Multiple sclerosis in twins

Encephalitogenic and Regulatory CD8 T Cells in Multiple Sclerosis and Its Animal Models

Multiple sclerosis (MS), a neuroinflammatory disease that affects millions worldwide, is widely thought to be autoimmune in etiology. Historically, research into MS pathogenesis has focused on autoreactive CD4 T cells because of their critical role in the animal model, experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis, and the association between MS susceptibility and single-nucleotide polymorphisms in the MHC class II region. However, recent studies have revealed prominent clonal expansions of CD8 T cells within the CNS during MS. In this paper, we review the literature on CD8 T cells in MS, with an emphasis on their potential effector and regulatory properties. We discuss the impact of disease modifying therapies, currently prescribed to reduce MS relapse rates, on CD8 T cell frequency and function. A deeper understanding of the role of CD8 T cells in MS may lead to the development of more effective and selective immunomodulatory drugs for particular subsets of patients.

Disentangling the molecular mechanisms of multiple sclerosis: The contribution of twin studies

Twin studies of disease concordance are useful to weight the relative contribution of genetic and environmental factors to the cause of common complex disorders. In multiple sclerosis (MS) different twinning rates from geographic areas at different prevalence suggested that heritable and non-heritable factors contribute in different proportions and ways to MS risk in diverse populations. This concept prompted genome-wide association studies, and the implementation of the co-twin control design, that allows stringent experimental approaches in MS-discordant identical pairs, controlling for genetic influences and many other known and unknown factors. The co-twin control design provided important clues on MS molecular model. These studies will be reviewed, focusing on those showing significant differences between affected and healthy co-twins. In some cases, differences that emerged in non-twin patients compared to matched controls were not confirmed in identical MS-discordant pairs, suggesting an 'MS subclinical trait'. Early patterns of magnetic resonance imaging and predictive biomarkers that characterize 'healthy' co-twins may be useful for the identification of a prodromal reversible phase of the disease.

Concordance for multiple sclerosis in Danish twins: an update of a nationwide study

The occurrence of multiple sclerosis (MS) in twins has not previously been studied in complete nationwide data sets. The existence of almost complete MS and twin registries in Denmark ensures that essentially unbiased samples of MS cases among twins can be obtained. In this population-based study, virtually all Danish MS cases among twins born before 1983 with onset of MS after 1948 and diagnosis before 1 January 1997 were identified. Of 13 286 MS cases, 178 were twins and, of these 164 twin pairs were discordant and seven were concordant. We found significantly higher proband-wise concordance among monozygotic twins than dizygotic twins, with estimated proband-wise concordances of 24% (95% confidence interval (CI): 5-39%) for monozygotic and 3% (95% CI: 0-8%) for dizygotic twins. Thus, a monozygotic twin whose co-twin has MS has a 24% risk of developing the disease, while the corresponding risk for a dizygotic twin is only 3%. Our results largely confirm previously published concordance estimates and indicate that genetic factors are of importance in susceptibility to MS.

The Increased Susceptibility of Women to Multiple Sclerosis

Many diseases with an auto-immune etiology have a skewed sex distribution. In the majority of instances, women are affected more frequently than men. A review of population studies demonstrates that the preponderance of women in multiple sclerosis (MS) is almost constant. We show that this preponderance is further increased in early as well as in late-onset cases, in familial cases as well as in MS twin pairs and that the HLA-DR2 allele, which has been associated with MS in Caucasian populations, is significantly more frequent in women than in men with MS. “Rules” have been established for multifactorial diseases; MS contravenes most of those rules. The skewed sex distribution in MS could be attributed to the known hormonal and gender influences on the immune response, as well as to genetic influences.

Twin studies in multiple sclerosis: A meta-estimation of heritability and environmentality

BACKGROUND

Most twin studies of multiple sclerosis (MS) are inconclusive regarding the impact of genes and environment on disease susceptibility. In particular, high uncertainty exists about whether shared environmental factors are aetiologically relevant.

OBJECTIVE

To disentangle, with a reasonable degree of confidence, the relative contributions of heritability and of shared and unique environmental components of MS susceptibility.

METHODS

We performed a meta-analysis of previous twin studies. After a MEDLINE search, we selected eight twin studies in France, UK, Canada, Denmark, North America, Italy, Finland and Sweden. We conducted a biometric multi-group analysis under the liability-threshold model, by taking account of the study-specific ascertainment strategies and the population-specific prevalence rates of MS.

RESULTS

The meta-analytic estimates of tetrachoric correlations were 0.71 (95% confidence interval (CI): 0.67-0.74) in monozygotic pairs and 0.46 (95% CI: 0.41-0.50) in dizygotic pairs. The biometric multi-group model provided meta-analytic estimates of 0.50 (95% CI: 0.39-0.61) for heritability, 0.21 (95% CI: 0.11-0.30) for shared environmental component and 0.29 (95% CI: 0.26-0.33) for unique environmental component.

CONCLUSION

Our results support the continuing efforts to identify unknown genetic factors that fill the gap of 'missing heritability'; moreover, a 'missing environmentality' deserves future investigations into the role of non-heritable components that act as both shared and individual-specific exposures.

Twin studies in autoimmune disease: genetics, gender and environment

Twin studies are powerful tools to discriminate whether a complex disease is due to genetic or environmental factors. High concordance rates among monozygotic (MZ) twins support genetic factors being predominantly involved, whilst low rates are suggestive of environmental factors. Twin studies have often been utilised in the study of systemic and organ specific autoimmune diseases. As an example, type I diabetes mellitus has been investigated to establish that that disease is largely affected by genetic factors, compared to rheumatoid arthritis or scleroderma, which have a weaker genetic association. However, large twin studies are scarce or virtually non-existent in other autoimmune diseases which have been limited to few sets of twins and individual case reports. In addition to the study of the genetic and environmental contributions to disease, it is likely that twin studies will also provide data in regards to the clinical course of disease, as well as risk for development in related individuals. More importantly, genome-wide association studies have thus far reported genomic variants that only account for a minority of autoimmunity cases, and cannot explain disease discordance in MZ twins. Future research is therefore encouraged not only in the analysis of twins with autoimmune disease, but also in regards to epigenetic factors or rare variants that may be discovered with next-generation sequencing. This review will examine the literature surrounding twin studies in autoimmune disease including discussions of genetics and gender.

Vitamin D, a neuro-immunomodulator: implications for neurodegenerative and autoimmune diseases

It has been known for more than 20 years that vitamin D exerts marked effects on immune and neural cells. These non-classical actions of vitamin D have recently gained a renewed attention since it has been shown that diminished levels of vitamin D induce immune-mediated symptoms in animal models of autoimmune diseases and is a risk factor for various brain diseases. For example, it has been demonstrated that vitamin D (i) modulates the production of several neurotrophins, (ii) up-regulates Interleukin-4 and (iii) inhibits the differentiation and survival of dendritic cells, resulting in impaired allo-reactive T cell activation. Not surprisingly, vitamin D has been found to be a strong candidate risk-modifying factor for Multiple Sclerosis (MS), the most prevalent neurological and inflammatory disease in the young adult population. Vitamin D is a seco-steroid hormone, produced photochemically in the animal epidermis. The action of ultraviolet light (UVB) on 7-dehydrocholesterol results in the production of pre-vitamin D which, after thermo-conversion and two separate hydroxylations, gives rise to the active 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D. Vitamin D acts through two types of receptors: (i) the vitamin D receptor (VDR), a member of the steroid/thyroid hormone superfamily of transcription factors, and (ii) the MARRS (membrane associated, rapid response steroid binding) receptor, also known as Erp57/Grp58. In this article, we review some of the mechanisms that may underlie the role of vitamin D in various brain diseases. We then assess how vitamin D imbalance may lay the foundation for a range of adult disorders, including brain pathologies (Parkinson's disease, epilepsy, depression) and immune-mediated disorders (rheumatoid arthritis, type I diabetes mellitus, systemic lupus erythematosus or inflammatory bowel diseases). Multidisciplinary scientific collaborations are now required to fully appreciate the complex role of vitamin D in mammal metabolism.

Season of birth and not vitamin D receptor promoter polymorphisms is a risk factor for multiple sclerosis

Both genetic and environmental factors contribute to multiple sclerosis, the most common neurodegenerative disorder with onset in young adults. The objective of the current study is, based on the hypothesis that environmentally predisposed individuals are at risk for multiple sclerosis, to investigate whether they also carry genetic variants within the vitamin D machinery. Using medical files and DNA samples from 583 trios (a patient and both parents) of the French Multiple Sclerosis Genetics Group as well as data from the French Statistics Bureau, we aimed to assess whether: (1) a seasonality of birth was observed in French multiple sclerosis patients; (2) three single nucleotide polymorphisms within the promoter region of the vitamin D receptor were associated with multiple sclerosis susceptibility; and (3) the combination of a high risk month of birth and vitamin D receptor polymorphisms were correlated to multiple sclerosis incidence. We observed a significantly reduced number of individuals born in November who were later diagnosed as multiple sclerosis patients. However, we found no association between the three studied vitamin D receptor polymorphisms and multiple sclerosis. In conclusion, our data suggest that high levels of vitamin D during the third trimester of pregnancy could be a protective factor for multiple sclerosis.

Twin studies and the heritability of MS: a conclusion

OBJECTIVE

The classical twin study has the potential to evaluate the relative contribution of genes and environment and guide further research strategies, provided the sampling and methods of analysis are correct. We wish to review all the more informative twin studies on multiple sclerosis (MS).

METHODS

We examined six large population-based twin studies in MS and calculated indices of heritability (h(2)), which is the traditional method of assessing genetic contribution to disease and to allow comparison between studies.

RESULTS

This index was found to vary widely from 0.25 to 0.76 with large confidence intervals that reflect small sample size and prevent robust interpretation.

CONCLUSION

Overall the studies support a genetic contribution to disease; however, the imprecision of the heritability estimates and potential biases that they contain mean that very little inference can be drawn its exact size. Given that the magnitude of genetic effect cannot be measured because of the relative infrequency of MS; the consequent difficulty in collecting an informative sample; and in many countries, the lack of a comprehensive twin register, we suggest that further twin prevalence surveys should not be undertaken. Twin studies could be used more effectively in other ways, such as the co-twin case-control approach.

Frontiers in nephrology: immune tolerance to allografts in humans

Vascularized allografts are rejected unless some indefinite modification to the recipient's immune system is made. This modification is typically achieved through the long-term administration of immunosuppressive drugs. Patients thus trade their end-stage organ failure for dependence on daily drug therapy and the accompanying chronic condition of immunodeficiency. However, it is clear from studies in experimental animals that rejection can be prevented through the use of several therapeutic approaches, including donor hematopoietic cell infusion, chimerism, T cell depletion, and/or co-stimulation blockade. Successfully treated animals avoid rejection beyond the period of therapy without a phenotype of chronic immunosuppression and are thus considered to be tolerant of their grafts. Although intriguing, this success in animals has yet to be reproducibly translated to the clinic, and human transplant recipients remain tethered to immunosuppressive drugs with rare exceptions. This article provides an overview of the existing, largely anecdotal, clinical experience with organ allograft tolerance. It reviews the various approaches that are being applied in pilot human trials and suggests avenues for future clinical investigation.

Clinical multiple sclerosis occurs at one end of a spectrum of CNS pathology: a modified threshold liability model leads to new ways of thinking about the cause of clinical multiple sclerosis

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a complex trait, the causes of which are elusive. A threshold liability model influences thinking about the causes of this disorder. According to this model, a population has a normal distribution of genetic liability to MS. In addition, a threshold exists, so that MS begins when an individual's liability exceeds the MS threshold; environmental and other causative factors may increase or decrease an individual's MS liability. It is argued here, however, that this model is misleading, as it is based on the incorrect assumption that MS is a disorder that one either has or does not have. This paper hypothesizes, instead, that patients with a diagnosis of MS share identical CNS pathology, termed MS pathology, with some individuals who have a diagnosis of possible MS and with some apparently healthy individuals, who may never have a diagnosis of MS. In order to accommodate this hypothesis, the current threshold liability model is modified as follows. (1) In addition to a normal distribution of MS liability within a population, a spectrum of MS pathology occurs in some who have a high MS liability. (2) A clinical MS threshold exists at a point on this liability distribution, where the burden and distribution of MS pathology permits a diagnosis of clinical MS. (3) Additional thresholds exist that correspond to a lower MS liability and a lesser burden of MS pathology than occur at the clinical MS threshold. This modified threshold model leads to the postulate that causes act at various time points to increase MS liability and induce MS pathology. The accumulation of MS pathology sometimes leads to a diagnosis of clinical MS. One implication of this model is that the MS pathology in clinical MS and in some with possible MS differs only in the extent but not in the type of CNS injury. Thus, it may be possible to obtain insight into the causative environmental factors that increase MS liability and induce MS pathology by focusing on patients who have clinical MS; some environmental factors that induce new lesions in patients with clinical MS may be identical to those that induce MS pathology in genetically susceptible individuals who do not have clinical MS. Identification of these causative factors has importance, as specific treatment may prevent the accumulation of MS pathology that leads to the significant CNS damage associated with clinical MS.

Multiple sclerosis in twins from continental Italy and Sardinia: A nationwide study

Knowledge about the balance between heritable and nonheritable risk in multiple sclerosis (MS) is based on twin studies in high-prevalence areas. In a study that avoided ascertainment limitations and directly compared continental Italy (medium-prevalence) and Sardinia (high-prevalence), we ascertained 216 pairs from 34,549 patients. This gives a twinning rate of 0.62% among MS patients, significantly less than that of the general population. In continental Italy, probandwise concordance was 14.5% (95% confidence interval, 5.1-23.8) for monozygotic and 4.0% (95% confidence interval, 0.8-7.1) for dizygotic twins. Results in Sardinia resemble those in northern populations but in limited numbers. Monozygotic concordance was 22.2% (95% confidence interval, 0-49.3) probandwise, but no concordant dizygotic pairs were identified. A questionnaire on 80 items possibly related to disease cause was administered to 70 twin pairs, 135 sporadic patients, and 135 healthy volunteers. Variables positively (7) or negatively (2) associated with predisposition and concordance in twins largely overlapped and were mainly linked to infection. If compared with previous studies, our data demonstrate that penetrance in twins appears to correlate with MS prevalence. They highlight the relevance of nonheritable variables in Mediterranean areas. The apparent underrepresentation of MS among Italian twins draws attention to protective factors, shared by twins, that may influence susceptibility.

Familial multiple sclerosis and other inherited disorders of the white matter

BACKGROUND

An objective demonstration of lesions disseminated in time and space remains the core of the last revision of diagnostic criteria for multiple sclerosis (MS), but this update is now empowered by a weighted use of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), which results in an earlier and more unambiguous diagnosis ("MS," "not MS," or "possible MS"). Nevertheless, the exclusion of other entities still remains an integral element of the diagnostic process.

REVIEW SUMMARY

Exclusion of genetic disorders can be challenging in some cases with familial recurrence of MS, particularly when the transmission is mimicking a mendelian or a maternal pattern of inheritance. Vice versa, many forms of mendelian leukodystrophies and leukoencephalopathies present with juvenile or adult onset, progressive or relapsing-remitting courses, intrafamilial phenotypic heterogeneity and MRI signs of multifocal white matter (WM) pathology, features potentially leading to a temporary confusion with MS. With the recent availability of disease modifying medications in MS, the development of specific molecular therapies in inherited WM disorders, and the general recognition of the effectiveness of early treatments, the accuracy of initial diagnostic assessment has become critical.

CONCLUSION

Considering the importance of disease specific treatments, here we review the major characteristics of familial MS and some of the inheritable diseases of the WM. Although no direct genetic link between MS and these WM abnormalities is known, molecular data from the field of rare genetic disorders may also provide some experimental paradigms to a further exploration of MS.

The multiple sclerosis trait: a disease waiting to happen?

There is increasing evidence that the etiology of MS is heterogeneous. MS is often described as a "disease waiting to happen". The pathogenesis of the critical transition to clinical disease according to diagnostic criteria is largely unknown. The role of environment and chance must also be considered. Implications for counselling "at risk" individuals, based on family history, are discussed.

Multiple sclerosis

Multiple sclerosis is a complex genetic disease associated with inflammation in the CNS white matter thought to be mediated by autoreactive T cells. Clonal expansion of B cells, their antibody products, and T cells, hallmarks of inflammation in the CNS, are found in MS. This review discusses new methods to define the molecular pathology of human disease with high-throughput examination of germline DNA haplotypes, RNA expression, and protein structures that will allow the generation of a new series of hypotheses that can be tested to develop better understanding of and therapies for this disease.

Genetics of multiple sclerosis

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is probably aetiologically heterogeneous. Systematic genetic epidemiological and molecular genetic studies have provided important insights. Both genetic and non-genetic (environment, stochastic) factors may be involved in susceptibility as well as outcome, but we have yet to understand their relative roles. Any environmental factor is likely to be ubiquitous and act on a population-basis rather than within the family microenvironment. Taken together, the results of genome screening studies provide strong evidence for exclusion of a major locus in MS. There are, however, many genes that seem to be associated with MS. These include, but are in no way limited to, HLA classes I and II, T-cell receptor beta, CTLA4, ICAM1, and SH2D2A. The future of MS genetics, as for most common complex disorders, will be dependent on the resources available, ranging from biological samples and comprehensive databases of clinical and epidemiological information to the development of new technologies and statistical methods.

Twin concordance and sibling recurrence rates in multiple sclerosis

Size and ascertainment constraints often limit twin studies to concordance comparisons between identical and fraternal twins. Here we report the final results of a longitudinal, population-based study of twins with multiple sclerosis (MS) in Canada. Bias was demonstrably minimized, and an estimated 75% of all Canadian MS twin pairs were ascertained, giving a sample sufficiently large (n = 370) to permit additional informative comparisons. Twinning was not found to affect prevalence, and twins with MS did not differ from nontwins for DR15 allele frequency nor for MS risk to their siblings. Probandwise concordance rates of 25.3% (SE +/- 4.4) for monozygotic (MZ), 5.4% (+/-2.8) for dizygotic (DZ), and 2.9% (+/-0.6) for their nontwin siblings were found. MZ twin concordance was in excess of DZ twin concordance. The excess concordance in MZ was derived primarily from like-sexed female pairs with a probandwise concordance rate of 34 of 100 (34 +/- 5.7%) compared with 3 of 79 (3.8 +/- 2.8%) for female DZ pairs. We did not demonstrate an MZ/DZ difference in males, although the sample size was small. We observed a 2-fold increase in risk to DZ twins over nontwin siblings of twins, but the difference was not significant.

Viral infections: their elusive role in regulating susceptibility to autoimmune disease

Viral infections may trigger autoimmune disease. Complicating our understanding of how viral infections promote disease is the realization that viral infections can sometimes prevent auto-aggressive reactions. Here, we will discuss recent findings that provide insights into how viral infections may alter susceptibility to autoimmunity.

Twins: mirrors of the immune system

Twin studies are a powerful tool to assess genetic and nongenetic factors in multifactorial, immune-mediated diseases. Here, Marco Salvetti and colleagues review important results from such studies and highlight their potential value. Future developments that should help to realize the potential of twin studies are discussed.

The genetics of multiple sclerosis. A review

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is characterized by chronic inflammation and demyelination in the central nervous system (CNS). Although the etiology of MS is unknown, both genetic and environmental contributions to the pathogenesis are inferred from epidemiologic studies. Geographic distributions and epidemics of MS and data from migration studies provide evidence for some, thus far unidentified, environmental effects. The co-occurrence of MS with high and low frequencies in ethnic groups often sharing an environment, the increased recurrence rate in families, and the high concordance rate among identical twins point to inheritable determinants of susceptibility. Based on the autoimmune hypothesis of demyelination, genetic studies sought associations between MS and polymorphic alleles of candidate genes which regulate either the immune response or myelin production. The most consistent finding in case-control studies was the association with the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) (also called human leukocyte antigen--HLA) class II, DR15, DQ6, Dw2 haplotype. Studies on other gene products encoded within or close to the MHC complex on chromosome 6p21.3 (e.g., HLA DP, complement components, transporter proteins, tumor necrosis factor, and myelin-oligodendrocyte glycoprotein) resulted in conflicting observations in different patient populations. The potential contribution of polymorphic alleles within the genes of the T-cell receptor alpha beta chains, immunoglobulins, cytokines, and oligodendrocyte growth factors or their receptors to MS susceptibility either remains equivocal or is rejected. Studies on families with multiple affected members have revealed that MS is a complex trait, that the contribution of individual genes to susceptibility is probably small, and that differences are possible between familial and sporadic forms. The development of molecular and computer technologies have facilitated the performance of comprehensive genomic scans in multiplex families, which have confirmed the possible linkage of multiple loci to susceptibility, each with a minor contribution. Several provisional sites were reported, but only 6p21 (MHC complex), 5p14, and 17q22 were positive in more than one study. The British update demonstrated segregation among regions of interest depending on DR15 sharing, and excluded a gene of major effect from 95%, and one with a moderate effect from 65% of the genome. The extended study by the US collaboration group revealed that the MHC linkage was limited to families segregating HLA DR2 alleles, which suggested that linkage to the MHC is related to the HLA DR2 association, and that sporadic and familial MS share at least one common susceptibility marker. Further identification of MS susceptibility loci may involve additional family sets, more polymorphic markers, and the exploration of telomeric chromosomal regions. Data from these studies may further elucidate pathogenic mechanisms of MS.

[Genetic aspects in multiple sclerosis: I. Twin studies]

The authors make a review and critical analysis of twin studies in multiple sclerosis (MS). The concordance rate among homozygotic twins is significantly greater than in heterozygotic twins. The average hertability in MS is about 28%; no single gene was identified as a sole risk factor for the development of the disease. MS may be considered a polygenic disease triggered by environmental factors in a genetically predisposed individual.

A twin study of age-related macular degeneration

PURPOSE

To determine the importance of genetic factors in age-related macular degeneration by using a twin study to compare the concordance of age-related macular degeneration in monozygotic and dizygotic twin pairs.

METHODS

We prospectively examined 134 consecutive twin pairs and two triplet sets for age-related macular degeneration. The zygosity was determined by genetic laboratory tests.

RESULTS

The concordance of age-related macular degeneration was 100% (25 of 25) in monozygotic and 42% (five of 12) in dizygotic twin pairs. The other twins or triplets had no macular changes of age-related macular degeneration.

CONCLUSIONS

The statistically significant higher concordance of age-related macular degeneration in monozygotic than in dizygotic twin pairs and the clinical heterogeneity of age-related macular degeneration strongly suggest the importance of genetic and nongenetic factors, respectively, in age-related macular degeneration.

British Isles survey of multiple sclerosis in twins: MRI

64/105 subjects who have a twin with multiple sclerosis included in a study of clinical concordance also underwent MRI of the brain. 8/23 monozygotic and 1/41 dizygotic co-twins from this subgroup were clinically concordant of whom 8/9 had MRI appearances typical of multiple sclerosis. Of the 48 clinically discordant twins aged less than 60, abnormalities on MRI were detected in 6/15 (40%) monozygotic and 13/33 (39%) dizygotic twins compared with 7/37 (19%) healthy age-matched controls. Abnormalities on MRI typical of multiple sclerosis (defined by the Fazekas criteria) were, however, present in only 2/15 (13%) monozygotic and 3/33 (9%) dizygotic twins and 0/37 controls. These results suggest that about 10% of monozygotic and dizygotic twins have "subclinical multiple sclerosis". It is likely that most of the MRI abnormalities seen in clinically discordant twins, however, represent incidental pathology.

Multiple sclerosis: occurrence of myelin basic protein peptide-reactive T cells in healthy family members

Genetic factors influence the susceptibility to multiple sclerosis (MS). This disease is accompanied by augmented T cell responses to CNS myelin components such as myelin basic protein. To evaluate the familial occurrence of such T cell autoreactivity, we have studied 12 MS families including 37 healthy first-degree relatives for occurrence of numbers of interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) secreting cells among blood mononuclear after culture in presence of myelin basic protein (MBP), eight synthetic MBP peptides and the control antigen acetylcholine receptor (AChR). There were no differences between MS patients and healthy family members regarding frequencies of autoreactive T cells recognizing MBP, the eight different MBP peptides or AChR. None of the MBP peptides predominated as T cell antigen among the MS patients or their unaffected family members. In some families the highest number of MBP peptide reactive T cells were found among unaffected family members. No correlation was observed between numbers of MBP or MBP peptide reactive T cells in various subjects and their HLA-DR-DQ phenotypes. In conclusion, this study has revealed the presence of MBP and MBP peptide reactive T cells of similar frequencies in MS patients and their healthy family members.

Genetic disorders that masquerade as multiple sclerosis

There are many genetic disorders that have signs and symptoms suggestive of multiple sclerosis and that may easily be overlooked in the evaluation of both adult and pediatric multiple sclerosis patients. The recognition of a genetic disorder as the cause of a patient's "multiple sclerosis" phenotype has important implications not only for the patient, but often also for others in the patient's family who may be at risk for the same disease. We present here a review of single gene disorders that can masquerade as multiple sclerosis. For each disorder, the major clinical and biochemical characteristics are discussed, together with the appropriate testing to screen for and confirm the diagnosis. In addition, guidelines are presented for when to suspect an underlying genetic condition in a patient with a diagnosis of definite or probable multiple sclerosis. The great variety of genetic disorders that can masquerade as multiple sclerosis and the many implications of a genetic diagnosis underscore the importance of recognizing genocopies of multiple sclerosis.

Multiple sclerosis in 54 twinships: concordance rate is independent of zygosity. French Research Group on Multiple Sclerosis

In a large population-based multiple sclerosis (MS) sample (n = 7,951), 116 twins were identified (1.4%), of which it was possible to contact 97. In 27 pairs, the twin of the patient with MS was dead. Among the 70 remaining pairs, 16 were excluded because either the index patient or their twin did not accept protocol requirements. The final sample included 54 pairs. Twin zygosity was determined by DNA fingerprint analysis. We found 17 monozygotic pairs and 37 dizygotic pairs. One of the 17 monozygotic pairs (5.9%) and 1 of the 37 dizygotic pairs (2.7%) were concordant for MS. In 42 of the clinically unaffected twins, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain was performed, and 9 scans were classified as indicative of MS. Three of these 42 patients had abnormal visual-evoked potentials, but all 3 had normal MRI scans. The overall proportion of pairs in which the co-twin had some form of clinical, radiological, or electrophysiological abnormality was approximately 30%; this proportion was independent of zygosity.

Familial multiple sclerosis: MRI findings in clinically affected and unaffected siblings

Subclinical demyelinating lesions may occur in the brains of asymptomatic individuals, and the first-degree relatives of multiple sclerosis (MS) patients are at particular risk. Clinical and MRI examinations were performed in nine sibships from families with two or more cases of MS. These included 14 patients with clinically definite MS, three patients with clinically probable MS, and 27 asymptomatic siblings. Systematic criteria were applied to MRI interpretations to increase their specificity for MS. Thirteen (76%) of the 17 patients with MS showed lesions suggesting MS. Lesions were also found in six (38%) of the 16 asymptomatic siblings under age 50 and in eight (73%) of the 11 over age 50. Judged by stringent criteria, the lesions of only three (11%) of the 27 asymptomatic siblings were considered to be due to demyelination. The results demonstrate the occurrence of subclinical demyelination in asymptomatic siblings of MS patients and stress the importance of clinical follow up and MRI studies of the first-degree relatives when classifying them as healthy in family studies.

HLAs and genes in Japanese patients with multiple sclerosis: evidence for increased frequencies of HLA-Cw3, HLA-DR2, and HLA-DQB1*0602

The distribution of HLA-A, B, C, DR and DRB1, DQB1, DPB1 alleles was studied in 60 Japanese patients with clinically definite multiple sclerosis (MS) using serologic and genomic analysis. We found significant associations with HLA-Cw3 (p = 0.002, pc = 0.012, RR = 3.2), DR2 (p = 0.007, RR = 2.6), and DQB1*0602 (p = 0.04, RR = 4.0) in Japanese patients for the first time. The combined presence of Cw3 and DR2 gave a higher risk than each antigen alone. The reported increase in the frequency of DPw4 in Japanese MS patients [12] could not be confirmed by our genomic study. The frequencies of all of the residues in each variable region of the amino acid sequences of DQ beta and DP beta chains were not different between the MS patients and the controls. These results suggest that MS susceptibility may result from polygenic influences and from the presence of environmental factors.

Uses and limitations of twin studies

Series of twin pairs selected because one (or both) is ill are prone to biassed ascertainment, and great care has to be taken to avoid this. Such bias is absent if the primary source is a twin registry established at birth. In general, series of twin pairs have no advantage over studies on sibs in assessing the size of genetic contribution to disease. However, individual monozygotic twin pairs who are discordant for single gene or multifactorial conditions offer unique opportunities for investigating postzygotic mutations, for searching for factors that may precipitate disease or influence its course, and for assessing the effect of prophylactic measures.

The contribution of non-MHC genes to susceptibility to autoimmune diseases

Genetic studies of experimental models of autoimmune diseases, including systemic lupus-like syndromes and organ-specific autoimmunity, provide major information on genetic control of autoimmune diseases. In addition to genes known to be linked to the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), these studies point to multiple genes located outside the MHC that influence the onset and the progression of autoimmune diseases. Identification of these genes and of their interrelationships is now a major task that will be facilitated by recent progress in molecular biology and gene mapping. Among candidate genes, antigen-receptor genes (i.e., immunoglobulin- and T-cell receptor genes) most likely contribute an important part of the autoimmune susceptibility in several of these animal models. Available linkage data suggest a similar involvement of these antigen-receptor genes in several human autoimmune diseases. In addition to a better understanding of pathogenic mechanisms associated with autoimmunity, the knowledge of these disease-predisposing genes is expected to permit a better classification of often complex syndromes as well as the design of new treatments.

Discordance of T-cell receptor beta-chain genes in familial multiple sclerosis

Restriction fragment length polymorphisms of the T-cell receptor beta-chain gene were studied in DNA obtained from 96 individuals from 14 multiplex families with multiple sclerosis (MS). Thirty-four family members had definite MS and two had probable MS. Five normal family members had abnormal findings on cranial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans. Linkage analysis was performed using the BglII and the KpnI polymorphisms. With penetrance values from 0.1 to 0.7, and altering the scoring of the normal individuals with abnormal findings on MRI scans from "unknown" to "affected," log of the odds scores between -4.59 to -12.76 were found for the autosomal dominant model. For the autosomal recessive model with a penetrance range from 0.1 to 1.0, the LOD scores ranged from -8.20 to -32.98. These findings do not support a direct role of T-cell receptor beta-chain gene in the inheritance of MS.

T-cell recognition of myelin basic protein

Multiple sclerosis is a chronic inflammatory disease of the central nervous system which has been hypothesized to be autoimmune in nature. To test whether this is the case, Kai Wucherpfennig and colleagues have developed a set of criteria that must be met to satisfy the hypothesis. Here, they present these criteria and assess the extent to which studies to date satisfy them.

A review of the aetiology of multiple sclerosis: an ecological approach

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a disease of unknown aetiology characterized by myelin destruction. Approaches to the aetiology of the condition have noted its differential geographic and demographic distribution; a tentative and inconsistent link with infectious agents; a genetic susceptibility; and a tendency to track with dietary lipids. This review proposes a multidisciplinary approach to the aetiology of MS, emphasizing the interlocking and interdependent nature of current aetiological arguments. We suggest that the most profitable interpretation of current empirical data on the aetiology of MS can be accomplished through this kind of analysis.

MS and SLE in twins of successive generations

During a nationwide twin study on multiple sclerosis (MS) in Finland a dizygotic pair discordant for MS was found. The affected co-twin had dizygotic twin daughters. The affected co-twin of the second generation had systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Both pairs were thoroughly examined. No evidence of CNS involvement in the healthy co-twins was found. In pairwise comparisons, virus-specific IgG antibodies to measles and mumps were significantly increased in the MS patient whereas the same was true for rubella in the SLE patient. Both MS and SLE patient expressed HLA alleles most often found to be associated with these disorders. Reversed CD4/CD8 ratios were observed in both MS and SLE patient. No difference in interleukin-2 receptor expression were found but gamma-interferon secretion in the MS patient showed marked increase whereas that of the SLE patient was of the same magnitude as in the healthy members. A different triggering stimulus rather than the dissimilarity in the immunogenetic predisposition may be decisive as to whether or not they develop MS or SLE.

Identification of a locus on mouse chromosome 3 involved in differential susceptibility to Theiler's murine encephalomyelitis virus-induced demyelinating disease

Theiler's virus-induced demyelinating disease results from a chronic infection in the white matter of the central nervous system and provides an excellent model for human multiple sclerosis. Like multiple sclerosis, there are genetic risk factors in disease development, including genes associated with the major histocompatibility complex and with those encoding the beta chain of the T-cell receptor. Comparisons of the susceptible DBA/2 and resistant C57BL/6 strains have indicated an important role for the H-2D locus and for a non-H-2 gene (not involving the beta chain of the T-cell receptor) in differential susceptibility. In the present report, analysis of recombinant-inbred strains (BXD) between the DBA/2 and C57BL/6 strains indicated that this non-H-2 locus is located at the centromeric end of chromosome 3 near (4 +/- 4 centimorgans) the carbonic anhydrase-2 (Car-2) enzyme locus.

The prevalence of multiple sclerosis in the health district of Bassetlaw

Planning by norms for health services means than any significant variation of need observed in a district must be quantified and taken into account. A postal questionnaire to all health care groups who might be giving a service to sufferers from Multiple Sclerosis yielded 182 names, representing 98 individual patients, a prevalence of 98 per 100,000 total population, 22% over the expected number based on other published sources and almost up to what would have been considered the exceptional levels in the Orkneys. General Practitioners notified 51% of cases; a higher proportion than any other group. Community occupational therapists, hospital medical records and the community nursing service accounted for nearly all the others.

Depressive illness in multiple sclerosis. Clinical and theoretical aspects of the association

The present state of knowledge of the possible relationship between depressive illness and multiple sclerosis is described. Problems of the research methodology are identified and suggestions made for useful areas of inquiry.

Magnetic resonance imaging studies in multiple sclerosis twins

Magnetic resonance (MR) imaging examinations were performed on a series of seven sets of twins (four monozygotic and three dizygotic) and one set of triplets who were clinically discordant for multiple sclerosis (MS). MR abnormalities were detected in some of the unaffected monozygotic pairs of twins.

A susceptibility locus for multiple sclerosis is linked to the T cell receptor beta chain complex

Inheritance of T cell receptor beta chain (TCR beta) genes was analyzed in families of 40 sibling pairs concordant for the relapsing-remitting form of multiple sclerosis (MS). TCR beta haplotypes were determined by segregation analysis of polymorphic markers within the TCR beta complex. The mean proportion of TCR beta haplotypes identical by descent (IBD) inherited by MS sibling pairs was significantly increased compared with expected values (means test, p less than 0.004), whereas the distribution of haplotype sharing was random when MS patients were compared with their unaffected siblings. Furthermore, one allelic form of a TCR beta variable region gene segment was overrepresented on MS chromosomes compared with those parental chromosomes not transmitted to MS offspring both in the MS sibling pair families and in a second group of families containing only one individual affected with MS. These results demonstrate that a gene within the TCR beta complex or a closely linked locus influences susceptibility to MS.

Multiple sclerosis: basic concepts and hypothesis

Multiple sclerosis, an inflammatory disease of the central nervous system, is characterized by primary destruction of myelin. This review covers recent advances in neuropathology, immunogenetics, neuroimmunology, and neurovirology that have provided insights regarding its pathogenesis. Three hypotheses are discussed: (1) autoimmunity, (2) "bystander" demyelination, and (3) immune destruction of persistently infected oligodendrocytes. A paradigm for induction of primary demyelination is proposed in which immune cells recognize "foreign" antigens on the surface of oligodendrocytes in the context of major histocompatibility complex gene products. The final result of this scheme may be "dying-back gliopathy," the alteration being noted first in the most distal extension of the oligodendrocyte--that is, the myelin sheaths.

A population-based study of multiple sclerosis in twins

Results from studies of twin concordance in multiple sclerosis have not conclusively differentiated between environmental and genetic factors that determine susceptibility to the disease. Published studies that have been based on case finding by public appeal have been characterized by difficulties in ascertainment. The data reported here are from a large population-based study of multiple sclerosis in twins, in which ascertainment has been relatively unbiased and the cooperation of patients nearly complete. A total of 5463 patients attending 10 multiple sclerosis clinics across Canada were surveyed. Twenty-seven monozygotic and 43 dizygotic twin pairs were identified, and the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis was verified by examination and laboratory investigation. Seven of 27 monozygotic pairs (25.9 percent) and 1 of 43 dizygotic pairs (2.3 percent) were concordant for multiple sclerosis. The concordance rate for 4582 nontwin siblings of patients at two multiple sclerosis clinics was 1.9 percent, closely paralleling the concordance rate in dizygotic twins. To the extent that the difference in concordance rates between monozygotic and dizygotic twins indicates genetic susceptibility, the results of this study show a major genetic component in susceptibility to multiple sclerosis.

Immunoglobulin allotypes and susceptibility to multiple sclerosis. An epidemiological and genetic study in the Hautes-Pyrénées county of France

Serum samples collected from 69 patients with multiple sclerosis (MS) living in the Hautes-Pyrénées county were tested for immunoglobulin Gm gamma 1, gamma 2, and gamma 3, heavy chain allotypes (Gm system), and immunoglobulin light chain Kappa (Km system). A control group was made up of normal individuals living in the same county. We found a significant excess of individuals with Gm3; +/- 23;5/Gm3; +/- 23;5 amongst the MS patients as compared with controls (relative risk = 2.4). A slight increase of the Km (1) frequency was found in MS patients compared with controls, 21.7% vs 11.8%, but this difference was not significant.