Alterations in somite patterning of Myf-5-deficient mice: a possible role for FGF-4 and FGF-6

dmrt2 and myf5 Link Early Somitogenesis to Left-Right Axis Determination in Xenopus laevis

The vertebrate left-right axis is specified during neurulation by events occurring in a transient ciliated epithelium termed left-right organizer (LRO), which is made up of two distinct cell types. In the axial midline, central LRO (cLRO) cells project motile monocilia and generate a leftward fluid flow, which represents the mechanism of symmetry breakage. This directional fluid flow is perceived by laterally positioned sensory LRO (sLRO) cells, which harbor non-motile cilia. In sLRO cells on the left side, flow-induced signaling triggers post-transcriptional repression of the multi-pathway antagonist dand5. Subsequently, the co-expressed Tgf-β growth factor Nodal1 is released from Dand5-mediated repression to induce left-sided gene expression. Interestingly, Xenopus sLRO cells have somitic fate, suggesting a connection between LR determination and somitogenesis. Here, we show that doublesex and mab3-related transcription factor 2 (Dmrt2), known to be involved in vertebrate somitogenesis, is required for LRO ciliogenesis and sLRO specification. In dmrt2 morphants, misexpression of the myogenic transcription factors tbx6 and myf5 at early gastrula stages preceded the misspecification of sLRO cells at neurula stages. myf5 morphant tadpoles also showed LR defects due to a failure of sLRO development. The gain of myf5 function reintroduced sLRO cells in dmrt2 morphants, demonstrating that paraxial patterning and somitogenesis are functionally linked to LR axis formation in Xenopus.

Assessing Myf5 and Lbx1 contribution to carapace development by reproducing their turtle-specific signatures in mouse embryos

BACKGROUND

The turtle carapace is an evolutionary novelty resulting from changes in the processes that build ribs and their associated muscles in most tetrapod species. Turtle embryos have several unique features that might play a role in this process, including the carapacial ridge, a Myf5 gene with shorter coding region that generates an alternative splice variant lacking exon 2, and unusual expression patterns of Lbx1 and HGF.

RESULTS

We investigated these turtle-specific expression differences using genetic approaches in mouse embryos. At mid gestation, mouse embryos producing Myf5 transcripts lacking exon 2 replicated some early properties of turtle somites, but still developed into viable and fertile mice. Extending Lbx1 expression into the hypaxial dermomyotomal lip of trunk somites to mimic the turtle Lbx1 expression pattern, produced fusions in the distal part of the ribs.

CONCLUSIONS

Turtle-like Myf5 activity might generate a plastic state in developing trunk somites under which they can either enter carapace morphogenetic routes, possibly triggered by signals from the carapacial ridge, or still engage in the development of a standard tetrapod ribcage in the absence of those signals. In addition, trunk Lbx1 expression might play a later role in the formation of the lateral border of the carapace. This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.

Axial skeleton anterior-posterior patterning is regulated through feedback regulation between Meis transcription factors and retinoic acid

Vertebrate axial skeletal patterning is controlled by co-linear expression of Hox genes and axial level-dependent activity of HOX protein combinations. MEIS transcription factors act as co-factors of HOX proteins and profusely bind to Hox complex DNA; however, their roles in mammalian axial patterning remain unknown. Retinoic acid (RA) is known to regulate axial skeletal element identity through the transcriptional activity of its receptors; however, whether this role is related to MEIS/HOX activity remains unknown. Here, we study the role of Meis in axial skeleton formation and its relationship to the RA pathway in mice. Meis elimination in the paraxial mesoderm produces anterior homeotic transformations and rib mis-patterning associated to alterations of the hypaxial myotome. Although Raldh2 and Meis positively regulate each other, Raldh2 elimination largely recapitulates the defects associated with Meis deficiency, and Meis overexpression rescues the axial skeletal defects in Raldh2 mutants. We propose a Meis-RA-positive feedback loop, the output of which is Meis levels, that is essential to establish anterior-posterior identities and patterning of the vertebrate axial skeleton.

Development and patterning of rib primordia are dependent on associated musculature

The importance of skeletal muscle for rib development and patterning in the mouse embryo has not been resolved, largely because different experimental approaches have yielded disparate results. In this study, we utilize both gene knockouts and muscle cell ablation approaches to re-visit the extent to which rib growth and patterning are dependent on developing musculature. Consistent with previous studies, we show that rib formation is highly dependent on the MYOD family of myogenic regulatory factors (MRFs), and demonstrate that the extent of rib formation is gene-, allele-, and dosage-dependent. In the absence of Myf5 and MyoD, one allele of Mrf4 is sufficient for extensive rib growth, although patterning is abnormal. Under conditions of limiting MRF dosage, MyoD is identified as a positive regulator of rib patterning, presumably due to improved intercostal muscle development. In contrast to previous muscle ablation studies, we show that diphtheria toxin subunit A (DTA)-mediated ablation of muscle progenitors or differentiated muscle, using MyoD^iCre or HSA-Cre drivers, respectively, profoundly disrupts rib development. Further, a comparison of three independently derived Rosa26-based DTA knockin alleles demonstrates that the degree of rib perturbations in MyoD^iCre/+/DTA embryos is markedly dependent on the DTA allele used, and may in part explain discrepancies with previous findings. The results support the conclusion that the extent and quality of rib formation is largely dependent on the dosage of Myf5 and Mrf4, and that both early myotome-sclerotome interactions, as well as later muscle-rib interactions, are important for proper rib growth and patterning.

Functional mutations in 5'UTR of the BMPR2 gene identified in Chinese families with pulmonary arterial hypertension

Pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) is a progressive pulmonary vasculopathy with significant morbidity and mortality. Bone morphogenetic protein receptor type 2 (BMPR2) has been well recognized as the principal gene responsible for heritable and sporadic PAH. Four unrelated Chinese patients with PAH and their family members, both symptomatic and asymptomatic, were genetically evaluated by sequencing all exons and the flanking regions of BMPR2. Functionality of the aberrant mutations at the 5' untranslated region (UTR) of BMPR2 in the families with PAH was determined by site mutation, transient transfection, and promoter-reporter assays. Four individual mutations in the BMPR2 gene were identified in the 4 families, respectively: 10-GGC repeats, 13-GGC repeats, 4-AGC repeats in 5'UTR, and a novel missense mutation in exon 7 (c.961C>T; p.Arg321X). Moreover, we demonstrated that (1) these 5'UTR mutations decreased the transcription of BMPR2 and (2) the GGC repeats and AGC repeats in BMPR2 5'UTR bore functional binding sites of EGR-1 and MYF5, respectively. This is the first report demonstrating the presence of functional BMPR2 5'UTR mutations in familial patients with PAH and further indicating that EGR-1 and MYF5 are potential targets for correcting these genetic abnormalities for PAH therapy.

Emerging from the rib: resolving the turtle controversies

Two of the major controversies in the present study of turtle shell development involve the mechanism by which the carapacial ridge initiates shell formation and the mechanism by which each rib forms the costal bones adjacent to it. This paper claims that both sides of each debate might be correct-but within the species examined. Mechanism is more properly "mechanisms," and there is more than one single way to initiate carapace formation and to form the costal bones. In the initiation of the shell, the rib precursors may be kept dorsal by either "axial displacement" (in the hard-shell turtles) or "axial arrest" (in the soft-shell turtle Pelodiscus), or by a combination of these. The former process would deflect the rib into the dorsal dermis and allow it to continue its growth there, while the latter process would truncate rib growth. In both instances, though, the result is to keep the ribs from extending into the ventral body wall. Our recent work has shown that the properties of the carapacial ridge, a key evolutionary innovation of turtles, differ greatly between these two groups. Similarly, the mechanism of costal bone formation may differ between soft-shell and hard-shell turtles, in that the hard-shell species may have both periosteal flattening as well as dermal bone induction, while the soft-shelled turtles may have only the first of these processes.

Satellite cells and the muscle stem cell niche

Adult skeletal muscle in mammals is a stable tissue under normal circumstances but has remarkable ability to repair after injury. Skeletal muscle regeneration is a highly orchestrated process involving the activation of various cellular and molecular responses. As skeletal muscle stem cells, satellite cells play an indispensible role in this process. The self-renewing proliferation of satellite cells not only maintains the stem cell population but also provides numerous myogenic cells, which proliferate, differentiate, fuse, and lead to new myofiber formation and reconstitution of a functional contractile apparatus. The complex behavior of satellite cells during skeletal muscle regeneration is tightly regulated through the dynamic interplay between intrinsic factors within satellite cells and extrinsic factors constituting the muscle stem cell niche/microenvironment. For the last half century, the advance of molecular biology, cell biology, and genetics has greatly improved our understanding of skeletal muscle biology. Here, we review some recent advances, with focuses on functions of satellite cells and their niche during the process of skeletal muscle regeneration.

A TGFβ-Smad4-Fgf6 signaling cascade controls myogenic differentiation and myoblast fusion during tongue development

The tongue is a muscular organ and plays a crucial role in speech, deglutition and taste. Despite the important physiological functions of the tongue, little is known about the regulatory mechanisms of tongue muscle development. TGFβ family members play important roles in regulating myogenesis, but the functional significance of Smad-dependent TGFβ signaling in regulating tongue skeletal muscle development remains unclear. In this study, we have investigated Smad4-mediated TGFβ signaling in the development of occipital somite-derived myogenic progenitors during tongue morphogenesis through tissue-specific inactivation of Smad4 (using Myf5-Cre;Smad4(flox/flox) mice). During the initiation of tongue development, cranial neural crest (CNC) cells occupy the tongue buds before myogenic progenitors migrate into the tongue primordium, suggesting that CNC cells play an instructive role in guiding tongue muscle development. Moreover, ablation of Smad4 results in defects in myogenic terminal differentiation and myoblast fusion. Despite compromised muscle differentiation, tendon formation appears unaffected in the tongue of Myf5-Cre;Smad4(flox/flox) mice, suggesting that the differentiation and maintenance of CNC-derived tendon cells are independent of Smad4-mediated signaling in myogenic cells in the tongue. Furthermore, loss of Smad4 results in a significant reduction in expression of several members of the FGF family, including Fgf6 and Fgfr4. Exogenous Fgf6 partially rescues the tongue myoblast fusion defect of Myf5-Cre;Smad4(flox/flox) mice. Taken together, our study demonstrates that a TGFβ-Smad4-Fgf6 signaling cascade plays a crucial role in myogenic cell fate determination and lineage progression during tongue myogenesis.

Hox genes and regional patterning of the vertebrate body plan

Several decades have passed since the discovery of Hox genes in the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster. Their unique ability to regulate morphologies along the anteroposterior (AP) axis (Lewis, 1978) earned them well-deserved attention as important regulators of embryonic development. Phenotypes due to loss- and gain-of-function mutations in mouse Hox genes have revealed that the spatio-temporally controlled expression of these genes is critical for the correct morphogenesis of embryonic axial structures. Here, we review recent novel insight into the modalities of Hox protein function in imparting specific identity to anatomical regions of the vertebral column, and in controlling the emergence of these tissues concomitantly with providing them with axial identity. The control of these functions must have been intimately linked to the shaping of the body plan during evolution.

Evidence for a myotomal Hox/Myf cascade governing nonautonomous control of rib specification within global vertebral domains

Hox genes are essential for the patterning of the axial skeleton. Hox group 10 has been shown to specify the lumbar domain by setting a rib-inhibiting program in the presomitic mesoderm (PSM). We have now produced mice with ribs in every vertebra by ectopically expressing Hox group 6 in the PSM, indicating that Hox genes are also able to specify the thoracic domain. We show that the information provided by Hox genes to specify rib-containing and rib-less areas is first interpreted in the myotome through the regional-specific control of Myf5 and Myf6 expression. This information is then transmitted to the sclerotome by a system that includes FGF and PDGF signaling to produce vertebrae with or without ribs at different axial levels. Our findings offer a new perspective of how Hox genes produce global patterns in the axial skeleton and support a redundant nonmyogenic role of Myf5 and Myf6 in rib formation.

Extrinsic regulation of domestic animal-derived myogenic satellite cells II

The existence of myogenic satellite cells was reported some 47 years ago, and, since that time, satellite cell research has flourished. So much new information is generated (daily) on these cells that it can be difficult for individuals to keep abreast of important issues related to their activation and proliferation, the modulation of the activity of other cell types, the differentiation of the cells to facilitate normal skeletal muscle growth and development, or to the repair of damaged myofibers. The intent of this review is to summarize new information about the extrinsic regulation of myogenic satellite cells and to provide specific mechanisms involved in altering satellite cell physiology. Where possible, examples from agriculturally important animals are used for illustrative purposes.

TGF-beta mediated Msx2 expression controls occipital somites-derived caudal region of skull development

Craniofacial development involves cranial neural crest (CNC) and mesoderm-derived cells. TGF-beta signaling plays a critical role in instructing CNC cells to form the craniofacial skeleton. However, it is not known how TGF-beta signaling regulates the fate of mesoderm-derived cells during craniofacial development. In this study, we show that occipital somites contribute to the caudal region of mammalian skull development. Conditional inactivation of Tgfbr2 in mesoderm-derived cells results in defects of the supraoccipital bone with meningoencephalocele and discontinuity of the neural arch of the C1 vertebra. At the cellular level, loss of TGF-beta signaling causes decreased chondrocyte proliferation and premature differentiation of cartilage to bone. Expression of Msx2, a critical factor in the formation of the dorsoventral axis, is diminished in the Tgfbr2 mutant. Significantly, overexpression of Msx2 in Myf5-Cre;Tgfbr2flox/flox mice partially rescues supraoccipital bone development. These results suggest that the TGF-beta/Msx2 signaling cascade is critical for development of the caudal region of the skull.

Comparative expression of mouse and chicken Shisa homologues during early development

During vertebrate embryogenesis, fibroblast growth factor (FGF) and Wnt signaling have been implicated in diverse cellular processes, including cell growth, differentiation, and tissue patterning. The recently identified Xenopus Shisa protein promotes head formation by inhibiting Wnt and FGF signaling through its interaction with the immature forms of Frizzled and FGF receptors in the endoplasmic reticulum, which prevents their posttranslational maturation. Here, we describe the mouse and chicken homologues of Xenopus Shisa. The mouse and chicken Shisa proteins share, respectively, 33.6% and 33.8% identity with the Xenopus homolog. In situ hybridization analysis shows that mouse shisa is expressed throughout embryonic development, predominantly in the anterior visceral endoderm, headfolds, somites, forebrain, optic vesicle, and limb buds. Cross-species comparison shows that the expression pattern of cshisa closely mirrors that of mshisa. Our observations indicate that the Shisa family genes are typically expressed in tissues known to require the modulation of Wnt and FGF signaling.

FGF6 in myogenesis

Important functions in myogenesis have been proposed for FGF6, a member of the fibroblast growth factor family accumulating almost exclusively in the myogenic lineage. However, the analyses of Fgf6 (-/-) mutant mice gave contradictory results and the role of FGF6 during myogenesis remained largely unclear. Recent reports support the concept that FGF6 has a dual function in muscle regeneration, stimulating myoblast proliferation/migration and muscle differentiation/hypertrophy in a dose-dependent manner. The alternative use of distinct signaling pathways recruiting either FGFR1 or FGFR4 might explain the dual role of FGF6 in myogenesis. A role for FGF6 in the maintenance of a reserve pool of progenitor cells in the skeletal muscle has been also strongly suggested. The aim of this review is to summarize our knowledge on the involvement of FGF6 in myogenesis.

The Neural Tube Is Required to Maintain Primary Segmentation in the Sclerotome

Primary segmentation in vertebrates is considered to be an intrinsic property of the presomitic paraxial mesoderm controlled by a number of interconnected oscillating signals. Re-segmentation, in contrast, has been shown to depend on signals from the axial structures. Here we report the requirement of the neural tube for maintenance but not formation of primary segmentation in chick embryos. Unilateral removal of the neural tube, next to the anterior presomitic mesoderm, caused disturbed development of the neural arches and the spinous processes. But already 24 h postsurgery, the sclerotome showed loss of primary segmentation in the craniocaudal axis. Cells strongly expressing twist and not showing any segmentation were located dorsomedially between the remaining left half of the neural tube and the right side dermomyotome, which frequently was truncated medially.

Targeted disruption of the DM domain containing transcription factor Dmrt2 reveals an essential role in somite patterning

Dmrt2 is expressed in the dermomyotome of developing vertebrate somites. To determine the role of Dmrt2 during mouse embryonic development, we generated a null mutation of Dmrt2 via homologous recombination in embryonic stem cells. Dmrt2 heterozygous mice derived from these cells are phenotypically normal. However, Dmrt2 homozygotes die soon after birth. The cause of death is likely due to abnormal rib and sternal development, leading to an inability to breathe. Loss of Dmrt2 leads to embryonic somite patterning defects, first evidenced at embryonic day (E) 10.5 and more pronounced by E11.5. Notably, both the dermomyotome and myotome fail to adopt a normal epithelial morphology in the absence of Dmrt2. Accompanying these morphological defects are alterations in the expression patterns of dermomyotomal and myotomal transcription factors including Pax3, Paraxis, Myf5, myogenin, Mrf4 and MyoD. Despite these defects, embryos harvested from E13.5 onwards exhibited relatively normal muscle pattern and mass, suggesting that early myotomal defects are corrected by a Dmrt2-independent mechanism. Taken together, our results define an essential function for Dmrt2 in somite development and provide evidence that DM domain genes have been co-opted into other critical developmental pathways distinct from that of sex determination or differentiation.

Epimorphin acts extracellularly to promote cell sorting and aggregation during the condensation of vertebral cartilage

Formation of vertebrae occurs via endochondral ossification, a process involving condensation of precartilaginous cells. Here, we provide the first molecular evidence of mechanism that underlies initiation of this process by showing that the extracellular factor, Epimorphin, plays a role during early steps in vertebral cartilage condensation. Epimorphin mRNA is predominantly localized in the vertebral primordium. When provided exogenously in ovo, it causes precocious differentiation of chondrocytes, resulting in the formation of supernumerary vertebral cartilage in chicken embryos. To further analyze its mode of action, we used an in vitro co-culture system in which labeled 10T1/2 or sclerotomal prechondrogenic cells were co-cultured with unlabeled Epimorphin-producing cells. In the presence of Epimorphin, the labeled cells formed tightly packed aggregates, and sclerotomal cells displayed augmented accumulation of NCAM and other early markers of chondrocyte differentiation. Finally, we found that the Epimorphin expression is initiated during vertebrogenesis by Sonic hedgehog from the notochord mediated by Sox 9. We present a model in which successive action of Epimorphin in recruiting and stacking sclerotomal cells leads to a sequential elongation of a vertebral primordium.

FGF6 regulates muscle differentiation through a calcineurin-dependent pathway in regenerating soleus of adult mice

Important functions in myogenesis have been proposed for FGF6, a member of the fibroblast growth factor family accumulating almost exclusively in the myogenic lineage, but its precise role in vivo remains mostly unclear. Here, using FGF6 (-/-) mice and rescue experiments by injection of recombinant FGF6, we dissected the functional role of FGF6 during in vivo myogenesis. We found that the appearance of myotubes was accelerated during regeneration of the soleus of FGF6 (-/-) mice versus wild type mice. This accelerated differentiation was correlated with increased expression of differentiation markers such as CdkIs and calcineurin, as well as structural markers such as MHCI and slow TnI. We showed that an elevated transcript level for calcineurin Aalpha subunit correlated with a positive regulation of calcineurin A activity in regenerating soleus of the FGF6 (-/-) mice. Cyclin D1 and calcineurin were up- and down-regulated, respectively in a dose-dependent manner upon injection of rhFGF6 in regenerating soleus of the mutant mice. We showed an increase of the number of slow oxidative (type I) myofibers, whereas fast oxidative (type IIa) myofibers were decreased in number in regenerating soleus of FGF6 (-/-) mice versus that of wild type mice. In adult soleus, the number of type I myofibers was also higher in FGF6 (-/-) mice than in wild type mice. Taken together these results evidenced a specific phenotype for soleus of the FGF6 (-/-) mice and led us to propose a model accounting for a specific dose-dependent effect of FGF6 in muscle regeneration. At high doses, FGF6 stimulates the proliferation of the myogenic stem cells, whereas at lower doses it regulates both muscle differentiation and muscle phenotype via a calcineurin-signaling pathway.

IGF-II is up-regulated and myofibres are hypertrophied in regenerating soleus of mice lacking FGF6

Important functions in myogenesis have been proposed for FGF6, a member of the fibroblast growth factor family accumulating almost exclusively in the myogenic lineage. However, the use of FGF6(-/-) mutant mice gave contradictory results and the role of FGF6 during myogenesis remains largely unclear. Using FGF6(-/-) mice, we first analysed the morphology of the regenerated soleus following cardiotoxin injection and showed hypertrophied myofibres in soleus of the mutant mice as compared to wild-type mice. Secondly, to examine the function of the IGF family in the hypertrophy process, we used semiquantitative and real-time RT-PCR assays and Western blots to monitor the expression of the insulin-like growth factors (IGF-I and IGF-II), their receptors [type I IGF receptor (IGF1R) and IGF-II receptor (IGF2R)], and of a binding protein IGFBP-5 in regenerating soleus muscles of FGF6(-/-) knockout mice vs. wild-type mice. In the mutant, both IGF-II and IGF2R, but not IGF-I and IGF1R, were strongly up-regulated, whereas IGFBP5 was down-regulated, strongly suggesting that, in the absence of FGF6, the mechanisms leading to myofibre hypertrophy were mediated specifically by an IGF-II/IGF2R signalling pathway distinct from the classic mechanism involving IGF-I and IGF1R previously described for skeletal muscle hypertrophy. The potential regulating role of IGFBP5 on IGF-II expression is also discussed. This report shows for the first time a specific role for FGF6 in the regulation of myofibre size during a process of in vivo myogenesis.

Site-specific delivery of acidic fibroblast growth factor stimulates angiogenic and osteogenic responsesin vivo

A major clinical problem in orthopedics is the healing of nonunion fractures. Limitations of this bone repair process include insufficient angiogenesis and mineralization. Integrating appropriate biomaterials with site-specific neovascularization and osteogenesis at the wound site has been the focus of several clinically relevant therapeutic strategies. As an extracellular protein, acidic fibroblast growth factor (FGF-1) induces, coordinates, and sustains site-specific molecular responses associated with angiogenesis and osteogenesis. To establish the ability of this growth factor to coordinate bone regenerative process in vivo, site-specific delivery of FGF-1, entrapped in a fibrin/hydroxyapatite composite, was evaluated. Kinetic analysis in vivo revealed the biocomposite was capable of delivering biologically active FGF-1. Release kinetics revealed an initial delivery of 87.5 ng/h of active FGF-1 in the first 20 h, followed by a reduced delivery of 28 ng/h during the next 20 h. In situ immunohistological analyses demonstrated that FGF-1-containing implants induced increased angiogenesis and infiltration of cells expressing osteogenic related markers (i.e., osteopontin, osteocalcin). Collectively, these efforts support that site-specific delivery of active FGF-1 in a fibrin/hydroxyapatite composite is competent to induce not only angiogenesis but also osteogenic cellular responses.

Injection of FGF6 accelerates regeneration of the soleus muscle in adult mice

FGF6, a member of the fibroblast growth factor (FGF) family, accumulated almost exclusively in the myogenic lineage, supporting the finding that FGF6 could specifically regulate myogenesis. Using FGF6 (-/-) mutant mice, important functions in muscle regeneration have been proposed for FGF6 but remain largely controversial. Here, we examined the effect of a single injection of recombinant FGF6 (rhFGF6) on the regeneration of mouse soleus subjected to cardiotoxin injection, specifically looking for molecular and morphological phenotypes. The injection of rhFGF6 has two effects. First, there is an up-regulation of cyclin D1 mRNA, accounting for the regulating role of a high FGF6 concentration on proliferation, and second, differentiation markers such as CdkIs and MHC I and Tn I increase and cellular differentiation is accelerated. We also show a down-regulation of endogenous FGF6, acceleration of FGFR1 receptor expression and deceleration of the FGFR4 receptor expression, possibly accounting for biphasic effects of exogenous FGF6 on muscle regeneration.

A new view of patterning domains in the vertebrate mesoderm

The musculoskeletal system of vertebrates is derived from the embryonic mesoderm. Its structures are categorized as epaxial or hypaxial based on their adult position and innervation. The epaxial/hypaxial terminology is also used to describe regions of the embryonic somites based on fate mapping of somitic derivatives. However, the adult, functional distinctions are not fully consistent with the changing embryonic environments of mesodermal populations during morphogenesis, and the traditional terminology loses accuracy when used to describe certain mutant phenotypes. Here we describe a new terminology naming two mesodermal environments defined by the lineage of the included cells. We discuss how mutant phenotypes may be better explained by consideration of the embryonic context in which genes take their effect and argue that the recognition of these embryonic territories clarifies description and discussion of the morphogenesis and patterning of the musculoskeletal system.

Inhibition of skeletal muscle development: less differentiation gives more muscle

The fact that stem cells have to be protected from premature differentiation is true for many organs in the developing embryo and the adult organism. However, there are several arguments that this is particularly important for (skeletal) muscle. There are some evolutionary arguments that muscle is a "default" pathway for mesodermal cells, which has to be actively prevented in order to allow cells to differentiate into other tissues. Myogenic cells originate from very small areas of the embryo where only a minor portion of these cells is supposed to differentiate. Differentiated muscle fibres are unconditionally post-mitotic, leaving undifferentiated stem cells as the only source of regeneration. The mechanical usage of muscle and its superficial location in the vertebrate body makes regeneration a frequently used mechanism. Looking at the different inhibitory mechanisms that have been found within the past 10 or so years, it appears as if evolution has taken this issue very serious. At all possible levels we find regulatory mechanisms that help to fine tune the differentiation of myogenic cells. Secreted molecules specifying different populations of somitic cells, diffusing or membrane-bound signals among fellow myoblasts, modulating molecules within the extracellular matrix and last, but not least, a changing set of activating and repressing cofactors. We have come a long way from the simple model of MyoD just to be turned on at the right time in the right cell.

T-box binding site mediates the dorsal activation of myf-5 in Xenopus gastrula embryos

Myf-5, a member of the muscle regulatory factor family of transcription factors, plays an important role in the determination, development, and differentiation of the skeletal muscle. Factors that regulate the expression of myf-5 itself are not well understood. We show here that a T-box binding site in the Xenopus myf-5 promoter mediated the activation of myf-5 expression through specific interaction with nuclear proteins of gastrula embryos. The T-box binding site could be bound by and respond to T-box proteins. T-box genes could induce Xmyf-5. The results suggest that T-box proteins are involved in the specification of myogenic mesoderm and muscle development.

Essential and redundant functions of the MyoD distal regulatory region revealed by targeted mutagenesis

Transgenic analyses have defined two MyoD enhancers in mammals, the core enhancer and distal regulatory region (DRR); these enhancers exhibit complementary activities and together are sufficient to recapitulate MyoD expression in developing and mature skeletal muscle. DRR activity is restricted to differentiated muscle and persists postnatally, suggesting an important role in maintaining MyoD expression in myocytes and muscle fibers. Here, we use targeted mutagenesis in the mouse to define essential functions of the DRR in its normal chromosomal context. Surprisingly, deletion of the DRR resulted in reduced MyoD expression in all myogenic lineages at E10.5, at least 1 day prior to detection of DRR activity in limb buds and branchial arches of transgenic mice. At later embryonic and fetal stages, however, no defect in MyoD expression was observed, indicating that the DRR is dispensable for regulating MyoD during muscle differentiation. Expression analyses in wild-type and Myf-5 mutant embryos also indicate that the DRR is not an obligate target for Myf-5- and Pax-3-dependent regulation. In contrast to embryonic and fetal stages, deletion of the DRR resulted in a pronounced reduction in MyoD mRNA levels in adults, showing a functional requirement for DRR activity in mature muscle. These data reveal essential and redundant functions of the DRR and underscore the importance of loss-of-function enhancer analyses for understanding cis transcriptional circuitry.

Sonic hedgehog is a survival factor for hypaxial muscles during mouse development

Sonic hedgehog (Shh) has been proposed to function as an inductive and trophic signal that controls development of epaxial musculature in vertebrate embryos. In contrast, development of hypaxial muscles was assumed to occur independently of Shh. We here show that formation of limb muscles was severely affected in two different mouse strains with inactivating mutations of the Shh gene. The limb muscle defect became apparent relatively late and initial stages of hypaxial muscle development were unaffected or only slightly delayed. Micromass cultures and cultures of tissue fragments derived from limbs under different conditions with or without the overlaying ectoderm indicated that Shh is required for the maintenance of the expression of myogenic regulatory factors (MRFs) and, consecutively, for the formation of differentiated limb muscle myotubes. We propose that Shh acts as a survival and proliferation factor for myogenic precursor cells during hypaxial muscle development. Detection of a reduced but significant level of Myf5 expression in the epaxial compartment of somites of Shh homozygous mutant embryos at E9.5 indicated that Shh might be dispensable for the initiation of myogenesis both in hypaxial and epaxial muscles. Our data suggest that Shh acts similarly in both somitic compartments as a survival and proliferation factor and not as a primary inducer of myogenesis.

Early myotome specification regulates PDGFA expression and axial skeleton development

Reciprocal defects in signaling between the myotome and the sclerotome compartments of the somites in PDGFRalpha and Myf5 mutant embryos lead to alterations in the formation of the vertebrae and the ribs. To investigate the significance of these observations, we have examined the role of PDGF signaling in the developing somite. PDGFA ligand expression was not detected in the myotome of Myf5 null mutant embryos and PDGFA promoter activity was regulated by Myf5 in vitro. PDGFA stimulated chondrogenesis in somite micromass cultures as well as in embryos when PDGFA was knocked into the Myf5 locus, resulting in increased vertebral and rib development. PDGFA expression in the myotome was fully restored in embryos in which MyoD has been introduced at the Myf5 locus but to a lesser extent in similar myogenin knock-in embryos. These results underscore the importance of growth factor signaling within the developing somite and suggest an important role for myogenic determination factors in orchestrating normal development of the axial skeleton.

Thoracic skeletal defects in myogenin- and MRF4-deficient mice correlate with early defects in myotome and intercostal musculature

Myogenin and MRF4 are skeletal muscle-specific bHLH transcription factors critical for muscle development. In addition to a variety of skeletal muscle defects, embryos homozygous for mutations in myogenin or MRF4 display phenotypes in the thoracic skeleton, including rib fusions and sternal defects. These skeletal defects are likely to be secondary because myogenin and MRF4 are not expressed in the rib cartilage or sternum. In this study, the requirement for myogenin and MRF4 in thoracic skeletal development was further examined. When a hypomorphic allele of myogenin and an MRF4-null mutation were placed together, the severity of the thoracic skeletal defects was greatly increased and included extensive rib cartilage fusion and fused sternebrae. Additionally, new rib defects were observed in myogenin/MRF4 compound mutants, including a failure of the rib cartilage to contact the sternum. These results suggested that myogenin and MRF4 share overlapping functions in thoracic skeletal formation. Spatial expression patterns of skeletal muscle-specific markers in myogenin- and MRF4-mutant embryos revealed early skeletal muscle defects not previously reported. MRF4-/- mice displayed abnormal intercostal muscle morphology, including bifurcation and fusion of adjacent intercostals. myogenin/MRF4-mutant combinations displayed ventral myotome defects, including a failure to express normal levels of myf5. The results suggested that the early muscle defects observed in myogenin and MRF4 mutants may cause subsequent thoracic skeletal defects, and that myogenin and MRF4 have overlapping functions in ventral myotome differentiation and intercostal muscle morphogenesis.

Gene expression patterns of the fibroblast growth factors and their receptors during myogenesis of rat satellite cells

Satellite cells are the myogenic precursors in postnatal muscle and are situated beneath the myofiber basement membrane. We previously showed that fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF2, basic FGF) stimulates a greater number of satellite cells to enter the cell cycle but does not modify the overall schedule of a short proliferative phase and a rapid transition to the differentiated state as the satellite cells undergo myogenesis in isolated myofibers. In this study we investigated whether other members of the FGF family can maintain the proliferative state of the satellite cells in rat myofiber cultures. We show that FGF1, FGF4, and FGF6 (as well as hepatocyte growth factor, HGF) enhance satellite cell proliferation to a similar degree as that seen with FGF2, whereas FGF5 and FGF7 are ineffective. None of the growth factors prolongs the proliferative phase or delays the transition of the satellite cells to the differentiating, myogenin(+) state. However, FGF6 retards the rapid exit of the cells from the myogenin(+) state that routinely occurs in myofiber cultures. To determine which of the above growth factors might be involved in regulating satellite cells in vivo, we examined their mRNA expression patterns in cultured rat myofibers using RT-PCR. The expression of all growth factors, excluding FGF4, was confirmed. Only FGF6 was expressed at a higher level in the isolated myofibers and not in the connective tissue cells surrounding the myofibers or in satellite cells dissociated away from the muscle. By Western blot analysis, we also demonstrated the presence of FGF6 protein in the skeletal musle tissue. Our studies therefore suggest that the myofibers serve as the main source for the muscle FGF6 in vivo. We also used RT-PCR to analyze the expression patterns of the four tyrosine kinase FGF receptors (FGFR1-FGFR4) and of the HGF receptor (c-met) in the myofiber cultures. Depending on the time in culture, expression of all receptors was detected, with FGFR2 and FGFR3 expressed only at a low level. Only FGFR4 was expressed at a higher level in the myofibers but not the connective tissue cell cultures. FGFR4 was also expressed at a higher level in satellite cells compared to the nonmyogenic cells when the two cell populations were released from the muscle tissue and fractionated by Percoll density centrifugation. The unique localization patterns of FGF6 and FGFR4 may reflect specific roles for these members of the FGF signaling complex during myogenesis in adult skeletal muscle.

Fate restriction in limb muscle precursor cells precedes high-level expression of MyoD family member genes

The mechanisms by which pluripotent embryonic cells generate unipotent tissue progenitor cells during development are unknown. Molecular/genetic experiments in cultured cells have led to the hypothesis that the product of a single member of the MyoD gene family (MDF) is necessary and sufficient to establish the positive aspects of the determined state of myogenic precursor cells: i.e., the ability to initiate and maintain the differentiated state (Weintraub, H., Davis, R., Tapscott, S., Thayer, M., Krause, M., Benezra, R., Blackwell, T. K., Turner, D., Rupp, R., Hollenberg, S. et al. (1991) Science 251, 761–766). Embryonic cell type determination also involves negative regulation, such as the restriction of developmental potential for alternative cell types, that is not directly addressed by the MDF model. In the experiments reported here, phenotypic restriction in myogenic precursor cells is assayed by an in vivo ‘notochord challenge’ to evaluate their potential to ‘choose’ between two alternative cell fate endpoints: cartilage and muscle (Williams, B. A. and Ordahl, C. P. (1997) Development 124, 4983–4997). Two separate myogenic precursor cell populations were found to be phenotypically restricted while expressing the Pax3 gene and prior to MDF gene activation. Therefore, while MDF family members act positively during myogenic differentiation, phenotypic restriction, the negative aspect of cell specification, requires cellular and molecular events and interactions that precede MDF expression in myogenic precursor cells. The qualities of muscle formed by the determined myogenic precursor cells in these experiments further indicate that their developmental potential is intermediate between that of myoblastic stem cells taken from fetal or adult tissue (which lack mitotic and morphogenetic potential when tested in vivo) and embryonic stem cells (which are multipotent). We hypothesize that such embryonic myogenic progenitor cells represent a distinct class of determined embryonic cell, one that is responsible for both tissue growth and tissue morphogenesis.

Sclerotomal origin of the ribs

The somites of vertebrate embryos give rise to sclerotomes and dermomyotomes. The sclerotomes form the axial skeleton, whereas the dermomyotomes give rise to all trunk muscles and the dermis of the back. The ribs were thought to be ventral processes of the axial skeleton and therefore to be derived from the sclerotomes; however, recently a dermomyotomal origin of the distal rib (the costal shaft) was suggested, with only the proximal parts (head and neck of the rib) being of sclerotomal origin. We have re-investigated the development of the ribs in quail-chick chimeras and carried out three experimental series. (1) Single dermomyotomes and (2) single sclerotomes were grafted homotopically, and (3) the ectoderm overlying the unsegmented paraxial mesoderm was removed in the prospective thoracic region. We found that the cells of the dermomyotome gave rise to epaxial and hypaxial trunk muscles, dermis of the back and endothelial cells, but not to ribs. Cells of the sclerotome formed the axial skeleton and all parts of the ribs. Ablation of the ectoderm, which affects dermomyotome development, results in severe malformations of the ribs, probably due to disturbed interactions between dermomyotome and sclerotome. Our results strongly confirm the traditional view of the sclerotomal origin of the ribs.

Sclerotome induction and differentiation

Inductive events in the development of the sclerotome and their possible underlying mechanisms were reviewed from the primary literature. A brief review of morphological and anatomical aspects of sclerotome development was given. The importance of the notochord and neural tube in sclerotome induction and somite chondrogenesis in vivo and in vitro was established. The functions and patterns of expression of different sclerotome markers were discussed. Shh and Noggin were discussed as two molecules produced by the neural tube and notochord that appear to maintain and initiate the sclerotome, respectively. While the abilities of the axial organs and Shh and Noggin to induce sclerotome marker expression in the somite was not disputed, the exact nature of these inductions was discussed with regard to possible effects on gene expression, effects on cell survival, and physical effects on the cells and it was argued that the fundamental nature of inductive events in the sclerotome is still unknown.

Changes in FGF and FGF receptor expression in low-frequency-stimulated rat muscles and rat satellite cell cultures

This study compares effects of chronic electrical stimulation on the expression levels of FGF-1, FGF-2 and their receptors (FGFRI, FGFR4) in rat tibialis anterior (TA) muscle of hypothyroid rat, as well as in satellite cell cultures derived from normal rat TA and soleus (SOL) muscles. In 5-day (5-d)-stimulated hypothyroid TA muscle, FGF-1 and FGF-2 mRNA levels were threefold elevated over control. FGFR1 and FGFR4 mRNAs were twofold and 1.5-fold elevated, respectively. In longer stimulated muscles, FGF-1 and FGFR4 mRNAs returned to basal levels, whereas FGF-2 mRNA remained elevated. FGFR1 mRNA decreased to control levels in 10-d stimulated muscles, but increased again after 20 days of stimulation. SOL- and TA-derived satellite cell cultures were stimulated for 5 days. At this time point, changes in myosin heavy chain isoforms were detectable consisting of increases in MHCI mRNA and decreases in MHCIIb and MHCIId mRNA. The comparison between 5-d-stimulated hypothyroid TA muscle and 5-d-stimulated TA- and SOL-derived satellite cell cultures revealed differences in the expression of FGF-1 and FGF-2, but similar expression levels of FGFR1 and FGFR4. Even though FGF-1 and FGF-2 mRNAs were elevated in the satellite cell cultures, their increases were less pronounced than in the stimulated hypothyroid muscle. Taking into consideration that skeletal muscle contains muscle fibres and various non-muscle tissues, e.g. blood vessels, these results suggest that the latter contribute to the observed increases in FGF-1 and FGF-2 expression in stimulated muscle.

Ventral neuroblasts and the heartless FGF receptor are required for muscle founder cell specification in Drosophila

Muscle founder cells are uniquely specified cells that fuse with neighboring myoblasts to generate the complex pattern of body wall muscles in the Drosophila embryo. We have investigated the positional specification of founder cells for ventral oblique muscles, marked by the restricted expression of tinman RNA and the activity of a D-mef2 enhancer. The formation of these ventral myoblasts requires the function of the Heartless FGF receptor in the mesoderm and the presence of ventral neuroblasts in the central nervous system. Overproduction of ventral neuroblasts due to the forced expression of the homeodomain protein Vnd leads to increased numbers of founder cells. These results suggest the use of a neuroectoderm-to-mesoderm signaling pathway in the specification of ventral muscle precursors.

Evidence that acidic fibroblast growth factor promotes maturation of rat satellite-cell-derived myotubes in vitro

Satellite cells isolated from fast tibialis anterior (TA) and slow soleus (SOL) rat muscles were cultivated on matrigel, and treated with acidic fibroblast growth factor (aFGF). The following observations were made: 1) aFGF-treated cultures exhibited enhanced proliferation as mirrored by a twofold increase in DNA content. 2) Compared to the untreated cultures, myotubes in the aFGF cultures were larger; 3) Using reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and northern blot analyses, we observed enhanced expression of all adult myosin heavy chain (MHC) isoforms, as well as of myogenin. These findings indicate that, under the culture conditions used, aFGF has a stimulatory effect on proliferation but also on maturation and differentiation of satellite cells. Furthermore, transcript levels of FGF receptor 1 (FGFR1) and 4 (FGFR4) isoforms, as well as of aFGF and bFGF were assessed by RT-PCR. aFGF-treated myotubes displayed increased expression of aFGF and bFGF, suggesting a paracrine effect of exogenous aFGF. In this regard, SOL-derived cultures responded more strongly than TA-derived cultures. The effects of aFGF treatment on the two receptors consisted of a decrease in FGFR1 and an increase in FGFR4 mRNA levels in 5-day-old cultures. In 8-day-old TA cultures, effects of FGF were similar to those in 5-day-old cultures. 8-day FGF-treated SOL cultures treated with FGF for 8 days exhibited higher FGFR1 and FGFR4 mRNA levels than the respective untreated cultures. Compared to 5 day-treated cultures, FGFR1 increased and FGFR4 decreased. This led to a shift in the ratio of FGFR1 to FGFR4 in the FGF-treated cultures which may explain the ability of satellite cells to differentiate under the influence of aFGF.

[Understanding of molecular biology]

OBJECTIVES

To display theorical and methodological basis of the molecular biology. To point out its main medical applications.

DATA SOURCES

For this review, we analysed the English and French literature concerning the research and clinical aspects of the molecular biology, especially in anaesthesiology and intensive care, using the Medline database. The current textbooks were also used.

STUDY SELECTION

We selected: 1) the original articles corresponding to the main advances that resulted in the present state of this discipline; 2) the reviews; 3) some chapters of textbooks.

DATA EXTRACTION

In this review, we report: 1) the current knowledge concerning the conservation and the expression of the genome; 2) the principles of the most widely used experimental techniques; 3) the medical applications of this knowledge in anaesthesiology and intensive care; 4) the more recent developments of this research field.

DATA SYNTHESIS

Within medical biology, molecular biology essentially corresponds to the study of nucleic acids. In this review, the general principles governing the organization and expression of the genome are discussed. The expansion of molecular biology has been a consequence of the widespread use of enzymatic tools, of which bacterial restriction enzymes were the first. Numerous enzymes are now available, permitting DNA strands to be cut, linked, synthesized and sequenced. Several of the most representative molecular biology techniques are described. Some of them, such as PCR, are commonly used in clinical situations. Animal experimental models have also been generated by genome altering methods, in order to analyse the phenotypic consequences of these modifications. Recently, a viable mammal, deriving from a differentiated cell, has been cloned. Human embryonic totipotent stem cells are now available in cultures. These advances have important ethical implications whilst, at the same time, offering new opportunities for medical applications. The state of gene therapy and human genome sequencing programmes is discussed.

Rib truncations and fusions in the Sp2H mouse reveal a role for Pax3 in specification of the ventro-lateral and posterior parts of the somite

The splotch (Pax3) mouse mutant serves as a model for developmental defects of several types, including defective migration of dermomyotomal cells to form the limb musculature. Here, we describe abnormalities of the ribs, neural arches, and acromion in Sp2H homozygous embryos, indicating a widespread dependence of lateral somite development on Pax3 function. Moreover, the intercostal and body wall muscles, derivatives of the ventrolateral myotome, are also abnormal in Sp2H homozygotes. Pax3 is expressed in the dermomyotome, but not in either the sclerotome or the myotome, raising the possibility that Pax3-dependent inductive influences from the dermomyotome are necessary for early specification of lateral sclerotome and myotome. Support for this idea comes from analysis of gene expression markers of lateral sclerotome (tenascin-C and scleraxis) and myotome (myogenin, MyoD, and Myf5). All exhibit ventrally truncated domains of expression in Sp2H homozygotes, potentially accounting for the rib and intercostal muscle truncations. In contrast, the medial sclerotomal marker Pax1 is expressed normally in mutant embryos, arguing that Pax3 is not required for development of the medial sclerotome. Most of the somitic markers show ectopic expression in anteroposterior and mediolateral dimensions, suggesting a loss of definition of somite boundaries in splotch and explaining the rib and muscle fusions. An exception is Myf5, which is not ectopically expressed in Sp2H homozygotes, consistent with the previous suggestion that Pax3 and Myf5 function in different pathways of skeletal myogenesis. PDGFalpha and its receptor are candidates for mediating signalling between myotome and sclerotome. We find that both genes are misexpressed in Sp2H embryos, suggesting that PDGFalpha/PDGFRalpha may function downstream of Pax3, accounting for the close similarities between the splotch and Patch mutant phenotypes. Our findings point to additional regulatory functions for the Pax3 transcription factor, apart from those already demonstrated for development of the neural tube, neural crest, and dermomyotome.

Control of muscle fibre and motoneuron diversification

Recent studies have elucidated both the mechanism of early formation of diverse muscle fibre types and the matching of diverse populations of motoneurons to their appropriate muscle targets. Highlights include the demonstration that distinct signals are necessary for the formation of several distinct myoblast populations in the vertebrate somite, the identification of motoneuron subtypes, studies of how motoneurons target appropriate muscles, and rapid progress on the Drosophila neuromuscular system. We propose a model in which four classes of decision control the patterning of both motoneurons and muscles.

Distinct regulatory elements govern Fgf4 gene expression in the mouse blastocyst, myotomes, and developing limb

Embryonic development requires a complex program of events which are directed by a number of signaling molecules whose expression must be rigorously regulated. We previously showed that expression of Fgf4, which plays an important role in postimplantation development and growth and patterning of the limb, is regulated in EC cells by the synergistic interaction of Sox2 and Oct-3 with the Fgf4 EC cell-specific enhancer. To verify whether this mechanism was also operating in vivo, and to identify new elements controlling Fgf4 gene expression in distinct developmental stages, we have analyzed the expression of LacZ reporter plasmids containing different fragments of the Fgf4 gene in transgenic mouse embryos. Utilizing these transgenic constructs we have been able to recapitulate, for the most part, Fgf4 gene expression during embryonic development. We show here that most of the cis-acting regulatory elements determining Fgf4 embryonic expression are located in conserved regions within the 3' UTR of the gene. The EC cell-specific enhancer is required to drive gene expression in the ICM of the blastocyst, and its activity requires the Sox and Oct-proteins binding sites. We were also able to identify specific and distinct enhancer elements that govern postimplantation expression in the somitic myotomes and the limb bud AER. The myotome-specific elements contain binding sites for bHLH myogenic regulatory factors, which appear to be essential for myotome expression. Finally, we present evidence that the very restricted pattern of expression of Fgf4 transcripts in the AER results from the combined action of positive and negative regulatory elements located 3' of the Fgf4 coding sequences. Thus the Fgf4 gene relies on multiple and distinct regulatory elements to achieve stage- and tissue-specific embryonic expression.

A crucial role for Pax3 in the development of the hypaxial musculature and the long-range migration of muscle precursors

Activated by dorsalizing and lateralizing signals, the Pax3 gene is an early marker for the entire paraxial mesoderm and its dorsal derivative, the dermomyotome. Later, its expression becomes restricted to the lateral dermomyotome and to the migratory muscle precursors giving rise to the hypaxial musculature. To understand better the role that Pax3 plays during development of paraxial mesoderm-derived structures, we followed the development of the musculature and skeleton in the murine Pax3 mutant Splotch. We found that the mutant dermomyotomes and myotomes failed to organize and to elongate medially and laterally, leading to the reduction and malformation of the entire trunk musculature. Mutants lacked ventral aspects of the body wall musculature and muscles derived from migratory myoblasts, suggesting a crucial function for Pax3 in the long-range migration of muscle precursors giving rise to the ventral hypaxial musculature. In addition, severe malformations were detected in the skeleton. The axial and appendicular skeleton displayed malformations and in particular multiple bone fusions.

Fibroblast growth factors as multifunctional signaling factors

The fibroblast growth factor (FGF) family consists of at least 15 structurally related polypeptide growth factors. Their expression is controlled at the levels of transcription, mRNA stability, and translation. The bioavailability of FGFs is further modulated by posttranslational processing and regulated protein trafficking. FGFs bind to receptor tyrosine kinases (FGFRs), heparan sulfate proteoglycans (HSPG), and a cysteine-rich FGF receptor (CFR). FGFRs are required for most biological activities of FGFs. HSPGs alter FGF-FGFR interactions and CFR participates in FGF intracellular transport. FGF signaling pathways are intricate and are intertwined with insulin-like growth factor, transforming growth factor-beta, bone morphogenetic protein, and vertebrate homologs of Drosophila wingless activated pathways. FGFs are major regulators of embryonic development: They influence the formation of the primary body axis, neural axis, limbs, and other structures. The activities of FGFs depend on their coordination of fundamental cellular functions, such as survival, replication, differentiation, adhesion, and motility, through effects on gene expression and the cytoskeleton.

Overlapping functions of the myogenic bHLH genes MRF4 and MyoD revealed in double mutant mice

The myogenic basic helix-loop-helix (bHLH) genes - MyoD, Myf5, myogenin and MRF4 - exhibit distinct, but overlapping expression patterns during development of the skeletal muscle lineage and loss-of-function mutations in these genes result in different effects on muscle development. MyoD and Myf5 have been shown to act early in the myogenic lineage to establish myoblast identity, whereas myogenin acts later to control myoblast differentiation. In mice lacking myogenin, there is a severe deficiency of skeletal muscle, but some residual muscle fibers are present in mutant mice at birth. Mice lacking MRF4 are viable and have skeletal muscle, but they upregulate myogenin expression, which could potentially compensate for the absence of MRF4. Previous studies in which Myf5 and MRF4 null mutations were combined suggested that these genes do not share overlapping myogenic functions in vivo. To determine whether the functions of MRF4 might overlap with those of myogenin or MyoD, we generated double mutant mice lacking MRF4 and either myogenin or MyoD. MRF4/myogenin double mutant mice contained a comparable number of residual muscle fibers to mice lacking myogenin alone and myoblasts from those double mutant mice formed differentiated multinucleated myotubes in vitro as efficiently as wild-type myoblasts, indicating that neither myogenin nor MRF4 is absolutely essential for myoblast differentiation. Whereas mice lacking either MRF4 or MyoD were viable and did not show defects in muscle development, MRF4/MyoD double mutants displayed a severe muscle deficiency similar to that in myogenin mutants. Myogenin was expressed in MRF4/MyoD double mutants, indicating that myogenin is insufficient to support normal myogenesis in vivo. These results reveal unanticipated compensatory roles for MRF4 and MyoD in the muscle differentiation pathway and suggest that a threshold level of myogenic bHLH factors is required to activate muscle structural genes, with this level normally being achieved by combinations of multiple myogenic bHLH factors.