Polypeptide specificity of antiviral serum antibodies in children naturally infected with human rotavirus

Non-structural protein NSP2 induces heterotypic antibody responses during primary rotavirus infection and reinfection in children

Rotaviruses are the single most important causes of severe acute diarrhoea in children worldwide. Despite success in developing vaccines, there is still a lack of knowledge about many components of the immune response, particularly those to non-structural proteins. This study established radioimmunoprecipitation (RIP) assays using labeled G1P[8], G2P[4], and G4P[6] human rotaviruses to examine the spectrum and duration of rotavirus antibodies in sera collected sequentially for 18-36 months from 27 children after hospitalization for primary rotavirus gastroenteritis. Five children experienced rotavirus re-infections. Primary responses detected to non-structural protein NSP2 declined to baseline after 100-150 days. Responses were heterotypic between NSP2 of G1P[8] and G4P[8] rotaviruses. Re-infections after 465-786 days boosted antibody levels to NSP2of both serotypes, together with the appearance of anti-NSP2 to G2P[4], even though there was no evidence of infection with this serotype. We developed an enzyme-immunoassay to measure sequential levels of anti-NSP2 IgG and IgA, using recombinant (heterotypic) NSP2 derived from SA11 (G3P[2]). Anti-NSP2 IgG and IgA were detected in sera from 23/23 (100%) and 18/24 (75%) of children after primary infection, declined to baseline after 100-150 days, were boosted after rotavirus re-infections, and again declined to baseline 150 days later. Anti-NSP2 IgA was also detected after primary infection, in duodenal juice from 14/16 (87%), and faecal extract from 11/19 (57%) of children. Sequential estimation of anti-NSP2 EIA levels in sera could be a sensitive index of rotavirus infection and re-infection. The potential of anti-NSP2 to limit viral replication after re-infection deserves further study.

Glycosphingolipid binding specificities of rotavirus: identification of a sialic acid-binding epitope

The glycosphingolipid binding specificities of neuraminidase-sensitive (simian SA11 and bovine NCDV) and neuraminidase-insensitive (bovine UK) rotavirus strains were investigated using the thin-layer chromatogram binding assay. Both triple-layered and double-layered viral particles of SA11, NCDV, and UK bound to nonacid glycosphingolipids, including gangliotetraosylceramide (GA1; also called asialo-GM1) and gangliotriaosylceramide (GA2; also called asialo-GM2). Binding to gangliosides was observed with triple-layered particles but not with double-layered particles. The neuraminidase-sensitive and neuraminidase-insensitive rotavirus strains showed distinct ganglioside binding specificities. All three strains bound to sialylneolactotetraosylceramide and GM2 and GD1a gangliosides. However, NeuAc-GM3 and the GM1 ganglioside were recognized by rotavirus strain UK but not by strains SA11 and NCDV. Conversely, NeuGc-GM3 was bound by rotaviruses SA11 and NCDV but not by rotavirus UK. Thus, neuraminidase-sensitive strains bind to external sialic acid residues in gangliosides, while neuraminidase-insensitive strains recognize gangliosides with internal sialic acids, which are resistant to neuraminidase treatment. By testing a panel of gangliosides with triple-layered particles of SA11 and NCDV, the terminal sequence sialyl-galactose (NeuGc/NeuAcalpha3-Galbeta) was identified as the minimal structural element required for the binding of these strains. The binding of triple-layered particles of SA11 and NCDV to NeuGc-GM3, but not to NeuAc-GM3, suggested that the sequence NeuGcalpha3Galbeta is preferred to NeuAcalpha3Galbeta. Further dissection of this binding epitope showed that the carboxyl group and glycerol side chain of sialic acid played an important role in the binding of such triple-layered particles.

Viral proteins VP2, VP6, and NSP2 are strongly precipitated by serum and fecal antibodies from children with rotavirus symptomatic infection

Rotavirus-specific IgA has been correlated with immune protection against rotavirus reinfection and symptomatic disease. Systemic and mucosal antibody responses were determined by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay in 11 infants with severe rotavirus gastroenteritis. Geometric mean titers of antirotavirus serum IgG and IgA antibodies were significantly higher during the convalescence of the disease (P < 0.001 vs. acute-phase titers). Rotavirus-specific fecal sIgA antibodies increased 4 times during the convalescence in 9 (81.8%) children (P < 0.001). The serum IgG and IgA antibody and fecal sIgA antibody responses to individual rotavirus polypeptides were characterized by radioimmunoprecipitation assay (RIPA) using Staphylococcus aureus protein A and the lectin jacalin to precipitate IgG- and IgA-immune complexes, respectively. The main IgG response was directed toward the structural viral proteins VP2, VP4, and VP6 and toward the nonstructural protein NSP2. Serum IgA reactivity was detected by RIPA in all serum samples, with major responses to VP2, VP6, and NSP2. Interestingly, fecal sIgA in convalescent samples reacted strongly toward NSP2 and VP6. These data reinforce the antigenic importance of rotaviral proteins other than VP4 and VP7, such as VP2, VP6, and NSP2, as main targets in the immune response to rotavirus.

Quantification of systemic and local immune responses to individual rotavirus proteins during rotavirus infection in mice

The purpose of the present study was to develop a quantitative assay that could be used to measure the local and systemic immune responses to specific rotavirus proteins following rotavirus infection of adult mice. To measure these responses, we used an immunocytochemical staining assay of Spodoptera frugiperda (Sf-9) cells which were infected with recombinant baculovirus expressing selected rotavirus proteins. The specificity of the assay was documented by using a series of monoclonal antibodies to individual rotavirus proteins. We observed that the assay had high levels of sensitivity and specificity for a series of VP7- and VP4-specific neutralizing monoclonal antibodies which recognized conformation-dependent epitopes on their target proteins. We also studied immunoglobulin G (IgG) immune responses in serum and IgA immune responses in the stools of mice infected with wild-type murine rotavirus strain EHPw. In both sera and stools, the most immunogenic proteins were VP6 and VP4. VP2 was less immunogenic than VP6 or VP4, and the immune responses to VP7, NSP2, and NSP4 were very low in serum and undetectable in stools.

Homotypic immune response to primary infection with rotavirus serotype G1

Some aspects of rotavirus humoral immunity were assessed on the basis of distinguishing serotype-specific specificities (VP4/VP7) by using rotavirus reassortants, human and animal strains in neutralization assays in serum samples obtained during the acute phase, and 1, 6 and 12 months after primary natural infection. In this study, all the infecting virus strains were characterized as G type and some also as P type. Primary natural infection induces a significantly greater homotypic neutralization response than heterotypic response. In addition, there was no significant difference in the number of homotypic or heterotypic responses following reinfection. Transplacentally acquired homotypic antibodies were associated with protection against dehydration during rotavirus gastroenteritis.

Rotaviruses: immunological determinants of protection against infection and disease

Although studies of rotavirus immunity in experimental animals and humans have often yielded conflicting data, a preponderance of evidence supports the following answers to the questions initially posed. 1. What is the importance of virus serotype in formulating an optimal vaccine? Both vp4 and vp7 induce virus-neutralizing antibodies after either natural infection or immunization; the capacity of vp4 to induce rotavirus-specific neutralizing antibodies is probably greater than that of vp7. However, protection against disease after immunization of infants and young children is induced by strains heterotypic to the challenge virus (e.g., immunization with WC3 induces protection against disease induced by serotypically distinct human G1 strains). In addition, oral inoculation of infants with primate or bovine reassortant rotaviruses containing genes that encode human vp7 has not consistently induced a higher level of protection against challenge than that induced by parent animal rotaviruses (see Table I). Therefore, although vp4 or vp7 or both are probably important in inducing protection against challenge, it has not been clearly demonstrated that inclusion of the epidemiologically important human (as distinct from animal) P or G type is important in protection against human disease. 2. Which immunological effector arm most likely protects against rotavirus disease? No immunological effector arm clearly explains protection against heterotypic challenge. Protection against disease is not predicted by rotavirus-specific neutralizing antibodies in serum. Rotavirus-specific, binding sIgA in feces [detected by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA)] induced after natural infection does correlate with protection against disease induced by subsequent infection. However, protection after immunization with WC3 may occur in the absence of a detectable fecal sIgA response. The relationship between rotavirus-binding sIgA and sIgA-mediated neutralizing activity directed against the challenge virus remains to be determined. Binding rotavirus-specific sIgA in feces detected by ELISA may only be a correlate of other events occurring at the intestinal mucosal surface. The presence of broadly cross-reactive, rotavirus-specific CTLs at the intestinal mucosal surface of mice acutely after infection is intriguing. It would be of interest to determine the degree to which the presence of cross-reactive, rotavirus-specific CTLs in the circulation is predictive of the presence of virus-specific CTLs among intestinal lymphocytes and protection against challenge. Unfortunately, studies of virus-specific CTLs are difficult to perform in children. 3. By what means is virus antigen best presented to the host to elicit a protective immune response? Oral inoculation may not be necessary to induce a protective, virus-specific immune response at the intestinal mucosal surface.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Humoral immune responses to VP4 and its cleavage products VP5* and VP8* in infants vaccinated with rhesus rotavirus

The humoral immune response to rhesus rotavirus (RRV) VP4 and its cleavage products VP5* and VP8* was determined in paired serum samples from 44 infants vaccinated with RRV or human rotavirus-RRV reassortants and 5 placebo recipients. Our aim was to try to measure the response to those regions of VP4 most closely related to protection. An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was used to measure the immunoglobulin G immune response to baculovirus-expressed full-length RRV VP4, full-length VP8*, and the amino-terminal polypeptide of VP5* called VP5*(1) (amino acids 248 to 474). The two antigenic regions of VP4 selected for study, VP5*(1) and VP8*, have previously been shown to contain most of the cross-reactive and strain-specific neutralization epitopes, respectively, while the remaining carboxy-terminal half of VP5* (amino acids 475 to 776) has not been clearly associated with neutralization. All three recombinant proteins were antigenically conserved, since they reacted with a library of neutralizing monoclonal antibodies directed at VP4. There was a high percentage of seroresponders to VP4 (61%) or to VP8* (52%), but fewer infants seroresponded to VP5*(1) (11%). In addition, infants responding to VP5*(1) had considerably lower titers than to VP4 or VP8*. Immune response to VP4 correlated strongly with the responses detected by the plaque reduction neutralization assay but did not correlate with the responses detected by the ELISA to whole RRV. These data imply that the VP5*(1) region is less immunogenic than the VP8* region of VP4 in infants immunized with RRV or RRV reassortants. The low immunogenicity of VP5* might adversely affect the efficacy of RRV vaccine candidates.

Neutralizing serum antibodies to serotype 6 human rotaviruses PA151 and PA169 in Ecuadorian and German children

Serum samples from 726 Ecuadorian children who underwent natural rotavirus (RV) exposure were tested for neutralizing serum antibodies against two serotype 6 (ST6) human RV (HRV) isolates from Italy, PA151 and PA169, and two ST6 bovine RV (BRV) isolates, NCDV and UK. Gene 4 was distinct in all four ST6 strains. Ninety-one, 56, 67, and 65 serum samples neutralized HRV PA151 (13%), HRV PA169 (8%), BRV NCDV (9%), and BRV UK (9%), respectively. A total of 44 of the 91 serum samples which neutralized HRV PA151 did not neutralize the other three ST6 RV strains. In addition, we identified three serum samples that neutralized HRV PA151 but none of the six human or four animal RV STs. However, we failed to identify serum samples that neutralized HRV PA169 without neutralizing at least one of the major HRV STs. With a hospital-based serum collection from German children (excluding gastroenteritis patients), we identified 3 out of 197 serum samples tested that neutralized HRV PA151 specifically, whereas none neutralized HRV PA169 exclusively. None of the 71 German infants hospitalized with primary RV gastroenteritis showed a PA151- or a PA169-specific antibody response.

Isolation and characterization of two distinct human rotavirus strains with G6 specificity

Two new human rotavirus (HRV) strains, PA151 and PA169, with subgroup I specificity and a long RNA pattern, yet with a serotype G (VP7) specificity different from those of any of the six well-established HRV serotypes (G1 to G4, G8, and G9), were isolated 3 months apart from two children with acute gastroenteritis in Sicily, southern Italy, in the winter season of 1987 and 1988. The HRV isolates were adapted to growth in cell cultures and were then characterized by neutralization and RNA-RNA (Northern blot) hybridization. Cross-neutralization studies with type-specific immune sera to RV serotypes 1 to 10 showed the antigenic relatedness of the two strains with serotype 6 bovine strains UK and NCDV. Monoclonal antibodies to VP7 of UK were able to recognize UK and NCDV strains as well as both HRV isolates. Cross-hybridization studies showed a genetic relatedness of PA151 and PA169 to bovine strains for all genes except gene 4. Gene 4 of PA151 appeared to be genetically related to that of AU228 (a human strain of subgroup I and with serotype G3 specificity that belongs to a feline genogroup), whereas gene 4 of PA169 appeared to be unique, yet it was related to gene 4 of two recently reported subgroup I HRV strains, one (PA710) with serotype G3 specificity and the other (HAL1271) with serotype G8 specificity. The new HRV strains must be taken into consideration when deciding strategies for the development of an effective RV vaccine.

Antibodies to seven rotavirus serotypes in cord sera, maternal sera, and colostrum of German women

Forty percent of colostrum samples from German women showed neutralizing antibody titers of greater than or equal to 50 to rotavirus (RV) serotypes 1, 3, 4, and 6. Antibody to serotypes 2, 8, and 9 was less prevalent. Titers are, however, too low to indicate an important effect of colostrum on the RV vaccine take rate. On the other hand, about 50% of the cord serum samples showed high neutralizing-antibody titers to serotypes 1, 3, and 4, which could interfere with the take rate of RV vaccines based on these serotypes in very young infants.

VP4-specific intestinal antibody response to rotavirus in a murine model of heterotypic infection

We have adapted a murine model of heterotypic rotavirus infection for the purpose of evaluating the intestinal antibody response to an infection that mimics human vaccination. Neonatal mice were infected with the rhesus rotavirus (RRV). The enzyme-linked immunospot assay was used in order to avoid common artifacts in the quantitation of intestinal immune responses inherent in measurements of luminal or serum immunoglobulins and to obtain easily quantifiable data in a flexible and convenient format. Functionally active lymphocytes were harvested from the spleen, small intestinal lamina propria, Peyer's patches, and mesenteric lymph nodes and processed into single-cell suspensions. Antibody-secreting cells (ASC) were quantitated from 5 to 50 days after infection for total, RRV-specific, baculovirus-expressed VP4-specific, and single-shell RRV-specific ASC secreting either immunoglobulin G (IgG), IgM, or IgA. The response to VP4 constituted less than 1.5% of the total virus-specific response, which was located almost exclusively in the gut and was 90% IgA. Intestinal ASC were directed overwhelmingly toward proteins incorporated in the single-shell particle, predominantly VP2 and VP6. We conclude that the antibody response to VP4, thought to be the site of the important neutralization sites conserved among several rotavirus serotypes, is an extremely small portion of the overall antibody response in the intestinal tract.

Neutralizing antibodies to heterologous animal rotavirus serotypes 5, 6, 7, and 10 in sera from Ecuadorian children

Serum samples from 870 Ecuadorian children who underwent natural rotavirus exposure were tested for neutralizing serum antibody to heterologous animal rotavirus (RV) serotypes. Six percent of the sera neutralized porcine RV OSU (serotype 5), 10% neutralized bovine RV NCDV (serotype 6), 4% neutralized avian RV Ch-2 (serotype 7), and 8% neutralized bovine RV V1005 (serotype 10). Neutralization was defined as a 90% reduction in infectious virus at a 1:100 serum dilution. The prevalence of antibody to all four heterotypic viruses increased with the age of the children and the number of human RV serotypes neutralized, but prevalences did not differ significantly between children from rural and urban areas of Ecuador. No serum sample that specifically neutralized bovine RV NCDV was identified. We inferred from the seroepidemiological analysis that human RVs contain immunorecessive neutralization epitopes that can stimulate cross-neutralizing antibody to heterotypic animal RVs. This occurs increasingly with age and with the number of human serotypes recognized by a child's neutralizing antibody. Thus, it appears that a broadened immune response to the heterotypic strains occurs with repetitive RV infections.

Prevalence of serum neutralizing antibody to serotype 9 rotavirus WI61 in children from South America and central Europe

Neutralizing serum antibody to serotype 9 rotavirus WI61 was detected in 41% of 870 Ecuadorian children and 26% of 140 German children. In both areas an age-related prevalence increase was observed. We identified 11 serum samples from Ecuadorian children which neutralized exclusively serotype 9 rotavirus. Thirteen of 71 (18%) German children hospitalized with serologically defined primary rotavirus gastroenteritis showed a seroconversion to serotype 9 rotavirus; however, in 10 of these 13 patients, the infecting serotype could be identified as serotype 1, 3, or 4. Furthermore, all 13 patients showed fourfold increases in titer to at least one further serotype.