Role of glutamic acid 177 of the ricin toxin A chain in enzymatic inactivation of ribosomes

Conserved Arginines at the P-Protein Stalk Binding Site and the Active Site Are Critical for Ribosome Interactions of Shiga Toxins but Do Not Contribute to Differences in the Affinity of the A1 Subunits for the Ribosome

The A1 subunits of Shiga toxin 1 (Stx1A1) and Shiga toxin 2 (Stx2A1) interact with the conserved C termini of ribosomal-stalk P-proteins to remove a specific adenine from the sarcin/ricin loop. We previously showed that Stx2A1 has higher affinity for the ribosome and higher catalytic activity than Stx1A1. To determine if conserved arginines at the distal face of the active site contribute to the higher affinity of Stx2A1 for the ribosome, we mutated Arg172, Arg176, and Arg179 in both toxins. We show that Arg172 and Arg176 are more important than Arg179 for the depurination activity and toxicity of Stx1A1 and Stx2A1. Mutation of a single arginine reduced the depurination activity of Stx1A1 more than that of Stx2A1. In contrast, mutation of at least two arginines was necessary to reduce depurination by Stx2A1 to a level similar to that of Stx1A1. R176A and R172A/R176A mutations eliminated interaction of Stx1A1 and Stx2A1 with ribosomes and with the stalk, while mutation of Arg170 at the active site reduced the binding affinity of Stx1A1 and Stx2A1 for the ribosome, but not for the stalk. These results demonstrate that conserved arginines at the distal face of the active site are critical for interactions of Stx1A1 and Stx2A1 with the stalk, while a conserved arginine at the active site is critical for non-stalk-specific interactions with the ribosome. Arginine mutations at either site reduced ribosome interactions of Stx1A1 and Stx2A1 similarly, indicating that conserved arginines are critical for ribosome interactions but do not contribute to the higher affinity of Stx2A1 for the ribosome.

Pokeweed antiviral protein: its cytotoxicity mechanism and applications in plant disease resistance

Pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) is a 29 kDa type I ribosome inactivating protein (RIP) found in pokeweed plants. Pokeweed produces different forms of PAP. This review focuses on the spring form of PAP isolated from Phytolacca americana leaves. PAP exerts its cytotoxicity by removing a specific adenine from the α-sarcin/ricin loop of the large ribosomal RNA. Besides depurination of the rRNA, PAP has additional activities that contribute to its cytotoxicity. The mechanism of PAP cytotoxicity is summarized based on evidence from the analysis of transgenic plants and the yeast model system. PAP was initially found to be anti-viral when it was co-inoculated with plant viruses onto plants. Transgenic plants expressing PAP and non-toxic PAP mutants have displayed broad-spectrum resistance to both viral and fungal infection. The mechanism of PAP-induced disease resistance in transgenic plants is summarized.

Wild type RTA and less toxic variants have distinct requirements for Png1 for their depurination activity and toxicity in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Ricin A chain (RTA) undergoes retrograde trafficking and is postulated to use components of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) associated degradation (ERAD) pathway to enter the cytosol to depurinate ribosomes. However, it is not known how RTA evades degradation by the proteasome after entry into the cytosol. We observed two distinct trafficking patterns among the precursor forms of wild type RTA and nontoxic variants tagged with enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) at their C-termini in yeast. One group, which included wild type RTA, underwent ER-to-vacuole transport, while another group, which included the G83D variant, formed aggregates in the ER and was not transported to the vacuole. Peptide: N-glycanase (Png1), which catalyzes degradation of unfolded glycoproteins in the ERAD pathway affected depurination activity and toxicity of wild type RTA and G83D variant differently. PreG83D variant was deglycosylated by Png1 on the ER membrane, which reduced its depurination activity and toxicity by promoting its degradation. In contrast, wild type preRTA was deglycosylated by the free pool of Png1 in the cytosol, which increased its depurination activity, possibly by preventing its degradation. These results indicate that wild type RTA has a distinct requirement for Png1 compared to the G83D variant and is deglycosylated by Png1 in the cytosol as a possible strategy to avoid degradation by the ERAD pathway to reach the ribosome.

Targeting ricin to the ribosome

The plant toxin ricin is highly toxic for mammalian cells and is of concern for bioterrorism. Ricin belongs to a family of functionally related toxins, collectively referred to as ribosome inactivating proteins (RIPs), which disable ribosomes and halt protein synthesis. Currently there are no specific antidotes against ricin or related RIPs. The catalytic subunit of ricin is an N-glycosidase that depurinates a universally conserved adenine residue within the sarcin/ricin loop (SRL) of the 28S rRNA. This depurination activity inhibits translation and its biochemistry has been intensively studied. Yet, recent developments paint a more complex picture of toxicity, with ribosomal proteins and cellular signaling pathways contributing to the potency of ricin. In particular, several studies have now established the importance of the ribosomal stalk structure in facilitating the depurination activity and ribosome specificity of ricin and other RIPs. This review highlights recent developments defining toxin-ribosome interactions and examines the significance of these interactions for toxicity and therapeutic intervention.

N-glycosylation does not affect the catalytic activity of ricin a chain but stimulates cytotoxicity by promoting its transport out of the endoplasmic reticulum

Ricin A chain (RTA) depurinates the α-sarcin/ricin loop after it undergoes retrograde trafficking to the cytosol. The structural features of RTA involved in intracellular transport are not known. To explore this, we fused enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) to precursor (preRTA-EGFP), containing a 35-residue leader, and mature RTA (matRTA-EGFP). Both were enzymatically active and toxic in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. PreRTA-EGFP was localized in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) initially and was subsequently transported to the vacuole, whereas matRTA-EGFP remained in the cytosol, indicating that ER localization is a prerequisite for vacuole transport. When the two glycosylation sites in RTA were mutated, the mature form was fully active and toxic, suggesting that the mutations do not affect catalytic activity. However, nonglycosylated preRTA-EGFP had reduced toxicity, depurination and delayed vacuole transport, indicating that N-glycosylation affects transport of RTA out of the ER. Point mutations in the C-terminal hydrophobic region restricted RTA to the ER and eliminated toxicity and depurination, indicating that this sequence is critical for ER exit. These results demonstrate that N-glycosylation and the C-terminal hydrophobic region stimulate the toxicity of RTA by promoting ER export. The timing of depurination coincided with the timing of vacuole transport, suggesting that RTA may enter the cytosol during vacuole transport.

Crystal structures of a type-1 ribosome inactivating protein from Momordica balsamina in the bound and unbound states

The ribosome inactivating proteins (RIPs) of type 1 are plant toxins that eliminate adenine base selectively from the single stranded loop of rRNA. We report six crystal structures, type 1 RIP from Momordica balsamina (A), three in complexed states with ribose (B), guanine (C) and adenine (D) and two structures of MbRIP-1 when crystallized with adenosine triphosphate (ATP) (E) and 2'-deoxyadenosine triphosphate (2'-dATP) (F). These were determined at 1.67Å, 1.60Å, 2.20Å, 1.70Å, 2.07Å and 1.90Å resolutions respectively. The structures contained, (A) unbound protein molecule, (B) one protein molecule and one ribose sugar, (C) one protein molecule and one guanine base, (D) one protein molecule and one adenine base, (E) one protein molecule and one ATP-product adenine molecule and (F) one protein molecule and one 2'-dATP-product adenine molecule. Three distinct conformations of the side chain of Tyr70 were observed with (i) χ(1)=-66°and χ(2)=165° in structures (A) and (B); (ii) χ(1)=-95° and χ(2)=70° in structures (C), (D) and (E); and (iii) χ(1)=-163° and χ(2)=87° in structure (F). The conformation of Tyr70 in (F) corresponds to the structure of a conformational intermediate. This is the first structure which demonstrates that the slow conversion of DNA substrates by RIPs can be trapped during crystallization.

Dislocation of ricin toxin A chains in human cells utilizes selective cellular factors

Ricin is a potent A-B toxin that is transported from the cell surface to the cytosol, where it inactivates ribosomes, leading to cell death. Ricin enters cells via endocytosis, where only a minute number of ricin molecules reach the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) lumen. Subsequently, the ricin A chain traverses the ER bilayer by a process referred to as dislocation or retrograde translocation to gain access to the cytosol. To study the molecular processes of ricin A chain dislocation, we have established, for the first time, a human cell system in which enzymatically attenuated ricin toxin A chains (RTA(E177D) and RTA(Δ177-181)) are expressed in the cell and directed to the ER. Using this human cell-based system, we found that ricin A chains underwent a rapid dislocation event that was quite distinct from the dislocation of a canonical ER soluble misfolded protein, null Hong Kong variant of α(1)-antitrypsin. Remarkably, ricin A chain dislocation occurred via a membrane-integrated intermediate and utilized the ER protein SEL1L for transport across the ER bilayer to inhibit protein synthesis. The data support a model in which ricin A chain dislocation occurs via a novel strategy of utilizing the hydrophobic nature of the ER membrane and selective ER components to gain access to the cytosol.

Identification of amino acids critical for the cytotoxicity of Shiga toxin 1 and 2 in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Shiga toxins (Stx1 and Stx2) are produced by E. coli O157:H7, which is a leading cause of foodborne illness. The A subunits of Stx1 (Stx1A) and Stx2 (Stx2A) are ribosome inactivating proteins (RIPs) that inhibit translation by removing an adenine from the highly conserved α-sarcin ricin loop (SRL) of the large rRNA. Here, we used mutagenesis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae to identify residues critical for cytotoxicity of Stx1A and Stx2A. The A subunits depurinated the SRL, inhibited translation and caused apoptotic-like cell death in yeast. Single mutations in Asn75, Tyr77, Glu167 and Arg176 reduced the cytotoxicity of both toxins around 10-fold. However, Asn75 and Tyr77 were more critical for the depurination activity of Stx2A, while Arg176 was more critical for the depurination activity of Stx1A. The crystal structures of the two proteins lack electron density for some surface loops, including one which is adjacent to the active site in both molecules. Modeling these loops changed neither the secondary nor the tertiary structures of the rest of the protein. Analysis of solvent accessible surface areas indicated that Asn75 and Tyr77 are more exposed in Stx2A, while Arg176 is more exposed in Stx1A, indicating that residues with higher surface exposure were more critical for enzymatic activity. Double mutations at Glu167 and Arg176 eliminated the depurination activity and cytotoxicity of both toxins. C-terminal deletions of A chains eliminated cytotoxicity of both toxins, but showed functional differences. Unlike Stx1A, cytotoxicity of Stx2A was lost before its ability to depurinate ribosomes. These results identify residues that affect enzymatic activity and cytotoxicity of Stx1A and Stx2A differently and demonstrate that the function of these residues can be differentiated in yeast. The extent of ribosome depurination and translation inhibition did not correlate with the extent of cell death, indicating that depurination of the SRL and inhibition of translation are not entirely responsible for cell death.

Small-molecule inhibitors of ricin and Shiga toxins

This review summarizes the successes and continuing challenges associated with the identification of small-molecule inhibitors of ricin and Shiga toxins, members of the RNA N-glycosidase family of toxins that irreversibly inactivate eukaryotic ribosomes through the depurination of a conserved adenosine residue within the sarcin-ricin loop (SRL) of 28S rRNA. Virtual screening of chemical libraries has led to the identification of at least three broad classes of small molecules that bind in or near the toxin's active sites and thereby interfere with RNA N-glycosidase activity. Rational design is being used to improve the specific activity and solubility of a number of these compounds. High-throughput cell-based assays have also led to the identification of small molecules that partially, or in some cases, completely protect cells from ricin- and Shiga-toxin-induced death. A number of these recently identified compounds act on cellular proteins associated with intracellular trafficking or pro-inflammatory/cell death pathways, and one was reported to be sufficient to protect mice in a ricin challenge model.

AB toxins: a paradigm switch from deadly to desirable

To ensure their survival, a number of bacterial and plant species have evolved a common strategy to capture energy from other biological systems. Being imperfect pathogens, organisms synthesizing multi-subunit AB toxins are responsible for the mortality of millions of people and animals annually. Vaccination against these organisms and their toxins has proved rather ineffective in providing long-term protection from disease. In response to the debilitating effects of AB toxins on epithelial cells of the digestive mucosa, mechanisms underlying toxin immunomodulation of immune responses have become the focus of increasing experimentation. The results of these studies reveal that AB toxins may have a beneficial application as adjuvants for the enhancement of immune protection against infection and autoimmunity. Here, we examine similarities and differences in the structure and function of bacterial and plant AB toxins that underlie their toxicity and their exceptional properties as immunomodulators for stimulating immune responses against infectious disease and for immune suppression of organ-specific autoimmunity.

The X-ray structure of ricin A chain with a novel inhibitor

Ricin is a potent heterodimeric cytotoxin; the B chain binds eucaryotic cell surfaces aiding uptake and the A chain, RTA, reaches the cytoplasm where it enzymatically depurinates a key ribosomal adenine, inhibiting protein synthesis. Ricin is known to be an agent in bioterrorist repertoires and there is great interest in finding, or creating, efficacious inhibitors of the toxin as potential antidotes. We have previously identified two families of bicyclic RTA inhibitors, pterins and purines. Both classes have poor solubility which impairs inhibitor development. Here we report the use of 2-amino-4,6-dihydroxy-pyrimidines as RTA inhibitors. Unlike previously observed single ring inhibitor platforms, these displace Tyr 80 and bind deep in the RTA specificity pocket. These compounds are at least 10 times more soluble than pterin-based inhibitors and appear to be useful new class of ricin inhibitors.

Invariant Ser211 is involved in the catalysis of PD-L4, type I RIP from Phytolacca dioica leaves

Multiple sequence alignment analysis of ribosome inactivating proteins (RIPs) has revealed the occurrence of an invariant seryl residue in proximity of the catalytic tryptophan. The involvement of this seryl residue in the catalytic mechanism of RIPs was investigated by site-directed mutagenesis in PD-L4, type 1 RIP isolated from Phytolacca dioica leaves. We show that the replacement of Ser211 with Ala apparently does not influence the N-beta-glycosidase activity on ribosomes (determined as IC(50) in a cell-free system), but it reduces the adenine polynucleotide glycosylase activity (APG), assayed spectrophotometrically on other substrates such as DNA, rRNA, and poly(A). The ability of PD-L4 to deadenylate polynucleotides appears more sensitive to the Ser211Ala replacement when poly(A) is used as substrate, as only 33% activity is retained by the mutant, while with more complex and heterogeneous substrates such as DNA and rRNA, its APG activity is 73% and 66%, respectively. While the mutated protein shows a conserved secondary structure by CD, it also exhibits a remarkably enhanced tryptophan fluorescence. This indicates that, although the overall protein tridimensional structure is maintained, removal of the hydroxyl group locally affects the environment of a Trp residue. Modelling and docking analyses confirm the interaction between Ser211 and Trp207, which is located within the active site, thus affecting RIP adenine polynucleotide glycosylase activity. Data accumulated so far confirm the potential involvement of Ser211 in the catalytic mechanism of type 1 RIP PD-L4 and a possible role in stabilizing the conformation of Trp207 side chain, which participates actively in the protein enzymatic activity.

Ricin: current understanding and prospects for an antiricin vaccine

Ricin is a potent cytotoxin that can be rapidly internalized into mammalian cells leading to cell death. The ease in obtaining the toxin and its deadly nature combine to implicate ricin as a convenient agent for bioterrorism. Research into the mechanism of toxicity, as well as strategies for treatment and protection from the toxin has been widely undertaken for a number of years. This article reviews the current understanding of the mechanism of action of the toxin, the clinical effects of ricin intoxication and how these relate to current and continuing prospects for vaccine development.

Vaccines against the category B toxins: Staphylococcal enterotoxin B, epsilon toxin and ricin

The threat of bioterrorism worldwide has accelerated the demand for the development of therapies and vaccines against the Category B toxins: staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB), epsilon toxin (ETX) produced by Clostridium perfringens types B and D, and ricin, a natural product of the castor bean. The diverse and unique nature of these toxins poses a challenge to vaccinologists. While formalin-inactivated toxins can successfully induce antibody-mediated protection in animals, their usefulness in humans is limited because of potential safety concerns. For this reason, research is now aimed at developing recombinant, attenuated vaccines based on a detailed understanding of the molecular mechanisms by which these toxins function. Vaccine development is further complicated by the fact that as bioterrorism agents, SEB, ETX and ricin would most likely be disseminated as aerosols or in food/water supplies. Our understanding of the mechanisms by which these toxins cross mucosal surfaces, and importance of mucosal immunity in preventing toxin uptake is only rudimentary.

Improved stability of a protein vaccine through elimination of a partially unfolded state

Ricin is a potent toxin presenting a threat as a biological weapon. The holotoxin consists of two disulfide-linked polypeptides: an enzymatically active A chain (RTA) and a galactose/N-acetylgalactosamine-binding B chain. Efforts to develop an inactivated version of the A chain as a vaccine have been hampered by limitations of stability and solubility. Previously, recombinant truncated versions of the 267-amino-acid A chain consisting of residues 1-33/44-198 or 1-198 were designed by protein engineering to overcome these limits and were shown to be effective and nontoxic as vaccines in mice. Herein we used CD, dynamic light scattering, fluorescence, and Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy to examine the biophysical properties of these proteins. Although others have found that recombinant RTA (rRTA) adopts a partially unfolded, molten globule-like state at 45 degrees C, rRTA 1-33/44-198 and 1-198 are significantly more thermostable, remaining completely folded at temperatures up to 53 degrees C and 51 degrees C, respectively. Deleting both an exposed loop region (amino acids 34-43) and the C-terminal domain (199-267) contributed to increased thermostability. We found that chemically induced denaturation of rRTA, but not the truncated variants, proceeds through at least a three-state mechanism. The intermediate state in rRTA unfolding has a hydrophobic core accessible to ANS and an unfolded C-terminal domain. Removing the C-terminal domain changed the mechanism of rRTA unfolding, eliminating a tendency to adopt a partially unfolded state. Our results support the conclusion that these derivatives are superior candidates for development as vaccines against ricin and suggest an approach of reduction to minimum essential domains for design of more thermostable recombinant antigens.

The effect of mutations surrounding and within the active site on the catalytic activity of ricin A chain

Models for the binding of the sarcin-ricin loop (SRL) of 28S ribosomal RNA to ricin A chain (RTA) suggest that several surface exposed arginine residues surrounding the active site cleft make important interactions with the RNA substrate. The data presented in this study suggest differing roles for these arginyl residues. Substitution of Arg48 or Arg213 with Ala lowered the activity of RTA 10-fold. Furthermore, substitution of Arg213 with Asp lowered the activity of RTA 100-fold. The crystal structure of this RTA variant showed it to have an unaltered tertiary structure, suggesting that the positively charged state of Arg213 is crucial for activity. Substitution of Arg258 with Ala had no effect on activity, although substitution with Asp lowered activity 10-fold. Substitution of Arg134 prevented expression of folded protein, suggesting a structural role for this residue. Several models have been proposed for the binding of the SRL to the active site of RTA in which the principal difference lies in the conformation of the second 'G' in the target GAGA motif in the 28S rRNA substrate. In one model, the sidechain of Asn122 is proposed to make interactions with this G, whereas another model proposes interactions with Asp75 and Asn78. Site-directed mutagenesis of these residues of RTA favours the first of these models, as substitution of Asn78 with Ser yielded an RTA variant whose activity was essentially wild-type, whereas substitution of Asn122 reduced activity 37.5-fold. Substitution of Asp75 failed to yield significant folded protein, suggesting a structural role for this residue.

Ricin

Ricin is a heterodimeric protein produced in the seeds of the castor oil plant (Ricinus communis). It is exquisitely potent to mammalian cells, being able to fatally disrupt protein synthesis by attacking the Achilles heel of the ribosome. For this enzyme to reach its substrate, it must not only negotiate the endomembrane system but it must also cross an internal membrane and avoid complete degradation without compromising its activity in any way. Cell entry by ricin involves a series of steps: (i) binding, via the ricin B chain (RTB), to a range of cell surface glycolipids or glycoproteins having beta-1,4-linked galactose residues; (ii) uptake into the cell by endocytosis; (iii) entry of the toxin into early endosomes; (iv) transfer, by vesicular transport, of ricin from early endosomes to the trans-Golgi network; (v) retrograde vesicular transport through the Golgi complex to reach the endoplasmic reticulum; (vi) reduction of the disulphide bond connecting the ricin A chain (RTA) and the RTB; (vii) partial unfolding of the RTA to render it translocationally-competent to cross the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) membrane via the Sec61p translocon in a manner similar to that followed by misfolded ER proteins that, once recognised, are targeted to the ER-associated protein degradation (ERAD) machinery; (viii) avoiding, at least in part, ubiquitination that would lead to rapid degradation by cytosolic proteasomes immediately after membrane translocation when it is still partially unfolded; (ix) refolding into its protease-resistant, biologically active conformation; and (x) interaction with the ribosome to catalyse the depurination reaction. It is clear that ricin can take advantage of many target cell molecules, pathways and processes. It has been reported that a single molecule of ricin reaching the cytosol can kill that cell as a consequence of protein synthesis inhibition. The ready availability of ricin, coupled to its extreme potency when administered intravenously or if inhaled, has identified this protein toxin as a potential biological warfare agent. Therapeutically, its cytotoxicity has encouraged the use of ricin in 'magic bullets' to specifically target and destroy cancer cells, and the unusual intracellular trafficking properties of ricin potentially permit its development as a vaccine vector. Combining our understanding of the ricin structure with ways to cripple its unwanted properties (its enzymatic activity and promotion of vascular leak whilst retaining protein stability and important immunodominant epitopes), will also be crucial in the development of a long awaited protective vaccine against this toxin.

Electrostatic effects on the free-energy balance in folding a ribosome-inactivating protein

Electrostatics of globular proteins provides structural integrity as well as specificity of biological function. This dual role is particularly striking for ricin A-chain (RTA), an N-glycosidase which hydrolyzes a single adenine base from a conserved region of rRNA. The reported X-ray crystallographic structure of the RTA mutant E177A demonstrated a remarkable rescue of charge balance in the active site, achieved by the rotation of a second glutamic acid (Glu-208) into the vacated space. To understand this conformational reorganization, molecular-dynamics simulations were applied to estimate relative free energies that govern the thermodynamic stability of E177A together with mutants E177Q and E177D. The simulations anticipate that while E177A is a non-conservative substitution, the protein is more stable than the other two mutants. However, the structural plasticity of the RTA active site is not obtained penalty-free, rather E177A among the mutants shows the largest unfavorable net change in the electrostatic contribution to folding. Of the E177A folded state, reorganization of Glu-208 lowers the electrostatic cost of the free-energy change, yet interestingly, protein interactions oppose the rotational shift, while solvent effects favor the transition.

Exploring steric constraints on protein mutations using MAGE/PROBE

When planning a mutation to test some hypothesis, one crucial question is whether the new side chain is compatible with the existing structure; only if it is compatible can the interpretation of mutational results be straightforward. This paper presents a simple way of using the sensitive geometry of all-atom contacts (including hydrogens) to answer that question. The interactive MAGE/PROBE system lets the biologist explore conformational space for the mutant side chain, with an interactively updated kinemage display of its all-atom contacts to the original structure. The Autobondrot function in PROBE systematically explores that same conformational space, outputting contact scores at each point, which are then contoured and displayed. These procedures are applied here in two types of test cases, with known mutant structures. In ricin A chain, the ability of a neighboring glutamate to rescue activity of an active-site mutant is modeled successfully. In T4 lysozyme, six mutations to Leu are analyzed within the wild-type background structure, and their Autobondrot score maps correctly predict whether or not their surroundings must shift significantly in the actual mutant structures; interactive examination of contacts for the conformations involved explains which clashes are relieved by the motions. These programs are easy to use, are available free for UNIX or Microsoft Windows operating systems, and should be of significant help in choosing good mutation experiments or in understanding puzzling results.

Analysis of active site residues of the antiviral protein from summer leaves from Phytolacca americana by site-directed mutagenesis

The summer leaf isoform of the pokeweed (Phytolacca americana) antiviral protein, PAP II, was produced in high yields from inclusion bodies in recombinant E. coli. On the basis of its sequence similarity with the spring leaf isoform (PAP I) and with the A chain of ricin, a three-dimensional model of the protein was constructed as an aid in the design of active site mutants. PAP II variants mutated in residues Asp 88 (D88N), Tyr 117 (Y117S), Glu 172 (E172Q), Arg 175 (R175H) and a combination of Asp 88 and Arg 175 (D88N/R175H) were produced in E. coli and assayed for their ability to inhibit protein synthesis in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate. All of these mutations had effects deleterious to the enzymatic activity of PAP II. The results were interpreted in the light of three reaction mechanisms proposed for ribosome-inactivating proteins (RIPs). We conclude that none of the proposed mechanisms is entirely consistent with the data presented here.

Position 120-123, a potential active site of trichosanthin

Trichosanthin (TCS) is a type-I ribosome-inactivating protein (RIP) with wide spectrum of biological and pharmacological activities. In the present study, a potential site on the TCS molecule (position 120-123) is identified which may be important for the biological activities of TCS. By using site-directed mutagenesis, position 120-123 of TCS was either deleted or changed from Lys-Ile-Arg-Glu (hydrophilic) to Ser-Ala-Gly-Gly (hydrophobic). Deletion of these residues rendered a TCS molecule completely deprived of ribosome inactivating activity, while hydrophobic replacement caused 4000-fold decrease in ribosome inactivating activity. The abortifacient activity of these two mutants was retained with decreased potency. This implies that position 120-123 of the native TCS molecule plays a critical role in maintaining its biological activity.

An In Vitro Model for Toxin-Mediated Vascular Leak Syndrome: Ricin Toxin A Chain Increases the Permeability of Human Endothelial Cell Monolayers

Vascular leak syndrome (VLS) is the dose-limiting toxicity observed in clinical trials of immunotoxins containing ricin toxin A chain (RTA). RTA itself is thought to cause VLS by damaging vascular endothelial cells, but the exact mechanism remains unclear. This is partially due to the paucity of appropriate models. To study VLS, we developed an in vitro model in which human umbilical vein-derived endothelial cells were first grown to confluence on microporous supports and then cultured under low pressure in the presence or absence of RTA. Endothelial cell barrier function was assessed by measuring the volume of fluid that passed through each monolayer per unit time. We found that RTA significantly increased monolayer permeability at times and concentrations consistent with the onset of VLS in patients treated with RTA-based immunotoxins. Scanning electron microscopy showed that intercellular gaps formed in endothelial monolayers exposed to RTA. Intercellular gap formation followed endothelial cell death caused by the enzymatic activity of RTA. We conclude that RTA is directly toxic to endothelial cells in vitro and speculate that this contributes to VLS in vivo.

An In Vitro Model for Toxin-Mediated Vascular Leak Syndrome: Ricin Toxin A Chain Increases the Permeability of Human Endothelial Cell Monolayers

Vascular leak syndrome (VLS) is the dose-limiting toxicity observed in clinical trials of immunotoxins containing ricin toxin A chain (RTA). RTA itself is thought to cause VLS by damaging vascular endothelial cells, but the exact mechanism remains unclear. This is partially due to the paucity of appropriate models. To study VLS, we developed an in vitro model in which human umbilical vein-derived endothelial cells were first grown to confluence on microporous supports and then cultured under low pressure in the presence or absence of RTA. Endothelial cell barrier function was assessed by measuring the volume of fluid that passed through each monolayer per unit time. We found that RTA significantly increased monolayer permeability at times and concentrations consistent with the onset of VLS in patients treated with RTA-based immunotoxins. Scanning electron microscopy showed that intercellular gaps formed in endothelial monolayers exposed to RTA. Intercellular gap formation followed endothelial cell death caused by the enzymatic activity of RTA. We conclude that RTA is directly toxic to endothelial cells in vitro and speculate that this contributes to VLS in vivo.

Structure-based identification of a ricin inhibitor

Ricin is a potent cytotoxin which has been used widely in the construction of therapeutic agents such as immunotoxins. Recently it has been used by governments and underground groups as a poison. There is interest in identifying and designing effective inhibitors of the ricin A chain (RTA). In this study computer-assisted searches indicated that pterins might bind in the RTA active site which normally recognizes a specific adenine base on rRNA. Kinetic assays showed that pteroic acid could inhibit RTA activity with an apparent Ki of 0.6 mM. A 2.3 A crystal structure of the complex revealed the mode of binding. The pterin ring displaces Tyr80 and binds in the adenine pocket making specific hydrogen bonds to active site residues. The benzoate moiety of pteroic acid binds on the opposite side of Tyr80 making van der Waals contact with the Tyr ring and forming a hydrogen bond with Asn78. Neopterin, a propane triol derivative of pterin, also binds to RTA as revealed by the X-ray structure of its complex with RTA. Neither pterin-6-carboxylic acid nor folic acid bind to the crystal or act as inhibitors. The models observed suggest alterations to the pterin moiety which may produce more potent and specific RTA inhibitors.

Investigation of ribosome binding by the Shiga toxin A1 subunit, using competition and site-directed mutagenesis

The enzymatic subunit of Shiga toxin (StxA1) is a member of the ribosome-inactivating protein (RIP) family, which includes the ricin A chain as well as other examples of plant toxins. StxA1 catalytically depurinates a well-conserved GAGA tetra-loop of 28S rRNA which lies in the acceptor site of eukaryotic ribosomes. The specific activities of native StxA1, as well as mutated forms of the enzyme with substitutions in catalytic site residues, were measured by an in vitro translation assay. Electroporation was developed as an alternative method for the delivery of purified A1 polypeptides into Vero cells. Site-directed mutagenesis coupled with N-bromosuccinimide modification indicated that the sole tryptophan residue of StxA1 is required for binding it to the 28S rRNA backbone. Northern analysis established that the catalytic site substitutions reduced enzymatic activity by specifically interfering with the capacity of StxA1 to depurinate 28S rRNA. Ribosomes were protected from StxA1 by molar excesses of tRNA and free adenine, indicating that RIPs have the capacity to enter the acceptor site groove prior to binding and depurinating the GAGA tetra-loop.

Structural analysis of ricin and implications for inhibitor design

Ricin is a potent cytotoxin with experimental and clinical uses; it has also been used as a poison. There is considerable interest in identifying or designing inhibitors of the toxin that could be administered as antidotes. The X-ray structure of ricin A-chain is known and a plausible mechanism of action has been proposed. This provides a structural and chemical framework around which inhibitors could be designed; such a structure-based project is underway. Computer programs such as DOCK, GRID, SYBYL, and CHEMX have been used to map the ricin A-chain binding site and to search for potential inhibitors. Inhibitor candidates can be assayed kinetically in a protein synthesis assay and binding can be observed crystallographically. Taken together, a workable search algorithm has been developed and initial tests indicate that at least one ricin A-chain inhibitor, pteroic acid, has been identified.

Modeling of the three-dimensional structure of luffin-alpha and its simulated reaction with the substrate oligoribonucleotide GAGA

A fundamental problem in biochemistry and molecular biology is understanding the spatial structure of macromolecules and then analyzing their functions. In this study, the three-dimensional structure of a ribosome-inactivating protein luffin-alpha was predicted using a neural network method and molecular dynamics simulation. A feedforward neural network with the backpropagation learning algorithm were trained on model class of homologous proteins including trichosanthin and alpha-momorcharin. The distance constraints for the C alpha atoms in the protein backbone were utilized to generate a folded crude conformation of luffin-alpha by model building and the steepest descent minimization approach. The crude conformation was refined by molecular dynamics techniques and a simulated annealing procedure. The interaction between luffin-alpha and its analogous substrate GAGA was also simulated to understand its action mechanism.

Importance of the Glu 160 and Glu 189 residues to the various biological activities of the ribosome inactivating protein trichosanthin

Site-directed mutagenesis of trichosanthin (TCS), a ribosome inactivating protein with a broad spectrum of biological activities, was carried out to ascertain the importance of the Glu 160 and Glu 189 residues to the protein synthesis-inhibitory, antiproliferative, immunosuppressive and embryotoxic activities of TCS. Replacement of Glu 160 with alanine and with aspartate produced muteins, designated [E160A] and [E160D] respectively, with considerably attenuated protein synthesis-inhibitory, antiproliferative, immunosuppressive and embryotoxic activities, indicating that Glu 160 in TCS plays a role in its biological activity. [E160A] was, however, more potent than [E160D] because in the former mutein, Glu 189 constitutes a back-up of the carboxylate group but in the latter mutein, the negative charge from Asp is at a suboptimal position. The mutein [E160A, E189A] formed by mutation of both Glu 160 and Glu 189 retained considerable embryotoxic activity, suggesting that other amino acids in the active site were able to partially replace the role of Glu 160 and Glu 189. The TCS muteins also exhibit higher toxicity toward cultured embryos than cultured cells (spleen cells and tumor cells).

Systematic deletion analysis of ricin A-chain function. Single amino acid deletions

The A-chain of ricin is a cytotoxic RNA N-glycosidase that inactivates ribosomes by depurination of the adenosine at position 4324 in 28 S rRNA. Of the 267 amino acids in the protein, 222 could be deleted, in one or another of 74 mutants, without the loss of the capacity to catalyze hydrolysis of a single specific nucleotide in rRNA (Morris, K. N., and Wool, I. G. (1992) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 89, 4869-4873). The 45 amino acids that could not be omitted when the deletions were in sets of 20, 5, or 2 residues have now been deleted one at a time; 9 of these deletion mutants retained activity. A RNP-like structural motif in ricin A-chain that may mediate binding to ribosomal RNA has been identified.

Mouse embryonic development and tumor cell growth under the influence of recombinant trichosanthin (a ribosome inactivating protein) and its muteins

Trichosanthin, a ribosome inactivating protein, is known to possess embryotoxic and antiproliferative activities. In the present study recombinant trichosanthin and its muteins produced by site-directed mutagenesis were tested for these activities using whole embryo culture and cell culture. The results revealed that when Glu 160 in trichosanthin was mutated to alanine or aspartate, the two aforementioned activities underwent a substantial decrease. However, the former mutein had a higher potency than the latter mutein. When both Glu 160 and Glu 189 were mutated, the resultant mutant possessed very low antiproliferative and yet considerable embryotoxic activity, indicating the contribution from other amino acids in stabilizing the transition state complex of trichosanthin.

Structure/function relationship study of Gln156, Glu160 and Glu189 in the active site of trichosanthin

Trichosanthin is a protein used medicinally in China for abortifacient purposes. It is also an RNA N-glycosidase which inactivates eukaryotic ribosomes by removing adenine4324 from 28S rRNA. Site-directed mutagenesis was performed to probe the role of Gln156, Glu160 and Glu189 in the active site of trichosanthin. The purified altered proteins were assayed for their potency in inhibiting in vitro protein synthesis. The data indicate Glu160 is involved in the catalytic reaction. Kinetics studies suggest the carboxylate group of Glu160 serves to stabilize the transition-state complex. Similar to ricin A, the variant [E160A]trichosanthin is more potent than [E160D]trichosanthin. This is because Glu189 serves as a back-up of the carboxylate group in case Glu160 is mutated to alanine. However, removal of Glu189 in the presence of Glu160 does not affect the ID50 value drastically. An activity of 1800-fold less than that of the wild-type protein was found when both Glu160 and Glu189 were changed to alanine, indicating that some other residues in the active site are also taken part in the lowering of energy barrier for the catalytic reaction. Although Gln156 is highly conserved in related proteins, its mutation to alanine only slightly decreases the activity, showing that this residue does not participate directly in catalysis.

The N-glycosidase mechanism of ribosome-inactivating proteins implied by crystal structures of alpha-momorcharin

BACKGROUND

alpha-Momorcharin (alpha MMC) is a type I ribosome-inactivating protein. It inhibits protein synthesis by hydrolytically removing a specific adenine residue from a highly conserved, single-stranded loop of rRNA.

RESULTS

Here we describe the determination and refinement of the crystal structures of alpha MMC in the native state and in complexes with the product, adenine, and a substrate analogue, formycin 5'-monophosphate (FMP) at high resolution. Both adenine and the base of FMP are tightly bound; the ribose of bound FMP adopts a strained, high-energy conformation, which may mimic the structure of the transition state.

CONCLUSIONS

These structures indicate that residues Tyr70, Glu160 and Arg163 of alpha MMC are the most critical for catalysis. We propose that the strained conformation of the ribose in the target adenosine weakens the glycoside bond. Partial protonation mediated by Arg163 then facilitates N-glycoside bond cleavage, leading to the formation of an oxycarbonium ion intermediate which is stabilized by the negatively-charged Glu160. Tyr70 adopts subtly different conformations in the three structures implying that it may be important in substrate recognition and perhaps catalysis.

Cloning and expression of three abrin A-chains and their mutants derived by site-specific mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

DNAs encoding of three abrin A-chains were obtained from the cDNA library of Abrus precatorius by polymerase chain reaction and ligated into the expression vector, pGEX-2T. The mature A-chains of abrins a, b and d have been expressed in the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli, and the yield of the soluble recombinant proteins was 7 mg/l induced culture. Three recombinant abrin A-chains were purified to be homogeneity and their N-glycosidase ability to inhibit protein biosynthesis in a cell-free system and to depurinate 28S rRNA in rat liver ribosomes was demonstrated in vitro. The recombinant abrin-a A-chain had the highest N-glycosidase activity among three recombinant abrin A-chains while the recombinant abrin-b A-chain, the least. Three mutants, glutamic-acid-to-alanine replacement (E164A), arginine to leucine (R167L) or double mutation (E164A and R167L) were constructed and expressed. The protein-biosynthesis-inhibitory activity of mutant (E164A), mutant (R167L) and the double mutant was found to be 25-fold, 625-fold and 1250-fold lower than that of wild type, respectively. The results indicated that Arg167 was essential for abrin toxin A-chain catalysis.

Cytotoxic proteins

Cytotoxic proteins, which enter eukaryotic cells and catalytically inactivate protein synthesis, are being increasingly studied using a combination of molecular biology, cell biology and structural approaches. The creation of genetically engineered fusions with alternative cell-binding ligands paves the way for tailor-made, cell-type-specific killing agents.

High-level expression and simplified purification of recombinant ricin A chain

Ricin toxin is a glycoprotein which catalytically inactivates eukaryotic ribosomes by depurination of a single adenosine residue from the 28S ribosomal RNA. The enzymatic activity is present in the A chain of the toxin molecule, whereas the B chain contains two binding sites for galactose. Since it is highly potent in inhibiting protein synthesis, the A chain is used to prepare cytotoxic conjugates effective against tumor cells. Such chimeric proteins are highly selective and have a wide range of clinical applications. Extensive preclinical studies on these conjugates require large amounts of purified A chain. Native ricin A chain is heterogeneous, since plants produce a number of isoforms of ricin toxin. Purified, native preparations often contain two types of ricin A chain which differ in the extent of glycosylation. By cloning and expressing the gene of A chain, one could obtain homogeneous toxin molecules devoid of carbohydrates. In addition, structural changes in the toxin polypeptide could be introduced by in vitro mutagenesis, which can improve the pharmacological properties and antitumor activity. Earlier methods of expression strategies using Escherichia coli have yielded only moderate levels of expression. In the present study, the coding region of ricin A chain was cloned into pET3b, a high-level expression vector under the control of the T7 promoter. Recombinant ricin A chain produced by this construct has an additional 14 amino acid residues at the NH2 terminus. Subsequently, a NdeI site was created at the 5' end of the gene by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis. The modified fragment was then introduced into pET3b vector to produce toxin polypeptide identical to the native sequence.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Alteration of an amino acid residue outside the active site of the ricin A chain reduces its toxicity towards yeast ribosomes

Yeast transformants containing integrated copies of a galactose-regulated, ricin toxin A chain (RTA) expression plasmid were constructed and used in an attempt to isolate RTA-resistant yeast mutants. Analysis of RNA from mutant strains demonstrated that approximately half contained ribosomes that had been partially modified by RTA, although all the strains analysed transcribed full-length RTA RNA. The mutant strains could have mutations in yeast genes giving rise to RTA-resistant ribosomes or they could contain alterations within the RTA-encoding DNA causing production of mutant toxin. Ribosomes isolated from mutant strains were shown to be susceptible to RTA modification in vitro suggesting that the strains contain alterations in RTA. This paper describes the detailed analysis of one mutant strain which has a point mutation that changes serine 203 to asparagine in RTA protein. Although serine 203 lies outside the proposed active site of RTA its alteration leads to the production of RTA protein with a greatly reduced level of ribosome modifying activity. This decrease in activity apparently allows yeast cells to survive expression of RTA as only a proportion of the ribosomes become modified. We demonstrate that the mutant RTA preferentially modifies 26S rRNA in free 60S subunits and has lower catalytic activity compared with native RTA when produced in Escherichia coli. Such mutations provide a valuable means of identifying residues important in RTA catalysis and of further understanding the precise mechanism of action of RTA.

Conserved amino acid residues in ribosome-inactivating proteins from plants

The amino acid sequences of eleven RIPs sequenced to date have been compared in the expectation that this would be useful in the location of functionally and/or structurally important sites of these molecules. In addition to several highly conserved hydrophobic amino acids, thirteen absolutely conserved residues have been found in ricin A-chain: Tyr21, Phe24, Arg29, Tyr80, Tyr123, Gly140, Ala165, Glu177, Ala178, Arg180, Glu208, Asn209 and Trp211. The role of these residues as well as of the C-terminal region have been discussed based on the results of chemical and enzymatic modifications, site-directed mutagenesis, and deletion studies.

Importance of arginine at position 170 of the A subunit of Vero toxin 1 produced by enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli for toxin activity

Comparison of the primary structures of the A subunits of Vero toxin 1 (VT1), Vero toxin 2 (VT2), and two variants of VT2 (VT2vp and VT2vh) and the ricin A chain revealed three conserved regions (amino acid residues 51-55, 167-171 and 202-207 from the N-terminus of VT1). All three regions of the ricin A chain corresponded in position to the active site of ricin proposed by X-ray crystal diffraction analysis. To determine the relative importance of the conserved amino acid residues for toxin activity of VT1, we prepared VT1 mutants with single amino-acid substitutions by oligonucleotide-directed site-specific mutagenesis. A total of 22 mutants were prepared to examine 14 conserved residues, and their cytotoxicities to Vero cells and inhibitory activities on protein synthesis in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate were compared with those of wild-type VT1. Replacement of glutamic acid at position 167 by glutamine and of arginine at position 170 by leucine reduced both activities drastically. These results suggest that, in addition to the glutamic acid at position 167 reported previously, arginine at position 170 also plays an important role in the toxin activity of VT1. A possible chemical mechanism of the enzymatic (N-glycosidase) activity of VT1 is proposed based on the relative activities of various mutants.

Mapping the minimal contiguous gene segment that encodes functionally active Shiga-like toxin II

Shiga-like toxin type II (SLT-II) is one of two antigenically distinct cytotoxins produced by enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli that are believed to play a central role in the pathogenesis of enterohemorrhagic E. coli-induced disease. SLT-II is a bipartite toxin with an enzymatically active A subunit that inhibits protein synthesis and an oligomeric B subunit that binds to the glycolipid globotriaosylceramide on eukaryotic cells. In this study, functional boundaries of the slt-II operon were mapped. Mutant proteins lacking the last four amino acids from the carboxy terminus of the 70-amino-acid mature SLT-II B polypeptide had no cytotoxic activity. However, when only two amino acids were removed from the carboxy terminus of the B subunit, the cytotoxic activity of the holotoxin was not altered drastically. Furthermore, a 21-amino-acid extension to the carboxy terminus of the SLT-II B polypeptide was tolerated with a minimum reduction in cytotoxic activity of the holotoxin. Deletion of the region coding for amino acids 3 through 18 of the 296-amino-acid mature SLT-II A polypeptide resulted in complete ablation of the cytotoxic activity of the holotoxin as well as abolition of the enzymatic activity of the A subunit. Thus, it appears that both 5'- and 3'-terminal coding sequences are essential for function of the slt-II operon.

Site-directed mutagenesis of ricin A-chain and implications for the mechanism of action

Ricin A-chain is an N-glycosidase that attacks ribosomal RNA at a highly conserved adenine residue. The enzyme is representative of a large family of medically significant proteins used in the design of anticancer agents and in the treatment of HIV infection. The x-ray structure has been used as a guide to create several active site mutations by directed mutagenesis of the cloned gene. Glu177 is a key catalytic residue, and conversion to Gln reduces activity 180-fold. Asn209 is shown to participate in substrate binding by kinetic analysis. Conversion to Ser increases Km sixfold but has no effect on kcat. Conversion of Tyr80 and Tyr123 to Phe decreases activity by 15- and 7-fold respectively. A mechanism of action is proposed that involves binding of the substrate adenine in a syn configuration that resembles the transition state; the putative oxycarbonium ion is probably stabilized by interaction with Glu177.

Minireview: enzymatic properties of ribosome-inactivating proteins (RIPs) and related toxins

Ribosome-inactivating proteins (RIPs) are a group of proteins that inhibit protein synthesis in eucaryotic cells. While the biological effects have been well characterized, the underlying enzymatic mechanisms have not been elucidated until recently. Two different mechanisms have been identified. Plant and bacterial RIPs act as N-glycosidases. They cleave a single N-glycosidic bond between adenine and ribose at a specific nucleotide A-4324 of the 28S rRNA of the 60S ribosomal subunit. On the other hand, the fungal RIPs act as ribonucleases and cleave a single phosphodiester bond between G-4325 and A-4326 of the same rRNA, just one nucleotide away from the site of action of plant/bacterial RIPs. Other protein synthesis inhibitory proteins act by their ADP-ribosyltransferase activity which modify and thus inactivate elongation factor-2. Recently, some toxins have been shown to possess deoxyribonuclease activity which may also account for their toxicity.