results obtained with other transgenes that may directly or indirectly promote bone formation. Data from experiments in small animal models confirm that intralesional delivery of BMP-2 cDNA is able to heal defects efficiently and safely while generating transient, local BMP-2 concentrations 2-3 log orders less than those needed by recombinant BMP-2. The next challenge is to translate this information into a clinically expedient technology for bone healing. Our present research focuses on the use of genetically modified, allografted cells and chemically modified messenger RNA.

Orthopaedic Gene Therapy: Twenty-Five Years On

»

Orthopaedics pioneered the expansion of gene therapy beyond its traditional scope of diseases that are caused by rare single-gene defects. Orthopaedic applications of gene therapy are most developed in the areas of arthritis and regenerative medicine, but several additional possibilities exist.

»

Invossa, an ex vivo gene therapeutic for osteoarthritis, was approved in South Korea in 2017, but its approval was retracted in 2019 and remains under appeal; a Phase-III clinical trial of Invossa has restarted in the U.S.

»

There are several additional clinical trials for osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis that could lead to approved gene therapeutics for arthritis.

»

Bone-healing and cartilage repair are additional areas that are attracting considerable research; intervertebral disc degeneration and the healing of ligaments, tendons, and menisci are other applications of interest. Orthopaedic tumors, genetic diseases, and aseptic loosening are additional potential targets.

»

If successful, these endeavors will expand the scope of gene therapy from providing expensive medicines for a few patients to providing affordable medicines for many.

Injectable biomaterials for delivery of interleukin-1 receptor antagonist: Toward improving its therapeutic effect

Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra) is a naturally occurring anti-inflammatory cytokine that inhibits IL-1 activity and has been proposed to treat a wide variety of systemic and local inflammatory pathologies for multiple decades. However, the short half-life and high concentration required to inhibit IL-1 activity has limited its use in clinical applications. Many strategies have been developed with the goal of improving the therapeutic efficacy of IL-1Ra for a variety of pathologies, including fusing IL-1Ra to protein/peptide/polymer partners, releasing IL-1Ra from injectable polymer or mineral particles, and release of IL-1Ra from injectable coacervates and gels. This literature review examines injectable biomaterials engineered to improve IL-1Ra delivery, both locally and systemically, to increase its efficacy and ease of use in clinic. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra) is a therapeutic protein with the potential to treat numerous inflammatory conditions and diseases. However, its short biological half-life and high therapeutic concentration may limit its utility in all but a few clinical scenarios. In this review, we present the biomaterial based delivery strategies which have been explored to deliver IL-1Ra to improve its efficacy and applicability to treat inflammation.

Gene therapy in rheumatoid arthritis: Strategies to select therapeutic genes

Significant advances have been achieved in recent years to ameliorate rheumatoid arthritis (RA) in animal models using gene therapy approaches rather than biological treatments. Although biological agents serve as antirheumatic drugs with suppressing proinflammatory cytokine activities, they are usually accompanied by systemic immune suppression resulting from continuous or high systemic dose injections of biological agents. Therefore, gene transfer approaches have opened an interesting perspective to deliver one or multiple genes in a target-specific or inducible manner for the sustained intra-articular expression of therapeutic products. Accordingly, many studies have focused on gene transferring methods in animal models by using one of the available approaches. In this study, the important strategies used to select effective genes for RA gene therapy have been outlined. Given the work done in this field, the future looks bright for gene therapy as a new method in the clinical treatment of autoimmune diseases such as RA, and by ongoing efforts in this field, we hope to achieve feasible, safe, and effective treatment methods.

Gene Delivery to Joints by Intra-Articular Injection

Most forms of arthritis are incurable, difficult to treat, and a major cause of disability in Western countries. Better local treatment of arthritis is impaired by the pharmacokinetics of the joint that make it very difficult to deliver drugs to joints at sustained, therapeutic concentrations. This is especially true of biologic drugs, such as proteins and RNA, many of which show great promise in preclinical studies. Gene transfer provides a strategy for overcoming this limitation. The basic concept is to deliver cDNAs encoding therapeutic products by direct intra-articular injection, leading to sustained, endogenous synthesis of the gene products within the joint. Proof of concept has been achieved for both in vivo and ex vivo gene delivery using a variety of vectors, genes, and cells in several different animal models. There have been a small number of clinical trials for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and osteoarthritis (OA) using retrovirus vectors for ex vivo gene delivery and adeno-associated virus (AAV) for in vivo delivery. AAV is of particular interest because, unlike other viral vectors, it is able to penetrate deep within articular cartilage and transduce chondrocytes in situ. This property is of particular importance in OA, where changes in chondrocyte metabolism are thought to be fundamental to the pathophysiology of the disease. Authorities in Korea have recently approved the world's first arthritis gene therapy. This targets OA by the injection of allogeneic chondrocytes that have been transduced with a retrovirus carrying transforming growth factor-β₁ cDNA. Phase III studies are scheduled to start in the United States soon. Meanwhile, two additional Phase I trials are listed on Clinicaltrials.gov , both using AAV. One targets RA by transferring interferon-β, and the other targets OA by transferring interleukin-1 receptor antagonist. The field is thus gaining momentum and promises to improve the treatment of these common and debilitating diseases.

MicroRNA-146a suppresses rheumatoid arthritis fibroblast-like synoviocytes proliferation and inflammatory responses by inhibiting the TLR4/NF-kB signaling

This study investigated whether microRNA-146a (miR-146a) mediating TLR4/NF-κB pathway affected proliferation and inflammatory responses of rheumatoid arthritis fibroblast-like synoviocytes from 12 RA patients (RA-FLSs). FLSs in the logarithmic growth phase were assigned into the control, miR-146a mimic miR-146a inhibitor, Tak-242 (treated with TLR4/NF-κB pathway inhibitor) and mimic + lipopolysaccharide (LPS) groups. Cell proliferation and apoptosis were detected using CCK-8 assay and flow cytometry. The expression of miR-146a, TLR4/NF-κB pathway-related proteins and cytokines were determined by RT-qPCR, western blotting and ELISA, and the release of NO by Greiss reaction. RA rat models were constructed and the primary cells were classified into the control, negative control (NC), miR-146a mimic, miR-146a inhibitor, Tak-242, mimic + LPS, and TLR4 groups. Immunohistochemistry was used to detect the expression of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and intercellular adhesion molecular-1 (ICAM-1). The results showed that miR-146a levels were lower in RA-FLSs than control fibroblasts. miR-146a mimic and Tak-242 decreased RA-FLS proliferation and increased RA-FLS apoptosis, while miR-146a inhibitor had an opposite trend. miR-146a mimic and Tak-242 also decreased expression of TLR4, NF-κB, IL-1β, IL-6, IL-8, IL-17, COX-2, MMP-3, Seprase, and iNOS, as well as reduced NO level in RA-FLSs while miR-146a inhibitor and TLR4 increased them. TLR4 and NF-κB levels and the positive rates of PCNA and ICAM-1 expressions were lower in RA-FLSs from RA rats given miR-146a mimic from control or miR-146a inhibitor-treated rats. These results suggest that miR-146a inhibits the proliferation and inflammatory response of RA-FLSs by down-regulating TLR4/NF-κB pathway.

Silencing of Wnt5a prevents interleukin-1β-induced collagen type II degradation in rat chondrocytes

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a joint disease, and few treatments to date have been able to delay OA progression. The degradation of collagen type II (COL2) in the cartilage matrix is an important initiating factor for OA progression; the upregulation of Wnt5a protein activates COL2 degradation. In the present study, small interfering RNA of Wnt-5a was delivered by a lentiviral vector (LV-Wnt5a-RNAi) to silence Wnt-5a mRNA and prevent COL2 degradation. To determine the function of LV-Wnt5a-RNAi, the OA chondrocyte model (OA-like chondrocytes) were constructed using interleukin (IL)-1β. Detected using reverse transcription-quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR), Wnt-5a mRNA in the OA-like chondrocytes were upregulated in a time-dependent manner, indicating that OA-like chondrocytes were successfully constructed. The bioactivity of OA-like chondrocytes was determined using Live-Dead staining, and the result illustrated that the OA-like chondrocytes stimulated with IL-1β for 6 h remained viable, and these were used in Wnt5a silencing. The OA-like chondrocytes were divided into three groups: Group I, cultivated with common medium; group II, cultivated with common medium supplemented with empty lentiviral vector; group III, cultivated with common medium supplemented with LV-Wnt5a-RNAi. The efficiency of LV-Wnt5a-RNAi transfection was determined using fluorescence microscopy, the result of which indicated that LV-Wnt5a-RNAi could efficiently be transfected into the OA-like chondrocytes. The LV-Wnt5a-RNAi efficiency for the Wnt5a mRNA silencing was determined using RT-qPCR. The result illustrated that the mRNA of Wnt5a in group III was significantly lower in group I compared with that in group II (P<0.05), indicating that the LV-Wnt5a-RNAi could successfully silence Wnt5a mRNA. To further verify whether the silencing of Wnt5a mRNA could prevent COL2 degradation, western blotting and immunohistochemical analyses were performed. The results demonstrated that COL2 in group III was significantly higher compared with that in groups I and II (P<0.05), which illustrated that the silencing of Wnt5a mRNA could prevent COL2 degradation. In conclusion, LV-Wnt5a-RNAi was formed successfully and could efficiently silence Wnt5a mRNA expressed by OA-like chondrocytes. In addition, the silencing of Wnt5a mRNA could prevent the degradation of COL2 in OA-like chondrocytes, confirming that LV-Wnt5a-RNAi may be used as a novel tool for OA treatment.

Optimization of a nonviral transfection system to evaluate Cox-2 controlled interleukin-4 expression for osteoarthritis gene therapy in vitro

BACKGROUND

Gene therapy appears to have the potential for achieving a long-term remedy for osteoarthritis (OA). However, there is a risk of adverse reactions, especially when using cytomegalovirus-controlled expression. To provide a safe application, we focused on the expression of therapeutic cytokines [e.g. interleukin (IL)-4] in a disease-responsive manner by use of the previously cloned Cox-2 promoter as 'genetic switch'. In the present study, we report the functionality of a controlled gene therapeutic system in an equine osteoarthritic cell model.

METHODS

Different nonviral transfection reagents were tested for their efficiency on equine chondrocytes stimulated with equine IL-1β or lipopolysaccharide to create an inflammatory environment. To optimize the transfection, we successfully redesigned the vector by excluding the internal ribosomal entry site (IRES). The functionality of our Cox-2 promoter construct with respect to expressing IL-4 was proven at the mRNA and protein levels and the anti-inflammatory potential of IL-4 was confirmed by analyzing the expression of IL-1β, IL-6, IL-8, matrix metalloproteinase (MMP)-1, MMP-3 and tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α using a quantitative polymerase chain reaction.

RESULTS

Nonviral transfection reagents yielded transfection rates from 21% to 44% with control vectors with and without IRES, respectively. Stimulation of equine chondrocytes resulted in a 20-fold increase of mRNA expression of IL-1β. Such exogenous stimulation of chondrocytes transfected with pNCox2-IL4 led to an increase of IL-4 mRNA expression, whereas expression of inflammatory mediators decreased. The timely link between these events confirms the anti-inflammatory potential of synthesized IL-4.

CONCLUSIONS

We consider that this approach has significant potential for translation into a useful anti-inflammation therapy. Molecular tools such as the described therapeutic plasmid pave the way for a local-controlled, self-limiting gene therapy.

Biologics for tendon repair

Tendon injuries are common and present a clinical challenge to orthopedic surgery mainly because these injuries often respond poorly to treatment and require prolonged rehabilitation. Therapeutic options used to repair ruptured tendons have consisted of suture, autografts, allografts, and synthetic prostheses. To date, none of these alternatives has provided a successful long-term solution, and often the restored tendons do not recover their complete strength and functionality. Unfortunately, our understanding of tendon biology lags far behind that of other musculoskeletal tissues, thus impeding the development of new treatment options for tendon conditions. Hence, in this review, after introducing the clinical significance of tendon diseases and the present understanding of tendon biology, we describe and critically assess the current strategies for enhancing tendon repair by biological means. These consist mainly of applying growth factors, stem cells, natural biomaterials and genes, alone or in combination, to the site of tendon damage. A deeper understanding of how tendon tissue and cells operate, combined with practical applications of modern molecular and cellular tools could provide the long awaited breakthrough in designing effective tendon-specific therapeutics and overall improvement of tendon disease management.

Progress in intra-articular therapy

Diarthrodial joints are well suited to intra-articular injection, and the local delivery of therapeutics in this fashion brings several potential advantages to the treatment of a wide range of arthropathies. Possible benefits over systemic delivery include increased bioavailability, reduced systemic exposure, fewer adverse events, and lower total drug costs. Nevertheless, intra-articular therapy is challenging because of the rapid egress of injected materials from the joint space; this elimination is true of both small molecules, which exit via synovial capillaries, and of macromolecules, which are cleared by the lymphatic system. In general, soluble materials have an intra-articular dwell time measured only in hours. Corticosteroids and hyaluronate preparations constitute the mainstay of FDA-approved intra-articular therapeutics. Recombinant proteins, autologous blood products and analgesics have also found clinical use via intra-articular delivery. Several alternative approaches, such as local delivery of cell and gene therapy, as well as the use of microparticles, liposomes, and modified drugs, are in various stages of preclinical development.

Adenovirus-mediated siRNA targeting TNF-α and overexpression of bone morphogenetic protein-2 promotes early osteoblast differentiation on a cell model of Ti particle-induced inflammatory response in vitro

Wear particles are phagocytosed by macrophages and other inflammatory cells, resulting in cellular activation and release of proinflammatory factors, which cause periprosthetic osteolysis and subsequent aseptic loosening, the most common causes of total joint arthroplasty failure. During this pathological process, tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-α) plays an important role in wear-particle-induced osteolysis. In this study, recombination adenovirus (Ad) vectors carrying both target genes [TNF-α small interfering RNA (TNF-α-siRNA) and bone morphogenetic protein 2 (BMP-2)] were synthesized and transfected into RAW264.7 macrophages and pro-osteoblastic MC3T3-E1 cells, respectively. The target gene BMP-2, expressed on pro-osteoblastic MC3T3-E1 cells and silenced by the TNF-α gene on cells, was treated with titanium (Ti) particles that were assessed by real-time PCR and Western blot. We showed that recombinant adenovirus (Ad-siTNFα-BMP-2) can induce osteoblast differentiation when treated with conditioned medium (CM) containing RAW264.7 macrophages challenged with a combination of Ti particles and Ad-siTNFα-BMP-2 (Ti-ad CM) assessed by alkaline phosphatase activity. The receptor activator of nuclear factor-κB ligand was downregulated in pro-osteoblastic MC3T3-E1 cells treated with Ti-ad CM in comparison with conditioned medium of RAW264.7 macrophages challenged with Ti particles (Ti CM). We suggest that Ad-siTNFα-BMP-2 induced osteoblast differentiation and inhibited osteoclastogenesis on a cell model of a Ti particle-induced inflammatory response, which may provide a novel approach for the treatment of periprosthetic osteolysis.

Adenovirus-mediated small interfering RNA targeting tumor necrosis factor-α inhibits titanium particle-induced osteoclastogenesis and bone resorption

Wear particles are phagocytosed by macrophages, resulting in cellular activation and the release of pro-inflammatory factors, which cause periprosthetic osteolysis and subsequent aseptic loosening, the most common causes of total joint arthroplasty (TJA) failure. During this pathological process, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α plays an important role in wear particle-induced osteolysis. Therefore, in this study, we used adenovirus-mediated small interfering RNA (siRNA) targeting TNF-α to suppress the TNF-α release from activated macrophages in response to titanium particles. Our results showed that recombinant adenovirus (Ad-TNF-α-siRNA) suppressed the TNF-α release from activated macrophages in response to titanium particles, and reduced titanium particle-induced osteoclastogenesis and bone resorption in the presence of receptor activator of nuclear factor-κB ligand (RANKL). In addition, the conditioned medium of macrophages challenged with titanium particles (Ti CM) stimulated osteoprogenitor RANKL expression. The conditioned medium of macrophages challenged with titanium particles and Ad-TNF-α-siRNA (Ti-Ad CM) reduced the mRNA expression in MC3T3-E1 cells compared to Ti CM. Based on these data, TNF-α strongly synergizes with RANKL to promote osteoclast differentiation. Furthermore, TNF-α promoted osteoclast differentiation by stimulating osteoprogenitor RANKL expression. Ad-TNF-α-siRNA effectively suppressed osteoclast differentiation and bone resorption following exposure to titanium particles in the presence of RANKL. In addition, recombinant adenovirus (Ad-TNF-α-siRNA) does not have a toxic effect on the murine macrophage cell line, RAW264.7. Consequently, it can be concluded that recombinant adenovirus-mediated siRNA targeting TNF-α (Ad-TNF-α-siRNA) may provide a novel therapeutic approach for the treatment of periprosthetic osteolysis.

Arthritis gene therapy and its tortuous path into the clinic

Arthritis is a disease of joints. The biology of joints makes them very difficult targets for drug delivery in a manner that is specific and selective. This is especially true for proteinaceous drugs ("biologics"). Gene transfer is the only technology that can solve the delivery problem in a clinically reasonable fashion. There is an abundance of preclinical data confirming that genes can be efficiently transferred to tissues within joints by intra-articular injection using a variety of different vectors in conjunction with ex vivo and in vivo strategies. Using the appropriate gene transfer technologies, long-term, intra-articular expression of anti-arthritic transgenes at therapeutic concentrations can be achieved. Numerous studies confirm that gene therapy is effective in treating experimental models of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and osteoarthritis (OA) in the laboratory. A limited number of clinical trials have been completed, which confirm safety and feasibility but only 3 protocols have reached phase II; as yet, there is no unambiguous evidence of efficacy in human disease. Only 2 clinical trials are presently underway, both phase II studies using allogeneic chondrocytes expressing transforming growth factor-β1 for the treatment of OA. Phase I studies using adeno-associated virus to deliver interleukin-1Ra in OA and interferon-β in RA are going through the regulatory process. It is to be hoped that the recent successes in treating rare, Mendelian diseases by gene therapy will lead to accelerated development of genetic treatments for common, non-Mendelian diseases, such as arthritis.

Orthopedic gene therapy--lost in translation?

Orthopedic gene therapy has been the topic of considerable research for two decades. The preclinical data are impressive and many orthopedic conditions are well suited to genetic therapies. But there have been few clinical trials and no FDA-approved product exists. This paper examines why this is so. The reasons are multifactorial. Clinical translation is expensive and difficult to fund by traditional academic routes. Because gene therapy is viewed as unsafe and risky, it does not attract major funding from the pharmaceutical industry. Start-up companies are burdened by the complex intellectual property environment and difficulties in dealing with the technology transfer offices of major universities. Successful translation requires close interactions between scientists, clinicians and experts in regulatory and compliance issues. It is difficult to create such a favorable translational environment. Other promising fields of biological therapy have contemplated similar frustrations approximately 20 years after their founding, so there seem to be more general constraints on translation that are difficult to define. Gene therapy has noted some major clinical successes in recent years, and a sense of optimism is returning to the field. We hope that orthopedic applications will benefit collaterally from this upswing and move expeditiously into advanced clinical trials.

Single intra-articular injection of adeno-associated virus results in stable and controllable in vivo transgene expression in normal rat knees

OBJECTIVE

To test the hypothesis that in vivo transgene expression mediated by single intra-articular injection of adeno-associated virus serotype 2 (AAV2) persists within intra-articular tissues 1 year post-injection and can be externally controlled using an AAV2-based tetracycline-inducible gene regulation system containing the tetracycline response element (TRE) promoter.

METHODS

Sprague Dawley rats received intra-articular injections of AAV2-cytomegalovirus (CMV)-enhanced green fluorescent protein (GFP) and AAV2-CMV-luciferase (Luc) into their right and left knees, respectively. Luciferase expression was evaluated over 1 year using bioluminescence imaging. After sacrifice, tissues were analyzed for GFP+ cells by fluorescent microscopy. To study external control of intra-articular AAV-transgene expression, another set of rats was co-injected with AAV2-TRE-Luc and AAV2-CMV-reverse-tetracycline-controlled transactivator (rtTA) into the right knees, and AAV2-CMV-Luc and AAV2-CMV-rtTA into the left knees. Rats received oral doxycycline (Dox), an analog of tetracycline, for 7 days. Luciferase expression was assessed by bioluminescence imaging.

RESULTS

Luciferase expression was localized to the injected joint and persisted throughout the 1-year study period. Abundant GFP+ cells were observed within intra-articular soft tissues. Transgene expression in AAV2-TRE-Luc injected joints was upregulated by oral administration of Dox, and downregulated following its removal, at 14 days and 13 months post-AAV injection.

CONCLUSIONS

This longitudinal in vivo study shows that sustained and stable AAV-mediated intra-articular transgene expression can be achieved through a single intra-articular injection and can be controlled using a tetracycline-controlled inducible AAV system in a normal rat knee model. Highly regulatable long-term intra-articular transgene expression is of potential clinical utility for development of treatment strategies for chronic intra-articular disease processes such as inflammatory and degenerative arthritis.

Getting arthritis gene therapy into the clinic

Gene transfer technologies enable the controlled, targeted and sustained expression of gene products at precise anatomical locations, such as the joint. In this way, they offer the potential for more-effective, less-expensive treatments of joint diseases with fewer extra-articular adverse effects. A large body of preclinical data confirms the utility of intra-articular gene therapy in animal models of rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis. However, relatively few clinical trials have been conducted, only one of which has completed phase II. This article summarizes the status in 2010 of the clinical development of gene therapy for arthritis, identifies certain constraints to progress and suggests possible solutions.

Clinical responses to gene therapy in joints of two subjects with rheumatoid arthritis

This paper provides the first evidence of a clinical response to gene therapy in human arthritis. Two subjects with rheumatoid arthritis received ex vivo, intraarticular delivery of human interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra) cDNA. To achieve this, autologous synovial fibroblasts were transduced with a retrovirus, MFG-IRAP, carrying IL-1Ra as the transgene, or remained as untransduced controls. Symptomatic metacarpophalangeal (MCP) joints were injected with control or transduced cells. Joints were clinically evaluated on the basis of pain; the circumference of MCP joint 1 was also measured. After 4 weeks, joints underwent surgical synovectomy. There were no adverse events in either subject. The first subject responded dramatically to gene transfer, with a marked and rapid reduction in pain and swelling that lasted for the entire 4 weeks of the study. Remarkably, joints receiving IL-1Ra cDNA were protected from flares that occurred during the study period. Analysis of RNA recovered after synovectomy revealed enhanced expression of IL-1Ra and reduced expression of matrix metalloproteinase-3 and IL-1beta. The second subject also responded with reduced pain and swelling. Thus, gene transfer to human, rheumatoid joints can be accomplished safely to produce clinical benefit, at least in the short term. Using this ex vivo procedure, the transgene persisted within the joint for at least 1 month. Further clinical studies are warranted.

Treatment of knee osteoarthritis with Orthokine-derived autologous conditioned serum

Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most prevalent arthritis in the world with increasing numbers of people expected to acquire the disease as the population ages. Therapies commonly used to manage the disease have limited efficacy and some carry significant risks. Current data suggest that the anti-inflammatory cytokine IL-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra) can alter the inflammatory response and cartilage erosion present in OA. Intra-articular gene expression of IL-1Ra has shown promising results in animal models to provide symptomatic improvement and minimize osteoarthritic changes. Orthogen AG (Dusseldorf, Germany) has developed a method to produce an autologous conditioned serum (ACS) rich in IL-1Ra marketed as Orthokine. Study participants treated with ACS have improved pain and function; however, these results are preliminary and need confirmation. If ongoing trials prove that ACS can retard cartilage degeneration and reduce inflammation, the management of OA would be dramatically altered, perhaps providing a mechanism to prevent the disease or at least its progression.

Use of stem cells in the biological repair of articular cartilage

IMPORTANCE OF THE FIELD

Articular cartilage is avascular, aneural, and renowned for its poor capacity to repair after damage. For decades scientists and clinicians have deliberated over the potential to repair or regenerate articular cartilage and to date many techniques have been used in an attempt to create the best possible repair tissue.

AREAS COVERED IN THIS REVIEW

This review article summarises surgical interventions that have been developed since the late 1940's; covering conservative strategies, invasive techniques and touching upon latest advancements involving stem cells and tissue engineering.

WHAT WILL THE READER GAIN

The reader will gain a sound understanding into the history and background of strategies that have developed in attempts to reverse clinical symptoms of damaged or diseased articular cartilage. The article provides an insight into the plethora of potential repair mechanisms, and reviews future developments involving stem cells and biomaterials.

TAKE HOME MESSAGE

Although work is still in its infancy, the use of stem cells in the biological repair of articular cartilage provides a promising outlook onto future developments; advancing from strategies and techniques that are already in use.

Orthopedic gene therapy in 2008

Orthopedic disorders, although rarely fatal, are the leading cause of morbidity and impose a huge socioeconomic burden. Their prevalence will increase dramatically as populations age and gain weight. Many orthopedic conditions are difficult to treat by conventional means; however, they are good candidates for gene therapy. Clinical trials have already been initiated for arthritis and the aseptic loosening of prosthetic joints, and the development of bone-healing applications is at an advanced, preclinical stage. Other potential uses include the treatment of Mendelian diseases and orthopedic tumors, as well as the repair and regeneration of cartilage, ligaments, and tendons. Many of these goals should be achievable with existing technologies. The main barriers to clinical application are funding and regulatory issues, which in turn reflect major safety concerns and the opinion, in some quarters, that gene therapy should not be applied to nonlethal, nongenetic diseases. For some indications, advances in nongenetic treatments have also diminished enthusiasm. Nevertheless, the preclinical and early clinical data are impressive and provide considerable optimism that gene therapy will provide straightforward, effective solutions to the clinical management of several common debilitating disorders that are otherwise difficult and expensive to treat.

Gene therapy of the rheumatic diseases: 1998 to 2008

During the decade since the launch of Arthritis Research, the application of gene therapy to the rheumatic diseases has experienced the same vicissitudes as the field of gene therapy as a whole. There have been conceptual and technological advances and an increase in the number of clinical trials. However, funding has been unreliable and a small number of high-profile deaths in human trials, including one in an arthritis gene therapy trial, have provided ammunition to skeptics. Nevertheless, steady progress has been made in a number of applications, including rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis, Sjögren syndrome, and lupus. Clinical trials in rheumatoid arthritis have progressed to phase II and have provided the first glimpses of possible efficacy. Two phase I protocols for osteoarthritis are under way. Proof of principle has been demonstrated in animal models of Sjögren syndrome and lupus. For certain indications, the major technological barriers to the development of genetic therapies seem to have been largely overcome. The translational research necessary to turn these advances into effective genetic medicines requires sustained funding and continuity of effort.

Perspectives on the use of gene therapy for chronic joint diseases

Advances in molecular and cellular biology have identified a wide variety of proteins including targeted cytokine inhibitors, immunomodulatory proteins, cytotoxic mediators, angiogenesis inhibitors, and intracellular signalling molecules that could be of great benefit in the treatment of chronic joint diseases, such as osteo- and rheumatoid arthritis. Unfortunately, protein-based drugs are difficult to administer effectively. They have a high rate of turnover, requiring frequent readministration, and exposure in non-diseased tissue can lead to serious side effects. Gene transfer technologies offer methods to enhance the efficacy of protein-based therapies, enabling the body to produce these molecules locally at elevated levels for extended periods. The proof of concept of gene therapies for arthritis has been exhaustively demonstrated in multiple laboratories and in numerous animal models. This review attempts to condense these studies and to discuss the relative benefits and limitations of the methods proposed and to discuss the challenges toward translating these technologies into clinical realities.

Arthritis gene therapy's first death

In July 2007 a subject died while enrolled in an arthritis gene therapy trial. The study was placed on clinical hold while the circumstances surrounding this tragedy were investigated. Early in December 2007 the Food and Drug Administration removed the clinical hold, allowing the study to resume with minor changes to the protocol. In the present article we collate the information we were able to obtain about this clinical trial and discuss it in the wider context of arthritis gene therapy.

Co-expression of IL-18 binding protein and IL-4 regulates Th1/Th2 cytokine response in murine collagen-induced arthritis

We constructed a recombinant adenoviral vector containing a murine interleukin (IL)-18 binding protein (mIL-18BP) and murine IL-4 (mIL-4) fusion gene (AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4) and used a gene therapy approach to investigate the role of IL-18BP and IL-4 in modulating the T-helper1 and T-helper2 (Th1/Th2) balance in mice with collagen-induced arthritis (CIA). Mice with CIA were intra-articularly injected with 107 pfu/6 microl of either AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4, or a control adenovirus, or with the control vehicle (phosphate-buffered saline). After intra-articular gene therapy with AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4, the serum levels of tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), gamma-interferon (IFN-gamma), IL-4, IL-10, and IL-18 in mice with CIA were assessed by ELISA. IFN-gamma-expressing and IL-4-expressing CD4+ T cells from mice splenocytes were monitored by flow cytometry. Mice with CIA at weeks 1, 2, and 4 after intra-articular injection of AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4 showed significantly increased serum concentrations of IL-4 and IL-10 (P<0.01 at all time points) but greatly decreased serum concentrations of IFN-gamma, TNF-alpha, and IL-18 (P<0.01 at all time points) compared to both the control adenovirus and phosphate-buffered saline control groups. The percentage of IFN-gamma-producing CD4+ T cells was significantly decreased in response to local AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4 treatment. The percentage of IL-4-producing CD4+ T cells increased significantly at 1 week after local injection of AdmIL-18BP/mIL-4 then returned to normal by week 4. These data indicated the significant modifying effects on the Th1/Th2 imbalance in murine CIA produced by local overexpression of IL-18BP and IL-4. Combination treatment with IL-18BP and IL-4 is a promising potential therapy for rheumatoid arthritis.

Transgene Persistence and Cell Turnover in the Diarthrodial Joint: Implications for Gene Therapy of Chronic Joint Diseases

Local gene therapy for chronic joint diseases requires prolonged transgenic expression, but this has not been reliably achieved in animal models. Using normal and immunocompromised animals, we examined the capacity of various cell types in joint tissues to maintain and express exogenous transgenes after direct intra-articular gene delivery. We found that transgenic expression could persist for the lifetime of the animal but required precise immunological compatibility between the vector, transgene product, and host. It was not dependent on vector integration or promoter origin. We identified two phenotypically distinct sub-populations of genetically modified cells within the joint: (i) transient cells, with a half-life of a few weeks, and (ii) stable cells that reside in the joint tissues indefinitely. Contrary to the prevailing assumption, the transient sub-population was composed almost exclusively of synovial fibroblasts, indicating that the synovium is not an appropriate tissue upon which to base a long-term therapy. Instead, fibroblasts in the ligaments, tendons, and capsule emerged as the primary cell types capable of sustained therapeutic transgene expression. This study sheds new light on the cellular dynamics of articular tissues and suggests that cell turnover and immune reactivity are the key determinants in achieving sustained transgenic expression intra-articularly.

[Role of gene therapy in trauma and orthopedic surgery]

Mit Hilfe molekularbiologischer und gentechnologischer Methoden kann durch den Transfer von spezifischen Genen das Erbgut einer Zelle verändert werden. Hierdurch werden die Zellfunktionen so moduliert, dass die Zelle, die durch das implantierte Gen verschlüsselte Funktionen erhält, Proteine synthetisiert, die sie normalerweise nicht oder nur in geringen Mengen produziert.

Wie erste tierexperimentelle Studien zeigen, kann die Gentherapie die Heilungs- und Regenerationsfähigkeit der Haut, von Sehnen, Knorpel und Knochen unterstützen und beschleunigen. In jüngster Zeit werden in Tierversuchen neue Vektoren mit einer geringeren Immunogenität und verbesserten Steuerbarkeit sowie einer erhöhten Transfersicherheit getestet. Es ist zu erwarten, dass die Gentherapie in den nächsten Jahrzehnten bei der Frakturheilung, der Sanierung von Knorpelschäden und für die Behandlung von Infektionen einen bedeutenden Stellenwert einnehmen wird.

Evaluation of permissiveness and cytotoxic effects in equine chondrocytes, synovial cells, and stem cells in response to infection with adenovirus 5 vectors for gene delivery

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate host cell permissiveness and cytotoxic effects of recombinant and modified adenoviral vectors in equine chondrocytes, synovial cells, and bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (BMD-MSCs).

SAMPLE POPULATION

Articular cartilage, synovium, and bone marrow from 15 adult horses.

PROCEDURES

Equine chondrocytes, synovial cells, and BMD-MSCs and human carcinoma (HeLa) cells were cultured and infected with an E-1-deficient adenovirus vector encoding the beta-galactosidase gene or the green fluorescent protein gene (Ad-GFP) and with a modified E-1-deficient vector with the arg-gly-asp capsid peptide insertion and containing the GFP gene (Ad-RGD-GFP). Percentages of transduced cells, total and transduced cell counts, and cell viability were assessed 2 and 7 days after infection.

RESULTS

-Permissiveness to adenoviral vector infection was significantly different among cell types and was ranked in decreasing order as follows: HeLa cells > BMD-MSCs > chondrocytes > synovial cells. Morphologic signs of cytotoxicity were evident in HeLa cells but not in equine cells. Numbers of transduced cells decreased by day 7 in all cell types except equine BMD-MSCs. Transduction efficiency was not significantly different between the Ad-GFP and Ad-RGD-GFP vectors.

CONCLUSION AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Sufficient gene transfer may be achieved by use of an adenovirus vector in equine cells. High vector doses can be used in equine cells because of relative resistance to cytotoxic effects in those cells. Greater permissiveness and sustained expression of transgenes in BMD-MSCs make them a preferential cell target for gene therapy in horses.

Regional gene therapy for full-thickness articular cartilage lesions using naked DNA with a collagen matrix

A novel gene therapy approach for treating damaged cartilage is proposed that involves placing endotoxin-free cDNA containing the gene for bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) in type I collagen sponges and then transferring the naked plasmid DNA construct to the injury site. A full-thickness cartilaginous defect in rabbits implanted with plasmid containing a marker gene (beta-galactosidase) showed expressed protein as detected by immunostaining. At 1 week postimplantation, mesenchymal cells subjacent to the defect had incorporated the implanted naked plasmid DNA and, once transfected, served as local bioreactors, transiently producing the gene product. Plasmids containing the gene for BMP-2 implanted in collagen sponges in cartilage lesions stimulated hyalinelike articular cartilage repair at 12 weeks postimplantation, nearly equivalent in quality to that induced by collagen sponges with recombinant BMP-2 protein. Our approach circumvents the risks of inflammation and immunogenic response associated with the use of viral vectors. Naked plasmid DNA as a vehicle for transferring therapeutic genes has been shown to be effective in a therapeutic model within rabbit articular cartilage and appears to be safe and cost effective.

Gene therapy for the treatment of musculoskeletal diseases

Research into the orthopaedic applications of gene therapy has resulted in progress toward managing chronic and acute genetic and nongenetic disorders. Gene therapy for arthritis, the original focus of research, has progressed to the initiation of several phase I clinical trials. Preliminary findings support the application of gene therapy in the treatment of additional chronic conditions, including osteoporosis and aseptic loosening, as well as musculoskeletal tumors. The most rapid progress is likely to be in tissue repair because it requires neither long-term transgene expression nor closely regulated levels of transgene expression. Moreover, healing probably can be achieved with existing technology. In preclinical studies, genetically modulated stimulation of bone healing has shown impressive results in repairing segmental defects in the long bones and cranium and in improving the success of spinal fusions. An increasing amount of evidence indicates that gene transfer can aid the repair of articular cartilage, menisci, intervertebral disks, ligaments, and tendons. These developments have the potential to transform many areas of musculoskeletal care, leading to treatments that are less invasive, more effective, and less expensive than existing modalities.

Gene transfer to human joints: progress toward a gene therapy of arthritis

This article describes the clinical application of gene therapy to a nonlethal disease, rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Intraarticular transfer of IL-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra) cDNA reduces disease in animal models of RA. Whether this procedure is safe and feasible in humans was addressed in a phase I clinical study involving nine postmenopausal women with advanced RA who required unilateral sialastic implant arthroplasty of the 2nd-5th metacarpophalangeal (MCP) joints. Cultures of autologous synovial fibroblasts were established and divided into two. One was transduced with a retrovirus carrying IL-1Ra cDNA; the other provided untransduced, control cells. In a dose escalation, double-blinded fashion, two MCP joints were injected with transduced cells, and two MCP joints received control cells. One week later, injected joints were resected and examined for evidence of successful gene transfer and expression by using RT-PCR, ex vivo production of IL-1Ra, in situ hybridization, and immunohistochemistry. All subjects tolerated the protocol well, without adverse events. Unlike control joints, those receiving transduced cells gave positive RT-PCR signals. Synovia that were recovered from the MCP joints of intermediate and high dose subjects produced elevated amounts of IL-1Ra (P = 0.01). Clusters of cells expressing high levels of IL-1Ra were present on synovia of transduced joints. No adverse events occurred. Thus, it is possible to transfer a potentially therapeutic gene safely to human rheumatoid joints and to obtain intraarticular, transgene expression. This conclusion justifies additional efficacy studies and encourages further development of genetic approaches to the treatment of arthritis and related disorders.

Dual transduction of insulin-like growth factor-I and interleukin-1 receptor antagonist protein controls cartilage degradation in an osteoarthritic culture model

This study evaluated the potential of gene induced synoviocyte expression of a combination of insulin-like growth factor-I (AdIGF-I) and interleukin-1 receptor antagonist protein (AdIL-1Ra) to control articular cartilage degradation in vitro. Cartilage explants and synovial membrane were harvested from young mature horses. Synovial monolayers were established and either (1) maintained as untransduced controls; (2) transduced with AdIGF-I at 200 MOI in 500 microl serum-free medium; (3) transduced with AdIL-1Ra at 100 MOI; or (4) transduced with a combination of AdIGF-I (200 MOI) and AdIL-1Ra (100 MOI). Following transduction, cartilage explants were exposed to the synovial monolayer medium using co-culture inserts. Cultures were maintained for 6 days in either serum-free medium or medium containing 10 ng/ml recombinant human interleukin-1beta. At termination, synovial cell RNA was isolated for real-time PCR analysis, and cartilage explants were collected for H&E and toluidine blue staining, immunohistochemistry for type II collagen and IGF-I, in situ localization of IGF-I and type II collagen gene expression, and biochemical assays. Synovial monolayers were readily transduced with both AdIGF-I and AdIL-1Ra. IGF-I and IL-1Ra protein were secreted at beneficial levels throughout the experiment, having peak concentrations of 94.6 ng/ml and 33.0 ng/ml, respectively. Transduction with IGF-I promoted cartilage production of proteoglycan and type II collagen, suggesting a beneficial role for healing injured cartilage. Transduction with IL-1Ra decreased the synovial expression of IL-1alpha and IL-1beta and matrix metalloproteinases, indicating a mechanism for prevention of matrix degradation. The beneficial effects of the combination of anabolic growth factors and catabolic blockers were evident in improved preservation of proteoglycan content of cartilage explants exposed to the depleting effects of IL-1. These results show that gene therapy combining anabolic growth factors to stimulate matrix synthesis and catabolic blockers to prevent matrix degradation by IL-1, protects and causes partial restoration of cartilage matrix, and suggest a potential benefit of combination gene therapy for cartilage healing.

Novel Biological Approaches to the Intra-Articular Treatment of Osteoarthritis

Osteoarthritis is common, incurable and difficult to treat. Because osteoarthritis is symptomatic only in a limited number of weight-bearing joints and lacks obvious extra-articular manifestations, it is well suited to local therapy administered by intra-articular injection. Several biologically based, local therapies of this type are either in clinical use or in development. Intra-articular injections of hyaluronic acid are widely used, but are highly controversial because their mode of action is unclear and clinical trials have provided contradictory results. The conclusions of meta-analyses are also discordant. An alternative therapy, based on the intra-articular injection of autologous conditioned serum, is used in Europe. This product, known as Orthokine, is generated by incubating venous blood with etched glass beads. In this way, peripheral blood leukocytes produce elevated amounts of the interleukin-1 receptor antagonist and other anti-inflammatory mediators that are recovered in the serum. Considerable symptomatic relief has been reported in clinical trials of this product. Alternatively, instead of injecting a heterogeneous, incompletely characterized mixture of native molecules into the joint, it is possible to inject recombinant growth factors and cytokine antagonists. None of these are in routine clinical use, but promising preliminary human trials have been performed with insulin-like growth factor-1 and the interleukin-1 receptor antagonist. It is possible that sustained intra-articular production of such factors could be achieved by gene transfer. Although gene therapy for osteoarthritis is not yet a clinical reality, the first human trial should begin next year.

The 2003 Nicolas Andry Award. Orthopaedic gene therapy

We review progress in the field of orthopaedic gene therapy since the concept of using gene transfer to address orthopaedic problems was initiated approximately 15 years ago. The original target, arthritis, has been the subject of two successful Phase I clinical trials, and additional human studies are pending in rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis. The repair of damaged musculoskeletal tissues also has proved to be a fruitful area of research, and impressive enhancement of bone healing has been achieved in preclinical models. Rapid progress also is being made in the use of gene transfer to improve cartilage repair, ligament healing, and restoration of various additional tissues, including tendon and meniscus. Other applications include intervertebral disc degeneration, aseptic loosening, osteoporosis, genetic diseases, and orthopaedic tumors. Of these various orthopaedic targets of gene therapy, tissue repair is likely to make the earliest clinical impact because it can be achieved with existing technology. Tissue repair may become one of the earliest clinical successes for gene therapy as a whole. Orthopaedics promises to be a leading discipline for the use of human gene therapy.

Telomerase-transduced osteoarthritic fibroblast-like synoviocyte cell line

To examine whether the life span of fibroblast-like synoviocytes (FLSs) can be extended and to establish FLS cell lines that preserve the characteristics of primary FLSs, we introduced human catalytic subunit of telomerase (hTERT) gene into human osteoarthritic (OA) FLSs. Two hTERT-transduced clonal cell lines were established and one line, hTERT-OA FLS 13A, was characterized. The hTERT-OA FLS 13A cells have a morphology similar to that of the parental untransduced cells and a population-doubling time similar to that of the parental cells of early passages. While the parental untransduced OA FLSs reached senescence after 100 days in culture, the hTERT-OA FLS 13A cells continued to grow at a population-doubling rate of once in about every 2-3 days. The hTERT-OA 13A cells have so far grown in culture beyond 450 days and maintained the same growth rate. Furthermore, the hTERT-OA FLS 13A cells preserved their sensitivity and response to the treatment with basic calcium phosphate crystals and interleukin-1beta. In conclusion, exogenous expression of telomerase represents a way to extend the life span of human FLSs and telomerase-transduced FLS cells offer a promising tool for gene regulation, cell-based assay, cell transplantation-based gene therapy, and tissue engineering research and development.

Suppression of early experimental osteoarthritis by gene transfer of interleukin-1 receptor antagonist and interleukin-10

Gene therapy offers a radically different approach to the treatment of arthritis. We demonstrated that cDNA coding for human interleukin-1 receptor-antagonist protein (IL-1Ra) and cDNA coding for human interleukin-10 (IL-10) can be delivered, by ex vivo techniques, to the synovial lining of joints, intra-articular expression of gene significantly reduced cartilage matrix degradation and cartilage breakdown. To achieve this, lapine synoviocytes were first transduced in culture by retroviral infection. The genetically modified synoviocytes were then transplanted by intra-articular injection into the knee joints of OA rabbits, assay of joint lavages confirmed that the gene expression was not lost 14 days after transfer. Knees receiving the IL-1Ra gene had significantly reduced cartilage breakdown. Delivery of the IL-10 gene was less effective, having only a moderate effect on cartilage breakdown. When both genes were injected together, there was a greater inhibition of cartilage breakdown, suggesting that simultaneous gene delivery may be necessary to treat OA by targeting the activities of multiple inflammatory effectors.

Gene therapy. Therapeutic approaches and implications

The present article is an overview of gene therapy with an emphasis on different approaches and its implications in the clinic. Genetic interventions have been applied to the diagnosis of and therapy for an array of human diseases. The initial concept of gene therapy was focused on the treatment of genetic diseases. Subsequently, the field of gene therapy has been expanded, with a major focus on cancer. Although the results of early gene therapy-based clinical trials have been encouraging, there is a need for gene delivery vectors that feature reduced immunogenicity and improved targeting ability. The results of phases I/II clinical trials have suggested the important role of gene therapy as a versatile and powerful treatment tool, especially for human cancers. One reasonable expectation is that performing gene therapy at an earlier stage in the disease process or for minimal residual disease may be more advantageous.

Osteoarthritis gene therapy

Osteoarthritis (OA) is the Western world's leading cause of disability. It is incurable, costly and responds poorly to treatment. This review discusses strategies for treating OA by gene therapy. As OA affects a limited number of weight-bearing joints and has no major extra-articular manifestations, it is well suited to local, intra-articular gene therapy. Possible intra-articular sites of gene transfer include the synovium and the cartilage. Most experimental progress has been made with gene transfer to synovium, a tissue amenable to genetic modification by a variety of vectors, using both in vivo and ex vivo protocols. The focus so far has been upon the transfer of genes whose products enhance synthesis of the cartilaginous matrix, or inhibit its breakdown, although there is certainly room for alternative targets. It is possible to build a convincing case implicating interleukin-1 (IL-1) as a key mediator of cartilage loss in OA, and the therapeutic effects of IL-1 receptor anatagonist (IL-1Ra) gene transfer have been confirmed in three different experimental models of OA. As transfer of IL-1Ra cDNA to human arthritic joints has already been accomplished safely, we argue that clinical studies of intra-articular IL-1Ra gene transfer in OA are indicated and should be funded. Of the available vector systems, recombinant adeno-associated virus may provide the best combination of safety with in vivo delivery using current technology.

Gene therapies for osteoarthritis

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a major health problem in urgent need of better treatment. Gene therapy offers to meet this need. Of the different strategies for using gene therapy in OA, local gene transfer to synovium is in the most advanced stage of development. Local gene transfer brings several advantages, including a focused, local therapy that promises greater efficacy with reduced side-effects, potentially at far lower cost. Moreover, its clinical feasibility has already been confirmed in two Phase I studies of gene therapy for rheumatoid arthritis. Although there are numerous candidate genes of potential use in treating OA genetically, considerable evidence identifies interleukin-1 (IL-1) as a key target. The existence of a natural antagonist, the IL-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra), provides a means with which to inhibit its biologic actions. Clinical studies are suggested in which IL-1Ra complementary DNA is transferred to knee joints shortly before they are surgically replaced with prostheses. This will permit the ready assessment of the safety and efficiency of gene transfer and expression in the human OA knee, as well as permitting preliminary functional data to be obtained, as a prelude to phase II efficacy studies. At this point, the major barriers to progress are financial rather than intellectual or technical.